DOCSLIB.ORG

N°7 March 2015

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
N°7 March 2015 EXPRESSION quaterly e-journal of atelier in cooperation with uispp-cisnep. international scientific commission on the intellectual and spiritual expressions of non-literate peoples N°7 March 2015 Bora initiation rite in Queensland, Australia. Late 19th century. (Photo Anati Archives). A MESSAGE FROM THE PRESIDENT Dear Friends and Colleagues, occasions, experts from various disciplines to share The International Scientific Committee on the experience and scientific approaches for a better “Intellectual and Spiritual Expression of Non-literate understanding of the human creativity and behavior. Peoples” (CISNEP-UISPP) gathered in its Session Multidisciplinary is a main aspect of our Committee. at the UISPP Burgos Congress 2014, as in previous Over 60 summaries and 25 full texts of papers were accepted. Participants included colleagues with UISPP-CISENP was founded in 2006 as an international sci- different scientific concerns and specializations. The entific commission of The International Union of Prehistoric Proceedings of the Session are in the process of being and Protohistoric Sciences (Union Internationale des Sciences Préhistoriques et Protohistoriques). Emmanuel Anati, President. printed. In the previous issue of EXPRESSION, part of these papers were presented. Additional papers are good ideas will survive while the bad ones will die. now included in this issue. A stimulating dialogue is The debate will be the judge, rather than aprioristic in progress and readers are encouraged to participate dogmas. Debate is alimented by new ideas. If there are in this dialogue by submitting to EXPRESSION no ideas there is no debate. comments and other pertinent considerations. Future Archaeology, both prehistoric and historic, needs a issues of EXPRESSION will face new themes: you are constant and open dialogue with other disciplines. invited to propose both papers and new ideas. This The study of man includes anthropology, sociology, quarterly e-journal will convey your ideas to colleagues psychology, human geography, semiotics, art history, in the different fields of the humanities and to other and other disciplines that have to join efforts. This is people of culture of over 60 different countries in five the aim of conceptual anthropology. You are welcome continents. to join in this effort. Our Committee is favoring a joint effort of its For the last three generations the trend has been participants, for a cooperation of different branches for researchers to be more and more specialized on of the humanistic and the social sciences, aiming limited research fields. Cultured humanistic formation at building up a new kind of broad-minded has often been sacrificed, being replaced by specific understanding of the past. It is a sincere pleasure to technicalities. Rather than broadminded thinkers, welcome this courageous common effort. Prehistoric this has favored the formation of technicians. They archaeology is in urgent need of this new landscape are welcome; as they are useful and needed, but it of “Conceptual Anthropology”, for a step forward. would be a dangerous dead-end for the humanities It is an important new academic approach for a solid if technicians would replace humanistic scholars and future of the study of man. thinkers. Both have to coexist side by side, both being In the last three generations, we have followed the conscious of their task and role. tendency of some humanistic disciplines, in stabilizing What is to be the image of Prehistoric and conservative concepts, as a mean to preserve the Protohistoric sciences in the future? Understanding past acquisitions and dictate the philosophical and the past is necessary to build a future. The knowledge ideological image of the discipline. Such trend creates of the past is the elementary base of culture. Even a sort of mysticism of the discipline, a special glossary in the tribal world young people are being initiated of conventional slangs, imposing a peculiar way of to the knowledge, to the history and the mytho- reasoning. This may turn out to become a handicap history of their past. Let us join efforts to develop for innovation and progress. Each discipline has the public awareness, education, formation, engagement, tendency to find a comfortable refuge in its own ghetto. research, for a broader understanding of our past. Join The spirit of conservation then favors the progress of actively in the dialogues and debates. those best integrated into the vernacular system. The obedient alumni are not necessarily the most brilliant Emmanuel Anati ones. Such conservationism may prevent new ideas President and new concepts to compete with old dogmas. Such a chain could have a negative effect on the progress of scientific research. In each regime, to make a career, it is useful to be a “member of the party”. Academic regimes tend to Subscribe to follow the same trend. Conformism helps to survive though it does not help much in the progress of EXPRESSION research. To avoid criticism, young archeologists and prehistorians prefer to remain descriptive, limiting new ideas that may displease “peer reviewers”. This is [email protected] favoring mediocrity. For the advancement of scientific research, new ideas should have space: in any case, 2 EXPRESSION N° 7 It is a pleasure to invite you to join this project and to reply to the three questions for a prehistoric art site or DISCUSSION assemblage: WHEN, WHY and TO WHOM. When: what kind of society produced the art: hunters, FORUM gatherers, agriculturists, ....? When was it produced and by whom? Why: Why was it produced. What did it intend to convey, what was