September 10, 2019

Norman E. Sharpless, M.D. Acting Commissioner Food and Drug Administration 1903 New Hampshire Avenue Silver Spring, MD 20993

Mitchell Zeller Director Center for Products Food and Drug Administration 10903 New Hampshire Avenue Silver Spring, MD 20993-0002

Dear Acting Commissioner Sharpless and Mr. Zeller,

We are writing to you today to express our concern for small businesses in the open vapor product industry in regard to the current PMTA guidance. Thousands of small vape shop owners and vapor product manufacturers are on the precipice of extinction. We are facing vague, unattainable regulatory gates and the terrifying threat of regulatory termination of the most impactful products to date. We are being forced to prepare for a future where we will not be able to afford costly and unclear premarket approval, casting small businesses out of the lifesaving industry that we once created. It is our that the FDA can convene with our industry representatives to develop a pathway to clear and concise industry regulation that is mutually agreeable.

Current PMTA guidance recommends extensive research into each product, which includes bottle size and variations, as well as environmental assessments. We are not large corporations that can afford to fund departments devoted to regulatory affairs, science, toxicology, and legal matters, nor do we have millions of dollars to secure these services. We are mostly “mom and pop” small businesses. Many of us started with nothing but a few thousand dollars and a desire to help smokers quit, using the same method we used ourselves. Through hard work, and a firm belief in our mission, we have been able to develop successful small businesses that have not only created job opportunities for thousands of people, but helped countless people quit , and even quit using nicotine entirely, for good. This industry was created by thousands of small business owners who exemplify the American Dream—that through dedication and hard work, everyone has the opportunity to be successful. The current PMTA structure may well turn out to be impossible to navigate or comply with, at least to any distinction of consistency and dependability for advancing products and incentivizing improvements.

Thus far, efforts to engage consultants, laboratory services, and legal counsel all seem to produce professional regulatory experts that are just as unclear on how to advance through FDA’s current regulatory structure successfully. This leaves the industry even further confused, and effectively paralyzed, as we consider the risk of potentially spending ourselves out of business – because none of these entities can provide definitive answers to a process that remains completely subjective. The estimated costs given to us by the very services we would need to utilize to achieve adequate PMTA submission, amounting to millions of dollars per SKU, are

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 2 of 36 significantly higher than the FDA’s “average application cost” of $131,643 for initial e-liquid submissions. PMTA guidance, by its very nature, gives the vapor industry a loose understanding of what will and won’t result in approval. These recommendations, combined with high costs for only a potential chance of approval, create an unrealistic paywall to industry compliance.

We are already beginning to see vape shops and vapor product manufacturers shut their doors—the smallest partnerships and family-owned businesses in the industry are steadily beginning to disappear. Some vapor product manufacturers are moving their American-based businesses to more vapor-friendly countries that have clear, attainable regulatory structures. Those manufacturers who do not have the ability to uproot their lives to make such a business move are instead selling their livelihood for pennies on the dollar, rather than risking a total loss when FDA exercises their enforcement discretion. Many members of the open vapor industry are making the difficult decision not to renew leases on the buildings they occupy because the pathway to remain on the market is completely subjective, undefined, and makes compliance extremely difficult, if not impossible. We will continue to see this industry slowly collapse under the heavy burden of the current regulatory framework that is unlike any other and offers no consistent baseline for the industry to follow.

It is clear that the outcome of the current regulatory structure will hand the entire vapor product industry to massive tobacco companies who have a long, sordid, and extremely profitable history of damaging the health and wellbeing of this country. The open vapor industry has and hopefully always will be able to be committed to helping combustible tobacco users transition to a nicotine delivery system that has been proven less harmful by orders of magnitude. We represent a group of businesses prepared to work with the FDA towards reasonable, realistic and sustainable regulations that are attainable for industry participants and more consistent with established and commonplace regulations for other consumable products.

Perhaps our most important concern is that combustible tobacco products, which are clearly and demonstrably harmful to public health, will be allowed to remain on the market in every smoke shop, gas station, grocery store, and convenience store in the country with little more than an age restriction and modest tax as a use deterrent. The only remaining choices Americans will have are combustible tobacco products, big tobacco company owned vapor products, or potentially hazardous, unsafe, and illegal black market products. Not only will these vague and unattainable PMTA guidelines reward tobacco companies for their current and past behavior, but they will also surely undo much of the hard work open vapor product manufacturers, distributors, and resellers have done to help millions of combustible tobacco users transition to safer nicotine delivery systems and even quit nicotine altogether.

Tobacco companies created the distrust that now exists. They also followed our lead into these less harmful alternatives while vilifying our products without factual basis. They have exponentially more resources, lobbyists, and influence, but current realities will give them the harm reduction market that we established and advanced. The current regulatory structure will take this from us and hand deliver it to those companies who created and advanced the harms of combustible cigarettes with no concern for the consequences. Furthermore, the FDA’s own age- of-sale enforcement stings show that youths are not obtaining these products from our industry participants, they obtain them from the tobacco distribution pathways.1

1 https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/statement-fda-commissioner-scott-gottlieb-md-forceful-new-actions-focused-retailers- manufacturers?utm_source=Eloqua&utm_medium=email&utm_term=stratcomms&utm_content=statement&utm_campaign=CTP+News%3A+ March4Announcement+-+3419&fbclid=IwAR3o1gS1Gx8R2QPExHlB_X3GUAoDp3u8rK_PGb2lD6CHTnwBGXBALeXyYVQ Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 3 of 36

So why allow tobacco companies to commandeer this industry when we are the ones who have introduced these products, created this new harm reduction strategy, and are verifiably (by the FDA’s own enforcement evaluations) maintaining youth sales prevention and discouragement?

Our concerns go beyond the loss of our businesses or the added power those losses would hand tobacco companies. We are equally concerned about vapor product manufacturing being handled by irresponsible, potentially dangerous black-market entities. These black-market entities will have no incentive to ensure that their illegal products follow standardized, unadulterated manufacturing practices. Consumers will unwittingly be put at risk by potentially hazardous and unsafe vapor products.

We understand and respect the FDA’s mandate to ensure reasonable consumer protections. We, the undersigned, are prepared to meet with FDA to cooperate and work together to find mutually satisfactory structures to regulate these products that will provide the requisite consumer protections, and also create a regulatory approach that is defined, clear, and attainable by those industry participants, like us, who are fully prepared to preserve and solidify the harm reduction public health benefits these products are capable of providing.

We hope the FDA will recognize and consider that this industry is different than any other. Most consumable products get introduced by big conglomerates or multinational manufacturers with correlative budgets and regulatory experts. Meanwhile, vapor products are facing regulatory approaches advanced many years after the products were already on store shelves. We acknowledge and respect the difficulties this adds for both the FDA and the industry. We are prepared to work with the FDA to find regulatory frameworks that meet our mutual goals. If we cannot find some realistic, consistent, and compliable common ground, businesses will close, thousands of jobs will be , many leases broken, investments lost (some even at life-changing levels) – many may lose their homes, savings, and much more.

On behalf of the undersigned 1,464 small vapor businesses, I respectfully request that you engage with us in a timely manner to navigate an attainable solution for small business owners so that we can reach our common goal: to save the lives of more than 480,000 American adult smokers a year without subjecting a new generation to nicotine addiction.

With warm regards,

Amanda Wheeler, Co-Owner Jvapes E-Liquid 1201 Iron Springs Rd., Suite 3 Prescott, AZ 86305 (928) 533-0352 [email protected]

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 4 of 36 Dustin & Cassy Pitts, Owners Eric Slaick, CEO Cornelius Hampton, Owner Cloud Addiction, LLC Save A Smoker Hit it N Quit it Vape Lounge Anniston, AL Dothan, AL Muscle Shoals, AL Curt Reynolds, Owner Keith R Lewis, Owner Lisa Murray, Owner Leet Vaping, LLC, dba Leet Vape North Alabama Vape S & L Vapes Athens & Toney, AL Florence, AL Opelika, AL Heidi Malone, Owner Tina Roberts, Owner Robert Ware, Owner Leet Vaping, LLC, dba Leet Vape TJ’s Juices Tiger Vapor Athens & Toney, AL Florence, AL Opelika, AL Sylvia Reynolds Stanford, Partner Debra Gruwell, Owner Wayne Murray, Owner Leet Vaping, LLC, dba Leet Vape Nu Way Vape S & L Vapes Athens & Toney, AL Florence, AL Opelika, Auburn & Montgomery, AL Joe Ferrell, Owner Karen Gean, Vice President Cindy West, Owner Attalla Vapor, Centre Vapes, Southern Vape Downtown Vape, LLC Gadsden Vapes & Southside Vapes Florence, AL Pell City, AL Attalla, AL Tina Roberts, Owner Jon Roundy, Owner

Jay & Meghan Hardesty, Owners Nu Way Vape & TJs Juices Tasty Haze, LLC VapenJays, LLC & The Amish Florence, AL Rainbow City, AL Collection Eliquid Daniel Duncan, Owner Ryan Austin, Owner Auburn, AL Vapor Craft Cold Vapes 907 Fort Payne, AL Anchorage, AK "Melissa Anderson , Owner Vapor Craft of Auburn Gordon Tinsley, Owner Shaun D'Sylva, Founder Auburn, AL" Sweet Home Vapor Co. Fatboy Vapors Gadsden, Guntersville & Anchorage, Wasilla & Fairbanks, AK Landon Barton, Owner Hampton Cove, AL 205 Vape Shop Ryan & Tanya Kitka, Owners

Bessemer, AL Phil Ferguson, Owner Kodiak Steam Trunk, LLC Kodiak, AK Amy Albers, Co-Owner Fergy’s Vape Gardendale, AL Vaper Forge Steven Mapes, Owner Birmingham, AL John Hurd, Owner Mapes Vapes Soldotna, AK Michael Ibe, Owner Mystik Vape, LLC Cahaba Vapes, LLC Hartselle, AL Elia Najm, Owner Birmingham, AL Randy Toffel, Owner .World Avondale, AZ Rhonda Osment Lambert, Co-Founder Vapeology, LLC The Vapor Apothecary Hoover, AL Parviz Barati, Owner Birmingham, AL Stokes Tod Yarbrough, Owner Vapor Solutions Bisbee, AZ Gordon Tinsley, Owner Vape On!, LLC Earths Bounty & The Vape Place Madison, AL Tim Tibbles, Owner Boaz, AL Stardust Martin, Owner Bullhead Vape, LLC Bullhead City, AZ Keith aldijaili, Owner Vapor Magic Vapors of Alabama, Inc. McCalla, AL Richard Blodgett, Owner Cullman, AL Buzzy Owen, Owner White Mountains Vape Concho, AZ Rod Cochran, CEO/Founder Vapor Dreamz Mobile, AL Vape Radio Elizabeth Browning, Owner Daphne, AL William H. Robertson, Owner Vixen Vapes Cottonwood, AZ Zack Carpenter, Owner Vapor Craft of Montgomery Cyclops Vapor, LLC Montgomery & Tuscaloosa, AL Daphne, AL

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 5 of 36 Alex & Jessica Griffith, Owners Karim Salem, President Minh Tran, Owner/CEO The Ohm Factory Lite it Up, Inc. Vape Central Gilbert, AZ Mesa, AZ Phoenix, AZ Dan Short, Owner Kris O'Connor, Owner Rick Avila, Owner Short Designs, LLC Irican Mods Spartan Distribution Glendale, AZ Mesa, AZ Phoenix, AZ Debbie Pearson, Owner Melissa Shedd, Owner Ronald Beneduce, Owner Red Vapor, LLC Southern Beginnings, LLC Nimbus House Glendale, AZ Mesa, AZ Phoenix, AZ Jessi Bell, Owner Tony Valenzuela, Owner Ronn Beneduce, Owner Red Vapor, LLC The Habit Smoke Shop Nimbus House, LLC, TrapT Eliquid & Juice Fiend Glendale, AZ Mesa, AZ Phoenix, AZ Amanda Rice, Owner Igor Vojvodic, Owner Steve Johnson, Co-owner Vape Escapes Glendale BroScience Vapes, LLC Glenn Johnson Ventures, LLC Glendale, AZ Peoria, AZ Phoenix, AZ Frank Zeiter, Owner Carlos Coe, Director William Sagert, Owner Frank N Juice, LLC Mr. Vape USA Phoenix Vape Supply, LLC Glendale, AZ Phoenix, AZ Phoenix, AZ Ali A Odeh, Owner Dave Morris, Owner Amanda & Jourdan Wheeler, Owners V. World, LLC Vape Gravy Brands, LLC Jvapes E-Liquid Goodyear, AZ Phoenix, AZ Prescott, AZ Carlos Olea, CEO Edward Townes, Owner John Fisher, Owner Exotica Vapor Shop Synergy Mixing Labs, LLC Jvapes Hermosillo, AZ Phoenix, AZ Prescott, AZ Patrick Legenzoff, Owner Eli Kaczka Michael Brown, Owner Designer Vape, LLC New Method, Owner Valor Vapor Prescott Laveen, AZ This Old Vape Shop, Co-owner Prescott, AZ Phoenix, AZ Randy Miller, Owner Geoff Habicht, President Joel Rivera, Owner The Vapor Pimp, LLC SV3, LLC Steam Heaven Laveen, AZ Phoenix, AZ Rio Rico, AZ Anthony & Sonia Perkins, Owner James Willett, Owner Sofia Coert, Owner Oracle Vapory American Vapor Group The Vaporium/A Vape Escape, LLC Mesa, AZ Phoenix, AZ Sedona, AZ Craig Larsen, Owner John-Paul Willett, CEO Benjamin Cruz, Owner Kidney Puncher, LLC Red Vapor Monstro, LLC Mesa, AZ Phoenix, AZ Surprise, AZ David Riddle, Owner Keith Higgins, Director of Operations Gunnar & Katie Birtel, Owner Vape Era Kure GK Vapor Mesa, AZ Phoenix, AZ Surprise, AZ Declan Clarke, General Managing Partner Kyle Adolph, Co-owner Josh Aguiar, Owner Gourmet Vapor Cream Vapor, Redline Vapor Mesa, AZ Adult Geared Eliquid & Loverly Surprise, AZ Phoenix, AZ James Thompson, Owner Conor Rauen, Owner Mt Baker Vapor Layal Aoufe, Owner Mums Fantasy Factory Mesa, AZ Liquid Vape Tempe, AZ Phoenix, AZ

