Novitates PUBLISHED by the AMERICAN MUSEUM of NATURAL HISTORY CENTRAL PARK WEST at 79TH STREET, NEW YORK, N.Y
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
AMERICAN MUSEUM Novitates PUBLISHED BY THE AMERICAN MUSEUM OF NATURAL HISTORY CENTRAL PARK WEST AT 79TH STREET, NEW YORK, N.Y. 10024 Number 2772, pp. 1-49, figs. 1-7, tables 1-5 November 9, 1983 The Origin and Affinities of the South American Condylarthra and Early Tertiary Litopterna (Mammalia) RICHARD L. CIFELLII ABSTRACT A previously unknown genus and species of Proectocion (including Oxybunotherium), previ- a primitive litoptem from the late Paleocene ously referred to the Didolodontidae, is placed in (Riochican) of Itaborai, Brazil, is described, and the advanced litoptern family Adianthidae. three previously described didolodontid and li- An ancestral morphotype for the Litoptema and toptern species from Itaborai are referred to new Didolodontidae is constructed on the basis oftheir genera. Comparative analysis of the dentition of known morphology and by comparison with didolodontids and primitive Litoptema suggests a primitive oxyclaenine arctocyonids such as Pro- number of revisions in their taxonomy. The two tungulatum. Relevant North American ungulate Itaborai didolodonts appear to be more closely families (Arctocyonidae, Hyopsodontidae, Phen- related to each other than to Patagonian forms; acodontidae, Periptychidae) are briefly reviewed Protolipterna, new genus, Miguelsoria, new genus, and their members compared with this hypothet- ?and Asmithwoodwardia are placed in the Litop- ical ancestor. The primitive litoptern/didolodont terna in a new family, Protolipternidae. Aniso- morphotype is closely comparable to and shares lambda (including Ricardolydekkeria and Joseph- derived conditions with Torrejonian mioclaenine oleidya) and allies seem to be related to true hyopsodonts such as Litaletes. Such an exclusive proterotheriids, and are placed in the Proterotheri- relationship implies that the indigenous South idae in a new subfamily, Anisolambdinae, whereas American ungulate orders may not represent a the Polymorphinae (including only the type genus) strictly monophyletic unit with respect to other appears to be related to the Macraucheniidae. Eutheria. INTRODUCTION The pre-Oligocene Litopterna and their and Simpson, consists ofjaw fragments and presumed allies, the didolodontid condy- isolated teeth from Patagonia. Because of its larths, are poorly known and little under- age, geographic location, and faunal repre- stood. Most of their early record, brought to sentation, the faunule from Sao Jose de Ita- light largely through the efforts of Ameghino borai, Brazil, is extremely important to in- 1 Student, Department of Vertebrate Paleontology, American Museum of Natural History. Copyright © American Museum of Natural History 1983 ISSN 0003-0082 / Price $3.80 2 AMERICAN MUSEUM NOVITATES NO. 2772 terpretation ofthe origin and early radiations mammals, I am grateful to Drs. M. Mc- of these and other indigenous South Ameri- Kenna, M. Soria, G. Simpson, and L. Mar- can mammals. shall, although they do not necessarily es- Most of the manmmals from Itaborai were pouse my conclusions. Comments and described in a series ofcontributions by Paula criticisms on an earlier draft of this paper Couto (1952a, 1952b, 1952c, 1952d, 1954, were provided by Drs. M. McKenna and F. 1961, 1962, 1963, 1970, 1978a, 1978b, Szalay, and their advice is warmly appreci- 1978c, 1979). Despite considerable ecologic ated. Partial funding for this research was variance with the Patagonian faunas (Paula provided by the Theodore Roosevelt Me- Couto, 1970), a Riochican (late Paleocene) morial Fund, Thomas J. Dee Fund, Walker age is indicated by the presence of Carodnia Johnson Fund, Department of Geological (Paula Couto, 1952a), which occurs in Pat- Sciences, Columbia University, and the So- agonia only in the earliest Riochican faunal ciety of Sigma Xi. zone (Simpson, 1935a). The fossils derive from fissure- and channel-fill argillaceous ABBREVIATIONS marl deposits cut into the Itaborai Forma- a limestone of Late Cretaceous ACM, Pratt Museum, Amherst College, Amherst, tion, probable MA. or early Paleocene age (Francisco and Souza AMNH, American Museum of Natural History, Cunha, 1978), and have been recovered dur- New York, NY. ing the process of commercial limestone DNPM (sometimes cited as DGM), Divisao Na- quarrying. The Itaborai Formation is local, cional de Producao Mineral, Rio de Janeiro, being restricted to a small tectonic basin about Brazil. 