Pete Stauber (MN-08) Research Report the Following Report Contains Research on Pete Stauber, a Republican Candidate in Minnesota’S 8Th District

Pete Stauber (MN-08) Research Report The following report contains research on Pete Stauber, a Republican candidate in Minnesota’s 8th district. Research for this research book was conducted by the DCCC’s Research Department between November 2017 and February 2018. By accepting this report, you are accepting responsibility for all information and analysis included. Therefore, it is your responsibility to verify all claims against the original documentation before you make use of it. Make sure you understand the facts behind our conclusions before making any specific charges against anyone.

Pete Stauber

Republican Candidate in Minnesota’s 8th Congressional District

Research Book – 2018 Last Updated February 2018

Prepared by the DCCC Research Department

Table of Contents

Table of Contents ...... 2 Thematics ...... 3 Stauber In Congress: Too High A Price For Minnesotans To Pay ...... 4 Ethics ...... 15 Personal & Professional History ...... 17 Biography ...... 18 Personal Finance ...... 24 Political Career ...... 26 Relationships ...... 36 Donald Trump ...... 39 Issues ...... 41 Budget Issues ...... 42 Crime & Public Safety Issues ...... 44 Economy & Jobs ...... 46 Education Issues ...... 48 Energy Issues ...... 49 Environmental Issues ...... 50 Gun Issues ...... 58 Health Care Issues ...... 60 Housing Issues ...... 65 Labor ...... 67 Seniors’ Issues ...... 69 State And Local Issues ...... 70 Tax Issues ...... 77 Trade Issues ...... 92 Transportation Issues ...... 93 Veterans Issues ...... 94 Women ...... 96 Appendices ...... 98 Appendix I – Personal Financial Disclosures ...... 99 Appendix II – Campaign Finance ...... 106 Appendix III – Resolutions & Motions ...... 113 Appendix IV – Personal Reimbursements ...... 145 2

Thematics

3 Stauber In Congress: Too High A Price For Minnesotans To Pay

Significant Findings

 Stauber voted to approve the Budget & Tax Levy each year – increasing property taxes by more than $20 million or 18.37 percent as a County Commissioner.

 Stauber voted four times to raise the property tax levy after campaigning to lower taxes.

 Stauber voted to increase the sales tax by a half percent to help fund transportation improvements.

 Stauber praised the Republican Tax Scam bill, which punished the poorest Minnesotans and prioritized the richest.

 Stauber voted to increase county health insurance premiums by 8 percent after previously voting against a smaller increase in order to cover a $9.2 million health insurance shortfall.

 Stauber called Obamacare a “disaster,” but repealing the law would kick over 200,000 Minnesotans off their health care insurance, including 21,000 Minnesotans in the 8th Congressional District.

While Stauber Sat On The Board Of Commissioners, Property Taxes Rose More Than $20 Million – 18 Percent

Stauber Voted To Approve The Budget & Tax Levy Each Year – Increasing Property Taxes By More Than $20 Million Or 18.37 Percent

St. Louis County Property Tax Increases During Stauber’s Tenure (FYs 2014-2018) Total Increase Over Percent Increase Over Budget Year Max Levy Previous Year Previous Year 2018 $132,181,558 $5,631,479 4.45% 2017 $126,550,079 $9,918,886 8.50% 2016 $116,631,193 $ - 0.00% 2015 $116,631,193 $3,386,982 2.99% 2014 $113,244,211 $1,575,038 1.41% *2013 $111,669,173 $ - - Totals: $20,512,385 -- 18.37% [Resolution No. 17-739, 12/19/17; Resolution No. 16-768, 12/20/16; Resolution No. 15-766, 12/15/15; Resolution No. 14-698, 12/16/14; Resolution No. 13-764, 12/17/13; Resolution No. 12-659, 12/11/12] *FY Budget immediately prior to Stauber taking office.

Stauber Voted Four Times To Raise The Property Tax Levy After Campaigning To Lower Taxes

Stauber Campaigned On Bringing The Final Property Tax Levy Down To One Percent Or Less As County Commissioner

2012: Duluth News Tribune: Stauber Said He Supported Bringing The Final Property Tax Levy Down To 1 Percent Or Less. “Budget and levy[.] Even challengers were hard-pressed to argue against the county board’s move last week setting their preliminary 2013 property tax levy increase at 1.5 percent. The final levy, set in December, could go lower, but can’t go higher. Incumbents generally said the number reflected a balance between increasing needs for law enforcement, roads, bridges and other county services weighed against a lingering

4 recession and property owners’ already high taxes. Dahlberg and Stauber said they would like to see additional cuts to bring the final levy increase down to 1 percent or less.” [Duluth News Tribune, 9/18/12]

2017: Stauber Voted For The 2018 Budget And Levy Resolution, Which Increased The Property Tax Levy By 4.45 Percent

Dec. 2017: Stauber Voted For The 2018 Budget And Levy Resolution. [Resolution No. 17-739, 12/19/17]

Duluth News Tribune: The 2018 Budget And Levy Resolution Included A 4.45 Percent Increase in The Property Tax Levy. “St. Louis County commissioners on Tuesday unanimously approved a 4.45 percent increase in the county’s property tax levy for 2018, although home and business owners should see a much smaller increase in their actual tax bills. A growing economy has helped raise the value of property and has led to more construction, spreading the property tax pain across a wider base.” [Duluth News Tribune, 12/19/17]

Sept. 2017: Stauber Voted To Approve A $132,181,558 Maximum Property Tax Levy For 2018 For Organized Townships, A 4.45 Percent Increase. “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Jugovich, moved that the St. Louis County Board certifies the maximum property tax levy for 2018 in the amount of $132,181,558. St Louis County Administrator Kevin Gray provided an overview of 2018 budget items. Administrator Gray said that the proposed levy increase is 4.45%; the impact to a taxpayer with a home value of $150,000 would be a tax increase of less than $1.00 annually. After further discussion, the motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 17-559.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 9/26/17; Resolution No. 17-559, 9/26/17]

Sept. 2017: Stauber Voted To Approve A $1,582,000 Maximum Property Tax Levy For 2018 For Unorganized Townships. “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Jugovich, moved that the St. Louis County Board, acting on behalf of unorganized townships for the purpose of road and bridge maintenance and construction, adopts and certifies a maximum levy of $1,582,000 for the year 2018 to be levied only in such unorganized townships. Commissioner Rukavina said he opposes the levy because he believe the levy is unfair for the unorganized township residents. The motion passed; six years, one nay (Rukavina). Resolution No. 17-558. [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 9/26/17; Resolution No. 17-558, 9/26/17]

2016: Stauber Voted For To Approve A Maximum 8.5 Percent Increase In The Property Tax Levy

Dec. 2016: Stauber Voted For The 2017 Property Tax Levy And Budget Resolution. “After further discussion, the Commissioners adopted the 2017 Property Tax Levy and Budget Resolution. The motion passed; five yeas (Jewell, Boyle, Stauber, Nelson, Raukar), two nays (Dahlberg, Rukavina). Resolution No. 16-768.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 12/20/16; Resolution No. 16-768, 12/20/16]

Dec. 2016: Stauber Voted Against Amending The 2017 Budget By Lowering The Proposed Tax Levy By $1.5 Million. “Commissioner Rukavina, supported by Commissioner Dahlberg, moved to amend the 2017 Property Tax Levy and Budget resolution and direct Administration to lower the proposed levy by $1.5 million. The motion failed; one yea (Rukavina), six nays (Jewell, Boyle, Dahlberg, Stauber, Nelson, Raukar).” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 12/20/16]

Dec. 2016: Stauber Voted Against Amending The 2017 Property Tax Levy And Budget “To Lower The Unorganized Township Road Levy By $250,000.” “Commissioner Rukavina, supported by Commissioner Jewell, moved to amend the 2017 Property Tax Levy and Budget Resolution to lower the Unorganized Township Road levy by $250,000 and ask Public Works to reduce their budget by $250,000. Commissioner Dahlberg stepped out of the meeting from 10:53 a.m. to 10:59 a.m. Commissioner Rukavina said increases to the Unorganized Township Road levy since 2009, were unfair to unorganized township residents. Public Works Director Jim Foldesi indicated that a $250,000 budget reduction would affect the 5-year plan and would result in delivery of less road and bridge projects. After further discussion, the motion failed; two yeas (Rukavina, Jewell), five nays (Boyle, Dahlberg, Stauber, Nelson, Raukar).” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 12/20/16] 5

Sept. 2016: Stauber Voted To Approve A 8.5 Percent Maximum Increase In The Tax Levy For Organized Townships For 2017. “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Jewell, moved to certify the maximum property tax levy for 2017 in the amount of $126,550,079. Commissioner Dahlberg entered the meeting at 1:24 p.m. St. Louis Administrator Kevin Gray gave a presentation to the Board regarding the 2017 preliminary levy amount. Administrator Gray indicated that the proposed preliminary maximum levy is 8.5% compared to 2016; however, due to the increased tax capacity over the last two years the impact to taxpayers is 0.5%. The motion passed; six yeas, one nay (Dahlberg). Resolution No. 16-583.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 9/13/16; Resolution No. 16-583, 9/13/16]

Sept. 2016: Stauber Voted To Increase The County’s Levy By 8.5 Percent In The 2017 Budget. “St. Louis County residents will be paying a little more for the county’s share of their property taxes in 2017 after the county board on Tuesday approved an 8.5 percent levy increase. The preliminary increase brings the county’s levy -- the part of the county’s budget paid for by property taxes -- to $126.5 million, up from $116.6 million this year. […] Commissioners Boyle, Rukavina, Frank Jewell, Steve Raukar, Pete Stauber and Keith Nelson voted for the preliminary budget. Commissioner Chris Dahlberg voted against it.” [Duluth News Tribune, 9/13/16]

The 8.5 Percent Increase Was Preliminary And Would Be Finalized In December 2016. “St. Louis County residents will be paying a little more for the county’s share of their property taxes in 2017 after the county board on Tuesday approved an 8.5 percent levy increase. The preliminary increase brings the county’s levy — the part of the county’s budget paid for by property taxes — to $126.5 million, up from $116.6 million this year. The preliminary levy can come down, but can’t go up, when the board sets the final number in December. Homeowners and businesses will get their formal tax notice next spring.” [Duluth News Tribune, 9/13/16]

2015: Stauber Voted For The 2016 Budget And Levy Resolution, Which Did Not Raise The Property Tax Levy

2015: Stauber Voted For The 2016 Budget And Levy Resolution. [Resolution No. 15-766, 12/15/15]

Duluth News Tribune: The County Board Increased The Levy By Zero Percent. “The 8.5 percent levy increase, if it holds, would be the highest in a decade for the county. Last year the county had zero increase in levy, which saw many homeowners property taxes going down. That compares to a 2.9 percent levy increase in 2015; a 1.5 percent increase in 2013 and 2014; and a 1.8 percent increase in 2012.” [Duluth News Tribune, 9/13/16]

*Important Note: This was not a vote to increase property taxes, but it was a vote to approve the tax levy and it did not decrease property taxes, so it is important in any argument that Stauber voted every time to approve budgets & levies that led to increased property taxes of $20 million.

2014: Stauber Voted For The 2015 Budget And Levy Resolution, Which Reportedly Increased The Property Tax Levy By 2.9 Percent

Dec. 2014: Stauber Voted For The 2015 Budget And Levy Resolution. “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Jewell, moved to approve the 2015 budget resolution. St. Louis County Administrator Kevin Gray gave an overview of the 2015 budget. After further Commissioner discussion, the motion passed; six yeas, one nay (Dahlberg). Resolution No. 14-698.” [St. Louis County Commissioners, minutes, 12/16/14; Resolution No. 14-698, 12/16/14]

Duluth News Tribune: The Taxy Levy Increased By 2.9 Percent. “The 8.5 percent levy increase, if it holds, would be the highest in a decade for the county. Last year the county had zero increase in levy, which saw many homeowners property taxes going down. That compares to a 2.9 percent levy increase in 2015; a 1.5 percent increase in 2013 and 2014; and a 1.8 percent increase in 2012.” [Duluth News Tribune, 9/13/16]

6 Sept. 2014: Stauber Voted To Adopt A Maximum Levy Tax Of $116,631,193 For St. Louis County. “WHEREAS, The St. Louis County Board must establish a maximum proposed property tax levy and have this amount certified to the County Auditor by the St. Louis County Board by September 30, 2014; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board certifies the maximum property tax levy for 2015 in the amount of$116,631,193.00.” [Resolution No. 14-513, 9/23/14]

Sept. 2014: Stauber Voted To Adopt A Maximum Levy Of $1,582,000 For Unorganized Townships. “WHEREAS, Minnesota Laws 1995, Chapter 47, authorizes St. Louis County to pool unorganized town road levies pursuant to Minn. Stat. §163.06; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board, acting on behalf of unorganized townships for the purpose of road and bridge maintenance and construction, adopts and certifies a maximum levy of$1,582,000 for the year 2015 to be levied only in such unorganized townships.” [Resolution No. 14-491, 9/9/14]

2013: Stauber Voted For The 2014 Budget And Levy Resolution, Which Reportedly Increased The Property Tax Levy By 1.5 Percent

Dec. 2013: Stauber Voted To Adopt The Budget And Levy Resolution For Fiscal Year 2014. “Commissioner Raukar, supported by Commissioner Nelson, moved to approve the 2014 proposed budget and property tax levy. County Administrator Kevin Gray reviewed the budget objectives for 2014. After further discussion, the motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 13-764.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 12/17/13; Resolution No. 13-764, 12/17/13]

Duluth News Tribune: The Taxy Levy Increased By 1.5 Percent. “The 8.5 percent levy increase, if it holds, would be the highest in a decade for the county. Last year the county had zero increase in levy, which saw many homeowners property taxes going down. That compares to a 2.9 percent levy increase in 2015; a 1.5 percent increase in 2013 and 2014; and a 1.8 percent increase in 2012.” [Duluth News Tribune, 9/13/16]

2013: Stauber Praised The County Board For Only Raising The Property Tax Levy By 1.5 Percent. “Little changed since September and St. Louis County commissioners used Tuesday’s year-ending meeting in Ely to finalize a property tax levy that’s going up by 1.5 percent. […] This marks the fifth year in a row that the county levy has come in under the rate of inflation, Duluth area commissioner Pete Stauber noted. Stauber also lauded the county for holding the levy down while addressing long-term needs. ‘We’ve been proactive as we’ve gone,’ said Stauber. ‘We don’t let our house go to pot. We don’t beat our resources into the ground and build anew.’” [Ely Echo, 12/21/13]

Sept. 2012: “[Seniors Aren’t] Getting A Raise. The People Without Jobs, They’re Not Getting A Raise. Even Though 1.5 Percent Sounds Like It’s Not A Lot, It Is.” “In an election year, I think that being fair to the Board members and Commissioner Rauker, the 1.5% is okay with me at this time because it is just a start. It’s the maximum. The County Board is going to have a couple of months to reduce that. They have promised the citizens, I was at the Board meeting, they promised us, the taxpayers, that they were going to do whatever they could to reduce the 1.5 percent. And I’m going to hold them to it. I believe that there are reductions that can be made if you look deep. So just because it’s an election year I’m not going to go against the 1.5 at this point, but I will demand that it get down to one percent. Of course I would like it to be zero. You look at the seniors in this community, they’re not getting a raise. The people without jobs, they’re not getting a raise. And even though 1.5 percent sounds like it’s not a lot, it is. It’s $1.6 million. And so if we can demand that the County Board, between now and the middle of December, that they reduce the 1.5 to maybe one or so, to continuously to look at ways that we can reduce the tax burden on the taxpayers of St. Louis County.” [St. Louis County Board Fifth District Candidate Forum, Andrew Krueger via YouTube, 9/19/12] (VIDEO)

Sept. 2013: Stauber Voted To Adopt A Maximum Levy Of $113,244,211 For 2014. “WHEREAS, The St. Louis County Board must establish a maximum proposed property tax levy and have this amount certified to the County Auditor by the St. Louis County Board by September 15, 2013. THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board certifies the maximum property tax levy for 2014 in the amount of $113,344,211. Unanimously adopted September 10, 2013. No. 13-579.” [Resolution No. 13-579, 9/10/13] 7

Sept. 2013: Stauber Voted To Adopt A Maximum Levy Of $1,130,000 For Unorganized Townships. “WHEREAS, Minnesota Laws 1995, Chapter 47, authorizes the county to pool unorganized town road levies pursuant to Minn. Stat. 3 163.06; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board, acting on behalf of unorganized townships for the purpose of road and bridge maintenance and construction, adopts and certifies a maximum levy of $1,130,000 for the year 2014 to be levied only in such unorganized townships.” [Resolution No. 13-571, 9/10/13]

Stauber Voted To Increase The County Sales Tax By A Half Percent

Stauber Voted To Adopt A Resolution Implementing A 0.5 Percent Sales Tax And $20 Per Motor Vehicle Tax To Help Fund Transportation Improvements

Dec. 2014: Stauber Voted To Adopt A Resolution Implementing A 0.5 Percent Sales Tax And $20 Per Motor Vehicle Tax To Help Fund Transportation Improvements. “THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board of Commissioners authorizes and implements a 0.5% sales tax as provided for in Minnesota Statutes beginning April 1, 2015, for the purpose of funding transportation improvements as identified in the "St. Louis County Greater MN Transportation Sales and Use Tax Transportation Improvement Plan", dated December 2, 2014 (County Board File No. 59971); RESOLVED FURTHER, That the St. Louis County Board of Commissioners authorizes an excise tax of $20 per motor vehicle as provided for in Minnesota Statutes beginning April 1, 2015, to fund transportation improvements as identified in the ‘St. Louis County Greater MN Transportation Sales and Use Tax Transportation Improvement Plan’, dated December 2, 2014; RESOLVED FURTHER, That the provisions of Minn. Stat. § 297 A.99, Subdivisions 4, and 6 through 12, shall govern the imposition, administration, collection and enforcement of the tax; RESOLVED FURTHER, That the St. Louis County Board of Commissioners hereby directs the County Auditor to certify the tax to the Minnesota Department of Revenue for collection of the sales and excise tax on or before December 31, 2014.” [Resolution No. 14-665, 12/4/14]

Dec. 2014: Stauber Voted To Increase The County Sales Tax By A Half Percent, Which Would Add 50 Cents To Every $100 Purchase And “Raise More Than $10 Million Annually” For Infrastructure Repair. “St. Louis County commissioners voted Tuesday to impose a new half-percent sales tax on most purchases within the county, with the money aimed at fixing dilapidated roads and bridges. The board voted 5- 1 to impose the new transportation sales tax starting next year, adding 50 cents to every $100 purchase and raising more than $10 million annually to help repair the county’s 3,000 miles of roads and 600 bridges. […] Commissioners Nelson, Forsman, Stauber, Raukar and Patrick Boyle voted in favor of the new tax.” [Duluth News Tribune, 12/2/14]

Stauber Praised The Republican Tax Scam Bill, Which Punished The Poorest Minnesotans And Prioritized The Richest

Nov. 2017: Stauber Praised The House’s Passage Of The Tax Cuts And Jobs Act And Said It Would “Bring Much-Needed Relief” To Middle Class Families In Minnesota…

Nov. 2017: Stauber Praised The House’s Passage Of The Tax Cuts And Jobs Act And Said It Would Lower Individual Taxes And Increase The Standard Deduction For Families. “Pete Stauber, who is running for the U.S. Congress from Minnesota’s 8th Congressional District, issued this statement today: ‘I am pleased that the House voted today to pass tax reform and bring much-needed relief to the middle-class families of Minnesota. The plan not only lowers individual tax rates for low and middle-income Americans, it also increases the standard deduction so families can keep more of what they earn. With 50 percent of families living paycheck-to-paycheck, this is a step in the right direction and a win for Minnesota families who will get to keep more from their paychecks each year.’” [Pete Stauber, press release, 11/16/17]

8 …But The Tax Cuts And Jobs Act Raised Taxes For Low- And Middle-Income Minnesota Families While Giving The Richest 1 Percent “An Outsized Share” Of The Tax Cuts…

The Final GOP-Trump Tax Bill Would Raise Taxes For The Poorest 20 Percent Of Minnesotans In 2027

Institute On Taxation And Economic Policy: The “Final GOP-Trump Tax Bill Gives Larger Tax Cuts To Upper-Income Minnesota Residents In 2019, Raises Taxes On Low-Income Residents In 2027.” [Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, accessed 1/31/18]

Institute On Taxation And Economic Policy: The Final GOP-Trump Tax Bill Would Raises Taxes For The Poorest 20 Percent Of Minnesotans In 2027. [Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, accessed 1/31/18]

24 Percent Of Middle-Income Households In Minnesota Would Receive Tax Increases In 2027

Center On Budget And Policy Priorities: 24 Percent Of Households In Minnesota Earning Less Than $153,800 Would Receive Tax Increases In 2027. [Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, accessed 1/31/18]

The Richest Minnesota Taxpayers Received “An Outsized Share” Of Tax Cuts

Institute On Taxation And Economic Policy: The Final GOP-Trump Tax Bill Gave The Richest Minnesota Taxpayers “An Outsized Share” Of Tax Cuts. [Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, accessed 1/31/18]

Institute On Taxation And Economic Policy: The Final GOP-Trump Tax Bill Gave The Richest 1 Percent In Minnesota 22 Percent Of The Tax Cuts In The Final GOP-Trump Tax Bill, While The Middle 20 Percent In Minnesota Received 9 Percent. [Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, accessed 1/31/18]

The Final GOP-Trump Bill Capped The State And Local Tax (SALT) Deduction To Just $10,000 – But 90 Percent Of Middle Class St. Louis County Filers Claimed SALT Deductions In 2015

Final Tax Bill Scaled Back The State And Local Tax Deduction To Just $10,000. “Under current law, the state and local deduction (SALT) is unlimited. In the final GOP plan, people can deduct up to $10,000 (married couples are also limited to just $10,000). The House initially restricted the $10,000 deduction to just property taxes, but the final bill allows any state and local taxes to be deducted, whether for property, income or sales taxes. The move is widely viewed as a hit to blue states such as New York, Connecticut and California, and there are concerns it could cause property values to fall in high-tax cities and leave less money for public schools and road repairs.” [Washington Post, 12/15/17]

National Association Of Counties: In 2015, 90 Percent Of St. Louis County Filers In The Middle Income Bracket Claimed A Deduction For State And Local Taxes. [National Association of Counties, 2015 State and Local Tax Deductions (SALT), accessed 1/31/18]*

National Association Of Counties: In 2015, 62.9 Percent Of All State And Local Tax (SALT) Deductions Were Claimed By Middle Income Brackets. [National Association of Counties, 2015 State and Local Tax Deductions (SALT), accessed 1/31/18]*

*The National Association of Counties defined middle income brackets as those earning less than $200,000.

The Final GOP-Trump Tax Bill Would Allow Individual Tax Cuts To Expire In 2025 While Reductions For Businesses Remain Permanent

Politifact: GOP Tax Bill Would Raise Taxes For The Middle Class After Individual Tax Cut Provisions Expired In 2025. “Gillibrand said the Republican ‘tax [plan] raises middle-class taxes.’ That's not true during the first years of the new tax provisions. If not for the sunset for the tax changes for individuals, we likely would have rated Gillibrand's statement False or perhaps Mostly False. Middle-income taxpayers will either benefit or see no change in their tax liability through 2025. But her claim could hold up after the bill's individual provisions expire that year. There's no guarantee a future Congress will extend those parts of the bill.” [Politifact, 12/22/17]

Under GOP Tax Bill, Individual Tax Cuts Expired In 2025, While Reductions For Businesses Were Permanent. “But all of the individual tax cuts are scheduled to go away after 2025. Republicans opted to make tax cuts for families temporary and reductions for businesses permanent.” [Washington Post, 12/15/17]

GOP Tax Bill Provided The Largest Benefit To High Income Households, While Low And Middle Income Families Would End Up Worse Off In 2025. “The final tax bill that the House and Senate will vote on this week provides by far the largest benefits to high-income people, and many middle- and lower-income households would end up worse off, new Joint Committee on Taxation (JCT) estimates show.[1] Under the amended bill, in 2025 (when most of its provisions would be in place), high-income households would get the largest tax cuts as a share of after-tax income, on average, while households with incomes below $30,000 would on average face a tax increase.” [CBPP, 12/19/17]

…And Could Cost As Many As 27,600 MN-08 Residents Their Health Coverage

The Final Tax Bill Could Reduce Health Care Coverage For As Many As 31,000 People In CA-49

Final Tax Bill Eliminated Central Affordable Care Act Provision, Leading To 13 Million Fewer Americans With Insurance. “The individual mandate is part of the Affordable Care Act, and removing it was a top priority for Trump and congressional Republicans. The Congressional Budget Office projects the change will increase insurance premiums and lead to 13 million fewer Americans with insurance in a decade, while also cutting government spending by more than $300 billion over that period.” [Washington Post, 12/15/17]

Center For American Progress: Repeal Of Individual Mandate Would Lead To Reduced Health Insurance Coverage For 27,600 In CA-49 By 2025. According to the Center for American Progress, 27,600 MN-08 residents would see reduced coverage by 2025 with the repeal of the individual mandate: 11,300 on Medicaid; 10,400 on the individual market; and 5,900 on the employer-sponsored insurance market. [Center for American Progress, 12/5/17]

The Tax Cuts And Jobs Act Would Increase Incentives To Move Jobs Overseas

Tax Experts Said The Tax Cuts And Jobs Act Increased Incentives For Companies To Move Jobs Overseas. “What happened to the workers in Clinton, tax experts say, will probably happen to more Americans if the Republican tax overhaul becomes law. The legislation fails to eliminate long-standing incentives for companies to move overseas and, in some cases, may even increase them, they say. ‘This bill is potentially more dangerous than our current system,’ said Stephen Shay, a senior lecturer at Harvard Law School and former Treasury Department international tax expert in the Obama administration. ‘It creates a real incentive to shift real activity offshore.’” [Washington Post, 12/15/17]

HEADLINE: “Trump Promised ‘America First’ Would Keep Jobs Here. But The Tax Plan Might Push Them Overseas.” [Washington Post, 12/15/17]

Because Of The Way The Tax Bill Taxed Foreign Income, Corporations Would Increase Tax Free Income The More Equipment It Had Abroad. “In the future, corporations would be required to pay about a 10 percent minimum tax on overseas income above a certain level. The provision is billed as a way to discourage the movement of jobs and profit overseas. But the fine print of the new global minimum tax would make the problem worse, several tax specialists said. […] First, a corporation would pay that global minimum tax only on profit above a ‘routine’ rate of return on the tangible assets — such as factories — it has overseas. So the more equipment a corporation has in other countries, the more tax-free income it can earn. The legislation thus offers corporations ‘a perverse incentive’ to shift assembly lines abroad, said Steve Rosenthal of the Tax Policy Center.” [Washington Post, 12/15/17]

Under Tax Bill, A Corporation That Built A Plant In A Foreign Country Would Pay Substantially Less In Taxes On Foreign Profit Than Profits Earned In The United States. “Second, the bill sets the ‘routine’ return at 10 percent — far more generous than would typically be the case. Such allowances are normally fixed a couple of percentage points above risk-free Treasury yields, which are currently around 2.4 percent. As a result, a U.S. corporation that builds a $100 million plant in another country and makes a foreign profit of $20 million would pay roughly $1 million in tax versus $4 million on the same profit if earned in the United States, said Rosenthal, who has been a tax lawyer for 25 years and drafted tax legislation as a staffer for the Joint Committee on Taxation.” [Washington Post, 12/15/17]

Sperling: GOP Tax Bill Would “Give A Permanent Preference To Foreign Income And Lead Companies To Shift More Profits To Tax Havens Knowing That They Could Permanently Avoid Virtually All Taxation On Such Profits.” “Yet, it is clear that a territorial system could have just the opposite impact: It could give a permanent preference to foreign income and lead companies to shift more profits to tax havens knowing that they could permanently avoid virtually all taxation on such profits. […] What was problematic about this design was that it not only encouraged companies to move profits to tax havens, but it actually encouraged them to simultaneously move jobs and operations such as manufacturing to industrialized countries that had typical tax rates and to shift more profits to tax havens.” [The Atlantic, Gene Sperling, 12/8/17]

The Tax Cuts And Jobs Act Increased The Federal Debt – And Republicans Planned To Pay For It With Cuts To Medicare And Social Security

11 nearly hit that mark. The official estimate -- released Friday evening alongside the bill -- came in at $1.46 trillion.” [Washington Post, 12/15/17]

Center For A Responsible Federal Budget Found True Cost of Tax Bill Would Be $2 Trillion Or More, After Budget Gimmicks Were Accounted For. “Adding these gimmicks to the cost of the bill would increase the total cost to $2.0 trillion to $2.2 trillion. Though the dynamic effect of making the bill permanent is unknown, we estimate a permanent bill would produce roughly $450 billion of feedback,* leading to a dynamic cost of roughly $1.6 trillion to $1.7 trillion. With interest, these costs would rise to $2.4 trillion to $2.5 trillion, or $1.9 trillion to $2 trillion with dynamic effects included, over a decade.” [CRFB, 12/18/17]

After Passing Tax Bill That Added Trillions To Deficit, Ryan And GOP Continually Said That Medicare And Entitlements Needed To Be Cut To Decrease The Deficit

HEADLINE: After Tax Overhaul, GOP Sets Sights on Medicare, Social Security [US News, 12/7/17]

HEADLINE: Ryan says Republicans to target welfare, Medicare, Medicaid spending in 2018 [Washington Post, 12/6/17]

HEADLINE: Paul Ryan Pushes to Keep Overhaul of Safety-Net Programs on GOP Agenda [Wall Street Journal, 2/4/18]

After Passing A Tax Bill That Added Trillions To The Deficit, Speaker Ryan Said Medicare And Medicaid Would Need To Be “Reformed” In Order To Decrease The Deficit. “With his dream of tax reform now realized, Ryan is hoping to make progress on two other issues he’s targeted during his two-decade career in Washington: entitlement and welfare reform. ‘We’re going to have to get back next year at entitlement reform, which is how you tackle the debt and the deficit,’ Ryan, a former Budget Committee chairman, said in a recent interview this month on the Ross Kaminsky radio talk show. Medicare and Medicaid are the ‘big drivers of debt,’ Ryan said, suggesting Republicans could once again use the budget reconciliation process to avoid a Democratic filibuster. Medicare is the ‘biggest entitlement that’s got to have reform,’ Ryan added.” [The Hill, 12/27/17]

Ryan: “We Have To Address Entitlements. Otherwise, We Can’t Really Get Our Handle On Our Future Debt.” “NORAH O`DONNELL: --will Congress take up entitlement spending next year? REPRESENTATIVE PAUL RYAN: Yes. We will. And Bob and I actually see a lot of these things very similarly. We have to address entitlements. Otherwise, we can`t really get our handle on our future debt. There`s two things you need to do to get the debt under control so that our kids and grandkids get a debt-free nation. Number one, grow the economy. This tax cut bill will help do that. Number two, reform entitlement programs. We`re-- it`s unfortunate that our health care bill which passed the House last May didn`t get through the Senate, but we need to revisit that issue because that`s key entitlement reform. And then back to the welfare issue.” [CBS This Morning, 12/20/17]

Economists Warned That The Tax Bill Would “Intensify Pressure To Cut Spending On Social Programs”

AP: “A Wide Range Of Economists And Nonpartisan Analysts Have Warned That The Bill Will Likely Escalate Federal Debt, Intensify Pressure To Cut Spending On Social Programs And Further Widen America's Troubling Income Inequality.” “The tax overhaul of 2017 amounts to a high-stakes gamble by Republicans in Congress: That slashing taxes for corporations and wealthy individuals will accelerate growth and assure greater prosperity for Americans for years to come. The risks are considerable. A wide range of economists and nonpartisan analysts have warned that the bill will likely escalate federal debt, intensify pressure to cut spending on social programs and further widen America's troubling income inequality.” [Associated Press, 12/17/17]

12 the structure of Social Security and Medicare for future beneficiaries.’ Ryan issued a similar assessment just a few days later, noting that ‘health care entitlements … are the big drivers of our debt.’” [US News, 12/7/17]

Stauber Voted To Increase County Health Insurance Premiums By 8 Percent To Cover A Budget Shortfall, After Previously Voting Against A Smaller Increase

Stauber Voted To Raise Health Insurance Premiums For The Self-Funded Employee Health Insurance Plan By 8 Percent After Previously Voting Against A Smaller Increase

Stauber Voted To Raise Health Insurance Premiums By 8 Percent

Nov. 2017: Stauber Voted To Raise Health Insurance Premiums For The Self-Funded Health Insurance Plan By 8 Percent. “WHEREAS, The County Board annually review health insurance trends, expected claims, and its self-insured health and dental fund to establish funding levels for the employee and retiree medical and dental plans; and WHEREAS, The County Board believes an 8.0% rate increase for the self-funded health plan and a 2.5% rate increase for the self-funded dental plan in 2018 are reasonable based on projections prepared by its claims administrators and the County Auditor and based on the recommendations by its Health Insurance Committee; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLIVED, That the St. Louis County Board authorizes 2018 monthly premium rates for the self-funded employee and retiree health insurance as follows: SINGLE COVERAGE: $866.01 FAMILY COVERAGE: ]$2,011.32[.]” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 11/7/17; Resolution no. 17-643, 11/7/17]

Single Coverage Premiums Raised To $866.01 A Month And Family Coverage Premiums To $2,011.32 A Month. “Commissioner Jugovich, supported by Commissioner Rukavina, moved to authorize the 2018 monthly premium rates for the self-funded employee and retiree health insurance as follows: an increase of comprehensive major medical health plan premiums by 8.0% which would result in Single Coverage: $ 866.01, Family Coverage: $2,011.32, and authorize the appropriate county officials to make necessary adjustments to the premium collected consistent with collective bargaining agreements and compensation plans.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 11/7/17]

Stauber Voted Against Raising Premium By 6.5 Percent

Nov. 2017: Stauber Voted Against Raising County Health Insurance Premiums For The Self-Funded Health Plan By 6.5 Percent. “Commissioner Jugovich, supported by Commissioner Rukavina, proposed an amendment to raise the health plan premiums by 6.5%. Commissioner Nelson said that the Health Care Advisory Committee has spent significant time on arriving on the 8.0% proposal and that if there is an approved reduction from that number, he will propose to have a reduction of the levy. Director Gottschald said that the costs for the employees will be an estimated $2.50 per employee, per month for each percentage point increase and that the majority of the cost increase will be paid by the County through the levy. Director Gottschald then explained that ifthe fund balance is depleted, the County would have to convert to a fully-insured plan which would result in higher costs and more restrictions. Commissioner Jewell said that many people had worked hard on getting to the 8.0% recommendation. The amendment did not pass; two yeas, five nays (Olson, Boyle, Jewell, Nelson, Stauber).” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 11/7/17]

The County Administration Recommended An 8 Percent Increase To Cover A $9.2 Million Health Insurance Short Fall

The County Administration Had Recommended An 8 Percent Increase To Cover A 9.2 Million Health Insurance Short Fall. “St. Louis County Human Resources Director Jim Gottschald said there has been a 9.2 million dollar reduction in the self-funded insurance plan over the last two years. Director Gottschald said a four to six-month reserve is considered a healthy fund balance; the current reserve balance is three months. Director Gottschald indicated that the Health Insurance Committee was unable to reach a consensus on the funding level;

13 therefore, the 8.0% increase was recommended by County Administration.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 11/7/17]

Stauber Called Obamacare A “Disaster,” But Repealing The Law Would Kick More Than 200,000 Minnesotans Off Their Health Care Insurance

Stauber Called Obamacare A “Disaster” And Said He Favored “State Control Over Health Care”

Aug. 2017: Stauber Called Obamacare A “Disaster” And Said He Favored “State Control Over Health Care.” “On the topic of health care, he said, ‘We all know Obama Care was a disaster and Congress needs to work together to fix it. I favor state control over health care. You should be able to pick your own doctor and health care should be between you and your doctor. Republicans and Democrats need to work on a health care plan that will work for all Americans. The healthcare issue is too big, too complicated and too important to care about which side wins. Congress needs to work together to get it right.’” [Cook County News Herald, 8/12/17]

More Than 217,600 Minnesotans Stood To Lose Their Health Insurance If Obamacare Was Repealed Through The American Health Care Act (AHCA)

Center For American Progress: 217,600 Minnesotans Stood To Lose Their Health Insurance If Obamacare Was Repealed Through The American Health Care Act. [Center for American Progress, 6/27/17]

137,500 Minnesotans Stood To Lose Medicaid Coverage. [Center for American Progress, 6/27/17]

79,800 Minnesotans Stood To Lose Individual Coverage. [Center for American Progress, 6/27/17]

An Estimated 21,100 Minnesotans In The 8th Congressional District Were Enrolled In The Affordable Care Act

Kaiser Family Foundation: An Estimated 21,100 Minnesotans In The 8th Congressional District Were Enrolled In The Affordable Care Act. [Kaiser Family Foundation, ACA Enrollments, 10/4/17]

Ethics

Significant Findings

 Stauber voted to support legislation in the Minnesota state legislature to stagger commissioner terms, after initially voting against it.

 Stauber voted to increase the per diem rate for members of the Board of Adjustment from $50 to $75.

 Stauber abstained from a vote to issue Stauber Properties a snow storage easement.

Conflict Of Interest

2014: Stauber Abstained From A Vote To Issue Stauber Properties A Snow Storage Easement

June 2014: Stauber Abstained From A Vote To Issue Stauber Properties A Snow Storage Easement. “Commissioner Raukar, supported by Commissioner Nelson, moved that pursuant to Minn. Stat. § 163.11, Subdivision 9, the St. Louis County Board provides Stauber Properties a snow storage easement. The legal description of the property from which the easement is granted is: That part of Lots 2 and 3, Block 1, Lot 1, Block 2, and Outlot A, BURNING TREE DIVISION shown as Parcel 27 on Minnesota Department of Transportation Right of Way Plats Numbered 69-93 and 69-94 as the same are on file and of record in the office of the Registrar of Titles in and for St. Louis County, Minnesota. The motion passed; six yeas, zero nays, one abstention (Stauber). Resolution No. 14-348.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 6/3/14; Resolution No. 14-348, 6/3/14]

Terms

2014: Stauber Voted To Support Legislation In The State Legislature To Stagger Commissioner Terms, After Initially Voting Against It

March 2014: Stauber Initially Voted Against Supporting Staggered Commissioner Terms. “Further discussion took place regarding proposed Seventh District Commissioner staggered term legislation. Administrator Kevin Gray discussed details of his conversation with Intergovernmental Relations Director, John Ongaro. A role-call vote was taken and the amendment failed. Yeas: Commissioners Dahlberg and Nelson – 2. Nays: Commissioners Jewell, Boyle, Raukar, and Vice-Chair Stauber – 4. Absent: Commissioner Forsman – 1. Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Dahlberg, moved to table the discussion. The motion failed. Yeas: Commissioners Dahlberg, and Nelson – 2. Nays: Commissioners Jewell, Boyle, Raukar, and Vice-Chair Stauber – 4. Absent: Commissioner Forsman – 1. After further discussion, the resolution was amended to include the word ‘current’ in the THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED section and requiring attachment of proposed legislation to the resolution. The motion passed. Yeas: Jewell, Boyle, Raukar, Nelson, and Vice-Chair Stauber – 5. Nays: Commissioner Dahlberg – 1. Absent: Commissioner Forsman – 1. Resolution No. 14-144.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 3/11/14]

Stauber Ultimately Voted To Support Legislation In The State Legislature To Stagger Commissioner Terms. “WHEREAS, Since a 2002 Court Order which ended a court case regarding the St. Louis County Board’s redistricting decision, all three Iron Range-based County Commissioners have been on the same election rotation cycle; and WHEREAS, Prior to this Order, the District Seven Commissioner seat had historically been tied to Presidential election years; and WHEREAS, The Court Order resulted in all Iron Range commissioners running for re-election at the same time, with the potential of all three retiring, or all three being 15 defeated in one election; and WHEREAS, Proposed legislation currently under consideration at the Minnesota State Legislature essentially returns the term of office for the St. Louis County Seventh District Commissioner to its historic staggered term; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board supports current legislation being proposed at the State Legislature to change the staggered terms of office for the Seventh District St. Louis County Commissioner to its historic election rotation which was in place prior to 2002.” [Resolution No. 14-127, 3/11/14]

16 Personal & Professional

History

17 Biography

This section provides background information on Stauber’s personal life, including education, personal finances, criminal and civil record, and other areas. Searches were conducted with various local media in St. Louis County, media outlets including the Duluth News Tribune and the Minnesota Star Tribune, as well as a number of other online resources, including Lexis-Nexis.

Birth Date

Stauber Was Born On May 10, 1966

Stauber Was Born On May 10, 1966. [Votebuilder, accessed 1/8/18]

Education

Stauber Attended Lake Superior State University, Where He Played Hockey And Won A National Championship

The Journal: Stauber Attended Lake Superior State University, Where He Was Captain Of Their Division 1 Hockey Team. “Stauber grew up in Duluth’s Piedmont Heights neighborhood with his five Brothers. He graduated from Duluth Denfeld High School in 1984 and then attended Lake Superior State University in Sault Ste Marie, Mich. As captain of the Lakers’ hockey squad, Stauber was part of its Division 1 Men’s Ice Hockey championship team in 1988.” [The Journal, 10/21/17]

Stauber Majored In Criminal Justice And Minored In “Fire Science.” “He earned a bachelor of arts in criminal justice with a minor in fire science at Lake Superior State.” [The Journal, 10/21/17]

1988: Chicago Tribune: Stauber Played Hockey For Lake Superior State University When It Won Its First NCAA Division I Hockey Championship. “Right wing Mark Vermette scored at 4:46 of overtime Saturday to give Lake Superior State a 4-3 victory over St. Lawrence and its first NCAA Division I hockey championship. Vermette picked up the rebound of a shot by Pete Stauber, eluded a sweep check of Gary Robertson and slid the puck through a maze of players and past goalie Paul Cohen for his 45th goal of the season.” [Chicago Tribune, 4/3/88]

1984: Stauber Graduated From Denfeld High School In Duluth, Minnesota

1984: The Journal: Stauber Graduated From Denfeld High School. “Stauber grew up in Duluth’s Piedmont Heights neighborhood with his five Brothers. He graduated from Duluth Denfeld High School in 1984 and then attended Lake Superior State University in Sault Ste Marie, Mich. As captain of the Lakers’ hockey squad, Stauber was part of its Division 1 Men’s Ice Hockey championship team in 1988.” [The Journal, 10/21/17]

Career

The following provides a brief overview of Stauber’s professional career:

Political  2017 – Present: Second Term, St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, District 5  2013 – 2016: First Term, St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, District 5  2011 – 2013: Second (nonconsecutive) Term, Hermantown City Council  2001 – 2005: First Term, Hermantown City Council

18 Professional  1995 – 2017: Duluth Police Department  1990 – 1993: Professional Hockey, Detroit Red Wings Organization  Labor Union President / Law Enforcement Labor Services (LELS) Local 363

Jan. 2018: Stauber Reported That He Was A Rental & Leasing Services Employee

Jan. 2018: Stauber Reported Himself As An Employee In The Rental & Leasing Services Business On His Minnesota Statement Of Economic Interest

Jan. 2018: Stauber Reported Himself As An Employee In The Rental & Leasing Services Business On His Minnesota Statement Of Economic Interest. [Pete Stauber Statement of Economic Interest, filed 1/3/18]

Feb. 2017: Stauber Reported Himself As A Real Estate Employee On His Minnesota Statement Of Economic Interest

Stauber Reported Himself As A Real Estate Employee On His Minnesota Statement Of Economic Interest. [Pete Stauber Statement of Economic Interest, filed 2/10/17]

CFB: Public Officials Must Report Any Business Where One Received More Than $50 In A Month As An Employee, While Also Owning 25 Or More Percent Of The Business. “The business or professional activity category section is where you list the following information: 1) The business or professional activity category of each business from which you received more than $50 in any month as an employee if you also own 25% or more of that business[.] [Minnesota Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board (CFB), Public and Local Officials Handbook, accessed 1/9/18]

CFB: Public Officials Must Report Each Business Worked As An Independent Contractor Where Compensation Totaled More Than $2,500 In The Past 12 Months. “…and 2) Each business or profession activity category in which you worked as an independent contractor if you received compensation of more than $2,500 in the past 12 months for work in that category. The business and professional activity categories are available at the end of this handbook and on the Board’s website. You may abbreviate a word in a category as long as the abbreviation sufficiently identifies the category that you are reporting.” [Minnesota Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board (CFB), Public and Local Officials Handbook, accessed 1/9/18]

1995 – 2017: Stauber Served As A Police Officer For More Than 20 Years And Was Shot In The Head In The Line Of Duty

1995: Stauber’s Head Was “Grazed” By A Bullet That Was Fired At His Squad Car

1995: Duluth News-Tribune: Stauber’s Head Was “Grazed” By A Bullet That Was Fired At His Squad Car. “The last time a Duluth police officer was shot was Dec. 15, 1995, when a bullet entered Officer Pete Stauber’s squad car and grazed his head.” [Duluth News-Tribune, 11/11/07]

The Journal: Stauber Claimed He Was Shot In The Head While Off-Duty By “An Individual With An Extended Criminal History.” “‘In December of 1995, I was shot in the head while off-duty by an individual with an extended criminal history,’ said Stauber. ‘A few years after that, while on duty, I was looking down the barrel of a handgun when the suspect pulled the trigger and, by the grace of God, the gun malfunctioned. Even after being a victim of a violent crime, I still adamantly support the Second Amendment, the right to keep and bear arms.’” [The Journal, 10/21/17]

July 2017: Stauber Retired From The Duluth Police Department

19 July 2017: Stauber Retired From The Duluth Police Department. “Pete Stauber grew up in Duluth and graduated from Denfeld High School before captaining Lake Superior State University to a Division I national hockey championship in 1988. He played in the Detroit Red Wings organization for three years, then was a Duluth police officer for 22 years before retiring in July 2017. Stauber is currently in his second term as a St. Louis County Commissioner. His wife, Jodi, is an Iraq War veteran and retired from the 148th Fighter Wing as its first female Command Chief. They have four children and reside in Hermantown.” [Pete Stauber, press release, 10/27/17]

2008: The Duluth Police Department Promoted Stauber To Lieutenant

2008: Duluth News-Tribune: Stauber Was Promoted To The Rank Of Lieutenant. “The other new officers sworn in by 6th Judicial District Judge Gerald Martin on Thursday are: […] Scott Drewlo, Scott Jenkins, Ed Moroney, Robin Roeser, Pete Stauber and Steve Stracek were formally promoted to the rank of lieutenant.” [Duluth News-Tribune, 2/29/08]

Feb. 2009: Duluth Chief Of Police Gordon Ramsey Congratulated Stauber For Completing “The One Year Probation Period For Your Promotion To Lieutenant With The Duluth Police Department.” “Dear Lieutenant Stauber: Congratulations on the successful completion of the one year probation period for your promotion to lieutenant with the Duluth Police Department.” [Duluth City Police Department, Pete Stauber Personnel File, 2/5/09]

2004: The Duluth Police Department Promoted Stauber To Sergeant

March 2004: The Duluth Police Department Promoted Stauber To Sergeant. “Dear Officer Stauber: At this time, we offer you promotion to the position of Sergeant in the Duluth Police Department. This is a full time regular position. The probation period for this position is one year. Your promotion to this position is scheduled to begin March 26, 2004. You will be paid at Pay Range 328 Step D.” [Duluth City Police Department, Pete Stauber Personnel File, 3/24/04]

1995: The Duluth Police Department Hired Stauber As A Probationary Police Officer

March 1995: The Duluth Police Department Hired Stauber As A Probationary Police Officer. “Dear Mr. Stauber: This letter confirms telephone information provided to you by Sgt. Tim Hanson, advising you that you will be hired as a probationary Duluth Police Officer. Your starting date is Money, April 3, 1995. Congratulations!” [Duluth City Police Department, Pete Stauber Personnel File, 3/9/95]

Stauber Was Reportedly A “Former National Registered Paramedic And A Member Of The Duluth Police Tactical Response Team”

Aug. 2017: Cook County News Herald: Stauber Was Reportedly A “Former National Registered Paramedic And A Member Of The Duluth Police Tactical Response Team.” “Pete has served as a St. Louis County commissioner since 2012. Before that, he served eight years on the Hermantown city council, the town where he and his wife Jodi and their four children reside. Stauber served as a commander in the Duluth Police Department, and he was also the president of the Law Enforcement Labor Services Union, Local 363. He was also a former national registered paramedic and a member of the Duluth Police Tactical Response Team.” [Cook County News Herald, 8/12/17]

2016: Stauber Was The President Of Law Enforcement Labor Services Local 363

Stauber Claimed He Was The Former President Of Law Enforcement Labor Services (LELS) Local 636. [Pete Stauber for Congress, accessed 1/25/18]

As Of October 2016, Stauber Was Reportedly Still The President Of Law Enforcement Labor Services Local. “He is president of Law Enforcement Labor Services Local 363. Stauber grew up in Duluth’s Piedmont 20 Heights neighborhood with his five brothers. He graduated from Duluth Denfeld High School in 1984 and then attended Lake Superior State University in Sault Ste Marie, Mich.” [The Journal, 10/21/17]

1990 – 1993: Stauber Was A Professional Hockey Player For The Detroit Red Wings Organization

Stauber Played Three Seasons For The Detroit Red Wings Organization, Beginning In 1990

Miami Herald: Stauber Played Three Seasons With The Detroit Red Wings’ Minor League Organization. “Players are listed in the order they were taken in the draft. Top 10 will be protected by the Panthers for Phase II of the Expansion Draft. […] Pete Stauber * Age: 27, born in Duluth, Minn. * Height: 5-11. * Weight: 185. * Drafted from: Detroit. * Career highlights: Plays left wing . . . Scored 20 or more goals four straight years at Lake Superior . . . Has spent past three seasons in minors with Detroit . . . Has no regular- season NHL experience . . . Signed as a free agent by Detroit in June 1990. Year Team GP G A TP PIM ‘92-93 Adirondack (AHL) 12 2 2 4 8[.] [Miami Herald, 6/25/93]

1990: United Press International: The Detroit Red Wings Signed Stauber To A “Multi-Year Contract.” “The Detroit Red Wings have signed free agent Pete Stauber, a senior left wing from Lake Superior State University-ty, to a multi-year contract, General Manager Jim Devellano announced Thursday. Stauber, 24, a native of Duluth, Minn., was voted the best defensive forward in the Central Collegiate Hockey Association for the 1989-90 season by a vote of the league coaches. An honorable mention All-CCHA selection, Stauber had 25 goals and 31 assists for 56 points for the Lakers in 46 games last season. A criminal justice major, Stauber was selected as the league’s only unanimous choice on the CCHA All-Academic Team for 1990. His brother, Robb, a Hobey Baker Award as college hockey’s outstanding player while at the University of Minnesota, is a goaltender for the Los Angeles Kings.” [United Press International, 6/21/90]

Stauber Was Reportedly “Loaned” To The U.S. Olympic Team For Training

1991: USA Today: The Detroit Red Wings Loaned Stauber To The U.S. Olympic Team For Its Training Camp. “ON LOAN: The Detroit Red Wings are lending minor-leaguer Pete Stauber to the U.S. Olympic team for its training camp next month.” [USA Today, 7/23/91]

Stauber Was Reportedly Paid $170,000 By The Detroit Red Wings Organization

Vancouver Sun: Stauber Was Reportedly Paid $170,000 By The Detroit Red Wings Organization For The 1992 To 1993 Season. “Following is a team-by-team list of 1992-93 player salaries filed with the NHL Players’ Association through Jan. 22 and obtained by The Canadian Press. Figures listed include deferred payments and signing bonuses but exclude incentive bonuses. Salaries are paid in the currency of the country in which the club is based, although players traded from Canadian to U.S. clubs are then paid in American currency (x-denotes players on Canadian teams paid in U.S. funds). […] Pete Stauber $ 170,000 Chris Tancill $ 140,000 Jason York $ 120,000 Paul Ysebaert $ 325,000 Steve Yzerman $ 1,500,000 EDMONTON OILERS[.]” [Vancouver Sun, 2/5/93]

Stauber’s Hockey Contract Was Terminated After The Florida Panthers Briefly Signed Him

June 1993: Associated Press: Stauber Was Reportedly Eligible To Be Drafted From The Detroit Red Wings. “A list of NHL players left unprotected by their teams and eligible to be selected in the 1993 expansion draft […] Forwards-Troy Crowder, Gerard Gallant, Alan Kerr, Steve Maltais, Pete Stauber.” [Associated Press, 6/21/93]

Aug. 1993: Miami Herald: The Florida Panthers Terminated Their Contact With Stauber After They Selected Him In The Summer Expansion Draft. “Four players picked up in the expansion draft, defenseman Gord Hynes, forward Doug Barrault, left wing Mark LaBelle and left wing Pete Stauber, were given their termination contracts by the Panthers. Despite this move, de-fined by Fletcher as a team saying ‘We don’t want you,’ the first three are expected in camp when it begins Sept. 10.” [Miami Herald, 8/8/93]

21 Voter Registration & History

Stauber Was Registered To Vote In Hermantown, Minnesota

According To Votebuilder, Stauber Was Registered To Vote In Minnesota. [Votebuilder, accessed 1/25/18]

Stauber Voting History

According to Votebuilder, Stauber’s voting history is depicted below:

Stauber’s Voting History Year General Primary Municipal General Special 2016 P P 2014 P P 2013 P 2012 P 2010 P P 2009 P 2008 P P 2007 P 2006 P 2005 P 2004 P P 2002 P P 2001 P P 2000 P 1998 P

[Pete Stauber, VoteBuilder, Accessed 7/14/17]

Key: P - At Poll, E – Early, A – Absentee, M – Mail, Q – Provisional, Y - Vote Method Unknown, D – Democratic Primary, Blank – Did Not Vote

Political Donations

Stauber Personally Contribution $1,100 To Federal Political Candidates

Federal-Level Political Donations Date Candidate (Office Sought) or Committee Party Amount 09/29/08 Republican National Committee R $100.00 08/07/00 Rod Grams For US Senate R $1,000.00 Total: $1,100.00 [FEC, individual contribution search, accessed 1/11/18]

Stauber Personally Contributed $200 To State-Level Political Candidates

State-Level Political Donations Date Candidate (Office Sought) or Committee Party Amount 10/09/10 Emmer, Tom Gov Committee (Governor / Lt. Governor) R $100.00 06/08/10 Emmer, Tom Gov Committee (Governor / Lt. Governor) R $100.00 Total: $200.00 [Minnesota Secretary of State, accessed 1/11/18] 22

Personal Finance

In 2017, Stauber had an estimated net worth of between $771,013 and $1,890,000, not including between $1,315,004 and $5,650,000 in liabilities.

