5132 Hon. Dan Burton

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

5132 Hon. Dan Burton 5132 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS March 29, 2001 room clerk for this newspaper, a shop stew- and union shop steward ‘‘a citizen/legislator: and others have been subjected to violence, ard and a teacher before getting a job that an educator who came to Capitol Hill and tyranny, and massive human-rights violations put him in charge of more vast stewardships. gave Congress a civics lesson.’’ for many years. Christian churches have been Those include oversight of all America’s pub- But Vento’s greatest legislative achieve- lic lands and helping to rescue the financial ments have been those he made as chairman burned. Priests have been killed, nuns have system from the ruin of the savings and loan and later ranking member of the Resources been raped, and many other atrocities have debacles. Committee’s Parks and Public Lands Sub- been committed with impunity. Muslims have Vento’s career in Congress, and before that committee. ‘‘I cannot think of another per- been killed in massive numbers and the ruling in the Minnesota Legislature, represent an son who has done more to protect America’s party has destroyed mosques. The Indian gov- old-fashioned sense of public service in a national parks,’’ said the Sierra Club’s exec- ernment has killed Sikhs. Religious pilgrims new-fashioned and too-slick political era. He utive director, Carl Pope. ‘‘Protecting our have been attacked with lathis and tear gas. knew what private-public partnerships were nation’s natural heritage is a passionate love This is just a recent sample of the atrocities before the concept became a sound bite for for him.’’ the ambitious. And he has never been afraid Vento’s hometown newspaper, the St. Paul against minorities in India. of a fight when the issue and the people mat- Pioneer Press-Dispatch—where he once Mr. Speaker, India is a significant recipient ter deeply. worked as a mailroom clerk—called him ‘‘an of American aid. Why should the taxpayers of The Reagan and Bush administrations Old Democrat in a New Democrat era’’ who this country pay taxes to support the corrup- were the source of frustration for the man exemplified ‘‘an old-fashioned sense of public tion and tyranny of the Indian Government? from the Fourth. When the Democrats were service in a new-fashioned and too-slick po- There is, however, something that America, as thrown into the congressional minority in litical era.’’ the world’s only superpower, can do about it. 1994, Vento found new rules but always kept Noting that Vento will not be part of the Democrats’ fight to regain the House, the America can stop sending aid to India and his eye on the prize of Democrats retaking support self-determination for the people of the reins. He noted with each election how newspaper added a poetic tribute: ‘‘Larger much the Republican majority had nar- things have taken over. But his mark will Khalistan, Kashmir, and Nagalim. Let us take rowed. This year, Vento will not be in the stand fast. An afternoon with only the these steps to free the people of the subconti- equation for a Democratic House. Larger sounds of the paddle dipping, the wind waft- nent from corruption and brutality. things have taken over. But his mark will ing, and the birds singing in the Boundary Mr. Speaker, I insert into the RECORD an ar- stand fast. Waters Canoe Area is the melody Bruce ticle from the current issue of The Economist An afternoon with only the sounds of the Vento makes in the woods of public policy. about the latest Indian Government bribery paddle dipping, the wind wafting and the . Godspeed, Congressman Vento.’’ scandal. I commend it to all my congressional birds singing in the Boundary Waters Canoe f colleagues who care about spending our for- Area is the melody Bruce Vento makes in eign aid dollars wisely. the woods of a public policy. So is the ani- CORRUPTION SCANDAL ENGULFS mated, personal Vento chatting with all INDIAN GOVERNMENT [From The Economist, Mar. 24, 2001] comers at the Labor Day picnic. INDIA’S CORRUPTION BLUES Godspeed, Congressman Vento. HON. DAN BURTON THOUGH IT MAY WELL SURVIVE THE LATEST CORRUPTION SCANDAL, THE AUTHORITY OF OF INDIANA THE LEADING PARTY IN THE GOVERNMENT IS [From the Hill, Feb. 8, 2000] IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES BADLY DENTED GODSPEED, CONGRESSMAN VENTO Thursday, March 29, 2001 Fatalism is ever present in India, and the The premature departure from Congress of Mr. BURTON of Indiana. Mr. Speaker, the government in Delhi seems to be hoping that Rep. Bruce Vento (D-Minn.) because he has a popular belief in the inevitability of cor- been diagnosed with lung cancer will deprive world has been shocked by the recent news stories