Online Study Summary – Africana Hymnal Study the Online Survey, More Comprehensive in Nature, Was Designed for Clergy and Church Leaders

Online Study Summary – Africana Hymnal Study The online survey, more comprehensive in nature, was designed for clergy and church leaders. 2276 e- mail invitations were sent to pastors, persons in extension ministries and bishops and district superintendents. The e-mail invitation contained a link to the study that could be shared with worship leaders, musicians and other local church leaders. Responses were recorded by 575 people.

Section One: Demographics (Questions 1-10) Research Findings: 1. What is your position? (N=575) Pastors and other 328 57.04% clergy Bishops and DS 21 3.65% Extension Ministries 27 4.69% Worship/music/ch 199 34.60% leaders

2. Is your position? (N=572) Paid 275 48.08% Full-time 100 17.48% Part-time 58 10.14% Volunteer 139 24.30%

3. Which jurisdiction are you from? (N=572) NEJ 157 27.45% SEJ 240 41.96% NCJ 58 10.14% SCJ 93 16.26% WJ 24 4.20%

4. What is your age category? (N=575) 75+ 16 2.78% 66-75 73 12.70% 56-65 225 39.13% 46-55 168 29.22% 36-45 61 10.61% 26-35 26 4.52% 25 or under 6 1.04%

5. What is the approximate membership of your church? (N=566) <100 151 26.68% 100-199 168 29.68% 200-299 89 15.72% 300-499 89 15.72% 500-749 20 3.53% 750-999 7 1.24% >1000 42 7.42%

6. What is the approximate worship attendance of your church? (N=564) <100 303 53.72% 100-199 152 26.95% 200-299 63 11.17% 300-499 11 1.95% 500-749 7 1.23% 750-999 6 1.06% >1000 22 3.90%

7. Do you consider your church: (N=565) Urban 191 33.81% Small Town 116 20.53% Rural 92 16.28% Inner City 85 15.04% Suburban 81 14.34%

8. Estimated average yearly income of members (N=564) <$20-35,000 169 29.96% $35-50,000 250 44.33% $50-75,000 120 21.28% >$75,000 25 4.43%

9. Estimate the gender make-up by percentage (N=558) Women 66% Men 34%

10. What percentage of your church members are in the following age categories (put in %) –

Children, birth to 12 8% Youth 12-18 9% Young Adult 19-30 12% Adults 31-49 17% Adults 50-65 27% Adults 65 and older 27%

Observations for Section 1: Q1: The dominant group in the online survey is clergy (57%); compared to the 87% laity that completed the shorter paper surveys. The online survey, more comprehensive in nature, was designed for clergy and church leaders. 2276 e-mail invitations were sent to pastors, persons in extension ministries and bishops and district superintendents. The e-mail invitation contained a link to the study that could be shared with worship leaders, musicians and other local church leaders. As we compare the number of responses received online to the number received at events and meetings, we note the great digital divide in the black church. There were a number of clergy and church that had no e-mail address on record who found it more difficult to participate in the study.

Q2: The majority of the people who completed the online survey held paid positions (76% paid/24%) volunteers. While we rejoice over the number of people who did complete the online survey, we lament the wealth of information and perspective that we did not receive from Black church leaders who serve on Boards and Agencies or who were 2008 General Conference delegates.

Q3: All Jurisdictions were represented proportionally. We received 41.91% of our online surveys from the SEJ (compared to the 45.45% of black church membership reported by GCFA most recent 2008 statistics). Other jurisdictions: 27.45% NEJ (22.17% GCFA), 16.26% SCJ (21.62% GCFA), 10.14% NCJ (7.43% GCFA), and 4.20% WJ (3.33% GCFA).

Q4: The demographics of our response group greatly resemble those of the larger church. The majority of our responses (68.35%) came from participants 46-65. Significantly, 15.48% of participants in the survey were over 65. And, 10.61% of participants were 36-45; 5.56% of participants were 35 and under.

Q5--6: The vast majority of our responses have come from small-membership churches with 54% of responses coming from churches that have less than 100 in worship on a typical Sunday Morning. The responses from small membership churches could infer a greater need for future music helps/tools that could possibly revitalize small membership congregations through dynamic worship. GCFA reports that 81% of black United Methodist Churches have less than 100 in worship and an additional 14% report less than 200 in worship on a Sunday morning. Small membership churches have traditionally been underserved and scantily resourced. We are presented with a tremendous opportunity to create and design worship and music resources that speak to and connect to their contextual reality. The number of responses received from churches 1000+ may be traced to the extraordinary efforts of at least two large membership churches in the SCJ.

Q7: We left it to participants to define the kind of church they came from. The majority of respondents described their churches as urban churches (34%) with 21% reporting that theirs were small town churches. Suburban, inner city and rural churches also responded in significant numbers to the survey. This is a picture of the diversity found within the black church. We anticipate that the urban and inner city churches might find similar resources useful in their context; we also expect the same for small town and rural churches. We expect that suburban churches will have uniquely different needs. We also note that the rural church is probably underrepresented in this survey because of limited computer access.

Q8: The majority of responses came from churches in the $35-50,000 dollar household income range. The National Statistical Abstract estimates the 2007 median income of blacks at $34,000 (vs. $50,000 for all US Households) http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/2010/tables/10s0674.xls it would appear that the average income levels of responding UMC congregations hovered just above and just below that figure.

Q9: Gender balance in the black church averages 66% women, 34% men compared to UMC averages of 57% women, 43% men http://www.gcsrw.org/LayMembershipin20042008.aspx

Q10: Distribution of ages in our sample group actually compares favorably to figures reported in the 2009 Congregational Life Study. Our sample group reported 27% of their church members were over 65 compared to an average of 34% for the entire UMC reported in the Congregational Life Study. http://www.umc.org/site/c.lwL4KnN1LtH/b.6072841/k.7ACF/2010_State_of_the_Church_Congregation al_Life_Survey.htm. Although the black Church appears from this sampling to be slightly younger than the general church, we must be careful to gear the development of resources for both the ages in the pews, and the emerging ages of those coming into worship.

Section 2: Worship in your church (questions 11-25) Research Findings: 11. Please indicate how many worship services you have. (N=527) Main worship 523 99.6% service Second Worship 151 30.4% Service Third Worship 38 7.8% Service Four or More 15 3.1% Services

12. Please indicate the best description of the style of worship for each service you have. (N=525) Traditional Blended Contemporary Other Main service 187 (34.8%) 329 (61.2%) 18 (3.3%) 4 (0.7%) Second svc 30 (19.7%) 81 (53.3%) 33 (21.7%) 8 (5.3%) Third svc 5 (12.5%) 8 (20.0%) 16 (40.0%) 11 (27.5%) Fourth and 4 (23.5%) 1 (5.9%) 4 (23.5%) 8 (47.1%) others

13. Please indicate whether each service is growing, declining or staying the same in attendance. (N=527) Growing Declining Same Main service 232 (43.6%) 71 (13.3%) 229 (43.0%) Second service 59 (40.4%) 9 (6.2%) 78 (53.4%) Third service 16 (39.0%) 4 (9.8%) 21 (51.2%) Fourth and 7 (50%) 1 (7.1%) 6 (42.9%) others

14. List any additional weekly services held at your church (Check all that apply.) (N=524) Bible 485 92.56% Prayer 250 47.71% Children’s 149 28.44% Family 96 18.32% Youth 75 14.31% Afternoon 62 11.83% Evening Service 34 6.49%

15. On a typical Sunday in our church worship is lead by: (Check ONE) (N=527) Minister 43 8.16% Minister, liturgist 176 33.40% Minister, Liturgist 113 21.44% Worship Leaders M, L, W, Others 195 37.00%

16. List other leaders active in worship at your church (Check all that apply) (N=525) Ministers (not 239 45.52% ordained or appointed) Evangelists 48 9.14% Dancers 269 51.23% Step Team 27 5.14% Flaggers 30 5.71% Class Leaders 75 14.28% SS Teachers 276 52.57% Youth Minister 102 19.49% Music Minister 326 62.09% Choir Director 354 67.43% Choir Section 178 33.90% leader(s) Ushers 419 79.81% Lay Leader 410 78.1% Prayer Group 102 19.43% Leaders Trustees 202 38.48% Outreach Minister 98 18.67% Young Adult 62 11.81% Minister Nurses(s) 39 7.43% Armor 26 4.95% Altar 165 31.43% Prayer Counselor(s) 43 8.19% Mothers of the 35 6.67% Church Communion 378 72.00% Stewards Stewardship 184 35.05% Committee Mime and Drama 85 16.19% Others: 54 10.28%

17. In our church, the bulletin is used for: (Check all that apply.) (N=522) Order of Worship 507 97.13% Announcements 469 89.85% Notes 315 60.34% Prayer Requests 279 53.45% Promotion 264 50.57% Education 201 38.51%

18. When is the sermon preached? (N=524) End 286 54.58% Middle 238 45.42%

19. Do worship services at your church have (Check all that apply.) (N=521) Altar Call 467 89.64% Corporate Prayer 377 72.35% at Altar Private Prayer at 325 62.38% Altar

20. Complete the statement: Most of the time when people are baptized, (N=524) Sprinkle/pour 441 84.16% Immersion 83 15.84%

21. How often does your church celebrate Holy Communion? (N=524) Weekly 34 6.49% Bi-weekly 11 2.10% Monthly 452 86.26% Quarterly 4 0.76% Other: 23 4.39%

22. How is communion served in your church? (N=523) Small Cups 317 60.61% Altar Rail 312 59.66% Line Up 164 31.36% Bread and Cup 151 28.87% Pre-packaged 99 18.93% Ushers Bring 74 14.15%

23. How is the offering received? (Check all that apply.) (N=524) Pass the Plate 404 77.10% Dedication Song 400 76.34% Choir Sings 359 68.51% Sing During Off 269 51.34% Walk to Table 194 37.02%

24. How are the announcements shared when your church meets for worship? (N=524) Bulletin 473 90.27 Liturgist 385 73.47% Pastor 354 67.56%

25. List the occasional worship services that your congregation observes. (Check all that apply.) (N=523) Christmas Eve 251 47.99% Christmas Day 104 19.88% Watch Night 388 78.19% New Year’s Day 39 7.46% Ash Wednesday 429 82.03% Maundy/Holy Thursday 332 63.48% Good Friday 383 73.23% Thanksgiving Eve 131 25.04% Thanksgiving Day 115 21.99% Bible Sunday 69 13.19% Black History Month 14 2.68% Boy/Girl Scouts 68 13.00% Choir Anniversary 153 29.25% Church Anniversary 333 63.67% Dedication of Officers 285 54.49% Foot Washing 129 24.66% Homecoming 273 52.20% Juneteenth 32 6.12% Kwanzaa 51 9.75% Love Feast 50 9.56% Men’s Day 359 68.64% MLK, Jr. Day 248 47.42% Mother’s Board 5 .95% Pastor’s Anniversary 140 27.77% Revival – Jan/Feb =7 196 37.48% Mar/Apr = 40, May/Jun = 17 Sep/Oct = 67, Nov/Dec =13 remaining Spring/Fall or Annual Rites of Passage 19 3.63% Usher’s Anniversary 171 32.69% Women’s Day 367 70.17% Other (Receiving 2-10 votes: 65 12.43% Holy Week, UMW, Children’s, Confirmation)

Observations for Section 2: Worship services Q11: Approximately 1/3 of black UMC churches participating in the survey report more than one service.

Q12: The majority of respondents described their worship as blended. (In the 2004 Music and Worship Study, most described their services as traditional; see sidebar below.) Second services and additional services also tended to be described as either blended or contemporary.

This suggests a desire to be more engaging and invitational to younger and more diverse audiences. This data also generates an instructional challenge, “where are congregations learning how to effectively blend worship elements?

Sidebar Comparison: Current Worship Style Practiced 2004 Joint Study Results Africana Hymnal Study Results 56% 35% Traditional Worship 7% 3.3% Contemporary 36% 61% Blended

Q13: Most (43.6%) responses indicate a perception that attendance is either growing or remaining the same. GCFA statistics reveal approximately 1% growth in the black church, (from 444k to 450k) between 2006 and 2008. It is great news to know the black church perceives itself as growing and is experiencing some measurable growth (or at least maintaining attendance) when most protestant congregations are in a state of overall decline. Yet, in light of the numbers of black churches have been closed since the 1968merger, the committee finds these answers surprising.

Q14: Bible studies were the most frequent additional services reported (93%), followed by prayer services (48%). Evening services are almost a thing of the past (6.5%).

Q15: On Sunday morning, the majority of churches have several people (minister, liturgist, worship leaders, and oftentimes others) in leadership as opposed to worship services lead by the minister only.

Q16: In the black church, the group of people who may be involved in worship is expansive, to include additional ministers at various stages of the ordination process, a variety of music and worship arts related participants, and several groups of people set aside for prayer either during the worship service or during the prayer and altar call times. Also present in ministry in worship at the black church are the unique ministries of nurses, armor bearers, mothers of the church and communion stewardesses. A number of churches report that class leaders continue to be an active part of their ministry. This is both good news and a cause for inquiry in light of the size of many of the responding churches. On one hand, this broad involvement of the congregation in worship continues the Black Church tradition of having a place to shine, to be included, to develop, and to grow; on the other hand, the committee notes concerns about the quality of this involvement.

Q17: The bulletin overwhelmingly continues to be used for the order of worship in the black church (97%) and it is also widely used for announcements, notes, prayer requests, advertising special programs of the church and spiritual formation or Christian education.

Q18: A majority of black churches, 55%, continue to use the pattern of worship from the 1966 hymnal and Book of Worship with the sermon preached at the end of the service. Word and Table, entered

widespread use through the 1989 UMH, places the sermon in the middle of worship. The findings that 45% of the black church has adopted Word and Table should be seen as a major theological shift in the worship practices of the black church. The rationale that black pastors have historically used for placing the sermon at the end of the service has been to focus the service toward decision or commitment -- to follow Christ, to make changes in lifestyle, behavior or attitude, etc. Newer denominational preferences for positioning the sermon in the middle of the worship service, where as a consequence less urgency and responsiveness are directed toward a commitment for Christ may create “unintended consequences” in the theology and worship patterns of the black church. The committee notes concern that adequate resourcing and opportunities for theological reflection be offered along with the option of a newer order of worship.

Q19: The black church also continues with decided frequency (90%) to extend altar calls and to offer opportunities for private prayer or corporate prayer with participants physically present at the altar. This is a theological tie into the previous question. The traditional black church tends to make heavy use of the language of sacrifice and altar. This points to a number of theological differences that we as black UM Christians have with the UMC. We have not moved away from the language of sacrifice, nor have we moved away from the concept that the sermon is a major part of the worship service as indicated in the question about where the sermon is preached. The committee notes that this has implications upon the hymnody selected for worship.

Q20: The majority of black United Methodists surveyed baptize by sprinkling or pouring. The committee would like to note that a significant portion of the survey group, 15%, reports baptism by immersion -- in a denomination where sprinkling or pouring is the historical preference, with Methodism descending from the Anglican Church. We are reminded of myriad stories in the black church about baptisms in the creek back in the day and to a time when life-long black Methodists would not allow their grandchildren to be baptized by sprinkling or pouring, because only baptisms by immersion were considered to be “real.” The committee is also aware of a number of black United Methodist churches that have baptismal pools. This data also has implications for hymnody.

Q21: An overwhelming majority of black United Methodists receive communion monthly (86%). Our earlier Methodist tradition would suggest that monthly communion was necessary several decades ago when “circuit riders” ruled the day. Unfortunately, in today’s culture, communion as a sacrament is a practice worth re-examining in terms of frequency. Teaching the importance of the sacramental meaning of Holy Communion would shift many congregations beyond “the tradition of tradition” to “a tradition of theological significance.”

Q22: Most black United Methodist worshippers (60%) receive communion wafers and small individual cups at the altar. Less than a third report use of the bread and cup (for intinction) and fewer than 20% report use of pre-packaged communion (bread and wafer packaged together).

Q23: Only slightly more than one third of black United Methodist report that they walk to the table to give their offerings. Most give as usher pass the offering plates. However, offering time is time for

singing with 51% reporting that they sing during offerings, 68% report that the choir is singing, and 76% report singing a dedication song sometime during the offering. This is an underrepresented area in the hymn selections of current Methodist hymnals or song books along with welcoming music which is used by 33% of worshippers in Q37.

Q24: Though 90% of the time the announcements are in the worship bulletin, 68-73% of the time announcements are also shared by a liturgist or pastor. On the short survey, when the laity were asked what they liked least about worship in their churches they repeatedly indicated the announcements!

Q25: The list of occasional worship services reported by respondents is expansive. Of note is the emphasis placed upon occasional services in the Lent/Easter cycle (more than that placed upon the Advent/Christmas cycle). This is also reflected in the black church’s theological emphasis upon the Crucifixion and our being people of the Resurrection. Not nearly as much theological emphasis is placed upon Advent or baby Jesus. The Incarnation and humanity of Jesus are theological points of identification, as is the motif of the Suffering Servant. Men’s Day and Women’s Day continue to be standard observances as are church anniversaries, homecoming (friends and family day?), choir anniversaries and pastor’s anniversaries. More than one- third of the respondents report yearly or twice yearly revivals, and nearly half report some observance of MLK, Jr. Day in worship. Special days are essential teaching and learning moments. However, there seems to be a slippage of observing special days such as MLK, Jr. day which may now be in exchange for Human Relations Day. Another concern is a black heritage issue for the less than adequate amount of time the black church celebrates or incorporates its historical roots in worship for Black History Month, Juneteenth or Kwanzaa.

Section 3: Worship Planning and Good Church (Questions 26-34) Research findings: 26. Does someone plan worship at your church? (N=463) Value Count Percent Yes 435 93.95 I don't know 17 3.67 No 11 2.38

27. Who participates in planning worship at your church (Check all that apply.): (N=463) Value Count Percent Pastor(s) 435 93.95 Musician(s) 297 64.15 W Com 213 46.00 W Lead 172 37.15 Lay L 131 28.29 secretary 91 19.65 Volunteer 39 8.42 don’t know 21 4.54

28. How far in advance is worship planned at your church? (N=463) Value Count Percent 4-26 weeks 224 48.38 That week 116 25.05 1-4 weeks 63 13.61 I don't know 47 10.15 do not plan 11 2.38 That morning 2 .43

29. Which of the following is most descriptive of worship planning at your church? (Choose one) (N=441) Value Count Percent women 364 82.54 men 77 17.46

30. Which of the following best describes worship planning at your church? (Choose one) (N=463) Value Count Percent traditional 264 57.02 committee 119 25.70 spontaneous 80 17.28

31. In your opinion, whose influence is strongest in worship at your church? (N=464) Value Count Percent pastor 390 84.05 church members 42 9.05 musicians 32 6.9

32. On an average Sunday, how long is worship at your church? (N=464) Value Count Percent 90 minutes 230 49.57 2 hours 141 30.39 1 hour 80 17.24 More than two hours 13 2.8

33. Describe a “good” church service. Is there one that stands out in your memory? (n=287) Online survey results: Most respondents described worship where the music, message and Holy Spirit were in synergy and where the people were allowed to participate without feeling restricted by time or conventions. A number of people could point to specific services that were “good church” Several words were used repeatedly to describe what contributes to good worship: 73.5% --music, song or singing 58.2% -- sermon, message or preaching 39.4% -- spirit, spiritual or Holy Spirit 16.4% -- praise 16% -- free, spontaneous 15% -- choir 14.3% -- prayer 13.6% -- participation 10% -- unity, accord, together or engaged 9% -- invitation, altar call or salvation 8% -- testimony 8% -- worship style (blended, contemporary, traditional, style)

Please see the Appendix on p. 34 for more detailed responses. (Laity were also asked this question.)

34. Which of the following is true about “good” worship services? (Check all that apply.) (N=463) Value Count % Online % Short Survey singing 365 78.83 71.84 spiritual disciplines 331 71.49 56.92 Organized 327 70.63 60.74 can be planned 265 57.24 47.85 should be planned 218 47.08 44.75

Observations for Section 3: Q26: An overwhelming 94% people are aware that their worship services are planned. This dispels any myth that suggests that black United Methodists lean more toward spontaneity than planning.

Q27: Pastors (94%) and musicians (65%) play a prominent role in planning with worship leaders, lay leaders, and even church secretaries credited with (20%) planning input.

Q28: Nearly half of the group (48%) reports that planning takes place 4-26 weeks in advance. One- fourth of the group plans that week; while almost 15% of the group plans 1-4 weeks in advance.

Q29: Women do approximately 83% of the worship planning in the congregations represented in the study. (Note Q9 where statistics report that women comprise 66% of black United Methodist Church membership.)

Q30: Most worshippers (57%), report that they know what to expect on Sunday mornings because they have traditional patterns of worship that do not vary significantly. One-fourth of the group reports that a committee is involved in worship planning. The remaining respondents (17%) report that their worship is more spontaneous than planned.

Q31: Pastors continue to be the dominant influence over worship in black United Methodist Churches

Q32: 80% of church services last 90 minutes to 2 hours.

Q33: From the written descriptions of “good church” given by both the laity and the clergy, and from those recorded on video at the 2010 National BMCR meeting, it appears that the black church has a fairly uniform definition of what makes for a good worship experience. Most describe the delicate balance between good singing (where the congregation sings and the choir sings), good preaching, praise, prayer, testimony, and spontaneous participation from members of the congregation. The Holy Spirit is credited with making good church happen though planning is considered important (see the next question).

Q34: Singing is important to good worship. Both laity and church leaders cite good singing as the most important factor in “good worship, with planning and spiritual disciplines listed as next in importance. Even as 78% believe that “good singing” is crucial to having good church, the committee recommends further exploration of the level of engagement in actual good singing (as opposed to just clapping or swaying along with the music) in different kinds of churches, i.e., rural, urban, small church, large church. The actual experience of singing in black church worship merits further examination. [The closing and down-sizing of so many black UM churches might indicate that people are not experiencing good singing and therefore “good church” in their worship services.]

Section 4: Music (questions 36-54) Research Findings: 35. How many songs are sung during worship in a typical Sunday worship service at your church? (N=451) Value Count Percent 4-6 314 69.62 7+ 70 15.52 1-3 67 14.86

36. How many of these are sung by the congregation? (N=451) Value Count Percent 1-3 338 74.94 4-6 105 23.28 7+ 8 01.77

37. Where in the order of worship is the congregation invited to sing? (Check all that apply) (N=451) Value Count Percent Offertory 324 71.84 Communion 305 67.63 Gathering 300 66.52 benedictions 283 62.75 Recessional 273 60.53 Altar call 256 56.76 Processional 232 51.44 discipleship 228 50.55 Response 199 44.12 Call to Worship 181 40.13 Welcome 150 33.26 New Members 132 29.27 Prayer 131 29.05 Baptism 130 28.82 Other 32 7.10

38. Does the congregation sing: (N=449) Main Other Item Service Services Total from printed music or hymnal 388 80 468 from projected music/lyrics 69 32 101 from both printed & projected music/lyrics 107 27 134 from memory 262 60 322 from lined out lyrics 59 18 77 with CD for accompaniment 59 23 82 from none of the above 4 6 10

39. Does your congregation sing call and response praise songs? (N=451) Value Count Percent Yes 261 57.87 No 190 42.13

40. List the kinds of songs that your congregation sings in worship at your church (Check all that apply.) (N=451) Value Count Percent Hymns 438 97.12 Spirituals 378 83.81 Praise music 364 80.71 Traditional 308 68.29 gospel 287 63.64 Contemporary 270 59.87 Hymn choruses 219 48.56 Urban gospel 180 39.91 Scripture 93 20.62 Chants 88 19.51 Quartet 61 13.53 prayers 58 12.86 Long meter 39 8.65 Dr. Watts 38 8.43 Hip-hop 36 7.98 Decalogue 32 7.10 Ring shouts 9 2.00

41. Approximately how many songs written by John or Charles Wesley have you sung in the last 12 months (yearly average)? ___7.93___ (N=448)

42. Do you have one or more church musicians that play an instrument for weekly worship? (N=449) Value Count Percent Yes 400 89.09 No 49 10.91

43. Do(es) your musician(s) (N=434) Value Count Percent Both 304 70.05 Read Music 89 20.51 Play by Ear 41 09.45

44. Which of the following instruments does your church use during the Main Worship Service? (N=443) Value Count Percent Drum Set 270 60.94 Acoustic Piano 259 58.46 Keyboard 189 42.66 Organ 140 31.6 Guitar(s) 137 30.92 Hammond 117 26.41 Tracks 106 23.93 Electric Piano 102 23.02 Pipe Organ 62 14.00 Conga 38 8.58 Brass 35 7.90 Strings 30 6.77 Woodwind (sax, flute, etc.) 17 3.84 tambourines 9 2.03 None 4 .90 Others 5 1.13

45. Who selects the music that is sung in worship at your church? (Check all that apply) (N=441) Main Other Item Service Services Total Church Musician/Music Minister 343 80 423 Choir Director/Leader 222 53 275 Worship Leader/Director 66 26 92 Worship Committee 52 19 71 Church Secretary 13 7 20 Pastor 322 78 400 Other 14 10 24

46. Who leads the congregational singing in worship at your church? (Check all that apply) (N=443) Main Other Item Service Services Total Church Musician/Music Minister 238 62 300 Worship Leader/Director 122 42 164 Choir Director/Leader 186 44 230 Pastor 168 38 206 Praise Team 117 43 160 No one 42 7 49 Other 34 8 42

47. Who accompanies the congregational singing in your worship? (Check all that apply) (N=444) Main Other Item Service Services Total Organist 234 56 290 Pianist/keyboardist 344 88 432 Praise band 54 28 82 Choir 284 57 341 Recorded tracks or CD's 56 13 69 No one 14 4 18 Other 18 5 23

48. How often do you use the following in worship: (Check all that apply.) (N=448) Item Always Frequently Occasionally Rarely Never Total The Doxology 316 58 37 17 22 450 The Gloria Patri 218 71 61 53 46 449 Communion Responses (Sung) 145 55 71 71 108 450 Baptism Responses (Sung) 51 29 90 101 176 447 Amens 190 71 69 58 62 450 Lord’s Prayer 179 101 93 42 36 451 Offertory Responses (Sung) 309 51 25 21 46 452 Benediction (Sung) 200 34 51 65 97 447 Prayer Responses (Sung) 145 62 82 62 98 449 Apostle’s Creed or Other Creed 228 72 66 35 47 448 Psalter 140 65 99 73 72 449

49. Does your church have a choir(s)? (N=448) Value Count Percent Yes 427 95.31 No 21 04.69

50. If yes, how many choirs does your church have? (N=427) Value Count Percent 2 to 3 199 46.6 4 to 5 110 25.76 1 96 22.48 6 or more 22 05.15

51. How many Sundays per month does the choir (one of the choirs) sing in worship? (N=426) Value Count Percent 4 256 60.09 1 78 18.31 2 61 14.32 3 31 07.28

52. List the musical groups that may participate in worship in your church on a typical Sunday. (Check all that apply.) (N=435) Value Count Percent Choir(s) 415 95.4 Soloists 257 59.08 Praise team 190 43.68 Quartets 79 18.16 Band 56 12.87 Orchestra 9 02.07

53. How is new music learned by the Choir? (Check all that apply.) (N=421) Value Count Percent sheet music 335 79.57 by ear 263 62.47

54. How is new music learned by the Congregation? (N=428) Value Count Percent hearing 326 72.77 hymnals 302 67.41

Observations: Q35: We are a SINGING Church! With 70% of the churches singing 4-6 songs during worship and another 15% singing 7 or more songs! Since this question was not asked in the 2004 Music and Worship study, we have no way to compare the amount of singing that takes place in the black church with that which is happening in the rest of the UMC, though we suspect that the black church sings more than most congregations within the UMC.

Q36. Congregational Singing, where a predetermined musical selection is shared in worship, is not reported with the same frequency. Black churches report that they sing 1-3 congregational songs during the context of worship. It is presumed that this does not count the number of times people join in with the choir or sing ritual songs (like welcome songs, or offertory songs).

Q37: Black United Methodist church goers are invited to sing in a variety of places from the offering to communion, to welcome songs (note the number of people responding that they sing to welcome visitors), to altar calls, etc. It could be that the previous number reported the number of times a hymnal was used for congregational singing.

Q38: In the main service roughly 75% of those polled sing from printed music or from hymnals. More than half sing from memory, slightly more than a tenth of respondents sing from lined out lyrics. Are we using technology? Roughly 30% sing from projected music lyrics, often with a print back-up. Slightly more than one-tenth polled use CD accompaniment.

Q39: The majority of black churches (58%) sing call and response praise songs.

Q40: The black church sings a variety of musical genres. Reported in high usage are hymns (97%), praise music (81%), traditional black church music (68%), gospel songs (64%), and contemporary music (60%). Musical forms unique to the black church that continue are long-meter (9%), Dr. Watts (8%), ring shouts (2%), spirituals (84%) and certain forms of quartet (13.5%) music. Newer music forms reported in use are urban gospel (40%), and hip-hop (8%). Nearly 7% of churches report singing the Decalogue -- which continues to be sung in Pan-Methodist churches and is found in many of the AME, AMEZ, or CME hymnals. Though respondents reported that spirituals are part of the worship of their church, they were largely missing from the top 10 or top 25 list of songs sung by congregations. The laity survey confirms that most of the time when spirituals are sung, they are sung by choirs, quartets or other musical groups. Another possibility is that congregations amp up their presentation of spirituals during Black History Month, or for MLK, Jr. Day. The committee also notes the high percentage of Urban Gospel used in worship and notes that urban gospel, along with contemporary music may be one of the preferred musical styles of missing generations.

Q41: The question of how many Wesley songs are in use in the black church is fuzzy. Many respondents appear to have answered with the (inflated) number of times they use Wesley music instead of the intended number of different Wesley songs they were using. The corrected number could be (4) is based on a sample size of 222 responses. The committee notes concerns about the importance attributed to the Wesley hymns. If Charles and John are not articulating our theology then WHO is?

Q42: 89% of black churches have some kind of church musician; in spite of the fact that most of our responses came from small membership churches. The results of the “good church” question point to the need for well-trained, spiritually alert musicians who can work as part of a ‘team’ with pastors and other worship leaders.

Q43: Participants report that 70% of their musicians both read music and play by ear.

Q44: The black church worships with a wide variety of instrumentation. Drums sets are in 60% of our congregations and skin drums are used in 8.5% of churches reporting. The majority of our congregations use more Keyboards, electric pianos, or acoustic pianos (count 550) than organs (count 179) – along with a variety of brass, strings, woodwinds, tambourines and other instruments.

Q45: Pastors, church musicians and choir directors select most of the music for worship.

Q46: Church musicians and choir directors lead most of the congregational singing, with pastors also leading congregational singing in the main worship service 38% of the time.

Q47: Most of the time congregational singing is accompanied by pianist/keyboardist, choir, or organist.

Q48: Service music, creeds, etc, top three used – doxology, offertory, apostle’s creed, Bottom three – baptism response, Psalter, sung prayer response

Q49: 95% of black churches have a choir (only 89% reported having musicians). The committee notes that with more frequency than usually reported, pastors also serve as church musicians, especially in smaller membership churches. When pastors serve as musicians, congregation may see this as a pastoral

role and still think of themselves as being without a musician. Persons who lead songs in rotation also substitute for choir directors in some congregational settings.

Q50: 47% reported having 2-3 choirs (again, the majority of churches reporting were small membership churches. I think this highlights the value of music and singing in the black church.)

Q51: 60% report that one of the choirs sing every Sunday.

Q52: A wide variety of musical groups participate in worship. 95% report having choirs, 59% soloists, 44% a praise team, 18% have quartets, and 15% have a band or orchestra!

Q53: More than half of the time, the choir learns new music from sheet music. 44% of the time choirs learn music by ear. This suggests that a significant portion of music is coming from the oral tradition or from outside sources.

Q54: Conversely, the congregation is slightly more likely (52%) to learn music by ear than from printed music

Section 5: Hymnal Resources, (questions 55-73) Research Findings: 55. Which hymnals or songbooks does your church use regularly during the main worship service? (Check all that apply.) (N=420) Value Count Percent UMH 379 90.24 Songs of Zion 256 60.95 Af Am Heritage 174 41.43 The Faith We Sing 126 30.00 Zion SS 88 20.95 Nat Baptist 65 15.48 Cokesbury 28 6.67 Other Methodist 19 4.52 Global Praise 7 1.67 Family of God 5 1.19 Other 19 4.52 none 12 2.86

56. Approximately what percentage of the time does your congregation sing from The 1989 United Methodist Hymnal in worship? (N=419) Value Count Percent 0-25% 117 27.92% 26-50% 91 21.72% 51-75% 94 22.43% 76-100% 117 27.92%

57. Approximately what percentage of the time does your congregation sing from Songs of Zion or Zion Still Sings in worship? (N=420) Value Count Percent 0-25% 305 72.62% 26-50% 91 21.67% 51-75% 19 4.52% 76-100% 5 1.19%

58. Approximately what percentage of the time does your congregation sing from the African American Heritage Hymnal, or another hymnal in worship? (N=420) Value Count Percent 0-25% 337 80.24% 26-50% 54 12.86% 51-75% 20 4.76% 76-100% 9 2.14%

Comparisons: Side by Side UMH SOZ/ZSS AAHH/other 0 -25% 27.92% 72.62% 80.24% 26-50% 21.72% 21.67% 12.86% 51.75% 22.43% 4.52% 4.76% 76-100% 27.92% 1.19% 2.14%

59. About how many new or unfamiliar songs do you sing each month? (N=420) Value Count Percent None 62 14.76 1-2 295 70.24 3-5 56 13.33 6-10 5 1.19 10+ 2 .48

60: List the top ten songs that are sung frequently in worship at your church: (for the remaining selections please see the Appendix, p. 48) Online Survey UM List from Count HYMNAL Facebook Sept 2010 1. Blessed Assurance 136 #369 UMH Here I Am, Lord 2. Amazing Grace 125 #378 UMH How Great Thou Art 3. Holy, Holy, Holy 78 #64 UMH Amazing Grace 4. Leaning On The Hymn of Promise Everlasting Arms (What A 63 #133 UMH Fellowship) 5. O How I Love Jesus 53 #170 UMH In the Garden 6. Pass Me Not O Gentle Lord of the Dance 52 #351 UMH Savior 7. How Great Thou Art 51 #77 UMH It is Well With My Soul 8. Great Is Thy Faithfulness 47 #140 UMH Be Thou My Vision 9. What A Friend We Have Great is Thy Faithfulness 45 #526 UMH In Jesus 10. My Hope Is Built 42 #368 UMH Blessed Assurance 11. O For A Thousand 39 #57 UMH The Old Rugged Cross Tongues To Sing / Sweet, Sweet Spirit (tie) 39 #334 UMH 12. Marching To Zion 34 #733 UMH Holy, Holy, Holy 13. We'll Understand It O for a thousand Tongues to 33 #525 UMH Better Bye And Bye Sing 14. Jesus, Keep Me Near The 32 #301 UMH Spirit Song Cross This Is The Day (tie) 32 #658 UMH 15. Let Us Break Bread 29 #618 UMH Victory in Jesus

Together 16. Here I Am Lord/ 28 #593 UMH Pass it On Spirit Song --tie 28 #347 UMH What a Friend We Have in 17. This Little Light 27 #585 UMH Jesus 18. Because He Lives 26 #364 UMH Christ the Lord Is Risen Today Doxology --tie 26

Lord, You Have Come to the 24 #8 SOZ 19. At The Cross/ Lakeshore Lift Every Voice And Sing -- tie 24 #519 UMH Joyful, Joyful We Adore Thee/ 20. I Surrender All 23 #354 UMH Come Thou Fount of Every Just As I Am -- tie Blessing (tie) 23 #357 UMH 21. Precious Lord 22 #474 UMH 22. We’ve Come This Far By 21 #192 SOZ Faith 23. Victory In Jesus 20 #370 UMH 24. Standing On The 19 #374 UMH Promises 25. What A Mighty God We 19 #6 ZSS Serve

61. Which of the following types of resources do you use for worship? (Check all that apply.) (N=405) Item Regularly Occasionally Never Total Hymnals 360 31 8 399 Songbooks 99 127 79 305 Downloadable Music/Lyrics 70 94 114 278 Copies of Music/Lyrics 110 126 65 301 Local Compositions and Arrangements 31 95 137 263 Local Song Collection 27 69 162 258 Charts/Scores Created from Listening to Music 16 62 169 247 CDs Learned by Ear and Taught to Choir Members 119 109 69 297

62. Do you use the Psalms in the United Methodist Hymnal? (If “no” skip to question #66.) (N=407) Value Count Percent Yes 260 63.88 No 147 36.12

3. If “yes” how do currently use the Psalter in the UMH? (N=267)

Value Count Percent Responsive 237 88.76 Read 89 33.33 Chanted 25 9.36 Use Psalms from other sources 14 5.24

64. How often do you re-write, rearrange, or substitute for the sung response given? (N=278) Value Count Percent Never 178 64.03 Occasionally 74 26.62 Frequently 26 9.35

65. Do you use the Psalm as: (Check all that apply.) (N=271) Value Count Percent Scripture reading 159 58.67 Call to Worship 120 44.28 Response to OT 72 26.57 Other 39 14.39

66. For each of the following services in The 1989 United Methodist Hymnal, please indicate whether or not you use that service from the hymnal or from the bulletin or if it is not used in your church. We have provided the page numbers on which the services appear in the hymnal for your convenience. (N=406) Use Use Printed Hymnal Hymnal in Item - Yes - No Bulletin Total Communion Service p. 12 358 35 21 414 Communion Music p. 17 144 35 235 414 Baptism Service p. 33 357 19 37 413 Baptism Music p. 53 82 21 304 407 Confirmation p. 45 289 19 103 411 Reception of Members p. 45 311 18 80 409 Reaffirmation p. 45 289 24 97 410 Marriage p. 864 253 32 127 412 Death/Resurrection p. 870 227 38 145 410 Daily Praise/Prayer p. 876 98 36 277 411

67. For each of the following services in The 1989 United Methodist Hymnal, please indicate any other sources you use for that type of service. Please see Appendix, p. 64, for details.

68. Do you use the services of Morning Prayer or Evening Prayer? (If “no,” skip to question #72) (N=408) Value Count Percent No 358 87.75 Yes 50 12.25

69. If “yes:” how often do you use them? (N=58) Value Count Percent Occasionally 38 65.52 Frequently 20 34.48

70. Who leads them? (N=66) Value Count Percent Pastor 37 56.92 Lay person 12 18.46 Worship leader 12 18.46 Other 4 6.06

71. When do you use them? (Check all that apply.) (N=63) Value Count Percent meeting 34 53.97 Sunday morning 31 49.21 Weeknight 23 36.51 Retreat 18 28.57 Weekday 18 28.57 Sunday night 3 4.76 Other 7 11.11

72. Are there other services you would use if they were in the hymnal? (N=404) Value Count Percent No 290 71.78 Yes 114 28.22

73. If “Yes” list them: Other services: Please see Appendix, p. 70, for details.

OBSERVATIONS for Section 5: Q55: The percentage of churches using the African American Heritage Hymnal (41%) and the National Baptist Hymnal (15%) bears mention. (Over 15% of black UM churches report that they exclusively practice of baptism by immersion.) As John Wesley taught, the people of the church learn doctrine through song. Denominational hymnals are repositories of religious doctrine and practice --which is exactly why we are engaged in this process. It is encouraging that a very large percentage of churches are finding what they need in resources produced for United Methodist congregations (UMH, TFWS, SOZ, ZSS). At the same time, such a hybrid of utilization is not easy on congregations or on worship leaders.

Q56-58: Compared side-by side, there are several conclusions to make about hymnal usage in the black UMC. It would appear that the black United Methodist church community has not found one hymnal or another that it prefers for primary usage. The written comments in q. 85 and in the listening sessions suggest that the black church has not yet found what it is looking for in terms of resourcing.

Q59: The Black Church is open to learning new music with 70% of respondents reporting that they sing 1-2 new or unfamiliar songs each month. If they are not coming from the three hymnals mentioned in q 56-58, where do these songs come from?

Q60: From previous questions, it appears that hymns are not the primary vehicle for music expression in the black United Methodist church. In question 12, 60% report blended worship in the main worship service suggesting that other styles of music are also being used with some frequency. In Q. 40 use of hymns was at the top of the list -- but responses for spirituals, praise music, traditional black church music, gospel and contemporary music were between 60 and 84%, followed closely by urban gospel at 40%. In the short survey completed by the laity, the laity mentioned gospel songs with greater frequency than they mentioned singing hymns. Seen in this light, it appears that this list of favorite songs may actually turn out to be core listing of traditional hymn music for the black United Methodist church. In other words, when we sing hymns, these are the hymns we usually sing! When old, traditional hymns are sung in the black church, they are rarely sung as written; and they are frequently played and sung from memory, not from printed music. Each church and each choir brings its own identity to the traditional hymn in an environment where improvisation is expected. Old hymns have been overlaid with blues harmonies, “blue notes” (flatted 3rds, 5ths, and 7ths), parallel second inversion chords – and other musical devices that break the rules of European harmony – all to appeal to the black church aesthetic. These, joined with other alterations create the ‘traditional’ black church sound. For years, older traditional hymns have been reharmonized by the congregation and rearranged by skilled musicians for a new generation of choirs. Black church musicians are known to change the time signature (i.e. 4-4 may become 12-8, or 3-4 may become 9-8) giving the song an entirely different feel. Occasionally, even the melody line is changed! Not every hymn is conducive to this radical style of contextualization. In spite of the aforementioned realities, the committee notes concerns that this song list raises. Why haven’t more of the newer hymns been embraced by the black worshippers in the United Methodist

church? Adherence to an old list of standards could suggest that there is resistance on the part of congregations to adopt newer favorites or hesitation on the part of musicians and worship planners to encourage enough congregational singing for congregations to adopt a broader repertoire of hymns. The committee also notes concerns that the insistence of some worship leaders upon the use of certain styles of new music may have created a silent “worship war” within the black church and traditional hymns are being used to placate more traditional factions within the congregation. The committee notes its concern about a decided decline in congregational singing and about the decline of congregational singing of Negro spirituals.

Q61: The black church gets its music for worship from four major sources: hymnals, copies of music/lyrics, or music learned by ear from CD’s and taught to choir members (and to the congregation), followed by songbooks. We are less likely to rely upon local song collections or compositions, or to create charts/scores from listening to music or to download music.

Q62-65: The black church does use the Psalter in the United Methodist Hymnal but most often for responsive readings, calls to worship or scripture readings. The Psalms are rarely sung or chanted.

Q66: 86% of respondents use the Communion ritual or the Baptismal ritual written in the hymnal and most use it from the hymnal (not printed in the bulletin). Confirmation and Reaffirmation rituals are used 70% of the time. Least used are baptism music 20%, and the communion music 35%. For a church that places a high value upon communion this is significant. Several musicians have asked the committee what happened to the blood songs (meaning the songs that mention the blood of Jesus that are frequently used as communion songs in the black church—“There is a Fountain Filled with Blood,” “Oh, the Blood of Jesus,” “The Blood that Jesus Shed for Me,” “I Know It Was the Blood,” etc.). The blood songs reflect a church that has historically embraced a theology of suffering and frequently takes the atonement view of the significance of the cross of Jesus Christ. At least two songs that are found on the Top-25 song list reflect this theological perspective, “Jesus Keep Me Near the Cross” and “At the Cross.”

Q67: leaders in the black church have been exceptionally creative in seeking or creating alternative resources for the basic rituals of the United Methodist Church. When asked about alternative sources, many refer to other resources found in the United Methodist Hymnal or UMBOW. However, a significant number of people cite the use of the African American Heritage Hymnal and GBOD’s Africana resources or other ritual resources made available online at GBOD.org. The use of the Songs of Zion or Zion Still Sings for supplemental music for communion or baptism was encouraging. It also would appear that the spirituals are used more heavily to accompany the rituals than in regular church worship.

Q68—71: Services of morning or evening prayer are used by only 12% of respondents. Pastors usually lead them when they are used, and they are most often used in a meeting.

Q72: 285 of people say that there are services that they would use if they were in the hymnal.

Q73: A great deal of response was received for this question. It seems that additional resources appropriate for use in black church settings were requested for the Advent/Christmas cycle and more specifically for the Lent/Easter Cycle. There were a number of requests for resources for Foot Washing, Healing Services, and resources that could be used to open meetings or bible studies. Aside for the requests for more resources for the Advent/Lent cycles most of the requests centered around observances that are unique to or characteristic of worship in the black church. Many requests were made for special days in the black church like Women’s day, Men’s day, Watch Night, Juneteenth and Kwanzaa. Materials for Rites of Passage and Confirmation were also requested.

Section 6: Technology, (questions 74-85) Research Findings: 74. What types of electronic resources do you use in planning/performing the music for worship? (N=383) Value Count Percent CD’s 222 57.96 Internet 188 49.09 tapes 104 27.15 Projection 98 25.59 None 85 22.19 MIDI 24 06.27 Other 12 3.13

75. Do you or your worship/music planners use the Internet for: (N=383) Value Count Percent worship resources 199 51.96 choir music 188 49.09 cong. music 98 25.59 Do not use 121 31.59

76. What equipment are you currently using in worship? (N=383) Value Count Percent Sound system 302 78.85 CD player 156 40.73 PowerPoint 109 28.46 LCD projector 91 23.76 none 43 11.23 MIDI 29 07.57 projector 27 07.05 Other 12 3.13

77. Are you using projection for congregational singing? (If “no,” please proceed to question #81) (N=383) Value Count Percent No 282 73.63 Yes 101 26.37

78. If “yes,” are you projecting: (N=104) Value Count Percent Words 95 91.35 Words and music 9 08.65

79. How often do you use projection? (N=124) Main Other Item Service Services Total Weekly 63 25 88 Bi-weekly 4 2 6 Monthly 11 4 15 Quarterly 6 4 10 Special Services/Infrequently 29 19 48

80. Where do you get your slides? (N=114) Value Count Percent creating slides 64 55.17 All 53 45.69 Internet 35 30.17 Pre-Packaged: Corel, Easy Worship, Hymnal on CD, UMH, Sunday Plus, ProPresenter, Media Shout Shoutables 7 6.14

81. Is your church using more, less or about the same level of technology as 3 years ago? N=383 Value Count Percent Same 191 49.87 More 149 38.90 Not sure 30 07.83 Less 13 03.39

82. Which kinds of technology do you expect your church to adopt for use in worship in the next 3-5 years? (N=383) Value Count Percent Power Point 216 56.40 LCD projector 162 42.30 Sound system 153 39.95 Internet 122 31.85 CD’s 102 26.63 tapes 83 21.67 projector 75 19.58 MIDI 34 08.88 None 11 2.87 N/A 6 N/A Not sure, don’t know 8 2.09 Other: (Live video stream, iPod, movie clips, wireless headsets, etc. 29 7.57

83. Is there anything in the area of music and worship that you wish you had but can’t find? Are there any unmet music resource needs? Please see the Appendix, p. 72, for details.

84. What has been the biggest change in worship and music at your church in the last 10 years? (For more details, see the Appendix, p. 74.)

A number of respondents noted fundamental change in their worship services like the addition of Projection and other technology New worship services Different times for worship Different styles of worship in new or old services New or enlarged use of Contemporary music More diversity in music selections Less use of More instrumentation Different kinds of choirs/ musicians Broader use of resources Addition of liturgical dance or mime groups Hip-hop

On the down-side, several lamented The loss of trained musicians The loss of someone to play the pipe organ Pastoral changes

85. Do you have any additional comments or suggestions you would like to make? (Please see the Appendix, p. 80, for details.)

Observations for Section 6: Q74: Among the electronic resources used in planning or performing the music for worship, CDs and Internet scored highest with 58% reporting the use of CDs and 49% reporting the use of the internet in worship planning.

Q75: When the Internet is used for worship planning, 51% use it to find worship resources, 49% look for choir music and only 26% look for congregational music. 32% report that they do not use the Internet for worship planning. In the age of electronic media, it is disappointing that so many of our African American congregations (49%) are still lagging behind the general population in the usage of the internet to research and to be exposed to relevant worship resources. It appears that it would helpful for congregations to utilize the internet more extensively for worship planning and not only just music.

Q76: Equipment. The majority of churches report the use of sound systems (79%) while 41% report use of CD players, and only 28% use PowerPoint.

Q77: Only 26% of those surveyed use projection for congregational singing.

Q78: Of that group, 91% are projecting words only.

Q79: Projection is most often used in the main service on a weekly basis.

Q80: Most create their own slides (55%), 30% get them from the Internet. A very small group (6%) uses pre-packaged slides.

Q81: About half (50%) are using the same level of technology as three years ago; 39% are using more.

Q82: More than half (56%) expect to add PowerPoint, 42% expect to add projectors, and 40% expect to add or upgrade sound systems.

Q83: Mentioned among unmet needs were African or Africana videos for use in worship, tracks for music, CDs that demonstrated multiple ways to sing songs, gospel music, praise music, ways to include children and youth in worship, use of jazz in worship, music arrangements more accurately notated for the black community and several suggested including more gospel songs in the UMH so that they would not need to purchase two books. They asked for instruction in worship planning for pastors, and workshops in worship for choirs and musicians. Also mentioned again were more resources for Advent/Lenten seasons, more seasonal resources, and orchestra arrangements of UMH selections (so they would not have to use those from the Baptist hymnals).

Q84: A number of people noted the addition of technology in their worship experiences and changes in worship that involved a broader use of music or the inclusion of the worship arts, like mime, hip-hop or liturgical dance. Instrumentation was broadened in a great number of places and many churches are happy to have found more skilled musicians. On the down side, some churches note the loss of one or more skilled musicians, organists. Several also regretted changes their leaders had made to make worship more contemporary in music and preaching style.

Q85: A number of people expressed interest in a new hymnal with updated music, gospel music and more “singable” music. Several spoke of the need for more contemporary music, or for more Caribbean and African liturgy. A number of people suggested either using the African American Heritage Hymnal or of adding more music to the new United Methodist Hymnal. Others spoke of giving attention to old standards in any new hymnal and of giving more attention to music suitable for young people and children.

Appendix. Question 33: “Good Church”

1. "Good" church service is when music is supportive of message and congregation is fully involved in the service. 2. "good" worship is when the music, songs and preaching all carry the same theme. When worshippers participate actively during singing and preaching. 3. *Participatory - multiple gifts operating, congregation fully engaged *Consistency of theme - all elements of worship reinforcing one another (sermon, music, graphics, etc.) *Open and flexible to the move of the Holy Spirit!!! 4. 1 1/2 hrs in length. Start on time. Choir singing for processional and recessional. Sermon 20- 30 minutes. Anthem(s). Hymns from hymnal. Altar prayer. Invitation. Offering by ushers passing plate. Liturgist. One person reading scriptures. Lord's prayer. Apostle's creed. Announcements at beginning or end of service. 5. A "good” church service is one where people feel free and unrestricted in experiencing God's presence. Such a service also reflects the varied ways God speaks to people (i.e., music, prayer, contemplation, dance, scripture, sermons, etc.) Each of these reflects advanced preparation, order and timeliness. However, all of these make room for the Holy Spirit to move throughout the worship experience. 6. A "good” worship service is one where the spirit of moves everyone to share the joy of the word by actively participating in the fellowship, thus enhancing the experience. 7. a "good" church service involves a movement of the Holy Spirit. 8. A "good" church service is a service when several people give their life to Christ. 9. A "good" church service is one in which persons hear a Word from God either through the scriptures, songs or spoken Word that moves them to action-either personal, corporate or in the world, making a difference in their lives and bringing them into closer relationship to God. 10. A "good" church service is one that incorporates as many "willing" participates as possible, young and old. Providing opportunities for individual and group leadership. 11. A "good" church service is one that moves from praise to worship and is not fragmented with misplaced rituals. It should flow from beginning to end so that a worshipful attitude is maintained throughout the entire service. Communion should not be separated out as a "2nd Service". It should somehow be part of the flow even if it means that part of the "ritual" is "blended". Currently, reverence is lost because people don't know the chants and have to flip pages in the hymnal. I would much prefer a blended communion celebration! 12. A "good" church service is one that the Holy Spirit is moving, the word is proclaimed, and the choir sings to the Glory of God! 13. A "good" church service is one where the music is powerful, the Holy Spirit is present, and the Word flows like water. It's one where people don't mind witnessing to the goodness of the Lord. 14. A "good" church service is to allow the movement of the holy spirit freely and moments of spiritual enrichment blended in with traditional worship agendas. 15. A "good" church service is when all involved give their all in worship, singing is done well, preaching is done well and the entire congregation comes in anticipation of encouragement for life. There is an effectiveness or positive end result to the worship experience. 16. A "good" church service is when the Holy Spirit is at work, the choir sings spirit filled songs of praise, and the preached word goes forth with power and anointing 17. A "good" church service to me is one that has much music and singing the gives me a message in song, and a sermon that is meaningful and that I can take away for reflection.

