<<

1 CLINKER SUBSTITUTION A case for low-lime The cement and industry is re-inventing itself through new and efficient processes to not only reverse its environmental impact, but to make improvements to the whole supply chain of the building materials industry. This sustainability drive has seen the emergence of low-clinker , including cements that have a reduced lime content. n by Dr Vahit Atakan, Dr Sada Sahu and Dr Nick DeCristofaro, Solidia Technologies, USA

ecognising the need to lower its carbon Rand energy footprints, the cement industry actively pursues four practices that can help reduce the industry’s carbon footprint: • improvement of energy efficiency in cement production • alternative fuel use • clinker substitution • carbon capture and storage. As part of a strategic approach to meet

its CO2 reduction goals and conserve energy and natural resources, the industry has also adapted clinker substitution technologies. In addition to transforming a waste product into a usable commodity, The production of low-lime clinkers such as Solidia® clinker helps to reduce CO emissions from cement production low-clinker cements can help save 2 energy, reduce pollutants and lower the consumption of raw materials. gas. Thus, Solidia Cement is also more into costs savings for manufacturers.

sustainable than ordinary Portland cement Inspired directly by the CO2 challenge, Reducing lime content (OPC). Solidia’s processes allow the industry Solidia Technologies® has developed Solidia Concrete™ is made with Solidia to address its environmental challenges

patented processes that offer cement and Cement and cures with CO2 instead with solutions that offer solid value to concrete manufacturers an alternative of water. A typical concrete product manufacturers and immeasurable value

means of achieving the targeted energy consumes about 240kg of CO2/t of cement. to the planet. That said, bringing a new

conservation and pollutant reduction In addition to helping meet CO2 reduction technology to an industry that has not goals. Solidia Cement™ is produced using goals, Solidia Concrete performs better, changed in nearly 200 years is a daunting a low-lime containing raw mix, and thus is more durable and cost-effective than prospect. produces low-lime containing traditional , and typically cures phases. These phases produce a in one day. When compared to the 28 days A low-lime cement

cement that is non-hydraulic, consumes required for traditional concrete to reach To meet CO2 reduction goals the cement less energy and emits less greenhouse full strength, this time saving translates industry strives continuously to substitute clinker with various supplementary cementitious materials (SCMs), such as , slag, silica fume, natural pozzolanic materials and fillers such as . Even with all the clinker substitution efforts, the World Business Council for Sustainable Development (WBCSD)

predicts the CO2 reduction achieved by producing low-clinker cements will reach

only 10 per cent of the industry’s 2050 CO2 reduction target. Solidia Technologies’ new low-lime cement offers an alternative approach to help the industry towards its Pavers ready for curing: Solidia Concrete® cures with goal at a much faster pace. CO rather than water and typically cures in one day 2 Adoption of these approaches has been

International Cement Review FEBRUARY 2017 © Tradeship Publications Ltd CLINKER SUBSTITUTION 2

