Jacob Kornbluh, the Hasidic Reporter Standing up for Social-Distancing by Avital Chizhik-Goldschmidt

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Jacob Kornbluh, the Hasidic Reporter Standing up for Social-Distancing by Avital Chizhik-Goldschmidt YOUR SHABBAT EDITION • MAY 29, 2020 Stories for you to savor over Shabbat and through the weekend, in printable format. Sign up at forward.com/shabbat. Credit: iStock/Forward Montage Life A prophet in his own city: Jacob Kornbluh, the Hasidic reporter standing up for social-distancing By Avital Chizhik-Goldschmidt A group of about a hundred Hasidic men and boys men might reach through the screen and grab you by milled about on a dark street in the Brooklyn the neck. neighborhood of Boro Park, a gleam of fire in the For Kornbluh, the incident was the most intense of a distance. Women watched from balconies above the weeks-long campaign against him by neighbors and street at the crowd that had gathered — in violation of others in the Orthodox community. New York City’s social-distancing guidelines — to celebrate the minor Jewish holiday Lag B’Omer. Since the start of the pandemic, Kornbluh has been tweeting to his 17,000 followers about coronavirus Jacob Kornbluh, a reporter for Jewish Insider who is developments in Boro Park, and reporting violations himself Hasidic and lives in the neighborhood, was when necessary — even as he himself was battling the passing the crowd on his way home when a man virus at home. recognized him — and started screaming “Muser, muser!” Traitor. He is one of several prominent Hasidim who have faced harsh criticism and even threats of violence during the Others started chiming in: In cellphone videos captured pandemic for urging Orthodox Jews to abide by social- both by Kornbluh and other passersby, and then distancing rules and reporting those who don’t to the circulated in Orthodox WhatsApp groups, the mob authorities. chants at Kornbluh as he passes through. Muser, muser! The rage is almost palpable; it feels like those Watching the video of the crowd taunting Kornbluh — A prophet in his own city: Jacob Kornbluh, the Hasidic reporter standing up for social-distancing 1 GET THE LATEST AT FORWARD.COM and watching the larger saga unfold via Twitter these hardware store, then behind a kosher deli-counter in past months — is painful for anyone who cares about Williamsburg, another Hasidic enclave in Brooklyn. the Orthodox world. It is a personal kind of pain for me, Throughout, he was inhaling news voraciously. “In both because I have considered Kornbluh a friend for Shabbos in shul, I was always the one leading the the past seven years, and because I, too, am an conversation about political events,” he said. When Orthodox Jewish journalist often writing about the Twitter launched in 2008, Kornbluh finally found an failings of my community. I, too, have gotten used to outlet for his political interests. “It was my first being called a traitor. opportunity to start communicating with others, Kornbluh, who turned 39 last week, is a fast-thinking, sharing my views,” he said. “I started writing, even fast-talking reporter with a velvet yarmulke and peyos though my English was bad.” whose byline, tweets and physical presence have By then, Kornbluh was running his own business — a become fixtures of the Jewish world. Pre-pandemic, if pizza shop in Boro Park. But on the side, he began you walked into any major Jewish event in New York blogging about the 2008 presidential election in the City, you’d undoubtedly see him (and, depending on United States, and the elections for Israel’s Knesset. In your social status, might or might not make it into his 2011, he started getting more engaged on the New York “spotted” list in the next morning’s Insider newsletter). political scene, tweeting, blogging and engaging in He and I are often seated together at conferences or conversations with local elected officials. charity dinners, the only two in Orthodox uniform alongside the bevvy of colleagues in jeans. By 2013, as the race for mayor took off, Kornbluh had sold his pizza shop to his brothers and decided to try After I saw the Lag B’Omer video, which had been his hand at journalism — to “run around to all the free shared on frum WhatsApp groups, I called Kornbluh to events, press conferences, candidate forums and check how he’s doing. campaign launches,” as he recalled in our recent “Rebbetzinnn,” he drawled. That’s how he always conversation. “I live-tweeted the events, got to know greets me — I happen to be married to a rabbi, but it’s the candidates on a more personal level.” That year, he not even about that: it’s a half-traditional, half-jesting got hired as a political reporter for Yeshiva World News, frum address to a woman. and a few