18. A "good" church service to me is where all members, visitors, and strangers come together to praise God without feeling alienated 19. A "good" church service: The presence of the Lord can be experienced by the congregation; You see the expression on their faces. People praising the Lord. 20. A "good" worship service is spirit filled, Songs are meaningful and inspiring, fervent heart-felt prayers, powerful sermons that teach and convict. persons accepting the invitation to Christian Discipleship. 21. A few weeks ago we had Friends and Family day and the Lord Blessed the singing and the preaching! 22. A good church service is when I can come away___ having been given food for thought through either the sermon, the music, and/or a testimony. 23. A good church is always wear God and his Son is the center of the service each and every Sunday. We praise the Lord in my church every Sunday through Preaching, Song and dance. 24. A good church is one that is faithful to the great commission, confronts injustice, and disciples its members to be kingdom people. 25. A good church service e is when all of God's people are on one accord One Sunday that happened, this church was on FIRE, everyone who came out left refreshed and ready to do service outside of church 26. A good church service begins and ends on time. The music compliments the sermon and everybody is a participant. 27. A good church service enables people to encounter our Living God. It provides the comfort of structure, yet is flexible enough for the spirit to move. A good worship service engages all ages and all styles. 28. A good church service entails youth and senior participation plus familiar hymns and sound transforming preaching 29. A good church service is a service where people come ready to be engaged in worship and allow the movement of the Holy Spirit 30. a good church service is an intergenerational service that meets the need of all 31. A good church service is Christ centered, focus is on the Bible, is celebratory, and spontaneous, love is expressed openly, participation is encouraged. 32. A good church service is one in which Jesus touches someone’s heart and a decision is made and a life is changed for Him. Music can set the stage and usually does. The message definitely has to be good. The music and the message have to connect together. This is so important. If they do not, the service will seem disjointed. 33. A good church service is one in which the people have participated and felt empowered by God by hearing the Word through music, preaching, prayers and/or sharing testimony. The Sunday after Obama's election was evidence of a good worship experience. Built into the sermon was an opportunity for persons to testify as to what the election meant to them. The eldest member testified as to how he had served in WWII and how African Americans had been treated. He prophesied that "the eyes of the world were watching to see how America handled this." Even after service dismissed, people were talking, praising God for Obama's election. 34. A good church service is one in which the presence of the Holy Spirit is most evident in the flow of worship and the continuity of the Message through the spoken Word and the Word in song. In a good service you can see and hear the presence of the Holy Spirit in all the participants in worship. 35. A good church service is one in which the singing is great and the pastor is dynamic and

timely. We have had several of these under our present pastor. 36. A good church service is one that empowers, equips, and encourages me through the preached word, the singing of hymns, spiritual songs and the testimonies of my sisters and brothers. 37. A good church service is one that inspires, equips, provided fellowship, and feeds the soul through word, songs, and interaction. 38. A good church service is one where the congregation is attentive and responsive to the sermon and filled with the spirit throughout the service. 39. A good church service is one where the congregation is attentive and responsive to the sermon and filled with the spirit throughout the service. 40. A good church service is one where the Spirit is in the church. It is one where you expect the Holy Spirit. You wonder what is going to happen. 41. A good church service is there are a combination of elements in worship that connect to the message and the people - when we use visuals, the dancers, mime, music and spoken word 42. A good church service is when all of the congregation is in sink with the flow of the Holy Spirit. 43. A good church service is when every member is in sink with the flow of the spirit. 44. A good church service is when people come expecting the move of the Holy Spirit worshipping in sprit and in truth. 45. A good church service is where ministry to the flock takes place. People who hurting and those who are not leave with something to feast on for the week ahead. 46. A good church service is where the presence of the Holy Spirit dwells. It reflects in the music and in the preaching. It is free in the sense that for those who are more demonstrative in their faith they can feel free to stand and say Hallelujah. And for those who prefer to be more reflective concerning their worship they can be free to do that as well. Also a good church proclaims the gospel message of the risen Savior and does not compromise that. 47. A good church service means that the congregation sang the two hymns, that they were engaged in the sermon and no one was angry enough to yell about the sermon. 48. A good church service to me is when the congregation shares with the choir in the worship through song and praise. When someone joins. 49. A good Church service would be one in which the choir prepares the congregation spiritually and the Pastor brings a soul stirring sermon. 50. A good praise and worship service with the members sharing and being involved as well as a good sermon with the members involvement. 51. A good service consists of good up-beat music that everyone participates in and sings with joy, excitement and reverence. Everyone is focused on the service and engaged in the ritual. NO Chatter during service! A strong choir that LEADS the singing and supports the pastor and rituals of the service. A good sermon with a message. A service that lasts only 1 hour. 52. A good service for us is when the music and the word mesh in such a way that congregants can feel the spirit and people are visibly moved accordingly. 53. A good service includes praise and worship plus testimony time. The songs sung by the choir also enhance the service, but I think the Altar Call is the most beneficial spiritually. 54. A good service is blessed with high spirit, an inspiring message and great singing 55. A good service is Spirit filled. There is good singing, dancing and little spontaneous coupled with sharing of testimonies. 56. A good service is when a sinner gives his or her life to Christ. 57. A good service is when the congregation, music, spoken word through the pastor all other

aspects of service are on one accord. 58. A good service is when the Holy Spirit presence is with us in singing, preaching and prayer with people watching the clock. 59. A GOOD SERVICE IS WHEN THE SPIRIT OF THE LORD IS PRESENT IN THE MEMBERS AND THE PRESENTATION OF THE MUSIC AND THE MESSAGE 60. A good service occurred when the praise team opened with lively contemporary music, where there were less traditional elements, no gospel or chancel choir, not many hymns sung, and contemporary worship music was sung at the end of the service. 61. A good worship is one that is organized with good music and excellent preaching. 62. A good worship service holds the various segments or acts of worship together so that they all glorify and praise God, and they all connect with each other and leave people enlightened and uplifted in Jesus the Christ. 63. A good worship service is multi-sensory with singing, dance, and biblical preaching. It is one in which the congregation is actively participating in with worship, not observing and it allows for the movement of the Holy Spirit. Sometimes in our church this has meant that persons are prayed over individually (this has happened a couple of times in that the anointing is there for an hour to pray). 64. A good worship service is one in which there is freedom to worship and experience worship through a variety of avenues. 65. a good worship service is one that includes order and sacraments, music, and worship, with input from the congregation. 66. A good worship service is one where folks feel like they have been touched by the Holy Spirit, where they have been challenged to make a change in their lives or grow in their spiritual lives, and where they have been strengthened for the journey or week ahead. A "good" worship service not too long ago was one where we wrote down conflicts, unforgiveness, resentments, disappointments, etc. on slips of paper and burned them on the altar! Release of the captives and deliverance from bondage! 67. A good worship service is one where the message and the music compliment each other. One where you leave thinking about what was said and have a hymn or the solo running around in your head. 68. A good worship service is planned, but allows the presence of the Holy Spirit to inspire the choir to sing at its best, the preacher to have a word from God and the congregation be filled with the presence of God's Spirit. 69. A good worship service is when the congregation is involved and acknowledges the presence of Holy Spirit. 70. A good worship service is when we have visitors and guests. Believe it or not, funerals are better than our normal worship service. 71. A good worship service to me is when people are being transformed delivered and prayer is offered for special needs. In addition good singing is important. 72. A planned service with a balance of music, prayer, and welcoming where the congregation is active/engaged. 73. A Sermon that tells how one should live, good songs and scripture relating to the subject. 74. A service of Prayer and Praise and the preached word. 75. A service of spontaneous praise and testimony, expository preaching and someone is saved! 76. A service that flows well; has meaningful music, meaningful prayer and Christ centered preaching that is understandable to all and where people leave with a message they can use

during their week; a service where the people can be involved 77. A service that is planned, but can be flexible, allow the moving of the Spirit and one that involves everyone at some point Blended more than one worship style 78. a service where the choir and the congregation and the pastor all seem to be on the same page and directed toward God. 79. A service where the presence of the Lord is felt from its onset and continues to develop throughout. 80. A service wherein the choir's music is openly responded to; there is active call/response to the sermon; someone dedicates their life to Christ/joins the church/is saved; and, the pews are full. 81. A Spirit-filled, well paced, with excellent musicians leading the congregation to praise and worship our Wonderful God; with moments of reflection, a stirring sermon that will lead individuals to DO something and join others to be the body of Christ. 82. A worship service that is inspirational, joyous and Spirit filled. 83. A worship celebration where scriptures songs/hymns sermon all connect with the Spirit of God 84. A" good "church service is well organized and orderly. One that has been planned. 85. active participation by worshippers, call and response to sermon, 86. active programs for youth, young adults, prayer life, strong music ministry, open to everyone, inviting 87. All of our services are 'good'; however, the better ones are those around holidays when members who haven't attended in a while and family members are in attendance. 88. All persons have the opportunity to witness if the spirit leads this to happen which enhances the services greatly. Music is a great factor in worship as well as the word. If request is made for special song, it is provided by choir or soloist. 89. An uplifting and spiritual service with good follow up and congregational interaction 90. Baptism Sunday when both children and adults are baptized 91. Being more a "family chapel" with a high attendance being 8-10, we enjoy a camaraderie and intimacy, that makes any service unique and joy-filled. 92. Black History Sunday services in February; prominent guests invited weekly to bring a Black History moment; choir's music is inspirational, the pastor's sermon is uplifting; after service soul food "pot-luck" lunch 93. Blended Music to reach all ages. Good preaching that is engaging use of all ages in worship Service that ushers in the spirit of God Congregations that is witnessing & responsive to the move of the spirit 94. Blended with praise singing, gospel and contemporary music, hymns and spirituals; meaningful liturgy that compliments Scripture reading, dynamic preaching and use of electronic visuals and technology 95. Celebration and spontaneity, visual screen, no altar, no Western-European religious relics, symbols of any kind--free sharing from parishioners during our worship, no printed songs except on overhead projection screen, no printed bulletin--we have collective prayer of entire congregation but no altar in the building. Members leave feeling spiritual and emotional release as well as intellectual stimulation wedded with experience and calls to action. 96. Church Anniversary/Homecoming combined. The people were very excited! 97. Cohesive content. Music, scripture, sermon/message, etc. all support the intended goal of the Good News message.

98. Congregational praising the Lord in song and someone accept Jesus Christ as their personal Savior. 99. Congregation comes in with positive attitude--smiling and speaking and generally glad to be there; the pastoral prayer is preceded with the people lifting joys and concerns from the preceding week, everyone sings, pastor engages all age groups' attention--even the young give up sneaking a text-message and the sermon later becomes a part of the family conversation--often brought up by the youth in the family. The people fill the altar for silent prayer following the sermon; all join in singing the postlude; and even then, no one is in a hurry to leave. 100. congregation involved 101. Congregational participation, flow (theme from beginning to end), spirited, planned, prepared for. 102. Easter or a special worship when we step outside the box. 103. Easter Sunday 2010. The combined choir was inspired in their singing. The praise dancer was inspired in her dancing. The musicians were inspired in their playing. The preacher was inspired in his preaching. And, all of this "inspiration" inspired the congregation, so that it was truly a worship experience and not a worship service. 104. Easter Sunday Pay It Forward Sunday Palm Sunday June 6, 2010 105. Easter. 106. Energetic congregational singing, inspiring choral selections, an anointed word (message), diverse age-group participation, moving prayer 107. Enthusiastic choir, responsive congregation, sermon well-organized and well- delivered, connectedness between music and sermon theme, responsiveness to the Altar Call, testimony(-ies) responding to service 108. Everyone participates in some of the singing. People clap and respond when moved by the music. The sermon relates to what is going on today. 109. Everything clicks - the music, the sermon and the congregation is in tuned with the spirit 110. excellent sermon- good related music 111. Excellent singing; powerful, relevant message; feel inspired to go out and act. 112. Flows smoothly; evidence of theme throughout prayers, music, scripture and message; obvious infusion of Holy Spirit's anointing and power; lack of contrary spirits at work 113. full participation of members Responding to the Holy Spirit Good Gospel preaching & teaching 114. Glide Memorial in San Francisco, Good music, preaching, connected to the community. 115. Good church in my experience is when the liturgy, music, and sermon fuses seamlessly together such that when parishioners leave they feel in harmony with one another, clear understanding of the intention of the sermon's message, and think about how they can best put message into action in their lives and lives of others 116. Good church is when the children and youth are the planners and participates in every worship experience 117. Good church is when you actually feel the presence of God in the church service. Gifts are active. Lives are changed. Prayers are answered. The word becomes alive 118. good church service has a blending of worship

119. Good church services is one in which the congregation is emotionally moved by the message and the music from the choir. 120. Good church services are when the entire church is on fire! The music is good and the sermon delivers a good message that makes one shout and you feel the Holy Sprit moving in you. 121. good music and good preaching with congregation involved 122. Good music from praise band a great sermon new members or adds pray requests 123. Good Music, good preaching, laity participation, and congregation response. People are moved to praise God. 124. Good music, good relevant preaching, expectant and participatory congregation 125. Good music, preaching, that teaches and/or guides to live by spiritual A feeling after leaving church, that will carry on through the week! Not a lot of unnecessary talking by Pastor or Laity 126. Good music, strong preaching and clear indication that there has been planning for all of the service. 127. good participation by majority, positive beginning, exciting singing and preaching, enthusiastic participation fervent prayer, meaningful liturgy, celebrations of life, good attendance 128. Good preaching from the Bible and good singing by both choir and congregation. 129. Good Preaching, music, congregational singing and liturgy 130. Good preaching, singing and a good children's sermon 131. Good Preaching Good music Youth participation 132. Good Scripture Good Music Good Preaching Spirit Filled 133. Good sermon and good music 134. good service to me is when the spirit is high and you know that God is at work because you can feel it in the atmosphere 135. Good singing, preaching and a wholesome atmosphere where the gospel is proclaimed through song and the spoken word. 136. Good worship is when everybody is not in a hurry to leave after service is over 137. Good worship is when the unrepentant come forward for salvation 138. Good worship is when the word is reached, the music is and dance ministry truly invites the spirit and God is lifted high in the words and movements. People are standing and clapping and Amen and praise God is voiced from the congregation and someone steps down to the altar to give their life to Christ because of something they have seen and heard in that worship service. 139. Good worship to me consists of awesome Praise portion of the service, prayer, and then numbers from the choir. But the icing on the cakes is the Word from the Lord. 140. great sermon, good music, not dead spots in worship (non activity and silence) 141. Greats singing from the choir and hearing a good word from the pastor. 142. Homecoming/Church Anniversary 143. I consider a "good church service" to be one that is planned, in advance, with the pastor, choir director, worship committee and one that feeds the needs of the majority of the congregation and not just the pastor or the pastor and close members/friends. 144. I enjoy a worship service that is well planned spirited. It is no longer than an hour but has cooperate interaction of song, prayer, appropriate touching and a well thought out

message. The music needs to follow the sermon and the theme of the message. 145. I feel that a good church service is where the congregation allows the LORD to have His way and the people give praises to GOD. 146. Inspirational moment whether it is through the sermon, music, testimony. 147. Inspirational, engaging, inviting, informative and challenging 148. Inspired singing, prophetic and insightful preaching, some spontaneity, good use of time, some reflective time, warm greeting and fellowship 149. intentional awareness of God 150. inviting, engaging, empowering, exciting and experiential 151. It is a service where the Holy Spirit moves us beyond a routine service. In a good service lives are transformed and renewed. Healing takes place and people are set free. 152. It is celebratory. One can tell the presenters have care for what they are doing. It is high energy, speaks to culture outside the church. The people in the pews seem to be having a good experience. And the presence of the Spirit of God is evident. 153. It is good when the music, sermon, prayers, etc. all seem to blend well and God's presence is felt. 154. It is when the Holy Spirit enlivens the service and the pastor preaches without his notes. 155. Jazz Cantata, were the Word, Drama and Music connected with the power of the Holy Spirit. The Service was at our main time of worship on Sunday morning; it was so powerful, we placed it YouTube. 156. led by the Spirit, every one united in praise in worship 157. Lots of congregation and choir singing, which is spirit-filled (Gospel or classical music doesn't matter--it's the movement of the Spirit); includes dance, drama, handbells, etc.-- though not all every Sunday. Team plans worship and involves laity of all ages and stages in leadership and execution of worship. 158. Meaning Worship, Bible Based Preaching Jubilistic Singing, Hymn, note music, band, pipe and or Hammond organ, choral and congregational sing. Reflective quiet as well. 159. meaningful liturgy 160. Meaningful Sermon, uplifting music, spirited response, souls saved/inspired 161. Message and the music really connect with the majority of the congregation would be generally described as a good church service. For me, when the music or spoken word really speaks to me, it is a good church service. Our choir is excellent and the anthems are always timely. I love singing in the choir. 162. most are good I just get a good feeling from everything that happens during the service 163. Music + spoken word and received and understood by all ages and genders. 164. Music always brings people in, then good preaching. 165. Music and Sermon of worship 166. Music that is more gospel and not ritualistic. 167. Music, scripture, and sermon carry the same message 168. N.A. 169. Needs addressed in all aspects of worship. All age groups participating, good singing and timely, spirited, sermons. 170. New commitment to Christ

171. On that is Spirit led, with careful planning for your members 172. One in which the congregation is involved in the singing and other worship experiences. It has more upbeat and uplifting move of the spirit. People seem to be moved by service. 173. one in which the presence of God was evident for me. 174. One Sunday about 2 years ago, our then new choir director had the choir sing Let the Light from the Lighthouse shine on me (our first song) we sang it and the Holy Spirit visited persons who had never experienced it. The church was filled with the Angels from heaven. When it was over, Pastor said "Enough said” Church was over at 11:30. It was the most memorable service for me. 175. One that flows from beginning to end. It is organized and there are no gaps or roller coaster movement. Worship should ascend. 176. One that has good preaching, good contemporary singing, an invitation to discipleship and prayer. 177. One that incorporates meaningful hymns, inspirational renditions by the choir with a rousing sermon lesson. 178. One that incorporates meaningful music with a powerful message 179. One that is anointed with the presence of the Holy Spirit in the atmosphere 180. One that is cognizant of time constraints, and realize that Christ is already there, and the minister and others do not have to "bring" Christ there. Just go ahead and worship and we will discover that Christ awaits our participation. 181. one that is inclusive of a variety of styles of worship (e.g., liturgical and extemporaneous) and styles of music (e.g., hymns and contemporary gospel music). Also one that is inclusive of all ages of the membership 182. One that is timely, and recognizes that spontaneity beyond responsibility is self- serving. 183. One where deviating from the planned worship service is welcomed. 184. One where music is exciting, testimonies are real, prayer time is meaningful, preaching is stimulating, and people are encouraged to live out their faith in their life. 185. One where the members of the church yield to the leading of the Holy Spirit. 186. One where the music (instrumental and singing), sermon, prayers all blend well together and you hear/sense God in the midst of it all. 187. One where the presence of the Holy Spirit is manifested by interactive worship. 188. One where the worshipers are more actively involved in the service 189. one with movement from beginning to end that enables participants to experience the presence of the Lord 190. Open and involved all in attendance in all aspects of the services which is a common practice in our local church 191. Our 4th Sunday worship 192. Our pastor provides "props" to explain what she is saying in her message to us. 193. passionate congregation and pastor, good sermon, rousing music 194. Passionate prayers, singing, and preaching. 195. passionate worship, good preaching, good fellowship with attendees, good clear sermon illustrations, media as a part of the service 196. People are in one accord with a desire to worship and give thanks to God. There is a

strong sense of community among the worshippers. The music is inspirational and uplifting. The preached word is biblically based, well organized, effectively delivered, and thought provoking-which leads to transformed lives. The entire experience is God-centered and people feel welcomed, engaged, and connected to the Spirit of God. It reaches all age groups. 197. Powerful praise and worship, prayer time, and anointed preaching and teaching. It was simple, giving was done quietly and persons of all ages were involved. 198. Praise & Worship in the beginning, followed by a strong music ministry from the choir, and concluding with a good word from the Pastor. 199. praise team sings, good worship and praise songs & hymns during service, good sermon, members involved in planning of service and having a choir 200. Praise, joyful, congregation participates, Presence of God is experienced by congregation, Lively and joyful music. 201. prayer; wonderful praise and worship service with musician and choir; followed by scripture; Psalter, hymn, offering solo, The Word 202. Presence of the Holy Spirit is evident. 203. processional, call to worship, opening prayer, doxology, songs, meet & greet, morning prayer, children's chat, scripture reading, sermon, benediction 204. Recently we had a Women's Day service @ Zoar It was a good service in that it was a divine space where people of all ages and genders participated actively in worship and praise 205. Sermon is applicable or addresses my life circumstances or is inspiring. Music is outstanding and well performed 206. Service in which congregation is very much involved. 207. services that have combined upbeat, spirited singing of congregational hymns and choir selections, solid preaching that offers a sense of hope and personal interaction with the pastor, such as joys and concerns, anointing or healing prayers. 208. Souls are saved and persons respond to the sermon, Scripture reading and the leading of the Holy Spirit 209. spirit filled 210. spirit filled service, good music, and good sermon. 211. Spirit filled, invites growth, builds community 212. Spirit filled/Spirit felt Music, Movement of the Holy Spirit, Praising from Congregation and choir, Liturgical Dancing, Powerful Scripture Based Message related to today's living, Coming forth to Accept Christ as Lord and Savior 213. Spirit-filled / members participation in singing & praising 214. Spirit-filled singing, sermon, warm feeling of fellowship 215. Spirit-filled; Bible-based preaching with life application and a response called for, Spirit-filled singing (I prefer gospel music, hymns and an anthem here and there); strong, fervent prayer; few announcements; celebrating the ministries of the church; emphasizing mission and giving. 216. spontaneous evocation and response to the Holy Spirit My congregation is not black It is traditional white, European liturgy and it is just now thinking about witness opportunities at the most informal of the 4 services 217. Starts on time. No changes to order of worship. Bible verses are not changed on a whim. Same announcements are not restated by captain after it is read. Points are not dragged out. Planned and pertains to scripture. 218. Strong attendance, music is great, response to the preached word, and students

rededicating their lives! 219. strong biblical message that applies current day living and is supported by the music and other worship elements 220. The Choir renders moving songs of praise; we have an inspirational or educational sermon of no more than 2 0 minutes; and someone turns their life over to God during to invitation to Christian discipleship. 221. The choir singing a very moving song and having the Holy Spirit enter the service and touch individual members and after the Holy spirit finishes. The Pastor saying enough said and church was over at 1130a.m. 222. The feeling that you get when you first walk into the sanctuary; The opening and greeting; The kind of music which can be traditional or gospel, preferably a mixture; A message that speaks to today's living, God's place in it, and our willingness to do His will. 223. The fourth Sunday in February we did God's Trombones with spirituals in between the sermons. That was a good service. In August the Anniversary celebration was 'Hip-Hop'. Young, energetic speakers. Everything was planned by the young adults as a result of a grant from GBOD. The service was excellent. One person did music at each service - everyone loved it. 224. The Holy Spirit manifests and peace, joy, and love abound. 225. The morning prayers were especially powerful and pointed to the congregation. The Choir music related to the service sermon. The sermon was delivered with passion and spoke to the issues and life's lesson for the day. 226. The music is coordinated with sermon and scriptural lessons and when there is a variety of traditional and contemporary music. 227. The music, sermon, praise dancers, and choirs are on one accord in the Spirit and no tech problems with sound and video ministry 228. the praise team ushers us into the presence of the Lord, the prayer is powerful but not too long, the choir is rocking and preferably singing my songs, sermon is lively and challenging, altar call brings new believers to Christ 229. The preached word - clear, exciting, providing teaching and appreciation to our lives; the inspiring music, liturgical dance and involving more persons 230. The presence of God, Jesus and the Holy spirit is felt throughout the sanctuary. The congregation is full of participation and joy in song and greeting other brethren. the Message is well received with Amen responses. 231. the spirit is felt in the music, the message and the prayer. 232. The spirit is high, the choir sings, the Pastor preaches 233. The word is faithfully proclaimed. The music is lively and enthusiastic. There is time for personal and corporate prayer. There is strong congregational singing. There is a time for members to interact with one another. 234. The worship leader led the church in a spontaneous prayer in which members of the church prayed for each other. This changed the tone of the worship. The choir sang with more spirit, the pastor preached a more dynamic message, and the people were energized spiritually--walking out saying "can we do that again?" 235. theme based, all music supports the sermon, multiple ages are involved 236. There can be many types of "good" church services, but I think one type is where the message is clear--the Scripture readings, the sermon, the hymns, and the instrumental and choral music all support communicating the same idea to the congregation, albeit in many

different ways. Ideally, there is a sort of "Pentecost" effect, in which everyone present can hear the message in whatever format will be "his/her own tongue." We like to do that with the musical offerings as well--there's a wide variety of styles of offering, from classical to contemporary, most Sundays. 237. Usher people into the presence of God. Good praise music. Congregation participates in praise and worship. Good down to earth preaching. An invitation to Christ. 238. Vibrant, full of praise, can sense the presence of the Spirit, relevant sermons, music is uplifting, choirs sing with vigor, you work up a sweat 239. Vigorous and inspired singing; excited scripture reading; use of instrumental music(guest musicians; liturgical dance 240. Watch night, good Friday service and world communion Sunday 241. We experience the visitation of the holy spirit more each week. It is evident in the prayers, songs sung & response to the preached message. Membership is increasing. Thus we have "good" church service. 242. We worship to please and honor God. Good worship is when all invited and encourage to be themselves before God; powerful music and participation in all levels of worship. Amen!!!! 243. Well planned and inspirational with a charge. 244. When all members comes together as one praising our Lord almighty 245. When all present are engaged 246. When congregation participates in worship and praise service. 247. When congregation senses an encounter with the holy... 248. When everyone comes to church happy, the music is good & the preaching is good. 249. When God's spirit is felt during worship and is expressed within the members 250. When I feel the presence of the Lord. 251. when lives are challenged and change takes place in lives. when salvation is received. 252. WHEN MY PASTOR'S MESSGER COULD BE REMEMBERED FOR A LONG TIME 253. When scriptures and music support the sermon and a lot of people actively participate in the worship service. 254. When the Associate Pastor preaches. He is Spirit-filled, God lead and gives a theme/topic and points to remember that are applicable to everyday living. He also is an excellent singer which enhances the sermon or is the "icing on the cake". 255. When the choir has sung a song and the congregation is responding to it by spiritual emotions, and the preacher has preached a sermon and someone has responded to the alter call for prayer or for membership into the kingdom. 256. When the congregation is attentive and responsive to the service-- singing and praising 257. When the congregation actively participating in the services. 258. When the congregation gives praises to God's words and blessing to them. A likely participation of hand clapping, singing, Amen, The worship is well organized and printed correctly on the bulletin. 259. When the holy spirit is allowed to be presence even in planned worship, good singing, prayer, preaching 260. When the Holy Spirit is expected, shows up and felt throughout the sanctuary. Music is necessary both congregational and choral singing

261. when the holy Spirit leads 262. When the members actively respond during worship and not just sit and stare appearing to not be emotionally or spiritually involved when it appears that they are at some level. They usually say how blessed and encouraged they are about the worship experience but it is not as obviously observable. 263. When the members of the congregation leave, knowing that they have been equipped for life by what they have heard and seen. 264. When the music is able to support the sermon because the Pastor collaborates with the musicians I've noticed that worship experience is heightened. There have been times where the musicians have been free from time constraints to play as they feel led, even with multiple reprises. 265. when the music, scripture and the word are all together 266. when the planned and the spontaneous can happen. when music and scripture touches the 'soul' not simply performed. when people leave the sanctuary with smiles on their faces and humming a hymn 267. When the praise of all is fully done/given. When the choir lifts the name of Jesus. When testimonies are given/stated. When the Holy Spirit is present and THE Word is going forth. 268. When the service is timely and the participants prepare in advance of the service. When the service is not too long. 269. When the songs, prayer and sermon all coincide with the same theme, with passionate singing and preaching; and the people praise and worship God , each in his/her own way--quietly or fervently. 270. When the spirit of the Lord manifests and the congregation is spiritually on one accord. 271. When the theme for a particular Sunday is expressed and experienced beginning with the Greeting through the Benediction; when God's presence is truly felt, worshipers are jubilant, the music is harmonious and the sermon is filled with hope and justice for our neighbors. 272. When there is a central theme and participation, and when everyone is involved in the worship service. 273. When we invite guest choirs and soloists to participate in our service. 274. when worship is free and the people are on one accord 275. where congregation encounters Jesus in meaningful ways thru the liturgy, praise, music, prayers at the alter or the proclamation 276. Where God is the central focus of the worship experience and the lives of people are transformed. 277. where I experienced God’s presence during worship. 278. Where people participate, love each other, and are very candid Where there is expression; via dance, singing, responsive reading 279. where the scripture, music, and sermon have the same theme when the music both congregational and choir led is vibrant and received by the congregants 280. Where the worshippers have been ushered into the presence of God. 281. Where there is a great balance between music, scripture and the Word Preached as the central part of the worship experience. 282. WORDOF GOD IS PREACHED

283. Worship Celebration that is vibrant, alive, and provides opportunity for reflection, prayer, and spiritual renewal. 284. Worship Service starts on time, everyone who has a responsibility knows their responsibility well, worship begin with people enter the church facility, the Praise Team, songs the choir sings, testimonies, prayer and preaching is meaningful and powerful. There is flexibility for the Holy Spirit to move in the worship experience. 285. Worship service with good singing to get the spirit moving and a great deliver of God's words. 286. Worship starts with Sunday School, praise and Worship and then a good sermon, hymns and choir music is on one accord 287. Worship!!! Intentional, transparent, real, focused and power filled worship. Included in worship, testimonies, and accounts of how God changed and altered one's week. Lastly, deep theologically sound spirit filled preaching. That to me makes a "good" church service.

Appendix. Question 60: List the top ten songs that are sung frequently in worship at your church Song Title Or First Line Count HYMNAL

1. Blessed Assurance 136 #369 UMH 2. Amazing Grace 125 #378 UMH 3. Holy, Holy, Holy 78 #64 UMH 4. Leaning On The 63 #133 UMH Everlasting Arms (What A Fellowship) 5. O How I Love Jesus 53 #170 UMH 6. Pass Me Not O 52 #351 UMH Gentle Savior 7. How Great Thou Art 51 #77 UMH 8. Great Is Thy 47 #140 UMH Faithfulness 9. What A Friend We 45 #526 UMH Have In Jesus 10. My Hope Is Built 42 #368 UMH 11. O For A Thousand 39 #57 UMH Tongues To Sing / 39 #334 UMH Sweet, Sweet Spirit (tie) 12. Marching To Zion 34 #733 UMH 13. We'll Understand It 33 #525 UMH Better Bye And Bye 14. Jesus, Keep Me 32 #301 UMH Near The Cross 32 #658 UMH This Is The Day (tie) 15. Let Us Break Bread 29 #618 UMH Together 16. Here I Am Lord 28 #593 UMH Spirit Song --tie 28 #347 UMH 17. This Little Light 27 #585 UMH 18. Because He Lives 26 #364 UMH Doxology (Praise 26 God From Whom All Blessings Flow) --tie 19. At The Cross 24 #8 SOZ Lift Every Voice 24 #519 UMH And Sing -- tie 20. I Surrender All 23 #354 UMH Just As I Am -- tie 23 #357 UMH 21. Precious Lord 22 #474 UMH 22. We’ve Come This 21 #192 SOZ Far By Faith 23. Victory In Jesus 20 #370 UMH 24. Standing On The 19 #374 UMH Promises 25. What A Mighty God 19 #6 ZSS We Serve Come Thou Fount Of Every 18 Blessing

He Is Lord 18 I Know It Was The Blood For 18 Me Lord’s Prayer 18 Something About That Name 18 I Will Trust In The Lord 17 Praise Him 17 Lord, Prepare Me To Be A 16 Sanctuary Soon And Very Soon 16 Thank You Lord 16 There Is A Fountain Filled 16 With Blood I Love You ;I Love You Lord 15 Today Nothing But The Blood 15 Sweet Hour Of Prayer 15 Glory, Glory, Hallelujah 14 He Touched Me 14 It Is Well With My Soul 14 Total Praise 14 How Great Is Our God 13 Spirit Of The Living God. 13 He Lives 11 I Am Thine, O Lord 11 Leave It Thee 11 Lord I Lift Your Name On 11 High All Hail The Power Of Jesus 10 Name Bless The Lord O My Soul 10 Blessed Quietness 10 Hold To God's Unchanging 10 Hand Old Rugged Cross 10 Victory Is Mine 10 We Have Come Into This 10 House A Charge To Keep I Have 9 Center Of My Joy 9 Gloria Patri 9 God Be With You Until We 9 Meet Again I Want Jesus To Walk With 9 Me In The Garden 9 Majesty 9 Shalom To You 9 Close To Thee 8 Jesus Loves Me 8 Lead Me; Guide Me 8 My Faith Looks Up To Thee 8 Yes, God Is Real 8 All Things Come Of Thee 7 Alleluia/Hallelujah 7 God Of Grace And God Of 7 Glory Grateful 7 Have Thine Own Way, Lord 7

Jesus Is All The World To Me 7 Joyful, Joyful, We Adore 7 Thee Love Lifted Me 7 My Tribute 7 Standing In Need Of Prayer 7 Through It All 7 'Tis So Sweet To Trust In 7 Jesus Come By Here 6 Come To Jesus 6 Fill My Cup Lord 6 Guide Me, O Thou Great 6 Jehovah Here I Am To Worship 6 His Name Is Wonderful 6 I Need The Every Hour 6 I Need You To Survive 6 Jesus Is On The Main Line 6 Lift High The Cross 6 Lord I Want To Be A 6 Christian Lord, I Want To Be A 6 Christian Love Divine All Love 6 Excelling O Thou, In Whose Presence 6 Order My Steps 6 Stand By Me 6 The Blood 6 To God Be The Glory 6 When We All Get To Heaven 6 Amen 5 Can't Nobody Do Me Like 5 Jesus Come, Thou Almighty King 5 Father I Stretch My Hand To 5 Thee Freely Freely 5 Give Thanks With A Grateful 5 Heart God Has Smiled On Me 5 God Is Good 5 He Looked Beyond My Faults 5 And Saw My Needs His Eye Is On The Sparrow 5 I Love To Praise Him 5 I Love To Tell The Story 5 Jesus 5 Just A Little Talk With Jesus 5 Just Want To Praise You 5 Lord Of The Dance 5 Lord You Are Good 5 On The Battlefield 5 Precious Name 5 Trust & Obey 5 We Lift Our Hands In The 5 Sanctuary We Offer Christ To You 5

You Can't Beat God Giving 5 All To Jesus I Surrender 4 Anointing Fall On Me 4 Blest Be The Tie That Binds 4 Every Time I Feel The Spirit 4 He Leadeth Me 4 I Just Want To Thank You 4 I Love The Lord 4 I Woke Up This Morning 4 Jesus, Jesus, Jesus 4 Lord, I Lift Your Name On 4 High Open The Floodgates Of 4 Heaven Rock Of Ages 4 Stand Up Stand Up For Jesus 4 The Blood Will Never Lose It 4 Power We Are Climbing Jacob's 4 Ladder We Are Marching In The 4 Light Of God/ Siyahamba All Night 3 Awesome God 3 Be Thou My Vision 3 Because Of Who You Are 3 Beneath The Cross Of Jesus 3 Breathe 3 Christ Is All The World To Me 3 Come On And Praise The 3 Lord With Me Come Ye Disconsolate 3 Faithful 3 God Is So Good 3 God Will Take Care Of You 3 Going Up Yonder 3 He's Sweet I Know 3 Hymn Of Promise 3 I Am Redeemed 3 I Come With Joy 3 I Know I've Been Changed 3 I Never Shall Forget What 3 He's Done For Me I Pray We All Be Ready 3 I Want To Be Ready 3 If It Had Not Been For The 3 Lord I'm So Glad Jesus Lifted Me 3 Is Your All On The Altar 3 Just A Closer Walk With Thee 3 Kum Ba Yah 3 Lead Me Lord 3 Let It Rain 3 Let It Rise 3 O Give Thanks Unto The Lord 3 O Lord How Excellent Is Your 3 Name O Magnify The Lord 3 Old Ship Of Zion 3

One Bread, One Body 3 Onward Christian Soldier 3 Our God Is An Awesome God 3 Power In The Blood 3 Praise Is What I Do 3 Somebody Prayed For Me 3 Spirit 3 Surely The Presence 3 Swing Low 3 Turn Your Eyes Upon Jesus 3 Walk In The Light 3 We Are Standing On Holy 3 Ground We Shall Overcome 3 Welcome Holy Spirit 3 What Wondrous Love Is This 3 When I Survey The 3 Wondrous Cross 298 UMH Your Grace And Mercy 3 A Mighty Fortress 2 All Hail King Jesus 2 Alpha And Omega 2 And Can It Be That I Should 2 Gain Anyway You Bless Me Lord 2 Battle Hymn Of The Republic 2 Better Than That 2 Bless That Wonderful Name 2 Of Jesus Blessed Be The Name 2 Breathe On Me Breath Of 2 God Changed 2 Come Let Us Worship The 2 Lord Come On In The Room 2 Come Out The Wilderness 2 Come, Now Is The Time To 2 Worship Come, Thou Long Expected 2 Jesus Days Of Elijah 2 Do Lord Remember Me 2 Don't Do It Without Me 2 Faithful Is Our God 2 Farther Along 2 Fix Me Jesus 2 Friend Of God 2 Give Me A Clean Heart 2 Glad To Be In His Service 2 God Favored Me 2 God Is A Good God 2 God Is Here 2 God Is Real 2 God Said He Will Make 2 Things Alright Grace Greater Than Our Sin 2 Guide My Feet 2 Hark The Herald Angels Sing 2

He Saw The Best In Me 2 Holy Ground 2 How Firm A Foundation 2 How I Got Over 2 Hush Somebody's Calling My 2 Name I Am A Friend Of God 2 I Don't Feel No Ways Tired 2 I Give Myself Away 2 I Shall Not Be Moved 2 I Thank You Jesus 2 I Will Bless The Lord 2 I Won't Complain 2 I'm Coming Lord 2 Jesus Christ Is The Way 2 Jesus Lover Of My Soul 2 Jesus Loves The Little 2 Children Jesus The Light Of The World 2 Just Jesus 2 Lamb Of God 2 Let Everything That Has 2 Breath Praise The Lord Lift Him Up 2 Must Jesus Bear The Cross 2 Alone Nearer My God To Thee 2 Never Would Have Made It 2 Nothing Between 2 O Come All Ye Faithful 2 O Happy Day 2 Only TRUST HIM 2 Pass It On 2 Praise, My Soul, The King Of 2 Heaven Remember Me 2 Run And Tell That 2 Shine On Me 2 Shout To The Lord 2074 FWS 2 Something Beautiful 2 Spirit Fall Down 2 Take My Life And Let It Be 2 Take Time To Be Holy 2 Tell Me The Stories Of Jesus 2 The Jesus In Me Loves The 2 Jesus In You The Lord Is My Light 2 The Summons 2 This Is A Day Of New 2 Beginnings This Is My Father's World 2 Too Close To The Mirror 2 Trouble In My Way 2 Victory 2 Wade In The Water 2 Walk With Me 2 Walking Up The Kings 2 Highway We Can Do All Things 2

Through Christ Who Strengthen Me We Worship You 2 Welcome 2 Welcome Into This Place 2 Welcome Song 2 When I See Jesus 2 Yes Lord 2 You Are Alpha And Omega 2 You Keep On Blessing Me 2 Above All 1 After All 1 Agnus Dei 1 Ain't God A Good God 1 All I Need 1 All I Wanna Do Is Praise His 1 Name Alright 1 Am I A Soldier Of The Cross 1 Amazing Grace My Chains 1 Are Gone I Been Set Free An Uncloudy Day 1 And They'll Know We’re 1 Christians Are We Yet Alive 1 Are Ye Able 1 Available To You 1 Be Blessed 1 Be Still My Soul 1 Beams Of Heaven 1 Bind Us Together Lord 1 Bless Thou The Gifts 1 Blessed 1 Blessed Be The Rock 1 Blessed To Be A Blessing 1 Blest Thou The Gifts 1 Bread Thou The Bread Of 1 Life Brightly Beams 1 Call Him Up 1 Calvary 1 Caribbean Medley 1 Celebrate Jesus 1 Celebrate New Life 1 Certainly Lord 1 Change Has Come Over Me 1 Church 1 Clap Your Hands 1 Come , Thou Almighty King 1 Come And Dine 1 Come And Find A Quiet 1 Center Come And Go To That Land 1 Come And Go With Me 1 Come Down Oh Love Divine 1 Come Just As You Are 1 Come Let Us Worship 1 Come Let Us Worship The 1 Lord In The Beauty Of

Come Thee Fool 1 Come Unto Jesus 1 Come We That Love The 1 Lord Come Ye Sinners 1 Come, Christians Join To 1 Sing Cooling Waters 1 Count Your Blessings 1 Crown Him With Many 1 Crowns Deliverance Is Available 1 Does Anybody Here Love The 1 Lord? Don’t Let Nobody Turn You 1 Around Don't Let The Devil Ride 1 Don't You Wanna Go To That 1 Land Down By The Riverside 1 Eagle's Wings 1 Easter People 1 Eat This Bread 1 El Shaddai 1 Emmanuel, Emmanuel 1 Encourage Yourself 1 Enter In 1 Every Step I Make 1 Every Time I Find A Reason 1 To Praise The Lord Excellent 1 Eye On The Sparrow 1 Fairest Lord Jesus 1 Faith Of Our Mothers 1 Falling In Love With Jesus 1 [Contemporary] Fix It Jesus Fix It 1 Flow To You 1 For All The Saints (SINE 1 NOMINE) For The Beauty Of The Earth 1 Forward Through The Ages 1 555 Give And It Will Be Given 1 Back To You Give Him The Highest Praise 1 Give Me Jesus 1 Give Myself Away 1 Glorious 1 Go Make Of All Disciples 1 Go Tell It On The Mountain 1 Go Ye Therefore 1 God Is Able 1 God Is Blessing Me Right 1 Now God Is My Everything 1 God Is Still On The Throne 1 God Of Ages 1 God Of Love And God Of 1

Power God Of Our Fathers 1 God's Amazing Grace 1 Gods Got A Blessing 1 Grace 1 Grace And Mercy 1 Grace Of God 1 Great Thing/Day 1 Have A Little Talk With Jesus 1 He Has Done Great Things 1 For Me He Has Made Me Glad 1 He Is A Keeper 1 He Is My Everything 1 He Is Wonderful 1 He Is Worthy 1 He Kept Me 1 He Laid His Hands On Me 1 Heart Of Worship 1 He's Already Here 1 He's Done So Much For Me 1 He's Got It All In Control 1 High And Lift Up Holy Holy 1 Hold On Change Is Coming 1 Hold On, Don't Let Go 1 Holy Ghost Power 1 Hosanna 1 Hosanna Blessed Be The 1 Rock Hosanna In The Highest 1 How Excellent 1 I Am Free 1 I Am Gonna Sing 1 I Am Satisfied With Jesus 1 I Am Still Holding On 1 I Call Jesus My Rock 1 I Call You Faithful 1 I Can Go To God In Prayer 1 I Can Only Imagine 1 I Can't Make It By Myself 1 I Come To Give You Life 1 I Come To Praise Him 1 I Don't Know What You've 1 Come To Do I Don't Mind Waiting 1 I Feel The Spirit 1 I Got A Feelin' Everything 1 Gonna Be Alright I Got A Testimony 1 I Have A Friend 1 I Have A Friend His Name Is 1 Jesus I Know The Lord Will Make A 1 Way I Know Whom I Have 1 Believed I Learned How To Lean And 1 Depend On Jesus I Made A Vow 1

I Must Tell Jesus 1 I Need A Blessing 1 I Prayed About It 1 I Really Love The Lord 1 I See The Love Of God In 1 You I Stand Amazed In The 1 Presence I Was There To Hear Your 1 Borning Cry I Will Enter His Gates 1 I Will Fly Away 1 I Will Trust In God 1 I"M On The Right Road Now 1 I’m Chasing After You 1 I’m So Glad Jesus Lifted Me 1 2151 FWS I’ve Decided To Make Jesus 1 My Choice If My People Who Are Called 1 By My Name If You Say Go 1 I'll Be Satisfied Then 1 I'll Go If I Have To Go 1 I'm Going With Jesus 1 I'm Grateful 1 I'm So Satisfied 1 Immortal Invisible God Only 1 Wise In Christ Alone 1 In The Beauty Of Holiness 1 In The Cross Of Christ I 1 Glory In The Tabernacle 1 In This House Today 1 In Times Like These 1 Incredible God 1 It Ain’t Over 1 It Could Have Been Me 1 It Is No Secret What God 1 Can Do It Is The Cry Of My Heart 1 It Is The Joy Of My Salvation 1 It's A New Day 1 It's Been Worth 1 It's In My Heart 1 It's Wonderful 1 It's Wonderful To Live With 1 Jesus It's Your Season 1 I've Been Redeemed 1 I've Got A New Name 1 I've Got It 1 I've Got The Joy 1 Jacob's Ladder 1 Jehovah Jireh (You Are More 1 Than Enough) Jesu Tawa Pana 1 Jesu, Jesu 1

Jesus Be A Fence 1 Jesus Died On Calvary 1 Jesus I Love You 1 Jesus Is A Rock In A Weary 1 Land Jesus Is A Waymaker 1 Jesus Is The Best Thing That 1 Ever Happened To Me Jesus Paid It All 1 Jesus Promised He'll Take 1 Care Of Me Jesus There's Something 1 About That Name Jesus Will Fix It 1 Jesus, Jesus 1 Jesus, Jesus 1 Jesus, Messiah 1 Jesus, Name Above All 1 Names Joy 1 Joy To The World 1 Just As Soon 1 Just Having Church 1 Just Over IN The Glory Land 1 Just Stand 1 Just Wait On The Lord 1 Koinonia 1 Let All Mortal Flesh Keep 1 Silence Let Go, Let God 1 Let The Redeemed Of The 1 Lord Say So Let There Be Peace On Earth 1 Let Your Living Waters Flow 1 Lift Me Up In Your Spirit Lord 1 Lily In The Valley 1 Living For Jesus 1 Living My Life Like It's 1 Golden Looking For A Miracle 1 Lord Help Me To Hold Out 1 Lord I'm Available To You 1 Lord Make Me Over 1 Lord Touch Me 1 Lord Whatever You Are 1 Doing In This Season Lord Whose Love Through 1 Humble Service Lord You Are Awesome 1 Lord You Are Holy 1 Lord, Do It For Me 1 Lord, I Thank You, Thank 1 You, Thank You Lord, I'm So Grateful 1 Lord, You Are Welcome 1 Lord, You Have Come To The 1 Lakeshore Lord's Prayer (Baptist 1 Hymnal)

Love 1 Love Medley 1 Love You 1 Make His Name Glorious 1 May The Lord God Bless You 1 Real Good May The Peace Of The Lord 1 May You Run And Not Be 1 Weary Morning Has Broken 1 My God Has Never Failed Me 1 Yet My Help 1 My Jesus I Love Thee 1 My Life Is In You Lord 1 My Soul Is Anchored 1 Never Could Have Made It 1 [Contemporary] Never Seen The Righteous 1 Forsaken No Not One 1 Nobody But Jesus 1 Nobody Can Do Me Like 1 Jesus Nobody Fault But Mine 1 Now I’m On My Way 1 Now Thank We All Our God 1 Now The Green Blade Riseth 1 O God Our Help In Ages Past 1 O Love Divine 1 O Master Let Me Walk With 1 Thee O Worship The King 1 O Young And Fearless 1 Prophet 444 Oh Brother You Ought To 1 Been There Old Time Religion 1 On Eagle's Wings 1 On Time God 1 One More Time 1 Only You Are Holy 1 Open The Eyes Of My Heart 1 Lord Our Faith 1 Over Yonder 1 Perfect Praise 1 Perfect Praise 1 Popular 1 Praise Him In Advance 1 Praise In The Temple 1 Praise The Lord Who Reigns 1 Above 96 UMH Praise The Lord, O My Soul 1 Praise, Praise, Praise 1 Pray For Me 1 Prayer Is The Soul's Sincere 1 Desire Precious Jesus 1

Precious Memories 1 Psalms121 Lord I Will Lift 1 Mine Eyes To The Hills Rain On Me 1 Redeemed 1 Reign On King Jesus 1 Rejoice 1 Rejoice Everybody 1 Rejoice In The Lord Always 1 Rejoice, The Lord Is King 1 Remove These Thorns 1 Responses To The Psalter 1 Revelation 19 1 Revive Us Again 1 Rough Side Of The Mountain 1 Safety 1 Savior Like A Shepherd Lead 1 Us See How Great A Flame 1 Aspires 541 UMH Seek Ye First 1 Send It On Down 1 Send Me, Lord 1 Shake The Devil Off 1 Ship Like Mine 1 Shout 1 Since I Gave The Lord My 1 Since I Met Jesus 1 Someday 1 Something About The Name 1 Of Jesus Souled Out 1 Speak To My Heart 1 Spirit Of God Descend 1 Stand Up , Show Some Sign 1 Steal Away 1 Stomp The Devil's Head 1 Stop By The Church 1 Sometimes Study War No More 1 Summons 1 Sweet Jesus 1 Sweet Little Jesus Boy 1 Take Our Bread 1

Tenderly Calling 1 Testimony 1 Thank You Lord For All 1 You've Done For Me The Best Is Yet To Come 1 The Blessing Of Abraham 1 The Church’s One 1 Foundation The Lord Is Blessing Me 1 The Lord Is Blessing Me 1 Right Now The Reason Why We Sing 1 The Victory Chant 1

There Is A Balm In Gilead 1 There'll Be Singing Over 1 Yonder There's A Crown Of Life 1 These Thorns 1 This Is Your House 1 This Morning When I Rose 1 This Morning When I Rose 1 This The Day 1 Those Who Trust 1 Thy Word Is A Lamp Unto My 1 Feet Till We Gather Again 1 Touch Me Lord Jesus 1 Trading My Sorrows 1 Unity 1 Victory Chant 1 We Are Called 1 We Are Tossed And Driven 1 We Bring The Sacrifice Of 1 Praise We Come To Worship 1 We Come With Joy 1 We Exalt Thee 1 We Fall Down 1 We Shall Behold Him 1 We Shall Wear A Crown 1 We Thank You Lord 1 We Thy People Praise Thee 1 67 We Will Glorify Him 1 We Won't Leave Here Like 1 We Came We Worship Christ; For Who 1 You Are Welcome Song (To Tune Of 1 Jesus Lifted Me) Welcome Song-Welcome To 1 Wesley Welcome Table 1 Welcome To St. James 1 Went Down In The Valley To 1 Pray We're Blessed 1 Were You There 1 We've Come To Lift Up Jesus 1 What Gift Can We Bring 87 1 UMH What God Has For Me 1 What Shall I Render 1 What You Need 1 When All God's Children Get 1 Together When He Was On The Cross, 1 I Was On His Mind When The Saints Come 1 Marching In When We All Get Together 1 When We Are Living, Spirit 1

Song When We Reach The Other 1 Shore Where Could I Go 1 Who Did It, God Did It 1 Whose SIDE ARE YOU 1 LEANING ON Woke Up This Morning 1 Worship 1 Worship His Majesty 1 Yes Christ Is All 1 Yes Jesus Loves Me 1 Yes Jesus Loves Me 1 Yes, Jesus Loves Me 1 Yes, Lord, Yes 1 You Alone Are Worthy 1 You Are Good 1 You Are Great 1 You Are Holy 1 You Can Do Anything, Yes 1 You Can You Can Use Me 1 You Can't Make Me Doubt 1 Him You Keep On Blessing Me 1 You Ought To Run And Tell 1 That [Quartet] You Should Of Been There 1 Your Love Oh God 1 Zion Is Calling 1

RESPONSES GIVEN THAT WERE NOT SONG TITLES AME Church Where I Knew 1 The Hymnal Congregational Theme Song 1 CWM RHONDDA (Both 127 1 And 577) Donald Lawrence 1 Fred Hammond Medleys 1 Hymn In Season 1 Israel Houghton 1 Kirk Franklin 1 Kirk Franklin Medleys 1 Kurt Carr 1 Medleys Form Integrity 1 Hymnal Negro Spirituals 1 Originals 1 Praise And Worship Songs 1 Praise Songs 1 Seasonal Selections 1 Selected Opening Hymns 1 Selected Songs From The 1 Faith We Sing Selected Songs From The 1 Songs Of Zion Sheet Music In Season 1

Something By Fred 1 Hammond Songs Are Requested At 1 Praise Time Songs From The Late 80's 1 Songs Selected And I Often 1 Wish I Were Back In The Spirituals 1 They Tend To Be The 1 Modern Gospel Songs Tye Tribbett 1 Unfamiliar/New 1 We Sing A Variety Of Songs. 1 We Use A Variety Of Music 1 We Use A Wide Variety Of 1 Hymns Welcome Song For Visitors 1 An Original Wesley Hymns 1 Yolanda Adams Medleys 1

Appendix. Question 67: Alternative resources for ritual in UMH. 67 a. Alternate sources for Communion n=78 Item Communion Count Percentage 1989 Hymnal (other services i.e. W&T V etc.) 13 16.66% Book of Worship 13 16.66% Africana worship book or 21st Century Africana 9 11.54% African American Heritage 8 10.26% developed locally 6 7.70% GBOD.org Resources 4 5.13% Internet 4 5.13% Printed in the Bulletin, source uncertain 3 3.85% Scripture 3 3.85% Book of common prayer 2 2.56% ad lib 1 1.27% Annual Conference or District Service 1 1.27% Baptist Hymnal 1 1.27% Book of Worship 1964 ed 1 1.27% Holy Communion (book of alternate readings for special Sundays) 1 1.27% Lutheran, Catholic 1 1.27% Methodist Supplement 1 1.27% other worship resources 1 1.27% Presbyterian Hymnal 1 1.27% Ruth Duck 1 1.27% traditional 1 1.27% Wee Worship 1 1.27% wherever I find relevant information 1 1.27%

