Nitrifiers and Their Contribution to Oxygen Consumption in Lake Erie
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Nitrifiers and their contribution to oxygen consumption in Lake Erie A dissertation submitted to Kent State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy By Curtis Clevinger November 2013 Dissertation written by Curtis C. Clevinger B.A., Hiram College, 1993 M.S., University of Texas at Austin, 1999 Ph.D, Kent State University, 2013 Approved by: Darren L. Bade Darren L. Bade. Chair Doctoral Dissertation Committee Members Doctoral Dissertation Committee Laura G. Leff Laura G. Leff Helen Piontkivska Helen Piontkivska Joseph Ortiz Joseph Ortiz Mietek Jaroniec Mietek Jaroniec Accepted by: Laura G. Leff Chair, Department of Biological Sciences Janis H. Crother Dean, College of Arts and Sciences ii Table of Contents LIST OF FIGURES------------------------------------------------------------------ v LIST OF TABLES------------------------------------------------------------------- vii DEDICATION------------------------------------------------------------------------ x ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS--------------------------------------------------------- x CHAPTER 1: General introduction------------------------------------------------ 1-31 Nitrification------------------------------------------------------- 1 Hypoxia ----------------------------------------------------------- 7 Study System ---------------------------------------------------- 9 Lake Erie History: Hypoxia and the link to phosphorus -- 11 Post GLWQA----------------------------------------------------- 13 Hypothesis-------------------------------------------------------- 15 Research Question----------------------------------------------- 15 Works Cited------------------------------------------------------- 17 CHAPTER 2: Ammonia oxidizing bacteria and archaea abundance and distribution in Lake Erie------------------------------------------------------------- 32-68 Abstract------------------------------------------------------------ 33 Introduction------------------------------------------------------- 35 iii Materials and Methods------------------------------------------ 38 Results------------------------------------------------------------- 43 Discussion--------------------------------------------------------- 47 Works Cited------------------------------------------------------- 53 CHAPTER 3: Nitrification and oxygen use due to nitrification in the water column and sediments of Lake Erie------------------------------------------------ 69-122 Abstract------------------------------------------------------------ 70 Introduction------------------------------------------------------- 72 Materials and Methods------------------------------------------ 74 Results------------------------------------------------------------- 82 Discussion--------------------------------------------------------- 89 Works Cited------------------------------------------------------- 100 CHAPTER 4: Conclusions---------------------------------------------------------- 123-134 iv LIST OF FIGURES CHAPTER 1: General introduction Figure 1: Bathymetry of Lake Erie and Lake St. Claire-- 30 Figure 2: Lake Erie Stratification---------------------------- 31 CHAPTER 2: Ammonia oxidizing bacteria and archaea abundance and distribution in Lake Erie Figure 3: Lake Erie study sample site----------------------- 64 Figure 4: Total nitrifiers and AOA to AOB ratio in the water column of Lake Erie----------------------------------- 65 Figure 5: Total nitrifiers and AOA to AOB ratio in the sediments of Lake Erie---------------------------------------- 66 Figure 6: Total nitrifiers in the epilimnion and hypolimnion sites that had repeated temporal sampling-- 67 Figure 7: Relationship between total nitrifiers in the epilimnion and hypolimnion and oxygen used due to nitrification ----------------------------------------------------- 68 v CHAPTER 3: Nitrification and oxygen use due to nitrification in the water column and sediments of Lake Erie Figure 8: Oxygen consumption rate and oxygen consumed due to nitrification in the hypolimnion of a longitudinal transect------------------------------------------- 116 Figure 9: Respiration rate and percentage of total oxygen use due to nitrification in the hypolimnion------- 117 Figure 10: Oxygen consumption rate and oxygen consumed due to nitrification in the epilimnion of a longitudinal transect------------------------------------------- 118 Figure 11: Respiration rate and percentage of total oxygen use due to nitrification in the epilimnion---------- 119 Figure 12. Total oxygen use by Nitrosomonas europaea cells in artificial lake water----------------------------------- 120 Figure 13: Oxygen use by Nitrobacter winogradskyi cells in artificial lake water----------------------------------- 