![Arxiv:1009.3281V1 [Astro-Ph.CO] 16 Sep 2010 Timi@Mpe.Mpg.De Bevn Rga 8.-25A N20 Ac 25](http://data.docslib.org/img/a84ee2de23a85034f729d173c0677dd8-1.webp)
arXiv:1009.3281v1 [astro-ph.CO] 16 Sep 2010 [email protected] bevn rga 8.-25A n20 ac 25. March 2009 d on Chile, 082.A-0255(A) Hemisphere, program Southern observing the in Research Astronomical iet ta.(05 on ufc rgtesecs with clusters excess SDSS R brightness 683 inner surface an of a to spect sample found (2005) a al. Using radi et a latter. Zibetti is the former of they the whether whether extension exten or (BCGs), components the galaxies independent cluster evolutionary and truly brightest (ICL) and the light physical of intracluster halo the the is between question relation open important An Introduction 1. atcutrwt eoiydispersion velocity a with co medium cluster flow, pact non-cooling of bright, region X-ray central an cluster, the I dominate Hydra 3309 NGC elliptical giant the gala host the of part and 2005). ICL al. compo the et from light (Gonzalez distinct diffuse is is cluster’s envelope it the cD whether this of or whether part known central yet not the is simply it but BCGs, the of iee sapooyeo neovdaddnmclyrelaxed dynamically and evolved an of c is prototype cluster a I Hydra as the sidered profile, regular temperature overall and the Given emission 2006). ray 2004, al. et Hayakawa of 2002; radius k few a a to from abundance out unifor metal fairly and a temperature h has of the 3311 distribution that NGC show on observations centered medium X-ray intracluster The 2008). al. et (Misgeld edofrn eussto requests offprint Send srnm Astrophysics & Astronomy oebr2,2018 20, November ⋆ ae nosrain olce tteErpa Organisati European the at collected observations on Based nteSuhr eipee h Dglx G 31and 3311 NGC galaxy cD the hemisphere, Southern the In h yaial o tla aoaon G 31 small a 3311: NGC around halo stellar hot dynamically The 1 2 Results. tr ocutrsasocr nterda ag o1 p fr kpc words. 12 to 4 Key dependin range galaxies, radial central the cluster star in in observed intracluster occurs kinematics central stars the cluster by to dominated stars is galaxy this of 33 NGC kinematics, halo hot Conclusions. dynamically its With galaxies. I Aims. Context. 2010 10, September accepted 2010; 27, July Received R Ael16)cutraon G 3311. Methods. NGC around cluster 1060) (Abell xe:niiul(G 3311) (NGC axies:individual 3 a-ln-ntttfu xrtreticePyi,Gies Physik, f¨ur Extraterrestrische Max-Plank-Institut uoenSuhr bevtr,Karl-Schwarzschild-Stra Observatory, Southern European NF sevtroAtooiod ioTrns,I105P I-10025 Torinese, Pino di Astronomico Osservatorio INAF, ≃ 12 eew eotrslsfo no on rjc ihteamto aim the with project going on an from results report we Here p.Frhrot to out, Farther kpc. efidavr te nraei h eoiydseso profil dispersion velocity the in increase steep very a find We nipratoe usini h eainbtenintraclu between relation the is question open important An eaayede ogsi bopinln pcr reaching spectra line absorption long-slit deep analyze We 230 1 hs eut n h ag muto akmte nerdfr inferred matter dark of amount large the and results These / aaiscutr:eea galaxies:clusters:individ – galaxies:clusters:general 4 rfieta hrceie h enprofile mean the characterizes that profile p Tmr ta.20;Ymsk tal. et Yamasaki 2000; al. et (Tamura kpc .Vniila -al gven- e-mail: Ventimiglia, G. : .Ventimiglia G. aucitn.gventimi no. manuscript lse-oiae eta galaxy central cluster-dominated ∼ 25 kpc, σ HydraI σ per ob osata hsvle hc is which value, this at constant be to appears 1 , 2 .Gerhard O. , 784 = L TE OTHE TO ETTER rn the uring ms km senbachstra nteeouinr tt fterhs clusters. host their of state evolutionary the on g nfor on ftecutr n httetasto rmpredominantly from transition the that and cluster, the of s nent, ABSTRACT β ded