DOCSLIB.ORG

Planning Committee Agenda 18 December 2014

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Planning Committee Agenda 18 December 2014 Agenda Item 5 REPORTS FOR DEBATE Eden District Council Planning Committee Agenda Committee Date: 18 December 2014 INDEX Item Officer Page Application Details No Recommendation Number 1 Planning Application No: 14/0652 Recommended to: Proposed Dwelling (Replacing Consent 01/0432) 3 Site adjacent Holly House, Ainstable APPROVE Mr and Mrs Robinson Subject to Conditions 2 Planning Application No: 14/0528 Recommended to: Outline Planning Permission for Residential Development with 30% Affordable APPROVE 31 Land at Staynegarth, Stainton Subject to Conditions Atric Ltd 3 Planning Application No: 14/0692 Recommended to: Retrospective application for the retention of a dry stone wall APPROVE 45 Lane Farm, Weasdale, Newbiggin-on-Lune, Kirkby Subject to Conditions Stephen CA17 4LY Mr J Davis 4 Planning Application No: 14/0872 Recommended to: Single storey side and rear extensions and raise roof to form first floor accommodation. APPROVE 50 9 Brackenber Lodge, Shap Subject to Conditions Miss L Evans 5 Planning Application No: 14/0884 Recommended to: Reserved Matters Approval Sought for Appearance, landscaping, Layout and Scale in Relation to the Outline APPROVE Application 13/0243 Subject to Conditions 56 Site Adjacent to Inglenook, Stainton JIW Properties Ltd 6 Planning Application No: 13/0514 Recommended to: Application to modify the Section 106 Agreement attached to Planning Approval 09/0098 and 11/0446 to APPROVE enable the provision of 65% market led housing and Subject to Conditions 35% affordable housing from 100% affordable housing 65 previously agreed. Land at Beacon Farm, Eamont Bridge, Penrith Mr J Heath 1 Agenda Item 5 REPORTS FOR DEBATE 7 Planning Application No: 14/0654 Recommended to: Erection of single dwelling 74 Braithwaite's Garage Ltd, Newbiggin, Stainton, Penrith APPROVE Mr Braithwaite Subject to Conditions 8 Planning Application No: 14/0834 Recommended to: Erection of a new dwelling on land adjacent to Brookside, Glassonby REFUSE 81 Land adj to Brookside, Glassonby, Penrith Subject to Conditions Mr and Mrs A and J Relph 9 Planning Application No:14/0947 Recommended to: Non-material amendment to planning permission 10/0273 requiring the omission of a first floor window APPROVE and inclusion of a canopy to the front elevation. Subject to Conditions 88 13 Moorside, Hunsonby, Penrith, CA10 1PL Mr and Mrs D Brier 10 Planning Application No: 14/0765 Recommended to: Outline planning permission for the erection of two houses with approval sought for access APPROVE 92 Garden to Orchard Cottage, Little Salkeld, Penrith Subject to Conditions Mr and Mrs D Addis 2 Agenda Item 5 REPORTS FOR DEBATE Item 1 Date of Committee: 18 December 2014 Planning Application No: 14/0652 Date Received: 24 July 2014 OS Grid Ref: 353046 Expiry Date: 19 September 2014 546213 Parish: Ainstable Ward: Kirkoswald Proposal: Proposed Dwelling (Replacing Consent 01/0432) Location: Site adjacent Holly House, Ainstable Applicant: Mr and Mrs Robinson Agent: Graham K Norman (Architect) Ltd Case Officer: Rachel Lightfoot Reason for Referral: The recommendation to approve the application is contrary to the view of the Parish Council and objectors have requested a hearing. 3 Agenda Item 5 REPORTS FOR DEBATE 1. Recommendation It is recommended that the application be approved subject to the following conditions: 1. The development permitted shall be begun before the expiration of three years from the date of this permission. 2. The development hereby granted shall be carried out strictly in accordance with the details and plans hereby approved (drawing numbers: 114-115-03H received 19/11/14 and drawing numbers: 114-115-04D, 114-115-05D, 114- 115-06D,114-115-07D, received 02/10/14) and shall not be varied other than by prior agreement in writing by the Local Planning Authority. 3. The dwelling hereby approved shall not be occupied until full details of both hard and soft landscape works, including a phased programme of works, have been submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority and these works shall be carried out within the first planting season following the occupation of the dwelling or in accordance with the programme agreed by the Local Planning Authority. This scheme will include planting along the northern boundary particularly to help screen views of the house and define the limits of the garden area. Any trees or other plants which die or are removed within the first five years following the implementation of the landscaping scheme shall be replaced during the next planting season. 4. The whole of the access area bounded by the carriageway edge, entrance gates and the splays shall be constructed and drained to the specification of the Local Planning Authority in consultation with the Highway Authority. 