Contents

Memorial Statement

'~~OJ. The Sound ofthe Sun, A Eulogy DANIEL GOLDSTEIN 1 in memory of my beloved father Dr. Leon J. Goldstein, ?~~l

Articles

Methodological Shuttle-Cocking: JEFFREY J. CORMIER 9 Or, Gellner Constructs A Non-Relativist Program for the Sociology of Knowledge

Depend UponMyWord ROGER w. GIBSON 37

Putnam and the Difficulty of MICHAEL HYMERS 55 Renouncing All Theory

The Problem of Beginning Hegel's SIMON LUMSDEN 83 Phenomenology and Seience ofLogic

An Intemalist Rejoinder to Skepticism GREG TEN ELSHOF 105

Kaspar Hauser: Crossing the Boundaries RICHARD WHlTE 115 of Humanity and History

Note

Circular Reasoning D. GOLDSTICK 129

Reviews

ADAMS, E. M., A Society Fit RAYMOND ANGELO BELLIOTII 131 for Human Beings ADDIS, M., Wittgenstein: Making ROM HARRE 132 Sense ofOther Minds ALLAN, JAMES, A Sceptical Theory of PETER SUBER 134 Morality and Law ALLISON, HENRY E., Idealism and Freedom: SIDNEY AXINN 135 Essays on Kant's Theoretical and Practical ANNAS, JULIA, Platonic Ethics, Old and New J. J. MULHERN 137 ApPEL, FREDERICK, Nietzsehe WERNERJ. DANNHAUSER 139 Contra Democracy ARDEN,JOHNBOGHOSIAN, Science, F.J. LICHTIGFELD 140 Theology, and Consciousness: The Search for Unity ARIEw,ROGER, Descartes and the RICHARDA. WATSON 141 Last Scholastics ARNHART, LARRY, Darwinian Natural Right: MICHAEL RUSE 142 The Biological Ethics ofHuman Nature ARTIGAS, MARIANO, The Ethical Nature of I. C. JARVIE 144 Karl Popper's Theory ofKnowledge AUDI, ROBERT, Moral Knowledge and REM B. EDWARDS 145 Ethical Character BABBfIT, SUSAN E., Impossible Dreams AUTHOR UNKNOWN 146 BABICH, BABETTE E., Nietzsche's JONATHAN R. COHEN 148 Philosophy ofScience: RefLecting Science on the Ground ofArt and Life BAILEY, LEON, JOSEPH D. LEWANDOWSKI 149 and the Sociology ofKnowledge: A Comparative Study in the Theory ofIdeology BALZER, WOLFGANG,ANDCHRISM. MICHAEL RUSE 151 DAWE, Models for Genetics BATNITZKY, LEORA, Idolatry and ALLAN ARKUSH 153 Representation: The Philosophy of Franz Rosenzweig Reconsidered BERGOFFEN, DEBRA B., The Philosophy SONIAKRUKS 154 Of : Gendered Phenomenologies, Erotic Generosities BERKOWITZ, PETER, Nietzehe: The Ethics PAUL FAIRFIELD 156 ofan Immoralist BERLIN, ISAIAH, The Roots ofRomanticism MARTIN BIDNEY 158 BEST, STEVEN, AND DOUGLAS KELLNER, MARK-NELSON The Postmodern Turn YOUNGERMAN 159 BIRD, ALEXANDER, Thomas Kuhn RUPERT READ 162 BIRDWHISTELL, ANNE D., Li Yong JOHN BERTHONG 164 (1627-1705) and Epistemological Dimensions ofConfucian Philosophy BITBOL, MICHAEL, Schrödinger's HENRY J. FOLSE 165 Philosophy ofQuantum Mechanics BLACK, DAVID W., Vico and Moral Perception LEONPOMPA 167 BLATTNER, WILLIAM D., Heidegger's CHARLES GUIGNON 168 Temporal Idealism BOBZIEN, SUZANNE, Determinism and NAOMI G. COHEN 170 Freedom in Stoic Philosophy BOISVERT, RAYMOND D., lohn Dewey: MICHAEL ELDRIDGE 172 Rethinking Gur Time BONSIEPEN, WOLFGANG, Die KARL-NORBERT IHMIG 173 Begründung einer Naturphilosophie bei Kant, Schelling, Fries und Hegel. Mathematische versus spekulative Naturphilosophie BOONIN-VAIL, DAVID, Thomas Hobbes RICHARDA. TALASKA 175 and the Science ofMoral Virtue BRENNER, WILLIAM H., Wittgenstein's ROM HARRE 177 Philosophical Investigations BROOKS, E. BRUCE, AND A. TAEKO BROOKS, LISA RAPHALS 179 The Original Analects: Sayings of Confucius and His Successors BRUDNEY, DANIEL, Marx's Attempt TOM ROCKMORE 180 to Leave