DOCSLIB.ORG

Record on Appeal from the Circuit Court of the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit in and for Broward County, Florida

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Record on Appeal from the Circuit Court of the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit in and for Broward County, Florida IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA RECORD ON APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE SEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA MICHAEL RIVERA 86-11716 CF10A APPELLANT CASE NUMBER: VS STATE OF FLORIDA SC 17 - 1991 APPELLEE APPEAL NUMBER: ______________________________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________________________ RECORD ON APPEAL CC: ATTNY GEN – W.P.B. CCRC - SOUTH MASTER INDEX ON APPEAL APPELLATE DIVISION Case NO: 86-011716-CF10A Appeal NO: 70,563; 85,079; 86,528; 95,766 DATE: KIND OF INSTRUMENT PAGES: 04/19/2016 File Mandate - Affirmed 1 - 38 12/05/2016 File Successive Motion to 39 - 68 Vacate Death Sentence 12/05/2016 File Successive Motion to 69 - 70 Exceed Page Limitations 01/10/2017 File States Motion For 71 - 72 Extension Of Time to file Response 01/13/2017 File Order Granting State 73 - 73 Motion Extension Of Time 01/25/2017 File States Motion to Toll Time 74 - 75 01/25/2017 File States Response to Motion 76 - 100 to Exceed Page Limitations 03/01/2017 File Defendants Reply to 101 - 108 State's Response 03/01/2017 File Defense Motion for Leave 109 - 116 to Amend Successive Motion 03/28/2017 File Order Denying Def Motion 117 - 117 to Exceed Page Limitation 03/28/2017 File Order Denying Def Motion 118 - 118 for Leave to Amend Pending Successive Motion 04/12/2017 File Defense Motion For 119 - 312 Rehearing 05/12/2017 File States Response to Motion 313 - 316 for Rehearing 06/27/2017 File State's Motion To Strike 317 - 319 Successive Motion 07/12/2017 Order Granting State's Motion 320 - 320 to Strike Successive Motion 07/12/2017 File Order Denying Def Motion 321 - 321 For Rehearing 07/18/2017 File Defense Motion For 322 - 324 Extension Of Time to file Successive Motion 07/18/2017 File Defense Amended Motion 325 - 327 For Extension Of Time to file Successive Motion 08/16/2017 File Order Requesting State To 328 - 328 Respond 08/16/2017 File State's Response per 329 - 330 Court's 08-16-17 Order 08/31/2017 File Successive Motion to 331 - 357 Vacate Death Sentence 09/15/2017 File States Response to 358 - 380 Successive Motion for Post Conviction Relief 09/27/2017 File Order Requesting State To 381 - 381 Respond 09/27/2017 File Order Denying Def Motion 382 - 405 For Post Conv Relief 10/27/2017 File Defendants Notice Of 406 - 407 Appeal FELONY CASE SUMMARY CASE NO. 86-011716-CF10A State of Florida § Location: Felony Vs. § Judicial Officer: Haury - FC, William W., Jr. Rivera, Michael T § Filed on: 02/15/1987 § 4th District Court of 70,563 § Appeals: § 85,079 § 86,528 § 95,766 § Arrest Number: BS94012287 § BS95006384 § BS99008808 § CS86000068 § BS12006873 § BCCN: 0012127 § Docketrac Conversion Case: 86011716CF10A § Florida Supreme Court: SC01-2523 § SC05-1873 § SC13-1077//NVI § Uniform Case Number: 061986CF011716A88810 CASE INFORMATION Offense Statute Deg Date Case Type: Felony Jurisdiction: Broward County 1. Murder in the First Degree 782.04(1)(a) CF6 01/30/1986 Case Flags: Appeal Filed OBTS: 0007737288 Sequence: 2 ACN: BS95006384 CTS Financial Balance Arrest: 04/05/1995 BS - Broward Sheriff Office DATE CASE