DOCSLIB.ORG

Leeds Thesis Template

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Leeds Thesis Template The effect of roads on bats in the UK: a model for evidence based conservation Anna Berthinussen Submitted in accordance with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy The University of Leeds School of Biology June, 2013 - ii - The candidate confirms that the work submitted is her own, except where work which has formed part of jointly-authored publications has been included. The contribution of the candidate and the other authors to this work has been explicitly indicated below. The candidate confirms that appropriate credit has been given within the thesis where reference has been made to the work of others. Chapters 2 and 5 are based on the following jointly-authored publications: Berthinussen, A. & Altringham, J. (2012) The effect of a major road on bat activity and diversity. Journal of Applied Ecology, 49, 82-89. Berthinussen, A. & Altringham, J. (2012) Do bat gantries and underpasses help bats cross roads safely? PLoS ONE 7, e38775. In both publications Anna Berthinussen and John Altringham designed the experiments. Anna Berthinussen performed the experiments, analyzed the data and wrote the first draft of the paper. John Altringham and Anna Berthinussen both made edits to later drafts. University of Leeds students assisted with field work and acknowledgements are given where due. This copy has been supplied on the understanding that it is copyright material and that no quotation from the thesis may be published without proper acknowledgement. © 2013 The University of Leeds and Anna Berthinussen - iii - Acknowledgements First and foremost, I would like to thank my excellent supervisor, John Altringham, for his support, guidance and enthusiasm. His faith in me has allowed my confidence to grow, and he has taught me a great deal about research, and the importance of sticking to your guns and being assertive! I would also like to thank the rest of the bat group (Anita Glover, Chloe Bellamy, Chris Scott, Claire Wordley and Emma Grubb) for their friendship and advice throughout my PhD. It has been a pleasure to work with such a great team, and I have many memories that I will cherish. I owe thanks to the students, volunteers, friends and family that assisted me in the field; David Bodenham, Tom Appleby, Emily Forbes, Nithya Xavier, Megan Resse, Chrissie Webster, Liane Hobson, Iroro Tanshi, Elizabeth Mason, Rebecca Copley, Reece Fullford and Carol Hazell. Their help, hard work and enthusiasm have been invaluable, and I look back fondly on the adventures we shared together in Cumbria, Northumberland and Somerset. This project was funded by a University of Leeds Research Scholarship, and I’d like to thank the Funds for Women Graduates and The Reid Trust for added financial support during a difficult time. I also thank the Highways Agency for permission to access road sites, Graeme Smart for providing monitoring reports, and Tom Cameron for help with statistics. I thank my close friends and family for supporting me, especially my parents for their unconditional love and encouragement in everything I do and for teaching me to believe in myself. Finally, I thank my beloved husband, Reece, for giving up the sunny climes of Australia to support me throughout my studies, for taking an interest in my work despite my lengthy absences every summer and the long hours spent holed up in my study, and for being proud of my every achievement! - iv - Abstract Despite their protected status, little research has been done into the effects of roads on bats or the effectiveness of current mitigation practice. We conducted broadband acoustic surveys on 20 walked transects perpendicular to two major roads in the UK, the M6 in Cumbria, and the M5 in Somerset. Bat activity and habitat variables were recorded at different distances from the road, and the relationship between these variables were investigated using generalised estimated equations (GEE), and ordinal logistic regression. Total bat activity and the activity of Pipistrellus pipistrellus (the most abundant species) were positively correlated with distance from both roads, although the magnitude of the effect was greater by the M6. Distance from the road was positively correlated with the number of bat species by the M6 only. Higher quality habitat surrounding the M5 may have reduced the negative road impacts. The use of direct sampling to collect acoustic data revealed a greater road effect than time expansion methods, which is likely due to increased accuracy through continuous sampling and a larger dataset. Three underpasses and four wire bat gantries were investigated in northern England using echolocation call recordings and observations. The bat gantries were ineffective and used by a very small proportion of bats. Only one underpass located on a pre-construction commuting route could be considered to be effective, and attempts to divert bats were unsuccessful. Further research should focus on crossing structures built on original bat commuting routes, such as underpasses and green bridges. We suggest an integrated approach to mitigation, combining crossing structures and habitat improvements. New crossing structures need to be developed and tested, given the poor success of current structures. Robust pre- and post-construction monitoring using a standardised methodology is essential to assess the effectiveness of mitigation schemes and build an evidence-base for successful conservation. - v - Table of Contents Acknowledgements .................................................................................. iii Abstract ..................................................................................................... iv Table of Contents ....................................................................................... v List of Tables ............................................................................................. ix List of Figures ............................................................................................ x List of Abbreviations ...............................................................................xiii Chapter 1: General Introduction ............................................................. 14 1.1 Scope ........................................................................................... 14 1.2 Bat ecology and conservation ...................................................... 14 1.3 Bats and the law ........................................................................... 15 1.4 The effects of roads on vertebrates .............................................. 15 1.4.1 The barrier effect ............................................................... 18 1.4.2 Collision mortality .............................................................. 20 1.4.3 Habitat fragmentation and edge effects ............................. 21 1.4.4 Noise pollution ................................................................... 22 1.4.5 Light pollution .................................................................... 24 1.4.6 Other effects ...................................................................... 26 1.5 Mitigation ...................................................................................... 26 1.5.1 Underpasses ..................................................................... 27 1.5.2 Overpasses ....................................................................... 27 1.5.3 Linear elements ................................................................. 28 1.5.4 Other possible measures ................................................... 28 1.6 The need for evidence-based conservation .................................. 29 1.7 Purpose of research ..................................................................... 29 1.8 Thesis outline ............................................................................... 30 1.9 References ................................................................................... 32 Chapter 2: The effect of a major road on bat activity and diversity ..... 39 2.1 Abstract ........................................................................................ 39 2.2 Introduction .................................................................................. 40 2.3 Methods ....................................................................................... 42 2.3.1 Survey Design ................................................................... 42 2.3.2 Acoustic analysis ............................................................... 45 - vi - 2.3.3 Statistical analysis ............................................................. 45 2.4 Results ......................................................................................... 48 2.4.1 Overall effects ................................................................... 48 2.4.2 Species-specific effects ..................................................... 52 2.4.3 Effect on the number of species ........................................ 55 2.4.4 Noise effects ..................................................................... 55 2.5 Discussion .................................................................................... 57 2.5.1 The effects of time and habitat .......................................... 57 2.5.2 Road effects ...................................................................... 57 2.5.3 Species effects .................................................................. 60 2.5.4 Conclusions and recommendations ................................... 60 2.6 References ..................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Batbox III D Bat Detector User Guide
    Batbox III D bat detector user guide The new Batbox III D is a heterodyne bat detector, which incorporates the latest technology, whilst retaining all the best qualities of its predecessor. The easy-to-read digital display, single-handed operation, high sensitivity and robustness make it an essential field tool for the professional or amateur batworker. The unit is very easy to use and comes supplied with a soft carrying case. Leaflet design : www.mikeharwood.co.uk IMPORTANT Please read these instructions before using your Batbox III D bat detector BatterY CONNECTION: When fitting the battery, make sure that the unit is switched off and that you fit it correctly. Connecting it the wrong way round may cause damage to the detector. The Batbox III D is designed to take a PP3, 9 volt battery. All brands and types should work but the performance and capacity will vary according to the type used. We recommend the use of NmHi batteries as they are the most economical way of powering the detector as well as being less harmful to the environment. They can be charged by day ready for use in the evening. Duration will depend on the quality of the battery but, on average, expect 12 hrs of intermittent use, per charge. BatterY LOW indicator: When the battery voltage drops below 7 volts a ‘BAT’ legend will appear in the top left hand corner of the display. The Batbox III D will continue functioning normally for a few more minutes. You should change the battery soon after this sign appears.