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 6 of 36 Beecher Howard, Owner Troy & Melissa Meuret, Owner Brian Buenaventura, Owner Coilturd, LLC Vapers BJC Tucson, AZ Little Rock & Russellville, AR Cerritos, CA Brett Flagg, Owner William & Brenda McCullough, Owners DJay Salas, VP Southwest Smokeless My Home Town Vapor The Finest Eliquid Tucson, AZ Little Rock, AR Chatsworth, CA Eddie & Maggie Jayko, Owners Shawn Bresnahan, Owner Jimmy Fung, Owner Southwest Smokeless Brooklyns Vape Shop VPR Collection Tucson, AZ Morrilton, AR City of Industry, CA Kyle Barnett, Owner Topher Kent, Owner Peter Koch, Chief Operating Officer The Vape Zone Smokeless Rogue Vapers 2 Cosmic Fog Vapors Tucson, AZ North Little Rock, AR Costa Mesa, CA Luke Carnathan, CEO Sharon Goodson, Owner/Operator Shane Simpson, Owner Double Tap Vapor, LLC JRILY Enterprises, LLC C3 Vapors and Coffee, Tucson, AZ Rogers, AR The Company MFG, LLC & Crumbz Vapor Costa Mesa, CA Rod Criger, Owner/Operator Rhonda Yi, Owner Suzanne Gearhart, Owner Vape or Dye, LLC, The Velvet Vapor & High Tide Vapes dba Southwest Smokeless Hillbilly Hooch E-Juice Co. Crescent City, CA Tucson, AZ Rogers, AR Allen Epley, Owner Bobby White, Owner Inho Choi, Owner Vapor Pros Rogue Vapers Searcy VAPE Couture Tucson, AZ Searcy, AR Cypress, CA Joshua Stewart, Owner Donna Miller-Stacy, Owner Mac Chu, Owner Vapor Pros Payless Tobacco & Vape Sensual Cloud Vapors Tucson, AZ Sherwood, AR Daly City, CA Nicholas LaBanca, Owner/CEO James H Stacy, Owner Molly Sylvester, Owner Vapor-Riffic, Inc. Alishas 3 Cs, Vapin the 619 Conway, AR dba Payless Tobacco and Vape El Cajon, CA Sherwood, AR Michael Glisson, Owner Mark Fabela, Owner James Raymond, CEO New Era Vapours Cool Whic Cotton South Coast Vapor Co. Corning, AR Alhambra, CA Encinitas, CA Jamie Weaver, Owner Garrett Mann, Owner Marlow Younan, Owner Drippers Vape Shop E-Cig , LLC TVL and PlanB Mods El Dorado, AR Aliso Viejo, CA Escondido, CA Alicia Fanning, Owner Anthony Garcia, Owner Anthony Jaramillo, Owner Vapor Springs Cyber Liquids, LLC Flawless Vapes and Supplies, LLC Eureka Springs, AR Anaheim, CA Fountian Valley, CA David Lawson, Owner Kiyo Sato, Owner Jason Davis, Owner Buffalo River Elixirs & 2 Pimps Juice Lab Sugarlicious E Liquids Midas Vape Flippin, AR Anaheim, CA Garden Grove, CA Scout Stubbs, Owner David Vanburen, Owner Patrick Mulcahy, CEO Drippers Vape Shop Big City Vapor Streamline Vape Co., LLC Greenbrier, AR Anderson, CA Garden Grove, CA Supreet Momi, Owner Hani Tannous, Owner Huy Nguyen, Owner Vapor House Tannous Enterprises USA Vape Lab Little Rock, AR Belmont, CA Huntington Beach, CA

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 7 of 36 Bert SY, CEO Ryan Thomas, Owner Steve Shazad, Owner Ism Vape, Inc. Lost Art Liquids Smokes Huntington Beach, CA , CA Palmdale, CA Daniel Coleman, Owner Scott Friedman, CEO Eddie Yin, Owner Desce, Inc. Tasty Cloud Vape Co., LLC Asmodus Distribution Huntington Beach, CA Los Angeles, CA Paramount, CA Chris Wheeler, CEO James Whiting, Co-Owner Raffy Tasmajian, Owner Savage Enterprises E-Cig City Mission Viejo, LLC The Clean Vape Irvine, CA Mission Viejo, CA Pasadena, CA Jay Oku, Partner Brian Weber, Owner Lacey Miller, Owner Five Pawns, LLC Mohawk Vapors The Vapour Lounge Irvine, CA Moreno Valley, CA Rancho Cucamonga, CA Mark Mathis, Owner Ryan Stump, Owner Jeff and Kari Hess, Owner Voltrove Charlies Chalk Dust Nor Cal Vape Kelseyville, CA Newport Beach, CA Redding, CA Chris Messick, Owner Brandon Acosta, President Rami Issa, Owner Vapor Meister The Neighborhood E-Liquid Royal Smoke Shop Lakeside, CA Norco, CA Rialto, CA Kristen & Dwane Morrison, Owners Ryan Chalme, Owner Brian Bereber, Owner/CEO Liquid EFX, Inc. Vapor Delux Drip More Long Beach, CA North Hollywood, CA Riverside, CA Travis Anthony, Owner Daoud Muwahed, Co-owner Brian Heacox, President Vapor Land The Right Investment Doomsday Gourmet, LLC Long Beach, CA Oceanside, CA Sacramento, CA Samer Kauzman, Owner Fabiola Elias Ramsey Khaled, Owner Smoking Box Feels Good Vapor, Inc. Cig Zone Long Beach, CA Oceanside, CA San Bernardino, CA Arsen Stepanyan, Owner Fig Ramsey Jake Rubenstein, President Aspire Vape Co FGV, Inc. Nude Nicotine Los Angeles, CA Oceanside, CA San Diego, CA Ash Mazarei, CMO Yazan Muowahid, Owner James Mitchell, Founder Liquid Barn Aroma Avenue Vape Vapor Invasion, LLC Los Angeles, CA Oceanside, CA San Diego, CA Brett Goldenberg, Managing Member Monica Schick, CEO Mike Ebrahimi, Owner All Day Vapes North Guide Solutions, Inc. Vapor Authority Los Angeles, CA Ontario, CA San Diego, CA Jennifer Cacavas, Owner Russ Smelser, Owner Todd Skezas, Owner J2 Productions Desert Vapors Vapor Authority Los Angeles, CA Palm Desert, CA San Diego, CA John JJ Jenkins, Owner Susan Decell, Co-Owner Elia Baida, Owner The Vapor Spot Vapor Capers, LLC dba LunaVapes Tobacco Spot Los Angeles, CA Palm Desert, CA San Fernando, CA Kai Chen, Managing Member Victoria Drower, Owner Nam Nguyen, Owner All Day Vapes Desert Vapors Stay Vaped Los Angeles, CA Palm Desert, CA San Jose, CA

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 8 of 36 Tony Doan, CEO Jacob Nesheiwat, Owner Joshua L Sprague, Owner Shijin Vapor Vaperack, Inc. Absolute Vapor Lounge San Jose, CA Whittier, CA Colorado Springs, CO Mike Guitron, Owner Louis Peick, Owner Margaret Shable, COO Cloud 9 Unique Vapors Flavor Monster San Marcos, CA Wildomar, CA Colorado Springs, CO Austin Hopper, President Joe Vondruska, Owner Tanner Adams, Owner Tailored Vapors MFG Cignot Colorado Chief Vapor Santa Ana, CA Arvada, CO Colorado Springs, CO Patrick Taylor, CEO Justin Ganoe, Owner Laura Riggs, President Nicky Drops Inno-Vapor Artisan Vaper, Inc., DBA Flavor Monster Santa Ana, CA Arvada, CO Colorado Springs, CO Travis Hostutler, President James Corey, Owner Clayton Kelley, Owner/Managing Partner Arc Distribution Woodshark Trading Company Vape Loft - Denver Santa Ana, CA Aurora, CO Denver, CO Nathan Kinghorn, Owner Patrick Vandiver, Owner Cory Vigil, President Simple, Inc. High-Voltage Vapes Boosted Ejuice Santa Ana, CA Aurora, CO Denver, CO Patrick Visconti, Co-founder Timothy Roberts, Owner Ian Firth, Owner Tailored Vapors, LLC Perfect Alternatives Cloud Provisions, LLC Santa Ana, CA Aurora, CO Denver, CO Dr. Andrew Dyson, Owner Caleb Vannice, Owner Robert Lindsey, Owner Mothers Milk WTA (MMWTA) Merkury, LLC Vapor HQ Santa Clara, CA Bailey, CO Englewood, CO Tarik Dugum, CEO Ginger & Sean Tanner, Owners Chris burgess, CEO DripNvape, Inc. Boulder Vapor House E cig, LLC Santa Clarita, CA Boulder, CO Federal heights & Denver, CO Randolph B Freer, CEO/Owner Nathan T Keller, President Dan Rzonca, Owner P.O.E.T. Ind. Inc. The Game Trader, Inc., The Magic Dragon Vape Shop Seal Beach, CA dba Steampunk E-lixers Glenwood Springs, CO Brighton, CO Steve Green, Owner Peggy Hegler, Owner Raquel Morton, Owner Mountain Vapors VAPEz, LLC 970 Vapor Cigs / 971 Vapor Cigs Sonora, CA Castle Rock, CO Glenwood Springs, CO Raymond Yang, Owner Mark Branson, Owner Shylo Harlan, Owner BLVK Unicorn Centennial Vapor 970 Vapor Cigs / 971 Vapor Cigs South El Monte, CA Centennia, CO Glenwood Springs, CO Jimmy Wilson, Owner Michael & Jennifer Mahaney, Owners Monica Vondruska, Owner Vapor Mo's Headed West Free Range Vapor Stockton, CA Centennial, CO Golden, CO Lonnie J. Bozeman, President & CEO Sarah Walter, Owner Monica Vondruska, Owner Saveurvape Vapewize Centennial, LLC Uska Designs Torrance, CA Centennial, CO Golden, CO Luis Martinez, Owner Christofer Parker, CEO Bill Lash, Owner VAME Vapory, LLC A Perfect Vape, Inc. Lost iN Time, L.i.T iN GJC LLC Torrance, CA Colorado Springs, CO Grand Jct, CO

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 9 of 36 Dominette Celli, President Corbin Elliott, Owner/Operator John Papaspyrou, Owner Lizard Lounge Vapor HTO, LLC, dba Up in Vape DeadMenzHandz Grand Junction, CO Thornton, CO Seymour, CT Dominette Celli, President Ann Fulgham, Owner Christine Solazzo, Founder Indy Vapes Elite Vapes Very Vocal Vapers Grand Junction, CO Thornton, CO South Windsor, CT Andrew Salsbury, Owner Kateri & Shawn Hillis, Owner Albert Barone, Owner Cloudy Peak Vapes, LLC Mountain Pass Premium Elixirs Ab3 LLC, DBA Puffin Vapor & Leaf Greenwood Village, CO Westminster, CO Vernon, CT James Beutler, Owner Shawn and Kateri Hillis, Owners Don Thompson, CEO Vapergate The Vapor Shop The Zen Vaper E-Liquids, LLC Lakewood, CO Westminster, CO Claymont, DE Keith Pettersen, Owner Lori Johnson, Owner David R Eisenhour, CEO Rocky Mountain Ecigs, LLC Steep Slope Vape Supply Delmar Vapor Lounge, LLC Lakewood, CO Wheat Ridge, CO Delmar, DE Robert South, Owner Betti & Dave Anderliter, Owners Don Wills, Owner Budz House of Vape Mountain Vapor Lounge Maxed Out Vape Lakewood, CO Woodland Park, CO Dover, DE Shaune Walter, Owner Ben Harrison, Owner Macchavelli Spielberg, Owner VapeWize, LLC E-Six, LLC The Modfather, Inc. Lakewood, CO Branford, CT Middle Island, DE James & Kelly Cline, Owners Joseph Menna, Owner Andrew Wolford, Owner FogTown, Ltd. E-Six, LLC Delaware Vapor Lamar, CO Branford, CT Newark, DE Anthony Acosta, Owner Ted Szabo, Owner Harrison Kay, Owner Skys The Limit Industries E-Six, LLC Evocation Elixirs Littleton, CO Branford, CT Odessa, DE James Evans, Owner Albert Hamon, Owner Michael Crilley, Owner Skys The Limit Industries UVAPE ,LLC Evocation Elixirs Littleton, CO Colchester, CT Odessa, DE Michael Huff, Owner Mark Nowak, Owner Barbara Hogan, COO Moutain View Vapes Pure Cigs, LLC LanMark Alternatives, LLC Littleton, CO Hartford, CT Bradenton, FL Daniel Garcia, Owner Chris Leary, Partner Brandy Shriver, Owner Legacy Vapors HLMS, LLC Big John’s Vapes Loveland, CO Milford, CT Brandon, FL Francesca Gettler, CEO Chandler Kopacz, Owner Shannon Whitesell, Owner Vapor Source, Inc. Fog Factory Elysium Vapor Co. Pueblo, Colorado Springs, Fountain, New London, CT Brandon, FL Trinidad & Canon City, CO Adam Webster, Owner Steven Kollias, Owner

Jason Casados, Owner The Steam Co. Red Shield Reserve, Inc. Vapor Source, Inc. Orange, CT Brooksville, FL Pueblo, Colorado Springs, Fountain, Cassidy Greathouse, Owner Monique Levesque, Owner Trinidad & Canon City, CO Quite Corner Vapor Shop, LLC Cloud 352, LLC Putnam, CT Bushnell, FL Beverly Strength, Owner Crazy B’s Smoke Shop Ridgway, CO

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 10 of 36 Robert Hargrove, Managing Partner Logan Lampert, Owner Bjorn B Johansen, President Naples Vapor, LLC Mamas Kitchen Broward Vapor Stores, Inc. Cape Coral, FL Jacksonville, FL Miramar, FL Nick Orlando, CEO Will Arnold, Owner Sam Markopulos, Partner/Owner The Vapers Depot Mamas Kitchen Sweet Southern Vapes Clearwater, FL Jacksonville, FL Niceville, FL Terrance & Bonnie Shaw, Owners Glen Newman, Owner Miles Corson, Owner Vapin Crazy E-cigs & Juice, LLC Blackhat Vapor Company Take a Break Vapes Clermont, FL Jacksonville, FL North Palm Beach, FL Ryan Silva, President Lance Culver, Managing Partner Stacey Pescosta, Owner Ryan Flavors Blackhat Vapor Company Breathe Free E Cig, Inc., & Coral Springs, FL Jacksonville, FL NPB Vapes North Palm Beach, FL Horacio Moreno, Owner Scott & Lorrie Covington, President

Offensive Clouds Distro Vapin in the Cape, LLC Jeff Wood, CEO Davie, FL Kissimmee, FL Let the Smoke Out! Ocala, FL Nick Bold, CEO Kevin Cinar, Owner Just Eliquids Distro, Inc. & Mountain Oak Vapors Stephen Perry, Owner The Vapor Club Lake Mary, FL Maxx Vape Co. Deerfield Beach, FL Ocala, FL Craig & Kristin Heflin, Owner

