Photographer Pablo Bartholomew's Book on His Father, Acclaimed Art Critic Richard Bartholomew, Is an Attempt to Exorcise Ghost

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Photographer Pablo Bartholomew's Book on His Father, Acclaimed Art Critic Richard Bartholomew, Is an Attempt to Exorcise Ghost THE SUNDAY READ www.mumbaimirror.com/city MumbaiMirror SUNDAY, SEPTEMBER 9, 2012 14 PICTURES: THE ESTATE OF RICHARD BARTHOLOMEW. ALL RIGHT RESERVED. Reema.Gehi suggests that Richard had no @timesgroup.com favourites. He was particularly fond of work put out by Ram lmost 27 years since Kumar, Satish Gujral, MF artist, photographer Husain, Kanwal Krishna, Sailoz and acclaimed art critic Mukherjee, Jeram Patel, A Richard Bartholomew Ramachandran, and Jagmohan A passed away in tragic Chopra. And it is they who ben- circumstances in 1985, his pho- efited most from his writings. tographer-son, Pablo In the name One of the most engaging Bartholomew has compiled a chapters in the book — Politics voluminous book on his work of Art — discusses his battle focussing on art criticism from with the state policy in Delhi 1950 to ’80s. during his tenure as secretary of In a revealing afterword of Lalit Kala Akademi. “I think he the Richard Bartholomew: The Art fought for the artists, the budg- Critic, the 56-year-old Pablo ets, and the kind of shows that recounts, “A stroke took him, at he put together for exhibitions an official meeting at the home of the father abroad. And of course, see that of the head of the arts’ organisa- Photographer Pablo Bartholomew’s book on his father, acclaimed the Triennale happened on tion he served then. Those time,” says Pablo. “There was around him thought it better to no blemish on my father’s let him lie and rest and not take art critic Richard Bartholomew, is an attempt to exorcise ghosts name, but it killed him.” him to hospital. So he lay there He admits that he was unconscious without medical always more concerned about attention and was brought that haunt him. Mirror gets a first look his father’s photography. home hours later in that unex- plained state…” After slipping into coma for 10 days, Richard left his body. A I don’t think my year after his death in 1985, Pablo put together an exhibi- father launched any tion of his father’s Indian and American street photography, in careers. However, he Delhi and Mumbai, as a tribute of some sort. “It was my way to was instrumental in deal with him,” he says over the phone from his Delhi residence. explaining to the Three years on, Pablo tried to make peace with Richard, a man artists what they with whom he shared an infor- mal relationship. “He was an were doing. When easy guy. I was the difficult one,” he adds. Difficult as he may be, Pablo went on to they went wrong, he explore the North Eastern region of India, trying to find wasn’t easy on them traces of his father — once a young Burmese boy displaced Perhaps, that’s why he chose to by the Second World War, who document his Richard’s exhaus- walked into India to escape the tive pictures in a coffee table Japanese. “It became a ten-year book — A Critic’s Eye — in 2009, project which temporarily filled while his recent edition was an emotional void, but never waiting to be tackled. “But this really answered enough,” he is the more important one,” he reflects. says. “It has history, it is a stan- Somewhere, Pablo knew it dard in writing. It is a bench- was imperative that he put mark on how and what criti- Richard’s writings out. Yet, it cism should be. I think it will be took a decade for the family to an important landmark in reconcile. “My mother edited decades to come.” the book, but she was not ready But on a personal level, as he to commit entirely to it, which admits in his afterword, it “is to slowed down the process,” he appease the ancestral spirits, says. “Then, like my father, she exorcise many ghosts that too suffered a stroke. The proj- haunt me and make peace with ect was on hold, till I took it his past that shadows mine.” upon myself.” It took three years to find the visual material, and put the one- A PAGE FROM kilo book together. “Not all of RICHARD’S COPY OF my father’s writings were in one MACBETH MAKES THE place. Newspapers and journals COVER, AND FEATURES across several libraries had to be INTENSE SCRIBBLINGS (CLOCKWISE FROM TOP LEFT) MF Husain, Viswanadhan searched, which took time,” he THAT THE FAMILY HAS and Madhu Jain at the Third Indian Triennale, 1975 points out. After a publisher FAILED TO DECIPHER Pablo says he was always more interested in Richard’s who sat on the project for four photography. Seen here in a picture dated 1960 years backed out, he decided to MF Husain and Ram Kumar publish the book himself in Jehangir and Shirin Sabavala talk to Biren De and GR association with The Raza Santosh at Shridharani Gallery, 1970 Foundation. A formal launch is Tyeb Mehta and Rati Bartholomew at Shridharani slated