26 November 1992

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

26 November 1992 7338 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY Thursday, 26 November 1992 THE SPEAKER (Mr Michael Barnett) took the Chair at 10.00 am, and read prayers. PETITION - BICYCLE HELMETS LEGISLATION OPPOSITION MR KIERATH (Riverton) [10.01 am]: I present the following petition - To: The Honourable the Speaker and members of the Legislative Assembly of the Parliament of Western Australia in Parliament assembled. We, the undersigned, protest strongly against the recent introduction of compulsory helmets for adult bicycle riders. This law is an unjustified restriction of our freedom, has no clear statistical justification, and is a cheap substitute for real improvement in traffic conditions, for cyclists and motorists alike. Your petitioners therefore humbly pray that you will give this matter earnest consideration and your petitioners, as in duty bound, will ever pray. The petition bears 12 234 signatures and I certify that it conforms to the Standing Orders of the Legislative Assembly. The SPEAKER: I direct that the petition be brought to the Table of the House. [See petition No 140.] STAMP AMENDMENT BILL Introduction and First Reading Bill introduced, on motion by Dr Lawrence (Treasurer), and read a first time. Second Reading DR LAWRENCE (Glendalough - Treasurer) [10.03 am]: I move - That the Bill be now read a second time. The purpose of the Bill is to exempt from stamp duty the standard form proprietor/resident nursing home agreements which are being introduced by the Federal Government to promote and protect the rights of nursing home residents. The Western Australian Government supports this initiative. The standard form agreement will apply in more than 90 approved non-Government nursing homes - those covered by the National Health Act 1953 - in Western Australia. These nursing homes provide accommodation and care for around 5 000 patients. In their current form, these agreements are liable for stamp duty only if they are signed under seal by the nursing home proprietors, a requirement in some cases where the proprietor is a corporate entity. Even then the stamp duty payable is only a nominal $5. However, the Federal Government has advised that an objection in principle to the payment of any stamp duty on these agreements may delay their introduction in this State. The cost of this exemption in 1992-93 will depend on how many agreements are entered into under seal, but should not exceed $25 000. In addition, to ensure the fairness of the exemption, the Bill provides flexibility for any similar agreements involving residents and proprietors of nursing homes other than nursing homes covered by the National Health Act - for example, State Government nursing homes - to also be declared exempt from stamp duty by way of notice published in the Goverment Gazette. I commend the Bill to the House. Debate adjourned, on motion by Mr Nicholls. MOTION - FRANCOIS PERON NATIONAL PARK, CREATION SUPPORT MR McGINTY (Fremantle - Minister for the Environment) [10.10 am]: I move - That this House supports the creation of the Francois Peron National Park on the boundaries defined in the plan tabled in the House today. [Thursday, 26 November 1992] 733933 The 1975 EPA System 9 Red Book recommended that attempts be made to purchase the then existing pastoral leases on the Peron Peninsula in Shark Bay, with the aim of creating an A class national park. The 1988 Shark Bay region plan specifically recommended that the "northern pant of Peron Peninsula should be made a national park". In October 1990 the Peron pastoral lease was acquired and the Government reiterated its intention to declare the northern part of the peninsula a national park. The area was subsequently dc-stocked and the Department of Conservation and Land Management has since been managing the area as if it were already a national park. The plan tabled in the House outlines the boundaries of the proposed park. Attention is drawn to the following aspects: Firstly, the area of the park is approximately 53 500 hectares. Secondly, the park will go to high water mark, abutting the surrounding Shark Bay Marine Park, which is declared to high water mark. Thirdly, the southern boundary will generally follow the Denham-Monkey Mia Road. However, in the south west corner it will abut Reserve 30899 and deviate around the Denham airstrip, and in the south east corner it will abut Reserve 1686, at Monkey Mia - Point of Order Mr CiJ. BARNET:. I wonder if the Minister can explain what he is doing? The Opposition is a little confused about what is happening. The SPEAKER: 1, not the Minister, will inform the House. On the Notice Paper appears notice of motion No 2, notice of which was given at the commencement of yesterday's sitting. The motion is described as follows - The Minister for the Environment: To move - That this House support the creation