Archival and Historical Investigations Into the Locations of Cherokee Trail of Tears Sites in Illinois

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Archival and Historical Investigations Into the Locations of Cherokee Trail of Tears Sites in Illinois ARCHIVAL AND HISTORICAL INVESTIGATIONS INTO THE LOCATIONS OF CHEROKEE TRAIL OF TEARS SITES IN ILLINOIS By Mark J. Wagner and Kayeleigh Sharp Mark J. Wagner Principal Investigator Submitted to The National Park Service National Trails Intermountain Region Santa Fe, New Mexico Center for Archaeological Investigations Southern Illinois University Carbondale Technical Report 13-1 July, 2013 Abstract This report is a historical and archival study of the types and locations of cultural properties associated with the Cherokee Trail of Tears (1837-1839) within Illinois. Such properties included taverns, mills, residences, stores, ferries, cemeteries, and campgrounds. We examined the distribution of the above properties within a 10 mile wide corridor (five miles north and five miles south) of Route 146, the modern version of the trail that extended for 55 miles from Golconda on the Ohio River in the east to several ferry locations on the Mississippi River in the west. Archival data used to determine the types and numbers of cultural properties contained within the corridor included descendant interviews and other information contained in the papers of two 1930s researchers—John G. Mulcaster and Dr. George W. Smith—now housed at Southern Illinois University Carbondale; business licenses, tax records, and other information contained in the Union, Johnson, and Pope County courthouses; original land purchase records; and other information. The results of this research were used to create a GIS database showing the distribution of cultural properties with the information from that database presented in both tables and figures within this report. A total of 545 cultural and 31 natural (springs) properties were located within the corridor. Of these, 414 were mappable as to location. Thirty-eight of these sites have associated oral history or written documents that link them to the Trail of Tears. Fifteen of these sites could be identified to specific location while 23 could be located in only a general sense. Recommendations are presented in the conclusion of the report identifying which sites have interpretive potential as well as which sites have the potential to present additional information regarding the Trail of Tears in Illinois through archaeological investigations. ii Table of Contents Abstract ............................................................................................................................................... ii Table of Contents .......................................................................................................................... iii List of Figures .................................................................................................................................. vi List of Tables ................................................................................................................................... ix Acknowledgments ......................................................................................................................... x 1 Introduction .................................................................................................................................. 1 Previous Trail of Tears Related Research in Southern Illinois ....................................... 3 2 Project Background ................................................................................................................... 8 Environmental Setting ................................................................................................... 8 Local Historical Background ......................................................................................... 15 3 Methods ........................................................................................................................................ 22 Archival Research ......................................................................................................... 22 Geographic Information System (GIS) Database ......................................................... 24 4 John G. Mulcaster and the Trail of Tears....................................................................... 28 Introduction .................................................................................................................. 28 Mulcaster and the Trail of Tears .................................................................................. 29 Summary of Mulcaster’s Trail of Tears Research ........................................................ 41 Union County Sites ...................................................................................................... 42 The Morgan Mill and Dutch Creek Campground ............................................ 42 The Willard and Davie Mills ................................................................................ 49 Campground Church (Hileman Farm) ............................................................... 51 Other Burial Areas in Union County .................................................................. 53 Winstead Davie House and Tavern .................................................................... 55 Johnson County Sites .................................................................................................... 57 Bridges Tavern........................................................................................................ 57 Pope County Sites ......................................................................................................... 60 iii Scott Cemetery ........................................................................................................ 60 5 Union County Properties ...................................................................................................... 98 Introduction .................................................................................................................. 98 Taverns .................................................................................................................... 99 Groceries ................................................................................................................ 100 Other Businesses .................................................................................................. 102 Mills ........................................................................................................................ 