67b. Communion Music N=127 Item: Communion Music Count Percentage

Af Am Heritage Hymnal 14 11.02% hymnal 14 11.02% none 12 9.45% Songs of Zion 11 8.66% other 10 7.87% memory 8 6.30% Choir, min music leads 7 5.51% The Faith We Sing 7 5.51% Zion Still Sings 5 3.94% Contemporary music 4 3.15% Negro Spirituals 4 3.15% sheet music 4 3.15% Congregational music 3 2.36% Gospel music or spirituals 3 2.36% let us break bread 3 2.36% Local Collection 3 2.36% traditional songs 3 2.36% Baptist Hymnal 2 1.57% CDs 2 1.57% AME Hymnal 1 .79% Annual Conf or District Services 1 .79% Blood of Jesus songs 1 .79% Instrumental 1 .79% Internet Recommendations 1 .79% Lutheran, Catholic 1 .79% Mark Miller communion setting TFWS 1 .79% Spiritually Decided 1 .79%

67c. Baptism Ritual N=44 Item Baptism Service Count Percentage none 15 34.09% Book of Worship 5 11.36% hymnal 4 9.09% same 2 4.54% Other Church Services 1 2.27% 1964 Book of Worship 1 2.27% AAHH 1 2.27% Africana worship 1 2.27% Bible 1 2.27% Book of Worship 1964 ed 1 2.27% bulletin 1 2.27% Internet 1 2.27% old and new Methodist Hymnal 1 2.27% other sources 1 2.27% Printed Resources from GBOD 1 2.27% Rewrite baptism service 1 2.27% Scripture 1 2.27% spirituals 1 2.27% the baptismal covenant 1 1 2.27% The Book of Worship 1 2.27% United Church of Canada 1 2.27% Wee Worship 1 2.27%

67d. Baptism Music (N=75) Item: Baptism Music Count Percentage None 14 18.67% Congregational singing 7 9.33% AAHH (African American Heritage Hymnal) 6 8.00% Songs of Zion 6 8.00% Spirituals 5 6.67% Hymnal 4 5.33% “Take me to the Water” 3 4.00% Baptist Hymnal 3 4.00% other sources 3 4.00% Choir music 2 2.67% contemporary music 2 2.67% Gospel Songs 2 2.67% The Faith We Sing 2 2.67% UMBOW Book of Worship 2 2.67% Zion Still Sings 2 2.67% "Wade in the Water" 1 1.33% “Ever flowing Streams” 1 1.33% “God Claims You” 1 1.33% “Sweet, Sweet Spirit” 334 1 1.33% 'Come Be Baptized' 1 1.33% Breathe On Me Breath of God 420 1 1.33% CDs 1 1.33% Local Collection 1 1.33% Memorized songs 1 1.33% Related Music for Baptism/ water songs 1 1.33% UM Worship Planner 1 1.33% hymns from supplements 1 1.33%

67e. Other Confirmation Resources (N=33) Item: Confirmation Resources Count Percentage None 13 39% Book of Worship 5 15.15% 1964 Book of Worship 2 6.06% Other: 13 3.03% Amazing Grace faith we sing Confirmation materials Congregational Singing of hymns contemporary gospel LGBT resources that are inclusive of all online resources Pastor's Liturgy Pastoral discretion. Spiritually Decided spirituals The Church’s One Foundation 545

67f. Other for Reception of Members (N=61) Item: Reception of Members Count Percentage hymnal 13 21.31% None 11 18.03% Book of Worship 5 8.20% AAHH 3 4.92% Traditionally sings "What a Fellowship" or other song 3 4.92% spirituals 2 3.28% Other: 24 39.34% ad lib Annual Conference or District Services choir special congregational praise songs Congregational Singing of hymns Contemporary, Gospel music create gospel song Hymn Memorized songs Music from other songbooks Negro Spiritual Pastor's Liturgy Pastoral discretion. resources from a variety of others. same Songs of Zion SOZ Spiritually Decided Sweet Hour of Prayer 496 the baptismal covenant 1 The pastor greets new members informally UM Book of Worship We have written our own pledge and process Zion Still Sings

67g. Other for Reaffirmation of Faith N=25 Item: Reaffirmation of Faith Count Percentage hymnal 4 16% Book of Worship 2 8% chosen by pastor/choir 2 8% Congregational Singing of hymns 2 8% none 1 4%

Other A Charge to Keep I have #413 14 56% Annual Conference or District Services choir specials Create my own musicians Presbyterian probably hymnal resources from a variety of others. Scripture Songs of Zion Spiritually Decided spirituals the baptismal covenant 3 We are spontaneous and do this before the congregation

67h. Other for Marriage (N=74) Item Count Percentage Book of Worship 17 22.98% none 12 16.22% hymnal 5 6.76% Couples Choice 5 6.76% pastor designs the worship 3 4.05% contemporary 2 2.70% Ceremony from another ministry 2 2.70% contemporary music CD 2 2.70% Other comments: 26 35.13% Additional Sheet music Africana Worship Baptist-Scripture-personal input Book of Common Prayer Book of common worship Book of worship, other printed sources of Christian weddings cd Couple write own vows Gift of Love 408 Holy Bible Marriage books, African Jumping the broom book Minister's Ritual Ministers Star Handbook Music chosen by bride/groom musicians Other contemporary vows Pastor's Liturgy Pastor's pocket guide (Cokesbury) pastors’ devotional book Use contemporary resources from a number of sources and our own writing. The UMC hymnal and book of worship do not work for us various Various of resources from other authors Wedding Guides wedding music or popular love songs work with couple www.gbod.org, Africana Worship Book

67i. Death and Resurrection (N=76) Item Count Percentage Book of Worship 17 22.37% none 11 14.47% AAHH 5 6.58% hymnal 4 5.26% Holy Bible 3 3.95% Family Chooses 2 2.53% pastor/family 2 2.53% Songs of Zion 2 2.53% Other Comments: 30 39.47% Abide With Me 700 Abingdon Funeral Manual Baptist Hymnal Book of common worship Cokesbury Resource for Pastors & The Book of Worship congregational songs family selections Funeral Manual Hymn Minister's Ritual Ministers Star Handbook musicians Online sources Other - Pastor Other Church Services other source pastors’ devotional book Pastor's Guidebook, Minister’s handbook Pastor's Handbook Pastor's pocket guide (Cokesbury) Presbyterian spirituals The Faith We Sing The pastor designs the worship The UM Book of Worship traditional Use some elements of the old Methodist Hymnal of 1964 Various of other resources- no particular ones in particular. whatever the family wants work with family - usually hymnal

67 j. Daily Praise and Prayer (N=45)

Item: Daily Praise and Prayer Count Percentage none 18 40% Book of Worship 5 11.11% Daily Bread 2 4.44% hymnal 2 4.44% Upper Room 2 4.44% computer 16 35.55% Create my own, write my own poetry, prayers GBOD, Africana Worship Book I Will Trust In The Lord 464 Individually Decided musicians Online prayers from sources such as Africana resources and GBOD Other Church Services Prayer Books Scripture, songs Songs of Zion, other hymnals, songbooks

spirituals Spirituals, African American Hymnal, and Gospels Use resources by Ruth Duck, Brian Wren and other contemporary writers both Protestant, Catholic and Jewish as well as our own. various various resources

Appendix. Question 73: Other services that would be used if available

Watch Night 8 Healing service 5 Foot washing, 4 Men’s Day 4 Women's day 4 Ash Wednesday 3 Children and Youth Worship 3 Holy Week Celebrations 3 Installation of Officers 3 Juneteenth celebration service outline 3 Maundy Thursday 3 Prayer Service 3 rites of passage 3 Bible Study/Small groups 2 Christmas 2 church council meetings 2 Good Friday 2 Kwanzaa 2 Taize 2 Advent, 1 African History Month African-American Creed 1 beginning of school 1 Black History 1 Blessing and Anointing 1 Blessing of a Home 1 Blessing of the Animals 1 Blessing services for the home 1 Blessing the fleet 1 camp and retreats 1 charge conference 1 Choir Celebrations 1 Choir Dedication, 1 Baccalaureate Service Music 1 Confirmation 1 Consecration of missions teams 1 Dedication of worship material 1 Dedication services, 1 Dedications of various celebrations other than what is listed 1 Easter Sunrise Service, 1 Evening service Baptisms 1 Graveside Service 1 healing from addiction 1 Healing/Anointing 1 homecoming, 1 hospital visitation 1 House blessings 1 Lenten Weekly Services, prior to Holy Week 1 Lenten, 1 Litanies for any African American celebration 1 Litanies for specific annual days observed in the African American 1 church tradition Love feast, 1 marriage celebration; 1 men/women’s meetings 1 Mid Week Prayer 1 More contemporary services 1 More urban/contemporary praise and worship songs 1

NAMING CEREMONIES 1 prayer breakfasts 1 prayers for homeless people 1 Recognitions 1 Renewal of Wedding Vows 1 Service for Graduates 1 Martin Luther King Service 1 Service of covenant 1 /consecration for new Certified Lay Ministers Service of covenant for church officers and chairpersons [to be used annually] service of death and resurrection; 1 special day worships 1 Special days relative to social justice 1 Special Sunday communion service for instance, Lent and other 1 alternative communion words Sunday school 1 typical devotion service that would happened before regular 1 Sunday a.m. service Unsure. Our church enjoys the freedom of creating new worship 1 experiences even for familiar services. Installation of Officers 1 Sunrise Easter 1 weekly bible study sessions 1 whenever prayers are needed 1 Youth Ministries 1 youth Sunday 1 Youth, Special Days 1 Family Day, I do use the UMC hymnal when called upon to officiate at weddings and funerals away; even at other denominations. It does provide a great guidance. The Hymns are just terrible

Appendix. Question 83: Unmet Resource Needs

1. A good resource for music videos for replacement of a praise band. 2. A great source that we lead us into the 21st century. 3. African American resources for media/movie clips to include in sermons and training on how to preach incorporating these. Also, I am interested in how the emergent trends may be helpful. 4. African video 5. All of what we need we can find, but we face financial constraints. 6. Appropriate cantatas, special music, drama productions suitable for church. Praise music for worship leaders. 7. Contemporary songs that appeal to youth. Upbeat songs with energy. We need projections and pre recorded music.....A resource would be a worship out line for small and rural churches with suggested music for African Americans. And perhaps a way to teach non-teachers to teach music.... 8. from time to time, I need lyrics not necessarily to sing, but sometimes to quote! 9. I do not really play be ear, but can write simple arrangements of songs I hear so that we can sing them. I like simple arrangements in playable/singable keys--often not easy to find in contemporary gospel arrangements. 10. I think our kids should be included in the worship service and we are beginning to explore the ways we can include them in the regular worship service. 11. I would just like a collection of music relevant to the Black community that has piano and vocal arrangements written the way we sing, not a Europeanized version as appears in the 1989 UMH by William Farley Smith. They are not written for us, they are written for others. 12. Information relative to the use of jazz in worship 13. It would be nice to have a more updated Hymnal with a cross denominational listing of songs. Not just for the United Methodist only. Music is the way to unite the body of Christ and the Hymnals should reflect all types of spiritual, gospel and religious music. It would also help if the music was categorized in a manner easier to find. Adding other musical genres would be helpful such as drums and guitars. Possibly a songbook with nothing but praise and worship songs that will accompany any service of any type. 14. More African American updated gospels. 15. More Contemporary Songs 16. More songs from songs of Zion in standard hymnal. Why must small churches buy both? 17. More spirituals and gospels in the UMH 18. more track tapes 19. Musical workshops at the local church 20. Negro Spirituals 21. Old gospel and prayer band songs, usually have to find an elder who remembers the song 22. Orchestrations for a traditional full orchestra of the UMH hymns!!!!!! Other denominations did this years ago--it is galling to have to use a Baptist hymnal product we bought years ago because there were no orchestrations of the 1989 UMH. 23. Resources for dance and children's choir. African choruses in UM hymnals 24. Scriptural foundations of gospel songs and some hymns; Summaries of background of songs (e.g., explanation of the lyrics); Wide range of litanies that relate to special Sundays (Mothers' Day, Fathers' Day, etc.) or concerns (Families with loved ones living with, and/or dying of cancer, AIDS, or other terminal illnesses; those incarcerated; those addicted) 25. Sheet music resources 26. Sheet music to current songs (what's on the radio right now). 27. Some of the resources recommended on the worship planner guides More helpful information about liturgical dance and mime 28. Someone or something to get the choirs out of their comfort zones and stretch them until they reach greater heights, and then not idolizing the musician. 29. the songs that african-americans song during the time of 1940_1970 30. There are many. We need a minister of music. 31. Tracks for songs popular with/favored by African American congregations, both traditional and contemporary 32. Someone who can work with the Pastor to help her design her sermons with music that coordinates with the message. Pastor is not up on the Methodist hymns old and new to use with sermons, times of the year. 33. Up lifting songs for all seasons of the lectionary year. 34. Use of accompaniment tapes 35. variety of music- but this is the choice of the Pastor and/or Music Director

36. videos to supplement the music 37. welcome songs, gathering songs, more songs for prayer time 38. Wish we had young people who are bolder in demanding more contemporary music and/or who can play drums, brass, guitars, etc.; 39. Workshops related to African-American music (gospel, etc.) 40. yes the Advent and Lenten music resources, especially from A heritage perspective, are very limited 41. Yes. I'd like to have a CD of hymns, spirituals, gospel, and contemporary music that shares several ways in which the songs could be sung (traditional, different tune, contemporary, etc.)

Appendix. Q 84: Biggest Change in Worship and Music Over the Last 10 Years

1. 2nd & 4th Sundays have the BETTER attendance and better music 2. a mime team, and children and youth choir 3. A move from one traditional choir to three choirs: traditional, contemporary, and gospel. 4. A new Pastor 5. A testimonial Service every week 6. About 20 years ago, we adopted blended worship and praise. 7. Acceptance of contemporary Praise & Worship music during formal services 8. added a choir 9. Adding a Praise and Worship Team and making Praise and Worship a MAJOR part of our Sunday Services - and ALL church events 10. adding drums 11. Adding drums and other instruments 12. Adding liturgical dance 13. Addition of a dance ministry 14. addition of contemporary music 15. addition of drums and string instruments 16. Addition of praise dancers; depending on the age and experience of the musician determines what kinds of music we get; we now have great depth and variety. 17. Additional choir members Types of instruments used 18. Additional worship service, tremendous expansion of the Liturgical Dance Ministry, inclusion of Martial Arts Ministry in the worship service, monthly involvement of youth in the worship service 19. Affording a musician who is technologically advanced 20. Although I have not been in the congregation for the past 10 years , I would offer that the biggest change in worship and music has been the inclusion of more musicians and greater participation of cross-section of members in the worship services. 21. An open and free time of inviting all to share what they want to share as it relates to worship 22. Blended service with various kinds of music 23. blended worship 24. CD 25. Change of worship time. Inclusion of lay leadership in worship Inclusion of songs not in the UM hymnal 26. Change to more contemporary and ethnic music 27. changing pastors frequently 28. Changing the music to fit all people with vigor and vitality. 29. children and youth singing; children and youth singing; children and youth singing 30. Choir not marching in Musical skills declining in musicians 31. Church is 13 yrs old and 5 yrs in Methodism 32. church only 9 years old 33. Commitment from choir members to rehearse regularly 34. Consolidating into adult one choir from#25 additional services: Baccalaureate Sunday, Children's Day, First Friday Daybreak Prayer, Harvest Sunday, Laity Sunday, Lenten Daybreak Prayer(daily), Youth Day, UMM and UMW Mission Sundays 35. Contemporary music being accepted as a part of worship. 36. Contemporary music. 37. contemporary/modern music use in worship 38. dance teams 39. Difficulty in finding worshipful musicians willing to stay with the church. 40. Don't. This a new appointment 41. Drums, and Key Boards, and praise dancing 42. Drums, dance and drama

43. DVD ministry Sound system 44. Employment of Music Director, purchase of new sound board and CD recorder/duplicator, Employment of sound tech, regular singing of Men's Chorus, Development of Liturgical Dance team 45. Fewer choir members. No young adults or youth choir. 46. Finding a good musician who knows the Lord and is a worshiper on a regular basis. 47. Finding a knowledgeable choir director at a price we can afford. 48. Finding printed music/lyrics to new choir songs 49. from traditional to contemporary music 50. Genre of music has become more diverse 51. Getting members to accept changes 52. Going from having a musician to utilizing accompaniment tapes and CDs 53. Gospel Music 54. Gospel Music 55. Greater variety of music for the Black church. We run the gamut. Gay-positive and women-positive language. Inclusive language is missing in Black church resources. 56. Have been here only one year and the music/worship does not seem to have changed much. Just now, we are forming worship planning teams at each of the three churches. 57. Haven't been worship with this particular congregation that long 58. Having the choir and to plan for worship 59. hip hop 60. I am a new pastor having only been in this church for a year. I am more Afrocentric in worship style than the last pastor so I use more typically African-American resources AND as a musician I incorporate more music in the worship. 61. including contemporary gospel music 62. Increase in contemporary music 63. increase in technology, less gospel more worship 64. Increase in the number of instruments 65. installation of LCD projectors and screens. 66. introduction of contemporary songs 67. Introduction of Contemporary worship songs and LCD projection of Power Point and other media. 68. IT HAS BECOME MORE VIBRANT AND IT APPEALS MORE TO YOUNGER PEOPLE. (WHILE IT CONTINUES TO PLEASE THE ELDERS) 69. It has remained virtually the same 70. It's planned. New means of liturgical expression have been included( dance and mime). 71. I've only been at my churches for 3 years. I do know that one added a praise team, and that was most helpful. That team has left to start their own ministry. Now this church just goes through the motions. 72. I've only been there since July of last year. 73. Just appointed in June 74. Keeping a Musician 75. Keyboard player drums LCD projector Addition of Young Adult Choir Singing more hymns and contemporary songs 76. Lack of folks singing who can read music. 77. Larger membership 78. Less people to worship. 79. Less use of the hymnal. 80. Liturgical Dancing, etc. 81. loss of musician for our gospel choir 82. making CD'S 83. Media and modern technology 84. Men from 100's traditional to blended services with drums and tambourines 85. merging of choirs 86. Merging of contemporary music with traditional 87. more arrangements 88. More contemporary

89. More contemporary and gospel tunes 90. More contemporary and worship and praise music. Use of projector and power points. More congregation participation. Praise dancers 91. More Contemporary Gospel songs are sung and more Negro Spirituals. There is a continuous array of accapella songs are done. 92. more contemporary music and praise teams performances 93. more contemporary music is used and praise music rather then hymns 94. More contemporary music is used in worship services. 95. More contemporary music. 96. More gospel, contemporary 97. More instrumentation 98. More involvement. 99. more tech -power point 100. more use of technology 101. More young people at worship 102. Move to a more urban contemporary feel in the last 3 years with the church's first African American pastor and more African American membership (approx. 60% AA in worship) 103. Movement of the Holy spirit through song 104. movie clips 105. Moving away from the old Tinley hymns. 106. moving from traditional to some contemporary liturgy and music. use of guitars and keyboard in worship. 107. Moving slightly away from traditional. 108. Moving to one worship service 109. music 110. music 111. Music Director with passion and vigor 112. Music has not changed in the past ten year. 113. Music lyrics projected on screen Power Point Presentation 114. Music more contemporary and drums as accompaniment 115. musical selections are more diverse 116. Musician 117. Musician 118. musicians 119. Musicians and Male choir singing during an entire worship service. 120. Need more musicians 121. New pastor and new music 122. New Contemporary Choir 123. new ideals and visions 124. new music 125. New music director, worship leader for Sunday mornings 126. new musician after 20 years 127. new musicians 128. New organist 129. new songs from the hymnal 130. New sound system/sound amplification and sound acoustics 131. NEW SPEAKERS,NEW MICRO 132. New to the congregation 133. No active musician 134. No persons have become trained musicians (Organ & Piano) to replace current persons. A lot of the Older Choir members have passed on and now down to Gospel Choir serving as the Sanctuary Choir also. 135. Not having a consistent musician for any choir, choir director, Minister of Music. No one wants to play or is not able to.

136. occasional use of The Faith We Sing/and Readings from the Lesson, Epistle, and Gospel 137. only been assigned to this church for eight months 138. order of worship and flow. Traditional but relaxed 139. Order of worship with change of pastor 140. ORGAN, DRUMS, GOSPEL MUSIC 141. Organization of a Gospel Choir and infusing more gospel music in our worship 142. Our church has become a home. Our music has changed from high church to a little bit of all types of music. 143. Our female pastor incorporates prayer requests directly from the congregation which was not done previously by the male pastors. The choir is beginning to sing a variety of songs. 144. pastor 145. pastor 146. People like different styles of music (i.e., contemporary Christian, gospel and chancel) 147. Picture screens, congregation, music equipment, talented musicians, exciting praise 148. Planning music for a changing society and fulfilling the needs of today's youth. 149. Power point with sermons 150. Praise & Worship team 151. Praise and Worship Contemporary Gospel Music 152. Praise and worship Music directed toward the community Sermons that incorporate timely issues and laughter and stories 153. praise and worship service dancers 154. Praise and Worship Team Children's Choir Purchasing the AAHH 155. Praise team 156. Probably the use of CD Tracks for learning new song. 157. problems in keeping up with change in general church music. 158. Projecting 159. Projection More contemporary music 160. projection music selection 161. Reduction in choirs 162. return to traditional resources 163. Several of my choirs are using different styles of music and singing better 164. Singing contemporary songs as opposed to "special selections" coming from the Baptist Hymnal. 165. Singing more contemporary songs. 166. Singing the canticle responses as well as the Lord's Prayer. 167. sometimes we use talent from the congregation 168. Students balancing academics and choir rehearsal times 169. Style and the method of getting the words to the congregation 170. Style and Type 171. style and type of music, less use of the pipe organ 172. Style Length of Service 173. style of music 174. Style of Music and worship setting 175. Style of music traditional to contemporary gospel 176. Style of Music, Praise 177. Technology 178. Technology 179. The infusion of "Praise Music" into a traditional service. 180. The addition of both TFWS and a UM Hymnal 181. The addition of Praise and Worship at the beginning of the worship service. 182. The addition of praise dancers and mimes 183. The addition of the children’s' and youth choirs

184. THE BIGGEST CHANGE IS WE WENT FROM HAVING A MINISTER OF MUSIC TO SINGING FROM CD'S. 185. The change in gospel sound. More Biblical inclusion in upbeat music....Mary Mary ' sound.... the sounds of Donnie McClurkin.... 186. The congregation is broadening its variety of hymns and liturgy. 187. the design of the bulletin, the incorporation of other elements in service( dancers, mime, visuals) the engaging of the congregation in the service, using a wireless microphone, using lights, colors and materials to set the worship atmosphere 188. The inclusion of current gospel music. 189. The inclusion of more contemporary songs in worship. 190. The intermingling of hymns, contemporary gospel, traditional gospel, and the use of my own original compositions or arrangements that embrace lyrics of old hymns that need to be in our spiritual arsenal. 191. The introduction of contemporary music and praise teams and praise dancers 192. The lost of good musicians. Lack of choir members. Little planning by the choir. 193. The music has changed from hymns and anthems to contemporary praise, and gospel music with only an occasional hymn. The sermon is 40 or more minutes and the service is changed around at the Pastor's whim. It often is not a good experience. 194. The musicians 195. The quality of choir music. The hiring of professional organist. the reestablishment of Sunday evening service with music and word. 196. The Sunday that the youth sing and participate is the best Sunday worship service. 197. the type of music and no one to play it 198. The type of songs that we sing. 199. the use of a ______to free the hands of the congregants 200. The use of Accompaniment CD's. 201. The use of CD's and accompaniment tapes. 202. The use of dance by our youth, and to bring our tithes/offerings to the altar 203. The use of electronic instruments with drum machines. 204. The use of more Contemporary Music 205. The use of technology projection, screens and power point. 206. The use of the UM Hymnal 207. The vitality of the congregational singing - much better because the church is growing. 208. The way we pray as God uses the music with prayer the same time in worship 209. The Youth Choir 210. The youthfulness of the musicians, and what new energy that brings to worship. 211. There has not been a significant change. 212. To follow the United Methodist Way 213. To get the church to adapt to some of the songs for the young people. 214. Tradition 215. traditional to contemporary 216. Transition from traditional to contemporary worship and music styles. 217. trying to find a musician who is passionate about playing for God 218. Trying to keep up with all of the technology. 219. Type of music and format of worship 220. Using more of the modern Gospel 221. Unable to respond to this question. Just came to this church in June 2009. 222. unknown 223. Use more electronic keyboard 224. use of CDs, DVDs 225. USE OF DIFFERENT INSTRUMENTS 226. Use of electronic piano (keyboard) by the 2nd Sunday youth musician that has resulted in more contemporary gospel music being sung by the choir and congregation 227. Use of electronics; full band; variety of music styles 228. Use of internet 229. Use of other resources(i.e. Faith We Sing, Af-Am Herit. Hymnal) and other sheet music for cantatas/special programs.

230. Use of PowerPoint and use of fewer hymns. 231. Use of praise and worship music and media in the services. 232. Use of projection and more upbeat music, addition of the keyboard , more variety in musical selections 233. Use of projector 234. use of technology 235. Use of technology, a pastor who is somewhat knowledgeable about music and who sings; Use of technology, a pastor who is somewhat knowledgeable about music and who sings; Use of technology, a pastor who is somewhat knowledgeable about music and who sings 236. using drums, singing contemporary gospels and other contemporary music 237. Using of the LCD, Overhead Projector, PowerPoint, Praise team and drums. 238. Using projection during the worship 239. Using technology more in worship 240. Variety 241. very little change 242. Video Taping Sunday Morning Worship for the sick and shut-in. Computer Ministry for people over 55 years of age. 243. We can't find an organist for our wonderful pipe organ. 244. We ditched the traditional songs of the UMC worship hymnal and started using other resources for more relevant hymn 245. we had a beautiful choir and musician & lost it all because our new pastor wanted to run everything. therefore, everyone left our church and joined other churches. 246. We had a drummer every Sunday and now we do not. At one time we had a musician for 4 choirs and now are down to 3 choirs and one musician. 247. We have a talented music leader who likes diversity in worship service and we continue to learn new songs to keep the service spiritually attractive. 248. We have begun to sing more in a gospel fashion rather than the methodical hymns. If we don't update the way we sing our songs and include more contemporary music, the future of the church is in for trouble, because the young people are no longer interested in the traditional church service. The world is offering them more exciting things. The church needs to catch up with the times and remember that no one came hear saved. 249. We have celebrated certain Sundays with additional Musicians...guitars, bongos, violins, etc. 250. We have more variety of hymns contemporary and more accomplished musicians 251. We now have a contemporary Gospel Choir 252. We now have a great sound system with microphones which help the elderly in the congregation. 253. We use the United Methodist Hymnal less 254. We've been here 2 years 255. What we call a "blended" worship format was adopted for our main 11:00 service. To me, this seems more like a traditional service format with projections than what most churches mean by "blended" (which usually seems to be a basically contemporary service with pipe organ and a choir)--except for the addition of projections, our service/liturgy format actually has changed very little. There has been a minor increase in use of contemporary Christian music. (There also has been a tiny increase in historical classical music. Both increases have come at the expense of a small decrease in nineteenth and early 20th-century gospel hymns.)

Appendix. Question 85: additional comments

1. A HYMN BOOK WITH MORE OF THE GOSPEL AND UP TO DATE MUSIC. 2. A/v team wants ability to communicate directly with persons in pulpit. 3. appreciate your work 4. appreciate your work 5. Blessings on your work. Know that we are not an exclusively African American church -- very diverse in all categories. 6. change in worship styles and music is very slow and intimidating because multi- media technology is very expensive 7. Churches the size of the one to which I belong need simplicity with depth in the music before us. Singable, stay with you songs--lyrics that feed and melodies that linger. 8. Consider making a fuller array of arrangements available as downloads. For example, a piano solo arrangement, a duet version, a SATB vs. the usual SAT arrangements for voice. Male chorus arrangements. Chord charts for bass, guitar, piano. Choose some of the more popular songs and do some special arrangements or provide suggestions for a medley. Provide some audio demonstrations of keyboard parts for tricky arrangements for those who only play by ear. Provide Africana liturgy options for prayers, calls to worship, benedictions, etc. These could be value added items or supplemental resources. 9. Do not reinvent the wheel -- just use the Rev Dr Carpenter's compilation, out of Howard U School of Theology. 10. Do something exciting that will encourage our church to try something new. 11. Explore options for "blended orders of services" to assure that reverence is maintained throughout the time spent in worship. 12. Financial costs and an older congregation that resists change prohibit fast updates in technology such as CD's, Video, PowerPoint capabilities. Yet, Hope springs alive or we will wither in due season. 13. From 77. would love to if had committed person to do the projection 14. Great survey... 15. Help for small membership churches with limited budgets and musical skills- Help for pastors who cannot sing! 16. Help pastors understand that the length of sermon is not t he measure of its quality. Help singers realize that good music can be sung with ordinary voices. Faddish music doesn't make bad/ordinary voices better. 17. Hymnal may add children's song section 18. I am a singing my self AKA singing preacher. 19. I am an African American pastor at a white church. I don't know how much weight you will put on my survey results and that's okay! :) 20. I am lay and may have answered some questions incorrectly. Sorry! 21. I appreciate the publications that have been written to assist clergy, worship player, etc... If I can help write any of the affirmations, call to worships or prayers, I offer my service. Rev Dr. Tara Sutton 810-919-5088 Bethel UMC Flint, MI 48507 22. I guess we just have to do it- make changes gradually and trust the Holy Spirit to do its work 23. I have composed an African-American Creed, and would love to see it included in a subsequent Hymnal. 24. I have had to supplement the hymnal to provide a broad range of music for the worship experience. 25. I think there needs to be some training about the use of contemporary music--everyone does not need 20 minutes worth of the same song. There needs to be more time for quiet contemplation and reflection and it ought to be written into the structure. 26. I like the Traditional Hymns and Anthems, They speak to me and I identify with them, This is possibly because of my age group and musical training. I like singing gospel music that are properly written and harmonized. I dislike all that shouting and screaming that sometimes come with the more hip gospel music. I sometimes cannot find Jesus in it. It is all about the performer. 27. I question the production of another hymnal or songbook of any kind. It is a non-Green, costly and unnecessary venture. Black churches would be better served by tech and music overhauls, creative writing and drama training for lay and clergy leadership. 28. I sincerely hope that special attention is given to "old standards" before they are deleted from the hymnal. 29. I support the project 30. I think Rev. Dr Lisa Allen should offer a free recordings of her and the ITC choir performing traditional I. e. Dr. Watts and Fanny Crosby songs so that rural churches can hear (again) the power and spirituality of these songs. This can be in DVD format so that it can be played at choir workshops. In fact, I, Rev Alan Jackson at Little Chapel UMC in Ocala am willing to be the pilot church for such an endeavor. 31. I'd like to do more creative things in designing worship, and I'd like to see more workshops that help in worship design and the use of technology Also resources for liturgical dance and mime, like devotional guides to emphasize these gifts as ministry 32. I'd like to see some type of incentive to get more young people to become interested in being musicians-piano players, keyboard players, etc. 33. If we had more resources we could create a greater worship experience. But we thank God for what we are doing lead God's people in worship. 34. It would be nice if new hymnals came with the option of ordering tracks, with and without background vocals, for use by soloists, choirs and churches with limited music budgets

35. Keep responding to a changing world 36. Large-scale music/worship workshops have virtually no impact on small churches that cannot afford to send anyone to them. Think about how to reach the grassroots within this highly rural state, if you really want to make a positive impact. 37. Many members of small church choirs don't read music. Could use more access to recorded music from which to learn new songs. 38. Need good musicians. Pay for full time musicians and band members so you do not have to share with other churches. 39. Need to pay attention to inclusive language, theology portrayed in praise and gospel music ("you're only going to heaven if you think like me and love Jesus the way I do" seems to be a wrong message). Need teaching academies for medium and small churches. 40. Offer options for Good Friday and other day time services during the week 41. Opportunities for more training of our church leaders in rural communities to help give new experience to worship would be great. 42. Our church will need to find something musical for the teens or children to do in order to keep them in the church and to make them a vital part of the congregation.

I believe music will be the place for their involvement just because many of the children are from inner city communities and they have lots of energy and they love music of all kinds.

Whatever hymnal is being developed should take into account that some non-African American churches are beginning to grapple with how to involve African American children in the life of their congregations and our non African American musicians do not always how to do this.

Reading music is a blessing, but also a hindrance, too, when it comes to spontaneity and courage to try something different. 43. Our song choices are limited by the present Methodist hymnal; therefore we use songs conducive to our culture. 44. Paper back does not wear well and makes book seem less important than UM Hymnal 45. Pastor needs to give Communion to Sick and Shut In, not just those in the hospital, but home visits. A secretary could also be a great asset to our Church. That way the Pastor will be able to handle more in church and community and the members will not feel neglected. They will also know in advance when she will be out, instead of walking in church to find someone there. That is where an Assistant Pastor is great and not just a Lay Leader all the time. 46. Praise God for this work and the new resources that will be produced. 47. Pray for our church to rebuild our membership and fellowship again. 48. Shorten the survey or condense the qu8estions 49. survey form did not allow forms left blank when none of answers applied...survey assumes racial/ethnic background 50. Takes money. The young adults would love us to grow in this area. 51. Thank you 52. Thank you for making this survey 53. THANK YOU! 54. Thank You!! 55. Thanks for offering the opportunity to share. 56. thanks for the survey opportunity 57. Thanks for this survey. 58. The Methodist Hymnal should be more inclusive when reprinted of Black music. 59. The song history of the black race has been buried almost by all churches and our mostly black congregations are now headed to the grave yard with the rest and we dare to talk about black history. 60. The type and quality of music makes all the difference in the life of the worship experience that will greatly assist in growing a vibrant congregation, but spiritually and numerically. 61. The UMH needs to be updated. 62. This is a very productive and energetic Church. I would love to see the use of more types of music, but I trust that this will come very soon!!! 63. This survey helped me to appreciate our worship services and how fortunate we are to have such a dedicated minister as Rev. Charles F. Bates and his Lay Leaders. 64. This survey is far too long and involved. It requires having a hymnal at one's disposal. I wonder how many will take the time to complete it. 65. This survey is too long. it does not encourage participation 66. Visitors to the church love the AAHH as well as the members 67. We are striving to add more in the area of worship, to God be the glory! 68. We don’t have enough songs that are upbeat for Pentecost 69. We have embraced the new ideas for sharing worship through song and dance. 70. We hope that all people working on any new UM hymn materials will remember that we are a very diverse denomination and that many of our congregations don't necessarily fit pat labels. We can like gospel AND shape-note tunes AND traditional spirituals AND blaring brass choirs AND historically-informed performance of Handel with gut strings and low tuning--all in the same congregation. (Sometimes even the same service!) 71. We need a lot of improvement. A workshop on worship music and planning would be appreciated. 72. We need some type of ongoing caucus/fellowship specifically for all musicians/music directors serving in AA UMC congregations. These events could serve as training/familiarizing musicians in UMC music traditions. In this writer's opinion we are marginalized by FUMMWA 73. We should constantly reach for fresh innovative ways to incorporate the past, present, and the future in our worship. It should be

alive and growing and seasoned with our heritage. 74. We should maintain music that is supportive of our culture in our United Methodist ministry. Culture and History is an important aspect of our forefathers and should be instilled in the generations to come. 75. We welcome a change to our present united Methodist hymnal. 76. When you decide to put a new hymnal together, do a general survey by age category with specific questions geared to that category. Then send them out to all the connectional churches and have them returned to you by a certain time. Ask the people what they want in the services. After all, it is they who support the church and the services should give them what they need to be fulfilled until they once again come into the sanctuary for another service. We need to not forget the old ways, but not stay trapped in them. The world has changed from the time of the founding fathers and if we as a body are to survive, we must change with it. Contrary to what some believe, we are in competition for peoples souls and unfortunately, the church is losing. The Word says for us not to be BOUND by tradition. It also tells us to be transformed by the renewing of our minds. If we are to do God's will in a manner that is pleasing to Him, we must find the ways to reach all His children before it is too late. 77. Why not just support the African American Heritage Hymnal rather than re-creating the wheel? 78. Would like more African and Caribbean liturgy available. 79. Yes, this survey was too long and took up too much time to complete. Writing a list of songs by memory was difficult. Make it shorter, please the next time. Thank you.

82 Online Survey

All Sections

83 Demographics: Questions 1-10 SECTION ONE

84 Q 1: What is your position?

350 328 300 250 199 200 150 100

50 21 27 0 Pastors and Other Bishop & DS Extension Min Worship, Music and Clergy 3.65% 4.69% Local church ldrs 57.04% 34.60%

N=575 85 Q 2: Paid or Volunteer?

24%

Paid Volunteers

76%

N=572 86 Q 3: Jurisdiction?

Jurisdiction 4.20%

10.14% SEJ 41.91% NEJ 16.26% SCH NCJ WJ 27.45%

N=572 87 Q4: What is your age category?

45.00% 40.00% 35.00% 30.00% 25.00% 20.00% 15.00% 10.00% 5.00% 0.00% 25 or 75+ 66-75 56-65 46-55 36-45 26-35 under Ages 2.78% 12.70% 39.13% 29.22% 10.61% 4.52% 1.04%

N=575 88 Q 5: Approximate Church Membership

35.00%

30.00%

25.00%

20.00%

15.00%

10.00%

5.00%

0.00% Under 100-199 200-299 300-499 500-749 750-999 1000+ 100 Membership 26.68% 29.68% 15.72% 15.72% 3.53% 1.24% 7.42%

N=566 89 Q6: Approximate worship attendance

Series 1 60.00%

50.00%

40.00%

30.00%

20.00%

10.00%

0.00% Under 100-199 200-299 300-499 500-749 750-999 1000+ 100 Series 1 53.72% 26.95% 11.17% 1.95% 1.24% 1.06% 3.90%

N=564 90 Q 7: Kind of Church?

14.34% 14%

33.81% 34% Urban 15.04% 15% Small Town Rural Inner City Suburban

16.28% 16% 20.53% 21%

N=565 91 Q 8: Average Yearly Income of Members

4.43%Avg Yrly Income 5%

21.28% 29.96% 21% 30%

<$20-35,000 $35-50,000 $50-75,000 $75,000+

44.33% 44%

N=564 92 Q 9: Average Gender balance in churches

Men women

N=558 93 Q 10: Average Age Categories in Churches Responding

Estimated % by Age 8%

27% 9% Birth - 12 12--18 12% 19--30 31-49 50-65 66 and older

17% 27%

N=510 94 SECTION TWO WORSHIP

95 Q 11: Please indicate how many worship services you have. (N=527)

600 523 500

400

300

200 151

100 38 15 0 Main worship Second Worship Third Worship Four or More service Service Service Services

96 Q 12: Please indicate the best description of the style of worship for each service you have. (N=525) 350 329 300 250 200 187 150 100 81 Traditional 50 30 33 Blended 18 8 16 5 4 1 4 Contemporary 0 Main Fourth and Second svc Third svc Other service others Traditional 187 30 5 4 Blended 329 81 8 1 Contemporary 18 33 16 4 Other 4 8 11 8 97 Q 13: Please indicate whether each service is growing, declining or staying the same in attendance. (N=527) 250 232 229

200

150

100 71 78 Growing 59 50 Declining 16 21 Same 9 4 7 1 6 0 Second Fourth and Main service Third service service others Growing 232 59 16 7 Declining 71 9 4 1 Same 229 78 21 6 98 Q 14: List any additional weekly services held at your church (Check all that apply.) (N=524)

300 250 250 200 149 150 Prayer 96 Children’s 100 75 62 Family 50 34 Youth 0 Afternoon Evening Service Youth Prayer Family Children’s Afternoon Evening Service Evening

99 Q 15: On a typical Sunday in our church worship is lead by: (Check ONE) (N=527)

250

195 200 176

150 113 Minister 100 Min, Lit Min, Lit, worship leaders 43 50 M, L, W, other

0 Minister Min, Lit Min, Lit, M, L, W, worship other leaders

100 Q 16: List other leaders active in worship at your church (Check all that apply) (N=525)

450 419410 378 400 354 350 326 269 276 300 239 250 202 200 178 165 184 150 102 102 75 98 85 100 48 62 39 43 54 50 27 30 26 35 0 … … Altar Armor Ushers Others: Others: Dancers Flaggers Trustees Nurses(s) Step Team Step Lay Leader Lay Evangelists SS Teachers SS Stewardship Stewardship Class Leaders Class Ministers (not Ministers Choir Director Choir Youth Minister Youth Music Minister Music Mime and Drama and Mime Outreach Minister Outreach Prayer Counselor(s) Prayer Young Adult Minister Young Prayer Group Leaders Group Prayer Communion Stewards Communion Choir Section Section leader(s) Choir Mothers of the Church Mothers 101 Q 17: In our church, the bulletin is used for: (Check all that apply.) (N=522)

600 507 500 469 400 315 300 279 264 201 200 100 0 Notes Education Promotion Prayer Requests Prayer Announcements Order of Worship Order

102 Q 18: When is the sermon preached? (N=524)

When is sermon preached?

238 End Middle 286

103 Q 19: Do worship services at your church have (Check all that apply.) (N=521)

500 467 450 400 377 350 325 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 Altar Call Corporate Prayer at Altar Private Prayer at Altar

104 Q 20: Complete the statement: Most of the time when people are baptized, (N=524)

83 16%

Sprinkle/pour Immersion

441 84%

105 Q 21: How often does your church celebrate Holy Communion? (N=524)

4 11 23 34

Weekly Bi-weekly Monthly Quarterly Other:

452

106 Q 22: How is communion served in your church? (Check all that apply. (N=523)

Series 1 350 317 312 300 250 200 164 151 Small Cups 150 99 Altar Rail 100 74 Line Up 50 Bread and Cup 0 Pre-packaged Ushers Bring Line Up Line Altar Rail Altar packaged - Small Cups Small Ushers Bring Ushers Pre Bread and Cup and Bread

107 Q 23: How is the offering received? (Check all that apply.) (N=524)

450 404 400 400 359 350 300 269 250 194 200 150 100 50 0 Pass the Plate Dedication Choir Sings Sing During Off Walk to Table Song

108 Q 24: How are the announcements shared when your church meets for worship? (Check all that apply.) (N=524) 500 473 450 400 385 354 350 300 Bulletin 250 Liturgist 200 Pastor 150 100 50 0 Bulletin Liturgist Pastor

109 Q 25: List the occasional worship services that your congregation observes. (check all that apply.) (N=523) 500 450 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 Other Other Revival Revival Kwanzaa Men’s Day Men’s Love Feast Love Juneteenth MLK, Jr. Day Jr. MLK, Good Friday Watch Night Watch Bible Sunday Bible Homecoming Women’s Day Women’s Foot Washing Foot Christmas Eve Christmas Christmas Day Christmas New Year’s Day Year’s New Boy/Girl Scouts Boy/Girl Mother’s Board Mother’s Ash Wednesday Ash Rites of Passage Rites Thanksgiving Eve Thanksgiving ThanksgivingDay Choir Anniversary Church Anniversary Church Usher’s Anniversary Usher’s Pastor’s Anniversary Pastor’s Black History Month Dedication of Officers Dedication

Maundy/Holy Thursday 110 SECTION THREE WORSHIP PLANNING

111 26. Does someone plan worship at your church? (N=463)

Yes I don't know No

94%

112 27. Who participates in planning worship at your church? (Check all that apply): (N=463)

Count 500 450 435 400 350 297 300 250 213 200 172 131 150 91 100 39 50 21 0 Lay L Lay W Com W W Lead W Pastor(s secretary Volunteer don’t know don’t Musician(s)

113 28. How far in advance is worship planned at your church? (N=463)

2% 1%

10% 4-26 weeks That week 14% 1-4 weeks 48% I don't know do not plan That morning

25%

114 29. Which of the following is most descriptive of worship planning at your church? (Choose one) (N=441)

17%

women men

83%

115 30. Which of the following best describes worship planning at your church? (Choose one) (N=463) Count

17%

predictable, traditional worship committee

spontaneous 57% 26%

116 31. In your opinion, whose influence is strongest in worship at your church? (N=464)

Count 7% 9%

pastor church members musicians

84%

117 32. On an average Sunday, how long is worship at your church? (N=464)

Count 3% 17%

90 minutes 2 hours 50% 1 hour More than two hours

30%

118 Q 33 “WHAT MAKES GOOD CHURCH?”

Most respondents described worship where the music, message and Holy Spirit were in synergy and where the people were allowed to participate without feeling restricted by time or conventions. A number of people could point to specific services that were “good church”

Frequently used words: • music, song or singing 211 times • sermon, message or preaching 167 times • spirit, spiritual or Holy Spirit 113 times • congregation 65 times • praise 47 times • choir 43 times • prayer 41 times • participation 39 times • testimony 24 times

119 34. Which of the following is true about “good” worship services? (online responses) (Check all that apply.) (Online, N=463) (short survey N=838) 90 78.83 80 71.49 70.63 70 60 57.24 50 47.08 40 online 71.84 30 56.92 60.74 short survey 47.85 20 44.75 10 0 singing spiritual Organized can be should be disciplines planned planned

120 SECTION FOUR MUSIC

121 35. How many songs are sung during worship in a typical Sunday worship service at your church? (comparison online/short survey) • Online Survey67 (N=451) • Short Survey (N=838) 15%

70 4 TO 6 15% 7+ 1 TO 3

314 70%

122 36. How many of these are sung by the congregation? (N=451) 8 2%

105 23%

1 to 3 4 to 6 7+

338

75% 123 37. Where in the order of worship is the congregation invited to sing? (Check all that apply) (N=451) 350 324 305 300 300 283 273 256 250 232 228 199 200 181 150 150 132 131 130 100 50 32 0 Other Prayer Baptism Altar call Altar Offertory Welcome Response Gathering Recessional discipleship Communion Processional benedictions New Members New Call to Worship to Call 124 38. Does the congregation sing: (N=449)

450 388 400 350 300 262 250 200 150 107 80 100 69 60 59 59 32 27 50 18 23 4 6 Main Service 0 Other Services music/lyrics with CD for CD for with from memory from hymnal from projected projected from accompaniment from lined out lined lyrics from from both printed & both printed from from printed music or music printed from projected music/lyrics projected

from nonethe above of from 125 39 Does your congregation sing call and response praise songs? (N=451)

190 42% Yes No 261 58%

126 40. List the kinds of songs that your congregation sings in worship at your church (Check all that apply.) (N=451) 500 450 438 400 378 364 350 308 300 287 270 250 219 200 180 150 93 88 100 61 58 39 38 36 32 50 9 0 hop - gospel Chants Hymns prayers Quartet Hip Scripture Dr. Watts Dr. Spirituals Decalogue Traditional Long meter Long Ring shouts Ring Praise music Praise Urban gospel Urban Contemporary Hymn choruses Hymn 127 41. Approximately how many different songs written by John or Charles Wesley have you sung in the last 12 months? (N=448)

yearly average=7.93

128 42. Do you have one or more church musicians that play an instrument for weekly worship? (N=449) 49 11%

Yes No

400 89%

129 43. Do(es) your musician(s) (N=434)

41 9%

89 21% Both Read Music Play by Ear

304 70%

130 44. Which of the following instruments does your church use during the Main Worship Service? (N=443) Count 300 270 259 250 200 189 140 137 150 117 106 102 100 62 50 38 35 30 17 9 4 5 0 … Brass None Organ Tracks Conga Others Strings Guitar(s) Drum Set Drum Keyboard Hammond Pipe Organ Pipe tambourines Electric Piano Electric Acoustic Piano Acoustic

Woodwind (sax, (sax, Woodwind 131 45. Who selects the music that is sung in worship at your church? (Check all that apply) (N=441) 400 343 350 322 300 250 222 200 150 80 78 100 53 66 52 50 26 19 13 1410 7 Main Service 0 Other Services Other Pastor Worship Worship Leader/Director Minister Church Secretary Church Worship Committee Worship Choir Director/Leader Choir

Church Musician/Music Musician/Music Church 132 46. Who leads the congregational singing in worship at your church? (Check all that apply) (N=443) 250 238 186 200 168 150 122 117 100 62 42 44 43 42 50 38 34 7 8 0 Main Service Other Services Other Pastor No one Praise Team Praise Worship Worship Leader/Director Minister Choir Director/Leader Choir Church Musician/Music Musician/Music Church 133 47. Who accompanies the congregational singing in your worship? (Check all that apply) (N=444) 400 344 350 300 284 250 234 200 150 88 100 56 54 57 56 28 50 13 14 4 18 5 Main Service 0 Other Services Choir Other No one No Organist CD's Praise band Praise Recorded tracks or tracks Recorded Pianist/keyboardist

134 48. How often do you use the following in worship: (Check all that apply.) (N=448)

350 300 250 200 150 Always 100 Frequently 50 Occasionally 0 … … … … … Rarely Never Psalter Amens Communion Lord’s Prayer Lord’s The Doxology The The Gloria Gloria Patri The Prayer Responses Responses Prayer Apostle’s Creed or or Creed Apostle’s Benediction (Sung) Benediction Baptism Responses Responses Baptism Offertory Responses Responses Offertory 135 49. Does your church have a choir(s)? (N=448)

21 5%

Yes No

427 95%

136 50. If yes, how many choirs does your church have? (N=427)

22 5%

96 22%

2 to 3 199 47% 4 to 5 1 6 or more

110 26%

137 51. How many Sundays per month does the choir (one of the choirs) sing in worship? (N=426) 31 7% 61 15%

4 1 2 3 78 256 18% 60%

138 52. List the musical groups that may participate in worship in your church on a typical Sunday? (Check all that apply.) (N=435) Count 450 415 400 350 300 257 250 200 190 150 100 79 56 50 9 0 Choir(s) Soloists Praise team Quartets Band Orchestra 139 53. How is new music learned by the Choir? (Check all that apply.) (N=421)

Count

263 44% sheet music 335 by ear 56%

140 54. How is new music learned by the Congregation? (N=428)

302 hearing 48% 326 52% hymnals

141 SECTION FIVE HYMNAL RESOURCES

142 55. Which hymnals or songbooks does your church use regularly during the main worship service? (Check all that apply.) (N=420) 400 379 350 300 256 250 200 174 150 126 88 100 65 28 50 19 7 5 19 12 0 none UMH Other Zion SS Zion Cokesbury Nat Baptist Nat Global Praise Global Songs ofSongs Zion Family of God Family Af Am Heritage Af Other Methodist Other The Faith We Sing We Faith The

143 56—58. % use of Hymnals

90.00% 80.00% 70.00% 60.00%

50.00% UMH 40.00% SOZ/ZSS 30.00% 27.92% 27.92% AAHH/other 21.72% 22.43% 20.00% 10.00% 0.00% 0-25% 26-50% 51.75% 76-100%

144 59. About how many new or unfamiliar songs do you sing each month? (N=420)

350 295 300

250 None 200 1 -- 2 150 3--5 6--10 100 10+ 62 56 50 5 2 0 None 1 -- 2 3--5 6--10 10+

145 60. List the top 10 songs sung in your church *UM List from Online Survey Facebook 2010 1. Blessed Assurance 1. Here I Am, Lord 2. Amazing Grace 2. How Great Thou Art 3. Holy, Holy, Holy 3. Amazing Grace 4. Leaning On The Everlasting Arms 4. Hymn of Promise (What A Fellowship) 5. O How I Love Jesus 5. In the Garden 6. Pass Me Not O Gentle Savior 6. Lord of the Dance 7. How Great Thou Art 7. It is Well With My Soul 8. Great Is Thy Faithfulness 8. Be Thou My Vision 9. What A Friend We Have In Jesus 9. Great is Thy Faithfulness 10. My Hope Is Built 10. Blessed Assurance

146 11—25 from Online Song List

11. O for a Thousand Tongues/ 18. Because He Lives/Doxology Sweet, Sweet Spirit (tie) (tie) 12. Marching to Zion 19. At the Cross/ Lift Every Voice 13. We’ll Understand It Better and Sing (tie) Bye and Bye 20. I Surrender All/Just As I Am 14. Jesus Keep Me Near the (tie) Cross/ This is the Day (tie) 15. Let Us Break Bread 21. Precious Lord Together 22. We’ve Come This Far by Faith 16. Here I Am Lord/ Spirit Song 23. Victory in Jesus (tie) 24. Standing on the Promises 17. This Little Light 25. What A Mighty God We Serve

147 61. Which of the following types of resources do you use for worship? (Check all that apply.) (N=405) 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 Regularly 0 Occasionally … … Never Hymnals Copies of Copies Songbooks Music/Lyrics Music/Lyrics Charts/Scores Charts/Scores Created from from Created Downloadable Downloadable and Arrangements and CDs Learned by Ear Ear by Learned CDs Local Compositions Compositions Local and Taught to Choir Choir to Taught and Local Song Collection Local

148 62. Do you use the Psalms in the United Methodist Hymnal? (If “no” skip to question #66.) (N=407)

147 36%

Yes No

260 64%

149 63. If “yes” how do currently use the Psalter in the UMH? (N=267)

14 25 4% 7% Responsive

89 Read 24% Chanted

237 Use Psalms from other 65% sources

150 64. How often do you re-write, rearrange, or substitute for the sung response given? (N=278)

