DOCSLIB.ORG

Review Emergency Powers to Prevent Or Control Disorder

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Review Emergency Powers to Prevent Or Control Disorder Review of Emergency Powers to Prevent or Control Disorder September 2007 Review of Emergency Powers to Prevent or Control Public Disorder September 2007 Any correspondence relating to this review should be sent to: Review of Emergency Powers to Prevent or Control Public Disorder NSW Ombudsman Level 24, 580 George Street Sydney NSW 2000 Phone (02) 9286 1000 Toll free (outside Sydney Metro Area): 1800 451 524 Facsimile: (02) 9283 2911 Telephone typewriter: (02) 9264 8050 Website: www.ombo.nsw.gov.au Email: [email protected] ISBN 978-1-921131-76-9 © Crown Copyright, NSW Ombudsman, September 2007 This work is copyright, however material from this publication may be copied and published by State or Federal Government Agencies without permission of the Ombudsman on the condition that the meaning of the material is not altered and the NSW Ombudsman is acknowledged as the source of the material. Any other persons or bodies wishing to use material must seek permission. September 2007 Level 24 580 George Street Sydney NSW 2000 Phone 02 9286 1000 Fax 02 9283 2911 Tollfree 1800 451 524 TTY 02 9264 8050 Web www.ombo.nsw.gov.au The Honourable John Hatzistergos MLC Attorney General Level 33, Governor Macquarie Tower 1 Farrer Place Sydney NSW 2000 Dear Attorney Under section 87O of the Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act 2002 I have been required to keep under scrutiny the exercise of powers conferred on police officers under the Part 6A emergency powers. I am pleased to provide you with my report, which details the activities undertaken, and my findings and recommendations that result from this review. I draw your attention to section 87O(5) of the Act that requires you to table this report in both Houses of Parliament as soon as practicable. Yours sincerely Bruce Barbour Ombudsman NSW Ombudsman Review of Emergency Powers to Prevent or Control Public Disorder 3 September 2007 Level 24 580 George Street Sydney NSW 2000 Phone 02 9286 1000 Fax 02 9283 2911 Tollfree 1800 451 524 TTY 02 9264 8050 Web www.ombo.nsw.gov.au The Honourable David Campbell MP Minister for Police Level 35, Governor Macquarie Tower 1 Farrer Place Sydney NSW 2000 Dear Minister Under section 87O of the Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act 2002 I have been required to keep under scrutiny the exercise of powers conferred on police officers under the Part 6A emergency powers. I am pleased to provide you with my report, which details the activities undertaken, and my findings and recommendations that result from this review. I note the NSW Police Force was provided with a draft of the report. Where appropriate, the police comments have been incorporated into the final report. I draw your attention to section 87O(5) of the Act that requires the Attorney General to lay a copy of this report before both Houses of Parliament as soon as practicable. Yours sincerely Bruce Barbour Ombudsman NSW Ombudsman 4 Review of Emergency Powers to Prevent or Control Public Disorder Foreword The Part 6A emergency powers to prevent or control public disorder were enacted in direct response to mob violence that occurred at Cronulla, Sydney on 11 December 2005 and the reprisal attacks in Sydney’s southern and eastern suburbs in the days that followed. The unexpected intensity of the violence and the speed and unpredictability of the attacks presented acute challenges for police. There were few precedents for policing this kind of apparently indiscriminate violence on such a large scale. Our review of the few occasions that police have used these extraordinary powers to date has found that police acted in a responsible and appropriate manner. The available evidence indicates that authorisations to use the powers were only granted in circumstances where senior police were genuinely of the view that other, less intrusive policing measures would be insufficient to restore order or prevent further attacks. An obvious difficulty in providing Parliament with information about and analysis of the practical application of these kinds of emergency powers is that they are seldom used, reflecting the fact that public disorder on this scale is fortunately very rare. Some of the powers are yet to be used at all. This means the potential operational value of the provisions and the extent of possible shortcomings will not be fully tested unless and until the laws are used in a range of circumstances. When introducing these exceptional police powers, Parliament took special care to ensure detailed oversight of their use. Until the community can be confident they will work in practice, and in a range of emergency situations, detailed annual reporting and some form of independent scrutiny of future police uses of the powers would seem to be an essential safeguard. I trust that this report will assist the Parliament in considering the future of the Part 6A emergency police powers. Bruce Barbour Ombudsman NSW Ombudsman Review of Emergency Powers to Prevent or Control Public Disorder 5 Glossary CAN Court Attendance Notice CCTV Closed circuit television COPS Computerised Operational Policing System, the primary NSW Police Force computer system for recording and retrieving information FCAN/Field CAN Field Court Attendance Notice EAFZ Emergency alcohol-free zone ECLO Ethnic Community Liaison Officer, a NSW Police Force position Emergency Powers Refers to the police powers throughout Part 6A HWP Highway Patrol, a NSW Police Force unit LAC Local Area Command LGA Local Government Area Liquor Powers Refers to the liquor powers or restrictions in Division 2 of Part 6A LEPRA Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act 2002 MLA / MLC Member of the Legislative Assembly / Member of the Legislative Council MP Member of Parliament NSWPD New South Wales Parliamentary Debates (Hansard) OSG Operations Support Group, a NSW Police Force unit POI Person of Interest Special powers Refers to the powers in Division 3 of Part 6A SOPs Standard Operating Procedures Part 6A The Part inserted into the Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act 2002 to create emergency police powers to prevent or control public disorder NSW Ombudsman 6 Review of Emergency Powers to Prevent or Control Public Disorder Contents Executive Summary Summary of Recommendations Chapter 1. Introduction New Part 6A emergency powers for police ................................................................................................ 1 Our role and this report .............................................................................................................................. 1 Chronology of events .................................................................................................................................. 1 Methodology ................................................................................................................................................ 3 Chapter 2. Implementing the Act Operation Seta ............................................................................................................................................. 5 NSW Police Force preparations for using the powers ............................................................................... 6 Other recorded uses of Part 6A .................................................................................................................. 6 Incidents where police chose not to use the emergency powers ............................................................. 