months later, moved on to Jewish news site JP Updates, where he covered New York City Hall. “How are you doing?” I asked. “Are you OK?” At public hearings and AIPAC conferences alike, he was “I’m fine,” he said in his usual calm demeanor. Because always an unusual sight. “People see this Hasidic guy nothing — not even an angry mob — fazes Kornbluh. with a long jacket, and they’re thinking, is he a lobbyist? A political junkie? No, I’m actually conducting The most famous Hasidic journalist in America interviews, reporting on this,” he said. Back home in Boro Park, at shul and on the street, there was a Kornbluh’s English is British with a tinge of Yiddish: he different sort of discomfort. “It was very hard for my grew up in a Belzer Hasidic family in the Stamford Hill community to digest that one of them is out there, neighborhood of London, the fifth of seven children. He posting pictures that include women, asking hard spoke mostly Yiddish with his father, a writer and local questions,” he said. community activist, English with his mother, who worked as a wig-maker and chef. “Both of my parents “I don’t have a high school diploma, no degrees,” are very booksmart,” he said. “So I read a lot, and I Kornbluh told me. “I learned on my own from reading. listened to the radio and read newspapers all the time.” When I needed a word, I googled it. I am self-made, because I am so passionate about it, that I really At 16, Kornbluh was sent to yeshiva in Israel; at 20, he wanted to do it.” moved to Brooklyn, was introduced to and married a woman from Williamsburg, and started working at a He quickly earned the attention of readers — and A prophet in his own city: Jacob Kornbluh, the Hasidic reporter standing up for social-distancing 2 GET THE LATEST AT FORWARD.COM respect from sources. David Greenfield, a former still Jacob from JP Updates, who instead of going member of the New York City Council who is now chief drinking with the other reporters went to the Kotel and executive of Met Council, a Jewish charity serving New to Meah Shearim.” York’s needy, described Kornbluh as a reporter of Until the coronavirus hit, Kornbluh tried to integrity who is careful to protect his sources. compartmentalize his work and his community. “I do “We have had people from the Hasidic community this six days a week,” Kornbluh told me, referring to his break into politics,” noted Greenfield, who is also journalism. “But there’s always the seventh day, when Orthodox.“But Jacob is the first to break into political you have a different role, as a member of the Hasidic journalism. I saw him once in the supermarket, back community and not as a journalist.” when he was just a blogger, and I told him, ‘You are going to become the most famous Hasidic journalist in Enemies of the people America.’” Then came the pandemic. In October 2015, Kornbluh moved on to Jewish Insider, In March, when some Hasidic shuls and schools were which aspired to be the Politico of the Jewish world, slower than secular institutions to shut down, Kornbluh with a must-read morning briefing. “The fact that for was a strong voice on Twitter and on community the past five years, I’ve written for a national Jewish WhatsApp groups urging people to take social publication, not an Orthodox one, helped me,” he said. distancing seriously. “I informed the community about “It’s not like I work for a Hasidic publication where I those guidelines,” he later explained to me. “I have to adhere to certain rules, where I couldn’t profile communicated with local officials about the issues a woman, for example.” raised by the community, and also about how very Kornbluh reports on Jewish politics, from New York to challenging it is for us to actually practice those Washington, D.C. to Jerusalem. He isn’t usually focused guidelines.” on the Orthodox beat, but he does regularly comment Early on, Kornbluh got sick himself — for three weeks, on community issues, on Twitter and elsewhere. “At the he chronicled his illness and recovery on Twitter. (His same time, outside, I am in this position where I can test later showed negative for antibodies.) One by one, shine a positive light on my community,” he said, “not Kornbluh watched family members, neighbors, and only tell the stories you read in the New York Post, the friends contract the virus — in Boro Park, in sex abusers and the slumlords.” Williamsburg, in Lakewood and back in his hometown Kornbluh has five children, yet seems to essentially of Stamford Hill. Eight of his relatives and friends died. work 24/6 (his phone is of course off for Shabbos). He Over Passover, he walked by his own synagogue and seems to know just about everyone, and to live-tweet was shocked to see 40 men davening inside, despite it events as easily as he breathes.
