![Arxiv:2108.09616V1 [Cond-Mat.Soft] 22 Aug 2021 Xmlsicuecletoso Mlindolt [ Droplets Emulsion of Stress](http://data.docslib.org/img/9d21c3452941867c3cf001db7ac03711-1.webp)
arXiv:2108.09616v1 [cond-mat.soft] 22 Aug 2021 xmlsicuecletoso mlindolt [ droplets emulsion of stress. applied collections under include shape Examples change can that particles soft l [ els ntrso h etcso l oyosi Do polyhedra or 2D in polygons all 3D. of in vertices the of written terms functions in shape-energy interpar- by with determined 3D, forces in ticle polyhedra or (2D) dimensions two in ain[ mation [ [ banding jamming shear shear including deformations, applied response to spatio-temporal complex, display systems These [ colloids r eeae yoelp ewe iceeprilsof particles discrete 1) between classes: shape overlaps forces fixed two interparticle by of the generated one which are re- into for fall vibrational models materials and “soft-particle” soft mechanical of the sponse investigate to used ∗ [email protected] ueospyia ytm r opsdo discrete, of composed are systems physical Numerous eety eitoue h eombepril (DP) particle deformable the introduced we Recently, ayo h hsc-ae,tertclmdl htare that models theoretical physics-based, the of Many 24 h tutrl irtoa,admcaia rprisof properties mechanical and vibrational, structural, The – 29 18 3 httettesse ssaefiln polygons space-filling as system the treat that ] ,bbls[ bubbles ], – [ 20 21 eomblt n hp hnewe oeigtepropertie th the underscore modeling studies when These change shape shape. and fixed deformability v with the matches particles which energy, ical bending non-zero with particles fdfral atce ihzr edn nry ncontra In energy. bending zero with particles deformable of n hp aaeesfrprilswt eobnigenergy bending zero with signi modulus con particles are shear the averaged freedom for that of parameters find degrees We shape shape and modes. the quartic from no matrix with dynamical deformabl 3D, of in packings numb isostatic jammed the are contrast, matches In and value. asphericity isostatic increasing with decreases n uvtr,adpeetitratceoelp eso t q low-frequency, show We possess energy overlap. bending interparticle without const prevent particles that and terms with di curvature, function three and shape-energy in polyhedron, a surface-triangulated by freedom a determined of as degrees modeled is shape particle with particles formable 4 ]. – eateto imdclEgneig aeUiest,Ne University, Yale Engineering, Biomedical of Department eivsiaetesrcua,vbainl n mechanica and vibrational, structural, the investigate We 23 12 .INTRODUCTION I. 7 n )vre-o ooo-ae mod- Voronoi-based or vertex- 2) and ] eateto ple hsc,Yl nvriy e Haven, New University, Yale Physics, Applied of Department , 5 13 ytm ilg nttt,Yl nvriy etHvn Co Haven, West University, Yale Institute, Biology Systems ihe .Murrell, P. Michael 3 eateto hsc,Yl nvriy e ae,Connect Haven, New University, Yale Physics, of Department ,aig[ aging ], ogWang, Dong 4 ,adhdoe atce [ particles hydrogel and ], 2 h iyCleeo e ok e ok e ok101 USA 10031, York New York, New York, New of College City The nertdGaut rga nPyia n niern Bi Engineering and Physical in Program Graduate Integrated 1 eateto ehnclEgneig&MtrasScience, Materials & Engineering Mechanical of Department eombeprilsi he dimensions three in particles deformable 14 aeUiest,NwHvn onciu 62,USA 06520, Connecticut Haven, New University, Yale aeUiest,NwHvn onciu 62,USA 06520, Connecticut Haven, New University, Yale 6 – ejmnLvc nttt n hsc Department, Physics and Institute Levich Benjamin 17 1 h G onD Treado, D. John ,admmr for- memory and ], i clswt pressure with scales ,3 5 3, 4, akD Shattuck, D. Mark Dtd uut2,2021) 24, August (Dated: 7 5 1 – , , 11 ,2 1, 6 2 ], ]. ], ra Boromand, Arman P as ytm.I diin h Pmdlcniesshape- (through considers individually parameter model particle shape DP each the for the range functions addition, wide energy a In confluent over to systems particles systems. study isolated DP fractions—from to the packing used of models, be thus Voronoi-based and can or object, model vertex- discrete to a contrast as in particle each treats model ryo h ytmicessas increases amplitude the system the with perturbing of When modes ergy quartic the matrix. along that dynamical system and the parameters, low-frequency, of by shape modes stabilized of are contacts range missing value) full isostatic the the than over contacts are energy fewer bending (with without hypostatic particles DP of packings that both [ of particles features soft optimal for combines models that of classes 2D in model Dwt n ihu edn energy[ bending in particles without DP and vibra- of with packings and 2D jammed mechanical previ- of the In properties investigated tional separately. we the over particle studies, control deformable en- ous provides each bending model of the DP and shape the particle, thus the and of ergy), area and perimeter ryudroabcln rniinwhen transition en- buckling bending a non-zero undergo with ergy Particles modes. non-quartic hc h iia nrysaei o eua polygon regular a not is shape and energy minimal the which h G ∼ i 6 A ihshrclvrie hs oiin are positions whose vertices spherical with atcvbainlmds hs number whose modes, vibrational uartic atce ihnnzr edn energy bending non-zero with particles e n oe .O’Hern S. Corey and ∗ lefrjme aknso ot spher- soft, of packings jammed for alue P rpriso amdpcig fde- of packings jammed of properties l st, nrae ihtebnigsins.Pcig of Packings stiffness. bending the with increases motneo noprtn particle incorporating of importance e efrhrso htteensemble- the that show further We . antepril ufc ra volume, area, surface particle the rain fjme otmaterials. soft jammed of s ro isn otcsrltv othe to relative contacts missing of er cn vrtefl ag ffrequency of range full the over ficant β esos(D.Ec Ddeformable 3D Each (3D). mensions a amdpcig fdeformable of packings jammed hat ae,Cnetct050 USA 06520, Connecticut Haven, w with , β rbtost h iemdso the of eigenmodes the to tributions ≈ 0 1 onciu 62,USA 06520, Connecticut β nciu 61,USA 06516, nnecticut . o aknso deformable of packings for 5 lk Norwick, Blake ≈ ct050 USA 06520, icut 0 A . 5frjme packings jammed for 75 amdpcig of packings jammed = ology, p 2 ,2 ,7, 3, 2, 1, / 4 πa δ 4 where , 3 ahrthan rather , ∗ 30 32 , p A .W showed We ]. 31 and > .TeDP The ]. δ A h en- the , a δ ∗ 2 above , r the are quartic sfor as 2 unbuckled particles with < ∗ are isostatic with no particles, as well two types of point processes. In Appen- quartic modes. In contrast,A packingsA of buckled parti- dices C and D, we show the influence of adding thermal cles with > ∗ possess quartic modes, but we showed fluctuations to the compression protocol for generating that it is difficultA A to determine how many degrees of free- jammed packings of deformable particles on the proper- dom are associated with each buckled particle [33]. The ties of jammed packings of deformable particles in two shape degrees of freedom contribute significantly to the and three dimensions. vibrational response for packings of DP particles without bending energy, which gives rise to power-law scaling of the ensemble-averaged shear modulus with pressure that II. METHODS differs from that for jammed packings of particles with fixed shape. We model deformable particles in 3D as surface- In this article, we develop the DP model in 3D, which triangulated polyhedra with Nv vertices as shown in considers particles as surface-triangulated polyhedra, and Fig. 1. The vertices are connected via Delaunay trian- then use it to investigate the structural, mechanical, and gulation, resulting in Nf triangles and Ne edges on the vibrational response of jammed packings of deformable surface of each polyhedron. We characterize the shape of particles in 3D. The 3D DP model allows us to deter- 3D deformable particles using the non-dimensional shape mine whether the structural, vibrational, and mechanical parameter (or asphericity) = s3/2/(6√πv), where s A properties of jammed packings of deformable particles in and v are the total surface area and volume of the par- 3D are similar to those in 2D, which is important for ticle, respectively. = 1 when the particle is a sphere, A classifying the critical behavior [34] of the jamming tran- and > 1 for any non-spherical shape. A sition for deformable particle packings. We will show that The total potential energy U for a collection of N de- many of the results for jammed packings of deformable formable particles in 3D obeys the following: particles are similar in 2D and 3D. For example, packings N 2 of deformable particles with no bending energy possess N ǫ v 2 N f ǫ a U = v n 1 + a nf 1 low-frequency, quartic modes, whose number matches the 2 v − 2 f − n=1 0 n=1 a0n ! number of missing contacts from simple contact counting. X X fX=1 (1) N N Also, the pressure-dependent mechanical response varies e ǫ + b (θ )2 + U int, strongly with the particle deformability; the ensemble- 2 ne averaged shear modulus scales with pressure as G P β n=1 e=1 h i∼ X X with β 0.75 for truly deformable particles, whereas f β 0.5 for≈ particles with non-zero bending energy. How- where v0 is the preferred volume for each particle and a0n ever,≈ in contrast to the results for 2D, we show that for is the preferred area for the fth triangle on the surface all non-zero values of the