ASSIGNMENT Current Case Assignment Case Number 86-011716-CF10A Court Felony Date Assigned 02/15/1987 Judicial Officer Haury - FC, William W., Jr. PARTY INFORMATION State State of Florida Defendant Rivera, Michael T DATE EVENTS & ORDERS OF THE COURT 10/27/2017 File Defendants Notice Of Appeal JGL - SUPREME COURT CASE 09/27/2017 File Document Certificate of Clerk 3.850 09/27/2017 File Document Certificate of Clerk 3.850 09/27/2017 File Order Denying Def Motion For Post Conv Relief Signed 092717 09/27/2017 File Order Requesting State To Respond Signed 092717; 60 Days; to Def Successive M/to Vacate Death Sentence 09/15/2017 File States Response PAGE 1 OF 34 Printed on 11/20/2017 at 11:05 AM FELONY CASE SUMMARY CASE NO. 86-011716-CF10A to Def's Successive Motion for Post Conviction Relief 08/31/2017 File Defense Motion to Vacate Death Sentence. 08/16/2017 File State's Response to Court Order 08/16/2017 File Order Requesting State To Respond Signed 08/16/2017, 15 Days. 07/25/2017 File Document Certificate Of Clerk Denying Rehearing 07/18/2017 File Defense Motion For Extension Of Time 07/18/2017 File Defense Motion For Extension Of Time 07/12/2017 File Order Denying Def Motion For Rehearing Signed July 12, 2017 07/12/2017 Order Granting State's Motion To Strike Deft's Successive Post-Conviction Motion Signed 7/12/17 06/27/2017 File Defense Motion To Strike 05/12/2017 File States Response to Deft's Motion for Rehearing (Emailed JA 5/25/17) 04/12/2017 File Defense Motion For Rehearing 03/28/2017 File Order Denying Def Motion Signed 03/28/17; for Leave to Amend Pending Success Rule and Alt M/to Correct Illegal Sentence 03/28/2017 File Order Denying Def Motion Signed 032817; to Exceed Page Limitation 03/01/2017 File Defense Motion for Leave to Amend Pending 3.851 M/Correct Illegal Sentc 03/01/2017 File Defendants Response to State's Response to M/to Exceed Page Limitation 01/25/2017 File States Response to M/to Exceed Page Limitations for Successive M/to Vacate Death Sentence (emailed JA 3/9/17) 01/25/2017 File States Motion to Toll Time 01/13/2017 File Order Granting State Motion Extension Of Time Signed 011217 Additional 14 days 01/10/2017 File States Motion For Extension Of Time 14 Days to File Response to Deft's Successive M/Vacate Death Sentence (Emailed JA 1/11/17) 12/05/2016 File Motion to Exceed Page Limitations 12/05/2016 File Defense Motion Successive M/Vacate Death Sentence 04/19/2016 File Mandate - Affirmed supreme court mandate SC13-1077 PAGE 2 OF 34 Printed on 11/20/2017 at 11:05 AM FELONY CASE SUMMARY CASE NO. 86-011716-CF10A 03/14/2015 Sent To Law Firm For Collections Linebarger 03/14/2015 CTS_Current Due Count(s):<|001|> Charges: 1 Amount: 33.75 02/25/2014 File Supreme Court Of Florida Order The motion for extension of time filed in the above cause is granted and the time for filing the supplemental record with this Court is extended to and including March 21, 2014 01/29/2014 File Supreme Court Of Florida Order Appellant's Motion to Supplement the Record on Appeal (copy attached) and Appellant's Motion to Toll Time for Filing Initial Brief are hereby granted. The trial court clerk is directed, on or before February 3, 2014, to supplement the record with the items listed in the attached motion. Appellant is allowed nineteen days from the filing of the supplemental record in which to serve the initial briefs on the merits 10/29/2013 File Notice STATUS REPORT REGARDING RECORD ON APPEAL 10/23/2013 Appeal Completed mailed