Appendix D.3 Scoping Report
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
PUBLIC COMMENTS PC00001 LGA Comments <[email protected]> LaGuardia Airport Access Improvement Project Denise Crockett <[email protected]> Thu, May 9, 2019 at 10:44 PM To: "[email protected]" <[email protected]> Dear Mr Andrew Brooks: Thank you for the opportunity to comment on the LaGuardia Airport Access Improvement Project. As a long term resident of Jamaica, NY, residing along the Grand Central Parkway, I do believe that there is a great need for these proposed improvements. Connecting the LaGuardia Airport to the LIRR and NYCT No. 7 Line is a great idea, but it does not go far enough! Both of these proposed connections are Manhattan centric, that is supporting more ridership between the Airport and the City. This does absolutely nothing to relieve or ease local traffic congestion we experience in Queens on the Long Island Expressway and the Grand Central Parkway with inbound and outbound Long Island traffic. It also does not reduce heavy traffic congestion on the Van Wyck Expressway between JKF and LaGuardia. It would be helpful if the proposed plan included plans to extend the Airtrain light rail service Train which ends at the Jamaica LIRR Station to LaGuardia Airport with a stop at the NYCT No 7 Line. Having lived here for over 40 years and having travelled extensively on business out of both airports, I believe that extending the Airtrain from the Jamaica Station to LaGuardia Airport would be a tremendous improvement and provide many more benefits for the greater NYC area. People traveling from Long Island can take the train to the plane! Sincerely, Denise Crockett 164-20 Grand Central Parkway Jamaica, NY 11432 Sent from my iPad PC00002 LGA Comments <[email protected]> LaGuardia Airport Airport Access Improvement Project Derek Sokolowski <[email protected]> Mon, May 20, 2019 at 3:39 PM To: "[email protected]" <[email protected]> To Whom It May Concern: My name is Derek Sokolowski and I am writing this email to send some comments to the Port Authority regarding the people mover plan between LaGuardia Airport and Willet Points-Citified. I would like to say that this idea of having the station originate at the Mets-Willets Point stop on the Long Island Railroad is a terrible idea for the following reasons: 1. The stop is not on the main line of the LIRR. Surely the origin of the people mover should be located at a major artery of the LIRR as well as the MTA Subway. I propose the Woodside Station. It has the right of way as it can travel on the LIRR tracks, onto the BQE and follow the road to Laguardia Airport with minimum environmental impact 2. Anyone travelling from Long Island or any points east of the Main-Line Woodside station would have an issue having to switch between trains either at Woodside or travel into Penn Station/Grand Central. Therefore., starting the people mover from Woodside would save time for everyone without needing to switch between trains (especially for those with Accessibility issues). 3. The people mover station would be crowded on Game Days at the Citifield Stadium and during the US Open. 4. There is an issue with the construction of the people mover to go around the 7 train tracks. 5. Not enough bus to people mover connections will be present. Local busses should have it easier to transfer into the station. Thank you for your time to read through the comments. Sincerely, Derek Sokolowski Assistant Coordinator – PRISM Jr. Scholars Program Programs for Research Initiatives in Science and Math (PRISM) Adjunct Lecturer – Biology & Biochemistry – John Jay College of Criminal Justice 524 West 59th Street Room 5.61.00 NB New York, NY 10019 PC00002 Tel. (212) 887-6189 Fax. (212) 621-3739 City College of New York 2019 Masters of Science - Biotechnology John Jay College of Criminal Justice 2015 Bachelors of Science - Forensic Science – Concentration Molecular Biology PC00003 LGA Comments <[email protected]> Form Submission - Website Scoping Formal Comment Squarespace <[email protected]> Wed, May 22, 2019 at 3:14 PM Reply-To: [email protected] To: [email protected] Name: Wayne Coppock Email: [email protected] Organization: None Address 1: Address 2: City: State: Zip: Comment Topic: Please extend the NW subway line instead of another air train Formal Comment: Please do not build another air train. It's a wasteful and inefficient use of public funds. Extending the NW line from Astoria to LGA is a far better idea that will result in a one seat ride for many visitors and actually integrate into the subway system properly instead of the awful airtrain setup. (Sent via LGA Access Improvement Project EIS) PC00004 LGA Comments <[email protected]> Hello, regarding the LaGuardia proposal