According to Stauber’s federal personal financial disclosures, his 2017 annual unearned income was between $7,504 and $20,400. Stauber also earned $89,762 in salary from the County of St. Louis as a County Commissioner and from the City of Duluth as a police officer. Stauber’s assets totaled between $771,013 and $1,890,000 in value. Stauber reported between $1,315,004 and $5,650,000 in liabilities.

NOTE: For detailed descriptions of Stauber’s personal financial disclosures by year, see Appendix I – Personal Financial Disclosures.

Stauber’s Federal And State Personal Financial Disclosure Summary

NOTE: For detailed descriptions of Stauber’s personal financial disclosures by year, see Appendix I – Personal Financial Disclosures.

Stauber Federal PFD Summary

Stauber Federal PFD Toplines Year Earned Asset Value Unearned Income Transactions Liabilities Income MIN MAX MIN MAX MIN MAX MIN MAX 2018 $89,762 $771,013 $1,890,000 $7,504 $20,400 None None $1,315,004 $5,650,000 [2018 Stauber Public Financial Disclosure Report, filed 8/18/17]

Stauber Minnesota Statements Of Economic Interest Summary

Stauber Minnesota Statements Of Economic Interest Toplines Year Sources Of Business & Securities Real Property Pari-Mutuel Compensation Professional Horse Racing Activities 2018 Duluth Hockey Employee, Rental Duluth Hockey Company 2541 Maple Grove Rd None Company, Owner & Leasing HarborView Homes 5177 Breezy Point Rd Stauber Services MN deferred compensation 5068 W. Arrowhead Rd Properties, Owner RedKing LLC Section 24. Range 15 Roth IRA 3231 Celia St. Stauber Properties Section 24. Range 15. 21 Kirkus St. 2017* None Employee, Real None 2541 Maple Grove Rd, None Estate Duluth 5068 W. Arrowhead Rd, Hermantown 5177 Breezy Point Rd, Duluth Section 24. Range 15, Hermantown 3231 Celia St., Duluth Section 24. Range 15. Hermantown [Stauber Statement of Economic Interest, filed 1/3/18; Stauber Statement of Economic Interest, filed 2/10/17]

*NOTE: Stauber’s statement of economic interest, filed on February 10, 2017, covered 30 days prior to the starting date of his new term in January 2017.

Taxpayer-Funded Salaries

2013 – 2017: Stauber Made $$304,029 In Salary As A County Commissioner And City Councilor

2013 – 2017: Stauber Made $304,029 In Salary As A County Commissioner And City Councilor. [City of Duluth, Stauber Commissioner Salary Record via through Data Practices Request, obtained 11/14/17; ]

Stauber Tax-Payer Funded Salary Year St. Louis County Board Of Commissioners Salary 2017 $41,138.101 2016 $59,432.40 2015 $61,606.472 2014 $57,947.953 2013 $52,844.344 Total: $272,969.26 Year Hermantown City Councilor 2012 $5,025.00 2011 $5,200.00 2010* $4,911.32 2009* $4,651.81 2004 $3,554.88 2003 $3,601.65 2002 $3,273.24 2001 $841.95 Total: $31,059.85 ALL YEARS TOTAL $304,029.11 [Stauber Commissioner Salary Record via Data Practices Request, obtained 11/14/17; City of Heramtown, Stauber Salary Record via Data Parctice Request, obtained 2/1/18]

1. “Year to date – reflects salary paid through September 1, 2017.” [City of Duluth, Stauber Commissioner Salary Record via through Data Practices Request, obtained 11/14/17]

2. “There were 27 pay periods during the 2015 Payroll year, which explains the increase, then decrease in County Commissioner salary from 2015 to 2016. Served as Board Chair in 2015 ($1,000 additional salary).” [City of Duluth, Stauber Commissioner Salary Record via through Data Practices Request, obtained 11/14/17]

3. “Served as Board Vice Chair in 2004 ($500.00 additional salary). [City of Duluth, Stauber Commissioner Salary Record obtained through Data Practices Request, obtained 11/14/17]

4. “Elected term commenced January 7th in accord with Minn. Stat. 204D.02, Subd. 2. The 2013 Payroll year started December 15, 2012, the outgoing District 5 County Commissioner received the 2013 Commissioner salary from December 15, 2012 – January 6, 2013.” [City of Duluth, Stauber Commissioner Salary Record via through Data Practices Request, obtained 11/14/17]

25 Further research is necessary to determine when exactly Stauber was elected to the City Council for a second term, and how.

Political Career

This section provides an overview of Stauber’s political career, from 2000 to 2017.

Significant Findings

 Stauber has served on the St. Louis County Board of Commissioners since 2013.

 Stauber was elected the Board of Commissioners for a four-year term in 2012 and re-elected in 2016.

 Stauber served on the Hermantown City Council from 2001 to 2005 and 2011 to 2013.

Attendance Record

Stauber Voting Attendance Record – St. Louis County Board Of Commissioners Year Number Of Meetings* Missed Meetings Date(s) Percent 2017 33 3 10/24/17 0.09% 6/27/17 4/4/17 2016 34 1 2/16/16 0.03%

2015 34 3 7/7/15 0.08% 6/23/15 5/26/15 2014 33 2 4/8/14 0.06% 2/25/14

2013 33 1 3/12/13 0.03%

[St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, 2017 Resolutions, accessed 1/12/18; St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, Resolutions for Prior Years, accessed 1/12/18]

*Only includes County Board minutes. Excludes Committee of the Whole Minutes and committee minutes.

Committees

Note: Committees and subcommittees listed in italics represent chairmanships.

Stauber St. Louis County Board Of Commissioners Years Committees Position 2018 Finance & Budget Committee Chair Duluth International Airport Joint Zoning Board (Two-Year Term) Representative Executive ATV Permit Committee Representative AMC District I Policy Transportation & Infrastructure Representative Arrowhead Regional Corrections Executive Board Alternate Representative

26 Arrowhead Regional Development Commission (ARDC) Metropolitan Alternate Representative Interstate Council Camp Esquagama Advisory Board Executive Committee Alternate Representative Community Health Services Board Alternate Representative Minnesota Inter-County Association (MICA) Alternate Representative 911 Emergency System User Board Alternate Representative 2017 Public Works & Transportation Committee Chair Arrowhead Regional Corrections Executive Board Representative AMC District I Policy Transportation & Infrastructure Representative Executive ATV Permit Committee Representative Minnesota Inter-County Association (MICA) Representative 911 Emergency System User Board Representative Seaway Port Authority Representative ARDC Metropolitan Interstate Council Alternate Representative Camp Esquagama Advisory Board Executive Committee Alternate Representative Community Health Services Board Alternate Representative 2016 Public Works & Transportation Committee Chair Arrowhead Regional Corrections Executive Board Representative AMC District I Policy Transportation & Infrastructure Representative Executive ATV Permit Committee Representative 911 Emergency System User Board Representative Duluth International Airport Joint Zoning Board (Two-Year Term) Representative Camp Esquagama Advisory Board Executive Committee Representative Northeast Regional Radio Board Representative ARDC Metropolitan Interstate Council Alternate Representative Seaway Port Authority Alternate Representative 2015 St. Louis County Board of Commissioners Chair of the Board Arrowhead Regional Corrections Executive Board Representative AMC District I Public Safety Committee Representative Camp Esquagama Advisory Board Executive Committee Representative 911 Emergency System User Board Representative Public Health & Human Services Advisory Committee Representative Northeast Regional Radio Board Alternate Representative 2014 St. Louis County Board of Commissioners Vice Chair of the Board Health & Human Services Committee Chair Arrowhead Regional Corrections Executive Board Representative AMC District I Public Safety Committee Representative 911 Emergency System User Board Representative Duluth International Airport Joint Zoning Board (Two-Year Term) Representative Arrowhead Economic Opportunity Agency (Five-Year Term) Representative County Election Canvassing Board Representative Arrowhead Healthy Alliance Representative St. Louis County Promotional Bureau Advisory Board Representative Promotion Bureau Advisory Board Representative Public Health & Human Services Advisory Committee Representative 2013 Health & Human Services Committee Chair Arrowhead Economic Opportunity Agency (AOEA) Representative Arrowhead Health Alliance Representative North Shore Management Board Representative Duluth/St. Louis County Joint Airport Zoning Board Representative Promotional Bureau Representative Public Health & Human Services Advisory Committee Representative Septic Committee Representative Solid Waste Advisory Committee Representative Arrowhead Regional Corrections (ARC) Board Alternate Representative Northeast Radio Board Alternate Representative

27 [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, Resolutions 18-01 – 18-31, 1/2/18; St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 1/3/17; St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 1/5/16; St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 1/6/15; St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 1/7/14; St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 1/8/13]

Campaigns

Election History

Pete Stauber Electoral History Year Office Candidates Results Stauber Margin St. Louis County Commissioner District 5 Pete Stauber 78.00% 2016 +57.0% General Election Todd Youngberg 21.61% St. Louis County Commissioner District 5 Pete Stauber 54.15% 2012 +8.55% General Election Todd Youngberg 45.60% Pete Stauber 42.04% 2010 Hermantown City Council General Election Brad Tafs 31.17% +16.0% (Elect Two) Rhonda Grussendorf 26.03% Hermantown City Council General Election 2000 (Elect Two) [Minnesota Secretary of State, 2016 Election Results, accessed 7/18/17; Minnesota Secretary of State, 2012 Election Results, accessed 7/18/17; Minnesota Secretary of State, 2010 Election Results, accessed 7/18/17]

*The DCCC is unable to confirm when Stauber began to serve his second term on the Hermantown City Council. Stauber was elected to the Hermantown City Council in 2010, but Stauber received a salary from the City of Hermantown in 2009 and 2010, according to salary records provided by the City of Hermantown. This could indicate he was elected in 2008, however he was NOT on the 2008 ballot. Further research is necessary to determine when exactly Stauber was elected to the City Council for a second term, and how.

NOTE: Further research necessary to obtain official 2000 election results from the Minnesota Secretary of State.

2018 Congressional Campaign

July 2017: Stauber Launched His Bid For Minnesota’s 8th Congressional District

July 2017: Stauber Announced His Run For Minnesota’s 8th Congressional District. “After back-to-back multi-million dollar races, there could be a change of faces in Minnesota’s 8th Congressional District. St. Louis County Commissioner Pete Stauber announced Monday that he’ll run as a Republican to unseat Democratic Rep. Rick Nolan in the northeastern Minnesota district. A longtime police officer in Duluth with a well-known name in the area, Stauber could pick up critical votes in the region’s urban core.” [Associated Press, 7/10/17]

Stauber Said He Was Running For Congress Because He Could “No Longer Sit Back And Watch As Washington Fails To Make Common Sense Legislation”

Stauber Said He Was Running Because He Could “No Longer Sit Back And Watch As Washington Fails To Make Common Sense Legislation.” “‘For many years I have watched Washington, D.C., from the perspective of a Christian, husband, father, small business owner, law enforcement officer, labor union president, city councilor and county commissioner,’ said Stauber, 51, who also briefly played professional hockey. ‘I can no longer sit back and watch as Washington fails to make common sense legislation. That is why, after careful consideration and prayer, I am today announcing my candidacy.’” [The Journal, 10/21/17]

28 Stauber Said He Would Not Let His Congressional Campaign “Interfere” With His Responsibilities As County Commissioner

Stauber Said He Would Remain An “Active County Commissioner” And Not Let His Congressional Campaign “Interfere” With His “Responsibilities” To St. Louis County. “Stauber is retiring soon from the Duluth Police Department, for which he’s served for 22 years, to devote his time to being a county commissioner and running for office. ‘We’re going to work very hard during this campaign, visiting people and businesses all across the district,’ he said. ‘But I will also remain an active county commissioner. I won’t let this campaign interfere with my responsibilities to the people of St. Louis County.’” [The Journal, 10/21/17]

The National Republican Campaign Committee (NRCC) Called Stauber One Of Their “Strongest Recruits In The Country”

The National Republcian Campaign Committee (NRCC) Called Stauber “One Of The Strongest Recruits In The Country,” After Rep. Rick Nolan (MN-08) Announced His Retirment. “NRCC Communications Director Matt Gorman released the following statement regarding MN-08 Congressman Rick Nolan’s retirement: ‘Rick Nolan, too liberal and out of step with his deep red district, saved us the trouble of defeating him this fall. We currently have one of the strongest recruits in the country, Pete Stauber, in the race who’s garnering strong local support,’ said NRCC Communications Director Matt Gorman. ‘This seat was already one of our best pickup opportunities and we look forward to turning this seat Republican in November.’” [NRCC, press release, 2/9/18]

Roll Call: Stauber Was A “Top GOP Recruit.” “Stauber is a top GOP recruit for a rural district that Republicans are hoping to pick up. A former professional hockey player with the Detroit Red Wings operation, he is currently a lieutenant in the Duluth Police Department and has been with the force for 23 years. He has also served two terms as Hermantown City Councilor.” [Roll Call, 7/10/17]

HEADLINE: “Stauber Recognized By National Republicans.” [Duluth News Tribune, 10/26/17]

Oct. 2017: Duluth News Tribune: The National Republican Campaign Committee Listed Stauber As An “On The Radar” Candidate. “Duluth’s Pete Stauber appears to be cementing his profile as a Republican to be reckoned with on the national stage -- making the National Republican Congressional Committee’s list of ‘On the Radar’ candidates, announced Thursday. A onetime Duluth police commander and current St. Louis County commissioner, Stauber is seeking the party’s 8th Congressional District endorsement for the 2018 midterm election. He was one of 31 candidates nationwide to earn the distinction -- something the NRCC has been doing for the past four election cycles.” [Duluth News Tribune, 10/26/17]

The NRCC Named Stauber As An “On The Radar Candidate.” “Today the National Republican Congressional Committee’s Young Guns program announced the first round of “On the Radar” candidates. Officially an NRCC effort for the past four election cycles, the program requires these candidates to hit specific goals throughout the cycle to ensure their campaigns remain competitive, well-funded and communicative within their districts. “On the Radar” is the first of three levels in the Young Guns program. ‘These 31 candidates are formidable competitors against the liberal agenda of Nancy Pelosi and the left,’ said NRCC Chairman Steve Stivers. ‘We look forward to working with these candidates to grow our Republican majority and enact policies that help hard working Americans.’ […] MN-08: Pete Stauber[.]” [NRCC, 10/26/17]

The Minnesota State Republican Party Endorsed Stauber Before The State Party Convention

Jan. 2018: Duluth News Tribune: The Minnesota State Republican Party Endorsed Stauber Before The State Party Convention. “Stauber, of Hermantown, has already earned the enthusiastic support of the state GOP in advance of the Republican party's 8th District convention June 1-2 at the Duluth Entertainment Convention Center.” [Duluth News Tribune, 1/16/18]

29 The Minnesota State GOP Convention Was Scheduled For June 2018. “Minnesota Republicans have scheduled their convention for the 2018 election. State party chairwoman Jennifer Carnahan announced Wednesday that Republicans will gather June 1-2, 2018 to endorse statewide candidates. The convention will be held in Duluth.” [WCCO CBS Minnesota, 9/6/17]

The Minnesota State GOP Listed Stauber As Their Candidate For MN-08. [MNGOP, Candidates, accessed 3/12/18]

Dec. 2017: Minnesota State GOP Chair Jennifer Carnahan “Kicked Off” Stauber’s Campaign Office Opening In Hermantown, Minnesota. “Stauber may not have wanted to talk about mining, but he had an Iron Range mayor, Eveleth’s Robert Vlaisavljevich, in an audience which featured roughly 50 invited supporters. Added clout came in the form of the state chair of the GOP, Jennifer Carnahan, who kicked off the festivities by calling on volunteers to ‘turn CD-8 red,’ and saying she knew from the moment she met Stauber and his wife Jodi that he was the one.” [Duluth News Tribune, 12/8/17]

Carnahan: “We Have The Right Candidate.” “Added clout came in the form of the state chair of the GOP, Jennifer Carnahan, who kicked off the festivities by calling on volunteers to ‘turn CD-8 red,’ and saying she knew from the moment she met Stauber and his wife Jodi that he was the one. ‘We have the right candidate," she said. ‘His resume? What’s not to be impressed.’” [Duluth News Tribune, 12/8/17]

Stewart Mills, The Republican Nominee For Minnesota’s 8th Congressional District In 2014 And 2016, Decided Not To Run Again In 2018, Which Left The Republican Primary Field Open For Stauber

Mesabi Daily News: Stewart Mills, The Republican Nominee For Minnesota’s 8th Congressional District In 2014 And 2016, Decided Not To Run Again In 2018, Which Left The Field Open For Stauber. “Ending speculation, Stewart Mills has opted out of running for the Republican nod in the 8th Congressional District, leaving Pete Stauber without a clear primary opponent. […] Mills narrowly lost to Nolan in 2014 by 2.4 percent and again in 2016 by 0.6 percent, just missing the cutoff for a mandatory recount. Democrats across the state saw momentum sapped from the races, especially in rural districts like the 8th. But the GOP faces some uncertainty in 2018 as President Donald Trump’s popularity has hovered in the 30 percent range, and lawmakers have failed to pass a long-promised health care overhaul.” [Mesabi Daily News, 11/1/17]

2016 County Board Of Commissioner Election

Stauber Beat Opponent Todd Youngberg With 78 Percent Of The Vote

Stauber Beat Opponent Todd Youngberg For A Second Term As The 5th District’s County Board Commissioner With 78 Percent Of The Vote. “Incumbent Pete Stauber of Hermantown also easily won his second term by easily defeating Todd Youngberg of Proctor for the 5th county board district that covers Hermantown, Proctor, Rice Lake and the townships that ring Duluth. Stauber took 78 percent of the vote to Youngberg’s 21 percent.” [Duluth News-Tribune, 11/9/16; Minnesota Secretary of State, 2016 Election Results, accessed 7/18/17]

Stauber Said Public Safety, Social Services, And Infrastructure Were The Top Priorities For The County Board

Stauber Said Social Services, Drug Abuse, And Infrastructure Were At The Top Of The Issues For The Board. “Stauber said the top three issues for the board during the next four years will remain public safety, social services and roads and bridges. Right now, social services has rocketed to the top of the priority list. Stauber said the county has to find new ways to prevent people from entering the social service system, including individuals and families who falter because of drug and alcohol abuse or mental health crises.” [Duluth News-Tribune, 10/16/16]

30 Todd Youngberg, Stauber’s Opponent, Said He Ran For The Board Of Commissioners Because He Felt The County Unjustly Seized His Private Property

Duluth News-Tribune: Todd Youngberg, Stauber’s Opponent, Said He Ran For The Board Of Commissioners Because He Felt The County Unjustly Seized His Private Property. “[Todd] Youngberg feels not just slighted by county commissioners but legally harmed, saying the county was complicit in a taking of his private property along a railroad line near Proctor. He says historic surveys show the land was his. The county later said it wasn’t, that the old survey was wrong and that the land had already been condemned and transferred. Youngberg says no one has been willing to help him. ‘I’m upset with how they treat their constituents and people and how they treated me, so that’s why I’m running. ... I want to be a voice for the people so they (the county) can’t do this to anybody else,’ he said.” [Duluth News-Tribune, 10/17/16]

2016: The Duluth News Tribune Endorsed Stauber For County Commissioner

2016: EDITORIAL: The Duluth News Tribune Endorsed Stauber For A Second Term On The St. Louis County Board Of Commissioners. “A generous public servant, Stauber was chairman of the County Board in 2015. He previously served eight productive years on the Hermantown City Council and has been on the advisory board for the Northeast Regional Corrections Center; on the board for Udac, a Duluth nonprofit that helps people with disabilities; and a coordinator for Beyond the Yellow Ribbon, which assists those returning from active overseas military duty. ‘I think I’ve done a real good job. I’ve learned a lot, and it has been a pleasure to sit on the County Board and to represent close to 20,000 people,’ Stauber said. ‘The phone calls I get, some of them not so nice, but at least we have those discussions; I tell people they can call me 24/7. I work nights. I’m a father of four. I’m up all the time. … I ask for the opportunity to serve another four years.’ It’s an opportunity Stauber has earned and voters can grant Nov. 8.” [Duluth News Tribune, Editorial, 10/5/16]

EDITORIAL: The Duluth News Tribune Praised Stauber For Putting “Abuses Of Heroin, Meth And Other Substances” As A “High Priority.” “As chairman of the Public Works and Transportation Committee, St. Louis County Commissioner Pete Stauber, when asked at a News Tribune-sponsored candidate forum last month what the biggest issue was facing the county, wanted to say it was maintaining county roads and bridges. But he just couldn’t bring himself to do it. As pressing as the need for ongoing public infrastructure repair is, Stauber knows that, right now in St. Louis County, problems stemming from unmet mental health challenges and from the abuses of heroin, meth and other substances are a higher priority. The highest even. He sees the problems, the lives being ripped apart, on a regular basis at his other job as a Duluth police officer.” [Duluth News Tribune, Editorial, 10/5/16]

2016: The Iron Range Building & Construction Trades And The Duluth Building & Construction Trades Endorsed Stauber For County Commissioner

2016: Duluth News-Tribune: Stauber Was Reportedly Endorsed By The Iron Range Building And Construction Trades, The Duluth Building And Construction Trades Council, And The Northeast Labor Council. “Pete Stauber -- Age: 50 -- Occupation: Duluth police officer -- Education: Graduate of Denfeld High School; BA degree in criminal justice with concentration in law enforcement, from Lake Superior State University in Sault Ste Marie, Mich. -- Elected/civic experience: Elected to two terms on the Hermantown City Council; elected 2012 to the St. Louis County Board. -- Endorsements: Iron Range Building and Construction Trades, the Duluth Building and Construction Trades Council and the Northeast Labor Council. -- Family: Wife, Jodi; four children.” [Duluth News-Tribune, 10/17/16]

Stauber Represented Hermantown, Proctor And Rice Lake, Brevator, Canosia, Duluth, Gnesen, Lakewood, Midway, And Solway Townships As Commissioner For The 5th District

The Journal: Stauber Represented Hermantown, Proctor And Rice Lake, As Well As Brevator, Canosia, Duluth, Gnesen, Lakewood, Midway, And Solway Townships As County Commissioner. “Stauber, elected to the St. Louis County board in 2012, represents its fifth district, covering the cities of Hermantown, Proctor and Rice

31 Lake, as well as the townships of Brevator, Canosia, Duluth, Gnesen, Lakewood, Midway and Solway. He was reelected in 2016 to a 4-year term that expires in January 2021.” [The Journal, 10/21/17]

2012 County Board Of Commissioners Election

Stauber Defeated 16-Year Incumbent Peg Sweeney With 54 Percent Of The Vote

Nov. 2012: Duluth News Tribune: Stauber Beat Incumbent Peg Sweeney For The 5th District St. Louis County Board Seat With 54 Percent Of The Vote. “Duluth police officer and conservative activist Pete Stauber toppled 16-year incumbent Commissioner Peg Sweeney on Tuesday in the St. Louis County Board’s 5th District, which covers Duluth’s suburbs and neighboring townships. Stauber, 46, a Hermantown city councilor, garnered 8,627 votes (54 percent) to 7,264 votes (46 percent) for Sweeney, 68, in the district that includes Hermantown, Proctor and townships that adjoin Duluth. The outcome tilts the County Board’s power base back to conservatives after the board leaned liberal for the past two years.” [Duluth News Tribune, 11/7/12]

Duluth News Tribune: Sweeney Was A 16-Year Incumbent. “Cut from the district were several precincts in West Duluth that usually gave Sweeney, of Proctor, a wide margin of victory in her 16-year run on the board. And that could give conservative challenger Pete Stauber of Hermantown a chance to topple the incumbent.” [Duluth News Tribune, 10/29/12]

Stauber’s Win Marked The First All-Male Board Of Commissioners In Four Decades

2013: Duluth News Tribune: No Women Served On The St. Louis County Board Of Commissioners For The First Time In Four Decades. “A new St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, with no women serving for the first time in four decades and a more conservative tilt than in recent years, will reorganize today in its first meeting of 2013. The seven-member board will have a new chairman -- Chris Dahlberg, who represents western Duluth -- and one new member, Pete Stauber, who represents Hermantown, Proctor and townships surrounding Duluth.” [Duluth News Tribune, 1/8/13]

Duluth News Tribune: Redrawn Fifth District Lines “Tilted” The District “More Conservative” In Stauber’s Favor

Duluth News Tribune: The Fifth District For St. Louis County’s Board Lines Were Redrawn To Reflect A Fast Growing Population, Which Gave Stauber “A Chance To Topple” Incumbent Commissioner Peg Sweeney. “Peg Sweeney calls District 5 on the St. Louis County Board the ‘Banana Belt’ -- the banana-shaped band of cities and townships that surround Duluth. It’s the fastest-growing area in the county, which means the district shrank in geographical size this year when political boundaries were redrawn to account for U.S. Census population shifts. Cut from the district were several precincts in West Duluth that usually gave Sweeney, of Proctor, a wide margin of victory in her 16-year run on the board. And that could give conservative challenger Pete Stauber of Hermantown a chance to topple the incumbent.” [Duluth News-Tribune, 10/29/12]

Duluth News-Tribune: The Redrawn District Lines “Tilted” The District “More Conservative.” “Stauber waged an active campaign against the popular incumbent in a district that tilted more conservative after lines were redrawn to drop some Duluth precincts and pick up more in Hermantown. Stauber said Sweeney had lost touch with much of her district, and he pressed hard on Sweeney’s vote last December against County Board support for copper mining in the region. Sweeney said the project hadn’t yet been given approval by regulators; Stauber said she should have offered unequivocal support for the new kind of mining and the promise of jobs.” [Duluth News- Tribune, 11/7/12]

Stauber Criticized Sweeney Over Her Lack Of Support For Copper Mining

Stauber Criticized Sweeney Over Her Lack Of Support For Copper Mining. “Stauber said Sweeney had lost touch with much of her district, and he pressed hard on Sweeney’s vote last December against County Board 32 support for copper mining in the region. Sweeney said the project hadn’t yet been given approval by regulators; Stauber said she should have offered unequivocal support for the new kind of mining and the promise of jobs.” [Duluth News Tribune, 11/7/12]

Sweeney Criticized Stauber For Planning To Keep His Position At The Duluth Police Department While Serving On Board Of Commissioners

Sweeney Criticized Stauber For Planning To Have Two Public Positions. “Sweeney has criticized Stauber’s plan to keep his full-time job on the Duluth Police Department and be a full-time county commissioner, noting he would serve two public bodies and draw two public paychecks. The County Board position pays $55,573 a year.” [Duluth News-Tribune, 10/29/12]

Stauber Said He Would Be An Advocate For “Seniors” And Individuals With Disabilities, Citing His Son’s Down Syndrome

Duluth News-Tribune: Stauber Said He Would Be An Advocate For “Seniors” And “Our Most Vulnerable” On The County Board, Citing His Son’s Down Syndrome. “Stauber, in addition to vowing to be a budget hawk and voting to promote local business and jobs, also said he will watch out for those who need the county’s and taxpayer’s help. He noted he and his wife have a son with Down syndrome. ‘Our seniors and most vulnerable will not have a greater advocate than me on the board,’ he said.” [Duluth News-Tribune, 10/29/12]

2012: The Duluth News Tribune Endorsed Stauber For County Commissioner

2012: EDITORIAL: The Duluth News Tribune Endorsed Stauber For The 5th District St. Louis County Board Seat. “The County Board voted in favor of this new brand of mining and the economic windfall it promises -- but hardly overwhelmingly at 4-3. In the minority was Stauber’s representative, Commissioner Peg Sweeney. Last week at a candidate forum in Duluth, Sweeney insisted she supports mining and ‘our being able to do it and do it right.’ But no mining company had asked the board for a resolution of support, she said. So a vote was ‘jumping the gun.’ Waiting to be asked to weigh in is hardly being a leader on any issue, especially an issue with the region- altering potential of precious-metals mining. Stauber is ready to be a proactive, effective, common-sense leader for residents of his District 5. He deserves voters’ support on Nov. 6.” [Duluth News Tribune, Editorial, 9/27/12]

EDITORIAL: The Duluth News Tribune Said Stauber Would Bring “An Aggressive, No-Nonsense Approach To Economic Development” To The St. Louis County Board. “Stauber would bring to the County Board experience, including eight years of effective and productive service on the Hermantown City Council; a strong, positive reputation after working as a community police officer and now as a lieutenant in the Duluth Police Department; and an aggressive, no-nonsense approach to economic development, service delivery, budgeting and other County Board responsibilities.” [Duluth News Tribune, Editorial, 9/27/12]

2012: The St. Louis County Deputy Sheriff’s Association Endorsed Stauber

2012: Duluth News-Tribune: Stauber Was Endorsed By The St. Louis County Deputy Sheriff’s Association And The Iron Range Building And Trades. “Stauber is a 1984 graduate of Duluth Denfeld and has a bachelor’s in criminal justice and a minor in fire science from Lake Superior State University. He was endorsed by the St. Louis County Deputy Sheriff’s Association and the Iron Range Building and Trades. He has served on the Hermantown City Council, the Hermantown Board of Appeals and Adjustment, Duluth Airport Authority, coordinator of Duluth ‘Beyond the Yellow Ribbon’ committee, advisory member to the Northeast Regional Corrections Center, board member of UDAC, volunteer coach for Hermantown Hockey, ‘Hawk Respect’ committee.” [Duluth News-Tribune, 11/7/12]

2004: Stauber Did Not Run For Re-Election After His First Term On The Hermantown City Council, Citing Family Obligations

33 Stauber Did Not Run For Re-Election After His First Term On The Hermantown City Council, Citing Family Obligations. “That family-first mentality led Pete to decide to get out of politics - at least for now. When his four-year term expires in a couple of months, he’ll step down to spend more time with his wife and three young sons. ‘I did not file for re-election because of my family,’ Pete said. ‘My family is my No. 1 priority.’” [Associated Press, 11/3/04]

NOTE: 2000 Hermantown City Council election results were not readily available.

Legislative Timeline

2001 – 2005; 2011 – Present: Stauber Has Served As An Elected Official For 13 Years And Appeared On The Ballot Four Times

As Of January 2018, Stauber Had Served As An Elected Official For 13 Years And Appeared On The Ballot Four Times. As of January 2018, Stauber has served as an elected official for 12 years. Stauber served on the Hermantown City Council from 2001 to 2005, and again from 2009 to 2013. In 2012, Stauber was elected to the St. Louis County Board of Commissioners for a four-year term. He was re-elected in 2016. [Minnesota Secretary of State, 2016 Election Results, accessed 7/18/17; Minnesota Secretary of State, 2012 Election Results, accessed 7/18/17; Minnesota Secretary of State, 2010 Election Results, accessed 7/18/17]

*The DCCC is unable to confirm that Stauber served on the Hermantown City Council in 2009 and 2010. Stauber was not on the 2008 ballot for Hermantown City Council, but according to the salary records provided by the City of Hermantown, Stauber was paid by the city in 2009 and 2010. However, Stauber was elected to the Hermantown City Council in 2010, Further research is necessary to determine when exactly Stauber was elected to the City Council for a second term, and how.

2013 – Present: Stauber Served On The St. Louis County Board Of Commissioners For Two Terms

As Of January 2018, Stauber Was Completing His Second Consecutive Term On The St. Louis County Board Of Commissioners. Stauber was elected to the St. Louis County Board of Commissioners for a four-year term in 2012. Stauber was re-elected in 2016. [Minnesota Secretary of State, 2016 Election Results, accessed 7/18/17; Minnesota Secretary of State, 2012 Election Results, accessed 7/18/17]

2010: Stauber Was Elected To The Hermantown City Council For A Second, Nonconsecutive Term

2010: Stauber Was Elected To The Hermantown City Council With 42 Percent Of The Vote. [Minnesota Secretary of State, 2010 Election Results, accessed 7/18/17]

Stauber Did Not Run For Re-Election After His First Term On The Hermantown City Council, Citing Family Obligations. “That family-first mentality led Pete to decide to get out of politics - at least for now. When his four-year term expires in a couple of months, he’ll step down to spend more time with his wife and three young sons. ‘I did not file for re-election because of my family,’ Pete said. ‘My family is my No. 1 priority.’” [Associated Press, 11/3/04]

*The DCCC is unable to confirm when Stauber began to serve his second term on the Hermantown City Council. Stauber was elected to the Hermantown City Council in 2010, but Stauber received a salary from the City of Hermantown in 2009 and 2010, according to salary records provided by the City of Hermantown. This could 34 indicate he was elected in 2008, however he was NOT on the 2008 ballot. Further research is necessary to determine when exactly Stauber was elected to the City Council for a second term, and how.

2001 – 2005: Stauber Served On The Hermantown City Council

NOTE: Further research necessary to obtain official 2000 election results from the Minnesota Secretary of State.

Partisanism

Stauber Was A Tea Party Organizer And “Conservative Activist”

Duluth News-Tribune: Stauber Was A Tea Party Organizer And A “Conservative Activist.” “‘People know who I am. They know I vote my conscience,’ Sweeney said. But those are votes that make Stauber, 46, a Tea Party organizer and conservative activist, bristle. ‘I promise a stark difference in leadership,’ Stauber said, calling the vote on the copper mining issue last December the deciding factor in his decision to run.” [Duluth News-Tribune, 10/29/12]

2009: Duluth News Tribune: Stauber Spoke At A Tea Party Protest Rally In Duluth. “THE MANTRA OF EXCESSIVE -- and uncontrolled -- government spending was the rallying chant for an estimated 700 protesters at a modern-day tea party today on the shores of the Duluth Harbor. With the 1773 Boston Tea Party that railed against taxation without representation serving as inspiration, about 12 speakers criticized recent federal stimulus spending and bailouts of corporations. Duluth was one of about 16 ‘tea parties’ held in Minnesota cities and as many as 600 nationwide. The speakers included Bob Hansen, Pete Stauber, Russ Stewart, Jenny Townsend, Brad Bennett, Matt Mead, Carinda Horton, Scott Drewlo, Taylor Trapp, Jake Loesch, Reagan Hall, Chuck Horton and Tom Wright.” [Duluth News Tribune, 4/15/09]

2010: Duluth News Tribune: Stauber Said “Progressive Thinking” Was “Socialism” During A Tea Party Rally In Duluth. “Patriots dressed from 1776 led the way Thursday afternoon followed by bagpipes and the Duluth VFW Honor Guard carrying the colors, and the 2010 Duluth Tea Party rolled into Bayfront Festival Park. Dozens of U.S. flags snapped stiffly as hundreds of people gathered on a warm, windy day -- the day federal taxes were due -- protesting a government they say is spending and taxing out of control. About 800 to 1,000 people participated, according to News Tribune and organizer estimates. ‘These are the winds of change ... and yours are the feet that are going to move that change,’ said Pete Stauber, a Duluth businessman and Tea Party activist, bashing the Obama administration and Congress for being far to the left of mainstream America. ‘Liberal thinking, progressive thinking is socialism.’” [Duluth News Tribune, 4/16/10]

Social Media Information

Pete Stauber Social Media Platforms Platform Page Information Campaign Website Pete Stauber for Congress Twitter (Campaign) @PeteStauber Facebook Pete Stauber for Congress

35 Relationships

Significant Findings

 Stauber introduced Vice President Mike Pence at a campaign rally in Duluth in November 2016.

 Stauber said he would vote for Paul Ryan as Speaker of the House after initially stating Ryan “might not even run for Speaker.”

 Stauber said he thought former Senator Al Franken “did the right thing” by resigning from Congress due to sexual harassment allegations.

 Stauber said sexual harassment allegations against Franken were “crystal clear” compared to Donald Trump or Roy Moore.

Al Franken

Stauber Said He Thought Franken “Did The Right Thing” By Resigning From Congress Due To Sexual Harassment Allegations

Dec. 2017: Stauber Said He Thought Franken “Did The Right Thing” And “Put The Country First” By Resigning From Congress Due To Sexual Harassment Allegations

Dec. 2017: Stauber Said He Thought Franken “Did The Right Thing” And “Put The Country First” By Resigning From Congress Due To Sexual Harassment Allegations. “The undisputed Republican candidate to represent the 8th Congressional District, Stauber appeared confident as he responded to the news of the day. ‘I think he did the right thing,’ Stauber said. "Sen. Franken put the country first. I really truly believe he made the right decision by stepping down.’” [Duluth News Tribune, 12/8/17]

Dec. 2017: Stauber Opened His Campaign Office In Hermantown The Day Former Senator Al Franken Resigned Based On Sexual Harassment Accusations. “Pete Stauber couldn’t have known he’d picked a historic day politically in the state of Minnesota to open his campaign headquarters in Hermantown. News of the Sen. Al Franken resignation hung just two hours old as Stauber christened his campaign office on Thursday. The undisputed Republican candidate to represent the 8th Congressional District, Stauber appeared confident as he responded to the news of the day.” [Duluth News Tribune, 12/8/17]

Dec. 2017: After Sen. Al Franken Announced His Intention To Resign, Stauber Called On Sen. Al Franken To Step Down Immediately From The Senate Based On Sexual Harassment Allegations

Dec. 2017: After Sen. Al Franken Announced His Intention To Resign, Stauber Called On Sen. Al Franken To Step Down Immediately From The Senate Based On Sexual Harassment Allegations. “Veteran police officer and Minnesota congressional candidate Pete Stauber says the allegations against Sen. Al Franken (D., Minn.) amount to ‘a clear pattern’ of ‘sexual assault’ and called on the embattled Democrat to step down immediately. Franken announced on Thursday that he intends to resign from the Senate in the coming weeks amid a handful of allegations that he groped and kissed women without their permission. Stauber, who is running for the Republican nomination in Minnesota ‘s eighth district, said the announcement did not go far enough. [Washington Free Beacon, 12/7/17]

Stauber On Allegations Against Franken: “This Was Sexual Violence Against Women And That Isn’t To Be Tolerated.” “‘For him to stay in the Senate is a distraction. His credibility is tarnished,’ Stauber said. ‘This 36 was sexual violence against women and that isn’t to be tolerated.’ Stauber, who served for 23 years as a police officer, said Franken’s alleged behavior amounted to sexual assault from a law enforcement perspective. ‘From all the information I’ve seen, this was sexual assault. There’s a clear pattern, he said. ‘We would call that behavior that of a sexual predator and I’m sure there are a lot more.’” [Washington Free Beacon, 12/7/17]

Stauber: “I Am Proud Of These Victims For Coming Forward. It Takes A Strong Person To Stand Up For Their Rights And Come Out To Speak Publicly.” “Stauber said Franken should accelerate his departure and praised his accusers for coming forward. ‘I am proud of these victims for coming forward. It takes a strong person to stand up for their rights and come out to speak publicly,’ he said. ‘What Franken did was unconscionable, uncalled for and many, many Minnesotans are disappointed.’” [Washington Free Beacon, 12/7/17]

Stauber Said Sexual Harassment Allegations Against Franken Were “Crystal Clear” Compared To Donald Trump And Roy Moore

Stauber Said The Sexual Harassment Allegations, In Contrast To Trump And Moore, Were “Crystal Clear.” “Asked if other politicians, namely Alabama Senate candidate Roy Moore or President Donald Trump, deserved consequences for allegations against them, Stauber said, ‘It depends.’ ‘With Sen. Franken, it’s clear,’ Stauber said. ‘You saw the picture I did. That was a sexual assault on a woman -- crystal clear -- and more and more are coming out. I just think that he did the right thing.’” [Duluth News Tribune, 12/8/17]

Mike Pence

Nov. 2016: Stauber Introduced Vice President Mike Pence At A Campaign Rally At Duluth International Airport

Nov. 2016: Stauber Introduced Vice President Mike Pence At A Campaign Rally At Duluth International Airport. “Republican vice presidential nominee Mike Pence rallied supporters at the Duluth International Airport on Monday to turn out the vote for his boss on Election Day, and then implored party regulars who might have wavered to ‘come home’ to the party’s ticket and Donald Trump. […] Pence was introduced by Stewart Mills, Republican candidate for Minnesota’s 8th Congressional District, and by St. Louis County Commissioner Pete Stauber of Hermantown.” [Duluth News Tribune, 11/7/16]

Paul Ryan

Aug. 2017: Stauber Said He Would Vote For Paul Ryan As Speaker Of The House After Initially Stating Ryan “Might Not Even Run For Speaker”

Aug. 2017: When Asked If He Planned To Vote Against Paul Ryan Continuing His Speakership, Stauber Said, “He Might Not Even Run For Speaker.” “‘Do you plan to vote against Paul D. Ryan continuing his speakership?’ It was an easy-sounding question, asked at the end of a friendly Republican candidate forum at Minnesota’s state fair. To the pleasant surprise of Democrats, four of five Republicans seeking to flip House seats next year declined to sup-port the speaker of the House, offering instead criticisms of Paul D. Ryan’s leadership. ‘I think he’s going in the wrong direction,’ said state Rep. Tim Miller. ‘I would prefer someone else,’ said commercial pilot Dave Hughes. ‘We’ll see who runs for speaker,’ said businessman Jim Hagedorn. ‘He might not even run for speaker,’ said St. Louis County Commissioner Pete Stauber.” [Washington Post, blog, 8/30/17]

Stauber Said He “Hope[d]” Paul Ryan Changed. “Stauber, who has no primary challenger as he seeks to defeat Rep. Rick Nolan (D-Minn.), was just as lukewarm about Ryan. ‘When I’m in Congress, I’ll let you know, because people can change their views, change their ways,’ he said. ‘People have the ability to change, and I hope he does.’” [Washington Post, blog, 8/30/17]

37 Stauber Clarified His Statements To The Washington Post And Said He Would Back Ryan For Speaker. “In a statement to the Washington Post, Stauber clarified that he favored Ryan’s agenda, but was irritated by the slow progress in Washington. ‘When I talk to Minnesotans, they care most about a tax reform plan that creates jobs, stopping rising premium hikes under Obamacare and making sure we keep our homeland secure,’ said Stauber. ‘House Republicans are following through on their promises and passing legislation only to see it stalled in the Senate. I respect Speaker Ryan and the job he’s done. While Speaker Ryan has not said whether he would run for Speaker in the 216th Congress, if he were to run, I would back him for Speaker. The one person I won’t vote for Speaker is Nancy Pelosi and I won’t ask Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren to come to my district.’” [Washington Post, blog, 8/30/17]

38 Donald Trump

Significant Findings

 Asked if Trump “deserved consequences” for sexual harassment allegations, Stauber said “it depends” and that allegations against former Senator Al Franken were “crystal clear.”