to the Supreme Court, A.G., Nicole Noel 09/13/2013 File Supreme Court Of Florida Order GRANTING BOSS REPORTING AGENCY AN EXTENSION OF TIME UNTIL 10/9/13 TO PREPARE TRANSCRIPTS Hearing/Status Conference (11:00 AM) (Judicial Officer: Backman - FX, Paul 08/26/2013 L ;Location: Room 5780) 08/26/2013 Hearing Held / Status Conference Ct Rept J. Garcia (I) 08/19/2013 File Transcript 071712/ Hearing for Defense Motion to Strike 07/24/2013 Order signed 072213/ Setting Hearing/ 082613/ Status Conference 07/24/2013 File Supreme Court Of Florida Order ACKNOWLEDGING NEW CASE 07/05/2013 File Designation To Court Reporter 07/05/2013 File Directions To The Clerk 06/17/2013 File Defense Notice Of Change Of Address 06/17/2013 File Letter from att re: Change of Address Form 06/11/2013 Clerk Assigned To Appeal NVI SC13-1077 06/11/2013 File Defendants Notice Of Appeal SUPREME COURT OF FLORIDA, FILED BY MARTIN MCCLAIN, DENIAL OF 3.851 MOTION FOR POST-CONVICTION 4/2/13, ORDER DENYING REHEARING 5/13/13 05/21/2013 File Notice Of Filing judge files copy of the floppy disk of the Record on Appeal 05/14/2013 File Order Denying Def Motion For Rehearing 051313 04/17/2013 File Defense Motion For Rehearing 04/03/2013 File Order Denying Def Motion To Vac/Set Aside Judgment signed 020413 fx dv (amended order denying d/amended motion t vacate judg. of conv. & sent.) 03/27/2013 File Order Denying Def Motion To Vac/Set Aside Judgment signed 032613 fx dv (amended motion) PAGE 3 OF 34 Printed on 11/20/2017 at 11:05 AM FELONY CASE SUMMARY CASE NO. 86-011716-CF10A 01/04/2013 File Defendant's reply closing argument 12/26/2012 File States Response To successive and untimely motion for post convicton relief 11/16/2012 File Document closing argument 11/08/2012 Release Status BS12006873 Date 2: 10/17/2012 10/22/2012 File Transcript 101012 10/22/2012 File Transcript 100912 10/22/2012 File Transcript 100812 Hearing /Evidentiary (3.850) (9:00 AM) (Judicial Officer: Backman - FX, Paul 10/10/2012 L ;Location: Room 5780) Reset 10/10/2012 File Order For Production Of Transcripts signed 101012 Hearing /Evidentiary (3.850) (9:00 AM) (Judicial Officer: Backman - FX, Paul 10/09/2012 L ;Location: Room 5780) Reset Hearing /Evidentiary (3.850) (1:30 PM) (Judicial Officer: Backman - FX, Paul 10/08/2012 L ;Location: Room 5780) Reset per ICC/Suzanne Hearing /Evidentiary (3.850) (9:00 AM) (Judicial Officer: Backman - FX, Paul 10/03/2012 L ;Location: Room 5780) Reset per ICC/Suzanne Hearing /Evidentiary (3.850) (9:00 AM) (Judicial Officer: Backman - FX, Paul 10/02/2012 L ;Location: Room 5780) 10/02/2012 Hrg Held / Evidentiary (3.850) d/ct rept v rock-boss/held in part recess until 1003 at 0900 10/01/2012 File Order Denying Def Motion signed 100112/denying defendant's request to waive his appearance at capital postconviction evidentiary hearing Hearing/Status Hearing (9:00 AM) (Judicial Officer: Backman - FX, Paul 09/20/2012
Load more

Recommended publications
  • IN the SUPREME COURT of FLORIDA JOHN MAREK Appellant
