DOCSLIB.ORG

Assessment in a Tribal College Context: a Case Study of NWIC

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Assessment in a Tribal College Context: a Case Study of NWIC ASSESSMENT IN A TRIBAL COLLEGE CONTEXT: A CASE STUDY OF NORTHWEST INDIAN COLLEGE by ANNE MARIE KARLBERG B.Sc. (Honours), The University of Toronto, 1986 M.P.H., Tulane University, 1989 B.Ed., The University of Toronto, 1992 A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY in THE FACULTY OF GRADUATE STUDIES (Educational Studies) THE UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA July 2007 © Anne Marie Karlberg, 2007 ABSTRACT Approximately 32 tribal colleges are located on reservations in the United States. Their aim is to provide Native American students with a culturally relevant and meaningful post- secondary education. Assessment uses methods of applied research to improve student learning. The aim of this study is to advance theoretical and applied knowledge in the field of assessment within tribal colleges. This undertaking is noteworthy given that tribal colleges are vital to the development and future of Native American communities. I use a case study methodology to examine a specific assessment program that is being developed at Northwest Indian College (NWIC), a tribal college in Washington state. In this study, I provide responses to three research questions: (1) What criteria are best used to evaluate an assessment program in a tribal college context? (2) Which elements of the NWIC assessment program are most and least successful according to the evaluative criteria established in Research Question 1? and (3) What preconditions and other contextual factors contribute to the relative success or failure of different elements of the NWIC assessment program? I review the history of Native Americans in higher education, provide an overview and critique of the emerging assessment movement, and discuss the state of assessment within the tribal college system. This study demonstrates that assessment can be done in a tribal college context in a culturally respectful and meaningful way and provides insights into how this can be approached. My findings suggest that effective tribal college assessment programs use three types of information to assess student learning — direct indicators, indirect indicators, and institutional and community data — and assess each of these at the tribal community, college, program, and course levels. It is equally important to pay attention to the inputs into the assessment program ii (i.e., plans and resources) and how the assessment program is carried out. Furthermore, the intention of the assessment program is to impact the college’s context. Articulating and revisiting the tribal college’s mission — with its focus on the self-determination of Native peoples — is a critical initial step in the development of assessment programs that should be emphasized in this framework. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT................................................................................................................................... ii TABLE OF CONTENTS ............................................................................................................ iv LIST OF TABLES .....................................................................................................................viii LIST OF FIGURES ..................................................................................................................... ix ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ......................................................................................................... x CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION................................................................................................. 1 Research Questions .................................................................................................................. 3 NWIC Assessment Program Case Study ................................................................................. 3 Positioning Myself ................................................................................................................... 6 Significance of Organizational Insider Research..................................................................... 9 Overview of the Doctoral Thesis ........................................................................................... 11 CHAPTER 2 NATIVE AMERICANS IN HIGHER EDUCATION — HISTORY AND OVERVIEW OF TRIBAL COLLEGES.................................................................................. 13 The History of Native Americans in Higher Education in the United States ........................ 14 The Founding of Tribal Colleges in the United States (1960s).............................................. 31 Tribal Colleges Today............................................................................................................ 38 Conclusion.............................................................................................................................. 58 CHAPTER 3 ASSESSMENT IN THE UNITED STATES — OVERVIEW AND CRITIQUE .................................................................................................................................. 60 What is Assessment?.............................................................................................................. 61 Why do Assessment? ............................................................................................................. 