Fashionable Nonsense Delivers the Perfect Coup De Grace.” — B a R B a R a E H R E N R E I C H , a U T H O R of Blood Rites a N D the Snarling Citizen

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Fashionable Nonsense Delivers the Perfect Coup De Grace.” — B a R B a R a E H R E N R E I C H , a U T H O R of Blood Rites a N D the Snarling Citizen — 7------ 1------ 7------ 7------ 1------- A New Yot\ Times Notable Book of the Year A Boston Globe and San Francisco Chronicle Bestseller _j_____1_____1_____ I_____I_____I_____L_____/____ /____ L____ L____ L_L _/ “A thoroughly hilarious romp through the postmodernist academy. Fashionable Nonsense delivers the perfect coup de grace.” — B a r b a r a E h r e n r e i c h , a u t h o r of Blood Rites a n d The Snarling Citizen FASHIONABLE NONSENSE POSTMODERN INTELLECTUALS’ ABUSE of SCIENCE Additional praise for Fashionable Nonsense “Sokal is trying to stake out a territory free from the political claims of cul­ ture.” — Edward Rothstein, The New York Times “The modem sciences are among the most remarkable of human achieve­ ments and cultural treasures. Like others, they merit— and reward— respect­ ful and scrupulous engagement. Sokal and Bricmont show how easily such truisms can recede from view, and how harmful the consequences can be for intellectual life and human affairs. They also provide a thoughtful and con­ structive critical analysis of fundamental issues of empirical inquiry. It is a timely and substantial contribution." — Noam Chomsky “A brilliant and entertaining book...Fashionable Nonsense exposes the fraud.” — The Advocate “A debut that promises to be [the debate’s] most explosive incarnation yet.” — Kristina Zarlengo, Salon Magazine “Sheer chutzpah and cleverness .. .The book is a sobering catalog o f idiocies by some of those claimed to be the best thinkers of our times.. .1 recommend this book.” — Russell Jacoby, Los Angeles Weekly “[An] important and well-documented book...Every passage is followed by the authors’ often humorous debunking of the writers’ garbled science and obscure language. It’s good reading.” —Raleigh News-Observer “Their book has come like a breath of fresh air.” —John Weightman, The Hudson Review “An in-depth examination." —Rolling Stone “Hilarious.. .What can be more irresistible than the opportunity to take some pompous, widely respected intellectual and knock him flat on his ass by exposing him as an idiot?” — Fred Moody, Seattle Weekly “[An] audacious debunking...The authors’ fervor and the precision of their writing makes this a most engaging read.” —Publishers Weekly “What they reveal is scandalous.. .true hilarity.. .The physicists aren’t staging some sort of anti-theoretical pogrom; they’re just standing up for rationali­ ty." — Glenn Dixon, Washington City Paper “This is a valuable and well-argued document in one of the key philosophi­ cal debates of our time.” —Kirkus Reviews Also by Alan Sokal Random Walks, Critical Phenomena, and Triviality in Quantum Field Theory (with Roberto Fernandez and Jiirg Frolich) Fashionable Nonsense Postmodern Intellectuals’ Abuse of Science Alan Sokal and Jean Bricmont Picador New York FASHIONABLE NONSENSE: POSTMODERN INTELLECTUALS' ABUSE OF SCIENCE. Copyright © 1998 by Alan Sokal and Jean Bricmont. All rights reserved. Printed in the United States of America. For information, address Picador, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10010. www.picadorusa.com Picador® is a U.S. registered trademark and is used by St. Martin’s Press under license from Pan Books Limited. For information on Picador Reading Group Guides, as well as ordering, please contact the Trade Marketing department at St. Martin’s Press. Phone: 1-800-221-7945 extension 763 Fax: 212-677-7456 E-mail: [email protected] Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Sokal, Alan. Fashionable nonsense : postmodern intellectuals' abuse of science / Alan Sokal and Jean Bricmont. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index ISBN 0-312-19445-1 (he) ISBN 0-312-20407-8 (pbk) 1. Science—Philosophy. I. Bricmont, J. (Jean) II. Title. Q175.S3659 1998 501—dc21 98-35336 CIP First published in France under the title Impostures Intellectuelles by Editions Odile Jacob, 1997 20 19 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11 For Marina For Claire,Thomas, and Antoine Contents Preface to the English Edition ix 1. Introduction 1 2. Jacques Lacan 18 3. Julia Kristeva 38 4. Intermezzo: Epistemic Relativism in the Philosophy of Science 50 5. Luce Irigaray 106 6. Bruno Latour 124 7. Intermezzo: Chaos Theory and “Postmodern Science” 134 8. Jean Baudrillard 147 9. Gilles Deleuze and Felix Guattari 154 10. Paul Virilio 169 11. Godel’s Theorem and Set Theory: Some Examples of Abuse 176 12. Epilogue 182 A. Transgressing the Boundaries: Toward a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity 212 B. Some Comments on the Parody 259 C. Transgressing the Boundaries: An Afterword 268 Bibliography 281 Index 297 Preface to the English Edition The publication in France of our book Impostures Intel- lectuelles1 appears to have created a small storm in certain in­ tellectual circles. According