    IN THE SUPREME COURT OF FLORIDA JOHN MAREK Appellant, v. CASE NO. SC09-765 STATE OF FLORIDA, Appellee. _________________________/ ON APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE SEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, STATE OF FLORIDA ANSWER BRIEF OF THE APPELLEE BILL McCOLLUM ATTORNEY GENERAL CAROLYN M. SNURKOWSKI Assistant Attorney General Florida Bar No. 158541 DEPARTMENT OF LEGAL AFFAIRS PL-01, THE CAPITOL Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1050 (850) 414-3566 (850) 487-0997 (Fax) COUNSEL FOR APPELLEE TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS.............................................. i TABLE OF AUTHORITIES.......................................... ii PRELIMINARY STATEMENT.......................................... 1 INTRODUCTION................................................... 1 STATEMENT OF THE CASE.......................................... 1 STATEMENT OF THE FACTS........................................ 10 SUMMARY OF THE ARGUMENT....................................... 24 ARGUMENT...................................................... 25 ISSUE I ..................................................... 25 MAREKS‘S SENTENCE OF DEATH VIOLATES THE EIGHTH AND FOURTEENTH AMENDMENTS BECAUSE IT PERMITS AN ARBITRARY AND CAPRICIOUS IMPOSITION OF A SENTENCE OF DEATH .............. 25 ISSUE II .................................................... 47 LACKEY V. TEXAS, 514 U.S. 1045 (1995) ARGUMENT ............ 47 ISSUE III ................................................... 50 PENDENCY OF CAPERTON V. MASSEY, CASE NO. 08-22, UNITED STATES SUPREME COURT
    [Show full text]
  • Rece Ived Florida Supreme Court 12/11/2017
    IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA MILFORD WADE BYRD DEFENDANT/APPELLANT CASE NO. 81-CF-010517-A VS. STATE OF FLORIDA PLAINTIFF/APPELLEE APPELLATE CASE NO: 17-1733 APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT, CRIMINAL DIVISION, OF THE THIRTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA, IN AND FOR HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY THE HONORABLE MICHELLE SISCO JUDGE OF CIRCUIT COURT CRIMINAL DIVISION MARTIN J. MCCLAIN, ESQ. ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL 141 NE 30TH ST CONCOURSE CENTER NO. 4 WILTON MANORS, FL 33334 3507 E FRONTAGE ROAD, STE 200 TAMPA, FLORIDA 33607 ATTORNEY FOR APPELLANT ATTORNEY FOR APPELLEE MASTER INDEX INDEX TO THE ORIGINAL RECORD ON APPEAL ITEM FILE DATE INSTRUMENT PAGE 81-CF-010517-A 1 12/6/2017 APPEAL CASE SUMMARY 1 - 42 2 11/2/2016 SUCCESSIVE MOTION TO VACATE JUDGMENTS OF 43 - 86 CONVICTION AND SENTENCE OF DEATH 3 11/2/2016 MOTION TO EXCEED PAGE LIMITATION 87 - 88 4 11/22/2016 STATE'S RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT'S SUCCESSIVE 89 - 112 MOTION TO VACATE JUDGMENTS OF CONVICTION AND SENTENCES 5 2/10/2017 ORDER ON FEBRUARY 9, 2017 STATUS HEARING, 113 - 114 SIGNED BY MICHELLE SISCO ON 02/10/17 6 3/13/2017 AMENDED SUCCESSIVE MOTION TO VACATE 115 - 201 JUDGMENTS OF CONVICTION AND SENTENCE OF DEATH 7 3/13/2017 MOTION TO EXCEED PAGE LIMITATION 202 - 203 8 3/28/2017 ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO EXCEED PAGE 204 - 206 LIMITATION, SIGNED BY MICHELLE SISCO ON 03/27/17 9 4/3/2017 STATE'S RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT'S 207 - 229 SUPPLEMENTAL SUCCESSIVE MOTION TO VACATE JUDGMENTS OF CONVICTION AND SENTENCES 10 4/11/2017 MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND SUCCESSIVE MOTION 230 -
    [Show full text]
  • JOHN MAREK, Appellant, V. STATE OF