of the Francois Peron National Park on the boundaries defined in the plan tabled in the House today. The Clerk tabled papers which defined the boundaries and the Minister is moving that this House support the creation of the park defined in those boundaries. It is open for the House to put that motion and for members to adjourn it or carry on. Debate Resumed Mr McCINTY: Fourthly, mining leases 0917 and 09/8 have been excluded. These leases are held by Agnew Clough/AMP. The companies have not been prepared to surrender the leases, so it is intended to leave both areas out of the park while the leases are in existence. When the leases expire in June 2005, or should the companies surrender the leases before then, the areas covered by the leases may then be added to the park. The Francois Peron National Park will be named after the French naturalist who visited Shark Bay with the Geographe expedition in 1801 and 1803. In his journals Peron describes the wildlife he collected, the Aborigines he encountered, and their dwellings at Cape Peron. Developed in the late 1880's the Peron pastoral lease was managed as a sheep station until bought by the State Government in 1990. In the late 1800s a pearling camp was established at Herald Bight, where old pearl shells still litter the beach. The park will protect rare wildlife, spectacular coastal scenery and arid shrub lands, and offer visitors a wilderness experience. Its landforms incorporate undulating sandy plains interspersed by gypsum claypans known as birridas. Most birridas were landlocked saline lakes formed when sea levels were much higher than at present, and gypsum was deposited on the lake floors. Where the sea has access to the claypans, such as at Big and Little Lagoons, shallow inland bays are created. Two distinct arid-vegetation types are found in the proposed park. Wattles dominate the red sandy plains and are typical of the region. H-akeas and grevilicas, flowering plants of the south west, reach their most northern range at Peron Peninsula. One of the most striking and abundant flowers is the Shark Bay daisy, a creeper that grows over shrubs and covers them in purple daisies. Navigator William Dampier visited the area in 1699 and was impressed by the area's blue flowering plant species such as Dampiera, the wild tomato bushes and halganias. Along with white myrtle, yellow wattles and purple peas, they form a colourful display in spring. A variety of seabirds and land birds are found on Peron Peninsula, including fairywrens, scrubwrens, finches and wedgebills. The thick-billed grasswren was once widespread on the 7340 (ASSEMBLY] mainland, but is now restricted to a small area that includes the proposed Francois Peron National Park. Distinctive dragons, known as thorny devils. are abundant and feed on the ants that are common in the proposed park. Several snake species, such as the gwardar and mulga, are found ini the area. From the cliffs at Cape Peron visitors may see bottlenose dolphins, dugongs, green and loggerhead turtles, and large manta rays. The area is a popular camping destination and a boating, fishing, scuba-diving. snorkelling and swimming location. Camping areas are located at Big Lagoon, Gregories. Bottle Bay, South Gregories and Herald Bight. Small boats can be launched from the beach at Big Lagoon, Gregories, Bottle Bay and Herald Bight. Creation of the national park will enable better management and development of visitor opportunities on the Peron Peninsula. Creation of the Francois Peron National Park was foreshadowed in the Government's "Resolution of Conflict - A Clear Policy for National Parks' document released in November 1990. Extensive consultation with the Shire of Shark Bay, the Environmental Protection Authority and the Departments of Land Administration, Marine and Harbours, Minerals and Energy and Conservation and Land Management has occurred. All outstanding issues have been resolved and the proposed national park is accepted by these parties. I commend the motion to create the Francois Peron National Park to the members of the House. Debate adjourned, on motion by Mr Nicholls. COMMISSION ON GOVERNMENT BILL Second Reading Debate resumed from 25 November. MR CJ. BARNETT (Cottesloc - Deputy Leader of the Opposition) [ 10. 17 am]: I seek clarification concerning this debate: As you, Mr Speaker, and members will be aware, the second part of the Royal Commission report was tabled nearly two weeks ago. At the time, Parliament was not sitting. The Government stated that a debate would take place on the second part of the report of the Royal Commission. The Opposition coalition wished to have that debate on Tuesday. The Government declined at the time and said that the House would debate it on Wednesday in the context of this Bill. As it happened, the Bill was not ready for the Parliament on Wednesday and was presented in the form of a second reading speech only at five o'clock last night.