for September 26 in New Delhi. In many ways, this compila- them repeatedly, so that you can careers. However, he was instrumen- several pieces in the book that tion of Richard’s incisive writing track and map their journeys.” tal in explaining to the artists what reprimand some artists, and in backed with subtext makes a Since Richard was an artist him- they were doing. When they went subsequent reviews, he appreci- readable history of modern self, he knew the craft intrinsically, wrong, he wasn’t easy on them. But ates the direction that they Indian art, and addresses issues could write as a practitioner, and elu- when they turned out something have taken. “So it was never of art and the state. In Pablo’s cidate complex ideas eloquently and good, he appreciated their work and about showering idle praise, words, “It talks about the giants simply. Yet, Pablo, believes, “I don’t contextualised it.” nor was it just negative writ- of modern Indian art; some of think my father launched any For instance, he says, there are ing,” he explains. This no way.
Recommended publications
  • Current Affairs 2013- January International
    Current Affairs 2013- January International The Fourth Meeting of ASEAN and India Tourism Minister was held in Vientiane, Lao PDR on 21 January, in conjunction with the ASEAN Tourism Forum 2013. The Meeting was jointly co-chaired by Union Tourism Minister K.Chiranjeevi and Prof. Dr. Bosengkham Vongdara, Minister of Information, Culture and Tourism, Lao PDR. Both the Ministers signed the Protocol to amend the Memorandum of Understanding between ASEAN and India on Strengthening Tourism Cooperation, which would further strengthen the tourism collaboration between ASEAN and Indian national tourism organisations. The main objective of this Protocol is to amend the MoU to protect and safeguard the rights and interests of the parties with respect to national security, national and public interest or public order, protection of intellectual property rights, confidentiality and secrecy of documents, information and data. Both the Ministers welcomed the adoption of the Vision Statement of the ASEAN-India Commemorative Summit held on 20 December 2012 in New Delhi, India, particularly on enhancing the ASEAN Connectivity through supporting the implementation of the Master Plan on ASEAN Connectivity. The Ministers also supported the close collaboration of ASEAN and India to enhance air, sea and land connectivity within ASEAN and between ASEAN and India through ASEAN-India connectivity project. In further promoting tourism exchange between ASEAN and India, the Ministers agreed to launch the ASEAN-India tourism website (www.indiaasean.org) as a platform to jointly promote tourism destinations, sharing basic information about ASEAN Member States and India and a visitor guide. The Russian Navy on 20 January, has begun its biggest war games in the high seas in decades that will include manoeuvres off the shores of Syria.
    [Show full text]
  • Please Scroll Down for Article
    This article was downloaded by: [Sternberger, Paul] On: 26 February 2009 Access details: Access Details: [subscription number 909051291] Publisher Routledge Informa Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registered office: Mortimer House, 37-41 Mortimer Street, London W1T 3JH, UK Photographies Publication details, including instructions for authors and subscription information: http://www.informaworld.com/smpp/title~content=t778749997 ME, MYSELF AND INDIA Paul Sternberger Online Publication Date: 01 March 2009 To cite this Article Sternberger, Paul(2009)'ME, MYSELF AND INDIA',Photographies,2:1,37 — 58 To link to this Article: DOI: 10.1080/17540760802696971 URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/17540760802696971 PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR ARTICLE Full terms and conditions of use: http://www.informaworld.com/terms-and-conditions-of-access.pdf This article may be used for research, teaching and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic reproduction, re-distribution, re-selling, loan or sub-licensing, systematic supply or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden. The publisher does not give any warranty express or implied or make any representation that the contents will be complete or accurate or up to date. The accuracy of any instructions, formulae and drug doses should be independently verified with primary sources. The publisher shall not be liable for any loss, actions, claims, proceedings, demand or costs or damages whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with or arising out of the use of this material. Paul Sternberger ME, MYSELF AND INDIA Contemporary Indian photography and the diasporic experience Recent Indian photographers have used their medium to reveal, interpret, and influence the multifaceted nature of Indian identity and cross-cultural experiences in India and abroad.