103 Ferries .................................................................................................................... 104 Cemeteries ............................................................................................................. 105 Campgrounds ....................................................................................................... 108 Residences ............................................................................................................. 114 Springs ................................................................................................................... 115 6 Johnson County Properties ................................................................................................ 144 Introduction ................................................................................................................ 144 Taverns .................................................................................................................. 145 Groceries and Other Retail Businesses ............................................................. 146 Mills ........................................................................................................................ 147 Cemeteries ............................................................................................................. 147 Campgrounds ....................................................................................................... 148 Residences ............................................................................................................. 149 Springs ................................................................................................................... 151 7 Pope County Properties ....................................................................................................... 164 Introduction ................................................................................................................ 164 Taverns and Groceries ......................................................................................... 164 Other Businesses .................................................................................................. 166 Mills ........................................................................................................................ 166 Ferries .................................................................................................................... 167 Euro-American Cemeteries ................................................................................ 168 Cherokee Burial Areas ......................................................................................... 168 Campgrounds ....................................................................................................... 169 Residences ............................................................................................................. 171 Springs ................................................................................................................... 172 8 Results and Recommendations .......................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • News Release
    Shawnee National Forest News Release Shawnee National Forest Contact: IL. Dept. of Natural Resources Contact: Chad Deaton Rachel Torbert (618) 253-7114 217-685-1163 [email protected] [email protected] www.fs.usda.gov/shawnee www2.illinois.gov/dnr Bicycle Trails Designated in Lake Glendale Recreation Area Glendale, Ill. May 27, 2021— Mountain bike enthusiasts will soon have access to the first bicycle trails designated in the Shawnee National Forest. Approximately 19 miles between Lake Glendale Recreation Area and Dixon Springs State Park will now be open with a dual designation for mountain bike use as well as hiking. The trail designation took years of planning and analysis with both the Illinois Department of Natural Resources (IDNR) and U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service working cooperatively through each of their individual agency’s planning processes. “For the Shawnee National Forest, this project represents the first set of trails designated for mountain bikes,” said Laura Lecher, Recreation, Trails, Engineering and Heritage Staff Officer, Shawnee National Forest. “Designating the system for bicycles will allow our agency to properly maintain the trail system for such use and reconstruct the trail to protect natural and cultural resources.” The trail system consists of sixteen miles on the Shawnee National Forest and three miles in the Dixon Springs State Park. The system includes the popular Lake Trail around Lake Glendale whose designation has been changed from hiker-only to hiker/bicycle use. Plans are being made for improving trail access points and trail system directional signage. Currently mountain bike enthusiasts can access the trail system in Lake Glendale Recreation Area at Cardinal Bay Boat Launch and Pine Point Picnic Area and at trailheads in Dixon Spring State Park.
    [Show full text]
  • Hardin County Area Map.Pdf
    YOUR GUIDE TO ADVENTURE IN SOUTHEASTERN ILLINOIS WWW.ILLINOISOZARKS.COM 1 Ohio River Scenic 4 Shawnee National 3 Old Stone Face 6 Sahara Woods State 7 Stonefort Depot Museum 11 Camp Cadiz 15 Golden Circle This former coal mining area Byway Welcome Center Forest Headquarters A ½ mile moderately strenuous Fish and Wildlife Area Built in 1890, this former railroad depot Natural Arch is now a 2,300 acre state park On the corner in downtown Equality. View Main office for the national forest with visitor trail takes you to scenic vistas This former coal mining area is now a is a step back in time with old signs from This unique rock arch forms a managed for hunting and fishing. their extensive collection of artifacts from information, displays and souvenirs for sale. and one of the finest and natural 2,300 acre state park managed for hunting railroad companies and former businesses, natural amphitheater that was Plans are being developed for the salt well industry while taking advantage stone face rock formations. and fishing. Plans are being developed tools and machines from the heyday of the secret meeting place of a off-road vehicle recreation trails. of indoor restrooms and visitor’s information. Continue on the Crest Trail to for off-road vehicle recreation trails. railroads and telegraphs are on display. group of southern sympathizers, the Tecumseh Statue at Glen the Knights of the Golden 42 Lake Glendale Stables O Jones Lake 3 miles away. Circle, during the Civil War. Saddle up and enjoy an unforgettable 40 Hidden Springs 33 Burden Falls horseback ride no matter what your 20 Lake Tecumseh Ranger Station During wet weather, an intermittent stream spills experience level.