about a corruption scandal that has en- ruption will help it survive the biggest scan- the House of Representatives of one of its dal of recent times. That hope seems well most dedicated, effective and popular mem- gulfed the Indian government. Already, the founded. But whether the government will bers. president of the ruling BJP and the Defense regain the authority it needs to pursue its Vento, who is retiring in December after 24 Minister have been forced to resign after they two main initiatives—economic reform and years in Congress, stunned and saddended his were caught taking bribes from two internet peace in Kashmir—is much more doubtful. colleagues and his St. Paul district when he news reporters posing as arms dealers in re- The uproar over the release of videotapes disclosed last week that he has a type of can- last week showing top politicians and offi- cer caused by exposure to asbestos. His doc- gard to a fake defense contract. The opposi- tion is calling for the government to resign. cials taking bribes from two Internet news tors at Minnesota’s famed Mayo Clinic have reporters posing as arms dealers has reached recommended an aggressive course of treat- The resignation of Defense Minister George a noisy impasse. The defence minister, ment that will make it impossible for him to Fernandes is no loss for friends of democracy. George Fernandes, has resigned, though he run for a 13th term. Mr. Fernandes is the man who led a meeting remains ‘‘covener’’ of the 18-party ruling Na- The 59-year-old St. Paul lawmaker’s an- in 1999 with the Ambassadors from China, tional Democratic Alliance. The NDA has nouncement that he will end a 30-year public Cuba, Russia, Libya, Serbia, and Iraq aimed lost one member, the Trinamul Congress service career, which began when he was at putting together a security alliance ‘‘to stop party of West Bengal, but remains sure elected to the Minnesota Legislature in 1971, the U.S.’’ This meeting was reported in the enough of its majority to dare the opposition triggered an outpouring of tributes and pray- to bring a no-confidence vote in Parliament. erful concern from lawmakers on both sides May 18, 1999 issue of the Indian Express. Those of us who have been following Indian The opposition, equally sure of its minority, of the aisle. President Clinton and Vice has declined. Instead, it has blocked par- President Gore, who came to Congress the and South Asian issues are not surprised. The liamentary proceedings for a week, relenting same year as Vento, also issued statements Indian Government has demonstrated many long enough only to allow money to be voted of praise and concern. times before how deeply it is infected with cor- for the state to continue functioning. None was more poignant than that from ruption. In India, people have come up with a Both sides have converted an occasion for his fellow Minnesota Democrat, Jim Ober- new word for bribery. They call it ‘‘fee for serv- shame into one for self-righteousness. Sonia star, who noted, ‘‘I lost my wife, Jo, to ice.’’ It has become necessary to pay a fee to Gandhi, leader of a suddenly alert Congress breast cancer, so Bruce’s disclosure that he get government workers of any kind to deliver party, vowed at its plenary meeting in Ban- too is fighting cancer hits close to home. galore to ‘‘wage every war’’ to ‘‘ensure that Bruce has spent the past 24 years in Congress the services that they are mandated to pro- this country is liberated from the shackles of fighting for working people, and now he is in vide. In November 1994, the newspaper this corrupt, shameful and communal gov- a fight for his life.’’ Hitavada reported that the Indian government ernment’’. But she herself was wounded when Even though they often clashed over the paid Surendra Nath, the late governor of Pun- her own personal assistant came under inves- issue of federal control of northern Min- jab, $1.5 billion to generate terrorist activity in tigation in a separate scandal. The prime nesota’s pristine Boundary Waters Canoe Punjab, Khalistan, and in Kashmir as well. minister, Atal Bihari Vajpayee, has blended Area Wilderness, Oberstar called Vento ‘‘a This is in a country where half the population penitence with defensiveness. He has prom- dear friend of mine’’ and ‘‘an exceptional lives below the international poverty line. ised a judicial probe into the allegations, and public servant.’’ a clean-up. But, in a television address on Rep. Jim Leach (R–Iowa), chairman of the Forty-two percent of the people live on less March 16th, Mr. Vajpayee reserved the word Banking and Financial Services Committee than a dollar a day and another forty-two per- ‘‘criminal’’ to describe the hurling of allega- on which Vento serves, praised him for his cent live on less than $2 per day.