Recommended publications
  • Three, Four, Five Civil Liberties Groups Emerge in WA
    Chapter 8 – Western Australia Three, four, five civil liberties groups emerge in WA The first mention of a civil liberties body in Perth came in an article in a local daily newspaper in September 1936: “The establishment of a Council of Civil Liberties in Perth was advocated yesterday by Mr. C. Bader (sic), readers’ counsellor under the adult education scheme of the University of Western Australia. Mr. Badger made the suggestion when discussing the action of the Customs Department in seizing 17 books from the Perth Literary Institute last week. “In view of the general tendency to interfere with the free circulation of books, and especially the tendency of the Federal Government to devolve its powers to irresponsible departments, said Mr. Badger, one felt there was a great need for a body in Perth affiliated to or parallel with the Council of Civil Liberties in Melbourne. This council, in its own way, was a development of the Council for Civil Liberties in England, whose president was Mr. E. W. Forster, the author of ‘Passage to India’. “It was a saddening fact that the battle for liberty, which people were apt to regard as having been won for them by their ancestors, had to be fought anew in each generation. “Despite the ample powers which governments had to suppress overt sedition and treachery, continued Mr. Badger, democratic governments still found it necessary to pass Acts like the Crimes Act, which were contrary to the whole tradition of British law and justice.” 1 Badger (photo), then just starting his career, went on to become the first Director of the Council of Adult Education in Victoria, a position he held until 1971.
    [Show full text]
  • Estelle Blackburn
    Estelle Blackburn Speaker, Author, Walkley Award winning journalist Estelle Blackburn took on the justice system and, against all odds, rectified two grave injustices, demonstrating the power of an individual to alter history and improve society at a fundamental level. Now based in Canberra, Estelle is a former Perth journalist who has worked for The West Australian and the ABC, various W.A. Government ministers and a Premier. She gave up full-time work and spent six years researching and writing the book Broken Lives, published in 1998. Estelle’s book exposed an injustice which led to the 2002 and 2005 exonerations of John Button and Darryl Beamish, who had been convicted of murder in the 1960s, and created history as the longest standing convictions to be overturned in Australia. Her unfunded, determined sleuthing unearthed fresh evidence that prompted the Attorney General to allow the men new appeals after they had lost a combined total of seven Appeals in the 60s. Coming across the story by chance and persisting with it turned Estelle’s life around. Here was a courageous woman who without a second thought impoverished herself to fight the cause for strangers. With no legal training and armed only with extraordinary qualities of courage and determination, she took on the system and won. Because of her vision, hard work and self-sacrifice the justice system may have been set on a truer course. This work won her an Order of Australia medal in the 2002 Queens Birthday Honours List for her service to the community through investigative journalism. She has also won journalism’s highest honour, a Walkley Award for the Most Outstanding Contribution to Journalism, the Perth Press Club Award, Western Australia’s Clarion Award, the Premier’s Award for non-fiction, the Australian Crime Writers’ Award for best true crime, and a scholarship to undertake a PhD in journalism at Murdoch University.
    [Show full text]
  • Electronic Document
    GriffithREVIEW47.indb 1 21/01/2015 3:43 pm Praise for Griffith Review ‘Essential reading for each and every one of us.’ Readings ‘A varied, impressive and international cast of authors.’ The Australian ‘Griffith Review is a must-read for anyone with even a passing interest in current affairs, politics, literature and journalism. The timely, engaging writing lavishly justifies the Brisbane-based publication’s reputation as Australia’s best example of its genre.’ The West Australian ‘There is a consistently high standard of writing: all of it well crafted or well argued or well informed, as befits the various genres.’ Sydney Review of Books ‘This quarterly magazine is a reminder of the breadth and talent of Australian writers. Verdict: literary treat.’ Herald Sun ‘Griffith Review editor Julianne Schultz is the ultra-marathoner of Australian cultural life.’ Canberra Times ‘At a time when long form journalism is under threat and the voices in our public debate are often off-puttingly condescending, hectoring and discordant, Griffith Review is the elegant alternative.’ Booktopia Buzz ‘Griffith Review is a consistently good journal. There is some terrific writing on display as well as variety and depth to the issues being grappled with.’ The Age ‘Australia’s most important literary essay magazine.’ Courier-Mail ‘At once comfortable and thought-provoking, edgy and familiar, [it] will draw the reader through its pages.’ Australian Book Review ‘Griffith Review is a wonderful journal. It’s pretty much setting the agenda in Australia and fighting way above its weight… You’re mad if you don’t subscribe.’ Phillip Adams ‘Once again, Griffith Review has produced a stunning volume of excellent work.