on- the are 1i nieohrnra al-yegalaxies. early-type normal other unlike is 11 re- m- − X- ,878Grhn e M¨unchen, Germany. bei Garching 85748 2, e xy mtecne fNC31.W omn ntewd ag fhalo of range wide the on comment We 3311. NGC of center the om pc 1 ot m al 1 n oiee Italy. Torinese, ino .Arnaboldi M. , h pcr sfo 4655 from is spectra the rmH from etrdo h wr aayHC2 at 26 HCC slit ex- long galaxy total the dwarf observations, a the FORS2 for the on each, In centered sec hrs. 4 1800 of of time spectra posure eight obtained We A). evtosrne from ranged servations eouinaogtesi of slit the along resolution pixel A 6 n hi mlctosaedsusdi et ,adorconc our and 5. 4, Sect. in Sect. summarized in kinematics are discussed sions halo are measured implications newly their The which kinemat and the 3. data, and Sect. archive reduction in data GMOS measurements the GEMINI describe We the reanalyze. and we VLT to at out spectr 3311 FORS2 NGC long-slit of use region We halo 3311. the ∼ in NGC kinematics of the uncover halo to stellar the of state BCG. a around halo dynamica stellar a extended for relaxed candidate a suitable of a therefore is it cluster; anddrn h ihso 09Mrh2-8 ihFR2on FORS2 long-slit with a 25-28, had March setup 2009 instrumental The of VLT-UT1. nights the spectra during tained slit long FORS2 VLT data archive and Observations 2. to ln oadsac ouu of modulus distance a to alent β ˚ ˚ a HdaI aaisknmtc n yais–gal- – dynamics and galaxies:kinematics – I) (Hydra ual trlgtadtehlso eta aaisi aaycluste galaxy in galaxies central of halos the and light ster . ′ ,D871Grhn e M¨unchen, Germany. bei Garching D-85741 1, e u to out 8 0 25 rmacentral a from e E eaotadsac oNC31 of 3311 NGC to distance a adopt We dynamical the establish to is work this of goal primary The . og rs 40+8 ihisrmna iprino 0.64 of dispersion instrumental with 1400V+18, Grism long, 247 hrceietednmclsaei h oeo h yr I Hydra the of core the in state dynamical the characterize DITOR p rmiscne.I et epeetosrain with observations present we 2 Sect. In center. its from kpc mXry rudNC31 ugs htteselrhalo stellar the that suggest 3311 NGC around X-rays om ∼ β − g ( MgI , kpc. 1 25 n pcrlresolution spectral and 2 p ntehl fNC3311. NGC of halo the in kpc , 3 n .Coccato L. and , λλ ∼ σ 5167 60% 0 150 = ftevlct iprino h Hydra the of dispersion velocity the of 0 , o5965 to A ′′ 5173 . ˚ 7 0 ′′ ms km . to 252 , 1 33 h ogsi pcr eeob- were spectra long-slit The - 5184 ⋆ ′′ . − 2 1 pixel . 1 54 σ h aeeghcvrg of coverage wavelength The . ,icuigasrto lines absorption including A, to ˚ 90 = )adF ( I Fe and A) ˚ a.Then mag. σ − out 1 h eigdrn ob- during seeing The . 51 ≃ ms km α p ND,equiv- (NED), Mpc 450 galaxy-bound 10 = − 1 1 ms km
λλ ′′ n spatial a and , c 1 ′′ h . corresponds S 2018 ESO 6 5270 36 rs. − ieand wide 1 m at 45 study l , 5328 . 85 lu- ic is 1 a s Ventimiglia et al.: The dynamically hot stellar halo of NGC 3311
Fig. 1. Optical DSS 7′ × 7′ image centered on NGC 3311 in the Hydra I cluster. The relative positions of the GMOS slit (5.′5, ′′ ′ Fig. 2. Kinematic fits with PPXF of the spectra extracted at −47 blue line) and FORS2 slit (6.8, red line) are illustrated. Green (VLT FORS2) and at −34′′ (Gemini GMOS). In black we dis- and yellow sections on the FORS2 slit indicate regions where play the galaxy spectra, in green the wavelength range excluded average spectra are extracted. The adjacent numbers specify the from the fit because of sky residuals, and in red the best-fit- radial distances of their light-weighted mean positions from the broadened template model. All spectra are normalized to the center of NGC 3311. The center of the FORS2 slit coincides value of the best-fit model at 5100 A.˚ with the position of the dwarf galaxy HCC 26 and is marked by a black circle. North is up and East to the left.
