Tracing Software Developers' Eyes and Interactions for Change Tasks
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
Tracing Software Developers’ Eyes and Interactions for Change Tasks Katja Kevic†, Braden M. Walters*, Timothy R. Shaffer*, Bonita Sharif*, David C. Shepherd‡, Thomas Fritz† †University of Zurich, Switzerland *Youngstown State University, USA ‡ABB Corporate Research, USA Department of Informatics Department of CS and IS Industrial Software Systems {kevic,fritz}@ifi.uzh.ch {bmwalters01,trshaffer}@student.ysu.edu [email protected] [email protected] ABSTRACT In order to successfully complete these tasks, they have to What are software developers doing during a change task? read, navigate and edit the relevant pieces of code [22, 16]. While an answer to this question opens countless opportuni- Since the inception of software development, researchers have ties to support developers in their work, only little is known been studying how developers read and navigate code, and about developers' detailed navigation behavior for realistic what kind of knowledge they acquire (e.g., [43, 5, 22]). The change tasks. Most empirical studies on developers perform- more we know about a developer's work, the better we are ing change tasks are limited to very small code snippets or are able to support her, for instance, by reducing information limited by the granularity or the detail of the data collected overload [21], improving defect prediction [24], or providing for the study. In our research, we try to overcome these automatic navigation recommendations [13, 29]. limitations by combining user interaction monitoring with Yet relatively few studies have been undertaken to investi- very fine granular eye-tracking data that is automatically gate detailed navigation behavior of developers for realistic linked to the underlying source code entities in the IDE. change tasks. The lack of realistic studies is due to the In a study with 12 professional and 10 student developers significant challenges and effort of acquiring the time of working on three change tasks from an open source system, professional software developers to participate as well as of we used our approach to investigate the detailed navigation capturing, transcribing and coding longer sessions of devel- of developers for realistic change tasks. The results of our opers' work on change tasks. More recently, approaches have study show, amongst others, that the eye-tracking data does been developed to automatically capture more data from indeed capture different aspects than user interaction data a developer's interactions with source code elements in an and that developers focus on only small parts of methods integrated development environment (IDE) [2, 21]. These that are often related by data flow. We discuss our findings approaches capture source code elements mostly on the class and their implications for better developer tool support. and method level and are based on explicit user interactions with the mouse or keyboard. Categories and Subject Descriptors Recent advances in technology afford new opportunities to collect a wide variety of more detailed information on a D.2.7 [Software Engineering]: Distribution, Maintenance, software developer and her work. Studies with sensors for and Enhancement tracking biometric features, such as eye gaze, have generated General Terms new insights on developers' work on small code tasks, such as perceptions of difficulty [15], brain activation patterns [42], Human Factors, Experimentation the scanning patterns of code [36] or the ease of compre- Keywords hending different representations of code [40, 6]. Most of these studies focus on very small code comprehension tasks eye-tracking, gaze, change task, user study with a single method or class, in particular, since they re- 1. INTRODUCTION quire manual linking between the gaze data collected with an eye-tracker and the source code elements a developer looked Software developers spend a majority of their time working at. on change tasks, such as bug fixes or feature additions [25]. While these studies provide valuable first insights, the advances in technology open up the opportunity to address further important research questions, such as, what is a de- veloper's fine-grained navigation behavior for realistic change Permission to make digital or hard copies of all or part of this work for personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are tasks, what is the difference in the data captured through not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies eye-tracking and interaction logging and how can we use bear this notice and the full citation on the first page. To copy otherwise, to eye-tracking data to support developers. Answering these republish, to post on servers or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific questions will allow us to better understand developers' com- permission and/or a fee. prehension of large code bases and to develop better and FSE ’15 more fine-granular tool support for developers. Copyright 20XX ACM X-XXXXX-XX-X/XX/XX ...$15.00. In our research, we take advantage of the opportunities developers' actions. Altmann, for instance, analyzed a ten that eye-tracking provides, and extend previous research minute interval of an expert programmer performing a task by addressing some of these questions by focusing on more and used computational simulation to study the near-term realistic change tasks to investigate how developers read memory [5]. Perhaps one of the most well-known user studies and navigate through code while working. In particular, we from this category is the study by Ko et al. [22]. In this study, are examining how eye-tracking data differs from the data the authors screen captured ten developers' desktops while captured by monitoring user interactions in an IDE, how they worked on five tasks on a toy-sized program and then developers' eyes move within and between methods, and how hand-coded and analyzed each 70 minute session. In a study these newly gained insights can be used to better support on developers performing more realistic change tasks, Fritz developers in their work on change tasks. We developed et al. [16] used a similar technique and manually transcribed an approach to automatically link eye-tracking data to the and coded the screen captured videos of all participants. source code elements in the IDE, which combines the ease While all of these studies are a valuable source of learning of automatically collecting data in an IDE with the finer and led to interesting findings, the cost of hand-coding a granularity of eye-tracking data. Our approach also supports developers' actions is very high, which led to only a limited the scrolling and switching of code editor windows by de- number of studies providing detailed insights on a developers' velopers and thus allows for change task investigations on behavior. a realistic-sized code base and is not limited to very small tasks as most previous studies are. This new approach for User Interaction Monitoring. conducting user studies in software development provides More recently, approaches have been developed to auto- the potential to reduce the cost of generating detailed, rich matically capture user interaction data within an IDE, such user data and valuable insights in developers' navigation as Mylyn [2, 20, 21]. Based on such automatically captured behavior. interaction histories|logs of the code elements a developer We conducted a study with 22 participants, 12 professional interacted with along with a timestamp|researchers have, developers and 10 students, working on three realistic change for instance, investigated how developers work in an IDE [27], tasks for a total of 60 minutes while automatically tracing how they navigate through code [28, 29, 47], or how devel- their eye gazes and their explicit user interactions in the code opers' micro interaction patterns might be used for defect editor of the Eclipse IDE. Our analysis of the gathered data prediction [24]. Even the Eclipse team themselves under- shows, amongst other results, that eye-tracking captures took a major data collection project called the Usage Data substantially different data than a developer's navigation Collector that, at its peak, collected data from thousands within the IDE, that developers only look at a few lines of a of developers using Eclipse. Overall, the automatic moni- method when working on a change task and that these lines toring of user interactions was able to significantly reduce are often related to the data flow of variables within these the cost for certain empirical studies. However, these studies methods. These results also provide evidence for the value are limited to the granularity and detail of the monitoring of combining eye-tracking with interaction monitoring in an approach. In case of user interaction monitoring, the gran- IDE in the future. ularity is predominately the method or class file level and This paper makes the following contributions: detailed information, such as the time a developer spends ● Study findings based on eye-tracking and user interac- reading a code element or when the developer is not looking tion monitoring that provide insights into the detailed at the screen, is missing and makes it more difficult to fully navigation behavior of 22 developers working on realis- understand the developers' traces. tic change tasks. Biometric Sensing. ● An approach to automatically and on-the-fly capture In parallel to the IDE instrumentation efforts, researchers the fine-grained source code elements a developer looks in the software development domain have also started to at in an IDE while working with large files, thereby take advantage of the maturing of biometric sensors. Most significantly improving current state-of-the-art that of this research focuses on eye-tracking [31, 19], while only limits eye tracking studies to only single methods. few studies have been conducted so far that also use other ● A discussion on the value of the data gathered and the signals, such as an fMRI to identify brain activation patterns opportunities the data and the findings offer for better for small comprehension tasks [42], or a combination of developer support.