5. Notwithstanding the details on the plans hereby approved, samples of the materials to be used for the external surfaces of the development shall be submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority before any part of the development is commenced. The development shall be carried out in accordance with these details as approved unless otherwise agreed in writing with the Local Planning Authority. Reasons 1. In order to comply with the provision of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990. 2. To ensure a satisfactory development and to avoid any ambiguity as to what constitutes the permission. 3. To ensure that the development is landscaped in the interest of the visual character and appearance of the area. 4. In the interests of road safety. 5. In the interests of visual amenity. 4 Agenda Item 5 REPORTS FOR DEBATE 2. Site Description and Proposal 2.1 Proposal 2.1.1 The site is within the village of Ainstable and forms part of a larger three plot site (approved under planning permission reference 01/0432) on which two plots have been constructed and are inhabited. The site includes an additional area of land measuring 112m2 (on the north boundary) which was not previously approved for development. Planning permission 01/0432 is extant as the first two plots have been constructed. 2.1.2 The application proposes amendments to the approved layout and design. In summary, the detached garage is to be removed and the placed under the lounge of the bungalow, the finished floor level (FFL) increases from 201.5 to 202.6 at its highest point over the lounge area (an increase of 1.1m) and the resultant ridge heights (the proposal has two ridges) increase by 0.15m and 0.67m. The total footprint of the approved dwelling (measured externally) is 165m2 (the house is 129m2 and the detached garage is 36m2) and the footprint of the proposed house and integral garage is 167m2 (an increase of 2m2). For clarity these changes are set out in the table below. 2.1.3 The application also proposes a change to the site area. The approved site area is shown on the approved drawing as 737m2 although in measuring it from a scale plan it appears to be more like 765m2. The application extends the site to the north to include an area of agricultural land (+112m2) and confirms the proposed site area is 830m2. Basing the approved site area on these known accurate figures suggests that the original site area was (830m2 (proposed) – 112m2 (additional strip) = 718m2 although this is slightly less (19m2) that what is shown on the approved plans and much less (47m2) when the site area is calculated from the scale plan. For clarity the changes are summarised in the table below: Ridge Max Ridge Min FFL Max Footprint Site Area Approved Dwelling 206.5 206.5 201.5 165m2* 737m2** Proposed Dwelling 207.17 206.65 202.6 167m2 830m2 Difference + 0.67m + 0.15 +1.1m +2m2 +93m2 * Including detached garage of 36m2 ** It has been difficult to ascertain the exact site area of the approved house due to the nature of the plans and apparent discrepancies between them. The approved site area is approximately 737m2 which is the site area given on the approved site plan. 2.1.4 The external appearance has changed including the proposed materials - most notably the change from stone to render on the south west elevation. The north east elevation includes additional and enlarged windows, the south east elevation includes an additional half-windowed door to a utility room and an additional door including side light, the south west elevation (which faces the properties Forella and Dean View) has one obscured glazed window and two roof lights as opposed to the bedroom and bathroom window, and the arrangement of openings on the north west elevation is slightly amended. 5 Agenda Item 5 REPORTS FOR DEBATE 2.1.5 The application has been amended on several occasions through the application process. The first amendment received by the department on 01/10/14 reduced the north west elevation by approximately 2m and decreased both ridge heights by 0.53cm and 0.42cm. Full re-consultation was undertaken for this amendment. The second amendment was received on 05/11/14and realigned the northern boundary, highlighted an ash tree that was to be retained and relocated an existing hedge on the site. Full re- consultation was undertaken for this amendment. Further non-material amendments were also made which reduced the red line boundary, and relocated the incorrectly plotted ash tree. Full re-consultation was not considered necessary given the nature of these changes although the immediate neighbours and the parish council were re- notified. 2.2 Description of the Site and the Surroundings 2.2.1 The site lies on ground falling from the properties Dean View and Forella. The ground level falls approximately 1.5m from the rear elevations of those properties to the fence line and a further 2.6m across the width of the site (south to north).
