A. Existing Conditions Analysis
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A p p e n d i x A PHASE ONE REPORT : E x i s t i n g C o n d i t i o n s A n a l y s i s Prepared by: Moore Iacofano Goltsman, Inc. Economic and Planning Systems Kittelson & Associates Land Design North Northern Economics RIM Architects Shannon & Wilson, Inc. TABLE OF CONTENTS Table of Contents 3 List of Diagrams 6 1 Overview 1 1.1 Introduction 1 1.1.1 Project Background 1 1.1.2 Planning Process 2 1.2 Vision and Goals 2 1.3 Opportunities and Constraints Analysis Diagram 3 1.3.1 Description of Key Elements 3 2 Natural, Cultural and Social Analysis 6 2.1 Overview 6 2.2 Key Planning Issues, Considerations and Opportunities 6 2.3 Natural Setting and Open space Conditions 6 2.3.1 Open Space System 6 2.3.2 Downtown Parks and Natural Systems 7 2.4 Historic and Cultural Influences 8 2.4.1 History of the Municipality 8 2.4.2 Cultural Influences 8 2.4.3 Downtown Cultural Events 9 2.5 Social Impacts 9 2.5.1 Streetscape Environment 9 2.5.2 Homelessness/Transient Populations 9 2.5.3 State/Regional Vehicular Traffic 10 2.5.4 Parking Limitations 10 2.5.5 Lack of Public Gathering Space 10 3 Land Use and Development Analysis 11 3.1 Overview 11 3.2 Key Planning Issues, Considerations and Opportunities 11 3.2.1 Commercial / Retail 13 3.2.2 Residential 14 3.2.3 Government/Office 14 3.2.4 Visitor Serving Commercial Land Uses 15 3.2.5 Civic/Cultural Uses 15 3.2.6 Transportation-Related Uses 16 3.2.7 Industrial Uses 16 3.2.8 Institutional Uses 17 3.3 On-Going Projects Affecting Downtown 17 3.3.1 Overview 17 3.3.2 Key Planning Issues/Considerations/Opportunities 17 3.3.3 E Street Downtown Corridor Enhancement 17 3.3.4 Civic and Convention Center 18 3.3.5 Museum Expansion 19 3.3.6 Alaska Railroad’s Ship Creek District 20 4 Urban Design Analysis 21 4.1 Overview 21 4.2 Key Planning Issues, Considerations and Opportunities 21 4.3 Pedestrian Environment 21 4.3.1 Sidewalk Conditions 21 4.3.2 Skybridges 23 4.3.3 Public Amenities 23 4.4 Building Heights 23 4.4.1 Solar Access 23 4.4.2 Flight Path Restrictions 24 4.4.3 Wind Impacts 24 4.4.4 Viewsheds 24 4.5 Historic Buildings and Landmarks 24 5 Transportation and Circulation Analysis 27 5.1 Overview 27 5.2 Key Planning Issues, Considerations and Opportunities 27 5.3 Existing Street Network 28 5.4 Traffic Patterns and Street Capacity 29 5.5 Parking 29 5.6 Public Transit 30 5.7 Pedestrian and Bicycle System 30 5.8 Conclusion 31 6 Seismic Analysis 32 6.1 Overview 32 6.2 Key Planning Issues/Considerations/Opportunities 32 6.3 Anchorage Seismicity 33 6.4 Carrying Capacity of Opportunity Sites within Downtown 34 7 Economic Analysis 35 7.1 Overview 35 7.2 Key Planning Issues, Considerations, and Opportunities 38 7.3 Economic and Demographic Overview 41 7.3.1 Location 41 7.3.2 State and Regional Economy 42 7.3.3 Anchorage Economy 44 7.3.4 Socio-Economic Profile 45 7.3.5 Household Units 52 7.3.6 Labor Force and Employment 55 7.4 Market for Potential Land uses in Downtown study area 61 7.4.1 Housing Market Assessment 62 7.4.2 Retail Market Assessment 72 7.4.3 Office Market Assessment 83 7.4.4 Hotel Market Assessment 86 8 Regulatory Framework Analysis 95 8.1 Overview of Title 21 and Anchorage 2020 Regulations 95 8.2 Key Planning Issues/Considerations/Opportunities 95 8.3 Uses 96 8.4 Dimensional Standards 96 8.4.1 Lot Requirements 96 8.4.2 Yard Requirements 96 8.4.3 Bulk and Lot Coverage 97 8.4.4 Structural Heights 97 8.5 Other Standards 97 8.5.1 Signs 97 8.5.2 Parking 98 8.5.3 Sidewalks 98 8.5.4 Street-level Design 98 8.5.5 Screening 98 8.5.6 Loading 99 8.5.7 Refuse Collection 99 8.5.8 Landscaping 99 8.6 Winter City Design 99 8.7 Structure of zoning districts 99 8.8 Title 21 Update 99 8.8.1 Commercial Centers 99 8.8.2 Adjacent Residential Areas 100 8.8.3 Compatibility 100 8.8.4 Coordination 100 9 Sources 101 LIST OF DIAGRAMS 1.1 Regional Context 1 1.2 Opportunities and Constraints 3 2.1 Natural Resources 7 3.1 Existing Land Use 9 3.2 Existing Infill and Parking Sites 11 4.1 Pedestrian Activity 22 4.2 Pedestrian Value 22 4.3 Shadow Study: Summer 23 4.4 Shadow Study: Winter 23 4.5 Flight Path Section 24 4.6 Historic Sites 24 5.1 Road Ownership 27 5.2 Existing Road Network 28 5.3 Possible Roadway Improvements 29 5.4 Existing Truck Routes 29 5.5 Existing Parking 29 5.6 Existing People Mover Bus Routes 30 5.7 Existing Pedestrian and Bicycle Trails 30 5.8 Possible Pedestrian/Bicycle Improvements 31 6.1 Seismic Hazard Diagram 32 8.1 Existing Zoning 95 1 OVERVIEW Nowhere else in Alaska is there an urban center that compares to Downtown Anchorage. With a strong economic base, cultural and