Stinky potatoes and their impact on biotic metal reduction

Debra Hausladen Stanford University Microbial Diversity Course, 2012

Abstract

Fermenting play an important role in supplying soluble organic carbon to metal reducing bacteria. An enrichment column of ferrihydrite-coated sand overlaying a thin layer of particulate organic carbon (POC) was constructed and monitored over time. and Firmicutes were observed as dominant classes over both layers after several days. Double hybridization CARD- FISH was conducted to investigate potential associations of metal reducing bacteria (MRB) and Firmicutes on a sub-micron level. Introduction

Heavy metal immobilization is possible by a number of sequestration pathways including: adsorption of metal complexes on solid surfaces, structural incorporation into Fe(III) oxides, formation of secondary minerals, adsorption to biomass, and precipitation and coprecipitation.

Perhaps one of the most important environmental factors influencing the biogeochemical cycling of metals is its association with ferric/ferrous iron. Metal species adsorb to the surface of Fe hydroxides, oxyhydroxides, and oxide mineral phases, hereafter referenced as Fe oxides. In the case of uranium contamination, Nico et al. (2009) and Stewart et al. (2009) demonstrated that U(VI) incorporation into Fe oxides allows for increased U stability during successive reduction and oxidation cycles. The increased stability of U occurs despite the possibility of U(VI) being released into solution during the reductive dissolution of these Fe(III) phases. The overlapping redox couples of U(VI/IV) and Fe(III/II) allow Fe to act as both an oxidant and reductant depending on environmental conditions (Ginder-Vogel et al., 2006). Often, the biotic reduction products Fe(II) and HS- are present at concentrations that may promote abiotic U(VI) reduction (Liger et al., 1999; Jeon et al., 2005). Fe(III) can also decrease the rate and extent of biotic uranium reduction by acting as a competing electron acceptor in microbial respiration. Due to overlapping redox couples, dissimilatory U(VI) and Fe(III) reduction can occur simultaneously. Wielinga et al. (2000) showed a 52% decrease in uranyl reduction by Shewanella algae BrY in the presence of ferrihydrite over 10 hours, while hematite and goethite had no effect on U reduction (Fredrickson et al, 2000). The complicated interactions between uranium and iron make the prediction of uranium speciation and mobility difficult, especially when other complexing ligands are present in the subsurface. It is critical that these biogeochemical processes and their effects on the reduction and stability of uranium are better characterized in order to develop more robust remediation strategies.

The presence of organic matter has been found to play a key role in the persistence of toxic metals such as U(IV). For example, the occurrence of U(IV) in seasonally oxic, open-pit mines has been attributed to organic matter (Suzuki et al., 2005). In other cases, naturally occurring organic ligands are also known to affect the mobility of metals under both oxic and anoxic conditions. Under strict anaerobic conditions, organic acids, especially humics, have been found to dramatically enhance U(VI) reduction rates (Gu et al., 2005). In the presence of oxidants, however, humic substances increase the oxidation of U(IV) by forming soluble complexes with U(IV) (Francis and Dodge, 2008). Since uranium is radioactive and difficult to work with, this study focuses on a more simplified iron-rich system that can later be expanded to inform the biogeochemical cycling of uranium. This experiment investigates which organisms are enriched in the presence of ferric iron-rich sediment and potato as a source of particular organic carbon. Community structure of potato and soil inocula was investigated prior to addition to the enrichment column and subsequent shifts in community composition was monitored during incubation. In order to better understand the microbial organisms responsible for iron reduction in the presence of particulate organic carbon, RNA was extracted from different column depths. This study also assessed whether close spatial associations formed between fermenting and iron reducing bacteria. A CARD-FISH technique was developed to attempt to resolve these associations on a sub-micron scale. The second half of the project investigated whether Clostridia in syntrophic associations support greater activity of metal reducing bacteria than those in isolation (data not shown). Methods