26 9%

74 Never 27% Occasionally Frequently

178 64%

151 65. Do you use the Psalm as: (Check all that apply.) (N=271)

39 10%

72 159 18% 41% Scripture reading Call to Worship Response to OT Other

120 31%

152 66. Please indicate whether or not you use the each service from The 1989 United Methodist Hymnal, from the bulletin, or if it is not used in your church. (N=406)

400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 Use Hymnal - Yes 0 Use Hymnal - No … … … … … … Printed in Bulletin Reception of Reception Baptism Service Baptism Marriage p. 864 p. Marriage Communion Music Music Communion Daily Praise/Prayer Praise/Prayer Daily Confirmation p. 45 Confirmation Death/Resurrection Death/Resurrection Communion Service Communion Baptism Music p. Music 53 Baptism Reaffirmation p. 45 p. Reaffirmation

153 67.a Other sources for Communion ritual. (N=78)

Count 14 13 13 12 9 10 8 8 6 6 4 4 3 3 4 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 … … … … … … … … … … … … ad lib ad Internet Scripture GBOD.org GBOD.org Ruth Duck Ruth traditional Presbyterian Presbyterian 1989 Hymnal Hymnal 1989 1964 Book of 1964 Wee Worship Wee other worship worship other Annual Conf or Conf Annual wherever I find wherever Baptist Hymnal Baptist Af Am Heritage Am Heritage Af Methodist Supp Methodist Book of Worship Book Print in Bulletin, Bulletin, in Print Africana worship worship Africana Book of common of common Book developed locally developed Holy Communion Communion Holy Lutheran, Catholic Lutheran,

154 67b. Other sources for Communion Music (N=127)

20 18 18 16 14 14 14 12 12 11 10 8 8 7 7 6 5 4 4 4 4 3 3 3 3 3 2 2 2 1 0 … … … CDs none other hymnal hymnal memory sheet music sheet AME Hymnal AME Songs of Zion Songs Zion Still Still Sings Zion Baptist Hymnal Baptist Af Am Heritage Am Heritage Af Local Collection Local Negro Spirituals Negro Gospel music or music Gospel Choir, min music min music Choir, traditional songs traditional The Faith We Sing We Faith The let us break bread us break let Contemporary music Contemporary Congregational music Congregational

155 67c. Other Baptismal Ritual Services(N=44)

16 15 14 12 12 10 8 5 6 4 4 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 Bible none same AAHH Other Other hymnal ed Services Book of Worship Book Africana worship Africana Other Church Church Church Church Other 1964 Book of Worship 1964 1964 of Worship Book

156 67d. Other Baptismal Music (N=74)

16 14 14 12 10 7 8 6 6 6 5 6 4 3 3 3 4 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 … … … … … … … none Hymnal spirituals Choir music Choir “Ever flowing flowing “Ever Gospel Songs Gospel other sources other sources other Songs of Zion of Zion Songs Zion Still Still Sings Zion AAHH (African (African AAHH “Sweet, Sweet Sweet “Sweet, Congregational Congregational Baptist Hymnal Baptist Breathe On Me Breathe “Take me to the to me “Take UMBOW Book of UMBOW “God Claims You” Claims “God The Faith We Sing We Faith The 'Come Be Baptized' Baptized' Be 'Come contemporary music contemporary "Wade in the Water" the in "Wade

157 67e. Other Sources Confirmation (N=33)

14 13 13 12

6 5 4 2 2

0 None Book of Worship 1964 Book of Other Worship

158 67f. Other sources Reception of Members (N=61)

30 24 25 20 13 15 11 10 5 5 3 3 2 0 None AAHH other hymnal spirituals Book of Worship Book or other or song Traditionally sings Traditionally "What a Fellowship" a Fellowship" "What

159 67g. Other sources for Reaffirmation of Faith (N=25)

16 14 14 12 10 8 6 4 4 2 2 2 2 1 0 none Other Other hymnal chosen by by chosen pastor/choir Congregational Congregational Book of Worship Book Singing of hymns Singing

160 67h. Other sources for Marriage Ritual (N=74)

30 26 25 20 17 15 12 10 5 5 5 3 2 2 2 0 none Other hymnal CD worship contemporary Couples Choice Couples Ceremony from from Ceremony Book of BookWorship another ministry another pastor designs the designs pastor contemporary music music contemporary

161 67i. Other Sources for Death/Resurrection

35 30 30 25 20 17 15 11 10 5 4 5 3 2 2 2 0 none AAHH hymnal Holy Bible Holy Songs of Zion Songs pastor/family Family Chooses Family Book of Worship Book Other CommentsOther

162 67j. Other Sources for Daily Praise/Prayer

20 18 18 16 16 14 12 10 8 6 5 4 2 2 2 2 0 none Book of Daily Bread hymnal Upper Room Other Worship

163 68. Do you use the services of Morning Prayer or Evening Prayer? (If “no,” skip to question #72) (N=408) 50 12%

No Yes

358 88%

164 69. If “yes:” how often do you use them? (N=58)

20 34%

Occasionally Frequently

38 66%

165 70. Who leads them? (N=66)

4 6% 12 18%

Pastor Lay person Worship leader 37 57% Other 12 19%

166 71. When do you use them? (Check all that apply.) (N=63)

40 34 35 31 30 25 23 20 18 18 15 10 7 5 3 0 Other Retreat meeting Weekday Weeknight Sunday night Sunday Sunday morning Sunday

167 72. Are there other services you would use if they were in the hymnal? (N=404)

114 28%

No Yes

290 72%

168 73. If “Yes” list them:

Among the additional resources requested : 1. Advent/Christmas cycle 2. Lent/Easter Cycle. 3. Foot Washing 4. Healing Services 5. resources to open meetings or bible studies 6. Women’s day, 7. Men’s day, 8. Watch Night 9. Juneteenth 10. Kwanzaa. 11. Rites of Passage 12. Confirmation

169 SECTION SIX TECHNOLOGY

170 74. What types of electronic resources do you use in planning/performing the music for worship? (N=383) Count 250 222 200 188

150 104 98 100 85

50 24 12 0 CD’s MIDI None tapes Other Internet Projection

171 75. Do you or your worship/music planners use the Internet for: (N=383)

Count 121 20% 199 33% worship resources choir music 98 cong. music 16% Do not use

188 31%

172 76. What equipment are you currently using in worship? (N=383)

Count 350 302 300 250 200 156 150 109 91 100 43 50 29 27 12 0 MIDI none Other projector CD player CD PowerPoint LCD projector LCD Sound system Sound

173 77. Are you using projection for congregational singing? (If “no,” please proceed to question #81) (N=383)

101 26%

No Yes

282 74%

174 78. If “yes,” are you projecting: (N=104)

9 9%

Words Words and music

95 91%

175 79. How often do you use projection? (N=124)

70 63 60 50 40 29 30 25 19 20 11 10 4 2 4 6 4 0 Main Service Other Services weekly Weekly - Monthly Quarterly Bi Special Special Services/Infrequently

176 80. Where do you get your slides? (N=114)

7 5% 35 64 22% 40%

53 33%

creating slides All Internet Pre-Packaged: Corel, Easy Worship, Hymnal on CD, UMH, Sunday Plus, ProPresenter,

Media Shout Shoutables 177 81. Is your church using more, less or about the same level of technology as 3 years ago? (N=383) 30 13 8% 3%

Same 191 More 50% Not sure Less 149 39%

178 82. Which kinds of technology do you expect your church to adopt for use in worship in the next 3-5 years? (N=383) Count 300 216 162 200 153 122 102 83 75 100 34 29 11 6 8 0 … N/A CD’s MIDI tapes None Internet projector know Power Point Power LCD projector LCD Sound system Sound Not sure, don’t sure, Not stream, ipod, stream, Other: (Live video (Live Other:

179 83. Is there anything in the area of music and worship that you wish you had but can’t find. Are there any unmet music resource needs? 1. African or Africana videos 2. tracks for music 3. CDs that demonstrated multiple ways to sing songs 4. More gospel music 5. More praise music 6. ways to include children and youth in worship 7. Instruction in use of jazz in worship 8. music arrangements more accurately notated for the black community 9. more gospel songs in the UMH 10. instruction in worship planning for pastors 11. workshops in worship for choirs and musicians 12. resources for Advent/Lenten seasons 13. more seasonal resources 14. orchestra arrangements of UMH selections

180 84. What has been the biggest change in worship and music at your church in the last 10 years? A number of respondents noted 9. Different kinds of choirs/ fundamental change in their musicians worship services like: 10. Broader use of resources 1. Projection and other technology 11. Addition of liturgical dance or 2. New worship services mime groups 3. Different times for worship 12. Hip-hop 4. Different styles of worship in new or old services On the down-side, several lamented 5. New or enlarged use of 1. The loss of trained musicians Contemporary music 2. The loss of someone to play the 6. More diversity in music selections pipe organ 7. Less use of 3. Pastoral changes 8. More instrumentation

181 85. Do you have any additional comments or suggestions you would like to make?

1. a new hymnal with updated music 2. more gospel music 3. more “singable” (black church) music 4. more contemporary music 5. more Caribbean and African liturgy 6. Use the African American Heritage Hymnal 7. add more gospel music to the new United Methodist Hymnal. 8. Keep the old standards in any new hymnal 9. more music suitable for young people and children.

182

Africana Hymnal Short Survey Summary and Observations Demographics

NCJ NEJ SCJ SEJ WJ Total % of whole Total Responses 68 167 180 379 44 838 Clergy 18 25 11 52 2 108 12.89% Laity 50 142 169 327 42 730 87.11%

What is the approximate Membership of your church? % of 687 responses < 100 11 17 18 46 92 13.39% 100-199 20 28 3 64 1 116 16.89% 200-299 16 18 4 58 96 13.97% 300-499 6 81 15 44 26 172 25.04% 500-749 2 10 1 6 14 33 4.80% 750-999 7 3 6 16 2.33% > 1000 7 5 136 13 1 162 23.58%

What is the approximate Average Sunday Worship Attendance of your church? % of 669 responses < 100 32 45 21 115 1 214 31.99% 100-199 16 26 12 81 26 161 24.07% 200-299 5 65 10 19 14 113 16.89% 300-499 1 14 2 10 27 4.03% 500-749 3 4 6 1 14 2.09% 750-999 1 1 0.15% > 1000 4 135 139 20.78%

Q1. Worship Practices a. How do you participate in Sunday worship? Respondents described their worship in terms of praising and praying, clapping and dancing and listening to sermons. They serve in a variety of ministries on Sunday like choir, scripture reading, communion stewards, liturgists, and children’s ministries.

b. What do you NOT like about what your church does in worship? The list is short but significant. Concerns about music head this list with 9% of responses. Several were concerned about musical styles or musicians that were not proficient, or about the kinds of music being sung. Services that lasted too long (8%) announcements (8%) Dull worship services (7%), and services that were too structured or too traditional (4%) were also mentioned. Less than 1% of the responses had to do with volume (too loud).

183

Q2a. Describe a good church service. One respondent wrote: “A good church service is one where the collective community is involved in corporate worship.” The laity responses were similar in principle to those received in the online survey. Participants described services where preaching, praying, singing and praise intersected and where the people were engaged and unified in worship. Words used to describe good worship in this survey group: 38% -- music, songs, singing 32% -- sermon, message, the word 21% -- spirit, Holy Spirit, or spiritual 15% -- praise 9% -- participation 7% -- unity, one accord 5% -- choir 5% -- prayer 5% -- hospitality/fellowship 4% -- planning or organization 3% -- inspiration/ though-provoking 3% -- worship style 3% -- linked worship to outside community 2% -- free, spontaneous 2% -- salvation, invitation, altar call

Q2b. Which of the following is true about good worship services? (Circle all that apply.) NCJ NEJ SCJ SEJ WJ Total % of whole a. Organized/planned 56 114 122 186 31 509 60.74% worship is important b. Good worship can be 42 89 83 160 27 401 47.85% planned. c. Good worship should 42 85 85 136 27 375 44.75% be planned. d. The spiritual disciplines 49 110 108 181 29 477 56.92% are preparation for good worship. e. Congregational singing 59 143 129 241 30 602 71.84% is vital to good worship.

Q3a. What kind of songs do you sing at your church and who sings them? Kinds of songs reported by laity: 49% gospel 41% hymns 26% contemporary 22% spirituals (sung by choirs or men’s choruses) 19% classical (sung by choirs) 17% traditional

184

13% praise music 2% rap or hip-hop <1% folk or global

Q3b. In our church, the CONGREGATION sings an average of NCJ NEJ SCJ SEJ WJ Total % of 739 responses 1-2 songs per service 24 21 52 50 9 156 21.11% 3-4 songs per service 35 89 72 162 25 383 51.83% More than 4 songs 6 45 43 99 7 200 27.06%

Q3c. How do you feel about the way instruments are used in your church? Attitudes about instruments were overwhelmingly positive with 63% saying that they loved them, liked them or that they were great and an additional 15% said they could use more instrumentation and 15% made mention of drums in worship. Nine percent (9%) said they were okay with instruments. Only 3% said that the instruments were too loud (less than 1% of those comments specifically mentioned drums) and less than 1% said that they did not like the use of instruments in their church.

Q4a. My church uses ______hymnbooks regularly in worship. NCJ NEJ SCJ SEJ WJ Total % of 498 responses 0 4 4 8 1 17 3.41% 1 21 59 81 84 4 249 50% 2 20 39 15 51 25 150 30.12% 3 12 9 5 18 7 51 10.24% 4 or more 1 2 3 24 1 31 6.23%

Q4b. Circle all that apply: NCJ NEJ SCJ SEJ WJ Total % of whole a. My church uses our 61 137 139 204 33 574 68.50% denominational hymnal b. My church uses a 23 48 41 84 19 215 25.66% hymnal other than our denominational hymnal c. Hymns are an 51 115 124 190 32 512 61.10% important contribution to the church. d. Hymns teach our 44 97 94 128 25 388 46.30% religious faith's theologies and doctrines. e. Our present hymnal 46 99 68 148 28 389 46.42% contains hymns of my religious heritage

185

f. Our present hymnal 44 65 53 110 25 297 35.44% contains hymns of my ethnic heritage g. My church uses our 42 86 52 122 21 323 38.54% hymn book at services other than Sunday morning h. Our present hymnal 40 66 46 102 27 281 33.53% contains hymns of my racial heritage.

Q4c. Where do you get resources for the kind of worship experienced in your church? 2% Lectionary 4% UMH 29% Cokesbury, UMPH 10% GBOD, Africana 10% Internet, online 6% UMBOW 9% Bible 2% AAHH 3% Songs of Zion, ZSS 10% choir leaders or pastor

Q5. What are some of the worship traditions that have been passed down in your church? Reported were: Devotions led by the seniors, Praying bands Singing bands Call and response singing Altar calls Watch Night services

Describe the special days observed at your church. The following were mentioned with frequency in addition to standard Christian holidays or special days on the United Methodist program calendar: 47% Women’s Day 32% Men’s Day 15% Youth Day 14% Usher’s Anniversary 11 % Church Anniversaries 8% Homecoming 6% Children’s Day 4% Friends and Family Day 4% Revivals 4% Harvest Sunday 4% Annual Day

186

Less was said about the use of resources for those days though several listed the hymnal, UMPH, Africana and local resources.

Observations

Demographics of the study: Every attempt was made to encourage balanced participation. The number of responses from each jurisdiction is within percentage points of the distribution of black church members within that jurisdiction as the chart below illustrates.

0-299 300+ Total % by Compare to % Attendance Attendance Short Jurisdiction Members by surveys of Short Jurisdiction (GCFA Surveys 2008) NCJ 53 15 68 8.11% 7.43% NEJ 64 103 167 19.93% 22.17% SCJ 26 154 180 21.48% 21.62% SEJ 280 99 379 45.22% 45.45% WJ 2 42 44 5.25% 3.33% Totals 425 413 838 100% 100%

In this survey group, there is a fairly equal balance between smaller churches and larger churches. The committee attributes this to the way these surveys were collected – at national and regional/jurisdictional events where participants from larger churches are also likely to be present in numbers. The number of responses received from churches 1000+ in the SCJ may be traced to the extraordinary efforts of at least two large membership churches in that jurisdiction. Finally, the responses come from 87% laity and 13% clergy, meaning that the trends noted in this study may be seen as the portion of the study most representative of the pews. We did not capture age demographics from this study but it bears mention that 212 surveys were collected at the 2010 Youth Harambee from youth ages 13-18.

Q1. Worship Practices How people participate in worship. The participants described the worship life of the traditional black church – filled with many participants in the service who will sing, praise, pray, clap, dance, and listen intently for a word from the Lord.

What they do not like about their worship services. The committee was surprised that they did not voice many complaints in this section. Many used the space to talk about how well things were going at their churches and how much they liked the worship. Those that did comment mentioned predictable things like the length of worship, the announcements and concerns with music style or the rigidness of the worship service.

187

Q2.a Descriptions of good worship This question was also asked in the online survey. How do the laity responses compare with those of pastors, musicians, worship leaders and other professionals?

Words used to describe good Online survey % Short survey % church Music, song, singing 73% 38% Sermon, message or preaching 58% 32% Spirit, spiritual or Holy Spirit 39% 21% Praise 16% 15% Free, spontaneous 16% 2% Choir 15% 5% Participation 14% 9% Unity, accord, together or 10% 7% engaged Invitation, altar call or salvation 9% 2% Testimony 8% 1% Worship style 8% 3%

In addition to these, the laity used several other words with some frequency 7% -- feel, feeling, love 5% -- prayer 5% -- hospitality/fellowship 4% -- planning or organization 3% -- inspiration/ though-provoking 3% -- linked worship to outside community

The laity responses were more descriptive of how good worship made them feel and how the music and sermons impacted them. The responses also suggest that church leaders and laity emphasize slightly different aspect of the worship service.

Q2b. When asked to quantify what they felt contributed to good worship the laity indicated that planning was important (61%), it is possible to plan a good worship service (48%), the spiritual disciplines are preparation for good worship (57%) and that congregational singing is vital to good worship (72%)! The strength of their answers was almost identical to those of church leaders in the online survey.

Q3a. Kinds of songs sung at church: Laity were given a blank space to write in the kinds of songs they sung with no prompting. Their responses indicate that gospel music is sung more than hymns and their responses confirm the committee’s speculation that the spirituals are being sung by the choir or by small groups like the male chorus. Several respondents made a distinction between black sacred music and music found in the UMH.

188

Q3b. Average number of songs sung by the congregation: Laity report that their congregations sing an average of 3-4 songs per service. Question 36 in the online survey reports that congregations are singing 1-3 songs per service. This suggests that congregations sing more than 1 song and probably closer to 3 songs in each worship service.

Q3c. Attitudes about the way instruments are used: The laity LOVE instruments! Their overwhelmingly positive attitudes toward the instruments were surprising. From their responses it would appear that there are relatively few worshippers that do not care for instruments in worship.

Q4a. Number of hymnbooks used in worship. The laity report the use of predominantly one hymnbook in worship (50%), with 30% reporting the use of two hymn books, 10% the use of three hymn books and 6% reporting that they use 4 or more hymn books in worship. From question 55 in the online survey, we learn that these books are likely to be the United Methodist Hymnal, Songs of Zion, the African American Heritage Hymnal, Zion Still Sings, and the National Baptist Hymnal (in this order of frequency). The laity group surveyed come from larger churches than the national average size for black congregations in the United Methodist church and they still report that 50% of this group worships at a church where there is only one hymnal. Question 55 in the online survey reports that 90% of black congregations use the United Methodist Hymnal in some way (although the data from questions 56-58 raise additional questions about how much the UMH is used). The committee is also aware of several churches that have replaced the UMH with the AAHH as their primary hymnal.

Q4b. Attitudes about denominational hymnal: Sixty-eight percent (68%) of the laity report that their church uses the denominational hymnal. This compares to 96% usage reported by the general church population in the 2004—08 Music study. One fourth (25%) of those responding report use of a hymnal other than our denominational hymnal. This group believes that hymns are an important contribution (61%), that they teach our faith’s theologies and doctrines (46%). When asked about their present hymnal only one third (33.5%) felt that their present hymnal contained music of their racial heritage.

Q5a. Worship Traditions

The committee notes its concern that the worship traditions of the black church are weakening. No mention was made of long-meter or Dr. Watts-style singing except, perhaps, in the comment about devotions by the seniors. The online survey documents that several kinds of traditional singing continue within the black church but from the laity reports, these appear to be more isolated practices.

189

Page intentionally left blank

190 Short Survey

Graphs/Charts of Selected Data

191 192 Short Survey: Responses by Jurisdiction (N=838) 44 68 5% 8%

180 22% NCJ SCJ 379 NEJ 45% SEJ WJ

167 20%

193 Short Survey: Laity/Clergy (N=838)

laity/clergy 108 13%

Laity clergy

730 87%

194 Short Survey: Approximate Church Membership (N=838)

Approximate Church Membership 200 180 160 140 Under 100 120 100 100 - 199 80 200 – 299 60 40 300 – 499 20 500 – 749 0 Under 100 - 200 – 300 – 500 – 750 – 750 – 999 1000+ 100 199 299 499 749 999 1000+ mbershp 92 116 96 172 33 16 162 Axis Title

195 Short Survey: Approximate Worship Attendance (N=838)

Worship att 250

200

150

100

0 Under 100 – 200 – 300 – 500 – 750 – 1000+ 100 199 299 499 749 999 Worship att 214 161 113 27 14 1 139

196 #2. Which of the Following is True about Good Worship?

CIRCLE ALL THAT APPLY: NUMBER OF RESPONSES PERCENTAGE of entire group a. Organized/planned 509 60.74% worship is important b. Good worship can be 401 47.85% planned c. Good worship should 375 44.75% be planned d. The spiritual 477 56.92% disciplines are preparation for good worship e. Congregational 602 71.84% singing is vital to good worship 197 Short Survey #3. Congregational Singing (N=838)

In Our Church the CONGREGATION sings (check one) 156 200 21% 27%

1-2 songs per service 3-4 songs per service More than 4 songs

383 52%

198 Short Survey #4. Number of Hymn Books Used in Worship

# of Hymn books 300 249 250

200 150 150

100 51 50 31 17 0 0 1 2 3 4 or more

199 Attitudes about Denominational Hymnal

CIRCLE ALL THAT APPLY NUMBER OF RESPONSES PERCENTAGE of entire group a. My church uses our denominational 574 68.50% hymnal b. My church uses a hymnal other than 215 25.66% our denominational hymnal c. Hymns are an important contribution 512 61.10% to the church d. Hymns teach our religious faith's 388 46.30% theologies and doctrines e. Our present hymnal contains hymns of 389 46.42% my religious heritage f. Our present hymnal contains hymns of 297 35.44% my ethnic heritage g. My church uses our hymnbook at 323 38.54% services other than Sunday morning h. Our present hymnal contains hymns of 281 33.53% my racial heritage

200

Africana Hymnal Study Report of Short Surveys

Africana Hymnal Study Committee January 2011

NCJ (0-299 Members) 201

0 to 299 - Membership & Worship Attendance -- NCJ

Jurisdiction

North Central 53 North Eastern South Central Southeastern Western

Clergy or Laity

Clergy 13 Laity 40

What is the approximately membership of your church?

Under 100 11 100 - 199 20 200 - 299 16 300 - 499 500 - 749 750 - 999 1000+

What is the approximate total Sunday worship attendance at your church?

Under 100 32 100 - 199 14 200 - 299 300 - 499 500 - 749 750 - 999 1000+

NCJ (0-299 Members) 202

1. Worship Practices

How do you participate in Sunday worship?

Usher; Communion Steward; Outreach & Nurture Sing in the choir. Prepare the worship service bulletin (voluntary secretary) I generally lead worship and preach/pray Sometimes liturgist or member in pew. Serve on various committees. Vol. Admin. Asst., Greeter, Usher, UMW President, Blk. History Day, International Day programs - Annual UMW Bake Sale, Clothing Day Various Ways Pastor Women's Chorus As a retired clergy, I have been invited to preach and to give the morning prayer Sing in choir; serve as liturgist; lay speaker I participate in the music worship Worship leader, scripture - bring the message Communion Steward, using when needed. Soloist. Lay Speaker, choir(s) member, liturgist Sometime preach, liturgist, Bible study participants (I am in an appointment beyond the local church) Planning includes worship committee input & worship team. I read gospel, preach, pray. (See Note 1 below) Varies: provide service as needed. I am constantly visiting a variety of services Leading Preacher, Pastoral Prayer Worshiping God, praising God, singing, praying, preaching Worship Leader, Scripture Reader, Usher Traditional, with blended contemporary aspects. Worship Leader Preacher and prayer Sing in choir, Sunday School Sing in choir I participate first as a willing worshipper (one who comes to be fully engaged in each particular celebration). As Lay Leader I am available to support the pastoral staff as needed.

NCJ (0-299 Members) 203

Occasional liturgist; Communion Steward Sing in two choirs, participate in worship Singing, Call to Worship, read from Pew Bible as liturgist, reads Offertory, out loud response to an inspiring message or song. (I have become my Mother - I love to worship.) Worship Leader Scripture Reading Sing in choir, liturgist, lay speaker Spiritual Worship Leader; Preacher Director of Music Dance, sing, pray, lead scripture, financial giving Worship leader & proclamation of The Word Usher - Audio Lay Leader Liturgist A Pastor - I do most of the preaching Lead, preach Singing, prayer, worship Praise God through song - and listening and taking in the preached word Worship Leader I participate by singing in the choir, and occasionally leading worship service. I often give the children's message. Trustee - wherever needed, and for whatever needs to be done. Sing in the choir. Begin with Sunday school, reading scripture Consistent altar praying, Sunday school teaching, liturgist or speaker of the Call to Worship, & Prayer of Praise & Adoration Worship leader, usher, scripture reader

What do you NOT like about what your church does in worship?

Drummer plays to loud The music instruments are too loud. Standing too long without participation Not enough lay participation. Too few creative worship music expressions. Children' moments

NCJ (0-299 Members) 204

Sing too many anthems Not inclusive Format that is ritualistic - some components that are very rigid and stale Not enough singing or variety of singing Announcements We do not have a minister of music To much movement Extra ann. (Windermere); Grace UMC (2nd service traditional service music) We do not have an altar call and we do not open the doors of the church. Where the worship is so routine there is no joy (A-A or Anglo) Churches that have no choir & sad congregational singing Musicians are sometimes too loud Very little "feedback;" No musical diversity Nothing for either. Interrupt the worship service for a 5 minute review/invitation of the morning Sunday School lesson. A bit too traditional to attract the masses of unchurched. Everyone sits where they want to sit - would like to see everyone together. They have no emotion. I believe that every component of worship is essential in the life of a community inasmuch that it may not speak deeply to me. However, I have found that someone is touched by aspects that I didn’t value as much. Deviation from UM practices nothing Every now and then dry songs with hard to follow music are sung. I like all that my church is doing. If anything could be eliminated, it would be announcements. Rituals Everything Nothing, except Announcements Wish more would participate like those attending a football, baseball, or soccer game. We have an ethos that worship is supposed to cater to us. Do not have a problem with it. Praise portion needs improvement No musician Close knit spirit

NCJ (0-299 Members) 205

Reading of announcements; getting worship folks to be excellent Upset the flow of the Spirit by not being organized I would like to see variety in worship service. Perhaps more dancing, or different songs. I'd like to see a main "theme" each Sunday or month of Sundays so that every part of worship blends together. More encouragement/expectation of visitors becoming members It moving in right direction The way they feel they don't have to be involved, come late, leave early from the congregation. Wait too long before removing crying/misbehaving kids. Too many announcements in the middle of service

2. "Good Church"

Describe a "good" church service. (Is there one that stands out in your memory?)

The sermon relates to everyday living. Pastor does some teaching. The songs touch your heart. Traditional & contemporary music blended well, congregational participation, well delivered & meaningful sermon Mix of music; time to give testimony - Praise the Lord, and have mercy; altar call Singing gospels, praying Morning Worship with singing, prayers, scriptures, preaching the word and the presence of the Holy spirit felt and lived out One when prayers, scriptures, hymns, preaching all fit together and when the music, especially, is spirit-filled and beautiful (not necessarily "gospel" to be considered spirit filled). When the message touches on something that you are personally dealing with and it heals you for a time; the music is uplifting; the congregation is happy and spirit filled A service that is warm and inspirational Opens with praise singing and dancing (liturgical dance group). Engage the worshippers in greeting each other; Congregational hymn singing is necessary. Good preaching, invitation, offering and responsive benediction. A good church service is the music. All Saints Day - 2009 A Good Church has something for everyone. Laity and clergy, women and men Christmas, Easter, Ash Wed. service Christmas Eve utilized liturgical dance; liturgy written for community.

NCJ (0-299 Members) 206

A Good Church service provides for the participation of the worshippers (through music, prayer, and other acts of praise)A service where God is glorified, Jesus is lifted and the Holy spirit reigns One that engages all people. A message to remember and grow by. Good music. Diversity - all kinds. Good - church - worship is planned but spirit-filled - musical diversity - solid and relative preaching. Service where God is glorified with excitement in the praises of his people. Services where God's word reaches people and transforms lives. Smooth flow service, with a worship leader that shows a passion for the job; powerful singing and powerful preaching based on scripture. Vibrant praise, singing, preaching, engaging, invokes response, challenges us in daily living, and sends us out in mission. Everyone of one accord - praising God and letting the spirit use and guide them. When all choirs are singing. Short but not too short, we sing, gospel and it excite you. Timely, good sermon, good music (we have variety). A good church service is a celebration that contextualizes and acknowledges God's activity in the community and world thru litanies, music (contemporary, hymns, anthems, gospels, etc.), sacramental life, public witness of the community and prophetic proclamation. The Word from which the message is based on remains the focus of the message and the highlight is not obscured by other stuff, and is not unreasonably lengthy. Easter - The Resurrection Definitely inspired meaningful message, spirit filled music. Two Sundays ago the windows were open and the music & singing was so awesome a person from the outside came and commented on how uplifting. One that I feel different than when I came. I have joy, joy, joy down in my heart! Praise & worship with uplifting songs. When the Holy spirit is very present. The Word, ministry of music and congregational participation is all as one. Peace & worship; time of corporate & individual prayer; good preaching One that is led by The Spirit in both the spoken word & music ministry, as well as all other supporting operations (ushers, welcome team, etc.) within or around the time frame goal. When God's word is being taught, sung & danced too, when all ages celebrate the Risen Christ, and when the Holy Ghost rains down & transforms lives. A good church service is one where the collective community is involved in corporate worship. Every service is a good service. When family, guests and friends attend on those special occasions. When someone accepts Christ; especially youth, and when you can feel The Spirit moving throughout the congregation. Most Sundays

NCJ (0-299 Members) 207

Multisensory; video screen; participation - liturgists, choir, pulpit guests and congregation participating; with openness to the Holy Spirit Non-traditional. We recently had a service of intergenerational dance. One in which you feel the Spirit moving. A service where the people allow the holy spirit to have its way with them. A "good" church service is spirit-filled. Whether there is dancing, singing or instrumental music, God's presence makes the service "good." A "good" church respects both young and old in the eyes of God. Spirit filled. Service that is filled with love and the Holy Spirit One that's spirit filled/lead. One that speaks directly to me regardless of how many are in church. The service flows, the spirit is alive with preaching, praising and good fellowship.

Which of the following is true about good worship services? (Circle all that apply.)

a. Organized/planned worship is important 46 b. Good worship can be planned 36 c. Good worship should be planned 36 d. The spiritual disciplines are preparation for good worship 37 e. Congregational singing is vital to good worship 48

3. Music

What kind of songs do you sing at your church and who sings them?

Gospel; contemporary; traditional Traditional and gospel. The choir has 1 or 2 selections. Praise songs, open and closing hymns, invitation led by choir with congregation. Traditional (UMH), contemporary (TFWS), some praise songs from Maranatha _____; congregation, choir, soloists Contemporary, classical songs with upbeat tempo; some sacred musical 1) Gospel & anthems; 2) Choir & Congregation All kinds of music Variety of styles: choir, soloists, congregation sings Spirituals, gospel, traditional - anthems, inspirational contemporary gospel

NCJ (0-299 Members) 208

Hymns, Gospel Music - The congregation, the Children's Choir, The Chancel Choir, a team of rappers Hymns (UMH, Songs of Zion & Zion Still Sings) - congregation. All style gospel - Male Chorus. Contemporary Gospel - Choir Hymnals the congregational sing at our church. Gospel - choir & congregation We sing Gospel and use the hymnals; special music on some Sundays. Traditional - 1) Sanctuary Choir; Contemporary - 2) Inspirational Choir; Inspirational - 3) Men's Chorus, 4) Women's Chorus Grace - traditional service - taped music; Grace - Praise Service - contemporary, PowerPoint, etc.; Windermere - hymns, gospels, no anthems but it would be nice. Global music for congregation and special music for community All - choirs, soloists, Praise Teams, children/youth, handbell choirs, other instruments Variety as congregant Gospel - mainly the choir. Hymns - choir & congregation. Congregation does 2 or 3; choir does introit and 1 selection Hymns and gospel by congregation and choir. UM Hymns, various popular contemp. songs. Hymns, anthems, gospel, contemporary. Old Gospel, contemporary, young songs/drums, dancing, etc! Songs from Songs of Zion/Faith We Sing Rock/gospel - the choir Congregation uses hymnals; choir sings anthems, spirituals, & gospel The songs that are song at our church are: Praise and hymns - sung by the congregation; Praise, gospels and contemporary - sung by the Angelic Choir (main); African American Spirituals - sung by the Male Chorus; Age appropriate contemporary and gospels - sung by the Children's Choir. Hymns; gospel; contemporary; choir; congregation; soloists Hymns, Gospel, & Songs of Zion A variety of hymns, spirituals and gospels - by congregation; choirs sings gospels, anthems and on special occasions, classical. Gospel, new & old hymns. Young folk - contemporary and rap. Hymns & spirituals UM Hymnal, Gospel We sing spirituals from the African American Hymnal, Songs of Zion and UM Hymnal. We also sing contemporary and old school music from various choirs. Hymns - congregation; choirs Gospel anthems & hymns - choir & congregation

NCJ (0-299 Members) 209

Hymns, negro spirituals, contemporary gospel, Christian Hymns, anthems, contemporary music also Hymns - spirituals - contemporary CDs and Hymnal Hymnals and we use CD's. We have no choir currently at this time. Mostly hymns sung by the congregation Contemporary songs - choir; hymns; traditional African American songs Gospels, hymns We sing all music types - hymns - contemporary - gospel Hymns and different styles of music. Congregation, choir, solos. We sing hymns and spiritual songs. The choir and congregation sing the songs. Methodist Hymnal - songs & gospel We sing a variety of music, hymns, anthems, spirituals, gospel, instrumental. Note: a new hymnal could focus on more praise/chant like songs. from Methodist Hymn book Traditional/ethnical/contemporary songs sung by our choir Hymns from the UM Hymn Book, gospel songs or AKA negro spirituals, modern day inspirational songs

In our church, the CONGREGATION sings an average of: (Check one)

1-2 songs per service 17 3-4 songs per service 30 More than 4 songs 5 Fewer than 2 songs Notation: 2-3 songs per service

How do you feel about the way instruments are used in your church?

Drums played to loud The drums are over-powering (loud). Keyboard is good, simulate bass percussion. The instruments are used well.

NCJ (0-299 Members) 210

Need more; mostly piano - need drum & others. Currently have a sax & piano. Good It adds to the service Always could incorporate more Don't have enough - (piano, electric keyboard). There are talented musicians in the church that I wish would use their musical gifts - we also recently had a saxophonist; a drum set (unused) I think instruments should be used because they can enhance the music ministry The piano every week is good. I would like to have the organ weekly. The drums sit idle. I want to see us use guitar & bass. I like instruments in worship service Good All of the instruments used, when the musical director and drummer work together. Great I find that the drums, etc., are most wonderful. Would like to hear the organ (Windermere) sometimes. We do an excellent job utilizing a variety of instruments. The worship is organ centric. I welcome all instruments. It is important that the instrument/music is used appropriately. Poorly and not enough. Very good, excellent musicians at Scott. Excellent sound system at The Way. Very vital to the atmosphere and enhances the worship experience. Good, drums, electric organ, would invite others. Special occasions, guitars, saxophone, tambourines. Great! What you need to make the worship a great experience. Fine We have no instruments OK All instruments are welcomed in our church. I feel that each can contribute to quality worship when played by trained musicians. I'm tolerant since many of the members seem to enjoy them. Good I love it - piano, organ and drums are used every Sunday. Sometimes other instruments are integrated. Two Sundays ago music included: piano, organ, drums, guitar, bass, trumpet, cello and clarinet and saxophone. Past six months a violin is included at least one a month. Great - all instruments are important. Poor No They are used quite well.

NCJ (0-299 Members) 211

Very positive - however we need to raise new musicians. I appreciate the way that our instruments are used. Love it! Wish we had more musicians to play more instruments!!! Great, organ, drums, piano, etc. We now have an organ player & drummer which adds a lot to the service - Love It!!! DNA No talent to use instrument Great - we have drums, 1 guitarist & keyboard every Sunday, with sax, trumpet and bass when persons are available Good - there are drums, piano, guitars Good - we need more - A band would be wonderful I feel any instrument can be sued to glorify God. He's worthy to be praised by any instrument. We don't use many instruments so I'd love to have more. Currently enjoy the piano and occasional saxophone. Any instrument can be used to uplift the voices of the people. They are adequately used but would like to see more instruments added and utilized/incorporated into worship. Instruments are very important. They allow us with not the best voices to sound like we do and allows everyone to be able to follow the music.

4. Hymnal/Worship Resources

My church uses ______hymnbooks regularly in worship

1 2 1 UM UM 1 or 2 1 3 2 1 AAHH UMH

NCJ (0-299 Members) 212

2 yes 35-45 3 2 2 2 UMC UM Songs of Zion, UMH 2 yes 2 2 UM 2 1 Songs of Zion 2 2 3 - congregation uses Hymnal; mainly choir uses Hymnal, Songs of Zion, African American Hymnal 3 3 3 10-15 2 1 1 3 Songs of Zion 2 2

NCJ (0-299 Members) 213

Circle all that apply: a. My church uses our denominational hymnal 47 b. My church uses a hymnal other than our denominational hymnal 15 c. Hymns are an important contribution to the church 39 d. Hymns teach our religious faith's theologies and doctrines 35 e. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my religious heritage 35 f. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my ethnic heritage 34 g. My church uses our hymnbook at services other than Sunday morning 33 h. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my racial heritage 31

Where do you get your resources for the kind of worship experience in your church?

The Lectionary UM Hymnal (for communion), Lectionary, African American Heritage Book of Worship UMH, TFWS, lay liturgy creation Cokesbury - Songs of Zion (more recent) GBOD and shared resources with fellow clergy Radio; DVD/CD's; UMH, Songs of Zion Cokesbury & other resources I believe the pastor uses the BOW and the UMH Internet, BCOD (worship) Cokesbury Various sources - worship committee and pastor take care of this. Members can recommend. Bd. of Discipleship; Cokesbury; on-line resources We have professional musicians and music educators who explore a variety of resources. Cokesbury, General Boards, Religious Book Stores, Internet GBOD website, worship planning resources - Africana Worship, Cokesbury planning annual, others Cokesbury, on-line, personal experience Various sources (most available from Cokesbury and/or UMPH) Scott: UMH, Songs of Zion, Book of worship. The Way: mostly originally designed. Some come from the internet, local stores, artifacts passed from one to another. Mostly Cokesbury

NCJ (0-299 Members) 214

Cokesbury, Echo's Book Stores Different kind of resources The choir Cokesbury UMH/SOZ and complimentary GBOD and other resources GBOD; Cokesbury The Bible UMPH - EOC Media Center Cokesbury/Echos UM Training Cokesbury Cokesbury, music stores UMPH Internet, book stores, Cokesbury, etc. UMPH Various UMPH BOW Internet Cokesbury Minister of Music, Children's Minister of Music BOW From African ritual books, Methodist ritual books and Indian ritual books The pastor's vision, lay leader and minister of music/choir

5. Worship Traditions

What are some of the worship traditions that have been passed down in your church?

I don't know how to answer this U.M. and A-A Don't know

NCJ (0-299 Members) 215

Not sure, new to both ministries Singing hymns, reciting creeds, musical responses Center yourself and invite the spirit of the Lord. Worship traditions have been passed down: First Sunday Communion, & consistent order for Sunday morning worship. Personal & Community Prayer - Passing of Peace Lighting of the candles; reciting the Apostles Creed; Prayer of Pardon

Describe the special days that are observed in your congregation (e.g. Ushers' or Annual Day, Women's Day, Men's Day, etc.) What resources do you use to plan for special days?

We have Women's Day; Men's Day; Student Day; Homecoming; Family & Friends Day Normal Christian Holidays - church anniversary; ministry celebration Men's Day, Women's Day, Youth Day, Scholarship Sunday, Friends & Family Day. Resources used - past experience. Children's moments Woman's Day Spkr. about a woman in the bible, Men's Day Spkr. Ushers' and Annual Day, Women's & Men's Day, Children's Sunday, Revival 1) Ushers hold a silent "tea party;" 2) Women's Day Worship celebration; 3) Men's Day musical program; 4) Annual Golf Outing; 5) UM Women's Special Sunday Celebration; 6) Special Sunday observances in February for Black History Month; 7) Christmas play or program; 8) Pastor Appreciation Day; 9) Church Anniversary Celebration; 10) Sunrise Service; 11) Watch Night Service Women's & Men's Day, Home Coming Days Church anniversary; UMM Anniversary; Male Chorus Anniversary; UMW Annual Women's Day Women's & Men's Day; Youth Worship Services Usher's Board - Men & Women Annual Day - Internet, (BCOD)(Worship) U.M.W. resource material is sent to V. President Church History, Ann. Church Historian does the planning using past history. Black History Month, Women's & Men's Day, Usher's Sermon, Laity Sunday, Youth Sundays, Mother's & Father's Day, memorial of deceased members, World Communion Sunday, World AIDS Windermere - Women's & Men's Day; Grace UMC - Resources read? A circle of friendship after the benediction; The music was commissioned, composed and we have permission to use it. Kwanza, Black History, Lent, Easter, Mother's & Father's Day, Women's & Men's Day, All Saints Day, Student's Day, Thanksgiving, Christmas, Laity Friends & Family Day, Black History Month, Laity Sunday, All Saints Day, Watch Night This congregation does not have any of the above (or other) traditions in worship.

NCJ (0-299 Members) 216

Scott: Men's & Women's Day, Choir Anniversary, Pastor Appreciation, Youth Day. The Way: Kwanza Celebration, Anniversary, King Holiday Breakfast UMW, UMM Annual Day - all available resources are used, no idea is not considered and we borrow from other denominations. Ushers, Women's & Men's Day, Scholarship Sunday, Consecration Sunday Honor and appreciation for that particular group, but praising God for the gifts and graces given to that group to be used in ministry. Annual Day A day full of songs Ushers', Women's & Men's Days, Homecoming Women's & Men's Day, Annual Angelic Choir Concert, Homecoming, Annual Scholarship/Graduation Program - the resources used to plan these special days are based on the preference & familiarity of the Planning Committee Ushers or Annual Day, Women's & Men's Day; Youth Sundays; Children's (5th) Sunday Ushers or Annual Day, Women's & Men's Day, Children's Choir, dramatization of scriptures UMW Sunday, Men's Day, Church Leadership Recognition Sunday, One Great Hour of Sharing, Native American Sunday, UM Student Day, Reconciling Sunday, World Communion Sunday Planned & spontaneous. Singing, prayer, praise, fellowship, The Message! Good physical & spiritual food. Women's & Men's Day Ushers', Women's & Men's Day Women's & Men's Day, Church Anniversary. Hymns and music. Women's & Men's Day, Youth Day (youth explosion), same as above Christmas, Easter, Lenten Services, Women & Men's Days, Church Anniversary, etc. BOW, Africana Worship, etc. Women's & Men's Day, Christmas, Easter, Church Anniversary, etc. DNA - small church Women's Day - Mostly UM Hymnal Women's & Men's Day, Youth led worship every 5th Sunday, Young Adult Sundays, leader-led special days, Father's & Mother's Day Women's & Men's Day Women's & Men's Day, Church Anniversary, New Year's Eve Youth Sunday, Women's & Men's Day, Mother's & Father's Day Service, Watch Night (New Year's Eve), Thanksgiving service. Resources: the scripture, being creative to deliver the message. Laity Sundays include Youth Day every 5th Sunday, Women's & Men's Day which includes plays in faith Women's & Men's Day, Laity Sunday, Usher Appreciation, Church Anniversary Women's & Men's Day. Both UMW and UMM Day cover the whole month each. Resources come from the Music Minister and what the group visions

NCJ (0-299 Members) 217

______

Note 1: Additional notation on survey says "We are a multiracial/multicultural congregation that works hard to utilize "representative" liturgy. We are disconnected in all the "mainline" denominations. African American serving in a cross-cultural appointment."

NCJ (0-299 Members) 218

300+ - Membership and/or Worship Attendance -- NCJ

Jurisdiction

North Central 14 North Eastern South Central Southeastern Western

Clergy or Laity Clergy 4 Laity 10

What is the approximately membership of your church? Under 100 100 - 199 200 - 299 300 - 499 6 500 - 749 2 750 - 999 1000+ 6

What is the approximate total Sunday worship attendance at your church? Under 100 100 - 199 2 200 - 299 5 300 - 499 1 500 - 749 3 750 - 999 1000+ 3

1. Worship Practices

How do you participate in Sunday worship?

NCJ (300+ Members) 219

Worship/Music, Preaching. Provide leadership for congregational life Worship leader, preacher, etc. Preach, pray, lead and coordinate the worship service Leader and Receiver Lay Speaker - Liturgist Sing in choir, liturgist, sometimes speaker, scripture reader Sing in Chancel Choir Choirs Music Director Scheduled to read scripture quarterly Attend Sanctuary choir, Women's choir, Sunday School Teacher Usher; do the café 9:30 - 10:45 Ushering, greeting

What do you NOT like about what your church does in worship?

Lack of comfort with contemporary. Too performance oriented (Praise) limits peoples participation. Lack of zeal in singing Too much time spent on announcements; limited time between worship service Too many individual announcements Too many members are spectators, criticizers, marginal participants Nothing Too many announcements Too many announcements & talking Lack of spiritual motivation Not enough audience interaction Nothing

2. "Good Church"

Enlivened worship - intergenerational; pray and praise Joyful music; energetic and substantive preaching; drama, dance, testimony When the presence and power of the Holy Spirit is evident in both traditional and contemporary worship experiences Spirit-led - Purposeful Preaching; scripture reading according to genre; passionate worship which glorifies God

NCJ (300+ Members) 220

Good Music; Good Message One that integrated the senses, imagination, visuals, drama Good preaching - biblically based; related to everyday challenges; calling to accountability; good music - biblically based, connected with the theme When the Word answers my needs and the music stirs my soul. Lively worship that engages the worshipper in a participatory experience. Music pertinent to message of the day, spirit-filled, prayer & God-centered, laity & general congregation participate in service Funeral of well like person Pentecost Celebration Song Sermon Song & Sermon

Describe a "good" church service. (Is there one that stands out in your memory?)

Which of the following is true about good worship services? (Circle all that apply.)

a. Organized/planned worship is important 9

b. Good worship can be planned 6

c. Good worship should be planned 5

d. The spiritual disciplines are preparation for good worship 11

e. Congregational singing is vital to good worship 10

3. Music

What kind of songs do you sing at your church and who sings them?

Traditional for 1 service, contemporary for 10:30. We have a tradition of one lay person reading. Lay participation in worship. Sacred; gospel; traditional hymns; jazz; contemporary praise; bluegrass Hymns, anthems, gospel, spirituals -- all are sung by the congregation, choir and soloists Hymns, spirited songs, contemporary songs, Songs of Zion, gospel songs - congregation, choirs, soloists Hymns, anthems and old fashioned spirituals

NCJ (300+ Members) 221

Hymns (African American tradition, other traditions), gospel, praise music, contemporary music Use of hymnals (standard, Faith We Sing) - congregation/choir. Praise songs. Wide variety - gospel - traditional), spirituals, anthems, etc. All types - gospel - hymns, anthems, praise & worship We sing a lot of Tindley's hymns - traditional, gospel, contemporary Traditional, recognizable hymns Anthems & acapella - choirs; Hymns - congregation & choirs; Gospel & contemporary - choirs Gospel song African American Gospel

In our church, the CONGREGATION sings an average of: (Check one)

1-2 songs per service 6

3-4 songs per service 5

More than 4 songs 1

Fewer than 2 songs

How do you feel about the way instruments are used in your church?

Very Good! There is an array of instruments used in the contemporary service. More is needed for our traditional services. Very pleased Thoroughly appreciate them Not enough instruments They are very important complements, drums and all Usually used for special services only unless instrumental They add much to the service 3-4 Wonderful. We use a wide array of instruments - drums, keyboard, organ, Hammond organ, piano, electric guitar Don't like Well (organ, piano, drums)

NCJ (300+ Members) 222

Good - piano, drum, horn Fine 4. Hymnal/Worship Resources

My church uses ______hymnbooks regularly in worship

2 3 4 3 UMC 3 2 3 3 3 1 2

Circle all that apply:

a. My church uses our denominational hymnal 13

b. My church uses a hymnal other than our denominational hymnal 7

c. Hymns are an important contribution to the church 12

d. Hymns teach our religious faith's theologies and doctrines 9

e. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my religious heritage 10

f. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my ethnic heritage 9

g. My church uses our hymnbook at services other than Sunday morning 9

NCJ (300+ Members) 223

h. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my racial heritage 8

Where do you get your resources for the kind of worship experience in your church?

UMC Worship Resources, internet, Worship Ways, Africana Worship Book, Songs of Zion, Faith We Sing GBOD, Interpreter, Resource Books, Textweek, etc. Cokesbury and other Christian bookstores, GBOD, GIA publications, some original works Cokesbury, Christian bookstores, Judson Press UM Resources - UM Hymnal, songs of Zion, Zion Still Sings, The Faith We Sing (Choirs) Internet, GBOD Resources/internet Cokesbury Music Directors Cokesbury Cokesbury Sabbath, UMW Sunday, Mother Day, Easter Upper Room & Cokesbury

5. Worship Traditions

What are some of the worship traditions that have been passed down in your church?

Annual Christmas concert -- Handel's Messiah; inclusiveness of all generations Steward Boards, Nurses Guild, Living Hymns

Describe the special days that are observed in your congregation (e.g. Ushers' or Annual Day, Women's Day, Men's Day, etc.) What resources do you use to plan for special days?

Laity Sunday, Youth Sunday, Mission Sunday, Children's Sabbath, Peace with Justice, Veterans' Day Inspirational & Gospel Choir Day, Liturgical Dance Recital, Laity Sunday, Student Day, Girl/Boy Scout Sunday, Martial Arts Sunday, Katrina Missions Sunday Use Hymnal, Book of Worship, internet All Saints Day, Women's Day, Men's Day, Anniversary; UMW's Day

NCJ (300+ Members) 224

Women's & Men's Day, Church Anniversary, Memorial Day Service - Mission focused (Mental Health, Domestic Violence Sunday, etc.)- UM Hymnal, GBOD, Africana Resources, other UM resources, online resources Women's & Men's Day, Youth Sunday (5th Sundays) On Women's Day we have an all women's choir group (non-choir members & choir members)and we wear hats (started as a memorial) Too many to list and it changes annually. Women's & Men's Day, Student Appreciation, Girls & Boy Scouts, Laity Sundays, Mission On Easter Sunday pastor had a martial demonstration - very disturbing Women's & Men's Day UMW Sunday, Women's Day, World Thanks, Children's Sabbath, Father's Day

NCJ (300+ Members) 225

0 to 299 - Membership & Worship Attendance -- NEJ

Jurisdiction North Central North Eastern 64 South Central Southeastern Western

Clergy or Laity Clergy 11 Laity 53

What is the approximately membership of your church? Under 100 17 100 - 199 20 200 - 299 18 300 – 499 500 - 749 750 - 999 1000+

What is the approximate total Sunday worship attendance at your church? Under 100 42 100 – 199 15 200 - 299 4 300 - 499 500 - 749 750 - 999 1000+

1. Worship Practices

How do you participate in Sunday worship?

