Copyright by David Lawrence Coleman 2005
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Copyright by David Lawrence Coleman 2005 The Dissertation Committee for David Lawrence Coleman certifies that this is the approved version of the following dissertation: Pleasant Fictions: Henry Peach Robinson’s Composition Photography Committee: Michael J. Charlesworth, Supervisor Linda D. Henderson Janice Leoshko Charles R. Rossman Richard A. Shiff PLEASANT FICTIONS: HENRY PEACH ROBINSON’S COMPOSITION PHOTOGRAPHY by David Lawrence Coleman, B.A., M.A. Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of the University of Texas at Austin in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy The University of Texas at Austin December 2005 For Sally Acknowledgements I owe many thanks to dozens of professors, colleagues and friends who have aided me during the course of researching and writing this dissertation. I am most grateful to my advisor, Michael Charlesworth, for the wealth of intellectual insight and guidance he has offered to me. I also thank the rest of my dissertation committee Linda Henderson, Janice Leoshko, Charles Rossman and Richard Shiff, for their helpful feedback and suggestions. Over the past several years my colleagues at the Harry Ransom Center have offered me tremendous support. My deepest gratitude goes to Thomas Staley, who has been extremely generous with resources and who supported my position at the Center while I pursued my doctoral studies. I also wish to thank Roy Flukinger for his willingness to hear my thoughts and for his generous commentary. Linda Briscoe Myers has also been enormously helpful. Many staff at various European collections and institutions offered me access to their holdings and made suggestions for further research. These include: Pam Roberts and Samantha Johnson at the Royal Photographic Society (formerly in Bath), Michael Rowlands and Ian Beavis at the Tunbridge Wells Museum and Art Gallery, and Jane Fletcher and Brian Liddy at the National Museum of Photography, Film and Television. I would also like to thank the staff at the Albert I Royal Library (Brussels), the British v Library and the National Art Library—Victoria and Albert Museum for their generous service. I would also like to thank Roger Taylor and Stephen Joseph for their warm hospitality while I was researching in England and Belgium, and for sharing their knowledge of nineteenth-century photography. I also thank my parents, Jean and George Coleman, for their tremendous love and encouragement. None of this, however, would have been possible without the sustained support of my wife, Sally Whitman Coleman. She has devoted immeasurable energy and made countless sacrifices not only in support of this dissertation but also in the care of our children, Lydia and Robert. I dedicate this dissertation to her. vi Pleasant Fictions: Henry Peach Robinson’s Composition Photography Publication No. _________ David Lawrence Coleman, Ph.D. The University of Texas at Austin, 2005 Supervisor: Michael J. Charlesworth Henry Peach Robinson (1830-1901) was one of the most prolific and vocal advocates of photography’s possible status as a fine art in nineteenth-century Great Britain. While previous scholarship has asserted that Robinson applied painting theory to photographic practice and fostered a pictorial idealism, this dissertation looks at the strategies photographic techniques Robinson used to fulfill this artistic potential. It then examines the implications and limitations his theory of photographic imitation imposed upon his imagery. Robinson’s manual for artistic photography, Pictorial Effect in Photography (1869), blended elements from Sir Joshua Reynolds’ Discourses (1769-1790), picturesque theory vii and John Burnet’s Treatise on Painting (1837) to encourage photographers to create more aesthetic imagery by conforming to academic pictorial standards. Robinson advocated a hybrid of fact and artifice to achieve this goal, and he produced a variety of photographic compositions by combining multiple negatives and by using painted backgrounds, dressed models and artificial props. Robinson’s deliberate manipulations were significantly controversial for those within the photographic and artistic communities who viewed photography as an unmediated record of the visible world. Robinson’s strategies of pairing his images with poetry and employing genre subjects encouraged his audience to judge his photographs by their conformity to pictorial standards rather than by their fidelity to nature. Painters had used poetry to elevate the estimation of their works, and Robinson imitated this practice to promote photography as an expressive medium. Rustic genre subjects turned his photographs away from their temporal specificity and toward typologies of industry, frugality