    [Show full text]
  • Open the Magazine
    September 26, 2017September 26, 2017 Search Open Keyword (/) ' Columns Features Essays #Salon Openings Blogs Gallery (https://www.facebook.com/openthemagazine) (/table-of-contents/2017-09-23) $ (https://twitter.com/Openthemag) SUBSCRIBEART (/subscribe) (/digitalmagazine) 02 June 2017 (/page/rss-feeds) (/subscribe)Bonsai Gone Wild 03 JUNE 2017 IN THIS ISSUE (/article/cinema/dobaara- see-your-evil-movie- review) (/article/cinema/a- death-in-the-gunj- movie-review) ∠ ∠ () () (/article/cover- #8 story/what-powers- the-dalit- resurgence) SHARE (/#facebook) $ (/#twitter) &0 HIGHLIGHTS % (/#google_plus) (/#linkedin) (https://www.addtoany.com/share#url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.openthemagazine.com%2Farticle%2Fart- culture%2Fbonsai-gone-wild&title=Bonsai%20Gone%20Wild%20%7C%20OPEN%20Magazine)(/article/art- culture/radhika- apte-i-m-famous- for-the-right- Rosalyn D’Mello (/User/738) reasons) Rosalyn D’Mello is an art critic and the author of A Handbook For My Lover TAGGED UNDER - ( Indian art (/category/tags/indian-art-1) (/article/india/a- ( creativity (/category/tags/creativity-0) crisis-called-rahul) ( exhibition (/category/tags/exhibition-3) ( Noida (/category/tags/noida-0) ( photography (/category/tags/photography-3) ( videos (/category/tags/videos) ( expression (/category/tags/expression-3) (/article/india/the- triple-talaq- Curatorial noise overwhelms this ambitious blowback) exhibition spanning more than eight decades of creative renderings BY THE AUTHOR TO CULTIVATE BONSAI, one must have a studied understanding of botanical anatomy as well as a proclivity towards relative cruelty. What could have been a sprawling tree with unwieldy roots and shade- giving leaves must literally be trimmed to size. Verticality, every tree’s natural predisposition, must be compromised through an intricate process of clamping and trimming with a range of delicate machinery, so it can be reduced to its miniature version.
    [Show full text]
  • Catalogue Fair Timings
    CATALOGUE Fair Timings 28 January 2016 Thursday Select Preview: 12 - 3pm By invitation Preview: 3 - 5pm By invitation Vernissage: 5 - 9pm IAF VIP Card holders (Last entry at 8.30pm) 29 - 30 January 2016 Friday and Saturday Business Hours: 11am - 2pm Public Hours: 2 - 8pm (Last entry at 7.30pm) 31 January 2016 Sunday Public Hours: 11am - 7pm (Last entry at 6.30pm) India Art Fair Team Director's Welcome Neha Kirpal Zain Masud Welcome to our 2016 edition of India Art Fair. Founding Director International Director Launched in 2008 and anticipating its most rigorous edition to date Amrita Kaur Srijon Bhattacharya with an exciting programme reflecting the diversity of the arts in Associate Fair Director Director - Marketing India and the region, India Art Fair has become South Asia's premier and Brand Development platform for showcasing modern and contemporary art. For our 2016 Noelle Kadar edition, we are delighted to present BMW as our presenting partner VIP Relations Director and JSW as our associate partner, along with continued patronage from our preview partner, Panerai. Saheba Sodhi Vishal Saluja Building on its success over the past seven years, India Art Senior Manager - Marketing General Manager - Finance Fair presents a refreshed, curatorial approach to its exhibitor and Alliances and Operations programming with new and returning international participants Isha Kataria Mankiran Kaur Dhillon alongside the best programmes from the subcontinent. Galleries, Vip Relations Manager Programming and Client Relations will feature leading Indian and international exhibitors presenting both modern and contemporary group shows emphasising diverse and quality content. Focus will present select galleries and Tanya Singhal Wol Balston organisations showing the works of solo artists or themed exhibitions.