    [Show full text]
  • Batbox Batscan Software
    Batbox batscan software click here to download BatScan Analysis software for Batbox Duet. Fast and easy analysis of bat sonar. Easy to install, BatScan will record and play back sound samples through. Batbox Batscan Software is optimised for use with the Batbox Duet, but also for use with other TE and FD detectors. Provides fast and easy analysis of bat sonar. BatScan is produced by Batbox Ltd and can be purchased on CD for a very small fee, or comes with Batbox's Baton bat detector. You will need to install the. Buy Batbox Duet & Zoom H2n Digital Recorder (requires mm jack lead, below), and get BatScan Software FREE!! £ + £ + £ BatScan processes PCM format digital audio data such www.doorway.ru sound files. Default settings have been optimised for use with Batbox Duet. "BatScan Software: This software's ease-of-use, affordability, and wonderful results make it an ideal choice for hobbyists just starting out. The application. low cost. Perfect gift for curious wildlife hobbyist; Ideal for interpretive programs; Real-time can be viewed using the included BatScan sound analysis software. Attention: Developers Of Bat Call Analysis Software - Just FYI: If you have ever I currently use Audacity (free), and BatScan from BatBox Ltd. High quality detectors designed and made in the UK Batbox Baton Bat Detector • Budget frequency division • Analyse sonograms with free BatScan software. The Batbox Baton bat detector is a simple but versatile bat detector having a monitor speaker allowing reduction of frequencies between 20kHz. BatScan is easy software to install, that will record and play back sound samples through Default settings have been optimised for use with the Batbox Duet.
    [Show full text]
  • TITLE PAGE.Wpd
    Proceedings of BAT GATE DESIGN: A TECHNICAL INTERACTIVE FORUM Held at Red Lion Hotel Austin, Texas March 4-6, 2002 BAT CONSERVATION INTERNATIONAL Edited by: Kimery C. Vories Dianne Throgmorton Proceedings of Bat Gate Design: A Technical Interactive Forum Proceedings of Bat Gate Design: A Technical Interactive Forum held March 4 -6, 2002 at the Red Lion Hotel, Austin, Texas Edited by: Kimery C. Vories Dianne Throgmorton Published by U.S. Department of Interior, Office of Surface Mining, Alton, Illinois and Coal Research Center, Southern Illinois University, Carbondale, Illinois U.S. Department of Interior, Office of Surface Mining, Alton, Illinois Coal Research Center, Southern Illinois University, Carbondale, Illinois Copyright 2002 by the Office of Surface Mining. All rights reserved. Printed in the United States of America 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Bat Gate Design: A Technical Interactive Forum (2002: Austin, Texas) Proceedings of Bat Gate Design: Red Lion Hotel, Austin, Texas, March 4-6, 2002/ edited by Kimery C. Vories, Dianne Throgmorton; sponsored by U.S. Dept. of the Interior, Office of Surface Mining and Fish and Wildlife Service, Bat Conservation International, the National Cave and Karst Management Symposium, USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service, the National Speleological Society, Texas Parks and Wildlife, the Lower Colorado River Authority, the Indiana Karst Conservancy, and Coal Research Center, Southern Illinois University at Carbondale. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references. ISBN 1-885189-05-2 1. Bat ConservationBUnited States Congresses. 2. Bat Gate Design BUnited States Congresses. 3. Cave Management BUnited State Congresses. 4. Strip miningBEnvironmental aspectsBUnited States Congresses.
    [Show full text]
  • Old Norvicensian
    ON Old Norvicensian Features 018/2019 ONs are getting serious 2 about business (page 20-43) 1 Old Norvicensian Welcome Welcome Welcome to this year’s edition of the or even reach out to acquaintances with Old Norvicensian magazine. As ever, it whom you have lost contact. seeks to provide a link with your school Contents by updating you on news from Cathedral Attending an ON event is always a good Close, both in terms of activities of the way to reconnect; please be in touch with current school and alumni events. the Development Team if you would like further details of what is coming up. You However, it also seeks to offer stimulation are guaranteed a warm welcome in School 02 94 114 and reflection from the ongoing lives of House, where my colleagues and I will Norvicensians in the wider world. After all, always be pleased to update you on the News & Announcements Obituaries our direct contact ends relatively early in latest news and plans. Updates Weddings, babies Remembering those ONs who your lives and the most we can do is set Development and and celebrations have sadly passed away you up for your ongoing experiences; most I should like to finish by offering my thanks School news of your life is lived as an Old Norvicensian to those who have worked hard to produce and, if we get it right, the best bits happen such a quality document – happy reading! then, too! Steffan Griffiths I therefore hope that the pages which Head Master follow will be of interest in their own right but will also encourage reflection on your own experiences from school and since 44 that time.
