Late Minoan IB at Kommos: a Sequence of at Least Three Distinct Stages Jeremy B
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
LM IB pottery relative chronology and regional differences Acts of a workshop held at the Danish Institute at Athens in collaboration with the INSTAP Study Center for East Crete, 27–29 June 2007 Edited by Thomas M. Brogan & Erik Hallager Monographs of the Danish Institute at Athens Volume 11, 1 3 © Copyright The Danish Institute at Athens, Athens 2011 LM IB pottery – relative chronology and regional differences Monographs of the Danish Institute at Athens Volume 11, 1 General Editor: Rune Fredriksen and Erik Hallager Graphic design: Erik Hallager Printed at Narayana Press Printed in Denmark on permanent paper conforming to ANSI Z 39.48–1992 The publication was sponsored by: The Carlsberg Foundation The Institute for Aegean Prehistory ISBN: 978 87 7934 573 7 Distributed by: AARHUS UNIVERSITY PRESS Langelandsgade 177 DK–8200 Århus N www.unipress.dk Gazelle Book Services Ltd. White Cross Mills, Hightown Lancaster LA1 4XS, England www.gazellebooks.com The David Brown Book Company (DBBC) P.O. Box 511 Oakville, CT. 06779, USA www.davidbrownbookco.uk Cover illustration: Double vase from the Royal Road: North at Knossos 4 Contents Volume 1 8 List of contributors 11 Preface Erik Hallager & Thomas M. Brogan 13 Bibliography 39 Introduction Thomas M. Brogan 55 LM IB pottery in Khania Maria Andreadaki-Vlazaki 75 From LM IB Marine Style to LM II marine motifs. Stratigraphy, chronology and the social context of a ceramic transformation: a response to Maria Andreadaki-Vlazaki Eleni Hatzaki 93 The LM I pottery from the ceramic workshop at Zominthos Sebastian Traunmueller 109 Response to Sebastian Traunmueller Nicola Cucuzza 117 LM IB pottery from the colonies. Hagios Georgios sto Vouno, Kythera Iphigenia Tournavitou 141 Kythera, the Levant, Myrtos-Pyrgos and Knossos: a response to Iphigenia Tournavitou Gerald Cadogan 153 Knossos Royal Road: North, LM IB deposits Sinclair Hood 175 Response to Sinclair Hood Birgitta P. Hallager 183 Late Minoan IB pottery from Knossos: Stratigraphical Museum Excavations, the North Building Peter M. Warren 197 The final LM IB destructions at Knossos and at Phaistos: a response to Peter Warren Orazio Palio 205 LM I pottery groups from the Palace and the town of Galatas, Pediada Giorgos Rethemiotakis & Kostis S. Christakis 5 229 Response to Giorgos Rethemiotakis & Kostis Christakis Tim Cunningham 241 Pithoi and economy in LM IB state societies Kostis S. Christakis 255 Remarks on storage and chronology in Late Cycladic I Akrotiri, Thera: a response to Kostis Christakis Irene Nikolakopoulou 267 From the end of LM IA to the end of LM IB: the pottery evidence from Hagia Triada Dario Puglisi 291 Makrygialos reloaded: the LM IB pottery: a response to Dario Puglisi Eleni Mantzourani 307 Late Minoan IB at Kommos: a sequence of at least three distinct stages Jeremy B. Rutter Volume 2 345 LM IB pottery from the rural Villa of Pitsidia: a response to Jeremy Rutter Despina Chatzi-Vallianou 379 Pottery from the LM IB building at Skinias Stella Mandalaki 393 Time, place and practice in the East Mesara: the case of Skinias. A response to Stella Mandalaki Carl Knappett 401 Pottery at Pseira in LM IB Philip P. Betancourt 413 Response to Philip P. Betancourt Penelope Mountjoy 427 Pottery of the late Neopalatial periods at Mochlos Kellee A. Barnard & Thomas M. Brogan 451 LM IB phases at Mochlos and the single phase of LM IB at Knossos: a response to Kellee Barnard & Thomas Brogan Colin F. Macdonald 463 LM IB Petras: the pottery from Room E in House II.1 Metaxia Tsipopoulou & Maria Emanuela Alberti 499 An introduction to the LM IB pottery from Poros: a response to Metaxia Tsipopoulou and Emanuela Alberti Eleni S. Banou 6 513 The LM IB Renaissance at postdiluvian Pre-Mycenaean Palaikastro Seán Hemingway, J. Alexander MacGillivray & L. Hugh Sackett 531 LM IB ceramic phases at Palaikastro and Malia: a response to Seán Hemingway, J. Alexander MacGillivray & L. Hugh Sackett Aleydis Van de Moortel 553 Between Palaikastro and Zakros: the pottery from the final Neopalatial horizon of the Sea Guard- House, Karoumes Leonidas Vokotopoulos 573 The LM IB pottery from Papadiokampos: a response to Leonidas Vokotopoulos Thomas M. Brogan, Chrysa Sofianou & Jerolyn E. Morrison 595 Zakros: one or two destructions around the end of the LM IB period Lefteris Platon 613 A West Cretan response (Nerokourou) to Lefteris Platon and the LM IB pottery from Zakros Athanasia Kanta 627 Closing comments Wolf-Dietrich Niemeier 629 General Discussion 647 Shape illustration index Thomas M. Brogan 650 Index 7 List of contributors Maria Emanuela Alberti Thomas M. Brogan Birgitta P. Hallager University of Udine, Italy INSTAP Study