Management of the Cumberland River System
Tennessee Silver Jackets Meeting Old Hickory Lock and Dam 09 April 2014
Benjamin L. Rohrbach, P.E. Hydrology & Hydraulics Branch Chief Nashville District
US Army Corps of Engineers
BUILDING STRONG® Agenda
. Background . History and Authorizing Legislation . Authorized Purposes . The Water Management Challenge . Water Management Program . Flood Operations . Protecting the Lower Ohio and Mississippi . Summary BUILDING STRONG®
Background
BUILDING STRONG® US Army Corps of Engineers Division Boundaries
BUILDING STRONG® Great Lakes & Ohio River Division District Boundaries
BUILDING STRONG® Nashville District River Basins & Boundaries
Lieutenant Colonel John L. Hudson Commander and District Engineer Nashville District
BUILDING STRONG® Cumberland River Basin Reservoir System . Cumberland River Basin Flood Control Project Storage ► 2 Drainage area – 17,913 mi (acre-feet) ► Total length – 694 miles . System of 10 multi-purpose projects Wolf Creek 2,094,000 ► Flood Damage Reduction • 5.3 M acre-feet of flood storage Dale Hollow 353,000 • > $2 B in flood damages prevented ($115 M/yr) • 77 % of drainage area above Nashville is controlled Center Hill 762,000 ► Hydropower • 9/10 projects have hydropower J. Percy 350,000 • 914 MW capacity from 28 hydropower turbines Priest ► Navigation • 380 miles of navigable waterway (4 locks) Barkley 1,472,000 • 795 miles on TN River (10 locks) ► Recreation Total 5,031,000 • 5 Nashville District projects in top 25 nationally • 31.3 M visitors last year (> $700 M economic impact) ► Environmental Stewardship • Environmental restoration projects • Tremendous mussel and fish diversity • Home to two world record fish
BUILDING STRONG® History and Authorizing Legislation
BUILDING STRONG® Historic Flood 1926-1927
BUILDING STRONG® Historic Flood 1937
BUILDING STRONG® Low Water on the Cumberland River
BUILDING STRONG® Authorizing Legislation
. Flood Control Act of 1938: PL 75-761 ► Wolf Creek (construction finished in 1952) ► Dale Hollow (1953) ► Center Hill (1951) ► J. Percy Priest (1970) ► Three Islands ► Rossview ► Devil’s Jump . River and Harbor Act of 1946: PL 79-525 ► Celina ► Cordell Hull (1974) ► Old Hickory (1957) ► Cheatham (1959) ► Barkley (1966) . Flood Control Act of 1960: PL 86-645 ► Laurel (1977) . Flood Control Act of 1965: PL 89-298 ► Martins Fork (1978)
BUILDING STRONG® Authorized Purposes
BUILDING STRONG® Congressionally Authorized Project Purposes Flood Damage Commercial Project Hydropower Recreation Reduction Navigation
Wolf Creek Dam
Dale Hollow Dam
Center Hill Dam
J. Percy Priest Dam
Cordell Hull Lock & Dam
Old Hickory Lock & Dam
Cheatham Lock & Dam
Barkley Lock & Dam
Project not designed for this purpose
Project primarily designed BUILDING STRONG for this purpose ® BUILDING STRONG® Congressionally Authorized Project Purposes
Wolf Creek Dam Old Hickory Lock & Dam
. Project Design . Project Design ► Flood Damage Reduction ► Flood Surcharge Storage ► 37 ft zone ► 5 ft zone ► Volume - 2,094,000 acre-feet ► Volume - 125,000 acre-feet ► Hydropower ► Hydropower ► 50 ft zone ► 3 ft zone ► Volume – 2,142,000 acre-feet ► Volume – 63,000 acre-feet ► Commercial Navigation
BUILDING STRONG® Scale and Impact to the System Lake Cumberland Available Storage Flood 760’ Control Pool 740’ Louisville District (20) 726’ May 2011 Level 700’ (Reduced Huntington District (35) flooding by 660’ 1.2’ at Cairo, IL) Elevation Elevation 620’ Pittsburgh District (17)
580’
540’ 460 480 500 520 540 560 Cumberland River Mile
BUILDING STRONG® The Water Management Challenge