63 Criticisms and Concerns about Assessment........................................................................... 66 Benefits of Effective Assessment Processes .......................................................................... 81 Mainstream Approaches to Assessment................................................................................. 82 Types of Information Used for Assessment Purposes ........................................................... 84 Assessment Issues Specific to Two-Year Colleges and Tribal Colleges............................... 97 Emerging Innovative Approaches to Assessment................................................................ 100 Planning and Reporting........................................................................................................ 105 Conclusion............................................................................................................................ 109 CHAPTER 4 ASSESSMENT IN TRIBAL COLLEGES...................................................... 110 Guiding Principles................................................................................................................ 110 State of Assessment in Tribal Colleges................................................................................ 116 Conclusion............................................................................................................................ 137 iv CHAPTER 5 METHODOLOGY............................................................................................ 139 Case Studies ......................................................................................................................... 139 The CIPP Model................................................................................................................... 147 Research Design................................................................................................................... 150 Respondents ......................................................................................................................... 151 Data Analysis ....................................................................................................................... 152 CHAPTER 6 EVALUATION FRAMEWORK AND RESULTS ........................................ 153 Context (Research Question 3) ............................................................................................ 153 Inputs (Research Questions 1 and 2).................................................................................... 156 Process (Research Questions 1 and 2).................................................................................. 171 Products (Research Questions 1 and 2)................................................................................ 180 Conclusion............................................................................................................................ 210 CHAPTER 7 CONCLUSIONS................................................................................................ 211 Response to Research Question 1 (Criteria) ........................................................................ 212 Response to Research Question 2 (Most and Least Successful Elements).......................... 219 Response to Research Question 3 (Preconditions and Contextual Factors)......................... 224 Implications of Research...................................................................................................... 228 Limitations of the Study....................................................................................................... 240 Suggestions for Future Research and Work......................................................................... 242 Concluding Remarks............................................................................................................ 243 REFERENCES.......................................................................................................................... 245 APPENDIX A SECTION OF THE NWIC ASSESSMENT PLAN (DRAFT) (2007 – 2012) ....................................................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Educating the Mind and Spirit 2006-2007
    Educating the Mind and Spirit 2006-2007 ANNUAL REPORT ENVISIONING OUR POWERFUL FUTURE MISSION The American Indian College Fund’s mission is to raise scholarship funds for American Indian students at qualified tribal colleges and universities and to generate broad awareness of those institutions and the Fund itself. The organization also raises money and resources for other needs at the schools, including capital projects, operations, endowments or program initiatives, and it will conduct fundraising and related activities for any other Board- directed initiatives. CONTENTS President’s Message 2 Chairman’s Message 3 Tribal Colleges and Students by State 4 The Role of Tribal Colleges and Universities 5 Scholarship Statistics 6 Our Student Community 7 Scholarships 8 Individual Giving 9 Corporations, Foundations, and Tribes 10 Special Events and Tours 12 Student Blanket Contest 14 Public Education 15 Corporate, Foundation, and Tribal Contributors 16 Event Sponsors 17 Individual Contributors 18 Circle of Vision 19 Board of Trustees 20 American Indian College Fund Staff 21 Independent Auditor’s Report 22 Statement of Financial Position 23 Statement of Activities 24 Statement of Cash Flows 25 Notes to Financial Statement 26 Schedule of Functional Expenses 31 1 PRESIDENT’S MESSAGE The Circle of Life, the Circle of Hope Dear Friends and Relatives, ast year I wrote about the challenges that faced Gabriel plans to graduate with a general studies the nation and how hope helps us endure those degree from Stone Child College, then transfer to the L