    [Show full text]
  • Outdoor Recreational Needs & the Hunter Lake Opportunity Illinois
    Outdoor Recreational Needs & The Hunter Lake Opportunity Illinois Department of Natural Resources December 3, 2018 Introduction In 2015, the Illinois Department of Natural Resources (IDNR) entered into agreement with the City of Springfield to manage city-owned property surrounding the City’s proposed secondary water supply (Hunter Lake). The City has already acquired 7,138 acres for the project located in southeastern Sangamon County. The lake is expected to cover 2,560 surface-acres with water. Outdoors recreation generates about $32 billion in economic activity each year for the State of Illinois, according to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. All this activity supports 90,000 jobs statewide. As the population of the United States continues its gradual migration from rural to urban areas (U.S. Census Bureau), demand for recreational land, open space and hunting and fishing opportunities will continue to grow. With 95 percent of Illinois land in private hands, the state ranks 46th in terms of land in public ownership. The IDNR owns and manages about 480,000 acres. The partnership between the City and IDNR is intended to provide additional public access for outdoor recreation, education and habitat conservation on Hunter Lake and its surrounding area. The City concluded the IDNR is the appropriate state agency to help the City achieve this objective. IDNR has statutory authority to manage the state’s fish and wildlife resources. To this end, the City chose to enter a Memorandum of Cooperation with IDNR (Appendix A) and tasked the Agency with managing the property’s outdoors potential for recreational opportunity, including hunting, fishing, bird-watching, biking, hiking and camping.
    [Show full text]
  • Tunnel Hill 100 MILE RUN & 50 MILE RUN
    Tunnel Hill 100 MILE RUN & 50 MILE RUN NOVEMBER 13, 2016 TUNNEL HILL STATE TRAIL Vienna, Illinois IN THE HEART OF JOHNSON COUNTY The citizens of Johnson County WOULD LIKE TO WELCOME YOU We encourage you to take advantage of all that Johnson County has to offer during your stay with us. Below is just a short list of attractions. Throughout this booklet you will find local restaurants, shops, and tourist destinations. We hope you enjoy your time and look forward to seeing you again! Shawnee National Forest 1-800-MY-WOODS Ferne Clyffe State Park South of Goreville, IL, (618) 995-2411 Paul Powell Home (Museum) Rt. 146 and Vine, Vienna, IL 62995 Vienna Depot Welcome Center Vienna City Park, Vienna, IL 62995, (618) 658-8547 Shawnee Hills Wine Trail (618) 967-4006, shawneewinetrail.com Cache River Wetlands Center THE JOHNSON COUNTY 8885 Rt. 37 S, Cypress, IL, (618) 657-2064 BOARD OF Johnson County’s Courthouse COMMISSIONERS and Carnegie Public Library ERNIE HENSHAW, PHIL STEWART Vienna, IL, both on the AND FRED MEYER National Registry of Historic Buildings Tunnel Hill 100/50 Mile Run - 2 SCHEDULE OF EVENTS FRIDAY NOVEMBER 12, 2016 Packet Pick up – 4 p.m. – 8 p.m. Pasta Dinner - 6 p.m. – 7:30 p.m. Vienna High School – 601 N 1st St, Vienna, IL 62995 SATURDAY NOVEMBER 13, 2016 Late packet pick up 6:30 – 7:30 a.m. Start – 100 mile and 50 mile 8:00 a.m. Finish – 100 & 50 mi. – Sun. Nov. 15 2 p.m. Vienna City Park – 298 E.