Recommended publications
  • Florida Film Festival Features a Short Film by 'Hometown Girl' Talia Osteen
    Back to School Section B WWW.HERITAGEFL.COM YEAR 44, NO. 49 AUGUST 7, 2020 17 AV, 5780 ORLANDO, FLORIDA SINGLE COPY 75¢ Patricia Sigman runs for state Senate By Christine DeSouza Longwood resident Patricia R. Sigman is a Democratic candidate on the primary ballot for state Senate, Dis- trict 9. There is one opponent running against her for the seat and she is hopeful voters will turn out for the Aug. 18 primary elections to get her name on the ballot for the elections on Nov. 3. Sigman is a long-standing member of this community. She and her husband, Phil, have been affiliated with Temple Israel and also Con- gregation of Reform Judaism. Patricia Sigman “Seminole County is our home and our roots here run tive. She is a small business The Jewish Foundation for the Righteous will air from July 27 to Aug. 31, 2020 one of its award-winning documentaries deep,” she told Heritage. “The owner (Sigman & Sigman, highlighting Righteous Gentiles who saved Jews during World War II and the Holocaust. Sigman family has been here P.A. in Altamonte Springs), since the early 1960s.” a voter protection leader, Sigman, a board-certified community volunteer, and Labor & Employment lawyer with her husband, Phil, has Online movie series to feature rescuers and a civil mediator for 26 raised three children — all years, has seen all aspects of of whom attended Seminole law from the business, com- and rescued during years of Holocaust munity and personal perspec- Sigman on page 14A (JNS) — The Jewish Foundation for the to themselves and their families—to save goal was two-fold: to share stories Righteous is launching a Monday-night Jews,” said JFR executive vice president of heroism and raise awareness of movie series, from July 27 to Aug.
    [Show full text]
  • KAJ NEWSLETTER January 9, ‘20 י"ב טבת תש"פ a Monthly Publication of K’Hal Adath Jeshurun
    KAJ NEWSLETTER January 9, ‘20 י"ב טבת תש"פ A monthly publication of K’hal Adath Jeshurun Volume 50 Number 4 New Security Measures In light of the recent sobering events in Jersey City and Monsey, we are reminded ever more of our tenuous Golus-situation and the need for vigilance and security. The Kehilla has implemented the following new security measure: Access to the Shul now requires the use of a code. The only two doors to be used to enter the Shul are the front left door (main entrance) and the ramp door (south side). All women should use the ramp door (only) when entering the Shul. We realize that this is an inconvenience, but the Board believes that it is a necessary step to take in light of recent events. The Board of Trustees is considering additional security measures as well, which will also cover 90 Bennett Avenue. At a recent meeting with elected officials and police, the police department’s dedicated Houses of Worship squad car was mentioned; this car makes periodic check-up patrols around neighborhood Shuls. CHANUKA 5780 The evening of 25 Kislev (Sunday, December 22nd) saw the first candle of Chanuka 5780 lit in the large Menora of our Beis Knesses by Chazon Ezra Lasdun. Vol. 50, No. 4 KAJ NEWSLETTER Page 2 As usual, many members—and others—from near and not-so-near came to our Shul’s Hadlokas Neiros Chanuka over the various evenings, which included two Sunday’s, ensuring a full measure of Pirsumei Nisso. Mr. Yosef Levi lit the Neiros on the second Sunday evening, Leil Zos Chanuka.