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Newsletter Winter 2013 Squirrel Ranger - We Take the Plunge in Ullswater
    Penrith and District Red Squirrel Group Newsletter Winter 2013 Squirrel Ranger - We Take the Plunge in Ullswater P&DRSG have jumped in with both feet and are delighted to confirm that as of 1st February 2013 Christian Bensaid is the new Red Squirrel Ranger for Ullswater. Christian is employed on a part time (three days per week) self employed basis. He is already well known in the area as one of our more active volunteers (regularly seen at shows and events), he has a wealth of experience from his current position as a red squirrel ranger at Center Parcs where he will continue to work for the other two days. We have long aspired to have ranger cover for Ullswater to support and coordi- nate the tremendous volunteer effort and landowner support that already exists throughout the valley but have simply not had the necessary local funding. All this changed however when the Lake District National Park Authority came forward with a grant for funding, sufficiently generous to kick start the project and give us the confidence we needed. All that remains for us to address now, is how on earth do we keep it going? We have applied to Nurture Eden for their support to the project and they have indicated a keen interest to be involved. They provide funding to pay for local conservation and environmental work by inviting voluntary donations from visitors who feel inspired to put something back into looking after the places they love. We would therefore encourage all tourism businesses in Eden/Ullswater to sign up to their innovative scheme.
    [Show full text]
  • Fell End Clouds Near Kirkby Stephen
    Fell End Clouds near Kirkby Stephen County/Area - Cumbria Author - Lou Johnson Length - 3.0 miles / 4.9 km Ascent - 550 feet / 167 metres Grade - easy Start - OS grid reference NY733005 Lat 54.399262 / Long -2.412767 Postcode CA17 4LL (approx. location only) This easy walk explores an area of limestone country that adjoins the western slopes of Wild Boar Fell. Besides the immediate interest provided by the limestone outcrops and pavements you get some fine views across the surrounding countryside including the Eden Valley, the Howgill Fells and northern slopes of Baugh Fell which lies above Dentdale. The start is at grid ref NY734005 where parking is available in an old quarry on the minor road formerly known as "the Street". This minor road is signed Ulldale and Fell End off the A683 Sedbergh to Kirkby Stephen Road. After parking walk towards the main road. On your right there is a stone wall. Leave the minor road just before the wall and follow a track that twists and turns up towards a ridge. In places the track is rather vague but it becomes more obvious as height is gained. The OS Explorer map provides good guidance. As you climb the views improve with the track eventually reaching a col (grid ref. NY742001). Ahead lies rough moorland that forms the western slopes of Wild Boar Fell. Turn right (southwest) along the ridge aiming for a large prominent cairn. Across the valley to your right lie the Howgill Fells with Harter Fell the dominant summit in the foreground. Beyond you can see the hump backed hills that are so typical of the Howgills.
