Cabinet

14 December 2016

Schools 20 mph Part-Time Speed Limits Project - Update Report

Report of Corporate Management Team Report of Ian Thompson, Corporate Director - Regeneration and Local Services Councillor Brian Stephens, Portfolio Holder for Neighbourhoods and Local Partnerships

Purpose of the Report

1. The purpose of this report is to provide Cabinet with an update on the Schools 20 mph Part-time Speed Limits Project including details of the additional 33 schools that have been selected.

Background

2. At its meeting on 17 December 2014 Cabinet approved the Schools 20 mph Part-time Speed Limits Project which involves introducing part-time 20 mph limits on main and distributor roads around the 33 schools with the highest accident rates.

3. The objective of the project is to reduce traffic speeds around the vicinity of schools during school drop off and pick up times which will improve road safety for vulnerable road users as well as making walking and cycling to school more attractive.

4. The project includes education and awareness raising to encourage motorists to reduce their speed and encourage walking and cycling.

5. The project is funded by a one-off Public Health Grant of £952,850 and is complemented by a revenue budget to help deliver road safety education and social marketing.

6. An update report was approved by Cabinet on 11 May 2016 which highlighted that the project was progressing under budget and ahead of schedule. Cabinet approved that the underspend be used to expand the scope of the project to a further 33 schools (66 schools in total) using the revised prioritisation criteria developed in consultation with the Scrutiny 20mph Working Group. Original 33 Schools

7. Phase 1 (2015/16) of the project has been successfully delivered and Phase 2 (2016/17) is progressing on schedule.

8. Since the last Cabinet Update report on 11 May 2016, schemes have been successfully delivered in the Consett, Stanley, Seaham, Peterlee, Newton Aycliffe, Spennymoor and Durham areas. Each scheme has been accompanied by media releases helping to reinforce the key education and social marketing messages of the project.

9. A number of photographs from a scheme in Chester-le-Street where we were able to introduce a 20mph Zone on the main road where traffic calming was already in place are shown below:

10. Please see Appendix 2: Project Plan - Original 33 Schools for further details of progress by each school.

Additional 33 Schools

11. All remaining 219 schools Countywide on main and distributor roads were evaluated based on the revised prioritisation criteria which has been developed in consultation with the Scrutiny 20mph Working Group. The revised prioritisation criteria is based on three risk factors:

. Collision history; . Measured PV2; and . Measured speeds.

Measured PV2 is a measure of pedestrian risk where: . P = Number of pedestrians; and . V = Number of vehicles.

12. Please see Appendix 4: Revised Prioritisation Criteria for further details.

13. The 33 schools with the highest overall score under the revised prioritisation criteria have been selected and they are summarised as follows:

Ranking School Name Type of School Division Area Action Partnership 1 Neville's Cross Primary Primary / Junior Nevilles Cross Durham 2 New College College Framwellgate/ Durham Newton Hall 3 Framwellgate School Secondary / 6th Framwellgate/ Durham Form College Newton Hall 4 Byron College College Peterlee West East Durham 5 Our Lady of the Rosary Primary / Junior Peterlee West East Durham RCVA Primary 6 St. Bede's RC Secondary / 6th Peterlee West East Durham Comprehensive & 6th Form Form College 7 Pelton Community Primary Primary / Junior Pelton Chester-le-Street & District 8 St. Joseph's RCVA Primary Primary / Junior Tanfield Stanley (Stanley) 9 Framwellgate Moor Primary Primary / Junior Framwellgate/ Durham Newton Hall 10 St. Leonard's Catholic Secondary / 6th Nevilles Cross & 6th Form Form College 11 (new site) Secondary / 6th Consett North Derwent Valley Form College Partnership 12 Easington Colliery Primary Primary / Junior Easington East Durham 13 Annfield Plain Junior Primary / Junior Annfield Plain Stanley 14 St. Bede's Catholic School Secondary / 6th Lanchester Mid Durham & 6th Form College Form College Rural West 15 Cockton Hill Primary / Junior Woodhouse Bishop Close Auckland/Shildon 16 Shield Row Primary Primary / Junior Tanfield Stanley 17 School Secondary / 6th Teesdale Form College East / Barnard Castle West 18 Whitworth Park School + 6th Secondary / 6th Spennymoor Spennymoor Form College Form College 19 Annfield Plain Infant School Infant / Nursery Annfield Plain Stanley 20 Our Lady & St. Thomas Primary / Junior Willington/ Three Towns RCVA Primary Hunwick Partnership 21 Ropery Walk Primary Primary / Junior Dawdon East Durham 22 Seaham Harbour Nursery Infant / Nursery Dawdon East Durham 23 Delves Lane Primary Primary / Junior Delves Lane Derwent Valley Partnership 24 Green Lane C of E Primary Primary / Junior Barnard Castle Teesdale East/Barnard Castle West 25 Sacriston Primary Primary / Junior Sacriston Chester-le-Street & District 26 Our Lady Star of the Sea Primary / Junior Horden East Durham RCVA Primary 27 (Science & Secondary / 6th Tanfield Stanley Engineering) Form College 28 Chester -le - Street C of E Primary / Junior Chester-le- Chester-le-Street Primary Street North & District 29 Shotton Hall Academy Secondary / 6th Passfield East Durham Form College 30 Shotton Hall Primary Primary / Junior Passfield East Durham 31 Secondary / 6th Easington East Durham Form College 32 Roseberry Primary Primary / Junior Pelton Chester-le-Street & District 33 Willington Primary Primary / Junior Willington/ Three Towns Hunwick Partnership

14. Please see Appendix 5: Evaluation of Additional Schools for details of the scores.

15. The additional 33 schools are scheduled for delivery in 2017/18 and 2018/19. Please see Appendix 3: Project Plan - Additional 33 Schools for further details.

Potential for Further Schools

16. The budget for this project has now being fully committed. However, there is potential to add further schools to the project if funding can be provided from schools, Town/Parish Councils, AAPs or Member budgets now or in the future.

