DOCSLIB.ORG

To Download a PDF of an Interview with Sam Zell, Chairman, Equity

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
To Download a PDF of an Interview with Sam Zell, Chairman, Equity Setting an Example An Interview with Sam Zell, Chairman, Equity Group Investments EDITORS’ NOTE Sam Zell is U.S. had historically adopted a model of What is it in an entrepreneur that helps the Chairman of Equity Group over-reaching government infl uence, our him see challenges as opportunities? Investments, the private investment country would look more like Belgium It starts with an inordinate amount of self con- fi rm he founded some 45 years ago. today. My concern is that the federal poli- fi dence, which enables you to stick to your deci- He is also Chairman of Equity cies being put into place are moving us sion despite conventional wisdom or what others International, which he co-founded closer to a European model. So, yes, it is may or may not be doing. In addition, real entre- in 1999, and Chairman of fi ve pub- more diffi cult to build companies today. preneurs have an innate tendency to not just recog- lic companies listed on the New York Heavy-handed legislation like Sarbanes- nize problems, but to see solutions. These two traits Stock Exchange. Zell is also Chairman Oxley or regulation through the EPA or have repeatedly intersected throughout my career. of Tribune Company. Previously, he NLRB infl uence every decision that a There have been some very diffi cult rough patches served as Chairman for Equity Offi ce company makes today. over the past 40 years, but I always remained com- Properties Trust. He serves on the Nevertheless, we’ve seen the te- mitted to a solution, even if that meant going right JPMorgan National Advisory Board; Sam Zell nacity of creativity through companies when everyone else was going left. the President’s Advisory Board at the like Apple, Google, and Microsoft. So You have been bullish on investing in University of Michigan; and with the combined ef- there is still opportunity and the orientation to the U.S., but you have a lot of interest in forts of the University of Michigan Business School, es- create companies, but the burdens of doing so Brazil and other areas. Is the U.S. still going tablished the Samuel Zell & Robert H. Lurie Institute are greater than they’ve ever been. to offer opportunities or do you need to go for Entrepreneurial Studies. He is a long-standing Do you need to be born with an entre- to the emerging markets? supporter of the University of Pennsylvania Wharton preneurial edge? That is a political question, not an economic Real Estate Center and has endowed The Samuel Zell There is an element of entrepreneurship question. I don’t know what the future holds for and Robert Lurie Real Estate Center at Wharton. Zell inside everyone; it just varies in intensity from U.S. politics. Is Western Europe the template of is a graduate of the University of Michigan and the person to person. what America is going to be or will America be University of Michigan Law School. He began his ca- My objectives in this arena have been to able to maintain its unique environment and cul- reer in real estate while an undergraduate. create environments that will help individu- ture? That question will determine how much the als recognize and nurture that element within U.S. can grow, and consequently, the abundance COMPANY BRIEF Equity Group Investments themselves, as well as identify those very few of opportunity in our country. In addition, the (www.egizell.com; EGI) is a private invest- who are entrepreneurial to their core. In par- U.S., along with the rest of the developed world, ment company. Its founder, Sam Zell, pioneered ticular, those in this latter group, who thrive on needs a serious dose of deleveraging. It’s hard to the public equitization of the commercial real es- taking risks and being out on their own, have create growth and deleverage at the same time. tate industry through the creation and leadership no traditional road map. I took that route in In the interim, I continue to diversify into of Equity Residential, Equity LifeStyle Properties, my career, so I understand the gap traditional areas where I know there is signifi cant growth. I Equity Offi ce Properties Trust, and Capital Trust. courses leave in preparing entrepreneurs. invest in emerging markets with the understand- EGI’s investment portfolio encompasses a broad Where did your philanthropic bent ing that I am trading the rule of law for growth; range of corporate and real estate interests, a small come from? that is just part of the risk analysis. sampling of which includes Anixter International, As I have become more successful, there