    [Show full text]
  • Dictatorships & Double Standards
    8/10/2021 Dictatorships & Double Standards - Jeane J. Kirkpatrick, Commentary Magazine NOVEMBER 1979 FEATURED Dictatorships & Double Standards The Classic Essay That Shaped Reagan's Foreign Policy by Jeane J. Kirkpatrick he failure of the Carter administration’s foreign policy is now clear to everyone except its architects, and T even they must entertain private doubts, from time to time, about a policy whose crowning achievement has been to lay the groundwork for a transfer of the Panama Canal from the United States to a swaggering Latin dictator of Castroite bent. In the thirty-odd months since the inauguration of Jimmy Carter as President there has occurred a dramatic Soviet military buildup, matched by the stagnation of American armed forces, and a dramatic extension of Soviet influence in the Horn of Africa, Afghanistan, Southern Africa, and the Caribbean, matched by a declining American position in all these areas. The U.S. has never tried so hard and failed so utterly to make and keep friends in the Third World. As if this were not bad enough, in the current year the United States has suffered two other major blows–in Iran and Nicaragua–of large and strategic significance. In each country, the Carter administration not only failed to prevent the undesired outcome, it actively collaborated in the replacement of moderate autocrats friendly to https://www.commentary.org/articles/jeane-kirkpatrick/dictatorships-double-standards/ 1/38 8/10/2021 Dictatorships & Double Standards - Jeane J. Kirkpatrick, Commentary Magazine American interests with less friendly autocrats of extremist persuasion. It is too soon to be certain about what kind of regime will ultimately emerge in either Iran or Nicaragua, but accumulating evidence suggests that things are as likely to get worse as to get better in both countries.
    [Show full text]
  • Reconstructing Yiddishkeit 12 Ben Weiner
    RECONSTRUCTING YIddISHKEIT 12 Ben WEIneR Among recent attempts to define “a yearning for a more authentic way “Jewish authenticity,” I find one of being Jewish.” Here, for a move- characterization of its absence most ment founded to diminish ritual for intriguing. In an essay titled “The the sake of a socially palatable ideal- Imaginary Jew” that appeared in ism, authenticity means combating an The Nation three years ago, literary identity crisis with a dose of authorita- critic William Deresiewicz analyzed tive tradition – solidifying a tenuous the failure of contemporary Jewish core by wrapping hoary leather straps fiction to produce hard-nosed explo- around arm and head. In contrast, Jay rations of the present, and noted its Michaelson, an author and spiritual- tendency to rely instead on whimsical ity teacher, struck a cautionary note exoticism. This, he claimed, could be in the Forward last year. “Meaningful contextualized as part of a larger social authenticity isn’t about an old reli- trend. “Over the past three decades, gious form,” he wrote. “It’s about when the dense particularity of American a religious, literary or cultural form Jewish life has, outside the Orthodox speaks to the depths of what it means community, largely disappeared,” he to be human.” Advocating “a personal- contended. “American Jewish experi- ized notion of authenticity measured ence is now, by and large, simply by integrity and individual coherence,” American experience.” In other words, Michaelson also warned against the the lack of a coherent Jewish present kind of nostalgia that distorts history to serve as the basis for, among other and handicaps the present, arising, for things, a compelling novel, bespeaks instance, out of repeated screenings of an American Jewish community “beset Fiddler on the Roof.
    [Show full text]
  • 20110613 AJN Watch: Gays, Reform Clergy and The
    Share Report Abuse Next Blog» AJN WATCH - the on-line voice of Australian Orthodox Jewry observes and comments on matters of interest to that community. We particularly monitor prejudice and monopolistic abuse of influence in the pages of the Australian Jewish News - the main source of information to and about Australian Jewry. We spotlight errors, expose misrepresentations and vigorously advocate our community's positions. MONDAY, JUNE 13, 2011 Search This Blog Gays, Reform clergy and the AJN - but where are Search our Rabbis? powered by Subscribe via email Enter your email address: Subscribe Delivered by FeedBurner Recent Comments The following post was received last week from "Jacob" (with some Anonymous wrote... editing and reworking by us). We apologise for the delay in posting - but The RCV has a long standing policy of total AJNWatch too has been busy over the past weeks with Yomtov and non engagement with the Progressives. They cheesecake as well as one of our stalwarts away overseas. We'll try to do not respond to anything the progressives catch up on the backlog of posts in the next few days. say or do as this simply, neither to them directly or in the public arena. Responding Hi AJN Watch, means that their views and... Continue >> Following your recent advice, I checked out the free online edition of the harold wrote... AJN. (Personally, I decided a year ago that I would no longer financially Rabbi Ingram - the conscience of Australian support the rag.) Jewry What hit me was seeing it has reverted with a Anonymous wrote... vengeance to its role as the Australian Thanks, what took you so long? Gayish News - with its front page, page 3, editorial and Kron's cartoon all featuring and ggg wrote..