and ∼ 25′′ × 1′′. 6 at distances of about 54” and 47” from the and δ = −27d31m24.2s (J2000), with a position angle of center of NGC 3311, and of ∼ 58′′ × 1′′. 6 and ∼ 36′′ × 1′′. 6 at ◦ P.A.=142 ; HCC 26 is seen in projection onto the NGC 3311 central distances of about 100” and 67”. We properly mask the halo. The position of the FORS2 long slit is shown in Fig. 1. Its spectra of foreground stars in those areas. ◦ center is located at P.A.=64 with respect to NGC 3311, approx- The data reduction for the GMOS long slit spectra is car- imately along the major axis of the galaxy. ried out independently here, also in IRAF and with the stan- Gemini GMOS-South long slit spectra - We use Gemini dard tasks in the Gemini package. The procedure is described ˚ archive long-slit spectra in the wavelength range from 3675 A to in Loubser et al. (2008) for the wavelength calibration and back- ˚ 6266 A observed with the B600 grating, a dispersion of 0.914 ground subtraction; also in this case the edges of the slit are used −1 −1 A˚ pixel , a spectral resolution of σ = 135 km s , and a to interpolate the sky emission in the regions covered by the stel- ′′ −1 spatial scale of 0. 146 pixel ; a detailed description of the in- lar continuum.Because our goal is to sample the kinematics well strumental setup is presented in Loubser et al. (2008). The see- ′′ ′′ into the halo, the one-dimensional spectra for the absorption line ing was typically in the range from 0. 6 to 1. 2. We target the measurements are summed along the slit direction so that a min- same absorption lines as for the FORS2 spectra, i.e. Hβ, MgI imum S/N ∼ 20 per A˚ is obtained in each radial bin, out to a (λλ5167, 5173, 5184 A)˚ and Fe I (λλ5270, 5328 A).˚ The 0′′. 5 radial distance of about 40” from the center of NGC 3311. ′ wide and 5.5 long Gemini slit is centered on NGC 3311, at Stellar kinematics - The stellar kinematics is measured from α = 10h36m42.74s and δ = −27d31m41.3s (J2000), along ˚ ◦ the extracted 1D spectra in the wavelength range 4800 A<λ< P.A. = 63 , the direction of the galaxy major axis. Its position is 5800 A,˚ using both the “penalized pixel-fitting” method (PPXF, shown in Fig. 1. Cappellari & Emsellem (2004)) and the Fourier correlation quo- tient (FCQ) method (Bender 1990), in order to account for pos- sible systematic errors and template mismatch. 3. Data reductions In the PPXF method, stellar template stars from the MILES The data reduction of the FORS2 long slit spectra is carried out library (Sanchez-Blazquez et al. 2007) are combined to fit the in IRAF . After the standard operations of bias subtraction and one-dimensional extracted spectra; the rotational velocity, the flat-fielding, the spectra are registered, co-added and wavelength velocity dispersion and Gauss-Hermite moments (e.g. Gerhard calibrated. The edges of the FORS2 slit reach well into sky re- (1993)) are measured simultaneously. Fig. 2 shows two of the gions, which are then used to interpolate the sky emission in the extracted spectra and the broadened templates fit by PPXF. In the regions covered by the stellar spectra. FCQ method, the rotational velocity and velocity dispersion are In the low surface brightness regions, spectra are summed derived for each extracted one-dimensional spectrum by assum- along the spatial direction in order to produce one-dimensional ing that the LOSVD is described by a Gaussian plus third- and spectra with an adequate S/N ratio (≥ 20 per A).˚ Four indepen- fourth- order Gauss-Hermite functions. Before to the fitting pro- dent one-dimensional spectra are extracted along the slit where cedure the MILES template spectra are smoothed to the GMOS the light is dominated by the halo of NGC 3311; of these, two and FORS2 spectral resolution with the measured broadening are from regions north and two from regions south of HCC 26, offsets. While FCQ provides error estimates along with the mea- respectively. We extract spectra from slit regions of ∼ 31′′ ×1′′. 6 sured kinematics, errors for the PPXF kinematic parameters are