Jonathan Risteen, Owner Doghouse Vapes, LLC Christopher Kennedy, Owner Gentleman’s Draw E-Liquid Largo, FL Psiquid E-Liquid Edgewater, FL Paul Vairo, Owner Orlando, FL Keilei Ann MacInness, Owner Viper Vape & Smoke Company David Jones, Owner TNA Vapes Largo, FL Orlando Vape & E-Cig Eustis, FL Timothy Gee, Owner Orlando, FL Nikole Maloy, Owner Mr. Gee Liquids Sonny Westmoreland, Owner Vape Out Largo, FL Monster Vape Labs Fernandina Beach, FL Orlando, FL Sean Kenny, Owner Brian Lavin, Owner Rock Bottom Vapes, LLC David Speung, Owner Pro Vapor & Sinful E-Liquids Longwood, FL O Town Vapes Fort Lauderdale, FL Eric Gilbert, Owner/President Orlando, FL Dan Marlin, Owner Vapor Technologies, Inc. Lievers, Owner Johnny Copper Vapor Co. Marianna, FL Lifted Spirits Vape & More Green Cove Springs, FL Joy & Patrick Vota, Owners Palatka, FL Sarah Fairman & Keith Fairman, Owners Simply Vapor John Avey, Owner Diamond Vapor, LLC & Mary Esther, FL Palm Beach Vapors Diamond Distro, LLC Rob Blankenship, Co-owner Palm Beach, FL Hollywood, FL Secret City Vapor Paul Strand, Owner Ft Walton Beach, Mary Esther & Victoria Parr, Owner Shop Vapes, Inc. Navarre, FL Palm Beach Gardens, FL Vapor This Florida, LLC Martha Rodriguez, Owner Inverness, FL Happy Vapor Shops Robert Watson, Owner Drew Chase, Owner Miami, FL Smokin Vapor Axis Vapor Panama City, FL James Jackson, Owner Jacksonville, FL Jacks Vapor Michael Angell, Owner Ernesto Fragoso, Owner Milton, FL Angel Vapors New Start Vapor Company Panama City Beach, FL Jacksonville, FL

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 11 of 36 Harvey Brodzki, Owner Alycia Singleton, Owner Jorge Rios, Owner Parkland Vapors Vapors Premier Vapor Lounge Parkland, FL Saint Petersburg, FL Tavares, FL Daniel Canceleno, Owner Judi Hall, Owner Laura Dupuis, Owner The Salty Vapor Vapor Vault Vero Vapor, LLC Pensacola, FL Sait Petersburg, FL Vero beach, FL Eugenia L Crump, Owner Joe Capozzi, Owner Trevor Campbell, Owner/CEA Vaping Genie, LLC Clean Blends Vapor Unlimited, LLC Pensacola, FL Sarasota, FL Wesley Chapel, FL Patricia Stokes, Owner Michael Boling, CEO Bogdan Gradinariu, Owner The Vape Shop of Pensacola American Bottle and Packaging Myvapor-Lounge, LLC Pensacola, FL Sarasota, FL Winter Garden, FL Joe Carco, Owner Matt & Shannon Conner, Owners Kathi Murtagh, Co-Owner Jim’s Vape Escape, Inc. CNR Vapors LLC & Vapor Trails, Inc. VapeRings Pensacola, FL Spring Hill, FL Acworth, GA Anthony Nieblas, Owner Chris Conte, Partner Evan M. Cochran, Owner Coil Butter Dixie Vapor Odysseus Vapor, LLC Pinellas Park, FL St. Augustine, FL Alpharetta, GA Paul Foote, Owner Ericka Nelson, Owner Melissa Anderson, Owner PDF Media Designs Blind Squirrel Blends Vapor Craft of Auburn Pinellas Park, FL Starke, FL Columbus, GA Auburn, AL Brad Kugler, Owners Aaron Cartwright, Owner Craig Perryman, Owner Steam Train Vapor Company C Solution Services Crazy Vapors, LLC Pinellas Park & Clearwater, FL Stuart, FL Augusta, GA Jordan Dalessio, Owner J.D. McCormick, Owner Kristy Valdes, Owner Steam Train Vapor Company Vape Haven, Chrome Liquid & Empire of E Cigs Pinellas Park & Clearwater, FL Rogue Liquid Blairsville, GA Tallahassee, FL Richard Webb, Owner Robin C Carter, Owner Molten Arts, LLC Angel Collazo, Owner Art of Vaping Port Richey, FL Wolfpaq E-liquid & The Vape Discount Bremen, GA Tampa, FL Jaime Price, Owner Sheryl Whitaker, Owner ATL Vaping John & Mike Synychak, Owners Smokers Wanted Vapor Company, LLC Port Saint Joe, FL Tampa Vapor, Inc. Brunswick, GA Tampa, FL Steve Scales, Owner Karen Norris, Owner VLS Brands, LLC Michael Cherup, Owner VapeWares Port St. Lucie, FL LBC Vapor, LLC dba South Tampa Vape Buford, GA Tampa, FL Peter Bertorello, Owner London Osborn, Owner Puffs Tobacco Thomas Mueller, Owner Working Class Vapors Riverview, FL Affluent Wellness and Vapor Lounge & Cairo, GA Affluent Eliquid Shane Johnson, Owner Jacob Menard, President Tampa, FL Fuzion Vapor Maximum Vapor Saint Augustine, FL TD Bowen, CEO Moon Mountain, LLC Canton, GA Tampa, FL Justin Sampson, Owner Eric Albright, Owner Downsouth Vapors Cool Vapors Carrollton Saint Cloud, FL Cindy Kinch, Owner Lady Boss Vapor Carrollton, GA Tarpon Springs, FL

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 12 of 36 Michael & Donya Davis, Owners Bobby Lewis, Owner Amy Washington, Owner Cedartown Vapor Lounge, LLC & My Vape Shack Smoke Stop Vape Shop Tasty Wicks, LLC Dawsonville, GA Lagrange, GA Cedartown, BA Alan & Vicki Futch, Owners Bob Lewis, Owner

Michael & Donya Davis, Owners Vaping Easy Hard Rock Vapor, LLC Cedartown Vapor Lounge Douglas, GA Lawrenceville, GA Cedartown, GA Donald &Tracy Shelnutt, Owners Tobey Cox, CEO Michael & Donya Davis, Owners Atl Vaping Juanavape Tasty Wicks E-liquid Douglasville, GA Leesburg, GA Cedartown, GA Justin Flores, Owner David & Jennifer Higginbotham, Owner Eric Turner, Co-Owner Venture E-Liquid Lab HiggyCigs, LLC Vapourizen Elberton, GA Lilburn, GA Clayton, GA Scott M Wolkow, COO Wesley Swanson, CEO Fredrick Setelin II, Co-owner Victorious Vapors, LLC Bulldog Vapor, LLC Rivertown Vapor, LLC Evans, GA Loganville, GA Columbus, GA Angela Funderburk, Owner Tara & Phillip Alexander, Owner Keith & Sherry Gossett, Owners Emote Vapes Opt2mist Vapor Shop, LLC Buckys, LLC, dba Buckys Vape Shop Fort Oglethorpe, GA Lula & Cornelia, GA Columbus, GA Joe King, Owner Joe Exum, Owner Michael Reynolds, Co-owner The Shoppe Macon Vape and More Rivertown Vapor, LLC Fort Oglethorpe, GA Macon, GA Columbus, GA Billy Lowery, Owner Lisa Gano, Owner Joseph Cacciatore, COO In the Cloudz, LLC VapeRite.com JC Vape Shop, LLC GA Marietta, GA Columbus, GA Donna Turner, Owner Jason Wells, Owner Melissa Anderson, Owner Electric Smoke, LLC Vaporious, LLC Vapor Craft of North Columbus Griffin, GA Marietta & Dallas, GA Columbus, GA Michael Lee Bailor, Owner Geraldo Saldanha, Owner Jason Carroll, Owner Olde Towne Vape Shoppe L&G Alibaba Smoke and Vapor Pipe Vapors Griffin, GA Moultrie, GA Cornelia, GA Deidra Casey, Owner Lester Rodrigues, Owner Noah Richardson, CEO Sundance Southern Vapors Alibaba Vapor and Tobacco Colonial Vapor, LLC Grovetown & Harlem, GA Moultrie, GA Cumming, GA Anthony Cecchetto, Owner Trent Struck, Jr., Owner Scott Tripp, Owner Crazycanadiangrass Vapes Gone Wild Vapors Emporium GA LLC Hiram, GA Newnan, GA Cumming, GA Cathy Stonemark, Owner Douglas Rudler, Owner Eric & Susan Stutzman, Owners Ciggys D and D Concessions, LLC Ciggys2 Hiram, GA Perry, GA Dallas, GA Keith England, Owner Gayle Kraft, Owner/Partner Carrie Heffner & John O'Connor, Owners FogItUp! Vape Shop Vapor Trails, LLC Vapers Alley Hiram, GA Pooler, GA Dalton & Chatsworth, GA Justin Kicklighter, CEO Joseph M Yarger, Owner John Ashley Fields, Owner My Vape Bar MFG The Wolfy Vape MidKnight Mods, LLC Kennesaw, GA Ray City, GA Danielsville, GA

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 13 of 36 Jon & Dana Alfred, Owners Garett Uyesugi, Owner James Sumner, Owner Signature Vapors Island ecig and Vape Co. Cloudhut Vaping Company Ringgold, GA Kahului, HI Nampa, ID Shea Dale, Owner Derek Dame Jose Quintero, Owner Star Promos, LLC, dba The Cloud Shack Known Distro, LLC Vape Kastle Rome, GA Vape Storm Labs, LLC & KL Labs, LLC Nampa, ID Boise, ID Jack & Morgan Nathan, Owners Erica Spivey, Owner Ben Bosworth, Owner VapeZone, Inc. Primal Elixir & Vapun Magazine Outlaw Vapor Roswell, GA Boise, ID Pocatello, ID Devin Flagor, Owner Ryan Muckenthaler, Owner Michael Thorn, Owner Patriot Vapors Vape Vaporland Saint Marys, GA Boise, ID Post Falls & Marysville, ID Dillon Gilbert, Owner Erica Louise Emory, CEO Travis Gledhill, Owner The Vape Loft Vapun Magazine Gtc, LLC dba Outlaw Vapor Savannah, GA Boise, ID Preston & Malad, ID Nancy Truong, Owner Evan Drake Fischer, Owner Samantha Pruitt, Co-owner Southeast Vapes Durity Vape and Smoke Mountain River Vapor Company Savannah, GA Boise, ID Rigby, ID Rick D Conner, Owner Michael Larsen, Partner/Director of Sales Shelly Papke, Owner City Vape, LLC Lotus Vaping Technologies Cjs Vapehouse, LLC Savannah, GA Boise, ID Twin Falls, ID Vimesh Patel, Owner Nathan Maggard, Owner Brandin Olsen, Co-Owner The Vape Loft, Foghouse Vapors & Atomic Vapor Supply Metro East Vapor Supply Skye Vapes Boise, ID Alton, IL Savannah, GA Charles M. Rose, Co-Owner Duston Wurtz, Owner Farris Tompkins, Owner Ejuice BLVD, LLP Metro East Vapor Supply Foghouse Vapors & Basic Eliquids Caldwell, ID Alton, IL Statesboro, GA Jeremy & Stacy Foresee, CFO/Co-owner Demondre Cotton, Owner Marcus Bannister, Owner Ejuice BLVD, LLC The Vapory Foghouse Vapors & Basic Eliquids Caldwell, ID Belleville, IL Statesboro, GA Heidi & Trent Carrell, Owner Kiel Carl, Owner Stephanie Hayes, Owner The Vaping Outlet Liquid Temptations Absolem Vapes Idaho Falls, ID Bloomington, IL Stockbridge, GA Nicholas Richards, Co-owner Scott Walk, Owner Brian McReynolds, Owner Wick N Vape, LLC Smokers Choice Angry Dragon Vapors, LLC Meridian, ID Bloomington, IL Villa Rica, GA Tessa Lancaster, Owner Wanda K. Janssen, Owner Paula Perkins, Owner Vapor Loft Chinden Veteran's Vape, Inc. West Georgia Vape Meridian, ID Bradley, IL Villa Rics, GA Shelley Epstein, Owner Shukri Yanni, Owner Apryl & Stewart Pickering, Owners Bear Lake Vape Transistor, LLC Epic Vapes, LLC Montpelier, ID Buffalo Grove, IL Winder, GA Bob miller, Owner Heather Hosick, Owner Keith Uyeno, Owner Canyon Vapors Up in Vape Pacific Express, Inc. Nampa, ID Carmi, IL Honolulu, HI

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 14 of 36 Tiffany Looman, Owner Reid Nuttall, Owner Kevin D Brazell, Owner Flavor Vapor, Inc. Cool Clouds, LLC Mixing-It-Up Vape Shop Centralia, IL Evergreen Park, IL Metropolis, IL Melissa Freeman, Owner Patrick Browning, Owner Tiffany Smith, Owner Vapors E-cigs E-Liquidz I80 Vapors Champaign, IL Fairfield, IL Morris, IL Michael Ballerini, Owner David & Marie Workman, Owners Kathy Linker, Owner Stardust Vapes, LLC D&M Vape and Nutrition Vapor Haus Mt. Prospect Champaign, IL Flora, IL Mt. Prospect, IL Scott Shull, Owner Dirk Critser, Owners Paul Hansel, Owner Vape Vault, Inc. 309 Vapors Vapor Haus Mt. Prospect Champaign, IL Macomb & Galesburg, IL Mt. Prospect, IL Chris Mann, Owner Stacey Crister, Owner Bryn Hubbard, Owner Legendary Vapor 311 Vapors Tri Moon Vapes Chicago, IL Macomb & Galesburg, IL Mt. Vernon, IL Richard Victorio, Owner Jeff & Tammy Thurow, Owners Steve Symmonds, Owner Isovape Corporation Vapor Effect, LLC Market Street Vaping Chicago, IL Harvard, IL Paxton, IL Larry Eng, Owner/Operator Roger Walker, Owner Donna Tello, Owner Level Vape, LLC Vapors 4 U E-Cigs Depot, LLC Chicago, IL Herrin, IL Peoria, IL Jodee Barks, Owner Jerrie M Belcher, Owner Joshua Malone, Owner Mystic Vapes Jerries Si Vapors, LLC Cloud Express & Lost City Creations Collinsville, IL Herrin, IL Peoria, IL Jill Yates, Owner Tony Persico, Owner Gail Smolinski, Owner Mystic Vapes Haze Vapor, Inc. TGI Vapor Collinsville, IL Island Lake, IL Robinson, IL William Peska, Owner Craig Kitson, CEO Thad Headley, Owner Bulk Clouds Vapor, LLC 911 Vapor, Inc. Quad City Vapers Club, LLC Dixon, IL Jacksonville, IL Rock Island, IL Tisha D'Ambrosio Shelli Tribble, Owner Marco Altamore, Owner St Vape 111, Inc, Downers Grove, IL Tribble Vapors Marcos Vapor Strictly, Inc., Woodridge, IL Jacksonville, IL Rockford, IL Michele Frans, Co-owner Tim Teml, CE0 Adam Fitzgerald, Owner Breathe Vapor, LLC That 1 Vape Vape-N-Juice & VPN Liquids East Peoria, IL Joliet, IL Rockford, IL Tom Connor, Owner Jaime Havenar & Wesley Martinez, OwnersJeremy Petrocelli, Owner Basic Liquid Boss Vapes, LLC Vape-N-Juice & VPN Liquids Elmhurst, IL Lasalle, Ottawa & Mendota, IL Rockford, IL Victoria Vasconcellos, Owner Tisha D'Ambrosio Kandy I Overton, Owner Cignot, Inc. Dank E-Juice LLC, Lockport, IL Gogos Variety and Vapor Elmhurst, IL St Vape 11, Inc., Lockport, IL Sivlis, IL Bridget Carey, Owner Diana Crister, Owner Tracy Larsen, Owner Cool Clouds, LLC 309 Vapors Elixrz Evergreen Park, IL Macomb & Galesburg, IL South Elgin, IL