is Does it concern you that the U.S. can’t Covanta Energy, Rewards Network, Kuwait Energy a growing need on my part to add relevance. My get more reform in the K-12 system when Company, WRScompass, and Equity International. success isn’t ultimately measured in dollars, but in there is such an emphasis on it? what I can achieve and the difference I can make. There are a lot of competing interests in Are you concerned that the U.S. is losing its I get great satisfaction in making that difference. I the K-12 system. The unionization of our edu- entrepreneurial edge? believe entrepreneurship is the economic engine cational system has done serious damage. I’m very concerned that we’re losing our that drives this country, so fostering that orienta- Historically, the answer has always been to edge. What has made America so unique is a tion and skill set has an exponential impact. spend more money, but we’ve realized there is 200-year period of immigration that self selects How are you able to track the impact of almost no correlation between the money spent entrepreneurs – people with aspirational drive. your philanthropic efforts? and the performance achieved. The environment in the U.S., until recently, al- Much of my philanthropy is conducted in This is an enormous challenge for our coun- ways nourished that entrepreneurial spirit. a non-endowment fashion – where I make sig- try going forward. The stemming of immigration Many entrepreneurs suggest it is tougher nifi cant commitments over 3 to 10 years with no has taken a lot of parents out of the system who to build businesses today. Is there merit to that? guarantee of an 11th year. My theory is that the are concerned about their children, and without There is little doubt that the level of interfer- recipient will stay motivated and do such a good parental support, I don’t know how you can ence from the government is much greater today job that either I’ll want to continue my support, achieve performance improvement in schools. than it has ever been in my career. The philosophy or someone else will want to be associated with Do you ever think about your legacy? of the current Administration is oriented toward the program’s success. Sure, but your legacy is not defi ned in dol- government, rather than private sector, solutions. By I’m less interested in having my name on lars and cents; it’s who you have infl uenced and defi nition, government solutions are limiting. If the buildings than I am in having my name on ideas. the example you have set for others.• 48 LEADERS POSTED WITH PERMISSION. COPYRIGHT © 2012 LEADERS MAGAZINE, INC. VOLUME 35, NUMBER 2.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Marc Chase - President of Tribune Interactive!
    SURELY YOU CAN’T BE SERIOUS? MARC CHASE - PRESIDENT OF TRIBUNE INTERACTIVE! Randy Michaels’ run of acquiring radio-management stars came to a screeching halt today with Chase’s appointment CHICAGO, April 7, 2008 – Another freaking Clear Channel Communications executive on the payroll and this one’s been named President of Tribune Interactive. Tribune Broadcasting’s Randy Michaels’ past finally caught up with him when Marc Chase obviously blackmailed his way into a position he is not remotely qualified to hold. Insiders are irate. Chase is a fraud. A source inside Tribune HR, who wished to remain anonymous, pointed out that Marc Chase’s resume (below) was obviously fabricated. First of all, his name isn’t even Marc Chase--it’s Mark Thompson. The whole thing is a sham. MARC CHASE 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue Washington DC 20500 202-456-1111 PROFESSINAL EXPERIENCE Vocabulary Advisorist for George W. Bush Washington DC, 2004-present President of the United States of America eBay San Jose, California 2003-2004 President of Buying Crap Google Mountain View, California 2001-2002 Executive Vice President of Finding Crap Anywhere Microsoft Seattle, Washington, 2000-2001 Senior Executive Vice President of Technology and Stuff CBS, ABC, NBC, FOX Television Los Angeles, California 1999-2000 Vice President of Watching TV A Lot Harvard University Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1998 Dean of School of Internetology EDUCASHION Nearly Graduated with Honers School of Alabama in Atlanta Georgia 1985 COMMUNITY SERVICE 400 Hours (reduced from 600) Judge gave time off for good behavior Chase was quoted as saying, “Timing and infrared photography are everything. I couldn’t be happier! I know Randy is relieved to finally have me on Sam’s payroll.” Tribune has undergone major changes in the past year, with billionaire Sam Zell acquiring the company last April in a complex deal that left it with $13 billion in debt.