    [Show full text]
  • Black-Jewish Coalition” Unraveled: Where Does Israel Fit?
    The “Black-Jewish Coalition” Unraveled: Where Does Israel Fit? A Master’s Thesis Presented to The Faculty of the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences Brandeis University Hornstein Jewish Professional Leadership Program Professors Ellen Smith and Jonathan Krasner Ph.D., Advisors In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Arts by Leah Robbins May 2020 Copyright by Leah Robbins 2020 Acknowledgements This thesis was made possible by the generous and thoughtful guidance of my two advisors, Professors Ellen Smith and Jonathan Krasner. Their content expertise, ongoing encouragement, and loving pushback were invaluable to the work. This research topic is complex for the Jewish community and often wrought with pain. My advisors never once questioned my intentions, my integrity as a researcher, or my clear and undeniable commitment to the Jewish people of the past, present, and future. I do not take for granted this gift of trust, which bolstered the work I’m so proud to share. I am also grateful to the entire Hornstein community for making room for me to show up in my fullness, and for saying “yes” to authentically wrestle with my ideas along the way. It’s been a great privilege to stretch and grow alongside you, and I look forward to continuing to shape one another in the years to come. iii ABSTRACT The “Black-Jewish Coalition” Unraveled: Where Does Israel Fit? A thesis presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences of Brandeis University Waltham, Massachusetts By Leah Robbins Fascination with the famed “Black-Jewish coalition” in the United States, whether real or imaginary, is hardly a new phenomenon of academic interest.
    [Show full text]
  • Hebrew Calendar “End Times” Floyd R
    CODE 166 CODE 196 CODE 228 CODE 243 CODE 251 CODE 294 CODE 427 CODE 490 CODE 590 CODE 666 CODE 01010 CODE 1260 CODE1447 CODE 1900 CODE 1975 CODE 2300 CODE 6000 CODE 144000 Hebrew Calendar “End Times” Floyd R. Cox (9-18-2018) (Translation: Copy & paste into: https://www.freetranslation.com/) The Hebrew Calendar covers 6,000 years, from 3761 BC to 2240 AD, and another 1,000 years, from 2240 to 3240 AD. This would include the “time of the end” (after 6,000 years), but Christ said he and his angels do not know when that will be (Mat 24:36). God, the Father only knows. PART I. 6,000 years in the Hebrew Calendar http://code251.com/ It becomes futile to understand the “time of the end” without first finding the beginning. A good example of taking things literally is found in the 6,000 years found in the Hebrew Calendar. This seems to support the 1,000 years in Revelation 20. Related Topics As explained HERE, the Hebrew calendar places creation in -3760 (3761 BC), and 6,000 years would thus end in year 2239 AD. This would mean the Messiah, the “Anointed One” Final Proof for Sabbatical in 27 AD would rule, beginning in year 6,000, for 1,000 years, from 2239 to 3239 AD (6,000 – 3761 = 2239). These are the dates proposed by the Hebrew calendar. Hebrew Calendar End Times 27 AD 6000 years after creation Ancient Riddle Solved 3761 BC NASA vs Hebrew 2239 AD = 2240 AD end of 6,000 years Context of Daniel 6000 years after 3761 BC (creation) would end in the fall of 2240 AD Context of Revelation 7000 years after 3761 BC (creation) would end in the fall of 3240 AD Utopia Unveiled Other Jewish Documents Eleven Forms The Book of Jubilees supports this view.