    [Show full text]
  • December 2020/January 2021
    Link THE PARISH MAGAZINE FOR ORTON, TEBAY AND RAVENSTONEDALE WITH NEWBIGGIN-ON-LUNE December 2020/January 2021 THE LINK IS PUBLISHED BY THE HURD THE WORD PAROCHIAL CHURCH COUNCILS OF ALL SAINTS’, CHURCH, ORTON, From the Revd. Alun Hurd with ST JAMES’ CHURCH, TEBAY, AND ST OSWALD’S CHURCH, RAVENSTONEDALE ‘So, this is Christmas…’ begins with lockdown and restrictions WITH NEWBIGGIN-ON-LUNE the John Lennon and Yoko Ono like we could never have Christmas song, Happy Xmas imagined. with lots of sorrow and VICAR (War is over) hitting No 4 in the sadness. We cannot ignore that, Revd. Alun Hurd 01931 714812 singles charts of 1972. 3 Crown Inn Fields, Morland, CA10 3EB and even if has not affected us Email: [email protected] They might be our words and personally, we must bear the thoughts as we contemplate what Curate weight along, with the bereaved, of Fran Parkinson 23393 our Christmas will be like this the tears and grief that engulf Email: [email protected] year. And as I write no one can be them and this planet. Retired clergy quite sure what we will be allowed I do not know what your Ian Elliott 24441 to do and where we can go during Christmas will be like or mine, or Christopher Jenkin 24410 the Christmas season. if you will be able to be with loved Reader Emeritus There is an uncertainty which ones or not. What I do know is Reg Capstick 24497 the pandemic has brought to the that the human spirit will ORTON with Tebay UK and our planet that may be persevere eventually through most CHURCHWARDENS resolved with the advent of difficulties, and with God’s Holy Chris Bland 24258 vaccines to combat the virus; we Spirit we can be encouraged and Angela Milburn 24382 Linda Garrick 24262 certainly hope so and pray for that strengthened to be little lights of Martin Lawson 26028 to be the case.
    [Show full text]
  • Appendix a APPLICATIONS DETERMINED UNDER OFFICER DELEGATED POWERS for the MONTH of APRIL 2015
    PLANNING COMMITTEE Appendix A APPLICATIONS DETERMINED UNDER OFFICER DELEGATED POWERS FOR THE MONTH OF APRIL 2015 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision 14/0656 Outline Clifton Outline application for residential development and LAND TO THE EAST OF TOWNEND The Lowther Estate APPROVED Application associated infrastructure. CROFT, CLIFTON, PENRITH Trust & North Associates Ltd - Mr A Ross 14/0795 Outline Bolton Outline application for residential development. LAND AT VIOLET BANK FARM, Mrs C Gollins APPROVED Application BOLTON, APPLEBY 14/1008 Full Application Brough Extension to rear of property to provide new entrance THE INN AT BROUGH, MAIN The Inn at Brough - Mrs APPROVED and reception, extended function site and refurbished STREET, BROUGH, KIRKBY S Coplowe toilet facilities. STEPHEN 14/1009 Listed Building Brough Listed building consent for the extension to rear of THE INN AT BROUGH, MAIN The Inn at Brough - Mrs APPROVED property to provide new entrance and STREET, BROUGH, KIRKBY S Coplowe reception, extended function suite and refurbished STEPHEN toilet facilities 14/1029 Full Application Sockbridge & Erection of 3 detached dwellings including re-use of LAND TO REAR OF THE COTTAGE, Mr & Mrs A. Morrison APPROVED Tirril stables as ancillary storage/amenity space. SOCKBRIDGE AND TIRRIL, PENRITH 15/0022 Full Application Kirkoswald Conversion of redundant workshop and garage to a 1-2 CROSS LANE, KIRKOSWALD, Mr & Mrs P Telford APPROVED dwelling. PENRITH 15/0090 Full Application Penrith Change of use from retail (class A1) to a tattoo 25A CORNMARKET, PENRITH Mr C Pearson APPROVED parlour (Sui Generis). 15/0095 Reserved Matters Penrith Approval of Reserved Matters comprising siting LAND AT BEACON FARM, Mr J Heath REFUSED design, external appearance, means of access KEMPLAY BANK, EAMONT BRIDGE, thereto and the landscaping relating to outline PENRITH planning permission 11/0446.