Recommended publications
  • Indian Leaders Programme 2013 Participants
    PARTICIPANTES PROGRAMA LÍDERES INDIOS 2013 INDIAN LEADERS PROGRAMME 2013 PARTICIPANTS FUNDACIÓN SPAIN CONSEJO INDIA ESPAÑA COUNCIL INDIA FOUNDATION PARTICIPANTES / PARTICIPANTS that started Tehelka.com. When and in 2013, the Italian Ernest Editor and Lead Anchor at ET NOW Tehelka was forced to close Hemingway Lignano Sabbiadoro & NDTV Profi t. Shaili anchored down by the government after Award for journalism across print, the 9 pm primetime slots and its seminal story on defence internet and broadcast media. She conducted exclusive interviews of corruption, she was one of four lives in Delhi and has two sons. people like Warren Bu ett, George people who stayed on to fi ght and Soros, Deutsche Bank CEO Anshu articulate Tehelka’s vision and Jain, PepsiCo’s boss Indra Nooyi, relaunch it as a national weekly. Microsoft’s CEO Steve Ballmer and more. Shoma has written extensively on several areas of confl ict In 2012, Shaili received India’s in India – people vs State; the principal journalism honour The Ms. Shoma Chaudhury Maoist insurgency, the Muslim Ramnath Goenka Award for best in Managing Editor question, and issues of capitalist business journalism. She also won TEHELKA development and land grab. the News Television Award for She has won several awards, the Best Reporter in India in 2007 Shoma Chaudhury is Managing including the Ramnath Goenka and later in 2008, her business- Editor, Tehelka, a weekly Award and the Chameli Devi Ms. Shaili Chopra golf show Business on Course, newsmagazine widely respected Award for the most outstanding Senior Editor won the Best Show Award. She for its investigative and public woman journalist in 2009.
    [Show full text]
  • In This Issue... Plus
    Volume 18 No. 2 February 2009 12 in this issue... 6 Vibrant Gujarat 8 India Inc. at Davos 12 15th Partnership Summit 22 3rd Sustainability Summit 8 31 Defence Industry Seminar plus... n India Rubber Expo 2009 n The Power of Cause & Effect n India’s Tryst with Corporate Governance 22 n India & the World n Regional Round Up n And all our regular features We welcome your feedback and suggestions. Do write to us at 31 [email protected] Edited, printed and published by Director General, CII on behalf of Confederation of Indian Industry from The Mantosh Sondhi Centre, 23, Institutional Area, Lodi Road, New Delhi-110003 Tel: 91-11-24629994-7 Fax: 91-11-24626149 Email: [email protected] Website: www.cii.in Printed at Aegean Offset Printers F-17 Mayapuri Industrial Area, Phase II, New Delhi-110064 Registration No. 34541/79 JOURNAL OF THE Confederation OF INDIAN INDUSTRY 2 | February 2009 Communiqué Padma Vibhushan award winner Ashok S Ganguly Member, Prime Minister’s Council on Trade & Industry, Member India USA CEO Council, Member, Investment Commission, and Member, National Knowledge Commission Padma Bhushan award winners Shekhar Gupta A M Naik Sam Pitroda C K Prahalad Editor-in-Chief, Indian Chairman and Chairman, National Paul and Ruth McCracken Express Newspapers Managing Director, Knowledge Commission Distinguished University (Mumbai) Ltd. Larsen & Toubro Professor of Strategy Padma Shri award winner R K Krishnakumar Director, Tata Sons, Chairman, Tata Coffee & Asian Coffee, and Vice-Chairman, Tata Tea & Indian Hotels Communiqué February 2009 | 5 newsmaker event 4th Biennial Global Narendra Modi, Chief Minister, Gujarat, Mukesh Ambani, Chairman, Investors’ Summit 2009 Reliance Industries, Ratan Tata, Chairman, Tata Group, K V Kamath, President, CII, and Raila Amolo Odinga, Prime Minister, Kenya ibrant Gujarat, the 4th biennial Global Investors’ and Mr Ajit Gulabchand, Chairman & Managing Director, Summit 2009 brought together business leaders, Hindustan Construction Company Ltd, among several investors, corporations, thought leaders, policy other dignitaries.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Jyotirmoy Thapliyal, Senior Staff Correspondent, the Tribune, Dehradun 2.Dhananjay Bijale, Senior Sub-Editor, Sakal, Pune 3
