DOCSLIB.ORG

Police Contracting in St. Louis County: Focusing Events and Changes in Image and Venue in Five Case Studies Alan W

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Police Contracting in St. Louis County: Focusing Events and Changes in Image and Venue in Five Case Studies Alan W University of Missouri, St. Louis IRL @ UMSL Dissertations UMSL Graduate Works 4-25-2016 Police Contracting in St. Louis County: Focusing Events and Changes in Image and Venue in Five Case Studies Alan W. Karr University of Missouri-St. Louis Follow this and additional works at: https://irl.umsl.edu/dissertation Part of the Political Science Commons Recommended Citation Karr, Alan W., "Police Contracting in St. Louis County: Focusing Events and Changes in Image and Venue in Five Case Studies" (2016). Dissertations. 126. https://irl.umsl.edu/dissertation/126 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the UMSL Graduate Works at IRL @ UMSL. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations by an authorized administrator of IRL @ UMSL. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Police Contracting in St. Louis County: Focusing Events and Changes in Image and Venue in Five Case Studies Alan W. Karr M.A., Political Science, University of Missouri – St. Louis, 2013 M.P.P.A., University of Missouri – St. Louis, 2010 B.A., Philosophy & Letters, St. Louis University – St. Louis, 2004 A dissertation submitted to The Graduate School at the University of Missouri – St. Louis in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Political Science with an emphasis in Public Administration and Urban Politics. May 2016 Dissertation Committee Todd Swanstrom, Ph.D. Chairperson E. Terrence Jones, Ph.D. Andrew Glassberg, Ph.D. Daniel Isom, Ph.D. Table of Contents Abstract ...............................................................................................................................3 Introduction .......................................................................................................................4 Policing St. Louis County ..............................................................................................18 Literature Review ............................................................................................................35 Hypotheses and Methodology ......................................................................................56 Contracting Municipalities: Fenton ...................................................................................................................71 Jennings ................................................................................................................85 Dellwood ............................................................................................................101 Non-Contract Municipalities: Rock Hill .............................................................................................................115 Hazelwood .........................................................................................................122 Conclusion .....................................................................................................................130 Tables ..............................................................................................................................145 Charts ..............................................................................................................................152 References ......................................................................................................................178 2 Abstract St. Louis County, Missouri is a fragmented suburban area, covering 505 square miles, with ninety separate municipalities. Fifty-six municipalities maintain in-house police departments, while thirty-four contract police services from other governments. Previous research concerning interjurisdictional collaboration efforts has been rooted in the rational choice theory. However, the rational choice theory alone does not explain why some municipalities do or do not enter into contracts for police services. The purpose of this work is to examine police contracting decisions in St. Louis County, specifically the drivers behind contracting discussions and decisions in five sample municipalities in St. Louis County. The five case studies were examined utilizing theories from the policy process literature, namely focusing events and changes in image and venue. Decisions were also examined utilizing Wilson’s typology of police styles. Of the case studies that resulted in a police contract, a change in both venue and image occurred. In the case studies that did not result in a police contract, a change in image and venue related to matters of policing did not occur. Therefore, it was determined that changes in image and venue as well as a focusing event on police were necessary for successful decisions to contract police services. 3 Chapter 1 Introduction St. Louis County is a patchwork of municipalities that, like a true patchwork quilt, vary in shape, size, and community fabric. Despite the differences in these municipalities, each community strives to protect its citizens through police services. The way in which these municipalities provide police services is just as much of a patchwork as the myriad of municipalities. Some municipalities maintain their own police departments while others contract police services from the County or another municipality. The purpose of this work is to examine police contracting decisions in St. Louis County, specifically, the drivers behind contracting discussions and decisions in five sample municipalities in St. Louis County. The question of contracting decisions touches on matters of efficiency, police- community relations, as well as justice and fairness. Agreements between governments may be made informally, through formalized networks, voluntarily created, or mandated