Ferghana Valley the Heart of Central Asia
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Ferghana Valley The Heart of Central Asia With some twelve million inhabitants, the Ferghana Valley is one of the most densely populated places in the world. It is also the most volatile region of Central Asia. Not only is the area ethnically and linguistically diverse, it is politically divided, with parts ruled by three different states—Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, and the Kyrgyz Republic—whose distant capital cities all relegate Ferghana to their respective peripheries. These complexities make a comprehensive, multidimensional understanding of the Ferghana region all the more elusive. In order to construct such an analysis, the Central Asia–Caucasus Institute assembled an international, interdisciplinary team of thirty scholars with the requisite expertise. Their carefully planned, collaboratively authored chapters cover the historical and topical terrain with unmatched depth and breadth and balance. STUDIE S OF CENTRAL AS IA AND THE CAU C A S U S Books in this series are published in association with the Central Asia– Caucasus Institute and Silk Road Studies Program Joint Center at the Johns Hopkins University’s Paul H. Nitze School of Advanced International Studies in Washington, DC, and the Institute for Security and Development Policy in Stockholm, under the editorship of Svante Cornell. Ferghana Valley The Heart of Central Asia Edited by S. Frederick Starr with Baktybek Beshimov, Inomjon I. Bobokulov, and Pulat Shozimov M.E.Sharpe Armonk, New York London, England Copyright © 2011 by the Central Asia-Caucasus Institute & Silk Road Studies Program Joint Center All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form without written permission from the publisher, M.E. Sharpe, Inc., 80 Business Park Drive, Armonk, New York 10504. The EuroSlavic and Transroman fonts used to create this work are © 1986–2011 Payne Loving Trust. EuroSlavic and Transroman are available from Linguist’s Software, Inc., www.linguistsoftware. com, P.O. Box 580, Edmonds, WA 98020-0580 USA, tel (425) 775-1130. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Starr, S. Frederick. Ferghana Valley : the heart of Central Asia / edited by S. Frederick Starr with Baktybek Beshimov, Inomjon I. Bobokulov, and Pulat Shozimov. p. cm. — (Studies of Central Asia and the Caucasus) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-7656-2998-2 (cloth : alk. paper) 1. Fergana Valley—History. 2. Fergana Valley—Geography. 3. Fergana Valley—Social conditions. I. Beshimov, Baktybek. II. Bobokulov, Inomjon I. III. Shozimov, P.D. IV. Title. DK919.F47S73 2011 958—dc22 2010044468 Printed in the United States of America The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information Sciences Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ANSI Z 39.48-1984. ~ EB (c)â 10ââ 9ââ 8ââ 7ââ 6ââ 5ââ 4ââ 3ââ 2ââ 1 Contents Acknowledgments vii Introducing the Ferghana Valley S. Frederick Starr ix 1. The Ferghana Valley: The Pre-Colonial Legacy Abdukakhor Saidov (Tajikistan), with Abdulkhamid Anarbaev (Uzbekistan) and Valentina Goriyacheva (Kyrgyz Republic) 3 2. The Rise and Fall of the Kokand Khanate Victor Dubovitskii (Tajikistan), with Khaydarbek Bababekov (Uzbekistan) 29 3. Colonial Rule and Indigenous Responses, 1860–1917 Ravshan Abdullaev (Uzbekistan), with Namoz Khotamov (Tajikistan) and Tashmanbet Kenensariev (Kyrgyz Republic) 69 4. Soviet Rule and the Delineation of Borders in the Ferghana Valley, 1917–1930 Sergey Abashin (Russia), with Кamoludin Abdullaev (Tajikistan), Ravshan Abdullaev (Uzbekistan), and Arslan Koichiev (Kyrgyz Republic) 94 5. The Ferghana Valley Under Stalin, 1929–1953 Kamoludin Abdullaev (Tajikistan), with Ravshan Nazarov (Uzbekistan) 119 6. The Ferghana Valley in the Eras of Khrushchev and Brezhnev Ravshan Nazarov (Uzbekistan), with Pulat Shozimov (Tajikistan) 140 7. Cultural Life in the Ferghana Valley Under Khrushchev and Brezhnev Zukhra Madamidzhanova (Tajikistan), with Ildar Mukhtarov (Uzbekistan) 164 v viââcont 8. The Ferghana Valley During Perestroika, 1985–1991 Pulat Shozimov (Tajikistan), with Baktybek Beshimov (Kyrgyz Republic) and Khurshida Yunusova (Uzbekistan) 178 9. A New Phase in the History of the Ferghana Valley, 1992–2008 Baktybek Beshimov (Kyrgyz Republic), with Pulat Shozimov (Tajikistan) and Murat Bakhadyrov (Uzbekistan) 205 10. Economic Development in the Ferghana Valley Since 1991 Sayidfozil Zokirov (Uzbekistan), with Khojamahmad Umarov (Tajikistan) 232 11. Land, Water, and Ecology Christine Bichsel (Switzerland), with Kholnazar Mukhabbatov (Tajikistan) and Lenzi Sherfedinov (Uzbekistan) 253 12. Culture in the Ferghana Valley Since 1991: The Issue of Identity Pulat Shozimov (Tajikistan), with Joomart Sulaimanov (Kyrgyz