connection g mc 3 <[email protected]> Thu, May 23, 2019 at 2:19 PM To: "[email protected]" <[email protected]> Hello, My name is George McCook and I've been a daily rider of the 7 train for over 15 years. When I heard that the powers that be are considering utilizing the 7 subway line to connect to LaGuardia, a small panic rang out in my head. First of all, the 7 train line is one of the most crowded lines in the system. During rush hour, there is hardly any room. Second, the train also has a tendency to break down and that could affect people attempting to catch a flight. Thirdly, the connection at 74th/Roosevelt already has a bus that goes to LaGuardia Airport. Lastly, with all the development in LIC, there will be even more people riding the 7 train in the near future, further straining that line's ability to fit everyone. My proposal: Why not use the N/W line to Astoria and extend towards LaGuardia? There is so much more room on the N/W going towards Astoria since they have the new model trains and there are simply less total train riders on that line than the 7 train. Plus there is room on 20th Ave to connect Astoria to LaGuardia. I feel very strongly about this issue and if you'd like to chat any more, please let me know. Thank you very much, George McCook PC00005 LGA Comments <[email protected]> Form Submission - Website Scoping Formal Comment Squarespace <[email protected]> Thu, May 23, 2019 at 5:36 PM Reply-To: [email protected] To: [email protected] Name: David Gerson Email: [email protected] Organization: Address 1: 166-08 73 Ave Address 2: City: Fresh Meadows State: NY Zip: 11366 Comment Topic: Opposed to current plan Formal Comment: I oppose the current plan for the following reasons: -the Willets Point terminal would utilize either the 7 train or the LIRR Manhasset line limiting access to a small subset of Long Island passengers -the 7 line is an outdoor, elevated train with chronic service problems and difficulty dealing with adverse weather conditions. -the LIRR Manhasset line bypasses the Jamaica terminal limiting access to a small portion of Long Island residents. -this plan does not provide any means of passenger or employees from moving between LGA and JFK airports. I believe a better option would be to direct the LGA AirTrain to the existing terminal at Jamaica. This provides many benefits, inckudibg: -utilizing the E and J subways that are more reliable and less subject to weather disturbances. -accessing the existing Jamaica terminal allows access to the vast majority of Long Island residents -provides a tradeoff between the additional cost of a longer route with the savings of utilizing existing infrastructure. -provides a means of passengers and employees to travel between LGA and JFK airports alliwing passengers additional options when booking flights. I believe the net benefits from this proposal more than offsets the additional cosr of a longer route from LGA. (Sent via LGA Access Improvement Project EIS) PC00006 LGA Comments <[email protected]> Form Submission - Website Scoping Formal Comment Squarespace <[email protected]> Thu, May 23, 2019 at 9:10 PM Reply-To: [email protected] To: [email protected] Name: Julio Rosique Email: [email protected] Organization: Ditmars Blvd. Block Association Address 1: 106-65 Ditmars Blvd Address 2: City: East Elmhurst State: NY Zip: 11369 Comment Topic: AirTrain Formal Comment: My concern is about the vibration of the train is going to affect the foundation of the home and make it dangerous to live in and possibly lower the value of the home. The noise from the construction as well as the noise from the train will be added to what is already going on. (Sent via LGA Access Improvement Project EIS) PC00007 LGA Comments <[email protected]> Form Submission - Website Scoping Formal Comment Squarespace <[email protected]> Thu, May 23, 2019 at 9:13 PM Reply-To: [email protected] To: [email protected] Name: Mark Jenkins Email: [email protected] Organization: Ditmars Blvd. Block Association Address 1: 106-36 Ditmars Blvd. Address 2: City: East Elmhurst State: NY Zip: 11369 Comment Topic: AirTrain Formal Comment: I believe that a better alternative will be a ferry service or a designated bus service. Having to go past the airport to Willets Point and back to the airport doesn't make any sense. (Sent via LGA Access Improvement Project EIS) PC00008 LGA Comments <[email protected]> Form Submission - Website Scoping Formal Comment Squarespace <[email protected]> Thu, May 23, 2019 at 9:16 PM Reply-To: [email protected] To: [email protected] Name: Junetta Smith Email: [email protected] Organization: Address 1: Address 2: City: State: Zip: Comment Topic: Formal Comment: The AirTram would be an obstruction and I object to it be built.