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 15 of 36 Paul & Vicki Schmidt, Owner Lisa Tift, Owner Jeremy Vallet, Owner Chuckin Clouds Vape Shop Indy’s Vape Escape, LLC Smokin Hot, LLC Troy, IL Greenfield, IN Centerville, Ottumwa & Oskaloosa, IA Richard Ussery, President Brent A. McCullough, President Thomas Hudson, Owner Meowphomet, Inc. dba RPM Vape Hoosier E-Cig Inc., Exiled Vapes & 515 Vape and Disc, LLC Vernon Hills, IL Exiled E-Liquid Clive, IA Greensburg, IN Rick Ussery, Co-Owner Todd Smith, Founder

RPM Vape James Colip, Owner The Vaporosity Shops, Inc. Vernon Hills, IL 317 Vapers Davenport, IA Charlene Craft, Owner Greenwood, IN Jason Glenn, Owner Hayze Vape, LLC David Schuetter, Owner / Partner Taste the Vape, LLC Waukegan, IL Db Vapes, LLC Des Moines, IA Danne & Heathe Reinke, Owner Indianapolis, IN Travis Puls, Owner 3D Vapor Melissa & Willie Zollicoffer, Owners Atmosphere Vapors Wood River, IL Big Willie’s Liquids Grinell, IA Indianapolis, IN Charlotte Stowers, Owner Heather Glenn, Owner Hoosier Vapes Tim & Patricia Birdwell, Co-owner Route 69 Vapor Anderson, IN The Vapor Vice, LLC Indianola, IA Indianapolis, IN Jessica Dreesen, Owner Andrew & Darcie Kiwacz, Owners Vapor This, LLC Josh Snead, Owner River City Vape Company Beech Grove, IN Vaper Kings Indy Mason City, Ft. Dodge & Algona, IA Michael Griffith, Owner Indianapolis, IN Johna Kraft, Owner Duneland Eliquid, LLC Charity Hlavsa, Owner E Cigarette Impressions Chesterton, IN HSC, dba VVJuice Mediapolis, IA Ryan Hickman, Owner La Porte, IN Midge Haller, Owner Warthog Wire Randy George, Owner No More Butts Vapor Lounge, LLC Colfax, IN NKY, LLC Muscatine, IA Lawrenceburg, IN Tracy Jones, Co-Owner James Deheer, Owner SturgillJones, LLC Brian Smith, Owner Solardrops Juice Co Columbus, IN Naptown Vapors Pleasantville, IA Tracy Lea Jobes, Owner Martinsville & Indianapolis, IN Corey Halfhill, Owner Hilltop Vape Shop Douglas Scott, Owner Central Iowa Vapors Columbus, IN Naptown Vapors Urbandale, IA Christopher Lee, Owner Martinsville & Indianapolis, IN Justin Petty, Owner/Partner Shifters Vapors Jeff Webb, Owner JD Vapour, LLC Corydon, IN Vapin Tonight, LLC & Andover, KS Wendy Meriwether, Owner Vapin Tonight Distribution Marc D Melton, Owner D&W Vapors Scottsburg, IN Marcs Place Vape Shop, LLC Corydon, IN Cara Caprino, Owner Chanute, KS Purely Vapor, Inc. Cassandra & Chris Brown, Owner Vincennes, IN Byron McNary, Owner Cool Breeze Vapor McVape, LLC Evansville, IN Seth Peters, Owner Derby, KS The Vaped Ape Brian Hockenberry, Owner Carroll, IA Robyn Slate, Owner Hock n Vape Smoke Shop Vaporwave Fort Wayne, IN Don Gier, Owner Garden City, KS Smokin Hot, LLC Centerville, Ottumwa & Oskaloosa, IA

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 16 of 36 Theresa Herlocker, Owner Tom Rogers, Owner Brian Chrystal, Owner Grasshopper Vapes Lucky's Convenience &Tobacco, LLC Mr. Salt-E Hays, KS Wichita, KS Midway, KY Ronald Nickle, Owner Melissa Goodwin, Owner Bill S, Owner Indy Vapes District 4 Vapor Elevated Vaporz Independence, KS Ashland, KY Newport, KY Walter L Gibson, Owner/CEO Stephen Hosfeld, Owner Bobbi Ironmonger, Owner One Stop VAPE Shop Hosfeld's Vapor Vapor Gear, LLC Independence, KS Berea, KY Nicholasville, KY Britt Klotz, Owner Matt Stringer, Owner Robin Trego, Owner Viscosity Vapor Iconic Vape & 270 Wirez eCig Source Lola, KS Bowling Green, KY Owensboro, KY Korey Owen, Co-owner Randy George, Owner Richard Keith Hall, Owner Juice-e Vapes Club Vape Mountain Vapors Lawrence, KS Florence, KY Pikeville, KY Joe Kopatich, Owner Chad Johns, Operating Partner Kristi Kendall & Johna Lawson, Owners Ritchy US, LLC Dripwell Vapors, LLC Kickin’ Ash Lenexa, KS Fort Wright, KY Prestonsburg, KY Antonio Saverino, Owner Rob Bowen, Owner Michael P Regan, Owner The Vapebar Nice Guy Vapors, LLC Kick Ash Vape, LLC Manhattan, KS Henderson, KY Providence, KY Colby White, Owner Angelique N Sulfsted, Owner Christopher Grayson & Wade Grayson, Owner Level Up Vapor Vape Shop Mafia Twisted Vapors Olathe, KS Independence, KY Russellville, KY Maria Harris, Owner Blayne Hogue, Owner Joshua LaVigne, Owner Vape Attic Vapor Vision Allen County Vapes Olathe, KS Junction City, KY Scottsville, KY Nathan Wells, Owner Russ Scarbrough, Owner Robert Crume, Owner Vaper Generation Vigilante Juice Co Main Street Vape Pittsburgh, KS Lexington, KY Taylorsville, KY Eric & Lori McPherson, Owners Tony Florence, President Jason Sutton, Owner Flatland Vapes 723 Vapor & Vapor Stockroom Cloudville Vapor Shawnee, KS Lexington, KY Tompkinsville, KY Dave Scott, Owner Jerry Scrivner, CEO Tabitha Sutton, Owner Puffs Magic Vapes, LLC Magic Vapor Shop, LLC Michael Sutton, Owner Wichita, KS London, KY The Flappy Flower Tompkinsville, KY Elizabeth Webb, Owner Jerry Wayne, Owner

Puffs Magic Vapes, LLC Magic Vapor Shop, LLC Jamie Harris, Owner Wichita, KS London, KY 3 LaBordes, LLC, Kirk Schminke, Owner Andrew Watkins, Owner dba The Hotbox Juice Bar and Vaporium Element Vapes Magic Vapes E-Cigs Bossier City, LA Wichita, KS Louisville, KY Robert owens, Managing Member Scott Mchargue, Owner Edward LeBlanc, Owner Great American Ventures Mcvapour OPMH Project Bossier City, LA Wichita, KS Louisville, KY Brittany Guidry, Owner Vapor Springs Denham Springs, LA

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 17 of 36 Adam Rivet, Owner Dale Stevens, VP Eric Frit, Owner Overcast Vapor Lounge Empire Vape Shop Vapor Worldwide Gonzales, LA Augusta, ME Gaithersburg, MD Peter Massoud, Owner Steven Roy, Owner Aaron McCracken, Owner Vapor Viper Vapes Vapor City, LLC Mean Street Vapor Lafeyette, LA Biddeford, ME Glen Burnie, MD Kym Condon, Owner Minh Q Nguyen, Owner Thomas & Amber Perdue, Owners Cajun Vapes Vapor Room HavoK Vape Co. Lake Charles, LA Lewiston & Gardiner, ME Glen Burnie, MD Brian Uzun, Owner Max Sobol, Co-owner Clinton Legg, Owner Legacy Vapor Co. Lunar Rover Liquid Art, Inc. Mandeville, LA Baltimore, MD Glen Burnie, MD Linda Bordelon, Owner Antoinette Shaffer, Owner William Jameson, Owner Red Dog Vape Shop and Collectibles NettMix Custom Vapes Inc. Vapors Lounge Marksville, LA Baltimore, MD Mechanicsville, MD Jeff Weber, Owner Steven Walman, Co-owner E.P. Bailey lll, Owner The Vaping Tiger & Crescent City Clouds Lunar Rover The Vapor Emporium Metairie, LA Baltimore, MD New Market, MD Victoria Wood, Owner Vic & Kyle Vega, Owner Andrew Raftery, Owner The Vaping Tiger & Crescent City Clouds Vapor Villa 4Ten Vapors, LLC Metairie, LA Baltimore, MD North East, MD Suzanne Thibodeaux, Owner Amanda McArdle, Owner Larry Abass, Owner City Vapes, LLC Class 5 Vapors Abass Vapors, LLC New Iberia, LA Bel Air, MD Owings Mills, MD Anthony Kolesa, Owner Penny Walker, Owner Lisa Barkhorn, Owner Smokecignals, LLC Walker Enterprises, LLC, B&B's Vape Café New Orleans, LA dba MaddCatt Vapors Parkville, MD Cumberland, MD Chad Rogers, Owner William Roberts, Owner Calhoun Vapor Joshua Hargett, Owner BS Vapes, LLC New Orleans, LA Jamz Vaporium, LLC Pasadena, MD Heather Hutton, Owner Curtis Bay & Pasadena, MD Barry Vuong, President Big Chief Vapor Products Melissa Hendrix, Owner DC Vapor, Inc. New Orleans, LA Vape Loft Rockville, MD Tim & Carmen Champagne, Owner Edgewater, MD Patrick Carpenter, Owner Troposphere Vapors, LLC Collin McIlvired, Business Partner Vape Chalet & Chalet MFG Scott & Lafayette, LA Wesleys Vape, LLC Severn, MD Daniel Borel, Owner Elkton, MD Gerald Reed, Owner BukuVapor Rich Wesley, Owner Smoke Free Nation Shreveport, LA Wesleys Vape, LLC Sykesville, MD Raymond Odom, President Elkton, MD Matt Milby, CEO Great American Vapes Dylan Vogtman, Owner Smoke Free Nation Shreveport, LA DVO, LLC & Straight Up Eliquid Sykesville, MD Finksburg, MD Crystal Hambrick-Burdick, Owner Nitanel arieh, Owner The Vapor Stop Taylor Cage, Owner Towson Vaporium Sulphur, LA Straight Up Eliquid & Towson, MD North American Nicotine Finksburg, MD

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 18 of 36 Charles & Candice Gott, Owners Michael Portelle, Owner Earl Fisher, Owner Vape Jungle, LLC Front Line Vapor, LLC Great Lakes Vapor Waldorf, MD Woburn, MA Farmington, MI Joe Rondoletto, Owner Josh Flavin, Owner Marion Ayar, Owner My Ecigs, Inc. Expressive E-liquid, Inc. Vaporia, Inc. Agawam, MA Worcester, MA Fenton, MI Jonathan Lau, Owner Marc O’Connor, Owner Todd Melancon, Owner Dragon Vapors, dba The Vape Shop Dawn of Hope Vapor, LLC The Vapor Shop, LLC Brighton, MA Worcester, MA Flushing, MI Jamey Petruzzelli, Owner Navi Sengaloune, Owner Sammy Garip, Partner North Shore Vapor House of Vapors Smoke & Vape Depot Everett & Malden, MA Worcester, MA Grand Rapids, MI Anthony Caldalda, Owner Anne Switala, Owner Rhiannon Oleson, Owner Vapers Edge Smokin Vapor Bay City, LLC Steaming Bull Vapors Holyoke, MA Bay City, MI Greenville, MI John Nathan, Co-Owner Richard LaFramboise, Owner Pete Calkins, Owner SN Holdings, Inc. Smokin Vapor Bay City, LLC The Vape Shop Kingston, MA Bay City, MI Hazel Park, MI Brian Philips, Owner Kaleb Spicer, Owner Marc Slis, Owner Sixty-2 Distribution, Inc. Encounters of Big Rapids Vape Shop 906 Vapor, LLC Mansfield, MA Big Rapids, MI Houghton, MI Sean Conway, Owner Christopher & Angela Davey, Owners Kimberly Manor, Owner Branded Vapors Eliquid Master Moose Jooce Vape Shops Mansfield, MA Byron Center, MI Houghton Lake, MI Ian Devine, Owner Joe & Nicole Barhoumi, Owners Scott Church, COO Wicked Vaped Ritual Vape, Ritual Craft Vapor Eliquid & KVS Licensing Company, LLC Mansfield & Walpole, MA Ritual Distribution Kalamazoo, MI Canton, MI Jaymin Patel, CEO Michael Lowery, Owner

Royal Smoke & Vape Ramon Garcia, Owner Nature Vaper Natick, MA Ritual Vape, Ritual Craft Vapor Eliquid & Lowell, MI David Bershad, Owner Ritual Distribution John Miller, Owner Canton, MI Vape Daddys, Inc. Johnny’s Juice Newton, MA Macomb Township, MI Tommy Huynh, Owner Chad Perry, Owner Vape N Chase Eric Curtis, Owner The Vape Way Canton, MI Rustic Vapor Ecigs, Inc. Plymouth, MA Marquette, MI Jennifer Marsack, Owner Thomas Coniaris, Owner Mad Buck Vapes Laboratories Alice Engelman, Owner Vape Cod, LLC Clinton Township, MI Cig Free Vape Shop Sandwich, MA Midland, MI John & Christy Miller, Owners Patrick Smith, Owner Johnnys Juice, LLC Carol Akiyama, Owner/Operator Safehouse Vapors, LLC Clinton Twp., MI Vaped Ape Vapor Shop Waltham, MA Mount pleasant, MI Chris Bacho, President Christian Henriquez, Owner TVS Distributors Mark Mills, Owner Uplifted Vapor and Smoke Supplies, LLC Detroit, MI E-Cig Outlet West Springfield & Agawam, MA Muskegon, MI Duane L Peterson, Owner TatJu, LLC Edmore, MI