made simple. Solidia’s patented cement chemistry and curing processes offer the building materials and construction industries the ability to manufacture cement and concrete products within existing plants and using traditional design specifications, with minimal requirements for new supply chains and capital investment. Solidia Cement is composed of a family of “green,” low-lime calcium silicate phases that are similar, but not identical to, the chemistry of Portland cement. As a result, it can be produced in existing cement kilns with the same raw materials that are used to make OPC, although in different proportions. Figure 1: comparative CO2 emission from raw material fuel and electricity for Portland cement (~940kg/t) and Solidia Cement (680kg/t). The curing reaction in Solidia Cement consumes CO Solidia Cement is produced using less 2 (~240kg/t) resulting in up to 500kg/t reduction in CO2 emission limestone and at lower temperatures than are necessary for Portland cement. These 7 factors translate into a reduction in CO2 of Solidia Cement used in the concrete theoretically be reduced by 5.0 x 10 t/year 8 emissions during cement manufacturing, formulation. Depending on the specific (10 t of OPC x 0.50t of CO2). from 940kg/t for OPC to 660kg/t of ratios of fine and coarse and Solidia Cement (~30 per cent reduction). Solidia Cement used in the concrete mix, Where sustainability adds value Other pollutants associated with cement the final Solidia Concrete part may contain The inclusion of all the SCMs, namely production, such as mercury, are also between about 3-7 weight per cent of fly ash, bottom ash and slag, led to reduced by approximately 30 per cent. sequestered CO2. improvements in the workability of Solidia For concretes made with Solidia Cement mortars, especially when class F Cement, curing is achieved by a reaction Production in existing kilns fly ash was used, suggesting a reduction in between the low-lime calcium silicate Working with global the overall water demand in the mixtures compounds CaSiO3 and Ca3Si2O7 and leader LafargeHolcim as a commercial thereby allowing for more rapid curing. gaseous CO2 within a moist environment. partner, Solidia has demonstrated that Solidia Cement can be partially replaced

Unlike its OPC-based counterparts, CO2- common cement kilns and raw materials with slag, class F and class C fly ash. The cured Solidia Concrete does not react can be used to produce Solidia Cement SCMs in Solidia Concrete do not produce with water. On average, 70-80 per cent simply by: any pozzolanic reaction but are rather just of the water used in the Solidia Concrete • adjusting the relative amounts of the fine fillers. formulation can be recovered during the raw materials that are fed into the kiln Tests have shown that the incorporation

CO2-curing process. The remaining water • operating the kiln at a lower reaction of SCMs can further reduce the carbon is retained in the concrete and can be temperatures. footprint associated with the production recovered if needed. While this approach does not and use of Solidia Cement. The research Deriving its strength from the formation completely avoid the decomposition demonstrated that waste materials such of CaCO3 () and SiO2 (silica gel), of limestone and the high temperature as fly ash and ground granulated blast the curing reaction of Solidia Concrete is reaction of CaO and SiO2 associated with furnace slag can be used to replace Solidia written as: the manufacture of OPC, it reduces the Cement by as much as 40 per cent by

H2O amount of limestone decomposed and weight in concrete formulations. When

CaSiO3 (s) + CO2 (g) → CaCO3 (s) + SiO2 (s) energy consumed by 30 per cent. This the ability to replace Solidia Cement

[Eq 1] reduces the amount of CO2 emitted from with moderate amounts of fly ash or a cement plant by ~260kg/t of cement blast furnace slag are considered, the

H2O produced. total CO2 savings associated with Solidia

Ca3Si2O7 (s) + 3CO2 (g) → CaCO3 (s) + 2SiO2 (s) When coupled with ~240kg of CO2 Cement production and use can be [Eq 2] captured during curing, the production further reduced, resulting in an additional and use of 1t of Solidia Cement will reduction in clinker factor. Moreover, some

The carbonation curing reaction is reduce airborne CO2 by up to 500kg when of the SCMs, such as slag, can partially exothermic and releases -87kJ/mole compared to the production and use of 1t during concrete curing, realising of heat. The heat generated during the of Portland cement (See Figure 1). This CO2 further savings in CO2. reaction is dissipated by the evaporation saving is equivalent to a clinker factor of As the carbon economy comes online, of water. The curing process is controlled between 0.47-0.53 in an OPC-based system. the demand for alternative cementitious by counter diffusion of CO2 and H2O Solidia Cement can potentially replace materials grows among concrete molecules. all Portland cement currently in use as it manufacturers. Solidia’s new, alternative The curing process described above can be made everywhere that Portland process presents the industry with a enables Solidia Concrete products to cement is made. In the North American sustainable and potentially profitable n permanently sequester 200-300kg of CO2/t market alone, airborne CO2 could means of meeting that demand.

© Tradeship Publications Ltd FEBRUARY 2017 International Cement Review