17. Members wishing to use their 2016/17 Neighbourhood Budget allocations have until 3rd February 2016 to commit funding.

18. Any Members wishing to pursue this option should contact Keith Jameson, Traffic Assets Manager, on telephone number 03000 263690 or by email at [email protected]

19. The Traffic Assets Team will need to survey each site to provide a fixed price estimate so Members are advised to request any estimates using 2016/17 Neighbourhood Budget by 5 January 2017. For information, the average cost of a scheme is £15,000 but the cost does vary by site depending upon the number of signs required and the presence of public utilities.

20. Members will be offered a fixed price and it is anticipated that any further schools funded by Members will be delivered in 2018/19.

Recommendations and Reasons

21. It is recommended that Cabinet endorses the additional 33 schools.

Appendices

. Appendix 1: Implications . Appendix 2: Project Plan - Original 33 Schools . Appendix 3: Project Plan - Additional 33 Schools . Appendix 4: Revised Prioritisation Criteria . Appendix 5: Evaluation of Additional Schools

Background Papers

. Cabinet Report dated 17 December 2014 . Cabinet Report dated 11 May 2016 . Overview and Scrutiny Working Group Meeting Report dated 1 July 2015

Contact: John Reed, Head of Technical Services Tel: 03000 267454 Appendix 1: Implications

Finance The Schools 20 mph Part-Time Speed Limit Project is providing Council funding on a priority basis on main/distributor roads outside existing schools Countywide.

Further schemes to introduce 20 mph speed limits/zones on existing roads will need to be funded from other sources such as Area Action Partnerships, Member Neighbourhood Budgets, Town Councils, Parish Councils and Schools.

Staffing Schemes are delivered by existing staff supported by our supply chain of competitively procured contractors.

Risk There may be objections to schemes which will be considered through the consultation process.

Equality and Diversity / Public Sector Equality Duty None.

Accommodation None.

Crime and Disorder None.

Human Rights None.

Consultation All changes to speed limits need to be consulted upon and any objections to the introduction of mandatory speed limits that cannot be resolved informally will be considered by Highways Committee.

Procurement Schemes are delivered by existing staff supported by our supply chain of competitively procured contractors.

Disability Issues None.

Legal Implications The Council has the power as the local Highway Authority to introduce 20 mph speed limits and zones under the Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984 (as amended) by making Traffic Regulation Orders and where appropriate the Highways Act 1980 (as amended). Appendix 2: Project Plan - Original 33 Schools

Phase Financial Schools Area Design Start Construction Year End 1 2015/16 Bishop Barrington December 2014 22/1/16 School Etherley Lane Bishop Auckland December 2014 5/10/15 Nursery Etherley Lane Bishop Auckland December 2014 5/10/15 Primary Evergreen Bishop Auckland December 2014 22/1/16 King James 1 Bishop Auckland December 2014 30/11/15 Academy St Anne's CE (Cont) Bishop Auckland December 2014 22/1/16 Primary Woodhouse Bishop Auckland December 2014 15/1/16 Community Primary Bullion Lane Primary Chester-le-Street December 2014 5/2/16 Cestria Primary Chester-le-Street December 2014 7/12/15 Newker Primary Chester-le-Street December 2014 5/2/16 Park View Chester-le-Street December 2014 7/12/15 Community School (Church Chare) St Cuthbert's RC VA Chester-le-Street December 2014 28/9/15 Primary The Hermitage Chester-le-Street December 2014 5/2/16 School 2 2016/17 Consett Infant School Consett December 2015 13/6/16 & Nursery Unit Shotley Bridge Infant Consett December 2015 2/12/16 Shotley Bridge Junior Consett December 2015 2/12/16 St Patrick's RCVA Consett December 2015 13/6/16 Primary New Seaham Primary Seaham December 2015 2/5/16 Seaview Primary Seaham December 2015 25/3/16 Seaham School of Seaham December 2015 2/5/16 Technology Seaham Trinity Seaham December 2015 30/5/16 Primary Westlea Primary Seaham December 2015 2/5/16 Greenland Stanley December 2015 25/11/16 Community Primary North Durham Stanley December 2015 25/4/16 Academy St Joseph's RC VA Durham December 2015 16/12/16 Primary Cotsford Junior Horden December 2015 16/12/16 St Mary's RC VA Newton Aycliffe December 2015 25/11/16 Primary Sugar Hill Primary Newton Aycliffe December 2015 7/10/16 Acre Rigg Infant Peterlee December 2015 2/12/16 Dene Community Peterlee December 2015 2/12/16 School of Technology Dene House Primary Peterlee December 2015 2/12/16 King Street Primary Spennymoor December 2015 9/12/16 Rosa Street Primary Spennymoor December 2015 9/12/16 Appendix 3: Project Plan - Additional 33 Schools

Phase Financial Schools Area Design Start Construction Year End 3 2017/18 Byron College Peterlee December 2016 July 2017 Our Lady of the Rosary Peterlee December 2016 July 2017 RCVA Primary St Bede’s RC Peterlee December 2016 July 2017 Comprehensive & 6th Form Shotton Hall Academy Peterlee December 2016 November 2017 Shotton Hall Primary Peterlee December 2016 October 2017 Seaham Harbour Nursery Seaham December 2016 December 2017 Ropery Walk Primary Seaham December 2016 December 2017 Our Lady Star of the Sea Horden December 2016 September 2017 RCVA Primary Easington Colliery Primary Easington December 2016 October 2017 Easington Academy Easington December 2016 October 2017 Nevilles Cross Primary Durham December 2016 December 2017 December 2016 August 2017 Framwellgate School Durham December 2016 August 2017 Framwellgate Moor Primary Durham December 2016 August 2017 St Leonard’s Catholic Durham December 2016 November 2017 School & 6th Form Whitworth Park School & 6th Spennymoor December 2016 September 2017 Form College 4 2018/19 Roseberry Primary Pelton December 2017 July 2018 Pelton Community Primary Pelton December 2017 July 2018 Sacriston Primary Sacriston December 2017 August 2018 Chester-le-Street C of E Chester-le- December 2017 November 2018 Primary Street St Joseph’s RCVA Primary Stanley December 2017 December 2018 Consett Academy Consett December 2017 November 2018 Annfield Plain Junior Annfield Plain December 2017 October 2018 Annfield Plain Infants Annfield Plain December 2017 October 2018 St Bede’s Catholic School & Lanchester December 2017 December 2018 6th Form College Shield Row Primary Shield Row December 2017 August 2018 Delves Lane Primary Delves Lane December 2017 August 2018 Tanfield School (Science & Tanfield December 2017 September 2018 Engineering) Barnard December 2017 July 2018 Castle Green Lane C of E Primary Barnard December 2017 July 2018 Castle Cockton Hill Primary School Bishop December 2017 November 2018 Auckland Our Lady and St Thomas Willington December 2017 December 2018 RCVA Primary School Willington Primary School Willington December 2017 December 2018 Appendix 4: Revised Prioritisation Criteria