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 19 of 36 Ryan Dalga, Owner John Dundas, Owner Sean Condon, Owner PushVape, LLC Vapor North eCig Store Portage, MI Brainerd, MN Shakopee, MN Bill Kosinski, CEO Melissa Plotnick, Partner Tony Spoden, Owner Tattoo Vape Premium E-Juice Vapor North MegaVapes Saginaw, MI Brainerd, MN St Cloud, MN Chris Hilanto, Owner Tom Murray, Owner Susan Sindt, Co-owner/CEO Inline Vape Lakes Vape Supply Simply Vapour Shelby Charter Township, MI Brainerd, MN St. Paul, MN Samuel Kis, Owner Tyler Burg, Owner Brian La Rochelle, Owner Heritage Vapor Bar Smokin Monkey CBs Custom Vape Taylor, MI Buffalo, MN Biloxi, MS Michael Mead, Owner Brian Annis, Owner/President Rob Roberts, Owner EVC Labs & Vapor Lounge Lake Effect Vapor, Inc. Nu Way Vape Wayne, MI Duluth & Hermantown, MN Columbus, MS Lloyd Patton, Owner Justin Danberry, Owner Allen & Ashley Hollman, Owner LDP Designs, LLC Lincoln Vapors, LLC Southern Vape Company Westland, MI Fergus Falls, MN Ellisville, MS Stephen Knight, CEO Candy Carsella-Kee, Owner Ann Jennings, Owner Vapejoose, Inc. Northland Vaporium, LLC Delta Vapors, LLC Wyoming, MI Grand Rapids, MN Greenville, MS Bill Boldenow, Owner Mike Harris, Owner Bill Wikstrom, Owner Infinite Vapor PBDragon, LLC Vaporized Alexandria, Burnsville, Coon Rapids & Inver Grove Heights, MN Hatteisburg, MS Minneapolis, MN Darren Tollakson, Owner Brandon Alshouse, Owner Floyd Gray, Owner Pops Vape Shop eCig Market Cloud 9 Vapors Aitkin, MN Maple Grove, MN Hattiesburg, MS Christopher Potvin, Owner Jason Thompson, Owner Jim Shearon, Owner E Cig Innovation Black Sun Camelot Distribution Becker, MN Minneapolis, MN Hattiesburg, MS Heather Bewley, Owner Andrea Ramaglia, Owner Joann Wilson, CEO/Owner/Operator Northern Vapes The Plume Room, LLC Paradigm Distro Bemidji, MN Minneapolis, MN Hattiesburg, MS Nathan Ruesch, CEO Michael Wolberg, Owner Robert Brad Labiche, Owner The E-cig Café, LLC The Plume Room, LLC A1 Vapor, LLC Blaine, MN Minneapolis, MN Hattiesburg, MS Eric Trotter, Owner Jason T Wiler, Owner Joie Barbieri, Owner Thee Fantastics Twisted Vape Shop Olde Style Vape Company, LLC Bloomington, MN Montevideo, MN Olive Branch, MS Jesse & Angie Griffith, Owners Ryan Wolff, Owner Taylor Upchurch, Owner Smokeless Smoking, Inc. Midwest Vapers, LLC Cloud 9, LLC Bloomington, MN New Brighton, MN Oxford, MS Tim Koester, Owner Sally Phelps, Co-owner Kristina Leach, Owner Smokeless Smoking, Inc. Ohm Premier Vaping Pops Vape Shop, LLC Bloomington, MN Ramsey, MN Philadelphia, MS

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 20 of 36 Dudziak, Owner Michael Bracken, Owner Alisha Shepard, Owner Big Time Vapes 510 Vapers, LLC Nimbus Cloud Lounge Picayune, MS Imperial, MO St Louis, MO Bryan Robbins, Owner John Baker, Owner Avery Evans, Owner Pbr Vapors Twizted Vapes, LLC Gillbert & Parsons, LLC Pontotoc, MS Joplin, MO St. Louis, MO Ryan Armstrong, Owner Mitchel W. Bush, Owner Bryan Grubbs, Owner Mystic The Vapor Lab, LLC Gillbert & Parsons, LLC Purvis, MS Kansas City, MO St. Louis, MO Mike Jefcoat, Owner Wyeth Ervin, Owner Chris Clinton, Owner Magnolia Vapes, LLC VaporWyse, LLC Sy2 Vapor, LLC Ridgeland, Laurel & Richland, MS Kearney, MO St. Louis, MO Amanda Stone, Owner Zackwrie Parr Sr., Owner Joseph Butler, Owner Amaza Vapors Three P Investments, LLC Cloud Creators E-Juice, LLC Tupelo, MS Kennett, MO St. Louis, MO Josef Enfinger, Owner Rhonda Shafer, Owner Robert Boesing, Owner 1810 Vapors Ozarks Vapor, LLC Lemay Vapor Tupelo, MS Lebanon, MO St.louis, MO Jason Terrell Kornman, Owner Brenda & John Callaghan, Co-owners Travis Huddleston, Owner Kornman, LLC dba Vaporied Nina & Phil Brown, Co-owners NU2U Vapors Wiggins, Biloxi, Ocean Springs & Vapur Of Lee’s Summit Warrenton, MO Laurel, MS Lee's Summit, MO Sally Haley, Owner

Stewart Finertie, Owner Shane Deines, Owner Custom Vapors, LLC Vape Cape Jesters Juices, LLC Weldon Spring, MO Neosho, MO Cape Girardeau, MO Frank Vanhorn, Owner Kevin Lacey, Owner Shelly Morrow, Owner Firehouse Vapes, LLC Pinnacle Vapor 4 State Vapors Willow Springs, MO Carthage, MO Neosho, MO Jason Cornfeld, Owner Jeff Hicks, Owner Cole McDonald, Owner Old Skool Vape Society USA Vapor Trails McDonald Consolidated Contractors Billings, MT New London, MO Farmington, MO Matt Culley, Owner John Huck, Owner April Aubuchon, Owner SMJ Co. E-cig Mania, LLC Kaleidosmok, LLC Kalispell, MT Pacific, MO Fenton, MO Tony Dobbs, Owner Rose Fogarty, Owner Wesley Bringer, Owner Liberty Smoke, Inc. Fogarty's House of Vapor Blind Rabbit Vape Supply, Missoula, MT Grindhouse Eliquid, LLC, Fog Chaser Vapes, Elusive & Salvage Florissant, MO Brett Erpelding, CEO Poplar Bluff, MO Northland Vapor Company Darrel & Debbie Wood, Owners Fargo, NE VaporWyse, LLC Leonard Young, Owner Gladstone, MO Def Liquids, LLC Lane Shannon, Owner Saint Charles, MO Wyeth Ervin, Owner Celtic Elixirs, Phoenix Elixirs & Kearney Vaper Supply VaporWyse, LLC Zach Parsons, CFO Kearney, NE Gladstone, MO Tri Guys Vapor James Newell, Owner Salem, MO Annette Burns, Owner Lefthand Vapors, LLC Stella Blues Vapors, Inc. Joe Forsee, Owner LaVista, NE High Ridge, MO Joe Vales, LLC Sedalia, MO

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 21 of 36 Chad Svoboda, Owner Christopher Stanley, COO Nathan Evans, Owner Big Red Vapor Alt Zero, Inc. The School of Vape Lincoln, NE Las Vegas, NV Reno, NV Joel Jedlicka, Owner Elmer Yumul, Managing Partner Gary Janczura, Owner Creative Juices Premium Elixir The Vapery Black Rock Vapor Lincoln, NE Las Vegas, NV Sparks, NV Sarah Linden, Founder & CEO Greg Belcher, Owner Cavan & Jackie Westlund, Owners Generation V Vapeco Guardian Angel Vapor Company & Lincoln, NE Las Vegas, NV Wicked Angel Vape Company Belmont, NH Jacob Vrbka, Owner Jamie Reza Homampour, President

Hardknock Hooligans, LLC Blue Diamond Vapors Alex Moody, CEO Malcolm, NE Las Vegas, NV Kinetik Enterprises, LLC Tooryalai Gul, Owner Joey Chung, Owner Franklin, NH Vapor Laze Vape Avenue Vegas Kara Tibbetts, Owner Omaha, NE Las Vegas, NV Lineage Vapors Nashua, NH Ann TeVelde, Owner Kevin Whelan, Owner Smokin Hot Vapors Decent Juice Co., LLC Kyle Ezzio, Owner Henderson, NV Las Vegas, NV Lineage Vapors Nashua, NH Christopher Tan, Owner Matthew Lewis, Owner Elephant Vapor Cape City, LLC Max Hager, Co-Owner Henderson, NV Las Vegas, NV Route 9 Vapors Erika Pearce, Owner Michael A Torsiello, Managing Partner Somersworth, NH Local Vape Enterprises, Inc. Vegas Vapor Emporium Tom Slawniak, Owner Henderson, NV Las Vegas, NV Raven Vapes Juan Gonzalez, Owner Nicholas Mercado, Owner Tilton, NH VapeSling, LLC Desu, LLC & Vapeverine, LLC Chris Cook, Owner Henderson, NV Las Vegas, NV Coil & Co. Vape Supply Asbury Park, NJ Thomas Harmon, Owner Patrick Blount, Owner Sin City Vapor, LLC Fillco, Inc. Bruce Guest, Owner Henderson, NV Las Vegas, NV Dream Drip Nicholas Mullen, Owner Penn Elletson, Owner Brick, NJ Vapor Rage, LLC Pink Spot Vapors Russ Jurczyk, Owner Henderson & Las Vegas, NV Las Vegas, NV Gorilla Vapes, LLC Alex Mazzola, Owner Alex & Brandi Mazzola, Owners E Brunswick, NJ Mob Liquid Labs Mob Liquid Labs Robert Eichenberger, Owner Las Vegas, NV Las Vegas, NV Popies Vapor Lounge Brandi Mazzola, Owner Joseph Landolfi, Managing Member Evesham Township, NJ Flavor Vapors, LLC Hot Shot Vapor, LLC. dba Ohms 2 Vapor Dan Donahue, Owner Las Vegas, NV Las Vegas, NV Good Karma Vapor Catherine Wong, Owner Wendy Pierce, Owner Fair Lawn, NJ One 2 Vapor Vape Pros Shobi Iqbal, Owner Las Vegas, NV Laughlin, NV Good Guy Vapes Fairfield, NJ Chris Finch, Owner Travis Centers, Owner Vapetasia Inked ATTY Mark Anton, President Las Vegas, NV Pahrump, NV What A Smoke, LLC Flanders, NJ

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 22 of 36 Amber Brown, Owner Anthony Brown, Owner/Operator James Lucas, Owner Glassboro Vapor House All City Vapes Pro Vapors NY, LLC Glassboro, NJ Woodland Park, NJ Amsterdam, NY Alicia Pizza, Owner Sheryl Agro, Owner Ross Walker, Owner The Vape Shop, LLC Inno Vapes, LLC RW Vapors Hamilton, NJ Wrightstown, NJ Batavia, NY Scott Thompson, Owner Ralph Lermayer, Owner Michele Siderius, Owner Cloudride Vapor Peace Out South Shire Vapor Lounge Hamilton Township, NJ Alamogordo, NM Blue Point, NY Carol Costello, Owner Damian Barth, Owner Matthew Butler, Owner OK 2 VAPE Electric Clouds, Inc. Vapor World Brockport Lakewood, NJ Albuquerque, NM Brockport, NY Patricia Fusaro, Owner Dylan Levenson, Owner Andrew Hurtado, Owner Liquid Labs, LLC Betamorph E-Cigs Unholy Water, LLC Lakewood, NJ Albuquerque, NM Brooklyn, NY Michael Terkildsen, Owner Lukas Lowery-Ross, Vice President Andrew Kaye, CEO MTERK LLC & MTERK INC Ludovico, Inc. PANANAL INC. VapeBand® Manasquan, NJ Albuquerque, NM Brooklyn, NY Maria Egberts, Owner Kane Oueis, CEO Andre Liszka, CEO Maja Flava Vape Den Oasis Vape The House of Vapor, LLC Marlton, NJ Albuquerque, NM Buffalo, NY Andrea Di Paolo, Owner Melanie Estrada, Owner Andrew Osborne, Owner/President Vaporistic - 4 locations The 505 Vapor Room, LLC Vapor Trail Electronics Ocean Township & Brick, NJ Bernalillo, NM Buffalo, NY Peter Montanaro, Owner Cindy David, Owner Jon Glauser, Owner 23 Vape Lounge Jacx Enterprise, Inc. Demand Vape Pompton Plains, NJ Carlsbad, NM Buffalo, NY Vincent Mattia, Owner/General Manager Tammy Garrison, Owner Joshua Pettit, Owner The Vapor Vault, LLC Everything Vapor Yeti Vape Pt Pleasant Beach, NJ Farmington, NM Buffalo, NY AnaMaria Silva, Owner Jarrod Friedenberg, Owner Brian Ellis, Vice President Clouds Cafe, LLC Planet Vape Yeti Vape Skillman, NJ Farmington, NM Buffalo, NY Gene Crane, Owner Denese Peterson, Owner Collin Tansey, Owner Vapor City Plus, LLC Kraz-e Vapes Prohibition Juice Company Sussex, NJ Hobbs, NM Deer Park, NY A.J. Holland, Owner Missy Pilkington, Owner Joey Dammacco, Owner Holland Coil Co. Vape Scape Prohibition Juice Company Wall, NJ Hobbs, NM Deer Park, NY Kristy Hartman, Owner Keith Thomas, CEO Nick Callister, Owner Middlesex Vapes Cloud 9 Vapor Products, LLC Prohibition Juice Company Watchung, NJ Portales & Clovis, NM Deer Park, NY Danish Iqbal, CEO Daniel Montano, Owner Adam Kielczewski, Owner Medusa Distribution, LLC D&D Vapor Co., LLC & I-Vape Clouds Kie industries West Caldwell, NJ Santa Fe, NM Deer Park, NY

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 23 of 36 Anthony Bottaro, Owner Charlene, Owner Jozef Lenders, Co-owner Absolute Vapor, Inc. Super Smoke n Save & Upstate NY Vapes Smoky Mountain , LLC Depew, NY Queensbury, NY Bryson City, NC Tom Snider, Owner Michael, Owner Bradley Howell, Manager/Co-owner Cloud Chasers BlackWaterVapor Juice Vapeorium Depew, NY Sayville, NY Cary, NC Tammy Mink, Owner Christopher Johnson, Owner Robert Long, Owner Shore Vapes The ZFO The Vape Escape, LLC Glen Cove, NY Spencerport, NY Cary, NC Luciano Manente, Owner Robert scribner, Owner Charles Harris, Owner Honest Vapor, Inc. Scribners E-Vapors H&T Capital, LLC Harrison, NY Vernon Center, NY Chapel Hill, NC Christopher Goode, Owner Corey Olivieri, CIO Andro Ringl, Owner Goode Vapes Fresh Vapes The Great Vape Escape Kingston, NY Warsaw, NT Fayetteville, NC Cheryl L. Richter, Owner Amir Gombiner, Owner James Boyd, Owner Cherry Vape, LLC Scripted Brands Coil Werx New Rochelle, NY Warwick, NY Fayetteville, NC Mike Ebrahimi, Owner Michael Bowers, Owner Johna Deroy, Owner Vapor Authority White Plains Vapors J&M Vapor New York, NY White Plains, NY Fayetteville, NC Spike Babaian, Owner Carla M Bowers, Co-owner Justin Walters, President VapeNY The Vape Cave Black Diamond Vapor Co. New York, NY Yonkers, NY Garrisburg, NC Brian Burke, Owner Jeff Barry, Owner Steven St. Germain, Owner Majestic Vapors, LLC Fresh Vapes, Penna Crude E-liquid & Juice Maniacc LLC Niagara Falls, NY Jack’s E-Liquid Graham, NC Yorkshire, Dansville & Warsaw, NY Shaun B Casey, President Ron & Terri Peeples, Owners