Column Set-up Ferrihydrite was synthesized according to Schwertmann and Cornell (1991) and mixed with quartz sand. Sand was dried for two days and then rinsed with 18 Ohm water until rinse water was clear. For the particulate organic matter layer a Russet potato was microwaved until soft before mashing 10g together 1g of soil from School Street Marsh. Five grams of soil inoculated potato was then spread in a thin layer at the bottom of a PVC tube. 13 g of sediment from School Street Marsh was then mixed with 130 g of ferrihydrite-coated sand and added on top of the potato layer. Five holes for anaerobic sampling were drilled along the tube, plugged with butyl rubber stoppers, and silicone sealed. Artificial groundwater medium was made (10 mM HEPES, 2.7 mM KCl, 0.3 mM MgSO4, 7.9 mM NaCl, and 0.4 CaCl2.2H2O; pH adjusted to 7.2) and added to saturate the artificial sediment.

454 Pyrosequencing Tag Pyrosequencing was performed on porewater filtered on polycarbonate membranes before addition to PowerBead tubes (0.5 ml of potato porewater and 1.0 ml of sediment porewater). Genes for the SSU rRNA was amplified using barcoded primers that contained Roche 454 Ti adaptor sequences along with individual barcode sequences on each forward primer. This primer specifically targets the 515F (5’- cgtatcgcctccctgcgccatcagxxxxxxxxgagtgycagmgccgcgtaa-3’) and 907R (5’- ctatgcgccttgccagcccgctcagggccgycattcmtttragtt-3’)region of the E. Coli 16s gene. Phusion HF polymerase (2X master mix) was used to amplify the 16s gene necessary for 16s amplification. PCR reactions were run on a MJ Thermocycler. Analysis of 454 data was performed using Qiime. Reference sequences were selected and aligned using the UCLUST algorithm via Qiime interface.

RNA Extractions Total RNA was extracted from flash frozen porewater samples which were thawed and filtered on polycarbonate membranes before addition to PowerBead tubes (0.5 ml of potato porewater and 1.0 ml of sediment porewater). The MoBio Power Biofilm RNA Extraction Kit was followed according tomanufacturers protocols. Total extracted RNA was resuspended in 25μl of H2O. Extracted RNA was run unde PCR conditions with DNA primers to identify potential sources of DNA contamination post RNAse treatment of the total RNA extraction product. RNA was converted to cDNA using the Invitrogen cDNA kit. A 25 minute incubation at room temperature was followed by one hour at 72°C and 10 minutes at 85°C. The converted cDNA was then used to amplify the 16s gene.

Cloning Universal 16S primers (8F, 1492R) were used to amplify the DNA from an extraction aliquot. A gel purification was used to identify and purify the PCR product. The product was then sued with the Topo cloning kit to create a clone library of 16S genes, which were sequenced by Sanger sequencing methodology. The 16S clone library sequences were aligned using the SILVA software before importing the sequences into ARB. The selected sequences were then clustered using the UCLUST algorithm via QIIME interface, and representative sequnces were selected, aligned, and used to create a maximum likelihood tree. Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) Fixation and cutting Sediment mini-cores (taken in 1 ml syringes) were fixed with 70% Ethanol for 3 hours before embedding with O.C.T. for 48 hours. Cores were then frozen in liquid nitrogen and stored at -80 C. Thin sections (approx. 50 um) were mounted on slides using approx. 50um cyrosections. Hybridization was attempted directly on the thin-section mounted to the slide but successive washes resulted in too much sediment loss. Next 300 uL of fixed sediment in 10 mL 1xPBS was filtered onto polycarbonate filters.

