Can State and Local Basic Income Policies Support Planning for Equity?

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Can State and Local Basic Income Policies Support Planning for Equity? Can state and local basic income policies support planning for equity? by Daniel L. Powers B.S., Industrial and Labor Relations Cornell University, 2014 Submitted to the Department of Urban Studies and Planning in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master in City Planning at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology May 19, 2020 © 2020 Daniel Powers. All rights reserved. The author hereby grants to MIT permission to reproduce and to distribute publicly paper and electronic copies of the thesis document in whole or in part in any medium now known or hereafter created Signature of Author: Department of Urban Studies and Planning May 19, 2020 Certified by: Karilyn Crockett Lecturer of Public Policy and Urban Planning Thesis Supervisor Certified by: Ceasar McDowell Professor of the Practice Chair, MCP Committee Department of Urban Studies and Planning 2 Can state and local basic income policies support planning for equity? by Dan Powers Submitted to the Department of Urban Studies and Planning on May 19, 2020 in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master in City Planning Abstract: Interest in basic income has been rising as more and more cities and places undertake basic income pilots, seams in existing supports become more and more apparent, and racial and class-based disparities widen. Yet the justifications offered for basic income programs are diffuse and sometimes in tension. Questions remain about the purpose of pilots, and whether pilots will ever make the jump to permanent policies. This thesis sets out to answer whether basic income policies at the city or state level can support equity. In doing so, it reviews the existing literature; examines failed basic income programs; investigates existing federal benefits systems and policies, and how they could constrain a basic income; and compares a city-level basic income pilot (Stockton’s Economic Empowerment Demonstration) with a state-level basic income program (Alaska’s Permanent Fund Dividend). Assessing this evidence demonstrates the breadth of decisions involved in designing basic-income policies, and the tradeoffs involved in each. Ultimately, basic income policies can support equity by providing a direct, flexible benefit to the poor and avoiding administrative burdens built into many benefit programs. However, whether a policy actually supports equity goals depends on the specific decisions involved in its design, including its financing, eligibility criteria, and whether other services are sacrificed to implement it. Serious questions remain unanswered by existing pilots about how a permanent policy would be financed and implemented. Uncritical calls for a basic income risk neglecting details that determine whether policies will support or undermine equity. City and state governments could still benefit from incorporating features of basic income into their equitable development strategies, and pilots and advocates could work more to answer unknowns about the transition to policies. Karilyn Crockett Lecturer, Department of Urban Studies and Planning Thesis Supervisor Jeff Levine Lecturer of Economic Development and Planning Thesis Reader 3 4 Acknowledgments I am immeasurably grateful to Karilyn and Jeff, for their support and (especially) patience throughout this process. Karilyn in particular deserves credit for most of the things I’ve done of any value in graduate school since my first semester in her Housing, Community, and Economic Development class, and I will forever be indebted to her for her assurance and advice throughout my time at MIT. I am also so appreciative of the chance to meet my classmates in DUSP. I am running out of time as I write this so I will be brief, but you all have been the best part of my time in graduate school and I am deeply saddened that our physical time together was cut short by the Coronavirus. Thank you to my parents and brother, for your love and support. Thank you to my friends, for existing and making my life better. Thank you to the basic income researchers and practitioners who took the time to meet with me and share information. I am especially grateful to the Stockton Economic Empowerment Demonstration, for sharing access to participant interviews. 5 6 Table of Contents Abstract...................................................................................................................................... 3 Acknowledgments ...................................................................................................................... 5 Table of Contents ....................................................................................................................... 7 Chapter 1: Introduction ........................................................................................................... 9 Introduction ......................................................................................................................... 