Flavourart Mike Biles, Owner BMF Labs Niagara Falls, NY Cozmik Vapes Greensboro, NC Brian Hitchcock, Owner Albemarle, NC Ronald Peeples Jr, Owner/President Cloud Haus 28 David Eason, Owner The Refinery Vaping Company North Creek, NY EZ eJuice Greensboro, NC Ryan Hallisey, Owner Angier, NC Jordan Beresko, President Priority Vape Carol Oster, Owner The Big Vape Theory Orange County & Warwick, NY Chasing Clouds Vapor Greenville, NC Donna Menz, Owner , NC Jacob Twisdale, Owner Southtowns Vape Robert Yelton, Owner Redd Dragon Vapor Orchard Park, NY My Freedom Smokes Henderson, NC Matthew Salter, Owner Apex, NC Benjamin Owen, Owner Vape Rescue, LLC Thomas Tilley, Owner Kingdom Vapors, LLC Philadelphia, PA Southbound Vapes Hendersonville, NC Ararat, NC Michael M Frennier, President Jeff Bracken, Owner MT Vapes, LLC Michael Cotellese, President VAPE ON, LLC Plattsburgh, NY Asheville Vapor, Inc. Hendersonville, NC Asheville, NC

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 24 of 36 Mike Wayne Staley, Owner Frans Gandasasmita, Owner April Hardy, Owner Peace Out Vapes Sanctuary Vape Destination E Vapor Hut Hickory Tree, NC Thomasville, NC Bryan, OH Pete Angelopoulos, Owner Mark Byrd, Owner Jason Ensinger, Owner Vaporland Byrdman, LTD Kurux Vapes Jacksonville, NC Vilas, NC Canton, OH David Marlow, Owner Ben Roberson, Owner Jason Gang, Owner CAF Coils ENC Vape Westside Vapor, LLC Kannapolis, NC Williamston, NC Massillon, OH

Christine M Beasley, Owner Bill Boldenow, Owner Jason Gang, Owner Outer Vapes Infinite Vapor Vapor Station Kill Devil Hills, NC Bismark, Fargo, Grand Forks & Canton, Hartville, Akron, , Pataskala, Minot, ND Robert Wagner, Owner Canal Winchester, Logan & Chillicothe, OH

Vapor Market, Inc. & Cassandra Collins, Owner Nate Lane, Owner Wagco Distribution, Inc. Steam Junkies Vapor, LLC & Knightdale, NC EcigN8- Carrollton Vape Shop Mrs. Blankenship’s House of Vape Carrollton, OH Dickinson, ND Mark Hoogendoorn, Founder Bo McCoy, Co-Owner Madvapes Darius Endres, Owner Vapors of Ohio, Inc. Mooresville, NC Sports Vape Chillicothe, OH Fargo, ND Sherwin Mena, Owner Charles Black, Owner Trinity Vapor Lounge, Inc. Todd Fiechtner, Managing Partner Vapors, Inc. Raleigh, NC Lazy Llama, LLC Chillicothe, OH Fargo, ND Rondell Mckoy, Owner Marcus Clarke, Owner Durham Vape Lounge Matthew Clark, Owner Vapors, Inc. Raleigh, NC Dutchman Vapor Chillicothe, OH Grand Forks, ND Steve Sizemore, Owner Ryan Mock, President 910 Vape Shop Ty Cox, Owner 3rd Rock Vapor, Inc Red Springs, NC Dutchman Vapor Chillicothe & Dayton, OH Grand Forks, ND Wanda Ridlon, Owner Jacqueline Cooper, Vice President Lunar Vapes Avery Kraemer, Owner 3rd Rock Vapor, Inc Reidsville, NC Omologato Ecigs Chillicothe & Dayton, OH West Fargo, ND Jami Mannion, Owner Frank Cahall, Owner 7 Wonderz Vapor, LLC Jocelyn Ledin, Owner Altsmoke Reidsville, NC Omologato Ecigs Cincinnati, OH West Fargo, ND Paul Radziewicz, Owner Jeff & Patty Kathman, Owners Rolling Fog Vapor Company Glenn Bivins, Owner Cincy Vapors Salisbury, NC Wraps Coils, LLC Cincinnati, OH Akron, OH Josh Bartlett, Owner Zach Odell, Owner Deep Blue Vapors John Potter, President/CEO Scarlet Smoke, LLC Shallotte, NC Cloud Chamber Vapor Lounge & Cincinnati, OH Emporium David Sparks, Owner Avon Lake, OH Emily & Nathan Overcash, Owners Magic Vaper Cincinnati Vapor Trail Sparta, NC Tim & Nola Lyons, Owners Cincinnati, OH Rapture Vapor Brian Osterheldt, Owner Maan Yousef, Owner Beavercreek, OH UnderGround Vapes Jojo’s OH10 Vapes Spindale, NC Cleveland, OH

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 25 of 36 Thomas Marolt, Co-owner Jamie Mundy, Owner Richard Wellington, Owner Cloud Brothers, LLC Vapor Emporia Jade Vapor Cleveland, OH Findlay, Marion, Tiffin & Kenton, OH Mansfield, OH Alan Pfeuffer, Owner Kenneth Jones, Owner Kellie Waller, Owner Evolved Vapors, LLC & EV Liquids, LLC Vape Cloud 7, LLC Vapor Station Columbus, OH Fremont, OH Massillon, OH Bryan & Adelle Keller, Owners Joshua Chitwood, Owner Tom Davis, Partner Twinspired Ejuice Underdog E-Liquids, LLC Vivid Vapor Columbus, OH Hamilton, OH Massillon, OH James Jarvis, Owner Larry Mead, Owner Erez Braun, Owner Jarvis Vaping Supply Underdog E-Liquid, LLC American Vape Company Columbus, OH Hamilton, OH Mentor, OH Jonathan Kosakowski, Owner/Franchisee Mario Esposito, Owner Juan Ortiz, Owner White Horse Vapor Columbus Galaxy Vapors Rhino Vapors, LLC Columbus, OH Harrison, OH Mentor & Willowick, OH Lowell Meade, Owner Justin Gang, Owner Sarah Hofmeister, Owner Uprite Vapor, Inc. Heath Vapor Station My Custom Vapes, LLC Columbus, OH Heath, OH Miamisburg, OH Nathan Williams, Owner James Jarvis, Owner Randy Burch, Co-owner Vapor State, LLC Vapor Station Euphoria Vapor, LLC Columbus, OH Hilliard, Clintonville, Gahanna, Middleburg Heights, OH London & Columbus, OH Omar Mousa, Owner Scott Landon, Owner Tim Jacobs, Owner Vapor State, LLC CFJ Liquids Phantasm Vapors Columbus, OH Hillsboro, OH Milford, OH Jason & Randilynn Thompson, Owners Zack & Anna Coffman, Owners Arron Hayes, CEO Poor Girls Vapor Vapor Town, LLC & Atmosphere Eliquid Vapology, Inc. Columbus, OH Hillsboro, OH Monroe, OH Scott Pendley, Owner Shane Daniel Guillozet, Owner Sonny Varma, Owner Vapor Haus Vapor Kings Sonny’s Vape Shop Dayton, OH Huber Heights, OH Mount Orab, OH Evan M. Nartker, Owner Antonio Russo, Owner Rodney Mowery, Owner Cloud Queen Vapors, LLC Cleveland Vape Rock Vapor Scissors, LLC Dublin, OH Lakewood, OH Mount Vernon & Newark, OH Jared Moody, Owner Thea Ramey, Owner Jeremiah & Carida Stevens, Owners Smokeless J Vape Shop Glass City Vapory Epic Vapes Express East Liverpool, OH Lancaster, OH Napoleon, OH Adrian Delgado, Owner Ron Crouse, Owner Lawrence Conti, Owner Vapor House, LLC Rons Vapor Station Corp. The Vapors Choice Eastlake, OH Lima, OH North Lima, OH Marc glowka, Owner John McKinney, Owner Rhonda Burch, Co-owner Ohm Town Vapes Bunny’s Vapor Lounge, LLC Euphoria Vapor, LLC Eaton, OH Louisville, OH Parma, OH Laura Salem, Owner Justin Parrott, Owner Thear Abusharif, Owner Euphoria Vapor of Fairview Park, LLC Ohm Slaw Vapors Just Vape Ohio Fairview Park, OH Loveland, OH Parma, OH

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 26 of 36 Justin Gang, Owner Amanda Newton, CFO Jack McCormack, Owner Picktown Vapor Station Ground Zero Vaping Plague MFG Pickerington, OH West Chester, OH Edmond, OK Bo McCoy, General Partner Eric Anderson, Owner Jerald & Justin Holt, Owners Vapors Portsmouth Cloud Nine Vapor Lounge Enid Vapor Emporium Portsmouth, OH West Chester, OH Enid, OK Larry Mead, Owner Robert Newton, Owner Janine L Davenport, CEO Max’M Vape, LLC Ground Zero Vaping Vapers Tek LLC Reading, OH West Chester, OH Grove, OK JoLynne Gates, Owner Brian Burke, Owner Katheryn Watson, Co-owner Reynoldsburg Vapor Station VaporKings Lounge The Vapor Hut Reynoldsburg, OH West Union, OH Newcastle, OK Jeff Queen, Owner Samantha Fitzgerald, Owner Matthew Pelter, Owner/Operator Atmosphere Eliquid Jojos OH10 Vapes Vape It Seaman, OH Westlake, OH Newcastle, OK Carrie Mitchell, Owner Sarah Rutland, Owner Hong Ritchal, CEO Totally Awesome Juice Top Notch Vapor OKC Vapes Shelby, OH Worthington, OH Oaklahoma City, OK Cole & Christine Naylor, Owners Cory Linthicum, Owner Jason Waldron, CFO/Owner Ohio Valley Vapor Station Monkey Hut Vapor Lounge Heartland Vapes, LLC St. Clairsville, OH Ada, OK Oklahoma City, OK JC Perry, Co-Owner Tera Schooley, Owner Matthew Eaton, Owner Nicecloud Vapor Dig Lyfe Vapor Co. Captivape, LLC Toledo, OH Bartlesville, OK Oklahoma City, OK Muhamed Jomaa, Owner Jeremiah Watts, Owner Melissa Bennett, Co-owner Smoke Out Corp. Vape Out The Vapor Hut, LLC Toledo, OH Bethany, OK Oklahoma City, OK Terrence Pounds, Owner Michelle Phillips, Owner Nadeem Khan, Owner Smoke Out Corp. Black Dog Vapes Vapor Plus OK Toledo, OH Bethany, OK Oklahoma City, OK James Shearer, CEO Ronda L McBrayer, Owner Randy Eacret, Owner Infinite Vapor USA, LLC Main Street Vapors RLE Enterprises, LLC dba N2 Vapes Toledo, OH Bristow, OK Oklahoma City, OK Kelliegh Stewart, Owner Fady Srour, Owner Steven Roper, Owner Mean Old Dog Vapes Vapor USA Ecig Depot , OH Broken Arrow, OK Sapulpa, OK Nicholas Stewart, Owner Jennifer Burton, Owner Kristen Shelby, Owner Rescued Eliquid Vape This Victory Vapor, Inc. Toronto, OH Broken Arrow, OK Tecumsah, OK David Looper, Owner Michael Shrier, Owner Howard Parton, President JoJo Vapes Juiceguys Vapor Lounge & Ecosmoke Troy, OH Juiceguys Distribution Tulsa, OK Broken Arrow, OK William Samaco, owner Jeffery S Jacobi, CEO

Awesome Sauce Vapor, Inc. Stacy Reid, Owner JEL Marketing, LLC, DBA Lifesaver Vapors Wadsworth, OH The Vape Escape Tulsa, OK Durant, OK

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 27 of 36 Jim McEntire, Owner Will Krause, Co-owner Jack Riley, Owner Rollin Vapor, LLC Northwest Vapors Guntown Vape Tulsa, OK Salem, OR Canonsburg, PA Krystle Moore, Managing Member Greg Gilfillan, Owner Christian Rider, CFO LoneStar Vapor Shop Liquivana Vape Shop, LLC & Fathom Vapor Tulsa, OK SnobJuice E-liquid Carlisle, PA Siverton, OR Michelle Ragan, Owner Jay Ewideh, Owner

Vapor Kings Eric Pinnell, Owner Puff & Bean, Inc. Tulsa, OK Oregon Vape Society Carlisle, PA Nick & Melissa Muller, Owner Springfield, OR Steven Kane II, Owner Elite Vapor Gary Vaughan, Owner Vast Vapor Weatherford, OK Silver Lining Vape Shop Chambersburg, PA Spencer Knowles, Owner Sweet Home, OR Jessica Oesterling, Owner High Mountain Mist, LLC Pam McBurney, Co-owner Kingdom Vapor Wholesale Bend, OR Vapor Galleria Clarion, PA Allentown, PA Steve Johnson, Managing Partner Randy Shicks, Owner High Mountain Mist, LLC Carmine Dellamarco, Owner Shicks Gift and Tobacco Bend, OR Casual Vapes Vaping Kicks Ash Clarion, PA Bensalem, PA Kimberly Thorsgard, Owner John Dolan, Owner Vape Junkies, LLC Bonnie J & Harley Butz, Owners Smooth Vape, LLC Coos Bay, OR The Vaping Oasis & Cleona, PA Jessica Black, COO Tidal Distribution International Tracy Burk, Owner Vapor Bethlehem, PA Goose Vapes, LLC

Cornelius, OR Columbia, PA Daniel Artim, Owner Colin Rau, CEO The Vaping Oasis & Trevor Chrysler, Owner Emerald Vapors Holdings, Inc. Tidal Distribution International Iron Vapor, LLC Eugene, OR Bethlehem, PA Danville, PA Eric Cooper, Owner Shaun D'Sylva, Founder Vapor Tease Anthony Cooper, Owner Fatboy Vapors Bethlehem, PA VaporCrux, LLC Gresham, OR Downingtown, PA Mariah J Bankes, Owner Timothy Porter, Owner The Juice Vaporium Kenneth Cala, Co-owner/Manager Saver E Smoke, LLC Bloomsburg & Berwick, PA The Local Vapor Mcminnville, OR Doylestown, PA Lea & Mike Scavello, Owner Bob Foote, CEO World’s Finest Vape Shop Mick Duvall, Owner ECBlend Flavors Bridgeport, PA MaddCraft Vapors, LLC Medford, OR Duncansville, PA Raffi Farraj, Owner Janna Collingwood, Member Vegas Vapes Carrie Krouse, Owner Smoke Free, LLC Bryn Mawr, PA Carrie's Smoke Shop Portland, OR Easton, PA Adam Piper, Owner Jason Weber, CEO Cloud 9 Vapor, LLC Ryan Strauss, Owner Vape Crusaders Butler, PA Vapes Roseburg, OR Easton, PA Ben Oesterling, Vice President Jeremy Ellison, Owner Kingdom Vapor Cody Brown, Owner Valley Vapors Butler, PA Tesla Vaping Salem, OR Elizabethtown, PA Bob Oesterling, President Kingdom Vapor Butler, PA