 Stauber said Trump won Minnesota’s 8th Congressional District in the 2016 presidential election because he pledged to protect mining jobs.

 Stauber reportedly “spoke out in support” of Trump during an introduction speech for Mike Pence at a November 2016 campaign rally.

2016 Presidential Election

August 2017: Stauber Reportedly Said Trump Won Minnesota’s 8th District Because He Pledged To “Protect Middle-Class Jobs In The Iron Range And Support Mining”

Aug. 2017: FOX News: Stauber Said That Trump Won Minnesota’s 8th Congressional District Because He Said He Would “Protect Middle-Class Jobs In The Iron Range And Support Mining.” “PETER DOOCY, FOX NEWS CORRESPONDENT: Beneath Minnesota’s eighth congressional district lay the mines that produce 75 percent of this country’s iron ore and on the surface of the iron range a 2018 a congressional contest is unfolding that could serve as a test tube for 2020 because one GOP hopeful, a police officer and former pro-hockey player named Pete Stauber (ph), thinks President Trump could help him win here. PETE STAUBER, MINNESOTA U.S. CONGRESSIONAL CANDIDATE: I will publicly say that President Trump won our district by almost 16 percent because he said he was going to protect middle-class jobs in the iron range and support mining. And I am a candidate that’s going to help do that.” [FOX News Network, 8/23/17]

NOTE: Further research necessary to obtain video.

November 2016: Stauber Praised Trump For His Stance On Guns And Called Ted Nugent “Great” During An Introduction Speech For Mike Pence At A Campaign Rally

Stauber Praised Trump For His Stance On Guns, Called Guns Life Saving Devices, And Called Ted Nugent “Great.” “Pence was introduced by Stewart Mills, Republican candidate for Minnesota’s 8th Congressional District, and by St. Louis County Commissioner Pete Stauber of Hermantown. […] Stauber praised Trump’s support for gun owner rights, noting iron ore from Northeastern Minnesota is used to produce ‘our life-saving devices that we call guns,’ and predicting Minnesota voters would ‘stand with the great Ted Nugent and Charlton Heston’ in support of Second Amendment rights to keep and use guns.” [Duluth News Tribune, 11/7/16]

Nov. 2016: Stauber Reportedly “Spoke Out In Support” Trump During An Introduction Speech For Mike Pence At A Campaign Rally. “Stauber spoke out in support of Republican Donald Trump’s presidential 39 campaign and helped introduce his running mate, now-Vice President Mike Pence, during a rally at the Duluth International Airport on the eve of the last year’s election.” [Duluth News Tribune, 7/9/17]

November 2016: Stauber Reportedly Called For Civility And Respect For Diversity Following The 2016 Election

Stauber Participated In A “Community Unity Event” Where He Reportedly Said The Community Needed To “Focus On Civility And Respecting Diversity.” “Two local partisan politicians, who in recent weeks have been rallying their backers to support opposing candidates for president, came together Sunday to ask for community unity in the Northland. Duluth Mayor Emily Larson, an avowed Democrat and Hillary Clinton supporter, and St. Louis County Commissioner Pete Stauber of Hermantown, a Republican activist and Donald Trump supporter, held a media event on the steps of City Hall in Duluth. […] Stauber said the community needs to focus on civility and respecting diversity.” [Duluth News Tribune, 11/14/16]

Sexual Assault Allegations

Asked If Donald Trump Or Roy Moore “Deserved Consequences” For Sexual Harassment Allegations, Stauber Said “It Depends” But That Allegations Against Franken Were “Crystal Clear”

Dec. 2017: Asked If Trump Or Roy Moore “Deserved Consequences” For Sexual Harassment Allegations, Stauber Said, “It Depends.” “Asked if other politicians, namely Alabama Senate candidate Roy Moore or President Donald Trump, deserved consequences for allegations against them, Stauber said, ‘It depends.’ ‘With Sen. Franken, it’s clear,’ Stauber said. ‘You saw the picture I did. That was a sexual assault on a woman -- crystal clear -- and more and more are coming out. I just think that he did the right thing.’ Stauber declined to talk about any of the issues shaping the 2018 November midterm race for the seat belonging to Rep. Rick Nolan, DFL- Crosby.’” [Duluth News Tribune, 12/8/17]

Stauber: “With Sen. Franken, It’s Clear… That Was A Sexual Assault On A Woman – Crystal Clear.” “‘With Sen. Franken, it’s clear,’ Stauber said. ‘You saw the picture I did. That was a sexual assault on a woman -- crystal clear -- and more and more are coming out. I just think that he did the right thing.’ Stauber declined to talk about any of the issues shaping the 2018 November midterm race for the seat belonging to Rep. Rick Nolan, DFL-Crosby.’” [Duluth News Tribune, 12/8/17]

Issues

41 Budget Issues

Significant Findings

 Stauber voted for the 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, and 2018 Budget and Levy Resolutions for St. Louis County as a County Commissioner.

 Stauber voted to raise the per diem rate for members of the Board of Adjustment committee.

 Stauber said elected officials had a “responsibility” to use tax money wisely.

Funding And Budgets

2017: Stauber Voted For The 2018 Budget And Levy Resolution

Dec. 2017: Stauber Voted For The 2018 Budget And Levy Resolution. [Resolution No. 17-739, 12/19/17]

2016: Stauber Voted For The 2017 Property Tax Levy And Budget Resolution

2015: Stauber Voted For The 2016 Budget And Property Tax Levy Resolution

2015: Stauber Voted For The 2016 Budget And Property Tax Levy Resolution. “Commissioner discussion continued regarding the amendment to the 2016 Budget and Property Tax Levy Resolution. A friendly amendment was offered by Commissioner Raukar, accepted by Commissioner Rukavina, to remove the line item transferring funds from Local Levy Road Construction (object 200-203001) to Road Maintenance Unorganized Townships (object 210- 210001), item #59 in the proposed amended budget. Commissioner Dahlberg stepped out of the meeting from 1:41 p.m. to 1:42 p.m. After further discussion, a roll-call vote was taken and the motion to amend the 2016 Budget and Property Tax Levy Resolution failed; three yeas (Boyle, Rukavina, Raukar), three nays (Dahlberg, Nelson, Stauber). After further discussion, the original motion passed; six yeas, zero nays, one absent (Jewell). Resolution No. 15-766.” [Resolution No. 15-766, 12/15/15]

2014: Stauber Voted For The 2015 Budget And Levy Resolution

2013: Stauber Voted For The 2014 Budget And Levy Resolution

42 passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 13-764.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 12/17/13; Resolution No. 13-764, 12/17/13]

2014: Stauber Voted To Increase The Per Diem Rate For Members Of The Board Of Adjustment From $50 To $75

Feb. 2014: Stauber Voted To Adopt A Resolution To Increase The Per Diem Rate For Members Of The Board Of Adjustment From $50 To $75. “WHEREAS, The St. Louis County Board appoints members and establishes the per diem rate for the Board of Adjustment; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board authorizes an increase to the per diem rate for the Board of Adjustment from $50 to $75. Commissioner Nelson moved the adoption of the Resolution and it was declared adopted upon the following vote: Yeas - Commissioners Jewell, Boyle, Dahlberg, Stauber, Nelson, Raukar and Chair Forsman – 7 Nays – None.” [Resolution No. 14-94, 2/4/14]

The Board Of Adjustment Was “Tasked With Hearing Variances And Appeals.” “The Board of Adjustment (BOA) is tasked with hearing variances and appeals to county’s official controls and staffed by the St. Louis County Planning and Community Development Staff.” [St. Louis County, Board of Adjustment (BOA), accessed 1/25/18]

Government Spending

Stauber Said “We Have A Responsibility To Use [Tax] Money Wisely”

Stauber Said “We Have A Responsibility To Use [Tax] Money Wisely.” “‘As elected officials, we invest in infrastructure, roads, bridges, human services etc. But that money we are spending has come from people who have worked and paid taxes. We have a responsibility to use that money wisely. We have to rightsize the government. That is what I hear on the campaign trail.’” [Cook County News Herald, 8/12/17]

Stauber Said Government Needed To “Streamline The Way Government Works” And Target Investments “So We Can Get [T]he Maximum Investment Back On Our Money”

Stauber Said Government Needed To “Streamline The Way Government Works” And Target Investments “So We Can Get [T]he Maximum Investment Back On Our Money.” “When it comes to government, Stauber believes the local, state and federal government must provide services to the public. But the overlapping redundancy ‘that we have to go through to get something done must be fixed. Government need not be in every facet of our existence. We need to streamline the way government works and investments must be targeted and reviewed so we can get he maximum investment back for our money.’” [Cook County News Herald, 8/12/17]

43 Crime & Public Safety Issues

Significant Findings

 Stauber voted to authorize two new full-time deputy sheriffs in some public schools.

 Stauber voted to request the state to allow a National Guard bomb squad be available for civilian threats.

Public Safety

Stauber Voted To Authorize Two New Full-Time Deputy Sheriffs In Some Public Schools

Stauber Supported Placing Deputies In Some Schools To Prevent Crime. “Stauber pointed to the county’s recent effort to place sheriff’s deputies in some rural county schools as an effort to keep kids out of the criminal and social service system. The best use of police, he said, is to prevent crime, not respond to it.” [Duluth News-Tribune, 10/16/16]

Aug. 2016: Stauber Supported A Motion To Authorize Hiring Two New Full Time Deputy Sheriff Positions As School Resources Officers. “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to authorize the addition of two (2.0) FTE Deputy Sheriff positions to backfill Deputies assigned to Independent School District (ISD) 2142 as School Resource Officers for the next three school years. Commissioner Rukavina, supported by Commissioner Raukar, move to table the resolution to the September 6, 2016 Board meeting.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 8/9/16]

The Motion Failed, With Stauber Voting In Favor. “The tabling motion failed; two yeas (Rukavina, Raukar), four nays (Boyle, Dahlberg, Stauber, Nelson), one absent (Jewell). Undersheriff Dave Phillips provided the Board with an overview of the duties of the School Resource Officers. After further discussion, the motion failed; three yeas (Boyle, Stauber, Nelson), three nays (Dahlberg, Rukavina, Raukar), one absent (Jewell). Commissioner Nelson indicated that he changed his vote to nay. Motion failed; two yeas (Boyle, Stauber), four nays (Dahlberg, Nelson, Rukavina, Raukar), one absent (Jewell).” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 8/9/16]

Sept. 2016: The Resolution Was Reconsidered And Passed. “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Boyle, moved to reconsider a resolution authorizing the addition of 2.0 FTE Deputy Sheriff positions to backfill Deputies assigned to Independent School District (ISD) 2142 as School Resource Officers (the item failed by a 2/4 vote on August 9, 2016) {16-371R}. The motion to reconsider passed; six yeas, one nay (Rukavina). Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved the resolution. […] The motion was amended requiring a report of activities be provided to the Board at the conclusion of the 2016-2017 school year. Commissioner Nelson moved to call the question, motion failed – no second. The Board recessed at 12:01 p.m. and reconvened at 12:13 p.m. with all Commissioners present. The motion passed; four yeas (Jewell, Boyle, Nelson, Stauber), three nays (Dahlberg, Rukavina, Raukar). Resolution No. 16-546.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 9/6/16]

Stauber Voted To Request The State For A National Guard Bomb Squad Be Available For Civilian Threats

44 Stauber Voted To Request The State To Allow The 148th Fighter Wing Bomb Squad Be Available For Civilian Threats

April 2015: Stauber Voted To Request The State To Allow An Air National Guard Bomb Squad Be Available For Civilian Threats. “St. Louis County Commissioners on Tuesday advanced a resolution asking Gov. Mark Dayton to order the 148th Minnesota Air National Guard to make its bomb squad available for civilian threats, but it appears the request won’t do much good. The letter asked the governor to declare the 148th bomb disposal unit a ‘community asset’ that would be available to law enforcement’s requests to deal with bombs off of the military base at Duluth International Airport. County Board Chairman Pete Stauber of Hermantown sponsored the resolution Tuesday, saying the county needed to urge state officials to intervene.” [Duluth News Tribune, 4/7/15]

April 2015: Stauber Voted To Adopt A Resolution Calling On Gov. Mark Dayton To Declare The Minnesota Air National Guard 148th Fighter Wing Explosive Ordnance Disposal (EOD) Unit As A Community Asset. “WHEREAS, On March 11, 2015, a pipe bomb was discovered at the Hermantown Early Childhood Family Education Center located on Highway 53, and although the trained Minnesota Air National Guard 148th Fighter Wing Explosive Ordnance Disposal (EOD) unit is located less than a mile from the site of the event, the Hermantown Police Department was told that the closest Bomb Squad asset available was located in Crow Wing County, MN (Brainerd area); and WHEREAS, The 148th Fighter Wing EOD possesses superior equipment and a very high level of training, and that it is only reasonable to have this asset available for use at the request of local law enforcement to both identify and render useless any explosive devices that may be encountered; and WHEREAS, The 148111 Fighter Wing EOD was, in fact, available to area law enforcement as recently as 2012, when a policy change was made by Minnesota National Guard Adjutant General Nash preventing use of this important asset; and WHEREAS, If the 148th EOD isn’t available to local law enforcement, they would proceed to utilize the services of other bomb squads pursuant to the duty officer’s list; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board hereby calls upon Governor Mark Dayton to declare the Minnesota Air National Guard 148th Fighter Wing Explosive Ordnance Disposal (EOD) unit as a community asset, once again allowing local community law enforcement to use the EOD, when available, to greatly enhance the public safety of our area.” [Resolution No. 15-218, 4/14/15]

March 2015: The 148th Fighter Wing’s Bomb Squad Responded To A Pipe Bomb Incident In Hermantown, But Regulation Prevented Them From Removing The Bomb

March 2015: The 148th Fighter Wing’s Bomb Squad Responded To A Pipe Bomb Incident In Hermantown, But Regulation Prevented Them From Removing The Bomb. “The issue has been brewing for about three years but came to a head March 11 during a pipe bomb incident in the parking lot of a Hermantown child services center. When the Hermantown Police chief asked the Minnesota Depart-ment of Public Safety for bomb squad assistance, he was told that Crow Wing County was the closest bomb squad available. The 148th’s EOD team did respond to the scene--about five minutes from its base--but said regulations prevented them from disarming or moving the bomb to a safe place.” [Duluth News Tribune, 4/7/15]

Stauber Said It Was “Odd” The Bomb Could Not Be Used As A “Community Asset”

Stauber Said It Struck Him As “Odd” That The Bomb Squad Unit Could Not Be Used As A “Community Asset.” “‘It strikes me as odd that we can’t have this (unit) as a community asset,’ said Stauber, who also is a Duluth city police officer.” [Duluth News Tribune, 4/7/15]

45 Economy & Jobs

Significant Findings

 Stauber said he would reduce “excessive and overlapping federal regulations that work against the entrepreneurial spirit” if elected to Congress.

 Stauber moved to hire two new full-time county positions to investigate welfare fraud.

Small Business

Stauber Said He Would Reduce “Excessive And Overlapping Federal Regulations That Work Against The Entrepreneurial Spirit”

Oct. 2017: Stauber Said He Would “Work To Greatly Reduce The Burden Of Excessive And Overlapping Federal Regulations That Work Against The Entrepreneurial Spirit” If Elected To Congress. “Stauber is co- owner of Duluth Hockey Company, formerly Stauber Bros. Sports. ‘I understand what it’s like to be a small business owner,’ he said. ‘I’ll work to greatly reduce the burden of excessive and overlapping federal regulations that work against the entrepreneurial spirit.’” [The Journal, 10/21/17]

Welfare

Stauber Moved And Voted To Hire Two County Positions To Investigate Welfare Fraud

Jan. 2014: Stauber Moved And Voted To Adopt A Resolution To Hire Two Additional County Workers In The Public Health And Human Services Department To Assist With A Pilot Fraud Prevention Program. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Raukar, moved that the St. Louis County Board authorizes the Public Health and Human Services Department to implement a pilot fraud prevention initiative for the period January 1, 2014 through December 31, 2014. The Board authorizes the increase of the department’s authorized FTE by 2.0 to allow for the hiring of one (1) FTE Eligibility Investigator and one (1) Financial Worker for this fraud prevention initiative with the understanding these positions are only authorized for the time frame of the pilot; the cost of this pilot fraud prevention initiative is projected to be $118,362. PHHS shall provide the Board with quarterly evaluations of this fraud prevention initiative. Commissioner Jewell exited the meeting at 9:53 a.m. The motion passed; six yeas, zero nays (Jewell absent). Resolution No. 14-58.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 1/14/14; Resolution 14-58, 1/14/14]

St. Cloud Times: Stauber Said He Did Not See The Appropriation As “Money From Washington Being Misspent; It’s All Taxpayers’ Money.” “The St. Louis County Board on Tuesday approved two new staff positions to track down incorrect payments for public-assistance programs, otherwise known as welfare fraud. The board approved a one-year, $118,362 appropriation to hire a fraud investigator and an additional county financial worker for the Health and Human Services Department to look for and correct improper payment cases - people who are receiving too much or too little public assistance. […] While any fraud would be perpetrated against federal or possibly state programs, with the money from Washington or St. Paul, St. Louis County officials say they are willing to spend county money to help thwart fraud. ‘It’s all of our money, yours and mine,’ said Commissioner Pete Stauber of Hermantown, who helped push for the new positions. ‘We don’t see it as money from Washington being misspent; it’s all taxpayers’ money.’” [St. Cloud Times, 1/13/14]

St. Cloud Times: Stauber Said The County Was Trying To Be Proactive. “Stauber pointed to recent local cases where law enforcement uncovered the illegal trading and selling of Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program cards, federal cards used for what formerly was called the food stamp program. ‘County commissioners have been 46 interested in seeing what we could do to see that people are getting the correct payments, that they aren’t being underpaid or overpaid,’ said Stauber, a Duluth police officer. ‘We’re trying to be proactive here, to find out what kind of a problem this is. We really don’t know what we’ll find.’” [St. Cloud Times, 1/13/14]

The Resolution To Hire Two New Staff Positions Was Passed Unanimously. “County Commissioners Keith Nelson of Fayal Township and Chris Dahlberg of Duluth said they hesitated to add staff positions but eventually came around to support the proposal. The resolution passed unanimously.” [St. Cloud Times, 1/13/14]

47 Education Issues

Significant Findings

 Stauber said he supported offering “chemistry, math, sciences and technology” to students in order to remain “competitive in our current world climate.”

Education

Stauber Said He Supported Offering “Chemistry, Math, Sciences And Technology” To Students

Stauber Said Students Need To Be “Offered Chemistry, Math, Sciences And Technology” In Order To Remain “Competitive In Our Current World Climate.” “‘We need to educate our kids. All children deserve the best education we can give them. Our best students need to be offered chemistry, math, sciences and technology in order for our country to remain competitive in our current world climate. Our biggest investment needs to be in our children. That will be the most significant payback we have in the future.’” [Cook County News Herald, 8/12/17]

48 Energy Issues

Significant Findings

 Stauber signed a letter calling on Governor Mark Dayton to expedite the permit process for Enridge’s proposed Sandpiper and Line 3 Replacement pipelines.

Pipelines

Stauber Signed A Letter Calling For An Expedited Permit Process On Enridge’s Proposed The Sandpiper And Line 3 Replacement Pipelines

Stauber Signed A Letter To The Governor Calling To Speed Up The Permit Process For Enbridge Energy’s Proposed Sandpiper And Line 3 Replacement Pipelines. “Five St. Louis County commissioners have joined their counterparts in other northern Minnesota counties supporting construction of new and expanded oil pipelines across the region. St. Louis County commissioners Steve Raukar, Keith Nelson, Tom Rukavina, Pete Stauber and Chris Dahlberg signed a letter to Minnesota Gov. Mark Dayton urging his support in speeding up the permitting process for Enbridge Energy’s proposed Sandpiper and Line 3 Replacement pipelines across Minnesota to move western state and Canadian oil to its Superior terminal and on to points south and east. […] Enbridge is expected to spend about $2.6 billion on both the Sandpiper and Line 3 Replacement projects, though the company has stated that costs will rise with more delays.” [Duluth News Tribune, 4/7/16]

The Letter Was Not Formally Voted On By The Board. “Commissioners Frank Jewell and Patrick Boyle, both of Duluth, did not sign the letter, which was not formally voted on by the board. St. Louis County joined one commissioner for Polk, four from Aitkin, one from Beltrami, one from Carlton, one from Clearwater, one from Kittson, two from Marshall, one from Pennington and five from Red Lake counties in signing the letter to Dayton.” [Duluth News Tribune, 4/7/16]

49 Environmental Issues

Significant Findings

 Stauber called himself an “environmentalist” because “no one” wanted “dirty air and polluted water.”

 Stauber wrote an op-ed titled “Stop Being Environmentalists Only When It’s Convenient, And Let’s Get These Mines Going!”

 Stauber supported the MINER Act, which would require congressional approval for any federal proposals to withdraw land from mining.

 Stauber stated he supported the permitting process for the PolyMet Hoyt Lakes Mine and Twin Metals Minnesota.

 Stauber said mining jobs were “permanent jobs” that could be done “in an environmentally friendly way.”

 Stauber voted against allocating $50,000 for freshwater testing in Lake Superior Harbors.

Environmentalism

Stauber Called Himself An “Environmentalist” Because “No One” Wanted “Dirty Air And Polluted Water”

Oct. 2017: STAUBER OP-ED: “Stop Being Environmentalists Only When It’s Convenient, And Let’s Get These Mines Going!” [Mesabi Daily News, Stauber op-ed, 10/25/17]

STAUBER OP-ED: Stauber Called Himself “An Environmentalist” Because “No One” Wants “Dirty Air And Polluted Water.” “My family and I love the lakes and forests of northern Minnesota. We realize there are few places in America - in the world - where we can know what it’s like to feel our cool, clear waters and breathe in our crisp air. So you’re darn right I’m an environmentalist. In fact, who among us wants dirty air and polluted water? No one. We’re all environmentalists.” [Mesabi Daily News, Stauber op-ed, 10/25/17]

Stauber Said Some Environmentalists “Pick And Choose What’s Right” And Forget Things “When It’s Convenient”

STAUBER OP-ED: Stauber Said Some Environmentalists “Pick And Choose What’s Right” And Forget Things “When It’s Convenient,” Like Using Natural Resources For “Every Day” Items. “But some in our region have a view of our environment that is unrealistic, and it’s gone on far too long. Those folks like to pick and choose what’s right, forgetting things when it’s convenient. For example, that dock on their lake has boards that came from northern Minnesota trees. The boat tied up to their dock is made from materials that came from the ground. And where did the gas and oil powering their boat’s trusty Evinrude come from? You see, it’s OK with pick-and-choose environmentalists to use natural resources from above and below the ground when it’s for things they enjoy. Kitchen appliances, cell phones and nearly everything we use every day comes from the environment. Even protest signs are made from trees.” [Mesabi Daily News, Stauber op-ed, 10/25/17]

Mining

50 Advocacy

July 2017: Stauber Said He Was “Proud” To Stand With The Minnesota Mining Community And Would “Not Quit” Until Miners’ Voices Were Heard

July 2017: Stauber Said He Was “Proud” To Stand With The Minnesota Mining Community And Would “Not Quit” Until Miners’ Voices Were Heard. “‘Northern Minnesota miners need a voice in Washington raising these complex and important issues on their behalf,’ Stauber said. ‘I’m proud to stand with our mining community to ensure congressional leadership understands how vital these jobs are for our region. I will not quit until Northern Minnesota miners’ voices are heard.’” [Pete Stauber, press release, 7/19/17]

July 2017: Duluth News Tribune: Stauber: “I Won’t Tiptoe Around The Fact That I Support Precious Metals Mining.” “In a news release accompanying his announcement, Stauber said he will soon retire from the Duluth Police Department, where he’s served for 22 years, and devote his time to being a county commissioner and running for office. Without summoning the incumbent, Stauber also made a point to say the Iron Range could be mined for precious metals while also protecting the environment. ‘I won’t tiptoe around the fact that I support precious metals mining,’ he said -- taking the same position as Nolan.” [Duluth News Tribune, 7/10/17]

Environmental Concerns

June 2014: Stauber Voted To Oppose A Proposal For The U.S. Dept. Of Agriculture To Conduct A Programmatic Environmental Impact Statement For The Superior National Forest

June 2014: Stauber Voted To Adopt A Resolution Opposing A Proposal For The U.S. Department Of Agriculture To Conduct A Programmatic Environmental Impact Statement For The Superior National Forest. “WHEREAS, Minnesota’s and the Iron Range economy cannot afford further unnecessary or duplicative delays in mining permitting; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board hereby opposes the proposed Programmatic Environmental Impact Statement being asked of the United States Department of Agriculture for the Superior National Forest; RESOLVED FURTHER, That the St. Louis County Board implores its elected leaders, including but not limited to Governor Dayton, Senators Klobuchar and Franken, and Congressman Nolan, to demand that the USDA reject the Programmatic Environmental Impact Statement currently under consideration for the Superior National Forest.” [Resolution No. 14-383, 6/24/14]

The Board Called The Proposal “Duplicative” And Said It Would Cause “Unnecessary Delays” And “Affect Not Only Future Mining Opportunities, But Current Mining And Associated Operations.” “WHEREAS, The St. Louis County Board of Commissioners understands that the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) is being asked to conduct a duplicative Programmatic Environmental Impact Statement (PElS) for the Superior National Forest (SNF) that would cause unnecessary delays and could affect not only future mining opportunities, but current mining and associated operations; and WHEREAS, Proposed nonferrous mining projects and other mines within the SNF are already subject to rigorous and responsible environmental oversight by the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources and relevant federal agencies; and WHEREAS, The St. Louis County Board has declared its support for the existing open, transparent, and comprehensive environmental review and permitting process in place for the various nonferrous mining initiatives planned for development on the Iron Range, and supports the success of these projects contingent upon approval of all state and federal permits necessary; and WHEREAS, None of these strategic metals mining projects will achieve permits to mine without approval from the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources and relevant federal agencies; and WHEREAS, The Iron Range legislative delegation is opposed to the proposed PElS because of its unnecessary cost, redundancy and negative effect on mining and related jobs in the region; and WHEREAS, The Iron Range legislative delegation has asked the USDA not to accept or move forward with the dilatory PElS; and WHEREAS, U.S. Congressman Rick Nolan has met with high level United States Forest Service representatives and has expressed his strong opposition to a PElS; and WHEREAS, Minnesota’s and the Iron Range economy cannot afford further unnecessary or duplicative delays in mining permitting[.]” [Resolution No. 14-383, 6/24/14] 51

March 2017: Stauber Said Mining Did Not Have To Be Chosen Over Clean Water, But Rather It Was Time “For A Solution For One And The Other”

March 2017: Stauber Said Mining Did Not Have To Be Chosen Over Clean Water, But Rather It Was Time “For A Solution For One And The Other.” “The state’s politically powerful mining industry argues that the ban would cripple the nascent copper-nickel industry in Minnesota. ‘These are the minerals that the good Lord put here so we can extract them,’ said St. Louis County Commissioner Pete Stauber. It doesn’t have to be one or the other, mining or clean water, he said: ‘It’s time we work for a solution for one and the other.’” [Star Tribune, 3/17/17]

Jobs

Stauber Said Mining Jobs Were “Permanent Jobs” And Could Be Done “In An Environmentally Friendly Way”

2012: Duluth News Tribune: Stauber Said Copper Mining Jobs Were Not “Temporary Jobs,” But Instead “Permanent Jobs For At Least Two Generations-Plus.” “On his opponent’s vote against copper mining, Stauber said, ‘I don’t know what else the resolution could have said to support the jobs at PolyMet, but to me (her vote was) unconscionable. In St. Louis County we have over an 8 percent unemployment rate. These are jobs that will benefit the community for years. These aren’t temporary jobs. These are permanent jobs for at least two generations-plus.’” [Duluth News Tribune, Editorial, 9/27/12]

Stauber: “We Can Create Good Jobs…We Will Do It In An Environmentally Friendly Way, And We Demand It Be Done That Way.” “‘We can expand jobs,’ Stauber said. ‘We can create good jobs. And we can do it in an environmentally friendly way. In fact, we will do it in an environmentally friendly way, and we demand it be done that way.’” [Duluth News Tribune, Editorial, 9/27/12]

Stauber Claimed He Met With House Natural Resources Committee Chairman Rob Bishop (R-UT) To Discuss Mining Jobs In Minnesota

July 2017: Stauber Met With House Natural Resources Committee Chairman Rob Bishop (R-UT) To Discuss Mining Jobs In Minnesota. “Pete Stauber, U.S. Congressional candidate for Minnesota’s Eighth District, met with House Natural Resources Committee Chairman Rob Bishop (R-UT) on Wednesday, July 19. The two discussed the importance of mining jobs in Northern Minnesota, where Stauber is currently seeking the congressional seat occupied by Rep. Rick Nolan (D-MN).” [Pete Stauber, press release, 7/19/17]

MINER Act

Oct. 2017: Stauber Wrote An Op-Ed In Support Of The MINER Act, Which Would Require Congressional Approval For Any Federal Proposals To Withdraw Land From Mining

Oct. 2017: STAUBER OP-ED: “Stop Being Environmentalists Only When It’s Convenient, And Let’s Get These Mines Going!” [Mesabi Daily News, Stauber op-ed, 10/25/17]

STAUBER OP-ED: Stauber Supported The MINER Act, Which Would Require Congressional Approval For Any Federal Proposals To Withdraw Land From Mining. “Legislation introduced in October was a nice start at providing a chance, when a bill was sponsored by three U.S. Congressmen from Minnesota to restore mineral rights in the state. Minnesota’s Economic Rights in the Superior National Forest Act, abbreviated to MINER Act, would require approval from elected representatives in Congress for any federal proposal to withdraw land from mining, and for the establish-ment of national monuments in Minnesota. Additionally, this legislation would allow the renewal of mineral leases in the area and would ensure that future leases in the area remain valid and renewed, consistent with current law. The bill, which is 52 great news for northern Minnesota, was introduced by Republican Minnesota U.S. Rep. Tom Emmer (CD6) and cosponsored by two other Minnesota congressmen: DFL Rep. Collin Peterson (CD7) and Republican Rep. Jason Lewis (CD2).” [Mesabi Daily News, Stauber op-ed, 10/25/17]

STAUBER OP-ED: Stauber Said He Was Running For Congress “To End The Posturing And Delays Once And For All” And To Help Make Mining Jobs “An Overdue Reality.” “Now we have before us a great, safe and thoroughly researched way to again use our environmental resources, but suddenly it’s apparently not OK. That’s worse than a double-standard, it’s dangerous in that it continues to cost us thousands of excellent family-supporting jobs. Right here. I’m running for U.S. Congress to end the posturing and delays once and for all, and help make these jobs an overdue reality.” [Mesabi Daily News, Stauber op-ed, 10/25/17]

PolyMet Hoyt Lakes Mine

Stauber Said He Supported PolyMet’s “Efforts To Safely Mine Precious Metals”

Aug. 2017: Stauber: “I Support Both Polymet And Twin Metals In Their Efforts To Safely Mine Precious Metals.” “Mining is a hot topic in the Northland and Stauber was quick to point out, ‘No one wants to pollute the soil or water. Those of us who have lived here our whole lives love nature. I believe that by using science and facts and new technology we can and will mine precious metals safely which will allow good paying American jobs. I support both Polymet and Twin Metals in their efforts to safely mine precious metals.’” [Cook County News Herald, 8/12/17]

Dec. 2015: Stauber Submitted A Letter To The MN Dept. Of Natural Resources And Gov. Mark Dayton To Support The Permitting Process For The PolyMet’s Hoyt Lakes Mine

Dec. 2015: Stauber Submitted A Letter Endorsing The Permitting Process For PolyMet’s Hoyt Lakes Mines. “St. Louis County Board Chair Pete Stauber submitted a letter endorsing the Final Environmental Impact Statement for PolyMet’s Hoyt Lakes mine, urging the state Department of Natural Resources and Gov. Mark Dayton to trust the permitting process.” [Hibbing Daily Tribune, 12/6/15]

2015: Stauber Said He Was “Proud” That The County Board Gave Unanimous Support For The Final Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) For The Proposed Polymet Project. “We certainly have seen challenges, especially on the Iron Range as layoffs continue in the mining industry. I was very proud that the County Board came together to give unanimous support for the Final Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for the proposed Polymet project. We are one County. We value the contributions and will continue working to preserve the jobs and livelihood of our citizens.” [St. Louis County, Pete Stauber blog post, 12/30/15]

The Mine Was Minnesota’s “First-Ever Copper-Nick Operation” And Was Expected To Have A $242 Million Economic Impact

Hibbing Daily Tribune: The Mine Was Minnesota’s “First-Ever Copper-Nickel Operation” And Was Expected To Bring 350 Permanent Jobs, 500 Spin-Off Jobs, And An Economic Impact Of $242 Million. “Minnesota’s first-ever copper-nickel operation is expected to generate more than 1 million construction hours at a $600 million cost over two years. Along with 350 permanent jobs at the site, with an annual payroll of around $40 million, PolyMet’s NorthMet project is anticipated to bring in an additional 500 spin-off jobs in the region. Stauber estimated the total economic impact to the county to be $242 million.” [Hibbing Daily Tribune, 12/6/15]

The PolyMet Mine Project Intended To Mine For Copper And Nickel In The Minnesota Iron Range. “The PolyMet mine represents a new frontier for the Iron Range: a mine for copper and nickel, rather than the iron that gave it its name. But it’s also an old frontier: a battle between economic and environmental interests with deep meaning for all sides.” [St. Paul Pioneer Press, 11/25/15]

53 2015: The PolyMet Mine Would Reportedly Reduce St. Louis County’s Unemployment Rate From 5.2 To 4.9 Percent, Which Stauber Said Was “A Huge Economic Impact” For The County. “In contrast, St. Louis County has a 5.2 percent unemployment rate, while Minnesota as a whole has a 3.7 percent rate. Even on a county level, the extra jobs would be nothing to sneeze at. If 360 of the roughly 5,409 unemployed St. Louis County residents got jobs, the county’s unemployment rate would drop to 4.9 percent. If 991 of them got jobs -- the number of direct and indirect jobs the Labovitz analysis predicted PolyMet would create -- the new unemployment rate would be 4.28 percent. ‘We view that as a huge economic impact for St. Louis County,’ said Stauber, the St. Louis County commissioner.” [St. Paul Pioneer Press, 11/25/15]

Stauber Reportedly Called The Mine’s Environmental Impact Beyond “Adequate”

Stauber Called The Environmental Impact Statement Beyond “Adequate.” “‘The time has come to move forward,’ he wrote to DNR Commissioner Tom Landwehr. ‘The MNDNR should affirm the adequacy of the Final EIS so it can serve as the foundation for the State of Minnesota’s permitting process. The Final EIS for the NorthMet Mine is far beyond ‘adequate.’’” [Hibbing Daily Tribune, 12/6/15]

Stauber: “These Are Minerals That The Good Lord Put There, And We’re Going To Extract Them And Use Them To Better Our World”

2015: Stauber Said “We Will Produce Great Jobs” By Extracting Minerals “The Good Lord” Put In St. Louis County. “Minnesota’s Iron Range has been buffeted for decades by the rise and fall -- but mostly fall -- of the mining industry. Now, the controversial PolyMet project has fired up hopes that mining could be on its way back. ‘We have been blessed with minerals in our earth up here in St. Louis County,’ said Pete Stauber, chair of the St. Louis County Board of Commissioners. ‘By extracting them safely, we will produce great jobs. ... These are minerals that the good Lord put there, and we’re going to extract them and use them to better our world.’” [St. Paul Pioneer Press, 11/25/15]

Twin Metals Minnesota

Stauber Supported Renewing Federal Mineral Leases For Twin Metals Minnesota

Dec. 2016: Mesabi Daily News: Stauber Reportedly Supported Renewing Federal Mineral Leases For Twin Metals Minnesota. “U.S. Sens. Amy Klobuchar and Al Franken will not offer an opinion on whether the federal leases for Twin Metals Minnesota mining exploration near Ely should be renewed. […] MiningMinnesota, an advocacy group for copper/nickel/precious metals, says many Minnesota political and business leaders have submitted comments or signed letters to the USFS supporting renewal of the federal mineral leases. They include: […] St. Louis County Commissioners Steve Rauker, Keith Nelson, Tom Rukavina and Peter Stauber.” [Mesabi Daily News, 8/6/16]

Feb. 2017: Stauber Voted To Ask The Trump Administration “To Rescind A Federal Ban On Copper Mining And Exploration Near The Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness”

Feb. 2017: Stauber Voted To Ask The Trump Administration “To Rescind A Federal Ban On Copper Mining And Exploration Near The Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness.” “St. Louis County commissioners on Tuesday approved a resolution asking the Trump administration to rescind a federal ban on copper mining and exploration near the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness. The majority of the board 54 wanted to be on record opposing the last-minute Obama administration policy that effectively could kill the proposed Twin Metals copper mine southeast of Ely on the edge of the BWCAW. […] While more than a dozen people spoke on the issue, for and against, commissioners avoided their usually lengthy speeches and quickly voted by voice 4-3 in favor of the resolution, as expected. Commissioners Tom Rukavina of Pike Township, Mike Jugovich of Chisholm, Pete Stauber of Hermantown and Keith Nelson of Fayal Township voted for the resolution. Duluth Commissioners Beth Olson, Patrick Boyle and Frank Jewell voted against.” [Duluth News Tribune, 2/7/17]

Stauber Voted For A Resolution To “Immediately Rescind The BLM-USFS Proposal To Withdraw 240,000 Acres Of Land…From Future Leasing, Exploration And Potential Development.” “THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board of Commissioners hereby request the Trump administration to immediately rescind the BLM-USFS proposal to withdraw 240,000 acres of land in NE Minnesota from future leasing, exploration and potential development and withdraw the BLM’s Federal Register notice announcing the proposal[.]” [Resolution No. 17-112, 2/7/17]

The Resolution Stated That Senator Klobuchar, Senator Franken, And Rep. Nolan Also Opposed The Proposal. “RESOLVED FURTHER, That Senator Klobuchar and Senator Franken join Congressman Nolan and publicly state both their opposition to the withdrawal and formally request immediate reversal by the Trump administration[.]” [Resolution No. 17-112, 2/7/17]

Jan. 2017: Stauber Voted To Oppose A Federal Move To “Withdraw More Than 235,000 Aces Of Land From Mining Development” After The Federal Government Denied Mineral Leases To Twin Metals

Jan. 2017: Stauber Voted For A Resolution Opposing A Federal Move To “Withdraw More Than 235,000 Aces Of Land From Mining Development. “St. Louis County Commissioners deadlocked on a resolution that would put the board on the record against a federal government move to withdraw more than 235,000 acres of land from mining development. Commissioner Tom Rukavina of Pike Lake called the resolution ‘the most important’ the county has taken up. It opposed U.S. Forest Service and Bureau of Land Management decisions that circumvented previous federal process for permitting and approving mining projects. In December, the feds took unilateral action to deny a mineral leases extension to Twin Metals for an underground copper-nickel mine near Ely, simultaneously proposing a massive land withdrawal from future mining leases for two years. […] Rukavina and Commissioners Mike Jugovich of Chisholm and Pete Stauber of Hermantown voted for the resolution. Commissioner Keith Nelson of Fayal Township was absent to attend a funeral.” [Grand Rapids Herald-Review, 1/24/17]

Public Lands

Stauber Was The Only Commissioner To Vote Against Supporting A Federal Land Swap Of Forested Land To Produce Revenue For Minnesota Public Schools

Stauber Voted Against Supporting The U.S. Forest Service’s Application For Federal Funds To Transfer Lands In The Boundary Water Canoe Area With School Trust And County Tax Forfeited Lands

Sept. 2017: Stauber Was The Only Commissioner To Vote Against A Resolution Supporting The U.S. Forest Service’s Application For Federal Funds To Transfer Lands In The Boundary Water Canoe Area (BWCAW) With School Trust And County Tax Forfeited Lands. “Commissioner Jewell, supported by Commissioner Nelson, moved that the St. Louis County Board supported the United States Forest Service’s application for federal funds for the purchase component of the Hybrid Purchase-Exchange Model, and supports the pursuit of Plan B, at any scale that complements the Hybrid model in order to help accomplish the orderly transfer of School Trust lands located in the Boundary Water Canoe Area Wilderness; and further, that the St. Louis County Board also supports using a similar approach as the Hybrid Purchase-Exchange Model and Plan B to accomplish the orderly transfer of 3,500 acres of County tax forfeited lands located in the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness. Commissioner Stauber said he opposed the resolution and fest the Wilderness Act of 1964 should be

55 followed. The motion passed; six yeas, one nay (Stauber). Resolution No. 17-587[.]” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 9/26/17; Resolution No. 17-587, 9/26/17]

Stauber Said He Voted Against The Resolution Because He Felt The “Wilderness Act Of 1964” Should Be Followed, Which States Public Lands Can Only Be Exchanged, Not Purchased

Nov. 2017: Stauber Voted Against A Motion In Support Of A Federal/State Land Exchange And Said He Felt The Wilderness Act Of 1964 Should Be Followed. “Commissioner Rukavina, supported by Commissioner Jewell, moved that the St. Louis County Board’s support for the Plan B Model is predicated on the federal/state land exchange (approximately 30,000 acres) and the acquisition of School Trust lands including the Plan B model (approximately 50,000 acres) proceed in tandem in accordance with the Hybrid Purchase-Exchange model agreed to by multiple parties. Commissioner Stauber commented that he felt the Wilderness Act of 1964 should be followed. The motion passed; six yeas, one nay (Stauber). Resolution No. 17-672.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 11/14/17; Resolution No. 17-672, 11/14/17]

Ely Echo: The Proposed Land Transfer “Provide[d] For A Scenario Where The Only Exchange Is Done Through A [Land] Purchase.” “Rukavina is concerned the county board may have given too much when a resolution was passed to approve a hybrid proposal that includes a land swap and purchase procedure. There are 83,000 acres of state school trust land that has been locked up in the BWCA since 1964. This hybrid proposal would swap 31,000 acres of federal land outside the BWCA for 31,000 acres of state school trust land inside the BWCA. The non-profit Conservation Fund would supposedly buy 52,000 acres of land owned by Potlatch and exchange those parcels for the remaining state lands in the BWCA. The feds will then buy the 52,000 acres from the Conservation Fund. The resolution actually is missing a key component: actual numbers. There is no mention of the 31,000 acres at all. The only number listed is the 83,000 in total acres. In a worse-case scenario it could be there are no state lands swapped for federal lands. The resolution would provide for a scenario where the only exchange is done through a purchase. This, of course, is not what was written in the 1964 Wilderness Act which says lands ‘shall by exchanged.’” [Ely Echo, 10/9/17]

The Wilderness Act Of 1964 Stated That State Or Privately Owned Land “Shall Be Exchanged For Federally Owned Land.” “STATE AND PRIVATE LANDS WITHIN WILDERNESS AREAS SECTION 5. (a) In any case where State-owned or privately owned land is completely surrounded by national forest lands within areas designated by this Act as wilderness, such State or private owners shall be given such rights as may be necessary to assure adequate access to such State-owned or privately owned land by such State or private owner and their successors in interest, or the State-owned land or privately owned land shall be exchanged for federally owned land in the same State of approximately equal value under authorities available to the Secretary of Agriculture.” [Government Publishing Office, Public Law 88-577, 9/3/64]

According To The County Board, The Land Transfer Would Allow Minnesota Public Schools To Benefit From Revenue From Timber Harvest, Mineral Leasing, Etc.

The County Board Stated That 83,000 Thousand Acres Of School Trust Lands In The BWCAW Were “Not Generating Revenue For Minnesota Public Schools From Activities Such As Timber Harvest, Mineral Leasing,” Etc. “WHEREAS, Approximately 83,000 acres of School Trust lands located in the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness (BWCAW) are not generating revenue for Minnesota public schools from activities such as timber harvest, mineral leasing, user fees or land sales; and[.]” [Resolution No. 17-587, 9/26/17]

The County Board Stated That St. Louis County Had “Lost Tens Of Millions Of Dollars (In Lieu Of Property Tax Revenue)” For Lands Located On The BWCAW. “WHEREAS, St. Louis, Lake and Cook Counties have lost tens of millions of dollars (in lieu of property tax revenue) for the past 53 years that this issue has gone unresolved; and[.]” [Resolution No. 17-587, 9/26/17]

A “Hybrid” And “Plan B” Model Involved Exchanging Private Forest Lands In St. Louis County And With Parcels On School Trust Lands Located In The BWCAW, Which The U.S. Forest Service With Then Purchase. “WHEREAS, A Hybrid model has been adopted that includes a combination of land sale and exchange 56 to transfer School Trust lands located in the BWCAW to the United States Forest Service (USFS); and WHEREAS, The Conservation Fund is a non-profit organization that finds solutions to land and water conservation issues benefiting both the environment and the economy; and WHEREAS, Plan B is a three-step proposal to accomplish the purchase component of the Hybrid model whereby the Conservation Fund will purchase private forest lands in St. Louis County and exchange these parcels for School Trust lands located in the BWCAW. The USFS will then buy the former School Trust lands from The Conservation Fund with funding from the Land and Water Conservation Fund; and [.]” [Resolution No. 17-587, 9/26/17]

The County Board Said The Plan Ensure That “Thousands Of Acres Of Private Forest Lands” Would Transfer To The School Trust, Which Could Then Generate Revenue For Minnesota Public Schools. “WHEREAS, The economic and environmental benefits of Plan B include consolidation of federal lands within the BWCAW and School Trust lands outside of the BWCAW. The plan will ensure that thousands of acres of private forest land in northern Minnesota will be transferred to the School Trust. The School Trust will then be able ot generate revenue for Minnesota public schools from activities such as timber harvest, mineral leasing, user fees or land sales. Plan B is an additional alternative that provides for the diversified source of revenue for Minnesota schools allowing for a sustained yield and stable employment for the forest products industry, and provides thousands of acres of lands for public recreation; and[.]” [Resolution No. 17-587, 9/26/17]

Waters

2015: Stauber Voted Against Allocating $50,000 For Freshwater Testing In Lake Superior Harbors.

Aug. 2015: Stauber Voted Against Allocating $50,000 For Freshwater Testing In Lake Superior Harbors. “WHEREAS, In 2014 the Minnesota Legislative Session established the Aquatic Invasive Species Prevention Aid Program, Mi1mesota Session Law Chapter 308; and WHEREAS, In 2015 the St. Louis County Board approved the Aquatic Invasive Species Prevention Plan and authorized the Planning and Community Development Director to solicit proposals for the use of the 2014 and 2015 Aquatic Invasive Species Prevention Aid; and WHEREAS, One such proposal was received from the Izaac Walton League of America- Mi1mesota Division for $100,000 for freshwater testing of a "Rapid Response Mobile Ballast Water Treatment System" for use in Lake Superior harbors; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board approves $50,000 from the 2014 and 2015 Aquatic Invasive Species Prevention Aid for the Izaac Walton League of America - Mi1mesota Division; RESOLVED FURTHER, That the appropriate county officials are authorized to execute a contract negotiated by the Planning and Community Development Director and a representative of the County Attorney in order to implement the aid program; RESOLVED FURTHER, That funding of $50,000 is contingent upon receiving $50,000 match funding from both the Department of Natural Resources and the National Park Service; RESOLVED FURTHER, That total funds of $50,000 will be payable from Fund 100, Agency 109999, Grant 10910, Year 2014 and Year 2015.” [Resolution No. 15-491, 8/4/15]

Gun Issues

Significant Findings

 Stauber said he “adamantly” supported the Second Amendment even though” he was “the victim of two gun incidents.”

