ERNEST CHAUSSON's POÈME, Op. 25 in CULTURAL CONTEXT
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ERNEST CHAUSSON’S POÈME, Op. 25 IN CULTURAL CONTEXT by Yan Mao A Dissertation Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Musical Arts Major: Music The University of Memphis May, 2016 For my father ! ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Writing this document has been an arduous journey. I would like to acknowledge the people who have helped me make this possible. I would like to express my deepest appreciation to Robert Riggs, musicologist, violinist, professor of music, and chair of the Music Department at the University of Mississippi. From him I have received valuable insight and advice, on research and writing throughout my work on this document. In addition, his professionalism and openness have been a great influence on me and on this document. Without his generous help and time, this document would not have been completed. I would like to thank Janet K. Page, my advisor and the chair of my committee. She offered great help during the hardest period of my doctoral study. She also has provided essential research and writing assistance. I have benefited very much from her musical and literary knowledge and rigorous scholarship. I also would like to thank the following people for their assistance and support. John Baur, my theory professor and my committee member, who helped me analyze the music of the composition and gave insight from different views to my performance and study. Timothy Shiu, my violin professor, who offered the great help throughout my doctoral study and introduced the conception of the beauty and the spirit of the music to me. I am grateful that I got the opportunity to study with him to pursue this last degree. Pu-Qi Jiang, the conducting professor, from whom I received much generous caring during my doctoral study. I have benefited from his professionalism and musicianship. Lenny Schranze, my viola professor, who helped me establish a new musical career. His teaching and perspective on the music have been a great influence on me. John Leslie, music catalog librarian and associate professor at the University of Mississippi, who offered great help to my research and helped me with the French translation. ! iii Also, without my family’s constant support, I could not have completed this document. Therefore, it is with great appreciation that I dedicate it to my father. ! iv ABSTRACT Mao, Yan. DMA. The University of Memphis. May, 2016. Ernest Chausson’s Poème, Op. 25 in Cultural Context. Major Professor: Janet K. Page, PhD. This document examines Ernest Chausson’s Poème (1896) for violin and orchestra in its cultural context. It provides information about the French cultural environment at the end of the nineteenth century, including literature, art, and music. Ivan S. Turgenev’s story The Song of Triumphant Love, which inspired Chausson’s composition of Poème, is also investigated in detail. Supported by musical analysis, I propose how Poème is related to the story. In addition, nineteenth-century composers’ relationships with program music, symbolism, and impressionism are discussed, using as examples excerpts from Hector Berlioz’s Symphonie Fantastique, Richard Wagner’s Tristan und Isolde, Eugène Ysaÿe’s Poème élégiaque, Op. 12, Claude Debussy’s Prélude à l’après-midi d’un faune, Modest Mussorgsky’s Night on Bald Mountain, and Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky’s Romeo and Juliet. I contend that Poème is more an impressionist than a late Romantic work. It was greatly influenced by painting and literature during the late nineteenth century. ! v TABLE OF CONTENTS Chapter Page List of Examples vii List of Figures ix Copyright Permission Letter x Introduction 1 1 Cultural Context and Background: Paris, 1880-1900 2 Interest in Richard Wagner 2 Symbolism in Literature 6 Impressionism in Painting 8 Ernest Chausson’s Friends and Salon Culture 12 2 The Background of Poème 20 The Commission from Eugène Ysaÿe and Ysaÿe’s Poème élégiaque 20 Chausson’s Interest in Ivan Turgenev 24 Program Music in the Late Romantic Era 27 The Song of Triumphant Love: Synopsis and Sources 29 Ivan Turgenev’s Connection with France and Musicians There 33 Exoticism 35 3 Poème and The Song of Triumphant Love 39 Musical Analysis and the Programmatic Content of Poème 39 4 Poème in Broader Musical Context 72 Poème in Broader Musical Context 72 Poème as an Impressionist Work 80 Bibliography 83 ! vi LIST OF EXAMPLES Example Page 2.1. Chausson, Poème, mm. 176-88 22 2.2a. Ysaÿe, Poème élégiaque, mm. 104-5 22 2.2b. Ysaÿe, Poème élégiaque, mm. 112-19 23 2.3. Chausson, Poème, mm. 335-47 23 2.4. Ysaÿe, Poème élégiaque, mm. 183-93 23 2.5. Debussy, Prélude à l’après-midi d’un faune, mm. 1-4 36 2.6. Rimsky-Korsakov, Scheherazade, mm. 