9 Methodology ......................................................................................................................12 Theoretical Grounding........................................................................................................13 Chapter 2: History of and Existing Research on Basic Income ..............................................18 Definition and History of Basic Income ...............................................................................18 Literature Review on Basic Income ....................................................................................24 Examining Basic Income Failures ......................................................................................34 Federal Social Services and Transfer Programs ................................................................44 Chapter 3: Examining Basic income in Stockton and Alaska .................................................64 Overview ............................................................................................................................64 Context-setting ...................................................................................................................65 Basic Income in Stockton and Alaska ................................................................................75 Chapter 4: Evaluating and Designing Basic Income Policies .................................................94 Overview ............................................................................................................................94 Policy Choices and Tradeoffs.............................................................................................95 Benefit Simulation in Stockton .......................................................................................... 104 Conclusion and Design Considerations ............................................................................ 105 Chapter 5: Conclusions ....................................................................................................... 109 Bibliography ........................................................................................................................ 114 7 8 Chapter 1: Introduction Introduction The US has a deeply problematic relationship with social assistance. Welfare has only been set aside for the “worthy” poor, defined in racist and regressive ways that direct aid away from the most needy, stigmatize recipients, and set up numerous administrative hurdles to claiming aid. Out of a patronizing concern that people who receive aid will use it in “unproductive” or non-socially sanctioned ways, aid is traditionally burdened with numerous conditions—such as work requirements—to control the type of beneficiary, the way that they use their benefits, and limit participation. Cities and states have a deeply problematic relationship with equity and inclusion. The tools available to each to ensure that the most-needy benefit from development are often compromised or vulnerable to compromise. Cities often view their responsibilities to their residents as magnets for private investment from which benefits will flow, rather than providers of essential services and structures that shape people’s lives. Community benefits agreements have been used to try to ensure that residents benefit from development, yet often require public giveaways as tradeoffs for private concessions and can give a façade of public approval to projects opposed to community interests.1 Cities and states often give tax incentives to projects purporting to provide public benefit without accountability mechanisms to ensure that they meet their promises.2 In March 2020, the advent of COVID-19 across the US made both failures apparent. The US social safety net is not equipped to help masses of people unable to work in conditions of social distancing, and who rely on discontinued public services to provide and offset expenses of childcare. Cities and states have strained to maintain existing systems while bleeding money from the pandemic’s economic hit.3 While COVID-19 has expanded the number of people victimized by the failings of our social safety net, those who will suffer most deeply are the same communities of color who status quo economic policies and processes have always failed. In the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, republican and democratic politicians have considered at least a short-term, national-level universal basic income to both counteract the economic pain wrought by the pandemic and facilitate social distancing, and have
Recommended publications
  • Download This Report
    Social Security Review2021 Evolution of Social Security in South Africa: An Agenda for Action ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Copyright 2021 The Department of Social Development extends its Department of Social Development appreciation to the HSRC for providing editorial services for this inaugural edition of the Social Security Review. Special thanks This publication is an output of the Development of Social go to Shirin Motala, Stewart Ngandu and Tim Hart for their Development with support from the Economic Development excellent guidance and support to the Department to ensure Programme, Human Sciences Research Council. a high standard for the publication, including the peer review of all the chapters. The Department is immensely grateful to EDITORS: Shirin Motala; Stewart Ngandu & Tim Hart the Authors who willingly responded to the requests from the HSRC for editing and approving of drafts. This is more so as Credits many of these requests came at short notice. Cover Illustration and design 2021 by Ilse Visagie, HSRC Book layout and production by Blackmoon Design and Advertising We wish to acknowledge the contribution of the team of Copy editing by John Seagar. Peer Reviewers, 23 of them who will remain unnamed as the approach was a double blinded peer review process. They Copyright Statement provided their intellectual insights and gave direction to the The text and data in this publication may be reproduced as long authors in order to enhance the quality of the contributions. as the source is cited. Reproductions for commercial purposes are forbidden. We appreciate other colleagues at the HSRC, whose various contributions in the execution of the project enabled the Rights and Permission - All rights reserved achievement of milestones under tremendous pressure.