historic attractions, natural beauty and diverse recreational opportunities, Downtown Anchorage has long been considered Alaska’s civic and cultural destination. Downtown Anchorage is at a very exciting time in its history. Throughout the Downtown area, housing opportunities, civic enhancements, open space and recreation improvements are shaping it into a destination for Anchorage residents and visitors alike. Catalytic projects such as the construction of a new Civic and Convention Center, expansion of the Museum of History and Art, transformation of E Street into an active, pedestrian-oriented corridor are just some of the on-going projects that will enhance the Downtown environment and attract more people to experience its historic, cultural, and natural resources. A major goal of the Downtown Comprehensive Plan is to provide strategic direction for development and growth, while embracing livability and a sense of place. In doing so, the Plan will coordinate all on-going projects and proposals and integrate them and other civic improvements to collectively strengthen Downtown Anchorage and firmly position it as Alaska’s civic, cultural and economic heart. In order to begin the planning process for Downtown, a thorough analysis of its existing conditions was required. The purpose of this analysis is to understand Downtown’s strengths and weaknesses; what current land use and development trends are beginning to take shape; how to best reconcile incongruent development and infrastructure; and what enhancements will have the most significant positive impact on Downtown for years to come. In addition to this introductory chapter, the report is organized into seven focus areas, each with its own chapter, including: Chapter 2: Social, Cultural and Natural Analysis Chapter 3: Land Use and Development Analysis Chapter 4: Urban Design Analysis Chapter 5: Transportation and Circulation Analysis Chapter 6: Seismic Analysis Chapter 7: Economic Analysis Chapter 8: Regulatory Framework Analysis Each chapter begins with a brief overview and a list of key issues, considerations and opportunities which provide a snapshot of how each area of focus affects Downtown. Following each chapter’s overview is a more thorough analysis of the specific components within each focus area. This analysis builds the case for the Plan’s recommendations and strategies to come later in the planning process. 1.1 INTRODUCTION 1.1.1 Project Background Just as the Municipality of Anchorage (the Municipality) has invested in public improvements, it has also become increasingly focused on developing connections within Downtown so these improvements benefit from their proximity to other revitalization efforts, as well as strengthening links to Ship Creek, Midtown and adjacent neighborhoods. To this end, the Municipality initiated a series of planning efforts to provide the city, and the Downtown specifically, with a clear direction to strengthen its standing as a regional destination (See Diagram1.1: Regional Context). The Anchorage 2020 Comprehensive Plan and the Downtown Development Framework were developed through these efforts. The Anchorage 2020 Comprehensive Plan is the adopted policy framework for guiding growth and development within the Anchorage Bowl. The 2020 Plan outlines policies Phase One Report Anchorage Downtown Comprehensive Plan Existing Conditions Analysis Page 1 in areas of land use and transportation, design and environment, and public facilities and services that encourage sustainable patterns of development, particularly in the Downtown area. Together with the Downtown Development Framework, the 2020 Plan set the stage for the Downtown Comprehensive Plan and Land Use Regulations, which will further articulate the vision for Downtown Anchorage and identify how Downtown should best enhance its civic, cultural and natural resources through coordinated decisions, guidelines and regulations regarding land use, zoning, economic development and design. The Comprehensive Plan will specify the implementation actions needed to realize its vision and goals. In addition to the Comprehensive Plan, Downtown Anchorage is in need of a Land Use Regulations update. The Central Business District (CBD) currently adheres to a three-tier zoning system that was adopted in early 1970s. The zoning system includes a bonus system that allows developments to go above the zoned height limitations and square footage requirements if they include public amenities in exchange. Though this system has resulted in some beneficial public spaces, it has also resulted in an incongruous mix of land uses, building heights and densities.