    1 Jyotirmoy Thapliyal, senior staff correspondent, The Tribune, Dehradun 2.Dhananjay Bijale, senior sub-editor, Sakal, Pune 3. Vaishnavi Vitthal, reporter, NewsX, Bangalore 4.Anuradha Gupta, web journalist, Dainik Jagran, Kanpur 5. Ganesh Rawat, field reporter, Sahara Samay, Nainital 6.Gitesh Tripathi, correspondent, Aaj Tak, Almora 7. Abhishek Pandey, chief reporter, Sambad, Bhubaneswar 8. Vipin Gandhi, senior reporter, Dainik Bhaskar, Udaipur 9. Meena Menon, deputy editor, The Hindu, Mumbai 10. Sanat Chakraborty, editor, Grassroots Options, Shillong 11. Chandan Hayagunde, senior correspondent, The Indian Express, Pune 12. Soma Basu, correspondent, The Statesman, Kolkata 13. Bilina M, special correspondent, Mathrubhumi, Palakkad 14. Anil S, chief reporter, The New Indian Express, Kochi 15. Anupam Trivedi, special correspondent, Hindustan Times, Dehradun 16. Bijay Misra, correspondent, DD, Angul 17. P Naveen, chief state correspondent, DNA, Bhopal 18. Ketan Trivedi, senior correspondent, Chitralekha, Ahmedabad 19. Tikeshwar Patel, correspondent, Central Chronicle, Raipur 20. Vinodkumar Naik, input head, Suvarna TV, Bangalore 21. Ashis Senapati, district correspondent, The Times of India, Kendrapara 22. Appu Gapak, sub-editor, Arunachal Front, Itanagar 23. Shobha Roy, senior reporter, The Hindu Business Line, Kolkata 24. Anupama Kumari, senior correspondent, Tehelka, Ranchi 25. Saswati Mukherjee, principal correspondent, The Times of India, Bangalore 26. K Rajalakshmi, senior correspondent, Vijay Karnataka, Mangalore 27. Aruna Pappu, senior reporter, Andhra Jyothy, Vizag 28. Srinivas Ramanujam, principal correspondent, Times of India, Chennai 29. K A Shaji, bureau chief, The Times of India, Coimbatore 30. Raju Nayak, editor, Lokmat, Goa 31. Soumen Dutta, assistant editor, Aajkal, Kolkata 32. G Shaheed, chief of bureau, Mathrubhumi, Kochi 33. Bhoomika Kalam, special correspondent, Rajasthan Patrika, Indore 34.
    [Show full text]
  • 6. Attack on Tehelka for Using Call Girls
    Phoney Concern Attack on Tehelka for Using Call Girls Intervention Petition Submitted to the Chairman National Human Rights Commission by Madhu Kishwar Hon’ble Justice J. C. Varma, of sedition is punishable with death attempted to “bring into hatred and It came as a shock that the or life imprisonment. Tehelka is also contempt and excite disaffection National Human Rights Commission alleged to have “seduced various against the Government of India and has admitted a petition against officials of the Indian defence the armed forces”. However, the main Tehelka for “using sex workers to establishment from their allegiance peg used by Shakti Vahini to hang all entrap Army officers in the course of and their duties and encouraged them their wild and motivated allegations its sting operation” at the behest of to be disloyal to the nation”. Therefore, is the pious pretence of seeking to Shakti Vahini, an organization very few Shakti Vahini has sought action protect the rights and lives of the people had heard of till they sought against Tehelka under Section 131 of exploited prostitutes. To quote from the intervention of the NHRC and the the Indian Penal Code. This very their letter to the Deputy Delhi Police to take action against stringent provision provides for life Commissioner of Police: Tehelka under various draconian imprisonment for anybody who By their admitted acts of firstly Sections of the Indian Penal Code. “attempts to seduce” an Army officer procuring call girls/prostitutes I submit before the honourable “from his allegiance or his duty”. and providing them to the said Commission that the charges levelled Charge of Sedition army officials for the purposes by Shakti Vahini are frivolous, wrong, The complaint further states that of prostitution and then by absurd and motivated.