    [Show full text]
  • Student Workbook Bat House
    Student Workbook Fifth Grade Bat House Safety Agreement 1. SAFETY IS AN ATTITUDE – Safety is the first thing you think about while doing any woodworking. 2. STAY ALERT – Always be aware of what you are doing and what others around you are doing. 3. NEVER GET INTO A HURRY- Take your time and do the job right. 4. FOLLOW THE INSTRUCTIONS – Always follow the teacher’s instructions and any instructions with your tools or project. 5. NEVER USE A BROKEN TOOL – Always keep your tools clean and in good shape and NEVER use a tool if it is broken. 6. KEEP YOUR WORK AREA CLEAN AND NEAT – Take time as you work to pick up scrap and trash and also put your tools away as you use them. 7. THINK AHEAD – Before starting a task, think ahead of all the tools and supplies you will need to finish it and the order you will need each tool. 8. DRESS FOR THE JOB – Secure loose clothes, jewelry and long hair. 9. IF YOU DON’T KNOW – ASK – If you are not sure how to do something ask the teacher or the teacher’s helper. 10. HAVE FUN AND FOLLOW THE RULES! I ___________________________________ have read the ten rules, understand them and agree to follow them. If I break one of the rules, I understand that I will not be allowed to continue in this class. ______________________________ __________________ Signature Date 2 Features of Wood 3 Let’s Do Research! Which wood feature prevents the wood from being scorched if there is a forest fire? 1.
    [Show full text]
  • The Quint : an Interdisciplinary Quarterly from the North 1
    the quint : an interdisciplinary quarterly from the north 1 Editorial Advisory Board the quint volume ten issue one Ying Kong, University College of the North Moshen Ashtiany, Columbia University Martin Kuester, University of Marburg Brenda Austin-Smith, University of Ronald Marken, Professor Emeritus, an interdisciplinary quarterly from Manitoba University of Saskatchewan Keith Batterbe. University of Turku Camille McCutcheon, University of South the north Donald Beecher, Carleton University Carolina Upstate Melanie Belmore, University College of the Lorraine Meyer, Brandon University ISSN 1920-1028 North Ray Merlock, University of South Carolina editor Gerald Bowler, Independent Scholar Upstate Sue Matheson Robert Budde, University Northern British Antonia Mills, Professor Emeritus, Columbia University of Northern British Columbia Ikuko Mizunoe, Professor Emeritus, John Butler, Independent Scholar Kyoritsu Women’s University David Carpenter, Professor Emeritus, the quint welcomes submissions. See our guidelines University of Saskatchewan Avis Mysyk, Cape Breton University or contact us at: Terrence Craig, Mount Allison University Hisam Nakamura, Tenri University the quint Lynn Echevarria, Yukon College Andrew Patrick Nelson, University of University College of the North Montana P.O. Box 3000 Erwin Erdhardt, III, University of Sherry Peden, University College of the The Pas, Manitoba Cincinnati North Canada R9A 1K7 Peter Falconer, University of Bristol Julie Pelletier, University of Winnipeg We cannot be held responsible for unsolicited
    [Show full text]
  • DOC Best Practice Manual of Conservation Techniques for Bats Version 1.0