Philosophy BUKDAHL, J0RGEN, Seren Kierkegaard ROBERT L. PERKINS 181 and the Common Man BURK, KATHLEEN, Troublemaker: The Life MELVIN C. SHEFFTZ 182 and History ofA. J. P. Taylor BURNYEAT, MYLES, AND MICHAEL TERENCE PENELHUM 184 FREDE, eds., The Original Sceptics: A Controversey CALHOUN, CRAIG, AND JOHN AUTHOR UNKNOWN 185 MCGowAN, eds., and the Meaning ofPolitics CARAWAY,JAMESE., Reflection on THOMASJAYOORD 188 Whitehead's Philosophical Theology CARTWRIGHT, NANCY, The Dappled World RONALD N. GIERE 189 CASSIRER, ERNST, The Philosophy of SEYMOUR W. ITZKOFF 190 Symbolic Forms. Val. 4, The Metaphysics ofSymbolic Forms CAUCHI, FRANCESCA, ROBERT GOODING-WILLIAMS 192 Zarathustra Contra Zarathustra CHAPPELL, T. D. J., Aristotle and JEAN BETHKE EISHTAIN 193 Augustine on Freedom CHIHARA, C. 5., The Worlds ofPossibility: M. J. CRESSWELL 194 Modal Realism and the Semantics of Modal Logic CLAYTON, PHILIPD., God and JOHN J. COMPTON 196 Contemporary Science COHEN, NAOMI G., Philo Judaeus: JOHNDILLON 197 His Universe ofDiscourse CONWAY, DANIELJ., Nietzsche's STANLEY ROSEN 198 Dangerous Game: Philosophy in the Twilight ofthe Idols COOK, DEBORAH, The Culture lOHN DURHAM PETERS 200 Industry Revisited: Theodor W. Adorno on Mass Culture COOK, ROGER F., By the Rivers of MARTIN BIDNEY 201 Babyion: Heinrich Heine's Late Songs and Reflections COOPER, LAURENCE D., Rousseau, TIMOTHY O'HAGAN 202 Nature, and the Problem ofthe Good Life COUTURE, JOCEYLNE AND KAI NIELSEN, eds., JOHNT. WILCOX 204 On the Relevance ofMetaethics: New Essays on Metaethics CRANSTON, MAURICE, The Solitary Self- HARVEY CHISICK 206 Jean-Jacques Rousseau in Exile and Adversity CRESSWELL, DENNIS R., St. Augustine's WILLIAM E. MURNION 207 Dilemma: Grace and Eternal Law in the Major Works ofAugustine ofHippo CURD, PATRICIA, The Legacy of ALEXANDER NEHAMAS 209 Parmenides: Eleatic Monism and Later Presocratic Thought CURRAN, NOEL, The Logical Universe: HAROLD I. BROWN 210 The Real Universe CUTROFELLO, ANDREW, Imagining SIDNEY AXINN 212 Otherwise, Metapsychology and the Analytic APosteriori D'AGOSTINO, FRED AND GERALD DAVIDSCHULTZ 213 F. GAUS, eds., Public Reason DASENBROCK, REED WAY, MARK-NELSON YOUNGERMAN 215 Truth and Consequences: Intentions, Conventions, and the New Thematics DAVIS, STEPHENT., God, Reason TERENCE PENELHUM 217 and Theistic Proofs HELM, P AUL, Faith and Understanding DAVIS, STEPHEN T., ed., Philosophy THOMASJ.J.ALTIZER 219 and Theological Discourse DE BARY, W. M. THEODORE AND DALE MAURICE RIEPE 220 Tu WEIMING, eds., Confucianism and Human Rights DEJNOZKA, JAN, The Ontology ofthe JACK KAMINSKY 221 Analytic Tradition and fts Origins DERRIDA, JACQUES AND GIANNI MARK CAUCHI 223 VATTIMO, Religion DES CHENE, DENNIS, Spirits and RICHARDA. WATSON 225 Clocks: Machine and Organism in Descartes DEWEY, JOHN, Principles ofInstrumental BRUCE KUKLICK 226 Logic: John Dewey's Lectures in Ethics and Political Ethics, 1895-1896 paPP, JEROME A., Naturalizing Philosophy ofEducation: John Dewey in the Postanalytic Period DOMBROWSKI, DANIEL A., Analytical JOHN B. COBB, JR. 228 Theism, Hartshorne, and the Concept ofGod DRAY, WILLIAM H., History as Re-enactment L. B. CEBIK 229 DRURY, SHADIA B., MICHAEL P. ZUCKERT 231 and the American Right DRYZEK, JOHN S., Deliberative Democracy DAVID SCHULTZ 233 and Beyond: Liberals, Critics, Contestations DU BOIS MARCUS, NANCY, Vico and Plato LEON paMPA 