its motivation: message, communication, commemoration, memorization? What is its content. ROCK ART: WHEN WHY AND TO WHOM? Prehistoric art is "Writing before Writing". Or was it produced just to embellish the rock surfaces? If it contains In February 2015, the following call for papers was messages, they could be read thousand years ago. If the sent off. Many replies arrived in one month time. messages are still there, can they be read and decoded Some requested a delay in the presentation of their today? paper, one scholar replied that in one month time To whom: To whom was the message addressed: he is unable to write four pages, several colleagues Human beings, ancestors, gods, nature? What kind of presented their ideas in a colloquial way and were communication was produced by the art? What did their invited to submit a paper that could be published. makers expected to obtain as a result of producing it? Over sixty interesting and pertinent papers were Length of each paper could be from 2 to 4 pages (1500 submitted, and are now being reviewed. The flow did to 3000 words) and may include up to 4 images. Texts not stop yet, so we decided to continue considering should be in English. They could include description of incoming papers although we are not sure that all locality and of the art, and reasoned considerations of of them can be included in a single volume. The these three queries. Illustrations should be of high quality discussion forum is leading towards new concepts in with a definition of 600 dpi. The papers received will be rock art studies and it is worthwhile to listen to voices considered by reviewers. Please let us know the locality coming from over 30 countries. Some of the papers of selected and the title of your communication as soon this “WWW PROJECT” may make the theme of one as possible. Kindly consider that we would appreciate of the following issues of EXPRESSION. receiving your final text within one month from the date of the present email. We look forward to hearing from you. ROCK ART: WHEN WHY AND TO WHOM UISPP-CISENP (International Scientific Committee on Best regards, the Intellectual and Spiritual Expressions of Non-literate Emmanuel Anati People) (President UISPP-CISENP) Dear friends, Some days ago an invitation was sent to a few rock art specialists to write and present short texts on “ROCK ART: WHEN, WHY AND TO WHOM?” and we were pleased to receive several positive replies. The same invitation is now extended to a larger number of specialists, in view of an international publication in English of the pertinent papers. Following specific requests, the participation is extended also to topics concerning mobile or “mobiliary” The logo of ATELIER art of non-literate people. In such case the title of the kokopeli, the American Indian resulting publication could be "Prehistoric art: when, story-teller. Tracing from rock art, why and to whom". Arizona (USA). MARCH 2015 3 CONTENTS Daniel Arsenault (Canada) The Canadian Shield rock art and its spiritual dimension: Finding some tangible and intangible aspects of rock art sites in the Canadian Shield through a contextual approach .............................. 5 Paul D. Burley (UK) As Above, So Below: Unveiling the Truth About Stonehenge’s Sacred Landscape .......................................... 14 Somnath Chakraverty (India) Pre-literate art in India: a source of indigenous knowledge, ethno-history and collective wisdom ................. 26 Bulu Imam (India) The intellectual and spiritual expressions of a nomadic tribe, the Birhor (of Hazaribagh, Jharkhand, Eastern India) ................................................................................................... 40 Mercedes Pérez Bartolomé, Emilio Muñoz Fernández (Spain) Colonization of the upper Miera and Asón Valleys (Cantabria, Spain) in the Late Pleistocene and the Early Holocene. ..........................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • La Pintura Membership Year 2009 Volume 35, Number 2
    2009 Conference Program La Pintura Membership Year 2009 Volume 35, Number 2 The Official Newsletter of the American Rock Art Research Association May 2009 Member of the International Federation of Rock Art Organizations www.arara.org Welcome to Bakersfield 36th Annual ARARA Conference, 2009 Evelyn Billo, ARARA President Thank you for bucking the current economic trend and Conservation Session and Round Table: Leigh Marymor. traveling to Bakersfield, California, where we expect you will be Publications Chair: Peggy Whitehead with helpers Bill rewarded for your effort with good friendships made and re- Whitehead, Ron Smith, and Anne McConnell. newed, excellent research projects and results, and pleasant field La Pintura Editor: Breen Murray. trip experiences, and will leave with fond memories of people La Pintura Design and Layout: Jennifer Huang. working together to educate, conserve, promote, interpret, Conference Program Layout and La Pintura Printing and manage, and respect our shared passion, the study and apprecia- Distribution: Ken Hedges. tion of rock art. Web Chair: Lloyd Anderson. ARARA is an amazing all-volunteer organization. We honor Press Releases: Chris Gralapp. the lifetime achievements of colleagues who serve as mentors as ARARA Online: Gary Hein and Lisa Werner. we strive to contribute individual actions and goals to assure a Deer Valley Rock Art Center Liaison: Kim Arth and Hannah strong ARARA of the Future. Please take time to thank your Kusinitz. fellow members who have donated their time and talents into making this a special gathering. And, please let me know and A big thanks to outgoing board members Chris Gralapp and accept my apology if I inadvertently left you off this list.
