The Development of the Roman Missal: Fostering the Growth Of
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ROMAN MISSAL: FOSTERING THE GROWTH OF THE ORDINARY AND EXTRAORDINARY FORMS OF THE ROMAN RITE Thesis Submitted to The College of Arts and Sciences of the UNIVERSITY OF DAYTON In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for The Degree of Master of Arts in Theological Studies By Alexander Dennis Long Dayton, Ohio August, 2016 THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ROMAN MISSAL: FOSTERING THE GROWTH OF THE ORDINARY AND EXTRAORDINARY FORMS OF THE ROMAN RITE Name: Long, Alexander Dennis APPROVED BY: ___________________________ William H. Johnston, Ph.D. Committee Chair ___________________________ Michael S. Carter, Ph.D. Committee Member ___________________________ Sandra A. Yocum, Ph.D. Committee Member ___________________________ Daniel S. Thompson, Ph.D. Department Chair ii © Copyright by Alexander Dennis Long All Rights Reserved 2016 iii ABSTRACT THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ROMAN MISSAL: FOSTERING THE GROWTH OF THE ORDINARY AND EXTRAORDINARY FORMS OF THE ROMAN RITE Name: Long, Alexander Dennis University of Dayton Advisor: Dr. William H. Johnston This study seeks to examine the development of the Roman missal in order to contribute to the discussion of the methods and potential changes for the Holy Mass. The task for us in this work involves analyzing several key areas in order to understand the foundations for liturgical growth and demonstrate how these foundation can be applied in order to facilitate the growth of the Roman missal. Our first goal is to examine the historical account of how the Roman missal has developed, which is seen through what is called “organic development.” This often involves growth from the ground up; a gradual process that usually begins on the local level. Through the passage of time, some liturgical features mature and graft themselves onto the liturgy in a more permanent fashion, which may then be adopted Church-wide beyond the more local boundaries where it grew. Often, these developments have as their motivation some type of pastoral response involving the current situation in the Church. Therefore, this study will also examine the Liturgical Movement of the 20th century leading into the reforms of the Second Vatican Council. This pastoral maneuver establishes the precedent to move the Roman missal out of its nearly 400 year stagnation since the Tridentine reforms and respond to the need to generate the “active iv participation” of the laity. The movement quickly developed into a Church-wide entity calling for not only education and intelligent involvement with the Roman missal, but also a call to enact reforms and revisions to the Holy Mass in order to better facilitate this “active participation.” The concept of “active participation” and the laity was the banner of the 20th century liturgical changes and is still one of the major focuses today. Our study will also analyze and attempt to derive from the concept of “active participation” several subcategories. This is in an effort to identify other forms of active participation, which reveals the interior, individual, and unitive aspects that see “active participation” as not merely belonging to the category of external physical activity. This is an important feature to fully understand, as the 20th century reforms were based largely upon active participation and any future reforms and restorations should revolve around a better understanding of the major pastoral foundation of the liturgical renewal. Having established the foundations for our work, the organic development of the liturgy and the pastoral desires of the Church with regards to active participation, we will then examine the necessity to continue the development and reform of the Roman missal. This is explained by firstly investigating the Extraordinary Form, or what is essentially the Roman missal of 1962 which Pope Benedict XVI authorized for a wider use in the Church. Here, we will argue that it should continue its development, moving out of the year 1962, and follow Benedict XVI’s vision of its enrichment derived from the “Ordinary Form” or the reformed Roman missal of Paul VI. Conversely, pastoral issues surrounding the Ordinary Form will be examined in order to justify the reform and enrichment it can derive from the Extraordinary Form. The potential future development of each form of the Roman missal will be followed by various examples of how this process may begin and what fruits it may bear in the near future. The proposals given here will take into account the organic development of the liturgy, the pastoral desire of the Church with emphasis on the active participation of the lay faithful, the edification of the Body of Christ, and the glorification of God. v ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would first wish to thank my thesis director Dr. William Johnston for all of work in guiding me and being patient in the face of my personal issues. I would also like to thank my readers, Dr. Sandra Yocum and Dr. Michael Carter for their assistance and patience as well. My heartfelt gratitude is also extended to Ms. Jessica Kozack for the time she has dedicated in proofreading this work. I especially would like to thank my family, and above all my mother, who have helped to support me and put up with my struggles. A very special and grateful thanks to the man who helped lead me into the Catholic faith; St. Padre Pio. Finally, and above all, I give the most supreme gratitude to the Blessed Virgin Mary and the Most Holy Trinity. vi TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT .................................................................................................................................... iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ............................................................................................................ vi INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................................... 1 The Organic Growth of the Roman Missal .................................................................................. 1 The Liturgical Movement ............................................................................................................ 3 Active Participation ..................................................................................................................... 4 Development of the Roman Missal .............................................................................................. 5 CHAPTER I: ORGANIC DEVELOPMENT .................................................................................. 7 Introduction .................................................................................................................................. 7 Organic Development: An Overview .......................................................................................... 8 Limits and Harmful Developments ........................................................................................ 10 Organic Development’s Instruments of Growth .................................................................... 11 The Four Principles of Organic Development ........................................................................... 12 Innovations ............................................................................................................................. 12 Simplifications ....................................................................................................................... 14 Restorations............................................................................................................................ 16 Eliminations ........................................................................................................................... 18 Summary of the General Principles of Organic Development ............................................... 20 Problematic Understandings of Liturgical Development ........................................................... 21 Antiquarianism ....................................................................................................................... 21 Restoration vs. Antiquarianism .............................................................................................. 23 Fabrications and Splicing ....................................................................................................... 26 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................. 27 CHAPTER II: THE LITURGICAL MOVEMENT ....................................................................... 30 Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 30 The 20th Century Liturgical Movement: A Pastoral Response ................................................. 32 The Eve of the Modern Liturgical Movement: St. Pius X ..................................................... 33 Dom Lambert Beauduin ............................................................................................................. 36 Pope Pius XI: Divini Cultus ....................................................................................................... 39 vii The Continuing Movement ........................................................................................................ 41 Virgil Michel .......................................................................................................................... 41 Fr. Roger Schoenbechler’s Overview of the Liturgical Movement ......................................