Center for East Greek-Swedish Excavations correspondence to: Crete c/o Danish Institute at Athens Via Anapo 29 Pacheia Ammos Herefondos 14 I-00199 Roma GR-72200 Ierapetra GR-10558 Athens Italy Greece Greece [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Maria Andreadaki-Vlazaki Gerald Cadogan Erik Hallager General Director of Antiquities The Old Rectory Danish Institute at Athens Hellenic Ministry of Culture and Culworth Herefondos 14 Tourism Banbury OX17 2AT GR-10558 Athens Bouboulinas 20–22 England Greece GR-106 82 Athens [email protected] [email protected] Greece [email protected] Despina Chatzi-Vallianou Eleni Hatzaki Museum of Cretan Ethnology Asst. Professor of Mediterranean Eleni Banou Researche Centre – Vori – Archaeology Director of the Department of GR-70200 Tympaki, Crete Department of Classics Sites at the Greece University of Cincinnati Second Ephorate of Prehistoric [email protected] P.O. Box 210226 and Classical Antiquities Cincinnati OH 45221–0226 Sygrou Ave. 98–100 Kostis S. Christakis USA GR-11741 Athens University of Crete [email protected] Greece Department of Education [email protected] Rethimnon, Crete Seán Hemingway Greece Associate Curator Kellee A. Barnard [email protected] Department of Greek and Roman Classics Department Art McCormack 4/649 Nicola Cucuzza The Metropolitan Museum of Art University of Massachusetts Università di Genova 1000 Fifth Avenue Boston, MA 02125 Dipartimento di Archeologia e New York, New York 10028–0198 USA Filologia Classica USA [email protected] via Balbi, 4 [email protected] I-16126 Genova Philip P. Betancourt Italy Sinclair Hood Department of Art History [email protected] The Old Vicarage, Tyler School of Art Building Great Milton, Oxford, Temple University Tim Cunningham OX44 7PB, Philadelphia, PA 19122 Département d’Archaéologie U.K. USA Université Catholique de Louvain [email protected] Place B. Pascal 1 B-1348 Louvain-la-Neuve Belgium [email protected] 8 Athanasia Kanta Penelope Mountjoy Giorgos Rethemiotakis 23rd Ephorate of Prehistoric and British School at Athens Director Classical Antiquities Souidias 52 The Archaeological Museum Xanthoudidou & Hadjidaki 1 GR-10676 Athens Xanthoudidou 1 GR-712 02 Heraklion Greece GR-712 02 Heraklion Greece Greece [email protected] Irene Nikolakopoulou [email protected] Archaeological Institute of Aegean Carl Knappett Studies Jeremy B. Rutter Walter Graham/Homer Thompson Plateia Megalou Alexandrou Department of Classics Chair in Aegean Prehistory, GR-85100 Rhodes Dartmouth College Department of Art, Greece Hanover, New Hampshire 03755– University of Toronto, [email protected] 3506 Canada U.S.A. [email protected] Wolf-Dietrich Niemeier [email protected] Deutsches Archäologisches Institut Colin Macdonald Athen L. Hugh Sackett British School at Athens Fidiou 1 Co-director Palaikastro Excavations Souidias 52 GR-10678 Athens British School at Athens, GR-10676 Athens Greece 52 Souidias Greece [email protected] GR-106 76 Athens [email protected] Greece Orazio Palio [email protected] J. Alexander MacGillivray Dipartimento Processi Formativi Co-director Palaikastro Excavations Università di Catania Iphigenia Tournavitou of the British School at Athens Via Biblioteca 4 Associate Professor Ampelonon 50 I-95124 Catania Department of History, GR-19002 Paiania Italy Archaeology and Social Greece [email protected] Anthropology [email protected] University of Thessaly Lefteris Platon Argonafton & Filellinon St. Stella Mandalaki Department of History and GR-382 21 Volos 23rd Ephorate of Prehistoric and Archaeology Greece Classical Antiquities University of Athens [email protected] Xanthoudidou & Hadjidaki 1 School of Philosophy [email protected] GR-712 02 Heraklion University Campus, Zographou Greece GR-15784 Athens Sebastian Traunmueller [email protected] Greece Institut für Klassische Archäologie [email protected] Ruprecht-Karls-Universität Eleni Mantzourani Heidelberg Professor of Prehistoric Dario Puglisi Marstallhof 4 Archaeology Università di Catania DE-69117 Heidelberg Dept. of History and Archaeology Dipartimento SAFIST Germany School of Philosophy via Biblioteca 4 (Palazzo Ingrassia) sebastian.traunmueller@ University of Athens I-95124, Catania googlemail.com University Campus, Zographou Italy GR-15784 Athens [email protected] Greece [email protected] 9 Metaxia Tsipopoulou Aleydis Van de Moortel Peter M. Warren Hellenic Ministry of Culture and Department of Classics Professor Emeritus Tourism University of Tennessee Dept of Archaeology and Director Knoxville, TN 37996 Anthropology, Directorate of the National U.S.A. University of Bristol, Archive of Monuments [email protected] 43 Woodland Road, 11, Agion Asomaton Street BRISTOL BS8 1UU GR-105 53 Athens Leonidas Vokotopoulos UK Greece Aghias Varvaras 32 [email protected]