to Jon Henley in The Guardian, we have shown that “modem French philosophy is a load of old tosh.”2 According to Robert Maggiori in Liberation, we are humorless scientistic pedants who correct grammatical errors in love letters.3 We would like to explain briefly why neither is the case, and to answer both our critics and our over- enthusiastic supporters. In particular, we want to dispel a num­ ber of misunderstandings. The book grew out of the now-famous hoax in which one of us published, in the American cultural-studies journal Social Text, a parody article crammed with nonsensical, but unfortu­ nately authentic, quotations about physics and mathematics by prominent French and American intellectuals.4 However, only a small fraction of the “dossier” discovered during Sokal’s library research could be included in the parody. After showing this larger dossier to scientist and non-scientist friends, we became (slowly) convinced that it might be worth making it available to a wider audience. We wanted to explain, in non-technical terms, why the quotes are absurd or, in many cases, simply meaning­ less; and we wanted also to discuss the cultural circumstances 'Editions Odile Jacob, Paris, October 1997. 2Henley (1997). 3Maggiori (1997). 4Sokal (1996a), reprinted here in Appendix A. The story o f the hoax is described in more detail in Chapter 1 below. X PREFACE TO THE ENGLISH EDITION that enabled these discourses to achieve such renown and to re­ main, thus far, unexposed. But what exactly do we claim? Neither too much nor too lit­ tle. We show that famous intellectuals such as Lacan, Kristeva, Irigaray, Baudrillard, and Deleuze have repeatedly abused sci­ entific concepts and terminology: either using scientific ideas totally out of context, without giving the slightest justification— note that we are not against extrapolating concepts from one field to another, but only against extrapolations made without argument— or throwing around scientific jargon in front of their non-scientist readers without any regard for its relevance or even its meaning. We make no claim that this invalidates the rest of their work, on which we suspend judgment. We are sometimes accused of being arrogant scientists, but our view of the hard sciences’ role is in fact rather modest. Wouldn’t it be nice (for us mathematicians and physicists, that is) if Godel’s theorem or relativity theory did have immediate and deep implications for the study of society? Or if the axiom of choice could be used to study poetry? Or if topology had something to do with the human psyche? But alas, it is not the case. A second target of our book is epistemic relativism, namely the idea— which, at least when expressed explicitly, is much more widespread in the English-speaking world than in France— that modem science is nothing more than a “myth”, a “narration” or a “social construction” among many others.5 Be­ sides some gross abuses (e.g. Irigaray), we dissect a number of confusions that are rather frequent in postmodernist and cultural-studies circles: for example, misappropriating ideas from the philosophy of science, such as the underdetermina­ tion of theory by evidence or the theory-ladenness of observa­ tion, in order to support radical relativism. This book is therefore made up of two distinct— but related— works under one cover. First, there is the collection of 5Let us emphasize that our discussion is limited to epistemic/cognitive relativism; we do not address the more delicate issues o f moral or aesthetic relativism. PREFACE TO THE ENGLISH EDITION xi extreme abuses discovered, rather haphazardly, by Sokal; this is the “fashionable nonsense” of our title. Second, there is our cri­ tique of epistemic relativism arid of misconceptions about “post­ modern science”; these analyses are considerably more subtle. The connection between these two critiques is primarily socio­ logical: the French authors of the “nonsense” are fashionable in many of the same English-speaking academic circles where epistemic relativism is the coin of the realm.6 There is also a weak logical link: if one accepts epistemic relativism, there is less reason to be upset by the misrepresentation of scientific ideas, which anyway are just another “discourse”. Obviously, we did not write this book just to point out some isolated abuses. We have larger targets in mind, but not neces­ sarily those that are attributed to us. This book deals with mys­ tification, deliberately obscure language, confused thinking, and the misuse of scientific concepts. The texts we quote may be the tip of an iceberg, but the iceberg should be defined as a set of in­ tellectual practices, not a social group. Suppose, for example, that a journalist discovers documents showing that several highly respected politicians are corrupt, and publishes them. (We emphasize that this is an analogy and that we do not consider the abuses described here to be of com­ parable gravity.) Some people will, no doubt, leap to the con­ clusion that most politicians are corrupt, and demagogues who stand to gain politically from this notion will encourage it.7 But this extrapolation would be erroneous.
