Exhibit 4 Case 5:16-Md-02752-LHK Document 416-4 Filed 01/31/20 Page 2 of 11
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Case 5:16-md-02752-LHK Document 416-4 Filed 01/31/20 Page 1 of 11 Exhibit 4 Case 5:16-md-02752-LHK Document 416-4 Filed 01/31/20 Page 2 of 11 All dollar amounts are in millions Primary Cross-Check % of Common Multiplier Case Name Cite Judge Fee Order Date Case Type Fee $ Approved Calculation Common Fund $ Lodestar $ Method Fund Approved Approved Method No. C 17-03421 WHA, Esparza v. Smartpay 2020 WL 465865 (N.D. 1 Leasing, Inc. Cal. Jan. 28, 2020 William Alsup January 28, 2020 TCPA $ 2.000 CF Lodestar $ 8.569 23% $ 0.914 2.19 No. 15-cv-05764-BLF, Corzine v. Whirlpool 2019 WL 7372275 (N.D. Products 2 Corporation Cal. Dec. 31, 2019) Beth Labson Freeman December 31, 2019 Liability $ 1.823 Lodestar CF $ 12.950 9% 1.86 No. 13-cv-03072 EMC, In re Myford Touch 2019 WL 6877477 (N.D. Consumer 3 Consumer Litigation Cal. Dec. 17, 2019) Edward Chen December 17, 2019 Protection $ 10.199 CF/Lodestar CF/Lodestar $ 33.000 31% $ 31.446 0.32 No. C 17-06874 WHA, Caudle v. Sprint/United 2019 WL 6841239 (N.D. 4 Management Company Cal. Dec. 16, 2019) William Alsup December 16, 2019 Wage & Hour $ 0.900 CF Lodestar $ 4.000 22.50% $ 0.444 2 Raquedan v. Centerplate labor 5 of Delaware Inc. 17-cv-3828-LHK Lucy H. Koh December 16, 2019 employment $ 1.363 CF $ 5.450 25% $ 0.666 2.05 Knapper v. Cox 6 Communications 2:17-cv-00913-SPL Steven G. Logan December 13, 2019 TCPA $ 3.010 CF $ 10.750 28% In re Transpacific Passenger Air No. 3:07-cv-05634-CRB, Transportation Antitrust 2019 WL 6327363 (N.D. 7 Litigation Cal. Nov. 26, 2019) Charles Breyer November 26, 2019 Antitrust $ 14.127 CF Lodestar $ 56.506 25% $ 18.647 No. 17-cv-02185-BLF, In re Nexus 6P Products 2019 WL 6622842 (N.D. Products 8 Liability Litigation Cal. Nov. 12, 2019) Beth Labson Freeman November 12, 2019 Liability $ 2.925 CF Lodestar $ 9.750 30% $ 3.848 0.76 In re Wells Fargo & Co. No. 16-cv-05541-JST, Shareholder Derivative 2019 WL 5458022 (N.D. Derivative 9 Litigation Cal. Oct. 24, 2019) Jon Tigar October 24, 2019 Action Deferred decision Deferred decision Abante Rooster and No. 3:16-cv-05486-JCS, Plumbing, Inc. v. Pivotal 2018 WL 8949777 (N.D. 10 Payments Inc. Cal. Oct. 15, 2018) MJ Joseph Spero September 21, 2019 TCPA $ 1.800 CF Lodestar 20% $ 663.641 2.7 No. 4:13-md-0242-YGR In re Lithium Ion (MDL), 2019 WL Batteries Antitrust 3856413 (N.D. Cal. Aug. 11 Litigation 16, 2019) Yvonne Rogers August 16, 2019 Antitrust $ 29.334 CF Lodestar $ 133.450 30% $ 41.458 0.82 No. 15-cv-01824-BLF, 2019 WL 3842075 (N.D. 12 Health v. Google LLC Cal. Aug. 15, 2019) Beth Labson Freeman August 15, 2019 ADEA $ 2.750 CF Lodestar $ 11.000 