Sidney I. Lezak: an Oral History

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Sidney I. Lezak: an Oral History Sidney I. Lezak: An Oral History i ii Sidney I. Lezak An Oral History FOREWORD BY JUDGE OWEN PANNER US District Court of Oregon Historical Society Oral History Project Portland, Oregon iii Copyright © 2013 United States District Court of Oregon Historical Society Printed in the United States of America PROJECT STAFF Janice Dilg, Editor & Production Manager Jack Collins, Interviewer Brongaene M. Griffin, Transcriber Muriel Lezak, Auditor & Editor iv CONTENTS Foreword..................................................................................................................vi Tape One, August 16, 1988....................................................................................1 Tape Two, August 16, 1988...................................................................................16 Tape Three, December 14, 1988............................................................................27 Tape Four, December 14, 1988..............................................................................41 Tape Five, September 7, 1989................................................................................49 Tape Six, June 6, 1990............................................................................................65 Tape Seven, June 6, 1990.......................................................................................77 Tape Eight, June 6, 1990........................................................................................95 v FOREWORD The Oral History Project of the District Court of Oregon Historical Society began in 1983. Through the efforts of Judge James Burns and his wife Helen, a gathering of lawyers, judges, and historians took place at the Society’s inception. The Honorable Robert F. Peckham, District Judge for the Northern District of California, discussed the Northern District Historical Society and the inspiration was born for Oregon’s District Court Historical Society, the second such organization in the country. The original Board of Directors of the Society was composed of twenty-one members with bylaws including the Presiding Judge of the Court, the Chief Justice of the Oregon Supreme Court, and the President and a representative of the Oregon State Bar. The original officers and directors included outstanding judges and lawyers – Judge John Kilkenny, Honorary Chair, Judge James Burns, Chairman, Randall Kester, President, Manley Strayer, Vice President, Elizabeth Buehler, Treasurer, Susan Graber, Corporate Secretary, and Robert M. Christ, Executive Secretary, along with many other top names in Oregon’s legal history. The Society decided to collect, study, preserve, analyze, and disseminate information concerning the history, development, character, operations, and accomplishments of the United States District Court for the District of Oregon. It was therefore logical that the Oral History Project should be established to preserve the histories of the judges, law firms, and lawyers who actively practice in the Court. With the assistance of Rick Harmon and James Strassmaier, the Oregon Historical Society held seminars to educate volunteers in taking oral histories with a biographical and Court-oriented focus. The Oregon Historical Society has been most vi cooperative in agreeing to maintain these histories in their permanent collection for study by scholars and other interested parties. These oral history interviews have been taken by recording devices, and are either transcribed or transcription is underway. A transcript reproduces, as faithfully as possible, the original sound recording that reflects the special value of oral history, namely its free and personal expressiveness. Most of the transcripts in the District Court Collection have been lightly edited and reviewed for clarity and accuracy by the narrators. That process continues. It is through these wonderful oral histories that the story of the Court is told. We now have recorded nearly 120 individuals since the project began. The goal is to record the individual histories of all the judges of the Court, as well as those of participating lawyers. The Court has a rich tradition reflected in the activities of the judges and lawyers of the Court. The recording has been done not only by professional historians, but also by dedicated volunteers. As one such volunteer said, “The opportunity to interview someone that you always admired is truly an exciting experience.” The history of the Court is being created by the men and women who have participated in its collection and activities. The Society’s goals are to collect as much of that history as possible, because is it the history of the law and those who make it that constitutes the moral development of humanity. All of us who are students of the law venerate it. We are also interested in the people who make it. Judge Owen Panner February 28, 2006 vii viii SL: Okay. Alright. I have every confidence Tape One in the