    [Show full text]
  • Exploring the Eden Viaducts the Northern Viaduct Trust
    EXPLORING THE EDEN SMARDALE GILL VIADUCT LOCATION VIADUCTS Also owned by the Northern Viaduct to Brough Trust, Smardale Gill is about three miles &A66 (5km.) west of Kirkby Stephen. This dramatic 90 feet high structure, with 14 N arches, snakes its way across a narrow valley and is best reached by walking about to one mile from Smardale. The approach is Hartley via a footpath along the former trackbed, Smardale Merrygill now a local nature reserve managed by the Kirkby Cumbria Wildlife Trust, which also owns the Stephen trackbed onwards to Ravenstonedale; this Podgill can be also walked. The old railway first Smardale Nateby passes under Smardale Viaduct on the Settle- Fell Carlisle Railway before reaching Smardale A685 T & M6 Gill. Longer walks, giving spectacular views of ebay A683 the viaduct, start from Newbiggin-on-Lune Sedbergh and Ravenstonedale. Former Trackbed Footpath Private THE NORTHERN VIADUCT TRUST For buses from Kirkby Stephen station phone Cumbria Traveline 0870 608 2608. All three viaducts are in the care of the Northern Viaduct Trust, which depends GRATEFUL THANKS entirely on grants and donations for their long-term maintenance. If you The NVT would like to express its grateful thanks to all the enjoyed your walk, a donation would following organisations, who have supported the project and be much appreciated. Please forward offered financial assistance and services. any contributions to Northern European Community Regional Development Fund, Rail Property Viaduct Trust, c/o Saint & Co. Ltd, Railway Heritage Trust, Friends
    [Show full text]
  • The History and Traditions of Ravenstonedale, Westmorland
    ESTMORLA BY THE THE LIBRARY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LOS ANGELES X<e ttuvfhs \ THE HISTORY AND TRADITIONS OF RAVENSTONEDALE WESTMORLAND. REV. W. N I C H O LLS PUBLISHED BY REQUEST. MANCHESTER : JOHN HEYWOOD, 141 AND 143, DEANSGATE. LONDON : Simpkin, Marshall, & Co. KIRKBY STEPHEN : J. W. Braithwalte. APPLEBY : J. Whitehead. PENRITH : J. Hodgson. KENDAL : Atkinson & Pollitt, and E. Gill. SEDBERGH : Jackson & Sons. SETTLE : Wildman & Son. HAWES : J. Hunter. [ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.] PREFACE. I HAD intended to publish my researches into the various features of the traditions and history of Ravenstonedale, rearranged, and composed in a written rather than a after spoken style ; but, mature consideration, I have determined, for several reasons, to present my lectures to the public in the style in which they were delivered, except that they have undergone careful revision, and several additions have been made to them which could not be introduced when they were delivered for want of time. I gladly avail myself of this opportunity of expressing my to the Rev. R. of Mr. obligations Robinson, Mallerstang ; John Robinson, of Ash Fell, who is in possession of some of the most of all to important MSS. ; but most Mr. A. Metcalfe, of Park House, wno was my chairman each evening, and through whose invariable kindness; and courtesy I have been able to obtain much of the information contained in the following lectures. To my critics I may say that I am responsible for the blunders, and that my rushing into print has not arisen from the cacoethes scribendi of which one has so often heard, and the disease from which one would wish to be free, but from the desire to comply with the unanimous request of a crowded audience to which the last lecture was delivered, and to preserve, if possible, in a permanent form, facts and traditions which might otherwise be lost to the finest drag-net of any chronicler who might come at all remotely after me.
    [Show full text]
  • The English Garden
    THE ENGLISH MARCH 2016 ForA everyone R who loves beautiful DEN gardens www.theenglishgarden.co.ukSARAH G RAVEN’S SWEET PEA OFFER THE SEASON STARTS HERE INSTANT CHARM Emerging bulbs and Creative containers beautiful blossom for colour now FIRST TO FLOWER Carol Klein picks Expert advice her favourite for exquisite early perennials camellias Spring essentials £4.20 l Best gardens for MAGNOLIAS l CITY CHIC in a small London plot l Sow seeds of HARDY ANNUALS l SPRING PRUNING masterclass Cover8 - MAR.indd 1 21/01/2016 11:53 THE NATIONAL TRUST GREENHOUSE COLLECTION www.alitex.co.uk 01730 826900 CONTRIBUTORS Carol Klein Carol is a television broadcaster, author and former nurserywoman, who Welcome... has a cottage garden at her home in Devon. She picks her favourite opeful signs of spring are always appreciated; this year we early spring perennials on page 77. have been able to enjoy plenty of them early, thanks to such H mild winter weather. I spotted daffodils blooming during the first week of January in a park, and primroses in my garden were out the week after, well ahead of their normal schedule. Some plants will forever be associated with spring in our combined gardening consciousness, despite the fast-forwarding effects of unusually warm weather. So this issue features gardens that are full of daffodils, including the former home of Queen Elizabeth, the Queen Robert Clark Mother, St Paul’s Walden Bury in Hertfordshire and Dunham Massey Robert is editor of the in Cheshire, where camellias also join in the show. The earliest species Literary Encyclopedia and an expert on tulips bring colour to The Old Rectory garden in Dorset, while in 18th-century garden history and Jane Hampshire, Little Court is painted purple by a wash of crocus.