Recommended publications
  • Beyond the Hoax: Science, Philosophy and Culture Kindle
    BEYOND THE HOAX: SCIENCE, PHILOSOPHY AND CULTURE PDF, EPUB, EBOOK Alan Sokal | 488 pages | 19 Mar 2010 | Oxford University Press | 9780199561834 | English | Oxford, United Kingdom Beyond the Hoax: Science, Philosophy and Culture PDF Book Jul 02, Ugh rated it liked it. Views Read Edit View history. He works in statistical mechanics and combinatorics. Friend Reviews. Read an excerpt of this book! This may have been his thinking, but I thought it came off as arrogant. Javascript is not enabled in your browser. Everyone in the US - even the Amish - makes at least some use of the fruits of science. Sokal is one of the most powerful voices in the continuing debate about the status of evidence-based knowledge. Religion, politics and survival It may be a particularly shitty butterfly, but that doesn't mean it's at all interesting to break. I found Sokal's critiq The only aspect of the Sokal Hoax I was aware of before I read this book was that the hoax article Sokal wrote about physics was submitted to a publication that did not subject articles to peer review. To ask other readers questions about Beyond the Hoax , please sign up. His critique would also gain more credibility from encompassing his own community: the failure of scientific institutions to address the abuse of statistical methods or promote systematic reviews is no less of a threat to progress than the ramblings of postmodernists or fundamentalists. However, he is a de The first couple of chapters the ones describing the hoax were pretty good, but after that it veers off into armchair philosophizing about the philosophy of science; it's not that I didn't agree with him on most points, but if I'm going to spend time reading about the philosophy of science, I'm going to read what a specialist says about it.
    [Show full text]
  • Light Shadows: Loose Adaptations of Gothic Literature in American TV Series of the 1960S and Early 1970S
    TV/Series 12 | 2017 Littérature et séries télévisées/Literature and TV series Light Shadows: Loose Adaptations of Gothic Literature in American TV Series of the 1960s and early 1970s Dennis Tredy Electronic version URL: http://journals.openedition.org/tvseries/2200 DOI: 10.4000/tvseries.2200 ISSN: 2266-0909 Publisher GRIC - Groupe de recherche Identités et Cultures Electronic reference Dennis Tredy, « Light Shadows: Loose Adaptations of Gothic Literature in American TV Series of the 1960s and early 1970s », TV/Series [Online], 12 | 2017, Online since 20 September 2017, connection on 01 May 2019. URL : http://journals.openedition.org/tvseries/2200 ; DOI : 10.4000/tvseries.2200 This text was automatically generated on 1 May 2019. TV/Series est mis à disposition selon les termes de la licence Creative Commons Attribution - Pas d'Utilisation Commerciale - Pas de Modification 4.0 International. Light Shadows: Loose Adaptations of Gothic Literature in American TV Series o... 1 Light Shadows: Loose Adaptations of Gothic Literature in American TV Series of the 1960s and early 1970s Dennis Tredy 1 In the late 1960’s and early 1970’s, in a somewhat failed attempt to wrestle some high ratings away from the network leader CBS, ABC would produce a spate of supernatural sitcoms, soap operas and investigative dramas, adapting and borrowing heavily from major works of Gothic literature of the nineteenth and early twentieth century. The trend began in 1964, when ABC produced the sitcom The Addams Family (1964-66), based on works of cartoonist Charles Addams, and CBS countered with its own The Munsters (CBS, 1964-66) –both satirical inversions of the American ideal sitcom family in which various monsters and freaks from Gothic literature and classic horror films form a family of misfits that somehow thrive in middle-class, suburban America.