Historical Society in meeting that JC: This is the oral history project of the commitment and on that understanding United States District Court for the District I’m willing to go ahead. I have nothing at of Oregon. We’re going to be talking this the moment that I specifically can think afternoon with Sidney I. Lezak the former of but something may come up; and I do United States Attorney for the District of have a feeling that on some stuff that may Oregon, to cover at least an earlier period be delicate that I nonetheless would like of his life up until and including his to have the whole story out but I may not appointment as United States Attorney want it to be public right now. for the District of Oregon. Sidney is that right? SL: Well let’s see—born November 8, 1924, and I assume you’d like to know SL: It certainly is. It’s certainly an a little about my ancestry. Mother and appropriate aspiration. father both were born in the same small city which was in, what was called the JC: The way we’d like to proceed this Pale of Settlement in Czarist Russia, the afternoon is in a narrative fashion, city is called Vasylkiv [or Vasylkov, which beginning back and ending in the question: was how Sid’s family pronounced it. How did you get to be United States MDL]. It’s about 30 miles outside of the Attorney? But, that began much earlier city of Kiev. I recall that they had to have in Chicago, Illinois. Give us some of the a special pass to go into the city of Kiev. biographical details that take you back to My parents came over at—let’s see, my Chicago before you came to Oregon. mother was 10, came over about 1910 on the Lusitania. My father came over in 1911 SL: At this point I don’t have any problem and at that time he was 14 years old. with having anything that I say be made There’s a story or two from that era public. I just want to know at some point, that made a difference in my life. Perhaps in the event that I get on territory that a digression might be worthwhile. My might be difficult—particularly in terms of father told me about getting a pass about anything I may have to say about people the age of eight to go in with his family who are still living—whether or not there’s to Kiev and remembers having his first ice any control that I have over this. cream cone. At about that time a group of drunks came through, in a kind of what JC: Yes. In that event we can mark those might be called a “mini” pogrom, through portions of the tape and simply say that the Jewish quarter, breaking windows those will not be disclosed during the lives and beating up on people around. He of any persons or during your life. remembered running into the back of a Lezak, Tape One 1 butcher’s shop where they were killing they had minimal amounts of money, chickens and hiding amidst all the blood just enough to pay their passage. I think and guts and sawdust of the chickens my father came with just a few cents in and enjoying his ice cream. I’ve always his pocket, for example, when he arrived taken that as a sort of measuring point in this country. They were poor people. from which to measure any success My mother’s father was a blacksmith. that I’ve had in my career and have My father’s father was a butcher in the marveled at the progress which has been old country and that was the trade that possible in this country within the space all of the brothers ultimately followed. of one generation. It just seemed to me Each one ultimately had his own meat a particularly poignant memory of my market on the south side of Chicago in father’s past. the Black neighborhood. My father was no exception. JC: Did your mother and father at young ages come with their parents? JC: They came through Ellis Island? SL: My mother came with her parents and SL: Through Ellis Island, yes, and they her younger sister and brother; I think had contacts in Gary, Indiana which, at her family came intact. My father came that time, was a town that had just been with his father and four or five of his founded maybe 15 years before for the brothers. My father had seven brothers steel mills. And my father’s family came and one sister [living to adulthood; his to Gary. My mother’s family came to grandmother, his father’s second wife, Chicago. One of my uncles remained in had 21 births], and I think that two Gary and had a meat market in Gary until brothers and one younger sister were WWII. left behind with the grandmother. They did not come over until after WWI and JC: Was there any change in the spelling after the revolution. I think in the early of the family name of Lezak? 1920’s there was a distinct lapse and it— it was indicated by different colorations SL: Well, the family spelling would have of political viewpoints between the older either been in Yiddish or Cyrillic and not brothers and the younger brothers. in the characters that we now know and accept. But the pronunciation was, “Lay- JC: Did your parents give you any shock,” and it might more appropriately explanation of their coming? have been LEZHAK or something like that, a softer Z.