    IN THE SUPREME COURT OF FLORIDA CASE NO. SC09-____ JOHN MAREK, Appellant, v . STATE OF FLORIDA, Appellee. ON APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE SEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN AND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, STATE OF FLORIDA INITIAL BRIEF OF APPELLANT MARTIN J. MCCLAIN Florida Bar No. 0754773 McClain & McDermott, P.A. Attorneys at Law 141 N.E. 30th Street Wilton Manors, FL 33334 (305) 984-8344 COUNSEL FOR APPELLANT PRELIMINARY STATEMENT This proceeding involves the appeal of the circuit court's summary denial of post-conviction relief. The following symbols will be used to designate references to the record in this appeal: “R." -- record on direct appeal; “1PC-R.” -- record on first Rule 3.850 appeal; “1PC-T.” -- hearing transcripts on prior Rule 3.850 appeal; “2PC-R." -- record on second 3.851 appeal; “2PC-T.” -- hearing transcripts on instant Rule 3.850 appeal; “Supp. 2PC-R.” -- supplemental record on instant 3.850 appeal; “3PC-R.” –- record on instant 3.851 appeal; “WR.” -- record from the trial of Wigley, Mr. Marek’s co- defendant. i REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT Mr. Marek has been sentenced to death. The resolution of the issues involved in this action will therefore determine whether he lives or dies. This Court has not hesitated to allow oral argument in other capital cases in a similar procedural posture. Lightbourne v. State, 742 So. 2d 238 (Fla. 1999); Mills v. Moore, 786 So. 2d 532 (Fla. 2001) Swafford v. State, 828 So. 2d 966 (Fla. 2002); Roberts v. State, 840 So. 2d 962 (Fla. 2002); Wright v.
    [Show full text]
  • Rece Ived Florida Supreme Court 09/14/2017
    IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA GEORGE MICHAEL HODGES DEFENDANT/APPELLANT CASE NO. 89-CF-002165-A VS. STATE OF FLORIDA PLAINTIFF/APPELLEE APPELLATE CASE NO: SC17-1586 APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT, CRIMINAL DIVISION, OF THE THIRTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA, IN AND FOR HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY THE HONORABLE MICHELLE SISCO JUDGE OF CIRCUIT COURT CRIMINAL DIVISION LINDA MCDERMOTT, ESQ. ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL 20301 GRANDE OAK BLVD. CONCOURSE CENTER NO. 4 SUITE 118-61 3507 E FRONTAGE ROAD, STE 200 ESTERO, FLORIDA 33928 TAMPA, FLORIDA 33607 ATTORNEY FOR APPELLANT ATTORNEY FOR APPELLEE MASTER INDEX INDEX TO THE ORIGINAL RECORD ON APPEAL ITEM FILE DATE INSTRUMENT PAGE 89-CF-002165-A 1 9/14/2017 APPEAL CASE SUMMARY 1 - 43 2 12/14/2016 SUCCESSIVE MOTION TO VACATE DEATH SENTENCE 44 - 79 PURSUANT TO FLA RULE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE 3.851 3 12/14/2016 MOTION TO EXTEND PAGE LIMITATION 80 - 81 4 12/14/2016 NOTICE OF FILING ATTACHMENT TO SUCCESSIVE 82 - 87 RULE 3.851 MOTION 5 3/1/2017 AMENDED SUCCESSIVE MOTION TO VACATE DEATH 88 - 128 SENTENCE PURSUANT TO FLA RUE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE 3.851 6 3/28/2017 STATE'S ANSWER TO DEFENDANT'S AMENDED 129 - 146 SUCCESSIVE MOTION FOR POSTCONVICTION RELIEF 7 4/18/2017 MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND PENDING AMENDED 147 - 152 SUCCESSIVE MOTION TO VACATE DEATH SENTENCE, PURSUANT TO FLA RULE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE 3.851 8 4/27/2017 ORDER ON APRIL 26, 2017 CASE MANAGEMENT 153 - 155 CONFERENCE, SIGNED BY MICHELLE SISCO ON 04/27/17 NUNC PRO TUNC 04/26/17 9 5/8/2017 SECOND AMENDED SUCCESSIVE MOTION
    [Show full text]
  • The Staying Power of Death Penalty Rituals - Last Meals and Beyond