 Stauber claimed he was “grazed” in the head by a bullet that was fired at his squad car.

 Stauber claimed a suspect pointed a gun at him, which malfunctioned.

 Stauber called guns “life-saving devices.”

 Stauber said he supported enforcing current gun laws, like cracking down on straw purchases, when asked what “gun control measures” he would support.

 Stauber claimed he and his wife both held “conceal and carry” permits.

Second Amendment

Stauber Said He “Adamantly” Supported The Second Amendment “Even Though I Am The Victim Of Two Gun Incidents”

Stauber Said He “Adamantly” Supported The Second Amendment After A Suspect Pointed A Gun At Him, Which Malfunctioned

The Journal: Stauber Said He “Adamantly” Supported The Second Amendment As “A Victim Of A Violent Crime” After A Suspect Pointed A Gun At Him, Which Malfunctioned. “Currently a lieutenant and West Area Commander with the Duluth Police Department, he said he is committed to protecting the rights of individuals and holding accountable those who commit crimes and disobey our laws. He has been a victim of a violent gun crime himself. ‘In December of 1995, I was shot in the head while off-duty by an individual with an extended criminal history,’ said Stauber. ‘A few years after that, while on duty, I was looking down the barrel of a handgun when the suspect pulled the trigger and, by the grace of God, the gun malfunctioned. Even after being a victim of a violent crime, I still adamantly support the Second Amendment, the right to keep and bear arms.’” [The Journal, 10/21/17]

Stauber: “Even Though I Am The Victim Of Two Gun Incidents, I Am A Strong Advocate Of The Second Amendment.” “Pete and his wife were the victim of gun violence in 1995 when Pete was shot in the head and survived. The suspect was found to have an extensive criminal record. In a separate incident, a suspect pointed a gun at Pete’s head while he was on duty but the gun malfunctioned. ‘There but for the grace of God I lived. The gun owners I have met who believe in the second amendment have been responsible and are lawful, law abiding citizens. I believe my life-saving device (gun) offers protection from those who would want to do me great bodily harm or death. Even though I am the victim of two gun incidents, I am a strong advocate of the Second Amendment.’” [Cook County News Herald, 8/12/17]

1995: Stauber’s Head Was “Grazed” By A Bullet That Was Fired At His Squad Car

Stauber Called Guns “Life-Saving Devices”

Nov. 2016: Stauber Called Guns “Life-Saving Devices” During An Introduction Speech For Vice President Mike Pence At A Campaign Rally. “Pence was introduced by Stewart Mills, Republican candidate for Minnesota’s 8th Congressional District, and by St. Louis County Commissioner Pete Stauber of Hermantown. […] Stauber praised Trump’s support for gun owner rights, noting iron ore from Northeastern Minnesota is used to produce ‘our life-saving devices that we call guns,’ and predicting Minnesota voters would ‘stand with the great Ted Nugent and Charlton Heston’ in support of Second Amendment rights to keep and use guns.” [Duluth News Tribune, 7/9/17]

Concealed Carry

Stauber Claimed He And His Wife, Jodi Stauber, Held Permits To “Conceal And Carry”

Cook County News Herald: Stauber Claimed He And His Wife, Jodi Stauber, Held Permits To “Conceal And Carry.” “Pete and his wife Jodi both hold permits to ‘conceal and carry,’ he said. Pete and his wife were the victim of gun violence in 1995 when Pete was shot in the head and survived. The suspect was found to have an extensive criminal record.” [Cook County News Herald, 8/12/17]

Gun Control

Stauber Said He Supported Enforcing Current Gun Laws, Like Cracking Down On Straw Purchases, When Asked What “Gun Control Measures” He’d Support

Stauber Said He Would Support Enforcing Current Gun Laws, Like Cracking Down On Straw Purchases, When Asked What Restrictions On Firearms And Gun Control Measures He’d Support. “QUESTION: “What restrictions on firearms, firearms sales, or other gun control measures would you support? […] STAUBER: My job, I carry a weapon with me. I’m fully trained in it. I’ve used it – I did have enough time to use it to defend my life. And I carry it with me almost 24/7. The gun I have will be used to protect me, you, or anybody else that’s in danger of great bodily harm or death. I promise you that. I swore twenty-three years ago when I raised my right hand to protect the Constitution. Part of the Constitution is the Second Amendment. With that being said, I am in favor of making sure that weapons are kept out of the hands of people that shouldn’t have them. Felons, drug dealers, habitual drugs or drug users, whatever we need to do. Because I see the gun violence. The people that use them in a dangerous fashion, I’m afraid of too. Law-abiding citizens that own guns, that have a conceal and carry permit, I’m not, as a police officer, I am not concerned of them using it wrong. It’s the ones that have it illegally. I think to have the ability to really enforce some of our gun laws, i.e. a straw purchase. Are you familiar with what a straw purchase is? AUDIENCE MEMBER: [inaudible]. STAUBER: Okay. Somebody that does that needs to be held accountable. Without question. When we enforce the current laws and hold them accountable ma’am, I think we can make a difference.” [St. Louis County Board Forum, Forum Communications Company via YouTube, updated 9/8/16] (VIDEO)

59 Health Care Issues

Significant Findings

 Stauber called Obamacare a “disaster” and saved he favored “state control over health care.”

 More than 200,000 Minnesotans stood to lose their health insurance if Obamacare was repealed through the American Health Care Act (ACHA).

 More than 21,000 Minnesotans in the 8th Congressional District stood to lose their insurance if Obamacare was repealed.

 Stauber moved and voted to hire a dozen county employees to help individuals enroll in the Affordable Care Act’s health care system.

 Stauber said he opposed a single-payer health care plan and said it would “break the bank.”

 Stauber voted to raise health insurance premiums for the county self-funded health insurance plan by 8 percent, after previously voting against a smaller increase, in order to cover a $9.2 million health.

 Stauber voted to adopt an ordinance banning e-cigarettes in public places.

 Stauber praised Trump for declaring a nationwide public health emergency to combat opioid addiction.

 Stauber voted to authorize the County to commence litigation against “pharmaceutical opioid manufacturers and distributors.”

 Stauber voted to hire two full-time social workers to assist with the opioid crisis.

Affordable Care Act (ACA)

Stauber Called Obamacare A “Disaster” And Said He Favored “State Control Over Health Care”…

…But More Than 200,000 Minnesotans Stood To Lose Their Health Insurance If Obamacare Was Repealed Through The American Health Care Act (AHCA)

217,600 Minnesotans Stood To Lose Their Health Insurance If Obamacare Was Repealed Through The American Health Care Act

Center For American Progress: 217,600 Minnesotans Stood To Lose Their Health Insurance If Obamacare Was Repealed Through The American Health Care Act. [Center for American Progress, 6/27/17]

60 137,500 Minnesotans Stood To Lose Medicaid Coverage. [Center for American Progress, 6/27/17]

79,800 Minnesotans Stood To Lose Individual Coverage. [Center for American Progress, 6/27/17]

An Estimated 21,100 Minnesotans In The 8th Congressional District Were Enrolled In The Affordable Care Act

Kaiser Family Foundation: An Estimated 21,100 Minnesotans In The 8th Congressional District Were Enrolled In The Affordable Care Act. [Kaiser Family Foundation, ACA Enrollments, 10/4/17]

Stauber Moved To Hire A Dozen County Employees To Help Individuals Enroll In The Affordable Care Act’s Health Care System.

June 2013: Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution To Hire Twelve New, Full-Time County Employees To Assist With Health Care Enrollment As Mandated By The Affordable Care Act. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Jewell, moved to authorize an increase to the staffing complement of the Public Health and Human Services Department of twelve full time equivalent (FTE) employees (11 Financial Workers and 1 Administrative Assistant I) through 2014, and a corresponding adjustment to the department’s budget for 2013 for the cost of the FTEs and the related technology expenses required to implement the first step in Medical Assistance in St. Louis County. After further discussion, the motion passed; four yeas, two nays (Dahlberg, Forsman). Resolution No. 13-364.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 6/11/13; Resolution No. 13-364]

Stauber Voted To Hire A Dozen Workers To Help Individuals Enroll In The Affordable Care Act’s Health Care System. “St. Louis County commissioners on Tuesday agreed to hire a dozen new workers to handle the influx of thousands of county residents expected to enroll in the new federal health-care system starting later this year. […] The 12 new positions are estimated to cost county taxpayers about $238,000 for the first year, although additional federal money could lower that amount, and were approved on a 4-2 vote. Commissioners Dahlberg and Forsman voted no. Commissioners Pete Stauber, O’Neil, Nelson and Jewell voted yes. Commissioner Steve Raukar was in Washington on county business.” [Duluth News Tribune, 6/12/13]

2013: The St. Louis County Board Built Up Their Reserves To Help Pay For Implementing The Affordable Care Act. “They saw it coming. And even though they were assured repeatedly the cash would be there to offset the costs of implementing federal health-care reform, St. Louis County officials started squirreling away money anyway. And now they’re glad they did. As glad as every taxpayer in the county can be, from the malls of Hermantown to the shores of Lake Kabetogama. That’s because implementing at the local level the federal Affordable Care Act is expected to cost counties throughout the state and across the U.S. big bucks, despite the initial guarantees and reports to the contrary. In St. Louis County alone, it’s expected to cost a cool $1.5 million -- just for the first year. That includes the hiring of 17 new county employees.” [Duluth News Tribune, 5/19/13]

County Health Insurance Plans

Stauber Voted To Raise Health Insurance Premiums For The Self-Funded Employee Health Insurance Plan By 8 Percent After Previously Voting Against A Smaller Increase

Stauber Voted To Raise Health Insurance Premiums By 8 Percent

61 claims administrators and the County Auditor and based on the recommendations by its Health Insurance Committee; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLIVED, That the St. Louis County Board authorizes 2018 monthly premium rates for the self-funded employee and retiree health insurance as follows: SINGLE COVERAGE: $866.01 FAMILY COVERAGE: ]$2,011.32[.]” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 11/7/17; Resolution no. 17-644, 11/7/17]

Stauber Voted Against Raising Premium By 6.5 Percent

The County Administration Recommended An 8 Percent Increase To Cover A $9.2 Million Health Insurance Short Fall

E-Cigarettes

May 2015: Stauber Voted To Adopt Ordinance Number 63 To Prohibit E-Cigarettes In Public Places, Retail Environments, And Places Of Work

May 2015: Stauber Voted To Adopt Ordinance Number 63 To Prohibit E-Cigarettes In Public Places, Retail Environments, And Places Of Work. “WHEREAS, E-cigarettes produce a vapor of undetermined and potentially harmful substances, which may appear similar to smoke emitted by traditional tobacco products; and WHEREAS, The United States Food and Drug Administration has determined that various samples of e-cigarettes from two leading manufacturers contained not only nicotine, but also detectable levels of known carcinogens and toxic chemicals; and WHEREAS, St. Louis County Ordinance Number 63 "Prohibiting Electronic Delivery Devices in Public Places, Retail Environments and Places of Work" was recommended for passage by the Public Health & Human Services Advisory Committee; and WHEREAS, The St. Louis County Board held a public hearing on May 12, 2015 at 9:40a.m., in the County Board Room, St. Louis County Courthouse, 100 N. 5th Avenue West, Duluth, 62 MN, to consider testimony on proposed Ordinance Number 63; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board of Commissioners adopts St. Louis County Ordinance Number 63, "Prohibiting Electronic Delivery Devices in Public Places, Retail Environments and Places of Work"; RESOLVED FURTHER, That the effective date for St. Louis County Ordinance Number 63 will be July 1, 2015. Commissioner Boyle moved the adoption of the Resolution and it was declared adopted upon the following vote: Yeas- Commissioners Jewell, Boyle, Nelson, Raukar and Chair Stauber- 5 Nays - Commissioners Dahlberg and Rukavina – 2[.]” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 5/12/15; Resolution No. 15-295, 5/12/15]

May 2015: Stauber Voted For A Countywide Ban On E-Cigarettes. “The proponents also were on the short end of a 5-2 vote, as the commissioners OK’d a countywide ban on e-cigarettes in public places, mimicking the statewide ban on traditional smoking in public places. The prohibition will take effect July 1. The decision will put the entire county in line with Duluth, Hermantown and Ely -- which already have bans in place. Commissioner Patrick Boyle, who sponsored the resolution, noted that this meant the prohibition was in place for nearly half of the county’s residents already. […] Commissioners Tom Rukavina and Chris Dahlberg voted against the resolution. Raukar, Boyle, Pete Stauber, Keith Nelson and Frank Jewell voted for it.” [Duluth News Tribune, 5/13/15]

May 2015: Stauber Voted Against An Amendment To Allow “Limited Product Sampling, Product Instruction, Or Testing Of An Electronic Delivery Device In A Tobacco Products Shop”

May 2015: Stauber Voted Against An Amendment To Allow “Limited Product Sampling, Product Instruction, Or Testing Of An Electronic Delivery Device In A Tobacco Products Shop.” “Commissioner Boyle, supported by Commissioner Jewell, moved to adopt St. Louis County Ordinance Number 63, “Prohibiting Electronic Delivery Devices in Public Places, Retail Environments and Places of Work”. The effective date for St. Louis County Ordinance Number 63 will be July 1, 2015. Commissioner Nelson stated that he owns a business that is licensed to sell tobacco products at retail and currently sells e-cigarettes; no Commissioners felt that there was a conflict of interest. Commissioner Raukar, supported by Commissioner Rukavina, offered an amendment to allow limited product sampling, product instruction, or testing of an electronic delivery device in a tobacco products shop. After further discussion, a roll-call vote was taken and the amendment failed; three yeas (Dahlberg, Rukavina, Raukar), four nays (Jewell, Boyle, Nelson, Stauber).” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 5/12/15]

Opioid Abuse

2017: Stauber Voted To Authorize Commencing Litigation Against “Pharmaceutical Opioid Manufacturers And Distributors And Other Parties Involved In The Opioid Epidemic”

Nov. 2017: Stauber Voted To Authorize Commencing Litigation Against “Pharmaceutical Opioid Manufacturers And Distributors And Other Parties Involved In The Opioid Epidemic.” “Commissioner Boyle, supported by Commissioner Nelson, moved to consider a request for authorization to commence litigation against pharmaceutical opioid manufacturers and distributors; the item had not been to Committee of the Whole. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Commissioner Boyle, supported by Commissioner Olson, moved to authorize the St. Louis County Attorney to commence litigation against pharmaceutical opioid manufacturers and distributors and other parties involved in the opioid epidemic; and further, that the St. Louis County Attorney is authorized to retain outside legal counsel, at his discretion, to assist and provide leadership in this litigation. St. Louis County Attorney Mark Rubin said that there are approximately sixty similar lawsuits in process throughout the country. Attorney Rubin said that a consequence of the reduction of prescribed opioid medication will be an increase in heroin demand. Vern Wagner said that St. Louis County is the first county in Minnesota to pursue this type of litigation and that he feels medical providers need to be held accountable for over-prescribing opioids. Commissioner Rukavina questioned how long litigation will take, the need for outside legal counsel, and stated that the Board should be in control of the funds if there is a settlement. The Board recessed at 10:27 a.m. and reconvened at I 0:34 a.m. with all members present. Attorney Rubin reiterated that this is the Board’s litigation and any settlement terms would be brought to the Board for approval. After further discussion, the motion passed; seven 63 yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 17-671.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 11/14/17; Resolution No. 17-671, 11/14/17]

According To St. Louis County, There Were 167 Overdose Deaths In The County Between 2011 And 2016. “The county board passed a resolution authorizing County Attorney Mark Rubin to start litigation against opioid manufacturers and distributors for being complicit and complacent in the opioid addiction epidemic. County officials say there were 167 overdose deaths in St. Louis County between 2011 and 2016, including heroin, opioids and other prescription pain medications.” [Duluth News Tribune, 11/14/17]

2017: Stauber Praised Trump For Declaring A Nationwide Public Health Emergency To Combat Opioid Addiction

2017: Stauber Praised Trump For Declaring A Nationwide Public Health Emergency To Combat Opioid Addiction. “As a 22-year veteran of the Duluth Police Department, I saw firsthand the destruction opioid abuse has caused in our communities as well as in the families who have experienced it. The effects of drug addiction extend beyond the user and impact all levels of our society. I am pleased that President Trump has declared this a Nationwide Public Health Emergency and has mobilized his Administration to address the crisis directly. I support the efforts to combat drug abuse and expand resources to those who need help the most in the fight against opioid addiction.” [Pete Stauber, press release, 10/27/17]

2016: Stauber Supported And Voted For A Motion To Hire Two Additional Full-Time Social Workers To Assist With The Opioid And Clinical Management Initiative In St. Louis County

Oct. 2016: Stauber Supported A Motion To Authorize The Hiring Of Two Additional Full Time Social Workers “To Support The Sixth Judicial District And Work As Part Of The Opioid And Clinical Case Management Initiative.” “Commissioner Boyle, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to authorize the Public Health and Human Services Department to hire two (2.0) FTE Social Workers to support the Sixth Judicial District and work as part of the Opioid and Clinical Case Management Initiative; and further, the positions will be funded from the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration grant in the amount of $75,000 for each position for a total of $150,000 per year for three years (2016-2018) with the positions ending when the grant funding ends. Commissioner Rukavina expressed concern that the majority of St. Louis County jobs were centered in Duluth. Deputy Administrator Linnea Mirsch indicated that these positions would be located in proximity to the Specialty Courts. Commissioner Dahlberg discussed his concerns that people in grant-funded positions remain employed by St. Louis County after grant funding stops. After further discussion, the motion passed; three yeas (Jewell, Boyle, Stauber), two nays (Dahlberg, Rukavina), two absent (Nelson, Raukar). Resolution No. 16-640.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 10/25/16; Resolution No. 16-640, 10/25/16]

Single-Payer

Stauber Said He Did Not Support A Single-Payer Health Care Plan And Said It Would “Break The Bank”

Aug. 2017: Stauber On Single-Payer: “If You Want To Break The Bank, If You Want To Break This Country, You Go To Single-Payer Health Care. And I Don’t Support That At All.” “DOOCY: Health care is also a hot topic with the Democrat Nolan pitching a progressive’s dream plan. NOLAN: The single payer is so fundamentally American. Countries that have single-payer do better for significantly less money. They do better in terms of life expectancy and they pay less and it’s the way that we simply have to go. DOOCY: But it’s not clear single-payer is going to fly in a district that’s barely blue. STAUBER: If you want to break the bank, if you want to break this country, you go to single-payer health care. And I don’t support that at all.” [Fox News Network, 8/23/17]

64 Housing Issues

Significant Findings

 Stauber voted to approve a two-year housing access center pilot program to prevent homelessness.

 Stauber voted to adopt a special sale of county non-conservation land to the Duluth Housing and Redevelopment Authority for low-income housing development.

Homelessness

June 2015: Stauber Voted To Approve A Two-Year Housing Access Center Pilot Program To Prevent Homelessness

June 2015: Stauber Voted To Approve A Two-Year Housing Access Center Pilot Program To Prevent Homelessness. “Commissioner Boyle, supported by Commissioner Rukavina, moved to approve the use of reserved ‘Prevention and Innovation Fund’ balance in the Public Health and Human Services Department (PHHS) budget for a two-year (2015-2016) Housing Access Center pilot program, and authorizes the transfer of $25,000 for each year from the fund to the PHHS operating budget for this purpose. The Housing Access Center (HAC) pilot program must be reviewed according to appropriate criteria during the two year period to determine if the HAC has helped reduce the approximately 500 eviction filings each year in St. Louis County through mediation efforts aimed at resolving tenant and landlord disputes. Any future funding from St. Louis County levy or grant funds applied for by St. Louis County must be approved by the St. Louis County Board. Duluth City Councilors Joel Sipress and Barb Russ spoke to the resolution. After further discussion, the motion passed; six yeas, one nay (Dahlberg). Resolution No. 15-376.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 6/9/15; Resolution No. 15-376, 6/9/15]

Public Housing

Stauber Voted To Adopt A Resolution For A Special Sale Of County Non-Conservation Land To The Duluth Housing And Redevelopment Authority For Low-Income Housing Development

Dec. 2015: Stauber Voted To Adopt A Resolution For A Special Sale Of County Non-Conservation Land To The Duluth Housing And Redevelopment Authority For Low Income Housing Development In A 5-2 Vote. “WHEREAS, The Duluth Housing and Redevelopment Authority (HRA) has requested to purchase state tax forfeited lands for the price of $40,000, plus fees, for the purpose of a low income housing development as described in County Board File No. 60098; and WHEREAS, Minn. Stat. § 282.01, Subd. 1(a), authorizes the sale of state tax forfeited land to an organized governmental subdivision for any public purpose for which the subdivision is authorized to acquire property; and WHEREAS, These parcels of land have not been withdrawn from sale pursuant to Mitu1. Stat. §§ 85.012, 92.461, 282.01, Subd. 8, and 282.018, and other statutes that require the withholding of state tax forfeited lands from sale; and WHEREAS, These parcels of land have been classified as non-conservation land pursuant to Mitu1esota Stat.§ 282.01; and WHEREAS, Mitu1. Stat. § 282.01, Subd. 1 a.( d), allows for non-conservation tax forfeited land to be sold to a governmental subdivision for less than market value if a reduced price is necessary to provide an incentive to correct blighted conditions or will lead to the development of affordable housing; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board approves the sale of state tax forfeited land, as described, to the Duluth HRA for $40,000 plus the following fees: 3% assurance fee of $1,200, deed fee of $25, deed tax of $132, recording fee of $46, for a total of $41,403 to be deposited into Fund 240 (Forfeited Tax Fund); RESOLVED FURTHER, That the St. Louis County Auditor shall offer for sale at public auction the state tax forfeited land described here if the Duluth HRA does not purchase the land by March 31, 2016.

65 Commissioner Boyle moved the adoption of the Resolution and it was declared adopted upon the following vote: Yeas- Commissioners Jewell, Boyle, Rukavina, Raukar and Chair Stauber- 5 Nays - Commissioners Dahlberg and Nelson – 2[.]” [Resolution No. 15-734, 12/1/15]

66 Labor

Significant Findings

 Stauber voted to support the “Keep Our Pensions Promises Act,” which would repeal a provision that allowed Teamsters’ Central States Fund to “cut benefits already being paid to retirees.”

Organized Labor

2016: Stauber Voted To Support The “Keep Our Pensions Promises Act” To Help Teamsters Union Members “Retain Their Central States Pension Fund Benefits”

Jan. 2016: Stauber Voted To Adopt A Resolution In Support Of The “Keep Our Pension Promises Act” And Teamsters Union Members In “Their Battle To Retain Their Central States Pension Fund Benefits.” “THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board of Commissioners hereby supports the efforts of current and retired Teamsters union members in their battle to retain their Central States Pension Fund benefits, and wishes to help ensure that other multiemployer pension plans are adequately funded for retirees through passage of the Keep Our Pension Promises Act, HR. 2844, which would repeal the provision in the 2014 federal budget, the Kline-Miller Multiemployer Pension Reform Act, that allowed pension reductions without federal oversight; RESOLVED FURTHER, That St. Louis County’s federal legislative delegation shall be provided this resolution as encouragement in the fight to protect the pensions of retired workers throughout the state of Minnesota and the nation.” [Resolution No. 16-84, 1/26/16]

The Keep Our Pensions Promises Act Would Repeal A Provision That Allowed The Teamsters’ Central States Fund “To Cut Benefits Already Being Paid To Retirees”

Congress.gov: The Bill Would Repeal “Elimination Of The Pension Anti-Cutback Provisions Under The Multiemployer Pension Reform Act Of 2014.” “This bill repeals the elimination of the pension anti-cutback provisions under the Multiemployer Pension Reform Act of 2014. The anti-cutback provisions prohibit reductions in pension benefits to participants in multiemployer pension plans. The bill amends the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) to allow a plan sponsor of an eligible multiemployer plan to petition the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation for a partition of a financially-troubled pension plan. PBGC is required to establish a legacy fund to cover the administrative and benefit costs resulting from a partition. The bill amends the federal bankruptcy code to assign first claim priority to pension obligations under ERISA. The bill amends the Internal Revenue Code to: (1) impose a limit of $1 million on the exemption of the gain from the exchange of real property in a like kind exchange, (2) prohibit the use of like kind exchanges for collectibles, (3) establish estate valuation rules for certain transfers of nonbusiness assets, and (4) limit estate tax discounts for certain individuals with minority interests in a business acquired from a decedent.” [Congress.gov, HR 2844 Bill Summary, accessed 1/16/18]

Minnesota Star Tribune: The 2014 Multiemployer Pension Reform Act Allowed “Certain Financially Stressed Plans To Cut Benefits Already Being Paid To Retirees.” “The $17 billion Central States fund is the first to seek cutbacks under the 2014 Multiemployer Pension Reform Act. The controversial law, affixed by parliamentary maneuver to a budget bill by Republican Rep. John Kline of Minnesota and former Democratic Rep. George Miller of California, allows certain financially stressed plans to cut benefits already being paid to retirees. It’s a radical shift from long-standing federal laws safeguarding private pensions, which prohibit

67 ongoing plans from cutting benefits that have already accrued. The new law creates an exception.” [Minnesota Star Tribune, 12/14/15]

Minnesota Star Tribune: The Keep Our Pensions Act Would “Pay For Pension Fund Shortfalls By Eliminating Tax Loopholes.” “Nyhan said he supports the Keep Our Pension Promises Act, which he said is the only legislative action he’s aware of that offers a meaningful solution. Nyhan said he would consider legislation combining pension cuts with direct aid to Central States. […] The Keep Our Pension Promises Act, introduced by Democratic presidential hopeful Sen. Bernie Sanders and co-sponsored by Minnesota Democratic Sens. Al Franken and Amy Klobuchar, would pay for pension fund shortfalls by eliminating tax loopholes. It has lain dormant in the Senate Finance Committee since last June.” [Minnesota Star Tribune, 5/9/16]

Rep. Rick Nolan Cosponsored The “Keep Our Pensions Promises Act”

Rep. Rick Nolan Cosponsored The “Keep Our Pensions Promises Act.” [Congress.gov, accessed 1/16/17]

The St. Louis County Resolution Stated That Congressman Rick Nolan Introduced The “Keep Our Pensions Promises Act,” Which Would “Repeal” The Kline-Miller Multiemployer Pension Reform Act. “WHEREAS, Several lawmakers, including Congressman Rick Nolan, opposing the cuts have introduced the Keep Our Pension Promises Act, HR. 2844, which would repeal the provision in the 2014 federal budget - the Kline-Miller Multiemployer Pension Reform Act - that enabled the cuts to occur without the intervention of the Federal Pension Benefit Guarantee Corp.; and WHEREAS, This bill could protect the pensions of not just the Teamsters under the Central States Pension plan, but also some 1.5 million workers in about 200 different multiemployer pension plans that are also underfunded[.]” [Resolution No. 16-84, 1/26/16]

68 Seniors’ Issues

Significant Findings

 Stauber said he was “very concerned” about fraud in the Social Security system.

 Stauber said the “best way to shore up” Social Security was to “get more people working in good jobs and pay into Social Security.”

Social Security

Fraud

Stauber Said He Was “Very Concerned” About Fraud In The Social Security System And Said “We Have To Find A Way To End That Abuse”

Aug. 2017: Stauber Said He Was “Very Concerned” About Fraud In The Social Security System And Said “We Have To Find A Way To End That Abuse.” “Nationally Social Security (SS) could someday run short of funds. When asked what can be done to shore up the program, Stauber said that in the 1940s and 1950s there were 40 to 50 workers who paid in to support one person who retired to collect SS. Today, he said only two to three people are working to pay for a retiree who collects social security. ‘I’m very concerned about fraud when it comes to Social Security. We have all read about the person who collects Social Security checks long after the recipient who is supposed to be receiving the money has died. We have to find a way to end that abuse.’” [Cook County News Herald, 8/12/17]

Funding

Stauber Said The “Best Way To Shore Up” Social Security Was To “Get More People Working In Good Jobs And Pay Into Social Security”

Aug. 2017: Stauber Said The “Best Way To Shore Up” Social Security Was To “Get More People Working In Good Jobs And Pay Into Social Security.” “Nationally Social Security (SS) could someday run short of funds. When asked what can be done to shore up the program, Stauber said that in the 1940s and 1950s there were 40 to 50 workers who paid in to support one person who retired to collect SS. Today, he said only two to three people are working to pay for a retiree who collects social security […] ‘Also, the best way to shore up the program is to get more people working in good jobs and pay into social security. It’s important to make sure our higher education and vocational school programs stay strong.’” [Cook County News Herald, 8/12/17]

69 State And Local Issues

Significant Findings

 Stauber voted to give Arrowhead Center, an addiction recover firm, management to a county youth camp over the YMCA, which cost taxpayers an extra $1.6 million in funding.

 Stauber supported Rice Lake Township in their dispute with the City of Duluth’s over annexation.

 Stauber supported conducting a poll of impacted residents before authorizing a petition to create a sanitary district for Sand Lake.

County Programs

June 2015: Stauber Voted Against Supporting A $15.5 Million Request For The Arrowhead Economic Opportunity Agency And Range Mental Health Center New Office Facility

June 2015: Stauber Voted Against A Motion To Support A Request For $15.5 Million For The St. Louis County/Arrowhead Economic Opportunity Agency And Range Mental Health Center New Office Facility. “WHEREAS, The State of Minnesota recently solicited requests for 2016 Capital Appropriations; and WHEREAS, The St. Louis County, Arrowhead Economic Opportunity Agency (AEOA) and Range Mental Health Center (RMHC) office facility was awarded $3 million in the 2014 State bonding bill for design of the facility, and possibly land acquisition and site work with no match required; and WHEREAS, This $3 million award requires St. Louis County to own and operate the facility and has necessitated that St. Louis County take an active role in project oversight, bidding and contract development; and WHEREAS, St. Louis County has also been working on preliminary programming and pre-design for a complete renovation or new construction of an office building in downtown Virginia on a similar timeline; and WHEREAS, AEOA and RMHC have asked St. Louis County to submit a second request on their behalf for construction of the planned new office facility located in the City of Virginia; and WHEREAS, This building could also meet St. Louis County office space and programming requirements while affording opportunities for construction and operating cost efficiencies, and all partners are open to possible co location of services; and WHEREAS, The 2016 Capital Appropriation would finance up to . 50% of the joint project cost estimated at $34 million and project partners have committed to funding their proportional project match; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board declares its support for the 2016 Capital Appropriation request of $15.5 million for the St. Louis County/Arrowhead Economic Opportunity Agency/Range Mental Health Center new office facility; RESOLVED FURTHER, That the St. Louis County Board designates this as its first priority bonding project for the 2016 Legislative Session. Commissioner Raukar moved the adoption of the Resolution and it was declared adopted upon the following vote: Yeas- Commissioners Jewell, Boyle, Rukavina, Nelson and Raukar- 5 Nays - Commissioners Dahlberg and Chair Stauber- 2[.]” [Resolution No. 15-379, 6/9/15]

2013: Stauber Voted To Give Arrowhead Center, An Addiction Recovery Firm, Management To A St. Louis County Youth Camp Over The YMCA, Which Cost Taxpayers An Extra $1.6 Million

Stauber Supported Giving Management Of A Longtime Youth Camp To Arrowhead Center, An Addiction Recovery Firm, Over To The YMCA

2013: Stauber Supported Giving Management Of A Longtime Youth Camp To Arrowhead Center, An Addiction Recovery Firm, Over To The YMCA. “St. Louis County commissioners appear poised to hand over management of the summer youth camp on Lake Esquagama to the Arrowhead Center, an addiction recovery operation in Virginia that would run youth and specialty camps at the county site. […] The board is trying to decide 70 which group could best run 77-year-old Camp Esquagama near Biwabik for the next decade or more. […] While other Duluth-area commissioners backed the YMCA plan, Commissioner Pete Stauber of Hermantown said he supported the Arrowhead Center because of the group’s commitment to provide camp programming to military veterans and children with special needs. He noted his wife is an Iraq war veteran, and his family has a child with Down syndrome.” [Duluth News-Tribune, 1/16/13]

Duluth News Tribune: The Arrowhead Center Proposal Would Reportedly Cost St. Louis County $2.1 Million Over Five Years, While The YMCA Plan Would Cost Only $485,000 – A $1.6 Million Difference

Duluth News Tribune: The Arrowhead Center Proposal Would Reportedly Cost St. Louis County $2.1 Million Over Five Years, While The YMCA Plan Would Cost Only $485,000 – A $1.6 Million Difference. “But County Board Chairman Chris Dahlberg of Duluth said the Arrowhead Center plan was too pricey, costing the county about $1.6 million more in capital improvements compared to the YMCA plan, adding that both proposals offered ample plans for nontraditional camping for special groups. The YMCA plan would cost the county about $485,000 over the next five years, including an annual operating subsidy of about $50,000 and $235,000 in repairs and upgrades. The Arrowhead Center proposal would cost the county about $2.1 million over five years, all of it in capital improvements.” [Duluth News-Tribune, 1/16/13]

The County Board Intended To Hand Over The Youth Camp In Order To Save Taxpayer Funds And Move Operations “Away From The County.” “Though commissioners say they want to keep the camp open and affordable for kids across the county, the vote is aimed at moving day-to-day and even year-to-year operations of the historic camp away from the county and to an organization with experience in youth camps. The board also wants to stop using taxpayer money to subsidize the camp. The county’s subsidy has jumped from about $54,000 in 2010 to $80,000 in 2011 to $180,000 in 2012.” [Duluth News-Tribune, 1/16/13]

The Duluth News Tribune Editorial Board Disagreed With Stauber’s Position To Choose The Arrowhead Center Over The YMCA

Jan. 2013: EDITORIAL: The Duluth News Tribune Urged Stauber To Consider The $1.6 Million Difference In Cost In Choosing Arrowhead Center Over The YMCA. “One Duluth-area commissioner, the newly elected Pete Stauber of Hermantown, also appears to be on the side of the Arrowhead Center. Stauber ran this fall as a fiscal conservative, so his support for the YMCA proposal could have been expected. But his wife is an Iraq War veteran, he has a child with Down syndrome, and the Arrowhead Center committed to camp programming specifically for military veterans and children with special needs. The YMCA said it also would run family and specialty camps and events but wasn’t specific. Here’s something specific Stauber can keep in mind as he considers his vote: the bottom line, $1.6 million. That’s the amount he and other commissioners stand to save -- or cost -- taxpayers as they move toward getting out of the summer camp business.” [Duluth News Tribune, Editorial, 1/22/13]

Jan. 2013: Stauber Voted To Approve The Arrowhead Center As The New Manager For Camp Esquagama

Jan. 2013: The County Board Voted To Approve Arrowhead Center As The Lake Esquagama Youth Camp’s New Manager, With Stauber Voting In Favor In A Four-Three Vote. “St. Louis County Commissioners decided in a split vote Tuesday to hire The Arrowhead Center to run the county’s summer youth camp on Lake Esquagama south of Biwabik. […] Commissioners Keith Nelson, Mike Forsman, Steve Raukar and Pete Stauber voted in favor of the Arrowhead center while Dahlberg, Steve O’Neil and Frank Jewell voted against it, favoring the YMCA plan. The board authorized county staff to enter into negotiations with The Arrowhead Center for long-term management of the camp and to determine how much money the county will provide to keep the camp afloat.” [Duluth News Tribune, 1/22/13; Resolution No. 13-67, 1/22/13]

Rice Lake Township

71 2013: Stauber Said He Would Support Rice Lake Township In The Decision On Whether To Be Annexed By The City Of Duluth

2013: Stauber Said He Would Support Rice Lake Township And Its Board In The Decision On Whether The City Of Duluth Should Annex Part Of Rice Lake Township. “St. Louis County Commissioner Pete Stauber, who represents the residents of Rice Lake Township and other areas in the 5th District, said: ‘My whole role is to support the township and its board, because townships are an important form of local government.’ Accordingly, Stauber said he hopes Duluth will honor the wishes of township residents, but he freely admitted he likely will have little say in the matter. ‘The county doesn’t have much standing on an issue like this,’ he said.” [Duluth News Tribune, 11/14/13]

2015: Rice Lake Township Voted To Become A City Rather Than A Township, Which Thwarted The Threat Of Future Annexation By Other Cities. “John Werner, a town supervisor, lifelong resident and supporter of incorporation, said the move was needed to retain Rice Lake’s identity. ‘The main reason (to incorporate) was to remove the threat of annexation’ by Duluth, Werner said. ‘It was simply no longer an option to remain a township. But the people clearly wanted to remain Rice Lake. So now we are the city of Rice Lake.’ […] The incorporation effort began in June 2014 when the town board passed a resolution to petition the state to become a city, in part because Duluth officials had earlier suggested Duluth should annex part of the township. A public hearing was held last November, with strong support for incorporation. Rice Lake formally applied for city status in January.” [Duluth News Tribune, 8/21/15]

Sanitation

2017: Stauber Voted To Conduct A Poll Of Impacted Residents Instead Of Authorizing A Petition To Create A Sanitary District For Sand Lake

Stauber Voted To Authorize A Poll Of All Impacted Property Owners Around Sand Lake Before Consideration A Petition For A Sanitary District

Nov. 2017: Stauber Voted To Authorize The Environmental Services Department “To Conduct A Poll Of All Impacted Property Owners” Before Further Consideration Of A Petition For A Sanitary District. “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Jugovich, moved that prior to further consideration of the petition to the Minnesota Office of Administrative Hearings for the creation of the Sand Lake Sanitary District, the St. Louis County Board directs the Environmental Services Department to conduct a poll of all impacted property owners to ascertain whether or not each property owner supports the creation of an independent sanitary sewer district and the concept of the construction of a community sewer system. A roll call vote was taken and the motion passed; four yeas (Boyle, Stauber, Nelson, Jugovich), three nays (Jewell, Olson, Rukavina). Resolution No. 17- 689.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 11/28/17; Resolution No. 17-689, 11/28/17]

Stauber Voted Against Authorizing A Petition For The Creation Of A Sand Lake Sanitary District

Nov. 2017: Stauber Voted Against Authorizing A Petition For The Creation Of A Sand Lake Sanitary District. “Commissioner Rukavina, supported by Commissioner Jewell, moved to authorize the petition to the Minnesota Office of Administrative Hearings for the creation of the Sand Lake Sanitary District. Commissioner Nelson felt more outreach, education, and buy in from the community was necessary before moving forward. Commissioner Nelson offered an alternate resolution directing the St. Louis County Environmental Services Department to conduct a poll to determine support for the creation of an independent sanitary sewer district; Chair Jewell said there was a resolution on the floor for discussion. […] Commissioner Olson indicated that it appears the majority of communication and people speaking have been opposed to the creation of a district. A roll call vote was taken and the motion failed; two yeas (Jewell, Rukavina), five nays (Boyle, Olson, Stauber, Nelson, Jugovich).” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 11/28/17]

72 Stauber “Expressed Concern Regarding Seasonal Residents Not Having A Voice In The Process” If The Petition To Create A Sanitary District Moved Forward. “Commissioner Nelson moved to call the question; Chair Jewell said that before the question is called, everyone at the table has a right to speak. Commissioner Stauber expressed concern regarding seasonal residents not having a voice in the process if the process moved forward. Chair Jewell indicated that he was not in favor of conducting additional surveys and it seems more sensible to move forward with the process so property owners can get more information to make decisions.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 11/28/17]

2014: Stauber Was Absent For A Vote On A “Controversial Provision” To Require Funds Be Placed In Escrow Accounts For Homes With Older, Non-Functional Septic Systems

Feb. 2014: Stauber Was Absent For A Vote To Adopt New Sewage Treatment Rules “Aimed At Protecting Water Quality While Making It Easier For Rural Homeowners To Meet State Regulations.” “St. Louis County commissioners on Tuesday approved sweeping new rules for septic systems across the county aimed at protecting water quality while making it easier for rural homeowners to meet state regulations. […] The board voted 5-to-1 in favor of the new septic rules. Commissioners Keith Nelson of Fayal Township, Mike Forsman of Ely, Steve Raukar of Hibbing, and Frank Jewell and Patrick Boyle of Duluth voted in favor; Commissioner Chris Dahlberg of Duluth voted no. Commissioner Pete Stauber of Hermantown is out of the country.” [Duluth News Tribune, 2/26/14]

The Rules Included A “Controversial Provision” That Required Money Be Reserved Through An Escrow Account For Homes With Older, Non-Functional Septic Systems. “The new rules, demanded by state lawmakers and in the works for seven years, include a controversial provision requiring that money be placed in an escrow account for any homes sold where an older septic system has not been tested and confirmed as functional. At least 20 other Minnesota counties have a similar requirement, which St. Louis County staff said is needed to make sure septic systems are tested before any home is sold and, if they don’t work properly, that new systems are installed.” [Duluth News Tribune, 2/26/14]

The County Board Adopted A Resolution To Adopt Ordinance No. 61, “Subsurface Sewage Treatment System Regulations.” “WHEREAS, St. Louis County through its Environmental Services Department has responsibility for administration of an Onsite Wastewater program authorizing and providing for sewage treatment and dispersal in un-sewered properties in the county; and WHEREAS, St. Louis County administers this program through an ordinance developed to meet requirements of state law and rule for onsite wastewater management; and WHEREAS, The State of Minnesota requires that all counties update their onsite wastewater management ordinances by February 8, 2014 to incorporate requirements of state law and rule changes established since the passage of the existing ordinances; and WHEREAS, St. Louis County has developed Ordinance No. 61 to comply with the requirements of the State of Minnesota; and WHEREAS, After soliciting comments for 60 days, on December 12, 2013 and continuing on January 21, 2014, the Planning Commission held a public hearing regarding the proposed St. Louis County Ordinance No. 61, Subsurface Sewage Treatment System Regulations, and recommended adoption of the ordinance with several modifications; and WHEREAS, St. Louis County Environmental Services Department has considered all proposed modifications, and has forwarded Ordinance No. 61 for final adoption by the County Board; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board hereby adopts Ordinance No. 61, as contained in County Board File No. 59812, effective February 26,2014.” [Resolution No. 14-124, 2/25/14]

Lawsuits Against St. Louis County

2017: Stauber Voted To Award A $20,000 Settlement To A Consistent Who Sued St. Louis County For Wrongful Arrest

July 2017: Stauber Voted To Award A $20,000 Settlement To Ronald Gustafson, Who Commenced An Action Against The County. “WHEREAS, In December 2016, Ronald G. Gustafson commenced an action against St. Louis County and other defendants; and WHEREAS, The action, captioned Gustafson v. St. Louis County, Case 73 No. 69DU-CV-17-848, is pending before the State of Minnesota District Court for the Sixth Judicial District in Duluth; and WHEREAS, The parties to the action have participated in mediation and reached agreement on a proposed settlement that is subject to the approval of the St. Louis County Board; and WHEREAS, Under the proposed settlement, Gustafson will release his claims relating to the facts and circumstances alleged in the complaint, and St. Louis County will make a settlement payment in the amount of $20,000.00; and WHEREAS, The St. Louis County Board wishes to approve the proposed settlement to avoid the expense and risk associated with further litigation; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board approves the proposed settlement and authorizes the appropriate county officials to negotiate and execute appropriate settlement documents and to make the settlement payment contemplated by the proposed settlement in the amount of $20,000.00, payable from Fund 720, Agency 720001, Expense Code 636200. Commissioner Rukavina moved the adoption of the Resolution and it was declared adopted upon the following vote: Yeas- Commissioners Boyle, Olson, Rukavina, Stauber, Nelson, Jugovich and Chair Jewell- 7 Nays- None[.]” [Resolution No. 17-447, 7/11/17]

Herald Review: Gustafson Sued The County For Wrongful Arrest. “ Grand Rapids man who was wrongly arrested and jailed will get $20,000 from St. Louis County in an out-of-court legal settlement approved Tuesday by the county board. Ronald Gary Gustafson also received $22,500 from the city of Duluth and apparently will get another $15,000 from Itasca County as part of the negotiated settlement. Gustafson was arrested on May 8, 2015 in Grand Rapids and spent five days in three different jails after being mistaken for another man with the same name. The city of Duluth had issued a warrant for a Ronald Joel Gustafson for failing to appear in court on the misdemeanor charge of tampering with a motor vehicle.” [Herald Review, 7/1317]

2016: Stauber Voted To Approve A $57,194.76 Settlement To Western National Mutual Insurance Company After A Motor Vehicle Accident With A Snowplow Owned By The County

July 2016: Stauber Voted To Approve A $57,194.76 Settlement To Western National Mutual Insurance Company After A Motor Vehicle Accident With A Snowplow Owned By The County. “Commissioner Jewell, supported by Commissioner Nelson, moved to approve the proposed settlement with Western National Mutual Insurance, authorize the appropriate county officials to negotiate and execute appropriate settlement documents, and to make the settlement payment contemplated by the proposed settlement in the amount of $57,194.76. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 16-479.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/26/16; Resolution No. 16-479, 7/26/16]

2015: Stauber Voted To Adopt A $112,500 Settlement To Two Constituents Who Accused St. Louis County Employees Of Invading Their Privacy By Illegally Using A County Database

Dec. 2015: Stauber Voted To Adopt A Resolution Settling A Complaint Against St. Louis County For $112,500. “WHEREAS, In January 2013, Jennifer Rae Heglund and Jamie Lee Heglund commenced an action against St. Louis County; and WHEREAS, In April 2015, the Heglunds filed an amended complaint naming eight employees of St. Louis County as additional defendants in the action; and WHEREAS, The action, captioned Heglund v. Aitkin County, Case No. 0:14-cv-00296-ADM-LIB, is pending before the United States District Court for the District of Minnesota in Minneapolis, Minnesota; and WHEREAS, The Heglunds and St. Louis County have reached an agreement on a proposed settlement that is subject to the approval of the St. Louis County Board; and WHEREAS, Under the proposed settlement, the Heglunds will release certain claims against the defendants and St. Louis County will make a settlement payment in the amount of $112,500 with no admission of fault or liability; and WHEREAS, The St. Louis County Board wishes to approve the proposed settlement to avoid the expense and risk associated with further litigation; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board approves the proposed settlement and authorizes the appropriate county officials to negotiate and execute appropriate settlement documents and to make the settlement payment contemplated by the proposed settlement in the amount of $112,500, payable from Fund 720, Agency 720001, Expense Code 636200. Commissioner Jewell moved the adoption of the Resolution and it was declared adopted upon the following vote: Yeas- Commissioners Jewell, Boyle, Dahlberg, Rukavina, Nelson, Raukar and Chair Stauber- 7 Nays- None[.]” [Resolution No. 15-736, 12/1/15]

74 Jennifer Rae And Jamie Lee Heglund Accused Eight St. Louis County Employees Of Invading Their Privacy By Illegally Using A County Database. “The Driver and Vehicle Services Division of the Minnesota Department of Public Safety (“DPS”) maintains a password protected database of Minnesota drivers’ motor vehicle records (“DVS database”), which includes each licensed driver’s name, date of birth, driver’s license number, address, photograph, weight, height, eye color, social security number, and some limited health and disability information. Compl. [Docket No. 1] ¶¶ 101-02. Law enforcement personnel and other state agency employees have access to the DVS database through either a DVS website or a system operated by the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension. Each state employee who is authorized access is issued a password allowing entry to the DVS database. In 2013, Plaintiffs requested and received an audit report prepared by the DPS. Id. ¶ 407. The report reflects that law enforcement or other state agency employees with DVS passwords viewed Plaintiffs’ driver’s license information at various times and from various locations from 2003-2013. Compl. Exs. A and B (“DPS Audit” for Jennifer and Jamie Heglund, respectively) ‘Upon information and belief,’ Plaintiffs allege each of these views, or ‘look-ups,’ was illegal, that is, viewed without a federally-permitted purpose.” [U.S. Government Publishing Office, Case No. 0:14-cv-00296-ADM-LIB, filed 7/22/14]

2014: Stauber Voted To Approve A $199,500 Settlement In A Personal Injury Case Against The St. Louis Sheriff’s Department

Oct. 2014: Stauber Voted To Approve A $199,500 Settlement In The Griesbach V. County Of St. Louis Case. “Commissioner Jewell, supported by Commissioner Boyle, moved to approve the proposed settlement in Griesbach v. County of St. Louis, Case No. 69DU-CV-14-1464 and authorizes the appropriate county officials to negotiate and execute appropriate settlement documents and to make the payments contemplated by the proposed settlement in the aggregate amount of $199,500. St. Louis County Civil Division Head Kim Maki discussed incident and the settlement terms. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 14-563.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 10/14/14; Resolution 14-563, 10/14/14]

The Case Was A Personal Injury Case Against The St. Louis Sheriff’s Department. [Minnesota Civil Court Records search, case no. 69DC-CV-14-1464, accessed 12/14/17]

2014: Stauber Voted To Approve A Mediated $100,000 Settlement In A Wrongful Death Case Against The County

Aug. 2014: Stauber Voted To Approve A Mediated $100,000 Settlement In A Wrongful Death Case Against The County. “WHEREAS, In April 2014, Steve Wilson, trustee for the next of kin of Hannah Wilson, commenced a wrongful-death action against St. Louis County and three other defendants; and WHEREAS, The action, captioned Wilson v. Reed, Case No. 69YI-CV-14-258, is pending before the Minnesota District Court for the Sixth Judicial District in Virginia, Minnesota; and WHEREAS, St. Louis County has denied liability in the action; and WHEREAS, In July 2014, the parties to the action participated in a mediation and entered into a mediated settlement agreement that is subject to the approval of the St. Louis County Board; and WHEREAS, The mediated settlement agreement calls for St. Louis County to make a settlement payment in the amount of $100,000; and WHEREAS, The St. Louis County Board wishes to approve the mediated settlement agreement to avoid the expense and risk associated with further litigation and without admitting liability; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOL YEO, That the St. Louis County Board approves the mediated settlement agreement and authorizes the appropriate county officials to negotiate and enter into the settlement documents contemplated by the mediated settlement agreement and to make the settlement payment in the amount of $100,000 payable from Fund 720, Agency 720001, Expense Code 636200. Commissioner Jewell moved the adoption of the Resolution and it was declared adopted upon the following vote: Yeas- Commissioners Jewell, Boyle, Dahlberg, Stauber, Raukar and Chair Forsman – 6 Nays - Commissioner Nelson - 1” [Resolution No. 14-458, 8/12/14]

St. Louis County Paid $100,00 “To The Family Of A Girl Killed In A 2012 Car Accident In Eveleth,” Who Said An “Improperly Placed Road Construction Sign Contributed To Her Death.” “St. Louis County will pay $100,000 to the family of a girl killed in a 2012 car accident in Eveleth, following a court-mediated settlement. The county was named as one of several defendants in a wrongful death lawsuit filed in May by the family of Hannah

75 Wilson who say an improperly placed road construction sign contributed to her death.” [Duluth News Tribune, 8/11/14]

76 Tax Issues

Significant Findings

 Stauber praised the House of Representative’s passage of the Republican Tax Scam bill, which punished the poorest Minnesotans and prioritized the richest.

