Enlightenment of Old Ideas from New Investigations: More Questions Regarding the Evolution of Bacteriogenic Light Organs in Squids
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
EVOLUTION & DEVELOPMENT 6:1, 41–49 (2004) Enlightenment of old ideas from new investigations: more questions regarding the evolution of bacteriogenic light organs in squids M. K. Nishiguchi,a,Ã J. E. Lopez,a and S. v. Boletzkyb aNew Mexico State University, Department of Biology, Box 30001, MSC 3AF, Las Cruces, NM 88003, USA bLaboratoire Arago, CNRS-UMR 7628, Banyuls sur mer, Cedex BP44, 66651, France ÃAuthor for correspondence (e-mail: [email protected]) SUMMARY Bioluminescence is widespread among many organ morphology from several closely related taxa within the different types of marine organisms. Metazoans contain two Sepiolidae and combined molecular phylogenetic data using types of luminescence production, bacteriogenic (symbiotic four loci (nuclear ribosomal 28S rRNA and the mitochondrial with bacteria) or autogenic, via the production of a luminous cytochrome c oxidase subunit I and 12S and 16S rRNA) to secretion or the intrinsic properties of luminous cells. Several determine whether this character was an ancestral trait species in two families of squids, the Loliginidae and the repeatedly lost among both families or whether it evolved Sepiolidae (Mollusca: Cephalopoda) harbor bacteriogenic independently as an adaptation to the pelagic and benthic light organs that are found central in the mantle cavity. lifestyles. By comparing other closely related extant taxa that These light organs are exceptional in function, that is, the do not contain symbiotic light organs, we hypothesized that morphology and the complexity suggests that the organ has the ancestral state of sepiolid light organs most likely evolved evolved to enhance and direct light emission from bacteria that from part of a separate accessory gland open to the are harbored inside. Although light organs are widespread environment that allowed colonization of bacteria to occur among taxa within the Sepiolidae, the origin and development and further specialize in the eventual development of the of this important feature is not well studied. We compared light modern light organ. INTRODUCTION (c) the mesodermally derived reflector formed by the ventral lining of the ink sac (Meyer 1906). These tissues, when fully Symbiotic (bacteriogenic) light organs associated with the ink developed, are poised to receive luminous bacteria from the sac and intestine are known in two representatives of the environment within the first few hours after hatching decabrachian families: Sepiolidae (order Sepiolida) and (McFall-Ngai and Ruby 1991). The colonization of the light Loliginidae (order Teuthida). These luminescent organs are organ complex is highly specific; that is, only symbiotically used for the production of light ventral to the squid mantle competent strains of bacteria from the genera Vibrio cavity, otherwise known as counter-illumination (Young (V. fischeri or V. logei)orPhotobacterium (P. leiognathi)can 1977). A similar organ exists in Chtenopteryx, a very peculiar colonize the light organ of host squids (Fidopiastis et al. 1998; teuthid squid that is thought to be closely related to the Nishiguchi 2002a,b). Once the light organ contains the Loliginidae (Young 1991). Among the oceanic teuthid squids symbiotic bacteria, it is fully functional for emission of living at epi- and mesopelagic levels, so-called anal light luminescence. organs of similar overall aspects occur but apparently never Naef (1923) previously hypothesized on the likely homo- house symbiotic luminous bacteria (Herring 1977). logous evolutionarily derived anatomical relationship of Basic components of bacteriogenic light organs in the bacterial light organs with the so-called accessory nidamental Sepiolidae and Loliginidae are (a) the crypts formed from glands (ANG). However, several variants raise new questions ectodermic invaginations during embryonic development, regarding the respective morphogenesis of these two com- ultimately housing the luminescent bacteria (Montgomery plexes. In Semirossia these variants range from a bilateral and McFall-Ngai 1993); (b) the mesodermally derived lens through a unilateral connection to ANG, or no connection to tissue covering the ventrolateral surface located on either side ANG, to a connection with supposedly ANG-homologous around the pore leading into the duct of the light organ structures in males (Boletzky 1970). Given this, we hope to (Montgomery and McFall-Ngai 1992; Weis et al. 1993); and elucidate the possible origin(s) of bacteriogenic light organs by & BLACKWELL PUBLISHING, INC. 41 42 EVOLUTION & DEVELOPMENT Vol. 6, No. 1, January^February 2004 comparing morphological similarities among representative Carlsbad, CA, USA). Samples were presequenced using Applied genera. To that end, we also