    [Show full text]
  • Extract from Hansard [ASSEMBLY — Thursday, 20 June 2019] P4438b
    Extract from Hansard [ASSEMBLY — Thursday, 20 June 2019] p4438b-4455a Mr Matthew Hughes; Dr Tony Buti; Mr Reece Whitby; Mr Simon Millman; Mr John Quigley; Mr Peter Katsambanis CRIMINAL APPEALS AMENDMENT BILL 2019 Second Reading Resumed from an earlier stage of the sitting. MR M. HUGHES (Kalamunda) [2.51 pm]: Given the contributions thus far to debate on the Criminal Appeals Amendment Bill 2019 by the lawyers present—I think we have a couple more to follow—I am a bit hesitant to make a contribution. I listened with interest to the observations made by the member for Hillarys and I clearly respect his position—that this government is bringing forward legislation that needs to ensure a sensitive balance between consideration of the needs of victims of crime and those of people who may find themselves in circumstances of wrongful conviction. From where I stand, the government has a strong record on protecting the interests of the victims of crime. Our Attorney General has been a very strong advocate for ensuring that we have legislative reform in that area. Before he leaves, I have a question for the member for Hillarys. When he talks about victims of crime, I am interested to know about those members of the Western Australian public who have been wrongfully convicted and are, in effect, innocent of the crimes for which they have been convicted. I ask the member for Hillarys: is a prisoner who has been wrongfully convicted and is serving a significant term of imprisonment as a result of that conviction not also a victim of our judicial system? I would argue that such a person clearly is, and we as a Parliament should be fulsome in our support for legislation that ensures speedier access to the appeals process.
    [Show full text]
  • Chap 8 WEST AUST CCL 200514 Proofed
    Chapter 8 – Western Australia Three, four, five civil liberties groups emerge in WA The first mention of a civil liberties body in Perth came in an article in a local daily newspaper in September 1936: “The establishment of a Council of Civil Liberties in Perth was advocated yesterday by Mr. C. Bader (sic), readers’ counsellor under the adult education scheme of the University of Western Australia. Mr. Badger made the suggestion when discussing the action of the Customs Department in seizing 17 books from the Perth Literary Institute last week. “In view of the general tendency to interfere with the free circulation of books, and especially the tendency of the Federal Government to devolve its powers to irresponsible departments, said Mr. Badger, one felt there was a great need for a body in Perth affiliated to or parallel with the Council of Civil Liberties in Melbourne. This council, in its own way, was a development of the Council for Civil Liberties in England, whose president was Mr. E. W. Forster, the author of ‘Passage to India’. “It was a saddening fact that the battle for liberty, which people were apt to regard as having been won for them by their ancestors, had to be fought anew in each generation. “Despite the ample powers which governments had to suppress overt sedition and treachery, continued Mr. Badger, democratic governments still found it necessary to pass Acts like the Crimes Act, which were contrary to the whole tradition of British law and justice.” 1 Badger (photo), then just starting his career, went on to become the first Director of the Council of Adult Education in Victoria, a position he held until 1971.
    [Show full text]
  • [Tuesday, 10 November 1998] 2973 Using the System on December 31
    [Tuesday, 10 November 1998] 2973 using the system on December 31 1998 to coincide with amendments to the Public Sector Management (Review Procedures) Regulations 1995. Similar errors therefore should not occur in future. I have advised the relevant Ministers. The letter is signed, "Don Saunders, Commissioner for Public Sector Standards, November 4, 1998". [See paper No 339.] SELECT COMMITTEE ON NATIVE TITLE RIGHTS IN WESTERN AUSTRALIA Final Report, Tabling Hon Tom Stephens (Leader of the Opposition) presented the final report of the Select Committee on Native Title Rights in Western Australia, and on his motion it was resolved - That the report do lie upon the Table and be printed. [See paper No 384.] Papers, Tabling HON TOM STEPHENS (Mining and Pastoral - Leader of the Opposition) [3.44 pm]: I seek leave to table papers of the Select Committee on Native Title Rights in Western Australia. By way of explanation to you, Mr President, and through you to the Leader of the Government, he will be familiar with this seeking of leave because he sought similar leave in similar circumstances for a committee that did some overseas work on an unrelated issue. Hon N.F. Moore: You do not have to talk me into it. Hon TOM STEPHENS: Okay. I have here a substantial number of documents which I hope the House will see fit to allow to lie on the Table of the House so that they may be accessed by the public. The committee has been particularly privileged in the work it undertook. The Select Committee on Native Title Rights in Western Australia has also directed me to present papers which the committee collected on its trip to Canada during July of this year.