bending energy (i.e. both un- of particle n. The bending angle θne is the angle between buckled and buckled particles), DP packings in 3D are the two unit normals to the triangles that share the eth isostatic at jamming onset and do not possess quartic edge on particle n. The three coefficients ǫv, ǫa, and ǫb modes. control fluctuations in the particle volume, surface trian- gle area, and curvature, respectively. To prevent overlap The remainder of the article is organized as follows. between deformable particles, we include the purely re- In Sec. II, we describe the shape-energy function for the pulsive, linear spring interaction potential between over- DP model in 3D and the computational methods used lapping spherical vertices on neighboring particles: to generate jammed packings of deformable particles in 3D and to calculate the dynamical matrix, density of vi- N N Nv Nv 2 ǫ r r brational modes, stress tensor, and shear modulus for U int = c 1 ni,mj Θ 1 ni,mj , 2 − σ − σ these packings. In Sec. III, we discuss the results in- n=1 m>n i=1 j=1 ni,mj ni,mj X X X X cluding calculations of the vibrational modes for a single (2) deformable particle (Sec. IIIA), and the packing frac- where rni,mj is the distance between the centers of spher- tion and contact number at jamming onset (Sec. IIIB), ical vertices i and j on separate particles n and m and the density of vibrational modes (Sec. IIIC), the con- σni,mj = (σni +σmj )/2 is the average diameter of the two tribution of the shape degrees of freedom to the vibra- vertices. The Heaviside step function Θ( ) enforces that tional modes (Sec. IIID), and the mechanical response the pairs of vertices only interact when they· overlap. (Sec. IIIE) of jammed packings of deformable particles in We focus on studies of jammed packings of monodis- 3D. In Sec. IV, we summarize the conclusions and provide perse deformable particles in 3D and have verified that promising directions for future research. In addition, we they do not possess structural order. To ensure that include four Appendices. In Appendix A, we describe the the particles do not inter-penetrate, we need to have a method we employ to decompose the vibrational modes sufficient number and uniform coverage of the spheri- into contributions from the translational, rotational, and cal vertices on the surface of each deformable particle. shape degrees of freedom of each particle. In Appendix B, To achieve this, we consider a geodesic polyhedron with we caclulate the shape parameter distribution for Voronoi Nv = 42, i.e. the 2nd frequency subdivision of an icosahe- tessellations of jammed packings of frictionless spherical dron with shape parameter =1.024. For this geodesic Av 3
(a) We isotropically compress the system by increasing the equilibrium lengths, areas, and volumes of the particles (Eq. 1) in small steps at fixed box length and fixed equi- librium shape parameter. We start with ∆σ/σ = 10−3, ∆as 2∆σ/σ, and ∆v0 3∆σ/σ, which corresponds to increases∼ in packing fraction∼ of ∆φ/φ 10−3. After each compression step, we use the FIRE algorithm≈ [35] to minimize the total potential energy U. If the pressure of the energy-minimized packing satisfies P < Pt, we com- press the system again, followed by energy minimization. If P > Pt, we return to the configuration before the most recent compression step and decrease ∆σ/σ by a factor of (b) 2. We continue this process until 1 < P/Pt < 1.1, where P =4 10−6, which yields packings of deformable par- t × ticles at jamming onset with packing fraction φ ( ). J A af We calculate the virial stress tensor using ¡ ne e N N 1 N N v v Σ = f r , (3) µν L3 ni,mj,µ ni,mj,ν n=1 m>n i=1 j=1
¢ X X X X ni rni,mj where µ,ν = x,y,z, fni,mj,µ is the µth component of the FIG. 1. (a) An example jammed packing of DP particles with force from vertex j on particle m on vertex i on particle n, r is νth component of the separation vector from zero bending energy, N = 16 particles, Nv = 42 vertices, and ni,mj,ν normalized shape parameter Ae = 1.04. (b) Close-up of two vertex j on particle m to vertex i on particle n. The particles in (a) to illustrate the definitions of the surface trian- pressure is defined as P = (Σxx +Σyy +Σzz)/3. gle area anf , the bending angle θne, vertex diameter σni, and To study the vibrational response of jammed packings the inter-vertex separation rni,mj . Several spherical vertices of deformable particles, we calculate the dynamical ma- are omitted for clarity. trix:
∂2U Mni,mj = , (4) polyhedron, there are Nf = 80 triangular faces: 20 of ∂~rni∂~rmj f the faces have larger area a0n = al, 60 have smaller f where ~rni = (xni,yni,zni) gives the position of the ith area a0n = as, and al/as 1.19. This geodesic poly- hedron also has N = 120≈ edges, half with larger edge vertex on particle n. To obtain the elements of the dy- e ~ length ll, half with smaller edge length ls, and length ra- namical matrix, we first evaluate fni = ∂U/∂~rni analyt- − ~ tio ll/ls 1.13. We choose σni = σ = ls as the diameter ically and then numerically calculate ∂fni/∂~rmj using for the spherical≈ vertices. When providing values of the a finite-difference method on a cubic− grid with uniform −6 shape parameter for systems with ǫ > 0, we provide spacing 10 L. We then diagonalize Mni,mj to obtain the b A obtained after minimizing the shape-energy function for =3NNv 3 non-trivial eigenvalues λk and correspond- f N − an individual particle, not defined from v and a . ing eigenvectors V~k, with V~k V~k′ = δkk′ and k =1,..., . A0 0 0n · N (For ǫ = 0, = .) Further, we normalize the shape The eigenfrequencies are given by ωk = λk/m, where b A A0 parameter such that = / . all of the vertices have mass mi = m. A A Av p We consider three important parameter regimes for the We also measure the packing fraction φJ and coor- DP model in 3D (Eq. e1): 1) Completely deformable par- dination number ZJ of packings of deformable particles ticles with ǫb = 0; 2) Partially deformable particles with at jamming onset. The packing fraction of a collection N 3 ǫ > 0, and 3) “Rigid” particles for which the relative of deformable particles is defined as φ = n/L , b n=1 V vertex positions within each particle are fixed (i.e. ǫv, where n is the volume of the nth particle. We deter- V 3 enc ol P ǫa, and ǫb ). For cases (1) and (2), we choose mine n = vn + πNvσ /6 n n by adding the vol- →2 ∞ V −V −V ǫv ǫav0σ/as ǫcv0/(asσ) 1 to achieve compara- ume vn of the underlying polyhedron, adding the volume ∼ ∼ ∼ enc ble area, volume, and vertex-vertex overlap forces near of the spherical vertices, subtracting the volume n of −4 V jamming onset. For case (2), we set ǫb/ǫv = 10 and the spherical vertices that is enclosed by the polyhedron, 10−3, but the results described below are similar for other and subtracting the volume ol of the overlapping regions Vn values of ǫb/ǫv. between neighboring spherical vertices but outside of the To generate jammed packings, we start with a dilute polyhedron. The volume of the spherical vertices inside system with packing fraction φ = 10−3, random par- the polyhedron is given by enc = Nv Ω σ3/24, where Vn i=1 ni ticle positions in a cubic box with length L, and peri- Ωni is the solid angle defined by the overlap between the odic boundary conditions in the x-, y-, and z-directions. polyhedron and spherical vertex i onP particle n [36]. The 4
volume of the overlapped regions between spherical ver- (a) 0 ol 10 tices and outside of the polyhedron is given by n = Ne 2 V e=1 π(1 θne/(2π))(2σ +lne)(σ lne) Θ(1 lne/σ)/12, − − − 10-5 where lne is the length of the eth edge on the nth par- k
P λ ticle. We also measure the contact number Z = 2Nc/N of jammed packings of deformable particles, where Nc -10 10 A~ is the total number of contacts between distinct pairs of A~ deformable particles. Note that for two particles n and A~ m, multiple vertices on n may overlap multiple vertices (b) on m. However, these are only counted as one contact 100 between particles n and m. To characterize the mechanical response of jammed 10-5 packings of deformable particles, we measure the static k shear modulus G by applying successive simple shear λ -10 strains and calculating the resulting shear stress. To gen- 10 A~ A~ erate affine simple shear strain, we shift the y-positions A~ of all particle vertices based on their z-positions, i.e. ′ 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 the new y-positions are given by yi = yi + δγzi with k δγ = 5 10−8, we fix their x- and z-positions, and ap- × ply Lees-Edwards boundary conditions. After each shear FIG. 2. Sorted eigenvalue spectrum λk (from smallest to strain step, we minimize the total potential energy U largest) for individual deformable particles with (a) ǫb = 0 e using FIRE and measure the shear stress Σ = Σyz. and (b) ǫb > 0, and three shape parameters: A = 1 (blue cir- The shear modulus is given by G = ∂Σ/∂γ. Finally,− cles), 1.1 (red crosses), and 1.2 (green triangles). The insets note that the length, energy, frequency, and stress scales show examples for the particle shapes associated with each 1/3 e e are provided in units of L = N , ǫc, ǫc/m/L and value of ǫb and A, with A increasing from left to right. The 3 ǫc/L , respectively. To assess system-size effects, we dashed vertical lines correspond to (a) k = 45 and (b) 6. study jammed packings with N = 16, 64,p and 128.