2 Ventimiglia et al.: The dynamically hot stellar halo of NGC 3311
by pχ2 in order to take into account systematic differences. 2 1 2 I.e., ǫ = n 2 × χ where ǫi, ǫx¯ are the errors on the x¯ Pi=1 1/ǫi individual measurements xi and the weighted mean x¯, re- spectively. Mean velocities and velocity dispersions in all radial bins are listed in Table 1, and the profiles are shown in Fig. 3 together with the previous measurements from Loubser et al. (2008). Table 1, which is available in electronic form, contains the following information: source of data (Col. 1), distance from galaxy center (Col. 2), P.A. (Col. 3), v,σ with errors for each of the procedures 1.-4. described in the text, in Col. (4-5), (6-7), (8-9), and (10-11), respectively. Heliocentric and relativistic cor- rections have been applied to the mean velocities. The systemic velocity is 3800km s−1 and has been subtracted. In the central region of NGC 3311, our new velocity dis- persion profile marginally agrees with that of Loubser et al. (2008). The new mean line-of-sight velocity measurements agree with the systemic velocity of NGC 3311 obtained by Misgeld et al. (2008), but have a systematic offset from the v data of Loubser et al. (2008), by about 91 km s−1. The agree- ment between the new FORS2 measurements at −47” and the revised value at −34” from archive GMOS data gives us con- fidence that the systematic effects from wavelength calibration Fig. 3. Major axis line-of-sight velocity and velocity dispersion ◦ offsets, template mismatch, etc., are sufficiently small in the new, profiles for NGC 3311 (P.A. = 63 ). The open light blue tri- independent data reductions. However, several tests have con- angles are the values published by Loubser et al. (2008), based vinced us that the data do not allow us to reliably determine full on Gemini-South GMOS data. The black asterisks are our inde- line-of-sight distributions (e.g., h3, h4), which could be used to pendent measurements from these GMOS (archival) spectra, and test for subcomponents, which one would expect in particular at the red asterisks show measurements from the new VLT-FORS2 radii ∼ 30” − 40”. spectra. These are weighted averages of three independent mea- surements which are obtained with PPXF and FCQ as described in Sec. 3 and shown separately as the gray, magenta and green 4. The kinematics of the NGC 3311 stellar halo diamonds. The FORS2 data points are obtained from averages over ∼ 25′′ and ∼ 31′′ in the inner regions and over ∼ 36′′ and The combined new velocity dispersion profile for NGC 3311 ′′ ′′ ∼ 58 in the outer regions of the slit; see Fig. 1. These off-axis reaches to Rmj = 39 ≃ 10 kpc from the center of NGC 3311 ◦ measurements are plotted at their light-weighted average radii, along the galaxy’s major axis (P.A.=63 ), and to an off-axis dis- corrected for projection onto the major axis of NGC 3311 with tance of R = 100′′ ≃ 25 kpc along the FORS2 slit. It shows an isophotal flattening of 0.89. Positive distances are south-west a very unusual steep rise with increasing radial distance from −1 from the center of NGC 3311 and negative values are north-east, the galaxy center: from a central value σ0 = 150 km s , to along P.A.