Pray, sing, listen, hear, liturgist

NEJ (0-299 Members) 226

Only on Communion Sunday and occasionally when asked by the pastor (remarks by retired pastor) I visit different churches each Sunday morning - rural/urban/suburban Preaching, singing, dancing, praying, serving congregation Preach, worship leader, liturgist, music leader I worship God by singing, praying & preaching Oversee & lead As a pastor I take full participation in the church. The whole service experience begins with me. Lead pastoral corporate prayer, preach (read sermonic scriptures), sing with adult choir Preach Yes - preaching, planning worship Actively as song leader, choir director/music director Head usher Worship leader, choir member, praise and worship team Choir, finance Liturgist, scripture reader, plan worship service, congregational prayer, choir member, meditation prior to coming to church Sing in the choir; liturgist, lay speaker Sing Usher, choir Usher, sing, praise, worship Finance Committee work, men's chorus Hostess - health & welfare - church school Lay speaker & worship leader I lead praise & worship with the praise team Part of ministerial team - stand in front & do the Creed, Lord's Prayer & welcome the guests Devotion, choir, Finance Chair From my pew except on Sundays when I am a Reader Singing, Praising I am a worship leader, the liturgist, etc. We predominately have conservative worship. Myself - on choir, ushering, praising God always Bring presence, inviting the Holy Spirit in prayer through praise & worship, singing and the praying Singing, praying, act as liturgist, read scripture Choir, read scripture Engaged member

NEJ (0-299 Members) 227

Part of Sunday School and parent of youth, Biblical Storyteller Liturgical dance, youth choir I listen to the service & sing along (I’m not in the choir) Bible study, choir, Sunday School Leading Praise and helping in any way to help others Lay Speaker (occasionally); Prayer (for worship & pastor) Worship leader, put bulletins together Worship leader, liturgist, Communion server Sing, pray, give Parishioner Praying, speaking. I am a lay speaker. Usher every 4 months Prayer – devotion Have been greeter, reader, worship leader, said altar prayer, liturgical dancer Sunday School and Choir participation Sing, sometime read scripture to congregation. Basically I attend service. Worship leader, choir Usher, sing Singing in the choir Sing in choir; liturgist Choir, Praise & Worship, sing in the choir Congregant Member of 7:45 AM worship & praise ministry I sing on the choir, praise & worship Praise & Worship Team, Usher, Worship Leader and preaching the word on some Sundays Worship leader, choir, on occasion Sermon, Altar Guild and Praise & Worship. The keyword is organize. Choir Biblical storytelling, singing, listening to the tug of the Holy Spirit Lay Liturgist, lay speaker, congregational singing

What do you NOT like about what your church does in worship?

NEJ (0-299 Members) 228

Sometimes too dry. Too much unnecessary talking and announcements; comments by pastor and laity When the focus is on the minister/people rather than God, and when it is not planned Lack of participation of congregation Lack of flexibility with regards to written order of service. Lack of participation in praise & worship. Non-responsiveness of congregation How people walk back and forth of the Sanctuary Nothing Needs more excitement and spirit None The Holy Spirit has control in our worship experience so there is nothing that I don't like. The praise/worship teams could be better prepared. All the stuff before the scripture & sermon & altar call Does not involve youth enough Waste time Music needs to be lively at times Need more youth participation Not having all members in service during the sermon More young adults needed I enjoy the total worship. I would like to see more audio visual technology included. Cuts the worship off to do announcements No hymns, no call after sermon, loud sermons, no singing together, delays, not start on time Members coming late No choir! And a mediocre musician Boring - the music sound the same. We need more people to modernize our church. Rushing the service because pastor has a 2nd church to get to. Especially Communion Sunday. I do not like that we say "I believe in the Holy Catholic Church" in reciting the Apostle's Creed. I enjoy our worship altogether – I think my church’s worship is engaging. The Call to Christ at the end sometimes makes me less willing to go up to the altar because I just want to go for prayer but I feel it is more about new people coming to Christ. We have 2 services – I think we need 1 until we can get attendance up We have concerns – nothing that is really out of the norm. We are a young church growing in maturity. We are aware church is what every one brings to the table.

NEJ (0-299 Members) 229

I find that the proclaimed word does not always “remain” with me – try to take notes – but . . . Not enough songs for youth Too much up & down Nothing Announcements Everything It is very structured. Would like for it to be a little more flexible to allow the Holy Spirit to come in. Nothing stands out at the moment Cannot think of anything Always putting inserts in the bulletin My church is too focused on time “right” hand fellowship – praise dancing Nothing in particular Sing the same songs Length of service – Worship service is never on time, we are not organized. Humdrum worship atmosphere; sometimes too long; songs are often too slow Lengthy announcements already listed in the bulletin We don’t recite Apostles Creed anymore

2. "Good Church"

Describe a "good" church service. (Is there one that stands out in your memory?)

Music & praise is uplifting, exciting, welcoming - courteous ushers, teaching/preaching - Bible based When it is apparent that the worship service has been planned and where the presence of the living God permeates throughout. Testimonies, response to the preaching, congregation fellowship, a response later in the week Virtually all are good. Internal Sunday tends to be great. Greater variety of music and the worship was more vibrant. Highly participatory - clergy & laity; Refreshing - spiritual movement; Strengthening - equipped to go & make disciples A good church service is a service where everybody is somebody, came to church and go back home renewed, lifted up and feel good physically , spiritually, mentally, emotionally Where there has obviously been prayer beforehand that invites the Holy Spirit to have its way with us; and , we have prepared our hearts & minds to receive whatever the Holy Spirit brings. Good attendance, good collection (offering), good spirit filled preaching where people's lives are changed accepting Christ

NEJ (0-299 Members) 230

One where people are fully engaged One where the Holy Spirit is evident through congregants' active participation and response Good church services are those which transform or surpass the "people plans" and follows the leading of the Holy Spirit Preaching, choirs, prayers Impact - doing church differently. Where scriptures, music, liturgy & sermons are all of the same accord; something lively & with energy; good usually equated with preaching Preaching, singing, praying, genuine concern for others, youth involvement, activities other than Sunday For me a good "Good" service is when the anointing is in the house When all members really take part and all that is said is very clear to all When pastor, laity and youth combine in service Lots of singing & music presentations Dr. Rev. C. Allen - wonderful - preacher - teacher - very spirited person A balance of worship & praise music, teaching of the word with the presence of the Holy Spirit. Good church is a great experience with God and his people. Great opening & welcome; lots of singing, good short message; asking & standing if you want to come to the Lord; good follow-up Participation with the youth The presence of the Holy Spirit. Vibrant music and preaching/praying that is planned to invite participation from all present. A good service you can feel the anointing when the praise goes out. I love the sounds of praising & singing. I liked all the music in the service. It was all uplifting. When the music can lead your spirit that the word just tops it off, and your soul is so excited you are still repeating what the word was after service is over. A (?) church service is a church that is in sync with the Holy Spirit (inviting the Holy Spirit in). Service focused on stewardship. We had a dynamic speaker who effectively convicted us and made us understand our responsibility. Music & sermon & Bible Study Pastor and worshippers are both engaged in the service. Good worship, singing, friendship Short & to the point. Sermon the youth can understand; pertinent to youth also Good church is welcoming – from the moment you enter the door you feel good about being there. Good church is about fellowship; we hold hands, pray for one another & share our joys. The service is uplifting & the people are a community. When the message and singing go together in the spirit A good church – I would say a church that is responding to the message of Christ, the needs of one another and community. Working to bring souls in. A relevant call of the gospel will keep folks coming as long as the gospel is given out.

NEJ (0-299 Members) 231

The “Word” (the proclaimed word stuck with me). The music was vibrant! One recently (at my own church in fact). It’s all about God – topic & the message by my bishop has remained with me. Women’s Day A “good” church service is a service that is Bible based, a good relevant sermon, and an opportunity to sing, well planned thematic, relevant Good praise much through the service Delivery of the message & singing One that has the love of Christ in it Good singing; message that you don’t forget Organized, spiritual – words & music Good message, appropriate & relative for time, helps my spiritual growth When everyone participates. Dancing, singing and the Word A church service that focuses on teaching, preaching, praise and worship, and less on ritual practices Most of the services are good. Uplifting songs, prayer and sermons. Most of the services are good Good singing. Joyful songs get you ready for service – processional & ending song Good music & good preaching Music – vocal and instrumental – teaching sermon Welcoming & greeting to visitors to set the tone for a wonderful worship Where we praise God with our mouth by praying, singing, and praising God, then the spoken word & we welcome everyone to come into join us Great preaching, good singing, music. Praise & Worship with music; choir with music, and practice before worship Great praise & worship songs up-tempo so you can feel the beat, feel the music, feel the worship. Great homily, something to inspire & motivate us so that when we leave we feel like it was worth coming to church Where all can participate – lusty singing, sound proclamation of the Word UMC Mission Sundays once a year. Family & Friends Day once a year. Most Sundays during Praise & Worship

NEJ (0-299 Members) 232

Which of the following is true about good worship services? (Circle all that apply.)

a. Organized/planned worship is important 42

b. Good worship can be planned 36

c. Good worship should be planned 31

d. The spiritual disciplines are preparation for good worship 41

e. Congregational singing is vital to good worship 56

Additional Note:

All of the above are good, but the Spirit the Holy is a must. Invite God service will be dynamic.

3. Music

What kind of songs do you sing at your church and who sings them?

Mostly traditional - some contemporary Hymn, spirituals I hear Gospel in African-American churches - also Anthems/spirituals. I also listen/participate in contemporary. One church - no choir, play CD, congregational singing; songs from UMH and Songs of Zion; Songs from radio - solos Hymns (traditional), gospel, inspirational, Anthems, congregation, choir, soloist Mostly hymns (congregation) & anthems (choir) Limited repertoire of traditional/gospel The choir and congregation sing all kinds of songs. We sing "traditional" hymns, African American spirituals & gospel (traditional & contemporary), Caribbean tradition & African traditional & Contemporary Christian Choir sings new music and one offering per service. Congregation sings from the UMH and Songs of Zion Traditional hymns and contemporary praise & worship songs

NEJ (0-299 Members) 233

All types of music are utilized by praise teams, choirs and congregation All types- we have 4 groups (choirs) Anthems - senior choir; gospel, inspirational - intergenerational singers; hymns - choir & congregation Methodist Hymnal - Sr. Choir; African American Hymnal - Methodist Men; Songs of Zion - Kids for Christ Choir & Mass Choir A variety of songs, several different choirs and soloists From the Hymnal, Songs of Zion Inspirational, joyous - all choirs Traditional & modern gospel - choirs & solos Songs of Zion, AAUH, regular hymnal Praise team, choir & congregation sing praise & worship music, hymns and contemporary gospel Hymns & contemporary gospel We do not sing as a congregation - whatever the choir brings - contemporary gospels Methodist hymnal, Faith We Sing - Choir and congregation Some traditional hymns and a mix of spirituals, traditional gospel. A few of us in the congregation sing along with the Pastor & keyboard Hymnal Choirs - some semi-modern music. Congregation - hymns. Hymns & gospel songs Gospel, contemporary, hymn, praise & worship (?). Praise team, & choir, congregation. Praise & worship - Chancel, Lion. Gospel songs. Negro spirituals, hymns, contemporary songs Hymns, Negro Spiritual & Gospel Gospel Gospel, spiritual Congregation; Choir - Gospel/Chancel Contemporary & traditional African spirituals All types We sing hymns & gospel; we also sing songs of the ethnic diversity in church. We use a variety of inspirational songs. Traditional from the hymnal; Contemporary. Sung by choir, soloists & congregation. Gospel, contemp. Hymns, anthems (variety), some contemporary Hymnal singing – congregation. Choir sings also. Variety Traditional & gospel

NEJ (0-299 Members) 234

Contemporary, gospel & hymns Hymns – traditional & spirited (lively) mixture From Methodist Hymnal, African-American Hymnal, modern music Some anthems, contemporary and gospel music – Chancel Choir, Gospel Chorus as well as the Children’s Choir Hymns/anthems. The choir and congregation sing. We sing a variety of songs – gospel, hymns & some anthems Variety of songs Negro spiritual, gospels, traditional from the hymn book A variety – I’m a member of a ethnically mixed congregation Standard hymns (everyone) Spirituals, hymns Gospel – 7:45 – Praise Team. Hymns (traditional) – general members Hymns, gospel, all kinds, old time Senior choir, youth choir & congregation; prayer & praise team – sing from tapes & song books. Senior choir – sings from hymn book; men’s choir sings from sheet music; women’s choir sings from sheet music; youth choir uses tracks Hymnal songs – the congregation sings them Boring songs mostly from the hymnal. I think the songs are chosen according to what kind of Sunday or season it is such as Pentecost Sunday, etc. Traditional hymns & contemporary – all Hymns, gospel, African & Caribbean beat, contemporary

In our church, the CONGREGATION sings an average of: (Check one)

1-2 songs per service 8

3-4 songs per service 35

More than 4 songs 16

Fewer than 2 songs 1

NEJ (0-299 Members) 235

How do you feel about the way instruments are used in your church?

Under-utilized Love all kinds of instruments I wish we had more. We only have organ or keyboard & tambourine Great. Need bongos Not great because the drummers are just learning how to play the drums. Would like to add drums & stringed instruments. Our musician is excellent - would like him to have more help. Great. Would like to add other instruments and use Zion Still Sings and The Faith We Sing They are effective tools in creating a good musical atmosphere and participation by the congregation Excellent I like all instruments; they add to the service! Would like to see more drums, guitars, horns, strings, woodwind, etc., percussion Adds to the worship experience I feel we need to use all of the instruments - organ, piano, drums, etc. More lively Wonderful Love instruments. We do not use them enough. More are needed - (drums only) Wonderful - our children & youth have organized a praise band - piano, drums, violin, guitar I love it Yes, yes, yes OK They are not present except for a keyboard I love the drums when it's missing its dead. We need more musicians. Very excited about keyboard & drums in our church service - helps move the spirit Instruments enhance worship - we have keyboard, drums - we can use more instruments - guitar, saxophone, piano We use only drums minimally. We could use more instruments.

NEJ (0-299 Members) 236

Could be better Could need more Organ mostly; sometimes sax, piano, clarinet I love live music! Would love to have more, other than piano Good – we used the piano, drums, keyboard with organ sound, and we switch up the sound depending on the worship service we are having. Right now – great two churches recently combined so we have the benefit of 2 musicians – at least for now! We have none They complement the songs More is needed Indifferent – does not matter Some are good and some are not so good. You have to know when to use them. Can there be too much noise? Yes and no. All instruments available should be used to glorify God Good – we have drums – guitar and keyboard & base Very effectively Fine – we use the organ, piano and guitar Would be nice if we had more Piano, organ, drums Usually only the piano & organ are used Alright Good – adds to service Have 7:45 service; 11 AM service needs to change to improve the worship experience It is good, would be nice to add an organ & guitar. Also a new keyboard. Wonderful – it lifts up the whole congregation Nothing is used to its full potential They are not being utilized to its full potential We have a great music director who is very conscious of congregation participation Great

4. Hymnal/Worship Resources

NEJ (0-299 Members) 237

My church uses ___ hymnbooks regularly in worship

2 2 UM 1 3 2 1 2 1 2 3+ 1 25 1 3 0 3 1 4 1 2 3 - use hymnbook (1989) 20 yrs.; Faith We Sing, Songs of Zion 1 1 2 2 0 – I do not know if they are in our current hymnals. 2 Once a month depending also the season.

NEJ (0-299 Members) 238

3 100 3 1 2 100 1 1 4 2 AAH UMC 2 3 2 Circle all that apply: a. My church uses our denominational hymnal 54 b. My church uses a hymnal other than our denominational hymnal 15 c. Hymns are an important contribution to the church 42 d. Hymns teach our religious faith's theologies and doctrines 35 e. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my religious heritage 36 f. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my ethnic heritage 26 g. My church uses our hymnbook at services other than Sunday morning 30 h. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my racial heritage 31

NEJ (0-299 Members) 239

Where do you get your resources for the kind of worship experience in your church?

UM Book of Worship; on-line resources; Heritage Worship Books GBOD, internet resources Cokesbury, Internet (GBOD), prayer books Trumpet of Zion, Songs of Zion, UM Hymnal, African American Heritage Hymnal, Africana Worship Book, GBOD.org Websites - UMC - personal experiences of members & leaders - now St. Luke-Monya From the UM worship calendar BOW, UMH, African American Heritage Hymnal, Songs of Zion, Faith We Sing, Zion Still Sings, internet, sheet music, other books, Africana Worship Books (all 3), write many myself, the Bible Radio, internet (especially GBOD), commentaries, secular and religious periodicals, and books, movies Internet, Hosanna Music, Hillsong Australia GBOD, online, Cokesbury My wife gets the resources Resources used are already in house Cokesbury Bible, hymns, community Dr. Rev. C. Allen with lay speaker Cokesbury & Jesus Book & Gift Store We usually are inspired by other churches Don't know Cokesbury Cokesbury Cokesbury Cokesbury, UMC Website, Pastor, Bible GBOD web site, Bible, common lectionary Cokesbury Pastor & lay people I believe it is from a worship CD resource Seminars, Music & Worship Seminars, training/visiting other churches and learning from others. Cokesbury Cokesbury Various places

NEJ (0-299 Members) 240

Ministers, people, teaching of church leaders – one’s Christ Education Cokesbury Lectionary online Methodist hymns Cokesbury and UMI Cokesbury Cokesbury Cokesbury Unknown I learned the songs from the hymns as do others from attending church Cokesbury; use some other sources but I do not know them Cokesbury Cokesbury UMC publishers – Cokesbury Pastor, Worship Committee & Music Director

5. Worship Traditions

What are some of the worship traditions that have been passed down in your church?

Solos by a favorite singer Traditional UM worship Advent candle lighting; observance of Lent; foot washing service Homecoming Praise & worship & be done before processing of the choir/start of service Candlelight service, Lent & Pentecost, Family Fellowship Singing, praying, Sunday School Format

Describe the special days that are observed in your congregation (e.g. Ushers' or Annual Day, Women's Day, Men's Day, etc.) What resources do you use to plan for special days?

NEJ (0-299 Members) 241

Past practices, Women's & Men's Day, Ushers or Annual Day Fill a Pew Sunday; Watch Night; Candle Lightening Sunday, 7 Last Words Watch Night Usher's Day, Men's & Women's Day Tradition - but that is changing Ushers, Women's & Men's, Friends, Family and Neighbor Day, Memorial Service Day, Hymns in Worship, Trustee's Day, Laity, Maundy Thursday service, Good Friday Women's & Men's Day, Harvest, Thanksgiving, Christmas Eve, Hanging of the Greens, Ash Wednesday, Maundy Thursday, Good Friday, Resurrection Sunday, Pentecost, Trinity Sunday, Youth Sunday, Children's Day, Blessing of the Animals. Resources used include: BOW, UMH, African American Heritage Hymnal, Songs of Zion, Faith We Sing, Zion Still Sings, internet, sheet music, other books, Africana Worship Books (all 3), write many myself, the Bible Women's Day, Family and Friends Day, Candlelight Service Mother's & Father's Day, Valentines Day - internet resources UMW Day, Women's & Men's Day, Ushers, Senior Day, Student Day, Commitment Day, MLK Day Women's & Men's Day, church anniversary - use the resources provided by GBOD & various items online Women's & Men's Day, Children's Day, Sunrise Service, Homecoming Day, Veteran's observance, Maundy Thursday, Revival Church anniversary, Women's Day Women's & Men's Day Our church members - pastor - laity - other churches - local announcements Usher's day, Annual Days, Unity Days - church choirs, guest choirs, solos Heritage Day - Senior luncheon, Family & Friends, Children's Sermon Student Recognition Sunday, Women's & Men's Day We use the ideas of the members Women's & Men's Day, raise money to support church; invite other churches, dancing, flag waving Women's & Men's Day, Family Friends Day, Summer Rally, Anniversary Church Anniversary, Youth Sunday, Holy Communion - 1st Sunday Other UMC Resources I don't know Women's & Men's Day, Ushers Day, Church Anniversary Usher's Day, UMW, Choir Day, Men's Day, Willing Worker Day, Grandparents Day, Mother & Father's Day, Veterans Day Women's Day, Older Adult Recognition Day, Trustee Day, Chancel Choir Day, Genesis Choir Day, Liturgical Dance Ministry Day Women's & Men's Day, Church Anniversary Women's & Men's Day, Usher's Day

NEJ (0-299 Members) 242

Women's & Men's Day, Youth Day Women's & Men's Day, Youth Sunday Women's & Men's Day – I’m not familiar with where they pull the resources Women's & Men's Day – Worship Team We allow the membership team leader to plan these events. And all events are prayed out and the leaders of team understand that service of worship is about calling folks to respond to the call of Christ in their life. Transformation of Heart. Usher’s Day, Women’s Day, Harvest (a Caribbean tradition which we celebrate Women's & Men's Day Mother’s Day, Children’s Day – not observed in my present church Women's & Men's Day, UMW, Family The people draw from their experience and the general plan of worship Leaflets Ushers’ & Women’s Day – BOW , UMW Program Book Ushers’, Annual, Women’s & Men’s Days, plus Homecoming, Laity Sunday, Youth Sunday, Choir Anniversaries, etc. Ushers’, Women’s & Men’s Day – Bible and other resource books from Cokesbury Women's & Men's Day, Ushers, etc. Usher’s, Annual, Women’s Day Usher’s, Annual, Women’s Day Women's & Men's Day Usher’s, Women’s Day, Family & Friends, UMW Day Women’s & Men’s Day, Anniversary Day – nothing special is used Usher’s, Women’s & Men’s Day, Women in White (UMW), Homecoming/Church Anniversary Usher’s, Usher’s, Women’s & Men’s Day, Choir, Willing Workers. I do not attend in the helping of planning. Usher’s service is at 3 in the afternoon with singing and/or preaching. Women’s Day with a women’s choir, lunch, guest speaker. Men’s Day same Black History Month, Christmas, Easter Black History Month, Friends & Family Day UMW Day – regular Christmas, Easter & all of the liturgical days. Book of Worship and other resources, e.g., UMW resources Usher’s, Family & Friends Day, Usher’s, Women’s & Men’s Day, UMW Mission Sunday, Father’s Day, Golden Cross, etc. – calendar, online & Pastor, worship

NEJ (0-299 Members) 243

300+ - Membership & Worship Attendance -- NEJ

Jurisdiction North Central North Eastern 103 South Central Southeastern Western

Clergy or Laity Clergy 14 Laity 89

What is the approximately membership of your church? Under 100 100 - 199 200 - 299 300 – 499 81 500 - 749 10 750 - 999 7 1000+ 5

What is the approximate total Sunday worship attendance at your church? Under 100 3 100 – 199 11 200 - 299 61 300 - 499 14 500 - 749 4 750 - 999 1000+

NEJ (300+ Members) 244

1. Worship Practices

How do you participate in Sunday worship?

Trustee Co-Worship Leader, Preacher Pastor - sing, pray, preach, acknowledgements of birthdays & achievements Pastor, spiritual guide, Prayer Advocate In all ways - preaching, singing, worship leadership, praying, etc Pastoral prayer, preach the word, extend invitation to discipleship, Pastor moments for sharing Head worship along with Senior Pastor Preaching, worship leader I sing, clap, and read scripture I sing in the choir Worship leader at times. Preaching mainly - singing with choir Member/sometimes Worship Leader Leader Occasional liturgist or assist with communion Celebrant at communion, greet people who are visiting for the first time Minister of Music/Organist Sometimes Worship Leader, most times Preacher As Director of Music, I assigned my assistant as musician to form a team to lead congregation in praise & worship Liturgist, announcements, bulletin items Read scriptures sometimes Congregation, read scripture (sometimes) General congregant Choir member, usher Lay speaker, congregant Congregational worship, UMW Attend, read scripture, attend Sunday school, service Fellowship hour I assist with St. Paul's Youth Choir Attend early service, 9:30 Sunday school Member

NEJ (300+ Members) 245

Sing in the choir and when called Prayer, scripture reading, singing Read scripture, preach, worship sending- forth LDM- Liturgical Dance Ministry Chair of Worship Committee, Lay Speaker, member of all choirs (except Male) Director of Music, Director of 3 choirs, Certified Lay Speaker, Associate Lay Leader Singing and dancing Ushering, offering counter Sing with the Chancel Choir, prepare another choir to sing in worship Singing to and praising the Lord All activities- singing, biblical activities Sing in the Gospel and Men’s Choirs Gospel Ushering and service One love Singing, reading, etc In songs and prayers Fellowship Singing, sometimes a liturgist Sing/ liturgist Member of the congregation By singing in the choir Choir, sing from congregation seat, drama By singing in the Chancel Choir or playing organ for the communion service I’m active in 2 Ministries of service Singing hymns, scripture reading Singing the hymns, reading the scriptures, praying I generally play the organ, conduct the choir, and sing Prayer and singing Try to be a good disciple and help anyway I can I come ready to be spiritually fed and commune with God and my sisters & brothers in Christ By listening to what the Pastor has to say Sit in the congregation or choir

NEJ (300+ Members) 246

Sing, dance, pray, storytelling By being an open willing vessel for God, I’m also new member intake officer As a congregational member, sometimes supporting youth participation, sing & dance in the pew Attend on occasion and help with Sunday school Preaching, praising, praying, singing, meditating, reflecting, teaching Sing in choir Be ready to serve where God needs me, remove or try to fix any blockage of the word Do the welcome at least every 2 months, give communion, participate in congregational singing I attend and participate but do not lead Associate Pastor, preaching, visitation Mostly as spectator, I stand and sing with the Praise team, I’ve given testimony once, I give to the offering Choir nearly every Sunday, liturgist every 8 weeks All ways, Lay Leader, Lay Speaker, Worship Leader Choir, Trustee, United Methodist Women I am a counter ( sometimes) I am a visitor at St. John’s, former choir director of my United Methodist Church Attendee , occasional liturgist Read the scriptures, sing hymns, listen to the Word(sermon), and Pass the Peace (meet & greet) I participate actively, singing joyously, and worshipping whole-heartedly By listening to the Pastor and participating in stuff like this Sing, dance, pray Worshipping God and do His will Congregation member, liturgist, nurse on duty Gospel Choir, Bible study Singing, prayer, finances Biblical storytelling, dance, usher Men and Gospel Choir, Ushers I month in yr Communion Steward, member of Gospel Choir, liturgist Singing hymns and order of service, choir member Usher Communion Steward, Gospel Choir, liturgist Coming to church, praying, I sing with the Men Choir

NEJ (300+ Members) 247

I sing, clap, and read scripture Sing with Chancel Choir, Mission Statement Mostly as a congregant but I also serve as an Usher and a liturgist Sing, read lessons, involved in Sunday school Musician, liturgist

What do you NOT like about what your church does in worship?

More singing I do not like the slow pace, the lack of attention to quality and the laziness of the ushers Too many announcements; at times no flow of the Spirit Time monitoring At our 2 morning services the bulletin is our "Bible", we have a little more freedom at our evening service, but we still don't deviate much from the printed bulletin Announcements I do not like that we do not have a Praise & Worship section included in our service The time taken sometimes on our announcements Sometimes too long Too many announcements Music in early service leaves much to be desired Too lethargic; needs to be more lively, but we can't find the appropriate music Nothing Announcements in middle of service The congregation many of them do not sing, they seem to prefer to listen or watch others worship Not relevant to 2000 - to issue people have total (?) Too long a sermon - yet well prepared Short service Trying to be too rigid with the time (length) of the service I enjoy the service totally since the arrival of Dr. Smothers I enjoy everything that pastor Smothers has implemented here Like everything Nothing

NEJ (300+ Members) 248

Lack of diversity in music and age groups Announcements are in the middle of the service and not at the beginning, or even before the service During communion, hymns are sung too loudly Members tend to talk to much prior to worship, they should spend more time preparing themselves for worship I can’t find a fault N/A Too much loud talking before service and immediately after Nothing Too much talking in the Sanctuary before the service, preparation should be reverence There’s nothing to not like Not involving the youth constantly I prefer when during communion the entire congregation has the elements at the same time, we all get served bread then share together, then the wine Sometimes the atmosphere of entertainment demonstrated Nothing A lack of freedom to express yourself as the spirit of God leads Christen too many babies whose families we’ll never see again Repeating our Mission Statement during worship, should reserve for council meetings When it’s not organized Give more and fund raise less Not a thing Nothing I like it all Sometimes can be too methodical Nothing I like it all Sometimes miss hearing a big choir, we have a large Praise Team Announcements are sometimes too long, perhaps break the flow of service Too many come and go to church for self unlike Peter & John, Acts:3 Too much down time, lack of spirit Wish there were more songs from the Black spiritual tradition I love everything about Sunday worship, but I’d rather they not play music while we’re kneeling at the alter during alter call, makes it hard to concentrate Liturgical dancers use of flags Nothing I do not like

NEJ (300+ Members) 249

Why don’t we get more youth to share their talents during service Before the worship service the talking too loud, the lack of reverence I like how the service worship is conducted, it brings joy to my soul Sometimes too short Nothing The Biblical storytelling, the music choirs Prolong the 10:30 am service for more than 2 hours Freedom in music not often enough I would love more to do more Praise & Worship There isn’t anything that I don’t like about my church worship Cannot recall at this time Running late, too long sometime Actual I like the worship service, we are trying to tighten up how we include the children/young adults in our service because Sunday school session overlaps with worship service I would have said “boring Pastor” but since we have Pastor Perrin we have life into the church If you say the Praise out loud, everyone is looking at you There is never enough room in the Sanctuary I am really not “big” on the screen being in front of the stained glass window, I have always enjoyed meditating as I look at the glow from the window I do not like the fact that there are people in the congregation that do not speak to others Nothing Too many unfamiliar hymns, service geared more towards older members, little interest in youth

2. "Good Church"

Describe a "good" church service. (Is there one that stands out in your memory?)

A good church service is one where the participants when leaving the service remark "We have been with Jesus." Great worship, outstanding preaching, animated altar call, transformed lives and commitment to transform the world Singing, preaching, praise dancers worked together - complimentary & complementary movement Altar call, stewardship moment (sharing), vibrant singing, authentic preaching A great blend of various music, powerful preaching, & transformative prayer, testimony & fellowship with no wasted time A blending of liturgy, music, preaching

NEJ (300+ Members) 250

A good church service gathers people from where they are in the "world" and guides them as a body through a process that leads to a transformative encounter with God A service where the people come prepared & are participating in worship & little bit of the Holy Ghost One that is live, organized and has good music A good church service is one in which everyone is so "in-tuned" that they do not want to leave with the last "Amen" - properly planned, flows, everyone participates lustily Full of a sense of the presence & power of God Where music, prayers, scripture & sermon follow one theme Clear order, participation by members Well planned music, preaching & other elements Excellent preaching, good participation/congregational singing/responses to preached word, where we know the spirit is present in our midst One where everyone is of one accord Message challenges me to take action - go deeper, the music inspires and provokes emotion Tithing - good attendance - various activities for youth, young adults, seniors & children Holy Spirit is moving through the congregation, good gospel (old school), good preaching using the Bible as their guide and applying to today & how I can do something about it A good church service gives me food for thought throughout the week Good message - lesson Very good friendly church Good singing, praising and a good sermon Scripture, litany, prayers, congregational singing, introit, announcements, passing of The Peace, The Message, altar call, Communion benediction, invitation to Christian Discipleship Sermon directly from the scripture - developed from beginning to end; good spiritual music The music is uplifting, the congregation is friendly & participates The service is thorough but not lengthy Sermon is clear, concise, relevant and delivered with conviction Where the Spirit of God is present in the church in the word and song Participation of all Spirit-filled and Spirit led Worship is free with lively choir songs, preaching is Word based taught with faith! Sermons that stretch you and challenge your faith Integration of all ages in the worship experience

NEJ (300+ Members) 251

Our Unity Services (both services worship at one time) are usually exceptional worship experiences A good service is one where the Holy Spirit is welcomed, not a lot of extra talking is done Good preaching, teaching, praying, and singing All services so far are good Where there is full participation by its members and not just the elected few Change the liturgists frequently and in the reading of the lessons One where the Pastor is totally into the congregation, also every member displays the state of singing and reference to the Lord Participating , enjoy Good Friday services More sermon relevant to day to day situation, teach family value, relate good and evil in the world-how it effects us Easter Sunday One love A “good” church service includes great music and many events that take the place of our sermon One in which you feel joyful and satisfied, comfortable in your relationship with God and your fellow man A good church service for me should included a lot of praising songs, people should be free to express themselves A defined set of activities each Sunday, an informal fellowship after the service Hearty singing of popular well loved hymns, great music and message filled sermon All good Good sermon, good music, 95% congregation participation The 10:30 service on the 1st of the month, when all can participate Good Friday Services, the sermon was rewarding the entire church in a humble manner, everyone felt so peaceful Organized planned worship Easter Sunday services, a good service is when the congregation participates, rejoicing One that praises God through His Son Jesus Christ One that edifies the church, and one that reaches out, embraces and ministers to the seekers and non- believers All service every Sunday is good for me Mostly Good Fridays – Easter A “good” church service engages the congregation on all levels, we become a “part” of the hymns, the liturgy and the service I think a good church service is singing, dancing, worshipping God with sermons, scripture readings, and youth talents A good teaching sermon Involves lots of music, dance, storytelling, choral speaking, -praise * worship Every Sunday is a good service, but the very best was when we had a lady pastor from South Carolina; I have never been so moved The first visit to the church honoring the Elders, technology used via a short film produced by the men in the church about W.H.O.L.E. principles, spirit led praise & worship, fun, humor

NEJ (300+ Members) 252

Good music, relevant message That I get there before service time is important and contributes to a good experience I am a “sermon” person, so when I hear a good sermon- that for me could be encouraging, admonishing, or an accountability and a time of praise & worship When hard eggshells are broken, enabling the weal chicks easy access to new life Thanks too Pastor Joe Daniels for his leadership in leading by example A good church service is where you have good singing and a meaningful sermon, you have participation from the congregants and Pastor, it’s the exchange Great music ( choral & instrumental) strong, insightful, inspirational preaching, smooth flow, diverse experiences, surprises A good church service is one where the clergy and lay have an experience that’s transformative, where thinking and goals change by what is said in their daily lives Traditional contemporary praise music, great preaching, ambulatory offering, Holy Communion(non-liturgical) every Sunday, casual/community atmosphere, liturgical dance When there is a service which is fully integrated with scripture, music, and sermon; there is continuity with children sermon The service that we had last week was one that I felt warmly , charged to do more in social justice A great blend of preaching and music The Word, choir More focus on Praise & worship, music that is uplifting and spiritual, whether sung by choir or congregation Welcoming celebration of community, thought provoking sermon based on the word- we have had many A good service to me is the singing of the hymns/praying, listening to the word, fellowshipping with the congregation Leaving church feeling filled with the Spirit Sometimes I do feel the presence of the Holy Ghost during service, the solemnity, the hymns/gospel songs and the prayers Roy Allen forgetting his lines When the singing gives me goose bumps, and the dancing makes me cry Sincere prayer, showing unconditional love to all personality young and old, songs that lift the soul Preaching that touches our life and enlightens our understanding, we need to sing and clap more Don’t hesitate to Praise the Lord when we are touched, praise God freely A church that preaching the good news Great songs/hymns, inspiring sermon, “sweet” Spirit in the “space” 4th Sundays A lot of singing and dance, there has been several including today(11/22) Good starting time and ending, good message, story relevant to our situation in this church and community Good story, start well-good middle information and excellent ending

NEJ (300+ Members) 253

A good church service is when I leave feeling uplifted and blessed, most Sundays I feel blessed to be here Is an organized planned service and when everyone is fulfilled with the Spirit St. John’s UMC worshipping, singing praise worship, occasional testimony I love Resurrection Sunday worship When I feel the Spirit moving that of music, reverence and overpowering message from the sermon Communion Service One that fills our need, speaks to our heart, fills the church with fire Visitation from the Holy Spirit A good church is one that reaches the people in Spirit and wherever they are One where there is active participation, Harvest Sunday A “good” church service is one where people are joyous in their praise and where the scriptures are related to our lives Full congregational participation in the singing ministry and sermons of self-examination, many stand out Good music, choir singing, Bible storytelling and lively sermon Participation in praying, singing, communion, and chorus Working in church organizations There are outstanding sermons, especially those that connect our Methodist religion to present events, such as the election of President Obama

Which of the following is true about good worship services? (Circle all that apply.) a. Organized/planned worship is important 72 b. Good worship can be planned 53 c. Good worship should be planned 54 d. The spiritual disciplines are preparation for good worship 69 e. Congregational singing is vital to good worship 87

NEJ (300+ Members) 254

3. Music

What kind of songs do you sing at your church and who sings them?

My wife sings on Sunday Hymns, praise music, spirituals, scripture songs, choruses, old time gospel, contemporary songs, and traditional songs Contemporary & traditional gospel; spirituals; hymns from UM Hymnal; other sacred music from other hymnal (African American Hymnal) Mixed congregation (black, white, Philippine) - gospel, spirituals, hymns & folk music Traditional - all types; Contemporary - choir & congregation sings; International Choir - Anthems, gospels & spirituals; Congregational hymns - UM Hymnal Generally we sing as congregation songs from the UM, sometimes we use songs from TFWS Songs of Zion, Hymnal Book, Praise Team Gospel, contemporary, some standards Anthems, hymns, gospels Um Hymnal that are adapted to the style of the African American style Variety; Anthems, gospel, jazz, hip/hop, contemporary We have 6 choirs that cover all genres of Christian music over the course of a month, also within every service there is congregational singing as well Hymns from UM Hymnal, Songs of Zion I & II, African American Heritage Hymnal an sheet music, these songs are sung by both choirs and congregation, sometimes together, sometimes separate When I preach I usually include a hymn from the African American Heritage Hymnal, the choir sings 1-2 songs each Sunday Hymns, traditional songs, contemporary songs A variety of songs - some by the choir(s); some by choir & congregation. (Traditional, modern, choruses) All genres - choir & congregation - also soloists All genres Hymnals of the church, spirituals, gospel music & meaningful praise music Traditional & come contemporary (everyone including the choir) Hymns, spirituals, gospel, contemporary, Anthems Contemporary praise songs, traditional African-American hymns The congregation sings hymns, spirituals & gospel music, we have 5 choirs & the music ranges from classical to contemporary UMC Hymnal - traditional; some gospel Gospel & hymns

NEJ (300+ Members) 255

Very few contemporary songs, classic gospel songs We have many choirs & sing contemporary, old hymns, & new generation music. Many instruments are used like drums, organ, piano, guitar, cymbals, etc. Variety - usually the choir Everyone sings Gospel Choir- Chancel Choir, One Voice in Praise, Men’s Choir, Wesley Choir The song, The Word Traditional, contemporary, gospel Mixed genre, UMH, Songs of Zion – Congregation; traditional, hymns, contemporary – Choirs and Bell Choir Choir - spirituals, older hymns Tradition & contemporary gospel, traditional hymns Classical- Chancel Choir, gospel and traditional Methodist hymns especially Charles and John Wesley Choirs, congregation; hymns, spirituals fro Songs of Zion Not much lively songs, we need lively songs to motivate us all, especially the youth Songs from the Hymnal and Praises; the congregation and choir Some of the songs the congregation sing are; He’s An On time God, our songs re from the Hymnal Methodist Hymnal and Songs of Zion, they are sung by choir and congregation We sing songs from the UM Hymnal, sometimes other contemporary gospel songs Methodist, Christian, African American hymns; everyone sings, this should continue Songs of Zion, traditional hymns Regular songs from Hymnals, everyone in church All types Gospel, spiritual music Anthems, classical and contemporary; Hymnal, Songs of Zion, and the additional BOH Praise songs mostly, Praise Team(small choir), sings but words are projected on screen and congregation may sing along Hymns, Anthems; our 40 -50 of the Chancel choir Contemporary praise songs- Praise team and congregation(optional) Some traditional hymns and gospel songs Soloists/duets, the choir sings and the Pastor does on occasion, congregation joins in, we sing contemporary gospel, traditional songs Nothing Between, Praise Is What I Do, His Eye is on the Sparrow, I Won’t Complain, Over My Head, Hear Music in the Air Father I Stretch My Hands To Thee, Praise Is What I Do Inspirational songs of praise, all sing along with the choir

NEJ (300+ Members) 256

Traditional hymns, the choir Hymns, gospel, choir and congregation, the words are put on a screen so that we can all participate The choir leads and everyone participates The choir, the Praise Team, primarily contemporary music songs, a cappella, instrument All kinds, pop, gospel, jazz, r & b Hymns, gospel, praise songs, spirituals We sing songs that feed us positive messages, the church choirs and congregation sings them Praise songs, gospels; sung by the choirs All songs- traditional hymns, Wesley hymns, Songs of Zion, sung by the choirs(Chancel, Gospel, Men’s Chorus, One Voice in Praise, Wesley, Youth) Traditional and gospel We all sing to the Glory of God We sing a variety of hymns, Anthems, spirituals, and gospel music Praise songs, gospel, inspirational sung by choir and special groups Congregational hymns- variety, gospel music- Gospel Choir, Anthems- Chancel Choir, Songs of Zion- congregation Songs from the United Methodist Hymnal and Songs of Zion Hymns from the UM Hymnal and also the Songs of Zion, sung by all Gospel, hymns, praise, all the choirs Spiritual – congregation, choir Anthems, hymns, traditional gospel, contemporary gospel, praise & worship The choirs, hymnal songs From church Hymnal and Songs of Solomon, the church and all members of congregation Hymns, gospel songs UMC hymns, everyone Hymns from the UMC Hymnal and Songs of Zion, the congregation Hymns and spiritual songs Relevant uplifting songs that give inspiration, that talks to your soul Hymns – congregation, Anthems – Chancel Choir, gospel – Gospel Choir, all other songs – Men’s Choir, Wesley Choir, Youth Choir, and One Voice in Praise UM songs, Songs of Zion, gospel Songs are sung from the UMC Hymnal by the choir/ congregation Musical presents are also offered by the various choirs – Chancel, Youth/Children’s, Gospel, One Voice in Praise Gospel

NEJ (300+ Members) 257

Lord’s Prepare Me, My Tribute, My Home is Built I particularly enjoy and am uplifted by the gospel songs, hymns are good too! Clearly the Director does research! Hymns from the United Methodist Hymnal, the choir and congregation Hymns, Negro Spirituals, gospel songs by the choir and congregation Music Ministry is very vital part of worship Anthems – Chancel Choir, gospel – Gospel Choir/ Men’s Choir From the Hymnal, the congregation and choirs Traditional hymns- everyone and the choir Religious/ classical Anthems, spirituals, and gospels; by the Chancel Choir, Gospel Choir, Men’s Choir, and Youth/Children’s Gospel, upbeat, on special occasions songs that have to do with that occasion; like Christmas Songs from the United Methodist Hymnal, songs from a small book of popular standards

In our church, the CONGREGATION sings an average of: (Check one)

1-2 songs per service 12

3-4 songs per service 54

More than 4 songs 29

Fewer than 2 songs 0

How do you feel about the way instruments are used in your church?

More can be used Very good They add to the music Wonderful They are used well We need to expand and diversify the instruments Very good utilization of drums, guitar, piano & organ & voices

NEJ (300+ Members) 258

Love it - want to add more More needed I feel they are necessary for good worship I feel they can use drums and more instruments We have the organ & piano regularly, but we need a more varied assortment of instruments Could be used where available - all kinds of instruments Should be used appropriately and may include many Could use more different kinds of instruments OK I would have liked to see more, i.e., Hammond organ, guitars We have an instrumental ensemble that plays the entire service OK - need more, basically organ and drummer Good Great accompaniment I enjoy the way instruments are used Should be more softly I love the music program, we have the best! Good - excellent addition to the service I am glad we are beginning to use more instruments We used to just have the organ and piano, now we also have drums, keyboard, sometimes bass & guitar Fine with me Love the use of instruments to enhance singing, organ, piano, drums, and others Very well, but there’s too much of the Dance Ministry, we need to worship God more and entertain less It’s getting better, I feel there could be more instruments in the church, according to the scripture we should use all kinds of instruments to praise God Effectively I feel as though the instruments uplift our souls Our church doesn’t have many instruments, would love to see and hear more Okay Good Wonderful Instruments are used appropriately- organ, piano, and youth musical talent Extremely blessed as a church, we are blessed to have many qualified persons who can play instruments of music

NEJ (300+ Members) 259

Need to incorporate more musicians to play the piano on a regular basis as well as more musical instruments to attract the young people Too feel good, wonderful good I feel all instruments were created by God for His Glory and Praise, they were not made for the world We use them some Sundays but want to expand to every Sunday Instruments should be more universally equipped to get smooth sound Good, I was a professional musician for 27 years Too loud Approve, it adds to the service Great, love them! Very well, to the Glory of God, variety of instruments are utilized especially in Handel Messiah Concerts Great! We have the Acts2 Band with keyboard, drums, congas, trumpets, sax, and guitars; excellent band although sometimes too loud over singers, has improved recently The cost of paying professional instrumentalists is almost prohibitive, we have this type at least 3 times a year Wonderful we have a full band and a great one I enjoy the variety- Hammond pipe organ, and drums, sometimes the combination of piano/organ All instruments are good, can become expensive on a low budget I like it Use of instruments are a vital contribution to the worship service, I believe that and so instruments are used in a spirit of worship Very, very good Love it! Contemporary(soul, old school, go/ go), the drums and trumpet Good Musical instruments are not sufficiently utilized in our church – organs I feel that we use them well and wisely Satisfied with organ and piano The instruments are used to heighten our worship Organ and piano are fine I feel all the instruments are used to the Glory of God We need drums and other instruments(bass guitar, lead guitar) for our uplifting selections and an orchestra(now being planned) to enhance the majesty of the service We need more No problem Excited and I am looking forward to the day that we have a full band Quite appropriate

NEJ (300+ Members) 260

Instruments need more space and should be placed differently with a shield for the drums Keyboards, drums, violins, organ, and flutes are used I wish there were drums and other instruments To enhance worship: very uplifting for the singing ministry of the church I believe that our church is in the process of getting instruments for use in the service We could use drums more often and… I love them all I enjoy instruments! It adds to the making of singing! Effectively! We use tambourines, drums, and piano youth Good Very good Our Minister is extremely musical, the Music Ministry is expanding We routinely use the piano, organ and sometimes a guest orchestra We are trying to form a band Very good Excellent tool when used right, does enhance quality of service, good inspiration Good Main instruments used are the piano, organ, and keyboards, so far these are acceptable Currently the church is in process of organizing a small band I feel that we could use more instruments Good, we utilize organ, piano, and at times show presentational elements It is a good thing Very well I love the way the instruments are used

4. Hymnal/Worship Resources

My church uses hymnbooks regularly in worship

NONE- 2

ONE- 40

NEJ (300+ Members) 261

TWO- 26

THREE- 1

4 OR MORE- 0

ADDITIONAL COMMENTS:

Also technology, Power point has song lyrics displayed during service We have enough books for everyone, also have large print Rarely, which I sometimes regret

Circle all that apply:

a. My church uses our denominational hymnal 83

b. My church uses a hymnal other than our denominational hymnal 33

c. Hymns are an important contribution to the church 73

d. Hymns teach our religious faith's theologies and doctrines 62

e. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my religious heritage 63

f. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my ethnic heritage 39

g. My church uses our hymnbook at services other than Sunday morning 56

h. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my racial heritage 35

NEJ (300+ Members) 262

Where do you get your resources for the kind of worship experience in your church?

The internet, resources from worship seminars, worship manuals and UM Resources Africana Worship Book, Methodist BOW Music Director and Cokesbury Easy Worship, African American Hymnal, gospel, contemporary BOW, Africana (GBOD), Homiletics (online) gbodworship.com; African American Heritage Hymnal; wingclips.com - evening worship BOW, lectionary From BOW, GBOD website, sermons.com We use UMH, TFWS, African American Heritage, Songs of Zion Variety Many & varied sources Internet, BOW, from other denominations BOW, GBOD web site BOW primarily Cokesbury Cokesbury Cokesbury From the pews I'm not sure Most from the denomination resources, the balance from the ethnic origins Television Worship planner, internet GBOD, UMC.org Other churches, websites Cokesbury Training, other churches From the Lord my God From the worshipping community, other religious bodies/denominations, music libraries From church resources, internet, and various bookstores around town Regular printed bulletins, announcements From our parents

NEJ (300+ Members) 263

We get our resources from God Donations Pastor and congregation input From all members and guest Pastors Cokesbury Pastor and Worship Committee From the teachings of John and Charles Wesley, the founders of Methodism My Ministers and other leaders within the church Worship Committee and the Pastor Congregation Internet, library Not sure- the Worship Committee and the Pastor undertake this ministry Bible I get them from the songs we sing and sermons Unsure Radio, television, contemporary and historical knowledge of these traditions From life Provided by the church/worship committee- material that is relevant for congregation which is multi-cultural Bible, testimonies of myself and others Book of worship, Pastor uses a variety of resources Video projection Cokesbury, many of the music company, several of our members are composers Don’t know UMC worship resources, African American worship service resources Cokesbury I have been a member of the UMC since 11962, have attended regularly Christian bookstores, internet Methodist Hymnal Bible Lectionary Friends/ family, religious bookstore Cokesbury Listening to the sermon Online and our Parrish Resource Center

NEJ (300+ Members) 264

Online, library, Parrish Resource Center Hymnal and the Bible are provided in the pews Methodist Publishing House, USA & UK, etc The church supplies From a newspaper, news shows, local papers, etc

5. Worship Traditions

What are some of the worship traditions that have been passed down in your church?

Singing & praying bands African/American/Afro-Caribbean Wesleyan (Evangelical); Pentecostal, traditional UMC Litany, Joys & Concerns, Call to Worship, Prayer Candlelight services Strong congregational singing Lenten is traditionally the high season for us Alter Call Communion, but done differently, music, preaching, invitation… Prelude, Doxology of praise, Gloria Patria, sermonic hymn, Apostles Creed, Lord’s Prayer Waving Palms on Palm Sunday Communion Divinity Dancers, singing groups(women, men, and small singing groups)

Describe the special days that are observed in your congregation (e.g. Ushers' or Annual Day, Women's Day, Men's Day, etc.) What resources do you use to plan for special days?

Youth Day , Church Anniversary Women’s Day, Men’s Day, African American resources Annual Day, Men’s Day, Women’s Day, Laity Sunday Christmas, Easter, Thanksgiving, Men’s-Women’s Day, International Women’s Day, Women’s Prayer Breakfast, everybody’s Birthday Dinner, Men’s day, Guest Pastor Dinner,

NEJ (300+ Members) 265

Black History Month-special guest and children’s presentation Family & Friends Day- evening service, guest churches Laity Sunday- Lay person giving sermon Annual Day International Days, Harvest Sunday, Communion Sunday Friends & Family Day, Harvest Sunday, Pastor’s Appreciation Day, International Sunday, Watch Night UMM Day, Women in White, UMW Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Angel tree, Thanksgiving, Outreach Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Women in White, Homecoming, Laity Sunday, Youth Sunday Friends & Family Day, Women's Day, Trustees Day, Ushers' or Annual Day, Women's Day, Men's Day, Youth Day Women's & Men's Day, Male Chorus Anniversary Involvement of different ministries in the church usually enhances the worship experience International Sunday, harvest Sunday, Communion every Sunday, Men’s Day, Women’s Day, Homecoming, Pastor Appreciation, Martin Luther King Day Youth Sunday, seasonal Sundays Thanksgiving, Harvest, Christmas, Easter Public relations and technical resources International Sunday, Harvest Sunday African Heritage, Christmas Eve Services, Resurrection Sunday Men’s Day, Women’s Day Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Disciple/Grad Day, Advent services and others too numerous to mention Annual Day, Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Senior Day, United Methodist Day and more Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Prayer & Meditation, practice We do not have special days at my church Usher's Anniversary, Men's & Women's Day, Homecoming/Church, Watch Night Service, Revivals Bible Sunday for the 4th grade, Nurses Recognition Day The leaders of the committees and committee members Women's & Men's Day, Mother's & Father's Day, MLK, Methodist Heritage & all days of the Xu (?) year Women’s Day, Men’s Day and Youth Sunday UMW Advent Service, Women’s Day Women's & Men's Day, special choir concert, organ recitals, certain national holidays, etc Alder’s Gate Sunday, Men’s Day and other days from the seasons and the church calendar We have to consult with other denominations that provide resources for these days

NEJ (300+ Members) 266

Usher's Annual Day, Unity Day, Easter Sunrise, Maundy Thursday Seder Service, Christmas Eve, Family & Friends, etc Men’s Day, Women’s Day, Easter Sunday, Homecoming, Usher’s Anniversary Easter services, Advent, Pentecost, Christmas, Thanksgiving, Youth Sunday; use of human resources, divinity dances Bible Storytelling by adults and youth Special music is selected for all high Holy Days, i.e., Easter. The directors of the Women's/Men's Day groups collaborate to enhance the music of the church. Usher's Women's & Men's, Veterans, Youth & Children, Student Recognition, UMW Recognition, Laity Sunday - resources vary Usher's Day, UMW Day, Church Women's Day, Memorial Day, Anniversary, Maundy Thursday Gospel concerts, bus rides, fish fry Prayer at the altar, gospel singing, gospel choirs Event is incorporated with regular morning worship service with special attention to give appreciation Usher's Day, Women's & Men's Day, Homecoming, Choir anniversaries Women's Day Women's & Men's Day All listed above I’m new to the church Anniversaries, Women’s and Men’s Day, Women in white Day, Easter Programs, Christmas Programs All of the above Easter, All Saints Day, Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Christmas, World Communion, Harvest, New Years Day Mother’s Day, Women’s Day, Harvest, Men’s Day, Consecration Sunday; guest speakers, Pastor/congregation, flowers/food, Parrish Resource Center Women’s Day, Men’s Day, nurses/Sunday school teachers/Bible Sunday/ Resurrection Sunday/ Children’s Christmas Pageant Women’s Day, Men’s Day, World Communion Day, MLK Day, laity Sunday, Pentecost Youth Day, Women’s Missionary Day, Men’s Sunday UMW Candlelight service, gifts are brought for UMW home I love to see the congregation wearing red, a sea of red for Pentecost Sunday All notable observed days are including Mother’s, father’s, Youth Sunday activities, ethnic activities, community outreach, homeless Men’s Day- the men group of the church sponsor the service, Women’s day- the women group of the church sponsor the service Women’s Day, men’s Day, Harvest, Easter, Christmas, Senior’s Day, Children’s/Youth Sunday Women’s Day, Women in White, Men’s Day, World Communion Men’s, Women’s and Youth Days The church supplies all the resources for special days

NEJ (300+ Members) 267

Above mentioned special days and other noted days in the Christian year have been a source of much Christian fellowship for members, visitors and friends The Good Friday experience has been very powerful with the cluster of UMC Parrish Resource, Sunday school Youth Sunday, UM Men’s Day, UM Women’s Day, Martin Luther King’s Day Some traditional and ethnic observances UMM or UMW usual y plan these events, Women’s Day, Kwanza, African American Heritage Month 8 A-10 A worship, Easter, Thanksgiving, Christmas, New Year ‘s Eve, Sunday school, Nurse Day Church calendar, different organizations in the church men. Women, and children Not too keen on this subject All of the above days are followed in worship, the Hymnal is used as well as other substantial information Christmas, Good Friday, Advent, Easter, Men’s and Women’s Day, church’s Hymnal and Bible Women’s Day, Harvest Thanksgiving, World Communion Sunday, Laity Sunday, Lenten Services, Pentecostal World Communion, New Year’s Eve, Christmas, Easter, Ash Wednesday, Good Friday, Communion; resources used could be obtained from PRC, and scriptures Watch Night, Usher’s Anniversary, Church Anniversary, Women’s and Men’s Day; UMC Hymnal, African American Heritage Hymnal, SOZ, ZSS

ADDITIONAL COMMENTS:

I am an old fashion Methodist and I enjoy the hymns of Charles Wesley and other writers of those ancient hymns You’re welcome – Alisha

NEJ (300+ Members) 268

0 to 299 - Membership & Worship Attendance -- SCJ

Jurisdiction North Central North Eastern South Central 26 Southeastern Western

Clergy or Laity Clergy 3 Laity 23

What is the approximately membership of your church? Under 100 18 100 - 199 3 200 - 299 4 300 - 499 500 - 749 750 - 999 1000+

What is the approximate total Sunday worship attendance at your church? Under 100 21 100 - 199 5 200 - 299 300 - 499 500 - 749 750 - 999 1000+

SCJ (0-299 Members) 269

1. Worship Practices

How do you participate in Sunday worship?