25% $ 2.443 1.13 No. 15-cv-04883-BLF, In re Extreme Networks, 2019 WL 3290770 (N.D. 13 Inc. Securities Litigation Cal. July 22, 2019) Beth Labson Freeman July 22, 2019 Securities $ 1.750 CF Lodestar $ 7.000 25% $ 3.261 0.53 No. 16-cv-02233-JST, 2019 WL 4164731 (N.D. Consumer 14 Edenborough v. ADT, LLC Cal. July 22, 2019) Jon Tigar July 22, 2019 Protection $ 4.000 CF Lodestar $ 16.000 25% $ 3.136 1.3 No. 17-cv-02533-HSG, Bisaccia v. Revel Systems 2019 WL 3220275 (N.D. 15 Inc. Cal. July 17, 2019) Haywood Gilliam, Jr. July 17, 2019 FLSA $ 0.688 CF Lodestar $ 2.750 25% $ 0.308 2.23 No. 17-cv-03763-JSC, 2019 WL 2929988 (N.D. 16 Wilson v. Tesla, Inc. Cal. July 8, 2019) Jacqueline Corley July 8, 2019 Wage & Hour $ 0.161 Lodestar CF $ 1.060 $ 0.161 0 Case 5:16-md-02752-LHK Document 416-4 Filed 01/31/20 Page 3 of 11 In Re HP Printer No. 5:16-cv-05820-EJD, Firmware Update 2019 WL 2716287 (N.D. Consumer 17 Litigation Cal. June 28, 2019) Edward Davilla June 28, 2019 Protection $ 1.773 Lodestar CF $ 2.958 No. 16-cv-02499-YGR, Congdon v. Uber 2019 WL 2327922 (N.D. Breach of 18 Technologies, Inc. Cal. May 31, 2019) Yvonne Rogers May 31, 2019 Contract $ 1.252 Lodestar CF $ 1.850 68% $ 1.252 0 In re: Volkswagen "Clean Dielsel" Marketing, Sales MDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC), Practices, and Products 2019 WL 2077847 (N.D. Products 19 Liability Litigation Cal. May 10, 2019) Charles Breyer May 10, 2019 Liability - MDL $ 11.920 CF Lodestar $ 48.000 25% 1.59 In re Chrysler-Dodge- Jeep Ecodisel Marketing, Sales Practices, and No. 17-md-02777-EMC, Products Liability 2019 WL 2554232 (N.D. Products 20 Litigation Cal. May 3, 2019) Edward Chen May 3, 2019 Liability $ 59.000 CF and Lodestar CF and Lodestar Not stated Hoffman v. G&K Services, labor 21 LLC 17-cv-04465-LHK Lucy H. Koh April 25, 2019 employment $ 0.180 CF $ 0.650 27.80% $ 0.180 0.97 Chavez v. Adidas Labor 22 America, Inc. 16-cv-06533-LHK Lucy H. Koh April 19, 2019 Employment $ 0.375 CF $ 1.500 25% $ 0.311 1.21 No. 14-cv-02329-BLF, Free Frange Content, Inc. 2019 WL 1299504 (N.D. Breach of 23 v. Google, LLC Cal. Mar. 21, 2019) Beth Labson Freeman March 21, 2019 contract $ 2.750 CF Lodestar $ 11.000 25% 1.21 No. 16-cv-01722-HSG, Giroux v. Essex Property 2019 WL 1207301 (N.D. 24 Trust, Inc. Cal. Mar. 14, 2019) Haywood Gilliam, Jr. March 14, 2019 Data Breach $ 0.140 Lodestar $ 1.600 $ 0.152 No. 16-cv-03294-EMC, McLeod v. Bank of 2019 WL 1170487 (N.D. Labor Code 25 America, N.A. Cal. Mar. 13, 2019) Edward Chen March 13, 2019 violations $ 3.000 CF Lodestar $ 7.552 27.20% $ 0.885 3.5 No. 17-cv-02092-HSG, Fowler v. Wells Fargo 2019 WL 330910 (N.D. 26 Bank, N.A. Cal. Jan. 25, 2019) Haywood Gilliam, Jr. January 25, 2019 HUD