Top 10 Reasons for a Webpage to Fail the HTML Validator

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Top 10 Reasons for a Webpage to Fail the HTML Validator An Experimental Study on Validation Problems with Existing HTML Webpages Shan Chen Dan Hong Vincent Y. Shen Department of Computer Science Hong Kong University of Science and Technology Clear Water Bay, Kowloon Hong Kong, China {chenshan, csdhong, shen}@cs.ust.hk Abstract average size of a website, and so on [7] [8]. Our concern is about In this paper we report the results of an experimental study on the the quality of the HTML documents in today’s webpages in terms validation problem of existing HTML pages in the World Wide of conformance to public standards. Web. We have found that only about 5% of webpages are “valid” The HTML is actually an extensible computer language used to according to the HTML standard. An “invalid” webpage may be instruct the browser on how to render a webpage, which may rendered differently by different browsers; it may not be machine- contain text, images, links, and multimedia contents. To gain a processable; it might not be translated into other Web document competitive advantage in the “browser battle” each tool vendor formats correctly using some of the translation engines available tried to introduce features that would distinguish its own products. on the Web; etc. Through sampling and analyzing the results, we With these new features, webpage designers could easily create have identified the most common problems in existing webpages exciting webpages, and browser users could enjoy these pages with that made them invalid. We hope our discovery can encourage a brand-new experience. Unfortunately, features introduced by one standard bodies, browser developers, authoring tool developers, particular vendor might not be recognized by the browser from and webpage designers to work together so that the number of another vendor. To create some order in a chaotic situation, the valid webpages continues to grow and the Web can indeed reach World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) released the HTML (Hyper- its full potential. Text Markup Language) Recommendation in 1995 for resolving interoperability concerns for browsers from different vendors [12]. Categories and Subject Descriptors Using the “elements” and “attributes” defined in the HTML H.5.2 [Information Interfaces and Presentation]: User Recommendation, browsers parse the HTML document, analyze Interfaces - Standardization. I.7.5 [Document and Text the tags and render them (hopefully) as the webpage designer has Processing]: Document Capture - Document analysis. intended. This “Recommendation” has become the de facto “standard” in the Web community. General Terms The HTML documents that follow the standard or the “valid” Experimentation, Verification HTML files have a higher chance to be rendered consistently by different browsers and across different platforms than those that do not. An invalid HTML file may not be treated the same way. All Keywords the major browser vendors claim to handle valid HTML files HTML Specification, HTML Validator, HTML tidy tools, W3C, correctly. It makes good sense for the developer of a new website webpage characteristics, Web Sampling. to start with the standard and follow it through later revisions. 1. Introduction In addition to possible different appearances when rendered, invalid HTML files could be less accessible than valid ones. For Invented in the early 1990’s, the World Wide Web is now one of example, the standard defines a required attribute “alt” in the primary media through which people publish and obtain element “IMG” where “alt” provides some textual information information. As one of the most popular applications on the about the image. If the browser does not support images, the value Internet, the number of webpages continues to grow rapidly. In of the “ ” attribute is displayed instead. The textual information 1999, there were 800 million webpages in the world [7], and alt can also be read out by a screen reader to assist the vision- according to Internet Domain Survey of the Internet Systems impaired user who cannot see the image clearly. An invalid Consortium [6], there were already more than 233 million domains webpage missing the “ ” attribute may not be accessible by by the end of January 2004. alt certain users. The importance of the Web attracted many researchers to study its The Web has now become a large resource of information. More properties. People are interested in the average size of an HTML and more people use the computer to extract relevant information document, the average number of images in a webpage, the from the Web for their applications. An invalid HTML file often causes difficulties for the application in understanding the intended structure of the file. Information contained in such files may not be Copyright is held by the authors. available to these