Recommended publications
  • Iqbal Brief: Barr Amicus Brief
    No. 07-1015 IN THE Supreme Court of the United States __________ JOHN D. ASHCROFT, former Attorney General of the United States, and ROBERT MUELLER, Director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, Petitioners, v. JAVAID IQBAL, et al., Respondents. __________ On Writ of Certiorari to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit __________ BRIEF OF WILLIAM P. BARR, GRIFFIN BELL, BENJAMIN R. CIVILETTI, EDWIN MEESE III, WILLIAM S. SESSIONS, RICHARD THORNBURGH, AND WASHINGTON LEGAL FOUNDATION AS AMICI CURIAE IN SUPPORT OF PETITIONERS __________ Paul J. Larkin, Jr. Daniel J. Popeo 1314 Cleveland St. Richard A. Samp Alexandria, VA 22302 (Counsel of Record) (703) 931-1704 Washington Legal Foundation 2009 Mass. Ave, NW Washington, DC 20036 (202) 588-0302 Date: September 5, 2008 QUESTION PRESENTED 1. Whether a conclusory allegation that a cabinet-level officer or high-ranking official knew of, condoned, or agreed to subject a plaintiff to allegedly unconstitutional acts purportedly committed by subordinate officials is sufficient to state individual- capacity claims against those officials under Bivens. 2. Whether a cabinet-level officer or other high- ranking official may be held personally liable for the allegedly unconstitutional acts of subordinate officials on the ground that, as high-level supervisors, they had constructive notice of the discrimination allegedly carried out by such subordinate officials. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Page TABLE OF AUTHORITIES................... iv INTERESTS OF AMICI CURIAE ...............1 STATEMENT OF THE CASE..................3 SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT ..................5 ARGUMENT...............................11 I. THE DECISION BELOW IMPROPERLY PERMITS COMPLAINTS TO PROCEED TO DISCOVERY BASED ON MERE CONCLUSORY ASSERTIONS OF WRONGDOING.......................11 II.
    [Show full text]
  • Bad Cops: a Study of Career-Ending Misconduct Among New York City Police Officers
    The author(s) shown below used Federal funds provided by the U.S. Department of Justice and prepared the following final report: Document Title: Bad Cops: A Study of Career-Ending Misconduct Among New York City Police Officers Author(s): James J. Fyfe ; Robert Kane Document No.: 215795 Date Received: September 2006 Award Number: 96-IJ-CX-0053 This report has not been published by the U.S. Department of Justice. To provide better customer service, NCJRS has made this Federally- funded grant final report available electronically in addition to traditional paper copies. Opinions or points of view expressed are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the official position or policies of the U.S. Department of Justice. This document is a research report submitted to the U.S. Department of Justice. This report has not been published by the Department. Opinions or points of view expressed are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the official position or policies of the U.S. Department of Justice. Bad Cops: A Study of Career-Ending Misconduct Among New York City Police Officers James J. Fyfe John Jay College of Criminal Justice and New York City Police Department Robert Kane American University Final Version Submitted to the United States Department of Justice, National Institute of Justice February 2005 This project was supported by Grant No. 1996-IJ-CX-0053 awarded by the National Institute of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, U.S. Department of Justice. Points of views in this document are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the official position or policies of the U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Get a Clue (Pdf)
    get a guide for incoming students incoming for guide a a clue a clue a get get a clueclue a get GETa clue GETnews Want to know where to find news and information about events? How Eugene is known as a center of do-it-yourself publications, but for information about some study tips or where to get involved on campus? Needing a on what to do, where to go, what time, and anything else under the sun, it is always advisable to check out sources you can trust. music break and want to know where to find it? As an incoming student and a new resident of the area, it can be tough to find the hot places to eat The Register Guard: Published seven days a week, the Guard provides local, national or the cool places to hike. This guide can help you out with that. It’s filled and international news with everything you can expect from a city daily. Fifty cents with tips, tidbits, restaurants, campus and city events, study hints, and on weekdays and Saturday and $1.25 on Sunday, the Guard has special student everything else we could think of that we wished we had known when we subscription rates. You will surely see sales reps outside the bookstore and in the got here. Use it, abuse it, read it cover to cover if you please, or check it out residence halls at the start of each term. if you happen to be bored. Whatever you do, let it help you get a clue about The Oregonian: Also published seven days a week out of Portland, The Oregonian what is going down in Eugene.
