Tragedy Or Scandal? Strategies Of GT, XR and the New Climate Movement February 2020 Chris Rose,
[email protected] www.campaignstrategy.org / http://threeworlds.campaignstrategy.org @campaignstrat (twitter) Content 1. Introduction 2. Greta Thunberg’s Nuclear Umbrella 3. The New Climate Movement And The Green Wave 4. Extinction Rebellion’s Narrative and Organising 5. ‘Nobody is Doing Anything: Nothing Is Happening’ 6. NGO Campaigns are Useless 7. Gloom-Picking The Science 8. Issues With XR’s Social Change Theory 9. Conclusions 10. Postscript Note: this paper is almost entirely based on public materials by or about the Extinction Rebellion movement and its founders, and Greta Thunberg’s movement, in 2018-19. It is heavily focused on the UK, where Extinction Rebellion as ‘XR UK’, has been most active. So where it refers to ‘XR’ it generally means XR in the UK in 2018-19. This is a self-funded project intended for readers of the free Campaign Strategy Newsletter 1 PART 1 - Introduction Greta Thunberg and Extinction Rebellion, or ‘GT’ and ‘XR’ have made a huge impression on the public debate about climate change. Greta Thunberg and the ‘school strikes’ because of the emotional power children and the young over adults and parents, Extinction Rebellion because of their energy and disruptive ‘rebellions’. The celebrity status which massive attention has conferred on Thunberg should not distract attention from the fact that as well as unsettling parental assumptions about climate, she is is an inspiration to young people, and in particular to women and girls, all over the world. Even if she stops now, her legacy will roll on.