    [Show full text]
  • 2003 15Th Year Evaluation Report
    NASA’s South Dakota Space Grant Consortium 15th Year Evaluation National Space Grant College and Fellowship Program Program Performance and Results (PPR) Report South Dakota Space Grant Consortium Dr. Sherry O. Farwell, Director South Dakota School of Mines and Technology 501 East Saint Joseph Street Rapid City, SD 57701 Phone: 605-394-1975 Fax: 605-394-5360 [email protected] Submitted October 16, 2003 1 Table of Contents Title Page ……………………………………………………………………………….. 1 Table of Contents …………………………………………………………………….…. 2 Executive Summary and Consortium Impact …………………………………………... 3 Introduction ……………………………………………………………………………... 5 National Program Emphases ……………………………………………………………. 7 Program Elements Consortium Management ……………………………………………………….. 10 Fellowship/Scholarship Program ……………………………………………….. 13 Research Infrastructure Program ……………………………………………….. 14 Higher Education Program ……………………………………………………... 18 Precollege Education Program …………………………………………………. 22 Public Service Program: General Public and External Relations ………………. 26 Statement of Consortium Concurrence …………………………………………………. 27 2 Executive Summary and Consortium Impact The South Dakota Space Grant Consortium (SDSGC) has facilitated tremendous advances in educational outreach and research in subject areas critical to NASA’s unique mission. Over the past 12 years since it’s inception, the SDSGC has greatly stimulated the growth and impact of our expanding network of industry, academic, and governmental organizations; thereby bringing the Consortium’s educational and research
    [Show full text]
  • Student Competition Winner
    STUDENT COMPETITION WINNER: KNOWLEDGE BOWL - 5 PARTICIPANTS 1st Place Team Aaniiih Nakoda College] 2nd Place Team Fort Peck Community College 3rd Place Team Institute of Am. Indian Arts BUSINESS BOWL 1st Place College of Menominee Nation 2nd Place Sinte Gleska University 3rd Place Oglala Lakota College WEB PAGE DESIGN 1st Place - Individual Steam Team Navajo Technical University 2nd Place - Individual Fort Peck Community College 3rd Place - Individual Navajo Technical University CRITICAL INQUIRY - TEAM # 1ST Place - Team (Traveling Trophy) Dine College 2nd Place - Team Northwest Indian College 3rd Place - Team Turtle Mountain Community College HANDGAMES - 12 participants 1st Place - Team Little Priest College 2nd Place - Team Oglala Lakota College 3rd Place - Team United Tribes Technical Best Hider Mariah Provincial Oglala Lakota College Best Guesser Jessica LaTray Little Priest College Best Group Singers Oglala Lakota College Most enthistic Haskell Indian Nations College Sponsorship Fond Lu Lac Tribal & Comm. College Best Dressed SIPI SCIENCE BOWL - 3 PARTICIPANTS 1st Place - Team Gabe Yellow Hawk, Joanne Thompson Oglala Lakota College Larissa Red Eagle 2nd Place - Team Lee Voight, Caley Fox Nueta Hidatsa Sahnish College 3rd Place - Team Darrell Yazzie, LeTanyaThinn, Jordan Mescal Dine College SCIENCE POSTER 1st place - individual Ashley Hall Nueta Hidatsa Sahnish College Comparsion of Yield of Various Cultivars of Amelanchier on Fort Berthold Reservation 2nd Place - individual Patrisse Vasek Oglala Lakota College "Bioavailable and Leachable
    [Show full text]
  • 2021 USDA 1994 Tribal Scholars Program College Application
    OMB No.:0503-0016 USDA 1994 TRIBAL SCHOLARS PROGARM COLLEGE STUDENT APPLICATION For students seeking careers in Food, Agriculture, and Natural Resource Sciences, and/or other Related Disciplines. Due January 31 , 2021 0 OMB No.:0503-0016 INTRODUCTION Thank you for your interest in the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) 1994 Tribal Scholars Program. The USDA 1994 Tribal Scholars Program was established to strengthen the long-term partnership between USDA and the 1994 Land-Grant Institutions by increasing the number of students studying, graduating, and pursuing careers in in food, agriculture, natural resources, and other related fields of study. The USDA 1994 National Scholars Program is implemented under the USDA Fellows Experience Program (FEP). Successful applicants will receive a temporary appointment to the USDA, not to exceed 4years. Upon successful completion of the degree requirements and the end of the agreement period, the scholar is eligible for conversion to permanent appointment in service to USDA without further competition. The USDA 1994 National Scholar is required to: Be a U.S citizen Have been admitted as well as enrolled as full-time student in a 1994 Land-Grant Tribal College or University. Have a cumulative GPA of 3.0 or better on a 4.0 scale. Have demonstrated leadership and community service. Have submitted an official transcript with a school seal and/or the signature of an authorized school official. Submit an essay that is 500-800 words describing 1) What motivates you to consider a career in public service working for the U.S. Department of Agriculture. Include information about your educational and career goals and how this scholarship may assist you to achieve them; 2) How did you become interested in studying food, agriculture, and natural resource sciences or another related discipline in college.