Republic) and Shamshad Abdullaev (Uzbekistan) 278 13. Islam in the Ferghana Valley: Between National Identity and Islamic Alternative Bakhtiyar Babadjanov (Uzbekistan), with Kamil Malikov (Kyrgyz Republic) and Aloviddin Nazarov (Tajikistan) 296 14. The Ferghana Valley and the International Community Inomjon I. Bobokulov (Uzbekistan) 373 Conclusion S. Frederick Starr 393 About the Editors, Authors, and Contributing Authors 405 Index 411 Acknowledgments This book was conceived by Drs. Pulat Shozimov of Dushanbe, Tajikistan, and Dr. Inomjon Bobokulov of Tashkent, Uzbekistan. Shozimov, having achieved early fame as a chess master and athlete, was already one of the most broadly gauged and internationally acclaimed anthropologists and ethnographers from Central Asia. Bobokulov, with his mild manner and fast-rising fame in the field of international relations, brought an encyclopedic knowledge of the region’s best social scientists, historians, and economists. At the time, both were fellows of the Central Asia– Caucasus Institute at Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies (SAIS) in Washington, DC. They burst into my office, carefully closed the door and, not even bothering to seat themselves, announced the plan. Now, in the context of the early twenty-first century, it is nothing short of amazing that scholars from two countries that maintain rocky relations with each other might conceive a joint study on one of the most sensitive topics that divides them. So much the better, we agreed. But we immediately realized that the project would be incomplete without participation from the third country into which the Ferghana Valley has been divided since 1991, the Kyrgyz Republic. Dr. Bakty- bek Beshimov was the obvious choice. A native of Osh and former rector of the university in that city, Beshimov had coordinated the United Nations’ program of research and assistance in the Ferghana Valley in the early 1990s. To our delight, Beshimov agreed to join us. This book is the product of a remarkable team effort involving Shozimov, Bobo- kulov, and Beshimov, a feat of cooperation that should be the envy of, and model for, political leaders in all three Ferghana countries. As the book’s editor, I know better than anyone else the generous yet rigorous spirit in which all three went about their assignments. It has been an honor to collaborate with them. Once the general issues and topics had been laid out, the four of us began seek- ing qualified scholars to contribute to the project of which we dreamed. Our plan was to have a “lead author” for each chapter, with the key people coming from the three Ferghana states. They were to be assisted by “contributing authors” for each chapter, who would be drawn from the other two countries. In selecting authors and contributors, we faced an abundance of riches and difficult choices had to be made. The resulting team proved remarkable in every respect. Little did we imagine when we began that the Ferghana book would include the best study ever written vii viiiâ ACKNOWLEDGMENTS on the Kokand Khanate or that it would present astonishingly new material on recent religious groups. The editors join me in thanking all the authors for their generous contributions. Even though the “Ferghana Project” was conceived in the Internet age, it nonetheless posed complex problems of coordination. These were ably handled by Katarina Lesandric and Roman Muzalevsky at the Central Asia–Caucasus Institute. Their task was as thankless—until now—as it was endless, with drafts to be elicited from several dozen very busy scholars, comments to be shared, cor- rections to be made, and then more drafts to be sent out for more comments and more corrections, ad nauseam. And so, on behalf of all the editors, I want to send warm thanks to these two heroes of virtual labor. Without them this book would never have seen the light of day. All the members of the Ferghana team join me in expressing our deep gratitude to M.E. Sharpe’s Irina Burns, whose meticulous and highly professional editing brought unity to the work of authors from six countries and as many scholarly traditions. The Ferghana Project was made possible through a generous grant to the Central Asia–Caucasus Institute from the Sasakawa Peace Foundation. Its Washington director, Mr. Keiji Iwatake, had to endure the multiple delays that were inevitable in so complex a project, and he did so with patience and understanding. Finally, warm thanks to Anna Starr Townsend for her splendid design of the cover. Selected by the editors from a bouquet of half a dozen alternatives she of- fered, this one appealed because it suggested that Ferghana was somehow still the center of Central Asia and also a bright and colorful place, rather than the grim and conflicted zone we imagine based on all