freedom over the full range of frequencies for packings of III. RESULTS completely deformable particles, whereas there are only large contributions from the shape degrees of freedom at In this section, we describe the results from the sim- large frequencies for packings with nonzero ǫb. We also show that the ensemble-averaged shear modulus displays ulations of jammed packings of deformable particles in β 3D. We first study the vibrational response for individ- power-law scaling with pressure, G P for packings of deformable particles, and thath thei ∼ scaling exponent ual deformable particles with ǫb = 0 and ǫb > 0. As expected, we find that single deformable particles with β 0.75 is larger for packings of completely deformable particles∼ than the value β 0.5 for packings of particles zero bending energy can change their shape without en- ∼ ergy cost, whereas changes in particle shape cost energy with non-zero ǫb and rigid, bumpy particles. for ǫb > 0. We then investigate the collective structural, vibrational, and mechanical properties in jammed pack- A. Single-particle vibrational response ings of deformable particles. The packing fraction φJ and coordination number ZJ at jamming onset increase dramatically with the shape parameter for completely For a single deformable particle with Nv vertices, there A deformable particles with ǫb = 0. However, φJ and ZJ are 3Nv eigenvalues of the dynamical matrix (Eq. 4). In do not increase significantly from the valuese at 1 Fig. 2 (a), we show the sorted eigenvalue spectrum (from A → smallest to largest) for a deformable particle with ǫ =0 for packings with nonzero ǫb, which is consistent with b prior results for packings of frictional, nonspherical par- and three shape parameters . For all , we expect e A A ticles with rigid shapes. We also show that packings of 3Nv Nf 1 = 45 zero modes, where Nf gives the number − − completely deformable particles possess a large number of area constraints for the triangulare faces ande 1 repre- − of low-frequency, quartic eigenmodes of the dynamical sents the volume constraint. In Fig. 2 (a), we show that < −10 matrix, and their number matches the number of missing λk 10 for 45 of the eigenvalues, and the remaining > −5 contacts relative to the isostatic value. In contrast, pack- 81 eigenvalues∼ are non-zero with λk 10 . Deformable ∼ ings with ǫb > 0 and rigid-shaped particles are isostatic particles with ǫb = 0 can change their shape by moving with no low-frequency, quartic modes. We then decom- along eigenvectors associated with these zero eigenvalues. pose the eigenmodes of the dynamical matrix into contri- Representative shapes for several are shown in the in- butions from the translational, rotational, and shape de- set to Fig. 2 (a); note that they canA possess dimples in grees of freedom of the system. The vibrational response their surfaces since ǫb =0. e has significant contributions from the shape degrees of When ǫb > 0, we add Ne constraints, so that the num- 5 ber of constraints is larger than the number of degrees of (a) freedom. In this case, only rigid translations and rota- # $%&
tions of individual particles cost zero energy. As shown in Fig. 2 (b), deformable particles with ǫb > 0 possess only < −10 6 “zero” eigenvalues λk 10 , corresponding to the !" J three rigid translations and∼ rotations, for all . The re- φ
A−4 maining eigenvalues are non-zero with λk > 10 . Thus, deformable particles with ǫb > 0 can change∼ their shape,
e but it costs energy. Example minimum energy shapes
with ǫb > 0 are shown in the inset to Fig. 2 (b). Note 0 that the shapes at a given and ǫb > 0 are more elon- (b) A 12 gated and smooth relative to those at the same and A ǫb = 0. e e 10 J B. Packing fraction and coordination number at Z jamming onset 8
In this section, we describe the results for the struc- 6
tural properties (i.e. the packing fraction φJ and coor-
¥ ¦§ ¨©
1 1 £¤ ~ dination number ZJ ) for jammed packings of deformable A particles at jamming onset. In Fig. 3 (a), we show φJ versus for packings with ǫ /ǫ = 0, 10−4, and 10−3, as A b v FIG. 3. Average (a) packing fraction φJ and (b) coordina- well as particles with completely rigid shapes. For com- tion number ZJ at jamming onset for jammed packings of pletelye deformable particles, φJ ( 1) 0.50 and it deformable particles with N = 16, ǫb = 0 (circles); N = 64, A → ≈ ǫb = 0 (diamonds); N = 128, ǫb = 0 (asterisks); N = 64, increases rapidly with , reaching a maximum packing −3 −4 A † ǫb = 10 (leftward triangles); N = 64, ǫb = 10 (right- fraction, φJ 0.76 near, but abovee > 1.16. ≈ A ∼ A ≈ ward triangles); and N = 64, rigid shape (squares). The data Note that disordered, jammmede packings of monodis- points are obtained by averaging over 500 jammed packings. perse, frictional spherical particles havee φJ e 0.55 [37] in the large-friction limit using the Cundall-Strack∼ model for friction [38]. Thus, the physical roughness of the de- rigid shapes. φ ( 1) 0.50, φ ( ) increases by a formable particles gives rise to more dilute jammed pack- J A → ≈ J A small amount ( 2%), reaching a peak near 1.08, ings in the large-friction limit than those obtained from ∼ A ≈ the Cundall-Strack model. and then decreasese to 0.50 at = 1e.2. The value at 1 is lower than that≈ foundA in simulationse of fric- The maximum jammed packing fraction is less than 1 A → because of the finite size of the spherical vertices. We tional, monodisperse spheres usinge the Cundall-Strack have shown that the maximum jammed packing frac- model[e 37] in the infinite-friction limit, but similar to val- tion increases as the surfaces of the deformable particles ues for random loose packing found in experiments of become smoother. The shape parameter at which φJ sequentially deposited rough spheres [39]. reaches its maximum value is similar to the peak value The packing fraction at jamming onset for packings of ( † 1.16) in the probability distribution of shape pa- frictionless non-spherical particles typically has a peak A ≈ near 1.1 that is greater than 22% above the value rameters of the polyhedra generated by Voronoi tessellat- A ∼ ing jammed, monodisperse frictionless sphere packings as in the 1 limit [40, 41]. Previous studies of packings e A → shown in Appendix B. In Appendices C and D, we show of frictional ellipsoids have shown that friction reduces that φJ reaches its maximum value at shape parameters the peake in packing fraction that occurs for small, but closer to † when the packings are generated by proto- finite values of 1 [42]. These prior results are con- A− cols thatA include thermal fluctuations. sistent with our observation of a small peak in φ ( ) for J A For anyeǫb > 0, there is a single minimal energy shape deformable particlee packings with nonzero ǫb. For both at each and deviations from this shape cost energy. zero and nonzero ǫb, φJ ( ) does not depend stronglye on A A For this reason, the structural properties (e.g. φ ( )) system size as shown in Fig. 3 (a). J A for jammede packings of deformable particles with any The coordination numbere ZJ = 6 at jamming onset for ǫb > 0 will differ from those for ǫb = 0. Further, thee disordered packings of frictionless spheres[22, 43]. In con- structural properties for jammed packings of deformable trast, 4 (a) (b) (') 100 10-5 100 -5 H,k 10 λ k -10 U , λ 10 k Δ λ 10-10 10-5 10-15 10-15 -6 -4 -2 0 -5 0500 1000 1500 2000 10 10 10 10 10-6 10 10-4 10-* 10-2 k P δ FIG. 4. (a) Eigenvalues of the dynamical (λk, circles) and stiffness (λH,k, crosses) matrices for a jammed packing of N = 16 e deformable particles with Nv = 42, ǫb = 0, and A = 1.06, sorted from smallest to largest. This packing has three “zero” < −9 −7 < eigenmodes (with λk ∼ 10 , also shown as the first three blue circles), 215 low-frequency, quartic eigenmodes (with 10 ∼ < −4 λi ∼ 10 ), and 1798 quadratic eigenmodes for a total of 3NvN = 2016 eigenmodes. For quartic modes and quadratic modes, every 30 modes are also shown with circles (λk) and crosses (λH,k). (b) The eigenvalues λk of the dynamical matrix plotted as a function of pressure P during isotropic compression for the same packing in (a). The dashed line has a slope of 1. (c) Change in the total potential energy ∆U plotted versus the amplitude δ of the perturbation when the packing in (a) at P = 4 × 10−6 is perturbed along each eigenmode of the dynamical matrix. The dashed (dot-dashed) line has a slope of 4 (2). The blue (red) color of the solid lines in all three panels indicates the quartic (quadratic) modes of the dynamical matrix highlighted by circles in (a). µ 0.1. For completely deformable particles with ǫ = 0, formable particles raises the question