    Eastern Kentucky University Encompass Online Theses and Dissertations Student Scholarship January 2013 Revulsion and Palatability: The tS aying Power of Death Penalty Rituals - Last Meals and Beyond Angie Wheaton Eastern Kentucky University Follow this and additional works at: https://encompass.eku.edu/etd Part of the Criminology and Criminal Justice Commons Recommended Citation Wheaton, Angie, "Revulsion and Palatability: The tS aying Power of Death Penalty Rituals - Last Meals and Beyond" (2013). Online Theses and Dissertations. 147. https://encompass.eku.edu/etd/147 This Open Access Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Student Scholarship at Encompass. It has been accepted for inclusion in Online Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Encompass. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Revulsion and Palatability: The Staying Power of Death Penalty Rituals - Last Meals and Beyond By Angie Wheaton Bachelor of Science Eastern Kentucky University Richmond, Kentucky 2013 Submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School of Eastern Kentucky University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF SCIENCE August, 2013 Copyright © Angie Wheaton, 2013 All rights reserved ii DEDICATION This thesis is dedicated to Joshua Wheaton for being my inspiration, the fuel to my fire, and helping me realize that the only way to proceed is aim for the stars and never look back. iii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would like to thank my thesis chair, Dr. Kevin Minor, for his guidance and support in all things academic and life. I would also like to thank the other committee members, Dr. Judah Schept and Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • Supreme Court of Tennessee at JACKSON ______
    No. W2009-01255-SC-DDT-DD IN THE Supreme Court of Tennessee AT JACKSON _____________ STATE OF TENNESSEE, Appellee, vs. CORINIO PRUITT, Appellant. _____________ APPEAL FROM COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TENNESSEE AT JACKSON NO. W2009-01255-CCA-R3-DD CRIMINAL COURT FOR SHELBY COUNTY NO. 06-00460 _____________ BRIEF OF AMICI CURIAE TENNESSEE ASSOCIATION OF CRIMINAL DEFENSE LAWYERS, AND THE CONSTITUTION PROJECT _____________ RUSSELL CASS ERIC G. OSBORNE* (BPR # 029719) DANIEL GREENFIELD SEEMA KAKAD JAIN SIDLEY AUSTIN LLP SIDLEY AUSTIN LLP One South Dearborn 1501 K Street, N.W. Chicago, IL 60603 Washington, D.C. 20005 (312) 853-7000 (202) 736-8000 Counsel for Amici Curiae March 4, 2013 * Counsel of Record (Additional Counsel Listed on Inside Cover) LA1 2659112v.9 MARY SCHMID MERGLER COLLIN P. WEDEL THE CONSTITUTION PROJECT SIDLEY AUSTIN LLP 1200 18th Street, N.W. 555 W. Fifth Street Suite 1000 Suite 4000 Washington, D.C. 20036 Los Angeles, CA 90013 (202) 580-6920 (213) 896-6600 WADE V. DAVIES (BPR #016052) ROB MCKINNEY (BPR #016807) RITCHIE, DILLARD, DAVIES & Attorney at Law JOHNSON, P.C. 214 2nd Avenue North 606 W. Main Street Suite 103 Suite 300 Nashville, TN 37201 Knoxville, TN 37902 (615) 686-2115 (865) 637-0661 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page TABLE OF AUTHORITIESError! Bookmark not defined. INTEREST OF THE AMICI CURIAE .............................. xi STATEMENT OF ISSUE .................................................... 1 STATEMENT OF THE CASE ............................................ 1 SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT ............................................. 2 ARGUMENT ........................................................................ 5 I. Imposing a Death Sentence on a Defendant Who Never Formed the Intent to Kill Violates the Proportionality Principle of the Federal and Tennessee Constitutions Because of Its Exceeding Rarity.
    [Show full text]