    [Show full text]
  • Basic Income on the Agenda: Reflections on the Finnish Basic Income Experiment
    Basic Income on the Agenda: Reflections on the Finnish Basic Income Experiment Presentation prepared for Institute for Policy Research, University of Bath, 1 June 2016 1 Jurgen De Wispelaere, University of Tampere [email protected] 2 Basic income attention, 2005-2016 Source: Scott Santens, Basic Income on the March (Google Trends) 3 Recent policy initiatives !Existing schemes: Alaska PFD, Iran’s oil subsidy grant, … !Legislation: Brazil’s Lei de Renda Bá sica de Cidadania (Law No. 10.835, 2004) and Switzerland’s Basic Income Referendum on 5 June 2016 !Pilot projects, past and planned: !1970s: NIT experiments (US), Mincome (Canada) !Experiments in Otjivero-Omitara (Namibia, 2008-2009), Quatinga Velho (Brazil, 2008-), Madhya Pradesh (India, 2011) !Planned experiments include Netherlands (Utrecht, Tilburg, Groningen, Wageningen), Kenya (GiveDirectly, 10-15y trial), Bay Area, US (Ycombinator), Finland (2017-2019). 4 Why basic income pilots now? ! Background context of 2008 financial crisis and its reaction: austerity, poverty and economic inequality … ! Growth of evidence-based policy-making ! Attention-grabbing events: e.g. Switzerland (2013), Finland/ Netherlands (2015), Kenya (2016) ! Media attention promotes policy attention ! Policy learning from examples around the world? ! Exponential increase in organised basic income movement ! Basic income pilots are a political compromise between doing nothing and implementing a novel policy idea 5 Why conduct a basic income pilot? !Scientific field experiment: examining actual behaviour/impact
    [Show full text]
  • Universal Basic Income: a Psychological Impact Assessment
    Universal Basic Income: A Psychological Impact Assessment recently arrived migrants to get involved in What if... community activities? She could do this with a Universal Basic Income. ...Just to make ends meet, Rachel did not need to do a late-night shift in Tesco, after giving her ...Paul and Amina could upgrade their computer children their tea and working all day as a low- system to make running their start-up business paid carer for a home care agency? She could more efficient? They could do this with a do this with a Universal Basic Income. Universal basic Income. ...Abdul, instead of working the long hours in the ...Jessica, tied financially to an abusive finance organisation, reduced his hours and spent husband, had the financial independence to more time at home with his two young children? leave him? She could do this with a Universal He could do this with a Universal Basic Income. Basic Income. ...Grace, instead of going back to work full ...Irene and Daryl could be sure they had enough time after maternity leave, was able to afford money for food if the agencies they worked for to return part time? She could do this with a had no work for them this week. They could do Universal Basic Income. this with a Universal Basic Income. ...Will, instead of working as a barista in between ...Michelle, instead of undergoing work commissions for his graphic design service, capability assessments, could decide the hours spent the time developing his skills? He could do she was able to work, on what, and where? She this with a Universal Basic Income.
    [Show full text]
  • Understanding Political Opportunities and Rethinking Social Welfare Governance 2 Number of Days of Strike
    Swetha Rao Dhananka, Indo-Swiss Conference, 10.9.2014! Understanding political opportunities and rethinking social welfare governance! 2 Number of days of strike! Eurostat, 2007 3 Structure of argument ! Rethinking social welfare governance (Rothstein & Uslaner 2005; Standing, 2013) Political opportunities in France, Switzerland (Kriesi et al, 1995) India Political well-being (Przewoski, 2000) 4 Defining political opportunities ! Political opportunities refer to those more structural aspects of the political system that affects the possibility that challenger groups have to mobilize effectively. ! (Giugni, 2011, 271).! 5 Ø" Thesis: Mobilisation of social movement is linked to conventional politics in the parliamentary and extraparliamentary arenas of a given country. Ø" They depend on: •" National cleavage structures •" Prevailing strategies •" Alliance structures •" Institutional structures 6 Strength and Strategy! 7 8 Social movement theories Conditions for social movement emergence ? Value ? 9 Quote “India’s political system can be described as a mediating framework for a dialogue between the two inherited traditions of governance and movement” ! (1964, 126 W.H. Morris-Jones in Mitra, 2006, 50)! Conditions for social movement emergence ? 10 Questions adressed! •" What formal political opportunities does the Indian legal polity offer? ! •" How does informality intervene?! •" Given these opportunities: ! –" What kind of political reshaping can be thought of?! 11 Interaction between formal & informal" political opportunities (Helmke & Levitsky,
    [Show full text]
  • The UNO a Model Complementary Currency Used to Reduce Poverty & Help Build Healthy Local Economies