of whether these ≈ b ZJ increases strongly with , reaching values above 12 packings are mechanically stable in the zero-pressure since they can squeeze throughA the gaps between closely limit. To address this question, we perturb the packings ~ packed particles. ZJ becomese independent of system size by an amplitude δ in the direction of each eigenmode Vk: −4 −3 for N 128. For ǫb/ǫv = 10 , 10 and completely rigid particles,≥ Z 6 and it does not increase signifi- J ∼ cantly with . R~ = R~ + δV~ , (5) A 0 k e ~ C. Vibrational response where R represents the positions of all vertices on all par- ticles in the perturbed packing and R~ 0 represents those in the original packing. In Fig. 4 (c), we show that the We investigate the vibrational response of jammed ~ ~ packings of deformable particles by calculating the change in the total potential energy ∆U = U(R) U(R0) increases quadratically with δ for perturbations− along eigenvalues λk of the dynamical matrix, where k = 1,..., 3N N, and the corresponding vibrational frequen- eigenmodes in the higher-frequency band. However, v for perturbations along the low-frequency eigenmodes, cies ωk. We first show the eigenvalue spectrum for 2 4 jammed packings of completely deformable particles with ∆U δ for small δ and ∆U δ for large δ. Based on the results∼ in Fig. 4 (b), the crossover,∼ δ∗, that separates ǫb = 0. In Fig. 4 (a), we plot λk (sorted from smallest the δ4 and δ2 scaling regimes decreases as √P . Thus, in to largest) for N = 16, N = 42, and = 1.06. Apart v the P 0 limit, the potential energy increases quarti- from the three “zero” eigenvalues (withAλ < 10−9) from k cally, not→ quadratically, with the perturbation amplitude the periodic boundary conditions, we find∼ two distinct e in these directions. These “quartic” eigenmodes of the bands in the eigenvalue spectrum: one with 215 eigen- −7 −4 dynamical matrix have also been observed in jammed values that satisfy 10 < λk < 10 and the other with −1 3 packings of rigid non-spherical particles [23, 44–46]. 1798 eigenvalues that satisfy∼ 10∼ < λk < 10 . To bet- ter understand the low-frequency∼ band,∼ we investigate We further investigate the existence of quartic eigen- the pressure dependence of λk as the jammed packings modes of the dynamical matrix for packings of com- are isotropically compressed above jamming onset. The pletely deformable particles by decomposing the dynami- higher-frequency eigenvalues are nearly independent of cal matrix into contributions from the stiffness and stress pressure P , whereas the low-frequency eigenvalues in- matrices, M = H S [32, 40, 45]. The total poten- crease linearly with P , as shown in Fig. 4 (b). Thus, tial energy for completely− deformable particles has three these low-frequency eigenvalues of the dynamical matrix terms, U = U v + U a + U int defined in Eqs. 1 and 2, and tend to zero in the P 0 limit. thus the stiffness and stress matrices have three terms, → The observation of pressure-dependent eigenvalues of H = Hv + Ha + Hint and S = Sv + Sa + Sint. The stiff- the dynamical matrix for packings of completely de- ness matrices for each of the three terms are given by: 7 (a) 40 2 v vw ∂ U ∂vn ∂vn 2 , if n = m v ∂vn ∂~rni ∂~rnj 20 Hni,mj = , (6) (0, otherwise N O m / N 10 0 o pq r stu Nf 20 1 klmn 2 a ∂ U ∂anf ∂anf ~ m / N A 2 , if n = m a ∂a ∂~rni ∂~rnj Hni,mj = f=1 nf , (7) 0P, otherwise 10 and P QRSTV Z[\]^ ghij _`ab c def W XY A~ 2 int int ∂ U ∂rni,mj ∂rni,mj 0 Hni,mj = 2 . (8) 0 10 20 L M 40 ∂r ∂~rni ∂~rmj ni,mj Nq / N The stress matrices for each of the three terms are given (b) I JK by: v 2 ∂U ∂ vn , if n = m E FGH v ∂vn ∂~rni∂~rnj Sni,mj = − , (9) (0, otherwise 0 Nf m / N a 2 ∂U ∂ anf , if n = m a ∂anf ∂~rni∂~rnj Sni,mj = − f=1 , (10) 0, P otherwise @ ABCD and int 2 <=>? 2 34 5 678 9:; 1 + ,./ int ∂U ∂ rni,mj ~ Sni,mj = . (11) A −∂rni,mj ∂~rni∂~rmj FIG. 5. (a) Average number of missing contacts per particle The number of non-zero eigenvalues λH,k for the stiff- ness matrix H provides the number of degrees of free- m/N (relative to the isostatic value) plotted versus the num- dom that are linearly constrained, while the number of ber of quartic modes per particle Nq /N for N = 64 packings of deformable particles with ǫb = 0. The colors of the symbols non-zero eigenvalues λ for the dynamical matrix M pro- e k indicate the value of the shape parameter from A = 1 (cyan) vides the total number of constrained degrees of freedom. to 1.2 (magenta). The dashed line indicates m/N = Nq /N. For jammed packings of completely deformable particles, e The inset shows m/N versus A for the same data in the main we find that the number of “zero” eigenvalues of the plot. (b) The number of missing contacts m/N plotted versus < −12 e stiffness matrix (with λH,k 10 ) matches the num- A for N = 64 jammed packings of deformable particles with ber of quartic eigenvalues of∼ the dynamical matrix plus −3 ǫb/ǫv = 10 (blue circles) and rigid bumpy particles (red the three trivial zero modes for periodic boundary con- e crosses) with same values of Nv and A. In both panels, the ditions, as shown in Fig. 4 (a). (Calculating the zero data were obtained by averaging over 500 packings. eigenvalues of the stiffness matrix provides a straightfor- ward method for independently identifying the quartic eigenmodes of the dynamical matrix.) We find that the studied, as shown in Fig. 5 (b) for the specific case of number of missing contacts relative to the isostatic value, −3 iso iso N = 16 packings with ǫb/ǫv = 10 . Similar results m = Nc Nc = Nq with Nc = 3NvN 2, matches are found for packings of rigid bumpy particles with the the number− of quartic modes N . This relationship− holds q same N and . The fact that 3D jammed packings of for jammed packings of completely deformable particles v rigid bumpy particlesA are isostatic is consistent with prior over the full range in studied, as shown in Fig. 5 (a). A studies of jammede packings of rigid bumpy particles in From Fig. 3 (b), we know that Nc increases with , and 2D[47]. In contrast, we showed previously that jammed A thus the number of missinge contacts decreases with , packings of “buckled” deformable particles with ǫ > 0 A b reaching zero for > 1.16 as shown in the inset toe Fig. 5 in 2D are hypostatic with m = Nq quartic eigenmodes (a). A ∼ e of the dynamical matrix[32]. These results emphasize Jammed packingse of deformable particles with nonzero an important distinction between jammed packings of ǫb possess only a single band of quadratic eigenmodes, deformable particles in 2D versus 3D. and are isostatic with m 0 for all shape parameters In Fig. 6 (a), we display the density of vibrational fre- ≈ 8 (a) (b) 105 105 0 ) ) 10 k k ¾ ω º 0 D( D( 10-5 ¢ £¤ 10-2 0 10 ² ³´µ -10 10 ¼½ 10 Á À A ¿ 10-4 10-2 ® ¯°± 10-4 10-2 100 102 10-4 10-2 100 102 » k ωk 1 1 ª «¬ ¶ ·¸¹ ¥ ¦§¨ © ~ ) ) k k ¡ ( ( ~ A {|} x yz 0 0 10-4 10-2 100 102 10-4 10-2 100 102 k k FIG. 6. Density of vibrational frequencies D(ωk) for N = 64 jammed packings of deformable particles with (a) ǫb/ǫv = 0 and −3 e (b) 10 over a range of A from 1 (cyan) to 1.2 (magenta). Curves in (a) and (b) are shifted up by 0.5 in the log scale between consecutive A values. Black dots in (a) indicate the average quartic eigenmode frequency ω0, which is also shown in the inset e to (a) as a function of A− 1. The dashed line has slope −1/3 in the inset to (a). The participation ratio ρ(ωk) is shown for −3 e N = 64 jammed packings of deformable particles with (c) ǫb/ǫv = 0 and (d) 10 over the same range of A. In all panels, the data are averaged over 500 packings. quencies D(ωk) for jammed packings of deformable par- tional, rotational, and shape degrees of freedom gener- ticles with ǫ = 0 over a wide range of . We find several ated by the effective friction of the spherical vertices on b A key features in D(ωk): 1) there is a large gap that sepa- each particle. rates the quartic and quadratic frequencye bands; 2) the We next examine the contribution of the motion of quartic band shifts to lower frequencies with increasing each particle to each eigenmode of the dynamical matrix ; and 3) the high-frequency part of the quadratic band at frequency ωk by calculating the participation ratio[50]: A is insensitive to , while the low-frequency part forms a N 2 plateaue that extendsA to lower frequencies with increas- e e ωkn · ωkn ing . In the insete of Fig. 6 (a), we plot the average ρ(ω )= n=1 , (12) A k PN quartic mode frequency ω0 as a function of . We find N e e 2 that eω ( 1)−1/3 displays power-law scalingA with a | ωkn · ωkn | 0 ∼ A− n=1 scaling exponent, 1/3, that is similar to thate observed P for 2D packings of− deformable