    [Show full text]
  • Swirling Water by Paradise Return to Main “Swirling Water” Page
    Contents x-libris.xf-redux.com Swirling Water by Paradise Return to main “Swirling Water” page From: [email protected] Date: Mon, 31 Jan 2000 20:05:48 EST Subject: Swirling Water Source: direct Disclaimer: I do not own Mulder and Scully. They belong to Chris Carter, David and Gillian, Fox, and 1013 Productions. No infringement intended. Title: Swirling Water Rating: NC-17 for sex Keywords: Mulder/Scully Romance Summary: Scully takes a vacation half way across the country, Mulder finds her, and does what we’ve all been waiting for. Spoilers: Minor for 2Shy, El Mundo Gira, Bad Blood Thanks to: Rita! You’re my savior! E-mail: [email protected] Author: Paradise Written: 1999 _____________ She’d escaped. Dana Scully had escaped. She stood now, at 2:13 in the morning, wearing a white bathing suit that she would never wear in the day time, in front of the beautiful San Diego beach. The moon reflected sparkling stars on the distant waves, and she felt shivers as the ocean moved. Her body moved with it. With millions of lit dots glittering on the swirling water, https://x-libris.xf-redux.com/story/swirling-water/ 2/11 x-libris.xf-redux.com Swirling Water by Paradise Dana felt as though it were a computer chip, blinking sparks and rays and her blood ran quickly through her body. She’d always wanted to see the world from the outside in, for she’d always felt she’d been someone outside looking in. She was always watching Mulder, watching him solve the cases, watching him believe, watching him with growing passion in his eyes for something he could never touch, it was never quite in his reach.
    [Show full text]
  • Pan Macmillan AUTUMN CATALOGUE 2021 PUBLICITY CONTACTS
    Pan Macmillan AUTUMN CATALOGUE 2021 PUBLICITY CONTACTS General enquiries [email protected] Alice Dewing FREELANCE [email protected] Anna Pallai Amy Canavan [email protected] [email protected] Caitlin Allen Camilla Elworthy [email protected] [email protected] Elinor Fewster Emma Bravo [email protected] [email protected] Emma Draude Gabriela Quattromini [email protected] [email protected] Emma Harrow Grace Harrison [email protected] [email protected] Jacqui Graham Hannah Corbett [email protected] [email protected] Jamie-Lee Nardone Hope Ndaba [email protected] [email protected] Laura Sherlock Jess Duffy [email protected] [email protected] Ruth Cairns Kate Green [email protected] [email protected] Philippa McEwan [email protected] Rosie Wilson [email protected] Siobhan Slattery [email protected] CONTENTS MACMILLAN PAN MANTLE TOR PICADOR MACMILLAN COLLECTOR’S LIBRARY BLUEBIRD ONE BOAT MACMILLAN Nine Lives Danielle Steel Nine Lives is a powerful love story by the world’s favourite storyteller, Danielle Steel. Nine Lives is a thought-provoking story of lost love and new beginnings, by the number one bestseller Danielle Steel. After a carefree childhood, Maggie Kelly came of age in the shadow of grief. Her father, a pilot, died when she was nine. Maggie saw her mother struggle to put their lives back together. As the family moved from one city to the next, her mother warned her about daredevil men and to avoid risk at all cost. Following her mother’s advice, and forgoing the magic of first love with a high-school boyfriend who she thought too wild, Maggie married a good, dependable man.