    [Show full text]
  • Nulldfr 2016 Report
    Image description. Cover Image End of image description. NATIONAL CENTER FOR EDUCATION STATISTICS What Is IPEDS? The Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS) is a system of survey components that collects data from about 7,500 institutions that provide postsecondary education across the United States. IPEDS collects institution-level data on student enrollment, graduation rates, student charges, program completions, faculty, staff, and finances. These data are used at the federal and state level for policy analysis and development; at the institutional level for benchmarking and peer analysis; and by students and parents, through the College Navigator (http://collegenavigator.ed.gov), an online tool to aid in the college search process. For more information about IPEDS, see http://nces.ed.gov/ipeds. What Is the Purpose of This Report? The Data Feedback Report is intended to provide institutions a context for examining the data they submitted to IPEDS. The purpose of this report is to provide institutional executives a useful resource and to help improve the quality and comparability of IPEDS data. What Is in This Report? As suggested by the IPEDS Technical Review Panel, the figures in this report provide selected indicators for your institution and a comparison group of institutions. The figures are based on data collected during the 2015-16 IPEDS collection cycle and are the most recent data available. This report provides a list of pre-selected comparison group institutions and the criteria used for their selection. Additional information about these indicators and the pre- selected comparison group are provided in the Methodological Notes at the end of the report.
    [Show full text]
  • Scholarship Endowment Campaign Iwicacaga Sakowin (THE SEVENTH GENERATION)
    OGLALA LAKOTA COLLEGE Scholarship Endowment Campaign Iwicacaga Sakowin (THE SEVENTH GENERATION) Oglala Lakota College 537 Piya Wiconi Road Kyle, SD 57752-0490 Phone: (605) 455-6000 Fax: (605) 455-2787 www.olc.edu Rebuilding e Lakota Nation rough Education www.olc.edu Rebuilding the Lakota Nation Through Education Wounspe Ihuniyan Hci Lakota Oyate Kin Akta Ic’icakagapi Kte lo VISION Tribal Rebuilding the Lakota Nation through Education. Provides the Lakota with outstanding graduates; promotes the study and practice of tribal sovereignty; MISSION works with tribal entities toward building our nation; and helps graduates in achieving meaningful The mission of OLC is to educate students employment and healthy lifestyles. for professional and vocational employment opportunities in Lakota country. The College Cultural will graduate well-rounded students grounded in Utilizes Lakota cultural values in all learning Wolakolkiciyapi - learning Lakota ways of life in frameworks; celebrates Lakota culture including the community – by teaching Lakota culture and sacred songs and ceremonies; researches, studies language as part of preparing students to participate and disseminates Lakota language, culture and in a multicultural world. philosophy; and provides leadership to maintain and revitalize Lakota culture and philosophy. VALUES Academic Oglala Lakota College strives to practice Encourages high student learning expectations and teach the values of traditional Lakota through active and collaborative learning which culture: Ohitika (Bravery), Wacantognakapi will be measured through assessment standards; (Generosity), Wowacintaka (Fortitude), Wokiksuye maintains a supportive campus environment (Remembrance), Unsihanpi (Humility), Woyuonihan through advising, counseling, tutoring, scheduling, (Respect), Woonspe (Learning), Woslolye and providing financial assistance; practices open (Knowledge), Wookahnige (Understanding) and enrollment; has students acquire relevant knowledge, Woksape (Wisdom).
