The Crystal Structure of Stronalsite and a Redetermination of the Structure of Banalsite
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
533 The Canadian Mineralogist Vol. 44, pp. 533-546 (2006) THE CRYSTAL STRUCTURE OF STRONALSITE AND A REDETERMINATION OF THE STRUCTURE OF BANALSITE RUSLAN P. LIFEROVICH Department of Geology, Lakehead University, 955 Oliver Road, Thunder Bay, Ontario P7B 5E1, Canada ANDREW J. LOCOCK Department of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta T6G 2E3, Canada ROGER H. MITCHELL§ Department of Geology, Lakehead University, 955 Oliver Road, Thunder Bay, Ontario P7B 5E1, Canada ARKADIY K. SHPACHENKO Geological Institute, Kola Science Centre, Russian Academy of Sciences, 14 Fersman Street, Apatity 184200, Russia ABSTRACT The structures of stronalsite, SrNa2Al4Si4O16, and banalsite, BaNa2Al4Si4O16, have been determined by direct methods using single-crystal X-ray diffractometry with a CCD area detector. The structures are topologically identical and adopt the non-centro- symmetric space-group Iba2 rather than the centrosymmetric space-group Ibam previously ascribed to banalsite. Unit-cell param- 3 3 eters are: a 8.4080(9), b 9.8699(11), c 16.7083(18) Å, V 1386.6(3) Å , Z = 4, Dcalc. 2.92 g/cm for stronalsite (Khibina massif, 3 3 Kola, Russia); a 8.5400(7), b 10.0127(9), c 16.7897(14) Å, V 1435.7(2) Å , Dcalc. 3.05 g/cm for banalsite from Wales (Benallt 3 3 mine, UK), and a 8.5068(16), b 9.9811(18), c 16.7485(31) Å, V 1422.1(5) Å , Dcalc. 3.08 g/cm for banalsite from Långban (Sweden). The structures are built on an infi nite framework of corner-sharing tetrahedra, with Si and Al being completely ordered at four independent sites. Alternately pointing up (U) and down (D) Si(1)–Al(1) and Si(2)–Al(2) tetrahedra form four- and eight-fold rings parallel to the (001) plane, resulting in a –UDUD– framework, which differs from the –UUDD– framework of feldspars. The stacking results in six-fold rings parallel to the (100) plane. The interstices of the framework are occupied by large Sr or Ba atoms (XA2+), and smaller VINa+, ordered at alternate levels parallel to (001), and separated by ¼ c. The isostructural character of banalsite and stronalsite accords well with the complete solid-solution Ba1–xSrxNa2Al4Si4O16 occurring in nature. Keywords: tectosilicate, stronalsite, banalsite, crystal structure, lisetite, solid solution, feldspar. SOMMAIRE Nous avons déterminé la structure de la stronalsite, SrNa2Al4Si4O16, et celle de la banalsite, BaNa2Al4Si4O16, par méthodes directes au moyen de données en diffraction X prélevées sur monocristaux et d’un détecteur à aire CCD. Les structures sont topologiquement identiques; elles adoptent le groupe d’espace non centrosymétrique Iba2 plutôt que le groupe centrosymé- trique Ibam attribué antérieurement à la banalsite. Les paramètres réticulaires sont: a 8.4080(9), b 9.8699(11), c 16.7083(18) 3 3 Å, V 1386.6(3) Å , Z = 4, Dcalc 2.92 g/cm pour la stronalsite (complexe de Khibina, péninsule de Kola, Russie); a 8.5400(7), 3 3 b 10.0127(9), c 16.7897(14) Å, V 1435.7(2) Å , Dcalc 3.05 g/cm pour la banalsite provenant du Pays de Galles (mine Benallt, 3 3 UK), et a 8.5068(16), b 9.9811(18), c 16.7485(31) Å, V 1422.1(5) Å , Dcalc 3.08 g/cm pour la banalsite de Långban (Suède). Les structures contiennent une trame infi nie de tétraèdres partageant leurs coins, avec Si et Al complètement ordonnés sur quatre sites indépendants. Les tétraèdres Si(1)–Al(1) et Si(2)–Al(2) pointent en alternance vers le haut (U) et vers le bas (D) pour former des anneaux à quatre et huit membres parallèles à (001), ce qui mène à une trame –UDUD–, distincte de la trame –UUDD– des feldspaths. L’empilement mène à des anneaux à six membres parallèles au plan (100). Les interstices de cette trame contiennent les gros atomes Sr ou Ba (XA2+) et les atomes plus petits de VINa+, ordonnés à des niveaux alternants parallèles à (001), avec une séparation de ¼ c. Le caractère isostructural de la banalsite et de la stronalsite explique la solution solide complète Ba1–xSrx- Na2Al4Si4O16 observée dans la nature. (Traduit par la Rédaction) Mots-clés: tectosilicate, stronalsite, banalsite, structure cristalline, lisetite, solution solide, feldspath. § E-mail address: [email protected] 534 THE CANADIAN MINERALOGIST INTRODUCTION structure. Stronalsite occurs as crystals measuring up to 4 mm in size in drill-core material collected from the Tectosilicates with the stoichiometry ANa2Al4Si4O16 Khibina peralkaline complex, Kola alkaline province, include banalsite, stronalsite, and lisetite, where A = Russia. The remarkable compositional homogeneity Ba, Sr, and Ca, respectively (Deer et al. 2001). Only of these crystals (Fig. 1b) permitted us to undertake limited crystallochemical data for these rare minerals the fi rst single-crystal determination of the structure are available. In common with feldspars, their structures of stronalsite. are built on an infi nite framework of four- and eightfold As expected on the basis of the