    [Show full text]
  • Antisemitism in MPA Classrooms and Beyond
    Journal of Public Affairs Education ISSN: 1523-6803 (Print) 2328-9643 (Online) Journal homepage: https://www.tandfonline.com/loi/upae20 Talking about antisemitism in MPA classrooms and beyond Jamie Levine Daniel, Rachel Fyall & Jodi Benenson To cite this article: Jamie Levine Daniel, Rachel Fyall & Jodi Benenson (2019): Talking about antisemitism in MPA classrooms and beyond, Journal of Public Affairs Education, DOI: 10.1080/15236803.2019.1646581 To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.1080/15236803.2019.1646581 View supplementary material Published online: 13 Aug 2019. Submit your article to this journal View Crossmark data Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at https://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=upae20 JOURNAL OF PUBLIC AFFAIRS EDUCATION https://doi.org/10.1080/15236803.2019.1646581 Talking about antisemitism in MPA classrooms and beyond Jamie Levine Daniel a, Rachel Fyall b, and Jodi Benenson c aIndiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis; bUniversity of Washington; cUniversity of Nebraska at Omaha ABSTRACT KEYWORDS On October 27, 2018, a gunman killed eleven people attending Antisemitism; Jews; cultural Shabbat services in the Tree of Life synagogue in Pittsburgh, PA. competency; administrative For many – both Jews and non-Jews – this tragedy served as evil; trust a wake-up call about the persistence of antisemitism in the United States today. MPA curricula and public affairs research have rarely addressed contemporary antisemitism, yet we argue for including conversations about antisemitism in MPA class- rooms. This article serves as a resource for the public affairs teaching community so our colleagues can feel prepared and empowered to address antisemitism in their classrooms.
    [Show full text]
  • The Saudi Religious Leader Who Condemns Anti
    Selected articles concerning Israel, published weekly by Suburban Orthodox Toras Chaim’s (Baltimore) Israel Action Committee Edited by Jerry Appelbaum ( [email protected] ) | Founding editor: Sheldon J. Berman Z”L Issue 8 4 6 Volume 20 , Number 2 5 Parshias Chukas - Balak July 4 , 20 20 The Saudi Religious Leader Who Condemns Anti - Semitism and Calls on Muslims to Learn about the Holocaust By Jeff Jacoby bostonglobe.com June 28 , 2020 Meet Mohammad al - Issa . murder of Jamal Khashoggi in the Saudi consulate in For years, Saudi Arabia worked tirelessly to export Istanbul shocke d the world. There have been real reforms Wahhabism, its home - grown strain of intolerant Islam, to in Saudi Arabia in recent years, but the country is still far Muslim communities worldwide. It poured many billions from anything resembling Al - Issa’s vision of openness. of dollars into funding mosques, schools, and cultur al Winston Churchill described Russia in 1939 as “a organizations that promoted Islamist e xtremism — an riddle, wrapped in a mystery, inside an enigma. ” But, extremism capable of turning murderous, as Americans Churchill added, “perhaps there is a key.” If the same is learned on Sept. 11, 2001, when 19 Al - Qaeda terrorists, 15 true today of Saudi Arabia, perhaps the key to its internal of them Saudi citizens, murdered thousands of people. contradi ctions is that Islamism is in retreat — not just in Given the link between Saudi Arabia ’s monarchy and Saudi society, but across much of the Muslim world. the rise of radical Isla m, Muhammad Al - Issa might not be Writing in the Glo be four years ago, Daniel Pipes, your idea of a typical Saudi cleric.