234 DWORKIN, RONALD, RAYMOND ANGELO BELLIOTTI 236 Freedom's Law EHRING, DOUGLAS, JERROLD L. ARONSON 237 Causation and Persistence ELKEN, STEPHEN L. AND CAROL DAVID SCHULTZ 239 EDWARDSOLTAN, eds., Citizen Competence and Democratic Institutions EVERSON, STEPHEN, Aristotle on DEBORAH K. w. MODRAK 241 Perception FAIRBANKS, SANDRAJANE, Kantian Moral JOHNSILBER 242 Theory and the Destruction ofthe Self GUEVARA, DANIEL, Kant's Theory ofMoral Motivation FELDMAN, FRED, Utilitarianism, HENRY R. WEST 244 Hedonism, and Desert FENDT, GENE AND DAVID ROZEMA, J. J. MULHERN 245 Platonic Errors: Plato, a Kind ofPoet FINOCCHIARO, MAURICE A., Beyond Right TONYSMITH 247 and Left: Democratic Elitism in Mosca and Gramsci FORSTER, MICHAEL N., Hegel's Idea JOHN W. BURBIDGE 248 ofa Phenomenology ofSpirit FRIEDLANDER, ELI, Signs ofSense: MICHAEL A. TISSAW 250 Reading Wittgenstein's Tractatus FRITSCHE, JOHANNES, Historical ALAN MILCHMAN 251 Destiny and National Socialism AND ALAN ROSENBERG in Heidegger's Being and Time GALLOIS, ANDRE, Occasions ofIdentity: BEDERUNDLE 253 The Metaphysics ofPersistence, Change, and Sameness GARBER, DANIEL AND MICHAEL RICHARDA. WATSON 254 A YER5, eds., The Cambridge History of Seventeenth-Century Philosophy GARBER, DANIEL, Descartes's Embodied: RICHARD A. WATSON 258 Reading Cartesian Philosophy Through Cartesian Science GAUKROGER, STEPHEN, Francis Bacon HARRY M. BRACKEN 259 and the Transformation of Early-Modern Philosophy GEFWERT, CHRISTOFFER, Wittgenstein MICHAEL A. TISSAW 261 on Thought, Language and Philosophy: From Theory to Therapy GELLNER, ERNEST, Language and RII< PINXTEN 262 Solitude. Wittgenstein-Malinowski and the Habsburg Dilemma GENNARO, RoccoJ. AND CHARLES RICHARD A. WATSON 264 HEUNEMANN, eds., New Essays on the Rationalists GOLDMAN, ALVINI., MICHAEL MARTIN 266 Knowledge in a Social World GONZALEZ, FRANCISCO, Dialectic and JACOB HOWLAND 267 Dialogue: Plato's Practice 0/ Philosophical Inquiry GRANT, RUTH W., Hypocrisy and TIMOTHY O'HAGAN 269 Integrity: Machiavelli, Rousseau, and the Ethics 0/Politics GRANT,EDwARD,Godand ANDREW S. CUNNINGHAM 271 Reason in the Middle Ages HAACK, SUSAN, Manifesto 0/a JACK KAMINSKY 273 Passionate Moderate HAHN, LEWIS E., ed., The Philosophy 0/ ROM HARRE 274 P. F. Strawson HALBERSTAM, MICHAEL, DAVID SCHULTZ 276 & the Modern Conception 0/Politics HAMILTON, RICHARD F., The Social ANTONY FLEW 278 Misconstruction 0/Reality: Validityand Verification in the Scholarly Community HARDIN, CLYDE L. AND LUISA H. STEPHEN STRAIGHT 279 MAFFI, eds., Color Categories in Thought and Language HARRIS, GEORGE W., Agent-centered FELICITAS MUNZEL 282 Morality. An Aristotelian Alternative to Kantian Internalism HARRIS, MARVIN, Theories 0/Culture RIK PINXTEEN 285 in Postmodern Times HARTSHORNE, CHARLES, The Zero Fallacy JOHNT. WILCOX 286 and Essays in Neoclassical Philosophy HARTSOCK, NANCY C. M., The Feminist TABOR FISHER 287 5tandpoint Revisited and Other Essays HARVEY, WARREN ZEV, Physics and MANACHEM KELLNER 289 Metaphysics in Hasdai Crescas HARVEY, VAN A., Feuerbach and the ROBERT L. PERKINS 291 Interpretation o[ Religion HAUSMAN, DAVIDANDALAN RICHARDA. WATSON 292 HAUSMAN, Descartes's Legacy: Minds and Meaning in Early Modern Philosophy HAYES, JULIE CHANDLER, Reading the HARVEY CHISICK 294 French Enlightenment: System and Subversion HEDLEY, DOUGLAS, Coleridge, Philosophy MARTIN BIDNEY 295