Schools 20 mph Part Time Speed Limits - Revised Prioritisation Methodology for Additional Sites

June 2015 ______

Introduction

1 On 17 December 2014 Cabinet approved that 20 mph part-time speed limits be introduced at 33 named schools with above average accident rates. The 33 named schools were determined using a methodology developed by a Multi-Agency Group led by Public Health based on accidents rates within a 600 metre radius of a school.

2 This document sets out a revised prioritisation methodology for selecting additional sites from the additional budget that has become available. It does not change the original 33 named schools approved by Cabinet in any way and these will proceed as planned.

3 The revised prioritisation methodology for additional sites builds upon and refines the good work undertaken by the Multi-Agency Group and where appropriate seeks to address issues raised by stakeholders with this original methodology.

Original Methodology

4 The scope includes age 0 to 16 educational establishments located on or near to main and/or distributor roads but typically referred to as ‘schools’. These include:

. Nursery / Infants; . Juniors / Primary; . Secondary / Sixth Form; . Private Schools; and . Special Needs.

5 The prioritisation methodology is based wholly on collision history (2008 to 2012) involving recorded child accidents aged 0 years to 19 years within a 600 metres radius of the school postcode.

6 The 33 schools with the highest number of collisions were selected.

Revised Methodology

7 The scope includes age 0 to 18 educational establishments (excluding the 33 named schools approved by Cabinet) located on or near to main and/or distributor roads but typically referred to as ‘schools’. These include: . Nursery / Infants; . Juniors / Primary; . Secondary / Sixth Form; . Colleges; . Private Schools; and . Special Needs.

8 The only change to scope from the Original Methodology is to include Further Education Colleges.

9 The original methodology was based wholly on collision history. It is important that collision history remains part of the revised methodology as it provides objective evidence of an accident trend.

10 Fortunately actual collision rates around schools are low and some collisions can be random in nature. As additional sites are considered with lower collision rates it is important that additional risk factors are considered to provide an objective measure of child pedestrian risk. The three risk factors in the revised methodology are as follows:

. Collision history; . Measured PV2; and . Measured speeds.

11 These risk factors are explained further below.

Collision History

12 The collision history is based on the last 5 years involving all recorded collisions (child and adult) within a 200 metre radius of school entrances.

13 A 200 metre distance from a school entrance is used in accordance with the Department for Transport (DfT) guidance on the siting of traffic signs which typically advises that warning signs associated with schools should be sited within 100 metres of the actual hazard to be credible to the motorist and to influence motorist’s behaviour.

14 The use of a 200 metre radius reduces the scope for collisions being included within more than one school’s collision numbers. Calculating the radius from the school entrance helps ensure more accurate results.

15 The scores have been weighted to take into consideration vulnerable road users, casualty age and severity of injury as set out in the table below.

Casualty Class Score Child Pedestrian / Cycling, Fatal / Serious Accidents 6 Adult Pedestrian / Cycling, Fatal / Serious Accidents 5 Child Pedestrian / Cycling, Slight Accidents 4 Child vehicle occupant Fatal / Serious Accident 4 Adult Pedestrian / Cycling Slight Accidents 3 Adult vehicle occupant Fatal / Serious Accident 3 Child vehicle occupant Slight Accident 2 Adult vehicle occupant Slight Accident 1

16 Child accidents are defined as aged 0 years to 19 years. Adult accidents are defined as ages 20 and over.

17 The scores take into consideration that the most vulnerable road user is a child and that one of the main objectives of the project is to reduce child accidents. Adult accidents are included as they provide objective evidence of an accident trend that poses a risk to children. In each scoring band a child accident will score +1 to the corresponding accident involving an adult.

Measured PV2

18 Measured PV2 provides an objective indicator of risk associated with both traffic and pedestrian flow on roads in the vicinity of a school.

19 Measured PV2 is a risk factor used nationally for assessing the provision of School Crossing Patrols. This policy is based upon a nationally recognised standard produced by Road Safety GB entitled ‘School Crossing Patrol Guidelines: June 2012’. It is endorsed and supported by the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents (RoSPA).

20 Measured PV2 is a formula for assessing the conflict between pedestrians and vehicles and, from this, whether or not a School Crossing Patrol site is justified where:

. P = Number of pedestrians; and . V = Number of vehicles.

21 By counting the number of pedestrians and vehicles at peak times at the start and end of the school day, the PV2 formula can be applied to determine whether or not a School Crossing Patrol meets the criteria.

22 The PV2 calculation also takes into account a number of additional factors which affect risk, such as unaccompanied children, accompanied children, different types of vehicles, etc.

Measured Speeds

23 If speeds are low then the introduction of 20 mph part time speed limits is not likely to help reduce the risk of accidents or the severity of accidents. If speeds are high then the introduction of 20 mph part time speed limits is likely to help reduce the risk of accidents or the severity of accidents. Therefore, measured speed is an objective indicator of risk based on traffic speeds.