examine the phylogenetic Biosystems Big Dye v.3.1 (Foster City, CA, USA) and excess relationships among closely related taxa with and without fluorescent dNTPs removed with Edge spin columns or plates bacteriogenic light organs. We ultimately hope to shed light (Gaithersburg, MD, USA). All samples sequenced for this study on the morphological diversification and functional co-option were run on an Applied Biosystems 3100 automated capillary sequencer. The resulting forward and reverse complete DNA of this dynamic complex among the Cephalopoda. sequence of each sample was then combined and edited using Sequencher v. 4.1 (Gene Codest, Ann Arbor, MI, USA). METHODS Phylogenetic analysis Morphology Sequence data were analyzed using the direct optimization method Serial sections (7 mm) of Semirossia spp. and Sepiola spp. were described by Wheeler (1996) and implemented in the computer obtained by sectioning paraffin-embedded specimens that were program POY (Wheeler et al. 2002). The four molecular partitions preserved in 70% ethanol after fixation in 10% formalin were analyzed independently and combined directly, with all (Semirossia spp., the original specimens described in Boletzky characters weighted equally (transitions/transversion/indel costs) 1970) or Bouin’s fixative (Sepiola spp.). Standard methods of without regard to source. These data sets are referred to as 12S histological staining (Azan, Masson’s trichrome, Prolabo, Paris, (12S rRNA data set alone), 16S (16S data set alone), COI (COI France) and mounting (Entellan, Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) data set alone), 28S (28S rRNA data set alone), and molecular were used. The sections were observed under a light microscope (12S116S1COI128S). The tree search strategy adopted combined (Leitz, Wetzlar, Germany) at 25 Â objective magnification, and spr and tbr branch swapping on the best of 50 random addition sections of embryonic stages of Sepiola ligulata were drawn using a replicates (-random 50), holding 100 trees per round (-maxtrees camera lucida (Leitz drawing arm). 100) and performing one round of tree-fusing (Goloboff 1999). The commands -slop 5 and -checkslop 10 were used. These commands DNA isolation, sequencing, and phylogenetic analyses are intended to check all cladogram lengths that are within ‘‘n’’ All squids used in the phylogenetic analyses had been previously tenths of a percent of the current minimum value. A slop value of collected at various localities or tissues were donated from various 10 would check all cladograms found within 1% of the minimum sources (Table 1). Approximately 25 mg of squid tissue was tree length. This option slows down the search but is less affected removed from either gill or mantle of each animal. DNA was then by the heuristics of the tree length calculation shortcuts. Nodal isolated from the tissue using the Qiagen DNAeasy Isolation kit support was evaluated via jackknifing for 1000 replicates. The ‘‘implied alignments’’ obtained with POY were checked with (Qiagen, Valencia, CA, USA). Once the DNA was isolated, Ã 1–10 ng was used for polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplifica- PAUP 4b (Swofford 2002) and identical tree lengths obtained. tions. For the analysis, four different loci were used: a partial sequence from the mitochondrial 12S rRNA, 16S rRNA, and the entire cytochrome c oxidase subunit I locus (COI), and a portion of RESULTS the nuclear 28S rRNA. Each primer set was used to amplify each of the four loci (Table 2A). These loci were chosen specifically for Comparative morphology of bacteriogenic light resolving relationships between sepiolid taxa because previous organs analyses have shown that they provide the most resolution for this The three components of bacteriogenic light organs men- family of squids (Nishiguchi et al. 1998; Nishiguchi 2001). All PCR tioned in our introduction show varying patterns of arrange- amplifications were performed in two thermocyclers (Perkin Elmer 9700, Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA, USA; and an MJ ment and overall outline depending on genera and species. Research Dyad, Waltham, MA, USA). Programs used to amplify The ontogenetic origin of the light organ can best be visualized the four loci were very similar with only slight variations in by observing the invagination of the first pair of crypts in annealing temperature and number of cycles (Table 2B). Some an embryo of, for example, Sepiola ligulata (Fig. 1). This variation shown in Table 2B for the 28S rRNA locus is due to the invagination appears at the earliest conceivable stage of fact that some species were more difficult to amplify than others morphogenesis. Indeed, the small volume of embryonic tissue (thus, the annealing temperature was decreased and number of available at this site virtually excludes the achievement of cycles was increased for those species). Each of the 50-mlPCR