    [Show full text]
  • Charles Springer of Cranehook-On-The-Delaware His Descendants and Allied Families by Jessie Evelyn Springer
    Charles Springer of Cranehook-on-the-Delaware His Descendants and Allied Families By JESSIE EVELYN SPRINGER ACKNOWLEDGMENTS For help on Springer research grateful acknow­ ledgment is extended to Mrs. Courtland B. Springer of Upper Darby, Pennsylvania, Mrs. Louise Eddleman, -Springfield, Kentucky, Mable Warner Milligan, Indian­ apolis, now deceased; the allied families, Gary Edward Young; John McKendree Springer, now deceased; Thomas Oglesby Springer and Lucinda Irwin, deceased; and Mary, Raymond and Theora Hahn. Much material has been secured from genealogies previously pub­ lished on the Benedicts, Saffords, Bontecous, and others, brought down to date by correspondence or interviews with Cora Taintor Brown, Springfield, Illi­ nois; Evelyn Safford Dew, Newark, Delaware; Isabell Gillham Crowder Helgevold, Chicago; John Harris Watts, Grand Junction, Iowa, and Glenn L. Head, Springfield, Illinois Charles Springer of Cranehook-on-the-Delaware His Descendants and Allied Families by Jessie Evelyn Springer OUR HERITAGE FORWORD Sarah John English has said "Genealogy, or the history of families, is not a service to the past gener­ ations, or a glorification of the dead, but a service to the living, and to coming generations." A study of those who gave us life can help us understand what makes us tick, and help us tolerate ourselves and each other. As this is the story of the heritage of four Springer sisters - Mary Springer Jackson, Florence Springer Volk, Carolyn Springer Dalton, and Jessie Springer, spinster, it seems best, to the writer, after
    [Show full text]
  • RV Sites in the United States Location Map 110-Mile Park Map 35 Mile
    RV sites in the United States This GPS POI file is available here: https://poidirectory.com/poifiles/united_states/accommodation/RV_MH-US.html Location Map 110-Mile Park Map 35 Mile Camp Map 370 Lakeside Park Map 5 Star RV Map 566 Piney Creek Horse Camp Map 7 Oaks RV Park Map 8th and Bridge RV Map A AAA RV Map A and A Mesa Verde RV Map A H Hogue Map A H Stephens Historic Park Map A J Jolly County Park Map A Mountain Top RV Map A-Bar-A RV/CG Map A. W. Jack Morgan County Par Map A.W. Marion State Park Map Abbeville RV Park Map Abbott Map Abbott Creek (Abbott Butte) Map Abilene State Park Map Abita Springs RV Resort (Oce Map Abram Rutt City Park Map Acadia National Parks Map Acadiana Park Map Ace RV Park Map Ackerman Map Ackley Creek Co Park Map Ackley Lake State Park Map Acorn East Map Acorn Valley Map Acorn West Map Ada Lake Map Adam County Fairgrounds Map Adams City CG Map Adams County Regional Park Map Adams Fork Map Page 1 Location Map Adams Grove Map Adelaide Map Adirondack Gateway Campgroun Map Admiralty RV and Resort Map Adolph Thomae Jr. County Par Map Adrian City CG Map Aerie Crag Map Aeroplane Mesa Map Afton Canyon Map Afton Landing Map Agate Beach Map Agnew Meadows Map Agricenter RV Park Map Agua Caliente County Park Map Agua Piedra Map Aguirre Spring Map Ahart Map Ahtanum State Forest Map Aiken State Park Map Aikens Creek West Map Ainsworth State Park Map Airplane Flat Map Airport Flat Map Airport Lake Park Map Airport Park Map Aitkin Co Campground Map Ajax Country Livin' I-49 RV Map Ajo Arena Map Ajo Community Golf Course Map
    [Show full text]
  • Final Environmental Impact Statement Appendices
    This document can be accessed on the Shawnee National Forest website: www.fs.fed.us/r9/forests/shawnee. The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) prohibits discrimination in all its programs and activities on the basis of race, color, national origin, gender, religion, age, disability, political beliefs, sexual orientation, or marital or family status. (Not all prohibited bases apply to all programs.) Persons with disabilities who require alternative means for communication of program information (Braille, large print, audiotape, etc.) should contact USDA's TARGET Center at (202) 720-2600 (voice and TDD). To file a complaint of discrimination, write USDA, Director, Office of Civil Rights, Room 326-W, Whitten Building, 14th and Independence Avenue, SW, Washington, DC 20250-9410 or call (202) 720-5964 (voice and TDD). USDA is an equal opportunity provider and employer. Shawnee National Forest Forest Plan FEIS Appendix A – Forest Plan Revision Issues and Public Involvement APPENDIX A FOREST PLAN REVISION ISSUES AND PUBLIC INVOLVEMENT I. INTRODUCTION The first SNF Land and Resource Management Plan (Plan) was approved on November 24, 1986. In 1988, following 23 administrative appeals, the Forest met with appellants and reached a settlement agreement. Significant changes in the Plan resulted in an amended Forest Plan signed in 1992. A lawsuit on nine counts was filed against the Plan in 1994. The court ruled in favor of the Forest Service on five counts and in favor of the plaintiffs on four. The court remanded the entire Plan, but allowed implementation, enjoining specific activities, including commercial, hardwood-timber harvest, ATV trail designation and oil and gas development.