    [Show full text]
  • Tribal Colleges and Universities STEM Resource List
    Tribal Colleges & Universities In an effort to promote partnership building as a strategy for broadening participation in STEM fields, this list provides the names and locations of Tribal Colleges and Universities, along with links to STEM-related programs (relevant academic programs, grants, networks, student organizations, recruitment/retention/support programs, community outreach initiatives, etc.) within these institutions. We encourage you to research the programs at Minority Serving Institutions to gain a sense of the work being done in those specific contexts and to explore possibilities for collaboration. Institution City State STEM-related Programs Ilisagvik College Barrow AL Information Technology Program Science & Physical Education Diné College Tsaile AZ Math, Physics, and Technology Tohono O'odham Community College Sells AZ Haskell Indian Nations University Lawrence KS Academics Bay Mills Community College Brimley MI Program Descriptions Keweenaw Bay Ojibwa Community College Baraga MI KBOCC STEM Programs Saginaw Chippewa Tribal College Mt. Pleasant MI S.T.E.M. Club Fond du Lac Tribal and Community College Cloquet MN Outreach Programs Leech Lake Tribal College Cass Lake MN Natural Sciences and Technology Department White Earth Tribal and Community College Mahnomen MN Degree Programs Blackfeet Community College Browning MT Degrees and Certificates Chief Dull Knife College Lame Deer MT © October 2015, CADRE Page 1 of 3 Institution City State STEM-related Programs Aaniiih Nakoda College Harlem MT T-CUP Program Fort Peck Community
    [Show full text]
  • Tcus As Engaged Institutions
    Building Strong Communities Tribal Colleges as Engaged Institutions Prepared by: American Indian Higher Education Consortium & The Institute for Higher Education Policy A product of the Tribal College Research and Database Initiative Building Strong Communities: Tribal Colleges as Engaged Institutions APRIL 2001 American Indian Higher Education Consortium The Institute for Higher Education Policy A product of the Tribal College Research and Database Initiative, a collaborative effort between the American Indian Higher Education Consortium and the American Indian College Fund ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This report is the fourth in a series of policy reports produced through the Tribal College Research and Database Initiative. The Initiative is supported in part by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Administration for Native Ameri- cans (ANA) and the Pew Charitable Trusts. A collaborative effort between the American Indian Higher Education Consor- tium (AIHEC) and the American Indian College Fund, the project is a multi-year effort to improve understanding of Tribal Colleges. AIHEC would also like to thank the W.K. Kellogg Foundation for its continued support. This report was prepared by Alisa Federico Cunningham, Senior Research Analyst, and Christina Redmond, Research Assis- tant, at The Institute for Higher Education Policy. Jamie Merisotis, President, Colleen O’Brien, Vice President, and Deanna High, Project Editor, at The Institute, as well as Veronica Gonzales, Jeff Hamley, and Sara Pena at AIHEC, provided writing and editorial assistance. We also would like to acknowledge the individuals and organizations who offered information, advice, and feedback for the report. In particular, we would like to thank the many Tribal College presidents who read earlier drafts of the report and offered essential feedback and information.
    [Show full text]
  • The Tribes of Washington State Map Download
    12 8 28 17 26 6 9 18 24 2 7 27 5 15 13 22 4 25 There are 29 federally-recognized Native American tribes 21 located on reservations throughout Washington state. 16 Each tribe has a body of elected officials that oversees its 20 governmental programs. They provide services including 14 health care, education, housing, public safety, courts, 10 transportation, natural resources, environment, culture 23 and economic development. Gaming revenue is a major source of funding to pay for tribal government services. 11 Tribes are investing in new initiatives to diversify their economic base. Investments range from hotels to golf 1 courses to shopping centers. 19 Tribes employ more than 30,000 people statewide and pay more than $1.5 billion annually in wages and benefits. Capital spending, and the purchase of goods and services from private companies, adds billions more dollars to the state’s economy each year. Tribal economic activities also generate millions of dollars in federal, state and local taxes. 29 Washingtontribes.org is a public education program of the Washington Indian Gaming Association. washingtontribes.org 3 1. Chehalis The Confederated Tribes of the Chehalis 4. Hoh The Hoh Tribe has 443 acres of 7. Lower Elwha Klallam The Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe is located on roughly 11. Nisqually The Nisqually Indian Tribe has more 14. Puyallup The Puyallup Tribe of Indians has more than 4,000 members and is 18. Sauk-Suiattle The Sauk-Suiattle Indian Tribe is located near Darrington and 22. Spokane The Spokane Tribe of Indians’ reservation is 159,000 acres located 26.