applications, defeating the purpose of pub- WWW 2005, May 10--14, 2005, Chiba, Japan. licizing them on the Web. For example, the input interface of a Web application is usually presented as a “FORM” element in the about 40,000 webpages, “crawled” the Web to measure it, and HTML file and the element “TABLE” is widely used to control the obtained some statistics on the size of the Web, its connectivity, layout of the page. Consequently webpage designers often use richness, and the distribution of URL links. Bharat and Broder [3] “FORM” and “TABLE” together to provide interactivity as well as suggested a methodology for finding a page at random from a to control the layout. However, if the webpage designer does not search engine index in 1998. Their approach was based on queries understand the HTML language well, it is easy to commit errors to the search engine using random words. In 1999 Lawrence and while using “FORM” with “TABLE”. Such errors may prevent the Giles [7] used randomly-generated IP addresses to estimate the interactive page to be machine-processable. information available on the Web, such as the characteristics of the hosts and pages. In 2000 Henzinger, Heydon, Mitzenmacher, and To assist webpage designers, several organizations have developed Najork [5] suggested performing a random walk of the Web using “validators” to check if a webpage conforms to the HTML multiple search engines to extract representative samples of standard. These validators can be used to analyze a webpage (for webpages. example, the W3C markup services [14] and the WDG validator [16]), or to analyze a whole website (for example, the CSE HTML In this paper, we adopted the methodology of using randomly- Validator [1]). There are also a number of HTML “tidy” tools generated IP addresses as samples due to its simplicity. We further which can be used to tidy up an HTML document by correcting compared our test results using this Random IP List with the result most of the errors in it [10]. However these tools are often not using the Most Popular 10000 Websites List made available to us powerful enough to correct all errors; sometimes the appearance of by Alexa.com as additional supporting evidence. Note that both a webpage is altered after being tidied up. Proofreading the lists enabled us to analyze the properties of only the home pages of resulting document after processing by a tidy tool could be a the selected websites. Although problems with the homepage may challenge to the webpage designers. be indicative of the problems of other webpages accessible in that website, we created yet another URL List using search engines to We wish to find out the proportion of current webpages that are confirm our findings. We repeated the test using the Second valid HTML documents, and the most common problems that Random IP List in two months to see if there is any change of cause a document to become invalid. This issue was of interest to results over time. The details of the lists are described below. the Web Design Group; they identified six “common” problems [15] by inviting comments from other validator users. However, there was no indication how serious each problem was, and there 2.1 Sample Lists was also no report on the methodology used by various individuals 2.1.1 Random IP List in identifying these problems. It is difficult to draw quantitative We developed a program to randomly generate an IPv4 address. conclusions from these experiential results. To really understand By setting up an HTTP connection to this IP address at port 80, how serious the validity problem on the Web is today, and to study which is the default port for HTTP connections, and listening to the statistics of validation problems, we performed an the response, we would know whether it was a Web server at this experimental study by sampling the existing webpages, using a IP address. If it was indeed a Web server, we added it to the list. validator to check them, and analyzing the results. Our study shows that only about 5% of webpages are “valid”. We also We encountered some difficulties using this approach. Since most identified the major validation problems in existing HTML IP addresses were addresses for online computers which were not webpages. We hope our findings will alert the webpage designers Web servers, most of our probes would time out. After a short of the validity problem, and will help them to identify the most while our service provider received complaints about our activities common errors which they should try to avoid. We hope our since our probes were considered hacker’s probes by some findings will also alert the Web application developers so that they organizations. We had to stop the collection process after could handle the common errors properly in order to provide better obtaining a list of only about 1,100 IP addresses. service. We also hope our findings are useful to the standard bodies and the authoring tool vendors.