    [Show full text]
  • Fewer Hands, More Mercy: a Plea for a Better Federal Clemency System
    FEWER HANDS, MORE MERCY: A PLEA FOR A BETTER FEDERAL CLEMENCY SYSTEM Mark Osler*† INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................... 465 I. A SWAMP OF UNNECESSARY PROCESS .................................................. 470 A. From Simplicity to Complexity ....................................................... 470 B. The Clemency System Today .......................................................... 477 1. The Basic Process ......................................................................... 477 a. The Pardon Attorney’s Staff ..................................................... 478 b. The Pardon Attorney ................................................................ 479 c. The Staff of the Deputy Attorney General ................................. 481 d. The Deputy Attorney General ................................................... 481 e. The White House Counsel Staff ................................................ 483 f. The White House Counsel ......................................................... 484 g. The President ............................................................................ 484 2. Clemency Project 2014 ................................................................ 485 C. The Effect of a Bias in Favor of Negative Decisions ...................... 489 II. BETTER EXAMPLES: STATE AND FEDERAL .......................................... 491 A. State Systems ................................................................................... 491 1. A Diversity
    [Show full text]
  • Stanley E. Weber Interviewer: Charles T
    Stanley E. Weber Oral History Interview –JFK #1, 2/12/1966 Administrative Information Creator: Stanley E. Weber Interviewer: Charles T. Morrissey Date of Interview: February 12, 1966 Place of Interview: Portland, Oregon Length: 33 pp. Biographical Note Weber, Stanley E.; Journalist, Oregon Journal. Weber discusses John F. Kennedy’s [JFK] presidential campaign and primary in Oregon (1960). He discusses his role in JFK’s campaign as the secretary of the Kennedy for President Committee in Oregon, and he touches upon campaign issues such as labor and Catholicism, among other issues. Access Restrictions No restrictions. Usage Restrictions According to the deed of gift signed June 12, 1968, copyright of these materials has passed to the United States Government. Users of these materials are advised to determine the copyright status of any document from which they wish to publish. Copyright The copyright law of the United States (Title 17, United States Code) governs the making of photocopies or other reproductions of copyrighted material. Under certain conditions specified in the law, libraries and archives are authorized to furnish a photocopy or other reproduction. One of these specified conditions is that the photocopy or reproduction is not to be “used for any purpose other than private study, scholarship, or research.” If a user makes a request for, or later uses, a photocopy or reproduction for purposes in excesses of “fair use,” that user may be liable for copyright infringement. This institution reserves the right to refuse to accept a copying order if, in its judgment, fulfillment of the order would involve violation of copyright law.
    [Show full text]
  • Records Officer
    Metro Councilor Caroline Miller District 8, 1979 to 1980 Oral History Caroline Miller Metro Councilor, District 8 1979 – 1980 Caroline Miller grew up in Santa Monica, California, to a Costa Rican mother and American father. Eventually she made her way to Oregon where she enrolled as a student at Reed College and received her Bachelor of Arts and later, her Masters of Arts in Teaching. She also received a second Masters of Arts degree in Literature from the University of Arizona, Flagstaff. After graduating, Ms. Miller adventured to England, Europe and Africa, eventually teaching in England and Rhodesia. (Zimbabwe). Upon her return to Oregon, after working as a teacher at Wilson High School (Portland), she applied her talents and education to political pursuits, heading the Portland Federation of Teachers #111 and lobbying for education in 1977. Ms. Miller’s credentials in the political arena grew as she assumed the role of the first woman Parliamentarian for the Oregon AFL/CIO Conventions; campaigned actively for Neil Goldschmidt (mayoral campaign); served on the City of Portland Economic Advisory Committee; and won a seat on the Metropolitan Service District (MSD) Council in 1979 (representing District 8). Caroline Miller’s journey through the public spectrum continued when she became a Multnomah County commissioner in 1980. After leaving political office in 1988, Ms. Miller became a volunteer mediator for the Multnomah County court system – a position that she held for over seventeen years. She also pursued a writing career and became a published author of short fiction stories. In addition, Ms. Miller’s artistic interests have resulted in installations of her silk paintings in galleries around Portland.
