Central Administrative Tribunal Principal Bench, New Delhi OA-4204/2016

New Delhi this the 07th day of September, 2018

Hon’ble Sh. Pradeep Kumar, Member (A)

1. Rakesh Kumar, Aged 33 years, S/o Sh. Balraj, Group-D Wording as Gateman under SSE, Bhadurgarh, in Delhi Division, R/o V.P.O. Atail, Tehsil Sampla, Distt. Rohtak () 124526

2. Parveen Kumar, Aged-27 Years, Group –D S/o Sh. Rajbir, Working as Gateman under SSE, Bhadurgarh, in Delhi Division R/o V.P.O. Asadudha (Siwan), Tehsil Bhadurgarh, Distt. Haryana-124505

3. Satyavir Singh, Aged 54 Years, Group D S/o Sh. Ram Mehar, Working as Gateman in Northern Railway, Delhi Division, R/o V.P.O. Loharheri Tehsil B. Garh, Distt. Jhajjar (Haryana)

4. Ishwar Singh, Aged -57 Years, Group 10 S/o Sh. Shiv Ram, Working as Gateman in Northern Railway, Delhi Division, R/o H.No. 943, Chhaju Puram Colony (Behind S.D.M. Resi), Mahendergarh (Haryana)

5. Bishamber Dayal, Aged -51 Years, Group -10 S/o Sh. Jai Ram Working as Gateman in Northern Railway, Delhi Division, R/o Vill. Amadalpur, P.O. Machhrauli, Tehsil Jhajjar, Distt. Jhajjar (Haryana)

6. Naveen, Aged-21 Years, Group -10 S/o Sh. Rambir, Working as Gateman in 2

Northern Railway, Delhi Division. R/o V.P.O. Ismaila-9B, Tehsil Sampla, Distt. Rohtak, State Haryana -12457

7. Monu, Aged -24 Years, Group –D S/o Sh. Med Singh, Working as Gateman in Northern Railway, Delhi Division R/o V.P.O. Gandhva Distt. Rohtak, Tehsil Sampla (Haryana-124501)

8. Sunil Kumar, Aged-30 Years, group-D S/o Sh. Bhadur Singh, Working as Gateman in Northern Railway, Delhi Division, R/o V.P.O. Gandhva Distt. Rohtak, Tehsil Sampla (Haryana-124501)

9. Yogende Kumar, Aged -25 Years, Group-D S/o Sh. Subhash Chand, Working as Gateman in Northern Railway, Delhi Division, R/o V.P.O. Bhainsru Kalan, Tehsil Sampla, Distt. Rohtak (Haryana)

10. Sandeep Kumar, Aged -26 Years, Group-D S/o Sh. Raj Singh, Working as Gateman in Northern Railway, Delhi Division, R/o V.P.O. Kharhar, Distt. Jhajjar, Tehsil (Haryana)

11. Jitender, Aged-27 Years, Group –D S/o Sh. Ajit Singh, Working as Gateman in Northern Railway, Delhi Division, R/o V.P.O. Road, Tehsil Bhadurgarh, Distt. Jhajjar (Haryana)

12. Pradeep Kumar, Aged-29 Years, Group –D S/o Sh. Rambir Singh, Working as Gateman in Northern Railway, Delhi Division, R/o V.P.O. Bhadani, Distt & Tehsil Jhajjar, (Haryana) 3

13. Suresh Kumar, Aged-55 Years, Group-D S/o Sh. Mahender Singh Working as Gateman in Northern Railway, Delhi Division. R/o Mahivir Park, Gali No.4, House No. 21/23, B.garh-124507

14. Chhuttan Lal, Aged-40 Years, Group –D S/o Sh. Ram Shai, Working as Gateman in Northern Railway, Delhi Division, R/o V.P.O. Namnher, Tehsil Sikrai, Distt. Dossa (Rajasthan)

15. Jagpal, Aged-54 Years, Group –D S/o Sh. Suraj Bhan, Working as Gateman in Northern Railway, Delhi Division, R/o Rewari Khera Tehsil Bahadurgarh, Distt. Jhajjar (Haryana)

16. Dileep Kumar, Aged -26 Years, Group-D S/o Sh. Ram Kishan, Working as Gateman in Northern Railway, Delhi Division, R/o Vill Saraiya, PO Kauwa, Distt. Etawah (U.P.)

17. Ramesh Kumar, Aged-51 Years, Group-D S/o Late Sh. Ram Kishan, Working as Gateman in Northern Railway, Delhi Division, R/o VPO Kasni Teh. & Distt. Jhajjar Haryana-124109

18. Hemant, Aged-29 Years, Group –D S/o Sh. Tale Ram, Working as Gateman in Northern Railway, Delhi Division R/o VPO Kheri Sadh Tehsil & Distt. Rohtak,

19. Deep Chand, Aged 56, Group-D S/o Sh. Jai Narayan, 4

Working as Gateman in Northern Railway, Delhi Division R/o H.No.410, Mast Nath Colony, Satrod Kalan Nisar Cantt.

