Studying the early history af life in Greenland

John S. Peel

Exceptionally preserved of soft-bodied animais animais ranging from , which dominate the have always aroused particular interest within the geol­ collections both in terms of the abundance of species ogical community. Not only do they supply anatomical and individuals, to sponges and bizarre fossils which can information not usually preserved, but they also provide not be accommodated within current schemes of classi­ insights into the structure of the living communities fication. Many of these fossils preserve exquisite details which are difficult to obtain from fossils preserved as of soft tissues, including limbs and gills. hard skeletal elements alone. The importance of these One of the most interesting aspects of the Burgess soft-bodied or poorly skeletised forms is indicated by Shale assemblage is its antiquity (more than 520 000 000 their dominance in present day environments where years). It provides a window through which the early animais without hard parts make up more than two evolution of highly organised life can be studied, occur­ thirds of the number of species and individuals present ring some few tens of millions of years after one of the (Conway Morris, 1986). greatest events in the history of life. This event, often The most famous assemblage of exceptionally pre­ referred to as the ' explosion', took place near served soft-bodied fossils occurs within the Middle the -Cambrian boundary (550000000 Cambrian Burgess Shale of British Columbia, Canada. years ago) and resulted in the relatively sudden appear­ The locality was discovered in the early part in this ance of highly developed organisms within the century by the eminent American palaeontologist Char­ record. les D. Walcott whose many contributions to Cambrian It is clearly of some consequence that an assemblage geology are recognised by the land area of North of Burgess Shale-like fossils some 20 000 000 years old­ Greenland which bears his name (fig. 1). Burgess Shale er than those preserved within the Burgess Shale has fossils have been described by many authors, but most been discovered recently in Greenland. This assem­ notably in a series of monographs by Walcott himself blage was discovered by A. K. Higgins within the Lower and by a group established at the University of Cam­ Cambrian Buen Formation in north-westem Peary bridge, England, under the leadership of Professor H. Land (fig. 1) during the final stages of a regional geol­ B. Whittington (see Conway Morris, 1986 for refer­ ogical project instigated by the Geological Survey of ences). A recent 'best-seller' evaluates the significance Greenland (GGU) in North Greenland (1978-1980 and of this "most precious and important of all fossil local­ 1984-1985). Unfortunately, the significance of the as­ ities" in terms of the development of life during the semblage was not recognised until the collections were 500 000 000 years since the Cambrian (Gould, 1989, p. examined in Copenhagen early in 1986, by which time it 13). Gould suggests that the importance of the Burgess was no longer possibie to revisit the locality within the Shale assemblage has been underestimated since earlier logistic frarnework established for the North Greenland work tended to interpret many of the fossils in terms of project. classifications largely based on present-day taxa, rather Apart from sponges described by Rigby (1986) and than recognising the diversity inherent within the as­ many specimens of a single species of nevadiid trilobite, semblage itself. subsequently described as BuenelIus higginsi gen. et sp. The Burgess Shale assemblage contains more than nov. by Blaker (1988), the small collection made by 100 species, but only some 2% of the 40 000 individuals Higgins contained a number of species of poorly skele­ counted by Conway Morris (1986) contain hard parts tised arthropods. The discovery was reported and capable of preservation under normal geological cir­ briefly described by Conway Morris et al. (1987). The cumstances. This latter group includes trilobites and assemblage was considered to be of special interest not hyolithids, readily fossilised on account of their calcare­ only on account of its excellent preservation (cf. fig. 2) ous skeletons and thus familiar to students of Cambrian but also because it demonstrated the presence of an fossils. The remaining species consist of a wide range of animal community of similar structure to that of the

Rapp. Grønlands geol. Unders. 148. 54-56 (1990) © GGU, Capenhagen, 1990 55

'~-v--.. ,-' ...

P e a r y L a n d 82

Wandel Valley Formation ()

Ordovician U Tavsens Iskappe Group 40km M c ro Brønlund Fjord Group ~ .§ Buen Formation E ro () lce margin L

Portfjeld Formation

Fig. l. Locality for exceptionully prcscrveu fossils from thc Buen Formation in North Greenland. The Occurrcncc (lf the asscmblage within Ihe lower part of the Buen Formation is starred (inset).