particles with ǫ = 0 [32]. where V~ = e ,..., e and e is the contribu- b k { ωk1 ωkN } ωkn However, the scaling exponent is different (even the oppo- tion to V~k from the nth particle. Small values of ρ(ωk) site sign) from the value (1/2) that has been observed for indicate localized eigenmodes, whereas large values indi- quartic modes in jammed packings of rigid non-spherical cate spatially-extended eigenmodes. For jammed pack- particles[45, 48]. ings of deformable particles with ǫb = 0, ρ(ωk) is com- We display D(ω ) for jammed packings of deformable plex; for a single value of , it increases and decreases k A particles with non-zero ǫ over a range of in Fig. 6 multiple times as the frequency increases and it depends b A (b). The -dependence is weak. In addition, D(ω ) for strongly on . (See Fig. 6 (c).)e Interestingly, for quartic A k A packings of deformable particles with non-zeroe ǫ is con- modes, ρ(ωk) at the lowest frequency increases from 0 b ∼ tinuous withe no large frequency gaps, as has been found to 0.8 as e increases from 1 to 1.2. This result sug- for jammed packings of rigid, frictionless non-spherical gests∼ that theA lowest frequency quartic modes become in- particles[45, 49]. The lack of a frequency band gap in creasingly de-localizede as jammed packings of completely D(ωk) is likely caused by the coupling of the transla- deformable particles approach confluence. In contrast, 9 (a) 1 (a) 100 õ ö÷ È ÉÊ òóô ) k ω 10-5 S( ï ðñ k Ø ÙÚÛ λ ì íî Ô ÕÖ× 10-10 0 1 (b) Ð ÑÒÓ Ü ÝÞß 0 500 1000 1500 2000 é êë k Ë ÌÍÎ Ï (b) 1 ) æçè k ω  ÃÄÅ ÆÇ S( 0.8 ã äå A~ 0.6 à áâ k S 0 0.4 10-4 10-2 100 102 ωk 0.2 FIG. 7. Contribution S(ωk) of the shape degrees of freedom to the kth eigenmode of the dynamical matrix (with frequency 0 0 50 100 150 200 ωk) for N = 64 jammed packings of deformable particles with −3 e k (a) ǫb/ǫv = 0 and (b) 10 over a range of A from 1 (cyan) to 1.2 (magenta). FIG. 8. (a) Eigenvalues of the dynamical matrix λk, sorted from smallest to largest, for N = 16 jammed packings of −3 e deformable particles with ǫb/ǫv = 10 , A = 1.06, and sev- −1 −2 for jammed packings of deformable particles with non- eral values of ǫc/ǫv : 1 (blue circles), 10 (red crosses), 10 −3 −4 zero bending energy, ρ(ω ) does not depend on as (green triangles), 10 (yellow squares), and 10 (black as- k A shown in Fig. 6 (d). In this case, ρ(ωk) is small at both terisks). (b) Magnitude of the projection of the shape degrees of freedom onto the kth eigenmode of the dynamical matrix small and large ωk, suggesting localized eigenmodese oc- Sk for the same data in (a). cur at these frequencies, and ρ(ωk) reaches a peak value −1 of 0.7 at ωk 10 . This behavior for ρ(ωk) is similar to∼ that found∼ for jammed packings of frictionless disks and spheres[50, 51], even though the degrees of freedom shape parameters 1 < < 1.2. This result suggests are different in these two cases. that particle shape deformabilityA plays an important role in the vibrational responsee for jammed packings of de- formable particles. We also find that S(ωk) increases D. Contribution of shape degrees of freedom to with for the lowest frequencies. The jammed pack- A vibrational modes ings become “confluent” for > 1.16, and in this regime particlee translations and rotationsA ∼ cost more energy than To understand the role of particle deformability in shape changes at low frequencies.e In Fig. 7 (a), we also > the vibrational response, we decompose each eigenmode show that S(ωk) 0.6 at intermediate frequencies above the quartic mode∼ frequencies. This result clearly distin- k (with frequency ωk) of the dynamical matrix into guishes these intermediate frequency modes from those contributions from the translational T (ωk), rotational in jammed packings of frictionless, rigid non-spherical R(ωk), and shape S(ωk) degrees of freedom, such that particles mainly associated with rotational degrees of T (ωk)+ R(ωk)+ S(ωk) = 1. Details about how to cal- culate the eigenmode projections can be found in Ap- freedom [45]. In contrast, for jammed packings of de- formable particles with nonzero ǫb, S(ωk) 0 at low ωk, pendix A. Each projection T (ωk), R(ωk), and S(ωk) ∼ varies from 0 to 1, with 0 indicating no contribution of as shown in Fig. 7 (b). S(ωk) only becomes appreciable > −1 the translational, rotational, or shape degrees of freedom for ωk 10 . In addition, S(ωk) does not vary signif- ∼ to the eigenmode and 1 indicating that only translation, icantly with for packings of deformable particles with A rotation, or shape change contributes to a given eigen- nonzero ǫb. mode. We now investigatee how to take the rigid-particle limit In Fig. 7 (a), we show that for jammed packings of for jammed packings of deformable particles to recover deformable particles with ǫb = 0 the shape contribu- eigenmodes that only contain contributions from parti- tion S(ωk) is non-zero over the full range of ωk for all cle rotations and translations, not particle shape changes. 10 102 (a) (b) øù ú 1 β , 0 £ 10 0 ¡¢ 0 û ü ý þ ÿ 1 1¤¥¦ § -2 β 10 , α 0 1¨ © A 10-4 10-6 10-4 10-2 100 10-6 10-4 10-2 100 10-6 10-4 10-2 100 P P P FIG. 9. Ensemble-averaged shear modulus hGi plotted versus pressure P for N = 128 jammed packings of deformable particles −3 e with (a) ǫb/ǫv = 0 and (b) 10 , and of (c) rigid bumpy particles, for several shape parameters: A = 1.02 (blue circles), 1.06 (red crosses), 1.1 (green triangles), 1.14 (magenta squares), and 1.18 (black asterisks). The dashed lines in (a) and (c) indicate fits to Eq. 13 and the power-law scaling exponents, α (blue circles) and β (red triangles), are shown in the insets. The dashed line in (b) has a slope of 0.5. The data is obtained by averaging over 500 configurations. To address this question, we study jammed packings of in 2D and spheres in 3D have found that α 1 and deformable particles with non-zero bending energy as a β 0.5[22, 53, 54]. In Fig. 9 (a), we show≈ that G −3 ≈ h i function of decreasing ǫc/ǫv and fixed ǫb/ǫv = 10 . In obeys Eq. 13 for all for jammed packings of deformable Fig. 8 (a), we show the eigenvalue spectrum of the dy- A particles with ǫb = 0. We find that G0 decreases as ap- namical matrix sorted from smallest to largest for N = 16 A proaches unity (becausee of the decrease in zJ as 1), jammed packings with = 1.06. As ǫc/ǫv decreases, a but the power-law scaling exponents α 1 and βA →e0.75 band gap emerges thatA separates 6N 3 small eigenval- ≈ ≈ − (shown in the insets) are insensitive to . Notee that ues from the larger bande of high-frequency eigenvalues. the power-law scaling exponent β is differentA for jammed (Note that the smallest three eigenvalues correspond to packings of completely deformable particlese compared to rigid translations of the system.) In Fig. 8 (b), we show that for rigid spherical frictionless and frictional particles that the contribution to the eigenmodes from the shape (β 0.5), as well as rigid, frictionless ellipse- (1.0)[23] degrees of freedom, Sk = 0, for the first 6N eigenmodes and≈ circulo-line-shaped particles (0.8-0.9)[55]. The larger > −3 for ǫc/ǫv 10 . (We index the eigenmodes by the in- values of β > 0.5 is correlated with the presence of quar- ∼ teger k instead of ωk, so that it is easy to identify the tic eigenmodes of the dynamical matrix. first 6N eigenmodes.) Thus, the first 6N eigenmodes For jammed packings of deformable particles with are composed of only particle translations and rotations, nonzero ǫ (and no quartic eigenmodes), we do not ob- similar to the eigenmodes of jammed packings of rigid b serve a low-pressure plateau in G (due to the relatively bumpy particles. small value of ǫ /ǫ ), and G h Pi0.5 over the full range c v h i∼ of pressure studied and for all . (See Fig. 9 (b).) As a comparison, we show G(P ) Afor jammed packings of E. Ensemble-averaged shear modulus h i rigid bumpy particles over the samee range of in Fig. 9 (c). Similar to jammed packings of deformableA particles In this section, we examine the effects of particle de- with non-zero bending energy, the power-law scaling ex- formability on the mechanical properties of jammed pack- e ponent β 0.5 and G(P ) is insensitive to . ings of deformable particles. In particular, we isotropi- ≈ h i A cally compress the packings and calculate the ensemble- averged shear modulus G as a function of pressure P e h i −3 for particles with ǫb/ǫv = 0 and 10 and rigid bumpy IV. CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE particles. We find that G(P ) can be fit by the following DIRECTIONS functional form: h i aP α In this article, we performed computational studies of G(P ) = G + , (13) h i 0 1+ cP α−β the structural, vibrational, and