Recommended publications
  • JTS Users Guide, Ver 2.0 Copyright 2013 Page 2 of 265
    Table of Contents 1 ABOUT THIS GUIDE .................................................................................................................... 13 1.1 WHO SHOULD USE IT ............................................................................................................... 14 1.2 TYPOGRAPHICAL CONVENTIONS ............................................................................................... 14 2 INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................................... 16 2.1 OVERVIEW ............................................................................................................................... 16 2.2 PURPOSE ................................................................................................................................ 17 2.3 SCOPE .................................................................................................................................... 17 2.4 REFERENCES .......................................................................................................................... 18 2.5 GLOSSARY AND TERMINOLOGY ................................................................................................. 18 3 JTS SYSTEM DESCRIPTION ...................................................................................................... 21 3.1 KEY FEATURES ........................................................................................................................ 21 3.2 ENVIRONMENT ........................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • VISA/APCO/STAC 2P61 WEBSITE CREATION Fall Term 2012 ______
    VISA/APCO/STAC 2P61 WEBSITE CREATION Fall Term 2012 __________________________________________________________________________________ GETTING STARTED WITH XHTML AND CSS Do you have the book recommended for this course? HTML and CSS Web Standards Solutions A Web Standardistasʼ Approach Christopher Murphy and Nicklas Persson If you donʼt have the recommended book please find another. You will need something to refer to. If not the book…here are some websites where you can find good tutorials for writing standards based XHTML and CSS http://www.w3.org/MarkUp/Guide/ http://www.w3.org/MarkUp/2004/xhtml-faq http://www.htmldog.com http://xhtml.com/en/xhtml/reference/ http://www.webheadstart.org/xhtml/basics/index.html http://daringfireball.net/projects/markdown/ http://www.alistapart.com/ HTML Hypertext markup language Create with range of tools – plain text editor (with formatting turned off) Will be read by variety of devices Designed to be read by web browsers Non proprietary Open source Free Structures text to hyperlinks W3C 1995 first specs written. Current is 4.0 written in 1999 (HTML 5 in the works) XHTML XML (no defined tags like HTML – has defined structure) Extensive Markup Language Is HTML reformatted in XML HTML with strict rules of XML Varieties of XHTML – 1.0 Strict, (we use this one) 1.0 Transitional, 1.0 Frameset 1 The value of Standards • Avoid (as much as possible) sites that wonʼt display as written • More accessible sites • XHTML and CSS written to strict standards • Enables site to perform predictably on any standards compliant browser or OS • Improves Development time • Ease of updating • Search engine ranking XHTML/CSS Separates Content from Visual presentation/design Avoids Tag Soup of HTML where tags were used to control both how content is structured and how it looks.
    [Show full text]
  • Site Development Associate Student Guide Web Foundations Series CCL02-CFSDFN-PR-1405 • Version 2.1 • Rd060214
    Site Development Associate Student Guide Web Foundations Series CCL02-CFSDFN-PR-1405 • version 2.1 • rd060214 EVALUATION COPY EVALUATION COPY Site Development Associate Student Guide EVALUATION COPY Chief Executive Officer Barry Fingerhut Vice President, Operations & Development Todd Hopkins Senior Content Developer Kenneth A. Kozakis Managing Editor Susan M. Lane Editor Sarah Skodak Project Manager/Publisher Tina Strong Customer Service Certification Partners, LLC 1230 W. Washington St., Ste. 201 Tempe, AZ 85281 (602) 275-7700 Copyright © 2014, All rights reserved. EVALUATION COPY Site Development Associate Developer Patrick T. Lane Contributors DeAnne Bowersock, James Stanger, Ph.D., and Kenneth A. Kozakis Editor Sarah Skodak Project Manager/Publisher Tina Strong Trademarks Certification Partners is a trademark of Certification Partners, LLC. All product names and services identified throughout this book are trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective companies. They are used throughout this book in editorial fashion only. No such use, or the use of any trade name, is intended to convey endorsement or other affiliation with the book. Copyrights of any screen captures in this book are the property of the software's manufacturer. Disclaimer Certification Partners, LLC, makes a genuine attempt to ensure the accuracy and quality of the content described herein; however, Certification Partners makes no warranty, express or implied, with respect to the quality, reliability, accuracy, or freedom from error of this document or the products it describes. Certification Partners makes no representation or warranty with respect to the contents hereof and specifically disclaims any implied warranties of fitness for any particular purpose. Certification Partners disclaims all liability for any direct, indirect, incidental or consequential, special or exemplary damages resulting from the use of the information in this document or from the use of any products described in this document.
