The First Child in a Chinese Family Who Could Read Prior to Entry Into Elementary School: a Qualitative Intrinsic Case Study
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Denver Digital Commons @ DU Electronic Theses and Dissertations Graduate Studies 1-1-2011 The First Child in a Chinese Family Who Could Read Prior to Entry into Elementary School: A Qualitative Intrinsic Case Study Shu Ping Zhang University of Denver Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.du.edu/etd Part of the Bilingual, Multilingual, and Multicultural Education Commons, Curriculum and Instruction Commons, and the Early Childhood Education Commons Recommended Citation Zhang, Shu Ping, "The First Child in a Chinese Family Who Could Read Prior to Entry into Elementary School: A Qualitative Intrinsic Case Study" (2011). Electronic Theses and Dissertations. 960. https://digitalcommons.du.edu/etd/960 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate Studies at Digital Commons @ DU. It has been accepted for inclusion in Electronic Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ DU. For more information, please contact [email protected],[email protected]. THE FIRST CHILD IN A CHINESE FAMILY WHO COULD READ PRIOR TO ENTRY INTO ELEMENTARY SCHOOL: A QUALITATIVE INTRINSIC CASE STUDY __________ A Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of the Morgridge College of Education University of Denver __________ In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy __________ by Shu Ping Zhang March 2011 Advisor: Dr. Nicholas Cutforth ©Copyright by Shu Ping Zhang 2011 All Rights Reserved Author: Shu Ping Zhang Title: THE FIRST CHILD IN A CHINESE FAMILY WHO COULD READ PRIOR TO ENTRY INTO ELEMENTARY SCHOOL: A QUALITATIVE INTRINSIC CASE STUDY Advisor: Dr. Nicholas Cutforth Degree Date: March 2011 ABSTRACT This study is an account of the literacy-related human environment a Chinese girl experienced as the first person in the history of her family who was able to read prior to entry into elementary school. Temporally speaking, the study spanned more than a decade from the initial, tentative research question to the formal, primary research question. Spatially speaking, it crossed three cultures: the Chinese, Korean, and American cultures. The study was inspired by the Zero Project in China, known as the “Project of Quality Education and Implementation for Children Aged Zero (fetus) to Six.” The significance of the content issue in a child’s literacy curriculum was explored in an interdisciplinary way. Case study served as a holistic research approach and provided the researcher with free temporal and spatial distance to pursue the indefinably multi-dimensional intricacies of a child’s early literacy acquisition among generations in the family. Interpretation of the case was based on the relevant concepts within the scope of the researcher’s knowledge of Chinese culture. Major findings revealed that the child’s literacy acquisition was inseparably related to her parents’ background as well as their awareness of and attitudes towards literacy, and that the foundation of all this was the harmony of the family. Through the lens of generational attitudes towards literacy and especially the lens of the researcher’s multicultural life experiences, this study contributes ii to the field of curriculum studies in general and early literacy curriculum in particular by stimulating people to reconsider what to read to children, besides how to read to them. It calls attention once again to the classic curriculum question, “What knowledge is of most worth?” as well as what is the most essential spiritual food human beings need besides physical needs. This study suggests that Chinese philosophy should be included in a child’s early literacy curriculum in China and calls for dialogues on the content issue of curriculum to gain a deeper understanding of human nature so that humans might co-live peacefully with all beings in the universe. iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS “书不尽言, 言不尽意,” said Confucius in the “Commentary of the Appended Judgments to the Yijing,” meaning that words and language cannot express thought completely. However I would still very much like, using my limited language, to express my heartfelt thanks to the people who have been indispensable in the completion of my dissertation. My sincere thanks go to Dr. Bruce Uhrmacher, whose inspiring courses laid an all-important foundation for the dissertation. I am deeply indebted to my former advisor, Dr. Edith King, who supported me extensively and gave me wise advice since the beginning of my Ph.D. studies and retired near the end of the dissertation process. Moreover, I am very grateful to Dr. Nicholas Cutforth, who graciously agreed to be my new advisor and dissertation chair despite his heavy workload. His efficiency, conscientiousness, and precious advice are most impressive. Further, I would like very much to thank my committee members, Dr. Karin Dittrick-Nathan and Dr. Peter Bonaker, and my outside chair, Dr. Ralph DiFranco, all of whom helped me by contributing their special expertise and perspectives. I also want to thank my editor, Pat Corwin, whose professionalism is phenomenal. I dedicate this dissertation to my family into which I feel very fortunate to have been born and lived with: my father, my mother, my elder sister, my younger brother, my husband, and my daughter. All my love for my family is expressed in the Chinese saying, 一切尽在不言中 [All that one wants to express is expressed in wordlessness]. iv TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER. 1. BACKGROUND .........................................................................................1 Statement of the Problem .........................................................................................1 Low Rate of Literacy and Language Reform in China ................................1 Chinese and Other Languages .....................................................................5 Difficulty of Learning to Read Chinese ...................................................... 5 Difficulty as a Culturally Relative Concept .................................................7 The Zero Project .........................................................................................7 Purpose of the Study ..............................................................................................11 Research Questions ...............................................................................................11 Significance of the Study .......................................................................................12 CHAPTER 2. REVIEW OF LITERATURE .....................................................................16 Introduction ............................................................................................................16 Early Childhood Education and Early Literacy in Ancient China .........................18 Human Nature and Deep Belief in the Importance of Education and Learning ..................................................................................18 The Aim and Principle of Early Childhood Education ..............................20 Fetal Education ..........................................................................................22 Early Character Recognition and Early Reading .......................................24 China Encountering and Learning From the West ................................................32 Three Debates on the Issue of Chinese and Western Culture ....................33 Three Movements of Studying Abroad in Modern China .........................34 Introduction of Western Thought and Western Educational Ideas in China ................................................................................36 The New Culture Movement .....................................................................38 John Dewey’s Visit to China and the American Influence on Chinese Education ....................................................................40 The New Early Childhood Education in China .....................................................41 Reform of Children’s Curriculum and Promotion of Baihua ....................42 Westernization of the New Early Childhood Education in China .............43 The New Early Childhood Education After Founding of the People’s Republic of China ..........................................................................46 The Zero Project ....................................................................................................47 Theoretical Foundations of the Zero Project .............................................47 Connection Between Western Literature and the Zero Project .................47 Theoretical Guide of the Zero Project .......................................................51 The Centrality of Mastery of Written Language in the Zero Project .........52 Deleterious Consequences of the Absence of Training in Early Character Recognition and Early Reading .....................................54 The Highest Ideal and “Only Right Way” for Early Character Recognition and Early Reading .....................................................55 v Optimal Age, Principles, and Methods for Early Character Recognition and Early Reading in the Zero Project ......................56 Successful Cases of Early Readers From the Zero Project ........................58 The Status Quo of Early Childhood Education and Early Literacy in China ........59 Relationship Between Chinese Culture, Family, and Language ............................60 Definition of Culture ..................................................................................61 Language,