aluminum-avoidance irregular rings of corner-shared tetrahedra. Apical atoms rule (Loewenstein 1954), the results of the refi nement of of oxygen of the rings point alternately up (U) and the structure of stronalsite is consistent with an ordered down (D) with respect to the (001) plane in banalsite, distribution of Si and Al in independent tetrahedral sites [the (100) plane in lisetite, nonstandard space-group (see below). We considered that ordering of Si and Pbc21], giving rise to a –UDUD– framework, which is Al, similar to that found in stronalsite and lisetite on one of the four possible ways to built up rings of tetra- the basis of the 1:1 Si to Al ratio, should also occur in hedra (Smith & Rinaldi 1962). This arrangement differs banalsite. The extensive banalsite–stronalsite solid solu- from the –UUDD– framework of feldspars (Haga 1973, tion that is known to exist in nature (Matsubara 1985, Rossi et al. 1986), and is similar to the framework in Koneva 1996, Liferovich et al. 2006) also suggests their nepheline, which consists of regular and irregular six- close structural similarity. In this context, we have used membered –UDUD– rings (Tait et al. 2003). single-crystal X-ray methods for the determination of In this paper, we present the results of the crystal- the structure of stronalsite from Khibina and a redeter- structure study of single crystals of stronalsite and mination of the structure of banalsite from two locali- banalsite. Discussion of the crystal chemistry, genesis ties; the type locality in Wales (Benallt mine, Rhiw, and parageneses of stronalsite, banalsite and their Lleyn Peninsula, UK) and from Långban, (Värmland, naturally occurring complete solid-solution series are Filipstadt, Sweden) (Figs. 1c and 1d, respectively) and presented in Liferovich et al. (2006). have confi rmed that these sodic tectosilicates of Sr and Ba are isostructural. BACKGROUND INFORMATION EXPERIMENTAL In the structure model presented for lisetite in space group Pbc21 (nonstandard setting of Pca21) and The sample containing stronalsite was collected nonstandard origin, offset by [¼, ¼, 0], Si and Al are from a drill core derived from a depth of 182 m in the fully ordered at the tetrahedral positions of the frame- tectonomagmatic contact zone between a semicircular work, and the intraframework VIICa and VINa cations are ijolite–urtite body and nepheline syenite in the north- distributed throughout common Ca + 2Na layers (Rossi eastern segment of the Khibina peralkaline complex, et al. 1986). This structural model is in accord with the Kola alkaline province, Russia. The sample represents composition of lisetite and the aluminum-avoidance an altered xenolith of cuspidine–melilitolite rock, principle (Loewenstein 1954) for tectosilicates with a which is unusual for this sodic peralkaline complex. A Si-to-Al ratio of unity (Smith et al. 1986). In contrast, detailed description of this rock and of its metasomatic the structure of banalsite was originally described as a alteration is given by Khomyakov et al. (1990). On the framework of tetrahedra with a disordered distribution basis of textural relationships, stronalsite is interpreted of Si and Al but with ordering of XBa and VINa cations as a late phase formed by alteration of nepheline or an into alternate layers owing to “the large difference in unusual Sr-rich melilite (or both). In turn, stronalsite their ionic radii” (Rossi et al. 1986). The structure was is commonly subjected to low-temperature alteration. considered in the centrosymmetric space-group Ibam by Slightly altered stronalsite shows anomalous interfer- Haga (1973). This structural model does not seem to be ence-colors and cloudy extinction in transmitted light, reasonable given that the same Si-to-Al ratio occurs in as a result of changes in composition and signifi cant both banalsite and lisetite. deviations from the theoretical stoichiometry due to Stronalsite has an X-ray powder-diffraction pattern leaching of Na. Further alteration results in replacement very similar to that of banalsite (Matsubara 1985). In of stronalsite by a fi ne-grained mixture of strontianite the absence of a structure refi nement, stronalsite has and unidentified zeolites. Unaltered stronalsite is been assumed to be isostructural with Ibam banalsite, preserved only where mantled by andradite or clino- although the possibility of complete ordering of Si and pyroxene (Fig. 1b). The paragenesis of the Khibina Al, resulting in an Iba2 polymorph, was also considered stronalsite is similar to that described in melilitolite by Matsubara (1985) and Hori et al. (1987). from the Turiy Mys peralkaline complex, Kola alkaline The small grain-size and compositional heteroge- province, Russia (Dunworth & Bell 2003). neity of stronalsite from previously known occurrences Descriptions of the banalsite occurrences in Mn- (e.g. Fig. 1a) have precluded a determination of the rich ores from the Benallt mine (Wales, UK) and THE CRYSTAL STRUCTURES OF STRONALSITE AND BANALSITE 535 FIG.