    The UNO A Model Complementary Currency Used to Reduce Poverty & Help Build Healthy Local Economies Michael Sauvante Vari MacNeil National Commonwealth Group, Inc. a Delaware 501(c)(3) non-profit corporation This document explores a topic introduced in a companion document titled Commonwealth Development Organizations (CDOs), which describes a more complete financial ecosystem of which this concept is a part. It can be found at: https://commonwealthgroup.net/doc/CommonwealthDevelopmentOrganizations.pdf Table of Contents 01 02 03 Overview What is Money? The UNO p4 p8 p12 Overview Definition of Money Distinguishing Features p8 p14 Bank-created Money Fractional Transactions p10 p14 Government-created Money UNO Bank p10 p15 Public and Non-profit Recruiting Participants Bank-created Money p15 p11 Linked to Cost of Living Citizen-created Money p16 Preventing Inflation 2 | The UNO: A new complementary currency National Commonwealth Group 04 05 06 The UNO in Practice Technology Benefits of the UNO System p17 p20 Local Circulation Server Side p22 Benefits Chart p17 p21 Small Businesses Client Side Appendix A p18 p21 Public Works Widespread Adoption p23 A Basic Income Primer p18 Remittances Appendix B p19 p27 Conversion to a National Complementary Currencies Currency Endnotes p34 National Commonwealth Group The UNO: A new complementary currency | 3 01 Overview Economic disparity - - is greater than at In 2002, C.K. Prahalad and Stu Treating the BoP as producers - any time in recent art Hart suggested that a for shows somewhat more promise, human history. tune could be made in serving but this approach faces huge chal the needs of the poor and in the4 lenges, including producers’ poor process coined the term BoP.
    [Show full text]
  • European Green Perspectives on Basic Income 57 European Green Perspectives on Basic Income 58 European Green Perspectives on Basic Income
    European Green Perspectives on Basic Income European Green Perspectives on Basic Income 57 European Green Perspectives on Basic Income 58 European Green Perspectives on Basic Income February 2019 GEF Project Coordination: Carlotta Weber & Jamie Kendrick Layout and design: Nuno Pinto da Cruz Editing and proofreading: Beatrice White & Aoife Daly Green European Foundation Rue du Fossé 3 – 1536 Luxembourg Brussels Office: 15 Rue d’Arlon 1050 Brussels – Belgium [email protected] www.gef.eu This publication has been realised with the financial support of the European Parliament to the Green European Foundation. The European Parliament is not responsible for the content of this project. You can order free copies of this publication by sending an email request to [email protected]. European Green Perspectives on Basic Income 1 European Green Perspectives on Basic Income 2 Table of Contents Foreword 5 I. Introduction 6 Twelve Questions and Answers on Universal Basic Income 7 II. Big Questions of Universal Basic Income 12 How Basic Income Can Make up for What Minimum Income Schemes Lack 13 Should We Have More Basic Income Pilots? 17 Basic Income Has Always Been a Women’s Cause 21 III. Universal Basic Income in Practice 24 Combining a Minimum Income with Active Social Policies: 25 Barcelona’s B-MINCOME Pilot The Hidden Success of the Swiss Referendum 30 IV. The Debate Across Europe 32 Green Debate on Basic Income in Germany: Evolution and Current Status 33 Universal Basic Income – The Case of Serbia 37 Is There Any Real Prospect for the Adoption of UBI in Greece 39 and What Should Be Done for This? V.
    [Show full text]
  • Basic Income Stud 2021; 16(1): 75–99
    Basic Income Stud 2021; 16(1): 75–99 Guy Standing* Basic Income Pilots: Uses, Limitations and Design Principles https://doi.org/10.1515/bis-2021-0021 Received June 9, 2021; accepted June 9, 2021 Abstract: The position underlying this article is that while pilots are not strictly required to justify moving in the direction of a basic income system, nevertheless they can play several useful functions in the debate. These include rebutting common preconceptions, for instance that basic income will make people ‘lazy’,indicating non-monetary benefits such as improved health and wellbeing, and testing how a basic income might best be introduced in a given region, country or city. In that context the article goes on to present 19 guiding principles for the design, imple- mentation and evaluation of basic income pilots, with examples of selected experi- ments and pilots past and present. Keywords: basic income experiments, pilots, ethics, basic income, principles for pilots 1 Introduction Within the community of academics, activists and commentators working on basic income, there has been considerable – and at times heated – controversy about the desirability and validity of what are generically called basic income ‘pilots’. Some assert that they are neither necessary nor desirable and others claim they are essential. Neither extreme position seems sensible, as was argued in an earlier version of this article presented at the Montreal BIEN Congress in 2014.1 The position underlying this article is that, while pilots are not strictly required to justify moving in the direction of a basic income system, nevertheless they can play several useful functions.