mechanical properties of jammed packings of deformable particles in three dimen- where a and c are constants, and α and β are the sions (3D). We first considered the vibrational response of power-law scaling exponents at small and large pres- single deformable particles with no bending energy and −1 sures, respectively[52]. G0 N gives the value of the showed that they possess numerous unconstrained de- shear modulus in the zero-pressure∼ limit. Prior studies grees of freedom. Adding a bending energy term for each of jammed packings of frictionless and frictional disks edge between triangular faces on the polyhedral surface 11 of the particle constrains all of the remaining degrees of planes that form the particle surfaces. It will be in- freedom. We then show that jammed packings of com- teresting to determine whether any of the properties of pletely deformable particles with zero bending energy are jammed packings of deformable particles depend on the hypostatic and possess Nq quartic eigenmodes of the dy- surface roughness. In addition, the current studies have namical matrix, where Nq matches the number of miss- determined the properties of jammed packings of de- ing contacts relative to the isostatic value. In contrast, formable particles at zero temperature. An important jammed packings of deformable particles with non-zero topic of future research is to understand how the struc- bending energy are isostatic with no quartic eigenmodes. tural, vibrational, and mechanical properties depend on This result in 3D is significantly different than that in temperature, and how the glass transition temperature 2D. Jammed packings of deformable particles with non- that determines long-time particle diffusion depends on zero bending energy in 2D can be hypstatic or isostatic the shape parameter and bending rigidity[56]. depending on whether the particles are buckled or not. The density of vibrational modes D(ωk) for packings of completely deformable particles in 3D possesses a fre- quency band gap between the quartic and higher fre- ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS quency modes. The average quartic eigenmode frequency −1/3 scales as ω0 ( 1) , which is different than the We acknowledge support from NSF Grants No. scaling behavior∼ A− of the quartic modes in jammed pack- CMMI-2029756 (J.D.T. and C.S.O.), No. CBET- ings of rigid, frictionlesse non-spherical particles (ω0 2002782 (J.D.T. and C.S.O.), and No. CBET-2002797 ∼ ( 1)1/2). D(ω ) does not depend on the shape pa- (M.D.S.), and NIH Award No. 5U54CA210184-04 A− k rameter for jammed packings of deformable particles (D.W.). This work was also supported by the High Per- A formance Computing facilities operated by Yale’s Center withe nonzero bending energy. In this case, D(ωk) is sim- ilar to thate for jammed packings of rigid, spherical par- for Research Computing. ticles with a plateau that extends to lower frequencies with decreasing pressure. We also investigate the effect of particle deformability on the mechanical properties of APPENDIX A jammed packings of deformable particles. Specifically, we calculate the ensemble-averaged shear modulus G as a function of pressure P as we isotropically compressh i In this Appendix, we describe how to decompose the the system above jamming onset. We find that for par- eigenmodes of the dynamical matrix into contributions ticles with non-zero bending energy G(P ) scales as a from the translational, rotational, and shape degrees of power-law in pressure, G P β withh β i 0.5, which freedom. We consider a packing of N deformable parti- is similar to the resultsh fori ∼ jammed packings∼ of rigid, cles, where each particle n’s center of mass is located at −1 Nv ~ k frictionless and frictional spherical particles. The scal- ~cn = Nv i=1 ~rin. Let V be the kth eigenvector of the ing behavior of the ensemble-averaged shear modulus is dynamical matrix M in Cartesian coordinates. Compo- different for jammed packings of completely deformable nents fromP the (3N (n 1) + 1)th to the (3N n)th po- v − v particles with ǫb = 0. In this case, the power-law scal- sition in V~ j correspond to the nth deformable particle, ing exponent β 0.75. Moreover, in all cases studied ≈ among which the first, second, and third Nv components for which jammed particle packings (with repulsive lin- are the Nv x-, y-, and z-coordinates, respectively. We ear spring interactions) possess quartic eigenmodes of can define six unit vectors to describe translation (ˆun,x, the dynamical matrix, the power-law scaling exponent ˆun,y, ˆun,z) and rotation (ˆun,r1, ˆun,r2, ˆun,r3) about the β > 0.5. For example, β 0.75 for 2D and 3D jammed center of mass of the nth particle as follows: packings of completely deformable≈ particles[32], β 1.0 for 2D jammed packings of ellipse-shaped particles,≈ and ~un,x β 0.8-0.9 for 2D jammed packings of circulo-lines[55]. ˆun,x = , ~un,x =( 0,..., 0 , 1,..., 1 , ≈ ~un,x We encourage future studies to understand the link be- | | 1 to (n − 1) nth particle x tween quartic eigenmodes of the dynamical matrix and (14) the non-trivial power-law scaling of G(P ) . | {z0,...,} 0 | {z, 0},..., 0 ), h i In summary, we have shown that particle shape de- nth particle y and z (n+1) to N formability has a significant impact on the structural, | {z } | {z } vibrational, and mechanical properties of jammed par- ticle packings. In the current studies, we used spheri- ~un,y cal vertices on the particle surfaces, i.e. the rough sur- ˆun,y = , ~un,y =( 0,..., 0 , 0,..., 0 , 1,..., 1 , ~un,y face model, to implement the particle-particle interac- | | 1 to (n − 1) nth particle x nth particle y tions. In future studies, we will investigate the smooth surface model, where deformable particles are modelled |0,...,{z }0 , |0,...,{z }0 ), | {z } as sphero-polyhedra, and inter-particle distances are de- n-th particle z (n + 1) to N termined by the separations between points, lines, and (15) | {z } | {z } 12 and ~u ′ ˆu ˆu n,z ~un,r3 ′ ~un,r3 n,x n,z = , ~un,z =( 0,..., 0 , 0,..., 0 , ˆu = , ~u =~u · ˆu ~u n,r3 n,r3 n,r3 ′ n,x n,z ~un,r3 − ~un,r3 | | 1 to (z − 1) nth particle x and y | | | | (16) ~u′ ˆu n,r3 n,y ˆu |1,...,{z 1} , 0,...,| {z0 )}, ′ · n,y − ~un,r3 nth particle z | | (n + 1) to N ′ ~u ˆun,z n,r3 · ˆu (21) | {z } | {z } − ~u′ n,z ˆu ~un,r1 | n,r3| n,r1 = , ~un,r1 =( 0,..., 0 , 0,..., 0 , ′ ˆu ~un,r1 ~un,r3 n,r1 | | · ˆun,r1 1 to (n − 1) nth particle x − ~u′ | n,r3| (z1n cn,z),..., (zN n cn,z), ′ | {z } | {z } v ~u ˆun,r2 − − − − n,r3 · ˆu . nth particle y − ~u′ n,r2 | n,r3| y c ,...,y c , |1n − n,y {zNvn − n,y } By defining the following coefficients, nth particle z k k p = V~ ˆun,x (22) | 0,..., 0 ), {z } n,x · pk = V~ k ˆu (23) (n + 1) to N n,y · n,y (17) pk = V~ k ˆu (24) | {z } n,z · n,z k ~ k ˆu ′ pn,r1 = V n,r1 (25) ~un,r2 =( 0,..., 0 , (z1n cn,z),..., (zNvn cn,z), · − − − − k ~ k ˆu p 2 = V n,r2 (26) 1 to (n − 1) nth particle x n,r · k ~ k ˆu 0,..., 0 , x c ,...,x c , pn,r3 = V n,r3, (27) | {z } | 1n − n,x {zNv n − n,x } · nth particle y nth particle z we can rewrite the eigenvector V~ k as 0|,...,{z 0} ), | {z } N N N ~ k k ˆu k ˆu k ˆu (n + 1) to N V = pn,x n,x + pn,y n,y + pn,z n,z (18) n=1 n=1 n=1 | {z } X X X N N and k ˆu k ˆu + pn,r1 n,r1 + pn,r2 n,r2 (28) ′ ~u =( 0,..., 0 , (y c ),..., (y c ), n=1 n=1 n,r3 − 1n − n,y − Nvn − n,y X X N 1 to (n − 1) n-th particle x + pk ˆu + V~ k, x c ,...,x c , 0,..., 0 , n,r3 n,r3 s 1|n {z n,x} | Nv n n,x {z } n=1 − − X n-th particle y n-th particle z where V~ k is the vector that remains after projecting the 0,..., 0 ). s | {z } | {z } particle translations and rotations out of V~ k. By apply- (n + 1) to N ing this decomposition, we can express each eigenmode (19) | {z } as the sum of particle translations, rotations, and shape deformations. Note that these six vectors do not form an orthogonal With these coefficients, we can define the contributions basis due to non-zero off-diagonal components in the mo- of translational T k and rotational Rk degrees of freedom ment of inertia matrix with respect to the center of mass. to the kth eigenmode of the dynamical matrix as: To construct six orthogonal unit vectors, we apply the Gram-Schmidt process (ˆun,x, ˆun,y, ˆun,z, and ˆun,r1 are N k k 2 k 2 k 2 already orthogonal to each other): T = pn,x + pn,y + pn,z (29) ′ n=1 ~u ~u ˆun,x X h i ˆu = n,r2 , ~u =~u′ n,r2 · ˆu N n,r2 n,r2 n,r2 ′ n,x k k 2 k 2 k 2 ~un,r2 − ~un,r2 R = p + p + p . (30) | | | | n,r1 n,r2 n,r3 ~u′ ˆu n=1 n,r2 · n,y ˆu X h i ′ n,y k k k − ~un,r2 S =1 T R gives the contribution of the shape de- | | (20) − − ~u′ ˆu grees of freedom to the kth eigenmode. As an example, n,r2 n,z ˆu k k k ′ · n,z we show T , R , and S for an N = 16 jammed packing − ~un,r2 | | of deformable particles with ǫb/ǫv = 0 with shape pa- ~u′ ˆu n,r2 · n,r1 ˆu rameter = 1.06 in Fig. 10 as a function of frequency − ~u′ n,r1 ω . A | n,r2| k e 13 1 30 !" 