    [Show full text]
  • Rock Art of Latin America & the Caribbean
    World Heritage Convention ROCK ART OF LATIN AMERICA & THE CARIBBEAN Thematic study June 2006 49-51 rue de la Fédération – 75015 Paris Tel +33 (0)1 45 67 67 70 – Fax +33 (0)1 45 66 06 22 www.icomos.org – [email protected] THEMATIC STUDY OF ROCK ART: LATIN AMERICA & THE CARIBBEAN ÉTUDE THÉMATIQUE DE L’ART RUPESTRE : AMÉRIQUE LATINE ET LES CARAÏBES Foreword Avant-propos ICOMOS Regional Thematic Studies on Études thématiques régionales de l’art Rock Art rupestre par l’ICOMOS ICOMOS is preparing a series of Regional L’ICOMOS prépare une série d’études Thematic Studies on Rock Art of which Latin thématiques régionales de l’art rupestre, dont America and the Caribbean is the first. These la première porte sur la région Amérique latine will amass data on regional characteristics in et Caraïbes. Ces études accumuleront des order to begin to link more strongly rock art données sur les caractéristiques régionales de images to social and economic circumstances, manière à préciser les liens qui existent entre and strong regional or local traits, particularly les images de l’art rupestre, les conditions religious or cultural traditions and beliefs. sociales et économiques et les caractéristiques régionales ou locales marquées, en particulier Rock art needs to be anchored as far as les croyances et les traditions religieuses et possible in a geo-cultural context. Its images culturelles. may be outstanding from an aesthetic point of view: more often their full significance is L’art rupestre doit être replacé autant que related to their links with the societies that possible dans son contexte géoculturel.
    [Show full text]
  • Program & Abstracts
    2004 Conference Program Membership Year 2003-2004 La Pintura Volume 30, Number 4 The Official Newsletter of the American Rock Art Research Association www.arara.org 31st Annual Conference Program & Abstracts 2 ARARA 2004 Conference Program Welcome to Nuevo Casas Grandes! We are pleased this year to be in Nuevo Casas Grandes for the 31st Annual Conference of the American Rock Art Research Association. It is exciting to be holding our first meeting south of the border, and with our fellow Rock Art Researchers from Mexico. We offer our thanks and appreciation to Mercedes Jiménez, Directora, and the Museo de las Culturas del Norte, Paquimé, Chihuahua, for their hard work to give ARARA a warm welcome and for planning and hosting our annual reception and helping with the planning of our marketplace; to Elsa Rodriguez, Directora, Centro INAH, and to the Instituto Nacional de Antropología y Historia for their support of the conference, and for approval of the use of images from Arroyo de los Monos in our logo design. We thank Richard O’Connor for providing a photo of the Arroyo de los Monos panel for use in logo design. Thanks to our reception entertainment, the Dance Group from Centro de Bachillerato Tecnológico Agropecuario #112, and our musicians, Grupo Música Coral Vida. We also thank Imelda Dávila Torres and Maria Christina Almedia of the Hotel Hacienda, our meeting venue. Thanks to our Banquet speaker César Quijada López, and our translators, Maria de Jesús Velasco Acuña and José Luis Leyva. Special thanks to Sandi Casillas of Casas Grandes in assisting with the organization and contributing to our Marketplace—which replaces our customary Vendor Room this year and provides an opportunity for local artisans to display and vend their wares—to Nicolas Quezada for his Mata Ortiz Pottery demonstration, and to local pottery artisan Julian Hernandez.