 While Stauber sat on the Board of Commissioners, property taxes rose more than $20 million – 18 percent.

 Stauber voted to raise the property tax levy four times as a County Commissioner.

 Stauber voted to increase the county sales tax by 0.5 percent to fund transportation improvements.

 Stauber voted to stop charging cities and townships assessment fees.

 Stauber voted against asking the State of Minnesota to restore a tax on taconite.

 Stauber voted to direct the county to find ways to freeze property taxes for senior citizens.

 Stauber supported easing taxes for small businesses.

Local Taxes & Fees

While Stauber Sat On The Board Of Commissioners, Property Taxes Rose More Than $20 Million – 18 Percent

Stauber Voted To Approve The Budget & Tax Levy Each Year – Increasing Property Taxes By More Than $20 Million Or 18.37 Percent

Stauber Voted Four Times To Raise The Property Tax Levy After Campaigning To Lower Taxes

Stauber Campaigned On Bringing The Final Property Tax Levy Down To One Percent Or Less As County Commissioner

77 2012: Duluth News Tribune: Stauber Said He Supported Bringing The Final Property Tax Levy Down To 1 Percent Or Less. “Budget and levy[.] Even challengers were hard-pressed to argue against the county board’s move last week setting their preliminary 2013 property tax levy increase at 1.5 percent. The final levy, set in December, could go lower, but can’t go higher. Incumbents generally said the number reflected a balance between increasing needs for law enforcement, roads, bridges and other county services weighed against a lingering recession and property owners’ already high taxes. Dahlberg and Stauber said they would like to see additional cuts to bring the final levy increase down to 1 percent or less.” [Duluth News Tribune, 9/18/12]

2017: Stauber Voted For The 2018 Budget And Levy Resolution, Which Increased The Property Tax Levy By 4.45 Percent

Dec. 2017: Stauber Voted For The 2018 Budget And Levy Resolution. [Resolution No. 17-739, 12/19/17]

2016: Stauber Voted For To Approve A Maximum 8.5 Percent Increase In The Property Tax Levy

Dec. 2016: Stauber Voted Against Amending The 2017 Property Tax Levy And Budget “To Lower The Unorganized Township Road Levy By $250,000.” “Commissioner Rukavina, supported by Commissioner Jewell, moved to amend the 2017 Property Tax Levy and Budget Resolution to lower the Unorganized Township Road levy by $250,000 and ask Public Works to reduce their budget by $250,000. Commissioner Dahlberg stepped out of the meeting from 10:53 a.m. to 10:59 a.m. Commissioner Rukavina said increases to 78 the Unorganized Township Road levy since 2009, were unfair to unorganized township residents. Public Works Director Jim Foldesi indicated that a $250,000 budget reduction would affect the 5-year plan and would result in delivery of less road and bridge projects. After further discussion, the motion failed; two yeas (Rukavina, Jewell), five nays (Boyle, Dahlberg, Stauber, Nelson, Raukar).” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 12/20/16]

2015: Stauber Voted For The 2016 Budget And Levy Resolution, Which Did Not Raise The Property Tax Levy

2015: Stauber Voted For The 2016 Budget And Levy Resolution. [Resolution No. 15-766, 12/15/15]

2015: Stauber Was The Board Chairman When The 2016 Budget Did Not Increase The County’s Levy. “Board Chairman Pete Stauber of Hermantown praised fellow commissioners and county staff for their efforts to reach the 0 percent levy increase goal that was set by the board earlier in the year. ‘I am extremely proud to chair the board in a year when we’ve worked so hard to overcome challenges, and I anticipate a zero percent levy increase,’ said Stauber.” [Mesabi Daily News, 9/9/15]

Stauber Applauded The 2016 Budget For Not Increasing The County’s Levy. “The St. Louis County Board has approved its 2016 budget in the amount of $358,733,410. Of most significance to tax payers is the fact that it includes no change in the levy, which will translate into a decrease in the county portion of property tax statements 79 for most residents and business owners. […] ‘It is really remarkable in these times that we have achieved a zero percent increase in the levy, and it is the culmination of a lot of work and some great ideas by my fellow commissioners and department heads,’ said County Board Chair Pete Stauber. ‘It is important that we are ever mindful of the levy impact on our citizens and businesses.’ […] Commissioner Stauber noted that the Board made it a priority throughout the year to work toward a zero levy increase while not cutting services.” [St. Louis County, press release, 12/15/15]

Stauber Wrote He Was Proud Of The 2016 Budget For Not Increasing The Levy While Maintaining Services. “Speaking on behalf of the board, I am proud the 2016 St. Louis County property tax levy will not be increased, despite cost pressures and other financial challenges. We accomplished this with good long-term planning and managing of finances. […] This is a significant accomplishment. Only a small number of Minnesota counties will hold the line on property tax growth in 2016. As we provide services required by the state with flat or dwindling state and federal dollars, we worked creatively and made difficult decisions. That said, the 2016 budget ensures we will continue the services our citizens expect and deserve.” [Duluth Budgeteer, Kevin Z. Gray and Pete Stauber op-ed, 9/25/15]

2014: Stauber Voted For The 2015 Budget And Levy Resolution, Which Reportedly Increased The Property Tax Levy By 2.9 Percent

Sept. 2014: Stauber Voted To Adopt A Maximum Levy Tax Of $116,631,193 For St. Louis County. “WHEREAS, The St. Louis County Board must establish a maximum proposed property tax levy and have this amount certified to the County Auditor by the St. Louis County Board by September 30, 2014; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board certifies the maximum property tax levy for 2015 in the amount of$116,631,193.00.” [Resolution No. 14-513, 9/23/14]

2013: Stauber Voted For The 2014 Budget And Levy Resolution, Which Reportedly Increased The Property Tax Levy By 1.5 Percent

Duluth News Tribune: The Taxy Levy Increased By 1.5 Percent. “The 8.5 percent levy increase, if it holds, would be the highest in a decade for the county. Last year the county had zero increase in levy, which saw 80 many homeowners property taxes going down. That compares to a 2.9 percent levy increase in 2015; a 1.5 percent increase in 2013 and 2014; and a 1.8 percent increase in 2012.” [Duluth News Tribune, 9/13/16]

Dec. 2014: Stauber Voted To Increase The County Sales Tax By A Half Percent To Fund Transportation Improvements

Stauber Voted To Adopt A Resolution Implementing A 0.5 Percent Sales Tax And $20 Per Motor Vehicle Tax To Help Fund Transportation Improvements

81 FURTHER, That the provisions of Minn. Stat. § 297 A.99, Subdivisions 4, and 6 through 12, shall govern the imposition, administration, collection and enforcement of the tax; RESOLVED FURTHER, That the St. Louis County Board of Commissioners hereby directs the County Auditor to certify the tax to the Minnesota Department of Revenue for collection of the sales and excise tax on or before December 31, 2014.” [Resolution No. 14-665, 12/4/14]

Stauber Voted Against An Amendment That Would Dedicate Part Of The Sales Tax To Duluth

Stauber Reportedly Voted Against An Amendment That Would Dedicate Part Of The Sales Tax To Duluth. “An amendment forwarded by Commissioner Frank Jewell of Duluth that would have dedicated a portion of the new money to specific Duluth road projects failed by a 4-3 vote, highlighting what has become a contentious north- south rift on the board, the latest in a long line of Duluth-Iron Range kerfuffles. […] ‘I refuse to let this become a north-south issue,’’ said Commissioner Pete Stauber of Hermantown. Stauber voted against the amendment that would have dedicated part of the sales tax to Duluth. But he later proposed an amendment that directs county staff to work with all cities and townships to forward the projects that are most needed. The amendment passed 6-0.” [Duluth News Tribune, 12/2/14]

Dec. 2014: Stauber Voted Against An Amendment To Include “Additional Projects” In The Original Sales And Motor Vehicle Tax Proposal. “Commissioner Raukar, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to authorize and implement a 0.5% sales tax and an excise tax of $20 per motor vehicle as provided for in Minnesota Statutes beginning April 1, 2015, for the purpose of funding transportation improvements as identified in the ‘St. Louis County Greater MN Transportation Sales and Use Tax Transportation Improvement Plan’, dated December 2, 2014 (County Board File No. 59971). Chair Forsman opened the floor to persons who wished to address the Board concerning the proposal. The following persons addressed the Board: David Brenna, Mayor of the City of Proctor, expressed concerns regarding the distribution of the tax proceeds and the impact the proposal may have on the City of Proctor’s proposed sales tax. Commissioner Jewell, supported by Commissioner Boyle, put forth an amendment to the original proposal to include additional projects. Chair Forsman asked if anyone wished to address the Board regarding the proposed amendment, and no one came forth. After further Commissioner discussion, the amendment failed; three yeas (Boyle, Dahlberg, Jewell), four nays (Stauber, Nelson, Raukar, Forsman). Commissioner Jewell stepped out of the meeting from 11:03 a.m. to 11:05 a.m.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 12/2/14]

Duluth News Tribune: Some Duluth Officials Opposed The Sales Tax And Argued That Revenues Would Benefit “Rural Areas At The Expense Of The City.” “With highway reconstruction now costing nearly $2 million per mile, and without some new source of money for road repairs, ‘we will have a point where people can’t get to where they need to go,’’ said Commissioner Mike Forsman of Ely. But critics, namely Duluth officials, say the new tax benefits rural areas at the expense of the city. Duluth officials noted that 55 percent of the tax would be raised in the city -- some 73 percent if Hermantown and Proctor are included -- yet most of the county’s road miles are outside the Duluth metro area.” [Duluth News Tribune, 12/2/14]

Dec. 2014: Bill Stauber, Pete Stauber’s Brother, Publicly Supported The Proposed Sales Tax During A Board Of Commissioner’s Meeting

Dec. 2014: Bill Stauber, Pete Stauber’s Brother, Publicly Supported A Proposed Sales Tax During A Board Of Commissioner’s Meeting. “Citizen discussion continued regarding the proposal. Bill Stauber, of Duluth, MN, 82 said he supports the sales tax. Commissioner Stauber disclosed that Bill Stauber is his brother and they own a local business together. Scott Dane, Executive Director of the Associated Contract Loggers and Truckers, spoke in favor of the proposal. Timothy Herstead, of Rice Lake Township, said he is against the tax and expressed concerns about the timing of the amendment.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 12/2/14]

2013: Stauber Voted To Stop Charging Cities And Townships Assessment Fees, Which Reportedly Would Result In $1.3 Million In Revenue Loss For The County

The St. Louis County Board Voted Unanimously To Stop Charging Cities And Townships For Assessment Fees, Which Would Reportedly Result In A $1.3 Million Revenue Loss For The County

2013: The St. Louis County Board Voted Unanimously To Stop Charging Cities And Townships For Assessment Fees, Which Would Reportedly Result In A $1.3 Million Revenue Loss For The County. “Come Jan. 1, 2014, St. Louis County will no longer be charging cities and townships for assessment services. The board voted in the affirmative Tuesday, adopting a resolution that approved eliminating the assessment fees. The vote was 6-0. The measure is expected to save local units of government up to $2 million annually, according to a county press release. On the flip side, the move is expected to result in the loss of about $1.3 million in revenue in 2014 for the county.” [Hibbing Daily Tribune, 9/25/13; Resolution No. 13-595, 9/24/13]

Ely Echo: The Cost Was Reportedly “Absorbed” Into The County’s Overall Levy, Which Would “Jump 1.5 Percent To About $113.3 Million In 2014.” “For the county, the decision costs about $1.5 million, according to Commissioner Mike Forsman of Ely. That expense is absorbed into the county’s overall levy, which will jump 1.5 percent to about $113.3 million in 2014. But county officials supported the measure, citing the recommendation of a 2012 ‘blue ribbon’ panel that explored assessment practices and found problems with the way real estate was assessed across the county. Currently, assess-ment is done in an assortment of ways, with most cities and townships already contracting with the county for assess-ment while others, Including Babbitt, either hiring their own assessors or contracting for the service.” [Ely Echo, 9/28/13]

Ely Echo: The Vote Would Reportedly Save The City Of Ely $37,000, Morse Township $31,000, And Babbitt $32,000. “St. Louis County finalized a move this week that’s expected to bring significant savings to several local government entities. By taking on assessment services county wide and offering it to local units of government at no charge, the county is taking on a function formerly assumed - and paid for - by area governments. The move, approved Tuesday on a 6-0 vote when the county board met in Ely, will save the city of Ely $37,000 next year. Morse Township will save nearly as much, with the county absorbing a service that previously cost the township $31,000. Nearby Babbitt will save $32,000 if it opts to have the county take over property assessment.” [Ely Echo, 9/28/13]

Stauber Was Reportedly “Responsible” For Bringing The Proposal Forward

Hibbing Daily Tribune: Stauber Was Reportedly “Responsible For Bringing The Proposal Forward” And Argued That Residents Could Either Used The Saved Funds For “Property Tax Relief” Or Personal Savings. “[Stauber] was responsible for bringing the proposal forward. Stauber argued that residents can use the money saved for property tax relief or redirect the savings toward other expenses. It was the Blue Ribbon panel charged with studying assessment practices that recommended a similar measure back in 2012. The panel suggested that the board go to a ‘true assessment system,’ which would make the county auditor responsible for conducting all assessments throughout the county.” [Hibbing Daily Tribune, 9/25/13]

Stauber Said The Decision Was A “Catch-22” Because Of Its Potential Impact On Local Contractors

Stauber Said Eliminating Assessment Fees Would Allow Local Government “The Opportunity To Use The County For Assessment Services Without Cost Being An Issue.” “‘By eliminating fees, this affords local government units the opportunity to use the county for assessor services with-out cost being an issue,’ Commissioner Pete Stauber was quoted in the release.” [Hibbing Daily Tribune, 9/25/13] 83

Ely Echo: Stauber Called The Decision A “Catch-22” And Said He Hoped County Administration Would Aleve Effects On Local Private Contractors. “But for the dozen or so private assessors who now work for various units of government, the move puts their future employment in jeopardy, a point of contention particularly for Forsman. […] Other commissioners said they preferred to stop short of a directive and said they trusted county staff to consider the skills of the soon-to-be-displaced local assessors. Commissioner Pete Stauber of Hermantown, who advanced the recommendation, said he ‘hopes the administration and board take steps to mitigate the affect on local assessors.’ ‘The last thing I want to do is have this be a negative effect on private contractors,’ said Stauber. ‘There’s a catch-22 for me as well. We know we have qualified local assessors who do a great job.’” [Ely Echo, 9/28/13]

2015: Stauber Voted Against Asking The State Of Minnesota To Restore A Tax On Taconite

April 2015: Stauber Voted Against Asking The State Of Minnesota To Restore A Tax On Taconite In A 4-2 Vote. “St. Louis County Commissioners voted Tuesday to ask for the 5-cents-per-ton taconite tax back that state lawmakers took away in 2014. The board voted 4-2 to ask lawmakers to restore the lost nickel per ton of taconite shipped, which amounts to $1.68 million each year, nearly $17 million over 10 years. […] Commissioners Nelson and Pete Stauber of Hermantown voted against asking for the taconite tax money back; Rukavina, Dahlberg, Jewell and Raukar voted in favor of the resolution.” [Duluth News Tribune, 4/7/15; Resolution No. 15-189, 4/7/15]

The State Of Minnesota Redistributed Revenue From The Taconite Tax, Which Was Paid By Mining Companies In Lieu Of Property Taxes, To Help Fund School Districts Pay Off Bonds. “The money was part of the county’s share of taconite production taxes paid by mining companies instead of property taxes. But lawmakers last year redistributed 5 cents per ton of from each county in the region and gave it to some Iron Range school districts for 10 years to help pay off bonds for new construction projects that result from school consolidations. The change in how taconite taxes are doled out was included in the larger 2014 omnibus tax bill with no hearing or public input on the taconite tax element, supporters of the county resolution noted.” [Duluth News Tribune, 4/7/15]

2017: Stauber Voted To Direct The County To Find Ways To Freeze Property Taxes For Senior Citizens

March 2017: The County Board Voted Unanimously To Look Into Ways To Freeze Property Taxes For Senior Citizens By Changing A State Law That Prohibits Giving Senior Citizens “A Special Break” On Property Assessments For Tax Purposes. “St. Louis County commissioners on Tuesday unanimously directed county staff to look into possible ways to freeze property tax values for senior citizens. State law currently prohibits local governments for giving seniors a special break on how much their home is valued for tax purposes. But Commissioner Pete Stauber of Hermantown said he wants the county to look into leading an effort to change that law. The resolution notes that 10 states already allow valuation limits or freezing of senior home values for tax purposes, with the option usually left up to the local taxing authority.” [Duluth News Tribune, 3/7/17]

NOTE: Further research necessary to locate the specific resolution number.

The Tax Cuts & Jobs Act

Nov. 2017: Stauber Praised The House’s Passage Of The Tax Cuts And Jobs Act And Said It Would “Bring Much-Needed Relief” To Middle Class Families In Minnesota…

Nov. 2017: Stauber Praised The House’s Passage Of The Tax Cuts And Jobs Act And Said It Would Lower Individual Taxes And Increase The Standard Deduction For Families. “Pete Stauber, who is running for the U.S. Congress from Minnesota’s 8th Congressional District, issued this statement today: ‘I am pleased that the House voted today to pass tax reform and bring much-needed relief to the middle-class families of Minnesota. The plan not only lowers individual tax rates for low and middle-income Americans, it also increases the standard 84 deduction so families can keep more of what they earn. With 50 percent of families living paycheck-to-paycheck, this is a step in the right direction and a win for Minnesota families who will get to keep more from their paychecks each year.’” [Pete Stauber, press release, 11/16/17]

…But The Tax Cuts And Jobs Act Raised Taxes For Low- And Middle-Income Minnesota Families While Giving The Richest 1 Percent “An Outsized Share” Of The Tax Cuts…

The Final GOP-Trump Tax Bill Would Raise Taxes For The Poorest 20 Percent Of Minnesotans In 2027

24 Percent Of Middle-Income Households In Minnesota Would Receive Tax Increases In 2027

Center On Budget And Policy Priorities: 24 Percent Of Households In Minnesota Earning Under $153,800 Would Receive Tax Increases In 2027. [Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, accessed 1/31/18]

The Richest Minnesota Taxpayers Received “An Outsized Share” Of Tax Cuts

The Final GOP-Trump Bill Capped The State And Local Tax (SALT) Deduction To Just $10,000 – But 90 Percent Of Middle Class St. Louis County Filers Claimed SALT Deductions In 2015

*The National Association of Counties defined middle income brackets as those earning less than $200,000.

The Final GOP-Trump Tax Bill Would Allow Individual Tax Cuts To Expire In 2025 While Reductions For Businesses Remain Permanent

86 …And Could Cost As Many As 27,600 MN-08 Residents Their Health Coverage

The Final Tax Bill Could Reduce Health Care Coverage For As Many As 31,000 People In CA-49

The Tax Cuts And Jobs Act Would Increase Incentives To Move Jobs Overseas

HEADLINE: “Trump Promised ‘America First’ Would Keep Jobs Here. But The Tax Plan Might Push Them Overseas.” [Washington Post, 12/15/17]

Gene Sperling: GOP Tax Bill Would “Give A Permanent Preference To Foreign Income And Lead Companies To Shift More Profits To Tax Havens Knowing That They Could Permanently Avoid Virtually All Taxation On Such Profits.” “Yet, it is clear that a territorial system could have just the opposite impact: It could give a permanent preference to foreign income and lead companies to shift more profits to tax havens knowing that they could permanently avoid virtually all taxation on such profits. […] What was problematic about

87 this design was that it not only encouraged companies to move profits to tax havens, but it actually encouraged them to simultaneously move jobs and operations such as manufacturing to industrialized countries that had typical tax rates and to shift more profits to tax havens.” [The Atlantic, Gene Sperling, 12/8/17]

Tax Cuts And Jobs Act Would Raise Taxes On Millions

HEADLINE: “Republican Plan Would Raise Taxes On Millions.” [New York Times, 11/6/17]

Politifact Found In 2018, Roughly 14 Million American Households Would See A Tax Increase, And The Number Would Grow Over Time, Increasing To 40 Million Americans By 2027. “In other words, while most Americans would indeed see a tax cut or a minor increase in the first year, 8 percent, or roughly 14 million American households, would see an increase of at least $100. (We approximated the raw number using Tax Policy Center data.) Meanwhile, the number of Americans facing a tax increase would grow over time. By 2027, 46 percent would see a decrease and 34 percent would see a change of less than $100, but 20 percent would see a tax increase. That could mean close to 40 million Americans would pay higher taxes in 2027 than they would under today’s tax laws.” [Politifact, 11/9/17]

HEADLINE: “A Quarter Of All Taxpayers Would Pay More In 10 Years Under GOP Tax Plan: Revised Report.” [CNBC, 11/8/17]

New York Times: “Analyses Published Since The Plan Was Introduced Last Week Have Consistently Found That Some Middle-Class Families Would See Their Taxes Go Up Immediately.” “Few independent economists find evidence to support that claim. Analyses published since the plan was introduced last week have consistently found that some middle-class families would see their taxes go up immediately, compared with existing law. One such analysis, from the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, found that 8 percent of middle-income earners would pay more in 2018 — and 21 percent in 2027 — with upper-middle-class taxpayers more likely to see their taxes rise.” [New York Times, 11/6/17]

Nearly Half Of All Middle Class Families Would Pay More In Taxes In 2026, And About One Third Would Pay More In 2018. “Nearly half of all middle-class families would pay more in taxes in 2026 than they would under current rules if the proposed House tax bill became law, and about one-third would pay more in 2018, according to a New York Times analysis, a striking finding for a bill promoted as a middle-class tax cut. […] By 2026, 45 percent of middle-class families would pay more than what they would under the existing tax system.” [New York Times, 11/6/17]

Millions Of Middle Class Families Would See An Immediate Tax Increase, Averaging About $2,000 – Including Those With Huge Medical Expenses. “President Trump and congressional Republicans have pitched the plan unveiled last week as a tax cut for most Americans. But millions of middle-class families — particularly those with children — would see an immediate tax increase, averaging about $2,000. Among the hardest-hit under the plan would be some of the most vulnerable taxpayers: those with huge out-of-pocket medical expenses.” [New York Times, 11/6/17]

Most Of The Direct Beneficiaries Of Republican Tax Legislation Were Corporations And Wealthy Individuals, While Many Of The Loopholes Eliminated Benefitted Middle Income Taxpayers. “Republicans say their tax reform plan benefits the middle and working classes, but the most direct beneficiaries are corporations and wealthy individuals. Many of the ‘loopholes’ slated for elimination under the bill introduced on Thursday benefit middle-income taxpayers. The legislation contains nothing that specifically benefits the poor, who already pay no federal income tax.” [Huffington Post, 11/2/17]

HEADLINE: “GOP Tax Plan May Offer Little Aid For Many In Middle Class.” [Associated Press, 11/2/17]

HEADLINE: “Republican Tax Plan Would Raise Taxes On Many Low Income Families, Slash Rates For The Richest: Analysis.” [CNBC, 11/6/17]

88 After 10 Years, Nearly One In Three Households Would See A Tax Increase. “Some taxpayers, however, would pay more under the plan, a fact that has dogged Trump administration officials since they began the push for tax reform earlier this year. The new TPC analysis found that 12 percent of taxpayers would pay more in taxes next year. By 2027, the number of taxpayers who would pay more jumps to 28 percent, or nearly one in three households.” [CNBC, 11/6/17]

Furman: “On The Individual Side, The Republican Plan Offers Almost No Direct Benefit To The Middle Class.” “On the individual side, the Republican plan offers almost no direct benefit to the middle class. Many details are still missing, but from what we know so far it would largely be a wash for most households. A larger standard deduction and child tax credit would roughly offset the elimination of personal exemptions and the increase in the lowest bracket from 10% to 12%.” [Wall Street Journal, Jason Furman, 10/22/17]

Tax Cuts And Jobs Act’s “Primary Beneficiaries” Were Wealthy Americans

AP: “The Tax Plan’s Primary Beneficiaries Would Be Wealthier Americans.” “Trump has frequently said that this would be the biggest tax cut in U.S. history. But outside analyses show that that’s not the case. The tax plan’s primary beneficiaries would be wealthier Americans, who would enjoy lower tax rates despite the elimination of some breaks, a repeal of the so-called alternative minimum tax and the termination of the estate tax.” [Associated Press, 11/2/17]

Washington Post Fact Checker: “No Matter How You Slice It, The Superwealthy Do Rather Well Under The House GOP Proposal.” “Contrary to the president’s claim, the tax plan is not ‘so bad’ for the wealthy. In fact, no matter how you slice it, the superwealthy do rather well under the House GOP proposal. As we have said, that’s because they already pay a large chuck of income taxes already. Trump could actually make the distribution tables look better if he pushed to keep the AMT in place for incomes above $1 million and the estate tax in place for estates larger than $11 million. The failure to do so underscores the fact that this tax plan is not only for the middle class.” [Washington Post, 11/9/17]

Tax Policy Center: “Within The Overall Tax Cuts, The Wealthiest 1 Percent Of Taxpayers Would Benefit Far More Than The Rest Of The Country.” “But within the overall tax cuts, the wealthiest 1 percent of taxpayers would benefit far more than the rest of the country. The analysis undermined Republican claims that the bill introduced last week would primarily benefit the middle class over the wealthy.” [CNBC, 11/8/17]

In 2018, The Top One Percent Of Taxpayers Would Receive 22 Percent Of The Total Cuts. “According to the preliminary report, in 2018 the top one percent of taxpayers -- those making more than $730,000 -- would receive 22 percent of the total cuts, or an average tax cut of $37,000. Middle income families (those making between about $48,000 and $86,000) would receive an average tax cut of $700 next year.” [CNBC, 11/6/17]

By 2027, The Top One Percent Would Get 50 Percent Of The Benefits Of The GOP Tax Plan. “The Republican-backed bill would also accrue even more benefits to the top 1 percent of taxpayers in 2027 than it would in 2018, the report found. That group would reap as much as 50 percent of the total tax benefits, or an average increase in after-tax income of 2.2 percent.” [CNBC, 11/8/17]

At The End Of The Decade, When The Estate Tax Is Fully Phased Out, The Top One Percent Would Receive 48 Percent Of The Bill’s Benefits. “By 2027, when the estate tax is fully phased out, the top 1% of earners would receive 48% of the benefit of the bill’s cuts. Middle-income earners would get 8% of the benefit.” [Los Angeles Times, 11/6/17] 89

The Top Quintile Of Earners Would Receive 60 Percent Of The Total Cuts. “The top 20% of the nation’s earners -- those making more than $149,400 a year -- would receive an average tax cut of $4,850, or about 1.4% of after-tax income. Those top earners would also receive 60% of the total tax benefits under the plan. Of that, the top 1% of earners, defined as those making more than $730,000 a year, receive about 22% of the total amount of tax cuts in 2018, the Tax Policy Center said.” [Los Angeles Times, 11/6/17]

HEADLINE: The wealthy get the biggest benefit from House Republican tax plan, analysis finds [Los Angeles Times, 11/6/17]

The Tax Cuts And Jobs Act Increased The Federal Debt – And Republicans Planned To Pay For It With Cuts To Medicare And Social Security

Official CBO Estimate Found Final Tax Bill Would Increase The Federal Deficit By $1.46 Trillion. “Republicans decided it would be all right to go into debt up to $1.5 trillion to fund the tax cut. In the end, they nearly hit that mark. The official estimate -- released Friday evening alongside the bill -- came in at $1.46 trillion.” [Washington Post, 12/15/17]

After Passing Tax Bill That Added Trillions To Deficit, Ryan And GOP Continually Said That Medicare And Entitlements Needed To Be Cut To Decrease The Deficit

HEADLINE: After Tax Overhaul, GOP Sets Sights on Medicare, Social Security [US News, 12/7/17]

HEADLINE: Ryan says Republicans to target welfare, Medicare, Medicaid spending in 2018 [Washington Post, 12/6/17]

HEADLINE: Paul Ryan Pushes to Keep Overhaul of Safety-Net Programs on GOP Agenda [Wall Street Journal, 2/4/18]

Economists Warned That The Tax Bill Would “Intensify Pressure To Cut Spending On Social Programs”

US News: “The Most Likely Targets For Cuts And Restructuring In The Coming Months Are Likely To Be Medicare And Social Security Benefits.” “Instead, the most likely targets for cuts and restructuring in the coming months are likely to be Medicare and Social Security benefits. Rubio last week indicated ‘the driver of our debt is the structure of Social Security and Medicare for future beneficiaries.’ Ryan issued a similar assessment just a few days later, noting that ‘health care entitlements … are the big drivers of our debt.’” [US News, 12/7/17]

Small Business

Stauber Called Small Business The “Backbone Of The Economy” And Called To Ease Taxes

Stauber Said Small Businesses Were The “Backbone Of The Economy” And Their “Tax Burden” Needed To Be Eased. “Small business owners have been hit with significant taxes and health insurance increases. When asked what can be done to help small businesses, Stauber replied, ‘As a small business owner, my brothers and I have owned Duluth Hockey Company for 27 years. I know what it’s like to make payroll. To survive through the tough times in business. We need to ease the tax burden on small business owners. They are the backbone of the economy.’” [Cook County News Herald, 8/12/17]

2012: Duluth News Tribune: Stauber “Vowed” To Keep Taxes Low For Businesses As County Commissioner

2012: Duluth News Tribune: Stauber “Vowed” To Keep Taxes Low For Businesses. “Economic development[.] Hall, Stauber and Dahlberg each vowed to keep taxes low for businesses and reduce government interference with companies that want to expand and create jobs. O’Neil and Sweeney, however, pointed out that public infrastructure investment, paid by taxes, is crucial for the roads and bridges and other public services critical for companies to get their products to market. There was little disagreement that county efforts -- such as property tax rebates to companies and tax increment finance districts -- are good ways to promote business development and jobs here.” [Duluth News Tribune, 9/18/12]

91 Trade Issues

Significant Findings

 Stauber voted to adopt a resolution opposing the Trans-Pacific Partnership.

Trans Pacific Partnership

2015: Stauber Voted To Adopt A Resolution Opposing The Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) Agreement

Dec. 2015: Stauber Voted To Adopt A Resolution Opposing The Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) Agreement. “THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board of Commissioners hereby calls upon our elected officials in the U.S. Senate and U.S. House of Representatives to oppose the Trans-Pacific Partnership and any similar trade deals, if they promote more business with low wage countries with undemocratic regimes and rampant human and labor rights abuses, costing American workers reduced wages and lost jobs; RESOLVED FURTHER, That the St. Louis County Board calls upon our elected officials in the Congress of the United States to support new trade deals such as the Trans-Pacific Partnership only if they will: • Exclude provisions that favor foreign companies over domestic ones and undermine public choices; • Ensure that other countries cannot undercut U.S. based producers with weaker labor and environmental laws and enforcement; • Ensure that the U.S. will engage in robust enforcement of trade rules, including labor and environmental rules; • Include strong ‘rule of origin’ language to promote economic growth and job creation in the U.S.; • Promote high standards of protection for workplaces, products, and natural resources. Commissioner Rukavina moved the adoption of the Resolution and it was declared adopted upon the following vote: Yeas- Commissioners Boyle, Dahlberg, Rukavina, Nelson, Raukar and Chair Stauber- 6 Nays- None Absent - Commissioner Jewell – 1[.]” [Resolution No. 15-767, 12/15/15]

92 Transportation Issues

Significant Findings

 Stauber said he supported the Northern Lights Express, a proposed commuter rail between the Twin Ports and Twin Cities.

Northern Lights Express Commuter Rail

Stauber Said He Supported The Northern Lights Express, A Proposed Commuter Rail Between The Twin Ports And Twin Cities

Stauber Said He Supported The Northern Lights Express, A Proposed Commuter Rail Between The Twin Ports And Twin Cities. “QUESTION: For more than 10 years, St. Louis County and other local governments in Minnesota have thrown hundreds of thousands of dollars into planning a commuter rail line between the Twin Ports and Twin Cities. Is the Northern Lights Express still worth pursuing? Why or why not? STAUBER: I do support it. I think that it’ll give us the ability to [inaudible] the congestion of the traffic [inaudible]. If you’ve been – I was down in Minneapolis, St. Paul area this weekend. It was terrible. I think it would alleviate some of the problems but I would like to look at some type of public-private partnership in order to make that succeed on its own without the continuous subsidies that may have – may bring about… I’m definitely in support of it. I think we just want to make sure that when we do it, we do it right and that we’ve done our studies [audible] we’ll be there to pay for itself.” [St. Louis County Board Forum, Forum Communications Company via YouTube, updated 9/8/16] (VIDEO)

93 Veterans Issues

Significant Findings

 Stauber said he and his family “lived the sacrifice and hardship of deployment” and promised veterans and military families they would have “no better advocate.”

 Stauber was the “Yellow Ribbon Coordinator” for the City of Duluth, which helped veterans readjust to life after deployment.

Advocacy

Stauber Said Veterans And Military Families Would Have “No Better Advocate” In Congress Than Him

Stauber Said Veterans Would Have “No Better Advocate,” Due To His Family’s Experience Of The “Sacrifice And Hardship” Of His Wife’s Deployment To Iraq

Stauber Said He And His Family “Lived The Sacrifice And Hardship Of Deployment” And Promised Veterans And Military Families They Would Have “No Better Advocate.” “Stauber’s wife, Jodi, is an Iraq war veteran and retired from the 148th Fighter Wing as Minnesota’s first female Command chief. They have four children, ranging in ages from 11 to 17. ‘My children, my wife and I have lived the sacrifice and hardship of deployment,’ he said. ‘I can promise our veterans and military families, that you will have no better advocate for the benefits you’ve earned and are entitled to than Pete Stauber.’” [The Journal, 10/21/17]

Stauber’s Wife Was An Iraq War Veteran And The First Female Command Chief Of The 148th Fighter Wing. “He was present at the podium with his wife, Jodi Stauber, and their four children. Jodi is an Iraq War veteran and retired from the local 148th Fighter Wing as Minnesota’s first female Command Chief.” [Duluth News-Tribune, 7/10/17]

Duluth News Tribune: Stauber “Painted Himself As A Strong Advocate For Armed Service Veterans” During His Campaign Launch Speech. “Flanked by more than 100 supporters, Pete Stauber launched his campaign for Minnesota’s 8th Congressional District on Monday. […] After outlining a varied career in hockey, law enforcement and local governance, Stauber painted himself as a strong advocate for armed service veterans, people with special needs, the elderly and small-business owners, among others.” [Duluth News Tribune, 7/10/17]

Stauber Was The “Yellow Ribbon Coordinator” For The City Of Duluth, Which Helped Veterans Readjust To Life After Deployment

2012: Duluth News Tribune: Stauber Was The “Yellow Ribbon Coordinator For The City Of Duluth,” Which Led “Efforts To Assist Those Returning From Active Overseas Military Duty.” “Stauber already is a generous public servant. In addition to being a police officer, he’s on the advisory board for the Northeast Regional Corrections Center; is a member of the board of Udac, a Duluth nonprofit that helps people with disabilities; and is the Yellow Ribbon coordinator for the city of Duluth, leading efforts to assist those returning from active overseas military duty.” [Duluth News Tribune, Editorial, 9/27/12]

Stauber Claimed He Was An “Original Member” Of The City Of Duluth Yellow Ribbon Committee. [Pete Stauber for Congress, accessed 1/25/18]

94 Stauber Said He “Helped Start” The Yellow Ribbon Committee In Duluth. “‘I am proud of my wife’s service to our country and I am an ardent supporter of our military and our veterans,’ said Pete. When one member of a family deploys, especially overseas, it’s tough on a family, said Stauber. So he said, “I helped start the Yellow Ribbon Committee in Duluth. If a military family had someone deploy, all they had to do was make one call, and someone would come to help them with whatever they needed. If it was a ride somewhere, that was provided. Need help with daycare? That was provided. A problem with the house, something broke and needed to be fixed, all it took was one call, and help was on its way. I know what it’s like to have a spouse deploy and have to take care of kids and a house while working full time.’” [Cook County News Herald, 8/12/17]

Stauber Reportedly Founded A Hockey Camp That Was Free For Children Of Military Families

2012: Duluth News Tribune: Stauber Brothers Hockey Hosted Its Second Annual “Military Heroes Hockey Camp,” An Admission Free, Three-Day Hockey Camp For Children With Military Parents. “The second annual Stauber Brothers Military Heroes Hockey Camp concludes today at Hermantown Ice Arena. About 60 children ages 6 to 14 who have parents in the military participated in the three-day camp. They came from Minnesota, Wisconsin and Michigan’s Upper Peninsula. Admission was free. Along with on- and off-ice training, the children took time each day to write a letter to active-duty troops currently deployed overseas, thanking them for their service to their country. ‘We appreciate the commitment these parents make to our country.” [Duluth News Tribune, 8/8/12]

Duluth News Tribune: Stauber Reportedly Organized The Camp. “‘We appreciate the commitment these parents make to our country, and this is a small way we can express our gratitude,’ said Pete Stauber, organizer of the camp. The camp was held in conjunction with Defending the Blue Line, a nonprofit organization created by a group of National Guard soldiers in Minnesota. It was funded, in part, by proceeds from a jersey auction hosted by the Minnesota Duluth Bulldogs men’s hockey team last season.” [Duluth News Tribune, 8/8/12]

95 Women

Significant Findings

 In July 2017, Stauber voted to award a $815,000 settlement to six female, former county employees who accused a former county employee of stalking.

 In 2013, Stauber voted to approve a $65,000 settlement to a former county employee who accused former County Commissioner Dennis Fink of sexual harassment.

 Stauber moved to adopt a resolution supporting Senator Amy Klobuchar’s federal legislative efforts to help eliminate sex trafficking across the country.

Abortion

Stauber Said He Stood With The “Thousands” Of Activists “Fighting The Good Fight” At The D.C. March For Life

Stauber Said He Stood With The “Thousands” Of Activists “Fighting The Good Fight” At The D.C. March For Life. “Thousands of activists are in D.C. today to March for Life. I stand with you in fighting the good fight. #MarchForLife2018[.]” [Pete Stauber, Twitter, 1/19/18]

Sex Trafficking

Jan. 2014: Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Supporting Sen. Amy Klobuchar’s Federal Legislative Efforts To Help Eliminate Sex Trafficking Across The Country

Jan. 2014: Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Supporting Sen. Amy Klobuchar’s Federal Legislative Efforts To Help Eliminate Sex Trafficking Across The Country. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Nelson, moved that the St. Louis County Board supports the federal legislative efforts of Senator Amy Klobuchar to expand the language of existing legislation that will help eliminate sex trafficking across the country by giving prosecutors the tools they need to combat the crimes and ensure support for the victims of those crimes. Eric Garcia Luna spoke to the board on behalf of Senator Amy Klobuchar’s office. Mr. Luna thanked the Board for their support and briefly discussed the legislation. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 14-46.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 1/14/14; Resolution 14-46, 1/14/14]

Workplace Harassment

2017: Stauber Voted To Award A $815,000 Settlement To Six Female Plaintiffs Who Accused A Former County Custodian Of Stalking

July 2017: Stauber Voted To Award A $815,000 Settlement To Six Plaintiffs Who Commenced An Action Against The County. “THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board approves the proposed settlement and authorizes the appropriate county officials to negotiate and execute appropriate settlement documents and to make the settlement payment contemplated by the proposed settlement in the amount of $815,000.00, payable from Fund 720, Agency 720001, Expense Code 636200. Commissioner Nelson moved the adoption of the Resolution and it was declared adopted upon the following vote: Yeas- Commissioners Boyle, Olson, Rukavina, Stauber, Nelson, Jugovich and Chair Jewell- 7 Nays- None[.]” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/11/17; Resolution No. 17-446, 7/11/17] 96

Duluth News Tribune: The Six Plaintiffs Were Women Who Accused A Former County Custodian Of Stalking. “Six women who worked for local law enforcement likely stand to receive $1.2 million as part of a mediated settlement involving St. Louis County and the city of Duluth. The settlement arises from the actions of Jeffrey Dominick Giacomini, a former custodian at the Public Safety Building shared by city and county law enforcement. Giacomini, a county employee, pleaded guilty in April to five gross misdemeanor counts of invasion of privacy and two gross misdemeanor charges of stalking, related to women he surreptitiously video recorded and photographed at work and in a locker room at the law enforcement center between 2014 and 2016. […] Under the terms of a settlement approved by the St. Louis County Board Tuesday, commissioners agreed to pay the plaintiffs $815,000. On Monday, the Duluth City Council is expected to vote on an additional $385,000 settlement from the city.” [Duluth News Tribune, 7/12/17]

2013: Stauber Voted To Approve A $65,000 Settlement For A Sexual Harassment Claim Against A Former County Commissioner

June 2013: Stauber Voted To Approve A $65,000 Settlement For A Sexual Harassment Claim Made By Betty Sislo. “Commissioner Jewell, supported by Commissioner O’Neil, moved to approve the settlement agreement between the county and Betty Sislo, whereby the county will pay Ms. Sislo $65,000 in exchange for a full and final settlement and release of all claims she may have against the county. The motion passed; four yeas, zero nays, one abstention (Commissioner Dahlberg abstained due to a conflict of interest). Resolution No. 13-352.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 6/4/13; Resolution No. 13-352]

Sislo Claimed Former Commissioner Dennis Fink Sexually Harassed Her While She Worked As His Secretary. “St. Louis County commissioners have voted to approve settling a sexual harassment claim for $65,000. Betty Sislo, of Duluth, came forward in 2007 and alleged a former commissioner sexually harassed her while she was employed as his secretary for 10 years. Sislo claims former Commissioner Dennis Fink made repeated comments of a sexual nature and inappropriate comments about her personal appearance. Fink has denied the allegations. The county took no action against him.” [Star Tribune, 6/4/13]

Appendices

98 Appendix I – Personal Financial Disclosures

2018 – Minnesota Statement Of Economic Interest

According to the Minnesota Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board, “county commissioners appointed or elected on or after January 1, 2014, must file statements of economic interest with the Board within 60 days of taking office. County commissioners also must recertify their statements in January each year. Peter Stauber was elected at the November 2016 election. He therefore was required to file a statement of economic interest within 60 days of taking office on January 3, 2017.” [171214 Correspondence re Stauber’s Statement of Economic Interest, 12/14/17]

NOTE: A copy of Stauber’s statement of economic interest is publicly available on the Minnesota Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board’s website.