    [Show full text]
  • Dixon Springs State Park Camping Area Are Available for Organized Groups
    Named For Pioneer Facilities Dixon Springs takes its name from William Dixon, who obtained State of Illinois I Picnicking I Picnic tables and outdoor stoves are available at Pat Quinn, Governor a school land warrant in 1848 from Gov. Augustus C. French. three shaded picnic areas. A picnic shelter, playgrounds, park- His cabin was a landmark for many years as was an old log Department of Natural Resources ing areas, and drinking water are also available. church on the adjoining knoll. I Swimming Pool I A modern swimming pool, bathhouse, A small community grew up at Dixon Springs and featured a and 45-foot water slide are provided for swimmers’ enjoyment. A general store, post office, blacksmith shop, grist mill, and several lifeguard is on duty at all times. Towering oaks, elms, and birch churches. trees shade the pool. Dixon Springs become a 19th century health spa which at- I Concession Stand I Located near the swimming pool, the tracted hundreds of people to its seven springs of mineral-en- stand provides a variety of refreshments. riched water. A bathhouse provided mineral or soft water baths, Dixon Springs hot or cold, available at any time. The natural beauty of the area I Trails I There is a self-guided, 1.7-mile nature trail and a STATE PARK and its interesting stone formations helped to give the park val- 1-mile trail through Ghost Dance Canyon. ley a more equable temperature in the summer than most of I Camping I There is a Class B trailer camp area with a san- southern Illinois.
    [Show full text]
  • Illinois State Parks
    COMPLIMENTARY $2.95 2017/2018 YOUR COMPLETE GUIDE TO THE PARKS ILLINOIS STATE PARKS ACTIVITIES • SIGHTSEEING • DINING • LODGING TRAILS • HISTORY • MAPS • MORE OFFICIAL PARTNERS This summer, Yamaha launches a new Star motorcycle designed to help you journey further…than you ever thought possible. To see the road ahead, visit YamahaMotorsports.com/Journey-Further Some motorcycles shown with custom parts, accessories, paint and bodywork. Dress properly for your ride with a helmet, eye protection, long sleeves, long pants, gloves and boots. Yamaha and the Motorcycle Safety Foundation encourage you to ride safely and respect the environment. For further information regarding the MSF course, please call 1-800-446-9227. Do not drink and ride. It is illegal and dangerous. ©2017 Yamaha Motor Corporation, U.S.A. All rights reserved. PRESERVATION WELCOME Energizing Welcome to Illinois! Thanks for picking up a copy of the adventure in partnership with Illinois State Parks guide to better plan your visit to our the National Parks Conservation remarkable state parks. Association. Illinois has an amazing array of state parks, fish and wildlife areas, and conservation and recreation areas, with an even broader selection of natural features and outdoor recreation opportunities. From the Lake Michigan shore at Illinois Beach to the canyons and waterfalls at Starved Rock; from the vistas above the mighty river at Mississippi Palisades to the hill prairies of Jim Edgar GO AND CONQUER Panther Creek; all the way to the sandstone walls of Giant City and the backwater swamps along the Cache River—Illinois has some of the most unique landscapes in America.