=63◦. σ = 231 km s−1 at R = 15′′ ≃ 3.7 kpc, and then on to −1 ′′ a flat σout ≃ 450 km s outside R = 47 = 12 kpc. The steep outward gradient is supported by two independent data sets calculated with a series of Monte Carlo simulations adopting the and data reductions. The measurements of Loubser et al. (2008) appropriate S/N for each bin. near the galaxy center had already hinted at a positive gradient Because the stellar populations in cD halos may have differ- from 190 km s−1 at R = 5′′ to ∼ 240 km s−1 at a radius of ent metal abundances and ages from those of the inner regions R = 10′′, and data shown in Fig. 1 of Hau et al. (2004) reach (Coccato et al. 2010a,b), systematic effects caused by template ≃ 300km s−1 at ∼ 25”. With the new data we now have very mismatch must be evaluated and accounted for. We therefore ex- clear evidence of a dynamically hot stellar halo in NGC 3311. tract kinematic measurements with PPFX and FCQ as follows: To put the extremely rapid rise of the velocity dispersion pro- file of NGC 3311 in context,we compareits kinematicproperties 1. fit with PPFX the best stellar template from the MILES li- with those of early-type galaxy (ETG) halos mapped using plan- brary in the central regions with the highest S/N, and extract etary nebula data (Coccato et al. 2009) and with the halos of the v and σ at all radii, using the same stellar template; two Coma BCG galaxies NGC 4889, NGC 4874 from deep ab- 2. simultaneously fit the best stellar template, v and σ in each sorption line spectroscopy (Coccato et al. 2010a). Fig. 4 shows radial bin with PPFX; the mean
3 Ventimiglia et al.: The dynamically hot stellar halo of NGC 3311
steep velocity dispersion gradientin the halo of NGC 3311 traces the transition from central galaxy stars to the diffuse intracluster stellar component. In the NGC 3311 halo, the transition between thetwo occursat smaller radiithan in other BCGs in nearbyclus- ters, in the range between 4 and 12 kpc. NGC 3311 appears to have a similar halo as the cD galaxy NGC 6166 in the Abell 2199 cluster (Kelson et al. 2002), whose σ-profile rises to cluster values at R ∼ 60 kpc. But NGC 3311 is even more extreme; it is a fairly small galaxy, based on its −1 central σ0 = 150 km s , and it is already dominated by the surrounding cluster component at R ∼ 12 kpc. Presumably, this is because the core of the “relaxed” Hydra cluster has had time to collapse onto the galaxy. For comparison, the two BCG gal- axies in the Coma cluster core, which have a nearly constant σ-profile (Coccato et al. 2010a), may be in the middle of an on- going merger (Gerhard et al. 2007), so that their previous sub- cluster halos would have been stripped and a new cluster halo could have been built only after the merger was completed; and in the outer halo of the more isolated M87, the velocity disper- sion appears to drop (Doherty et al. 2009) towards the edge.
5. Conclusions Based on two independent long-slit data sets and reductions, we find a steep gradient in the velocity dispersion profile of the cen- tral galaxy NGC 3311 in the Hydra I cluster, from σ0 ≃ 150 −1 −1 km s to σout ≃ 450 km s outside 12 kpc (60% of the ve- Fig. 4. Properties of the stellar halo of NGC 3311 compared with locity dispersion of the galaxies in the surrounding cluster). other early-type galaxy halos: mean < V/σ > (upper panel), The new data provide evidence that NGC 3311 is a fairly total X-ray luminosity (central panel), and B-band total magni- small galaxy dominated by a large envelope of intracluster stars tude (lower panel) against stellar velocity dispersion σ. Solid di- already beyond R ∼ 12 kpc, whose orbits are dominated by the amond, circle, and square show the measured σ of NGC 3311 at cluster dark matter potential. Comparison with other BCG gal- the center, 15” (≃ 3.7 kpc), and 47” (≃ 12 kpc). Crosses show axies shows a wide range of dynamical behavior in their halos. outermost velocity dispersions from Coccato et al. (2009), and open diamonds for NGC 4889/4874from Coccato et al. (2010a). Acknowledgements. The authors wish to thank the ESO VLT staff for their sup- port during the observations and the referee for a constructive report. This re- search has made use of the Gemini archive data, the NASA/IPAC Extragalactic Database (NED), which is operated by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California center, at 15” (≃ 3.7 kpc) and at 47′′ (≃ 12 kpc). Only the