    [Show full text]
  • Nifa Land-Grant Colleges and Universities
    NIFA LAND-GRANT COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES 199418901862 Northwest Indian College Aaniiih Nakoda College Turtle Mountain Cankdeska Cikana Blackfeet Community College Comm. College White Earth Tribal Community College & Community College Washington Stone Child Lac Courte Oreilles Ojibwa Salish Fort Berthold University State University College Community College Univ. Kootenai Fort Peck Comm. College Leech Lake of Maine Community University of Idaho College United Tribal College of Vermont College North Dakota Oregon State University Little Tribes Bay Mills Community College Montana Technical State Univ. Fond du Lac State Big Horn Chief Tribal & Comm. College Sitting Bull Coll. University College Dull Knife College College Sisseton Wahpeton Saginaw Chippewa University of Community College College of University of Tribal College New Hampshire Menominee Massachusetts Si Tanka/Huron Univ. University of Nation Oglala Lakota South Dakota Minnesota Cornell University College University of Michigan State University Wisconsin State University University of Sinte Gleska Univ. Rhode Island Pennsylvania State University Nebraska Indian of Connecticut Community College Iowa State University University Utah State University of Wyoming D-Q University Little Priest Rutgers University University of Nevada West Virginia University Tribal College Ohio State University University of Delaware University University Colorado State University Delaware State University of Nebraska University Purdue University of Illinois University University of Maryland of California
    [Show full text]
  • TRIBAL Colleges & Universities: Educating, Engaging, Innovating
    AMERICAN INDIAN HIGHER EDUCATION CONSORTIUM TRIBAL Colleges & Universities: Educating, Engaging, Innovating, Sustaining, Honoring AIHEC Native American Research Center for Health (NARCH) Project Summary Report Trauma—including historical trauma—is a crippling reality among Indigenous nations, impacting many of the 5.2 million American Indians and Alaska Natives in this country. To the leaders of the largest education system created to serve Indian Country—the nation’s 37 Tribal Colleges and Universities (TCUs)—this reality has reached a tipping point. Operating more than 75 campuses and sites across 16 states and serving 160,000 AI/ANs from more than 250 federally recognized Indian tribes each year (AIHEC, 2016), TCU faculty and staff are on the frontline in addressing the behavior health needs of their students, families, and communities. They know all too well the toll that unmet health and wellness challenges are having on teaching and learning, and more systemically, the threat they pose to the sovereignty and sustainability of our tribal nations. TCUs also know that effective solutions to reverse the generational impact of historical trauma must come from within Native communities. TCUs are the best resource to implement the tribally-driven and tribally- directed research needed to find answers. But currently, the capacity to conduct the research we need, on the scale that we need it, does not exist. The AIHEC NARCH Project is working to build research capacity in behavioral health at TCUs to find answers and share them with all AI/AN communities. Overview of Sub-Award Projects and Status The AIHEC NARCH Behavioral Health Initiative is a 5-year project launched in 2013 to build tribal research capacity in behavioral health through two 2-year cohorts of competitively selected TCUs engaging in professional development, community-based participatory research, and research partnerships with tribes and R-1 institutions.
    [Show full text]
  • For Indigenous Students
    For Indigenous Students SAY EDUCATION GUIDE 2018 | 21 SAY Magazine Survey Tips on how to use our Education Guide This Guide features over three hundred institutions, which includes You will find some information on Aboriginal/Native American some new listings and some updates from last year’s Guide. specific programs, services and courses offered by that particular institution. Use the legend below which explains the different types We want to thank those institutions who were very generous of symbols used in the grid. in sharing this information for your benefit. Some institutions were unable to respond to our request for information. If your For further information and a full description of the programs/ institution needs to be added, or has new/updated information, services these institutions offer, you should always review the insti- this can be done at http://saymag.com/2018-education-guide- tution’s website. You will discover more information that the SAY native-people-survey/. Scroll down the home page to ‘SAY 2018 Guide does not provide. Education Directory Form’. Although SAY Magazine has made every attempt to ensure The material in the grid comes from counsellors dealing with material in the Guide is correct, this is not a comprehensive listing Indigenous students. We asked them what information is most and SAY Magazine is not responsible for any errors or omissions. requested by Indigenous students and those are the questions asked in the survey sent to education institutions. This will give you a better understanding of the types of schools Electronic copies of back issues from 2009-2017 and the featured in the Guide, making it easier to find a good fit for you.
    [Show full text]