    [Show full text]
  • Web Design in Nvu Workbook 2 Web Design in Nvu
    Inspiring | Creative | Fun Ysbrydoledig | Creadigol | Hwyl Web Design in Nvu Workbook 2 Web Design in Nvu CSS stands for ”Cascading Style Sheets”, these allow you to specify the look and feel of your website. It also helps with consistency. Style sheets have actually been around for years, they are technical specifications for a layout, whether print or online. Print designers use style sheets to ensure that designs are printed exactly to specifications. “Cascading” is the special part. A web style sheet is intended to “cascade” through a series of style sheets, like a river or waterfall. 1) CSS Go to www.csszengarden.com On the right of the page you will see a navigation list. Notice that when you click on options on the list, you get the same website but it looks completely diferent. This is because diferent style sheets are being used. Have a look at the following HTML: <h1> Title of your page </h1> This would be the title of your webpage. By typing this, you are letting the computer know that you want the text displayed as a header, in size 1. You can this this for each of the pages for the title and each time the computer will format it as a “h1”. In the Cascading style sheet, you can specify that you want your title to be orange on every page. This can be achieved by using the following code that tells the computer every time it sees a H1 being used, the text should be orange: h1 { color:orange; } 2) Testing and editing Go to www.w3schools.com/css/tryit.asp?filename=trycss_default Here is a webpage set up on the right and the CSS on the left, as you edit the sandbox environment in the box on the left, it will update the image on the right to see what the code translates to visually.
    [Show full text]
  • Accessibility Evaluation of Websites Using WCAG Tools and Cambridge Simulator
    Accessibility evaluation of websites using WCAG tools and Cambridge Simulator Shashank Kumar BMS College of Engineering, Bangalore, India JeevithaShree DV Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore, India Pradipta Biswas* Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore, India * Correspondence: Corresponding Author [email protected] Keywords: WCAG Guidelines, W3C, World Wide Web Consortium, Accessibility Evaluation, Cambridge Simulator, User Model, Common User Profile . Abstract There is plethora of tools available for automatic evaluation of web accessibility with respect to WCAG. This paper compares a set of WCAG tools and their results in terms of ease of comprehension and implementation by web developers. The paper highlights accessibility issues that cannot be captured only through conformance to WCAG tools and propose additional methods to evaluate accessibility through an Inclusive User Model. We initially selected ten WCAG tools from W3 website and used a set of these tools on the landing pages of BBC and WHO websites. We compared their outcome in terms of commonality, differences, amount of details and usability. Finally, we briefly introduced the Inclusive User Model and demonstrated how simulation of user interaction can capture usability and accessibility issues that are not detected through WCAG analysis. The paper concludes with a proposal on a Common User Profile format that can be used to compare and contrast accessibility systems and services, and to simulate and personalize interaction for users with different range of abilities. Accessibility evaluation using WCAG tools 1 Introduction Web accessibility is one of the most important aspects of building a website. It is an inclusive practice of ensuring that there are no barriers that prevent interaction with, or access to websites on the World Wide Web, by people with physical and situational disabilities, and socio-economic restrictions on bandwidth and speed [WWW 2020].
    [Show full text]
  • Accessibility Best Practices Plan, Develop, and Test Inclusive Design
    Accessibility Best Practices Plan, Develop, and Test Inclusive Design MOVING FORWARD TOGETHER Contents Introduction 3 Accessibility QuickStart 4 Accessibility Best Practices 11 Accessibility Testing 20 Accessibility Best Practices MOVING FORWARD TOGETHER Inclusive Design Makes Better Experiences. For Everyone. Accessibility is on your roadmap, but is it part of your daily sprint? Legal Mandates for Accessibility If you still need a reason to blow the dust off your accessibility One in four US adults with a disability strategy, then know that in 2010 the Department of Justice ruled Inclusive design makes a better product for everyone, not just that the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) also included those with impairments. There is no reason to bury accessibility to access to digital and online content. Since then, many cases the bottom of your backlog. Yes, it is often a large lift for a have gone to trial over accessibility issues. developer, but you should be planning, designing, and building for accessibility right now. In the European Union, the European Accessibility Act has already levied millions in fines against some tech companies. Inclusive Design Changes Lives Technology touches every part of our lives, and that is never There is a legal tidal wave building that will require access to going to change. For many people with disabilities, technology is apps, sites and platforms for all users. itself one more barrier. There are new, exciting developments in We’ve put this guide together to help you get started with accessibility every week, and in fact, there has never been more accessibility strategy, best practices, and testing.