24 Traffic data collection units are used to help analyse traffic speeds outside of each school. The data set used in the analysis will comprise the peak times at the start and end of the school day, when traffic speeds are being influenced by the school run, being typically 8 am to 9 am and 3 pm to 4pm. 25 The following scoring is then applied:

‘Mean’ Speed Score 0-24 mph 1 25-33 mph 3 33+ mph 5

Applying the Methodology

26 The scores are added together allowing a weighted ‘Multiplier Factor’ (derived from the School Crossing Patrol Guidelines June 2012’) to be determined using Appendix A.

27 Therefore, using Collision History + Speed to get the Multiplier Factor.

28 The overall risk is then determined as:

Measured PV2 x Multiplier Factor = Total Score

29 Therefore the Total Score ranks the schools based upon the exposure to risk and the potential severity of injury taking into consideration mean average speeds at the start and end of the school day.

School Rankings

30 With the methodology described above, it is possible to rank each school according to the Total Scores. For example ‘School A’ generated a total score of 914, being the highest priority, whereas the ‘School H’ generated a total score of 19, being the lowest priority as shown below. Appendix A: Multiplier Factor

Combined value of Weighing applicable Factor criteria 1 1.000 25 10.283 49 91.193 2 1.210 26 11.262 50 99.874 3 1.331 27 12.334 51 109.382 4 1.464 28 13.508 52 119.796 5 1.610 29 14.794 53 131.200 6 1.772 30 16.203 54 143.690 7 1.949 31 17.745 55 157.370 8 2.144 32 19.434 56 172.351 9 2.358 33 21.285 57 188.759 10 2.594 34 23.311 58 206.729 11 2.853 35 25.530 59 226.409 12 3.139 36 27.961 60 247.964 13 3.453 37 30.622 61 271.570 14 3.782 38 33.538 62 297.423 15 4.142 39 36.730 63 325.738 16 4.536 40 40.227 17 4.968 41 44.057 18 5.441 42 48.251 19 5.959 43 52.844 20 6.526 44 57.875 21 7.147 45 63.385 22 7.828 46 69.419 23 8.573 47 76.028 24 9.389 48 83.266 3-4pm) &

(average 8-9am within within (5pts) (6pts) 200m 200m 200m between (3pts) 200m 200m within within (3pts) (4pts) 200m (1pts) (2pts) 200m 200m (4pts)

Appendix 5: Evaluation of Additional Schools

within within accident accident within within 33+=5pts) Accidents Accidents

accident serious accident serious / /

Serious Serious Accidents Accidents

/ / Road 24-33=3pts,

fatal slight Former fatal slight Ranking School Name Town Type of School District Fatal Fatal Slight