CARD-FISH The Deltaproteobacteria-probe (Delta 495a, b, c + competitor a,b,c) was used to target potential metal reducing bacteria, while LGCa394 was used to stain members of the Firmicutes. Cell permeabilization was performed by incubating the filters in 20mg/ml Lysozyme for 60 minutes at 37 C, followed by washing the samples with mQH2O and 96% EtOH. Bleaching of endogenous peroxidases was performed by incubating the filters in H2O2/Methanol mix under the hood for 30 min before rinsing again in mQH2O and 96% EtOH and air drying. Hybridization was first performed for Deltaproteobacteria probe. Filters (2 filters per vial) were hybridized for 3 hrs at 46 C. CARD was done using Alexa 594. After filters dried, the inactivation step was repeated and hybridization/CARD repeated for the LGCaXX with Alexa 488. Pictures were taken using Axio IMAGER MZ Microscope equipped with a color camera (AxioCam HRc, Zeiss) and Laser Confocal Microscopy was done using LCM 700. Batch Reactors Clostridia was isolated from School Street Marsh and, using BLAST, found to be closely related to C. acidisoli. One colony was selected from a streak plate and resuspended in X media. Methanogen enrichments were cultured by inoculating sediment from School Street Marsh into H2/CO2 flushed serum vials. Enrichments were transferred to fresh media three times. The final media contained no rifampicin. An isolate of M. hungatei was shipped from the McIrney lab at University of Oklahoma. Media was made following McInerney, 1979. 20 ml of media was transferred to 130 mL serum vials containing 0.1 g of Russet potato in an anaerobic chamber. Vials were sealed with butyl rubber stoppers and autoclaved. Four different treatments were monitored. The following additions were added in duplicate: 1 ml of liquid Clostridia isolate, 1 ml of liquid Clostridia isolate with 0.1 ml of liquid methanogen suspension, 1 ml of liquid Clostridia isolate with 0.01 ml of liquid methanogen suspension, and finally 1 ml of liquid methanogen suspension. One set of vials was run with a methanogen enrichment; the second used M. hungatei inoculum. Batch reactors were monitored daily for CH4, H2, and fermentation products using FID-GC and HPLC.

Results and Discussion

Visible iron reduction was seen after several days. After only ca. 5 days the potato layer had produced so much gas that the entire sediment layer was lifted ~1 cm. The iron reduction front continued toward the sediment surface and white sand, indicative of reduction to soluble Fe(II), became apparent along the potato layer (Figure 1).

Figure 1. Visual observation of ferrihydrite reduction. Picture on left is ferrihydrite at t =0; right indicates column after 16 days.

Oxygen profiles were measured over time in order to monitor biological oxygen consumption. After 12 hours, the profile remained aerobic except in the potato layer. The oxygen profile became relatively stable after 5 days and appeared as shown in Figure 2.

Figure 2 . Oxygen and Redox potential profiles. Oxygen profile was taken using Unisense Oxygen probe while redox potential was measured with a Unisense redox electrode. Profiles taken Day 14 of column experiment. The profile starts at the water surface and continues to the potato layer at the bottom of the column. The red line indicates where the sediment layer begins. In order to see whether fermentation was producing forms of soluble organic carbon capable of supporting iron reducing bacteria such as Geobacter, organic acids were monitored over the course of the column’s lifetime. Further sampling resolution over time is necessary to elucidate when peak acetate production occurs, but by day 11 acetate production seems to be on the decline (Figure 3a). In the potato layer, acetate production was detected before butyrate, and time courses for both compounds indicate that fermentation is highest in the potato layer and diffuses over time through the entire sediment column (Figure 3a-e).

Figure 3. Acetate and butyrate concentrations over time. Pore water was extracted anaerobically from five different depths and measured using High Performance Liquid Chromotography (HPLC). Each graph corresponds with a depth represented in Figure 2: a) 5000 um, b) 1400 um, c) 2400 um, d) 3300 um , e) 3800 um.