    [Show full text]
  • The Lune Valley and Howgills
    THE LUNE VALLEY AND HOWGILLS A WALKING GUIDE About the Authors Both native Lancastrians, Dennis and Jan Kelsall have long held a passion for countryside and hill walking. Since their first Cicerone title was published in 1995, they have written and illustrated around 50 guides covering some of Britain’s most popular walking areas and regularly contribute to various outdoor magazines. Their enjoyment of the countryside extends far beyond a love of fresh air, the freedom of open spaces and an appreciation of scenery. Over the years Dennis and Jan have developed a wider interest in the environment, its geology and wildlife, as well as an enthusiasm for delving into the local history that so often provides clues to interpreting the landscape. Other Cicerone guides by the authors The Pembrokeshire Coastal Path The Ribble Way The Yorkshire Dales: North and East The Yorkshire Dales: South and West Walking in Pembrokeshire THE LUNE VALLEY AND HOWGILLS A WALKING GUIDE by Dennis and Jan Kelsall JUNIPER HOUSE, MURLEY MOSS, OXENHOLME ROAD, KENDAL, CUMBRIA LA9 7RL www.cicerone.co.uk © Dennis and Jan Kelsall 2017 Second edition 2017 ISBN: 978 1 85284 916 0 First edition 2012 Printed in China on behalf of Latitude Press Ltd A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. All photographs are by the author unless otherwise stated. This product includes mapping data licensed from Ordnance Survey® with the permission of the Controller of Her Majesty’s Stationery Office. © Crown copyright 2017. All rights reserved. Licence number PU100012932. Updates to this Guide While every effort is made by our authors to ensure the accuracy of guidebooks as they go to print, changes can occur during the lifetime of an edition.
    [Show full text]
  • Link July 10
    THE BARNABY RUDGE TAVERN TEBAY Free house Excellent home-made food served Link 12 noon-2pm and 7pm-9pm daily THE PARISH MAGAZINE FOR ORTON, TEBAY AND RAVENSTONEDALE WITH NEWBIGGIN-ON-LUNE Children and dog friendly Internet Access - read/write e-mails Wifi capable Tel: 015396 24328 EMAIL: [email protected] Spring/summer opening times: BAIRD’S COSY CATS NEWS RELEASE Issued 16 June 2010 Mid Town Farm Monday– Friday 12-2pm 6-11.30pm Crosby Ravensworth Saturday and Sunday open all day 101 stories for Tebay and Orton Wide selection of homemade traditional foods using local produce, 10 minutes from M6 Junction 39 Lunchtime, Baguette and Evening menus Spacious & modern heated accom- What is it about living in Tebay, Orton or any of the hamlets in the surrounding area that you love? If modation Wonderful refurbished beer garden to relax in and enjoy the sun! you had to pick one thing to explain what makes your neighbourhood a distinctive and special place Special diets catered for Entertainment ~ please visit our website: to live, what would it be? Local collections available Fully Licensed www.thegeorgehotelorton.co.uk • Would it be a photo that tells a story, a wartime memory? Tel: 01931 715246 • Would it be an object, a view or the fact that you live near great transport links? Chapman’s Chimney Vac Service CUSHION CRAFTS Or would it be the farming traditions, geology, wildlife, flora or archaeology? RIVERSIDE GOLF Cushion covers and fun cushions for all occasions. COURSE THE VILLAGE SWEEP Are you struggling to find the perfect gift yet again.
    [Show full text]