7 Chapter 3. Emergency powers for emergency situations Defining ‘large-scale public disorder’ ........................................................................................................ 9 Policing public demonstrations and protests ......................................................................................... 10 Summary .................................................................................................................................................... 11 Chapter 4. Liquor controls Emergency prohibition on the sale or supply of liquor ........................................................................... 13 Emergency alcohol-free zones ................................................................................................................. 16 Chapter 5. Authorising the use of ‘special powers’ The authorisation provisions .................................................................................................................... 19 Use of authorisations ............................................................................................................................... 20 Where authorisations were considered but not used .............................................................................. 22 Issues associated with authorising the use of the emergency powers .................................................. 23 Defining a ‘public place’ ............................................................................................................................ 28 NSW Ombudsman Review of Emergency Powers to Prevent or Control Public Disorder 7 Chapter 6. Core powers Establishing cordons and roadblocks ...................................................................................................... 33 Stopping and searching vehicles and people ......................................................................................... 38 Requiring the disclosure of identity ......................................................................................................... 41 Seizing
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Section 3 ABC Divisions
    Section 3 ABC Divisions Sue Howard Director of Radio and Regional Content Sue Howard joined the ABC in 1986. She has presented programs on three ABC Radio networks. Sue has achieved some notable firsts for the ABC, including pioneering ABC Radio’s midnight-to-dawn shift, becoming the first woman to present an ABC Breakfast program (in 1993) and the first female Local Radio Manager, taking on the combined metropolitan and regional management responsibilities in Victoria in 1996. Sue became Head of Regional Services in 1996, Director of Radio in 2000 and Director of Radio and Regional Content in 2007. She holds a Bachelor of Arts from Monash University and a Diploma of Education. ABC Radio and Regional Content In 2007–08, ABC Radio and Regional Content built The emphasis on developing cross-media on its investment in cross-media initiatives and production skills continued in both local and intensified its preparation for the introduction of national content areas. In addition, the Division digital radio on 1 January 2009. undertook a comprehensive program of craft skills training and launched the first two in a series of The launch of ABC Local (formerly The Backyard) craft skills books—Talk Radio: The ABC of Writing in March 2008, provided Australian communities and Talk Radio: The ABC of Interviewing. with enhanced local coverage of their regions as well as a gateway to ABC Online. Communities and Emergency Services National ABC Radio networks increased their ABC Radio, especially the ABC Local Radio network connection with regional audiences, with added of 60 stations across Australia, continued to impetus provided by the extension of ABC provide support and opportunities for community NewsRadio to regional Australian communities in engagement throughout metropolitan and New South Wales, Victoria, Queensland, South regional centres.
    [Show full text]
  • ABC Divisions
    IN 2008–09, ABC Radio’s primary focus was the ABC Divisions introduction of digital radio in Australia in the five mainland capital cities and the development of ABC Digital Radio services to commence on air Section 3 from 1 July 2009. ABC Digital Radio will initially comprise simulcasts Radio of its existing analog services—ABC Radio National, ABC Classic FM, ABC NewsRadio, triple j and the relevant Local Radio metropolitan station—along with new music services, ABC Dig Music, ABC Jazz and ABC Country, each complemented by media-rich websites (abc.net.au/ radio/digital). In 2008, ABC Radio achieved record audience results for a second consecutive year: a record market share of 21.2% and a record reach of 3.82 million listeners a week in the five major cities (or 33% of that population). Each of the radio networks recorded year-on-year growth in reach (see page 39). Not all feedback to ABC Radio was positive. In October 2008, decisions to change Radio Kate Dundas National’s 2009 program schedule generated significant adverse reaction from loyal listeners, Director of Radio many of whom incorrectly perceived the changes Kate Dundas was appointed Director would deliver increased online content at the of Radio in March 2009 after 18 expense of radio programs. In 2009, the response months as Director of People and to new radio programs has generally been positive. Learning. Prior to this, Kate was Head Communities in Crises of ABC Radio’s National Networks. In addition to her ABC career, Kate has The unique role played by ABC Local Radio in worked in public and communications times of emergency was never more evident than policy areas in both state and federal with the Victorian bushfires and the floods in governments and held two senior Queensland and northern New South Wales.
    [Show full text]
  • Strike Force Neil, Cronulla Riots, Review of the Police Response
    Review of the Police Response Report and Recommendations STRIKE FORCE NEIL Cronulla Riots .Corporate Review PREFACE ..................................................................... 3 DOCUMENT REFERENCES ......................................................3 INTRODUCTION ................................................................4 STRIKE FORCE 'NEIL' TERMS OF REFERENCE ..................................... 5 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .........................................................6 RECOMMENDATIONS .......................................................... 12 METHODOLOGY ........................................................... I5 THE NATIONAL CENTRE FOR POLICING EXCELLENCE .............................16 Chief Inspector Michael Homden ............................................... 16 ISSUES OF ETHNIC TENSION .CRONULLA ........................................I7 CRIME TRENDS .CRONULLA ................................................... 18 Countryoforigin ......................................................... 18 Racialappearance ........................................................18 Crime Trends within Cronulla ..............................................19 Country of Birth - Person of Interest .........................................19 Country of Birth .Father ...................................................20 Country of Birth - Mother ..................................................20 Lastknownaddress ...................................................... 21 Last known address (LAC) of POI ...........................................21
    [Show full text]