20 ) A ( T, R, S P 10 0 -2 0 2 10 10 10 0 ωk )*+ & '( , -. 1 # $% 2 A FIG. 10. Magnitude of the contributions of the translational T (blue circles), rotational R (red crosses), and shape S (black FIG. 11. The probability distribution P(A) of the polyhdedra triangles) degrees of freedom to each eigenmode of the dynam- generated from Voronoi-tessellating the centers of spheres in ical matrix with frequency ωk for N = 16 jammed packings jammed monodisperse sphere packings (blue circles) and ran- e of deformable particles with ǫb = 0 and A = 1.06. dom points (red crosses), as well as the polyhedra generated from Lloyd’s algorithm (black triangles). In all cases, the number of points is Np = 64 with periodic boundary condi- tions in the x-, y-, and z-directions. The vertical dashed line APPENDIX B is located at A = 1.18. In this Appendix, we provide insight into the value tion ( ) with the most probable 1.316 = 1.285 , of the shape parameter at which jammed packings of P A A≈ Av deformable particles with zero bending energy become which is much larger than the most probable values from confluent. In particular, we show results for the proba- the other two types of Voronoi tessellations. bility distribution of the shape parameters obtained from Voronoi tessellation of random points and of the sphere centers in jammed packings of monodisperse, frictionless APPENDIX C spheres, as well as the shape parameters of the polyhedra generated from Lloyd’s algorithm[57]. In all three cases, In this Appendix, we describe the effects on the pack- we consider Np = 64 points and periodic boundary con- ing fraction at jamming onset φJ in 2D from packing- ditions in the x-, y-, and z-directions. For the jammed generation protocols that include thermal fluctuations. sphere packings, we use the same packing-generation pro- In previous studies [30], we found that φJ increases cess described in Sec. II. For Lloyd’s algorithm, we start with shape parameter for < † 1.16. Above †, A A ≈ A with a set of random points and apply Voronoi tessella- φJ reaches a plateau and the particle shapes begin to tion. We then use the centroids of the tessellated poly- buckle inward. As the polygonse ofe Voronoi tessellationse hedra as the new set of points and apply Voronoi tes- of jammed disk packings possess typical shape parame- sellation again. We repeat this process 104 times after ter of † 1.16, we hypothesized that the plateau in A ≈ † which the distribution of the polyhedra shape parame- φJ for > indicates a confluence transition, where ters, ( ), reaches a stationary distribution. deformableA ∼ particlesA completely fill their Voronoi cells as P A In Fig. 11, we show ( ) for the three point pro- †e. Fore > †, the particles cannot further ex- P A cesses described above. The distributions ( ) from pandA → inA area toA increaseA their perimeter, so they invagi- P A jammed frictionless sphere packings and Lloyd’s algo- natee instead.e e e rithm are narrow with peaks near 1.185 = 1.157 v We show in Fig. 12 that the confluence transition is A≈ A and 1.176 = 1.148 v, respectively. As discussed in sensitive to the packing-generation protocol. We prepare ≈ A Sec. II, v = 1.024 is the smallest shape parameter for jammed packings of N = 64 2D deformable particles with A the Nv = 42 polyhedral deformable particles that we con- ǫb = 0 in square, periodic boundaries with side length L. sider in the main text. Thus, the most probable shape pa- To include thermal fluctuations in the packing-geneartion rameters for these two types of Voronoi tessellations are proptocol, we run constant N, constant boundary area similar to the value of = / 1.16 above which the L2, and constant temperature T dynamics for a time 50τ, A A Av ≈ packing fraction at jamming onset φJ reaches a plateau where τ = a0/ǫc, a0 is the preferred area of the parti- for deformable particlese with ǫb = 0. This value of cle, and thermal energy kBT is given in units of ǫc. We is also similar to the critical shape parameter at whichA a then rapidlyp quench the system to T = 0 using FIRE, fliud-to-solid transition occurs in the 3D vertex model for take a small compression step, and then re-minimize the confluent tissues [29]. In contrast, Voronoi tessellations total potential energy to achieve force balance. We re- obtained from sets of random points yield a wide distribu- peat this thermalization, compression, and energy min- 14 :;< ) ) ~ ~ A -1 A ( 10 ( J 7 89 φ φ 3 - 1 1 10-2 10-1 100 45610-2 10-1 100 ~ ~ 2 = > A / A FIG. 12. Local (symbols) and global (lines) packing fraction FIG. 13. Packing fraction at jamming onset 1 − φJ plotted e e 1−φ versus particle shape parameter A−1 for jammed pack- as a function of shape parameter A− 1 for jammed packings ings of deformable particles in 2D prepared using a packing- of N = 16 deformable particles with ǫb = 0 in 3D, generated generation protocol that includes thermal fluctuations at tem- using the protocol with thermal fluctuations at temperature − − − −4 −3 peratures T = 10 6 (blue), 10 4 (cyan), 10 3 (yellow), and T = 0 (blue circles), 10 (cyan squares), 10 (yellow tri- − −2 10 2 (red). Error bars correspond to averages over configu- angles), and 10 (red diamonds). The dashed vertical line rations (lines) or both particles and configurations (symbols). is located at Ae = 1.16. Note that the confluence transition e The vertical dashed line is drawn at A = 1.16. Example in 3D sharpens for packings with increasing T , but it is still particles with Ae = 1.16 for their surface-Voronoi cells are smoother than that for packings of deformable particles in 2D drawn in the inset, sorted by increasing temperature from as shown in Fig. 12. top to bottom. Arrows indicate excess free area in each cell. Surface-Voronoi cells are drawn with black solid lines, while total particle areas are shaded in blue, and the underlying polygons of the deformable particles are indicated with white dashed lines. for > †. In the inset of Fig. 12, we include examples A A of single deformable particles with = 1.16 and their associatede e surface-Voronoi cells. AtA lower temperatures, imization process until reaching jamming onset with a we find small regions of excess freee area near the cell pressure that satisfies 10−7 † 1.16. A A ≈ fractions for 2D deformable particle packings generated For T = 10−2, we find a sharper transition near = † with large thermal fluctuations. When T 10−3, both for the maximum φ , likely from reducinge thee A surfaceA ≥ J measures of the packing fraction possess maxima near friction between particles via thermal fluctuations.e How-e 1.16. When T < 10−3, the packing fraction at jam- ever, the confluence transition in 3D still appears to be mingA≈ onset is generally smaller and continues to change less sharp than that in 2D. e 15 [1] J. Paredes, M. A. J. Michels, and D. Bonn, Rheology [21] D. J. Durian, Bubble-scale model of foam mechan- across the zero-temperature jamming transition, Phys. ics:mmelting, nonlinear behavior, and avalanches, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 015701 (2013). Rev. E 55, 1739 (1997). [2] I. Jorjadze, L.-L. Pontani, K. A. Newhall, and J. Bruji´c, [22] C. S. O’Hern, L. E. Silbert, A. J. Liu, and S. R. Nagel, Attractive emulsion droplets probe the phase diagram Jamming at zero temperature and zero applied stress: of jammed granular matter, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 108, The epitome of disorder, Phys. Rev. E 68, 011306 (2003). 4286 (2011). [23] C. F. Schreck, N. Xu, and C. S. O’Hern, A comparison [3] K. N. Nordstrom, E. Verneuil, P. E. Arratia, A. Basu, of jamming behavior in systems composed of dimer- and Z. Zhang, A. G. Yodh, J. P. Gollub, and D. J. Durian, ellipse-shaped particles, Soft Matter 6, 2960 (2010). Microfluidic rheology of soft colloids above and below [24] R. Farhadifar, J.-C. R¨oper, B. Aigouy, S. Eaton, and jamming, Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 175701 (2010). F. J¨ulicher, The influence of cell mechanics, cell-cell in- [4] G. Katgert and M. van Hecke, Jamming and geometry of teractions, and proliferation on epithelial packing, Curr. two-dimensional foams, EPL 92, 34002 (2010). Biol. 17, 2095 (2007). [5] N. Brodu, J. A. Dijksman, and R. P. Behringer, Spanning [25] D. Bi, J. Lopez, J. M. Schwarz, and M. L. Manning, A the scales of granular materials through microscopic force density-independent rigidity transition in biological tis- imaging, Nat. Commun. 