    [Show full text]
  • Accountability for Mass Violence Examining the State’S Record
    Accountability for mass violence Examining the State’s record By Surabhi Chopra Pritarani Jha Anubha Rastogi Rekha Koli Suroor Mander Harsh Mander Centre for Equity Studies New Delhi May 2012 Preface Contemporary India has a troubled history of sporadic blood-letting in gruesome episodes of mass violence which targets men, women and sometimes children because of their religious identity. The Indian Constitution unequivocally guarantees equal legal rights, equal protection and security to religious minorities. However, the Indian State’s record of actually upholding the assurances in the secular democratic Constitution has been mixed. This study tries to map, understand and evaluate how effectively the State in free India has secured justice for victims of mass communal violence. It does so by relying primarily on the State’s own records relating to four major episodes of mass communal violence, using the powerful democratic instrument of the Right to Information Act 2005. In this way, it tries to hold up the mirror to governments, public authorities and institutions, to human rights workers and to survivors themselves. Since Independence, India has seen scores of group attacks on people targeted because of their religious identity1. Such violence is described in South Asia as communal violence. While there is insufficient rigorous research on numbers of people killed in religious massacres, one estimate suggests that 25,628 lives have been lost (including 1005 in police firings)2. The media has regularly reported on this violence, citizens’ groups have documented grave abuses and State complicity in violence, and government-appointed commissions of inquiry have gathered extensive evidence on it from victims, perpetrators and officials.
    [Show full text]
  • Sabrang Elections 2004: FACTSHEETS
    Sabrang Elections 2004: FACTSHEETS Scamnama: The unending saga of NDA’s scams – Armsgate, Coffinsgate, Customscam, Stockscam, Telecom, Pumpscam… Scandalsheet 2: Armsgate (Tehelka) __________________________________________________________________ ‘Zero tolerance of corruption’. -- Prime Minister Vajpayee’s call to the nation On October 16, 1999. __________________________________________________________________ March 13, 2001: · Tehelka.com breaks a story that stuns the nation and the world. Tehelka investigators had captured on spy camera the president of the BJP, Bangaru Laxman, the Samata Party president, Jaya Jaitly (described as the ‘Second Defence Minister’ by one of the middlemen interviewed on videotape), and several top Defence Ministry officials accepting money, or showing willingness to accept money for defence deals. · This they had managed to do through a sting operation named Operation West End, posing as representatives of a fictitious UK based arms manufacturing firm. · Tehelka claims it paid out Rs. 10,80,000 in bribes to a cast of 34 characters. · Among the shots forming part of the four-and-a-half hour documentary are those of Bangaru Laxman accepting one lakh and asking for the promised five lakhs in dollars! He did not deny accepting the money. Bangaru Laxman resigns as BJP president. · Even before screening of the tapes at a press conference at a leading hotel here was over, the issue rocked both Houses of Parliament forcing their adjournment with the opposition demanding an immediate government statement on the issue. · The Union government says it is prepared for an inquiry into the tehelka.com expose of the alleged involvement of top politicians and government officials in corrupt defence deals. At an emergency Union Cabinet meeting George Fernandes reportedly offers to resign but the offer is rejected by the Prime Minister.
    [Show full text]
  • The Indian Economy at a Crossroads
    THE INDIAN ECONOMY AT A CROSSROADS Stephen Ezell Robert Atkinson I T IF The Information Technology APRIL 2014 & Innovation Foundation TABLE OF CONTENTS Table of Contents ..................................................................................................... 2 Executive Summary.................................................................................................. 5 The Modern Economy Path .......................................................................... 7 Policy Recommendations ............................................................................. 8 Vision of the Future ................................................................................... 10 Introduction .......................................................................................................... 11 The Evolution of India’s Post-Independence Economic Policies ................................. 13 A Heavily Statist Approach .............................................................................................. 13 Adoption of an Import Substitution Industrialization Strategy ........................................ 14 Embrace of a “Small is Beautiful” Mindset and the “Lump of Labor Fallacy” .................. 15 Toward the Economic Reforms of the 1990s ................................................................... 16 Two Paths Forward for India ................................................................................... 18 Embracing Innovation Mercantilist Policies or a Modern Economy Path .......................