by an outside party. Mandated agreements may be required by legislative bodies. In St. Louis County, contractual agreements for police services are formal agreements created voluntarily between governments. Formal agreements have been described as “transactions that require financial transfers [that are] usually…formalized in order to protect property rights of the participating governments” (Andrew 2009, 134). Legally binding agreements are important to delineate responsibilities and to ensure that financial 4 commitments and responsibilities are met. Lakewood Plan Lakewood, California was one of the first examples of a municipality that contracted all of its municipal services with another government. In 1954, Lakewood incorporated to stave off annexation by Long Beach, a neighboring municipality. Lakewood utilized contractual agreements to avoid start-up and maintenance costs of standard municipal bureaucracies (Miller 1981). Lakewood maintained its legislative governing functions, which included responsibilities such as budgeting, finance, planning, and policy formation, while contracting municipal services, such as police, fire, and trash services. This model became known as the “Lakewood Plan.” The Lakewood Plan provided a road map for municipalities to contract services production traditionally reserved as a responsibility of the provisioning municipality (Jamison and Bigger 1957). The police services provided to Lakewood represent a standardized service delivery model. Services are standardized because the provider, the County Sheriff’s Department in this case, maintains a set of uniform standards that apply to police practices (Mehay 1979, 61). Under the Lakewood Plan the Sheriff’s Department developed a unitized method through which police services were offered. An example of a defined unit was a police-car-on-continuous-patrol with the associated auxiliary services provided (Ostrom, Tiebout, and Warren 1961, 839). The Lakewood Plan also 5 provided an example of standardized police services provided to a municipality by a contracted agency and an example of how to provide police service with unitized methodology. The Lakewood Plan is important to any discussion of contractual agreements for the provision of municipal law enforcement services because the plan has been successful. Lakewood was the first municipality to contract police services from the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department (Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department 2009, 5). Today, the Sheriff’s Department still provides police services to the City of Lakewood. The Sheriff’s Department provides police services for forty-two of the eighty-eight municipalities within Los Angeles County (personal interview, September 11, 2015). One former ranking member of the St. Louis County Police Department pointed out that the Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department program was an example for St. Louis County officials on how to effectively implement and manage municipal police contracts (personal interview, June 9, 2014). Why Understanding Police Contracting is Important The state provides police services as a public good for order maintenance. A pure public good is non-rival and non-excludable. Non-rival means that the consumption of the good by one consumer does not diminish the ability of another consumer to utilize the good. Non-exclusion means that it is impossible to prevent people from using the good, even those who may not be paying for the good (i.e. free-riders). When a public good is both non- 6 rival and non-exclusionary then it is known as “pure.” However, most public goods—such as police services—are not pure (Hirsch 1970 and Hardin 1982). Police services are rivalrous, therefore, they are not pure. Traffic on a freeway is commonly used as an example to explain rival goods. As traffic increases, the ability for drivers to fully enjoy the
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Missouri: the Impact of Community/Police Interactions On
    The Impact of Community/Police Interactions on Individual Civil Rights in Missouri A Report of the Missouri Advisory Committee to the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights June 2016 Advisory Committees to the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights By law, the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights has established an advisory committee in each of the 50 states and the District of Columbia. The committees are composed of state citizens who serve without compensation. The committees advise the Commission of civil rights issues in their states that are within the Commission’s jurisdiction. More specifically, they are authorized to advise the Commission in writing of any knowledge or information they have of any alleged deprivation of voting rights and alleged discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, age, disability, national origin, or in the administration of justice; advise the Commission on matters of their state’s concern in the preparation of Commission reports to the President and the Congress; receive reports, suggestions, and recommendations from individuals, public officials, and representatives of public and private organizations to committee inquiries; forward advice and recommendations to the Commission, as requested; and observe any open hearing or conference conducted by the Commission in their states. Letter of Transmittal Missouri Advisory Committee to the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights The Missouri Advisory Committee to the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights submits this report regarding the civil rights impact of police and community relations in Missouri, particularly disparities in the use of force on people of color. The Committee submits this report as part of its responsibility to study and report on civil rights issues in the state of Missouri.