violations $ 7.500 CF Lodestar $ 30.000 25% $ 2.168 3.46 No. 16-cv-05479-JST, Hefler v. Wells Fargo & 2018 WL 6619983 (N.D. 27 Company Cal. Dec. 18, 2018) Jon Tigar December 18, 2018 Securities $ 95.900 CF Lodestar $ 480.000 20% $ 29.504 3.22 28 Ledo v. Prado 17-cv-02393-LHK Lucy H. Koh December 6, 2018 FLSA $ 0.068 N/A $ 0.275 25% Outley v. Turner 29 Contracting, Inc. 17-cv-03465-LHK Lucy H. Koh November 19, 2018 FLSA $ 0.338 N/A $ 1.200 28.19% $ 0.338 No. 17-cv-06255-YGR del Toro Lopez v. Uber 2018 WL 5982506 (N.D. 30 Technologies, Inc. Cal. Nov. 14, 2018) Yvonne Rogers November 14, 2018 FLSA $ 2.500 CF Lodestar $ 10.000 25% $ 0.856 2.9 No. C 17-00184-WHA, Etter v. Allstate 2018 WL 5791883 (N.D. 31 Insurance Company Cal. Nov. 4, 2018) William Alsup November 4, 2018 TCPA $ 1.593 Lodestar CF $ 6.533 25% $ 0.629 2.53 No. 17-cv-02193-BLF, 2018 WL 5794532 (N.D. Consumer 32 Sheikh v. Tesla, Inc. Cal. Nov. 2, 2018) Beth Labson Freeman November 2, 2018 Protection $ 0.961 CF Lodestar $ 5.400 17.70% 2.36 In re Lithium Ion No. 13-MD-2420-YGR, Batteries Antitrust 2017 WL 4872978 (N.D. 33 Litigation Cal. Oct. 27, 2017) Yvonne Rogers October 27, 2018 Antitrust $ 4.495 $ 44.950 10% Case 5:16-md-02752-LHK Document 416-4 Filed 01/31/20 Page 4 of 11 No. 17-cv-3400-CW, 2018 WL 6040194 (N.D. 34 Banerjee v. Avinger, Inc. Cal. Oct. 24, 2018) Claudia Wilken October 24, 2018 Securities $ 1.500 Lodestar CF $ 5.000 30% $ 1.593 0.94 No. 3:17-md-02801-JD, In re Capacitors Antitrust 2018 WL 4790575 (N.D. 35 Litigation Cal. Sept. 21, 2018) James Donato September 21, 2018 Antitrust $ 16.725 CF Lodestar $ 66.900 25% $ 77.764 4 No. 14-md-02521-WHO, In re Lioderm Antitrust 2018 WL 4620695 (N.D. 36 Litigation Cal. Sept. 20, 2018) William Orrick September 20, 2018 Antitrust $ 34.916 CF Lodestar $ 480.000 33.33% $ 25.560 1.37 In re Yahoo! Securities 17-cv-1525-LHK 17-cv- 37 Litigation 373-LHK Lucy H. Koh September 7, 2018 PSLRA $ 14.400 CF $ 80.000 18% $ 7.200 2.00 No. 11-cv-03003-JST, 2018 WL 4030558 (N.D. Breach of 38 Rodman v. Safeway, Inc. Cal. Aug. 23, 2018) Jon Tigar August 23, 2018 contract $ 11.850 CF Lodestar $ 42.321 28% $ 6.782 1.7472 In re Anthem Data 2018 WL 3960068 (15- 39 Breach Litig. md-02617-LHK) Lucy H. Koh August 17, 2018 data breach $ 31.050 CF $ 115.000 27% $ 31.027 1.00 CF (notice to class Des Roches v. California capped to 40 Phys. Serv. 16-cv-2848-LHK Lucy H. Koh July 5, 2018 insurance $ 1.988 requested fees) $ 7.000 28.40% $ 7.400 0.27 No. 09-cv-05796-CW, 2018 WL 3108924 (N.D. 41 Ashker v. Cole Cal. June 25, 2018) MJ James June 25, 2018 Civil Rights $ 1.032 Lodestar No Common Fund $ 1.620 0 No. 10-cv-01811-YGR, In re Sony PS3 "Other 2018 WL 2763337 (N.D. Consumer 42 OS" Litigation Cal.