    [Show full text]
  • Becoming a Journalist in Exile
    Becoming A Journalist In Exile Author/Editor T. P. Mishra Co-authors R. P. Subba (Bhutan) Subir Bhaumik (India) I. P. Adhikari (Bhutan) C. N. Timsina (Bhutan) Nanda Gautam (Bhutan) Laura Elizabeth Pohl (USA) Deepak Adhikari (Nepal) David Brewer (United Kingdom) Book: Becoming a journalist in exile Publisher: T. P. Mishra for TWMN - Bhutan Chapter Date of publication: March, 2009 Number of copies: 2000 (first edition) Layout: Lenin Banjade, [email protected] ISBN: 978-9937-2-1279-3 Cover design: S.M. Ashraf Abir/www.mcc.com.bd, Bangladesh and Avinash Shrestha, Nepal. Cover: The photo displays the picture of the Chief Editor cum Publisher of The Bhutan Reporter (TBR) monthly, also author of "Becoming a journalist in exile" carrying 1000 issues of TBR (June 2007 edition) from the printing press to his apartment in Kathmandu. Photo: Laura Pohl. Copyright © TWMN – Bhutan Chapter 2009 Finance contributors: Vidhyapati Mishra, I.P. Adhikari, Nanda Gautam, Ganga Neopane Baral, Abi Chandra Chapagai, Harka Bhattarai, Toya Mishra, Parshu Ram Luitel, Durga Giri, Tej Man Rayaka, Rajen Giri, Y. P. Kharel, Bishwa Nath Chhetri, Shanti Ram Poudel, Kazi Gautam and Nandi K. Siwakoti Printed at: Dhaulagiri Offset Press, Kathmandu Price: The price will be sent at your email upon your interest to buy a copy. CONTENTS PART I 1. Basic concepts 1.1 Journalism and news 1.2 Writing for mass media 1.3 Some tips to good journalistic writing 2. Canons of journalism 2.1 The international code of journalist 2.2 Code of ethics 3. Becoming a journalist 4. Media and its role PART II 5.
    [Show full text]
  • Tehelka - India's Independent Weekly News Magazine
    Tehelka - India's Independent Weekly News Magazine http://tehelka.com/story_main53.asp?filename=Ne180812Coverstory.asp 29 OCTOBER 2012 MONDAY TEHELKAHINDI.COM TEHELKAFOUNDATION.ORG CRITICALFUTURES.ORG Print Email to Friend | From Tehelka Magazine, Vol 9, Issue 33, Dated 18 Aug 2012 CURRENT AFFAIRS COVER STORY Follow @tehelkadotcom 45.6K followers 693 Like 41k ANNA-MORPHOSIS The Kejriwal Conundrum Arvind Kejriwal had tapped into a crucial anger. As chief architect of the Anna Hazare anti-corruption movement, he could have leveraged real change despite political resistance. Revati Laul assesses what his sudden change of course means PERHAPS IDEALISM, conscience and a keen sense of righteous rage are not enough. Perhaps intransigent ego — even a modicum of megalomania, a small zone of blindness — are necessary traits in a would be revolutionary. How else can one make the leap and believe powerful vested structures can be overthrown overnight and supplanted with one’s own? At THiNK — TEHELKA’s event in Goa — last year, there was one man international guests like The New York Times columnist Tom Freidman and astronomer C AMPAIG N Mike Brown wanted to meet more than any other. A ARTICLE 17: Our first call to the short, stout, earnest man in trademark loose grey National Commission of Scheduled Castes pants and chequered shirt. And an even more Photo: Shailendra Pandey trademarked earnest face. A man around whom zealous crowds had swelled last year, teeming seas of humanity, shouting anti-corruption slogans in ‘I’m ALSO READ Anna’ caps. All along though, it was clear to everyone that the real face of the India Against Corruption (IAC) Team Anna has been too movement wasn’t Anna Hazare.
    [Show full text]
  • The Creation of Indian Integrated Commands
    Draft for FLASCO-ISA Conference: NOT FOR CITATION Defense Reforms in a Rising India: An Organizational and Normative Shift towards Power Projection?1 Dr. Patrick Keo Clifton Bratton Hawai‘i Pacific University For the past decade, pundits and commentators have showcased India as another rising Asian power like China. India’s growing economy, larger international profile, and particularly its increased military spending, are seen as proof of India rising from being a regional power to perhaps a new Asian or even global power. Will India correspondingly move its military posture away from internal security and territorial defense, to emphasize power projection? Many commentators have pointed to India’s large military purchases as evidence that India is moving toward power projection and rivalry with China. Whether this is really happening is hotly debated in India. This paper will look at the debate over defense and security reform in India and the establishment of India’s first joint theatre command (for the Andaman and Nicobar Islands) as a test case. India took an unprecedented step ten years ago by setting up a joint regional command for the Andaman and Nicobar Islands. The establishment of the Andaman and Nicobar Command (ANC) was perceived as evidence that India is starting to balance against a larger China by reforming its defence organization (Posen, The Sources of Military Doctrine; Rynning, Changing Military Doctrine). Although the ANC is a strategic location, India has historically avoided building up forces there and it has resisted building up power projection capabilities. Moreover, India has been reluctant to build jointness and joint operational commands, even though India’s development of hard power capabilities are receiving increased attention.