MiddJe Cambrian Burgess Shale in subslanriaJly alder The most cammon fossils within rhe more than 30 Lower Cambrian strata. species <.:urrently recogniscd are arthropods, some of During July 19R9 a 4-man group revisited the locality which must have cxceecled half a metre in length tIming to make Illrger coJiections and Io try and assess Ihe life. Most conspicuous are large specimens of !he trilo­ extent of the fossiliferous deposi{~. The expedition was bite BuenelIus higginsi but bivalved carapace:-i ol" ostra~ made possibie by a generous grant from the Carlsberg couc-like species (Iength 1-2 cm) are numcricaJly dOIll­ Foundation, Copenhagen, and logistical support from in3nl. Otber speejes vary from eJongate forms witil GGU's geological mapping programme in North-East abundant segments to squac ovoid arthropods with Greenland (see Henriksen, 1990). Dcspite problems fewer segments and large head and tai I shields af similiH with poor weather, a collection af more than 1500 rock proportions. Many specirnens of the hItter group prc­ smnples was secured. scrve traces af limhs, gi lis and possibIe cnleric muscula­ Almost all thc fossils were derived from approxi~ ture (fig. 2). Sponges and worms are well rcpresented matcly 5 m af shale occurring at a single locality near J. but brachiopods and echinoderms are apparently ab­ P. Koch Fjord. The fossiliferous sha1cs apparelltly occur sent. Molluscs are rcprescnted by a few Snlall cap­ within the lo\ver part af the Buen Formation and not shaped shelIs af 1I1lcertain affinity. I-Iyolithids are also \virhin thc upper part. as had heen suggesled by Comvay rare but same prescrve tbe operculum and appendages Morris et ai. (1987). ('hekns'), 56

Fig. 2. Fossils from tile Lower Cambrian Buen Formation nem.L P. Koch Fjord, central North Greenland. A, an lacking mineralis

Sevcral taxa currently defy c1assificarion. Most nota­ References ble amongst these is li worm-hke species (Iength c. 5 cm) covcrcd with a dense thatch uf pointcd spines hut with Hlak.er, M. R. t9R8: A new genus of nevadiid trilubite from the larger ovoid plates at both extrcmitics. This remarkable Buen Formation (Early Cambrian) of Peary Land, central taxon promises to bc the key to unravelling Lhc affinities North Greenland. Rapp. Grønlands geo/. Unders. 137, of a number af described taxa af spine-hke microfossils 33-41. COllway Morris. S. 1986: The comrnunity slructure af the Mio­ whicb are common in Lower Cambrian strata from die Carnbrian Phyllopod Bed (Burgess Shale). Palaeon[ol­ many areas (Conway Marris & Peel, 1990). ogy 29, 423-467. The assemblage of poorly skeletised fossils from lhc Conway Morris, S. & Peel, J. S. 1990: Arliculaled halkicnids Buen Formation is bc:ing studied by li group af palaeon­ from thc Lowcr Cambrian of north GrcenlaIld. Nature 345, tologists centred amund tile University of Cambridge 802-805. and the Geological Survey of Greenland. Tlle investiga· Conway Mords, S., Peel. J. S., Higgins, A. K., Soper, N. .I. & tians wiJl writc not only a new chapter an ancient life in Davis, N. C. 1987: A Burgcss shalc·like fauna from the Grccnland but also contribute to the understanding af Lower Cambrian of North Greenland. Nature 326, 181-183. the carly history of life an carth. Gould, S. J. 1989: W01l(lerfullife. The llurgess SJwle and fhl! nature afhis/ory, 347 pr. New York: W. W. Norton & Co. Henriksen, N. 1990: Regional geol()gy and 1:500 000 mapping Acknowledgements. FclIow expedition members Simon Con­ in North-East Greenlancl. Rapp. Grønlands geo/. Unders. way Morris (Cambridge). Paul Smith (Geologieal Museum, 148 (Ihis volume). Copenhagcn) and Poul Scl1iøler (GGU) are thanked for mak­ Rigby, J. K. 1986: Cambrian and sponges from North ing thc trip to Peary Land a success. The programrne, financed Greenland. I?app. C,,>nland,\' geol. Unders. 132,51--63. by the Carlsberg Foundation, was supporlcd logistically by GGU, the 'Sirius' sledge patrol and the Royal Danish Air Force. J. S. P., Geologica/ Sl4rvey af Greenland, Copenhagen.