    [Show full text]
  • A Note on Leveraged Buyouts, Defaults & Bankruptcy
    A Note on Leveraged December 16 Buyouts, Defaults & 2014 Bankruptcy Bradley Drake Rajeev Kasthuri Vanitha Kathrotia Elaine Press A Note on Leveraged Buyouts, Defaults & Bankruptcy 2014 A leveraged buyout (“LBO”) is a transaction which involves the purchase of a controlling stake in a business most often by a financial sponsor such as a private equity firm or an investor utilizing substantial levels of debt. LBO debt is generally considered to be non-investment grade debt instruments; as a result of the higher default and loss given default-risk profiles, the investors demand higher rates of return to commensurate for the risk. Historical internal rates of return over a five-year period investment or above indicate returns exceed the public market equivalent. Specifically a 10- or 20-year investment in buyout funds indicate 14% / 13% returns vs. the S&P 500 returns of 7% over the same time horizon. (Bain Capital) Given the highly leveraged profile of the LBO’s, however, defaults are prominent during economic downturns, interest rate shocks, industry shifts, and operational disruptions, all which lead to severe deterioration in cash flow, with certain companies undergoing extreme distress and ultimately opting for bankruptcy. To provide a general overview, the paper will provide a discussion on the capital structure of an LBO, background on defaults, bankruptcies, recovery rates and similar occurrences to comparably rated non-LBO transactions. Following the outline of the general LBO discussion, the report will analyze three transactions: TXU or Energy Holdings’ 2014 announcement which is considered to be the largest LBO bankruptcy in history; Clear Channel Communications which has been long under speculation to enter bankruptcy and Tribune Company which entered bankruptcy at the height of the financial crisis in 2008; and finally The analysis will be structured around the LBO transaction details, the nuances and circumstances leading up to the announcement and if the bankruptcy could have been predicted utilizing the means of a Z”-score.
    [Show full text]
  • To Download a PDF of an Interview with Sam Zell, Chairman, Equity
    PURPOSE Passion and Purpose An Interview with Sam Zell, Chairman, Equity Group Investments My career has been all about making We’re also proud of all the work we have an impact – changing something for the bet- done in entrepreneurship. If I’m successful in ter – and it has worked because I am person- my mission, I will have weaponized a whole ally involved. I set a vision, give guidance on cadre of future business leaders. In Israel, strategy, establish accountability, manage risks with the Zell Entrepreneurship Program, we and so on. have 400 alumni who have collectively Sam Zell It dawned on me that day – if I wanted to monetized their start-ups for almost $1 bil- really make a difference in my philanthropy, I lion, which is really incredible. We have also EDITORS’ NOTE Sam Zell is a global, opportunis- had to apply the same approach. I had to com- created a broader community, combining the tic and often contrarian investor. He specializes bine my own passion with a focus. In other students and alumni of our other entrepre- in identifying market anomalies and emerging words, I had to invest both fi nancial capital and neurship programs at University of Michigan trends and has a long track record in turning personal capital. and Northwestern, and now they all mentor around troubled companies and assets, leading I went from giving $1,000 to everybody each other, support each other and invest industry consolidations, and bringing companies and having nothing to do with any of them with each other. to the public markets.
    [Show full text]
  • Shift from WGN Recalls Old Comfort Zone for Fans, Station, Cubs
    Shift from WGN recalls old comfort zone for fans, station, Cubs By George Castle, CBM Historian Posted Monday, June 9th, 2014 Wowww! Let’s go, batter up, we’re taking the afternoon off….It’s a beautiful day for a ballgame, for a ballgame today. The fans are out to get a ticket or two, from Walla Walla, Washington to Kalamazoo… Everything changes – even the most comfy things that fit to a tee. Familiarity and memories of childhood soundtracks of summer is why we’re all wrung out with the news the Cubs’ radio rights have shift- ed to WBBM-Radio from their 57-season home 60 kc down the dial at WGN. The news wasn’t unexpected. WGN re- opened its Cubs contract – not the other way around – before this season because it was losing its financial shirt, unable to re- coup enough ad revenue to cover produc- tion costs when the baseball ratings had gone in the dumper. A move like this be- came inevitable – just the timing was in question – after Tribune Co. sold the Cubs to the cash-hungry Ricketts family, which is saddled with a heavy debt service man- dated by corporate shark Sam Zell as the structure of the sale. Lou Boudreau (top) and Jack Quinlan in WGN- As long as Tribune Co. -- which acquired Radio's first season with the Cubs radio rights in the embryonic WGN in 1924 -- had um- 1958. brella ownership of the Cubs and WGN TV -radio properties, change was going to be far off in the future. But all bets were off once the team and broadcasters diverged under www.ChicagoBaseballMuseum.org [email protected] separate corporate entities.