121 Figure 14: The effect of additional nitrifiers on epilimnion nitrification rates--------------------------------- 122 vi LIST OF TABLES CHAPTER 1: General introduction Table 1: Reactions involved in the oxidation of ammonia to nitrate--------------------------------------------- 28 Table 2: GPS locations of study sample site-------------- 29 CHAPTER 2: Ammonia oxidizing bacteria and archaea abundance and distribution in Lake Erie Table 3. Sampling regime in Lake Erie 2008-2010. ----- 61 Table 4: Pearson correlation coefficients between total nitrifiers, environmental variables and nitrification rates in the epilimnion and hypolimnion-------------------------- 62 Table 5: Totals nitrifiers in the sediments with repeated sampling at selected sites in Lake Erie--------------------- 63 CHAPTER 3: Nitrification and oxygen use due to nitrification in the water column and sediments of Lake Erie Table 6: Rate of oxygen consumption, SD, and % of oxygen use due to nitrification in hypolimnion samples from Lake Erie 2009------------------------------------------ 107 vii Table 7: Rate of oxygen consumption, SD, and % of oxygen use due to nitrification in epilimnion samples from Lake Erie 2009------------------------------------------ 108 Table 8: Correlations between measured environmental variables, total oxygen consumption, nitrification rate, and % of oxygen use due to nitrification in the hypolimnion---------------------------------------------------- 109 Table 9: Correlations between measured environmental variables, total oxygen consumption, nitrification rate, and % of oxygen use due to nitrification in the epilimnion------------------------------------------------------- 110 Table 10: Correlations between measured environmental variables, total oxygen consumption, nitrification rate, and % of oxygen use due to nitrification in the water column----------------------------- 111 Table 11: Rate of oxygen consumption, SD, and % of oxygen use due to nitrification in sediment slurries from Lake Erie 2009------------------------------------------------- 112 Table 12: Rate of oxygen consumption, SD, %of oxygen use due to nitrification in intact sediments from viii Lake Erie 2009. ------------------------------------------------ 113 Table 13: Oxygen consumption due to ammonia oxidation and nitrite oxidation in sediment slurry samples from Lake Erie--------------------------------------- 114 Table 14: Oxygen consumption due to ammonia oxidation and nitrite oxidation in water column samples from Lake Erie. ------------------------------------------------ 115 ix Dedication: To family and friends who believed in me. Acknowledgements: I wish to acknowledge my funding sources: NSF, Ohio Sea Grant R/ER082 and Kent State Graduate Student Senate. My committee members, Darren Bade, Robert T.Heath, Laura Leff, Helen Piontkivska, and Joseph Ortiz have been invaluable resources in this great journey. I also thank Heather Kirkpatrick, Josh Smith, Jennifer Clevinger, Moumita Moitra, numerous undergraduate assistants, the captains and crews of RV Lake Guardian, RV Erie Monitor, and CCG Limnos for their laboratory and field assistance. In addition I thank many of my fellow graduate students from the Bade lab, L.Leff lab, Mou lab, and Blackwood lab for their moral and technical support. x CHAPTER 1 Hypothesis, objectives and general introduction Nitrification Nitrification is the oxidization of ammonium to nitrite and nitrate in a process that consumes oxygen and generates a small amount of energy that organisms can use to fix inorganic carbon. Nitrification yields a small amount of energy, produces nitrate, and consumes oxygen (2 moles of oxygen per mole of ammonium). This is the basis of my measurements of nitrification rates later in this paper by measuring the consumption of oxygen. Nitrification is a two-step process. First ammonia is oxidized to nitrite by ammonia oxidizing bacteria (AOB) or by ammonia oxidizing archaea (AOA): - + NH3 +3/2O2 NO2 + H + H2O And then to nitrate by nitrite oxidizing bacteria (NOB): - - NO2 +1/2 O2 NO3 The classification of nitrifiers differs depending on whether a traditional view or a more modern molecular viewpoint is used. Traditionally, nitrifying bacteria have been lumped together into one group, the family Nitrobacteriaceae. Further divisions were based on the ability to oxidize ammonia or nitrite, and morphological features such as cell size, shape and arrangements of membranes (Watson et al. 1989). This arrangement is contradictory to the more recent molecular phylogenetics based primarily on 16s rRNA and the differences in the key enzyme systems involved (Purkhold et al. 2000). 1 2 Nitrifiers, with the exception of Nitrospina and Nitrospira, which are distantly related to methane oxidizing bacteria, are related to photoautotrophs. There were