    [Show full text]
  • Comprehensive Evaluation of the St. Louis Metropolitan Police Department (SLMPD) by the Ethical
    Comprehensive Evaluation of the St. Louis Metropolitan Police Department (SLMPD) by the Ethical Society of Police July 2016 Page 1 of 112 Copyright 2016 © Ethical Society of Police Table of Contents ABOUT THE ETHICAL SOCIETY OF POLICE (E.S.O.P.) 3 PART I – CITY OF ST. LOUIS & SLMPD MAKEUP – TRANSFERS & PROMOTIONS 3 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 3 SECTION I: DEMOGRAPHICS OF THE CITY OF ST. LOUIS AND SLMPD 7 POPULATION OF THE CITY OF ST. LOUIS - REPORTED AS OF JULY 1ST, 2015 7 THE DEMOGRAPHICS OF SLMPD ON FEBRUARY 15TH 2016 7 SLMPD COMMANDERS (LIEUTENANTS, CAPTAINS, MAJORS, COLONELS) ON FEBRUARY 15TH 2016 8 COVETED SPECIALIZED UNITS WITHIN SLMPD ON FEBRUARY 15TH 2016 8 SECTION II: 2015 AND 2016 SLMPD ARREST APPREHENSION LISTING FOR ADULTS 18 YEARS OF AGE AND OLDER 15 ARRESTEES FROM JANUARY 2015 - DECEMBER 2015 FROM THE SLMPD ARREST APPREHENSION LISTING 15 PERCENTAGE OF ARREST TOTALS FOR 2015 15 TOTAL 16 PERCENTAGE OF DRUG ARREST TOTAL FOR 2015 16 WEAPON ARREST TOTAL JANUARY 2015 - DECEMBER 2015 FROM THE SLMPD ARREST APPREHENSION LISTING 16 PERCENTAGE OF WEAPONS ARREST TOTAL FOR 2015 16 TOTAL ARRESTEES FROM JANUARY 2016 - MAY 2016 FROM THE SLMPD ARREST APPREHENSION LISTING FOR ADULTS 18 YEARS OF AGE AND OLDER 17 ARRESTEES FROM JANUARY 2016 - MAY 2016 ARREST APPREHENSION LISTING 17 TOTAL 17 PERCENTAGE OF ARREST TOTAL FOR 2016 17 TOTAL 17 PERCENTAGE OF DRUG ARREST TOTAL FOR 2016 18 WEAPON ARREST TOTAL JANUARY 2016 – MAY 2016 FROM THE SLMPD ARREST APPREHENSION LISTING 18 PERCENTAGE OF WEAPONS ARREST TOTAL FOR 2016 18 SECTION III: RACIAL PROFILING DATA FOR 2012, 2013, 2014, AND 2015 FOR THE CITY OF ST.
    [Show full text]
  • Husch Blackwell LLP 190 Carondelet Plaza, Suite 600 Tel: 314.345.6462 Email: [email protected]
    Jeff Jensen Partner 190 Carondelet Plaza, Suite 600 St. Louis, MO 63105 Direct: 314.345.6462 Fax: 314.480.1505 [email protected] June 10, 2016 VIA E-MAIL & COURIER Amy Senier Trial Attorney Civil Rights Division U.S. Department of Justice 601 D Street, NW Washington, D.C. 20006 Jared L. Hasten Winston & Strawn LLP 35 West Wacker Drive Chicago, IL 60601 De'Carlon Seewood City Manager City of Ferguson 110 Church Street Ferguson, MO 63135 RE: Application to Serve as Independent Monitor for the City of Ferguson Case No. 4:16-cv-00180-CDP (USDC E.D. Mo.) Dear Ms. Senier and Messrs. Hasten and Seewood: Thank you for the opportunity to submit an application to serve as the Independent Monitor for the City of Ferguson pursuant to the Consent Decree in the case referenced above. As demonstrated in our enclosed application, our team has decades of experience relevant to ensuring the City of Ferguson meets every requirement under the Consent Decree, and we believe our locally-based team is eminently qualified to serve as the Independent Monitor. As discussed in our application, we will provide objective, cost-effective, and thorough assessments of whether the terms of the Consent Decree have been implemented, and whether implementation is resulting in constitutional and otherwise lawful policing and administration of SLC-7909087-1 justice, and as well as increased trust between the people of Ferguson and the City, the Ferguson Police Department, and the Municipal Court. We will also assist in compliance efforts by offering technical assistance, issuing recommendations, and preparing public reports on the Consent Decree’s implementation.