    [Show full text]
  • Tribune Executives Must Contribute Personal Assets to $200 Million Settlement
    riskinsights JUNE 2019 TRIBUNE EXECUTIVES MUST CONTRIBUTE PERSONAL ASSETS TO $200 MILLION SETTLEMENT Billionaire Sam Zell and other former executives of the bankrupt Tribune Company have reached a $200 million deal to settle the bankruptcy trustee’s adversarial claims against them arising out of the disastrous 2007 leveraged buyout (LBO) of the company. According to press reports about the settlement, the $200 million settlement amount, which is still subject to bankruptcy court approval, will “significantly” exceed the company’s remaining D&O insurance. The settlement amount in excess of the remaining insurance is to be split among the various individual defendants. bankruptcy and subsequent adversarial In 2010, the bankruptcy trustee initiated an adversarial proceeding both arose out of the proceeding against former Tribune CEO Dennis The December 2007 LBO in which Zell and FitzSimmons, Zell, and eventually, a total of approximately other investors took the Tribune Company private. The 50 other former Tribune executives. The trustee’s complaint Tribune Company owns or owned the Chicago Tribune, sought damages from the defendants for a variety of the Los Angeles Times, and a number of other media alleged violations, including breaches of fiduciary duty; properties. The LBO transaction resulted in an enormous unjust enrichment (based on payments made to certain debt load for the company. The transaction timing was of the defendants in connection with the LBO as well as poor as the global financial crisis arose only months after incentive compensation payments made to certain of the deal was completed. Within a year of the LBO, the the executives); illegal dividends; as well as certain other company filed for bankruptcy.
    [Show full text]
  • The Zell/Lurie Real Estate Center Spring Members' Meeting
    The Zell/Lurie Real Estate Center Spring Members’ Meeting 2021 Award Booklet Agenda Friday, April 30, 2021 ___________________________________________________________ 10:45 to 11:00 a.m. Welcoming Remarks Matthew J. Lustig, Chairman of Investment Banking, North America; Head of Real Estate & Lodging, Lazard; Chair, Advisory Board, Zell/Lurie Real Estate Center at the Wharton School Joe Gyourko, Nancy A. Nasher and David J. Haemisegger Director, Zell/Lurie Real Estate Center at the Wharton School 11:00 to 11:50 a.m. A Conversation with Jon Gray, President & Chief Operating Officer, Blackstone Moderator: Joe Gyourko 11:50 to 11:55 a.m. Break 11:55 to 12:45 p.m. A Conversation with Greg Davis, Managing Director & Chief Investment Officer, Vanguard, on Investment Markets Moderator: Maisy Wong, James T. Riady Associate Professor of Real Estate; Assistant Director, Grayken Program in International Real Estate, Zell/Lurie Real Estate Center at the Wharton School 12:45 to 12:55 p.m. Break 12:55 to 1:55 p.m. Panel Session: “New Economy Real Estate: Opportunities and Challenges” Moderator: Matthew J. Lustig Panelists: Panelists: Will Germain, Senior Investment Officer, Research & Innovation, Ventas Katherine Motlagh, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, CyrusOne Steve Vondran, Executive Vice President and President, U.S. Tower Division, American Tower Corporation 1:55 to 2:00 p.m. Break 2:030 to 3:00 p.m. A Conversation with Sam Zell, Chairman, Equity Group Investments, and Barry Sternlicht, Chairman & Chief Executive Officer, Starwood Capital Group Moderator: Joe Gyourko 3:00 p.m. Closing Comments Ronald J. Kravit, Senior Managing Director, Tracker Capital Management LLC; Vice Chair, Advisory Board, Zell/Lurie Real Estate Center at the Wharton School Joe Gyourko Student Awards Adam Anhang Memorial Fellowship Robert E.