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 28 of 36 David Petrozzo, Owner Walter Wright, Owner Brent Brookstein, Owner Get Your Vape On, LLC The Vape Lab Artifax Emmaus, PA Kittanning, PA Philadelphia, PA Kerry Medina, Owner Anh Mai, Owner Steven Rosenfeld, Co-owner Vapor Café King’s Vapor Vapor Funky Monkey Ephrata, PA Lancaster, PA Philadelphia, PA Marty Blevins, Owner Nancy Parrillo, Owner Eric & Clairissa Bordas, Owners Vapors Nirvana Culture & Vapor Shop EB Vape Attix Gettysburg, PA Mansfield, PA Philipsburg, PA Mike Kaminkow, Owner James Martin, Co-Owner Kate & Marc Conn, Co-owners Mother Vapors Photography by Renee and James Steel City Vapors & SCV Distribution Gettysburg, PA Monaca, PA Pittsburgh, PA Amelia & Ismael Rivera Jr., Owner Jesse Shore, Owner Michael Simko, Owner Sabor Vapors Jay Shore Liquids, LLC Zuro Enterprises & Vaper Shack Hamburg, PA Monaca, PA Pittsburgh, PA Kelly Friedlander, Owner David Durley, Owner Olga Bazhutin, Owner Vapors Paradise, Inc. The Vape Spot SCV Distribution, LLC Hanover, PA Murrysville, PA Pittsburgh, PA Michael Curry, Owner Chris McGrath, Owner Olga Bazhutin, Co-owner LifeSmoke Vapors Octopus Ink Vapor, LLC Steel City Vapors & SCV Distribution Hanover, PA Natrona Heights, PA Pittsburgh, PA Dan Messner, Owner Sarah Kastner, Owner Todd Zuro, Owner Elevape Worldwide, Inc. Lehigh Vapor Zuro Enterprises & Vaper Shack Harrisburg, PA Nazareth, PA Pittsburgh, PA Dave Norris, Owner Brian Wilson, Owner Eric Zurlo, Owner Blue Door Vaping & Fog Vapes New Castle, LLC Swirling Wind Vapors Foundation Vapor E-Liquid New Castle, PA Pittsburgh, PA Harrisburg, PA Alan Fox, Owner Stanley Adelsheinrr, Owner Gina Henkle, Owner VaporPhoxxe, LLC Beer4Less Cool Vapes Hatboro, PA New Castle, PA Pittsburgh, PA Shannon Slane, Owner Dan Messner, Owner Bethe' Boe-Corriere, CFO/Administrator The Vape Shoppe DMV Distribution Mountain Vaporz North Irwin, PA New Cumberland, PA Pocono Summit, PA Christopher Hare, Owner Jas Smith, Owner Jessica Matharu, Owner Nomad Vapors, LLC Kick’n Butts Vape House, LLC Six One Vapor Jeanette, PA Oakdale, PA Pottsville, PA Bill Nichols, Owner Kathleen Dvorsky, Owner Christopher Wanner, President/Founder Top Grade Vapors & Rip It Vapors Kick’n Butts Vape House, LLC Dominant Vapor, LLC Kennett Square, PA Oakdale, PA Reading, PA William Nichols, Owner Kenny Strickland, Owner Sheree King, Owner Rip It Vapors, LLC Ken You Dig It? Vapor The Vapor Den Kennett Square, PA Philadelphia, PA Scottdale, PA Holly Freshwater, Owner Robert Wiley, Owner James & Leigh Anne Dargocey The Vape Lab Philly Vape Society, LLC Infamous Vape Shop & Infamous E Liquid Kittanning, PA Philadelphia, PA Scranton, PA

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 29 of 36 Sean Slane, Owner Deborah Gibbens, Owner Domanick Vary, Owner Uis Vapes One Stop Smoke Shop, LLC Handcheck Vapors Somerset, PA Hardeeville, SC Rapid City, SD Todd Harhager, Owner Jodi Steffen, Owner Greg Mumm, President Hopper's Retro Gaming & Vaping Smart Choice Vapors City Vapes, Inc. Union City, PA Lexington, SC Rapid City, SD Serena Richter, Owner/CEO David OBrien, Owner Kevin Quick, Owner Rich Vapors The Mad Vaper Down Ohm Vapors, Down Ohm Drips & Uniontown, PA Mauldin, SC Cloud 9 R.C. Rapid City, SD Joshua Whoolery, Owner Joseph Battista, CEO

the Vaporium, LLC iVape Mitch Carlson, Owner Waynesburg, PA Myrtle Beach, SC Psyclone Mods Mike Burgoyne, Owner Orit Deverell, Owner Rapid City, SD MN Vapes Corp, dba Vapor Shark Warlock Vapes, LLC, dba Zuluvape Mitchel Carlson Jr, Owner West Mifflin, PA Myrtle Beach, SC Psyclone Mods Rapid City, SD Lawrence Scholl, Owner Shiela Wood, Owner Creekside Vapes, LLC Whim Wham Vapes, LLC Tyler Burdis, Managing Member White Oak, PA Pendleton, SC Black Hills Vapors Rapid City, SD Anthony Crook, Owner Joseph Cook, Owner Apb VAPES, LLC Vapor in a Bottle Zane Jones, Co-Owner Cranston, RI Piedmont, SC Down Ohm Vapors David Cervone, Owner Jeffrey Wilkinson, Owner Rapid City, SD Tvlri Pairadice Vapin Karn Elofson, Owner Providence, RI , SC The Cloud & CloudT3n, LLC Lisa Ciarlone, Founder Matthew Rhone, Owner Sioux Falls, SD Vaporetti, LLC Pairadice Vapin James & Sandy Luther, Owners Rumford, RI Seneca, SC Blown Away Vaping, Inc. Sioux Falls, SD Keith Cohen-Skali, CEO/Owner Michael Grant, Owner Sunshine Vape Pairadice Vapin Paul Provorse, Co-Owner Warwick, RI Seneca, SC Crow Peak Vapor, LLC Stan & Devon Holcombe, Co-owners Richard Lee Henning, Owner Spearfish, SD Electric City Vapor NicVape Andrew Harrod, Owner Anderson, SC Spartanburg, SC Friendly City Vapors Billy Bales, Owner Noah long, Owner Athens, TN Pirates Cove Vapor Lounge Noble Vapor Scarlett White, Owner Bluffton, SC Spartanburg, SC Elk River Vapor Shop Brad Rubright, Owner Celeste Rosensteel, Owner Belvidere, TN Mutiny Vapors, Airavata Vapors & Sully Vapes Misty Pinkerton, Owner Avalon Vapor Sumter, SC Angela Duschl, Managing Member Charleston, SC FF Vapors, LLC Ron Titus, Owner Brent Ellis, Owner Milan, TN Columbia Vapes Family Vape Shop Williamston, SC Pramod Potluri, Owner Columbia, SC Chattanooga Vapor CO Chattanooga, TN Lee Lance, Partner/COO Rebecca Smith, CFO Carolina Vapor Mill Family Vape Shop Williamston, SC Buckley Pepper, Owner Greenville, SC Nova Vapors Clarksville, TN

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 30 of 36 David Sykes, Owner David Moyer, COO Tru luong, Owner Pro Vapor L7 Vapors a Subsidiary of The Rabid, Inc. Tru Vapors Clarksville, TN Knoxville, TN Maryville, TN Daniel Osment, Owner Glenn Cate, Owner Sara N Kennedy, Owner Osment Enterprises, LLC, Vintage Vapors Vape Street Lounge dba The Vapor Apothecary Knoxville, TN Maryville, TN Cleveland, TN Steve Nair, Owner Katherine A Cornelius, Co-owner/VP Chris Grezeszak, Owner Moutain Oak Vapors, LLC The Rabbit Hole Vaporium Dieselbycg Cleveland, TN Knoxville, TN Mckenzie, TN Steven Nair, Owner Lysette Aviles, CEO Chris Leigh, Owner Mountain Oak Vapors L7 Vapors Mid South Vapors Cleveland, TN Knoxville, TN , TN Tim LeGrand, Owner Philip Harrell, Owner Ken & Karla Roadinger, Owner Golden Vapors, LLC The Vape Shop, LLC Chase the Vape, LLC Cleveland, TN Knoxville, TN Memphis, TN Jason Knowles, Owner Adam and Toni Gafford, Owner Carl Groll, Owner Discount Vape Secret City Vapor The Vape Place Cookeville, TN Knoxville, TN Mount Juliet, TN Karen & Glenn Morin, Owners Bill & Teresa Livezey, Owners Gina Ritter, Owner West Tennessee Vapors Knoxville Vapor, LLC Vapesboro, LLC Dyersburg, TN Knoxville & Sevierville, TN Murfreesboro, TN Kathie Simpson, Owner Kirby Fuller, Owner Kim Liles, Owner Laughing Kat Vapors Monkey Vapors Skull & Roses Juice Co. Elizabethton, TN Knoxville, TN Nashville, TN Johnathan Pitt, Owner Richelle Richmond, Owner Curtis G Hance, CEO Greeneville Vapor of TN, LLC Tennessee Vapor Factory Vivian Cameron, COO Greeneville, TN Knoxville, TN H&H Vapors, LLC Newport, TN Morris Abernathy, Owner Kem Denton, Owner Jill Gregg, Owner Victory Vapor North Smoke Busters Vapor Ecig Shop 2, LLC Newport Vapor Jackson, TN Lebanon, TN Newport, TN Donald Grayer, Owner Teri Dixon, Owner Kirk Hines, Owner Volunteer Vapors Smoke Busters Vapor Ecig Shop 2, LLC Ranger Vapes, LLC Johnson City, TN Lebanon, TN Palmyra, TN David Justin Nelson, Owner Chris & Destiny Hatton, Owners Gary Hovis, Owner Rocky Top Vapor, LLC Vapor Boss, Inc. The Vape Hut Johnson City & Jonesborough, TN Lenoir City, TN Paris, TN Joe Harvey Nelson, Jr., Owner Kim Liles, Owner Amanda Castillo, Owner Rocky Top Vapor, LLC Mellow Vape E-Vaperz Johnson City & Jonesborough, TN Madison Hermitage, TN Spring Hill, TN Dwight Spears, Owner Richard Banaski, Owner Sam Oechslin, CEO Savvy Enterprises Mid-TN Vapor Shop & Mastermix E-liquid Old School Vapor Co. Kingsport, TN Manchester, TN Spring Hill, TN Adam & Toni Gafford, Owner Brian Jones, Owner Tamara Yount, Co-Owner Secret City Vapor Vintage & Vapor Marketplace The Vapor Vendor Knoxville, TN Martin, TN Springfield, TN

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 31 of 36 Roger Brockman, Owner Tyler cohen, Owner Christopher Bowman Sweet Vapor PC Vapes, LLC & KCB&B Distributors Primitive Vapor Co. & The Vapor Cave Sweetwater, TN Austin, TX College Station, TX Kim Hammond, Owner Scott & Betty Hamett, Owners Brett Coppolo, President Electric Smoke Vapor House MNP Vape Texas Select Vapor Tullahoma, TN Bastrop, TX Conroe, TX Donnie Jones, Owner Larry Jackson, Owner Judi DeHaan, Owner Vintage & Vapor Marketplace Captain Jacks Elixirs Absolute Vapor, LLC Union City, TN Baytown, TX Cypress & Houston, TX Tarl & Caren Kendall, Owners Greg Johnson, Managing Member Alvon, CEO Secret City Vapor Boomtown Vapor, LLC Third Eye Management Group, LLC Winchester & Oak Ridge, TN Beaumont, TX Dallas, TX Stephen W Chitty, Owner Lauren Wynn, Owner Kris McClain, Owner Bang Vapors, LLC Phattys E-Liquid All Vapes Amarillo, TX Bedford, TX Dallas, TX Cory Blankenship, Owner Chad Lasater, Owner Luan Huynh, Owner Lucky Ruckus Vape Shop Big Spring Vape Centerpoint Vapes Amarillo, TX Big Spring, TX Dallas, TX Terrie Connelly, Owner Michael R. Goodwin, Owner Rick Leyba, President Vape Aroma MRG Ventures, LLC Vapor Candy, LLC Andrews, TX dba Mikes Vape Shop Dallas, TX Boerne & Kerrville, TX Abbas Khatri, Owner Charles Sproles, Owner Steve Stovall, Owner Vapor Pulse CESME Essentals Tribal Vapor, LLC Arlington, TX Cosmic Charlies Vapor Dallas, TX Beau Boniface, Owner Bowie, TX William Darin Guynes, Owner PC Vapes, LLC & KCB&B Distributors Sherry Gray, Owner Denton Vape Shoppe Austin, TX Peace Pipe Vape Shop Denton, TX Brenham, TX Darrell Suriff, CEO Dylan Thompson, COO Tyler Jones, Owner American Vapor Company Vaporescence SQ, LLC Austin, TX Jones Vape Lounge Denton, TX Brownfield, TX Ian Kistler, Owner Renee McMahon, Owner Bryan Scogins, Owner PC Vapes, LLC & KCB&B Distributors D Town Vapes Austin, TX Burleson Vapor Duncanville, TX Burleson, TX Kenneth T Greenwood, Owner Christopher Garcia, Owner DrippersnDroppers Kathleen Russell, Owner Vape30 Austin, TX Vapor Depot, LLC Eagle Pass, TX Burleson, TX Lanette Yoakle, Owner Jonathan Golden, Owner New Freedom Vapor Jamie Walker, Owner Golden Vapor Co., LLC Austin, TX Vaping , LLC El Paso, TX Burnet, TX Lukas Gilkey, CEO Mandi Tory, Owner Hometown Hero Dell Mashburn, Owner Paranormal Blends, LLC Austin, TX Dell Vapers Farmersville, TX Canyon, TX Michael Laughlin, Founder Shamecka Dittman, Owner Austin Vapor, LLC Stephen Robertson, Owner Dittmans Vapor and Gift Shop Austin, TX Vaperz Flint & Tyler, TX Cedar Park & Liberty Hill, TX

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 32 of 36 Chase Price, Owner Max & Zach Jones, Owners Jackie Arnold, Owner Vapor Source DFW Max & Zachs Vapor Shops, Caterpillar Paradise Vapor Fort Worth, TX eJuice, British Vapor Co. & Lindale, TX Royal Distro Co. Jason Tamplin, Owner Houston, TX Veronica Mora, Owner Steamist Vape Supply Electric Cloud Vapors & Social Vapes