    [Show full text]
  • 19Th BIEN Congress Hyderabad, India
    19th BIEN Congress Hyderabad, India Abstracts of Papers presented at the Congress August 22-25, 2019 Abstracts ABSTRACTS OF PAPERS PRESENTED AT THE CONGRESS AUGUST 22-25, 2019 Contents CS1- Perspectives on Basic Income ....................................................................................... 6 Telemaque Masson ................................................................................................................ 6 Basic Income as an answer to the Fundamental Contradiction of all Liberal Theory .......................... 6 Chloe Halpenny ...................................................................................................................... 8 Basic Income: A Feminist Proposal? ..................................................................................................... 8 Michael W. Howard ................................................................................................................ 9 The Left Debate on Basic Income in the United States......................................................................... 9 Otto Lehto .............................................................................................................................10 Evolutionary Economics and Universal Basic Income: Complex Adaptation under Radical Uncertainty ......................................................................................................................................... 10 Malcolm Torry ........................................................................................................................12
    [Show full text]
  • Guaranteed Income in the U.S. - Abridged Toolkit Best Practices, Resources, and Existing Models of Planned and Ongoing Research in the U.S., from JFI Experts
    Guaranteed Income in the U.S. - Abridged Toolkit Best practices, resources, and existing models of planned and ongoing research in the U.S., from JFI experts For the full, unabridged toolkit, please reach out to [email protected] About the Jain Family Institute The Jain Family Institute (JFI) is a nonpartisan applied research organization in the social sciences that works to bring research and policy from conception in theory to implementation in society. Within JFI’s core policy area of guaranteed income, JFI is the ​ ​ design and research partner on The Compton Pledge and has consulted on the Stockton, ​ ​ CA SEED pilot, the Alaska Permanent Fund Dividend, and related policies in New York City and Chicago, as well as on forthcoming pilots in Newark and Atlanta. JFI is leading an evaluation of a 42,000-person guaranteed income program in Marica, Brazil, a keystone of the movement for a solidarity economy. JFI has also provided expert commentary on a range of cash transfer policies from relief checks to the EITC and CTC. Founded in 2015 by Robert Jain, JFI focuses on building evidence around the most pressing social problems. The Phenomenal World is JFI’s independent publication of theory and commentary on the ​ social sciences. [email protected] Copyright © 2021 Jain Family Institute. All rights reserved. 568 Broadway, Suite 601, New York, NY, 10012 www.JFIresearch.org Jain Family Institute - JFI January 2021 What is in this toolkit? This toolkit, of which this document is an abridged version, is designed to provide a concrete starting point for anyone interested in supporting a guaranteed income for their community, particularly by launching a guaranteed income pilot.
    [Show full text]
  • Newsflash No. 78
    BIEN BASIC INCOME EARTH NETWORK NewsFlash Volume 27, no. 78, November 2014 www.basicincome.org This is the newsletter of the Basic Income Earth Network (BIEN), which was founded in 1986 as the Basic Income European Network and expanded to become an Earth- wide Network in 2004. It serves as a link between individuals and groups committed to or interested in basic income. It fosters informed discussion on this topic throughout the world. This NewsFlash, below, can also be downloaded as a PDF document on our website www.basicincome.org. This NewsFlash goes out to more than 2,000 subscribers four times a year. If you would like to be added or removed from the subscription list, please go to: http://www.basicincome.org/bien/subscribe.php. For up-to-date information about basic income, see: http://binews.org/ Contents 1. Editorial 2. News 3. Events 4. BI Literature 5. BI Audio-Video 6. New Links 1. Editorial It is an exciting time in the basic income movement. Discussion of the idea is growing, and so is activism. The Swiss initiative for basic income will move toward a nationwide ballot within two years. Activists who helped organize the European Citizens Initiative for UBI (which concluded last year) have solidified themselves into Unconditional Basic Income Europe (UBIE) a permanent Europe-wide activist group dedicated solely to basic income. And an activist movement might be growing in the United States. The USBIG Network is more of a research group than an activist group. But several activists are organizing a free public event that will take place immediately following the Fourteenth Annual North American Basic Income Guarantee (NABIG) Congress, which will be held in New York City starting Thursday, February 26 – Sunday March 1, 2015.
