IT’STELECOMMUNICATIONS OUR OPINION... INSIGHT SHARED SERVICES WINTER 2008

Wholesale MOBILE The conventional view of the mobile virtual network operator is out of date. Service providers that buy wholesale minutes at a discount price and sell no- frills telephony and to price sensitive customers are finding it hard to survive. This old guard will soon be superseded by virtual operators whose business models come from the world of internet services.

Problematic partnerships attribute the failures to bad marketing AUTHOR The wholesale channel for mobile and poor business decisions by individual network operators is open and growing, companies? Or were they due to viability but it is riddled with problems. problems with the MVNO business model itself? Industry analysts highlight the increasing value of the mobile virtual network The impact of MVNO partnerships on operator (MVNO) business. Yankee the network operator needs careful Group projects that MVNO services in analysis as well. Even the best wholesale the US will produce revenues of $10.7 plan can cause conflicts of interest. The billion by 2010 and attract 29 million scale and growth potential of this subscribers, although a small elite of business makes the operators keen to

first-tier companies will account for compete for new contracts. almost 80 per cent of this market. On both sides of the Atlantic, however, The UK wholesale market alone will be Duncan Stewart is an industry prominent MVNOs have failed, raising worth about £1 billion this year and could consultant working in the 1 telecommunications team of our questions about the sustainability of double in value by 2012 . Choosing the business transformation group. businesses that do not own a mobile wrong MVNO strategy can, however, His expertise includes strategy infrastructure but market themselves as damage an operator’s overall business. and marketing, value propositions independent service providers. and business development. He is The costs of building and managing an particularly interested in infrastructure to support MVNOs are innovation and R&D from both In theory, this business model makes business model and technology economic sense for both the MVNO and high and operators might never recover the network operator. Virtual players their investments. Furthermore, MVNOs perspectives and regularly works with Fujitsu Laboratories on usually target niche segments of the that offer standard voice and SMS technology futures. community that the incumbents find services exacerbate the industry’s difficult to reach, thus generating traffic problems with customer churn and the Outside of the office Duncan is often found on the rugby pitch and revenue streams that would not downward pressures on pricing and or supporting his favourite team, otherwise exist. The reality today, average revenue per user (ARPU). the Leicester Tigers. particularly in western Europe, is far Operators need to evaluate the potential from harmonious. Most MVNOs are impact of resellers on their core business; [email protected] struggling and the operators face a toxic co-ordinating their wholesale and retail

combination of business cannibalisation, packages is a major challenge.

market saturation and economic

downturn. As they weigh up the opportunities

1 http://www.mobilenewscwp.co.uk/News/97108 against these risks, it is also vital for /uk_networks_ramp_up_mvno_activities.html Hundreds of MVNOs have designed and operators to understand how the MVNO launched new services, but very few market is going to change. stand out as true success stories. Can we

TELECOMMUNICATIONS INSIGHT

SHARED SERVICES Understanding success and failure Other MVNOs, however, have survived In the early years of this decade, when and grown by targeting specific social the hype around the MVNO model was at categories. These successes include a peak, it was widely believed that niche Labara Mobile and , which branding would become the best way to specialise in telephony and SMS services attract and retain subscribers on mobile for ethnic groups, and Blyk whose pan- networks. What actually happened was European service targets young people that early MVNOs, such as Virgin who are willing to view in Mobile and Tracfone, saw that the pre- exchange for free minutes and texts. paid business was still relatively untapped and took advantage of this gap In general, though, it has become in the market before the network increasingly difficult for any MVNO to operators ramped up their own pre-paid compete against the major operators in offerings. Virgin Mobile, which launched basic voice and SMS services. The in 1999, was the world’s first MVNO and spread of flat rate voice and data plans, became the most successful in both the not only for post-pay but also for pre- US and Europe. Many others tried to paid services, has strengthened the hand emulate its business model, but failed to of the network operators. MVNOs, establish a significant market presence. whose costs are determined by the wholesale price of the minutes that they MVNOs proliferated in the Nordic buy, cannot compete with the all-you- countries before they appeared in other can-eat telephony tariffs. Furthermore, markets. The new entrants differentiated the network operators are better placed to their services by cutting voice and text secure the most popular handsets and can prices and took customers away from the negotiate better terms with the suppliers. established operators. The net result was The volumes at which MVNOs trade are considerable decline in ARPU and falling seldom high enough to get the OEMs share values across the industry. Stability excited. was restored after most of the leading MVNOs were acquired by network As we move into a new era of wireless operators2. communications it is clear that the traditional MVNO model is flawed. Japan proved to be an easier environment Voice is now a saturated market and for MVNOs, partly because they met a reselling bulk minutes is no longer rising demand for data services and economically viable. MVNOs are partly because there were only two therefore moving away from mobile operators that could act as conventional telecommunications and wholesalers. into activities that look more like internet services. The US climate was much harsher. New MVNOs such as Helio and Amp’d promised to be different by concentrating on value added applications and content- based services. Subscriber numbers for both have come in well under forecast leading to substantial losses. Even

Disney, one of the biggest brands in the

world, tried to penetrate the US mobile

market through two separate initiatives; 3 both attempts ended in closure .