14-15 38 2.7. Debussy, Prélude à l’après-midi d’un faune, mm. 61-64 38 3.1. Chausson, Poème, Theme 1, mm. 31-51 41 3.2. Chausson, Poème, Theme 2, mm. 123-26 41 3.3. Chausson, Poème, Linking motive, mm. 65-68 41 3.4. Chausson, Poème, mm. 1-11 44 3.5. Chausson, Poème, mm. 18-20 45 3.6. Chausson, Poème, mm. 75-83 47 3.7. Camille Saint-Saëns, Bacchanale in Act III of Samson et Dalila, 49 3.8. Chausson, Poème, mm. 99-108 50 3.9a. Chausson, Poème, Theme 2, mm. 123-26 50 3.9b. Chausson, Poème, Transformed version of Theme 2, mm. 138-41 51 3.10. Chausson, Poème, Longing motive, Chausson, Poème, mm. 146-47 51 3.11. Chausson, Poème, mm. 164-67 52 3.12. Mussorgsky, Night on Bald Mountain, mm. 1-3 53 ! vii 3.13. Chausson, Poème, mm. 255-69 55 3.14. Chausson, Poème, mm. 277-81 56 3.15. Chausson, Poème, mm. 290-94 58 3.16a. Tchaikovsky, Romeo and Juliet (overture-fantasia), mm. 121-23 62 3.16b. Tchaikovsky, Romeo and Juliet (overture-fantasia), mm. 127-29 63 3.17. Chausson, Poème, mm. 312-20 65 3.18. Wagner, Tristan und Isolde, mm. 1782-90 66 3.19. Chausson, Poème, mm. 339-47 68 3.20. Chausson, Poème, mm. 113-19 71 4.1. Wagner, Tristan und Isolde, mm. 1-9 74 4.2. Chausson, Poème, mm. 12-20 75 4.3. Wagner, Transfiguration in Tristan und Isolde 77 ! viii LIST OF FIGURES Figure Page 1.1. Maurice Denis, Avril (April), ca. 1894 18 2.1. Opening page of the autograph draft of Poème, Opus 25 27 3.1. Overview of the Structure of Chausson’s Poème 42 3.2. Structure of the Introduction 43 3.3a. Chausson, Poème (manuscript), mm. 185-88 69 3.3b. Chausson, Poème, mm. 184-88 69 3.4a. Chausson, Poème (manuscript), mm. 179-84 69 3.4b. Chausson, Poème, mm. 179-83 70 ! ix COPYRIGHT PERMISSION LETTER Dear%Yan, Thank%you%for%your%email%of%DATE%requesting%permission%to%reproduce%Maurice%Denis%April,'ca.'1894on% the%ProQuest%UMI%Dissertation%Publishing%website%in%conjunction%with%your%forthcoming%dissertation% titled%Ernest%Chausson's%Poeme,%Op.%25%in%Cultural%Context.%% Permission%is%hereby%granted%for%the%print%and%online%uses%as%detailed%in%your%email.%%Specifically,%for%the% use%of%the%work%in%the%context%of%a%dissertation%only,%available%for%download%as%a%locked%digital%file%on% the%UMI%password%protected%website,%http://www.proquest.com.%%No%rights%fees%shall%be%attendant%to% this%usage.%%Please%note%that%in%the%event%that%any%additional%uses%of%the%work%are%planned%such%as% further%print%or%online%publication,%permission%must%be%obtained%in%advance%from%ARS%and%a%permissions% fee%may%apply.% Please%include%the%following%copyright%credit%line: ©"2016"Artists"Rights"Society"(ARS),"New"York The%WWW%Images%may%not%be%transferred%to%or%reproduced%on%any%other%storage/retrieval/% transmission/display%system,%including%but%not%limited%to%CDRROM,%DVD,%CDRI,%whether%now%known%or% hereafter%devised%for%sale,%rental,%public%display,%or%distribution%of%any%kind%without%the%express%written% permission%of%ARS.%The%Licensee%shall%not%grant%a%license%to%print,%download,%copy,%share,%modify,%or% otherwise%extract%the%Images%listed%below%for%commercial%purposes,%and%the%licensee%shall%take%all% necessary%measures%to%impede%the%commercial%exploitation%of%the%Images.%% Permission"is"contingent"upon"the"following:""complete"attribution"of"Images"reproduced;"obligatory" copyright"credit"line"affixed"to"the"reproductions"on"screen"and"on"any"computer"print"outs;" integration"of"copy"protection"mechanisms;"no"alteration"or"manipulation"of"the"Images;"and" resolution"not"to"exceed"1024"x"768"pixels"and"72"dpi"definition. Please%feel%free%to%contact%me%if%you%have%any%questions.% Best,% Hannah Rhadigan Rights Administrator A R S Artists Rights Society . 536 Broadway . Fifth Floor . New York, NY 10012 tel. 212.420.9160 fax. 212.420.9286 ! x INTRODUCTION Ernest Chausson’s Poème for violin and orchestra was composed in 1896, and it was dedicated to Eugène Ysaÿe. Listening to this piece for the first time made me feel like I was watching a French movie. I was intrigued by its distant beauty. Is it programmatic or impressionistic, and, if so, what are the extra-musical associations? Is there an obscure plot involving fear, hope, and introverted passion? It made me curious about how all of these feelings were conveyed through the music. Poème was inspired by The Song of Triumphant Love, a story by Ivan S. Turgenev. The work’s relationship to the story was unknown until the publication of Jean Gallois’ biography of Chausson in 1967. No documents indicating the reasons that Chausson suppressed this information in the published score have been discovered. Perhaps the ambiguity and vagueness of Chausson’s final title are related to the impressionist aesthetic? If so, how does an impressionist tell a story via music? In order to answer these and other questions, I began this research.