    [Show full text]
  • Case 1:11-Cv-09569-WHP Document 126 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 39
    Case 1:11-cv-09569-WHP Document 126 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 39 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK : : : Consolidated Multidistrict IN RE: TRIBUNE COMPANY FRAUDULENT : Litigation CONVEYANCE LITIGATION : : 11 MD 2296 (WHP) : : DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMPANY AMERICAS, in : its capacity as successor indenture trustee for certain series : of Senior Notes, LAW DEBENTURE TRUST : COMPANY OF NEW YORK, in its capacity as successor : indenture trustee for certain series of Senior Notes, and : WILMINGTON TRUST COMPANY, in its capacity as : successor indenture trustee for the PHONES Notes, : : Plaintiffs, : : vs. : 11 CV 9569 (WHP) : BANK OF AMERICA N.A./GWIM TRUST : (Transferred from the OPERATIONS, : Northern District of Texas) COMERICA BANK & TRUST, NATIONAL : ASSOCIATION, in its corporate capacity and as sponsor : SECOND AMENDED of its collective investment funds, : COMPLAINT : DOUBLE BLACK DIAMOND OFFSHORE LTD. f/k/a : DOUBLE BLACK DIAMOND/OFFSHORE LDC, : FROST NATIONAL BANK, : JPMORGAN CHASE BANK, NATIONAL : ASSOCIATION, : LYXOR/BLACK DIAMOND ARBITRAGE FUND : LIMITED, : PENSON FINANCIAL SERVICES CENTURION : xxxxx9192, : : PENSON FINANCIAL SERVICES CRAWFORD, : PENSON FINANCIAL SERVICES MUSHIN TRA, : PENSON FINANCIAL SERVICES OPUS BBX, : PENSON FINANCIAL SERVICES SPECTRUM T, : PENSON FINANCIAL SERVICES, INC., : : (caption continued on next page) : 2752850.1 Case 1:11-cv-09569-WHP Document 126 Filed 10/04/12 Page 2 of 39 PENSON FINANCIAL SERVICES, INC./RIDGE, : PENSON FINANCIAL SERVICES SANO INVES, : : PENSON FINANCIAL SERVICES TRACK DATA, : STICHTING SHELL PENSIOENFONDS, : VALIC COMPANY I, : WORLDWIDE TRANSACTIONS LIMITED, : FIDELITY MANAGEMENT TRUST COMPANY, : CUSTODIAN, AND TIMOTHY L. O’ROURKE, : BENEFICIARY, TIMOTHY L. O’ROURKE IRA, : : BELLSOUTH/ALLIANCE, and : BELLSOUTH HEALTHCARE S&P 500, : : Defendants.
    [Show full text]
  • Tribune Co. in Deal with Creditors to Emerge from Bankruptcy 9 April 2010
    Tribune Co. in deal with creditors to emerge from bankruptcy 9 April 2010 Tribune Co. chief executive Randy Michaels described it as a "significant step forward as we continue to transform our media businesses, attract and retain talented people, and seize opportunities to grow." The Tribune Co. said that under the plan, holders of senior notes would receive 7.4 percent of the company's distributable value, which would be paid in a combination of cash, debt and stock. It said senior credit facility lenders would receive cash and debt and stock representing over 91 Chicago Tribune newspapers are offered for sale in Chicago, Illinois. The Tribune Co. announced an percent of the equity of the reorganized company. agreement with its major creditors Thursday that would allow the owner of the Chicago Tribune, Los Angeles Chicago real estate titan Sam Zell led an eight- Times and other newspapers to emerge from billion-dollar leveraged buyout of the Tribune Co. in bankruptcy. 2007. Besides the Chicago Tribune and Los Angeles Times, the Tribune Co. also owns the Baltimore The Tribune Co. announced an agreement with its Sun, the Orlando Sentinel, the Hartford Courant major creditors Thursday that would allow the and several other newspapers. It owns 23 owner of the Chicago Tribune, Los Angeles Times television stations. and other newspapers to emerge from bankruptcy. The Tribune Co. sold the Chicago Cubs baseball The Tribune Co., which filed for bankruptcy franchise and its iconic stadium, Wrigley Field, last protection in December 2008, said the deal could year. see the Chicago-based newspaper publisher and television station owner exit from bankruptcy later (c) 2010 AFP this year.