and Religion: 11Aids to Reflection" and the Mirror o[ the Spirit HENKEL, JACQUELINE, MARK-NELSON YOUNGERMAN 296 The Language o[ Criticism HERSH, REUBEN, What is CHARLES F. KIELKOPF 298 Mathematics Really HEYD, DAVID, ed., Toleration: WALTERS. WURZBURGER 299 An Elusive Virtue HOOPES, JAMES, Community Denied: BRUCE KUKLICK 301 The Wrong Turn o[ Pragmatic Liberalism HURSTHOUSE, ROSALIND, On Virtue Ethics TED LOCKHART 303 HUTCHINSON, BRIAN, G. E. Moore's PANAYOTBUTCHVAROV 304 Ethical Theory: Resistance and Reconciliation JENKINSON, SALLY L., Pierre Bayle: HARRY M. BRACKEN 306 Political Writings JOLLEY, NICHOLAS, ed., The Cambridge JOHN KRONEN 307 Companion to Leibniz KEKES, JOHN, Against Liberalism CARL COHEN 310 KELLER, PIERRE, Husserl and FRANK SCHALOW 312 Heidegger on Human Experience KELLY, EUGENE, Structure and Diversity, PHlLlP BLOSSER 313 Studies in the Phenomenological Philosophy ofMax Scheler KLOSSOWSKl, PIERRE, Nietzsche DOUGLAS KELLNER 315 and the Vicious Circle WAlTE, GEOFF, Nietzsche's Corpse/e KOERTGE, NORETTA, ed. A House Built JOHN T. WlLCOX 318 on Sand: Exposing Postmodernist Myths about Science KRAMER, MATTHEW H., Hobbes and MARTlN A. BERTMAN 319 the Paradoxes ofPolitical Origins KORSGAARD, CHRlSTlNE M., Creating SlDNEY AXlNN 321 the Kingdom ofEnds KUEHN, MANFRED, Kant: A Biography ALLENWOOD 323 LACOUR, CLAUDlA BRODSKY, RICHARD A. WATSON 325 Lines ofThought: Discourse, Architectonics, and the Origin 0/Modern Philosophy LAlDLAW-JOHNSON, ELlZABETH A., MARY MULHERN 326 Plato's Epistemology: How Hard Is 1t to Know? LAMB, DAVID, ed., Hegel JONMAHONEY 328 LANGAN, THOMAS, Being and Truth FREDERICK SONTAG 331 LEAHY, D. G., Foundation: Matter THOMAS J. J. ALTlZER 332 the Body 1tself LEHRER, KElTH, Self-Trust: A Study of PAULK. MOSER 334 Reason, Knowledge, and Autonomy LENNON, THOMAS H., Reading Bayle HARRY M. BRACKEN 336 LENNOX, JAMES G., Aristotle's ANTHONY PREUS 338 Philosophy ofBiology: Studies in the Origins ofthe Life Sciences LETSON, BEN H., Davidson's PANAYOTBUTCHVAROV 339 Theory ofTruth and Its 1mplications for Rorty's Pragmatism LEVESQUE, PAULJ., Symbols of THOMASJ. J. ALTIZER 340 Transcendence: Religious Expression in the Thought ofLouis Dupre LONGUENESSE, BEATRICE, Kant and the SIDNEY AXINN 341 Capacity to ]udge: Sensibilityand Discursivity in the Transcendental Analytic ofthe Critique ofPure Reason Low-BEER, F. H., Questions of ROBERT HALLBORG, JR. 342 ]udgment: Determining What's Right LÖWITH, KARL, Nietzsche's Philosophy ROBIN SMALL 344 ofthe Eternal Recurrence ofthe Same MACDoNALD, P AUL S., Descartes and FRED KERSTEN 345 Husserl: The Philosophical Project ofRadical Beginnings MACHAMER, PETER, ed., The MAURICE A. FINOCCIARO ·346 CambridgeCompanion to Galileo MACINTYRE, ALASDAIR, Dependent ARTHUR R. MILLER 349 Rational Beings: Why I-Iuman Beings Need the Virtues MADDY, PENELOPE, Naturalism in Mathematics NEIL TENNANT 351 MALEBRANCHE, NICOLAS, The Search STEVEN NADLER 352 After Truth MALEBRANCHE, NICOLAS, Dialogues on Metaphysics and Religion MANN, WOLFGANG-RAINER, CHRISTOSC. EVANGELIOU 353 The Discovery ofThings: Aristotle's Categories and their Context MARION, JEAN-Luc, Reduction and JEFFREY A. BELL 356 Givenness: Investigations ofHusserl, Heidegger, and Phenomenology MARTIN, MIKE W., Meaningful Work: JON MAHONEY 358 Rethinking Professional Ethics MATTHEWS, PATRICIA M., RICHARD E. AQUILA 359 The Signijicance ofBeauty: Kant on Feeling and the System ofthe Mind MAXWELL, NICHOLAS, OLIVER A. JOHNSON 360 The Comprehensibility ofthe Universe: A New Conception MAY, TODD, Reconsidering EVANSELINGER 361 MAYERFIELD, JAMIE, Suffering JOSHUA GLASGOW 363 and Moral Responsibility MAZZOTTA, GIUSEPPE, The New Map LEON POMPA 364 ofthe World: The Poetic Philosophy ofGiambattista Vico McFARLANE, ADRIAN ANTHONY, NICHOLAS F. GIER 365 A Grammar ofFear and Evil: A Husserlian-Wittgensteinian Hermeneutic MCGEE, GLENN, ed. Pragmatic Bioethics STUART G. FINDER 367 MCGINN, MARIE, Wittgenstein and the ROM HARRE 370 Philosophical Investigations MCPHERRAN, MARK L., The Religion AUTHOR UNKNOWN 372 ofSocrates MENDOLA,JOSEPH, Human Thought PANAYOTBUTCHVAROV 373 MILES, MURRAY, Insight and Inference: RICHARDA. WATSON 374 Descartes's Founding Principle and Modern Philosophy MILLER, ALEXANDER, Philosophy ofLanguage JACK KAMINSKY 376 MILLER, DAVID, Critical Rationalism: HAROLD I. BROWN 378 ARestatement and Defense MISAK, C. J., Verificationism JACK KAMINSKY 379 MORGENSTERN, MIRA, Rousseau and HARVEY CHISICK 381 the Politics ofAmbiguity: Self, Culture, and Society Contributors 383