    [Show full text]
  • General Studies Series
    IAS General Studies Series Current Affairs (Prelims), 2013 by Abhimanu’s IAS Study Group Chandigarh © 2013 Abhimanu Visions (E) Pvt Ltd. All rights reserved. No part of this document may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or any information storage or retrieval system or otherwise, without prior written permission of the owner/ publishers or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright Act, 1957. Any person who does any unauthorized act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil claim for the damages. 2013 EDITION Disclaimer: Information contained in this work has been obtained by Abhimanu Visions from sources believed to be reliable. However neither Abhimanu's nor their author guarantees the accuracy and completeness of any information published herein. Though every effort has been made to avoid any error or omissions in this booklet, in spite of this error may creep in. Any mistake, error or discrepancy noted may be brought in the notice of the publisher, which shall be taken care in the next edition but neither Abhimanu's nor its authors are responsible for it. The owner/publisher reserves the rights to withdraw or amend this publication at any point of time without any notice. TABLE OF CONTENTS PERSONS IN NEWS .............................................................................................................................. 13 NATIONAL AFFAIRS ..........................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • 20Years of Sahmat.Pdf
    SAHMAT – 20 Years 1 SAHMAT 20 YEARS 1989-2009 A Document of Activities and Statements 2 PUBLICATIONS SAHMAT – 20 YEARS, 1989-2009 A Document of Activities and Statements © SAHMAT, 2009 ISBN: 978-81-86219-90-4 Rs. 250 Cover design: Ram Rahman Printed by: Creative Advertisers & Printers New Delhi Ph: 98110 04852 Safdar Hashmi Memorial Trust 29 Ferozeshah Road New Delhi 110 001 Tel: (011) 2307 0787, 2338 1276 E-mail: [email protected] www.sahmat.org SAHMAT – 20 Years 3 4 PUBLICATIONS SAHMAT – 20 Years 5 Safdar Hashmi 1954–1989 Twenty years ago, on 1 January 1989, Safdar Hashmi was fatally attacked in broad daylight while performing a street play in Sahibabad, a working-class area just outside Delhi. Political activist, actor, playwright and poet, Safdar had been deeply committed, like so many young men and women of his generation, to the anti-imperialist, secular and egalitarian values that were woven into the rich fabric of the nation’s liberation struggle. Safdar moved closer to the Left, eventually joining the CPI(M), to pursue his goal of being part of a social order worthy of a free people. Tragically, it would be of the manner of his death at the hands of a politically patronised mafia that would single him out. The spontaneous, nationwide wave of revulsion, grief and resistance aroused by his brutal murder transformed him into a powerful symbol of the very values that had been sought to be crushed by his death. Such a death belongs to the revolutionary martyr. 6 PUBLICATIONS Safdar was thirty-four years old when he died.
    [Show full text]
  • The Digital Camera Interview
    The Digital Camera Interview Photojournalist Pablo Bartholomew A chronicler of the Bhopal tragedy and winner of World Press Photo awards, Pablo Bartholomew’s career is anything but conventional – as Geoff Harris discovers Call it pride, stubbornness or sheer bloody “What I remember most from those holidays mindedness, but the best photographers was my father making contact sheets from the have a bolshy integrity, an independence of rolls of film that he’d sent to the shop to be spirit, that makes their work so memorable processed,” recalls Pablo. “He would do it by and transcendent. A great example of this is gas light in the house that we’d rented for the Pablo Bartholomew, a leading photojournalist summer. There was no electricity, which is why and winner of the World Press Photo of the we used lamps in the evenings. I watched as Year award. His shots of the child victims of the blank paper was put into the developing the Bhopal disaster, the Kashmir conflict or tray and an image would gradually appear. Profile Mother Teresa’s funeral, stay with you forever, There was a kind of mystery in seeing the ● Born in India, Pablo’s and remain benchmarks of excellence in an images that had been taken a few days photographic career age of image saturation. before, of landscapes or of the family, forming began in his teens. Pablo’s a true maverick, and fascinating to on paper as if by magic. I suppose the magic ● Since becoming a talk to for several reasons – as well has having of photography was embedded from there.” photojournalist in 1983, lots to say about the digital versus film his work has appeared debate, he’s someone who honed his craft in Heat and dust in major news the film industry, working with directors from After being kicked out of school at 15, Pablo publications, including both Hollywood and Bollywood.