Sources Of Compensation

Jan. 2018: Stauber Reported Sources Of Compensation From Duluth Hockey Company And Stauber Properties

Stauber Sources Of Income Source Relationship To Source Director Officer Owner Member Partner Employer Employee Honorarium Duluth Hockey X Company Stauber Properties X [Stauber Statement of Economic Interest, filed 1/3/18]

Jan. 2018: Stauber Reported Sources Of Compensation From Duluth Hockey Company And Stauber Properties. [Stauber Statement of Economic Interest, filed 1/3/18]

CFB: Public Officials Must List The Entity That Paid Them More Than $50 In A Month For Services. “In the sources of compensation section, you list the name of any type of entity listed in Column A above that paid you more than $50 in a month for your services in one of the positions in Column B. For each associated business, you must check the box or boxes on the form showing your relationship with that associated business.” [Minnesota Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board (CFB), Public and Local Officials Handbook, accessed 1/9/18]

CFB: Public Officials Are Not Required To Report Payments For Services Performed As An Independent Contractor. “You are not required to report payments made to you for services you performed as an independent contractor in this section because independent contractor services are covered by the business or professional activity categories section on the statement. You also do not need to report social security payments, unemployment compensation, workers’ compensation, pension benefits, insurance benefits, or income from rental property.” [Minnesota Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board (CFB), Public and Local Officials Handbook, accessed 1/9/18]

Jan. 2018: Stauber Stated He Was The Owner Of Duluth Hockey Company And Stauber Properties

Jan. 2018: Stauber Stated He Was The Owner Of Duluth Hockey Company And Stauber Properties. [Stauber 2017 Statement of Economic Interest, filed 1/3/18]

Business And Professional Activities

99 Jan. 2018: Stauber Stated He Was An Employee In “Rental And Leasing Services”

Stauber Businesses Or Professional Activities Business Or Professional Activity Category Engaged As Employee Engaged As Contractor Rental & leasing services X [Stauber Statement of Economic Interest, filed 1/3/18]

Jan. 2018: Stauber Stated He Was An Employee In “Rental And Leasing Services.” [Stauber Statement of Economic Interest, filed 1/3/18]

CFB: Public Officials Must Report Any Business Where One Received More Than $50 In A Month As An Employee, While Also Owning 25 Or More Percent Of The Business. “The business or professional activity category section is where you list the following information: 1) The business or professional activity category of each business from which you received more than $50 in any month as an employee if you also own 25% or more of that business[.] [Minnesota Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board, Public and Local Officials Handbook, accessed 1/9/18]

Securities

Jan. 2018: Stauber Reported Six Securities

Stauber Securities Duluth Hockey Company HarborView Homes MN deferred compensation RedKing LLC Roth IRA Stauber Properties [Stauber Statement of Economic Interest, filed 1/3/18]

Jan. 2018: Stauber Reported Six Securities. [Stauber Statement of Economic Interest, filed 1/3/18]

CFB: Public Officials Must Report “The Names Of Associates Businesses In Which You Own Securities.” “The securities section is where you report the names of associated businesses in which you own securities. A complete definition of associated business is contained in a previous section of this handbook. Briefly, for purposes of the securities section, an associated business is one of the following types of entities in which you own securities that have a fair market value of more than $2,500: • An association; • A corporation; • A partnership; • A limited liability company; • A limited liability partnership; or • Any other organized legal entity, including trusts and mutual funds.” [Minnesota Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board (CFB), Public and Local Officials Handbook, accessed 1/9/18]

Real Property

Jan. 2018: Stauber Reported Himself As The Owner Of Seven Different Properties In St. Louis County, Minnesota. [Stauber Statement of Economic Interest, filed 1/3/18]

100

Pari-Mutuel Horse Racing Interests

Jan. 2018: Stauber Did Not Report Any Interests In Pari-Mutuel Horse Racing

Jan. 2018: Stauber Did Not Report Any Interests In Pari-Mutuel Horse Racing. [Stauber Statement of Economic Interest, filed 1/3/18]

2017 – Federal Personal Financial Disclosure

TOPLINES - STAUBER PERSONAL FINANCIAL DISCLOSURES

Earned Unearned Unearned Income Income (Previous Asset Value Income Trans- Liabilities Year Year) MIN MAX MIN MAX Actions MIN MAX 2017 $89,762 $160,361 $771,013 $1,890,000 $7,504 $20,400 None $1,315,004 $5,650,000 [2017 Stauber Public Financial Disclosure Report, filed 8/18/17]

Net Worth

2017: Stauber Had An Estimated Net Worth Between $771,013 And $1,890,000, Not Including Liability

2017: Stauber Had An Estimated Net Worth Between $771,013 And $1,890,000. [2017 Stauber Public Financial Disclosure Report, filed 8/18/17]

Earned Income

2017: Stauber Reported $89,762 In Earned Income

2017: Stauber Reported $89,762 In Earned Income From Current Year To Filing. [2017 Stauber Public Financial Disclosure Report, filed 8/18/17]

2017 STAUBER EARNED INCOME SOURCE TYPE AMOUNT (CURRENT YEAR TO FILING) AMOUNT PRECEDING YEAR City of Duluth Salary $56,721.00 $100,906.00 County of St. Louis Salary $33,041.00 $59,455.00 TOTAL: $89,762.00 $160,361.00 [2017 Stauber Public Financial Disclosure Report, filed 8/18/17]

Assets & Unearned Income

2017: Stauber Reported Between $7,504 And $20,400 In Unearned Income

2017: Stauber Reported Between $7,504 And $20,400 In Unearned Income. [2017 Stauber Public Financial Disclosure Report, filed 8/18/17]

2017 STAUBER ASSETS AND "UNEARNED" INCOME TYPE OF AMOUNT OF Income Preceding ASSET YEAR-END VALUE INCOME INCOME Year 101 MIN MAX MIN MAX MIN MAX 5068 W. Arrowhead Road Location: St. Louis, MN, US $250,001 $500,000 Rent $5,001 $15,000 $5,001 $15,000 Duluth Police Department Credit Union $1,001 $15,000 Interest $1 $200 $1 $200 Harborview Homes Location: St. Louis, MN, US $15,001 $50,000 Rent $1 $200 $1 $200 PERA Balanced Fund $1,001 $15,000 Tax-Deferred N/A N/A N/A N/A PERA Bond Fund $1,001 $15,000 Tax-Deferred N/A N/A N/A N/A PERA International Stock Fund $1,001 $15,000 Tax-Deferred N/A N/A N/A N/A PERA US Stock Active Fund $1,001 $15,000 Tax-Deferred N/A N/A N/A N/A PERA US Stock Index Fund $1,001 $15,000 Tax-Deferred N/A N/A N/A N/A RedKing LLC Capital Gains, Location: St. Louis, MN, US $100,001 $250,000 Rent $2,501 $5,000 None None Stauber Brothers, LLC. Capital Location: St. Louis, MN, US $100,001 $250,000 Interest, Rent None None $100,001 $1,000,000 T. Rowe Price Group, Inc. (TROW) $100,001 $250,000 Tax-Deferred N/A N/A N/A N/A Vanguard Growth ETF-DNQ (VUG) $100,001 $250,000 Tax-Deferred N/A N/A N/A N/A Vanguard Institutional Index Fund $100,001 $250,000 Tax-Deferred N/A N/A N/A N/A TOTAL: $771,013 $1,890,000 $7,504 $20,400 $105,004 $1,015,400 [2017 Stauber Public Financial Disclosure Report, filed 8/18/17]

Transactions

2017: Stauber Did Not Report Any Transactions

2017: Stauber Did Not Report Any Transactions. [2017 Stauber Public Financial Disclosure Report, filed 8/18/17]

Liabilities

2017: Stauber Reported Between $1,315,004 And $5,650,000 In Liabilities

2017: Stauber Reported Between $1,315,004 And $5,650,000 In Liabilities. [2017 Stauber Public Financial Disclosure Report, filed 8/18/17]

2017 STAUBER LIABILITIES AMOUNT OF DATE LIABILITY OWNER CREDITOR INCURRED TYPE MIN MAX North Shore Bank of Personal guarantee on Stauber Commerce 06/2004 Properties Mortgage $250,001 $500,000 North Shore Bank of Personal guarantee on Stauber Commerce 06/2004 Brothers, Inc. $50,001 $100,000 Personal guarantee on Stauber Wells Fargo Bank 01/2010 Brothers, Inc. $15,001 $50,000 Personal guarantee on RedKing, LLC Cotrust Bank 01/2014 Mortgages $1,000,001 $5,000,000 TOTAL: $1,315,004 $5,650,000 [2017 Stauber Public Financial Disclosure Report, filed 8/18/17]

102 Positions

2017: Stauber Stated He Was A Partner Of Three LLC’s And Treasurer Of One Company

2017: Stauber Stated He Was A Partner Of RedKing, LLC, Stauber Properties, LLC And Harborview Homes*. [2017 Stauber Public Financial Disclosure Report, filed 8/18/17]

*NOTE: “Harborview Homes” registered with the Minnesota Secretary of State under the name “Harbor View Homes LLC” in May 2016. The initial filing listed Stauber as Harbor View Homes LLC’s registered agent and his home address, 5078 Arrowhead Road, was listed as the registered address.

2017: Stauber Stated He Was Treasurer Of Stauber Properties, Inc. [2017 Stauber Public Financial Disclosure Report, filed 8/18/17]

2017 STAUBER POSITIONS POSITION NAME OF ORGANIZATION Partner RedKing, LLC Partner Stauber Properties, LLC Partner Harborview Homes* Treasurer Stauber Properties, Inc. [2017 Stauber Public Financial Disclosure Report, filed 8/18/17]

Agreements

2017: Stauber Reported Two Agreements With The City Of Duluth

2017: Stauber Reported An Agreement With The City Of Duluth’s Public Employees Retirement Account.

2017 STAUBER AGREEMENTS DATE PARTIES TO TERMS OF AGREEMENT Mar-95 City of Duluth/PERA Public Employees Retirement Account Mar-95 City of Duluth/MN Deferred Comp MN Deferred Compensation Retirement Account [2017 Stauber Public Financial Disclosure Report, filed 8/18/17]

2017 – Minnesota Statement Of Economic Interest

NOTE: Stauber’s statement of economic interest, filed on February 10, 2017, covered 30 days prior to the starting date of his new term.

Sources Of Compensation

Feb. 2017: Stauber Did Not Report Any Sources Of Compensation

Feb. 2017: Stauber Did Not Report Any Sources Of Compensation. [Stauber Statement of Economic Interest, filed 2/10/17]

CFB: Public Officials Must List The Entity That Paid Them More Than $50 In A Month For Services. “In the sources of compensation section, you list the name of any type of entity listed in Column A above that paid you more than $50 in a month for your services in one of the positions in Column B. For each associated business, you must check the box or boxes on the form showing your relationship with that associated 103 business.” [Minnesota Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board (CFB), Public and Local Officials Handbook, accessed 1/9/18]

CFB: Public Officials’ First Economic Statement Of Interest Only Includes Sources Of Compensation From The Calendar Months Before The Date One Became A Public Official. “On your first Statement of Economic Interest, you look at only the calendar month before the date on which you became a public or local official to determine if you reached the $50 income threshold or the $2,500 securities threshold. On later statements, you have an interest in an associated business if you reached the income or securities threshold in any month since the date of your last statement.” [Minnesota Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board (CFB), Public and Local Officials Handbook, accessed 1/9/18]

Business And Professional Activities

Feb. 2017: Stauber Stated He Was A Real Estate Employee

Stauber Businesses Or Professional Activities Business Or Professional Activity Category Engaged As Employee Engaged As Contractor Real Estate X [Stauber Statement of Economic Interest, filed 2/10/17]

Feb. 2017: Stauber Stated He Was A Real Estate Employee. [Stauber Statement of Economic Interest, filed 2/10/17]

CFB: Public Officials Must Report Any Business Where One Received More Than $50 In A Month As An Employee, While Also Owning 25 Or More Percent Of The Business. “The business or professional activity category section is where you list the following information: 1) The business or professional activity category of each business from which you received more than $50 in any month as an employee if you also own 25% or more of that business[.]” [Minnesota Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board, Public and Local Officials Handbook, accessed 1/9/18]

Securities

Feb. 2017: Stauber Did Not Report Any Securities

Feb. 2017: Stauber Reported Six Securities. [Stauber Statement of Economic Interest, filed 2/10/17]

104 CFB: Public Officials Must Report “The Names Of Associates Businesses In Which You Own Securities.” “The securities section is where you report the names of associated businesses in which you own securities. A complete definition of associated business is contained in a previous section of this handbook. Briefly, for purposes of the securities section, an associated business is one of the following types of entities in which you own securities that have a fair market value of more than $2,500: • An association; • A corporation; • A partnership; • A limited liability company; • A limited liability partnership; or • Any other organized legal entity, including trusts and mutual funds.” [Minnesota Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board (CFB), Public and Local Officials Handbook, accessed 1/9/18]

Real Property

Feb. 2017: Stauber Reported Six Non-Homestead Properties In St. Louis County, Minnesota. [Stauber Statement of Economic Interest, filed 2/10/17]

Pari-Mutuel Horse Racing Interests

Feb. 2017: Stauber Did Not Report Any Interests In Pari-Mutuel Horse Racing

Feb. 2017: Stauber Did Not Report Any Interests In Pari-Mutuel Horse Racing. [Stauber Statement of Economic Interest, filed 2/10/17]

105

Appendix II – Campaign Finance

Items of Interest

 As of January 26, 2018, Pete Stauber for Congress Volunteer Committee raised more than $130,000 and spent more than $19,000.

 Pete Stauber Volunteer Committee, Stauber’s campaign committee for County Commissioner, raised more than $108,000 and spent over $107,000 from 2012 to 2016.

Toplines

NOTE: As of January 26, 2018, Pete Stauber for Congress Volunteer Committee has reported only one filing for the 2018 cycle.

Stauber’s Congressional Campaign Committee Raised More Than $130,000 And Spent More Than $19,000

Pete Stauber For Congress Volunteer Committee – Top Lines Contributions Disbursements

Other Party Operating Refunds Cycle Total Indivs Total Committees Cmtes Expenditures Indivs Cmtes 2018 $136,329.93 $133,829.93 $2,500.00 $0.00 $19,049.32 $19,049.32 $0.00 $0.00 [Federal Election Commission, Candidate and Committee Viewer, accessed 1/26/18]

2018: Raised $136,329

Q3 2017: Pete Stauber For Congress Volunteer Committee Raised A Total Of $136,329. [Federal Election Commission, Candidate and Committee Viewer, accessed 1/26/18]

Pete Stauber For Congress Volunteer Committee Raised $133,829.93 From Individual Contributions. [Federal Election Commission, Candidate and Committee Viewer, accessed 1/26/18]

Pete Stauber For Congress Volunteer Committee Raised $2,500 From Other Committees. [Federal Election Commission, Candidate and Committee Viewer, accessed 1/26/18]

2018: Spent $19,049

Q3 2017: Pete Stauber For Congress Volunteer Committee Spent $19,049.32. [Federal Election Commission, Candidate and Committee Viewer, accessed 1/26/18]

Stauber’s State Campaign Committee For County Commissioner Raised More Than $108,000 And Spent More Than $107,000

2012 – 2016 Stauber Volunteer Committee Campaign Finance Year Loans Total Contributions Total Expenditures 2016 $0.00 $15,335.00 $14,601.75 106 2012 $6,000.00 $93,318.40 $92,892.84 TOTAL $6,000.00 $108,653.40 $107,494.59 [St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 1/26/17; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 12/7/16; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 10/25/16; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 7/21/16; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee 2013 & 2014 campaign finance reports via Data Practices Act, obtained 11/27/17]

2012 – 2016: Raised $108,653

2012 – 2016: Stauber Volunteer Committee Raised A Total Of $108,653.40. [St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 1/26/17; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 12/7/16; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 10/25/16; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 7/21/16; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee 2013 & 2014 campaign finance reports via Data Practices Act, obtained 11/27/17]

2012 – 2016: Spent $107,494

2012 – 2016: Stauber Volunteer Committee Spent A Total Of $107,494.59. [St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 1/26/17; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 12/7/16; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 10/25/16; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 7/21/16; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee 2013 & 2014 campaign finance reports via Data Practices Act, obtained 11/27/17]

2018 – Campaign For Minnesota 8th Congressional District

NOTE: As of January 26, 2018, Pete Stauber for Congress Volunteer Committee has reported only one filing for the 2018 cycle.

Stauber’s Campaign Raised $136,329 And Spent $19,049.32

Pete Stauber For Congress Volunteer Committee – Q3 2017 Contributions Disbursements

Q3 2017: Pete Stauber For Congress Volunteer Committee Raised $136,329

Q3 2017: Pete Stauber For Congress Volunteer Committee Raised $136,329. [Federal Election Commission, Candidate and Committee Viewer, accessed 1/26/18]

Stauber’s Campaign Raised $133,829.93 From Individual Contributions. [Federal Election Commission, Candidate and Committee Viewer, accessed 1/26/18]

Stauber’s Campaign Raised $2,500 From Other Committees. [Federal Election Commission, Candidate and Committee Viewer, accessed 1/26/18]

107 Q3 2017: Pete Stauber For Congress Volunteer Committee Spent $19,049.32

Q3 2017: Pete Stauber For Congress Volunteer Committee Spent $19,049.32. [Federal Election Commission, Candidate and Committee Viewer, accessed 1/26/18]

Pete Stauber For Congress Volunteer Committee Spent On $19,049.32 On Operating Expenditures. [Federal Election Commission, Candidate and Committee Viewer, accessed 1/26/18]

Pete Stauber For Congress Volunteer Committee Did Not Have Any Refunds. [Federal Election Commission, Candidate and Committee Viewer, accessed 1/26/18]

2016 – Campaign For St. Louis County Commissioner

Stauber Volunteer Committee Raised $15,255 And Spent $14,601

2016 Stauber Volunteer Committee Campaign Finance Totals Period Loans Total Contributions Total Expenditures Total Cash On Hand 2/3/16 - 7/21/16 N/A $1,610.00 $1,551.13 $224.87 7/22/16 - 10/25/16 N/A $13,095.00 $6,787.44 $6,532.43 10/26/16 - 12/7/16 N/A $650.00 $5,992.24 $1,190.14 12/7/16 - 1/26/17 N/A $0.00 $270.94 $919.25 TOTAL: $15,355.00 $14,601.75 [St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 1/26/17; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 12/7/16; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 10/25/16; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 7/21/16]

Stauber Volunteer Committee Contributors

Stauber’s Top Campaign Contributors Included IUPAT District Council 82 PAC And The Waste Management PAC Of Minnesota

Stauber 2016 Contributors Date Amount Name Address Employer/Occupation 9/8/16 $600.00 George Hanson 615 Snively Rd Duluth MN 55803 Retired Elizabeth Stauber- 9/8/16 $600.00 Johnson 2400 Minnesota Ave Duluth MN 55802 Business owner 4909 Wild Rose Trail Hermantown MN 9/9/16 $600.00 Alan Hodnik S5811 CEO 9/22/16 $600.00 James Holmgren 4843 Rice Lake Rd Duluth MN 55803 Business owner 9/22/16 $600.00 Nancy Holmgren 4843 Rice Lake Rd Duluth MN 55803 Retired 9/28/16 $600.00 Michael Welch 6941 Seville Rd Saginaw MN 55797 Business owner 10/3/16 $600.00 Steve Paulson 4514 Rice Lake Rd Duluth MN 55803 Business owner 9/22/16 $500.00 Keith McKinzie 6944 Klimek Rd Saginaw MN S5797 Business owner 9/22/16 $500.00 Scott Sinnott 227 Jay Cooke Rd Esko MN 55733 Business owner 9/22/16 $500.00 Brian Maki 610 Hovland Ln Duluth MN 55811 Business owner 10/3/16 $500.00 Steven Overom 50005 Point 0 ' Pines Rd Barnes WI 54873 Attorney 10/7/16 $300.00 Plumbers & Steamfitters 4402 Airpark Blvd Duluth MN 55811 PAC

108 10/17/16 $300.00 Duluth Building & Trades 2002 London Rd Duluth MN 55812 PAC IUPAT District Council 10/25/16 $300.00 82 PAC 3205 Country Dr Little Canada MN 55117 PAC Waste Management PAC 11/4/16 $300.00 of Minnesota 924 Ivy Hills Rd Belle Plane MN 56011 PAC 9/6/16 $250.00 Robert Schroeder 1107 Riverside Dr Kaukauna WI 54130 Business owner 9/1/16 $200.00 James Stauber 5126 Wyoming St Duluth MN 55804 Professor Allete/Communications 9/1/16 $200.00 Margaret Hodnik 1811 Tyrol St Duluth MN 55811 specialist 9/19/16 $200.00 Carmen Arnold 5787 Lakewood Road Duluth MN 55804 Retired 9/22/16 $200.00 Mark Christiansen 6826 Bear Island Rd Duluth MN 55803 Business owner 9/22/16 $200.00 Heath Line 5733 Ryan St Aurora MN 55705 Construction 9/28/16 $200.00 Katy Stoyanoff 243 Nynas Rd Esko MN 55733 UPS 9/28/16 $200.00 Northern Routes Roll-Off 128 E Chapman St Ely MN 55731 Business owner 10/17/16 $200.00 Linda Poshak 13697 Paradise Rd Ely MN 55731 Retired 4929 West Island Beach Lane Duluth MN 11/8/16 $200.00 Michael Robertson 55802 Unknown Northeast Area Labor 8/24/16 $150.00 Council PAC 2002 London Rd #100 Duluth MN 55812 PAC 133 Summit St- Unit 134 Duluth MN 10/7/16 $150.00 David McMillan 55803 Attorney 9/1/16 $100.00 Mark Monte 4974 Maribe Dr Hermantown MN 55811 Anesthesiologist 9/1/16 $100.00 Robbin Champaigne 2411 Asbury Dr Duluth MN 55811 Information specialist 9/6/16 $100.00 Alan Amatuzio 84 Howard Gnesen Rd Duluth MN 55811 Business owner 4906 West Pike Lake Rd Duluth MN 9/6/16 $100.00 Scott Krenzen 55811 Business owner 9/6/16 $100.00 Ben Boo 102 East Arrowhead Rd Duluth MN 55803 Retired 9/6/16 $100.00 Kerry Kolodge 803 Ann Circle Cloquet S5720 Retired 4952 Morris Thomas Rd Duluth MN 9/6/16 $100.00 Patricia Royer 55811 Retired 4366 Grouse Ridge Dr Hermantown MN 9/8/16 $100.00 Amy Abernethy 55811 Retired 9/9/16 $100.00 Phillip Fish 4245 Lavaque Rd Hermantown MN 55811 Business owner 9/9/16 $100.00 Carol Kleinschmidt 3130 E First St Duluth MN 55812 Retired 5027 Bay Road South Fredenberg MN 9/10/16 $100.00 Jeff Hausmann 55803 Business owner 4391 Grouse Ridge Dr Hermantown MN 9/19/16 $100.00 Tam Landrigan 55811 Homemaker 4420 Cold Creek Ln Hermantown MN 9/19/16 $100.00 Gary Doty 55811 Retired 4420 Cold Creek Ln Hermantown MN 9/19/16 $100.00 Marcia Doty 55811 Retired 9/19/16 $100.00 Fred Strom 15940 Windrift Dr Jupiter FL 33477 Retired 9/22/16 $100.00 Lois Nelson 7251 E Townline Rd Eveleth MN 55734 Business owner 9/22/16 $100.00 Charles Andrews 1004 l0th St South Virginia MN 55792 Construction 9/22/16 $100.00 Gary Abramson PO Box 161 Orr MN 55771 Construction 9/28/16 $100.00 Andrea Zupancich 37 Locust Dr Babbitt 55706 Business owner 9/28/16 $100.00 Kathy Vraa PO Box 352 Babbitt MN 55706 Business owner 9/29/16 $100.00 Mildred DeBolt 7018 Van Rd Duluth MN 55803 Business owner 10/3/16 $100.00 Rebecca Hall 4760 London Rd Duluth MN 55804 Homemaker

109 10/7/16 $100.00 Paul Fish 3935 Solway Rd Duluth MN 55810 Retired 5263 Arrowhead Rd W Hermantown MN 10/17/16 $100.00 James Barash 55811 Waste Mgmt/5upervisor 10/17/16 $100.00 Lloyd Gustafson PO Box 369 Cook MN 55723 Retired 10/25/16 $100.00 Daniel Dougherty 600 E Second St Duluth MN 55805 Business owner 11/28/16 $100.00 Keith Stauber 4139 Lake Avenue S Duluth MN 55802 Retired [St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 1/26/17; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 12/7/16; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 10/25/16; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 7/21/16]

2012 – Campaign For St. Louis County Commissioner

Stauber Volunteer Committee Raised $93,318 And Spent $92,892

2012 Stauber Volunteer Committee Campaign Finance Totals Period Loans Total Contributions Total Expenditures Total Cash On Hand 2/1/12 - 2/29/12 N/A $760.00 $1,520.56 N/A 3/1/12 - 8/9/12 N/A $10,935.48 $7,117.67 $3,817.81 8/10/12 - 10/24/12 $2,000.00 $26,908.48 $25,662.21 $3,246.27 10/29/12 - 12/1/12 $2,000.00 $27,293.44 $29,103.44 $190.00 2/23/12 - 1/17/13 $2,000.00 $27,421.00 $29,488.96 -$67.96 TOTAL: $93,318.40 $92,892.84 [St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 1/17/13; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 3/5/12; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 8/10/12; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 10/29/12; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 12/4/12]

NOTE: The St. Louis County Auditor’s website does not list campaign finance documents pre-2014. The DCCC requested these documents through a Data Practices Act request.

Stauber Volunteer Committee Top Campaign Contributors

Stauber Was His Own Largest Contributor – With $2,504 In Contributions

Stauber Contributed $2,504.48 To His Campaign Committee. [St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 1/26/17; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 12/7/16; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 10/25/16; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 7/21/16]

Stauber 2016 Contributors Date Amount Name Address Employer/Occupation 10/19/12 4/20/12 2/22/12 5078 West Arrowhead Rd 3/1/12 $2,504.48 Pete Stauber Hermantown MN City of Duluth, MN 8/11/12 $300.00 A Ronald Johnson 2400 Minnesota Ave Contractor

110 4909 Wild Rose Trail Hermantown 8/6/12 $300.00 Al Hodnik MN Allete 8/6/12 $300.00 Brian Maki 1214 Denny Rd Duluth MN Lakehead Constructors Carpenters Local 361 PAC 5238 Miller Trunk Hwy Hermantown 10/15/12 $300.00 Fund MN Union 10/10/12 $300.00 Diane R Lunde-Hansen 315 W 1st Street Duluth MN Essentia Health Duluth Building and 10/25/12 $300.00 Construction T C 2002 London Rd Duluth MN 55812 Union Elizabeth Stauber-Johnson 8/11/12 $300.00 PH.D. 2400 Minnesota Ave Homemaker 4909 Wild Rose Trail Hermantown 8/6/12 $300.00 Erika Hodnik MN Homemaker 7/30/12 $300.00 Erin Dungan 4266 Evergreen Ln N Plymouth MN Attorney 4420 Cold Creek Ln Hermantown 9/19/12 $300.00 Gary Doty MN Business Owner 10/12/12 $300.00 Ilissa Stauber 2916 Palisade Dr Duluth MN 55811 Student Self 8/16/12 $300.00 Jef & Patti Hauseman 5027 Bay Rd S Fredenberg MN Employed/Homemaker 10/12/12 $300.00 John Stauber 2916 Palisade Dr Duluth MN 55811 Innovative Pine Tech 10/12/12 $300.00 Kelly Stauber 2916 Palisade Dr Duluth MN 55811 AT&T 4420 Cold Creek Ln Hermantown 9/19/12 $300.00 Marcia Doty MN Business Owner 7/26/12 $300.00 Mark Christiansen 6826 Bear Island Rd Duluth MN Engineer 7/27/12 $300.00 Mary Lou Christiansen 6826 Bear Island Rd Duluth MN TBI Care 7/22/12 $300.00 Meghan law 2721 Black Oaks Ln N Plymouth MN IRA Business Owner - Advant 6/19/12 $300.00 Nathan Bentley 3838 Crosby Rd Cloquet MN Signs 6/11/12 $300.00 Rebecca Hall 4760 London Rd Duluth MN Housewife Superior Computer 10/10/12 $300.00 Robert M Hansen 315 W 1st Street Duluth MN Products 2/22/12 $300.00 Sandra J. Finch 4911 Whitetail Dr Hermantown MN Piedmont HTS Dental 7/26/12 $300.00 Sandra Paulson 4819 Breezy Point Rd Duluth MN Homemaker 8/24/12 $300.00 Sue Strapple 5256 Falcon Rd Hermantown MN Impact Advisors 6/19/12 $300.00 Tricia Bently 3838 Crosby Rd Cloquet MN Housewife 7/25/12 $250.00 Laura Rothe 5108 Larson Ln Duluth MN Homemaker 11695 E Lake Ave, Lake Business Owner-Superior 5/24/12 $250.00 Patty & Guy Peterson Negabomon, WI Wood 7/25/12 $250.00 Todd Rothe 5108 Larson Ln Duluth MN General Contractor 7/11/12 $200.00 Andrew High 5877 Wargin Rd Duluth MN St Louis Co Sheriff Dept. 5787 Lakewood Road Duluth MN 10/4/12 $200.00 Carmen Arnold 55804 Retired 6035 S Pike Lake Rd Duluth MN 10/20/12 $200.00 Cindy Stauber 55811 Small Business Owner 5506 Hwy 194 Hermantown MN 9/17/12 $200.00 Daniel Dougherty 55811 Business Owner 12 Randy Johnson St Superior WI 8/29/12 $200.00 Don Warmington 54880 Business Owner 9/24/12 $200.00 James Stauber 2706 W 11th St Duluth MN Business Owner 9/25/12 $200.00 Laura Budd 4435 Sunshine Lake Rd Duluth MN Retired 9/18/12 $200.00 Margaret L Hodnik 1811 Tyrol St Duluth MN 55811 Minnesota Power 7/26/12 $200.00 Mildred DeBlot 7018 Van Rd Duluth MN Homemaker

111 8/30/12 6/11/12 $200.00 George Hanson 615 Snivley Rd Duluth MN Self Employed 7/26/12 $200.00 Nancy Holmgren 401 W Skyline Pkway Duluth MN Homemaker 8/30/12 $200.00 Orlando Fladmark 5683 N Shore Drive Duluth MN Retired 4870 Sbnow Blossom Ln Becksville 6/8/12 $200.00 Paul Clifford OH Sherwin Williams 1107 Riverside Dr Kaukauna WI 8/27/12 $200.00 Robert J. Schroeder 54130 Business Owner 10/6/12 $200.00 Thomas Schlotec 2346 Birch Point Rd Tower MN Self Employed 14379 Wilson Drive Eden Prairie 9/20/12 $199.00 Eric Meiners MN 55347 Sales 7/26/12 $150.00 Cynthia Urshan 6828 Bear Island Rd Duluth MN Urshan Retirement Group 7/26/12 $150.00 Dan Urshan 6828 Bear Island Rd Duluth MN Urshan Retirement Group 8/16/12 $150.00 David McMilan 2724 Graysalon Rd Duluth MN Allete 4391 Grouse Ridge Drive 7/7/12 $150.00 Dr. Brian Landrigan Hermantown MN Arrowhead Orthodontics 6/3/12 $150.00 Jeff Jablosnki N 1631 Olive Ct, Greenville, WI Edwards Sales 5139 W Arrowhead Rd Hermantown 7/26/12 $150.00 Jordan Urshan MN Urshan Retirement Group 6/27/12 $150.00 Kevin Herstad 5219 Miller Trunk Hwy Duluth MN United Truck Body 7/25/12 $150.00 Marian Prahl 5152 2nd Ave Duluth MN Homemaker 6/11/12 $150.00 Paul King 1210 Missouri Ave Duluth MN Performance Artist 6/11/12 $150.00 Theresa Schmaedke PO Box 3156 Duluth MN Real Estate/Rental 9/24/12 $150.00 Wayne Boucher 4263 Lavaque Rd Hermantown MN Retired 5078 West Arrowhead Rd 1/2/13 $127.56 Pete Stauber Hermantown MN City of Duluth, MN

8/30/12 $100.00 John Vaughn 2010 Woodhaven Ln Duluth MN Retired 10/20/12 $50.00 Carta Bayerl 17 Magnolia Dr Duluth MN 55810 Retired 8/28/12 $50.00 Shari Fedora 3001 Palisade Dr Duluth MN Retired [St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 1/26/17; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 12/7/16; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 10/25/16; St. Louis County Auditor, Stauber Volunteer Committee campaign finance report, filed 7/21/16]

112

Appendix III – Resolutions & Motions

This section includes the majority of Stauber’s offered and supported resolutions and motions as a County Commissioner. Offered resolutions are resolutions that Stauber himself moved to vote on. If a resolution passes, the Commissioner’s name who offered the resolution is included on the resolution. Offered motions are motions that Stauber himself moved to vote on. Supported resolutions, however, are resolutions that Stauber “seconded” to move on. “For example, Commissioner Jewell, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to vote on a resolution.”

2017 – Offered Resolutions And Motions

Appointments

Stauber Moved To Confirm The Reappointment Of James Foldesi As The St. Louis County Highway Engineer/Public Works Director For A Four-Year Term Ending May 2021

May 2017: Stauber Moved To Confirm The Reappointment Of James Foldesi As The St. Louis County Highway Engineer/Public Works Director For A Four-Year Term Ending May 2021. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Nelson, moved to confirm the reappointment of James T. Foldesi as the St. Louis County Highway Engineer/Public Works Director, for a four-year term effective May 1, 2017 and ending May 2021. St. Louis County Administrator Kevin Gray noted that approximately $320 million was spent on road and bridge projects during the five-year plan. Director Foldesi thanked the Board for their ongoing support. After further discussion, the motion passed; six yeas, zero nays, one absent (Rukavina). Resolution No. 17-303.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 5/9/17; Resolution No. 17-303, 5/9/17]

Contracts

Stauber Moved To Consider Awarding A Bid To Proctor For A Construction Project

May 2017: Stauber Moved To Consider Awarding A Bid To Proctor For A Construction Project. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Nelson, moved to consider an award of bid for a tied mill/paving/seal coat project in Proctor, and a culvert replacement/reclaim/seal coat project in Duluth, Proctor and Midway Township; the item has not been to Committee of the Whole. The motion passed; six yeas, zero nays, one absent (Rukavina).” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 5/9/17]

Stauber Moved To Consider An “Award Of Bid For A Tied Mill/Paving/Seal Coat Project In Proctor And A Culvert/Replacement/Reclaim/Seal Coat Project In Duluth, Proctor And Midway Township”

May 2017: Stauber Moved To Consider An “Award Of Bid For A Tied Mill/Paving/Seal Coat Project In Proctor And A Culvert/Replacement/Reclaim/Seal Coat Project In Duluth, Proctor And Midway Township.” “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Nelson, moved to consider an award of bid for a tied mill/paving/seal coat project in Proctor, and a culvert replacement/reclaim/seal coat project in Duluth, Proctor and Midway Township; the item has not been to Committee of the Whole. The motion passed; six yeas, zero nays, one absent (Rukavina).” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 5/9/17]

Stauber Moved To Award A $1,341,431 Bid to Ulland Brothers, Inc. For A Construction Project

May 2017: Stauber Moved To Award A $1,341,431 Bid to Ulland Brothers, Inc. For A Construction Project. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Olson, moved to award a bid to Ulland Brothers, Inc., of Cloquet, MN, in the amount of $1,341,431.00 for the following tied mi11/paving/seal coat project in Proctor: A.)

113 CP 0011-278904 (Low), SAP 69-611-018, on County State Aid Highway (CSAH) I J (4111 Street/5th Avenue) between CSAH 284 (Ugstad Rd) and 2nct Street, length 0.56 mile; B.) CP 0014-278073 (Tied), SAP 69-614-018, on CSAH 14 (5111 Street) between Trunk Highway (TH) 2 and CSAH 14 (Boundary Avenue), length 0.42 mile; C.) CP 0000- 329279 (Tied), 3rd Avenue between 5th Street and 202 feet north of TH 2, length 0.03 mile; and D.) CP 0048-153453 (Tied), SAP 69-648-030, on CSAH 48 (211 ct Avenue) between TH 2 and CSAH 14 (5th Street), length 0.38 mile. The motion passed; six yeas, zero nays, one absent (Rukavina). Resolution No. 17-304.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 5/9/17; Resolution No. 17-304, 5/9/17]

Stauber Moved To Award A $2,761,416 Bid To Ulland Brothers, Inc. For A Construction Project

May 2017: Stauber Moved To Award A $2,761,416 Bid To Ulland Brothers, Inc. For A Construction Project. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Olson, moved to award a bid to UIJand Brothers, Inc., of Cloquet, MN, in the amount of $2,761,426.00 for project CP 0003-216102 TST (Low Prime), culvert replacement, full depth reclamation, miii bituminous surface, base stabilization, bituminous surface, aggregate shoulders and bituminous seal coat, grade corrections and guard rails at 8 locations throughout Duluth, Proctor and Midway Township. The motion passed; six yeas, zero nays, one absent (Rukavina). Resolution No. 17-305.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 5/9/17; Resolution No. 17-305, 5/9/17]

Stauber Moved To Award A $1,158,711.81 Bid To Scott Construction Of Lake Delton, Wisconsin For A Construction Project

April 2017: Stauber Moved To Award A $1,158,711.81 Bid To Scott Construction Of Lake Delton, Wisconsin For A Construction Project. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Boyle, moved to award a bid to Scott Construction, Inc., of Lake Delton, WI, in the amount of $1,158,711.81 for project CP 0000- 323208 (Prime), Bituminous Seal Coat, Fog Seal, and Pavement Markings at 19 locations throughout St. Louis County, Lake County, and the City of Duluth. Commissioner Rukavina voiced concerns regarding the chip seal process and the lack of Project Labor Agreements for chip seal projects. After further discussion, the motion passed; five yeas, one nay (Rukavina), one absent (Jewell). Resolution No. 17-265.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 4/25/17; Resolution No. 17-265, 4/25/17]

Stauber Moved To Table The Award Of A Bid To Mark Sand & Gravel Co. For A Combined Bituminous Reclamation And Surfacing Project To March 28

March 2017: Stauber Moved To Table The Award Of A Bid To Mark Sand & Gravel Co. For A Combined Bituminous Reclamation And Surfacing Project To March 28. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Nelson, moved to table the Award of Bid, Mark Sand & Gravel Co., Combined Bituminous Reclamation and Surfacing Project, to the March 28, 2017 Board meeting. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 3/14/17]

Stauber Moved To Award A $4,050,861.50 Bid To ASTECH Corp For A Construction Bid

Feb. 2017: Stauber Moved To Award A $4,050,861.50 Bid To ASTECH Corp For A Construction Bid. “WHEREAS, Bids have been received electronically by the St. Louis County Public Works Department for the following project: CP 0000-322853 Prime: 58 locations throughout St. Louis County and 3 locations in Canosia Township; and WHEREAS, Bids were opened in the Richard H. Hansen Transportation & Public Works Complex, Duluth, MN, on January 19,2017, and the low responsible bid determined; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board approves the award on the above project to the low bidder: LOW BIDDER ASTECH Corp. ADDRESS P.O. Box 1023 AMOUNT $4,050,861.50 St. Cloud, MN 56302 RESOLVED FURTHER, That the appropriate county officials are authorized to approve the Contractor's Performance Bonds and to execute the bonds and contract for the above listed project, payable from Fund 200, Agency 203466, Object 652800. With additional revenue budgeted for expense: Canosia Township, Fund 200, Agency 203466, Rev. Object 551511 $68,476.69 Commissioner Stauber moved the adoption of the Resolution and it was declared adopted upon the following vote: Yeas - Commissioners Boyle, Olson, Stauber, Nelson, Jugovich and Chair Jewell- 6 Nays -

114 Commissioner Rukavina – 1[.]” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 2/7/17; Resolution No. 17- 79, 2/7/17]

Funding

Stauber Moved To Direct The Public Health And Human Services Department To Include $45,000 In Its 2018 Budget For The Arrowhead Economic Opportunity Agency Rural Rides Program

Oct. 2017: Stauber Moved To Direct The Public Health And Human Services Department To Include $45,000 In Its 2018 Budget For The Arrowhead Economic Opportunity Agency Rural Rides Program. [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 10/3/17; Resolution No. 17-427, 10/3/17]

Stauber Moved To Authorize An Agreement With Arrowhead Regional Corrections For The “Reconstruction Of Abrahamson Road And North East Regional Corrections Center Parking Lots”

March 2017: Stauber Moved To Authorize An Agreement With Arrowhead Regional Corrections For The “Reconstruction Of Abrahamson Road And North East Regional Corrections Center Parking Lots.” “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Nelson, moved to authorize the appropriate county officials to enter into an agreement, and any amendments approved by the County Attorney, with Arrowhead Regional Corrections for the reconstruction of Abrahamson Road and North East Regional Corrections Center (NERCC) parking lots, CP 0000-322411 , whereby Arrowhead Regional Corrections will pay the ‘Arrowhead Regional Corrections’ items listed in the Plan. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 17-137.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 3/7/17; Resolution No. 17-137, 3/7/17]

Licenses

Stauber Moved To Consider A Resolution To Waive An Ordinance In Order To Allow On-Sale Intoxicating Liquor Sales Between 8 And 10 AM On Sunday 29, 2017

Oct. 2017: Stauber Moved To Consider A Resolution To Waive An Ordinance In Order To Allow On-Sale Intoxicating Liquor Sales Between 8 And 10 AM On Sunday 29, 2017. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Olson, moved to consider a resolution to waive Ordinance No. 28, Section 11.02, to allow On-sale Intoxicating Liquor sales between the hours of 8:00 a.m. to 10:00 a.m. on Sunday, October 29, 2017, only; the item had not been to Committee of the Whole. The motion passed; six yeas, zero nays, one absent (Rukavina).” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 10/10/17]

Stauber Moved To Approve An Off-Sale Intoxicating Liquor License To Gnesen Convenience Store, LLC

July 2017: Stauber Moved To Approve An Off-Sale Intoxicating Liquor License To Gnesen Convenience Store, LLC. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Rukavina, moved to approve the issuance of an off-sale intoxicating liquor license to Gnesen Convenience Store, LLC d/b/a Gnesen Convenience Store, LLC, Gnesen Township. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 17-427.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/11/17; Resolution No. 17-427, 7/11/17]

Stauber Moved To Approve A Lawful Gambling License Application To The Lake Superior Steelhead Association

April 2017: Stauber Moved To Approve A Lawful Gambling License Application To The Lake Superior Steelhead Association. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Boyle, moved to approve a Lawful Gambling License Application (raffle) on file in the office of the County Auditor, identified as County Board File No. 60394, for the following organization: Lake Superior Steelhead Association, P.O. Box 16034, Duluth, MN, 55816, to conduct off-site gambling on April 22, 2017, raffle, at Clearwater Grille, 5135 North Shore Drive,

115 Duluth, MN, 55804, Duluth Township. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 17-244.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 4/11/17; Resolution No. 17-244, 4/11/17]

2017 – Supported Resolutions And Motions

Contracts

Stauber Supported A Motion To Award A $4,873,697.27 Bid To KGM Contractors For A “Combined Bituminous Reclamation And Surfacing Project”

March 2017: Stauber Supported A Motion To Award A $4,873,697.27 Bid To KGM Contractors For A “Combined Bituminous Reclamation And Surfacing Project.” “Commissioner Rukavina, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to award a bid to KGM Contractors, Inc., of Angora, MN, in the amount of $4,873,697.27 for a combined bituminous reclamation and surfacing project in Kabetogama Township and Unorganized Townships 68-21,68-20 and 68-19. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 17- 183.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 3/28/17; Resolution No. 17-183, 3/28/17]

Environment

Stauber Supported A Motion To Authorize The Land And Minerals Department To Submit A $4 Million Grant Application To Promote Biomass Utilization And Production

May 2017: Stauber Supported A Motion To Authorize The Land And Minerals Department To Submit A $4 Million Grant Application To Promote Biomass Utilization And Production. “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to authorize the Land and Minerals Department to submit a grant application to the Legislative and Citizens Commission on Minnesota Resources (LCCMR) in the amount of four million dollars to promote biomass utilization on St. Louis County lands and support biomass production for the logging and business community and for local biomass facilities. Commissioner Nelson mentioned that the Board had considered a similar resolution a few weeks ago; this resolution differs because St. Louis County is applying for the grant as a separate entity. Commissioner Olson stepped out of the meeting from 10:28 a.m. to 10:32 a.m. Scott Dane, Executive Director of the Associated Contract Loggers and Truckers, said his organization feels that Xcel Energy should honor their original deal regarding biomass production; however, they are comfortable with St. Louis County being named on the grant application. St. Louis County Land and Minerals Director Mark Weber noted that funds would be used to improve public safety, promote biomass energy, and for forest management purposes. After further discussion, the motion passed; six yeas, zero nays, one absent (Rukavina). Resolution No. 17-306.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 5/9/17; Resolution No. 17-306, 5/9/17]

Development

Stauber Supported A Motion To Consider Authorizing A Petition “To Vacate 1st Street South As Part of The Government Services Center – Virginia Project”

Sept. 2017: Stauber Supported A Motion To Consider Authorizing A Petition “To Vacate 1st Street South As Part of The Government Services Center – Virginia Project.” “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to consider a resolution to authorize a petition process to vacate 1st Street South as part of the Government Services Center - Virginia project; the item had not been to Committee of the Whole. The motion passed; six yeas, one nay (Rukavina).” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 9/5/17; Resolution No. 17-477, 9/5/17]

Stauber Supported A Motion To “Consider A Resolution To Amend A Demolition Contract With Carleton Companies, Inc.”

