THE SLOPE (Paleocene) and BULLION CREEK (PALEOCENE) FORMATIONS of NORTH DAKOTA
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE SLOPE (pALEOCENE) AND BULLION CREEK (PALEOCENE) FORMATIONS OF NORTH DAKOTA by Lee Clayton, C. G. Carlson, Walter L. Moore, Gerald Groenewold, F. D. Holland, Jr., and Stephen R. Moran REPORT OF INVESTIGATION NO. 59 NORTH DAKOTA GEOLOGICAL SURVEY E. A. Noble, State Geologist 1977 THE SLOPE (PALEOCENE) AND BULLION CREEK (PALEOCENE) FORMATIONS OF NORTH DAKOTA by Lee Clayton, C. G. Carlson, Walter L. Moore, Gerald Groenewold, F. D. Holland, Jr., and Stephen R. Moran REPORT OF INVESTIGATION NO. 59 NORTH DAKOTA GEOLOGICAL SURVEY E. A. Noble, State Geologist 1977 Printed by Kaye's Inc. CONTENTS Page ABSTRACT . 1 INTRODUCTION . .. 1 THE LUDLOW PROBLEM .... 1 SLOPE FORMATION (NEW NAME) ............................ 7 Source of name 7 Type area and section .................................. .. 7 Description ............................ .......... .. 7 Contacts 7 Thickness and regional extent 7 Differentiation . .. 9 THE TONGUE RIVER PROBLEM . 9 BULLION CREEK FORMATION (NEW NAME) . 10 Source of name . 10 Type area and section , .,. 10 Description 10 Contacts 10 Regional extent. ............................... .. 10 Thickness ................................. .. ..... 10 Differentiation . .. 10 REFERENCES ... .. 13 ILLUSTRATIONS Figure Page 1. Stratigraphic column incorporating revisions of the Fort Union Group as proposed in this paper 2 2. Location map 3 3. Generalized stratigraphic section from the North Cave Hills, South Dakota . 5 4. Diagrammatic cross sections showing alternative solutions to the Ludlow problem 6 5. Type section of the Slope Formation ..... 8 6. Type section of the Bullion Creek Formation 11 ABSTRACT The Slope Formation is a drab-colored, lignite-bearing sequence that Stratigraphic problems in correlating overlies either the Cannonball Formation the Ludlow and Tongue River Formations or the Ludlow Formation. It is separated between North Dakota and adjacent areas from the similar-looking, underlying are best resolved by a revision of the Ludlow Formation strata by the T Cross nomenclature and the introduction of two bed, which occurs at the top of the new formation names, the $lope Formation Ludlow. The sequence that is included in and the Bullion Creek Formation. The the Slope Formation has, in the past, been newly defined Slope Formation considered to be equivalent to the upper (Paleocene) consists of strata that have part of the Ludlow Formation or to part of been considered to be the upper part of the the Tongue River Formation. Ludlow Formation or part of the Tongue The Bullion Creek Formation consists River Formation. The newly defined of a bright-colored, lignite-bearing sequence Bullion Creek Formation (Paleocene) that occurs beneath the drab-colored consists of strata that have been considered Sentinel Butte Formation and above the to be equivalent to either the entire Tongue white marker zone at the top of the Slope River Formation or to the lower, middle, Formation. The sequence has been or upper part of the Tongue River considered to be equivalent to either the Formation. en t ire Tongue River Formation or, variously, to the lower, middle, or upper INTRODUCTION parts of the Tongue River Formation. Over the years, many attempts have been made to correlate the complex THE LUDLOW PROBLEM sequence of continental deposits that make up the Fort Union Group over areas in The Ludlow was introduced by Lloyd which surface exposures are scarce and and Hares (1915) as a lignitic member testhole data were lacking. Most of the between the "Cannonball and Hell Creek Upper Cretaceous and Tertiary formations members of the Lance Formation" in in western North Dakota were introduced northwestern South Dakota and without designating specific type sections, southwestern North Dakota. Hares states and these poorly defined fonnation terms that the type locality is near the Ludlow have commonly been extended great post office (1928, p. 24) and later states (p. distances to other areas from their original 47) that the Giannonatti bed of localities without the benefit of detailed northwestern South Dakota corresponds to correlation or specific criteria for the T Cross bed of southwestern North recognition of formational boundaries. This Dakota. Hares restricted the term "Ludlow has led to placing contacts at different member" to bed'S below the "Cannonball horizons in different areas. member" in South Dakota; he mapped the With the completion of detailed field top of the Ludlow at a higher horizon in studies of Fort Union Group strata in western North Dakota. He considered a southwestern North Dakota and nearby sandstone bed to be the base of his areas recently, numerous stratigraphic "Tongue River member of the Fort Union inconsistencies have become apparent. Formation" in the Marmarth area, Several stratigraphic problems have arisen considering it to be similar to a sandstone in