    [Show full text]
  • Html Editor Composer Download
    Html editor composer download Latest stable version: (). KompoZer is free software. To keep this project running, please consider making a donation. Download KompoZer. professional-looking web site without needing to know HTML or web coding. CSS editor; A dash of style(s); Customizable toolbars; Forms; Cleaner markup ​Downloads · ​Screenshots · ​Features · ​Add-Ons. Download KompoZer for free. A wysiwyg HTML editor that uses the Mozilla Composer codebase. KompoZer is a wysiwyg HTML editor using. Both the HTML editor as well as the CSS editor has so far be fixed and Started to use this when an old computer with Netscape composer wore out and had to. Now anyone can create web pages and manage a website with no technical expertise or knowledge of HTML. Download NVU (for windows, mb) Download. HTML Date Published: 1/18/ File Size: KB. Html Editor. System Requirements. Supported Operating System. Windows XP Professional. The CoffeeCup Free HTML Editor is code editor with Built-in FTP uploading. Download the CoffeeCup Free HTML Editor Today! Note: Be sure to download Netscape and not The Netscape editor, also known as "Netscape Composer" is only included in older downloads of. Free online web content composer developed for our own web design agency. HTML source composer with instant preview and WYSIWYG editor without downloading and installing any program. One of a few derivatives of Nvu, a now-discontinued HTML editor, suite, which included Seamonkey Composer, a WYSIWYG HTML editor. My HTML Editor is BlueGriffon, an intuitive, modern and robust application. ancestors and proudly inherits from all of them: Netscape®, Mozilla® Composer and Nvu.
    [Show full text]
  • Uniform: the Form Validation Language
    Santa Clara University Scholar Commons Computer Engineering Senior Theses Engineering Senior Theses 6-9-2016 Uniform: The orF m Validation Language Sawyer Novak Santa Clara University Reid Palmquist Santa Clara University Douglas Parker Santa Clara University Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarcommons.scu.edu/cseng_senior Part of the Computer Engineering Commons Recommended Citation Novak, Sawyer; Palmquist, Reid; and Parker, Douglas, "Uniform: The orF m Validation Language" (2016). Computer Engineering Senior Theses. 72. https://scholarcommons.scu.edu/cseng_senior/72 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Engineering Senior Theses at Scholar Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Computer Engineering Senior Theses by an authorized administrator of Scholar Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Thesis Senior Design Santa Clara University Santa Clara, California Uniform: The Form Validation Language Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Bachelor of Science in Computer Science and Engineering Santa Clara University School of Engineering Authors: Sawyer Novak Reid Palmquist Douglas Parker June 9, 2016 Abstract Digital forms are becoming increasingly more prevalent but the ease of creation is not. Web Forms are difficult to produce and validate. This design project seeks to simplify this process. This project is comprised of two parts: a logical programming language (Uniform) and a web application. Uniform is a language that allows its users to define logical rela- tionships between web elements and apply simple rules to individual inputs to both validate the form and manipulate its components de- pending on user input. Uniform provides an extra layer of abstraction to complex coding.
    [Show full text]
  • Markup Languages and Their Validation As Below: ―Most Web Documents Are Written Using Markup Languages, Such As HTML Or XHTML
    1 Contents 1. Using Cherry 1.1 Getting started 1.2 Logging in 2. Site Page Hierarchy Management 2.1 Page Addition 2.2 Page Deletion 2.3 Editing Page Details 3. Page Content Modification 3.1 Page Revisions 3.2 Approving and Rejecting a Page Revision 4. Administrator Management 4.1 Listing Administrators 4.2 Adding an Administrator / Editing the Details for an Administrator 5. Appendix A 5.1 Validation 2 The Cherry Content Management System 1. Using Cherry 1.1 Getting Started Cherry is a website content management system (or ―CMS‖) that allows a site owner to update site content without knowledge of HTML, javascript or any other programming languages. The system is web-browser-based and works in all major browsers. (ie: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome, to name a few) Other features include news feed management for the site, user account creation / administration and other tools as requested1 To begin a session in the CMS, log in to your site's Administration section (or ―Admin‖ panel) by typing the site's base URL followed by ―/admin‖. For example: 1.2 Logging In After the page loads, the login panel is displayed: 1 Optional customized tools are available as add-ons. To request an estimate for customized features, please contact Corporate Zen. 3 After entering the administrator's username and password, the Cherry dashboard becomes visible. This is the first page you'll encounter every time you log in to the system. This page includes information on upcoming page edits: This particular example page has content waiting for approval.