Slight Distributor occupant occupant occupant occupant / (0-24=1pts, Cycling, Cycling Cycling, Cycling, / / / / Factor Main speed Ped Ped vehicle vehicle Ped Ped vehicle vehicle Score to Near PV2 Child Child Adult Adult Child Child Adult Adult Mean Multiplier Total 1 Nevilles Cross Primary Nevilles Cross Durham Primary / Junior √ 136.9 2 1 5 3 2 22 24.7 65 53,492 2 New College Durham Durham College √ 53.7 1 3 2 4 19 29.8 54 7,716 Framwellgate 3 Framwellgate School Moor Durham Secondary / 6th Form College √ 88.88 1 3 2 4 5 27.0 40 3,575 4 Byron College Peterlee Easington College √ 49.77 1 2 2 4 12 25.5 45 3,155 Our Lady of the Rosary RCVA 5 Primary Peterlee Easington Primary / Junior √ 49.77 1 2 2 4 12 25.5 45 3,155 6 St. Bede's RC Comp + 6th Peterlee Easington Secondary / 6th Form College √ 49.77 1 2 2 4 12 25.5 45 3,155 Chester-le- 7 Pelton Community Primary Pelton Street Primary / Junior √ 15.46 1 1 1 7 3 14 30.6 51 1,691 8 St. Joseph's RCVA Primary (Stanley) Stanley Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 42.06 4 1 1 4 2 23.0 35 1,074 Framwellgate 9 Framwellgate Moor Primary Moor Durham Primary / Junior √ 88.88 1 1 2 1 4 27.0 25 914 10 St. Leonard's Catholic School + 6th Durham Durham Secondary / 6th Form College √ 51.18 1 2 3 1 11 18.5 31 908 11 Consett Academy (new site) Consett Derwentside Secondary / 6th Form College √ 62.4 1 2 1 8 29.3 27 770 12 Easington Colliery Primary Easington Colliery Easington Primary / Junior √ 22.35 1 2 1 1 1 9 24.5 36 625 13 Annfield Plain Junior Annfield Plain Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 62.36 1 1 3 3 23.7 24 586 St. Bede's Catholic School & 6th 14 Form College Lanchester Derwentside Secondary / 6th Form College √ 32.48 1 1 3 13 47.1 31 576 15 Cockton Hill Bishop Auckland Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 94.5 1 3 3 20.3 18 514 16 Shield Row Primary Shield Row Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 21.01 1 2 1 2 9 25.4 34 490 17 Teesdale School Barnard Castle Teesdale Secondary / 6th Form College √ 62.66 4 2 26.3 21 448 18 Whitworth Park School + 6th College Spennymoor Sedgefield Secondary / 6th Form College √ 18.37 1 3 1 1 9 22.4 33 391 19 Annfield Plain Infant School Annfield Plain Derwentside Infant / Nursery √ 62.36 1 3 1 1 23.7 19 372 Our Lady & St. Thomas RCVA 20 Primary Willington Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 34.09 2 3 1 4 35.8 24 320 21 Ropery Walk Primary Seaham Easington Primary / Junior √ 19.16 1 2 4 4 14.0 29 283 22 Seaham Harbour Nursery Seaham Easington Infant / Nursery √ 19.16 1 2 4 4 14.0 29 283 23 Delves Lane Primary Consett Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 50.82 2 1 4 25.4 18 277 24 Green Lane C of E Primary Barnard Castle Teesdale Primary / Junior √ 62.66 3 1 26.3 15 260 Chester-le- 25 Sacriston Primary Sacriston Street Primary / Junior √ 46.85 1 1 10 24.6 18 255 Our Lady Star of the Sea RCVA 26 Primary Horden Easington Primary / Junior √ 4.36 2 3 1 1 3 5 23.1 44 252 Tanfield School (Science & 27 Engineering) Tanfield Lea Derwentside Secondary / 6th Form College √ 42.06 2 2 4 30.6 19 251 Chester-le- 28 Chester-le-Street C of E Primary Chester-le-Street Street Primary / Junior √ 23.4 2 1 1 2 1 1 13.9 25 241 29 Shotton Hall Academy Peterlee Easington Secondary / 6th Form College √ 43.43 1 1 6 28.8 15 180 30 Shotton Hall Primary Peterlee Easington Primary / Junior √ 43.43 1 1 6 28.8 15 180 31 Easington Academy Easington Village Easington Secondary / 6th Form College √ 48.26 1 7 28.0 13 167 Chester-le- 32 Roseberry Primary Pelton Street Primary / Junior √ 30 1 2 1 27.1 18 163 33 Willington Primary Willington Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 8.93 1 2 1 1 2 4 14.9 31 158 34 Shotton Primary Shotton Colliery Easington Primary / Junior √ 28.31 1 1 5 26.5 18 154 St. Helen Auckland Community 35 Primary St Helen Auckland Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 13.13 1 2 2 5 29.5 26 148 36 St. Margaret's C of E Primary Durham Durham Primary / Junior √ 51.18 2 6 23.9 11 146 37 Middlestone Moor Primary Spennymoor Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 11.64 2 1 1 9 23.5 27 144 38 Benfieldside Primary Consett Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 12.33 1 1 4 7 17.5 26 139 St. Patrick's RCVA Primary (Langley 39 Moor) Langley Moor Durham Primary / Junior √ 33.46 1 1 2 31.1 15 139 40 Brandon Community Primary Brandon Durham Primary / Junior √ 46.12 1 2 25.4 11 132 Chester-le- 41 St. Bede's RCVA Primary Sacriston Street Primary / Junior √ 19.32 1 2 8 24.7 18 105 Durham Johnson Comprehensive + 42 6th Crossgate Moor Durham Secondary / 6th Form College √ 76.91 0 27.5 3 102 43 Staindrop C of E Primary Staindrop Teesdale Primary / Junior √ 11.42 2 1 1 3 29.0 22 89 44 Howletch Lane Primary Peterlee Easington Primary / Junior √ 39.41 1 2 27.5 8 84 Chester-le- 45 Woodlea Primary Bournmoor Street Primary / Junior √ 19.51 1 1 7 23.8 15 81 46 Belmont C of E (Controlled) Junior Belmont Durham Primary / Junior √ 5.04 1 1 2 2 9 18.6 29 75 47 Belmont Durham Secondary / 6th Form College √ 5.04 1 1 2 2 9 18.6 29 75 48 Belmont Infant Belmont Durham Infant / Nursery √ 5.04 1 1 2 2 9 18.6 29 75 49 Browney Primary Browney Durham Primary / Junior √ 46.12 2 32.3 5 74 50 Blackhall Colliery Primary Blackhall Colliery Easington Primary / Junior √ 4.39 2 2 1 13 12.1 30 71 51 Wingate Junior Wingate Easington Primary / Junior √ 18.66 1 4 2 23.8 14 71 Chester-le- 52 Edmondsley Primary Edmondsley Street Primary / Junior √ 24.16 2 4 27.1 11 69 53 Toft Hill Primary Toft Hill Teesdale Primary / Junior √ 23.77 10 23.5 11 68 54 Collierley Primary Dipton Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 37.09 3 27.4 6 66 Chester-le- 55 Park View School (lower school) Chester-le-Street Street Secondary / 6th Form College √ 32.35 4 31.8 7 63 56 Silver Tree Primary Ushaw Moor Durham Primary / Junior √ 9.56 2 1 1 26.6 20 62 St. Joseph's RCVA Primary (Ushaw 57 Moor) Ushaw Moor Durham Primary / Junior √ 9.56 2 1 1 26.6 20 62 58 Stephenson Way Community Primary Newton Aycliffe Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 19.15 1 1 1 25.8 12 60 59 Tanfield Lea Community Primary Tanfield Lea Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 40.01 1 28.7 4 59 60 Oxhill Nursery Oxhill Derwentside Infant / Nursery √ 2.48 1 7 13 25.4 34 58 61 Peterlee College Peterlee Easington College √ 4.54 1 2 2 1 3 39.7 27 56 62 Crook Nursery Crook Wear Valley Infant / Nursery √ 16.87 1 1 4 22.3 12 53 Chester-le- 63 Fyndoune Community College Sacriston Street Secondary / 6th Form College √ 22.44 1 2 26.2 9 53 64 St. Andrew's Primary South Church Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 7.16 1 1 13 27.0 21 51 65 North Park Primary Spennymoor Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 8.55 1 1 2 2 25.2 19 51 St. Joseph's Catholic Primary 66 (Murton) Murton Easington Primary / Junior √ 14.37 1 1 3 28.6 13 50 67 All Saints RCVA Primary Lanchester Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 39.42 1 23.8 2 48 68 Endowed Parochial Primary Lanchester Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 39.42 1 23.8 2 48 69 Dean Bank Primary & Nursery Ferryhill Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 4.84 1 2 2 18.8 23 41 70 Wingate Nursery Wingate Easington Infant / Nursery √ 18.66 1 3 21.4 8 40 71 South Stanley Infant South Stanley Derwentside Infant / Nursery √ 7.28 2 1 1 2 25.8 18 40 72 South Stanley Junior South Stanley Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 7.28 2 1 1 2 25.8 18 40 73 Staindrop School Staindrop Teesdale Secondary / 6th Form College √ 11.42 2 2 28.6 13 39 74 St. Stephen's C of E Primary Willington Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 12.52 1 7 22.1 12 39 St. Joseph's RCVA Primary 75 (N/Aycliffe) Newton Aycliffe Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 7.04 1 1 1 5 28.6 18 38 76 Parkside Sports College Willington Wear Valley Secondary / 6th Form College √ 34.09 0 22.1 1 34 77 Gilesgate Primary Gilesgate Durham Primary / Junior √ 14.19 1 3 22.5 9 33 78 Seascape Primary Peterlee Easington Primary / Junior √ 16.62 1 2 14.7 7 32 79 Langley Park Primary Langley Park Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 9.37 1 2 4 23.3 13 32 80 Catchgate Primary Catchgate Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 20.88 1 31.8 4 31 81 Gilesgate Sports College + 6th Gilesgate Durham Secondary / 6th Form College √ 12.87 1 3 22.5 9 30 82 Houghall College Durham Durham College √ 15.1 1 38.5 7 29 83 Durham School Durham Durham Private School √ 21.67 2 20.2 3 29 84 St. Charles' RCVA Primary Tudhoe Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 12.16 1 3 25.3 9 29 85 Fishburn Primary Fishburn Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 9.07 1 5 30.5 12 28 Chester-le- 86 St. Benet's RCVA Primary Ouston Street Primary / Junior √ 8.94 1 1 1 21.9 12 28 87 Woodham Burn Community Primary Newton Aycliffe Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 19.15 1 21.2 4 28 88 Tudhoe Colliery Primary Tudhoe Moor Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 16.48 1 28.1 4 24 89 Burnopfield Primary Burnopfield Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 17.77 0 29.2 3 24 90 Broom Cottages Primary & Nursery Ferryhill Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 9.83 1 3 25.8 9 23 91 Pupil Referral Unit – Ferryhill Ferryhill Sedgefield Special Needs √ 9.83 1 3 27.5 9 23 92 Easington C of E Primary Easington Village Easington Primary / Junior √ 8.53 1 1 28.5 9 20 93 The Grove Primary The Grove Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 4.43 1 1 2 1 13.8 16 20 94 Aycliffe Village Primary Newton Aycliffe Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 14.14 2 22.1 3 19 Greenfield Community College 95 (Art/Sci) Newton Aycliffe Sedgefield Secondary / 6th Form College √ 7.04 1 1 34.4 10 18 96 Durham High School Durham Durham Private School √ 4.82 1 1 35.1 14 18 Wellfield College of Maths & 97 Computing Wingate Easington Secondary / 6th Form College √ 3.66 1 4 4 23.8 17 18 Chester-le- 98 Lumley Junior Lumley Street Primary / Junior √ 4.8 1 1 1 24.5 13 17 99 Oakley Cross Primary West Auckland Teesdale Primary / Junior √ 8.22 1 24.3 7 16 100 Belmont Cheveley Park Primary Belmont Durham Primary / Junior √ 8.8 1 1 25.7 6 16 101 Ox Close Primary Spennymoor Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 15.36 0 21.6 1 15 102 Consett Derwentside College √ 1.73 1 1 1 2 4 28.1 23 15 103 Beechdale Nursery Consett Derwentside Infant / Nursery √ 10.1 1 1 12.0 4 15 104 Consett Junior Consett Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 10.1 1 1 12.0 4 15 105 Kirk Merrington Primary Kirk Merrington Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 10.96 0 26.2 3 15 106 Victoria Lane Academy Coundon Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 3.33 1 3 3 25.8 15 14 St. Joseph's RCVA Primary 107 (Blackhall) Blackhall Colliery Easington Primary / Junior √ 4.39 2 1 2 12.8 12 14 108 Coxhoe Primary Coxhoe Durham Primary / Junior √ 9.75 2 19.2 3 13 109 St. Oswald's CE (Aided) Infant Durham Durham Infant / Nursery √ 8.71 1 20.2 4 13 110 Wolsingham Primary Wolsingham Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 7.48 2 27.4 5 12 111 Witton Gilbert Primary Witton Gilbert Durham Primary / Junior √ 6.07 1 3 23.6 7 12 112 St. Joseph's RCVA Primary Coundon Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 3.33 1 3 3 23.4 13 11 113 St. Pius X RCVA Primary The Grove Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 4.43 1 2 1 14.2 10 11 114 Tow Law Millennium Primary Tow Law Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 2.53 1 1 4 23.6 16 11 Sedgefield Community College 115 (sports) Sedgefield Sedgefield Secondary / 6th Form College √ 11.34 0 21.0 1 11 116 Sedgefield Hardwick Primary Sedgefield Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 11.34 0 21.0 1 11 117 St. Patrick's RCVA Primary (Dipton) Dipton Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 8.42 0 27.3 3 11 118 St. Cuthbert's RCVA Primary (Crook) Crook Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 6.58 1 22.0 5 11 & Community 119 College Wolsingham Wear Valley Secondary/6th Form College √ 7.48 0 27.4 3 10 120 St. Mary's RCVA Primary (Blackhill) Blackhill Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 5.57 1 1 23.4 6 10 121 Timothy Hackworth Primary Shildon Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 5.06 1 1 24.5 7 10 122 Sunnybrow Primary Sunnybrow Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 4.48 1 2 25.8 8 10 123 St. Godric's RCVA Primary (Durham) Newton Hall Durham Primary / Junior √ 3.03 3 3 24.5 12 10 Chester-le- 124 Red Rose Primary Chester-le-Street Street Primary / Junior √ 5.72 4 13.5 5 9 125 Howden-le-Wear Primary Howden-le-Wear Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 5.11 1 27.3 6 9 Our Lady & St. Joseph's RCVA 126 Primary Leadgate Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 4.2 1 3 25.7 8 9 Chester-le- 127 Ouston Primary Ouston Street Primary / Junior √ 8.94 0 22.9 1 9 St. Mary's RCVA Primary (South 128 Moor) South Moor Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 1.97 1 1 1 3 26.1 16 9 Sunnydale Community College 129 (Maths) Shildon Sedgefield Secondary / 6th Form College √ 5 3 25.6 6 9 130 West Rainton Primary West Rainton Durham Primary / Junior √ 2.88 1 3 34.8 11 8 131 Ribbon Academy Murton Easington Primary / Junior √ 3.82 1 1 27.0 8 8 132 St. John's C of E Primary (Shildon) Shildon Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 5 2 19.3 5 8 133 Blue Coat C of E Junior Newton Hall Durham Primary / Junior √ 4.41 1 1 24.7 6 8 134 Sherburn Village Primary Sherburn Village Durham Primary / Junior √ 5.2 1 24.7 4 8 135 Bishop Ian Ramsey C of E Primary Medomsley Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 4.28 1 1 26.2 6 8 136 Copeland Road Primary West Auckland Teesdale Primary / Junior √ 3.62 1 2 24.3 7 7 137 Sherburn Hill Primary Sherburn Hill Durham Primary / Junior √ 1.7 1 1 5 28.6 15 7 138 Laurel Avenue Community Primary Gilesgate Moor Durham Primary / Junior √ 5.18 0 24.3 3 7 139 Hunwick Primary Hunwick Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 3.8 1 1 24.6 6 7 140 St. Godric's RCVA Primary (Thornley) Thornley Durham Primary / Junior √ 2.51 1 2 25.5 10 7 141 Crook Primary Crook Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 2.06 1 1 4 22.3 12 6 Chester-le- 142 Nettlesworth Primary Nettlesworth Street Primary / Junior √ 3.23 1 2 29.1 7 6 143 Ferryhill Station Primary Ferryhill Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 4.03 0 29.0 3 5 