I am the Pastor so I do children sermon & preach. Preach Preach the word. I participate in Sunday worship thru song, praise, stewardship I’m the liturgist, all around assistant, lay pastor’s wife Singing & altar prayer, singing or acknowledging birthdays, anniversaries, prayer lists & concerns Worship leader (Music Director) Provide scripture, prayer – sing in the choir. Sunday school teacher – work with youth – ushers I’m an usher Read the scripture Sing in choir, read announcements, produce all written programs, all IT, and help with food pantry Getting involved in praising & worshipping God; letting the Holy Spirit come in Musical ministry; Sunday program I’m in the choir – run the audio I sing in the choir Plan, design bulletin/PowerPoint Singing & praising with the congregation Communion steward; announcements Call to Worship response, singing in the choir, and serve as alternate pianist/organist Lay leader, worship committee, choir – assist with planning worship & music, lay speaker – assist with developing PowerPoint presentations Sing, pray with the congregation Accompanist for Senior Choir Sing in choir, speak, care of AV equipment Communion Steward Communion Steward

SCJ (0-299 Members) 270

What do you NOT like about what your church does in worship?

Fellowship time – they only go to themselves & forget about visitors – hard to pull them back together. Nothing I don’t like when people don’t get into the worship spirit. Small young adult program We’re a small church – hardly any dislikes Communion ritual not used from UM Hymnal Not starting on time Not starting on time When everyone does not worship Not enough help from other members Outdated hymns Not reaching out to children and youth The music could be more upbeat & up to date We have praise and worship time and the word, we greet each other Praise and worship songs (2) are sometimes too lengthy I like our forms of worship – contemporary & traditional Reminder of church announcements Too much talking Not lively Not enough reminders about coming events Not enough reminders about coming events When everyone doesn't want to support yet heavily criticizes

2. "Good Church"

Describe a "good" church service. (Is there one that stands out in your memory?)

All on one accord – choir, ushers, liturgist, pastor and members worshipping together. St. Luke “Community” Dallas; Christ UMC When everything blend in worship Inspiring music, message

SCJ (0-299 Members) 271

A Palm Sunday service where we baptized 12 plus children and babies, with special music and a large crowd – great day Inspirational preaching, good singing; with congregation participating; altar prayer and praises Music that moves everyone to really praise God! When everyone is into God’s word and witnesses to it! When the song, scripture ties right into the sermon When everyone gets involved. A service where the Spirit prevails Planned, organized, etc. The Holy Spirit is present One with a lot of praising – with purpose and moves smoothly When it flows good within the spirit Easter Sunday 2010 – Spirit was alive Good upbeat music that gets me in the spirit. A good sermon that touches on everyday life. Good church is when Rev. Scott brought his family church from Tulsa & Rev. Jackson also brought his church to help us celebrate one of our When the “holy spirit” is present and evident, that’s a “good” church service. On this past Easter (4-4-10) we experienced a memorable service that involved youth participation, an “excellent” message, appropriate music, and congregation response. A service that has a mixture of music (contemporary & traditional; relevant messages Good singing – Village Church as guest Presentation of youth program by lay leader Very lively When our kids took over & speaker Lloyd spoke. When we had a guest church with us. The Village Church participated. When the youths sing. Church with an outstanding/outgoing pastor & congregation. Teaches the Bible with scholarship (explaining what other scholars have to say about the scripts, explaining symbols & other means) ties scripture and worship into everyday life. Teaches tradition yet open to changes.

Which of the following is true about good worship services? (Circle all that apply.) a. Organized/planned worship is important 22 b. Good worship can be planned 17

SCJ (0-299 Members) 272

c. Good worship should be planned 18

d. The spiritual disciplines are preparation for good worship 20

e. Congregational singing is vital to good worship 20

3. Music

What kind of songs do you sing at your church and who sings them?

Hymns, praise songs, spirituals – all who will open their mouths to sing Gospel, hymns, choir congregation, choir Gospel & contemporary Inspiring songs – the body as well as the choir Mostly gospel (old fashioned) and familiar hymns from Hymnal Gospel, spiritual & praise song – choir or soloist Praise & worship – everyone! (Choir/Director); Altar Call – Everyone (Choir/Director); Good meaningful/purpose songs, hymns, selections, etc.) Contemporary – choir/congregation; Gospel – choir; Children & youth choir Gospel Hymns & Gospels – choir & congregation Mixture old & new – choir (mostly) Contemporary Gospel – the choir and congregation Choir, congregation – hymns, Gospel, contemporary Hymns – Choir Open Gospel, hymns, contemporary Hymns (congregation & choir); contemporary, gospel (choirs) We have 3 choirs – men’s chorus, adult & children’s choirs. We sing contemporary & traditional – from UM Hymnal, Songs of Zion, Zion Still Sings, Faith We Sing & other resources Hymnal, spiritual, contemporary Hymns – Anthems – Spirituals – Choir/Congregation. Contemporary selections – Current CD artists.

SCJ (0-299 Members) 273

Upbeat and lively Hymns, spirituals, anthems, contemporary Hymns – Spirituals – Anthems - Contemporary New and traditional - all members participate.

In our church, the CONGREGATION sings an average of: (Check one)

1-2 songs per service 3

3-4 songs per service 14

More than 4 songs 7

Fewer than 2 songs 0

How do you feel about the way instruments are used in your church?

The more the merry – the band (drums, saxophones, organ, piano, violin) – instrumental music – important We only have one Good can be more I feel that instruments enhance the music which in turn enhances the worship – end result strengthening your connection Good! I feel that is good – and needed. I would like to see more used. I approve of the way they are used. Okay They are utilized to the best of the musician’s abilities We could use more Not enough variety Enjoy the instruments I like everything that we have at this time; need a piano player

SCJ (0-299 Members) 274

Piano, organ, and drums serve as a positive reinforcement (when not overpowering) I would like to occasionally add drummer, violinist, guitar. We use the piano & organ. Good Only piano and organ are used Brings life and passion to overall service.

4. Hymnal/Worship Resources

My church uses ___ hymnbooks regularly in worship

40 1-2 2 2 40 2 UMH 3 UM – Songs of Zion, Zion Still Sings 3 3 3

Circle all that apply:

a. My church uses our denominational hymnal 24

b. My church uses a hymnal other than our denominational hymnal 7

c. Hymns are an important contribution to the church 19

SCJ (0-299 Members) 275

d. Hymns teach our religious faith's theologies and doctrines 11 e. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my religious heritage 17 f. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my ethnic heritage 13 g. My church uses our hymnbook at services other than Sunday morning 14 h. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my racial heritage 14

Where do you get your resources for the kind of worship experience in your church?

Cokesbury Worship.com, GBOD.org Book of Worship; internet Africana Worship Cokesbury, other music stores, online sources Our ministry of music Going to other churches UM Book of Worship, PowerPoint Methodist offerings Africana Book of Songs & Worship – Rev. Gordon’s book, internet & pastor Cokesbury or other Christian bookstores UMC web site, Mardels Mardels Book Store Pastor, UM Program Calendar, and Worship Ministry Committee Cokesbury, internet, other churches, Book of Worship, Hymnal UM Book of Worship UM Book of Worship – PowerPoint presentations Book of Worship Book of Worship (UM); PowerPoint Other churches, the community, members

SCJ (0-299 Members) 276

5. Worship Traditions

What are some of the worship traditions that have been passed down in your church?

Praise & worship Praise service before preaching Pass the Peace, Celebration Days, i.e., Women’s Day, Men’s Day, etc. Altar Call, Passing the Peace, The Apostles Creed-Traditional Version Congregational singing, altar call Altar Call – Affirmation of Faith – Invocation – Passing the Peace – Offertory Sentence Altar Call Altar call, Passing the Peace, Affirmation of Faith, Invocation, Offertory sentence Men's & Women's Day, Bible Camp, lunch programs, breakfast on Sunday, Church garden, scholarship program

Describe the special days that are observed in your congregation (e.g. Ushers' or Annual Day, Women's Day, Men's Day, etc.) What resources do you use to plan for special days?

All of the above. Africana books, worship planner. Women’s Day. Book of Worship Church Anniversary, Men & Women’s Day, UM Women, Youth day/Sunday Church Anniversary – special service & reception. UMW Sunday, Mother & Father’s Day – meal after service prepared by men for mother’s day and women prepare the meal for father’s day. UMW Day, Student Day, World Communion Day, Men’s Day, deaf ministry, Mother’s Day (Mom/Muffins), Father’s Day breakfast We observe all of the above – Mother’s Day – Muffin for Moms; Father’s Day – Donut for Dads Women’s & Youth Day Church Anniversary, Women’s Day, religious holidays UMW – Mission – Anniversary The Holy Spirit, hymn books, resources from Cokesbury or other Christian bookstores UMW Day, Anniversary Reach out and touch (meet and greet) All the above We celebrate our Church Anniversary

SCJ (0-299 Members) 277

Church Anniversary, Women’s Day (committees plan); Youth and children present special programs for Black History Month, Christmas and Easter Mother’s & Father’s Day, Grandparent’s Day, Women’s Day, Laity Sunday, World Communion, Heritage Sunday, Go Red for Women, Pentecost, Advent, Lent, Easter, Palm Sunday. Use Hymnal, Book of Worship, internet. Women’s Day, Black History, Men’s Day, Laity Sunday UMW Day Program Planning Book; Laity Sunday – UM Book of Worship Men’s Day – Women’s Day; Black History; Laity School Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Black History, Laity Sunday Altar call – Passing the Peace – Affirmation of Faith – Black History – Invocation – Offertory sentence – Women’s Day – Men’s Day – Laity Sunday

SCJ (0-299 Members) 278

300+ - Membership & Worship Attendance -- SCJ

Jurisdiction North Central North Eastern South Central 154 Southeastern Western

Clergy or Laity Clergy 8 Laity 146

What is the approximately membership of your church? Under 100 100 - 199 200 - 299 300 – 499 15 500 - 749 1 750 - 999 3 1000+ 136

What is the approximate total Sunday worship attendance at your church? Under 100 100 – 199 7 200 - 299 10 300 - 499 2 500 - 749 750 - 999 1 1000+ 135

SCJ (300+ Members) 279

1. Worship Practices

How do you participate in Sunday worship?

Worship leader, liturgist, planning Invitational devotion, short centering prayer, lighting, P&W altar prayer, meet/greet, etc. Planning, worship leadership Sing, Worship Chair By attending Serve as liturgist or Announcement Clerk as needed Choir Communion Steward weekly Sing, pray Greeter Sing in the Young Adult Choir. Congregational participation/count offertory Chair of Church & Society, Stewardship Committee member Choir Minister of Music, Conference Lay Speaker I go to Children's Church Usher, youth minister, reading announcements, delivering the word, serving as liturgist I am a member of the church youth choir. I participate in every aspect of worship - I am the Worship Chairperson. Varies – liturgist, welcome & announcements Usher, lay member, Sunday school teacher, membership orientation I am a member of the Worship Committee. I work with the Pastor to plan activities of the service (Altar Guild, Praise dancers & musicians, etc.) Through music and singing Worship celebration Sing songs, pray, clap hand, we greet each other during praise time Sing, clap my hands, tap my feet Prayer, praise, fellowship thru welcome, sing Clap, yell comments i.e. Amen, praise the Lord, etc.

SCJ (300+ Members) 280

Greeter, count offering, adult Sunday school teacher, Lay leader By giving God glory and obeying the Holy Spirit, to receive God instruction so that we can go out and serve Prayer, song, listen Parishioner In every area for it Sing, clap, welcome visitors 8:00 am service, Sunday school Listen to the sermon, praise with song, dance and musical instruments Praise, prayer, singing, worshipping with family, loving the Lord Usher Sing Choir, pew participation, Bookstore Ministry Choir, active in Praise & Worship even when I’m in the pews Participate by praying, greeting of each other, join in song, reading scripture I do the whole package, sing, clap, stomp feet, pray, meet and greet Praying, singing, communicating with one another Singing, reading the Bible, participating in Sunday school class Sing, clap my hands, stand, pray Congregation-singing, clapping Praise him by clapping, singing and praying along with other fellow members Sit quietly in pew Sing in choir, Hospitality Ministry Congregational praise I sing and worship in the congregation presently, but was a choir member for 30 years New member, previous 21 years in ministry Choir Singing, praying, being a greeter Attendance, prayer, support, fellowship, singing, fellowship, singing, praise Attend service weekly Just attend I primarily attend Sunday worship Every Sunday Praise & Thanksgiving member of the choir

SCJ (300+ Members) 281

Usher, praise Bench warmer Singing, praising God Occasional liturgist, preach Clergy, Pastoral Assistant 1st Sunday Choir, others regular attendance Minister- call to worship, invocation, offering Attend church every Sunday Yes Greeting, standing , clapping Singing, praise, prayer Attend service, work with Ministries Choir, Male Chorus, Chorale, Sanctuary, Dance Ministry Attending service Being on time, prayer before service, praise and worship time, offering Children’s church, worship services Usher, prayer, singing Attendance Singing occasionally, standing-showing and being vocal, and to give witness to God Praise Attendance and praise Sing, pray, read congregation responses from bulletin as appropriate, go to Alter Singing and praying Worship Praying, singing Attend 8:00 Sunday worship, Bible Study, Prayer Service Praise and prayer Show up, tithes, sing and acknowledge blessings from God 8:00 worship service Music Sing, praise, pray Worship Sing in choir

SCJ (300+ Members) 282

I am an offering counter Good Choir Ministry, I come to Sunday worship weekly, I’ve completed Bible Study Choir, pew member, prepare announcements, Ministry Information & sign up table Sing, listen and pray Sing and fellowship Serve Pastor and others Prayer & Praise Worship, sing in the choir Attend and praise the Lord Bring my Bible, songs an giving Member, attend, give time, talent and money Attending main worship service and the Mandela Ministry I worship and serve on Senior Usher Board Prayer, sing, tithe, serve Yes Lay Member Lay Member Music Ministry, Loaves and Fishes Ministry Attending service regularly and being a part of a great congregation Intake Ministry, usher Greeter and social action Sing, clap, Praise & Worship, Scared Dance Weekly attendance, offering counter Sit in pews, sing, tap my feet, listen to sermon, pray, some dance Tithes, presence, gifts Music Ministry Attend worship on Sundays @ 8:00 and/or 11:00 am Actively Choir Greeters Ministry, praising Choir As a regular attending member of the Music Ministry

SCJ (300+ Members) 283

Tithes Choir, bookstore member, regular service Praising, sing songs, glorying his words New membership intake, singing, prayer & worship with congregation Sing in choir, prepare for worship before church at home Sanctuary Choir, male Choir Singing, praising, reading, offering, recording of the sermon Member of the Women’s Chorus, attend service regularly when not singing Pray, sing, greet and talk with my members & visitors Choir Attend and tithe Praise, song, scripture, fellowship, congregational responses, tithes/offerings Attendance and choir Attend service Choir, announcements, special announcements Active pew member Attending the worship services I stand up and clap with the music I feel the need, I sing along, I pat my feet to the music, I respond verbally to what the Preacher says in his sermon Singing, call response, dancing Member of congregation By coming to church I am a Music Ministry member With joy in African American /African Sacred music, sacred dance and expressive, call response, liturgy Attendance

What do you NOT like about what your church does in worship?

Sometimes too much needless talking; worship leader not as in tune during worship experience Complain about it being too long Not enough technology Passing of the Peace

SCJ (300+ Members) 284

I like everything but song words on the media screen I enjoy the entire worship experience When praise is too long There is nothing that I don't like Passing of the Peace takes too long We have had alter prayer - it was discontinued for a short time but returned to the worship this past week. Announcements made at the time when the service had not started. On monitors. Announcements at the very beginning. Too many members flock down to the altar area during the invitation for one person needing pray (not bad in itself), however, if someone joins the church you can't tell who it is and their outward giving/coming to God is lost by this "other" aspect going on simultaneously. The two need to be separate so newcomers can be authentically welcomed Nothing Lately the preaching has been off I think our services are meeting my needs Nothing I like it Walking N/A Sometimes the instruments get a little too loud for me, but overall I enjoy it (the service) and I look for to coming again Not enough praise time Traditional with African American accent Nothing I don’t have any complaints Sometimes too many songs Try to be too uppity; re: quenching the Spirit We are on a time barrier at the service I prefer to attend so we can’t “let go & let God” When we let the Spirit lead us Organize Meet & Greet too long I do not dislike Walking when the Minister says “ no walking” I like everything about it On other Sundays than Youth Sunday, church tends to be too old fashioned, traditional, and "ceremonial" Nothing

SCJ (300+ Members) 285

Song has been changed, the Lord’s Prayer has been changed When Pastor stays in Pulpit Right now I am excited about God moving in St. Luke Musician plays while participants reads scriptures We read scripture that does not pertain to the sermon. Too much rigidity, need to be more flexible Nothing There is nothing that I do not like about our great services I enjoy everything about my church None None Sermon delivery, method of delivery It’s all good, announcements at times get lengthy( already in the bulletin) Sometimes I don’t know what the words to the praise & worship songs, and they are not available Pastor singing Sometimes we are too structured and scripted Political candidates attendance before the vote Assume that others know their worship practices/liturgy I’ve not found one thing I don’t enjoy Sometimes it seems rushed I can’t think of anything I don’t like about worship service, I look forward to coming Not enough music Not much visual or video opportunities in Sanctuary or halls Nothing Look at your neighbor and say what ever the Pastor asks you to say I like everything Thoroughly appreciate the full range of our worship practice Stupid questions Needs more energy Much of the music is not from the African American experience/ heritage Musicians do not support Pastor they come in too late during his “whoop” Too much walking during service Some members of the congregation walk out of service before the service ends

SCJ (300+ Members) 286

I love everything my church does I don’t feel there is anything I dislike My church welcomes everyone There’s nothing I dislike More gospel music Need to link word more to day to day events I love everything about the worship service Absolutely nothing Bible Study Hmmm… Lack of African worship songs in service All is good Nothing I like it all Throwing a “big kiss” Letting people in a certain time Pastor singing and not from the choir I like it all Everything is ok, however, I would like to see church pals reinstated Most things are done well and in order, there is nothing I don’t like Everything I do like, but we need to have Black music in hymnals Sometimes too rushed Usually late comers can’t go in until after about 5 things on the program has commenced Sermon scripture are only printed for the Senior Pastor’s sermons, it’s a good idea that should be used for all preachers When message is not prepared and sermon is read to congregation I like everything Nothing Too predictable not spontaneous I used to hate when Children’s Day was but now God has given me a love for their services Kneeling not used as often Poor energy I like our worship service, I don’t like announcements, sometimes the older people don’t see well so it’s not about what I don’t like Stupid questions

SCJ (300+ Members) 287

2. "Good Church"

Describe a "good" church service. (Is there one that stands out in your memory?)

Inspiring preaching, motivating music, orderly, timely One full of spontaneity and expectation Everything planned well & flows; Holy Spirit's leadership Higher Way Church 1) greeting at the door, 2) good preaching, 3) good music, 4) friendly people We had a wonderful church service last week( 157th Anniversary) Beautiful music, sermon, testimonies from members of all ages Old fashion hymns Any service that addresses economic, political, social injustice; informing us to become better members to uplift anyone everyday When the choir sings more hymns than praise songs, and when the congregation acknowledges during the service that they enjoyed the minister's sermon Music, good sermon (a prepared sermon) Prayer, welcome to visitors, exciting singing, sermons to live by ( Exciting!!!) Any time the Spirit of the Lord is present and the congregation allow it to move within is a good service A good church service includes a whole lot of things - inclusivity of all persons at service are represented, musical variety, and pertinent preaching Talking about stuff all the time Welcoming, accepting, open, interactive A few years back at Wesley UMC in Austin, TX, the Holy Spirit had its way to the fullest, everyone truly had praise as the intention on their hearts The Spirit of the Lord's presence makes a "good" service, when most members are blessed in some way, a good service is when you see family and individuals come join in When the Holy Spirit is present from the beginning to the end Church bulletin, praise & worship, readings, & sermons are all flowing together A good church service is vibrant, inclusive of all ages, good preaching A service filled with the Holy Spirit The spirit is present, the music is good and inviting, the word is meaningful Welcoming members/visitors, praise and worship X10 Where everyone’s involved

SCJ (300+ Members) 288

When the Spirit was so high Pastor G dismissed church without a sermon Good singing, message with substance, people uniting with church, Pastor engaging congregation Experience of Holy Spirit, where word of God transmitted through the sermon and offers hope… A good service is when there’s good singing, prayer, greeting visitors and members, and the Ministers teach through his message Last Sunday 08-08(Youth Sunday)it’s wonderful to see the youth participate in the church and praise God, today 08-15 we just had a hallelujah good time worshipping and praising God, I especially enjoyed our guest musician Diverse singing of all styles, open worship to all Inspirational singing and message Good music, songs and praise Good message in songs and preached word today Anytime Pastor Gordon sings, then the choir sings, then everyone is on fire at worship sermon Great hymns of the church by congregation, up to date gospels, great message The choir sang gospels and anthems in a spiritual manner, the sermon was Bible based and life centered, the congregation were active participants with verbal praise and feedback When the desires of the church are open and Pastor G invites people to come to Christ and inviting them back to the alter for prayer One where there is prompt starting on time, I like a great praise song, a challenging sermon, and hospitable people Half hour to 45 minutes of praise music(fast-slowing) from loud to worshipfully quiet Directed to service and worship of God for the renewing of Spirit A service of stamina They are numerous, every Sunday Disciples are made, Lives are transformed Yes every Sunday Good singing, good message from the Pastor you can relate to Same as below including the Holy Spirit I love the 11 am service because there isn’t a time restraint, but it doesn’t fit into my schedule, I visit the Nursing Home after Sunday school class after 8:00 am service When we let the Spirit lead us A church knows that God is first, and we’re to love one another as God Loves us Freedom of the Holy Spirit When the word has been explained so that when you leave, you want to apply what’s been taught to your life forever, music can be minister to your heart When the message has been given and you’ve learned something or something has been more defined Full of energy

SCJ (300+ Members) 289

A “good church” is one that uses many forms of praise and worship, like praise dance, songs and instruments It’s having a lively congregation When I am so involved in my relationship with the Lord that I lose myself and not aware of my surroundings, which lets me know others can experience God the way I am The word and singing Singing, instruments Good order of worship The holy Spirit has made his presence known- he is a part of the service Everyone is touched by all facets of worship ( song, sermon, joining together in Spirit) call to worship, litany A good church service is one that I take home with me and act upon it immediately, like have you ever been intercepted by God When the Holy Spirit stands out and people change attitudes, relationships Going forward to tell the good news that they have learned When a church family combined themselves and deliver a good church service, by greeting and making you feel welcome and making you want to keep coming over and over, hopefully convert you to Christ Good music, good preaching, participation in the worship Good church to me is when the singing and message is so good that members are talking about it after church and sharing God’s message throughout the week Well organized, not too long, spiritual (traditional not contemporary) Youth Sunday- energy and passion Hanging of the Greens Christmas service, very spiritual and inspiring Worship, praise and fellowship with each other Good sermons and music, fellowship, friendliness, compassion, spiritually uplifting and educationally stimulating Inclusive, informative, engaging, uplifting, instructional enhances, relevant, practicable Good fellowship, songs and preaching When the Holy Spirit abounds from good singing and good preaching Every Sunday at the Luke Great preaching, quality spiritual music Led by the Holy Spirit A good service is one in which the message from the Pastor and the music provides me with inspiration through the week Good music, good message, great fellowship, Bible based Freedom of praise and participation Hospitable, loving, good singing, good preaching, and teaching When the spirit of the Lord is moving and the word is fresh, the music is uplifting with spirituals and Negro hymns

SCJ (300+ Members) 290

Spontaneity, openness, call and response Where disciples are made through the preaching, teaching, and singing Lively worship including congregational singing, dedicated preaching The use of Negro spirituals to complement the message, heightened sense of God’s presence and the membership embracing His Spirit Songs/ music that invigorates and allows the full expression of our faith and commitment to saving souls for Christ Hearing the word from a teaching prospective Good music and good preaching When the Holy Spirit sweeps through the room Spirit filled Today One that bring the word and the Spirit of the Lord in song and love A good service is one which engages attendees with a word from the Lord and ways to deal with topical issues, good music Good Everyone was on the same page as the Pastor’s sermon and the way the Holy Spirit moves in me and the other members Much participation from congregation Good singing, individual and group singing, sermons that make you think about your lit Feeling it all week or thinking of the message An excellent church service consists of one such as that of St. Luke “Community” UMC Dallas, Texas; under the direction of Pastor Tyrone Gordon The congregation is energized and ready to worship before they even get to church, and I am geared up to worship before I even arrive When the message speaks directly to me Starts on time, provides a word from the Lord, opens arms and doors to everyone A good church has many ministries that reaches out into the community to the needs of the community A good church is a church that make you feel welcome and appreciated immediately when you walk thru the doors Singing and teaching from the Bible Oal Brown, Pastor was here for Youth Sunday, when Pastor Green preaches and others own roster Prayer & Praise Spiritual growth A church with radical hospitality and a variety of music A good message good singing, praise & worship Pastor’s word and the spiritual synergy of a congregation

SCJ (300+ Members) 291

Starting with the call to worship, praying, singing, more singing, and a word about discipleship, our Pastor G sings the word, closing and fellowship Yes One that is lively, Minister has a good message, members are friendly and supportive, one that ministers to the community Supports higher education Offers a variety of worship experiences from a stylistic point of view, i.e. meditation, prophetic preaching, powerful prayer and community sharing Excellent preaching and singing A good church service involves a mixture of good music and the word Where everyone worships together and can reflect on how songs are important to my walk with God from young to present Hospitable members, good group participation, great fellowship When the spirit is high I like it all Praise and worship Wonderful sense of community with people I know and the effort to be open to others I do not know How the Pastor personally gives each member their rights of membership, also how the Pastors make themselves available to greet people at he end of worship Good church= active in community, welcoming, cooperative Pastor with additional good stewardship of finances Good music that’s uplifting and has a message, strong preaching of the Gospel Great preaching, great singing, excellent worship Radical friendship hospitality I like litany for special holidays and occasions, I like Dance Ministry for involvement in the service, I also like active congregational involvement The whole experience of worship, being warmly greeted congregational prayer, singing, and preaching Where the fellowship, song, and word line up together and God’s presence is felt Meaningful sermon When we sing praise and the Holy Spirit is in control When all are praise and worship in unity being led by the Pastor Hospitality, music, sermon They’re all good  Worship service followed by God’s plan and went a different direction than planned People are actively engaged in service, choir sings songs, people connect to, Pastor preaches experientially and does not read the message

SCJ (300+ Members) 292

Lively engaging and spirit filled praise & preaching, warm/welcoming members, not a lot of extraneous “talking”/announcements, focus on the word Great music Good music, good preaching, good alter prayer Where the Spirit of the Lord comes in and takes over the service When I leave feeling more inspires and spiritually filled than when I came in When it is directed by the Spirit Good preaching We worship God with our hearts, souls, minds, and bodies, call & response, edifies of the body of Christ, we praise and serve as a body We are attentive to time, but not “ anal” about it Relevant preaching and good music

Which of the following is true about good worship services? (Circle all that apply.) a. Organized/planned worship is important 100 b. Good worship can be planned 66 c. Good worship should be planned 67 d. The spiritual disciplines are preparation for good worship 88 e. Congregational singing is vital to good worship 109

Additional comments:

Planning included plenty of good room for spontaneity, we are space oriented people, we worship God not time Time to gather is planned in –not about organ music starting right at the start of the worship time, we gather first, the we leave some time for praise and invocation Good preaching

SCJ (300+ Members) 293

3. Music

What kind of songs do you sing at your church and who sings them?

Gospel, mostly contemporary; few hymns - led by praise team & choir; congregational singing led by choir with words on the screens Mostly choir, Men-Southern Gospel - some contemporary Gospel, hymns, praise music, spirituals Choir – contemporary, Gospel, Hymnals Congregation & choirs (adult, children) - songs from the UMC Hymnal We sing a variety of music - hymns, contemporary gospel, spirituals Old 100, Gospel, Contemporary Congregation-choir Hymns Gospel and the choir sings them Hymnals, contemporary gospel, gospel Gospel, contemporary, very few anthems Traditional & contemporary - also gospel Gospel, contemporary Gospel, Spirituals We sing all genres of music. Choirs, soloists, congregation, ensembles We just sing songs. None in particular though. My mom and the choir (sometimes the people) sing the songs. At least one hymn each week - contemporary worship and contemporary gospel "Victory" - Tye Tribbett (sung by youth choir); "Lead Me, Guide Me" (adult choir); "You Are Good" - Israel Haighton Youth Choir All types :hymns, gospel, contemporary, praise music, hip/ hop, Anthems Ministers of music, choir, sing hymns, contemporary, spoken word, etc. Contemporary, hymns, congregational Chancel Choir – hymns, anthems, contemporary Christian; Gospel Choir – gospel; Children/Youth – gospel; Men’s Chorus – hymns, gospel; 8:00 Ensemble – gospel Gospel – Choirs; Anthems, Hymns – Congregation Anthems, Gospels, hymns, and spirituals, the choirs and general congregation All kinds- choirs and ensembles, musicians Negro spirituals, traditional, contemporary, old 100’s Spirituals, contemporary, traditional gospel, choirs, chorale and guest soloists Hymns and progressive spirituals

SCJ (300+ Members) 294

There is variety in songs that are sung All, Pastor The choir and congregation engage in singing songs of praise and worship ( gospel, contemporary, modern gospel, spirituals, Negro Spirituals, jazz, contemporary gospel jazz) We sing traditional as well as contemporary and classic Methodist style hymns We sing gospel and Anthems Mix of old and modern songs, sung by the choir All types of music that praises the goodness of the Universe All types of music- hymnal, praise, joyful All types of music Choir sings and Pastor also songs, some of the old 100’s are sung All Spiritual Gospel Contemporary and traditional, gospel and old Negro Spirituals Contemporary and traditional African American songs Spirituals All Choirs- various Gospel, hymns, traditional, spirituals, contemporary gospel Current and old spirituals, hymnals Hymns, contemporary jazz, and patriotic Contemporary Gospel songs with African American influence, some Anthems, group and choir participation Our choir Hymnals and praising songs Hymns, standards, gospel, contemporary, spirituals Some from the Hymnal to them from the Music Ministry Melodic, instrumental, organic,”pipe hymnal” Hymns, gospel Hymns- congregational Spirituals- choir, praise songs, various On the Battlefield for My Lord, Hymnal, praise

SCJ (300+ Members) 295

All genres of music such as gospel, spiritual, hymns…something to reach everybody Gospels, hymns, spirituals, congregational songs All gospel>contemporary, spirituals, hymns N/A All songs- praise & worship, African Gospel Spirituals, hymns, choir, congregation Hymns, modernized hymns, spirituals, various others, everyone is invited to sing along New songs, old Hymnals-ethnic and those with heritage Songs that our forefathers used to sing All types from spirituals, to contemporary, hymns, hip/hop gospels All kinds as long as the choir/ensemble can sing and musicians can play African American Choir and congregation, all types of music; Negro Spirituals, hymns, contemporary, and traditional gospels Choirs, congregation, solo, instruments Spiritual Choral, gospel, traditional and contemporary Songs that relate soul salvation All kinds, traditional, contemporary, hymns Traditional Black hymns, new scale Gospel, Anthems, spirituals Good gospel music, old 100 songs I grew up, hymns song to help not running through Old time spirituals, gospel African influenced gospel, spiritual hymns Standard hymns, devotionals, new age gospel, Pentecostal music, some gospel rap, the congregation, various choirs, A variety of songs are sung, traditional hymns, new songs, top spirituals from the radio All songs are good songs when singing for the Lord We sing all kinds of songs from traditional to modern, I think they are both needed so we can reach and inspire the young as well as the old All styles, spirituals, traditional hymns, gospel, contemporary gospel Choir and congregation sing Gospel songs( traditional and modern), Hymnal, songs sung by choir and congregation Gospel hymns, choir and congregation

SCJ (300+ Members) 296

Negro Spirituals-Chorale, contemporary-N’Christ, traditional-Sunrise Choir, gospel- Sanctuary Choir, Women’s and Men’s Choirs, new & rap gospel-Youth Choir Anthems, gospels, hymns, all are needed Various genre of music- Anthems, gospels, spirituals, the choir and congregation Gospel, contemporary This is the Day that the Lord Has Made, Marvelous All kinds, mix it up Minister, choir and congregation sing traditional and current songs of praise Disciple and old hymns, Disciple Hymnals I’m a member of the Sunrise Choir and we prepare weekly and plan according to our Director’s orders, and all are so ready and able to help us Diverse hymns, contemporary, diverse leaders Congregational songs and choir sings Variety of songs, some old songs Pastor sings spiritually, the choirs sing spiritually All kinds, gospel, Anthems, instrumentals Praise & Worship, the choir and congregation. Spirituals Contemporary and tradition song, most of time the choir Hymns- congregation Contemporary Spiritual-choir Several choirs, contemporary Several choirs, contemporary hymns Variety, choir, membership, old spirituals, traditional, new gospel Old spirituals (Negro) Choirs/Ensembles, congregation, soloists, instrumental A total variety from a cappella, Negro Spirituals, youth and young adults, contemporary Music in Hymnals, “old time songs” Spiritual songs, heart touching songs, the choir sings, the members sing Hymns, contemporary Spirituals, gospel, contemporary songs, congregation, several choirs: Youth, Chorale, Gospel Negro Spirituals, gospel songs, youth rap songs, sung by several choirs, groups and ages Traditional hymns and spirituals

SCJ (300+ Members) 297

Praise & Worship, spiritual, gospel Traditional African American hymns Hymns, spirituals, gospel, choirs, ensembles, congregation Variety Gospel, old hymns from African decent A variety from praise music to old fashioned hymns and gospel Gospel, praise & worship, the choir and congregation Hymns, spirituals, gospel, congregation, choirs, Pastor Gospel, spiritual and hymns I appreciate all the songs from the traditional to non-traditional Hymns, contemporary gospel, the choirs and congregation Many kinds The choir, gospel songs, new age, religious songs, old heritage songs, traditional Traditional contemporary, spirituals Gospels, spirituals, occasional hymns Songs that uplift the good news of the Gospel in a continually relevant manner Variety! As we experienced this morning! Congregational singing, hymns, contemporary, instrumental, spirituals Negro spirituals, traditional, contemporary Gospel, hymns, and contemporary Christian Mostly Black gospels Gospels Choir, African American hymns Choir and congregational singing, leadership and response All kinds, hymns, gospel songs We sing songs of many origins I especially am moved by music/song that reflects my African American heritage Gospel, new music by current artist, Black church music which comes from the Baptist Hymnals & tradition The choir and congregation sings, we have a blended worship experience that incorporates many genres of church worship music

SCJ (300+ Members) 298

In our church, the CONGREGATION sings an average of: (Check one)

1-2 songs per service 49

3-4 songs per service 58

More than 4 songs 36

Fewer than 2 songs 0

How do you feel about the way instruments are used in your church?

Great! Hammond, grand piano, keyboard, drums, bass guitar I enjoy instruments Excellent! Excellent use- Hammond organ, drums, strings, Allen Organ, piano, bass guitar Need more OK No drums, good organ I enjoy various instruments that are used in the service I like it I like it - we only have a piano & guitar occasionally No comment Love them - adds to the worship - enhances the performance of the choirs We could use better quality of instrument & more instruments as well Vital to the spirit of the music If played skillfully they should always be used in any manner possible Very good Often the music/instruments are too loud Instruments are a vital part of praise and worship I appreciate the diversity of instruments in our service Instruments are used well, volume balance is the key

SCJ (300+ Members) 299

Love instruments, drums, horns There has been improvement, I like the different instruments Sometimes too much organ, could use more drums and piano, need better sound system I feel instruments should be used as testament to talents from God Approve of all instruments They are too loud sometimes, especially when praying Love it, the musicians are very knowledgeable and can play When it is directed at making a joyful noise unto the Lord, its all good All types of instruments should be used I enjoy all of our instruments Great, instruments are one of many expressions, it is acceptable Instruments other than voice are extremely important I enjoy them Could be increased, most non-traditional instruments played by guests Terrific, our church uses them well I feel good I feel they enhance the worship service I love the fact that we have instruments in the church We are open minded, we enjoy variety I feel they are needed They are part of our worship All of the time Positive- organ, piano and visiting musicians I feel good about the different instruments used in the church They are presented very appropriately Ok, we get comprehensive exposure I enjoy the music department in our church I love it, they are great Great Love to have instruments Good Good Love the use of instruments to enhance worship service

SCJ (300+ Members) 300

I am not a fan of the “Allen Organ” ( a pipe organ), but other than that I love all the instrumentation that is used Enjoy it Good Excellent- we need them all Very vital to worship I love it, it enhances the spiritual experience They add to the worship services Good I enjoy and welcome them Good Like all instruments Yes Our instruments are well used Love it Like I like it Used well- exposed to guests who bring variety of music styles and instruments I love it Could use more strings like violins( they only come as guest musicians), otherwise pretty good Size of the music area seems to be an issue-its sometimes too small Good They are all use in everyway to and beyond what they’re used for Ok All over- bass, organ, piano, drums Love the addition of strings Great! Could use more Instruments are a plus and takes Excellent, we have guests sometimes also Like them They are making a “joyful” noise so all instruments are okay They are a great compliment Good I truly enjoy the instruments

SCJ (300+ Members) 301

Not placed on a pedestal, like some churches Special- beautifully done Very good I like the piano, organ and the praise instrument that is used in our church Love it They are well trained and enjoy performing I enjoy piano and organ music We use Praise Band well, we could use more guitar and synthesizer Very professional sounding, there is a degree of excellence I feel the instruments are used in great taste We have a variety of instruments piano, organ, drums, strings; all add to the quality of the service Great asset, praise Him with cymbals, harps I enjoy how musical our church is, would love trumpets and acoustic guitar as well We have wonderful musicians, none better All the instruments are great Love it Could use more strings for example I love the Music Ministry, at times I feel its just too loud as it drowns out the choir I like them, they enhance the service I love instruments I enjoy them Great They are effective, yet often too loud for my preference Acceptable to me, maybe the volume could be turned down Awesome- love the music Very appropriate Good Music, singing and the use of instruments help to soothe and minister to the soul-that feel good portion It’s great, especially the instruments We have a variety of instruments and an excellent group of musicians, I enjoy the music I enjoy the instruments used in our congregation I feel good, it makes me want to sing along always I like the instruments as they alone are praising God and bring to my remembrance the words that touch me

SCJ (300+ Members) 302

Love it! A complete band, sometimes stringed instruments It’s very inspirational- gives a “lift” Love it ! It’s vital Love them I love it! No other way to worship I am very inspired by the use of instruments during worship If there weren’t instruments I don’t think that I would feel the Spirit in a vibrant and lively way Love it Good I appreciate all the varied music expressions Really enjoy the musical instruments I feel there is anointment through instruments that can touch your heart Blessed Too loud All are welcome and are used within our services They significantly add to the worship experience Good, could be better I like the instruments, we often include variety such as violin and bongo drums Good, they make the church come alive I’m always excited when we place emphasis on instruments, we should do it more We need more Key to vibrant worship experience I love the use of instruments and would like to see more emphasis placed on its use I love how the church use instruments in songs of praise I feel that they are a part of worship

4. Hymnal/Worship Resources

My church uses ___ hymnbooks regularly in worship

NONE- 4 ONE- 78 TWO- 11

SCJ (300+ Members) 303

THREE- 1 4 OR MORE- 3 Circle all that apply:

a. My church uses our denominational hymnal 115

b. My church uses a hymnal other than our denominational hymnal 34

c. Hymns are an important contribution to the church 105

d. Hymns teach our religious faith's theologies and doctrines 83

e. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my religious heritage 51

f. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my ethnic heritage 40

g. My church uses our hymnbook at services other than Sunday morning 38

h. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my racial heritage 32

Additional Comments:

But we sing other hymns we know Way too few Songs of Zion

Where do you get your resources for the kind of worship experience in your church?

GBOD, Africana Resources From the cultural heritage and church experience My parents pass from person to person Members

SCJ (300+ Members) 304

Seek them out from related sources Baptist hymnal, Africana materials, African American Hymnal Cokesbury and other UM agencies and boards Prior knowledge Cokesbury Cokesbury Members within the church, Minister of Music is a great resource, inviting guests Oral tradition Cokesbury, and other places Internet, CD’s, radio, printed material Hymnal, not ethically balance Choir Director, Pastor UMC Hymnal, Songs of Zion Selected by the Pastoral staff/worship committee Not sure Tithes & offering Everywhere A lot of places. Africana, Worship Connection, the web Internet, GBOD, Worship Connection, visiting other churches A variety of resources are used including the internet Cokesbury Internet From my elders that have taught me Minister of Music From our Music Ministry Leaders Cokesbury Bibles Various via Minister of Music We use music that has been handed down as spirituals, Moses Hogan Bible, Hymnal Minister of Music and the Choir Director, along with the Senior Pastor who has a gift of singing Everyone (Senior Pastor, Minister of Music)

SCJ (300+ Members) 305

From our Pastor Minister of Music, Pastor Churches and bookstores Music Ministry (Monya Logan) Most are provided by the church to include Bibles Personal experience Bible and from elders Bible and Hymn books From memory Lifeway, church bookstore Hymnals, Disciple Bible Study Bible, Hymnals, inspirational books by other authors UM Hymnal, Songs of Zion From the church Music heard on the radio, sheet music, hymns Hymn books, popular gospel songs Worship Guide From past experiences thru family and church efforts, my spiritual growth Worship helps Singing and message Church bookstore, commentary and Christian bookstores From growing up in church Minister of Music, foundation of attending church growing up Choir, music workshop, leaders of worship Inspirational bookstores Worship Committee, Director of Music Ministry Handle by Minister of Worship/Music Offering Monya Logan Bible Family tradition. Worship Ministries Hmm…I think much of it is generational if not traditional

SCJ (300+ Members) 306

Worship Leader Church bookstore Childhood Public gospel radio, media From recorded CDs, purchased sheet music, hymnals, guest Ministers and musicians Church bookstore, secular bookstore Religious family up bringing Attending church From the Ushers at the door Family background, the way I was raised From the church bookstore Being of African heritage I think our Hymnal should reflect that From the Bible From the bookstore Members Outside reading

5. Worship Traditions

What are some of the worship traditions that have been passed down in your church?

Traditional, contemporary Open worship-charismatic Call and response The way we ask our neighbors questions Old Negro Spirituals, instruments Congregational singing Call and response Singing Negro Spirituals Alter worship, greeting each other Bible reading Alter call, Negro Spirituals, Gospel

SCJ (300+ Members) 307

Communion, praise worship, Sacrament of Baptism, Discipleship, Invitation to Christ Prayer, praise, singing, letting the Spirit move as should Family service and worship Watch Night and Christmas Eve Jazz Not enough Call and response, praise dance, Preacher leads songs Standing during scriptures, call and response, style singing, rocking side to side Call and response, spirituals I grew up in the Baptist traditions, this is different from the Methodist churches I visited Old time gospel songs Baptism Singing, prayer, communion, congregational responses Singing, prayer Spiritual hymns and Anthems Kwanza, Watch Night, Sacred Dance African traditions and spiritual heritages

Describe the special days that are observed in your congregation (e.g. Ushers' or Annual Day, Women's Day, Men's Day, etc.) What resources do you use to plan for special days?

Usher's/Greeters Day, Women's & Men's Day, planned by organization/ministry. Founder's Day planned by Pastor & team We have all the days listed, we often invite women and men from other churches to lead such services UM Men’s Day, dictated by committee Lenten, African American Lecture Service, Watch Night, Thanksgiving All are well planned and carried out Martin Luther King Jr., Black History Month, African American lectures and services, Women’s Month, Men’s month, Church Anniversary All Christian holidays, Men’s and Women’s Day Birthdays Usher’s and Annual Day, Women’s Day, Men’s Day, our Church Anniversary is very special day for us all Church Anniversary, Easter Programs My church engages in strong spiritual and heritage worship

SCJ (300+ Members) 308

All of the ones mentioned above Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Church Anniversary, Choir and Praise Dance, concerts and musicals They are important and celebrated lavishly Anniversaries, Women’s And Men’s Day, Youth Sunday, Revival, Laity Sunday, African American Heritage Month, we use poetry and other literature of the African American experience Worship helps planning services Women’s Day, Mother’s Day, Father’s Day, Christmas Program Books, radio and current events I’m not sure We use the talents of all the members and their professions to assist in planning these services All those listed below includes Youth Revival and Children’s Church All of the above, various ministers and members in the church Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Church Anniversary Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Church Anniversary, Youth Sunday Women’s and Men’s Day, Revivals, Lay Sunday Youth Sunday, Laity Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Church Anniversary All resources are provided Men’s Day, Women’s Day, Anniversaries Annual day, Women’s and Men’s Day Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Laity Sunday, Youth/Children’s Sunday, Anniversaries Women’s, Men’s, Youth, etc Mother’s Day, Easter, Christmas African American Heritage Month, Youth Revival, Men’s & Women’s Month, Church Anniversary, Upper Room Bible commentary, Religious Literature, and Christian books( current publications) Women’s Day, Men’ s Day, Children’s Day, Church Anniversary Women’s Day- women are in charge of the full service, all women wear red and white; Black History Sunday is play and music Watch Night, Kwanza, Hanging of the Greens, majority of every day and holiday observed All of the above, honoring Seniors and youth Men’s and Women’s Day, Church Anniversary Women’s Day, Men’s Day Annual Day, Women’s Day, Men’s Day, past history Pastor’s report card, Anointing before school starts, College Day, Valentine’s Day Renewal of Vows

SCJ (300+ Members) 309

All – I am a member of only 8 months and I don’t know all I have observed the above listed but also Church Anniversary, College and Youth Days Worship-African American gospel music, we observe all the above and then others Men’s Day, Women’s Day, Easter, Lent, Christmas, High school/College Recognition Day, Mother’s Day, Father’s Day Sunday school graduation, Aids Awareness Day, Youth Sunday, among other days, guest speakers, money, volunteers, ministries Always something new and exciting to show/ express appreciation for those being honored Women’s & Men’s Days, Black History month, MLK birthday Hanging of the Greens, Palm Sunday, Easter, women’s and Men’s Day Church Anniversary, revival, Youth Revival, Bible Study, Youth Sunday Youth Month, Youth Sunday, Church Anniversary, Children’s Sabbath, Aids Day, Unity Sunday, Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Youth and Children’s Sunday, Laity Youth Sunday, Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Laity Sunday, not sure which resources are used to plan All of the above Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Children Easter Program, Youth College Tours, college and educational emphasis, members research and development of programs in the past joined with new ideas Annual calendar Women’s Day, Church Anniversary, Men’s Day, Youth Sunday, different committees plan these days UM Men, UM Women, Church Anniversary Annual Women’s and Men’s Day Special praise dances, special music Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Hanging of the Greens, Christmas, Easter We plan and prepare for each of the following days, and allow everyone to partake in the special worship Women’s Day, Men’s day, Hanging of the Greens Men's & Women's Day, Homecoming, Choir Annual Day - we utilize people Men's & Women's Day, Watchnight, Church Anniversary All of the above, Easter, and Christmas Women's & Men's Day, UMW Sunday, Human Relations Day, One Great Hour of Sharing, Native American Awareness, UM Student Day, World Communion Sunday, AIDS Awareness Sunday UMW, Black History, Native American, and all ethnic groups, round-up Sunday Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Prayer & Praise, Youth Sunday, Church Anniversary, African American Heritage Sunday, Hanging of the Greens All of the above to include Church and Pastor Anniversary that are planned and resourced through various committees Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Youth Sunday, Hanging of the Greens, Higher Education Sunday, Senior Saints Sunday

SCJ (300+ Members) 310

All special days plus Ethnic Heritage, Worship Planner & worship committee UMW Sunday, Native American Sunday, Round-up Sunday, African American Sunday; all ethnic groups are celebrated. Women's Day, UMW Sunday Women's & Men's Day, Usher's Anniversary, Church Anniversary, Annual Choir Day Usher's Annual Day, Women's & Men's Day, Children Sabbath, Founder's Day, Youth Sunday The standard ones in a typical UM church Women's & Men's Day, Ushers Anniversary UMW, UMM, Youth, Children, Usher, Women's History, HIV/AIDS Awareness Women's Day, Usher's Day, Church anniversary Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Usher’s or Annual Day Church Anniversary, Youth Sunday, Laity Sunday, Men’s Day, Women’s Day Easter is our church's biggest day - it usually has the best worship Women’s month, Men’s month Human Relations, other special Sundays, Usher Day & World AIDS Day & UMW Day, Watch Night, Church Anniversary, Music Ministry Sunday Worship Committee handles these special days UM program books, resources on the internet, Worship Committee is very good at resourcing information Women’s & Men’s Day, Laity Sunday, Pentecost, Human Relations Day, Black History Month, Women’s History Month. We use the Book of Worship for resource Women’s Day , Men’s Day Speakers and musicians Women’s Week, Youth Sunday, Men’s Month, Laity Sunday Women’s Day, Men’s Day Church Anniversary, Pray and Praise, Youth Day We cover so much, you name it, very diverse Hymns Watch Night, Men’s & Women’s Day, Church Anniversary All listed, drama, music Christmas, Homecoming, Watch Night Women’s Day, Church Anniversary, Men’s Day Women’s, Men’s and Youth Days, Laity Sunday Praying for all students and educators before beginning of the school year Women’s Day

SCJ (300+ Members) 311

All listed- music drawn from traditional African American history books All of the above are underlined Quite a few, Hanging of the Green(Christmas) Annual day, Men’s Day, Women’s Day Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Youth Sunday, Education Sunday, Black History Month, King’s Birthday, Christmas Eve Jazz Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Youth Revival, Church Anniversary, Laity Sunday, Harvest Sunday, Stewardship, African Lecture services, Easter, Good Friday, Christmas Eve Jazz, Prayer & Praise on Wednesday

ADDITIONAL COMMENTS:

I am a Black Christian who would like to have an inclusive worship experience within the United Methodist Church and In inclusive hymnal would aid in achievement of this goal This survey does not address Black issues in the United Methodist Church Stupid questions

SCJ (300+ Members) 312

0 to 299 - Membership & Worship Attendance -- SEJ

Jurisdiction North Central North Eastern South Central Southeastern 280 Western

Clergy or Laity Clergy 41 Laity 239

What is the approximately membership of your church? Under 100 46 100 - 199 64 200 - 299 58 300 – 499 500 - 749 750 - 999 1000+

What is the approximate total Sunday worship attendance at your church? Under 100 114 100 – 199 53 200 – 299 1 300 – 499 500 – 749 750 – 999 1000+

SEJ (0-299 Members) 313

1. Worship Practices

How do you participate in Sunday worship?