    [Show full text]
  • Alternative Textbooks Publishers
    ALTERNATIVE TEXT PUBLISHERS TUTORING SERVICES 2071 CEDAR HALL ALTERNATIVE TEXT PUBLISHERS Below is a list of all the publishers we work with to provide alternative text files. Aaronco Pet Products, Inc. Iowa State: Extension and Outreach Abrams Publishing Jones & Bartlett Learning ACR Publications KendallHunt Publishing Alpine Publisher Kogan Page American Health Information Management Associations Labyrinth Learning American Hotels and Lodging Legal Books Distributing American Technical Publishers Lippincott Williams and Wilkins American Welding Society Longleaf Services AOTA Press Lynne Rienner Publishers Apress Macmillan Higher Education Associated Press Manning Publications ATI Nursing Education McGraw-Hill Education American Water Works Association Mike Holt Enterprises Baker Publishing Group Morton Publishing Company Barron's Mosby Bedford/St. Martin's Murach Books Bison Books NAEYC Blackwell Books NASW Press National Board for Certification in Bloomsbury Publishing Dental Laboratory Technology (NBC) National Restaurant Association/ Blue Book, The ServSafe Blue Door Publishing Office of Water Programs BookLand Press Openstax Broadview Press O'Reilly Media Building Performance Institute, Inc. Oxford University Press BVT Publishing Paradigm Publishing Cadquest Pearson Custom Editions ALTERNATIVE TEXT PUBLISHERS Cambridge University Press Pearson Education CE Publishing Peguin Books Cengage Learning Pennwell Books Charles C. Thomas, Publisher Picador Charles Thomas Publisher Pioneer Drama Cheng & Tsui PlanningShop Chicago Distribution
    [Show full text]
  • New Religious Movements
    New Religious Movements New Religious Movements: Challenge and response is a searching and wide-ranging collection of essays on the contemporary phenomenon of new religions. The contributors to this volume are all established specialists in the sociology, theology, law, or the history of new minority movements. The primary focus is the response of the basic institutions of society to the challenge which new religious movements represent. The orientation of this volume is to examine the way in which new movements in general have affected modern society in areas such as economic organisation; the operation of the law; the role of the media; the relationship of so-called ‘cult’ membership to mental health; and the part which women have played in leading or supporting new movements. Specific instances of these relationships are illustrated by reference to many of the most prominent new religions – Hare Krishna, The Brahma Kumaris, The Unification Church, The Jesus Army, The Family’, The Church of Scientology, and Wicca. For students of religion or sociology, New Religious Movements is an invaluable source of information, an example of penetrating analysis, and a series of thought-provoking contributions to a debate which affects many areas of contemporary life in many parts of the world. Contributors: Eileen Barker, James Beckford, Anthony Bradney, Colin Campbell, George Chryssides, Peter Clarke, Paul Heelas, Massimo Introvigne, Lawrence Lilliston, Gordon Melton, Elizabeth Puttick, Gary Shepherd, Colin Slee, Frank Usarski, Bryan Wilson. Bryan Wilson is an Emeritus Fellow of All Souls College, Oxford. He is the author and editor of several books on sects and New Religious Movements.
    [Show full text]
  • Reply by Jean Bricmont and Alan Sokal
    Reply to Turnbull Krips Dusek and Fuller For Metascience Jean Bricmont Institut de Physique Theorique Universite Catholique de Louvain chemin du Cyclotron B LouvainlaNeuve BELGIUM Internet BRICMONTFYMAUCLACBE Telephone Fax Alan Sokal Department of Physics New York University Washington Place New York NY USA Internet SOKALNYUEDU Telephone Fax February Biographical Note Jean Bricmont is professor of theoretical physics at the University of Louvain Belgium Alan Sokal is professor of physics at New York University Introduction 1 In the preface to the second edition of Intel lectual Impostures we wrote that the criticisms of our b o ok can b e divided roughly into four types A very few reviewers discuss what we wrote and try to refute it Other commentators raise ob jections often p erfectly valid ones to ideas