    DOC best practice manual of conservation techniques for bats Version 1.0 This manual was prepared by Jane Sedgeley, Colin O’Donnell, John Lyall, Hannah Edmonds, Warren Simpson, Jo Carpenter, Jo Hoare and Kate McInnes (2012). Contents Introduction ................................................................................................................................................... 2 Introduction to New Zealand bats/pekapeka ............................................................................................... 5 Conservation management of New Zealand bats ..................................................................................... 21 Finding bats with bat detectors .................................................................................................................. 37 Species identification in the hand .............................................................................................................. 49 Inventory and monitoring methods for counting bats ................................................................................ 56 Catching bats ............................................................................................................................................. 58 Handling, examining, measuring and releasing bats ................................................................................ 85 Banding and marking ............................................................................................................................... 112 Attaching radio
    [Show full text]
  • The United Kingdo Environmental Change
    577 .4. - . 001.4 - The United Kingdo Env ironm ental Chang e Protocols for Standard Measurements at Th e En viro nm e nta l Chang e Netw ork is co-ordin a ted a nd ma n a ge d by t h e Nat u ra l En viron m e n t Re sear ch Co un cil, on b e h alf of t h e spo ns oring org an is a t io n s : Biot ech n o log y & Biolog ica l Scie n ce s Re sear ch Cou n cil Co u n t ry sid e Cou ncil fo r Wale s Dep ar t m e n t of Ag ricu lt u re fo r Nort h ern Ire lan d De p art m e n t of t h e En v ironm e nt De p a rt m e n t of t h e En vironm e nt for Nor t h e rn Ir e la n d En g lis h N a tu r e En vironm e n t Ag en cy Fo re st r y Com m is sion Min is t ry of De fe n ce Min is t ry of Agr ic ult u re , Fis h e ries & Foo d Na t u ra l En v iron m e n t Re searc h Cou n cil Scot t is h E n viron m e n t Pro t ec ti on Ag e ncy Scot t is h Office , Ag ric ult u re , En viron m e n t & Fis h e rie s De p a rt m en t We ls h Offi ce Th e E CN Ce n t ral Co -o rd inatio n Unit is b a se d a t t h e Ins t it ut e of Te rr e st ria l Ecolog y 's Merle w oo d Re s e a rc h St a tio n .
    [Show full text]
  • Blackheath & Bromley Courier
    Blackheath & Bromley Courier December 2020. President 2020-21. Nic Corry. Editor. Pat Calnan ([email protected]) It had already been a tough year for the passing of Club members and now we have lost Past President Ian Wilson. As always his obituary will appear in the Gazette and it will need to be a bumper edition, but briefly… Joined the Club in 1959 Best of 7th in the Southern Junior Cross Country Champs. Best of 16th in the National Junior Cross Country Champs. Best of 11th in the Southern Senior Cross Country Champs Best of 70th in the National Senior Cross Country Champs. Finished in the scoring 6 in all 15 Nationals he ran for the Club Finished in scoring 6 in 15 of the 17 Southerns he ran for the Club. A regular in the Club’s road relay teams and a British League track athlete Pb for 5000m – 14.47.4 Pb for 10,000 – 30.26.6 Pb for 10 miles – 50.49 Pb for marathon – 2.28.16 Club President 1981-82, one of our youngest ever Presidents President of the Southern Counties Cross Country Association 1982 President of the South Of The Thames Cross Country Association 1982 Southern CCCA team manager England Cross Country Union Junior mens team manager England Cross Country Union Senior mens team manager Great Britain Senior Mens Cross Country team manager 1989 – 1995 including 7 World Cross Country Championships Blackheath Cross Country and Road team manager Active coach since 1964 and to, amongst others, 10 time world record holder Angela Copson, the first over 65 woman in the world to run under 6 minutes for the mile.