Ferryhill Business & Enterprise 144 College Ferryhill Sedgefield Secondary / 6th Form College √ 2.75 2 36.6 7 5 145 Trimdon Grange Infant & Nursery Trimdon Grange Sedgefield Infant / Nursery √ 2.16 1 2 26.4 9 5 146 Blessed John Duckett RCVA Primary Tow Law Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 2.53 2 36.1 7 5 147 Leadgate Community Junior Leadgate Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 2.07 1 3 24.9 9 5 148 Byerley Park Primary Newton Aycliffe Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 2.69 5 19.0 6 5 149 Pittington Primary Pittington Durham Primary / Junior √ 1.54 1 1 2 23.7 11 4 150 Bloemfontein Primary The Middles Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 2.72 0 33.3 5 4 151 Durham Community Business College Ushaw Moor Durham Secondary / 6th Form College √ 2.87 0 30.7 3 4 152 The Studio (DCBC 6th Form College) Ushaw Moor Durham Secondary / 6th Form College √ 2.87 0 30.7 3 4 153 Langley Moor Primary Langley Moor Durham Primary / Junior √ 0.8 1 1 6 24.7 16 4 154 Montalbo Primary Barnard Castle Teesdale Primary / Junior √ 3.6 0 21.4 1 4 Our Lady Queen of Martyrs RCVA 155 Primary Esh Winning Durham Primary / Junior √ 2.05 1 2 24.0 5 3 156 Peases West Primary Billy Row Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 1.68 1 28.8 7 3 St. Michael's RCVA Primary Esh 157 Laude Esh Village Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 2.99 0 22.3 1 3 158 Shincliffe C of E Primary Shincliffe Durham Primary / Junior √ 2.84 0 21.5 1 3 159 Finchale Primary Newton Hall Durham Primary / Junior √ 2.12 0 25.5 3 3 160 South Hetton Primary South Hetton Easington Primary / Junior √ 1.56 1 29.2 6 3 161 Trimdon Village Community Infant Trimdon Village Sedgefield Infant / Nursery √ 1.64 1 23.9 4 2 162 Wheatley Hill Community Primary Wheatley Hill Easington Primary / Junior √ 2.4 0 15.8 1 2 163 Frosterley Community Primary Frosterley Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 1.42 1 23.8 4 2 164 St. Mary Magdalen's RCVA Primary Seaham Easington Primary / Junior √ 1.48 0 25.8 3 2 165 Bowburn Infant & Nursery Bowburn Durham Infant / Nursery √ 0.32 1 1 10 25.5 18 2 166 St. William's RCVA Primary Trimdon Village Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 1.74 0 23.9 1 2 167 Trimdon Junior Trimdon Village Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 1.74 0 23.9 1 2 168 West Cornforth Primary West Cornforth Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 0.47 1 1 25.9 12 1 Middleton-in- 169 Middleton-in-Teesdale Primary Teesdale Teesdale Primary / Junior √ 0.86 1 1 18.2 5 1 170 Ingleton C of E Primary Ingleton Teesdale Primary / Junior √ 0.82 2 27.8 5 1 171 Sedgefield Primary Sedgefield Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 0.45 2 4 20.7 11 1 172 Hesleden Primary Hesleden Easington Primary / Junior √ 0.91 0 25.2 3 1 173 Chilton Primary Chilton Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 0.82 1 19.0 3 1 174 Esh C of E Primary Esh Village Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 1.09 0 22.3 1 1 175 Evenwood C of E Primary Evenwood Teesdale Primary / Junior √ 0.61 3 28.1 6 1 176 St. Thomas More RCVA Primary Belmont Durham Primary / Junior √ 1.03 0 20.2 1 1 177 Our Lady of Lourdes RCVA Primary Shotton Colliery Easington Primary / Junior √ 0.63 2 27.0 5 1 Chester-le- 178 West Pelton Primary West Pelton Street Primary / Junior √ 0.46 1 3 27.8 8 1 179 Cockfield Primary Cockfield Teesdale Primary / Junior √ 0.71 0 26.0 3 1 180 Ebchester C of E Primary Ebchester Derwentside Primary / Junior √ 0.33 1 1 3 16.1 9 1 181 Thornley Primary Thornley Easington Primary / Junior √ 0.76 0 19.2 1 1 182 Tudhoe Moor Nursery Tudhoe Moor Sedgefield Infant / Nursery √ 0.32 1 1 30.6 8 1 183 Thornhill Primary Shildon Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 0.19 1 1 1 17.7 13 1 St. Mary's RCVA Primary (Barnard 184 Castle) Barnard Castle Teesdale Primary / Junior √ 0.6 0 19.2 1 1 185 Deaf Hill Primary Trimdon Station Easington Primary / Junior √ 0.52 0 21.2 1 1 186 Stanhope Barrington C of E Primary Stanhope Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 0.51 0 20.0 1 1 187 Esh Winning Primary Esh Winning Durham Infant / Nursery √ 0.5 0 18.9 1 1 188 Kelloe Primary Kelloe Durham Primary / Junior √ 0.25 2 1 21.9 6 0.4 189 Primary Cotherstone Teesdale Primary / Junior √ 0.28 1 20.6 2 0.3 190 Bowburn Junior Bowburn Durham Primary / Junior √ 0.2 0 22.2 1 0.2 191 Ramshaw Primary Ramshaw Teesdale Primary / Junior √ 0.13 1 26.5 4 0.2 192 Stanley Crook Primary Stanley Crook Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 0.1 0 36.3 5 0.2 193 UTC South Durham Newton Aycliffe Sedgefield Secondary / 6th Form College √ 0.1 0 33.9 5 0 194 Cassop Primary Cassop Durham Primary / Junior √ 0.1 0 28.7 3 0 195 Prince Bishop's Community Primary Close House Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 0.08 0 28.6 3 0 196 Hutton Henry C of E Primary Hutton Henry Easington Primary / Junior √ 0.1 0 22.6 1 0.1 Startforth Morritt Memorial C of E 197 Primary Startforth Teesdale Primary / Junior √ 0.08 0 22.6 1 0 198 Witton-le-Wear Primary Witton -le-Wear Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 0.06 0 25.5 3 0.1 199 The Oaks School Spennymoor Sedgefield Special Needs √ 0.01 1 2 1 3 21.6 21 0.1 200 Rosemary Lane Nursery Easington Village Easington Infant / Nursery √ 0.05 0 28.5 3 0.1 201 Escomb Primary Escomb Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 0.05 0 21.9 1 0.1 202 St. Mary's RCVA Primary (Wingate) Wingate Easington Primary / Junior √ 0.01 1 1 1 1 28.2 16 0.05 203 Woodland Primary Woodland Teesdale Primary / Junior √ 0.03 0 30.6 3 0.04 204 Villa Real School Consett Derwentside Special Needs √ 0.01 1 1 2 31.2 11 0.03 205 Butterknowle Primary Butterknowle Teesdale Primary / Junior √ 0.02 0 24.2 3 0.03 206 St. Chad's RCVA Primary Witton Park Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 0.02 0 26.4 3 0.03 207 The Crofts Annfield Plain Derwentside Special Needs √ 0.02 0 30.5 3 0.03 208 Bowes Hutchinson's C of E Primary Bowes Teesdale Primary / Junior √ 0.02 0 19.7 1 0.02 209 The Meadows School Spennymoor Sedgefield Special Needs √ 0.01 0 35.0 5 0.02 210 Wearhead Primary Wearhead Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 0.01 2 27.9 5 0.02 211 Windlestone School Chilton Sedgefield Special Needs √ 0.01 0 33.4 5 0.02 St. Michael's C of E Primary (Bishop 212 Middleham) Bishop Middleham Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 0.01 1 12.6 4 0.01 213 Walworth School Newton Aycliffe Sedgefield Special Needs √ 0.01 1 27.7 4 0.01 214 Barnard Castle School Barnard Castle Teesdale Private School √ 0.01 0 31.9 3 0.01 Forest in 215 Forest of Teesdale Primary Teesdale Teesdale Primary / Junior √ 0.01 0 30.7 3 0.01 216 Hamsterley Primary Hamsterley Teesdale Primary / Junior √ 0.01 0 27.0 3 0.01 217 Byers Green Primary Byers Green Sedgefield Primary / Junior √ 0.01 0 23.1 1 0.01 218 Rookhope Primary Rookhope Wear Valley Primary / Junior √ 0.01 0 23.4 1 0.01 Chester-le- 219 Lumley Medway Infant & Nursery Lumley Street Infant / Nursery √ 4.8 0 0 0 220 Aclet Close Nursery Bishop Auckland Wear Valley Infant / Nursery x 221 Beamish Primary No Place Derwentside Primary / Junior x 222 Bearpark Primary Bearpark Durham Primary / Junior x Not evaluated as not on