    [Show full text]
  • Exploring Universal Basic Income: a Guide to Navigating Concepts, Evidence, and Practices
    Exploring Universal Basic Income A Guide to Navigating Concepts, Evidence, and Practices Ugo Gentilini, Margaret Grosh, Jamele Rigolini, and Ruslan Yemtsov Editors Exploring Universal Basic Income Exploring Universal Basic Income A Guide to Navigating Concepts, Evidence, and Practices Ugo Gentilini, Margaret Grosh, Jamele Rigolini, and Ruslan Yemtsov Editors © 2020 International Bank for Reconstruction and Development / The World Bank 1818 H Street NW, Washington, DC 20433 Telephone: 202-473-1000; Internet: www.worldbank.org Some rights reserved 1 2 3 4 22 21 20 19 This work is a product of the staff of The World Bank with external contributions. The findings, interpretations, and conclusions expressed in this work do not necessarily reflect the views of The World Bank, its Board of Executive Directors, or the governments they represent. The World Bank does not guarantee the accuracy of the data included in this work. The boundaries, colors, denominations, and other information shown on any map in this work do not imply any judgment on the part of The World Bank concerning the legal status of any territory or the endorsement or acceptance of such boundaries. Nothing herein shall constitute or be considered to be a limitation upon or waiver of the privileges and immunities of The World Bank, all of which are specifically reserved. Rights and Permissions This work is available under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 IGO license (CC BY 3.0 IGO) http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo. Under the Creative Commons Attribution license, you are free to copy, distribute, transmit, and adapt this work, including for commercial purposes, under the following conditions: Attribution—Please cite the work as follows: Gentilini, Ugo, Margaret Grosh, Jamele Rigolini, and Ruslan Yemtsov, eds.
    [Show full text]
  • Alma Mater Studiorum Universita' Di Bologna
    ALMA MATER STUDIORUM UNIVERSITA’ DI BOLOGNA SCUOLA DI SCIENZE POLITICHE E SOCIALI Corso di laurea magistrale in Sviluppo Locale e Globale Il Reddito di Base: cenni storici e analisi delle esperienze nel Mondo Tesi di laurea in Economia dello Sviluppo Internazionale Relatore Presentata da Ch.mo Prof. Gianluca Piscione Pier Giorgio Matr. 0000820580 Ardeni Sessione III Anno Accademico 2017/2018 Introduzione p .5 1- Il reddito di base p. 10 1.1 - Reddito di base incondizionato e sistemi di reddito minimo condizionati. Vantaggi e limiti. p. 17 1.2 - Fonti di finanziamento p. 22 1.3 - Opinioni nella società civile, politica e religiosa p. 28 2- La nascita di un’idea p. 35 2.1 - Dall’assistenza pubblica al reddito minimo: breve sintesi p. 36 2.2 - Da Paine al dividendo dell’Alaska p.37 2.3 - Il reddito di base e i suoi “simili” p. 40 3 - Reddito di base nel XX e nel XXI secolo p. 49 3.1 - Conditional Cash Transfers p. 50 3.1.1 Bolsa Familia in Brasile p. 55 3.2 - Esperimenti concreti/progetti pilota p. 56 3.2.1 Africa p. 57 3.2.2 India p. 61 3.2.3 America del Nord p. 65 3.2.4 Altri esperimenti e progetti nel Mondo p. 74 3.3 - Il referendum svizzero p. 81 3.4 - Il caso italiano. Dall’assenza del reddito minimo al Reddito di Cittadinanza. p. 85 Conclusioni p. 90 Riferimenti bibliografici p.96 p. 111 Siti web p. 98 3 4 INTRODUZIONE La fase storica che stiamo attraversando – e in particolare da un paio di decenni ad oggi – porta con sé numerose e profonde trasformazioni.
    [Show full text]