    [Show full text]
  • NOUNOUS : Lrenfer
    NE PAS JETER SUR LA VOIE PUBLIQUE FOOT / MONDiAL 2018 FiScALiTÉ LES BlEUS SE SoNT La Baisse d’impôts FIFE HEURTÉS aU MUR CK PRoMISE aUX FRaNÇaIS BIÉloRUSSE FRAN SE PRÉCISE PEU À PEU Page 9 Page 7 AFP / AFP © GRATUIT - N°2286 mERcREdI 7 SEPTEmBRE 2016 www.bordeaux7.com ILS GALÈRENT POUR FAiRE GARDER LEURS ENFANTS TOURiSME Le premier cru de la Cité du vin sera NOUnOUS : de bonne tenue p.2 OUEST D SU l’enpage 3FER D / BONNAU G. IVES CH AR © NUMÉRiQUE Une école forme des développeurs en cinq mois p.2 FESTiVAL / BORDEAUX L’Ocean Climax va à nouveau rugir pour la planète p.5 UEST O d U S / d . DAVI T IVES ch R A © ST CLiMAT OUE D SU D / LES ÉTUDES BONNAU E AlaRMaNTES M UILLAU SE G IVES SUCCÈDENT CH AR p.6 © 2 MERCREDI 7 SEPTEMBRE 2016 Bordeaux Actu www.bordeaux7.com bASSINS À FlOT L’inFO ÉcO / lE mErcrEDi aVEc BON DÉMARRAGE LA MAÎTRISE DU POUR LA CITÉ DU VIN CODE EN CINQ MOIS La Wild Code School vient de s’implanter dans le quartier Saint- Michel à Bordeaux et entend se faire une place sur le marché EST avec une pédagogie basée uni- u EST EST quement sur la pratique. Elle cible D O ou Su D tout particulièrement des personnes en recon- / u version professionnelle. D / S D Il y a une pénurie de développeurs en France. ONNAU Le pays pourrait avoir un déficit de près de B ONNAU 40 000 “codeurs” d’ici trois ans, c’est-à-dire des ME B personnes capables créer de toutes pièces un ME LLAU site Internet ou un logiciel et de le modifier à I LLAU I tout moment.
    [Show full text]
  • An Analysis of the Usage of Bat Boxes
    AN ANALYSIS OF THE USAGE OF BATBOXES IN ENGLAND, WALES AND IRELAND FOR THE VINCENT WILDLIFE TRUST BY SIMON M.C. POULTON BIOECOSS LTD. 30TH MAY 2006 Biological & Ecological Statistical Services Biological & Ecological Statistical Services Summary of Major Results Σ For sites in England and Wales there was a highly significant difference in batbox occupancy rate from west to east, ranging from 15% in Devon and west Wales to only 4% in the midlands and eastern England. Σ Occupancy rates showed a clear winter trough, with less than 2% in Feb- ruary rising to 10% in August/September. Σ In 1999, mean occupancy rate in winter was around 1.6%, whereas in 2002, 2004 and 2005 it was 5.7%. In the six summer months occupancy rate more than doubled over this period from around 6% to over 13.5%. Σ There was a highly significant difference in occupancy rates between bat- box types. In general, concrete types were prefered to wooden ones. Σ Occupancy rates, bat counts and species counts all increased significantly with the length of time the boxes had been established. Σ For all six individual species/groups, occupancy rates differed significantly between batbox type, although the most frequently used type differed be- tween species. Less marked differences occurred for bat counts. Σ Batbox height seemed to have a significant effect on occupancy and time to first use by Natterer’s bats, which showed a strong preference for lower boxes. Biological & Ecological Statistical Services Contents Part I The Use of Batboxes to Indicate the Presence of Barbastelle and Bechstein’s bats .........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • APECS April/May 2011 Newsletter
    SEQUOIA CLUB APECS April/May 2011 Newsletter APECS has (as always) been busy and active thanks to our enthusiastic members - and I'm happy to be writing an introduction to another newsletter completely packed with news, features, photos, opportunities, events, jobs, career development, and networking possibilities! Recent highlights include a strong APECS presence at the recent Arctic Monitoring and Assessment Programme (AMAP) conference in Copenhagen, APECS contributions at a planning meeting for a potential International Polar Decade, and the resurgence of the Research Activities Committee with monthly focuses: April was for Atmospheric Sciences, May is Marine Biology, and June will be Social Sciences. There are so many great ways to get involved in APECS - so take a moment to read through the newsletter, put yourself out there, take advantage of these unique opportunities, and as always please contact us if you have any questions/comments/feedback/etc. Yours in Polar Research, - Allen Pope, APECS President 2010-2011 APECS News & Message from the • SCAR March Sheets and Glaciers • Scientific Education Newsletter Now with the Ocean Outreach Updates Director Available • ICASS VII 2011 • Meltdown?: Climate May is Polar Marine • Arctic Monitoring and • • Arctic Science and • APECS Workshop at Change and Biology Assessment Education IUGG 2011 Geopolitics in the Programme (AMAP) organizations Arctic • APECS Members Join APECS at the 11th strengthen • Sea Ice Biodiversity • Centre for Ice, Climate International • Giving a clear and cooperation:
    [Show full text]