6, 6361 (2015). sues, Nat. Phys. 11, 1074 (2015). [6] G. M. Conley, P. Aebischer, S. N¨ojd, P. Schurtenberger, [26] D. M. Sussman, J. M. Schwarz, M. C. Marchetti, and and F. Scheffold, Jamming and overpacking fuzzy mi- M. L. Manning, Soft yet sharp interfaces in a vertex crogels: Deformation, interpenetration, and compression, model of confluent tissue, Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 058001 Sci. Adv. 3, e1700969 (2017). (2018). [7] M. E. Cates, J. P. Wittmer, J.-P. Bouchaud, and [27] M. Merkel, K. Baumgarten, B. P. Tighe, and M. L. P. Claudin, Jamming, force chains, and fragile matter, Manning, A minimal-length approach unifies rigidity in Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 1841 (1998). underconstrained materials, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 116, [8] D. Bi, B. Charkraborty, and R. P. Behringer, Jamming 6560 (2019). by shear, Nature 480, 355–358 (2011). [28] X. Wang, M. Merkel, L. B. Sutter, G. Erdemci- [9] T. Bertrand, R. P. Behringer, B. Chakraborty, C. S. TandoganBaumgarten, M. L. Manning, and K. E. Kasza, O’Hern, and M. D. Shattuck, Protocol dependence of the Anisotropy links cell shapes to tissue flow during conver- jamming transition, Phys. Rev. E 93, 012901 (2016). gent extension, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 117, 13541–13551 [10] D. Wang, J. Ren, J. A. Dijksman, H. Zheng, and R. P. (2020). Behringer, Microscopic origins of shear jamming for 2d [29] M. Merkel and M. L. Manning, A geometrically con- frictional grains, Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 208004 (2018). trolled rigidity transition in a model for confluent 3d tis- [11] R. Seto, A. Singh, B. Chakraborty, M. M. Denn, and J. F. sues, New J. Phys. 20, 022002 (2018). Morris, Shear jamming and fragility in dense suspensions, [30] A. Boromand, A. Signoriello, F. Ye, C. S. O’Hern, and Granul. Matter 21, 82 (2019). M. D. Shattuck, Jamming of deformable polygons, Phys. [12] T. Unger, J. T¨or¨ok, J. Kert´esz, and D. E. Wolf, Shear Rev. Lett. 121, 248003 (2018). band formation in granular media as a variational prob- [31] A. Boromand, A. Signoriello, J. Lowensohn, C. S. Orel- lem, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 214301 (2004). lana, E. R. Weeks, F. Ye, M. D. Shattuck, and C. S. [13] P. C. F. Møller, S. Rodts, M. A. J. Michels, and D. Bonn, O’Hern, The role of deformability in determining the Shear banding and yield stress in soft glassy materials, structural and mechanical properties of bubbles and Phys. Rev. E 77, 041507 (2008). emulsions, Soft Matter 15, 5854 (2019). [14] G. Ovarlez and P. Coussot, Physical age of soft-jammed [32] J. D. Treado, D. Wang, A. Boromand, M. P. Murrell, systems, Phys. Rev. E 76, 011406 (2007). M. D. Shattuck, and C. S. O’Hern, Bridging particle de- [15] A. Shahin and Y. M. Joshi, Prediction of long and short formability and collective response in soft solids, Phys. time rheological behavior in soft glassy materials, Phys. Rev. Materials 5, 055605 (2021). Rev. Lett. 106, 038302 (2011). [33] O. K. Damavandi, V. F. Hagh, C. D. Santangelo, and [16] D. Esp´ındola, B. Galaz, and F. Melo, Ultrasound induces M. L. Manning, Energetic rigidity: a unifying the- aging in granular materials, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 158301 ory of mechanical stability, arXiv preprint:2102.11310 (2012). https://arxiv.org/abs/2102.11310 (2021), arXiv:arXiv [17] F. Bonacci, X. Chateau, E. M. Furst, J. Fusier, J. Goyon, preprint:2102.11310. and A. Lemaˆıtre, Contact and macroscopic ageing in col- [34] P. Charbonneau, E. I. Corwin, G. Parisi, and F. Zam- loidal suspensions, Nat. Mater. 19, 775–780 (2020). poni, Jamming criticality revealed by removing local- [18] D. Fiocco, G. Foffi, and S. Sastry, Encoding of memory in ized buckling excitations, Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 125504 sheared amorphous solids, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 025702 (2015). (2014). [35] E. Bitzek, P. Koskinen, F. G¨ahler, M. Moseler, and [19] J. R. Royer and P. M. Chaikin, Precisely cyclic sand: P. Gumbsch, Structural relaxation made simple, Phys. Self-organization of periodically sheared frictional grains, Rev. Lett. 97, 170201 (2006). Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 112, 49 (2015). [36] M. Bevis and G. Cambareri, Computing the area of a [20] N. Pashine, D. Hexner, A. J. Liu, and S. R. Nagel, Di- spherical polygon of arbitrary shape, Phys. Rev. Lett. rected aging, memory, and nature’s greed, Sci. Adv. 5, 19, 335 (1987). aax4215 (2019). [37] L. Silbert, Jamming of frictional spheres and random loose packing, Soft Matter 6, 2918 (2010). 16 [38] P. A. Cundall and O. D. L. Strack, A discrete numeri- [50] L. E. Silbert, A. J. Liu, and S. R. Nagel, Normal modes in cal model for granular assemblies, G´eotechnique 29, 47 model jammed systems in three dimensions, Phys. Rev. (1979). E 79, 021308 (2009). [39] G. R. Farrell, K. M. Martini, and N. Menon, Loose pack- [51] N. Xu, V. Vitelli, A. J. Liu, and S. R. Nagel, Anharmonic ings of frictional spheres, Soft Matter 6, 2925 (2010). and quasi-localized vibrations in jammed solids – modes [40] A. Donev, R. Connelly, F. H. Stillinger, and S. Torquato, for mechanical failure, EPL 90, 56001 (2010). Underconstrained jammed packings of nonspherical hard [52] K. VanderWerf, A. Boromand, M. D. Shattuck, and C. S. particles: Ellipses and ellipsoids, Phys. Rev. E 75, 051304 O’Hern, Pressure dependent shear response of jammed (2007). packings of frictionless spherical particles, Phys. Rev. [41] Y. Yuan, K. VanderWerf, M. D. Shattuck, and C. S. Lett. 124, 038004 (2020). O’Hern, Jammed packings of 3d superellipsoids with tun- [53] C. P. Goodrich, A. J. Liu, and S. R. Nagel, Finite-size able packing fraction, coordination number, and order- scaling at the jamming transition, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, ing, Soft Matter 15, 9751 (2019). 095704 (2012). [42] G. W. Delaney, J. E. Hilton, and P. W. Cleary, Defining [54] E. Somfai, M. van Hecke, W. G. Ellenbroek, random loose packing for nonspherical grains, Phys. Rev. K. Shundyak, and W. van Saarloos, Critical and non- E 83, 051305 (2011). critical jamming of frictional grains, Phys. Rev. E 75, [43] H. A. Makse, D. L. Johnson, and L. M. Schwartz, Packing 020301 (2007). of compressible granular materials, Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, [55] J. Zhang, K. VanderWerf, C. Li, S. Zhang, M. D. Shat- 4160 (2000). tuck, and C. S. O’Hern, Mechanical response of pack- [44] M. Mailman, C. F. Schreck, C. S. O’Hern, and ings of nonspherical particles: A case study of two- B. Chakraborty, Jamming in systems composed of fric- dimensional packings of circulo-lines, Phys. Rev. E 104, tionless ellipse-shaped particles, Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 014901 (2021). 255501 (2009). [56] A. K. Omar, K. Klymko, T. GrandPre, and P. L. Geissler, [45] C. F. Schreck, M. Mailman, B. Chakraborty, and C. S. Phase diagram of active brownian spheres: Crystalliza- O’Hern, Constraints and vibrations in static packings of tion and the metastability of motility-induced phase sep- ellipsoidal particles, Phys. Rev. E 85, 061305 (2012). aration, Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 188002 (2021). [46] K. VanderWerf, W. Jin, M. D. Shattuck, and C. S. [57] S. Lloyd, Least squares quantization in pcm, IEEE Trans- O’Hern, Hypostatic jammed packings of frictionless non- actions on Information Theory 28, 129 (1982). spherical particles, Phys. Rev. E 97, 012909 (2018). [58] Z. Mei, J. D. Treado, A. T. Grigas, Z. A. Levine, L. Re- [47] S. Papanikolaou, C. S. O’Hern, and M. D. Shattuck, Iso- gan, and C. S. O’Hern, Analyses of protein cores re- staticity at frictional jamming, Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, veal fundamental differences between solution and crystal 198002 (2013). structures, Proteins 88, 1154 (2020). [48] C. Brito, H. Ikeda, P. Urbani, M. Wyart, and F. Zam- [59] M. P. Allen and D. J. Tildesley, Computer Simulation of poni, Universality of jamming of nonspherical particles, Liquids, 2nd ed. (Oxford University Press, 2017). Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 115, 11736 (2018). [60] F. M. Schaller, S. C. Kapfer, M. E. Evans, [49] Z. Zeravcic, N. Xu, A. J. Liu, S. R. Nagel, and W. van M. J. Hoffmann, T. Aste, M. Saadatfar, K. Mecke, Saarloos, Excitations of ellipsoid packings near jamming, G. W. Delaney, and G. E. Schr¨oder-Turk, Set EPL 87, 26001 (2009). voronoi diagrams of 3d assemblies of aspherical particles, Philosophical Magazine 93, 3993 (2013), https://doi.org/10.1080/14786435.2013.834389.