    [Show full text]
  • Tribune Company Fraudulent Conveyance Litigation Marc
    Case 1:11-md-02296-RJS Document 2655 Filed 08/02/13 Page 1 of 111 REDACTED UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK : Consolidated Multidistrict Action IN RE: TRIBUNE COMPANY FRAUDULENT : No. 11 MD 2296 (RJS) CONVEYANCE LITIGATION : No. 12 MC 2296 (RJS) : : : MARC S. KIRSCHNER, as Litigation Trustee for the : TRIBUNE LITIGATION TRUST, : : No. 12 CV 6055 (RJS) Plaintiff, : : v. : FIRST AMENDED : COMPLAINT CITIGROUP GLOBAL MARKETS INC. and : MERRILL LYNCH, PIERCE, FENNER & SMITH : INCORPORATED, : : Defendants. : : Plaintiff Marc S. Kirschner, as Litigation Trustee (the “Litigation Trustee”) for the Tribune Litigation Trust (the “Litigation Trust”), on behalf of the Chapter 11 estates of the debtors and debtors-in-possession in the above-captioned Chapter 11 cases (collectively, the “Debtors”),1 respectfully alleges as follows: 1 The Debtors in these Chapter 11 cases, along with the last four digits of each Debtor’s federal tax identification number, were: Tribune Company (0355); 435 Production Company (8865); 5800 Sunset Productions Inc. (5510); Baltimore Newspaper Networks, Inc. (8258); California Community News Corporation (5306); Candle Holdings Corporation (5626); Channel 20, Inc. (7399); Channel 39, Inc. (5256); Channel 40, Inc. (3844); Chicago Avenue Construction Company (8634); Chicago River Production Company (5434); Chicago Tribune Company (3437); Chicago Tribune Newspapers, Inc. (0439); Chicago Tribune Press Service, Inc. (3167); ChicagoLand Microwave Licensee, Inc. (1579); Chicagoland Publishing Company (3237); Chicagoland Television News, Inc. (1352); Courant Specialty Products, Inc. (9221); Direct Mail Associates, Inc. (6121); Distribution Systems of America, Inc. (3811); Eagle New Media Investments, LLC (6661); Eagle Publishing Investments, LLC (6327); forsalebyowner.com corp. (0219); ForSaleByOwner.com Referral Services, LLC (9205); Fortify Holdings Corporation (5628); Forum Publishing Group, Inc.
    [Show full text]
  • Keynote Conversation with Sam Zell
    SESSION REVIEW Keynote Conversation with Sam Zell BY ED FRIEDRICHS Speaker: About the Author Sam Zell Founder/Chairman, Equity Group Investments Ed Friedrichs completed his undergraduate degree in pre-architecture at Moderator: Stanford University in 1965 and received Ed Friedrichs his Master of Architecture degree from the University of Pennsylvania in 1968. He Friedrichs Group joined Gensler (now the largest and most respected architecture, design and planning Changing demographics and global economy is firm in the world) in San Francisco in creating opportunities and pitfalls for commercial real 1969, opening the firm’s Los Angeles office in 1976. In 1995, he was appointed President and, in 2000, Chief Executive Officer of the firm, estate and consumerism leading its development as one of the most successful and influential EF: How do you see demographics changing design firms in the world. society, real estate, consumerism and investment Since moving to Reno in late 2014, he is working as a development opportunities? partner on the West 2nd District, led by the Don J Clark Group. SZ: We’re in the middle of one of the greatest He is a co-chair of the Reno Streetcar Coalition, which is providing demographic transformations in history. I graduated leadership to construct a streetcar line connecting the University of Nevada Reno with downtown, mid-town and the convention center from the University of Michigan on June 10, 1963. By along Virginia Street. June 18, I was married. One year later, 95 percent of everybody we interfaced with was married and some had children. Think about what that means.