    [Show full text]
  • Mathieu Deflem
    Curriculum Vitae Mathieu Deflem (August 2021) University of South Carolina Department of Sociology 911 Pickens Street ColumBia, SC 29208 [email protected] (803) 777 3123 www.mathieudeflem.net ACADEMIC EMPLOYMENT 2002– Professor (since 2010), Associate Professor (2005–2010), Assistant Professor (2002–2005), Department of Sociology, University of South Carolina, ColumBia, SC. 1997–2002 Assistant Professor of Sociology, Department of Sociology and Anthropology, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN. 1996–1997 Visiting Assistant Professor of Sociology and Law and Society, Department of Anthropology & Sociology, Kenyon College, GamBier, OH. 1989–1996 Pre-doctoral positions: Research Assistant (1992–1995), Teaching Assistant (1995), Instructor (1996), Department of Sociology, University of Colorado, Boulder, CO; Assistant (1989–1992), Afdeling Strafrecht, Strafvordering en Criminologie (Department of Criminal Law, Criminal Procedure, and Criminology), Katholieke Universiteit te Leuven, Belgium. EDUCATION 1996 Ph.D. Sociology, University of Colorado, Boulder, CO. Dissertation: “Borders of Police Force: Historical Foundations of International Policing Between Germany and the United States.” 1990 M.A. Sociology of Developing Societies, University of Hull, England. Thesis: “Processual SymBolic Analysis in the Work of Victor W. Turner.” 1987 Special Diploma Social and Cultural Anthropology (M.A. equivalent), Katholieke Universiteit te Leuven, Belgium. Thesis: “Antropologie van de Ruimte” (Dutch: “The Anthropology of Space”). 1986 Licentiate
    [Show full text]
  • US Representative, 5Th District - Democratic Party - Vote for One
    Unofficial results Cumulative Results Marion County, Oregon Registered Voters Official Election Results May 15, 2018 Primary Election 44886 of 194881 = 23.03 % Run Time 3:28 PM Precincts Reporting Run Date 05/16/2018 5/15/2018 123 of 123 = 100.00 % Page 1 of 93 US Representative, 5th District - Democratic Party - Vote for one Choice Party Ballots Cast Total Peter Wright 2311 13.78% 2311 13.78% Kurt Schrader 14389 85.82% 14389 85.82% Mark Callian (W) 1 0.01% 1 0.01% Lassi (W) 1 0.01% 1 0.01% Robert Reynolds (W) 8 0.05% 8 0.05% Pam Marsh (W) 2 0.01% 2 0.01% Clluffy Be Jorn (W) 1 0.01% 1 0.01% Joey Nations (W) 14 0.08% 14 0.08% Mark Callahan (W) 32 0.19% 32 0.19% Shelley Hanson (W) 1 0.01% 1 0.01% Dave McTeague (W) 1 0.01% 1 0.01% Robert L Reynolds 3 0.02% 3 0.02% (W) Andrea Williams (W) 1 0.01% 1 0.01% Erin P Baker (W) 1 0.01% 1 0.01% Dennis Richardson 1 0.01% 1 0.01% (W) Cast Votes: 16767 100.00% 16767 100.00% Undervotes: 1181 1181 Overvotes: 1 1 Unresolved write-in votes: 61 61 Governor - Democratic Party - Vote for one Choice Party Ballots Cast Total Ed Jones 2058 12.09% 2058 12.09% Kate Brown 13303 78.18% 13303 78.18% Candace Neville 1424 8.37% 1424 8.37% Tina Kotek (W) 1 0.01% 1 0.01% Jeff Smith (W) 2 0.01% 2 0.01% Teresa Alonso Leon 1 0.01% 1 0.01% (W) Bud Pierce (W) 2 0.01% 2 0.01% Knute Blum (W) 1 0.01% 1 0.01% Knute Bueler (W) 1 0.01% 1 0.01% Nicholas Parker (W) 1 0.01% 1 0.01% Audrey Broyles (W) 1 0.01% 1 0.01% Unofficial results Cumulative Results Marion County, Oregon Registered Voters Official Election Results May 15, 2018
    [Show full text]
  • Pastor's Ponderings