correlating the Ludlow and Tongue bed overlying the "Cannonball member" in River Formations between North Dakota exposures along the Cannonball River. and adjacent South Dakota and Montana. Moore (1976, p. 35), in detailed These problems can be best resolved by studies of these strata in Slope County (fig. revising the nomenclature and by 2), recognized a "white siliceous bed," introducing two new formation names, the which he described as aphanitic to Slope Formation and the Bullion Creek fine-grained quartz, a few centimetres to a Formation (fig. 1). few metres thick, white on fresh fractures, 2 White River Group Oligocene Golden Valley Formation Eocene Sentinel Butte Fm. > a. ~ ::J c ...0 Bu II ion Creek Fm. . (!) ~ - CI) c t- o Slope Fm. Paleocene c :::> -... Cannonball Fm. u..0 Ludlow Fm. Hell Creek Formation Cretaceous Figure 1. Stratigraphic column incorporating revisions of the Fort Union Group as proposed in this paper. but buff or yellowish on weathered Creek in Slope Coonty. Also, the lower surfaces. The siliceous bed is commonly member of the Golden Valley Formation, overlain by lignite or Iignitic shale, and it where the whitish silty clay is capped by a overlies a variety of sedimen t types, which siliceous bed such as at Pretty Rock Butte are bleached white. The bleached zone (T131N, R89W), is similar in appearance, ranges from a few centimetres to as much but it is separated from the white marker as ten metres thick. Moore found this white zone by a stratigraphic interval sufficiently marker zone to be a useful marker for the thick to eliminate the possibility of top of the Ludlow in Slope County, confusion. Siliceous zones bearing petrified although he noted that Hares (p. 48) wood also occur at various horizons within considered this "quartzite" marker to be the lignite-bearing strata. These are not just below the H bed, about 60 feet above associated with white bleached zones, so the base of his Tongue River in the they are not likely to be confused with the Marmarth area. Carlson, in agreement with white marker zone. White siliceous beds Moore, found the white marker zone to be about 50 to 80 feet above typical a useful marker in mapping the contact Cannonball Formation sediment in areas of between the Ludlow and Tongue River poor bedrock exposures in Adams, Grant, Formations in Bowman, Adams, Grant, and and Morton Counties (fig. 2) are considered Morton Counties. to be equivalent to the white marker zone. The white marker zone is relatively Moore divided the Ludlow into lower persistent, but it is not unique within the and upper units, with the T Cross bed as lignite-bearing zone. Moore noted small the base of the upper unit. He noted surface exposures of a similar material well brackish-water units in Slope County. A 3 below the white marker zone along Horse to 6-foot-thick bed of clay directly overlies 3 EXPLANATION • TYPE SECTION BULLION CREEK FORMATION & TYPE SECTION SLOPE FORMATION x EXPOSURES OF WHITE MARKER ZONE @ TYPE AREA OF LUDLOW FORMATION ~""""" ~/ '-...... '- ~~ , 1------------\ r ,;~-...Jr) ! Me KEN Z I E I , ----I ~ L_-, I Me LEAN I ,I'" 1"'''°""" "V£H :'",--,--( . --__ -1.. DUN N !.., MER C E R '- Wo.~llurn -' i! ! I ---~ '1 I I I I I I ...--' i ,BILLINGS, I 'OLIVER \7r-. I I I 1_ I II -J U\ i;AOLl~i~-! l--L--~D;k,n.on ',--------- \ \ lIt STARK I 1 !_8~'~ '" 'BULLIOJ I M 0 R T ~ N ~ ,..I-I\.. BUTTE I ~ " ----T:-~::GER-I-------i )~ ! i -II (HOff E 'Ir S LOP E. I .~ G RAN T,l~ FR:EK ~_ ..K i I C'4NNON'~LL I_-)I/~~~l <t j;;iGr-niGri"-; ---rl------~I Z. 1 II II I .,/ i I Cl II I ADAMS II I ·p~~Ul f, 1-1 8 OW MAN II, II ..---....-" ...... IIU~... S IOU x \ i---~~RTH -~------Jr---II-.!'-----Ii~~~ ~---~::~~~-----J : I CAVE -Ludlow HILLS ::i I HARDING I 1 I Figure 2. Map of southwest North Dakota and Harding County, South Dakota showing locations of type sections for the Bullion Creek and Slope Fonnations and type area for the Ludlow Fonnation. Exposures of the white marker zone are designa ted by crosses. 4 the T Cross bed and an "oyster clay brackish-water clay; this has been used to and lignite" bed occurs approximately 1SO divide the Ludlow into upper and lower feet above the T Cross bed. The white members. Alternative D represents current marker zone is well above the brackish beds practice in westem North Dakota, except in this area. In South Dakota, the Ludlow that Ludlow is restricted to the western has been limited to the nonmarine strata area; and new names are introduced for the between the Hell Creek and cannonball nonmarine strata above and below the strata. In the absence of cannonball strata, Cannonball Formation to the east. a sandstone bed near the horizon of the Alternative E would restrict Ludlow to the Giannonatti bed has been considered to be strata between the Hell Creek and the base of the Tongue River. The white Cannonball Formations. It would introduce marker zone is present in the North Cave a new name for the strata between the Hills of South Dakota (fig.