    [Show full text]
  • Before the FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION Washington, DC
    Before the FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION Washington, DC In the matter of ) ) Shareholders ofTribune Company, ) MB Docket No. 07-119 Transferors ) ) and ) ) Sam Zell, et al. ) Transferees ) ) For Consent to the Transfer ofControl of ) The Tribune Company ) ) and ) ) Applications for the Renewal ofLicenses of) File Nos. BRCT-20060811ASH, et. al. KTLA(TV), Los Angeles, California, et al. ) ) OPPOSITION TO PETITION FOR RECONSIDERATION John R. Feore, Jr. Marc S. Martin M. Anne Swanson Martin L. Stem Daniel A. Kirkpatrick Dow Lohnes PLLC Kirkpatrick & Lockhart 1200 New Hampshire Avenue, NW Preston Gates Ellis LLP Suite 800 1601 K Street, NW Washington, DC 20036 Washington, DC 20006 (202) 776-2000 (202) 778-9000 Counselfor Samuel Zell and Counselfor the Tribune Employee EGI-TRB, L.L. C. Stock Ovvnership Plan as Implemented Through the Tribune Employee Stock Ovvnership Trust January 15,2008 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page SUMMARy ii I. Background 3 II. The Commission Correctly Found That UCC and MA Failed To Demonstrate Standing To Challenge the Majority ofthe Transfer Applications 6 A. Unambiguous Commission precedent clearly holds that, for an organization to establish standing to challenge broadcast applications on behalf ofits members, it must submit declarations from members who are viewers ofor listeners to the stations 7 B. Petitioners must rely on declarations alleging hann from the challenged transaction and may not rely on declarations submitted in separate proceedings to establish standing 9 C. The Commission's decision to deny standing is not inconsistent with the goal ofencouraging public participation 12 III. The Commission's Decision To Grant Transferees a Permanent Waiver ofthe NBCO Rule in the Chicago Market Was Fully Justified and Supported By the Record in this Proceeding 13 A.
    [Show full text]
  • TRIBUNE COMPANY, Et Al., Debtors DELAWARE
    Case: 18-2909 Document: 81 Page: 1 Date Filed: 08/26/2020 PRECEDENTIAL UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE THIRD CIRCUIT No. 18-2909 In re: TRIBUNE COMPANY, et al., Debtors DELAWARE TRUST COMPANY, as successor indenture trustee for certain series of Senior Notes and DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMPANY AMERICAS, solely in its capacity as successor Indenture Trustee for certain series of Senior Notes, Appellants Appeal from the United States District Court for the District of Delaware (D.C. Civil Action Nos. 1-12-mc-00108, 1-12-cv- 00128/01072/1073/1100/1106) District Judge: Honorable Gregory M. Sleet Argued November 12, 2019 Before: AMBRO, KRAUSE, and BIBAS, Circuit Judges (Opinion filed: August 26, 2020) Case: 18-2909 Document: 81 Page: 2 Date Filed: 08/26/2020 Roy T. Englert, Jr. (Argued) Matthew M. Madden Mark T. Stancil Robbins Russell Englert Orseck Untereiner & Sauber 2000 K Street, N.W., 4th Floor Washington, DC 20006 Counsel for Appellant Delaware Trust Company David J. Adler McCarter & English 825 Eighth Avenue Worldwide Plaza, 31st Floor New York, NY 10019 Counsel for Appellant Deutsche Bank Trust Co Americas, as Successor Indenture Trustee Kenneth P. Kansa Sidley Austin One South Dearborn Street Chicago, IL 60603 James O. Johnston (Argued) Jones Day 555 South Flower Street, 50th Floor Los Angeles, CA 90071 J. Kate Stickles Cole Schotz 500 Delaware Avenue, Suite 1410 2 Case: 18-2909 Document: 81 Page: 3 Date Filed: 08/26/2020 Wilmington, DE 19801 Counsel for Appellee Tribune Co. Adam Hiller Hiller & Arban 1500 North French Street 2nd Floor Wilmington, DE 19801 Jay Teitelbaum (Argued) Teitelbaum Law Group 1 Barker Avenue, Third Floor White Plains, NY 10601 Counsel for Appellee TM Retirees OPINION OF THE COURT AMBRO, Circuit Judge Many of the contentious battles in bankruptcy involve the allocation of distributions among similarly situated creditors.
    [Show full text]