Fort Worth, TX Dawn Rogers, Owner Lubbock, TX Micheal Rasor, Owner Ecig & Vapor Lounge Joanne Heston, Owner Steamist Humble, TX The Vape House Fort Worth, TX Garrett Kilcrease, Owner Lytle, TX Troy Johnston, Owner NerdEJuice, LLC Jeffrey Lee Bradford, Owner Vapor Salon Joshua, TX Four Horsemen Productions Fort Worth, TX Mark Lusk, Founder Mansfield, TX Gerry Clark, Partner Vape Militia James Slater, Owner Vapor ‘Licious Katy, TX Vicious Vapors, Inc. Fredericksburg, TX Penelope McCormick, Owner Mansfield, TX Sweet Carolina Vapors John Young, Owner Toby Gooch, President Underground Vapes Katy, TX Jaded Vapors, LLC Gainesville, TX Twanda Brown, Owner Mansfield, TX Kerrville Vape Station Jake Southers, Owner Daniel Matocha, Managing Co-Owner Kerrville, TX Bombvapor, LLC Fog on the Lake Garland, TX Aaron Smith, COO Mathis, TX Todd Rhoades, Owner/COO AAA Strate Vape Larry & Dennisa Moore, Owners Posh Vapors Killeen, TX Joosie Vapes Garland, TX David Pavelsky, Owner Mesquite, TX Johann Phipps, Owner Amazing Vapor, LLC Mark Zuccaro, Owner Antique Clouds, LLC Killeen, TX Great Vapes, LLC Gatesville, TX Dylan Drews, Co-Owner Midlothian, TX 7 Seas Vapor Company, LLC Desiree Tillman, Owner Steven Belcher, Owner Killeen, TX Me Mid Cities Vapor, LLC Haslet, TX Tammy Rhodes, Owner North Richland Hills, TX Marwan Mahmoud, Owner Trenchant Vapes, LLC Melvin Herron, Co-Owner Lagrange, TX 2nd Wife Vape Vape Shack, LLC Haslet, TX Chad Lasater, Owner Odessa, TX Neaman Cain, Managing Member Lamesa Vape Justin Gibson, Co-founder/President Electrik Smoke, LLC Lamesa, TX Vintage Vapor, LLC Hawkins, TX Tim Meredith, Owner Pflugerville, TX Holly L Benton, CEO Valeo Ventures, LLC Christopher Adams, Owner One Vapor Place, LLC Lewisville, TX Xtreme Vapes, LLC Helotes, TX Kenneth Brattain, Member Plano, TX Erasmo Franco Jr, Owner The Mod Squad Vape Shop David Davila, Owner Vape King Houston, LLC Lewisville, TX Moore Than Vapes Houston, TX Don Weckler, Owner Portland, TX Starlite Vapor, LLC Katy Aitken, Owner Ashlie A Gantt, Owner Elysian Labs & K and C Aitken, LLC Liberty Hill, TX Fuzzy Juice, LLC Houston, TX Jordan Weckler, Owner Powderly, TX Starlite Vapor Liberty Hill, UT

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 33 of 36 Chris Snuffer, Owner Layla Hicks, Owner Brandon Farnsworth, Owner Vape Dudes Vape Girl The Chubby Baker Richardson, TX Terrell, TX South Jordan, UT Crystal Clausen, Owner Michael Shane Weeks, Co-owner Weston Jarvis, Owner Great White Vapes Vape Girl Freedom Vapors Royse City, TX Terrell, TX Spanish Fork, UT Juan M Benavides IV, Owner Larry & Dennisa Moore, Owners Tysen Johnsen, Owner Desertwind Vapors Rusty Rail Vapor Co., Cloud 9 San Angelo, TX Tyler, TX St. George, UT Bill & Jennifer Maxey Don & Rhonda Dameron, Partners Kevin Henrie, Owner Bad Wolf Vape & BreezEsmokes, LLC Rebel Goat, Inc. Mayhem Vapor Products Waco, TX Tooele, UT San Antonio, TX Misty Burke, Owner Juan Bravo, Owner

Chris Lumsden, Owner Cloud Chasers Vapor Shop VIP Vapors Mayhem Vapor Woodway, TX Vineyard, UT San Antonio, TX William Thomas, Owner Brendon Gunn, Owner Janet Binder, Owner Unicorn Vapors Cloud 9 Systems, LLC The Vapor Room S.A. Inc. Wylie, TX Washington, UT San Antonio, TX Lewie Lambros, Owner Farhan Iqbal, Owner Keith Stasney, Owner Vapor Dreams Alternatives Wise Vice Vapors Bountiful, UT West Jordan, UT San Antonio, TX Whitney Black, Owner Ahmad Kabir, Owner Michel Barillet, Owner Urban Vapor, LLC Liberty Vapors, LLC Valkyrie Vapor Shop, LLC Bountiful, UT Ashburn, VA San Antonio, TX Edward Mock, CEO Jennie Baxter, Owner William Hildebrand, President Vape Affliction Steam Mill, LLC Hildebrand Ventures, Inc. Ogden, UT Blacksburg, VA San Antonio, TX Kyle Bertagnolli, Owner Deborah Markwith, Owner Gary & Shirley Wood, Owners Nolli Designs Cape Vapes Wood Creek Vapory Ogden, UT Cape Charles, VA Schertz & Converse, TX Tyler Malan, Owner Tami Taucher, Owner Charlotte Owen, Owner Nolli Designs Mom and Pop Vapor Shop Matrix Minds Ogden, UT Charlottesville, VA Seguin, TX Chris Talbot, CEO Jay Taylor, Owner John Stowe, Owner Ovapes Voltage Vapin, Inc. The Smoker’s Alternative Orem, UT Chester, VA Sherman, TX Paul Evans, Co-owner Jaimie Dobra, Owner Nikolai D Dimitrov III, Owner Vapor Craziness Cushymod Spring Vapor, LLC Riberton, UT Chesterfield, VA Spring, TX Riley Farr, Owner Yan Gleyzer, Owner Shane Robbins, Owner Vapor Craziness Vape Guys, Inc. Krazy Ape Vapor Riberton, UT Colonial Heights, VA Spring, TX Grant Hiller, Owner Alexandra Morano, Owner Shawn Burke, Owner iVape The Valley Vape Company, LLC That Smoke Shop Salt Lake City, UT Essex Junction, VT Temple, TX

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 34 of 36 Daniel George, Owner Rodolfo Reyes, Owner Chris Davis, Owner I95 Vapors Juiced Up Vapes, LLC Puffin Vape Fredericksburg, VA Richmond, VA Allyn, WA Kristen Pryor, Owner Charles M. Hutsell Eugene T Lee, Owner RVA Vapes WC Vapor Company & WC Vapor Distro i-vape NW Glen Allen, VA Roanoke, VA Auburn & Federal Way, WA Michael Maculley, Owner Jason L Williams, Owner Patricia Haven, Owner 7 Cities Vapes Pro Vapes, LLC Vapor Haven Hampton, Newport News, Gloucester & Roanoke, VA Enumclaw, WA Virginia Beach, VA Michael Provost, Owner Levi Brennan, Owner

Don Sr, Don Jr & Andrew Henley, Owners Vapamotive Clouds the Limit, LLC DNA Enterprise, LLC, dba Mech Sauce Stafford, VA Everett, WA Lynchburg, VA Claudia Kabir, Owner Michael Clark, Owner Leonard Wright, Owner Liberty Vapors 2, LLC Vapor Cloud, LLC Lake Anna Vapes, LLC , VA Federal Way, WA Mineral, VA Hoyt Adickes, Owner Eric Green, Owner Justin & Amanda Jacobson, Co-Owners Driptography Voodoo Vapors Dr. Fogsmiths Vaporium & Suffolk, VA Gig Harbor, WA SVC Distribution Duane Lassiter, President Gary Delgado, Owner Moneta, VA 7 Cities Vape Two Knight Vapors Virginia Beach, VA Gig Harbor, WA Dennis Davis, Owner 7 Cities Vapes Phillip Thompson, Owner Kathy Delgado, Owner Newport News, VA Master Vapor Two Knight Vapors Virginia Beach, VA Gig Harbor, WA Alex Batista, Owner Vape Xotix, LLC Randall Steele Smith, Owner Gary Fletcher, Owner Norfolk, VA Vapor Chasers SmokeStop Vapor, Inc. Virginia Beach, VA Kennewick, WA David Masker &, Owner Maskervape Plus, Inc. Elhoussin & Amy Baddi, Owners Margo Ross, Owner Norfolk, Newport News, Virginia Beach, VA Vape Shop, LLC Dr GoodVape Enterprise, Toano & Simpsonville, VA Virginia Beach, VA Kennewick, WA

Phillip Condrey, Owner Roger Gregoire, President Craig A Bradford, Owner Maskervape Plus, Inc. Roovapes Tri City Vaperz Norfolk, Newport News, Virginia Beach, Waynesboro, VA Kennewick, WA Enterprise, Toano & Simpsonville, VA Denise Ann Forney, Owner Austin McKinney, Owner Paul & Angela Harvey, Owners Vapezone Mega Vape Cloud System Solutions, LLC Williamsburg, VA Lynnwood, WA Pearisburg, VA Tracy Musgrove, President Margo Ross, Owner Revolutionary Vapes, LLC & Cloud 509 Sammy Gaita, Owner Colonial Vapes Moses Lake, WA Frontline Vapes Williamsburg, VA Poquoson, VA Chelsea Karche, Owner James Hoy, Owner Ohana Vapors, LLC Northwest Fog, LLC Andrew Byrd, Owner Winchester, VA Oak Harbor, WA The Last Machine, LLC & Pinkies up, LLC Richmond, VA Tanya Cagle, Co-owner Alex Lewis-Young, Owner Chip Anderson, Owner Vaporzz, LLC South Sound Vapor Lounge Zen RVA Winchester, VA Olympia, WA Richmond, VA

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 35 of 36 Allan Kettle, Owner Margo & Lawrence Pierini, Owners Casey & Janel Adams, Owners Vape D Lish & Trekker Vapors MiOmi Ejuice CJ Vapors, LLC Olympia, WA Tumwater, WA Inwood, WV Larry Pierini, Owner Aaron Oxford, Owner Frank Pauley, Owner Miomi Ejuice Vapor Factory Fabulous E Puffs Olympia, WA Vancouver, WA Oak Hill, WV Sopheara Buth, Owner Josheph Fennen, Owner Aurelius Jeffrey, Owner South Sound Vapor Lounge Vapor Factory & Avg Joes Juice, LLC Soul Vapor Olympia, WA Vancouver & Spokane, WA Princeton, WV Margo & Lawrence Pierini, Owners Clint Pettee, Co-Owner Cheryl Lockhart, Owner South Sound Vapor, LLC River Reserve Eliquid Hazy Hollow Vapors, LLC Olympia, WA Vancouver, WA South Charleston, WV Shane Brooks, Owner Shaun D'Sylva, Founder Scott Gillenwater, Owner Clandestine Vapes Fatboy Vapors Gillen Pine LLC, dba Vape Escape Pullman, WA Vancouver, Battle Ground, Hazel Dell, St. Albans, WV Belfair & Silverdale, WA Jayson Silva, Owner Ryan Caplinger, CEO/Owner

Vape Fusion USA, LLC & VF Liquids, Inc.Kristin Sealock, Owner Elite Vapors, Inc. Puyallup, WA All Things Vape N Smoke Vienna, WV West Richland, WA Richard & Lisa Sauve, Owners Jessica Hall, Owner MAXX Vape Roger Stout, Owner Ella Vape, LLC Puyallup, WA The Vaping, LLC Weirton, WV Greg Todd, Owner Bridgeport, WV Bill Boldenow, Owner Vapehead Origins Tiler W Lockhart, Owner Infinite Vapor Richland, WA Third Eye Elixir Madison, Milwaukee, Waukesha & Charleston, WV West Allis, WI Gabriel Laurant, Owner/VP Sales George Packard, Owner Vertigo Vapor Andrew Hilts, Owner Xtreme Vape, LLC Seattle, WA Capital City Vapors Antigo, WI Charleston, WV Kevin Knapp, Owner Benjamin Grothe, Proprietor Pure Vapor Marta & Robert Hays, Owners Good Nature EVAPOR Seattle, WA Vandalia Mist Extracts and Vapors Appleton, WI Charleston, WV Aaron Crisp, Owner Brad Busse, Owner Crisp Vapes Kevin Raymond Walker Schoolcraft, CEO Fox Valley Vapor Silverdale, WA Vapescape Appleton, WI Clendenin, WV Chris Bateman, Owner Kari Knabenbauer & Khris Fischer, Owners Vapor Select Jason Lewis, Owner E-Cig Store, LLC Spokane, WA Elk River Fog Vapor, LLC Appleton, WI Elkview, WV Krew Cunnington, Owner Todd Smith, Owner/CEO Krew’s Vape Shop Nicole & Burl Barker, Owners That’s No Smoke, LLC Spokane, WA Fairmonts Vapor Lounge, LLC Bulter, WI Fairmont, WV Judy Courchaine, Owner Debbie Hille, Owner Freedom E-Cig, LLC Shawn Dunn, Owner Medford Vapor Spokane Valley, WA Evapor, LLC Dorchester, WI Fairmont, WV Kimberly Thompson, Owner David Beaupre, CEO The Vaporium Christopher Aldrich, Co-Owner TruVibe, Inc. & Vapor Station FDL Tacaom, WA Dustin & Jessica Boggess, Co-Owners Fond du Lac, WI Full Steam Vapor Hurricand & Huntington, WV

Small Business Letter to Commissioner Sharpless September 10, 2019 Page 36 of 36 Kevin DeBauch, President Jesse Musha, CEO/Owner Hydra Puff Vapes, Inc. The Vape Spot, LLC & Yo Vape Sauce Madison, WI Waterford, WI Patti Arnold, Owner Alyssa Sweeney, Owner Central City Vapors Friday Vapes Marshfield, WI Waupaca, WI Jason Clark, Owner Don Muehlbauer, Owner Smokes on State Securience, LLC dba Durasmoke Mauston, WI Wauwatosa, WI Michael Budish, Owner Todd Buckley, CEO The Vapor Stop The Vapor Stop USA Mayville, WI West Bend, WI Kathy Aiello, Member Alyssa Sweeney, Owner Hugh G. Vapes Adrenaline Vapors Mequon, WI Wisconsin Dells, WI Matthew W Murphy, Co-owner Steven Howe, Managing Member Lakeview Vapor Flutterby Services, LLC, DBA Norse Vapor Milwaukee, WI Casper, WY Yash Patel, Owner Amy Williams, Owner Fortune, Inc. Straight Line Vapors Oak Creek, WI Cheyenne, WY Charles Bilek, Owner Kellie Rogers, Owner Vapewaukee Juicity Vapor Pewaukee, WI Evanston, WY Cory James Koziczkowski, President Spencer D. Pittman, Owner Outlaw Vapor Limited Steam Vapour Co., LLC Plover, WI , WY Alyssa Sweeney, Owner Arron Brown, Owner Cloud 10.0 The Vape Spot Portage, WI Thayne, WY Clay Pry, Owner Levi Carlston, Owner Midwest Vapery The Vape Spot Racine, WI Thayne, WY Timothy Frey, Owner Rachelle Brown, Owner Ignite Vapor & Tobacco The Vape Spot Spooner, WI Thayne, WY Kaesey Chojnacki, Owner Vipaka Vape and Glass Stevens Point, WI James Chamberlain, Owner/Operator Ignite Vapor and Tobacco Superior, WI Fred Wojciechowski, Owner Pro Clouds Trevor, WI