116 Oct. 2017: Stauber Supported A Motion To “Consider A Resolution To Amend A Demolition Contract With Carleton Companies, Inc.” “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to consider a resolution to amend a demolition contract with Carleton Companies, Inc., for emergency repairs at 507 and 511 Grant Avenue (Eveleth); the item had not been to Committee of the Whole. The motion passed; six yeas, zero nays, one absent (Rukavina).” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 10/10/17]

Funding

Stauber Supported A Motion To Remove From The Table A Resolution To Authorize A 2018 $45,000 Contribution To The Arrowhead Economic Opportunity Agency (AEOA) Rural Rides Program

Nov. 2017: Stauber Supported A Motion To Remove From The Table A Resolution To Authorize A 2018 $45,000 Contribution To The Arrowhead Economic Opportunity Agency (AEOA) Rural Rides Program. “Commissioner Boyle, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to remove from the table a resolution to authorize a 2018 contribution in the amount of $45,000 to the Arrowhead Economic Opportunity Agency (AEOA) Rural Rides Program (Tabled on October 3, 2017). The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 11/7/17]

Stauber Supported A Motion To Authorize The Expenditure Of The 2016 State Homeland Security Program

Aug. 2017: Stauber Supported A Motion To Authorize The Expenditure Of The 2016 State Homeland Security Program. “Commissioner Boyle, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to authorize the expenditure of the 2016 State Homeland Security Program grant in the amount of$42,846, to be accounted for in Fund 100, Agency 132999, Grant 13212,Year 2017; that the match of$47,265.33 will be accounted for by $30,000 from federal forfeitures and $17,265.33 from Fund 100, Agency 136001 , Object 629900; and further, that the appropriate county officials are authorized to execute all agreements and contracts necessary to fulfill the 2016 State Homeland Security Program as approved by the St. Louis County Attorney, with St. Louis County serving as coordinator and fiscal agent for the grant. St. Louis County Sheriff Ross Litman said the grant money will be used to add a bi-directional amplifier, which will improve Allied Radio Matrix for Emergency Response (ARMER) signal strength in various school districts. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 17- 477[.]” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 8/1/17; Resolution No. 17-477, 8/1/17]

Taxes

Stauber Supported A Motion To Remove From The Table A Resolution To Consider The Abatement Request For The Art Center Real Estate In Duluth, MN

Nov. 2017: Stauber Supported A Motion To Remove From The Table A Resolution To Consider The Abatement Request For The Art Center Real Estate In Duluth, MN. “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to remove from the table a resolution to consider the abatement request for Parcel Coe 010-0410-00080, 222 Art Center Real Estate in Duluth, MN (Tabled on October 3, 2017). The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 11/7/17]

2016 – Offered Resolutions And Motions

Ceremonial

Stauber Moved To Consider A Proclamation Recognizing The Service of Deputy Administrator Gary Eckenberg

Oct. 2016: Stauber Moved To Consider A Proclamation Recognizing The Service of Deputy Administrator Gary Eckenberg. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Dahlberg, moved to consider a 117 proclamation recognizing the service of Deputy Administrator Gary Eckenberg; the item had not been to committee. The motion passed; five yeas, zero nays, two absent (Nelson, Raukar). Commissioner Rukavina, supported by Commissioner Boyle, moved to proclaim the week of October 24-28, 2016, as Gary Eckenberg Appreciation Week in St. Louis County. St. Louis County Administrator Kevin Gray read the proclamation. After further discussion, the motion passed; five yeas, zero nays, two absent (Nelson, Raukar). Resolution No. 16-654.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 10/25/16]

Contracts

Stauber Moved To Authorize An Agreement With Carlton County And Itasca County To Install Roadway Lighting At 58 Rural Intersections

Nov. 2016: Stauber Moved To Authorize An Agreement With Carlton County And Itasca County To Install Roadway Lighting At 58 Rural Intersections. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Nelson, moved to authorize the appropriate county officials to enter into a cooperative agreement with Carlton County and Itasca County, and any amendments authorized by the County Attorney, to install roadway lighting at fifty-eight (58) rural intersections. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 16-693.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 11/22/16; Resolution No. 16-693, 11/22/16]

Stauber Moved To Award A $493,306.60 Bid To Ulland Brothers, Inc. For A Paving Project In Rice Lake

Oct. 2016: Stauber Moved To Award A $493,306.60 Bid To Ulland Brothers, Inc. For A Paving Project In Rice Lake. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Rukavina, moved to award a bid to Ulland Brothers, Inc., Cloquet, MN, in the amount of $493,306.60 for a paving project on Rice Lake Dam Road located in the city of Rice Lake (CP 0000-215963, SAP 69-600-044). The motion passed; four yeas, zero nays, three absent (Boyle, Nelson, Raukar). Resolution No. 16-646.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 10/25/16; Resolution No. 16-646, 10/25/16]

Stauber Moved To Consider A Resolution “To Authorize The Award Of Bid For Project CP 00023-72711”

March 2016: Stauber Moved To Consider A Resolution “To Authorize The Award Of Bid For Project CP 00023-72711.” “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Nelson, moved to consider a resolution authorize the award of bid for project CP 00023-72711 TST/SP 69-623-032 (City of Orr, Leiding and Portage Townships); the item has not been to Committee of the Whole. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 3/22/16]

Stauber Moved To Award A $3,693,796.80 Bid To Northland Constructors Of Duluth, LLC For A Reclaim/Resurface/Chip Seal Project

March 2016: Stauber Moved To Award A $3,693,796.80 Bid To Northland Constructors Of Duluth, LLC For A Reclaim/Resurface/Chip Seal Project. “Award of Bid: Reclaim/Resurface/Chip Seal Project (City of Orr, Leiding and Portage Townships) […] Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Boyle, moved to award a bid to Northland Constructors, LLC, of Duluth, MN, in the amount of $3,693,796.80 for project CP 0023-72711 TST/SP 69-623-032, located on CSAH 23 from TH 53 to CSAH 24, length 15.92 miles, City of Orr, Leiding and Portage Townships. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 16-185. [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 3/22/16; Resolution No. 16-185, 3/22/16]

Stauber Moved To Award A $2,444,480.96 Bid To ASTECH Corp For A Tied Chip Seal Project

March 2016: Stauber Moved To Award A $2,444,480.96 Bid To ASTECH Corp For A Tied Chip Seal Project. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Nelson, moved to award a bid to ASTECH Corp., of St. Cloud, MN, in the amount of $2,444,480.96 for combined project […] After further Commissioner discussion,

118 the motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 16-184.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 3/22/16; Resolution No. 16-184, 3/22/16]

Commissioner Rukavina “Expressed Concerns With ASTECH Utilizing Their Own Crew” And Not “Local Labor.” “Commissioner Rukavina expressed concerns with ASTECH utilizing their own crew (not using local labor) and questioned the use of chip sealing. Commissioner Jewell stepped out of the meeting from 10:20 a.m. to 10:22 a.m. Commissioner Stauber stepped out of the meeting from 10:24 a.m. to 10:25 a.m. Commissioner Dahlberg stepped out of the meeting from 10:26 a.m. to 10:27 a.m. After further Commissioner discussion, the motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 16-184.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 3/22/16]

Development

Stauber Moved To Consider A Resolution For The “Establishment And Designation Of County Road 102” In The City Of Mountain Iron

Jan. 2016: Stauber Moved To Consider A Resolution For The “Establishment And Designation Of County Road 102” In The City Of Mountain Iron. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Nelson, moved to consider a resolution for the establishment and designation of County Road 102 (City of Mountain Iron); the item has not been to Committee of the Whole. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 1/5/16]

Taxes

Stauber Moved To Approve The St. Louis County Greater MN Transportation Sales And Use Tax Transportation Improvement Plan

July 2016: Stauber Moved To Approve The St. Louis County Greater MN Transportation Sales And Use Tax Transportation Improvement Plan. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Nelson, moved to approve the St. Louis County Greater MN Transportation Sales and Use Tax Transportation Improvement Plan, dated November 25, 2014, Amended July 5, 2016 and approves the funding of such transportation improvements identified in the Transportation Improvement Plan, as amended, by the local option sales and use tax for transportation authorized by County Board Resolution No. 14-665, adopted December 2, 2014. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 16-447.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/5/16; Resolution No. 16-421, 7/5/16]

The Tax Transportation Improvement Plan Included “Additional Projects To Be Funded” From The Tax And An Increase In The Estimated Cost Of The Projects From $642,000,000 To $894,916,448. “WHEREAS, Under and pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, Section 297A.993 (the “Act”), the St. Louis County Board (the “County Board”) has previously approved Resolution No. 14-665 on December 2, 2014, implementing the Greater Minnesota Transportation Sales and Use Tax and approving the projects to be funded with such sales and use tax as set forth in the transportation improvement plan identified as the St. Louis County Greater MN Transportation Sales and Use Tax Transportation Plan dated November 25, 2014, and approved on December 2, 2014 (the ‘Transportation Improvement Plan’); and WHEREAS, The County Board has proposed an amendment to the Transportation Improvement Plan, which includes within the proposed amendment the additional projects to be funded from local option sales and use tax for transportation and an increase in the estimated cost of the projects to be financed under the Transportation Improvement Plan, as amended, from $642,000,000 to $894,916,448; and WHEREAS, Pursuant to the Act and County Board Resolution No. 14-665 and following published notice of the public hearing, the County Board held a public hearing for the purpose of receiving comments on the proposed amendment to the Transportation Improvement Plan on Tuesday, July 5, 2016, in the St. Louis County Courthouse, Duluth, Minnesota. THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board of Commissioners hereby approves the St. Louis County Greater MN Transportation Sales and Use Tax Transportation Improvement Plan, dated November 25, 2014, 119 Amended July 5, 2016 (County Board File No. 60387), and approves the funding of such transportation improvements identified in the Transportation Improvement Plan, as amended, by the local option sales and use tax for transportation authorized by County Board Resolution No. 14-665 adopted December 2, 2014. Unanimously adopted July 5, 2016. No. 16-447[.]” [Resolution No. 16-447, 7/5/16]

Transportation

Stauber Moved To Express Approval And Support For The Development Of A U.S. Bicycle Route

Oct. 2016: Stauber Moved To Express Approval And Support For The Development Of A U.S. Bicycle Route. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Nelson, moved that the St. Louis County Board hereby expresses its approval and support for the development of United States Bicycle Route 41 to the extent that the designation does not obligate the county to future expenditures as a result of the designation and requests that the appropriate government officials take action to officially designate the route accordingly as soon as possible; and further, that the St. Louis County Board urges the Minnesota Department of Transportation (MnDOT), and the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO) and the Federal Highway Administration to seek and/or support the creation of funding sources or programs specific to designated United States Bicycle Routes for the purpose of constructing, reconstructing and maintaining those routes. St. Louis County Public Works Director Jim Foldesi reviewed changes to the replacement resolution as recommended by the Board during the October 4, 2016 Committee of the Whole meeting. The motion passed; six yeas, zero nays, one absent (Rukavina). Resolution No. 16-637.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 10/11/16; Resolution No. 16-421, 10/11/16]

Stauber Moved To Consider A Resolution To Establish An Additional Public Hearing On An ATV Ordinance

April 2016: Stauber Moved To Consider A Resolution To Establish An Additional Public Hearing On An ATV Ordinance. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Boyle, moved to consider a resolution to establish an additional public hearing on the ATV Ordinance to occur on Tuesday, May 10, 2016, at 9:45 a.m. at the St. Louis County Courthouse, Duluth, MN; the item had not been to committee. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 4/26/16]

Stauber Moved To Pass A Resolution In Support Of The FASTLANE Grant Application That The Minnesota Department Of Transportation Was Submitting To The Federal Highway Administration

April 2016: Stauber Moved To Pass A Resolution In Support Of The FASTLANE Grant Application That The Minnesota Department Of Transportation Was Submitting To The Federal Highway Administration. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Dahlberg, moved to consider a resolution in support of the Fostering Advancements in Shipping and Transportation for the Long-Term Achievement of National Efficiencies (FASTLANE) grant application that the Minnesota Department of Transportation (MnDOT) will be submitting to the Federal Highway Administration to replace the I35/I535/TH 53 interchange in Duluth; the item had not been to committee. The motion passed; six yeas, zero nays, one absent (Rukavina).” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 4/12/16; Resolution No. 16-253, 4/12/16]

Stauber Moved To Pass A Resolution To Offer The County’s Support In Helping The Duluth Airport Authority “Retain AAR” And Stakeholders Affected By Proposed Runway Extension And Improvements

March 2016: Stauber Moved To Pass A Resolution To Offer The County’s Support In Helping The Duluth Airport Authority “Retain AAR” And Stakeholders Affected By Proposed Runway Extension And Improvements. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Jewell, moved to offer the good offices of the county in support of the City of Duluth and Duluth Airport Authority in their effort to retain AAR and other affected stakeholders, and in support of obtaining critical funding for the 321 and 927 runway extension needs and

120 improvements. After further discussion, the motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 16-186.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 3/22/16; Resolution No. 16-186, 3/22/16]

The Duluth City Administrative Officer Spoke During A Commissioner Meeting About The Planned Reconstruction’s “Potential Impacts To AAR Aircraft Services.” “Chair Raukar introduced City of Duluth Chief Administrative Officer Dave Montgomery. Mr. Montgomery discussed the planned reconstruction of the Duluth International Airport’s 10,200-foot main runway (runway 927) and discussed issues relating to the reconstruction. Among the concerns discussed included scheduling and potential impacts to AAR Aircraft Services.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 3/22/16]

Stauber Moved To Consider A Resolution For The French River Wayside Transportation Alternatives Program Grant Application, A Federal Funded Program For Infrastructure Projects

Jan. 2016: Stauber Moved To Consider A Resolution For The French River Wayside Transportation Alternatives Program Grant Application, A Federal Funded Program For Infrastructure Projects. “WHEREAS, The Transportation Alternatives Program (TAP) is a federally funded program to fund infrastructure and non-infrastructure projects; and WHEREAS, The Minnesota Department of Transportation administers the Transportation Alternatives Program for local agencies in Minnesota; and WHEREAS, St. Louis County is working in cooperation with the Duluth-Superior Metropolitan Interstate Council to submit a TAP grant application to perform ADA improvements, parking lot improvements, and bicycle safety improvements at the French River Wayside and on County Bridge 906; and WHEREAS, Funding is anticipated to be 60% Federal ($360,000) and 40% St. Louis County local match ($240,000), payable from Fund 220, Agency 220001, Object 652700 (St. Louis County State Aid funds); THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board of Commissioners agrees to act as sponsoring agency for a Transportation Alternatives Program project identified as CP 0061-283486 and has reviewed and approved the project as proposed. Sponsorship includes a willingness to secure and guarantee the local share of costs associated with this project and responsibility for seeing this project through to its completion, with compliance of all applicable laws, rules and regulations. Commissioner Stauber moved the adoption of the Resolution and it was declared adopted upon the following vote: Yeas- Commissioners Jewell, Boyle, Dahlberg, Rukavina, Stauber, Nelson and Chair Raukar- 7 Nays- None[.]” [Resolution No. 16-34, 1/5/16]

Jan. 2016: Stauber Moved To Appoint St. Louis County As The Sponsoring Agency, Which Would Assume Full Responsibility “For The Operation And Maintenance Of Property” Related To The Grant. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Boyle, moved that the sponsoring agency (St. Louis County) agrees to assume full responsibility for the operation and maintenance of property and facilities related to the Transportation Alternatives Program project identified as CP 0061-283486. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 16-35.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 1/5/16; Resolution No. 16-35, 1/5/16]

2016 – Supported Resolutions And Motions

Bonds

Stauber Supported A Motion To Issue $23,315,000 General Obligation Improvement Bonds, “Establish The Terms And Form For The Bond Sale, Create A Debt Service Fund, And Award The Sale

Aug. 2016: Stauber Supported A Motion To Approve The Issuance Of $23,315,000 General Obligation Improvement Bonds, “Establish The Terms And Form For The Bond Sale, Create A Debt Service Fund, And Award The Sale.” “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to approve the Issuance of $23,315,000 General Obligation Capital Improvement Bonds, Series 2016A, establish the terms and form for the bond sale, create a debt service fund, and award the sale. Commissioner Dahlberg stepped out of the meeting from 10:37 a.m. to 10:40 a.m. Commissioner Rukavina stepped out of the meeting from 10:37 a.m. to 10:42 a.m. Commissioner Stauber stepped out of the meeting from 10:43 a.m. to 10:48 a.m. St. Louis County Auditor Don Dicklich indicated the issuance would result in a lower debt service for the citizens of St. Louis 121 County. Terri Heaton, of Springsted Incorporated, reviewed the bond sale results and said the low interest rates can be attributed St. Louis County’s AA+ bond rating, strong management, and strong financial practices. After further discussion, the motion passed; six yeas, zero nays, one absent (Jewell). Resolution No. 16-528.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 8/9/16; Resolution No. 16-528, 8/9/16]

Contracts

Stauber Supported A Motion “To Authorize The Purchase Of 2016 Fleet Vehicles From Various Vendors”

March 2016: Stauber Supported A Motion “To Authorize The Purchase Of 2016 Fleet Vehicles From Various Vendors.” “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to authorize the purchase of 2016 fleet vehicles from various vendors in accordance with Bid No. 5278. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 16-166.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 4/8/16; Resolution No. 16-666 4/8/16]

Aug. 2016: Stauber Supported A Motion To Award A Bid To Redstone Construction, LLC For $728,780.45 For A Construction Project. “Commissioner Rukavina, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to award a bid to Redstone Construction, LLC., of Mora, MN, in the amount of $728,780.45 for project CP 0937-243934 TST, Approach Grading and Bridge 69A44 (County Bridge 655) located on County Road (CR) 937 between County State Aid Highway (CSAH) 115 and CR 540, length 0.12 mile, in Field Township, MN. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 16-497.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 8/2/16; Resolution No. 16-497, 8/2/16]

Stauber Moved To Consider A Bid Award For A Bridget Project On County Road 937

Aug. 2016: Stauber Supported A Motion To Consider A Bid Award For A Bridget Project On County Road 937. “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to consider an award of bid for a bridge project on County Road 937 located in Field Township; the item had not been to committee. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 8/2/16]

Stauber Supported A Motion To Purchase Four City Lots From The City Of Virginia For “Purposes Of County Parking” For $118,000

Aug. 2016: Stauber Supported A Motion To Purchase Four City Lots From The City Of Virginia For “Purposes Of County Parking” For $118,000. “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to approve the purchase of four city lots (parcel codes 090-0010-07570, 090-0010-07550 and 090-0010- 07530) from the City of Virginia for purposes of county parking adjacent to the County Motor Pool in Virginia, MN, for a cost of $118,000, plus filing fees. The motion passed; six yeas, zero nays, one absent (Jewell). Resolution No. 16-524.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 8/9/16; Resolution No. 16-524, 8/9/16]

Funding

Stauber Supported A Motion To Authorize A $15,000 Contract With The Arrowhead Regional Corrections For The Hiring Of One Full Time Probation Officer For Mental Health Court Participants

Nov. 2016: Stauber Supported A Motion To Authorize A $15,000 Contract With The Arrowhead Regional Corrections For The Hiring Of One Full Time Probation Officer For Mental Health Court Participants. “Commissioner Boyle, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to authorize the appropriate county officials to enter into a contract with Arrowhead Regional Corrections in the amount of $150,000 for the period January 1, 2017 through December 31, 2018, for the hiring of a 1.0 FTE Probation Officer to serve Mental Health Court participants; and further, that the program will be evaluated on a bi-annual basis, and if the program is not continued, the position will be eliminated. Arrowhead Regional Corrections Executive Director Kay Arola briefly 122 discussed the program. Commissioner Rukavina expressed concern regarding the lack of data confirming success of the program in other jurisdictions. After further discussion, the motion passed; five yeas, two nays (Dahlberg, Rukavina). Resolution No. 16-709.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 11/22/16; Resolution No. 16-709, 11/22/16]

Stauber Supported A Motion To “Approve The Apportionment Of The 2015 Land And Minerals Department Net Proceeds Of $2,432,632.91”

March 2016: Stauber Supported A Motion To “Approve The Apportionment Of The 2015 Land And Minerals Department Net Proceeds Of $2,432,632.91.” “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to approve the apportionment of the 2015 Land and Minerals Department net proceeds of $2,432,632.91. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 16-147[.]” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 3/22/16; Resolution No. 16-147, 3/22/16]

Elections

Stauber Supported A Motion To Designate Unorganized Precinct 24 As A Mail Ballot Precinct

March 2016: Stauber Supported A Motion To Designate Unorganized Precinct 24 As A Mail Ballot Precinct. “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to designate Unorganized Precinct 24 as a mail ballot precinct for all future state and county elections pursuant to Minn. Stat. § 204B.45. The motion was amended to include wording that if the Morse Township Board allows Unorganized Precinct 24 to vote at the Morse Township polling place at no charge to St. Louis County, then Unorganized Precinct 24 is not designated as a mail ballot precinct. After further discussion, the motion passed; five yeas, two nays (Rukavina, Jewell). Resolution No. 16-183.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 3/22/16; Resolution No. 16-183, 3/22/16]

Licenses

March 2016: Stauber Supported A Motion To Approve An Off-Sale Intoxicating Liquor License To Cast Iron, IIC. “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to approve granting the off-sale intoxicating liquor license to Cast Iron, LLC d/b/a Cast Iron, LLC, Grand Lake Township. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 16-143[.]” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 3/1/16; Resolution No. 16-143, 3/1/16]

Stauber Supported A Motion To Approve Granting An Off-Sale Intoxicating Liquor License To Shane Clemens D/B/A Alborn Rail Station

March 2016: Stauber Supported A Motion To Approve Granting An Off-Sale Intoxicating Liquor License To Shane Clemens D/B/A Alborn Rail Station. “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to approve granting the off-sale intoxicating liquor license to Shane Clemens d/b/a Alborn Rail Station, Alborn Township. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 16-142[.]” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 3/1/16; Resolution No. 16-142, 3/1/16]

Opioids

Stauber Supported A Motion To Hire Of Two Additional Full Time Social Workers “To Support The Sixth Judicial District And Work As Part Of The Opioid And Clinical Case Management Initiative”

123 Public Health and Human Services Department to hire two (2.0) FTE Social Workers to support the Sixth Judicial District and work as part of the Opioid and Clinical Case Management Initiative; and further, the positions will be funded from the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration grant in the amount of $75,000 for each position for a total of $150,000 per year for three years (2016-2018) with the positions ending when the grant funding ends. Commissioner Rukavina expressed concern that the majority of St. Louis County jobs were centered in Duluth. Deputy Administrator Linnea Mirsch indicated that these positions would be located in proximity to the Specialty Courts. Commissioner Dahlberg discussed his concerns that people in grant-funded positions remain employed by St. Louis County after grant funding stops. After further discussion, the motion passed; three yeas (Jewell, Boyle, Stauber), two nays (Dahlberg, Rukavina), two absent (Nelson, Raukar). Resolution No. 16-640.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 10/25/16; Resolution No. 16-640, 10/25/16]

Public Safety

Stauber Supported A Motion To Authorize Hiring Two New Full Time Deputy Sheriff Positions As School Resources Officers

Stauber Supported A Motion To Declare A State Of Local Emergency In St. Louis County Due To Storms

July 2016: Stauber Supported A Motion To Declare A State Of Local Emergency In St. Louis County Due To Storms. “Commissioner Dahlberg, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to declare a STATE OF LOCAL EMERGENCY in St. Louis County, Minnesota, due to conditions resulting from the thunderstorms, hurricane velocity winds, massive tree blowdown, damage to public and private property and extended power outages resulting from the severe thunderstorms of July 5 and July 21, 2016, and requests state public disaster assistance in accordance with Minn. Stat. §12B.30 for any eligible storm recovery activities. Commissioner Stauber stepped out of the meeting from 12:02 p.m. to 12:04 p.m. Commissioner Rukavina stepped out of the meeting from 12:03 p.m. to 12:05 p.m. St. Louis County Sheriff Ross Litman said that the Division of Emergency Management has been meeting twice daily to discuss storm related issues. Sheriff Litman said that by declaring a local

124 emergency, the county could take advantage of potential state and federal disaster funds. Commissioner Boyle stepped out of the meeting from 12:32 p.m. to 12:34 p.m. Commissioner Dahlberg stepped out of the meeting from 12:35 p.m. to 12:40 p.m. County Assessor Dave Sipila said the Assessor’s Office would begin re-assessing the areas affected by the storm starting Monday, August 1, 2016. After further discussion, the motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 16-480.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/26/16; Resolution No. 16-480, 7/26/16]

Stauber Supported A Motion To Pass A Resolution Proclaiming Child Abuse Prevention Month

April 2016: Stauber Supported A Motion To Pass A Resolution Proclaiming Child Abuse Prevention Month. “Commissioner Boyle, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved that the St. Louis County Board recognizes that protecting children is everyone’s job, and declares its continued commitment to the collaboration between St. Louis County staff and all community partners in this effort and hereby proclaims April 2016 as Child Abuse Prevention Month and urges all citizens to work together to help protect children from abuse and neglect. Commissioner Boyle read the proclamation. St. Louis County Social Services Supervisor Mary Ness discussed challenges relating to foster care and thanked the Board for their continued support. After further discussion, the motion passed; six yeas, zero nays, one absent (Rukavina). Resolution No. 16-252.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 4/12/16; Resolution No. 16-252, 4/12/16]

Stauber Supported A Motion To Authorize Public Safety Innovation Funds For A Trial Initiative, Which Included A New County Employed Probation Officer And Social Worker

April 2016: Stauber Supported A Motion To Authorize Public Safety Innovation Funds For A Trial Initiative, Which Included A New County Employed Probation Officer And Social Worker. “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to authorize the use of Public Safety Innovation Funds for Team 25 for a 21-month initiative from April 1, 2016 through December 31, 2017; that the appropriate county officials are authorized to enter into a contract with Arrowhead Regional Corrections for St. Louis County and to authorize payment at a 21-month cost of $193,99; and further, that an additional1.0 FTE Social Worker be added to PHHS for this initiative, to be paid out of the transfer of funds from the Public Safety Innovation assigned fund balance account in the amount of $189,408 to a new agency in the Sheriff’s Office budget for this grant program and that the additional $20,000 be transferred into this agency for training and mileage expenses. If the Team 25 initiative is terminated, these additional positions will be eliminated. St. Louis County Sheriff Ross Litman said the program will help get people in the right program quicker, which would in turn reduce the average length of stay in St. Louis County jails. After further discussion, the motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 16-222.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 4/5/16; Resolution No. 16-222, 4/5/16]

Taxes

Stauber Supported A Motion To Authorize The County Auditor “To Spread Local Levies For The Provision Of Fire Protection And/or First Responder Services To Identified Unorganized Townships”

Sept. 2016: Stauber Supported A Motion To Authorize The County Auditor “To Spread Local Levies For The Provision Of Fire Protection And/or First Responder Services To Identified Unorganized Townships.” “Commissioner Rukavina, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to authorize the County Auditor to spread local levies for the provision of fire protection and/or first responder services to identified unorganized territories within the county beginning January 1, 2017 and to authorize the agreements with the listed corporations for the provision of these services (Option B). The Board recessed at 10:59 a.m. and reconvened at 11:11 a.m. with all Commissioners present. Commissioner discussion continued regarding the authorization of Fire Protection / First Responder Services Contracts for Unorganized Territories. St. Louis County Auditor Don Dicklich indicated the difference between the two options is coverage for Unorganized Township 61-12. Terry Soderberg, of Ely, spoke in favor of Option B. Bruce Williams, of Eveleth, spoke in favor of Option A. Fire Chief Trent McDowell and Assistant Chief Tony Chamberlin, of the Babbitt Fire Department, discussed the number of square miles the Babbitt Fire Department covers. After further discussion, the motion was amended to select Option A. The amended motion

125 passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 16-582.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 9/13/16; Resolution No. 16-582, 9/13/16]

Tax Forfeited Land

Stauber Supported A Motion To Move An Application For Repurchase Of State Tax Forfeited Property To The Committee Of The Whole Meeting

April 2016: Stauber Supported A Motion To Move An Application For Repurchase Of State Tax Forfeited Property To The Committee Of The Whole Meeting. “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to send Item #3b, Application for repurchase of state tax forfeited property, Prosperity House, LLC, Duluth, MN, to the Committee of the Whole meeting. The motion passed; six yeas, zero nays, one absent (Rukavina).” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 4/12/16]

Transportation

Stauber Supported A Motion To Pass A Resolution For St. Louis County To Support To Replace The I35/I535/TH 53 Interchange Through The FASTLANE Grant

April 2016: Stauber Supported A Motion To Pass A Resolution For St. Louis County To Support To Replace The I35/I535/TH 53 Interchange Through The FASTLANE Grant. “Commissioner Dahlberg, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved that the St. Louis County Board supports the project to replace the I35/I535/TH 53 interchange and associated bridges and authorizes the County Board Chair to send a letter to MnDOT in support of the project to replace the I35/I535/TH 53 interchange and associated bridges to be included in the FASTLANE grant application being submitted to the Federal Highway Administration. The motion passed; six yeas, zero nays, one absent (Rukavina). Resolution No. 16-253.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 4/12/16; Resolution No. 16-253, 4/12/16]

Stauber Supported A Motion To Consider A Resolution For The Stoney Point Wayside Transportation Alternatives Program Grant Application

Jan. 2016: Stauber Supported A Motion To Consider A Resolution For The Stoney Point Wayside Transportation Alternatives Program Grant Application. “Commissioner Boyle, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to consider a resolution for the Stoney Point Wayside Transportation Alternatives Program Grant Application; the item has not been to Committee of the Whole. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 1/5/16]

Jan. 2016: Stauber Supported A Motion To Consider A Resolution For The Stoney Point Wayside Transportation Alternatives Program Maintenance Commitment. “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to consider a resolution for the Stoney Point Wayside Transportation Alternatives Program Maintenance Commitment; the item has not been to Committee of the Whole. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 1/5/16]

Jan. 2016: Stauber Supported A Motion To Agree That St. Louis County, The “Sponsoring Agency,” Assume Full Responsibility For The Transportation Alternatives Program. “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved that the sponsoring agency (St. Louis County) agrees to assume full responsibility for the operation and maintenance of property and facilities related to the Transportation Alternatives Program project identified as CP 0222-283485. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 16-37.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 1/5/16; Resolution No. 16-37, 1/5/16]

2015 – Offered Resolutions And Motions

126 Health Care

Stauber Moved To Proclaim A “Public Health Week,” Which Urged Citizens To Focus On Healthy Lifestyles

April 2015: Stauber Moved To Proclaim A “Public Health Week,” Which Urged Citizens To Focus On Healthy Lifestyles. “Chair Stauber, supported by Commissioner Nelson, moved to proclaim the week of April 6 - 10, 2015, as Public Health Week in St. Louis County, and urges all citizens to focus on steps they can take to live a healthier life and to work as a community to eliminate barriers to making healthy choices. Chair Stauber read the proclamation. St. Louis County Public Health and Human Services Director Ann Busche talked about the importance of the work that Public Health and Human Services does and introduced staff members. After further discussion, the motion passed; six yeas, zero nays, one absent (Boyle). Resolution No. 15-187.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 4/7/15; Resolution No. 15-187, 4/7/15]

Taxes

Stauber Moved To Authorize Up To $400,000 Tax Abatement Financing To The City Of Hermantown For The Hermantown Marketplace Project

March 2015: Stauber Moved To Authorize Up To $400,000 Tax Abatement Financing To The City Of Hermantown For The Hermantown Marketplace Project. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Nelson, moved to authorize up to $400,000 tax abatement financing to the City of Hermantown for the Hermantown Marketplace Project; that the City of Hermantown is not required to pay applicant fees; and further, that provided all required documentation is submitted by the City of Hermantown, the appropriate county officials are authorized to execute a business subsidy agreement with the City of Hermantown and any other related documents after review and approval by a representative of the County Attorney’s Office. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 15-139.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 3/10/15; Resolution No. 15-139, 3/10/15]

Oct. 2015: The Board Of Commissioners Voted To Rescind Resolution No. 15-139 And Replace It With Resolution No. 15-625, Which Added An Additional $100,000 In Tax Abatement. “WHEREAS, Minn. Stat. §§ 469.1812 through 469.1815, Abatement Authority, require that a public hearing be conducted prior to approving a tax abatement; and WHEREAS, On March 10, 2015, by Resolution No. 15-139, the St. Louis County Board authorized up to $400,000 in tax abatement financing for the public infrastructure in the Hermantown Marketplace Project; and WHEREAS, The City of Hermantown, MN, has requested St. Louis County to consider an additional $100,000 for a total of $500,000 tax abatement to cover additional costs for the project; and WHEREAS, The St. Louis County Board held a public hearing on Tuesday, October 13, 2015, at 9:40 a.m., at the Hermantown City Council Chambers, Hermantown, MN, to solicit public input prior to considering the additional business subsidy request; and WHEREAS, The St. Louis County Board has determined that the public benefits of increasing the county tax base exceed the costs of tax abatement; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board authorizes up to $500,000 tax abatement financing to the City of Hermantown payable from Fund 100, Agency 100001, Object 500900; RESOLVED FURTHER, That the City of Hermantown is not required to pay applicant fees; RESOLVED FURTHER, That provided all required documentation is submitted by the City of Hermantown, the appropriate county officials are authorized to execute a business subsidy agreement with the City of Hermantown and any other related documents after review and approval by a representative of the County Attorney’s Office; RESOLVED FURTHER, That St. Louis County Board Resolution No. 15-139 is hereby rescinded. Unanimously adopted October 13, 2015. No. 15-625[.]” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 10/13/15; Resolution No. 15-625, 10/13/15]

2015 – Supported Resolutions And Motions

127 Property

Stauber Supported A Motion To Rescind Resolution That Added Two Parcels To A List Of Properties Adjacent Property Owners Would Be Offered Right Of First Refusal

Stauber Supported A Motion To Rescind Resolution 15-103. “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Chair Stauber, moved to rescind Board Resolution No. 15-103. Commissioner Boyle stepped out of the meeting from 12:17 p.m. to 12:18 p.m. Dave Johnson, of Duluth, addressed the Board and stated that Park Point residents were hopeful that parcel 010-4400-01330 (Tract 9) and not parcel 010-4400-01210 (Tract 8) would be removed from the sale. Mr. Johnson said parcel 010-4400-01210 (Tract 8) was more ready for development and he felt that parcel 010-4400-01330 (Tract 9) was a more significant piece of land and should be held in conservation. After further discussion, Commissioner Nelson, supported by Chair Stauber, withdrew the motion to rescind Board Resolution No. 15-103. The meeting recessed from 12:30 p.m. to 12:38 p.m.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 5/5/15]

Feb. 2015: Resolution 15-103 Added Two Parcels To The List Of Properties Adjacent Property Owners Would Be Offered Right Of First Refusal In An Initial 4-3 Vote. “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Raukar, offered an amendment supporting special enabling legislation to offer these thirty-six (36) parcels to adjacent property owners contingent upon the county’s offering for public sale in June 2015, two (2) additional tax forfeited parcels located in the Park Point neighborhood, identified as Parcel ID Numbers 010-4400-01330 and 010-4400-01210. The amendment passed; four yeas (Dahlberg, Nelson, Raukar, Stauber), three nays (Boyle, Jewell, Rukavina). The following citizens addressed the Board regarding the resolution: Ken Kollodge, Dennis Fink, and Dulce Proud. After further discussion, the amended motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 15-103.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 2/17/15; Resolution 15-103, 2/17/15]

2014 – Offered Resolutions And Motions

City Lines

Stauber Moved To Support The Town Of Rice Lake To Incorporate As A City

Nov. 2014: Stauber Moved To Support The Town Of Rice Lake To Incorporate As A City. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Nelson, moved that the St. Louis County Board hereby declares its support for the proposed incorporation of the Town of Rice Lake as a city governmental jurisdiction under the laws of the State of Minnesota. St. Louis County Administrator Kevin Gray discussed potential impacts of the incorporation on St. Louis County. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 14-599.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 11/4/14; Resolution 14-599, 11/4/14]

Funding

Stauber Moved To Hire A Full Time Social Worker To Help Provide Adult Mental Health Case Management Services

Dec. 2014: Stauber Moved To Replace A State Operated Service Employee At The Public Health And Human Services Department With A Full Time Employee To Help Provide Adult Mental Health Case Management Services. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Jewell, moved to authorize the Public Health and Human Services Department to replace one State Operated Services employee by increasing the complement of social workers by one FTE, at an annual cost of $69,500, to provide adult mental health case management services to eligible residents from St. Louis County; and further, should the state funding be discontinued, this FTE will be eliminated from the department’s FTE complement. The motion passed; seven yeas,

128 zero nays. Resolution No. 14-664.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 12/2/14; Resolution 14- 664, 12/2/14]

Stauber Moved To Authorize The Public Health & Human Services Department To Implement A Regional Electronic Document System Management System For Child Support Programs

Sept. 2014: Stauber Moved To Authorize The Public Health & Human Services Department To Implement A Regional Electronic Document System Management System For Child Support Programs. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Boyle, moved to authorize the Public Health & Human Services Department (PHHS) to execute purchase agreements and professional service contracts to implement a four-county regional Electronic Document Management System (EDMS) and that the County Board decreases the PHHS Technology Improvements fund balance by $387,470 and increases the expenditure budget by $387,470. In addition, the County Board authorizes a 1.0 FTE Technical Services Analyst II position within the Information Technology (IT) Department, estimated to cost $69,226, effective January 1, 2015. The County Board requests that PHHS work with county administration to incorporate ongoing software maintenance and IT support into the department’s 2015 operating budget and authorizes PHHS to enter into contracts with Cook, Lake, and Carlton counties for this regional project including hosting the EDMS and allocating ongoing costs in a proportionate manner, subject to County Attorney review and approval. St. Louis County Public Health & Human Services Director Ann Busche discussed the agreement. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 14-511.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 9/23/14; Resolution 14-511, 9/23/14]

Stauber Moved To Authorize The Public Health & Human Services Department To Implement An Internal Document Management System

Sept. 2014: Stauber Moved To Authorize The Public Health & Human Services Department To Implement An Internal Document Management System. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Boyle, moved to authorize the Public Health & Human Services Department (PHHS) to execute purchase agreements and professional service contracts to implement an Internal Document Management System (IDMS) in the PHHS Department and that the County Board decreases the PHHS Technology Improvements fund balance by $1,060,908 and increases the expenditure budget by $1,060,908. In addition, the County Board authorizes a 1.0 FTE Technical Services Analyst II position within the IT Department, estimated to cost $69,226, effective January 1, 2015. The County Board requests that PHHS work with county administration to incorporate ongoing software maintenance and IT support into the department’s 2015 operating budget. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 14-512.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 9/23/14; Resolution 14-512, 9/23/14]

Public Safety

Stauber Moved To Approve The “Child Abuse Prevention Month” Proclamation, Which Urged “Citizens To Work Together To Help Protect Children From Abuse And Neglect”

April 2014: Stauber Moved To Approve The “Child Abuse Prevention Month” Proclamation, Which Urged “Citizens To Work Together To Help Protect Children From Abuse And Neglect.” “WHEREAS, Every child is entitled to be loved, cared for, secure and safe; and WHEREAS, The St. Louis County Public Health and Human Services Department conducted 1,321 child maltreatment assessments in 2013; and WHEREAS, All forms of abuse - sexual, physical, emotional and neglect - impacts children and can lead to behaviors that affect their functioning in families, schools and communities; and WHEREAS, St. Louis County Public Health and Human Services provided prevention services to 1,528 families to help ensure safety and stability for their children in the home and community; and WHEREAS, Child abuse prevention is a community responsibility, and finding solutions depends on involvement of all people; and WHEREAS, Communities must make every effort to promote programs that benefit children and their families; and WHEREAS, Everyone in the community should become more aware of child abuse prevention and contribute to helping parents raise their children in a safe, nurturing environment; and WHEREAS, The message to children of St. Louis County is ‘You Matter’; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board hereby proclaims April 2014 as CHILD ABUSE PREVENTION MONTH in St.

129 Louis County and urges all citizens to work together to help protect children from abuse and neglect.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 4/1/14; Resolution 14-205, 4/1/14]

Sex Trafficking

Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Supporting Sen. Amy Klobuchar’s Federal Legislative Efforts To Help Eliminate Sex Trafficking Across The Country

Welfare Fraud

Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution To Hire Two Additional County Workers In The Public Health And Human Services Department To Assist With A Pilot Fraud Prevention Program

Jan. 2014: Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution To Hire Two Additional County Workers In The Public Health And Human Services Department To Assist With A Pilot Fraud Prevention Program. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Raukar, moved that the St. Louis County Board authorizes the Public Health and Human Services Department to implement a pilot fraud prevention initiative for the period January 1, 2014 through December 31, 2014. The Board authorizes the increase of the department’s authorized FTE by 2.0 to allow for the hiring of one (1) FTE Eligibility Investigator and one (1) Financial Worker for this fraud prevention initiative with the understanding these positions are only authorized for the time frame of the pilot; the cost of this pilot fraud prevention initiative is projected to be $118,362. PHHS shall provide the Board with quarterly evaluations of this fraud prevention initiative. Commissioner Jewell exited the meeting at 9:53 a.m. The motion passed; six yeas, zero nays (Jewell absent). Resolution No. 14-58.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 1/14/14; Resolution 14-58, 1/14/14]

2014 – Supported Resolutions And Motions

Contracts

Stauber Supported A Motion To Consider Authorizing A Contract “O Provide Temporary Leachate Haulage From The Regional Landfill In Virginia, MN, To The Western Lake Superior Sanitary District.”

May 2015: Stauber Supported A Motion To Consider Authorizing A Contract “O Provide Temporary Leachate Haulage From The Regional Landfill In Virginia, MN, To The Western Lake Superior Sanitary District.” “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to consider a resolution to authorize a contract to provide temporary leachate haulage from the Regional Landfill in Virginia, MN, to the Western Lake Superior Sanitary District (WLSSD) in Duluth, MN; the item has not been to Committee of the Whole. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 5/13/14]

Stauber Supported A Motion To Authorize A One-Year Contract With Aramark Uniform Services For An Annual Cost Of $30,447.20

130 March 2014: Stauber Supported A Motion To Authorize A One-Year Contract With Aramark Uniform Services For An Annual Cost Of $30,447.20. “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved that the St. Louis County Board authorizes the appropriate county officials to execute a one-year contract, with five (5) possible one-year extensions, with Aramark Uniform Services, La Crosse, WI, at an annual cost of $30,447.20. After further discussion, the motion passed; six yeas, zero nays (Raukar absent). Resolution No. 14- 172.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 3/25/14; Resolution No. 14-172, 3/25/14]

Funding

Stauber Supported A Motion To Appropriate Funds Between The North And South St. Louis Soil And Water Conservation Districts, Which Passed With A Five-Two Vote

Feb. 2014: Stauber Supported A Motion To Appropriate Funds Between The North And South St. Louis Soil And Water Conservation Districts, Which Passed With A Five-Two Vote. “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved that the St. Louis County Board authorizes the appropriate County officials to execute agreements between St. Louis County and the following entities: North St. Louis Soil and Water Conservation District Office Administration, Outreach and Education $20,000 South St. Louis Soil and Water Conservation District Wetland Assistance $ 4,500 Water Plan Implementation $14,500 Lake and Stream Protection Projects $10,000 Technical Assistance to Landowners $10,000 Outreach and Education $10,000 After further discussion, the motion passed: Yeas: Commissioners Boyle, Dahlberg, Stauber, Nelson, and Chair Forsman – 5 Nays: Commissioners Jewell and Raukar – 2 Resolution No. 14-97.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 2/4/14; Resolution No. 14-97, 2/4/14]

A Constituent Spoke About “The Lack Of Funding For The North St. Louis Soil And Water Conservation District” During A County Board Meeting. “Chair Forsman then opened the meeting to persons who wanted to address the Board concerning issues not on the agenda. Marcie Moe, of Tower, MN, spoke about the lack of funding for the North St. Louis Soil and Water Conservation District. Walter Moe, of Tower, MN, discussed the annual report for Polymet Mining.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 2/25/14]

Licenses

Stauber Supported Approving An Off-Sale Liquor License To New Scenic Café In Duluth

June 2014: Stauber Supported Approving An Off-Sale Liquor License To New Scenic Café In Duluth. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Nelson, moved to approve granting the off-sale liquor license to New Scenic Café, Inc. d/b/a New Scenic Café, Inc., Duluth Township. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 14-382.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 6/24/14; Resolution 14-382, 9/23/14]

Stauber Supported Approving An Off-Sale Intoxicating Liquor License To Eagle’s Nest Resort

June 2014: Stauber Supported Approving An Off-Sale Intoxicating Liquor License To Eagle’s Nest Resort. “Commissioner Dahlberg, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to approve granting the off-sale intoxicating liquor license to Michael Fink and Robert Pierce d/b/a Eagle’s Nest Resort, Fredenberg Township. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 14-581.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 6/24/14; Resolution 14-381, 9/23/14]

Taxes

131 Stauber Voted To Adopt A Resolution Implementing A 0.5 Percent Sales Tax And $20 Per Motor Vehicle Tax To Help Fund Transportation Improvements

Stauber Supported The Motion To Authorize The Sales Tax. “Commissioner Raukar, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to authorize and implement a 0.5% sales tax and an excise tax of $20 per motor vehicle as provided for in Minnesota Statutes beginning April 1, 2015, for the purpose of funding transportation improvements as identified in the “St. Louis County Greater MN Transportation Sales and Use Tax Transportation Improvement Plan”, dated December 2, 2014 (County Board File No. 59971). […] The motion passed; five yeas (Boyle, Stauber, Nelson, Raukar, Forsman), one nay (Dahlberg), one absent (Jewell). Resolution No. 14-665.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 12/2/14; Resolution 14-665, 12/2/14]

2013 – Offered Resolutions And Motions

Appointments

Stauber Moved To Appoint Valerie Strukel And Hal Nathan Thompson To The Heading Home St. Louis County Leadership Council To Fill Two Open At-Large Positions

Aug. 2013: Stauber Moved To Appoint Valerie Strukel And Hal Nathan Thompson To The Heading Home St. Louis County Leadership Council To Fill Two Open At-Large Positions. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Jewell, moved that the St. Louis County Board appoint Valerie Strukel, Eveleth, MN, and Hal Nathan Thompson, Gilbert, MN, to the Heading Home St. Louis County Leadership Council to fill two (2) open At-Large positions. After further discussion, the motion passed; six yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 13-507.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13-507]

Bonds

Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution To Approve The Official Terms Of Offering “General Obligation Capital Improvement Bonds”

July 2013: Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution To Approve The Official Terms Of Offering “General Obligation Capital Improvement Bonds.” “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Forsman moved to approve the official terms of offering of General Obligation Capital Improvement Bonds, Series 2013C. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 13-405.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/2/13; Resolution No. 13-405]

132 Contracts

Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Agreeing To Serve As A Government Sponsor For Purchase Of “Trail Grooming Equipment” On Behalf Of The Pequaywan Area Snowmobile Club

July 2013: Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Agreeing To Serve As A Government Sponsor For Purchase Of “Trail Grooming Equipment” On Behalf Of The Pequaywan Area Snowmobile Club. “WHEREAS, The Pequaywan Area Snowmobile Club will make application to the Minnesota Trail Assistance Program, and has requested that St. Louis County serve as the local government sponsor for the purchase of trail grooming equipment, identified as Project #0005-13-2C, to be funded by the State of Minnesota Trail Assistance Program and the Federal Recreational Trails Program; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That St. Louis County agrees to sponsor the purchase of trail grooming equipment on behalf of the Pequaywan Area Snowmobile Club; RESOLVED FURTHER, That the appropriate county officials are authorized to sign grant applications, agreements, and reimbursement claims to the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources for purchase of the trail grooming equipment; RESOLVED FURTHER, That the appropriate county officials are authorized to sign all easements, licenses, or other instruments associated with the purchase, subject to the approval of the County Attorney. Adopted July 9, 2013. No. 13-441.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13-441]

Stauber Moved To Approve A Resolution Authorizing A $17 Million Contract With Johnson Wilson For Construction Management Services Of The Government Services Center Remodeling

Aug. 2013: Stauber Moved To Approve A Resolution Authorizing A $17 Million Contract With Johnson Wilson For Construction Management Services Of The Government Services Center Remodeling. “WHEREAS, The St. Louis County master space plan for the Duluth area offices has been in place since 1995 with the Government Services Center (GSC) being the primary site for consolidation of county provided services; and WHEREAS, State of Minnesota tenants have vacated the building and the next phase of the master space plan is to develop construction and bid documents for the GSC remodeling project as the basis for the most accurate bond amount possible; and WHEREAS, The Purchasing Division solicited proposals in December 2012; and WHEREAS, The construction firm offering the best product/service at the best value was Johnson Wilson Constructors of Duluth, Minnesota; and WHEREAS, the St. Louis County Board has authorized the sale of bonds to finance this Capital Improvement Project; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board authorizes the appropriate county officials to enter into a contract with Johnson Wilson of Duluth, Minnesota, for Construction Management At-Risk services for the Duluth GSC infrastructure replacement and general remodeling project in the amount of $17,413,000, which includes all hard project construction costs, a general project contingency, and Construction Management At-Risk fees of $498,847, payable from 2013 Capital Improvement bond proceeds in Fund 440, Agency 440001. Unanimously adopted August 6, 2013. No. 13-514[.]” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 8/6/13; Resolution No. 13-514]

Stauber Moved To Approve A Resolution Authorizing The Purchase Of Property Insurance Coverage For “Major Structures” From Chubb Group Of Insurance Companies, Orit-Magie Insurance Agency Of Duluth

July 2013: Stauber Moved To Approve A Resolution Authorizing The Purchase Of Property Insurance Coverage For “Major Structures” From Chubb Group Of Insurance Companies, Orit-Magie Insurance Agency Of Duluth. “WHEREAS, St. Louis County has in excess of $323,363,000 in property to insure; and WHEREAS, St. Louis County has been purchasing property insurance on a loss limit basis which is less expensive with lower deductibles than a scheduled buildings type of insurance; and WHEREAS, The current policy expires on July 24, 2013, and St. Louis County received a proposal from the current insurer, Chubb Group of Insurance Companies, through Otis- Magie Insurance Agency of Duluth, MN, to provide coverage at the same terms at a rate of $0.65 per $100 of value for the coming year; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board authorizes the purchase of Property and Related Insurance coverage on major structures and equipment, amended contents, and boiler and machinery from Chubb Group of Insurance Companies through Otis-Magie Insurance Agency of Duluth, MN, for the period July 24, 2013 to July 24, 2014 at the annual premium of $215,254

133 payable from Fund 720 (Property, Casualty, Liability), Agency 720001 (Property, Casualty, Liability), Object 635100 (Insurance); RESOLVED FURTHER, That the Purchasing Division is authorized to add or delete county properties to the policy, or increase the base amount on future determination of valuation of county structures during the policy period. Adopted July 9, 2013. No. 13-436.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13-436]

Stauber Moved To Approve A Resolution Authorizing A Ten Year Master Space And Power Lease With Minnesota Telecommunications With Initial Rates Of $1,187.40 Per Month

July 2013: Stauber Moved To Approve A Resolution Authorizing A Ten Year Master Space And Power Lease With Minnesota Telecommunications With Initial Rates Of $1,187.40 Per Month. “WHEREAS, St. Louis County has entered into a long term agreement for data communication services with Minnesota Telecommunications, a unit of the Northeast Service Cooperative; and WHEREAS, Minnesota Telecommunications has developed a separate lease agreement for the space and power the county requires at these sites; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board authorizes a ten year Master Space and Power Lease Agreement with Minnesota Telecommunications at facilities in Duluth and Hermantown with the initial rental rates of $1,187.40/month, payable from Fund 100, Agency 116002, Object 634900; RESOLVED FURTHER, That the lease rates will be renegotiated periodically thereafter for the life of the data communications agreement with Minnesota Telecommunications with the new rates tied to the Energy Consumer Price Index. The Information Technology Department will build these costs into its budget. Adopted July 9, 2013. No. 13-435.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13-435]

Stauber Moved To Approve A Resolution To Allow The County Execute A Property Lease Agreement With Wisconsin Central, Ltd. To Develop A Cul-De-Sac To Assist With Railroad Safety