454 Pyrosequencing was used in order to monitor changes in community structure. was shown to dominate for both initial potato and sediment inocula, as well as column subsamples taken after 4 days. Firmicutes represent a very small fraction of the microbial community in the initial inocula but become heavily enriched in both the potato and ferrihydrite-coated sediment layers (Figure 4). Although Bacteroidetes were present in both the sediment and potato inocula, they appear to only be retained in the sediment portion of the column.

Figure 4. Phylogenetic relationships of 454 Sequences to nearest reference sequences at the phylum level. Analyzed using the QIIME workflow. Sediment and potato communities analyzed 4 days after column set-up. The dominant phylum, Proteobacteria, was then split by class. Both the sediment and potato inocula include several classes of Proteobacteria with Delta- and Beta- proteobacteria dominating, respectively (Figure 5). After 4 days in the enrichment column, the community shits dramatically to be heavily dominated by Gammaproteobacteria.

Figure 5. Phylogenetic relationships of 454 Sequences to nearest reference sequences of Proteobacteria. Analyzed using the QIIME workflow. Sediment and potato communities analyzed 4 days after column set-up.

In the second most dominant phylum, Firmicutes, the community shift is much less than that seen in Proteobacteria. Unlike Proteobacteria, however, a difference in community structure is apparent between the enriched sediment and potato. Bacili is absent in both sediment inoculum and enrichment, but present in similar relative abundance for both potato inoculum and enrichment.

Figure 6. Phylogenetic relationships of 454 Sequences to nearest reference sequences of Firmicutes. Analyzed using the QIIME workflow. Sediment inoculum (a) and sediment porewater sampled after 4 days (b) are depicted alongside potato inoculum(b) and potato layer sampled after 4 days (d).

Looking at dominant classes across phyla, the sediment inoculum appears to have greater representation of Deltaproteobacteria while Betaproteobacteria is the most represented class in the potato inoculum. Any class represented by less than 1% of sequences is classified as other. After enrichment, Gammaproteobacteria shift to a dominant role followed by Firmicutes as previously discussed.

Figure 7. Phylogenetic relationships of 454 Sequences to nearest reference sequences at the class level. Analyzed using the QIIME workflow. Sediment and potato communities analyzed 4 days after column set-up. Clone library results from RNA extractions yielded 82 sequences. Of these, 1 sequence BLASTed as a match for gaviniae strain S1/1-984 16S ribosomal RNAs. The remaining 81 sequences fell within the Firmicutes (Figure 8). Sixty-one of these sequences plotted closest to Clostridium butyricum, which corresponded to the strong smell of butyrate present in the column. The rest fell near environmental reference samples from uranium, arsenic, and chromium contaminated sites. Clostridium magnum is one notable reference sequence, as it is known to be a homoacetogenic bacteria. As Geobacter, one prominent metal reducing bacteria, is known to consume acetate as an electron donor, the presence and identification of homoacetogenic clostridia would provide useful information when designing bioreduction experiments.

Figure 8. Phylogenetic tree showing 16S cDNA clones in relation to their nearest neighbors. Tree made in ARB.

In order to quantify the proportion of Firmicutes to Deltaproteobacteria and resolve the spatial distribution of these two groups on a sub-micron scale, a double hybridization CARD-FISH approach was used. Thin sectioning of sub-cores was attempted by cryosectioning. However, FISH was not successfully optimized to allow thin-sections to remain intact throughout successive washing steps. Instead, sediment was filtered onto polycarbonate membranes and associations on single sand grains were investigated. Firmicutes were found associated with Deltaproteobacteria on some sediment grains (Figure 10b,c; Figure 11), but in order to more critically document associations between these two taxa a more consistent method of differentiating between Alexa 488 and sediment auto-fluoresence is necessary. Laser confocal microscopy was shown to be able to image cell distribution and association across single sand grains by setting up Z-stack experiments.

Figure 9. CARD-FISH images of potato-layer sediment. Double hybridization CARD-FISH was performed on sediment filtered onto polycarbonate membranes. Slides stained for (a) DAPI, (b) Firmicutes, and (c) Deltaproteobacteria were imaged using an Axio IMAGER MZ Microscope.