2 http://www.ofcom.org.uk/research/cm/interim/ feb06_report/comms_mkt.pdf

3 http://www.moconews.net/entry/419-disney- mobile-closingsecond- disney-mvno-to-shutter-wdig-will-explore-l/]

TELECOMMUNICATIONS INSIGHT

SHARED SERVICES Opportunities for MVNOs download any of 88,000 book titles from Most of the emerging opportunities for its store in less than one minute to a MVNOs involve data services or Kindle user in any location with cellular machine-to-machine (M2M) coverage. communications. New handset types such as the iPhone, coupled with faster speeds A second cluster is emerging around and quality improvements on the medical services. Qualcomm has networks, have accelerated the demand announced the launch of an MVNO, for mobile data delivery and are paving LifeComm, that will to help individuals the way for more vertical market to live with conditions like diabetes, services. Wireless M2M applications asthma and heart disease. The company have advanced beyond the early metering describes its service as a ‘virtual nurse’ applications that required only a low data that will evaluate various bio- rate and now support services like real- measurements, assist users to comply time video surveillance and medical with prescribed treatments and provide monitoring. The compound average advice and information when they are annual growth rate for M2M services in needed. Europe now stands at 42.9 per cent and Wireless applications are already making forecasts suggest that this rapid expansion will continue4. an impact in transport management and

additional services are under

The introduction of information devices development. Navigation equipment

that connect to the internet through supplier TomTom, for example, plans to wireless networks supports the long term become an MVNO in order to deliver progression towards cloud computing. In traffic updates and other data to its GPS- ten years time all networks will be enabled devices. This cluster will also ubiquitous, high-speed and IP-based. include integrated reservations for public From a user perspective this will mean transport and ‘smart city’ applications the replacement of items like cash, keys that control traffic lights and street and loyalty cards with connected devices. cameras. The automotive industry, For the MVNO, cloud computing meanwhile, is working on wireless presents opportunities to develop new communications services to reduce the types of service and to experiment with risks of collision, alerting drivers to alternative business models. potential dangers or even taking control of the braking systems on their cars5. New trendsetters are starting to appear. Internet retailer Amazon.com, in-car The advance of wireless data services is navigation systems vendor TomTom and also producing a cluster of companies mobile messaging infrastructure service that will provide operational support to provider mBlox have entered the wireless the mobile applications industry. The services arena from very different trendsetter here is mBlox, which directions, but each is now the most originally offered transmission and prominent player in an emerging cluster financial settlement services for text of mobile applications. messaging and has now positioned itself as a transactions management

One such cluster focuses on high-speed intermediary between mobile service

content delivery. Amazon has negotiated operators and mobile content providers.

an MVNO agreement with Sprint to This company, which runs network

support its Kindle device – a portable management centres in North America, reader that downloads books, blogs, Europe and Asia-Pacific, has thus emerged as a mobile virtual network magazines and newspapers to a crisp, high-resolution display that looks and enabler (MVNE), pioneering a business

reads like real paper. Sprint’s EVDO model that should also be considered by

4 Ref. Berg Insight cellular network enables Amazon to the major operators.

5 http://www.ofcom.org.uk/media/news/ 2008/05/nr_20080507

TELECOMMUNICATIONS INSIGHT

SHARED SERVICES

Strategies for operators Both approaches reduce the operator’s

The future prospects for the mobile capital expenditure but preserve the operators’ wholesale divisions will not ability to differentiate its offering for only depend on their ability to select MVNOs by delivering a different service suitable MVNOs from an increasingly class or basket to each partner. diverse population. We believe that the design and management of their network Platform outsourcing projects are enablement platforms will also be critical underway inside single countries, with a to success. Different operators are systems integrator managing the MVNE looking at this challenge in different infrastructure and delivering back office ways. services like billing and customer care. These resources can be scaled up to Platform investments will be costly and support pan-European partnerships, the operators should look for economies multiple MVNOs that operate in different of scale. This will probably mean clusters and an end user population that building a pan-European infrastructure ranges from individuals to large instead of introducing resources on a metropolitan authorities. country-by-country basis. Investment sharing can also make the MVNE model Operators can and will share the rewards economically viable. Radio Area of growing the new MVNO markets, but Network infrastructure agreements have they must look far beyond the price of demonstrated the commercial advantages wholesale minutes. Success will come of this principle and it is just as from careful and appropriate investments, applicable to network enablement. selecting the right partners and an in- depth knowledge of the new market Mobile operators should therefore choose dynamics. between two strategic options. They can either build one central platform to support a range of MVNOs in multiple countries or they can combine their resources and negotiate joint platform outsourcing arrangements with a systems integrator. The outsourcing option has the additional advantage of stronger data protection, as long as the systems integrator ensures that operators and MVNOs are never given access to information about their competitors.

Duncan would welcome your comments by email ([email protected]) or at uk.fujitsu.com/opinion

Fujitsu Services Limited, Registered in England no 96056, Registered Office: 22 Baker Street, , W1U 3BW Copyright © Fujitsu Services Limited 2008. All rights reserved. No part of this document may be reproduced, stored or transmitted in any form without the prior written permission of Fujitsu Services Ltd. Fujitsu Services endeavours to ensure that the information in this document is correct and fairly stated, but does not accept liability for any errors or omissions.