that are not in fact ours and that we may have expressly rejected in the b o ok while attributing them to us implicitly or explicitly Yet a third group of critics pretend to discuss our b o ok while actually doing something completely dierent for example attacking our p ersonalities our alleged motivations for writing the b o ok or the failings of scientists in general And nally some reviewers agree with us but think that we do not go far enough I I p xv The comments by Turnbull and Dusek fall squarely into the second and third cat egories apart from o ccasional brief excursions into category while Krips and Fuller oer a mixture of the rst and second categories It would b e a hop eless task to address al l the issues
    [Show full text]
  • Co-Workers Mourn, Address Elton's Murder
    www.tooeletranscript.com TUESDAY TOOELE RANSCRIPT ‘The Nerd’ sure T to keep THS theatre buffs in hysterics See B1 BULLETIN February 21, 2006 SERVING TOOELE COUNTY SINCE 1894 VOL. 112 NO. 78 50 cents Many bills Co-workers mourn, address Elton’s murder unresolved Owners: no new policies needed as session by Jesse Fruhwirth STAFF WRITER nears end Fitting but surreal, the press conference was held across a by Jesse Fruhwirth pond from the Clearfield home STAFF WRITER where Raechale Elton was The Legislature is running out of raped and murdered. The for- time in its regular session, and many mer employers and co-workers of issues remain unresolved. The gover- the slain Tooele college student nor has locked horns with legislators spoke with the media Monday, over food and income taxes and radio- describing the last moments any- active waste disposal licensing. one would see her alive. Waste veto The owners of Youth Health Governor John Huntsman Jr. has Associates where Elton worked, promised to do what he can to stop and 17-year-old Robert Cameron SB-70, but legislators are only three Houston lived, said the victim votes from getting their way. The bill would have known her attack- allows the Legislature to override the er’s past criminal history, which governor’s veto in applications for included past sex crimes. They waste disposal licenses with a two- went on to describe the nature of thirds majority vote. their operations and how Elton That two-thirds vote is precisely found herself alone in a YHA- what the Legislature will need to over- owned home with her murderer.
    [Show full text]
  • Mathematics and the Roots of Postmodern Thought This Page Intentionally Left Blank Mathematics and the Roots of Postmodern Thought
    Mathematics and the Roots of Postmodern Thought This page intentionally left blank Mathematics and the Roots of Postmodern Thought Vladimir Tasic OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS 2001 OXTORD UNIVERSITY PRESS Oxford New York Athens Auckland Bangkok Bogota Buenos Aires Cape Town Chennai Dar es Salaam Delhi Florence Hong Kong Istanbul Karachi Kolkata Kuala Lumpur Madrid Melbourne Mexico City Mumbai Nairobi Paris Sao Paulo Shanghai Singapore Taipei Tokyo Toronto Warsaw and associated companies in Berlin Ibadan Copyright © 2001 by Oxford University Press, Inc. Published by Oxford University Press, Inc. 198 Madison Avenue. New York, New York 10016 Oxford is a registered trademark of Oxford University Press All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior permission of Oxford University Press. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Tasic, Vladimir, 1965- Mathematics and the roots of postmodern thought / Vladimir Tasic. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-19-513967-4 1. Mathematics—Philosophy. 2. Postmodernism. I. Title. QA8.4.T35 2001 510M—dc21 2001021846 987654321 Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper For Maja This page intentionally left blank ACKNOWLEDGMENTS As much as I would like to share the responsibility for my oversimplifications, misreadings or misinterpretations with all the people and texts that have in- fluenced my thinking, I must bear that burden alone. For valuable discussions and critiques, I am indebted to Hart Caplan, Gre- gory Chaitin, Sinisa Crvenkovic, Guillermo Martinez, Lianne McTavish, Maja Padrov, Shauna Pomerantz, Goran Stanivukovic, Marija and Milos Tasic, Jon Thompson, and Steven Turner.