    [Show full text]
  • Imagereal Capture
    JAN 19991 BOOK REVIEWS Who Killed Rosemary Anderson? By Estelle Blackburn (Stellar Publishing Pty Ltd 1998 pp 410 $24.95) ESPITE its status as the capital city of Western Australia, Perth in the year D 1960 was much more akin to a large country town than a bustling metropolis. Even today long-term residents reminisce about the 'good old days' when people could leave their houses unlocked, sleep on front verandahs on hot summer nights and walk the streets without fear. But in the early 1960s all this was to change. This book begins by chronicling the life and crimes of Eric Edgar Cooke. During the period 1958 to 1963, Cooke was, on his own admission, responsible for causing the deaths of five Perth residents, causing serious injury to nearly a dozen others and committing innumerable burglaries and car thefts. Ultimately Cooke found a place in Western Australian history as the last person to die on the gallows of Fremantle gaol. But this book is not just a chronicle of Cooke's activities. Before he was apprehended, two men were charged and convicted of offences to which Cooke later confessed. The first and perhaps better known of these was a hearing and speech impaired youth named Darryl Raymond Beamish who was sentenced to death (later commuted to life imprisonment) for the wilful murder of Jillian Brewer in 1959. Subsequent to his apprehension in 1963, Cooke confessed to this murder, and declared that Beamish was innocent. As a result the then Minister of Justice referred Beamish's conviction to the Court of Criminal Appeal; however, after hearing evidence from Cooke, the court concluded that there were no grounds to set aside the conviction and dismissed the appeal.
    [Show full text]
  • Connect with Us Via Twitter @Corrugatedlines Or Find Us on Facebook Write a Limerick Competition – Theme: the Colour Red FREE ONLINE EVENT Entries in by 3Rd August
    Connect with us via Twitter @CorrugatedLines or find us on Facebook Write a Limerick competition – Theme: The Colour Red FREE ONLINE EVENT Entries in by 3rd August Write and submit one original Limerick on the theme The Colour Red to the Backroom Press Facebook page before the closing date. Winning entries announced and read at Word of Mouth on Saturday night, August 11. For guidelines on writing a Limerick, see the Backroom Press Facebook page. Non-users of Facebook may submit by email to [email protected] PRE-FEST Yawuru Haiku BOOKINGS REQUIRED 4–5.30pm Nyamba Buru Yawuru – 55 Reid Road, Cable Beach Join the Mabu Yawuru Ngan-ga language team and create short Japanese-style haiku poems. Using Yawuru words, this traditional poetic form will give expression to our country and seasons, and introduce you to some Yawuru language. Max 12 participants. Bookings with [email protected] Landscape writing with Donna Marie Carman FREE EVENT 4.30–5.30pm Gallery Sobrane – 48 Carnarvon Street (next door to Matso’s) Landscape Snapshot: Personal responses of the beholder. Create prose, poetry or a single word to represent your experience of landscape in light of guided imagery and ideas. Perspectives of Broome landscapes will be explored through written word during this workshop as part of Donna’s ten-day Artist Residency at Gallery Sobrane in August. Prologue FREE EVENT 6.30–7.30pm Broome Public Library – Corner Hamersley and Haas Streets Join us for the opening of Corrugated Lines 2018. Be welcomed by the Traditional Owners of Yawuru country and listen to some Yawuru songs performed by the Walalanga Ngan-ga singers.