and piety. In examining these seemingly simple images of pretty maids and content cottagers, we find deeply imbedded social values regarding differences between levels of franchisement, wealth and property rights. Although poetic associations and genre subjects were common in British painting, this dissertation demonstrates that Robinson nonetheless had difficulty negotiating the balance between painting’s conventionality and photography’s link to external reality—evidence that he was unable to counteract completely photography’s intractable documentation of its time and place. viii Table of Contents List of Illustrations xi Introduction 1 State of Current Research and Methodology 4 Aesthetic theory – Joshua Reynolds 13 Aesthetic theory – John Burnet 19 Aesthetic theory – John Ruskin 21 The Picturesque 27 Chapter 1: Defining the Fictive Space 41 Introduction 41 Combination Printing 44 Theory of Photographic Imitation 87 Utility and Positivism 100 A Variety of Fakery 104 Chapter 2: Poetry and the Fictive Space 114 Introduction 114 Fading Away 118 The Lady of Shalott 136 Sleep 155 Chapter 3: Robinson’s Genre Subjects 164 Introduction 164 Genre Painting in Britain 173 Robinson’s Genre Photography 184 Tradition and Continuity 185 Frugality and Industriousness 195 Piety 201 Family / Cycle of Life 203 Class Stability 204 Sympathy 213 Analysis 217 Models 224 Illustrations 238 Appendix A: The Lady of Shalott (1842) by Alfred Tennyson 316 ix Appendix B: Tristram and Iseult (1852) by Matthew Arnold 319 Appendix C: Bibliography of Nineteenth-Century Journal Articles 328 Bibliography 378 Vita 385 x List of Illustrations 1. John Burnet, Plate I. Burnet, John. Practical Hints on Composition 238 in Painting, in A Practical Treatise on Painting in Three Parts: consisting of hints on composition, chiaroscuro, and colouring: the whole illustrated by examples from the Italian, Venetian, Flemish and Dutch schools. London: J. Carpenter, 1827. 2. George Grundy & Son, Old Manchester, undated. Harry Ransom 239 Center, University of Texas at Austin. [All subsequent images are found in the Harry Ransom Center, unless otherwise noted.] 3. Henry Peach Robinson, [Landscape with houses], undated. [All 240 subsequent images are by Henry Peach Robinson unless otherwise noted.] 4. [Landscape with houses], undated. RPS Collection, National 241 Museum of Photography, Film & Television, UK. 5. Oscar Rejlander, The Two Ways of Life, 1857. RPS Collection, 242 National Museum of Photography, Film & Television, UK. 6-11. [Photographic sketch for Carolling], c.1887. (Plates 7-11 digitally 243-8 altered by the author.) 12. Oscar Rejlander, St. John the Baptist, c.1858. 249 13. A Holiday in the Wood, 1860. George Eastman House. 250 14. Bringing Home the May, 1862. 251 15. William Frith, Derby Day, 1858. Tate Britain. 252 16. Autumn, 1863. RPS Collection, National Museum of Photography, 253 Film & Television. 17. Watching the Lark, 1868. 254 18. Sleep, 1867. RPS Collection, National Museum of Photography, 255 Film & Television. 19. When the Day’s Work is Done, 1877. 256 xi 20. Little Red Riding Hood, 1858. RPS Collection, National Museum of 257 Photography, Film & Television. 21. Down to the Well, 1864-66. 258 22. On the Hill-Top, c. 1868. Robinson, Henry Peach. Pictorial Effect in 259 Photography. London: Piper & Carter, 1869. 23. Dr. John Percy and John Spiller, The New Mill, Near Lynton, North 260 Devon, 1857. The Photographic Album for the Year 1857: Being Contributions from the Members of the Photographic Club. London: Charles Whittingham, 1857. 24. Lord Alfred Tennyson, The Miller’s Daughter. The Photographic 261 Album for the Year 1857: Being Contributions from the Members of the Photographic Club. London: Charles Whittingham, 1857. 25. Mark Anthony, Wild Flowers, 1856. The Photographic Album for 262 the Year 1857: Being Contributions from the Members of the Photographic Club. London: Charles Whittingham, 1857. 26. Mrs. Sigourney, Untitled poem. The Photographic Album for the 263 Year 1857: Being Contributions from the Members of the Photographic Club. London: Charles Whittingham, 1857. 27. William Lake Price, The Soldier’s Toast, c. 1856. Photographic Art 264 Treasures, or, Nature and art illustrated by art and nature: by this new and beautiful art of engraving, the uncertainty of colour and the liability to fade, so objectionable in photographs, is obviated, while the detail and touch of nature is faithfully preserved. London: Patent Photo-Galvano-Graphic Co., 1856. [The author has modified the scan of this image to increase readability of the text.] 28. Fading Away, 1858. RPS Collection, National Museum of 265 Photography, Film & Television. 29. Fading Away. Harper’s Weekly 2, no. 99 (November 20, 1858): 740. 266 30. Thomas Webster, Sickness and Health, 1843. Victoria