cen- Institute of Technology, under contract with the National Aeronautics and Space Administration. tral σ0 puts NGC 3311 in the middle of the ETG distribution; σ(47”) deviates strongly, with a much larger σ than expected for the given LX , BT . References The natural interpretation for these results is that the outer stellar halo of NGC 3311 is dominated by the central intracluster Bender, R. 1990, A&A, 229, 441 Cappellari, M. & Emsellem, E. 2004, PASP, 116, 138 star component of the Hydra cluster. This is supported by sev- Coccato, L., Arnaboldi, M., Gerhard, O., et al. 2010a, ArXiv e-prints eral pieces of evidence: (i) The steep rise of the σ-profile; more Coccato, L., Gerhard, O., & Arnaboldi, M. 2010b, MNRAS, L97+ isolated ETGs all have slightly or even steep falling σ-profiles Coccato, L., Gerhard, O., Arnaboldi, M., et al. 2009, MNRAS, 394, 1249 (Coccato et al. 2009). (ii) The saturation of σ at ≃ 12 kpc, out- de Vaucouleurs, G., de Vaucouleurs, A., Corwin, Jr., H. G., et al. 1991, Third Reference Catalogue of Bright Galaxies, ed. de Vaucouleurs, G. and de side of which the dynamically hot component dominates com- Vaucouleurs, A. and Corwin, Jr., H. G. and Buta, R. J. and Paturel, G. and pletely. σ(47”) is ∼ 60% of the galaxy velocity dispersion in Fouque, P. the cluster core. (iii) The large amount of dark matter inferred Doherty, M., Arnaboldi, M., Das, P., et al. 2009, A&A, 502, 771 12 from X-ray observations around NGC 3311 (∼ 10 M⊙ within Dolag, K., Murante, G., & Borgani, S. 2010, MNRAS, 405, 1544 20 kpc, Hayakawa et al. (2004)). Gerhard, O., Arnaboldi, M., Freeman, K. C., et al. 2007, A&A, 468, 815 Gerhard, O. E. 1993, MNRAS, 265, 213 In recent cosmological hydrodynamic simulations of cluster Gonzalez, A. H., Zabludoff, A. I., & Zaritsky, D. 2005, ApJ, 618, 195 formation, Dolag et al. (2010) applied a kinematic decomposi- Hau, G. K. T., Hilker, M., Bridges, T., et al. 2004, in IAU Colloq. 195: Outskirts tion to the stellar particles around cD galaxies. With a double of Galaxy Clusters: Intense Life in the Suburbs, ed. A. Diaferio, 491–495 Maxwellian fit to the velocity histogram of star particles cen- Hayakawa, A., Furusho, T., Yamasaki, N. Y., Ishida, M., & Ohashi, T. 2004, PASJ, 56, 743 tered on a simulated cD, they were able to separate an inner, Hayakawa, A., Hoshino, A., Ishida, M., et al. 2006, PASJ, 58, 695 colder Maxwellian distribution associated with the central gal- Kelson, D. D., Zabludoff, A. I., Williams, K. A., et al. 2002, ApJ, 576, 720 axy, and an outer, hotter componentof stars that orbit in the clus- Loubser, S. I., Sansom, A. E., S´anchez-Bl´azquez, P., Soechting, I. K., & ter potential. For both components they derived radial density Bromage, G. E. 2008, MNRAS, 391, 1009 Misgeld, I., Mieske, S., & Hilker, M. 2008, A&A, 486, 697 profiles and, fitting Sersic profiles, found that the inner stellar O’Sullivan, E., Forbes, D. A., & Ponman, T. J. 2001, MNRAS, 328, 461 component is much steeper than the outer diffuse stellar com- Sanchez-Blazquez, P., Peletier, R. F., Jimenez-Vicente, J., et al. 2007, VizieR ponent. A comparison with these simulations indicates that the Online Data Catalog, 837, 10703
4 Ventimiglia et al.: The dynamically hot stellar halo of NGC 3311
Tamura, T., Makishima, K., Fukazawa, Y., Ikebe, Y., & Xu, H. 2000, ApJ, 535, 602 Yamasaki, N. Y., Ohashi, T., & Furusho, T. 2002, ApJ, 578, 833 Zibetti, S., White, S. D. M., Schneider, D. P., & Brinkmann, J. 2005, MNRAS, 358, 949
5 Ventimiglia et al.: The dynamically hot stellar halo of NGC 3311 o the galaxy has been obtained by a 1 − ). Col. 6: Velocity measured ) 5 8 8 9 1 22 23 33 19 11 13 16 28 14 − ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± = 0” R km s at ) ( = 3800 km s 1 31 401 11 235 7 151 5 154 15 460 17 457 5 191 13 429 31 464 33 289 9 174 11 231 − 12 195 ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± sys ± 5 8 V 17 39
6