    [Show full text]
  • Three Accounts of Eric Edgar Cooke's Murderous Reign
    The town becomes a city: three accounts of Eric Edgar Cooke’s murderous reign Paul Genoni School of Media, Culture and Creative Arts Curtin University The town becomes a city: three accounts of Eric Edgar Cooke’s murderous reign Eric Edgar Cooke is remembered as Perth’s, and Western Australia’s, most notorious serial killer. From the mid-1950s Cooke engaged in a prolonged series of break-ins, thefts, violent attacks and eventually murders that ended only with his arrest in August 1963. In this time he was responsible for causing serious physical injury to over 20 people, many in their own homes, and eight were killed. Cooke was an opportunist murderer. Unlike most serial killers he had no obvious modus operandi— his murders including the running down of a pedestrian; a stabbing; a bludgeoning with a hatchet; a strangulation, and four shootings. It was because of this bizarre aspect of his crimes that police and the public took some time to realise they had a serial killer in their midst. Many of Cooke’s crimes occurred in Perth’s well-to-do western suburbs, and in his most notorious outrage he went on a shooting spree in the beachside suburb of Cottesloe and riverside Nedlands in the early hours of January 27th 1963. In a series of four incidents, unrelated except for Cooke’s involvement, five people were shot and three killed. It was at this point that the killer was dubbed ‘The Nedlands Monster’ and Perth went into a state of shock and fear. Not only are the Cooke murders infamous because of their scale and oddity, but for other reasons they have lingered in the memory of West Australians.
    [Show full text]
  • A Public Lecture
    Networked Knowledge Media Reports Networked Knowledge Western Australia Media Reports This page set up by Dr Robert N Moles [Underlining, where it occurs, is for NetK editorial emphasis] University of Western Australia – Lumina Public Lecture Challenging justice – changing lives - A public lecture by Estelle Blackburn OAM It is generally agreed that 1% of the prison population are innocent inmates who are the victims of injustice. This presentation will detail two wrongful convictions in 1961 and 1963 and how a Perth journalist with no legal training could succeed in gaining the innocent men’s exonerations 40 years later, winning against the odds after they had lost seven combined appeals in the 60s. When John Button’s manslaughter conviction was quashed by the WA Court of Criminal Appeal in 2002, and Darryl Beamish’s wilful murder conviction was quashed in 2005, they were the longest standing convictions to be overturned in Australia. As well as the exonerations, the work corrected Perth’s history. Eric Edgar Cooke, the perpetrator of the two murders and the last person executed in WA, had been remembered for killing six people and attempting to kill two more in 1963. Cooke is now recognised for eight murders and 14 attempted murders over a five-year period from 1958. The work also gave a voice to 12 of Cooke’s previously-unknown attempted murder victims, gave hope to innocent prisoners and raised public awareness of wrongful conviction and its causes: police misconduct including blinkered investigation, over-zealous prosecutors, weak legal representation for the uneducated and marginalised, false confessions, fabricated evidence by witnesses with incentives, faults in forensics, eyewitness misidentification and fallible memory.
    [Show full text]
  • Griffithreview47.Indb 1 21/01/2015 3:43 Pm Praise for Griffith Review
    GriffithREVIEW47.indb 1 21/01/2015 3:43 pm Praise for Griffith Review ‘Essential reading for each and every one of us.’ Readings ‘A varied, impressive and international cast of authors.’ The Australian ‘Griffith Review is a must-read for anyone with even a passing interest in current affairs, politics, literature and journalism. The timely, engaging writing lavishly justifies the Brisbane-based publication’s reputation as Australia’s best example of its genre.’ The West Australian ‘There is a consistently high standard of writing: all of it well crafted or well argued or well informed, as befits the various genres.’ Sydney Review of Books ‘This quarterly magazine is a reminder of the breadth and talent of Australian writers. Verdict: literary treat.’ Herald Sun ‘Griffith Review editor Julianne Schultz is the ultra-marathoner of Australian cultural life.’ Canberra Times ‘At a time when long form journalism is under threat and the voices in our public debate are often off-puttingly condescending, hectoring and discordant, Griffith Review is the elegant alternative.’ Booktopia Buzz ‘Griffith Review is a consistently good journal. There is some terrific writing on display as well as variety and depth to the issues being grappled with.’ The Age ‘Australia’s most important literary essay magazine.’ Courier-Mail ‘At once comfortable and thought-provoking, edgy and familiar, [it] will draw the reader through its pages.’ Australian Book Review ‘Griffith Review is a wonderful journal. It’s pretty much setting the agenda in Australia and fighting way above its weight… You’re mad if you don’t subscribe.’ Phillip Adams ‘Once again, Griffith Review has produced a stunning volume of excellent work.
    [Show full text]