    The Beacon NEWS AND INFORMATION | FBC ALVARADO, TX JULY - AUGUST 2019 Pastor’s Ponderings Church Events July 1-31 Back Pack Drive for AISD We’ve always seemed to have a fascination for things that are connected with famous people. Leonardo da Vinci’s 72 page journal named the Codex July 3 No Activities Hammer was sold to billionaire Bill Gates in 1994 for a cool $30.8 million. Some of Elvis Presley’s hair went for $15k at auction in 2009, much reduced from the $115k July 4 Church Office / Daycare Closed price tag some sold for only 7 years earlier. His Bible was also sold -- it brought Youth Party @ Farmers 6 PM - 10 PM $94k. An original drawing of Winnie-the-Pooh’s The Hundred Acre Wood map, and 4 other sketches created by E.H. Shepard in 1926 was auctioned last year for July 5 Church Office Closed $600k. These things are valuable because they once belonged to someone significant. July 7 Deacon’s Breakfast 8:00 AM While I write this I’m studying 1Peter 2 in preparation for a sermon on the passage. One phrase stands out to me in particular -- 1Pt.2:9 says, …you are a… people for His own possession… Yes, I know that some translations render it, a July 12-13 GA Lock-In 6:00 PM - 10:00 AM peculiar people, but the word refers to a private possession. As He entered into covenant with the Israelites at Sinai, God told them July 20 Youth Service Project that you shall be my treasured possession among all peoples… (Ex.19:5) Several times throughout the OT God reminds His people that they are valuable because July 23-27 RA/GA Camp they belong to Him.
    [Show full text]
  • Sherrill Genealogy
    THE SHERRILL GENEALOGY THE DESCENDANTS OF SAMUEL SHERRILL OF EAST HAMPTON, LONG ISLAND NEW YORK BY CHARLES HITCHCOCK SHERRILL SECOND AND REVISED EDITION COMPILED AND EDITED BY LOUIS EFFINGHAM de FOREST CoPnxG:e:T, 1932, :BY CHARLES IDTCHCOCK SHERRILL THE TUTTLE, MOREHOUSE & TAYLOR COMPANY, KEW KA.VEN, CONK. SHERRILL THIS BOOK IS DEDICATED TO MY SHERRILL ANCESTORS WHO SERVED THE STATE EITHER LOCALLY OR NATIONALLY AND TO MY DESCENDANTS WHO SHALL ALSO DO SO TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE.. Editorial Note . vu Introduction ......................................•... 1 First Generation ..................................... 24 Second Generation . .............••... 31 Third Generation ....................................• 34 Fourth Generation . •• 41 Fifth Generation . 58 Sixth Generation . 98 Seventh Generation ................................... 151 Eighth Generation . ............................. 201 Ninth Generation .................................... 229 Tenth Generation . .................. 236 Bibliography . ................. 237 Index of Persons . ............... 241 V EDITORIAL NOTE The first edition of this work was compiled by Charles Hitchcock Sherrill and published privately by him in the year 1894. In this second and revised edition General Sherrill has written the entire Introduction and First Generation which are signed with his name. The editor assumes the usual responsibility for the remainder of the book and hopes that it will be acceptable to the Sherrills and to his fellow genealogists. The arrangement of material is the one generally found in modem genealogies. Each head of a family is given a number, in a sequence beginning with the first settler who is No. 1. By looking ahead to the given number the succeeding generation will 4 be found. The superior or raised numbers ( as Jonathan ) indicate the degree of descent from the founder of the family in America. The usual abbreviations are used.