20. Ramesh Lal, Aged-55 Years, Group-D S/o Sh. Jai Karan, Working as Gateman in Northern Railway, Delhi Division R/o VPO Nigana, Tehsil Kalanour, Distt. Rohtak-124115

21. Alam, Aged-28 Years, Group-D S/o Sh. Shipat Rahaman, Working as Gateman in Northern Railway, Delhi Division, R/o RZF-441, Gautam Budh Nagar, Raj Nagar, Palam Colony, New Delhi-110077.

22. Ishwar Singh, Aged -56 Years, Group-D S/o Sh. Chiranji Lal, Working as Gateman in Northern Railway, Delhi Division, R/o VPO Baliana Tehsil Sampla, Distt. Rohtak (Haryana)

23. Pawan, Aged-23 Years, Group-D S/o Sh. Wazir Singh, Working as Gateman in Northern Railway, Delhi Division, R/o VPO Kheri Sadh, Tehsil Sampla, Distt. Rohtak (Har.)

24. Sandeep, Aged-24 Years, Group C S/o Sh. Jagbir, Working as Gateman in Northern Railway, Delhi Division, R/o VPO Chuliana, Tehsil Sampla, Distt. Rohtak (Haryana-124527)

(By Advocate : Ms. Sonika Gill for Sh. Yogesh Sharma)

Vs. 1. Union of through the General Manager, 5

Northern Railway, Baroda House, New Delhi.

2. The Divisional Railway, Manager, Northern Railway State Entry Road, New Delhi.

3. The Sr. Divisional Personal Officer, Northern Railway, Delhi Divsion, State Entry Road, New Delhi.

4. The Divisional Engineer, N.Railway, Delhi Division State Entry Road, New Delhi.

By Advocate : Sh. Shailender Tiwari)

ORDER (ORAL)

Learned proxy counsel for the applicant mentioned that this case relates to the non-payment of the OTA. A legal notice was also served upon respondents on 21.11.2016.

2. The respondents further brought out that the applicant had not made any representation to the department and even, thereafter, there is a provision to redress the grievance through Permanent Negotiating

Machinery (PNM), Divisional Railway Manager and Regional Labour

Commissioner. All these options have not been availed by the applicant and they had approached the Tribunal straight away.

3. The present O.A. is disposed off with the direction to the applicant to file a proper representation to the respondents, who are in turn directed 6

to dispose off such a representation by passing a reasoned and speaking order within a period of three months thereafter.

4. O.A. is disposed of accordingly at the admission stage itself. No costs.

(Pradeep Kumar) Member (A) Sarita 7

8

9

Amrita Wadhawan, D/o. Shri Ravinder Kumar Jaitley, Age 49 yrs., R/o.-A-223, Gaur Green Avenue Abhay Khand-II, Indirapuram, Ghaziabad-201010 Neha Bajpai, D/o. Shri Shyam Sunder Kapoor, Age 42 yrs. R/o.-F-901, Neelpadm - I, Sec-5, Vaishali, Ghaziabad Kanti Singh Sangher, D/o. Shri Madhav Singh Sangher, Age 38 yrs., R/o.-Varun Apartments, Flat No. 472, C-58/28,C Block , Sector -62, Noida, G.B. Nagar, 201301, U.P Astha Gupta, D/o. Shri Rakesh Mohan Goel, Age 33 yrs., R/o.-D-105, Aashina Heritage, Vaishali, Sector 4, Ghaziabad, U.P Sanjay Ojha, S/o. Shri R.K. Ojha, Age 40 yrs., R/o.-House No.957, third floor, sector-15, Vasundhra, Ghaziabad(U.P) 201012 Rosy Verma, D/o. Shri T. N. Verma, Age 49 yrs., R/o.-F-172, Beta-II, Greater Noida Uttam Kumar, S/o. Shri S.P. Kureel, Age 40 yrs., R/o.-C- 12, Pocket - VI, Kendriya Vihar-II, Sector - 82, Noida - 201 304 Vineet Kumar Birla, S/o. shri Sanatan Birla, Age 38 yrs., R/o.-Kamal Residency, Flat No.SF-1, Plot No.A-2, Sector-5, Chiranjiv Vihar, Ghaziabad, U.P Nitin Kumar Varshney, S/o. Shri Pramod Kumar Varshney, Age 37 yrs. R/o.-C-2/3, Rail Vihar, Near DPS School, Indirapuram, Ghaziabad - 201010

10

11

12

... Respondents ORDER (ORAL)

M.A. No. 3475/2018 & M.A. No. 3474/2018 filed for joining and condonation of delay are dismissed.

O.A. No. 3108/2018

Learned counsel for the applicants mentioned that the some of the other applicants who are the part of the present petition, their name are not included in the present petition. Certain recoveries have been ordered for certain excess payments made. They are already retired.

The petitioners in the instant case are apprehensive that certain recoveries may be ordered against them also and this is the grievance in the present O.A.

2. Learned counsel for the respondents mentioned that no such order has been issued by the department against any of the applicants in the present petition. Hence, the case of the present petitioners is not known.

3. The matter was heard at length. The O.A. is dismissed being devoid of merits at this stage.

(Pradeep Kumar) 13

Member (A)