. Water Control . Water Quality . Balancing Act . Project Authorized Purposes . Environmental Statutes . Changing Societal Values/Expectations
BUILDING STRONG® Hydropower Water Supply
Environmental Stewardship
USACE Navigation Water Management
Flood Damage Reduction Recreation
BUILDING STRONG® TDEC EPA Cumberland SEPA TVA River Compact Environmental Organizations
Hydropower Water USFWS Private Supply Utilities Environmental Boaters Stewardship
Towing Industry USACE KDFWR Navigation Water Emergency Management Management
TVA
TVA KDFWR Flood Damage Public Reduction
NWS TWRA Recreation
Recreation Recreation Interests FEMA Industry
BUILDING STRONG® Water Management Program
BUILDING STRONG® Water Management Program
. Water Quality ► Data Collection • 7 real-time water quality monitors • 4 real-time temperature • 62 stream sampling sites • 95 reservoir sampling sites ► Water Quality Modeling • Project specific CE-QUAL-W2 models • System water quality modeling ► Water Quality Restoration • Dissolved oxygen • Minimum flow
BUILDING STRONG® Water Management Program
Water Control Program . Data Collection Program • Project data from 10 multi- purpose projects • 75 rainfall sites • 45 river stage sites . Hydrology, Hydraulic, and Reservoir Simulation Modeling . Reservoir System Operations • Daily analysis of reservoir conditions • Balance operating objectives • Prepare 8-day forecast
BUILDING STRONG® Water Management Team
. Nashville District Water Management ► Multidisciplinary staff – engineers & scientists ► Perform complete system analysis every day . Nashville District Hydropower Operators ► 24/7 operational support . Great Lakes & Ohio River Water Management ► Ohio/Mississippi flood control operations ► Program oversight . Federal Partners ► Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) ► National Weather Service ► U. S. Geological Survey
BUILDING STRONG® Water Management Center
BUILDING STRONG® Flood Operations
BUILDING STRONG® Flood Operations
National Weather Service 1 NWS generates observed radar rainfall Nashville USACE Water Management
Nashville WM runs hydrology models to 2 forecast reservoir releases National Weather Service
NWS uses forecast reservoir releases 3 and rainfall to predict flood stages Public
BUILDING STRONG® Wolf Creek Inflow & Discharge (2011)
150,000150,000 730 Discharge (cfs) (cfs) Inflow (cfs) (cfs) 725 Headwater (ft) 125,000125,000 720
715 100,000100,000 710
705 75,00075,000 700 Flow (cfs) Flow (cfs)
695 Headwater (ft) 50,00050,000 690
25,00025,000 685
680
00 675 2/12/1 2/82/8 2/152/15 2/222/22 3/13/1 3/83/8 3/153/15 3/223/22 3/293/29 4/54/5 4/124/12 4/194/19 4/264/26 5/35/3 5/105/10
BUILDING STRONG® Cumberland River Stage at Nashville (2011)
Observed vs Natural River Stage for Nashville 45
40
35
30
25
Nashville Stage (ft) Stage Nashville 20
15
Observed with Projects 10 Natural River Conditions Flood Stage 5 2/1 2/8 2/15 2/22 3/1 3/8 3/15 3/22 3/29 4/5 4/12 4/19 4/26 5/3 5/10
BUILDING STRONG® 2013 Wolf Creek Dam Inflow & Discharge
120,000 Discharge Inflow 100,000
80,000
60,000 Flow (cfs)
40,000
20,000
0 1/1 1/16 1/31 2/15 3/2 3/17 4/1 4/16 5/1 5/16 6/1 6/16 7/1 7/16
BUILDING STRONG® Cumberland River Stage at Nashville
Observed vs Natural Stage for Nashville (2013) 45
40
35
30
25
20 Nashville Stage (ft)
15
Observed with Projects 10 Natural River Conditions Flood Stage Low Water Navigation Impacts 5 1/1 1/16 1/31 2/15 3/2 3/17 4/1 4/16 5/1 5/16 6/1 6/16 7/1 7/16
BUILDING STRONG® Protecting the Lower Ohio and Mississippi Rivers
BUILDING STRONG® Protecting the Lower Ohio and Mississippi Rivers