    [Show full text]
  • The Silver Series - 3
    DAG : THE SILVER SERIES - 3 THE SILVER SERIES EDITION 3 6 - 10 JULY 2020 10% SALE PROCEEDS TO 1 DAG : THE SILVER SERIES - 3 THE SILVER SERIES EDITION 3 100 ARTISTS ² 100 WORKS Modern and Contemporary Indian Art 6 - 10 JULY 2020 FIXED-PRICE ONLINE SALE The Silver Series is DAG’s initiative towards raising funds for charity through its fixed-price online sales For further information please contact us at [email protected] 1 DAG : THE SILVER SERIES - 3 FROM ASHISH ANAND’S DESK Hundreds of great artists have marked every decade of the twentieth century, which is why I have always been surprised at the invisibility of so many of our masters. Painters, sculptors, printmakers, teachers, they have made a name for themselves, but in the absence of their work being shown nationally—rather than regionally, as has been the norm—many have remained outside mainstream discourse. At DAG, it has been our effort to ensure their rediscovery and recognition, something we continue to do with our Silver Series, fixed-price online sales. The outstanding success of the first two editions is an indicator that art-lovers also have an appreciation for lesser-known names, as well as those whose works do not appear frequently in the market. Our endeavour with every edition will be to continue to surprise you with the mix of artists and the quality of their work. I hope the additions in this edition will bring you joy. If you miss any favourites, I assure you that you will find them in subsequent editions.
    [Show full text]
  • Critical Theory Richard Bartholomew: the Art Critic
    LOMEW HO rt BA D R D VE R E ES R E OF RICHAOF E T T A H T S IG E R LL THE A “Richard Bartholomew at his typewriter at his Jangpure home, New Delhi, 1984” Critical theory Richard Bartholomew: The Art Critic A Critic’s Eye, an exhibition of the late Richard Bartho- lomew’s black-and-white photographs of his family and artist friends, was organised by his son Pablo at the Photoink gallery in 2009. These images had been shot while Bartholomew Senior was working as a painter, gal- lery director, critic and writer for The Indian Express, The Times of India and other publications. Now, Pablo has brought out a compilation of these writings, published between the 1950s and early 1980s, edited by him, his mother Rati, and Carmen Kagal. Art The 640 pages are a treasure-trove of historical anec- dotes to engross anyone interested in art: perceptive writings on the role of art criticism, contemporary Indian art, and “pen portraits” or profiles of artists such as MF Husain, Satish Gujral, Ram Kumar and Biren De, and his reviews of landmark exhibitions such as the First Indian Triennale in 1968. There are also provocative essays on public institutions like the National Gallery of Modern Art and the Lalit Kala Akademi (Richard was its secretary from 1977 to 1985) that seem relevant in the wake of the recent allegations of mismanagement at the Akademi. These writings are framed in context with an analytical introduction by critic Geeta Kapur and a more personal afterword by Pablo, who sums up the book in these words: “So this book needs to be out… to allow this man to breathe his words and as a toast [to] all those who have passed on and to the ones surviving; Memory, collectively lost, can now be somewhat regained.” Bart, `3,000.