25 km. northeast of Niteroi, State of Rio de FMNH, Field Museum of Natural History, Chi- Janeiro, Brazil. Additional material collected cago, IL. since the studies of Paula Couto reveal the MACN, Museo Argentino de Ciencas Naturales presence of a new litoptern species, and de- "Bernardino Rivadavia," Buenos Aires, Argen- tailed with the type and referred tina. comparison MLP, Museo de La Plata, La Plata, Argentina. specimens from Patagonia indicates three MHN, Museum National d'Histoire Naturelle, previously described species to represent new Paris, France. genera. In the present offering I describe these MNRJ, Museu Nacional de Rio de Janeiro, Rio materials and reevaluate the interrelation- de Janeiro, Brazil. ships and affinities ofthe Didolodontidae and Litopterna. SYSTEMATIC PALEONTOLOGY ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ORDER CONDYLARTHRA COPE, 1881a2 FAMILY DIDOLODONTIDAE SCOTT, 1913 For permission to study specimens in their care and help in so doing, I thank Drs. M. Didolodidae Scott, 1913, p. 489. Bunolipternidae Schlosser, 1923, p. 525. Coombs (Amherst College), C. Schaff (Mu- Didolodontidae Simpson, 1934, p. 6. seum of Comparative Zoology), D. Baird (Princeton University), W. Tumbull (Field DIAGNOSIS: Dentition complete and mio- Museum of Natural History), E. Lindsay claenine-like in primitive forms, but a hy- (University of Arizona), R. Emry (United pocone is present on M3. Tarsus, where States National Museum), F. de Souza Cunha known, lacking astragalocuboid contact (se- (Museu Nacional de Rio de Janeiro), D. rial); astragalus with relatively deep body but Campos (Divisao Nacional de Producao Mineral), J. Bonaparte and M. Soria (Museo de Ciencas Naturales "Bernardino 2 This aggregate of primitive ungulates has long been Argentino recognized to be a horizontal or paraphyletic group in Rivadavia") and R. Pascual and M. Bond the formal taxonomic sense, an arrangement not wholly (Museo de La Plata). The fine halftone illus- satisfactory but maintained because available evidence trations of figure 4 are the work of Mr. H. is inadequate to permit distribution ofthe included groups Galiano. For informative exchanges of fact into more meaningful suprafamilial categories. See dis- and opinion regarding South American fossil cussion below. 1983 CIFELLI: CONDYLARTHRA 3 margins of the tibial trochlea not raised into Simpson (1948) has already shown. Proec- sharp crests; superior astragalar foramen ves- tocion, based on upper cheek teeth, I place in tigial or absent. Astragalar head medially and the Litopterna and refer to it the lower molars transversely expanded. Astragalar facet for described by Pascual (1965) as Oxybuno- the medial malleolus ofthe tibia vertical and therium. Stirton (1947)3 described a worn M3 turning sharply mediad anteriorly. Peroneal from the Oligocene of Colombia as Lophio- tubercle of calcaneum extending posterodor- dolodus chaparralensis, but pertinence to this sally and terminating at the base of the ectal group is not clear, and it may be sirenian, as prominence. speculated by McKenna (1956). Paula Couto Simpson (1948, p. 95) noted that, "it is at (1952a) described four species of didolodon- present impossible to frame a purely mor- tids from Itaborai: Ernestokokenia parayi- phological definition (i.e., of the Didolodon- runhor, E. protocenica, Asmithwoodwardia tidae) which would ... exclude the North scotti, and Lamegoia conodonta. Based on American condylarth families." The above pedal evidence presented elsewhere (Cifelli, pedal characters, all advanced with respect 1983), I here refer Ernestokokenia parayi- to the primitive ungulate condition seen in runhor to the Litopterna under a new generic Protungulatum (see Szalay and Decker, 1974; name. Ernestokokenia protocenica is pedally Cifelli, 1983), do distinguish the didolodonts, and dentally a didolodontid, but differs sig- but they are based on unassociated tarsals of nificantly from the Patagonian species ofthat only a few of the included genera (Cifelli, genus and therefore also warrants generic sta- 1983), and the diagnosis must therefore be tus; Asmithwoodwardia is very tentatively re- regarded as provisional. An M3 hypocone is moved to the Litopterna. The addition of characteristic of all didolodontids (unless previously described and new material to La- Asmithwoodwardia is included), and does megoia conodonta improves knowledge of distinguish them from litopterns and the that distinctive species. McKenna (1956) de- primitive members, at least, of the Holarctic scribed Megadolodus from the Friasian La condylarthran families. Venta locality in Colombia, based on a jaw Simpson (1948) has reviewed the taxo- fragment with Ml and broken P4. Pertinence nomic history ofspecies placed in this family, to the family is clear, but more precise affin- and repetition here is unnecessary. Simpson ities are problematic. Perutherium altipla- listed the following genera of Didolodont- nense, based on two fragmentary specimens idae as valid: Didolodus, Argyrolambda, from a Late Cretaceous faunule near Laguna Paulogervaisia, Proectocion, Enneoconus, Umayo, Peru, has been referred to the Arc- Asmithwoodwardia, Ernestokokenia, and Ar- tocyonidae (Grambast