Factors Which Enable Or Hinder the Protection of Human Rights Eventh Seventh Olicies
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Factors which enable or hinder the protection o which enable or hinder the protection Factors human rights are high on the eu agenda. however, the eu is facing multiple Factors which challenges to fulfil its declared commitment to promote and protect human rights. enable or these challenges are the focus of Frame, hinder the an interdisciplinary research project on Fostering human rights among european protection oF (external and internal) policies. Frame is a large-scale, collaborative research human rights project funded under the eu’s seventh Framework programme (Fp7), coordinated by the leuven centre for global governance studies and involving 19 research institutes from around the world. our research focuses on the contribution of the eu’s internal and external policies to the promotion of human rights worldwide. eva maria lassen (editor) monika mayrhoFer as part of the Frame project, researchers peter vedel kessing and other experts at the danish institute hans-otto sano F daniel garcía san José for human rights, in collaboration with human rights researchers from other universities, have rikke Frank Jørgensen been working on key historical, cultural, legal, economic, political, ethnic, religious and technological factors that may impact human rights at the eu, international and national levels. in this series, we present some of the results of our work. the research is relevant to human rights academics, practitioners, civil society, and policy-makers at the national, regional, international and eu levels. Frame_omslag_11,6.indd 1 05/04/2017 16.29 Factors which enable or hinder the protection oF human rights authors: eva maria lassen (editor), monika mayrhofer, peter vedel kessing, hans-otto sano, daniel garcía san José, rikke Frank Jørgensen Funding: Frame Fostering human rights among european (external and internal) policies. large-scale Fp7 collaborative project ga no. 320000 1 may 2013-30 april 2017 isbn: 978-87-93241-97-8 doi.org/20.500.11825/69 coverdesign: heddabank.dk print: toptryk grafisk © 2017 the danish institute for human rights denmark’s national human rights institution wilders plads 8k dk-1403 copenhagen k phone +45 3269 8888 www.humanrights.dk provided such reproduction is for non-commercial use, this publication, or parts of it, may be reproduced if author and source are quoted. Frame_omslag_11,6.indd 2 05/04/2017 16.29 Fostering Human Rights among European Policies Large-Scale FP7 Collaborative Project GA No. 320000 1 May 2013-30 April 2017 Factors which enable or hinder the protection of human rights Work Package No. 2 – Deliverable No. 1 Due date 31 July 2014 Submission date 4 August 2014 Dissemination level PU Lead Beneficiary The Danish Institute for Human Rights Authors Eva Maria Lassen (editor), Monika Mayrhofer, Peter Vedel Kessing, Hans- Otto Sano, Daniel García San José, Rikke Frank Jørgensen http://www.fp7-frame.eu doi.org/20.500.11825/69 Preface The EU today stands at a crossroads with regard to human rights: although human rights are high on its agenda the EU is facing multiple challenges of carrying the torch of human rights, within EU Member States and in relation to the wider world. These challenges are the focus of FRAME, an interdisciplinary research project on Fostering Human Rights Among European (External and Internal) Policies. FRAME is a large-scale, collaborative research project funded under the EU’s Seventh Framework Programme (FP7), coordinated by the Leuven Centre for Global Governance Studies and involving 19 research institutes from around the world. Our research focuses on the contribution of the EU’s internal and external policies to the promotion of human rights worldwide. In this series of publications, we have collected some of the work carried out by researchers and other experts at the Danish Institute for Human Rights, in collaboration with researchers from other universities, as part of the FRAME project. The four publications have been written with contributions from scholars and experts from The Ludwig Boltzmann Institute of Human Rights, Vienna; European Training and Research Centre for Human Rights and Democracy, Graz; University of Seville; Leuven Centre for Global Governance Studies, KU Leuven, and the Danish Institute for Human Rights. In our work we have aimed at illuminating contemporary human rights challenges by way of analysing the historical, political, legal, economic, social, cultural, religious, ethnical and technological factors that both facilitate and hamper the efforts of the EU in its efforts to promote and protect human rights, within the EU and in the world at large. It is hoped the insights gained from this research may contribute to informing the debate – among human rights academics, practitioners, civil society, and policy-makers - about the EU’s future direction in the important field of human rights. April 2017 Eva Maria Lassen Senior researcher The Danish Institute for Human Rights FRAME Deliverable No. 2.1 Executive Summary In assessing the factors that influence the protection and promotion of human rights in the European Union (EU), this report elucidates those factors that cut across the catalogue of human rights. This report seeks to examine contemporary human rights challenges in this context by mapping the historical, political, legal, economic, social, cultural, religious, ethnical and technological factors that both facilitate and hamper human rights in the EU. Preface This report is part of Work Package 2 ‘Challenges and Factors’ of the EU’s Seventh Framework Programme (FP7) project Fostering Human Rights among European Policies (FRAME). This first cluster of FRAME constitutes the foundations of a sound knowledge base for the assessment of EU human rights policies, The EU today stands at a crossroads with regard to human rights: although human rights are high on its encompassing the evolving factors, concepts, institutions and instruments that underlie human rights agenda the EU is facing multiple challenges of carrying the torch of human rights, within EU Member States protection and promotion. and in relation to the wider world. These challenges are the focus of FRAME, an interdisciplinary research project on Fostering Human Rights The objective of the report is to analyse these crucial factors while taking into account challenges brought Among European (External and Internal) Policies. FRAME is a large-scale, collaborative research project about by globalisation, with a focus on access to basic rights. The report does this through the provision funded under the EU’s Seventh Framework Programme (FP7), coordinated by the Leuven Centre for Global of a qualitative mapping addressing the major topics related to each factor. The report is divided into 10 Governance Studies and involving 19 research institutes from around the world. Our research focuses on chapters and provides a chapter on each of the above cross-cutting factors, including an overview of the the contribution of the EU’s internal and external policies to the promotion of human rights worldwide. factor drawn from a literature review, an assessment of current knowledge of the factor and its impact on human rights in the EU, and challenges and gaps requiring further study. In this series of publications, we have collected some of the work carried out by researchers and other experts at the Danish Institute for Human Rights, in collaboration with researchers from other universities, The report canvasses the major landmarks in EU history, with a view both to its external and internal as part of the FRAME project. The four publications have been written with contributions from scholars and policies (Chapter II, Historical), before addressing the inherently political nature of human rights experts from The Ludwig Boltzmann Institute of Human Rights, Vienna; European Training and Research themselves and the importance of States, sovereignty, ideologies, power, citizenship and democracy to Centre for Human Rights and Democracy, Graz; University of Seville; Leuven Centre for Global Governance their implementation (Chapter III, Political). Turning to legal factors, the report considers the coherence Studies, KU Leuven, and the Danish Institute for Human Rights. of obligations within the EU; whether the EU is bound by human rights obligations when acting externally; In our work we have aimed at illuminating contemporary human rights challenges by way of analysing the the relationship of human rights obligations and other international law norms; and finally shared human historical, political, legal, economic, social, cultural, religious, ethnical and technological factors that both rights responsibility between the EU and Member States (Chapter IV, Legal). facilitate and hamper the efforts of the EU in its efforts to promote and protect human rights, within the EU and in the world at large. Taking post-crisis Europe as its departure point, the report analyses the economic dimensions of human rights in the EU, including the significance of economic decline, the internal market, poverty, employment, It is hoped the insights gained from this research may contribute to informing the debate – among human foreign policy, and development and trade (Chapter V, Economic). Turning to social factors, the report rights academics, practitioners, civil society, and policy-makers - about the EU’s future direction in the addresses the importance of the principle of non-discrimination in EU policy and institutions, before important field of human rights. specifically considering the