    [Show full text]
  • A Path Toward Racial Equity
    A PATH TOWARD RACIAL EQUITY A printed companion to FORWARDTHROUGHFERGUSON.ORG as of September 14TH #STLFwdThru CONTENTS INTRODUCTION THE CONTEXT OF THE FERGUSON COMMISSION REPORT . 6 ABOUT THIS REPORT. 8 ABOUT THE FERGUSON COMMISSION . 12 THE PROCESS OF CHANGE . 18 NEXT STEPS . 20 SIGNATURE PRIORITIES JUSTICE FOR ALL . 24 YOUTH AT THE CENTER . 38 OPPORTUNITY TO THRIVE . 48 RACIAL EQUITY . 59 CALLS TO ACTION ALL JUSTICE FOR ALL CALLS . 61 ALL YOUTH AT THE CENTER CALLS . 101 ALL OPPORTUNITY TO THRIVE CALLS . 127 ALL RACIAL EQUITY CALLS . 151 SUMMARY OF TERMS . 155 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS CONTENT EXPERTS . 170 WORKING GROUP MEMBERS . 172 COMMISSIONERS . 174 COMMISSION RESOURCES AND SUPPORT . 175 DEMOGRAPHICS RECAP . 179 INTRODUCTION THE CONTEXT OF THE FERGUSON COMMISSION REPORT CLARIFYING OUR TERMS are the answer. We can’t. But they are what we believe to be the best starting point, the beginning of a path toward The title of this report is “Forward Through Ferguson: a better St. Louis. A Path Toward Racial Equity.” We want to take a few moments to explain what we mean. We expect that as we travel, the path will change, and we’ll find ourselves navigating places we couldn’t have “FORWARD THROUGH FERGUSON” imagined. That is the nature of efforts like this. But there must be a starting point, and we believe, based on the As with any organization that works closely together on work we have done, that this is the right starting point. serious issues, the Ferguson Commission has found itself coming back to several phrases again and again. One We are certainly open to the idea that we will uncover of those phrases has been, “The only way forward is new routes and unexpected roadblocks.
    [Show full text]
  • Dr. Martin Luther King Jr
    “There is no easy way to create a world where men and women can live together, where each has his own job and house, where all children receive as much education as their minds can absorb. But if such a world is created in our lifetime, it will be done in the United States by Negroes and white people of good will. It will be accomplished by persons who have the courage to put an end to suffering by willingly suffering themselves rather than inflict suffering upon others. It will be done by rejecting the racism, materialism and violence that has characterized Western civilization and especially by working toward a world of brotherhood, cooperation and peace.” Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. May 4, 1966 Some quotations and pictures listed in this brochure are excerpts from Dr. King’s speeches; others are from “Visions of Excellence – African- American Words of Inspiration.” Photographs are from the following books: “He Had a Dream;” “King, the Photo Biography of Martin Luther King Jr.;” “The Story of Martin Luther King;” “The Life and Death of Martin Luther King Jr.;” and “Martin Luther King Jr.” The activities and events that are listed in this calendar represent those submitted to the Commission prior to the printing deadline. 1 Table of Contents The 2017 Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. State Celebration Commission Members 4 Letter from the Governor 6 The National Celebration 8 “I Have a Dream” Speech 9 A Word from the Late Coretta Scott King 16 City of St. Louis Official Proclamation 17 King Holiday Bell Ringing 19 Major Issues of Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • I:\Journal Production\Webtemp
    JOURNAL OF THE SENATE NINETY-EIGHTH GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE STATE OF MISSOURI FIRST REGULAR SESSION FIRST DAY—WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 7, 2015 The Senate was called to order at 12:00 noon by Lieutenant Governor Peter Kinder. The Reverend Carl Gauck offered the following prayer: “See, former things have come to pass and new things I now declare.” (Psalm 42:9a) O, Lord it is a new session for all of us and for some a new status and time for change with this New Year. So with the challenges that confront our state we ask your guidance and help to do that which is needed and pleasant in your sight. Grant us wisdom to do what is necessary, even and especially when it is difficult to do, so we accomplish the purpose for which you have brought us here. And bless, O Lord, the work we put forth. In Your Holy Name we pray. Amen. Missouri State Highway Patrol Troop F presented the Colors. The Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag was recited. The “Star-Spangled Banner” was performed by Lauren Hieger. The President of the Senate stated that the Rules of the Senate would be the Missouri Senate Rules of the 2nd Regular Session of the Ninety-seventh General Assembly until temporary or permanent rules are adopted. Senator Richard announced that photographers from ABC 17, KSDK-TV, the Senate and family members had been given permission to take flash pictures and to video in the Senate Chamber and gallery. Senator Richard submitted the following appointments of officers for the temporary organization, which were read: President Pro Tem............................................Tom Dempsey Secretary of Senate ......................................
    [Show full text]