    [Show full text]
  • When Scholarship Obfuscates: Methodological Problems with Fan Studies
    When Scholarship Obfuscates (Mason) When Scholarship Obfuscates: Methodological Problems with Fan Studies Paul Mason Abstract Fields of study are based on more-or-less arbitrarily defined boundaries, and researchers should be aware of these boundaries and their limitations. The methodologies and rigor of fields of study should also be subject to critique if they are to retain academic relevance. Fan studies exhibits problems with the use of its key terminology, and its scope has also been artificially limited as a result of the preoccupations of the media scholars who were instrumental in its formation. This has led to potentially instructive aspects of the field being almost entirely excluded from consideration, which in turn has led to theory which fails to take account of distinctive characteristics of the excluded aspects. To challenge this vicious circle, more attention should be paid to these areas of fan activity which lie at a remove from the media-dominated mainstream. Keywords: Fandom, fan, consumption, methodology Introduction What concerns me here is the extent to which specific academic agendas have tended to dictate the conceptual shape of fandom within cultural studies. (Hills, 2002, p. 8) Hills’s concern about the “conceptual shape” of fan studies from 17 years ago succinctly expresses an issue to be addressed in the present paper. Any field of study is based on more- or-less arbitrarily defined boundaries. This is necessary for fields of study to exist at all. But the nature of these boundaries needs to be borne in mind, and their validity interrogated, to ensure that the field of study is not merely the covert expression of an academic agenda.
    [Show full text]
  • Regimes of Truth in the X-Files
    Edith Cowan University Research Online Theses: Doctorates and Masters Theses 1-1-1999 Aliens, bodies and conspiracies: Regimes of truth in The X-files Leanne McRae Edith Cowan University Follow this and additional works at: https://ro.ecu.edu.au/theses Part of the Film and Media Studies Commons Recommended Citation McRae, L. (1999). Aliens, bodies and conspiracies: Regimes of truth in The X-files. https://ro.ecu.edu.au/ theses/1247 This Thesis is posted at Research Online. https://ro.ecu.edu.au/theses/1247 Edith Cowan University Research Online Theses: Doctorates and Masters Theses 1999 Aliens, bodies and conspiracies : regimes of truth in The -fiX les Leanne McRae Edith Cowan University Recommended Citation McRae, L. (1999). Aliens, bodies and conspiracies : regimes of truth in The X-files. Retrieved from http://ro.ecu.edu.au/theses/1247 This Thesis is posted at Research Online. http://ro.ecu.edu.au/theses/1247 Edith Cowan University Copyright Warning You may print or download ONE copy of this document for the purpose of your own research or study. The University does not authorize you to copy, communicate or otherwise make available electronically to any other person any copyright material contained on this site. You are reminded of the following: Copyright owners are entitled to take legal action against persons who infringe their copyright. A reproduction of material that is protected by copyright may be a copyright infringement. Where the reproduction of such material is done without attribution of authorship, with false attribution of authorship or the authorship is treated in a derogatory manner, this may be a breach of the author’s moral rights contained in Part IX of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth).
    [Show full text]
  • The X-Files Mythology Volume 2 – Black Oil
    The X-Files Mythology Volume 2 – Black Oil PDF generated using the open source mwlib toolkit. See http://code.pediapress.com/ for more information. PDF generated at: Sun, 18 May 2014 19:28:27 UTC Contents Articles Overview 1 The X-Files Mythology, Volume 2 – Black Oil 1 Episodes 6 "Nisei" 6 "731" 11 "Piper Maru" 16 "Apocrypha" 21 "Talitha Cumi" 25 "Herrenvolk" 30 "Tunguska" 34 "Terma" 38 "Memento Mori" 41 "Tempus Fugit" 45 "Max" 49 "Zero Sum" 53 "Gethsemane" 57 "Redux" 61 References Article Sources and Contributors 67 Image Sources, Licenses and Contributors 68 Article Licenses License 69 1 Overview The X-Files Mythology, Volume 2 – Black Oil The X-Files Mythology Volume 2 – Black Oil Region 1 DVD cover Country of origin United States No. of episodes 15 Home video release DVD release Region 1 August 2, 2005 Series chronology ← Previous Volume 1 – Abduction Next → Volume 3 – Colonization Volume 2 of The X-Files Mythology collection is the second DVD release containing selected episodes from the third to the fifth seasons of the American science fiction television series The X-Files. The episodes collected in the release form the middle of the series' mythology, and are centered on the discovery of a mind-altering extraterrestrial "black oil". The collection contains five episodes from the third season, eight from the fourth season, and two from the fifth. The episodes follow the investigations of paranormal-related cases, or X-Files, by FBI Special Agents Fox Mulder (David Duchovny) and Dana Scully (Gillian Anderson). Mulder is a believer in the paranormal, while the skeptical Scully has been assigned to debunk his work.
    [Show full text]