    [Show full text]
  • Ten Years of Instability in a Nuclear South Asia Ten Years of S
    Ten Years of Instability in a Nuclear South Asia Ten Years of S. Paul Kapur Instability in a Nuclear South Asia India’s and Pakistan’s nuclear tests of May 1998 put to rest years of speculation as to whether the two countries, long suspected of developing covert weapons capabilities, would openly exercise their so-called nuclear option. The dust had hardly settled from the tests, however, when a ªrestorm of debate erupted over nuclear weapons’ regional security implications. Some observers argued that nucleari- zation would stabilize South Asia by making Indo-Pakistani conºict prohibi- tively risky. Others maintained that, given India and Pakistan’s bitter historical rivalry, as well as the possibility of accident and miscalculation, proliferation would make the subcontinent more dangerous.1 The tenth anniversary of the tests offers scholars an opportunity to revisit this issue with the beneªt of a decade of hindsight. What lessons do the intervening years hold regarding nu- clear weapons’ impact on South Asian security? Proliferation optimists claim that nuclear weapons had a beneªcial effect during this period, helping to stabilize India and Pakistan’s historically vola- tile relations. Sumit Ganguly and Devin Hagerty, for example, argue that in recent years “the Indian and Pakistani governments, despite compelling incen- tives to attack one another...weredissuaded from doing so by fear that war S. Paul Kapur is Associate Professor in the Department of National Security Affairs at the U.S. Naval Post- graduate School and a Faculty Afªliate at Stanford University’s Center for International Security and Co- operation. He is author of Dangerous Deterrent: Nuclear Weapons Proliferation and Conºict in South Asia (Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press, 2007).
    [Show full text]
  • Wie Indien Deutschland Sieht Indische Politiker Über Das Verhältnis Zur Bundesrepublik
    SWP-Studie Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik Deutsches Institut für Internationale Politik und Sicherheit Klaus Julian Voll (ext.) Wie Indien Deutschland sieht Indische Politiker über das Verhältnis zur Bundesrepublik S 37 Oktober 2001 Berlin Nachweis in öffentlich zugänglichen Datenbanken nicht gestattet. Abdruck oder vergleichbare Verwendung von Arbeiten der Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik ist auch in Aus- zügen nur mit vorheriger schriftlicher Genehmigung gestattet. © Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik, 2001 SWP Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik Deutsches Institut für Internationale Politik und Sicherheit Ludwigkirchplatz 3−4 10719 Berlin Telefon +49 30 880 07-0 Fax +49 30 880 07-100 www.swp-berlin.org [email protected] Gestaltungskonzept Gorbach Büro für Gestaltung und Realisierung Buchendorf Inhalt Problemstellung und Empfehlungen 5 Allgemeine Einschätzung 7 Deutschland als Wirtschaftspartner 9 Sicherheitspolitischer Dialog 11 Außenpolitische Gemeinsamkeiten? 13 Zukunftsperspektiven 15 Anhang 17 Politiker, die für Gespräche in Frage kommen 17 Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) 17 Congress(I) 18 Kommunisten 19 Regionalparteien 19 Unabhängige 20 Abkürzungen 21 Der Autor, seit 1970 Lehrbeauftragter für Politikwissenschaft am Otto-Suhr-Institut der Freien Universität Berlin, war kontinuierlich in Indien als Landesvertreter der Friedrich- Ebert-Stiftung (1983–1987), Sozialreferent an der Botschaft der Bundesrepublik Deutsch- land (1988–1993), FES-Auslandsmitarbeiter (1997 bis September 2001) und zwischen- zeitlich als Journalist und FES-Gutachter tätig. Dr. Voll ist zusammen mit Dr. Werner Pfennig Herausgeber der Schriftenreihen »Berliner Studien zur Internationalen Politik« und der »Critical Studies in Inter- national Development« zusammen mit Dr. H. C. F. Mansilla. Problemstellung und Empfehlungen Wie Indien Deutschland sieht. Indische Politiker über das Verhältnis zur Bundesrepublik Die Beziehungen zwischen Deutschland und Indien sind – ohne nennenswerte Konflikte – traditionell gut, jedoch keineswegs außerordentlich.
    [Show full text]