Figure 10. Laser confocal image of potato-layer sediment using double hybridization CARD-FISH. Firmicutes represented in green, Deltaproteobacteria in red. DAPI represented in blue. Future Work

This mini-project provided preliminary indication of microbial enrichment resulting from simplified geochemical reactor experiments. RNA extractions, however, worked for only one sample. In the future, optimization for samples extracted from sediment with lower biological activity will provide an important picture of microbial activity along the Fe(III)-reduction gradient. It would be interesting to compare the effect of different inocula on the resulting microbial enrichment, in addition to comparing environmental inocula with inocula of select model organism assemblages. The development of a method to perform CARD-FISH on sediment thin-sections has potential to greatly help evaluation of environmental samples. Given more time, CARD-FISH directly on thin-section slides would be optimized. Acknowledgements A special thanks to our Course Directors Steve Zinder and Dan Buckley for bringing a geochemist into the fascinating world of microbiology. I’m looking forward to continue combining the two worlds. Thanks to all the TAs for all the patient guidance! And especially thank you to my wonderful class of 2012. You were all so passionate, dedicated, and inspiring. You so patiently introduced me to microbiology labwork. Finally, thank you to those whose funding allowed me to be here: The Gordon & Betty Moore Foundation and the Microbial Diversity Endowment Fund. References

Francis A.J, and Dodge CJ. (2008) Bioreduction of Uranium(VI) Complexed with Citric Acid by Clostridia Affects Its Structure and Solubility. Environmental Science & Technology 42:8277-8282. Fredrickson JK, Zachara JM, Kennedy DW, Duff MC, Gorby YA, Li SMW, Krupka KM. (2000) Reduction of U(VI) in goethite (α-FeOOH) suspensions by a dissimilatory metal-reducing bacterium. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 64:3085– 3098. Fredrickson JK, Zachara JM, Kennedy DW, Liu CX, Duff MC, Hunter DB and Dohnalkova A. (2002) Influence of Mn oxides on the reduction of uranium(VI) by the metal- reducing bacterium Shewanella putrefaciens. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 66:3247–3262. Ginder-Vogel M, Criddle CS, Fendorf S. (2006) Thermodynamic constraints on the oxidation of biogenic UO2 by Fe(III) (hydr)oxides. Environ Sci Technol 40:3544–3550. Jeon BH, Dempsey BA, Burgos WD, Barnett MO, Roden EE. (2005) Chemical reduction of U(VI) by Fe(II) at the solid-water interface using natural and synthetic Fe(III) oxides. Environ Sci Technol 39:5642–5649. Liger E.; Charlet, L.; Van Cappellen, P., (1999) Surface catalysis of uranium(VI) reduction by iron(II). Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 63:2939-2955. Nico P. S., Stewart B. D., Fendorf S. (2009) Incorporation of oxidized uranium into Fe (hydr)oxides during Fe(II) catalyzed remineralization. Environmental Science & Technology 43:7391-7396. Schwertmann, U.; Cornell, R. M., Iron Oxides in the Laboratory: Preparation and Characterization; VCH: New York, 1991; p137. Stewart BD, Nico PS, Fendorf S. (2009) Stability of uranium incorporated into Fe (hydr)oxides under fluctuating redox conditions. Environ Sci Technol 43:4922– 4927. Suzuki Y.; Kelly, S. D.; Kemner, K. M.; Banfield, J. F., (2005) Direct microbial reduction and subsequent preservation of uranium in natural near-surface sediment. Applied and Environmental Microbiology 71: 1790-1797. Wielinga B, Bostick B, HanselCM, RosenzweigRF, Fendorf S. (2000) Inhibition of bacterially promoted uranium reduction: Ferric (hydr)oxides as competitive electron acceptors. Environ Sci Technol 34:2190–2195.