Singing Pastor I am an usher I participate in a lot in Sunday worship Sing in the choir Youth on youth Sunday I will sing on the choir Praise dance, sing Singing, speaking , praying I sing in the choir Lead worship prepare for worship I pray, I share my opinion I talk and ask questions By going to Sunday School Men and Children’s choir By doing the offering as a usher, singing in the choir, and helping around Singing songs, clap my hands, it could be better Choir director I participate in choir on some Sundays then Usher on others I don’t go to often, but when I do I stand to my feet and clap Sunday School, sing Praise dance Take part in the service when needed usher praise dance Choir member I participate by listening to the message I usher every other Sunday and I feed the poor every end of the month Sunday morning worship, community service By singing and giving a testimony if called upon Tell my students in my dorm to attend, encourage students leaders to continue there calling Singing actively serving Congregation member, leader Play my instrument Choir

SEJ (0-299 Members) 314

By participating in the worship and conversations and youth activities Singing, praise dance, prayer By helping out listening and praying Whatever is ask of me such as reading the scripture, affirmation of faith Attending in it Praise dancing, singing, and , lighting the candles Singing, dancing Lay leader, Sunday school teacher Usher, choir, praise dance Worship Leader Attending Sunday School Music, service, worship, education Treasure, children Sunday teacher Lay leader Worship Leader Singing, praising, praying Usher , choir , praise dance Sing, dance Attend Sunday School Music, service, worship, education Singing, praising, praying Lay speaker, worship leader, member of the mass choir Music Ministry Teaching, praise dancing, singing I pray, sing in choir Overall in charge of worship Hymns, gospel special selection as musician director I am heavily involved in the these areas Singing Scripture reading some Sunday when ask Sing in youth choir and help with praise team Sing, dance Follow the program, help with children’s church What ever they ask me to do mainly new members Lead guitarist , Lay speaker I sing in the choir I sing in the choir

SEJ (0-299 Members) 315

I sing in the choir I preach the word on the 1st and 3rd Sunday, 2nd and 4th Sunday I am the residing Lay speaker for our pastor, read scripture, children church, Christian education Sing in choir, dance Sing, praise dance, usher I help pray and sang songs We talk about what we hear, read and learn Sing in choir, worship leader Choral singing fellowship with each other Sunday School and choir On first Sunday I sang with youth choir and with the adult choice on 4th Sunday and I am a member of the usher board and I usher every Sunday What ever they ask me to do, mainly new members Youth group By ushering, by singing in my youth choir and men’s choir Sing Dance I stand and just praise the lord Whatever they ask me to do mainly new member I read scripture, join in the discussion, and contribute funds for the literature I’m an Usher and sometimes lead the church service Very well by being part of the choir and youth group Gospel choir, Chancel choir, and linguist Ushers, Attendance, Communion Steward, U.M. Women Sunday school, choir, liturgist Youth activities I sing and play the drums We sing, clap and dance I participate in Sunday worship by singing in the choir I sing in the choir, help by being worship leader, sometimes play the drums I don’t Sing in the choir, read the Psalm I go to Church Choirs, dance, serve communion, and call to worship I sit, listen, pray and sing with the congregation I sing in the choir

SEJ (0-299 Members) 316

I sing either with the choir in the stands or in the pews Go to Sunday school I sing in the young adult choir Singing in the choir Playing the drums Most Sundays I go to the Adult Sunday school class, then I participate in the morning service I stand and clap to worship him and sing some of his song Stand up and clap, read my bible, sing along with the choir I am the worship leader once a month and I also help out with the children each Sunday Church school teacher, President of UMW, acc to the annual conference, Chairperson of Missions I attend church school and sometimes teach the children, President of UMW unit By singing in the choir, reading a scripture, leading a prayer, or anything else I’m asked to do Choir Sing in choir We do not have a youth Sunday school Standing, listening, singing I am the greeter, I open the door and greet people when they walk into church I sing in the choir I go to Sunday school I help with the kids I participate in Sunday worship by attending Sunday service just about every Sunday, and I sing with the songs and stuff I am the associate and I make sure the things are ready for the Senior Pastor, I sing with the youth choir on the 3rd Sunday Leading the worship services as Lay Reader I am worship leader, Preacher Preach, sing, pray Regular attendance, preach and share in Holy Communion Attend worship, sing praise songs, listen to message, and participate with the worship attenders Preach, prepare worship Liturgist, Preacher Preach and proclaim, assist in praise and worship to “God” Singing, preaching Provide pastoral leadership and preaching the word Lead worship, preach, and pray Sermon and Pastor’s moments Worship leader

SEJ (0-299 Members) 317

Our participation in Sunday worship is expressed through praise music and congregational singing, psalter music responses offered for congregational participation Pastor (various ways) Lead worship Singing, praying and worshipping in general Usher, choir, catering over the kitchen Greeter Worship Sing in choir, Communion Steward, worship leader Chair of Sunday school Singing, Greeter, and Usher Usher, prepare bulletins I sing in 2 choirs, I am a lay speaker, I am chair of the greeter/hospitality ministry Assist in leading worship if Pastor is running late, choir member, Lay Leader Singing, prayer, worship leader Congregational member Dance ministry Gospel choir, usher, welcome visitors Announcements and update on ministries Praise team, choir Liturgist, praise & worship Usher In discussing the lesson where everyone gets involved Singing in choirs Usher on 4th and 5th Sundays When the choir sings I stand up with them, usher, read scriptures I go to church I play trumpet in the praise & worship service Yes The children’s moments Usher on the 4th Sunday Sing in 3 choirs, dance, serve Communion, read scripture I sing in choir and dance I watch and sometimes sing along if I know the song Sunday school, choir, sometimes children’s service, liturgist, and worship service Liturgist, choir

SEJ (0-299 Members) 318

Musician, piano Music director I have served as a lay reader, speaker Worship leader, trainer committee I sing in the choir and sometimes read the scripture Listening Preach, sing, pray, extend invitation to Christ Carrying cross Acolyte Listen, acolyte Listen to the service Listen to service Listen As a member By praise dancing Choir, praise, prayer, fellowship ,offering, communion Liturgist, sometimes sing, deliver message, other including prayer and announcements Praying, singing, and preaching I am on the usher board, I sing and pray during church Usher, read opening prayer, scripture Sing, usher, read scriptures Singing, clapping At church I participate in the choir every 4th Sunday I sing, dance and sometimes work on sound Yes Musician Male choir member, member of the finance committee, leader chairperson of the scholarship committee I am on the usher board Nothing really but sometimes praise dance Praise dancing, junior ushering I sing in the choir and usher I am a junior usher Singing in the choir, acolyte, praise dance, praise & worship I sing and work in the sound booth I am in the youth choir (voices of praise), I am on the junior usher board, I am on my praise dance team( praise in motion), I am an acolyte I get up and clap

SEJ (0-299 Members) 319

Doing various jobs in the pulpit, acolyte and ushering Coordinator of praise dancers I listen and sing songs Usher, choir Sing, drum, and waiter in fellowship, UMM Everyone is friendly Worship leader, usher, attendance, also read scripture I just listen, usher, read scripture Choir, youth plays Choir Men’s choir, scripture reading Like when it’s praise time I would stand up and clap my hands Usher, youth Usher, cook Choir, usher I sing in the choir and I also usher rand dance I am in the choir, praise dance, usher board, communion stewardess, acolyte Choir, praise dance, help with the little kids Answering questions, giving questions, choir, dance, usher, acolyte, scripture I’m in the choir I sing in the choir every 3rd Sunday I sing in the choir every 3rd Sunday, I do praise dances I read the old and new testament every Sunday and I help coordinate the Sunday school class Singing 3rd Sunday youth choir We work on stuff in groups then present it in front of the church Sometimes I sing for Sunday school Sunday school, choir Choir, usher, liturgist Usually I sing in the choir, sometimes I usher I am in the choir 1st & 3rd Sunday, 5th Sunday is youth Sunday I usher and sing in the choir I go every day and every Sunday Lead worship, prayer, sometimes raise offerings, but mostly listening/discerning the presence of God and the move of God Singing, preaching Pastoral prayer, reading of scriptures, offering, sermon Sing, Pastoral prayer, welcome visitors, preach, give Benediction

SEJ (0-299 Members) 320

Pastor, singing, praising, preaching Various times: liturgist, child sermon, adult sermon, Sunday school, choir Sing, praise, give, listen and fellowship I attend Sunday school and church, sing in the choir most Sundays, and help with communion on the 1st Sunday I participate in Sunday worship by attending Sunday school regularly, attending worship service, collecting the offering in Sunday school However and where in any way that God leads my preparation Laity Praise & worship, prayer, PR I do what the congregation does, pray, sing from my pew, support programming/special programs Usher members, Education Ministry, PPRC Committee, alternate Lay member Praise & worship prayer, Sunday school, youth Worship Leader, Lay Speaker As an usher Serve as worship chairperson Sing in choir Sunday school, Worship service Sing in the choir, Praise & Worship Team Sing in the choir Liturgist, singer Choir, CD & Tape Ministry, van driver Sing in choir, Liturgist Member of Worship Committee, make announcements periodically, Liturgist, and Lay person Choir and committees Sing in choir and committees Liturgist, deliver sermons on occasion Choir member Choir, Lay Speaker, Sunday school substitute, women’s conference

What do you NOT like about what your church does in worship?

Too ritualistic The way they do the same thing all the time Nothing we do a lot Amount of announcements need to be minimize – move to screen going strictly by the program – boring at times Too much of announcements

SEJ (0-299 Members) 321

Routine, organ No new ideas, same songs, same message, lack of organization at times The call to worship It is not a fire as I would like. We are very traditional, we need a musician who can play contemporary music They don’t stand up clap they dry in church My church doesn’t get hyped like some other churches and haronilee does I don’t like it when it’s the same every Sunday Nothing really I say I like everything We sit there like we’re dead & too cute to get loose and praise him Time they do announcements and taking most of it out Old songs The sermon don’t relate to the world I cannot relate to the sermons Follow the same bulletin every Sunday I don’t like how the quite it is in my church I don’t like when people play around in church when something is going on Sometimes so much singing I enjoy hearing the word so I yearn for the message Lack of participation It’s not catered to youth/college students Too traditional Standing up all the time Nothing No freedom of praise Taking forever to do things We do the same thing every Sunday Most of the songs are not uplifting We do not have announcements and recognize our visitors by name at certain point in the service Nothing Do not understand what the pastor is talking about sometimes The lack of a spiritual atmosphere the service feels like we are just going through the motions, the spirit is very low Not understand the word When they talk about people Need to sing more song from this hymn Sometimes we skip day affirmation Lack of passion in service, lack of adequate music preparation

SEJ (0-299 Members) 322

Sing old songs Dance group during worship service to much gospel music during service Nothing to dislike I don’t know to be honest Our pastor is not trained Announcement “pop ups” Follow the program like it is every Sunday it keeps the church alive When out youth does not participate in service It’s to long and filled with beating around the bush for the word, I don’t understand the preacher sometimes Lack of participation I think that we let the spirit lead and guide us in the way of the lord I love all service I do not like that we do not have a long testimonial nor devotional service Boring music The announcements I like everything Have to wait for them to come up When our youth does not participate in service It is too long and filled with beating around the bush for the word, I don’t understand the preacher sometimes Lack of participation I think we let the sprit lead and guide us in the way of the Lord I love all service I do not like the way that we have a long testimonial nor conversational service Boring music The announcements I like everything Have to wait for them to come up Announcements “pop ups” Follow the program like it is every Sunday it keeps the church alive When our old preacher preached for a long time Sometimes seems to get repetitive Well, the Church really doesn’t have anything for the youth that’s actually fun It’s the same thing every Sunday, basically Too traditional It’s boring Not interactive

SEJ (0-299 Members) 323

It is not interactive I’m not sure I like everything my church does in worship It’s too long, and there is nothing for the youth N/A Seems only certain people are called on to do everything Too routine Routine- sometimes that’s a good thing Order of worship does not change That they stick to traditional and do not want to try anything new. The Pastor can’t grab everyone’s attention Nothing Our Church does not do outreach ministry as much as it should! It’s very routine, it can be boring at times There isn’t anything I didn’t like about my church’s worship Occasionally the length We need to begin singing more modern songs the youth can relate to They take too long and sometimes they go on a different subject when they are on one The offering right before communion makes visitor think they have to pay, I wish it was explained more Standard form of worship N/A Nothing, I love everything about my church Of the churches I attend there is only one church I do not like the order I like everything about my church My church service is boring and repetitive They have no energy I don’t know What I do not like is how every Sunday is the same Sometimes the music on the first and second Sunday the pianist only want to play from the hymnal Spend too much time on announcements Over concern with length of service Same boring moments Inconsistency in the music ministry Reading the announcements that are printed in the program They do not like to sing hymns and anthem, very good gospel mostly by ear and repeated phrases Not communicate well as to what is different in the service that day to liturgist, or on specific changes Everything too scheduled

SEJ (0-299 Members) 324

Boring, very quiet Too many traditional things It’s not a good service for teens Nothing On how long it is and less singing The youth don’t really have a role in the service Its boring Nothing Lack of youth participation Does not do the Psalter & Affirmation of faith Starts later than should, not on schedule The audience does not participate, when singing spirituals they don’t really get into the service Sometimes not enough congregation involvement On the 1st and 3rd Sundays the music is very dry and slow I think we focus too much on tradition We don’t sing enough hymns Nothing, I love worship My church try to end at a specific time, I feel like the spirit does not work by a clock I do not like it when get too wordy and redundant Announcements Too traditional Have persons in congregation to stand and give birthdays of everyone in family and not just their own Passing of the peace Meaningful music Not enough activity for youth and children I like my church Participation is low Nothing that much Welcome, praise& worship, closing Timeliness Long announcements, 4 choirs with little participation in all I would like to see one united choir Lack of free flow, distraction from service I’m relatively new and I’m just get acquainted, church went from full-time appt to part-time We still need growth in bringing multiple art forms into the worship experience Any dull boring moments

SEJ (0-299 Members) 325

Often times awkward flow, lack of connectedness, lulls, inadequate use of music Meet and greet Everything is good Too long Too long Its too long Too long I like everything Too long It’s all good Too long It is sometimes “dead” and the worship service goes the same way all the time Sing too many hymnals The average age 60-65 church is slowly dying, no young people, no music( with exception of clapping hands) I don’t have any specific gripes with my church Becoming more contemporary, drums not organs I don’t think anything is bad about church Music needs to change They are not hardly singing, doing nothing at my church I don’t like when people fuss a lot Singing hymnal Sing old boring songs When its boring I don’t like that there is no youth choir or youth ministry We sing the same songs over and over, we don’t have any classes just for the youth All of our songs are boring, they’re always slow, we never get excited I don’t like that our Sunday school is kind of boring and I don’t learn anything I like everything in my church I like everything Not let us text during worship How long the Pastor talks The Pastor exaggerates, like huffs and puffs when he’s not really saying anything Communion every Sunday Idk I like everything The traditional feel to it

SEJ (0-299 Members) 326

Don’t like how people talk during worship That there are not a lot of teens in the church Nothing They don’t pay as much attention to the youth as they do the adults He doesn’t relate to all age groups in sermon Not involving our youth every Sunday I don’t like how it’s the exact same order every service all the time, no matter what Sometimes I don’t know what my preacher is saying I don’t like how sometimes they point all the direction to the adults and they rarely communicate with the children and youth I think that many people speak in tongues Singing a song after each section and the amount of time each song takes I don’t like how some people talk when they aren’t supposed to I like everything what the church does in worship The faking of Holy Ghost Too predictable, stick strictly to the bulletin Preaching too long, people crying Sometimes I don’t understand some of the sermons, but most of the times I do get into it Some of the service is boring There’s nothing I didn’t like There’s nothing really not to like There isn’t anything not to like I don’t like that it is so organized and we never do anything new, I also don’t like there is no young people Fluctuates Lack of preparation, lack of knowledge of worship leader, inadequate rehearsals of choirs & musicians Nothing Children/ young adults need to take more leadership All of the walking that some do during service Too quiet, older members do not like open praise, younger members are leaving The flow of the service The quietness, the feeling of deadness I sometimes wonder if we are thankful or understand who we are responsible and belong to. Do they realize how good God has been? They seem not to get into the service until they’ve warmed up, don’t know hymns No praise music, can’t get in the feelings Doing the same thing often Working on “IT” Not any

SEJ (0-299 Members) 327

Praise & worship with songs and instruments N/A Lack of consistency in affirming our faith, turn to your neighbor and repeat (too often),inconsistency in protocol for prayer, when to come to the Alter Signifying from the Pulpit What I don’t like about worship service at my church is when the Pastor while preaching stops and says “look to your neighbor from right to left” Reading the announcements are not done in an orderly fashion, the Affirmation of Faith is omitted from Sunday services Facilities and play equipment for youth such as, basketball & tennis courts, recreation center for family use The calling of one out when we are all imperfect works in progress Sing Amazing Grace EVERY Sunday as the hymn of invitation-will change soon only been there since June 2010 Read every word of announcements Just appointed in June, haven’t witnessed any “don’t likes” yet Too much unnecessary movement and dead time Lack of blended practices

2. "Good Church"

Describe a “good” church service. (Is there one that stands out in your memory?)

A church that worship God in Spirit and truth A church that is filled with spiritual fire and the Holy Ghost When the sermon is powerful and what the pastor preach about relates to you and your issues A church service that does what I want No A good church service is one that moves according to the Holy Spirit Good upbeat choir, sermon that teaches and engages, one that people are happy Fresh and new service that stays on top of correct events and tailors to what is going on to the member’s lives. Good music with all instruments, good message from preacher, not to long of service Planned but open for spontaneous response, can move with the movement of the Holy Spirit When you get excited and you can remember what the preacher said It would have good preacher, a good style, and have people get happy all the time Getting loose! When the minister reaches someone that is lost or standing in the intersection and it made a different when service is not so When every age gets to be a part of service

SEJ (0-299 Members) 328

A service that gets the whole church active in praising Lots of praise and connection with young and old not just old and not just young Good sermon, music, would like REV. Steve to come visit Good sermon, music The service at Harambee 2010 When the spirit is working in me Good service is when people give there heart to God A service in which everyone can relate and learn something from that they can share with others Good music from the Hymnal followed by great message and congregational participation Good attendance, strong message, great praise and worship and outreaching church community, a committed pastor/reverend A service where you feel the power of God Can’t recall When the spirit is in the air and everyone love to praise Where you feel the Holy Sprit and it breaks you down and sets you free from sin Praise and worship time, freedom in praise When the speaker has fun with it and has demonstrations One that is lead by the Spirit My own God and I love him for that When the gospel is preached and the Lord speaks to me The songs they sang at church and also at Harambee The church that are here at the Harambee why? Because the pastor relates to everyone on every level Songs and praises and the message Congregation that worship in spirit people who love each other and vital Good singing good message On the 4th Sunday we have come as you are Sunday we sing songs from our u.m.tt and other old time hymn of praise to me that’s a good church service Singing shouting and understanding the word Our choir anniversary Story on Mary Martha and Jesus A note able presence of worshipers, with a well explained service that allows time for the spirit to flow Morning service well planned One that includes a visit from the Holy Spirit, and it’s apparent A service full of Gods praise without limitation People appear to be happy and enjoy serving God, music and all parts of service are genuinely present as worship to an adoring savor I feel that church service is good every Sunday at my church

SEJ (0-299 Members) 329

Recently youth entered sanctuary singing Joe Pace praise song. Congregation was excited, set a high praise and worship atmosphere excellent sermons A good church service that stands out in my memory is one where in we were very motivated and moved by the message that we shared it will all that we communicated with that day and week Great worshiping service and sermon The Holy communion o the 1st Sunday very well plan Family and friend’s day service, last year or year before our guest minister spoke a great word about family and I really enjoyed it. Looking for you – Kirk Franklin Follow the order of the United Methodist Church Everyone participate and fellowship When our kids participate in children’s moments, fifth Sunday service for youth Is one I listen 2 Youth Sundays When you praise God and you make it fun and dance and things like that here at Harambee The service I went to at my church This one. Anything that touches you. A great church service is one that has an outline and a conversational tone Everyone is not sleep, but standing up and praising. The preacher not just preaching but having a conversation with the people One where the Holy Spirit is always present. It guides us and lets us worship without any bounds or ties Everyone is awake and they have come to give praise – in other words God came with them The church services at last year’s Harambee and at a funeral when they were talking about being made out of iron. When we all worship with song and a good prayer moment (powerful) and there’s a good sermon that gets everyone interested and going Well, for me, good church service is when the youth participate in the service A good church is one who reaches out to the community to assist in spiritual needs, as well as, financial and emotional Involving all of the members in praising God and worship A good church service is one that has everyone involved and everyone can take something away from it When the singing is great and the Pastor appeals to everyone in the audience and all of the congregation is involved and uplifted Good singing, praising the Lord in word and song A good message Feeling the Holy Spirit, shouting and praising his name Harambee And Rev Steve When everything is good Don’t’ repeat the same service every Sunday A good church service is one that the Chapel gives When everybody is praising and worshiping God When the church is worshiping , no sermons

SEJ (0-299 Members) 330

When the church is all together A good church service is good music and also good worship One with an excited choir and congregation with a touching message A “good” service would be when the Pastor preaches about something everyone relates/ or can relate to Honestly, no One where there is high energy, the music is sung powerfully, and everyone is excited to be there When we had church service at Harambee A vibrant, spirit- filled, God-serving, mission focused people of God Great music, great preaching, powerful biblical worship, music that isn’t performance but music helps connect worshippers with God, connection with people, timely service( no more 1 ½ hours) Good singing with variety, testimonials well prepared, and effective preaching also balanced with liturgy, scripture singing and preaching, warm and authenticity with hospitality Every service is good and it is hopeful that the Holy Spirit will move us into better One that flows through the liturgy on the program and the spirit can be felt through the liturgy provideal A good church service to me is when we allow the Holy Spirit to take over, last Sunday service was a memorable one- the Senior Pastor preached a powerful message ”God specializes in things that seem impossible”, and the spirit moved freely throughout the congregation A good church service to me is when the Preacher preaches good and the music is good A good church service is when everyone can understand what the Preacher is saying and the music is really good It has a lot of energy, people are being touched, and people cry When everyone participates in the service A good church is when there’s a lot of energy and everybody is involved, also when everybody truly loves who they worship Thursday service The church service here at Bennett A “good” church service is when everyone is involved Song source, good preachery Song service, good preaching To me it’s when everybody in the church is jumping up in praise and crying for him like Thursday in Harambee Where the minister teaches preach and sometimes “simple example hand on things” A well open service which will give each person an opportunity to received the Holy Spirit for themselves A good worship service is one that reminds attendees to carry that word out in their lives, community and workplace freely A good church service is when everyone stands up and sings, also praise God, everyone or a majority goes up to the alter, everyone is happy When we had church on Hester Sunday, when we was worshiping his name When we have an inspiring sermon/morning message, I also like when we do a lyrical dance, most of our homecoming services have been great Praise and worship when it escalates to a high level and sets the tone for the service One that has good singing, the spirit is high and the word is good

SEJ (0-299 Members) 331

Diversity of music and leadership A service that clears all hearts and minds, encourages others to study the word of God, and to go and witness to make disciples of for “the Christ” When the entire congregation id collectively involved in praising, acknowledging, receiving the presence of God Hospitable & friendly, excellent music singers, good message without acrobatics When the preached word and song word and prayed word end up with a response of people coming to Christ The word of God is lifted up, not just the preaching or the singing New birth Charlotte A good church service is where we go through great lengths to involve all age groups in the various elements of worship, supports the scriptures and sermon One where there is evidence of planning, and spirit presence, theme and spirit occurs due to obedient prayer before, during, and after worship Sanctuary choir with organ music, high church Singing, praise team, teaching not screening Praise Starts on time, meaningful and spirit filled Prefer “great church” or “weak church” Great church –consistent bible teachings for leadership, mission minded, intentional in apportionment paying, desirable programs for children, youth and young adults Good preaching, singing, special worship moments, organized and planned Good music(gospel) A good church service does not go by a clock Good music, good sermon text, coming together on one accord Loads of hymns, prayer, sermon, invitation to Christ Praise & worship (choir and congregational), prayer(alter, etc), the word of God When I leave church feeling as though I’ve learned something A good church service is full of spirit, vibrant, and the Pastor has a very spiritual and uplifting service Involving the entire congregation Everyone is into the music and scriptures and the message from the Pastor Lead with good, vibrate, stimulating music Where the service is led by the Holy Spirit and we just go with the flow, good sermon When people confess, Christ testimonies, alter call in giving the invitation Music, sermon with 3 focal points A good service is where the music is good and everyone is into the worship Its not such a strict routine We sing songs that get everyone up and also the sermon is particularly moving and excites everyone A good church service is a short and sweet message with a strong meaning

SEJ (0-299 Members) 332

When the service is interactive A good church service in my opinion will have scripture, prayer, praise & worship, and alter calls A good church is when the youth get some attention Praise & worship, scripture, pray, sing, offering, sing, message; a good service is a service that draws the audience Loud music, up beat today music, preacher out reaching to youth Christmas and Easter One when you freely praise, move your cymbals and the word reaches your soul and you feel the nourishment of the teaching sinking in A good church service the liturgist is excited about leading the church service, the choir sing to the glory of God(best), the word is preached and the congregation responds The one today; Women Assembly St. Mark Church chicks Vibrant worship, great/inspiring preaching, transformational experiences Spirit moving preaching—relevant spirit moving music Creative worship using many art forms, color banners/video/dance/music to relate to all generations, good preaching Singing that everyone participates in, then the message makes sense and I can get something out of it When the choir sings good Planned presentation, congregation participation, and most importantly the presence of the Spirit of God 10:00 More youth participate 8:00 service Early service 8:00 service When they sing a lot One that starts with praise and worship filled with spirit The one that we had the other night, it was emotional and loving of God Brief praise period-gentle coming into the presence of the Lord, spirit filled altar call and prayer time, spirit filling music throughout the service, sermon that relates scripture to living today and guides a Christian’s journey Enthusiastic filled invitation to Discipleship that not only invites but strengthens and renews Spirit filled Bible based message with content, inspired singing with a message, depart with a challenge and message Spirit filled God serving and helping people, connect to God through singing and preaching a vibrant message There isn’t one that stands out in my memory The day I was baptized Just having fun A good church to me is on youth day To me a good one is a service that stands out from all the other services Everyone When the Holy Spirit arrives and the congregation recognizes it

SEJ (0-299 Members) 333

Building on the tradition of the church with youth involvement and participation A lot of songs and a power message When we do communion service, also on holidays like Father’s day and Mother’s day we have service for A good church service is when the choir sings good songs, and there is a good sermon Opening song, opening prayer, Announcements, song, word, invitation, distinguishing of candles, benediction A good church service is when you worship God in an uncontrollable way One where everybody sings praise & worship, the preacher uses illustrations and the congregation, I pretty much want a church service like Harambee When the preacher preaches a good sermon that affects the congregation When there’s lots of good music and the environment is good, the Pastor gives a good message he doesn’t have to yell necessarily but deliver an encouraging sermon Passion in the message yes A service that is interesting for all age groups When the preacher gets down and tries to touch everyone not just a select group of people Good sermon, good prayers, good music, not overly long for the sake of “minimum length”, flexible enough to vary from planned order of worship if so directed by the Spirit Thursday night at Harambee Chapel A church service where the preacher talks to us and not just preaches Where God is the center of attention and there is no earthly distractions, just serene and beautiful The one on Thursday where the youth are more involved with service A good church is whenever you worship God and pray and praise A good church service is where the Pastor explains the scripture without going all over the place, i.e. preaching and being able to follow the message The special days We sing, usher, and cook When everything is in order and planned out Everyone can do or say something When everyone got into all the songs that the children’s / youth choir sang When we sing A good church service isn’t routine and I would like the songs and the stuff we were talking about A song that’s interesting, a good praise dance, and a good and fun preacher When they sing a lot and don’t talk a lot, when they use drums to sing A good church service is when we don’t go by the program and everyone just worships and praises the Lord while doing certain steps on the program When we have about 3 to 5 people shouting The testimonies that everyone shared at Russ College

SEJ (0-299 Members) 334

Let everyone but actively I think our group leader stand out a lot A good church knows how to worship God, good songs, everything Great music to prepare for the word to be delivered Music and word coincide- everyone involved even if its nothing but a hand clap The hymns don’t drag on for eternity, the sermon is concise and relevant and it lets out on time A gathering of everybody, anniversaries, combined church service and a good speaker When we sing really good and I can relate to the sermon A good church service is when people are active and interested, there is good singing and the sermon actually reaches out to people One where it’s good from the beginning to end and there is a genuine sense of love & “Spirit” and music was inclusive, involved congregation and witness, strong presence of God One that reflect a burning in the hearts of all God’s children Sermon, music, and worship on one accord A service where congregation participates in service, i.e. singing, litany, etc. A good service is one that has a theme, continuity of music, scripture, message and sending forth The good and right word expressed, explained and affirming, witness, trust, love, community creating the nourishment & receiving a Holy Spirit hug Cooperation, participation, dedication, and community outreach When the service begins on time, things are decent and in order, text of the message from the Pastor is given and a well prepared sermon is delivered A good church service is when the Pastor’s message is such that I can follow, good choral selection, and the church service is decent and in order Call and response Where there is dissection of the scripture, this is where knowledge of the word is gained Timely, funny, emotional sermon; beautiful music, surprise involvement Spirit filled, well developed message, great song service When everyone was in the Spirit and everyone was worshipping the Lord in their own space, not worrying what the next person was doing Singing and praising God When everyone is on one accord worship God A church service that has a variety of worship styles Praising music in dance Praise & worship with participation from all in attendance, along with fellowship and rejoicing by everyone Welcomed, the word has gone forth, when the presence of God is felt, when we enter and feel the excitement and leave the same way to serve others A good church service is one where the Spirit is present A good church service is one that is well planned, everyone knows what they are to do and are timely and ready

SEJ (0-299 Members) 335

Good music good word Good praise & worship before service and good participation by all members The praise & worship service was at a high- the choir was dynamic and the Pastor came in with a dynamic message All are good Homecoming service Includes every generation, variety of music, makes it easy for visitors/non UM, length of worship is not too long, doesn’t tire or exhaust you Contemporary When everyone is prayed up, fasted up, on one accord and Shekinah Glory falls over the sanctuary; that’s good church

Which of the following is true about good worship services? (Circle all that apply.)

a. Organized/planned worship is important

148

b. Good worship can be planned

134

c. Good worship should be planned

111

d. The spiritual disciplines are preparation for good worship

142

e. Congregational singing is vital to good worship

191

SEJ (0-299 Members) 336

3. Music

What kind of songs do you sing at your church and who sings them?

Zion Songs Hymns, Gospel, Spirituals, Contemporary, We sing gospel and the choir sings Youth all types of songs Hymns, gospel, little contemporary, Senior choir, young adult choir, youth choir, praise team Usual Methodist songs choir leads Hymns, current songs on radio, old songs on radio Hymns and Gospel, mostly Gospel songs because we might not any music on Sundays Hymns, contemporary, spirituals, choir and congregation We have young and old songs Traditional songs and other songs We sing Leaning On, new songs, old songs, traditional songs Hymns and Gospel Lord prepare me to be a blessed, the leader Boring and dull songs that are not sang with emotions Gospel, hymnal, youth, youth adult, senior and congregation We start with hymns then the choir sings gospel songs Older songs, the whole church All kinds Choir sings ok songs All kinds, the whole congregation Old Spirituals, Contemporary Old spiritual and new songs Radio, gospel, hymnals All types of songs (diverse) Older Hymns, these songs are performed by the choir as well as the congregation All types/different leaders Lift our hands and blessed be the rock, Spiritually uplifting/ motivation Negro spirituals, Hymnals Up tempo and slow steady All kinds

SEJ (0-299 Members) 337

Old hymns, spirituals, hymns from the African American Heritage, depends on what choir is singing on what Sunday ( Gospel, Youth, Senior, Men’s, Women’s, and Main) Praise, hymnal, African American hymnal, negro spiritual, contemporary gospel The songs out of the hymnal, older songs, the combine choir Gospel mostly the adults 5 different choirs with all types of songs such as hymns, spirituals, up beat, and more Don’t know the names Hymnals, and up to date songs, youth, young adult, senior Up lifting songs and inspirational songs, choir and congregation To much gospel singing not much hymns Worship and song of praise, choir Rock of ages, do remember me , don’t let me miss heaven song by me We sing from the hymnal book and also gospel we have adult choir and we have youth and children’s choir and also male choir Hymns the choir Hymnals and Gospel Mostly black gospel music Gospel, Traditional, contemporary We sing old spirituals gospel songs and praise songs, the mass choir and youth choir sing them Hymns, contemporary gospel, negro spiritual, both the choir and the congregation participate at intervals Contemporary, traditional Contemporary, and Traditional Contemporary choir sings hymns and gospel traditional choir sing mostly hymns We sing songs from the United Methodist Hymnal and songs of Zion and gospel and negro spiritual songs Hymns-congregational gospel selections, negro spirituals, traditional African American songs, such as Jesus on Mainline Hymns are sang using the Methodist Hymnal and printed copies All kinds Some hymnals and gospel all the choir have different ones, we have a variety that leads them Good All kind of gospel song, the choir sings the songs Traditional hymns and Contemporary, congregation and choirs Hymnals I won’t complain ,Never would have made, Harvest Time The classics, Older members We sing uplifting songs and hymns Jesus Promised( I sing it), Spirit( another member), and The Glora Patria Hymns and spirituals

SEJ (0-299 Members) 338

Hymns, spirituals, and contemporary Contemporary and traditional along with Hymnal We sing African American Holy music…such as I will trust in the Lord. The whole church sings but mostly the choir Say Yes, Lean on Me, Souled Out, Jesus promised me a home Gospel songs (slow, fast, also the old time and modern) I sing in the youth choir, Voices of Bluff Road, and Pastor sings I Love the Lord, Got a Reason. Mostly the adults sing, but we get it in Church songs, everyone sings Order my steps- Gospel choir, Glory Glory-Kids choir, basically gospel music The whole congregation sings sometimes, and sometimes only the choir Hymnals, contemporary ,etc; all Good music, and the men or the women and the men Hymnal songs and the choir I don’t sing them Spiritual songs that skilled singers sing We sing spiritual songs Choir All songs All kinds Mainly old spirituals Gospel, hymns, choirs Gospel and traditional hymns Up beat songs and powerful slow gospel songs Gospel and gospel hip/hop We sing hymns as well as gospel songs Hymns, older praise and worship songs Gospel, different members of the choir to include myself as well as the Pastor We sing modern songs and the choir sings them Traditional hymns, hymns from the African American hymnal. Then our senior choir and youth choir will sing more modern songs Idk the choir sometimes sings many different songs The songs that we sing at my church are Jesus is a Rock, Nothing but the Blood, O How I Love Jesus, youth choir , Men’s and Women’s choir African American Heritage Hymnal, UM Hymnal only Gospel, Contemporary All types, the choirs individuals, etc Contemporary, Gospel, Hymnals Contemporary Hymnals and mostly old songs from the older people, the youth sing up-beat new songs

SEJ (0-299 Members) 339

The choir and well I don’t really know the name or the song, its a lot We sing all gospel hymnals Gospel songs…everybody The choir sings songs that are spiritual songs Church songs and everyone The choir sings the songs and they sing songs that involve Jesus and how he has blessed people Praise songs, spirituals, and a few hymns; the choir and congregation Hymns, gospel ,and spiritual Hymns and gospel- choir and congregation Congregational singing, primarily praise and worship, contemporary music, some hymns at different times Hymns, traditional gospel We sing multiple genres; contemporary, traditional, hymns, anthems arias, R & B Gospel, praise music, Latino, African American Songs from the standard UM hymnals, the songs of Zion, and contemporary gospel music, led by the choir director and praise & worship team Hymns, spirituals, gospels Songs of Zion, gospel, songs of praise Gospel (gospel choir), hymns(chancel choir), spirituals and other contemporary songs(men’s choir) Praise & worship and hymns, lead by a worship leader and or choir/praise team Blended, contemporary- traditional- hymns-gospels Praise music/spiritual songs from our praise team, choral opening is extended to the congregation join in singing, spiritual and hymns are important to our experience in worship Congregational choir praise, we use African American Heritage Hymnal, UMH and Zion regularly Hymns and gospel Hymns, spiritual, contemporary music Gospel Hymns, gospel, and contemporary gospel Gospel music by various choirs Spirituals, hymns, contemporary gospel Gospels, Songs of Zion, hymnal The choirs do most of the singing, we mostly sing gospel, spiritual and hip/hop gospel UM Hymnal, AA Spirituals, contemporary, Songs of Zion Six choirs(spiritual/inspirational songs) Men’s/ Young adult/ Youth/ Children/ Senior/ Adult, hymns- congregation Hymns, praise & worship, songs by choirs and congregational Contemporary, traditional

SEJ (0-299 Members) 340

First Sunday-Chancel choir sings hymns, 2nd & 4th Sunday-Gospel choir sings a variety of songs, 3rd Sunday- Men’s choir sings hymns, quartet style Methodist hymns, modern gospel We do hymns as well as gospel and some contemporary Soul stirring songs with the music from our keyboards, drums, and gospel choir Contemporary songs- Praise & worship team We are Marching Up to Zion, We are Gathering in his name, I am on the Battlefield for my Lord Gospel, hymns Gospel songs, the choir and congregation sings them Hymnals and the choir & congregation or Songs of Zion The choir mainly sings out of the hymnal and we join in The adults sing them and the sing slow gospel songs The songs of Jesus, AKA gospel, our choir Gospel and Christian pop Gospel, the choir and congregation Gospel; the choir Hymnals, a little contemporary They sing basically the same songs every Sunday The praise & worship team or the choir, hymnals, sometimes new songs Contemporary, hymns, spirituals, 2 choirs and congregation Hymns, gospel, contemporary Gospel singing, most anthems and hymns Gospel, hymns Hymns- congregation/choir, spirituals- choir, classical- choir Gospels songs and some hymns( not enough) Hymns, spirituals, traditional gospel/some modern gospel, youth live (urban hip/ hop), anthems, praise songs Hymns, gospel and traditional Gospel, praise, hymns, classical, negro spirituals, choirs and congregation Variety (traditional, gospel, spirituals, contemporary), choir and congregation Emmanuel, I am Souled Out, etc. I can’t explain Praise and worship songs, some foot stomping, hand clapping songs Hymns, contemporary and spiritual Hymns, spiritual and contemporary songs “Amen”, hymns Never Let Me Go, hymns, spirituals, and contemporary songs Amen

SEJ (0-299 Members) 341

The songs my church sings is gospel, and the choir sings them Jacob Ladder Hymns, spiritual and contemporary songs, the choir and Pastor Hymns, spiritual and contemporary, the choir Worship hymns, songs that were sang at previous anniversaries, the youth choir and gospel choir sang the songs Our church sings a lot of quick beat music, but we also sing a lot of hymnals, most of the same people sing all the time We sing hymnals and radio gospel songs Hymnals and gospels, the adult choir and the youth choir on 4th Sundays Old songs ( 4-5 yrs old), the congregation or choir ( youth combined) Lift Him Up, Blessed Assurance, To God Be the Glory, Psalm 23, sung alternatively by the senior choir, Kelley Memorial choir and /or Inspirational choir Contemporary gospel Hymns, choir and congregation This is My Story, choir; Jesus Loves Me, kindergarten class O Come Let Us Adore Him, We Praise You O Lord; the youth, adult and silver tones Good Hymnals and old people Old boring songs and old people Same songs every Sunday Old slow Methodist songs and the Senior choir sings them We sing We always sing hymns and they are always very slow and boring We sing slow songs like hymns that are boring Our youth choir and all different kinds Hymnal song, whole congregation; modern gospel music, children’s youth choir Hymnal songs and congregation and youth songs Hymnal songs We sing gospel songs and one sings them is Mrs. Pole All gospel songs, the choir The choir, every gospel song in the book From the hymnal, mixed, men’s, women and children’s choir Gospel songs about the Lord and the youth sings them sometime the adult choir More traditional songs, the older men Contemporary/old school soulful musical songs A variety Traditional hymns (UMH) Anthems, choir and congregation; inspirational and adult choir- contemporary/ popular gospel

SEJ (0-299 Members) 342

Up beat not too many hymnals Hymns and gospel, choir and congregation Up beat happy songs and also songs that are slow but still uplifting and those in the choir sing Some hymnal songs and some songs from the radio…all the choirs sing hymnal songs a lot but mostly only the Voices of Praise ( youth choir) the ST. James Ensemble( young adults) sing songs off the radio Because He Lives, My Hope is Built Same songs same singers I Got a Reason to Praise the Lord, I’m Excited, Excellent, and Move Mountain Hymnals, same person every time A Reason to Praise the Lord, Bless the Lord with Me, the choir sings it and the people in the audience A Reason, Nobody, Excellent; the choir Some traditional, other gospel songs Praise & worship, choir; songs from the hymnal, the congregation Gospel, gospel rap Kirk Franklin, Mary Mary, and others from the hymnal We sing songs from the hymnal, choir sings them Hymns and regular gospel songs ( Kirk Franklin, Marvin Sapp, Tye Tibbett) Sing hymns, radio gospels what the Holy Spirit leads us to sing, sometimes what we plan is not what we sing Spirituals as Anthems weekly, hymns, youth choir- age appropriate Gospel, hymns, praise, Anthems; choir and congregation Conventional variety Choir and congregation sing, we sing a variety of songs Some hymns and tradition; the choir Hymns, Gospel and contemporary All kinds Spiritual, Gospel, and hymns Gospel, choir/soloist; hymns, congregation; contemporary, choir/congregation We do hymns, gospel, and contemporary Gospel sometimes, hymnals a lot, contemporary Gospels, hymns, and contemporary; the choir Three choirs: children/youth choir 2nd Sunday, 1st Sundays choir service 9:30 a.m., 3rd Sunday Gospel choir Songs Zion, UM Hymnal Hymns, Gospel, Traditional Choirs(Male, Youth, Mass), sometimes the Pastor sings a solo, Gospel, Praise & worship and soft instrumental A mixture of hymns and gospel combined with Anthems Formal hymnal, old spirituals, contemporary ( 3 choirs)

SEJ (0-299 Members) 343

Traditional spirituals and contemporary hymns; adult and male choirs Anthems, Gospel A number of blended songs, Praise Team, congregation, spiritual by song leaders I sing a variety of songs, choir , Pastor and congregation sing the songs The songs awe sing at our church are mostly Gospel, hymns(although I’d like to see more hymns done), soloists from alto, soprano, and tenor sections of our choir, Pastor and congregation Traditional hymns New Gospel music Diverse praise & worship, hymns, contemporary, Gospel Hymns from the UMC Hymnal, Songs of Zion, the AAHH, Gospels and some classical liturgical songs, all songs are sung by choir and congregation Contemporary, hymnal (Methodist) Hymns are from the Zion’s Sing and UMH, Gospels Hymns, spirituals, contemporary, Songs of Zion, choirs, soloists, musicians, men & women, congregation Contemporary and Traditional

In our church, the CONGREGATION sings an average of: (Check one)

1-2 songs per service

3-4 songs per service

127

More than 4 songs

Fewer than 2 songs

SEJ (0-299 Members) 344

How do you feel about the way instruments are used in your church?

I feel very good about God said to praise him with instruments I think they could use the drums more Most cannot play hymnals well or can play hymns and not the other staff we need some who can play both very well I like them all Good our church has organs, drums, tambourines Good We could use more instruments Like the piano and drums We do not use as many as I would like we have piano, keyboard, drums and guitar We need a better drummer We need more musicians We need new drum mist for youth choir Good because it sounds really good I feel great Besides the piano everything sounds a mess Joyful I feel we are very well It’s okay They are used in a good way They are ok It’s okay We have a great music team They help the service Good because we have people that have the right talent to play the instruments I feel they are used good Very well usage I enjoy how instruments are used in the church Happy they utilize their resource wisely They are used to our fullest extent Could use more That they move others Depends I am very traditional Great

SEJ (0-299 Members) 345

Very good I enjoy great about instruments Psalm 150 Instruments used just fine I like it when they play the piano Fine Good Good I myself love the instruments that we use Good I feel the two that we have is vey important they help us a lot Only using piano now need more instruments The piano is a good compliment to singing however the drums can be loud I think drums, guitar, piano, organ really enhance worship No instruments but use what we have like cd music , radio and our mouths Good drums, piano, organ add to service along with keyboards I feel very good about the musical instruments that are use in our church We use the piano, keyboard, drums, and sometimes the organ. We enjoy them all We do not have a musician I feel good about it We have drums and guitar, we lack in instruments playing, the guitarist is constantly out of tune We only have an organ and a piano They are ok, could be better I like them and think they are very important I feel they add more to the music Okay I feel it gives spirituality to the service. It helps everyone get into the service spiritually. I love our instruments, especially the piano Well we only have one piano player and he is wonderful It sounds okay Good Very good I enjoy them They are good and great They are amazing I like the instruments in our church, it keeps the songs going They are used pretty good

SEJ (0-299 Members) 346

I feel they could be used better, more energetically They’re used appropriately Very well, I enjoy! That they are used very well I feel they are very uplifting I feel good about them, they make the church more alive Good Good they are good Wish we had more than an organ or piano It’s moving in the right direction, opening to other instrument other than piano and organ Great Good, instruments are a vital part of our worship A piano and drums are used, but they are not uplifting unless our youth choir’s singing They really use them in an effective way Our church only uses the piano regularly, we do have drums but nobody to play them each Sunday Need a full time musician Instruments are very important-music executed well, makes the worship service enjoyable Good-wish we could expand and consistency Instruments are good Feel good about it, the other instruments should be uncovered and used I like the instruments I feel the instruments are used well but the people sometimes mess up the music I feel like the instruments are used very well I love them and there is a wide variety of them I think its good to use them I think they are used to their full advantage They are the average instruments We have really good instruments We need new instruments, such as drums and a piano Good Excellent Excellent Good this is part of making a joyful noise unto the Lord Instruments add greatly to worship We only use a piano-no instruments however, I think it assist in lifting the spirit I loved the way are used in church, they make you wanna stand up and praise…especially drums

SEJ (0-299 Members) 347

The instruments are used to worship his name and to take use in prayer I love the way the organ, piano, and drums are used in each service Good They are an addition to the betterment of the service Currently instruments are not used at my church I like many instruments but it can over power the voices We only have piano, I love the drums and tambourine I am comfortable with all instruments used I enjoy incorporating many different Love instruments Very good about the instruments they enhance the singing of the choir Good when available Some people use them They aren’t used to their full potential but I still enjoy the use of them during worship service I like it I like them I enjoy hearing how they’re played to help get people enthusiastic The same as when I hear a band, sounds good Its cool I’m the only instrument other than the organ and piano Inspirational Enjoy them Instruments help the beat of the songs, instruments help get the congregation moving- it adds something to the heart They are used very well, not too loud Sometimes good I feel that my church needs to use more instruments other than piano We have drums, piano, and occasional organ, I feel we can do more They’re fine ( piano/organ/drums) Excellent ( drums, keyboard, guitars) The instruments are too loud Great Uses a piano that does a lot of things Enhance service Love them…piano, organ, drums, guitar, tambourine We only have piano and organ Good

SEJ (0-299 Members) 348

I like it, the Bible says make a joyful noise unto the Lord We only use piano and organ at this time Ok with taste I feel very good about the use of our music instruments in our churches We can’t have them The more the better I would like a real set of drums instead of a drum box. I would like all the instruments instead of the machine that plays them Utilization of instruments used is okay- but would like additional accompaniment such as tenor guitar, and bass I only have organ, piano, and drums however; I pray God will send violin, guitar, and something woodwind The church needs traditional musicians Wonderful, it adds vitality and rhythm, enhances all we do I would like to see more strings, horns, DJ They are well used in support of the music ministry Inadequate, I wish the organ was used regularly, I wish the music flowed throughout the service more I feel that its used in its best potential Good Good Good All good Good I feel fine about the way the instruments are used in my church Good, kind of loud I think the instruments are used properly Our musician is dealing with an illness right now, so there isn’t any kind of music They are being used well in the right way Very well played I feel great about the way instruments are used in my church I feel that instruments at my church are great They are awesome Instruments add to the worship These are good enough Good, the drummer and piano player do a very good job I feel fine about the way instruments are used in my church I feel great about the way they are being used I love the way our instruments are being used even though we only have a drum set and organ It be so loud

SEJ (0-299 Members) 349

I like it They’re okay, I guess, they are basic instruments like the piano and drums Very positive Good Yes could use more In a positive way that inspires most who listen Its very little I wish we had more trumpets, trombones and a bass guitar I feel good about it okay good Great I love the piano, keyboards but not the drums I like the instruments in our church I feel that instruments are used well at church, but could be better if the youth tried it I feel great about it I really like it They make the song sound better I like the way they’re used I guess, we really only have drums and piano I really don’t like just using a piano I don’t like the way that they only use a piano or an organ when we sing They play the drums, piano, etc. very well and it really brings the sound out of the choir I feel like the right people are playing the right instruments The organ is not necessary Good I think they help very well We need horns, guitars More glory to God Fine it’s not like the instruments are thrown at people Ha Ha ! there are no musicians currently so we just clap along We don’t really have a wide variety of instruments but I do feel we use the ones we have well I like them I feel like the instruments in our church are the best things

SEJ (0-299 Members) 350

Good but we need a new drum set I think the way instruments are used in church are great I wish that my church can do the same thing They are used good I feel like it touches me more with the music We use the piano, organ and sometimes drums; I would like to incorporate some brass and woodwinds Use only the piano, could use drums Love it! Guitar, keyboard, piano, organ, drums, tambourine; good mix/ blend, soloist sometimes Very good we have a mixture of instruments Excited! Wish we had more we’re incorporated, we have no musicians Need to practice more N/A We don’t use any instruments, but I do like them We need someone on keyboards and drums Love different instruments Love them and they have a place during worship; drums, piano, keyboards, organ Good I feel that instruments are important they help with getting in the feeling I like a variety of instruments that blend together Good about it Need to use them more Great! I like it, I also love a cappella Drums and keyboards are acceptable Excellent Love the idea I feel good about the instruments at my church I feel that instruments are a vital part in church service, as along as they don’t overshadow the soloist I think all instruments can be used to worship through music- it is good Some do not approve of loud drums and tambourine

SEJ (0-299 Members) 351

4. Hymnal/Worship Resources

My church uses ____ hymnbooks regularly in worship

NONE 8 ONE 68 TWO 42 THREE 16 FOUR + 21

Circle all that apply:

a. My church uses our denominational hymnal 155

b. My church uses a hymnal other than our denominational hymnal 70

c. Hymns are an important contribution to the church 153

d. Hymns teach our religious faith's theologies and doctrines 104

e. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my religious heritage 118

f. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my ethnic heritage 88

g. My church uses our hymnbook at services other than Sunday morning 100

h. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my racial heritage 82

SEJ (0-299 Members) 352

Where do you get your resources for the kind of worship experience in your church?

Christian book stores From the bible Order of worship, Cokesbury The Methodist Bookstore Supply GBOD, other churches, internet, Africana worship workshop, African- Am Heritage hymnal, tradition I don’t really speak Adults Saving souls and keeping members Sunday school and youth meetings I get my resources from the pastor and the members of the church The Holy Bible The community Pastor, bring from home Christian education course, personal relationship with God The bulletin My pastor Cokesbury, Life way, Family Christian, Pastor Tithes and offering also with the church conference Parents Cokesbury Cokesbury Going to different workshop in our district and order from Cokesbury UMC Cokesbury bookstore, sheet music, contemporary songs Local Christian Book Store, songs of praise youth hymnal, UMC Hymnal old and new Cokesbury Black book stores, online All resources listed above Programs handed out when come in the door, church calendars, reminders from members From other churches Cokesbury From our Pastor and the Bishops My Preacher Worship Committee

SEJ (0-299 Members) 353

Cokesbury, worship books Methodist Publishing House Cokesbury, but we always use pg. 890, pg. 880 From the Church We use the Bible, the internet, Songs of Zion songbook(African/American Hymns), overhead projector, and members input N/A Cokesbury, other Christian bookstores Cokesbury The Pastor From Ministries From the Minister Other church services, t.v., radio I’m not sure I’m really not sure My grandma, mother, father, and other family Idk I’m not sure of the correct answer to this question. I assume we order most of our resource via website Idk Cokesbury From the UMC worship book, and other resources Cokesbury store Cokesbury Cokesbury The Pastor(Bishop), and the bible I get my resources from the bible and my Pastor Cokesbury, for VBS we use Urban Ministries material Hymnals and other resources Cokesbury Baptist hymnal, Pentacostal hymnal, some UMC hymnals, on-line music resources Hymn book, book of worship, spontaneity We wind up developing our own resources for the worship as we span traditional to “new church” worship models We use the UM Hymnal, Songs of Praise, Zion Sings, we use an overhead projector with words Holy scriptures, and inspiration of the Holy Spirit Urban Ministries and Cokesbury Various song books, many are afro centric Cokesbury, Lifeway, Cedar Springs, and Christian book stores

SEJ (0-299 Members) 354

Internet and software Online music, Lifeway Cokesbury Bookstore, gospel music store Cokesbury Cokesbury, GBOD Cokesbury, off the radio, and cd Cokesbury We use many songs from the African Heritage Hymnal (copies) The five principals of a Cokesbury N/A Cokesbury We use traditional methods and from Cokesbury Cokesbury Minister of Music is in charge of worship music Book of worship hymnal Our Pastor and the Bible I don’t know The Bible and my church elders My Pastor and the Bible Other churches By going to another church Cokesbury, Laity, bible classes, Sunday school Hymnal, Book of worship, internet Cokesbury Denominational resources Cokesbury Some from UMC and other resources Get resources for the Pastor Pastor White Pastor Our Pastor Cokesbury , UM resource centers, music stores, and other Christian Ministry related resource centers UMC and other sources Hymn book, Book of Worship The congregation and the Pastor

SEJ (0-299 Members) 355

The Bible and past events Family, friends, walk-ins, donations and offering Radio, fellow choir members We listen to the cd or the tape and learn it By going to other churches My hymn book and the Bible I really don’t know I don’t know Bible studies The Bible, Sunday school, Bible study Pastor Tithes I don’t know The Bible and topics inside the verses I have no clue but if I did it would be from my Pastor Music Directors (?) Pastor I really don’t know Cokesbury Cokesbury I get them from the Bible The Bible The Bible By mouth, internet I get my resources from the pastor, choir, and the Bible The Holy Spirit and the will of God to serve him My resources for the kind of worship experienced in my church stems from early years of dedication to the Methodist Church, the Methodist tradition of worship has been of great influence to me My worship experience comes from my background study of the Bible Cokesbury Cokesbury Not sure Cokesbury and the internet Cokesbury Hymnal Book of Worship, Worship workbook Budget, spiritual gifts, outreach

SEJ (0-299 Members) 356

Prayer lead by the spirit, connection to the congregation based on their needs Songs on CD, sheet music Reading and Pastoral leadership Cokesbury Leading of the Holy Spirit through Pastor and worship leaders Cokesbury Cokesbury, Family Life, iTunes, internet, liked hymns(radio/ television influence) Most are obtained from Cokesbury

5. Worship Traditions

What are some of the worship traditions that have been passed down in your church?