    [Show full text]
  • The Hoosier- Shawnee Ecological Assessment Area
    United States Department of Agriculture The Hoosier- Forest Service Shawnee Ecological North Central Assessment Research Station General Frank R. Thompson, III, Editor Technical Report NC-244 Thompson, Frank R., III, ed 2004. The Hoosier-Shawnee Ecological Assessment. Gen. Tech. Rep. NC-244. St. Paul, MN: U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, North Central Research Station. 267 p. This report is a scientific assessment of the characteristic composition, structure, and processes of ecosystems in the southern one-third of Illinois and Indiana and a small part of western Kentucky. It includes chapters on ecological sections and soils, water resources, forest, plants and communities, aquatic animals, terrestrial animals, forest diseases and pests, and exotic animals. The information presented provides a context for land and resource management planning on the Hoosier and Shawnee National Forests. ––––––––––––––––––––––––––– Key Words: crayfish, current conditions, communities, exotics, fish, forests, Hoosier National Forest, mussels, plants, Shawnee National Forest, soils, water resources, wildlife. Cover photograph: Camel Rock in Garden of the Gods Recreation Area, with Shawnee Hills and Garden of the Gods Wilderness in the back- ground, Shawnee National Forest, Illinois. Contents Preface....................................................................................................................... II North Central Research Station USDA Forest Service Acknowledgments ...................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Fiscal Year 2000 Appropriations
    IL L I N O I S AP P R O P R I A TI O N S 20 0 0 VOLUME II Fiscal Yea r 20 0 0 July 1, 1999 June 30, 2000 iii TABLE OF CONTENTS VOLUME II Page List of Appropriation Bills Approved: Senate Bills.......................................................................... v House Bills........................................................................... iv Text of Fiscal Year 2000 Appropriations: Other Agencies: Arts Council........................................................................ 1 Bureau of the Budget................................................................ 5 Capital Development Board........................................................... 6 Civil Service Commission............................................................ 69 Commerce Commission................................................................. 70 Comprehensive Health Insurance Board................................................ 72 Court of Claims..................................................................... 73 Deaf and Hard of Hearing Commission................................................. 97 Drycleaner Environmental Response Trust Fund Commission............................. 97 East St. Louis Financial Advisory Authority......................................... 97 Environmental Protection Agency..................................................... 98 Environmental Protection Trust Fund Commission...................................... 113 Guardianship and Advocacy Commission................................................ 114 Historic
    [Show full text]
  • Discover Illinois Archaeology
    Discover Illinois Archaeology ILLINOIS ASSOCIATION FOR ADVANCEMENT OF ARCHAEOLOGY ILLINOIS ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY Discover Illinois Archaeology Illinois’ rich cultural heritage began more collaborative effort by 18 archaeologists from than 12,000 years ago with the arrival of the across the state, with a major contribution by ancestors of today’s Native Americans. We learn Design Editor Kelvin Sampson. Along with sum- about them through investigations of the remains maries of each cultural period and highlights of they left behind, which range from monumental regional archaeological research, we include a earthworks with large river-valley settlements to short list of internet and print resources. A more a fragment of an ancient stone tool. After the extensive reading list can be found at the Illinois arrival of European explorers in the late 1600s, a Association for Advancement of Archaeology succession of diverse settlers added to our cul- web site www.museum.state.il.us/iaaa/DIA.pdf. tural heritage, leading to our modern urban com- We hope that by reading this summary of munities and the landscape we see today. Ar- Illinois archaeology, visiting a nearby archaeo- chaeological studies allow us to reconstruct past logical site or museum exhibit, and participating environments and ways of life, study the rela- in Illinois Archaeology Awareness Month pro- tionship between people of various cultures, and grams each September, you will become actively investigate how and why cultures rise and fall. engaged in Illinois’ diverse past and DISCOVER DISCOVER ILLINOIS ARCHAEOLOGY, ILLINOIS ARCHAEOLOGY. summarizing Illinois culture history, is truly a Alice Berkson Michael D. Wiant IIILLINOIS AAASSOCIATION FOR CONTENTS AAADVANCEMENT OF INTRODUCTION.
    [Show full text]