    [Show full text]
  • Table of Contents
    TABLE OF CONTENTS OVERVIEW 3 USING ‘DEAR EDITOR’ IN YOUR CLASSROOM 4 EDUCATION 8 LOVE 12 LABOR 16 IDENTITY 20 HISTORIC RESPONSES 24 A BINTEL BRIEF AND VISUAL ARTS 26 LEARNING STANDARDS 38 GLOSSARY OF TERMS 39 RECOMMENDED READING 40 2 OVERVIEW IMMIGRATION Between 1880 and 1924, over 2.5 million Eastern European Jews made the journey to the United States. Two million of these immigrants settled on New York’s Lower East Side. Fleeing the poverty, restrictions and violence of Eastern Europe, this community arrived to New York with the hopes and aspirations that they would find peace, opportunity and prosperity in the land dubbed the “Golden Medina” (the Golden Land). As immigrant writer and Lower East Sider Anzia Yezierska states in her short story The Miracle, “Like all people who have nothing, I lived on dreams.” ADAPTATION Upon arrival to the Lower East Side, life was anything but the stuff of dreams. By 1900, the Lower East Side was the most densely populated place on the planet. Families were forced to live in dark, crowded and unsanitary blocks of tenement housing. To make ends meet, people toiled in sweatshops and garment factories, oftentimes working in their already overcrowded homes. Although immigrants were tackling the struggles and tensions of a new country, they were also experiencing a new kind of culture that was a distinct mix of Jewish and American. Throughout the neighborhood they built dozens of theaters, teahouses and cafes where people could socialize, exchange ideas and discuss politics. Hundreds of synagogues and benevolent societies and settlement houses were established as institutions where immigrants could find spiritual and communal support.
    [Show full text]
  • A Y2K Solution to the Chronology Problem
    67 A Y2K Solution to the Chronology Problem By: SHELDON EPSTEIN, BERNARD DICKMAN and YONAH WILAMOWSKY Introduction Scholars have long grappled with the apparently differing chronological dating for the Second Temple implied by the Talmud date the עבודה זרה ח:-ט. and historical records: Seder Olam and building of the Temple to about 350 BCE; Historians date it to about 516 BCE. In general three approaches have been taken to address the chronological differences, i.e. Historical dating is in error; the Talmud’s chronology is in error; the Talmud purposely manipulated the dating to achieve some important objective. The first approach would have us reject the objectivity and integrity of the historical records. The problem with this approach is that there is a substantial amount of available historical evidence that is difficult to refute. In a 1962 essay Rabbi S. Schwab found this discrepancy a “truly vexing problem” and wrote1 that the historical chronological dating: “can hardly be doubted for they appear to be the result of painstaking research by hundreds of scholars and are borne out by profound erudition and by ever increasing authoritative evidence … we are compelled to admit that the Bayis Sheni must have existed for no less than 586 years.” The second approach, that the Gemara erred, is equally unacceptable. Without resorting to arguments about the infallibility ______________________________________________________ Sheldon Epstein, Bernard Dickman and Yonah Wilamowsky are professional educators. Their joint works on Biblical and
    [Show full text]
  • The Sabbatical Year: from the Practical to the Mystical
    Behar The Sabbatical Year: From the Practical to the Mystical The Torah portion of Behar deals exclusively with the Shemittah (Sabbatical year), which falls every seven years, and the Yovel (the Jubilee year), which takes place every fifty years. The concept of Shemittah and the elucidation of its laws were considered so important that Shemittah is the only commandment to have an entire weekly Torah portion devoted to it. While the Sabbbatical year had fallen into disuse from both a conceptual and practical perspective over the last two thousand since the destruction of the Temple and the subsequent exile, in the last century renewed Jewish settlement of the Land of Israel has made it necessary to again observe and contemplate the practical and deeper implications of the seventh year. The single most important idea to grasp about Shemittah is that practically, spiritually, and even mystically, it is the cornerstone of Torah society. Like all the other mitzvot the Sabbatical year is ultimately meant to manifest and fulfill Judaism’s spiritual values, underscoring the fact that in Judaism religious practice and belief are not divorced from daily life. Loving and honoring God goes hand in hand with loving one’s fellow man, and in fact the two are dependant on one another. The primary spiritual message that the Sabbatical year teaches is that all human striving and achievement must be in tune with the Divine cycle and plan for humankind. Just as we are commanded to work for six days and rest on the seventh day, likewise we are commanded to work the land for six years and on the seventh allow ourselves and the land to rest.
    [Show full text]