Bible, Hymn books Usher’s, Anniversary, women’s day, men’s day, choir anniversary Printed bulletins, Hymn Fellowship afterward Old time religions Hymnals Singing the old hymns, reciting the apostle creed, book of worship is used to plan service Candlelight Holy communion, 4th Sunday mission, 2nd building fund, each Sunday a different choir sings Worship tradition are good but we must change Evelyn Jackson Tea N/A Singing Family nights Evening service, communion(1st Sunday),standing & sitting Old time religion, testimony Black traditional worship Following a program New Year’s Eve service Old song Welcome song, hymn singing

SEJ (0-299 Members) 357

Testimonial services Been there starting 7/01/09 Engaging ourselves through vocal intercom (call- members, from pupil to pupil) Preaching/music/affirmation/fellowship Testimonies and old time religion Praise, Lord’s Prayer, alter call, offering, communion, invitation to Discipleship Responsive reading, group alter call The choir marches in singing Kids run the service every 3rd Sunday (except preach) Church for children, 12 and under I don’t know this one either Communion Instruments Don’t know cam e from Baptist doctrine The light of Christ, 1st Sunday Communion Devotion, Affirmation of faith, same order of service Yes

Describe the special days that are observed in your congregation (e.g. Ushers' or Annual Day, Women's Day, Men's Day, etc.) What resources do you use to plan for special days?

We have a women’s and men’s day contest to win gifts We do a lot like women’s day, men’s day, cook on fathers day women cook, usher day every usher from different church comes Mothers Day program, revivals Women’s Day, Mothers Day, homecoming, Fathers Day, Youth Sunday, Grad Sunday We observed everything 1 thing children’s day and Fathers Day All of the above and Homecoming, Revival, Church Anniversary Fathers Day is fun along with Easter Food Our church homecoming, at homecoming we celebrate the year the church was founded and other events, we have people bring food in United Methodist Women’s Day, Friends and Family, Homecoming Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Ushers Anniversary, Children’s Sabbath Children’s Sabbath, Ushers, Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Youth Explosion Men’s Day, Women’s Day, Choir Day

SEJ (0-299 Members) 358

Usher Women’s Day, College Sundays, Youth Sunday Paine College Founders Day, Convocation None Women’s Day, Men’s Day, , Harvest Women’s Day, Men’s Day Usher’s Annual Day, Women’s Day, Men’s Day; the book of worship Women’s Day, Men’s Day Black History, students day, Mothers Day, Fathers Day, Annual Day, Women’s Day and Men’s Day Usher’s Day, Women’s Day, and men’s day are observed in our congregation the usher’s plan their programs the um women plan the program for the women’s day Annual Homecoming, Revival, Children fun Day it is carefully plan with members and pastor Women’s and Men Day, Homecoming Church Anniversary, Choir Day Men’s Day, women’s Day, Easter, Christmas, Thanksgiving Easter, Christmas, Mothers Day, Fathers Day, with black history programs and health moments All the above and Homecoming, Easter, youth Church Anniversary We have someone that plans out the days and hands out programs for those days as well as regular church worship Our service are well planned Heritage Sunday, Black History Month, Laity Sunday, United Methodist Women’s Day, Youth Day Meetings UM Women’s Day and UM Men’s Day, and Women In White Women’s Day, Men’s Day , and Vacation Bible School Response The women and the men do the planning along with the Pastor and worship committee All the above and Pastor Appreciation A committee and the Pastor Collesburg Women’s day, Men’s day, homecoming, Trustee’s day, Veteran’s day, student recognition day We contact outside speakers for most of these days, we also have special hymns and prayers we do on these days Women’s day, Men’s day, Homecoming, Revival, and Children’s day None

SEJ (0-299 Members) 359

Having children sing in the choir, Women’s day, Men’s day, and having Ushers Ideas from members and from other churches Youth Sunday, Men’s and Women’s day, Trustee day, student recognition, Cokesbury and ABM Usher Anniversary, Choir Anniversary, Women’s day, and holidays Children’s time Youth Sunday I don’t know Women’s day, I don’t know Vacation Bible school, Men’s day, Women’s day… Women’s day- women are honored and celebrated, Men’s day- men are honored and celebrated, there are committees that help plan these Family nights, food, games, and praise and worship Men’s day, Choir day, Women’s day, Children and Youth Sunday, Black History day, Mother’s day, Father’s day These days are assigned to a committee to plan, and then parts are assigned to different members of the church

These days are spirit filled and enjoyable, attendance is good

Women’s day, Men’s day, Church anniversary, Youth day Birthday Tea, Women’s day, Men’s day, Church anniversary, Youth day Women’s day, Men’s day, Homecoming, Choir anniversary, Youth day Men’s day, UMW day, Easter, Christmas, Mother’s day, Children and Grandparents days, Choir anniversary, Father’s day. Church anniversary Revival services, Easter or Lent, services with both black congregations and exchange of preachers, women in the pulpit Sunday Usher, Children, Sabbath, Men’s and Women’s days The ideas come from the people in the church Women’s and Men’s days Food, grills, cookouts, presents and elders usually plan it They use charts and they have meetings so that all of the events come out right Men’s day, Women’s day, Grandparents day, student recognition day, one great hour of sharing, Pastor’s appreciation, watch night, Harvest day, Usher appreciation. We use provided materials from Cokesbury or the planned outline from our Pastor Following previous traditions N/A Celebrate advent and Lent seasons, used GBOD Upper Room resources to assist in services planning Veteran’s day, Women’s weekend Church anniversary, Easter program, Christmas program, Revival Martin Luther King, Jr. prayer breakfast ,Black/Heritage service, Easter Sunday, Palm Sunday, Feast in the Upper Room Father’s, men’s, and Mother’s Day services, Homecoming, Harvest rally, Church Anniversary, Revivals, International Tea, Watch Night service We area new start and have yet to establish any traditional days None of the above, basically liturgical seasons. However many resources are used to enhance the service, network along with UMC resources

SEJ (0-299 Members) 360

Founders day, Men’s and Women’s days Men’s day, Women’s day, Cancer Awareness promotions, Homecoming Christmas Eve is the only tradition currently Women’s day, Men’s day, Homecoming, we use the internet, worship pioneer, and the Holy Spirit, hymnals All listed in the example plus Heritage, Founders, Harvest Sunday, Revival, Youth & Children’s days Women’s day, Mother’s and Father’s day, Easter, and Christmas services Church Anniversary, Homecoming, Friend and Family day Women’s day Women’s day, Men’s day, Children’s day, UMW Women’s day, Men’s day, Hymnal Women’s day, Men’s day, Church Anniversary Women’s day, Men’s day, Homecoming, Good Friday We do have special programs for all of the above We have Women’s day, Men’s day, Usher’s day, Homecoming, Church Anniversary Usher day, women’s day, men’s day, Black History, children Sabbath, Choir day, all of the UM special Sundays, some from UM resources, Book of worship, AA resources Ushers program, UMW day, choir anniversary, praise team anniversaries The Lord’s prayer used to be sung every Sunday( it was just based on tradition), Women’s day is special at our church, the men cook for our women and participate in an honoring ceremony Usher’s Homecoming- invites another church to come and provide service, same for women’s day Women’s day, always sponsored by the United Methodist Women, we use a variety of resources; speakers from other denominations Youth Day Women’s day, our heritage on a common sense basis, men’s day, Mother’s day, Father’s day, UMW, Youth Sunrise, New Year’s Eve, The birth of Christ I don’t know Women’s day, Men’s day, and I forget like 2 Men’s day, Women’s day Women’s day, Jubilee is like church anniversary Women’s day, Christmas, Jubliee (homecoming, church anniversary) Easter Choir day, UMW day Homecoming, Women’s day, Men’s day Women’s day, Men’s day, Trustees day and Homecoming, youth and young adults Sunday Women’s day, Men’s day, church anniversary, Friend & Family day Women’s day and Men’s day Women’s day, Men’s day, Pastor’s day, Dancer’s day

SEJ (0-299 Members) 361

Women’s day, and Men’s day Women’s day, Men’s day and annual dancing We use leader to plan the special days We usually bring or make food Women’s day, Men’s day, Family and Friends day, Pastor anniversary There are sometimes meetings held after church services UMW special Sunday, sometimes Black History, Ash Wednesday, Maundy Thursday, Good Friday, Easter, Thanksgiving, Christmas, Mother’s and Father’s day, Laity Sunday, Watch Night, we use the Bible, hymnals, leadership guides, offering envelopes, order of service program Revival, church anniversary Women’s day, Men’s day, Usher annual program, Revival, Youth revival, special choir days Women’s day is good you wear all white, Men’s day they wear like red and white and that’s about it Usher’s day, Women’s Day, Men’s Day ; I don’t know how they plan them but it happens some how Usher’s Day, Women’s Day, Men’s Day ; we usually have a dinner after the service on Mother’s and Father’s Day, we also have ushers Mother’s Day, Easter, Christmas- we have speeches plays and dinner, we sing and a lot of visitors sing Women’s Day every year the women do the whole ceremony and our Pastor picks a woman to lead the service and a dinner is later held Video, keyboards, drums Usher’s Day, Women’s and Men’s Day; invite cards, placement in bulletin Women’s Day, Men’s Day, birthdays and anniversaries Homecoming, Men’s Day, Women’s Day and the Kwanza; we use the UM Hymnal, the Songs of Zion, the African American Hymnal and assorted cd Youth Day, Women’s Day, Men’s Day and the SBC Women’s Day and its symbol with color is red and white Usher’s and Church anniversary, and women in red, men in black On Women’s Day my church will give the elderly mothers a gift, also the children will give flowers to their moms Women’s Day – remember all mothers Father’s Day- remember all fathers Youth Day, Children’s Day, homecoming Usher’s anniversary, Women’s Day, Men’s Day, children’s worship, various hymnals, tradition, internet Men’s Day, Women’s Day, casual Day, Youth Day Bulletins weekly, holidays are important to the church We sing and do plays Harvest, Men’s Day, Women’s Day, Youth Day, resources provided by the church Women’s day, Men’s Day, Youth Harvest, Harvest, Easter, Christmas Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Youth Harvest, Harvest, Easter, Christmas Youth Day, Men’s Day, Women’s Day Mother’s Day, Thanksgiving, Christmas, Laity Day, Pastor’s Appreciation, Revival, Black History, Easter, Graduation, Homecoming

SEJ (0-299 Members) 362

Unite Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Youth Day, Harvest Sunday, pastor Appreciation Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Mother’s Day, Father’s Day, Pastor Appreciation and anniversary, choir day, youth day; done by committees and past practices We recognize and appreciate the men, women, choir members, family and friends Different work areas sponsor the above days Work areas promote their programs Women’s and Men’s Day are celebrated with a program once a year, each ministry has a planned program with a speaker and songs of praise & worship Every holiday is observed in my church Homecoming, Women’s Day, Men’s Day We celebrate a lot of appreciation programs, usually there is a speaker, music, and food served afterward Harvest, Women’s Day, Men’s Day Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Pastor appreciation Youth Harvest, Annual Harvest, Youth Day, Christmas, Thanksgiving Men’s Day, Women’s Day Taste of St. James is an annual event that we invite everybody to come and eat different things Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Church anniversary, Usher’s Day, Relay for Life, Mother’s Day, Watch Night, Easter, Christmas Usher’s anniversary Usher’s or Annual Day, Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Friends and family Day Children’s Day, Mother’s Day, Father’s Day, Easter, and Christmas Women’s Day, Gospel Jamboree, Founders Day(old time day)- planning committees Men’s/Women’s Day, Easter play, Black History Month, choir celebration-xmas I do not have the discretion to make such decisions, if asked I will be prayerful and creative Women’s Day, Men’s Day Traditions handed down in my church are Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Christmas Concert, Revival The specific days observed at my church are Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Choir Concert, these special events are used for fundraisers so as to help those that are in need. Some money used for these events comes from the treasure of each organization We use the word of God for our foundation, the purpose of the activity or celebration is to draw others to Christ Things that come through the resources of the UMC centers Usher’s, Women’s and Men’s Days, Homecoming, anniversaries Homecoming-hymn books, Women’s and Men’s Day, Women in the Pulpit Sunday, UM resources Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Mother’s Day, Father’s Day, Pastor Anniversary UMW Resource Workbook Armed Forces, Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Youth Day, Mother’s and Father’s Day Watch Night, funerals, Baccalaureate, Family week ends with Family Day, Church Anniversary, Memorial Service My resources are “why are we doing this?” How long? Is it traditional or religious?

SEJ (0-299 Members) 363

Annual or Usher’s Day, Family & Friends Day, Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Children’s Sabbath, Christmas Cantata Labor Day, Holy Week Services, Revival

SEJ (0-299 Members) 364

300+ - Membership & Worship Attendance -- SEJ

Jurisdiction North Central North Eastern South Central Southeastern 99 Western

Clergy or Laity Clergy 11 Laity 88

What is the approximately membership of your church? Under 100 100 - 199 200 – 299 300 – 499 44 500 – 749 6 750 – 999 6 1000+ 13

What is the approximate total Sunday worship attendance at your church? Under 100 1 100 – 199 28 200 – 299 18 300 – 499 10 500 – 749 6 750 – 999 1000+

SEJ (300+ Members) 365

1. Worship Practices

How do you participate in Sunday worship?

Worship leader; preacher I plan it Worship leader, preach Preach Worship each Sunday when in town Senior Pastor, plan worship with Committee, Altar Guild, ushers and musicians Attend Usher, choir Worship Leader Primarily from the pew Devotion, Praise & Worship Team, Young President Sing in one of the 3 choirs Communion steward; liturgist; usher Lay speaker, Choir Liturgist; Lay Reader, Communion Steward, Chair of Worship & Celebration Ministry Choir Conduct the announcements and I welcome visitors every other month. By attending each Sunday Visits & attendance Prayer Prayer, song Celebration of worship includes dynamic praise, exhortive (sp?) preaching and anointing music Sing in choir Lead Worship Service, choir member, sermon 2 times yr. Sing/work on worship work area with planning Lay Speaker, Worship Chairperson, UMW Usher Choir Member Worship; prayer; Breakfast Ministry; Sunday School

SEJ (300+ Members) 366

Singing, prayer, meditating, reading scripture Ministry team Singing, dancing & giving praise Sing on the choir, read scriptures, praise dance, speak I sing on the choir Choir, lay speaking I am sometimes the host, I sing in the choir Depending on which Sunday, sometimes I dance or participate in service like reading scripture. Youth President. Singing, dancing Sing with choir. In all aspects - varies Sometimes I am in the pulpit or singing, or ushering, or acolyting, or working in the sound booth. Singing in the choir, praise dancing, participating in scriptures. Choir/Usher Board I am the communicator coordinator and I also do children/youth ministry once a month. I come to church and listen. I sing and dance. I clap and go up and put money in the collection plate. Dance, praise, scripture I put money in the collection plate Singing, Praise, Dance Dance, Sunday School Singing, dancing, readings I come to church to learn more about God I am an acolyte and I sing in the choir. Sing on the choir, usher, go to Sunday School Sing in the choir By dancing and having bake sale after church service Sing, dance, usher, play in bell choir, direct children's bell choir, hostess I go in expecting God to show up - go in praising - sing in choir Attentive and support young people Word & Table, Sacrament Traditional style - order of worship - songs, scripture - prayer - message

SEJ (300+ Members) 367

Sing, Pray, Worship Pray & preach Directing worship services Preaching – reading – praying – singing I am s Sunday School teacher 2-5 yrs, Lay Speaker, Health Reach, PPRCCP, Selah Prayer, Women Resource Sunday School, workshop, worship service, sacrifial prayer Usher, Communion leader, Hospitality , praise the Lord I participate by getting involved with worship service, bible scriptures praise and worship, greet my neighbors, being more open to God Communion, usher, to praise the Lord our Savior and provider I sing, I open my heart and mind to God for his glory Singing along with the choir Sunday school superintendant, Sunday school student/ teacher, praise team, choir member

What do you NOT like about what your church does in worship?

The making & reading of announcements Not enough contemporary worship elements, music, spontaneity We do not welcome well at this time; we need better hospitality. We have not learned to sing our hymns with spirit. Service too long. Services lack vitality and movement. Only one congregational hymn. The order of worship which had separated scripture from sermon which is being changed Music Ministry not that great – need sound system Length of service Long services Could be more lively, but I like the overall experience Nothing really Choir doesn’t process in; the gathering is raggedy before call to worship or praise songs Length; drags – pastor acting as a master of ceremonies rather than letting services flow Nothing Time management I wish that our choir would perform a selection during our offering. Nothing

SEJ (300+ Members) 368

I don’t! Children leave for Church School without prayer Same old – same old; tired Nothing – it is great I like our worship services The use of non-lay speakers to do children’s ministry We are working on changing our music worship experience. I don’t want to loose too much of our traditional music. Hymns, anthems and cantatas. Nothing. Worship is very spiritual & loving place Where we place the greeting of visitors and members announcements – should be at the end of service Enjoy worship at my church To constricting I don't like that they take to long to do what they have to do I like everything Hymns are not upbeat, too much order, no ideas for change The same preacher-on-podium consistency. In other words, the preacher always preaches on the podium instead of interacting and diversifying the service. How everything is printed in the bulletin; it is exactly the same every week. Very predictable; it drags. I don’t like how we do the same exact thing every single Sunday! I can tell you the agenda by heart! They are very old school They don't really relate to the youth during the sermon. When people from the choir try to sing. I like how my church worships Long services, and sometimes scriptures and stuff we don’t' understand I like how my church worship The sermon because I don't understand it sometimes. Sometimes it take too long in church. The pastor doesn't put emphasis in his sermon. I don't like when we have long worship and I don't get anything out of it. I do not like how sometimes the Spirit is cut off to have service completed by a particular time. Really nothing Just a little too structured with rituals Opportunities for any different style other than traditional is never tried.

SEJ (300+ Members) 369

Worship leader has tendency to MC services Include too many announcements Announcements Everything is fine and ok with me. Traditional everyone has it on difference When we have to end service I like everything There is nothing I don’t like about worship service I love everything about or worship Everything is fine to me

2. "Good Church"

Describe a "good" church service. (Is there one that stands out in your memory?)

Good church happens when everything is in sync. The prayers, the hymns, the choir selections and the Word. A combination of “old church” and new church practices – blended but with a definite Afro-centric flavor. When we have done new and changing formats. Our youth 5th Sunday worship was a CNN news format. Begins on time; end on time, vibrant in spirit. The worship is too long Orderly flow. Theological sound order of worship, hymns and selections are excellently delivered, good theological/biblically sound sermon. Good praise and worship – strong music ministry Message, scripture & song coincide When I say church is good is when the music is very uplifting and the message is very timely Youth/children integrated throughout; strong preaching; good choirs and congregational singing When the spirit has its way Jordan Memorial UMC Starts on time; participants prepared; flow of services; well prepared sermon; attention to communal needs; diverse participants 1) praise & worship 2) awesome teaching and preaching 3) uplifting choirs, or creative worship All participants in place; move through service; relevant preached word, music A good church service is one where the sermon is complemented by the choir selections and hymns. The spirit always seems to be there when all are on one accord. A “good” church service is feeling Spirit of the Lord as it swells from the music from our choir and a sermon that (?)

SEJ (300+ Members) 370

Good (choir) Good singing and preaching Plenty of good music with use of an organ and choir that practiced. A good message from the Bible. When the Rust Acapella Choir visited. Music makes a service special Every Sunday is a great celebration of worship at Galilee UMC Good singing, prayers and sermons One that motivates, teaches, gives people something – to encourages non-Christians to draw near to God Sermon that teaches the Word and speaks to the need of our day. Music that stirs the heart – freedom of spirit – joyful. Open to the Holy Spirit. When people praise God openly. Central UMC Variety of Music When the Holy Spirit is allowed to move and flow freely; when the bulletin can not be followed as God has taken He service to where he wants the experience When it is obvious that the anointing is present in the sanctuary when entering. Everything else happens according to the Spirit. Spirit is free to reign Good church is what I call good Service & when the sermon is about something I'm going through One where the spirit has its way One where the spirit haves its way When people are singing with excitement the pastor doesn't have to preach One that the preacher interacts with the congregation. Also, one that has UPBEAT gospel songs, and that talks about things that appeal to all ages in congregation. A spontaneous service with good music/prayers. A really good sermon as well. When people also join the church or give their lives to Christ. A “good” church service to me is when it feels like everyone in the church is hit by the Holy Spirit and it feels like he is in the building. Bad fruit & good fruit A time when everyone was touched by the hand of Jesus. The singing One day they had the children and youth sing and dance and it just touched everyone. A pastor that can speak the word and let adults as well as children understand. One when God has really shown up and the people has shown out. When the pastor talk to the people and not just go by some outline. Anytime you come into the Lord's House it is a good church service. When everyone is praising the Lord and when the preaching is good and when one or more person gives their life to Christ.

SEJ (300+ Members) 371

The preacher does not preach at you but converses with you. More youth involvement, praising God with no agenda. Being able to be free. A good service is when we get to praise how we want to. One that gets me involved When we gave our life to Christ. When they preach about good interesting things that I can relate to. When all congregants participate A good church service is when you have 2 hr. service. Not singing songs out of the hymnals all the time; sermon relates to the youth A good church is nurturing - doing mission work while evangelizing to win souls for Christ with members who are in relationship with God. When the pastor directs the services to young people, have them sit up front, just talk to them and telling the older women and men that we have the duty of teaching and training our children. Structure - order Special days when praise dancers, special choirs, lay speakers or guest speaker, opportunities for lay involvement. Good singing, good preaching, good communication A service where the response from the congregation adds to church, membership, confessions and testimonies One where the spirit of God is unmistakably evident, and everyone is participating Spiritual felt service by the whole church, good prays – singing – preaching – and congregation participation Yes all services are very good and we serve God to the highest. WE go where God leads use We have an excellent prayer ministry. Prayer should always be first in anything; the Holy Sprit is always present in our church. When everyone joins in and you can feel the Holy Ghost Sprit throughout the church Prayer, praise and worship, scriptures, spoken word, When everyone participates in everything When the Spirit just over takes the church and God’s presence is all over us When God and his spirit meet you at the church and the Holy Ghost takes control and you don’t go home the same One that is thoroughly filled with the Holy Spirit, singing , shouting, praising, and, praising, and preaching

Which of the following is true about good worship services? (Circle all that apply.) a. Organized/planned worship is important 38

SEJ (300+ Members) 372

b. Good worship can be planned 26

c. Good worship should be planned 25

d. The spiritual disciplines are preparation for good worship 39

e. Congregational singing is vital to good worship 50

3. Music

What kind of songs do you sing at your church and who sings them?

Hymns and spirituals and gospel songs – the choir and congregation Gospel choir does some traditional & contemporary Afro-centric music. Chancel choir sings UMH stuff. 4 choirs sing various traditional & contemporary gospel & hymns All kinds – choirs and congregation Hymns. Spirituals & Gospel. The choir sing all hard gospel music Hymns, gospel, spirituals, original compositions Contemporary – traditional Inspirational gospel, senior choir Spiritual, traditional and contemporaries – both choir and congregation Traditional hymns, praise music Modern gospel, hymnals Hymns (congregation); gospel-contemporary (choirs and audience sing along – visuals) We’re blessed to have 4 choirs/ singers’ group; variety of musical instruments so genre of music is done and done very well! Contemporary songs, old hymns (occasionally) Sanctuary Choir – anthems & spirituals; Imani Choir – Gospel; Men’s Ensemble – variety; Agape – Contemporary; Young Adults – Gospel & Contemporary; Young People (children & youth) – variety; congregation – hymns, spirituals Hymns (congregation); spirituals & anthems (Cathedral Choir); Gospel (Voices of Central) Songs range from spirituals to contemporary worship music - from the adult, senior and children’s choirs Traditional song

SEJ (300+ Members) 373

The choir and music director All kinds of stuff. Upbeat; Methodist Hymns Men’s choir has a dynamic leader Choirs & congregation do a wide range of music including spirituals, hymns, gospel, contemporary! Gospels, hymns, spirituals & contemporary – Jr. choir, Senior choir, and congregation Hymns & gospel and some anthems. Hymns of Zion. Traditional hymns – choir, congregation, individual. Contemporary sometimes – too repetitive. Hymns, Gospel Gospel/Hymnal Older adults, young adults, men, children & youth choirs – spirituals, traditional hymns Gospel songs; hymns – led by the different choirs and participation from the congregation Gospel, spirituals, familiar hymns Traditional to contemporary - several choirs We sing lots of songs and different people sing them Modern gospel & hymns I sing - I got another Yes, Lord in my soul Mixed - chancel choral gospel - all men - all children - contemporary - youth - all A variety of people sing songs. For instance, the children sing Joy to the World, the youth sing "I Am Soul Out, and the adults + sing Never Could Have Made It. Praise & worship songs from the choir; hymns from the congregation as a whole. Gospel. Everyone sings them. The children, youth, adults, and elderly folks. Faithful, choir Spiritual, Gospel, Contemporary We sing up beat songs. We really don't sing out of the hymnal. Praise songs, worship songs. My cousin and I basically lead all of them. Gospel All types spirituals/hymns. When have a different choir on each Sunday so we have different leaders. We sing all kinds of gospel songs - sometimes the choir sings - sometime the church members sing. My church does a variety of music. They sing all gospel songs. The choir sing them and the director. Songs that have a lot of people up singing and praising. Any kind of spiritual songs - everyone

SEJ (300+ Members) 374

We sing up beat songs and some of the choir membership sing the song We sing songs to minister to peoples spirit Some hymnals or songs we hear that we like and everybody who wants to sing them We sing hymns and praise songs Everybody sing in our church - the youth, men, women and children. African American Hymnals - Chancel Choir; upbeat gospel music - Gospel Choir, Youth Choir, & Children's Choir Gospels - hymns and today's favorites - congregation joins choir with hymns - various choirs sing All kinds - we have 4 choirs Gospel/Hymns Traditional UM Hymnals. Choir sings more popular tunes. Gospel songs, worship songs Choir sings hymnal, contemporary and traditional, African American spirituals Mix of hymnals from the UMC Hymnal and gospels Hymns – everybody; traditional – congregation & choir; spirituals – choir; contemporary – choir WE sing all kings of music, which is very good for the young middle and older age or who ever see the need Everybody sings we have different ministry on Sunday and Wednesday worship. We sing hymns, we meet the need of every age Group Spiritual, contemporary Old hymns, modern day, recent up to date, we sing a variety of them, sing song from every age level, everyone joins in Singing and I follow them in singing songs Contemporary Gospel and Hymnals Gospel – church choir Spirituals, gospel, traditional/ contemporary hymns, choir, praise team

SEJ (300+ Members) 375

In our church, the CONGREGATION sings an average of: (Check one)

1-2 songs per service 15

3-4 songs per service 35

More than 4 songs 14

Fewer than 2 songs 2

How do you feel about the way instruments are used in your church?

Praying to get more musical instruments We have drums, guitar, keyboard & piano at both churches They are welcomed gladly. Great OK, but lacks preparation. Excellent usage Love them! Great! I feel more instruments could be used and more often Good – use of drums, brass (horns), guitars, etc. at various times They are used respectively Love it (we have drums, piano, keyboard, guitar) Great They are vital to the worship experience Appropriately and well done. Men have additional group musicians. I like instrumental accompaniment but not overwhelming and not too loud. Love the organist, guitars and drum players Good

SEJ (300+ Members) 376

Just organ is enough Love all instruments Not enough Love instruments Good – we have drums, organ, guitar and piano We only have pianos. I feel OK I like the use of instruments. Very good. Ok – we need more variety Would like to see more used. Like the drums played quietly – love the organ and piano Various instruments adds to service I feel that they do what they are suppose to do Need more Instruments are used occasionally. Also, the same instruments are used - piano and drums. More instruments should be used like trumpets, etc. It’s good because there is a piano, base guitar, drums, violin, flute & more. I think the instruments are used well in the church. We have a full band. (Drums, piano, guitar, trumpet, sometimes) I really don’t like it. I enjoy them. They are used well. They help the church service out. They give it that extra thing. I feel good because all of our musicians are excellent. I feel very strong, confident that they aren't misused and also they are in excellent shape. I enjoy it because we have keyboards, guitars and drums. Good because they used to make music. Good All instruments are used to glorify God. I feel the instruments are used well. Good They use them to the best they can I like the instruments at my church They are used okay

SEJ (300+ Members) 377

I feel that they are used to make a joyful noise to praise the Lord. Good - the player do very good Great Our instruments are really good. I mean we really have good beats and stuff. Instruments other than piano are used. (African drums & drums) We should have more and use more frequently. We have an organ and drums - members have tambourines and cow bells They enhance the services. They are very important. I embrace and respect the use of instruments in church. We use drums - organ - piano - keyboard. No problem - great music opportunities. Sometimes other instruments have been used. Sometimes too loud We need drums! They add to the tempo of the music I like the use of instruments All instruments are important to carry the service on At times to loud We have an excellent music department, we have drums, keyboard, guitar, tambourine Good as long as they know how to use them Great they are used according to worship service I love the instruments that are being used I love the instruments that are being used I love the instruments that are being used. I believe that they’re the core of praise and worship I think the instruments use well in the church Very effective

4. Hymnal/Worship Resources

My church uses____ hymnbooks regularly in worship

AAHH, UMC, Celebration, FWS, ZS. (“Hymns are an important contribution to the church” – They need to be sung with consideration for ethnic flavor – We sing many too fast – Caucasian style.) 1 2

SEJ (300+ Members) 378

2 1 3 – use projection of words on a screen 1 – opening hymn 2 – (specified Songs of Zion) 2 – (specified Songs of Zion) 1 1 1 UM African American 1 1 UM 1 2 4 2 2 10 1 3 1 2 National 1 2 UM

SEJ (300+ Members) 379

Circle all that apply: a. My church uses our denominational hymnal 49 b. My church uses a hymnal other than our denominational hymnal 14 c. Hymns are an important contribution to the church 37 d. Hymns teach our religious faith's theologies and doctrines 24 e. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my religious heritage 30 f. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my ethnic heritage 22 g. My church uses our hymnbook at services other than Sunday morning 22 h. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my racial heritage 20

Where do you get your resources for the kind of worship experience in your church?

GBOD, other churches, Cokesbury UMH, Songs of Zion, Baptist Hymnal, GBOD online worship helps, UM Book of Worship, African American Heritage Hymnal Cokesbury/websites Cokesbury, Christian book distributors GBOD, UMPH, Cokesbury Books From various sources and from the Song of Zion UMC – Cokesbury Pastor Cokesbury Cokesbury Variety of sources: Cokesbury, Music Team selects sheet music, tape, etc. Hymnal and other music resources; UMC liturgical calendar

SEJ (300+ Members) 380

Congregational contributions I don’t know Cokesbury Cokesbury Pastor has indoctrinated folk–type, guitar playing Books, web, Pastor, Worship Committee Cokesbury Bookstore Workshops, Cokesbury, Pastor, Leadership Training Cokesbury, Lifeway, Family Christian Cokesbury and other stores, online A great feeling – a connection to God (not sure how this answer fits) Cokesbury, other music stores UM Varies Cokesbury I get my resources from family members The pastor, musician, youth director The resources used in church are the African-American Heritage Hymnal, the Bible, and the UMC Hymnal. Lifeway From travelling around to different churches. From what I see in the church. Committee board provides the resources. Not exactly sure Cokesbury Cokesbury Book of Worship - GOOGLE - Cokesbury No particular resources Lectionary Cokesbury Mainly Cokesbury The experiences of the pastor & church tradition Cokesbury- Olive Tree Cokesbury

SEJ (300+ Members) 381

Cokesbury, Olive Tree Workshops, Conferences and cokes From church Pastor and Lay Leader Workshop, conference and Cokesbury Cokesbury, Pastor Supplies Cokesbury, Pastor Supplies

5. Worship Traditions

What are some of the worship traditions that have been passed down in your church?

Method of Passing the Peace, Altar Guild, Good Samaritans Songs are forefathers used as slaves, Watch Night Service Baptism, communion African beats; black church Music during ______and on 1st Sundays To dance & sing in church Singing hymns, preaching, ushering Order of Worship/hymns Devotion services Devotion from the senior citizen group

Describe the special days that are observed in your congregation (e.g. Ushers' or Annual Day, Women's Day, Men's Day, etc.) What resources do you use to plan for special days?

Homecoming, church anniversary, UMM & UMW Day, Mother’s Day, Father’s Day Men’s & Women’s, Young Adult, Senior, Laity, Founder’s Day Book of Worship, Gen. Board web sites, books on AA worship – Women’s Day is a 2-day celebration of workshops and worship. The men prepare two meals for the women and serve them. Men’s Day includes a fishing trip for boys and a mission activity at the Church then a worship service. Men’s & Women’s Day, Children’s Day Good Samaritan, Hymnal, UMC worship resources - Laity Day

SEJ (300+ Members) 382

Only biblical days – following liturgical calendar Altar Call Homecoming, UM Women’s Day, Men’s Sunday, 5th Sunday gathering - reading material, Book of Worship, Bible, Hymnal Church holy days, Women’s Children’s Sundays Grandparents’ Day, Youth Day, etc. Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Y/YA Day, Homecoming Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Homecoming, Family & Friends, Mother’s & Father’s Day, Easter Service, Sunrise Service Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Homecoming, Youth Sundays (5th Sun.), Heritage Month (Feb.), variety of resources available at Cokesbury Men’s & Women’s Day; Grandparent’s Day, Mother’s Day Women’s & Men’s Day - special contributions from individuals Women’s Day, Men’s Day – I don’t know Women’s Day, Men’s Day Women’s Day, Men’s Day Pastor Appreciation, Women’s/Men’s, Youth, Homecoming, Lay Leadership Homecoming, Pastor Appreciation, Children’s Sabbath, Men’s & Women’s Day, Heritage Sunday, Christian Education Day, Organization celebrations UM Women or resources for our day Women’s Day is observed 1st Sunday in May. A Certified Lay Speaker or minister delivers the message. Women’s Day, Memorial Day/Labor Day, Mothers’ & Fathers’, All Saints, most special days noted in UM Calendar and or Worship Planner Women’s Day, All Saints Day, Father’s Day, Children’s Day – Book of Worship Ushers’ Men’s Day – Members/books Hymnals, worship resources, worship planning resources. Extra Notation: We need a worship resource that would reflect our heritage. Contained in one resource. Men’s Day; Senior (Older Adult); Laity Sunday; many different resources are used; some come from the UM organization Men’s Day; Older Adults Sunday I plan & if someone needs help We have many different services including Youth Week Celebration We honored these days by preaching stuff out of the Bible, commemorating special individuals. Church Anniversary, Men’s Fish Fry, Women’s & Men’s Day, holidays, etc. Women & Men’s Days, Children’s Day Bible hymnals Children's Day, Youth Day, Homecoming

SEJ (300+ Members) 383

Generally we give gifts, plan a ceremony to honor/celebrate the special day. During Women's/Men's Days they (each group) organizes their own programs. Special programs. Things are given out for the program. Mother's & Father's Day Not exactly sure Mother's Day, Father's Day For Men's & Women's Day we have one service and a big breakfast. On Easter & Christmas, we always have a play with the children. On Women's Day the women wear white and have their worship. Women’s Day, Men’s Day Pastor Day and more. Appreciation. Women’s Day, Men’s Day, youth renewal, Casual Sunday Book of Worship used for special days. Usher & Choir anniversaries - church anniversary - family week, Ash Wednesday, Holy Week, Evangelistic Explosion. Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Youth Day Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Revivals Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Laity Day, & Good Samaritan Day - groups planning team designs the services.. Older Adult Sunday - pastor driven. Homecoming, revivals User Day – Ushers; Black History Month – children; Women’s & Men’s Day – guest speakers Women’s & Men’s Day, Usher’s Day, Church Anniversary, Harvest Day, Children’s Day, Revivals All plans are made and well productive material from bookstores- PPRC and online all days are celebrated Family and Friends Day, Pastor Appreciation We observe special days always. Everyone’s area they work in is appreciated, no group is over looked. Resources are used from our pastor and Um literature Ushers, Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Fathers Day, Mothers Day Mother’s Day and Fathers Day, Church does not do to much Women’s Day, Men’s Day , pastor Appreciation, Staff Appreciation, Family and Friends, Church Anniversary Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Pastor Appreciation, Staff appreciation, Family and Friends Day, Church Anniversary Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Pastor Appreciation, Staff appreciation, Family and Friends Day, Church Anniversary, team/ committee meetings, UM Men and Women Church bulletins Various ministries is in the church everyone is recognized no age group is left out.

SEJ (300+ Members) 384

0 to 299 - Membership & Worship Attendance -- WJ

Jurisdiction North Central North Eastern South Central Southeastern

Clergy or Laity Clergy Laity 2

What is the approximately membership of your church? Under 100 100 - 199 1 200 - 299 300 - 499 500 - 749 750 - 999 1000+

What is the approximate total Sunday worship attendance at your church? Under 100 1

100 - 199 200 - 299 300 - 499 500 - 749 750 - 999 1000+

WJ (0-299 Members) 385

1. Worship Practices

How do you participate in Sunday worship?

Greeter, Trustee Conduct all music throughout the worship.

What do you NOT like about what your church does in worship?

Offering is very quick and non-eventful. If more emphasis was placed on it, I think people would give more.

2. "Good Church"

Describe a "good" church service. (Is there one that stands out in your memory?)

One that engages the attendees, lively choir, one involved with community A "Good" church service is when the Holy Spirit is present.

Which of the following is true about good worship services? (Circle all that apply.)

a. Organized/planned worship is important 1

b. Good worship can be planned 1

c. Good worship should be planned 1

d. The spiritual disciplines are preparation for good worship

e. Congregational singing is vital to good worship 1

WJ (0-299 Members) 386

3. Music

What kind of songs do you sing at your church and who sings them?

Old and new gospel Adult and youth choir sing. We sing gospel music and hymns and anthems.

In our church, the CONGREGATION sings an average of: (Check one)

1-2 songs per service

3-4 songs per service 1

More than 4 songs 1

Fewer than 2 songs

How do you feel about the way instruments are used in your church?

Love it Love all instruments. We have keys including organ and keyboard, bass guitar, drums and sometimes electric guitar.

4. Hymnal/Worship Resources

My church uses 0 hymnbooks regularly in worship

Circle all that apply:

a. My church uses our denominational hymnal 1

WJ (0-299 Members) 387

b. My church uses a hymnal other than our denominational hymnal

c. Hymns are an important contribution to the church 1

d. Hymns teach our religious faith's theologies and doctrines 1

e. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my religious heritage

f. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my ethnic heritage

g. My church uses our hymnbook at services other than Sunday morning

h. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my racial heritage

Notation: The hymnbook if not as good to me as the National Baptist Standard Hymnal. It has more Black hymns.

Where do you get your resources for the kind of worship experience in your church?

Various Christian bookstores Concerts, church services, radio, television

5. Worship Traditions

What are some of the worship traditions that have been passed down in your church?

Communion

Describe the special days that are observed in your congregation (e.g. Ushers' or Annual Day, Women's Day, Men's Day, etc.) What resources do you use to plan for special days?

Church anniversary Choir Annual Day, Communion

WJ (0-299 Members) 388

300+ - Membership & Worship Attendance -- WJ

Jurisdiction North Central North Eastern South Central Southeastern Western 42

Clergy or Laity Clergy 2 Laity 40

What is the approximately membership of your church? Under 100 100 - 199 200 - 299 300 - 499 26 500 - 749 14 750 - 999 1000+ 1

What is the approximate total Sunday worship attendance at your church? Under 100 100 - 199 26 200 – 299 14 300 - 499 500 – 749 1 750 - 999 1000+

WJ (300+ Members) 389

1. Worship Practices

How do you participate in Sunday worship?

As a member President of Usher Board & Lay Leader Taking notes from sermon – participate in ritual Pray, sing, lead meditation prior to service, attendance slips Preach, plan, pray Fellowship – mingling with congregates, thank God, I always enjoy Pastor Staci’s word! Sing in the choir, operate the sound board Fellowship, sing, clap hands, Pastor’s teaching Listening, singing, touching fellow Christians Praise, music, community setting an example for young children Choir, Worship Leader Response Through songs and praise Choir member Sing in choir, sign language Choir member Choir Sing in the choir, prayer, read scripture(Lay Speaker) Choir, liturgist, pulpit supply, communion Choir, Sunday school Sing in VOG Sing 1st & 2nd Sundays, prayer, reading the Bible, liturgist 10:45 Each Sunday Response reading, praying, singing, usher Praise Team, choir member VOG, nursery attendant Choir member, and Praise Team I sing in VOG Choir, I participate in praise & worship Sing in the Youth Choir Sing, dance, praise Worship Leader, Transportation Ministry, usher, choir

WJ (300+ Members) 390

Choir, usher Usher and minister on different times Totally Sing, usher, and dance By singing and ushering Usher Praise Team, choir member Sing in choir, worship in congregation Lay Speaker, liturgist, choir member Sing in congregation/choir Sing in Senior Choir, teach Sunday school, sing in A cappella Ensemble Worship with congregation, sing in choir Praising

What do you NOT like about what your church does in worship?

Nothing Offering before sermon Nothing The special Sundays (too many), announcements, and special presentations I would like more time for reflection Anything that isn’t singing, preaching, or scripture Sometimes too quiet, not participating Reading and giving the announcements, begging for money Announcements Nothing I enjoy every moment Announcements Need more moments of quiet meditation, hymn singing with congregation, need more organ and instrumentals I like the flow of the service overall, I would prefer prayer after the sermon instead of earlier in the service I love our worship service Miss the Apostle’s Creed, should be said on Sundays Nothing

WJ (300+ Members) 391

Praise before service can be quieter and more solemn, otherwise everything is great Length of service, hymn at invitation- I prefer, sermon at the end, a choral selection Too many announcements Not setting tone for Praise & Worship, people talk in the Narthex, I think it should be quiet Crazy people screaming It’s very repetitive I like all our worship as we do at this time Praise singing N/A Sometimes sermon is too long, we need to have only one service, we don’t have enough parishioners for 2 services N/A

2. "Good Church"

Describe a "good" church service. (Is there one that stands out in your memory?)

When the church is over half full and all the choirs are joined with organ, piano and drum, and the pastor gives an inspiring sermon Church begin on time Biblical based with ways to live out the text Congregation participation, stimulating sermons relevant to today’s issues, good singing, children’s ministry Ash Wednesday, it was a powerful service with wonderful reading, singing, dramatic liturgy and pageantry Powerful, inspirational sermon set to soulful music The music backing up the Pastor’s sermon Presence of the Spirit- feeling His presence, good music, good focused message Good music, sermons you can understand and recall, seeing & touching church family member Substance, passion, message with the music, connection, interaction Good dynamic preaching, good music, participatory congregation Great sermon, great music, integration of music and sermon Great worship through songs, sermons, praise and fellowship with congregation Songs of praise, hymns and prayer, thanksgiving, asking congregation to come and be in the Spirit of worship Timely sermon, stay in Spirit and thanksgiving

WJ (300+ Members) 392

A wonderful, powerful sermon, great music, fellowship The presence of the Lord in church When the congregation reacts to our Spirit filled anointed Pastor, we have some members who are reluctant to show engagement On time, precise, lively Powerful, thought provoking, Spirit filled preaching and singing(praise & worship, choir, instrumental selections) Prayer, praise, testimony, teaching of the word, music, scripture Good sermon, music, hospitality invitation to join Grace UMC Youth participation in dance and songs, spoken word, Men’s and Women’s Day are also special There are many, when the sermon and music speaks directly to you Praise, worship, great engaging sermon, great choral music or solos Cross generational participation, particularly youth/children When the Spirit is high, choir, Pastor, congregation, ushers, musicians When the spoken sung word come together in the Spirit, and the people of God are open to receive When you allow the Spirit to move with out trying to keep things on track Everything Everyone standing up praising God, singing, waving their hands in the air Good strong message A lively service A good church service is when the Pastor makes his sermon funny Most services are good- congregation gets the word in song and message Youth speaking A good church service is all the people participate in the service and worship God Homecoming 42nd, Pastor Gillespie spoke Scriptural sermon, appropriate spiritual music, multiple genres of praise & worship, including spoken word, song and dance 5th Sunday- youth service speaker, GUMW Women’s Day speaker and choir Most are good Youth service; very inspirational/good organization Friendly good preaching and good singing choir Inspiring sermon, uplifting songs, congregational participation; an example youth Sunday

WJ (300+ Members) 393

Which of the following is true about good worship services? (Circle all that apply.)

a. Organized/planned worship is important 30

b. Good worship can be planned 26

c. Good worship should be planned 26

d. The spiritual disciplines are preparation for good worship 29

e. Congregational singing is vital to good worship 29

3. Music

What kind of songs do you sing at your church and who sings them?

Hymns – congregation and sometimes a soloist; gospel All songs but we love to sing old spirituals and songs that are scriptures from Bible not in UMC “Red” Hymnal Variety – Gospel Choir Hymns, gospel, contemporary Gospel, traditional hymns, both the congregation and choir I enjoy the traditional, simple spirituals Gospel, classical, contemporary Christian spirituals Hymns, contemporary and traditional All kinds- choir, soloists, congregation, we also have musicians who complement the experiences Choir, children, members, men on Men’s Day, women on Women’s Day, gospel, Anthems, traditional spirituals, classical All kinds- traditional hymns, gospel, contemporary Christian Choir and congregation sing; hymns, gospel, traditional hymns, South African, classical Anthems, hymns, gospel, classical Songs of Praise, choir and congregation Hymn of invitation to prayer Invitation to fellowship and membership, Anthem at times(choir)

WJ (300+ Members) 394

Gospel, classics, spirituals, contemporary Contemporary gospel( mainly choir, congregation as well), classical Anthems( choir) Spirituals and traditional hymns( choir and congregation) Hymnal, gospel, formal choir songs Contemporary and traditional gospel, Anthems, contemporary classical spirituals Anthems, gospels, spirituals Gospel, traditional hymns Spiritual songs, slow and uplifting and meaningful Gospel- Voices of Grace, hymns-Chancel Choir, Spirituals- Chancel and Men’s Chorus Praise- Praise Team, hymns- congregation, choral selections- Choir Gospel- VOG, some rap- Youth Choir and Half Notes, traditional- Chancel and Men’s Choir Gospel, contemporary, Anthems, hymns Modern gospel music, spirituals, hymns All kinds of music Upbeat popular gospel, hymns, spirituals Hymns, Anthems, Contemporary Upbeat, heartfelt, Kirk Franklin, Fred Hammond I sing gospel and the congregation joins the choir Gospels, hymns – choirs and congregation Upbeat/slow/a cappella, Youth/adults/seniors It’s a lot of songs but I can’t remember them, the choir or sometimes the youth Contemporary, gospel music ( Voices of God), traditional hymns/Anthems ( Chancel Choir) Anthems, gospels, spirituals Old hymns Spirituals, Anthems, gospels, are sung by choir, Praise Team, and congregation Boring songs mostly, the congregation doesn’t know how to sing, we sound pathetic Good singing, good preaching Anthems, gospels, spirituals; congregation, choirs, and Praise Team

WJ (300+ Members) 395

In our church, the CONGREGATION sings an average of: (Check one)

1-2 songs per service 9

3-4 songs per service 24

More than 4 songs 6

Fewer than 2 songs 0

How do you feel about the way instruments are used in your church?

Good Adds to the service and gets our young people that like to hear other instruments How to live in spirit Good Greatly approve Good, blessed, make happy The instruments are played well, organ, piano, and drums, sometimes tambourine I like instruments Enhance service Instruments enhance the Music Ministry Instruments make the music more upbeat Its cool They’re fine they don’t take away from anything Quite tasteful; adds to songs and music They are ok I think we need and would like to see a few more than drums I think they should be used more They’re good and sound good too

WJ (300+ Members) 396

I love my musicians I like I want electric guitar and wind instrument sometime Great Wonderful! We use organ, piano, drums and tambourine Enhances the worship experience- keyboard, bass, drums, saxophone, trumpets, tambourines Well planned and purposeful Our instruments add depth to the service, makes it current and appealing to young people whom we need to attract Great-musicians & instruments, percussionist, keyboards, guitarist, sax, and tambourines Love how all instruments are used I enjoy them, they add to the worded music Instruments well used, bass guitar, drums, piano, technies ( different voices) Enjoy it I like it The instruments enhance the music and prayer Our musicians are second to none!!

4. Hymnal/Worship Resources

My church uses ______hymnbooks regularly in worship

ONE- 4

TWO- 25

THREE- 7

4 OR MORE- 1

WJ (300+ Members) 397

ADDITIONAL COMMENTS:

We need 1) Songs of Zion Hymnal; 2) African American Hymnal

Circle all that apply:

a. My church uses our denominational hymnal 32

b. My church uses a hymnal other than our denominational hymnal 19

c. Hymns are an important contribution to the church 31

d. Hymns teach our religious faith's theologies and doctrines 24

e. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my religious heritage 28

f. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my ethnic heritage 25

g. My church uses our hymnbook at services other than Sunday morning 21

h. Our present hymnal contains hymns of my racial heritage 27

Where do you get your resources for the kind of worship experience in your church?

UMW Music Headquarters, Cokesbury Cokesbury Cokesbury Cokesbury Bookstore Kids and senior selections I really don’t know but it seems that some of the songs are popular gospel songs that you hear on the radio

WJ (300+ Members) 398

Music warehouse Don’t know All over computer The Bible, Hymnals Mostly our hymnbook, Holy Bible, choir selections Internet, church leaders, UMC resources Pastor, Minister of Music, Hymnals UMC Pastor and Worship Leader Bible Cokesbury bookstore, worship planner, Holy Spirit, trial & error From God ( let the spirit move) All over the place We have seminars, retreats, disciple/Bible studies The people People I do not know

5. Worship Traditions

What are some of the worship traditions that have been passed down in your church?

Involving the children

Describe the special days that are observed in your congregation (e.g. Ushers' or Annual Day, Women's Day, Men's Day, etc.) What resources do you use to plan for special days?

Each group for special days plans their own order of service. (Ushers) Usher’s Day, Annual Day, Church Anniversary, Homecoming, Church Picnic, Women’s & Men’s Day Women’s & Men’s Day - don’t know

WJ (300+ Members) 399

Mothers & Fathers Day, Easter, Christmas, New Year’s Eve, Wednesday’s Wonderful Word (evening on Wed.), Maundy Thursday, Laity Sunday, Good Friday, World Aids Day Usher’s or Annual Day, Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Homecoming, Youth Sunday, Easter, Christmas; worship planner States day, Youth day, Homecoming, Pastor’s Appreciation, Choir Day Usher Day, Men’s Day, Homecoming, Choir Day, Youth Sundays, Marriage Renewal Sunday, Women’s Day, State’s Day, Easter Sunrise, Graduation Recognition, Laity Sunday Concerts, VOG Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Children’s Day, Youth Day Usher’s Day, Women’s Day, Men’s Day; speaker theme, music, special soloists Annual Day, Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Youth/Children’s Day Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Children’s Day, 40 Days of Day Break Prayer, Pentecost, No excuse All and the Youth Day, Choir Day, State Day All above including Choir Day, States Day, and Church Anniversary Usher’s Day, Women’s Day, Youth Sunday, combined Choirs Day Mother’s Day, Christmas, a lot of other special days All of the above including Youth Day, Choir Day, States Day; utilize special speakers, musicians Usher’s Day, Women’s Day, Men’s Day Usher Day, Choir Day, Women’s Day, Men’s Day, Graduate recognition Usher’s Day, Men’s Day, Women’s Day, Homecoming Youth Sunday, Usher’s Day, Women’s Day, Men’s Day Women’s Day, Men’s Day 40 Days of Day Break Prayer Women’s and Men’s Day All of the above; guest speakers are a great resource We have committees and ask for congregation to participate Women’s, Children’s/Youth, Men’s Day; Mission Emphasis Sunday, UMM Sunday, Wesleyan, Church Anniversary Major Methodist Christian calendar days Men’s, Usher’s, Women’s, Youth, Choir Usher’s Day, Choir Day, Women’s Day, States Day, Graduates Appreciation Being a part of a choir Usher, Women’s, Men’s, Anniversaries, Youth, and Choir Days, All Saints Day, Christmas, Easter, and Passover Usher’s and Choir Days, Women’s, Men’s, and Youth Days

WJ (300+ Members) 400