    [Show full text]
  • FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE August 3, 2012
    WLF News Release Washington Legal Foundation Advocate for freedom and justice® 2009 Massachusetts Avenue, NW Washington, DC 20036 202.588.0302 FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE August 3, 2012 FORMER ATTORNEYS GENERAL URGE DISMISSAL OF CONSTITUTIONAL CHALLENGE TO FOREIGN SURVEILLANCE STATUTE (Clapper v. Amnesty International USA, No. 11-1025) A bipartisan group of six former Attorneys General yesterday urged the U.S. Supreme Court to throw out a lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of a 2008 federal statute that expanded the authority of federal officials to engage in overseas electronic surveillance. In a High Court brief drafted by the Washington Legal Foundation (which also joined in the brief), the group argued that allowing the case – filed by individuals and organizations that are not permissible surveillance targets – to proceed to trial threatens to interfere with efforts to protect national security. WLF’s brief was written with the substantial pro bono assistance of Megan Brown, Claire Evans, and Matthew Dowd of Washington, D.C.’s Wiley Rein LLP. The former Attorneys General who signed the brief were John D. Ashcroft, William P. Barr, Benjamin Civiletti, Edwin Meese III, Michael B. Mukasey, and Dick Thornburgh. The brief was filed in support of the Obama Administration, which has asked the Supreme Court to overturn a decision of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit reinstating the suit. WLF and its clients argued in their brief that the appeals court erred in concluding that the plaintiffs have suffered a cognizable injury and thus have standing to assert their claims. The Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA), adopted by Congress in 1978, governs the conduct of “electronic surveillance” for national security purposes.
    [Show full text]
  • Nancy Buenger Abstract
    Nancy Buenger Abstract HOME RULE: EQUITABLE JUSTICE IN PROGRESSIVE CHICAGO AND THE PHILIPPINES ______________________________________________________________________________ The evolution of the US justice system has been predominantly parsed as the rule of law and Atlantic crossings. This essay considers courts that ignored, disregarded, and opposed the law as the United States expanded across the Pacific. I track Progressive home rule enthusiasts who experimented with equity in Chicago and the Philippines, a former Spanish colony. Home rule was imbued with double meaning, signifying local self-governance and the parental governance of domestic dependents. Spanish and Anglo American courts have historically invoked equity, a Roman canonical heritage, to more effectively administer domestic dependents and others deemed lacking in full legal capacity, known as alieni juris or of another’s right. Thomas Aquinas described equity as the virtue of setting aside the fixed letter of the law to expediently secure substantive justice and the common good. In summary equity proceedings, juryless courts craft discretionary remedies according to the dictates of conscience and alternative legal traditions—such as natural law, local custom, or public policy—rather than the law’s letter. Equity was an extraordinary Anglo American legal remedy, an option only when common law remedies were unavailable. But the common law was notably deficient in the guardianship of alieni juris. Overturning narratives of equity’s early US demise, I document its persistent jurisdiction over quasi-sovereign populations, at home and abroad. Equity, I argue, is a fundamental attribute of US state power that has facilitated imperial expansion and transnational exchange. Nancy Buenger Please do not circulate or cite without permission HOME RULE: EQUITABLE JUSTICE IN PROGRESSIVE CHICAGO AND THE PHILIPPINES _____________________________________________________________________________________ Progressive home rule enthusiasts recast insular and municipal governance at the turn of the twentieth century.
    [Show full text]