Year One Progress Report: Strategies for Sustainable Development, Kars, Turkey
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Christensen Fund Year One Progress Report: Strategies for Sustainable Development, Kars, Turkey Phase II Institute for International Urban Development Cambridge, Massachusetts September 2007 Year One Report: Strategies for Sustainable Development, Kars, Turkey – Phase II Institute for International Urban Development Cambridge, Massachusetts Year One Report: Strategies for Sustainable Development, Kars, Turkey – Phase II STUDY TEAM Mona Serageldin Ali Kural Berhan Ipek Christa Lee-Chuvala The Institute would like to acknowledge the excellent assistance received from Ceren Ozgen of Istanbul Technical University in the preparation of this report. This study is sponsored by the Christensen Fund. Institute for International Urban Development Cambridge, Massachusetts Year One Report: Strategies for Sustainable Development, Kars, Turkey – Phase II Institute for International Urban Development Cambridge, Massachusetts Year One Report: Strategies for Sustainable Development, Kars, Turkey – Phase II TABLE OF CONTENTS 1 INTRODUCTION................................................................................................................. 1 2 MAJOR ISSUES OF VULNERABILITY AND RESILIENCE ...................................... 3 2.1 Artificial Insemination .................................................................................................. 5 2.2 Control and Registration of Food Products ............................................................... 5 2.3 Animal Health and Vaccination .................................................................................. 6 2.4 Pasture improvement and management projects, courses and programs .............. 7 2.5 The Use of Manure as Fertilizer .................................................................................. 9 2.6 Village Social Collaboration Projects ........................................................................ 10 2.7 Collaboration with ICARDA Rural Development Experts .................................... 11 3 PILOT PROJECTS IN SELECTED VILLAGES ........................................................... 17 3.1 Animal Husbandry and agricultural products......................................................... 19 3.1.1 Bulanik .................................................................................................................. 19 3.1.2 Çakmak ................................................................................................................. 28 3.1.3 Büyükçatma .......................................................................................................... 32 3.1.4 Boğatepe ............................................................................................................... 37 3.2 Revitalization of carpet weaving and traditional handicrafts ................................ 38 3.2.1 Koçköyü ................................................................................................................ 38 4 ECO-TOURISM POTENTIAL ......................................................................................... 43 4.1 Progress of tourism development in Kars Province ................................................ 44 4.2 Corridor 1: Kars-Çildir Lake-Posof.......................................................................... 44 4.2.1 General features of the corridor ............................................................................ 44 4.2.2 Opportunities and challenges ................................................................................ 44 4.2.3 Evaluation ............................................................................................................. 46 4.3 Corridor 2. Posof-Susuz-Çakmak-Kars.................................................................... 46 4.3.1 General features of the corridor ............................................................................ 46 4.3.2 Selected villages along the corridor ...................................................................... 47 4.3.3 Opportunities and challenges ................................................................................ 47 4.3.4 Evaluation and Suggestions .................................................................................. 48 Institute for International Urban Development Cambridge, Massachusetts Year One Report: Strategies for Sustainable Development, Kars, Turkey – Phase II 4.4 Corridor 3. Kars-Ani Ruins ....................................................................................... 48 4.4.1 General features of the corridor ............................................................................ 48 4.4.2 Selected villages along the corridor ...................................................................... 48 4.4.3 Opportunities and challenges ................................................................................ 49 4.5 Corridor 4. Kars-Çilehane-Tunckaya-Kagizman-(can be followed to Igdir- Dogubeyazit) ................................................................................................................ 50 4.5.1 General features of the corridor ............................................................................ 50 4.5.2 Tunckaya hilltop village ....................................................................................... 50 4.5.3 Çilehane ................................................................................................................ 51 4.5.4 Evaluation ............................................................................................................. 55 5 WORKPLAN FOR 2008 .................................................................................................... 57 ANNEXES ................................................................................................................................... 63 Institute for International Urban Development Cambridge, Massachusetts Year One Report: Strategies for Sustainable Development, Kars, Turkey – Phase II LIST OF MEETINGS Province ERDEN, Mehmet Ufuk Governor of Kars Province KAPLAN, Jale Secretary of the Governor Municipality ALİBEYOĞLU, Naif Mayor of Kars; President, Turkish Association of Local Authorities KARAYAZI, İhsan Project Coordinator ATALAY, Turan Directorate of Public Works – Kars Municipality Department of Culture and Tourism ALP, Necmettin Deputy Director, Department of Culture and Tourism, Ministry of Culture and Tourism of the Central Government Department of Agriculture YURDALAN, Yusuf Director, Department of Agriculture ŞEKERCİ, Gültekin Head of the Division of Control and Registration of Food Products DOĞAN, Sadık Head of the Division of Animal Health EKİZ, Halil Head of the Division of Projects and Statistics TAÇYILDIZ, Yavuz Dede Head of the Division of Farmer Information and Education Koçköyü VERGÜL, Ağabey Mayor of Koçköyü Village GÜLMEZ, Nesif Farmer GÜLMEZ, Yadigar Farmer KIRKAY, Dursun Farmer Bulanık LEVENT, Öztürk Farmer LEVENT, Mustafa Farmer Çakmak SARAÇLI, İlhan Muhtar of Çakmak Village SARAÇLI, Bülent Farmer KARTALMIŞ, Muhlis Farmer KADİRHAN, İlyas Farmer KADİRHAN, Nebi Farmer Institute for International Urban Development Cambridge, Massachusetts Year One Report: Strategies for Sustainable Development, Kars, Turkey – Phase II Büyükçatma EYÜP, Dinçer Farmer BEY, Eyüp Farmer Çilehane PEHLİVAN, Mehmet Farmer BEY, Alaattin Farmer Boğatepe AYDAR, Paşa Farmer Yolboyu ŞAİR, Ertaş Farmer ŞAİR, Fevzi Farmer ŞİMAY, Cemalettin Farmer ŞİMAY, Ayhan Farmer Institute for International Urban Development Cambridge, Massachusetts Year One Report: Strategies for Sustainable Development, Kars, Turkey – Phase II 1 INTRODUCTION This progress report details the work that the Institute for International Urban Development has completed in the first year of Phase II of the Project “Strategies for Sustainable Development in Kars, Turkey.” In the previous phase, the IIUD team completed a survey of 22 villages in the Province and selected six villages with high development potential in the areas of animal husbandry, dairy production, organic farming, carpet weaving and eco-tourism, the major components of rural development in Kars Province. In January 2007 the team presented to the Governor the findings and recommendations of the 2006 study and discussed with him the preparation of an action plan focusing on the six villages to promote sustainability and resilience through better adapted production and improved practices reversing the pernicious cycle of intensified use and degradation and preserving biodiversity. The Governor agreed with the proposal and requested that the team work in close collaboration with the Department of Agriculture. This year, the IIUD team conducted visits to the villages to initiate a participatory process for the formulation of strategies and action plans and the identification of projects. Discussions were directed at promoting the establishment of village associations and cooperatives to increase productivity and facilitate the marketing of agricultural products. The team also continued to study the development of a tourism strategy centered on key corridors in the Province with outstanding natural and cultural assets. An interim report was submitted in June 2007 presenting information gathered from two separate visits to selected villages reachable in winter, in December and January 2007. The visits were undertaken to meet with both men and women in the less busy winter months, the best time to hold long relaxed discussions with farmers as work in the fields is at a standstill.