    [Show full text]
  • Camerawork Delhi Delhi December 2006 Nature Morte Vol 1, No 1 Dayanita Singh Ends 20Th Jan 2007 Mumbai J
    Shows camerawork delhi Delhi December 2006 Nature Morte Vol 1, No 1 Dayanita Singh ends 20th Jan 2007 Mumbai J. Nicholson Gallery, NCPA “Just by the Way—Rocks, Clouds, Nudes” Raghu Rai January 9—17th, 2007 Bombay Art Gallery Sunil Gupta February 12—28th, 2007 Travelling Peace Women Photography exhibit In 2005, an historic nomination was made to the Nobel Peace Prize Committee. It was a collective nomination of 1000 women working in different fields for peace and social justice. They came from over 150 countries, and diverse backgrounds. The nomination to the Nobel Committee formed the heart of a campaign to make women’s work visible, recognized and supported. The exhibition has 500 A5 size cards with the faces of the women activists on one side, and a quote and short profile text on the other side. These cards include 157 women from South Asia and some from other parts of the world. There is also a display of photographs taken by photographer Gauri Gill who travelled all over India to take the nominees pictures. If you would like to show the exhibit in your school or college please contact Retika at [email protected]. Nude VII © Raghu Rai, 1985 In India, it was first shown at the Chinmaya Mission, New Delhi on September 21st 2006, and has since travelled to the American Embassy School (see above), as well as to Manipur Uni- Info versity, Imphal to show solidarity and connect Sharmila’s struggle for justice with the global We are an independent group of individu- struggle for peace and justice.
    [Show full text]
  • The Paintings of Ram Kumar
    SWASTI RAM KUMAR SMRITI Raza Foundation 1 The Paintings of Ram Kumar Among the Indian painters today Ram Kumar is he strives after in his paintings would influence his perhaps the only one who has no imitators and no method of work. His hours are regular the fresh hours followers, for both his themes and method are simple. of the morning he spends in his studio in Karol Bagh in His themes are everyday subjects we in the cities see; Delhi. There he paints, sketches, thinks his way out of the poor, the oppressed, the destitute, the frustrated problems, always within reach and in the company of lower middle class, not necessarily or typically Indian, the finished work and the tools and implements of his but nevertheless alive and boldly stated in non- craft. This is a very necessary discipline, for the ground theatrical yet dramatic terms. of a great painting is craft, the knowledge of surfaces, textures, the limits there can be no heavenly bread he For all this there is nothing of the grotesque or the knows, too, that the spirit of man that destroys the ugly or the sentimental in his paintings. Subject matter enemy of essentially fragile in its desire for peace and and style are mutually supporting. With the minimum for love. He is content to depict the fragility of life and delineation of the human figure, he strengthens line people. He is a painter of the people, not the people of and perspective, allowing eye to see first things first, a the people of the countryside but of the city.
    [Show full text]
  • Starred Articles
    GKCA Update 1st to 31st Jan Starred Articles 01 No Cliffhanger for the US economy Jan Corporate > USA The American Taxpayer Relief Act of 2012, which includes a rare increase in taxes on the wealthiest households in US, was approved by the US Congress. The tax rates would rise to 39.6 per cent from 35 per cent for individual incomes more than $400,000 and couples more than $450,000, while tax deductions and credits would start to be phased out on incomes as low as $250,000. This bipartisan budget deal will prevent the world's largest economy from falling into another fiscal crisis. Background: A package of significant tax cuts, first enacted under President George W. Bush expired in December 2012. As the marginal tax rate was reduced from 39.6 per cent to 35 per cent by these cuts, after these cuts expired tax rates would have increased in January 2013. The Budget Control Act of 2011, effective from January 2013, would automatically cut or “sequester” the government spending if it would exceed the budget resolution. This increase in taxes coupled with spending cuts in the budget would have resulted in reduction in the US Budget deficit and would have pulled the nation dependent on financial stimulus into another official recession. So the US Congress debated about the measures to make the deficit larger by reducing taxes or increasing spending. By signing the American Taxpayer Relief Act of 2012, the US has successfully avoided the conundrum. Although the bill is passed on 1st January 2013, the passing of this bill is backdated to help the US to technically avoid going over a "fiscal cliff”.
    [Show full text]