    [Show full text]
  • Rock Art Studies: a Bibliographic Database Page 1 North America Mexico Sonora (90 Citations) Compiled by Leigh Marymor 02/09/16 Pt
    Rock Art Studies: A Bibliographic Database Page 1 North America_Mexico_Sonora (90 Citations) Compiled by Leigh Marymor 02/09/16 Pt. Richmond CA Aguilar Valenzuela, Bertha Aguilar, ed. and Amador Bech, Julio Pfeifer, Padre David Joseph Beuamont, ed. 2011 2004 "Figures of Ritual and Ecstasy in the Rock Art of El Mensaje de las Rocas. Pinturas Rupestres en the Sonoran Desert" in International Newsletter la Region Pima, 102 pgs, Instituto Sonorense de on Rock Art, 59, 9-18. Comite International Cultura PAYMAC (Programa de Apoyo a las d'Art Rupestre, Foix, France, ISSN 1022-3282. Culturas Municipales y Comunitarias, Sonora, Mexico. La Proveedora, Caborca, Sonora, Mexico. North America. Trincheras sites. Ritual, rain La Cueva Gacha, El Hierbanis, La Cueva Pinta de Los production, fertility, ritual deer hunting, maize Vallecitos, La Cueva de El Quipor, El Cajoncito de El ceremonies, vision quests. Quipor, La Cueva Pinta del Pollo, La Cueva de los Monos, La Cueva Pinta de Arroyo Hondo, Las Gallinas and La LMRAA. Cueva Pinta de Yepachic, Tierra Blanca. Sierra Madre Occidental, Sonora, Mexico. North America. Pima rock art. Cultural resource management. Conservation and Amador Bech, Julio preservation. Regional survey. Spirituality. Community. LMRAA, RASNW3. 2011 -Cultural del Arte Rupestre en el Amador Bech, J. Noroeste de Sonora" in Perspectivas de la 2011 Investigación Arqueológica VI, Patricia Fournier "El Arte Rupestre y el Simbolísmo del Paisaje en y Walburga Wiesheu, coords., el Noroeste de Sonora" in Identidad, Paisaje y Patrimonio, INAH-ENAH-DEH-DEA, Stanislaw Iwaniszewski y Silvina Vigliani, Coords., 287- (CONACULTA/INAH/ENAH), Mexico, D.F.. 320, , Mexico. ISBN: 9786074841824. Northwest Sonora, Mexico.
    [Show full text]
  • IFRAO 2013 Albuquerque, New Mexico, USA 1 Session 1 SYMBOLS, MYTHS, and COSMOLOGY Archaeological Material and Anthropological Meanings
    IFRAO 2013 Albuquerque, New Mexico, USA 1 Session 1 SYMBOLS, MYTHS, AND COSMOLOGY Archaeological Material and Anthropological Meanings Dario Seglie CeSMAP, Pinerolo - Polytechnic of Torino, Italy [email protected] Mike Singleton University of Louvain, Belgium [email protected] Herman Bender Hanwakan Center for Prehistoric Astronomy, Cosmology and Cultural Landscape Studies, Fond du Lac, Wisconsin, USA [email protected] Enrico Comba University of Torino, Torino, Italy [email protected] The Symposium seeks to occasion new ideas and innovative research, to afford fresh theories and bold hypothesis to- gether with unpublished information and recent discoveries relative to the study of Rock Art in general and in particular to the philosophies and practices it implies. The Symposium thus provides an opportunity to discuss the roles played by Iconography and Myth in archaeological times thanks, in part, to the light which can be shed thereon by insights emerg- ing from the anthropological study of peoples whose material life styles and assimilated mentalities can be plausibly paralleled to those of our prehistoric forebears. There is no third way beyond conscious or unconscious ethnocentrism. It must consequently be recognized that anthro- pology and archaeology with their respective categorizations of empirical reality (amongst which “Art” and “Prehis- tory”, “Ritual” and “Myth”) are pure products of recent Western history. This recognition, rendered creative as well as critical, could lead, far beyond the usual interdisciplinary
    [Show full text]
  • Ÿþp Etroglyph
    PETROGLYPH Newsletter of the Arizona Archaeological Society Volume 45, Number 7 www.AzArchSoc.org March 2009 Taste of Prehistory and Visit the Ancient Ones Get-Together In celebration of Arizona Archaeology Payson area’s ancient history. Who to be visited. Afterwards, we will and Heritage Awareness Month the says you can’t have fun and learn at car-pool to two sites in Payson: Rim Country Chapter of the Arizona the same time? Archaeologists Scott Wood and Dr. Archaeological Society is hosting a Penny Minturn will be our guides at ‘Taste of Prehistory’ and ‘Visit the The fun begins at 10:00 am. Saturday, the Goat Camp Ruins and the Risser Ancient Ones’ get-together. The March 21st in the meeting hall of the Ruins ancient Native American activities are open to the public and all Church of the Holy Nativity, 1414 N. village sites. are invited to attend and participate. Easy Street. There will be a sampling This is an opportunity to experience of prehistoric-type foods along with a All activities are free to the public, foods of prehistoric people and visit presentation of archaeological interest although donations will be greatly ancient Native American sites located by Forestry Ranger Eddie Colyott, appreciated. One hundred percent of in Payson. It’s also a chance for Tonto National Monument, and all donations received will go to the young people to realize some of the information about the historical sites Goat Camp Ruins preservation fund. HELP NEEDED FOR ARCHAEOLOGY EXPO The Arizona Archaeology Expo is being held at Pueblo Grande Museum, 4619 E.
    [Show full text]