Smithland Lock
Lock 53
Lock 52 Paducah
Canal
Cairo
Birds Point- New Madrid Floodway
BUILDING STRONG® Kentucky-Barkley Canal
BUILDING STRONG® Kentucky-Barkley Flood Operations
National Weather NWS forecasts flooding on the lower 1 Service Ohio & upper Mississippi Rivers Tennessee Valley Authority & Nashville WM
TVA & Nashville WM forecast inflows and 2 reservoir stages on Kentucky & Barkley Lakes
Lakes & Rivers Division Headquarters LRD coordinates Kentucky & Barkley releases 3 to reduce flooding on the Ohio & Mississippi Kentucky & Barkley Operators
BUILDING STRONG® Operation Watershed
Operation Watershed - Wolf Creek Dam 730 Observed 4/26/2011 – 5/4/2011 Without Reductions 725 Top of Hydropower Pool Rainfall & Project Operations 720
715
710
Cumberland River Basin Elevation (ft)
705
700
Barkley Lock & Dam 695 4/12 4/22 5/2 5/12 5/22 6/1
Cordell Hull Lock & Dam Wolf Creek Dam Cheatham Lock & Dam
Old Hickory Lock & Dam
Operation Watershed - Dale Hollow Dam 664 Top of Flood Control Pool
662 Observed Without Reductions
Storage conserved in 660 Barkley and Kentucky 658 4.65 feet 656 Dale Hollow Dam Elevation (ft)
654 Dale Hollow – 0.51’ 652 J. Percy Priest – 0.65’ Top of Hydropower Pool 650 4/12 4/22 5/2 5/12 5/22 6/1 Center Hill – 0.95’
Operation Watershed - Center Hill Dam 660 Observed Wolf Creek – 2.54’ Without Reductions J. Percy Priest Dam 655
650 Top of Hydropower Pool Operation Watershed - J. Percy Priest Dam 506 645 Top of Flood Control Pool 504 Observed Center Hill Dam 640 Without Reductions Elevation (ft) 502
635 500
498 630
496
Elevation (ft) 625 4/12 4/22 5/2 5/12 5/22 6/1 Storage at Peak Elevation 494
492 Available 490 488 4/12 4/22 5/2 5/12 5/22 6/1 Peak BUILDING STRONG® Pie area scaled to storage capacity Water Stored After February 24, 2011
Headwater Headwater Water Stored Project (02/24/2011) Crest (acre-feet)
Wolf Creek1 681.12 725.96 1,992,000 Dale Hollow 643.75 660.16 459,000 Center Hill1 625.70 658.15 576,000 J. Percy Priest 483.75 501.65 280,000 Total 3,307,0002
1 Wolf Creek and Center Hill Dams have been classified as DSAC 1 dams and are under pool restrictions to assure the stability of the dams. 2 This volume of water is roughly equivalent to 1.08 quadrillion gallons of water BUILDING STRONG or if stacked on a football field it would be 3.2 million feet (606 miles) high. ® Protecting the Lower Ohio and Mississippi Rivers
Smithland Lock
Lock 53
Lock 52 Paducah
Canal
Cairo May 2011 Flood Stage Reduction at Cairo Birds Point- New . 2-ft (0.62-m) due to Madrid Floodway Cumberland River Projects .0.8-ft (0.24-m) due to Tennessee River Projects .3.8-ft (1.2-m) for all LRD Storage Projects
BUILDING STRONG® Summary
BUILDING STRONG® Cumberland River System Water Management
. Requires coordinated operation of a complex system to fulfill a wide range of often competing purposes and benefits . Flood Damage Reduction for the Cumberland as well as the Ohio/Mississippi averages $149 M per year . Hydropower production at nine plants worth ~$35 M per year . Recreation valued at $568 M per year, the highest for a Corps district in the nation . Navigation for ~73 M tons of commodities per year over 1,175 river miles with 14 lock & dams on the Tennessee & Cumberland Rivers . Cumberland River projects play a critical role in a regional system, including the Ohio and Mississippi Rivers . Federal Partners including Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA), National Weather Service, and U.S. Geological Survey are important members of the water management team
BUILDING STRONG® Questions?
BUILDING STRONG®