223 (Spennymoor) Spennymoor Sedgefield College x main distributor roads Chester-le-

224 Bournmoor Primary Bournmoor Street Primary / Junior x 225 Burnhope Primary Burnhope Derwentside Primary / Junior x 226 Burnside Primary Stanley Derwentside Primary / Junior x 227 Castleside Primary Castleside Derwentside Primary / Junior x Durham Trinity School & Sports

228 College Aykley Heads Durham Special Needs x 229 Elemore Hall School Pittington Durham Special Needs x 230 Gainford C of E Primary Gainford Teesdale Primary / Junior x 231 Glendene Arts Academy Easington Easington Special Needs x 232 Hartside Primary Crook Wear Valley Primary / Junior x 233 Horndale Infant Newton Aycliffe Sedgefield Infant / Nursery x 234 Ludworth Primary Ludworth Durham Primary / Junior x 235 Moorside Primary Castleside Derwentside Primary / Junior x 236 New Brancepeth Primary New Brancepeth Durham Primary / Junior x 237 Real Life College (special needs) Consett Derwentside College x 238 St. Francis C of E Junior Newton Aycliffe Sedgefield Primary / Junior x 239 St. John's Chapel Primary St Johns Chapel Wear Valley Primary / Junior x 240 St. Wilfrid's RCVA Primary Bishop Auckland Wear Valley Primary / Junior x 241 The Choristers Durham Durham Private School x