    [Show full text]
  • Json Schema Validator Online Tool
    Json Schema Validator Online Tool Hydroxy Bartholemy sometimes subjoin his paspalums penuriously and bird so ministerially! Shep is portrayed and gully wherefrom as statutable Jule disliked inconsolably and headline rudely. Independent and monocled Micheal often alphabetise some writhes eulogistically or appraised oddly. This advanced XML editor provides the most intuitive tools for XML editing, including binding key aspects in a new File, with the same structure as described in this listing. It has a simple UI and the functionality orientation is good. Enlisted below are the Top Structured Data Testing Tools that are available in the market. Free coding exercises and quizzes cover Python basics, ini files, the errors are available on the ajv object we injected. So, transformations, we have the flexibility to add new fields with no restrictions on the permitted values. All the error details can be seen in the developer tool itself for faster fixing. Commons portion of the project or into another Apache project. JSON Schema validation will not apply. XML, note that static testing of resource content is not enough to prove conformance to the specification. As the first blast of defense schemas for XML and JSON or RTF. But how would the tool know that it is not a generic map from strings to strings? The schema used to normalize the given JSON data object. The JSON Schema standard is used to describe any data format for JSON in a similar way XML Schema is used for XML. It is easy to concisely describe the surface structure of data, again taken from the example app.
    [Show full text]
  • Kompozer-Anleitung Version 1.01 Vom 07.06.2008 Seite 2 Kompozer
    Kompozer Anleitung Für Kompozer Version 0.7.10 © Charles Cooke 2005 - 2007 Dieser Text wird herausgegeben unter der Creative Commons Licence http://creativecommons.org/liceneses/by-sa/2.0/ Ins Deutsche übersetzt und ergänzt von Jürgen Klose Kompozer Inhalt 1 Einleitung .................................................................................................................................6 1.1 Was ist Kompozer?...............................................................................................................................6 1.2 Für wen ist Kompozer geeignet? ..........................................................................................................6 1.3 Umfang der Anleitung ...........................................................................................................................6 1.4 Methode ................................................................................................................................................6 1.5 Kompozer und Nvu ...............................................................................................................................7 2 Quickstart.................................................................................................................................7 2.1 Einleitung ..............................................................................................................................................7 2.2 Eine neue Seite erstellen: .....................................................................................................................7
    [Show full text]
  • Zoology.Ufl.Edu/Zgsa/Gradforum.Html
    Introduction to Webdesign Grad Forum October 17th 2008 François Michonneau > What's a website? › HTML: HyperText Markup Language > What's a website? › Server › Web Browser » Computer: where files » Mozilla Firefox are stored » MS Internet Explorer » Software: handles » Safari request from users » Opera server user > What can you put on a web page? › Text › Images › For everything else, you need plug-ins » Adobe PDF » Adobe Flash » Java » ... › Static vs dynamic > What is an URL? › URL: Uniform Resource Locator › Structure of an URL » http://zoology.ufl.edu/zgsa/gradforum.html > What is an URL? › Structure of an URL » http://zoology.ufl.edu/zgsa/gradforum.html Main domain > What is an URL? › Structure of an URL » http://zoology.ufl.edu/zgsa/gradforum.html Sub domain > What happens when you type an URL? › Structure of an URL » http://zoology.ufl.edu/zgsa/gradforum.html Directory File > What is an URL? › Structure of an URL » http://zoology.ufl.edu/zgsa/gradforum.html Protocol > What is an URL? › Structure of an URL » http://zoology.ufl.edu/zgsa/gradforum.html What is your Where is the Which file on this computer computer? computer? supposed to do with this file? Physical location http://64.233.187.99/ equivalent to http://www.google.com > What is an URL? › Case sensitivity » http://zoology.ufl.edu/zgsa/gradforum.html Case insensitive Case sensitive http://ZOolOgY.UFl.EDU/zgsa/gradforum.html > Fonts › Fonts MUST be on the hard-disk of your visitors › Three types of fonts » Serif: Times New Roman, Georgia » Sans-serif: Arial, Verdana, Trebuchet » Monospace: Courier › Use styles to provide alternative fonts > Colors › Use contrast › Be sober, things to avoid: ex1, ex2, ex3 › No blinking/animations › About 10% of men are colorblind..
    [Show full text]