July 2013: Stauber Moved To Approve A Resolution To Allow The County Execute A Property Lease Agreement With Wisconsin Central, Ltd. To Develop A Cul-De-Sac To Assist With Railroad Safety. “WHEREAS, St. Louis County, Wisconsin Central, Ltd. and the City of Iron Junction have approved the permanent closure of two railroad crossings (DOT No. 251968W & 251990J) in 2012 within Iron Junction, in accordance with St. Louis County Resolution No. 12-570; and WHEREAS, St. Louis County revoked the county state aid highway status of CSAH 127/Merritt Avenue and Main Street and reassigned this road as CR 789/Merritt Avenue and Main Street in accordance with St. Louis County Resolution No. 12-571; and WHEREAS, St. Louis County has determined a need to establish a cul-de-sac on CR 789/Merritt Avenue within the railroad right of way to provide an area for traffic to turn around; and WHEREAS, Wisconsin Central, Ltd. has approved the use of the necessary area of the railroad right of way to be used for a cul-de-sac; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board authorizes the appropriate county officials to execute a property lease agreement, and any amendments approved by the County Attorney’s office, with Wisconsin Central, Ltd., a Limited Liability Company under the laws of the State of Illinois, setting forth the terms and conditions for the maintenance of the cul-de-sac area within the railroad right of way as described above. Adopted July 9, 2013. No. 13-428.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13-428]

Stauber Moved To Approve A Resolution To Purchase Two Dump Bodies From Towmaster, Inc. For $226,615.94

July 2013: Stauber Moved To Approve A Resolution To Purchase Two Dump Bodies From Towmaster, Inc. For $226,615.94. “WHEREAS, The Public Works Department’s 2013 equipment budget includes two dump bodies with hydraulic systems, and snow fighting equipment for trucks purchased previously; and WHEREAS, Towmaster, Inc., of Litchfield, MN, responded with the State of Minnesota contract price for this purchase in the amount of $212,038.31, plus state sales tax of $14,577.63, for a total cost of $226,615.94; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board authorizes the purchase and installation of two dump bodies with hydraulic systems and snow fighting equipment from Towmaster, Inc., of Litchfield, MN, for $226,615.94, payable from Fund 407, Agency 407001, Object 666300. Adopted July 9, 2013. No. 13-427.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13-427]

134

Stauber Moved To Approve A Resolution Authorizing A Three-Year Haulage Contract With Mahkahta Trucking, Inc. And G-Men, Inc. For An Annual Cost Of $64,660.75 And $32,416, Respectively

July 2013: Stauber Moved To Approve A Resolution Authorizing A Three-Year Haulage Contract With Mahkahta Trucking, Inc. And G-Men, Inc. For An Annual Cost Of $64,660.75 And $32,416, Respectively. “WHEREAS, St. Louis County supports effective and efficient waste management programs to enhance services to residents and businesses while protecting the environment; and WHEREAS, St. Louis County requires a contractor to load and haul Class I demolition waste from six (6) specified transfer locations to designated Minnesota Pollution Control Agency landfills for disposal; and WHEREAS, The haulage service was competitively bid in June 20 13, with several bids received; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board authorizes three-year haulage contracts with Mahkahta Trucking, Inc., Eveleth, Minnesota, and G-Men, Inc., Ely, Minnesota, beginning July 1, 2013, at an estimated annual cost of respectively $64,660.75 and $32,416.62, subject to delivery amounts plus possible fuel adjustment charges, payable from Fund 600, Agency 605001, Object 629900.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13-422]

Stauber Introduced A Motion To Adopt A Resolution Awarding General Waste, Inc. (GW) A Three-Year Contract With An Estimated Annual Cost Of $34,000 For Disposal Of Waste

July 2013: Stauber Introduced A Motion To Adopt A Resolution Awarding General Waste, Inc. (GW) A Three-Year Contract With An Estimated Annual Cost Of $34,000 For Disposal Of Waste. “WHEREAS, St. Louis County supports effective and efficient waste management programs to enhance services to residents and businesses while protecting the environment; and WHEREAS, the county collects Class I demolition waste which requires disposal at a Minnesota Pollution Control Agency permitted disposal facility; and WHEREAS, Environmental Services considers several factors prior to deciding where to direct its demolition waste for disposal, including proximity of the transfer location, tipping fee cost, haulage cost, facility environmental controls, weigh scale availability, haulage road condition, overall site accessibility, permit history and remaining airspace capacity; and WHEREAS, The department has negotiated a three-year contract with General Waste, Inc., for disposal of Class I demolition waste at its landfill in Keewatin, MN, up to 2,000 tons annually, from waste collected at the Hibbing and, potentially, the Cook transfer stations, at its quoted price of $17 per ton; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board authorizes the appropriate county officials to enter into a three-year contract with General Waste, Inc. (GW) for disposal of Class I demolition waste delivered by the department from the Hibbing and potentially the Cook transfer stations to the GW landfill in Keewatin, MN, at an estimated annual cost of $34,000, subject to actual delivery amounts, payable from Fund 600, Agency 605001, Object 629900. Adopted July 9, 2013. No. 13-423. [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13- 423]

Funding

Stauber Moved To Approve A $400,000 Grant From The Minnesota Department Of Human Services, Alcohol And Drug Abuse Division To The Center City Housing Of Duluth

May 2013: Stauber Moved To Approve A $400,000 Grant From The Minnesota Department Of Human Services, Alcohol And Drug Abuse Division To The Center City Housing Of Duluth. “WHEREAS, Center City Housing of Duluth has applied for funding from the state under the category of chronic public inebriates and has been awarded $400,000 for the period July 1,2013, to June 30,2015, for group residential housing services at Rivercrest Program in St. Cloud in the amount of $200,000 and the San Marco Project in Duluth in the amount of $200,000; and WHEREAS, Minn. Stat. 254A.07 requires that local agencies applying for funding from the Alcohol and Drug Abuse Division of the Department of Human Services must obtain approval from their host county board before the state can execute a contract with such entities; and WHEREAS, St. Louis County will not receive any funding, will not serve as fiscal agent, and will not be involved in the use of the grant funds; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board supports Center City Housing's acceptance of a grant from the Minnesota Department of Human Services, Alcohol and Drug Abuse Division.” [Resolution No. 13-327, 5/28/13]

135

The Resolution Was Adopted Six To One. “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Nelson moved to approve Center City Housing’s acceptance of a grant from the Minnesota Department of Human Services, Alcohol and Drug Abuse Division. After further discussion, the motion passed; six yeas, one nay (Commissioner Dahlberg). Resolution No. 13-327.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 5/28/13]

Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Authorizing The County To Enter Into An Agreement With Fayal Township To Provide Engineering And Construction Services For A Highway Project

July 2013: Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Authorizing The County To Enter Into An Agreement With Fayal Township To Provide Engineering And Construction Services For A Highway Project. “RESOLVED, That the appropriate county officials are authorized to enter into an agreement with Fayal Township whereby the county will provide engineering and construction services for redesign and reconstruction of the intersection of County State Aid Highway 96/Ely Lake Drive with Woodlawn Drive East and Park Drive (both Fayal Township roads) as a part of CP 0096-1486 using St. Louis County Local Funds (Fund 200, Agency 203106, Object 652800), with a local lump sum match from Fayal Township in the amount of $10,000. Adopted July 9, 2013. No. 13-429.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13-429]

Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Accepting The FY 2013 Housing And Urban Development Grants To St. Louis County

July 2013: Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Accepting The FY 2013 Housing And Urban Development Grants To St. Louis County. “THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board accepts the FY 2013 HUD grants and authorizes the St. Louis County Planning and Community Development Director to execute the grant agreements on behalf of St. Louis County, along with all the necessary forms, attachments, addendums, certifications, and subsequent forms to implement the program and complete the agreements between St. Louis County and the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development; RESOLVED FURTHER, That grant funds will be allocated as follows: $ 1,834,411 CDBG Grant 2013 to Fund 260 $ 431,357 HOME Grant 2013 to Fund 270 $ 124,995 ESG Grant 2013 to Fund 173.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13-434]

Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution To Authorize $127,078.65 For A Microwave Link To Douglas County, WI

May 2013: Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution To Authorize $127,078.65 For A Microwave Link To Douglas County, WI. “WHEREAS, The Department of Homeland Security has made funding available to the Port of Duluth/Superior under the FY 2010 Port Security Grant Program; and WHEREAS, On July 28, 201 1, St. Louis County received a 2010 Port Security Grant from the Department of Homeland Security, Office of Grants and Training for the Fiscal Year 2010 Infrastructure Protection Program: Port Security; and WHEREAS, The State of Minnesota, through its Department of Public Safety, is the fiscal agent on behalf of Port area partners for purposes of this grant, which expires on May 30,20 13; and WHEREAS, The purchase of a microwave link from Microwave Network, Inc., Stafford, TX, will connect the Douglas County, WI, Public Safety Answering Point to the Duluth ARMER site; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board authorizes the expenditure of $127,078.65 ($1 18,904 for Microwave Networks, Inc., Stafford, TX, plus $8,174.65 for state use tax) for the purchase of a microwave link to Douglas County, WI, to be accounted for in Fund 100, Agency 129999, Grant 1293 8; RESOLVED FURTHER, That the St. Louis County Board authorizes the appropriate county officials to sign any associated contract documents.” [Resolution No. 13-307, 5/14/13]

Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution To Allow The County To Enter Directly Into Agreements With The State Of Minnesota Investment Fund For Disaster Recovery Financing Upon State Approval

136 May 2013: Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution To Allow The County To Enter Directly Into Agreements With The State Of Minnesota Investment Fund For Disaster Recovery Financing Upon State Approval. “WHEREAS, On August 24, 2012, state legislation was passed which provided $15 million in the Minnesota Investment Fund (MIF) Disaster Recovery Financing for local units of government to assist businesses impacted from the 2012 flood; and WHEREAS, The County Board adopted resolutions 12-588 and 13-5 1 authorizing the Planning and Community Development Director to apply for and execute agreements on behalf of St. Louis County; and I WHEREAS, St. Louis County has entered into a grant agreement with the Minnesota Department of Employment and Economic Development (DEED) for $1 70,000; and WHEREAS, An additional business has requested assistance under the MIF program and there may be additional eligible applications or changes in the requested loan amounts; and WHEREAS, The St. Louis County Board conducted a public hearing on May 7, 2013, at 9:45 a.m. at the St. Louis County Courthouse in Duluth, Minnesota, for the purpose of receiving public comments on to the Minnesota Investment Fund Disaster Recovery Financing agreement; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That upon state approval, St. Louis County may enter into agreements and any amendments with the State of Minnesota for the MIF Disaster Recovery Financing and that St. Louis County certifies that it will comply with all applicable laws and regulations as stated in all contract agreements; RESOLVED FURTHER, That the St. Louis County Planning and Community Development Director is authorized to execute such agreements, and amendments thereto, as are necessary to implement Minnesota Investment Fund Disaster Recovery projects on behalf of St. Louis County; RESOLVED FURTHER, That the St. Louis County Planning and Community Development Director and a representative of the County Attorney are authorized to execute loan agreements and all necessary documents for the DEED approved projects; RESOLVED FURTHER, That funds be deposited into and dispersed from Fund 176, Agency 176999, Grant 17601, Year 2012.” [Resolution No. 13-274, 5/7/17]

Stauber’s Resolution Was Unanimously Adopted. [Resolution No. 13-274, 5/23/17]

Health Care

Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution To Hire Twelve New, Full-Time County Employees To Assist With Health Care Enrollment As Mandated By The Affordable Care Act

Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Supporting The Public Health And Human Service’s Recommendation Of Medica And UCare As Health Care Providers In St. Louis County

July 2013: Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Supporting The Public Health And Human Service’s Recommendation Of Medica And UCare As Health Care Providers In St. Louis County. “WHEREAS, The Minnesota Department of Human Services has published a Request For Proposals to provide health care services to recipients of Medical Assistance and MinnesotaCare in Aitkin, Benton, Carlton, Chisago, Cook, Fillmore, Houston, Isanti, Kittson, Koochiching, Lake, Lake of the Woods, Malmomen, Marshall, Mille Lacs, Mower, Norman, Olmsted, Pennington, Pine, Polk, Red Lake, Roseau, Sherburne, Stearns, Winona and St. Louis Counties; and WHEREAS, The Minnesota Department of Human Services has requested county evaluations and recommendations regarding the managed care organization proposals from each respective county; and WHEREAS, Medica, UCare and Blue Plus submitted proposals to provide managed health care services in St. Louis County; and WHEREAS, Representatives of the St. Louis County Public Health and Human Services Department have reviewed and evaluated the proposals; and WHEREAS, Based on the evaluation of the proposals, it has been determined that Medica and UCare have submitted proposals suitable to meet the needs in St. Louis

137 County; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board supports the recommendation of Public Health and Human Services in recommending Medica and UCare as the managed care organizations providing managed health care services in St. Louis County.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13-420]

Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution To Amend Board Letter 13-178 So It Stated “The Minnesota Legislature Has Passed Legislation Mandating The Expansion Of Medical Assistance As Allowed In The ACA”

June 2013: Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution To Amend Board Letter 13-178 So It Stated “The Minnesota Legislature Has Passed Legislation Mandating The Expansion Of Medical Assistance As Allowed In The ACA.” “Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Jewell, offered an amendment to Board Letter 13-178, Minnesota Medical Assistance Expansion Costs. Public Health & Human Services Director Ann Busche discussed the County’s phase-in approach and the workflow impact as a result of the Affordable Care Act (ACA). Commissioner Stauber, supported by Commissioner Forsman, moved to change the wording of the second Whereas in the Amendment to “The Minnesota Legislature has passed legislation mandating the expansion of Medical Assistance as allowed in the ACA”. The motion passed; six yeas, zero nays. After lengthy Commissioner discussion, the amendment to Board Letter 13-178 passed; five yeas, one nay (Forsman).” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 6/11/13]

Stauber Moved To Adopt A “Community Wellness Day Proclamation”

April 2013: Stauber Moved To Adopt A “Community Wellness Day Proclamation.” “WHEREAS, the health and well-being of our community is a shared responsibility; and WHEREAS, the public safety of our community is a significant concern for our residents, community leaders and health care providers; and WHEREAS, the financial literacy of our community is a critical factor in the ultimate success of our citizens in achieving their life goals; and WHEREAS, the environmental welfare of our community is of universal concern and deserves our highest attention; and WHEREAS, bringing awareness and raising the consciousness of our health and well-being, public safety, financial literacy, and environmental wellness is the utmost concern to all the members of our community, so that all may have the tools required to take responsibility for our community's overall wellness; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, the St. Louis County Board of Commissioners hereby proclaims Saturday, April 27,2013, as Community Wellness Day in St. Louis County and urges all our citizens to recognize and participate in its observance; FURTHER RESOLVED, that citizens are encouraged to visit the free Northland Wellness Day event held at the University of Minnesota-Duluth Romano Gymnasium on Saturday, April 27 from 11:OO a.m. - 3:00 p.m. Commissioner Stauber moved the adoption of the Resolution and it was declared adopted upon the following vote: Yeas - Commissioners Jewell, O'Neil, Forsman, Stauber, Nelson, Raukar and Chair Dahlberg – 7 Nays – None[.]” [Resolution No. 13-248]

Homelessness

Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Accepting State Funds For Family Homeless Prevention And Assistance Program

July 2013: Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Accepting State Funds For Family Homeless Prevention And Assistance Program. “WHEREAS, The Minnesota Housing Finance Agency has grant funds available through the Family Homeless Prevention and Assistance Program (FHPAP) to nonprofit organizations and counties; and WHEREAS, St. Louis County has received funding for FHPAP since the 1995-97 biennium; and WHEREAS, The Minnesota Housing Finance Agency has notified St. Louis County of an award of $627,750 for the biennium beginning July 1, 2013, and ending June 30, 2015; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board accepts grant funding in the amount of $627,750 for the Family Homeless Prevention and Assistance Program for the 2013-15 biennium beginning July 1, 2013 through June 30, 2015, with funds to be deposited into Fund 230, Agency 232001, Grant 23204, Grant Year 2013, Object 530701; RESOLVED FURTHER, That the St. Louis County Board authorizes the Public Health and Human Services Department and St.

138 Louis County Attorney to execute agreements with various community agencies to deliver services funded by the grant, such contracts to be paid from Fund 230, Agency 232001, Grant 23204, Grant Year 2013, Object 607200; and Fund 230, Agency 232001, Grant 23204, Grant Year 2013, Object 629900; RESOLVED FURTHER, That the 2013 budgeted revenues and expenditures for Fund 230, Agency 232001, Grant 23204, Grant Year 2013, be increased by $156,937.50 to reflect the first six months’ expenditures for the biennial grant. Adopted July 9, 2013. No. 13-419. [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13-419]

Property

Stauber Moved To Approve A Resolution Allowing The Sale Of State Tax Forfeited Land To The The State For The Improvement Of Trunk Highway 23

July 2013: Stauber Moved To Approve A Resolution Allowing The Sale Of State Tax Forfeited Land To The State For The Improvement Of Trunk Highway 23. “WHEREAS, The State of Minnesota, through the Department of Transportation, has requested to purchase the following described state tax forfeited land for the improvement of Trunk Highway 23: City of Duluth NLY 30 FT OF LOT 61 FOND DU LAC THIRD STREET DULUTH Parcel Code: 010-1610-00311 City of Duluth NLY 30 FT OF WLY 20 FT OF LOT 63 FOND DU LAC THIRD STREET DULUTH Parcel Code: 010-1610-00321; and WHEREAS, Minn. Stat. § 282.01, Subd. 1(a) authorizes the sale of state tax forfeited land to an organized governmental subdivision for any public purpose for which the subdivision is authorized to acquire property; and WHEREAS, These parcels have been classified as non-conservation land pursuant to Minn. Stat. § 282.01; and WHEREAS, These parcels have not been withdrawn from sale pursuant to Minn. Stat. §§ 85.012, 92.461, 282.01, Subd. 8, and 282.018, and other statutes that require the withholding of state tax forfeited lands from sale; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board approves the sale of state tax forfeited land to the State of Minnesota for the appraised value of $500 plus the following fees: administration fee of $100, 3% assurance fee of $15, deed fee of $25, deed tax of $1.65, and recording fee of $46; for a total of $687.65, to be deposited into Fund 240 (Forfeited Tax Fund). Adopted July 9, 2013. No. 13-421. [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13-421]

Public Safety

Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution To Authorize The County To Develop A Contract With The Arrowhead Regional Corrections For St. Louis County Female Offender Program Enhancement

July 2013: Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution To Authorize The County To Develop A Contract With The Arrowhead Regional Corrections For St. Louis County Female Offender Program Enhancement. “WHEREAS, The St. Louis County Board approved assigning $921,378 of savings in the 2012 Jail budget for the purpose of Public Safety Innovation and has approved funding for two proposals totaling $571,761.33 to date; and WHEREAS, The Criminal Justice Coordinating Committee continues to meet and work towards solving the complex jail overcrowding problem; and WHEREAS, The Criminal Justice Coordinating Committee has reviewed and recommended funding for a proposal prepared by Arrowhead Regional Corrections Offender Committee for Female Offender Program Enhancement at Duluth Bethel to move women out of the jail earlier in their incarceration time as well as potentially serve additional women; and WHEREAS, This program will be delivered through a new contract with Arrowhead Regional Corrections for this specific program which includes expanded reporting and evaluation; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board authorizes the appropriate county officials to develop a contract with Arrowhead Regional Corrections for St. Louis County Female Offender Program Enhancement (County Board File No. 59685) and authorizes payment for the 18-month cost of up to $187,376.40, payable from the Public Safety Innovation assigned fund balance account, Fund 100, Object 311426, to be transferred into Fund 100, Agency 103002, Object 694700, to facilitate payment. Adopted July 9, 2013. No. 13-444.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13-444]

Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Declaring The Board’s Supporting For A $837,500 Appropriation Request For The St. Louis County Sheriff’s Rescue Squad Storage And Meeting Space

139 July 2013: Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Declaring The Board’s Supporting For A $837,500 Appropriation Request For The St. Louis County Sheriff’s Rescue Squad Storage And Meeting Space. “WHEREAS, The State of Minnesota recently solicited requests for 2014 Capital Appropriations; and WHEREAS, The Sheriffs Volunteer Rescue Squad Storage and Meeting Space projects in Virginia and Canosia Township meet the criteria and are needed investments included in the St. Louis County 201 3-2017 Capital Improvement Plan; and WHEREAS, The Capital Appropriation would finance up to 50% of the joint project cost, allowing this investment to be made in 20 14; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board declares its support for the 2014 Capital Appropriation request of $837,500 for the St. Louis County Sheriffs Rescue Squad Storage and Meeting Space; RESOLVED FURTHER, That the St. Louis County Board designates this as its priority bonding project for 20 14.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13-437]

Timber

Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Approving An Appraisal Report For Timber

July 2013: Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Approving An Appraisal Report For Timber. “RESOLVED, that the appraisal report for sale of timber, numbered Tract 1 as submitted by the Land Commissioner, on file in the Office of the County Auditor, identified as County Board File No. 59590, are approved and the County Auditor is authorized to carry out the recommendation as listed in said appraisal report. Adopted July 9, 2013. No. 13-426.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13-426]

Transportation

Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Authoring The County Board To Agree To The Terms And Conditions Of Multiple State Transportation Grants

July 2013: Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Authoring The County Board To Agree To The Terms And Conditions Of A State Transportation Grant. “WHEREAS, St. Louis County has applied to the Minnesota Commissioner of Transportation for a grant from the Minnesota State Transportation Fund for Bridge 69A09 construction of project SAP 69-656-017 on CSAH 56/Morris Thomas Road in Hermantown, MN; and WHEREAS, The Commissioner of Transportation has given notice that funding for this project is available in the amount of $733,497.39; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board agrees to the terms and conditions of the grant consistent with Minn. Stat. § 174.50, Subd. 5(3), and will pay any additional amount by which the cost exceeds the estimate, and will return to the Minnesota State Transportation Fund any amount appropriated for the bridge reconstruction but not required; RESOLVED FURTHER, That the appropriate county officials are authorized to execute a grant agreement with the Minnesota Commissioner of Transportation concerning the above-referenced grant. Acct 266 Flood Bond.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13-430]

July 2013: Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Authoring The County Board To Agree To The Terms And Conditions Of A State Transportation Grant. “WHEREAS, St. Louis County has applied to the Minnesota Commissioner of Transportation for a grant from the Minnesota State Transportation Fund for Bridge 69K09 construction of project SAP 69-599-038 on TR 2903 in Rice Lake Township; and WHEREAS, The Commissioner of Transportation has given notice that funding for this project is available in the amount of $264,539.25; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board agrees to the terms and conditions of the grant consistent with Minn. Stat. §174.50, Subd. 5(3), and will pay any additional amount by which the cost exceeds the estimate, and will return to the Minnesota State Transportation Fund any amount appropriated for the bridge reconstruction but not required; RESOLVED FURTHER, That the appropriate county officials are authorized to execute a grant agreement with the Minnesota Commissioner of Transportation concerning the above- referenced grant. Acct 266 Flood Bond Funds: $264,539.25 Construction Adopted July 9, 2013. No. 13-431.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13-431]

140 July 2013: Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Authoring The County Board To Agree To The Terms And Conditions Of A State Transportation Grant. “WHEREAS, St. Louis County has applied to the Minnesota Commissioner of Transportation for a grant from the Minnesota State Transportation Fund for Bridge 69K03 construction of project SAP 69-598-048 on CR 211, Meadowlands Township; and WHEREAS, The Commissioner of Transportation has given notice that funding for this project is available in the amount of $341,595.00; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board agrees to the terms and conditions of the grant consistent with Minn. Stat. § 174.50, Subd. 5(3), and will pay any additional amount by which the cost exceeds the estimate, and will return to the Minnesota State Transportation Fund any amount appropriated for the bridge reconstruction but not required; RESOLVED FURTHER, That the appropriate county officials are authorized to execute a grant agreement with the Minnesota Commissioner of Transportation concerning the above- referenced grant. Acct 266 Flood Bond Funds: $341,595.00 Construction Adopted July 9, 2013. No. 13-432.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13-432]

July 2013: Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Authoring The County Board To Agree To The Terms And Conditions Of A State Transportation Grant. WHEREAS, St. Louis County has applied to the Minnesota Commissioner of Transportation for a grant from the Minnesota State Transportation Fund for Bridge 69K02 construction of project SAP 69-598-049 on CR 192, Van Buren Township; and WHEREAS, The Commissioner of Transportation has given notice that funding for this project is available in the amount of $136,385.86; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board agrees to the terms and conditions of the grant consistent with Minn. Stat. § 174.50, Subd. 5(3), and will pay any additional amount by which the cost exceeds the estimate, and will return to the Minnesota State Transportation Fund any amount appropriated for the bridge reconstruction but not required; RESOLVED FURTHER, That the appropriate county officials are authorized to execute a grant agreement with the Minnesota Commissioner of Transportation concerning the above- referenced grant. Acct 266 Flood Bond Funds: $136,385.86 Construction Adopted July 9, 2013. No. 13-433.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13-433]

Zoning

Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Authorizing A Public Hearing On The County Planning Commission’s Proposed Amendments To Zoning Maps

July 2013: Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Authorizing A Public Hearing On The County Planning Commission’s Proposed Amendments To Zoning Maps. “WHEREAS, Improvements have been made to St. Louis County electronic property records that require updates to the St. Louis County zoning maps; and WHEREAS, The proposed changes have been reviewed by county staff, city and township officials and the Planning Commission; and WHEREAS, The St. Louis County Planning Commission held a public hearing on proposed amendments to Ordinance 46, zoning maps; and WHEREAS, The Planning Commission voted to recommend that the St. Louis County Board adopt the proposed changes to Ordinance 46, zoning maps; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the St. Louis County Board authorizes a public hearing to be held on Tuesday, August 6, 2013, at 9:40 a.m. at the St. Louis County Courthouse in Duluth, Minnesota, for the purpose of receiving citizen comments on proposed amendments to Ordinance 46, zoning maps. Adopted July 9, 2013. No. 13- 424.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13-424]

Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Authorizing A Public Hearing To Receive Citizen Comments To Proposed Amendments To Subdivision Regulations

July 2013: Stauber Moved To Adopt A Resolution Authorizing A Public Hearing To Receive Citizen Comments To Proposed Amendments To Subdivision Regulations. “WHEREAS, The St. Louis County Planning Commission, on April 11, 2013, initiated proposed amendments to St. Louis County Ordinance No. 60, Subdivision Regulations; and WHEREAS, The Planning Commission, after soliciting comments for 60 days, held a public hearing regarding the proposed amendments to St. Louis County Ordinance No. 60, Subdivision Regulations on June 13, 2013; and WHEREAS, The Planning Commission voted to recommend that the St. Louis County Board adopt the proposed amendments; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That a public hearing will be held on

141 Tuesday, August 6, 2013 at 9:35 a.m. at the St. Louis County Courthouse in Duluth, Minnesota, for the purpose of receiving citizen comments on the proposed amendments to Ordinance No. 60, Subdivision Regulations. Adopted July 9, 2013. No. 13-425.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13-425]

2013 – Supported Resolutions And Motions

Appointments

Stauber Supported A Motion To Appoint Angie Miller As Interim Commissioner

Sept. 2013: Stauber Supported A Motion To Appoint Angie Miller As Interim Commissioner. “Commissioner Jewell, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved that the St. Louis County Board, acting pursuant to its authority found in Minn. Stat. § 375.101 and other relevant statutes and law, does hereby appoint Angie Miller to fill the vacancy in the office of Second District County Commissioner pending the outcome of the special election scheduled for January 14, 2014, to permanently fill the vacancy. The Board thanked Jim Laumeyer for his willingness to serve and praised his credentials. After further Commissioner discussion, the motion passed; six yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 13-582.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 9/10/13; Resolution No. 13-582, 9/10/13]

Bonds

Stauber Supported Moving A Motion To Approve The Amended Capital Improve Plan And “State Its Intent To Issue General Obligation Capital Improvement Bonds”

Oct. 2013: Stauber Supported Moving A Motion To Approve The Amended Capital Improve Plan And “State Its Intent To Issue General Obligation Capital Improvement Bonds.” “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved that the St. Louis County Board approve the amended Capital Improvement Plan and state its intent to issue General Obligation Capital Improvement Bonds under Minn. Stat. § 373.40. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 13-612.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 10/1/13; Resolution No. 13-612, 10/1/13]

Property

Stauber Supported A Motion To Adopt A Resolution To Develop A “Comprehensive Trails Approval Policy For Any Proposed Trail Over Tax-Forfeited Lands And Engages All Potential User Groups”

July 2013: Stauber Supported A Motion To Adopt A Resolution To Develop A “Comprehensive Trails Approval Policy For Any Proposed Trail Over Tax-Forfeited Lands And Engages All Potential User Groups.” “Commissioner Nelson, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to direct County Administration and the Land & Minerals Department to develop a comprehensive trails approval policy for any proposed trail over tax-forfeited lands and engages all potential user groups. This policy proposal is to be ready for County Board review and consideration by October 15, 2013. David Montgomery, Chief Administrative Officer for the City of Duluth, discussed Duluth’s trail development philosophy and said that the City of Duluth welcomes the opportunity to continue their partnership with St. Louis County in trail development. Commissioner Raukar offered an amendment to add the verbiage ‘when and where appropriate’ to the third whereas; the amendment was accepted. Land Commissioner Mark Weber discussed Standard Operating Procedures and said the Board may want to consider modifying the existing procedure. After further discussion, the motion passed; six yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 13-445.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 7/9/13; Resolution No. 13-445, 7/9/13]

142 Taxes/Fees

Stauber Supported Moving A Motion To Eliminate All Assessment Fees For Cities And Townships Using County Assessment Services

Sept. 2013: Stauber Supported Moving A Motion To Eliminate All Assessment Fees For Cities And Townships Using County Assessment Services. “Commissioner Raukar, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to eliminate all assessment fees, as defined in the proposed 2014 County Fee Schedule, for those cities and townships using county assessment services. All future assessment services beginning in 2014 for any current or additional jurisdictions choosing to use the assessment services of the St. Louis County Assessor’s Office will be able to do so free of charge. Gene Baland, Chair of the Greenwood Board of Supervisors, asked that the Board consider amending the motion to include a statement that St. Louis County would employ tax assessors who will be losing their jobs, if they meet the qualifications for county tax assessors. Commissioner Forsman introduced Ellen Trancheff, Greenwood Township. Jan Jackson, Kelsey, MN, discussed her concerns about the elimination of assessment fees. Carolyn Mackai, Babbitt, MN, said she has been an assessor for twenty-two years. After further discussion, the motion passed; six yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 13-595.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 9/24/13; Resolution No. 13-595, 9/24/13]

Contracts

Stauber Supported A Motion To Adopt A Resolution Awarding Northland Constructors Of Duluth LLC A $1,333,568.60 Bid For A Culvert Replacement And Slop Replacement

July 2013: Stauber Supported A Motion To Adopt A Resolution Awarding Northland Constructors Of Duluth LLC A $1,333,568.60 Bid For A Culvert Replacement And Slop Replacement. “Commissioner Forsman, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to award a bid to Northland Constructors of Duluth, LLC, Duluth, MN, in the amount of $1,333,568.60 for SAP 69-661-017, CP 173268 (Storm), Culvert Replacement, Slope Repair, Guardrail, and Bituminous Surface on CSAH 61/North Shore Drive in Duluth Township. The motion passed; seven yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 13-411.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 6/25/13; Resolution No. 13-411]

Stauber Supported A Motion To Adopt A Resolution Awarding Northland Constructors Of Duluth, LLC A $733,497.39 Bid For A Bridge Project

June 2013: Stauber Supported A Motion To Adopt A Resolution Awarding Northland Constructors Of Duluth, LLC A $733,497.39 Bid For A Bridge Project. “Commissioner Forsman, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to award a bid to Northland Constructors of Duluth, LLC., Duluth, MN, in the amount of $733,497.39 for SAP 69-656-017, CP 177719 (Storm), Approach Grading, Bituminous Paving and Bridge 69A09 located on County-State Aid Highway (CSAH) 56/Morris Thomas Road in Hermantown, MN. The motion passed; six yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 13-380.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 6/25/13; Resolution No. 13-380]

Stauber Supported A Motion To Adopt A Resolution Awarding Watters & Sons Excavating A $516,983.20 Bid For A Culvert Replacement Project In Rice Lake Township

June 2013: Stauber Supported A Motion To Adopt A Resolution Awarding Watters & Sons Excavating A $516,983.20 Bid For A Culvert Replacement Project In Rice Lake Township. “Commissioner Forsman, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to award a bid to Watters & Sons Excavating, Duluth, MN, in the amount of $516,983.20 for CP 0036-180241, Culvert Replacement and Bituminous Patches on CSAH 36/Arnold Road in Rice Lake Township. The motion passed; six yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 13-381.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 6/25/13; Resolution No. 13-381]

143 Stauber Supported A Motion To Adopt A Resolution Awarding Northland Constructors Of Duluth, LLC A $4 Million Bid For A Construction Project

June 2013: Stauber Supported A Motion To Adopt A Resolution Awarding Northland Constructors Of Duluth, LLC A $4 Million Bid For A Construction Project. “Commissioner Forsman, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to award a bid to Northland Constructors of Duluth, LLC., of Duluth, MN, in the amount of $4,015,950.25 for combined project SP 69-609-032(Low), STPM 6913(210) CP 0009-8236, and SP 69-610-006, CP 0010-8237, Milling, Reclaiming, Curb and Gutter and Bituminous Paving on CSAH 9 and CSAH 10/Martin Road in Rice Lake Township.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 6/25/13]

The Motion Was Tabled Until The July 2, 2013 Board Meeting. “After further discussion, Commissioner Forsman, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved table the motion until the July 2, 2013 Board meeting ; six yeas, zero nays.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 6/25/13]

Stauber Again Supported A Motion To Adopt A Resolution Awarding Northland Constructors Of Duluth, LLC A $4 Million Bid For A Construction Project, Which Passed Unanimously

July 2013: Stauber Again Supported A Motion To Adopt A Resolution Awarding Northland Constructors Of Duluth, LLC A $4 Million Bid For A Construction Project, Which Passed Unanimously. “Commissioner Forsman, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to award a bid to Northland Constructors of Duluth, LLC., of Duluth, MN, in the amount of $4,015,950.25 for combined project SP 69-609-032(Low), STPM 6913(210), CP 0009-8236, and SP 69-610-006, CP 0010-8237, Milling, Reclaiming, Curb and Gutter and Bituminous Paving on CSAH 9 and 10/Martin Road in Rice Lake Township. The motion passed; six yeas, zero nays (O’Neil absent). Resolution No. 13-407.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 6/25/13; Resolution No. 13-407]

Stauber Supported A Motion To Adopt A Resolution Awarding Utility Systems Of America, Inc. A $264,539.25 Bid For A Bridge Project

June 2013: Stauber Supported A Motion To Adopt A Resolution Awarding Utility Systems Of America, Inc. A $264,539.25 Bid For A Bridge Project. “Commissioner Forsman, supported by Commissioner Stauber, moved to award a bid to Utility Systems of America, Inc., Eveleth, MN, in the amount of $264,539.25 for SAP 69-599- 038, WO 177733 (Storm), Bridge 69K09 and Approaches on TR 2903 in Rice Lake Township. The motion passed; six yeas, zero nays. Resolution No. 13-382.” [St. Louis County Board of Commissioners, minutes, 6/25/13; Resolution No. 13-382]

144

Appendix IV – Personal Reimbursements

NOTE: A Data Practices Act request to the City of Hermantown for Stauber’s reimbursements as a city councilor was outstanding as of January 30, 2018.

Career

2013 – 2017: Stauber Collected $9,329.97 In Personal Reimbursements As A County Commissioner

2013 – 2017: Stauber Collected $9,329.97 In Personal Reimbursements As A County Commissioner. From 2013 to September 14, 2017, Stauber collected $9,329.97 in personal reimbursements. [Stauber County Commissioner Reimbursements, St. Louis County via Data Practices Act, obtained 9/14/17]

Personal Reimbursements To Stauber As County Commissioner Year Amount Subject 2017 $1,835.81 Employee Auto Allow IRS Rate, Employee Lodging, Meals, Transportation, Travel Expense 2016 $2,135.90 Employee Auto Allow IRS Rate, Employee Lodging, Meals, Transportation, Travel Expense 2015 $874.37 Employee Auto Allow IRS Rate, Meals 2014 $2,783.80 Employee Auto Allow IRS Rate, Employee Lodging, Meals, Travel Expense 2013 $1,700.09 Employee Auto Allow IRS Rate TOTAL $9,329.97 [Stauber County Commissioner Reimbursements, St. Louis County via Data Practices Act, obtained 9/14/17]

2017

2017: Stauber Collected $1,835.81 In Personal Reimbursements

2016: Stauber Collected $1,835.81 In Reimbursements. From January 1, 2017 to September 14, 2017, Stauber collected $1,835.81 in personal reimbursements. [Stauber County Commissioner Reimbursements, St. Louis County via Data Practices Act, obtained 9/14/17]

Stauber Expenditure Reimbursements As County Commissioner (1/1/17 - 9/14/17) Check Payment Object Description Period Year Date Name Payment # Check # Amount Description Employee Auto STAUBER CKUS015 6/5/17 - Allow IRS Rate 8 2017 9/1/17 PETER A003QA 1007368 $105.66 7/26/17 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK 5/16/17- Allow IRS Rate 6 2017 6/14/17 PETER 987529 50116827 $81.59 5/24/17 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK Allow IRS Rate 5 2017 5/10/17 PETER 979659 50115629 $434.42 3/4/17 STAUBER CKUSBK Employee Lodging 5 2017 5/10/17 PETER 979659 50115629 $395.41 3/4/17 Employee Meals- STAUBER CKUSBK Overnight Trip 5 2017 5/10/17 PETER 979659 50115629 $27.87 3/4/17 Employee Other STAUBER CKUSBK Travel Expense 5 2017 5/10/17 PETER 979659 50115629 $27.00 3/4/17 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK 2/14/17, Allow IRS Rate 3 2017 3/15/17 PETER 966021 50113540 $91.49 2/21/17 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK 1/17 - Allow IRS Rate 2 2017 2/8/17 PETER 958520 50112279 $115.29 1/26/17 Employee Meals- STAUBER CKUSBK 1/17 – Overnight Trip 2 2017 2/8/17 PETER 958520 50112279 $45.03 1/26/17

145 Employee Other STAUBER CKUSBK 1/17 - Travel Expense 2 2017 2/8/17 PETER 958520 50112279 $16.65 1/26/17 Employee Air/Other STAUBER CKUSBK 1/17 – Pub Carrier 2 2017 2/8/17 PETER 958520 50112279 $495.40 1/26/17 TOTAL: $1,835.81 [Stauber County Commissioner Reimbursements, St. Louis County via Data Practices Act, obtained 9/14/17]

2016

2016: Stauber Collected $2,135.90 In Personal Reimbursements

2016: Stauber Collected $2,135.90 In Reimbursements. In 2016, Stauber collected $2,135.90 in personal reimbursements. [Stauber County Commissioner Reimbursements, St. Louis County via Data Practices Act, obtained 9/14/17]

Stauber Expenditure Reimbursements As County Commissioner - 2016 Object Check Payment Payment Description Period Year Date Name # Check # Amount Description Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK Allow IRS Rate 4 2016 4/13/16 PETER 882375 50101528 $502.74 3/16/16 Employee STAUBER CKUSBK Lodging 4 2016 4/13/16 PETER 882375 50101528 $384.05 3/16/16 Employee Other STAUBER CKUSBK Travel Expense 4 2016 4/13/16 PETER 882375 50101528 $36.00 3/16/16 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK 2/9/16 – Allow IRS Rate 3 2016 3/23/16 PETER 875487 50100763 $111.24 2/23/16 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK 1/15/16 - Allow IRS Rate 2 2016 2/10/16 PETER 865730 50099111 $78.03 1/26/16 Employee Meals- STAUBER CKUSBK 1/15/16 - Day Trip 2 2016 2/10/16 PETER 865730 50099111 $13.00 1/26/16 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK Allow IRS Rate 12 2016 1/18/17 PETER 948900 50111495 $81.00 12/16/16 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK 10/14/16 - Allow IRS Rate 12 2016 12/14/16 PETER 941435 50110185 $142.83 11/22/16 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK Allow IRS Rate 10 2016 10/19/16 PETER 926590 50108290 $191.16 9/16 – 27/16 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK 8/9/16 - Allow IRS Rate 9 2016 9/7/16 PETER 917384 50106747 $163.62 8/19/16 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK 7/15/16 - Allow IRS Rate 8 2016 8/3/16 PETER 909731 50105494 $145.26 7/26/16 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK 5/17/16 - Allow IRS Rate 7 2016 7/6/16 PETER 901113 50104497 $181.17 6/28/16 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK 4/12/16 - Allow IRS Rate 5 2016 5/18/16 PETER 889559 50102791 $64.80 4/26/16 Employee Meals- STAUBER CKUSBK Overnight Trip 4 2016 4/13/16 PETER 882375 50101528 $41.00 3/16/16 TOTAL: $2,135.90 [Stauber County Commissioner Reimbursements, St. Louis County via Data Practices Act, obtained 9/14/17]

2015

2015: Stauber Collected $874.37 In Personal Reimbursements

146 2015: Stauber Collected $874.37 In Reimbursements. In 2015, Stauber collected $874.37 in personal reimbursements. [Stauber County Commissioner Reimbursements, St. Louis County via Data Practices Act, obtained 9/14/17]

Stauber Expenditure Reimbursements As County Commissioner - 2015 Object Check Payment Description Period Year Date Name Payment # Check # Amount Description Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK 11/12/15 - Allow IRS Rate 12 2015 12/23/15 PETER 852927 50097456 $167.33 11/24/15 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK 10/20/15, Allow IRS Rate 11 2015 11/10/15 PETER 843050 50095926 $70.73 10/27/15 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK 9/8/15, Allow IRS Rate 10 2015 10/14/15 PETER 836071 50094856 $189.75 9/16/15 Employee Meals- STAUBER CKUSBK 9/8/15, Day Trip 10 2015 10/14/15 PETER 836071 50094856 $11.00 9/16/15 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK 7/21/15, Allow IRS Rate 8 2015 9/2/15 PETER 826157 50093370 $68.71 7/28/15 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK Allow IRS Rate 6 2015 6/17/15 PETER 806954 50090659 $13.80 5/15/15 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK 3/17/15, Allow IRS Rate 4 2015 4/15/15 PETER 791186 50088534 $172.50 3/24/15 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK 2/10/15 - Allow IRS Rate 3 2015 3/4/15 PETER 782438 50086934 $109.25 2/17/15 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK 1/8/15, Allow IRS Rate 2 2015 2/11/15 PETER 776470 50086080 $71.30 1/27/15 TOTAL: $874.37 [Stauber County Commissioner Reimbursements, St. Louis County via Data Practices Act, obtained 9/14/17]

2014

2014: Stauber Collected $2,783.80 In Personal Reimbursements

2014: Stauber Collected $2,783.80 In Reimbursements. In 2014, Stauber collected $2,783.80 in personal reimbursements. [Stauber County Commissioner Reimbursements, St. Louis County via Data Practices Act, obtained 9/14/17]

Stauber Expenditure Reimbursements As County Commissioner - 2014 Object Check Payment Description Period Year Date Name Payment # Check # Amount Description Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 12/3/14- 12 2014 1/7/15 766823 $160.16 Allow IRS Rate PETER 0084778 12/16/14 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 12 2014 12/17/14 762786 $101.36 11/14/14 Allow IRS Rate PETER 0084057 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 11 2014 11/19/14 755925 $276.36 11/14/14 Allow IRS Rate PETER 0083110 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 9/4/14 - 10 2014 10/15/14 746976 $77.28 Allow IRS Rate PETER 0081841 9/22/14 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 8/12/14, 9 2014 9/17/14 740766 $56.00 Allow IRS Rate PETER 0080796 8/15/14 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 8 2014 8/13/14 731960 $61.60 7/22/14 Allow IRS Rate PETER 0079491 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 6/20/14 – 7 2014 7/9/14 724162 $197.12 Allow IRS Rate PETER 0078278 6/26/14 Employee Meals- STAUBER CKUSBK5 6/20/14 – 7 2014 7/9/14 724162 $9.00 Day Trip PETER 0078278 6/26/14

147 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 6 2014 6/11/14 717368 $170.24 5/14/14 Allow IRS Rate PETER 0077282 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 5 2014 5/14/14 712103 $175.29 5/14/14 Allow IRS Rate PETER 0076340 Employee Meals- STAUBER CKUSBK5 5 2014 5/14/14 712103 $35.06 4/14/14 Overnight Trip PETER 0076340 Employee Meals- STAUBER CKUSBK5 5 2014 5/14/14 712103 $22.00 4/14/14 Day Trip PETER 0076340 Employee STAUBER CKUSBK5 5 2014 5/14/14 712103 $478.62 4/14/14 Lodging PETER 0076340 Employee Other STAUBER CKUSBK5 5 2014 5/14/14 712103 $43.00 14/14/14 Travel Expense PETER 0076340 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 3/3/14 - 4 2014 4/9/14 703510 $435.12 Allow IRS Rate PETER 0075057 3/25/14 Employee Meals- STAUBER CKUSBK5 3/3/14 - 4 2014 4/9/14 703510 $25.48 Overnight Trip PETER 0075057 3/25/14 Employee STAUBER CKUSBK5 3/3/14- 4 2014 4/9/14 703510 $214.75 Lodging PETER 0075057 3/25/14 Employee Other STAUBER CKUSBK5 3/3/14- 4 2014 4/9/14 703510 $18.00 Travel Expense PETER 0075057 3/25/14 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 2/12/14, 3 2014 3/19/14 697563 $140.00 Allow IRS Rate PETER 0074159 2/25/14 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 1/8/14 – 2 2014 2/12/14 688240 $87.36 Allow IRS Rate PETER 0072837 1/28/14 TOTAL: $2,783.80 [Stauber County Commissioner Reimbursements, St. Louis County via Data Practices Act, obtained 9/14/17]

2013

2013: Stauber Collected $1,700.09 In Personal Reimbursements

2013: Stauber Collected $1,700.09 In Personal Reimbursements. In 2013, Stauber collected $1,700.09 in personal reimbursements. [Stauber County Commissioner Reimbursements, St. Louis County via Data Practices Act, obtained 9/14/17]

Stauber Expenditure Reimbursements As County Commissioner - 2013 Object Check Payment Description Period Year Date Name Payment # Check # Amount Description Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 1/18/13 - Allow IRS Rate 12 2013 2/12/14 PETER 689820 0072837 $94.92 12/20/13 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 Allow IRS Rate 12 2013 1/8/14 PETER 679770 0071620 $120.35 12/17/13 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 11/12/13 – Allow IRS Rate 12 2013 12/11/13 PETER 673936 0070700 $160.46 11/26/13 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 Allow IRS Rate 11 2013 11/13/13 PETER 667808 0069760 $135.60 10/13/13 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 9/18/13 – Allow IRS Rate 10 2013 10/9/13 PETER 659859 0068461 $274.59 9/25/13 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 8/14/13, Allow IRS Rate 9 2013 10/2/13 PETER 658707 0068209 $113.00 8/21/13 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 7/10/13 - Allow IRS Rate 8 2013 8/7/13 PETER 646905 0066117 $163.85 7/23/13 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 Allow IRS Rate 7 2013 7/3/13 PETER 637968 0064771 $124.30 6/25/13 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 Allow IRS Rate 6 2013 6/19/13 PETER 634655 0064218 $62.15 5/15/13

148 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 4/10/13 - Allow IRS Rate 5 2013 5/8/13 PETER 623098 0062683 $175.15 4/29/13 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 3/21/13, Allow IRS Rate 4 2013 4/10/13 PETER 618715 0061664 $133.34 3/26/13 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 2/15/13, Allow IRS Rate 3 2013 3/6/13 PETER 611818 0060345 $74.58 2/20/13 Employee Auto STAUBER CKUSBK5 Allow IRS Rate 2 2013 2/6/13 PETER 604998 0059325 $67.80 1/23/13 TOTAL: $1,700.09 [Stauber County Commissioner Reimbursements, St. Louis County via Data Practices Act, obtained 9/14/17]

149

150