Arigin 3D Pro Mimics
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
9ęඈඋ1࣏ۘऺ: Chinese Journal of Tissue Engineering Research www.CRTER.org ऺƣጛۘ Arigin 3D Proḳâ^MimicsḳâYමₑņµƧՈஂòۘऺ ŵʾ¿1 Ŭ;2 ☢1 Ả ᅭ3 ǜºṍ2 (1ʮaȁîŲƜΡ~½KŲàŲƜď 215021Z2ŲƜāƟΧĴu˳ɼśK ŲàŲƜď 215021Z3ʮaȁî·̨ƅïˊȌɵiˋνƗļôκđK£ʮàʮaď 710049)+ DOI:10.3969/j.issn.2095-4344.0729 ORCID: 0000-0002-8359-6094(ŵʾ¿) তȷợⓉᪿ ˁͬK˃K1993 ˝ÛK Arigin 3D Pro ḳâʐ Mimics ḳâńĿƚĚʻYමₑņ̠ˊՈஂܲò ʮàAƍďNKÝŸœ þΡ~ÛKƶϙÎā ȕ̆¡ŨǒɻĝΡ~" (1)Arigin 3D Pro ḳ â ^ ȁ·ȔŀYƅιKʮa Mimics ḳâ 3D ₑȀµƧՈ ȁî·̨ƅïˊȌɵi òּƟஂ ˋνƗļôκđK£ʮà (2)ȭzཡ࿓µƧ໐ᣄ Arigin ʮaď 710049 3D Pro ḳâՈₑņrⒸº Ąz Mimics ḳâ4 Ě ିǻ:R318 B:ۅDzʃ ɘ4ěY2018-01-09 L₎5 ĿƚĚʻYමₑņՈĄÃּṇzxම)ɶĚʻ ĿƚĚʻYමₑņdzńYමाⒸͱº߾҉̢ĽǍǎɬĐඈ උाⒸĹา͟ி ẟ໐ṉĿϣஂܲȷợŌẟᜐƫQ) ὃ̹᪳4 Arigin 3D Pro«Z#ɑĿћäƫƅ└͘ǼႮ'ۘǕՈȖz 3D ·ŴՈĿƚₑȀḳâிඣ dzǒɴĿƚĚʻ ɜ3ཐཌྷ3ղཨ3ȏ࿓3ཡ࿓3ₕʒΉ͑ĭՈYමₑņ Âdz^͊ĚՈ 3D ·Ŵƶ\Ảȉ ֲQ>t v5☦ Arigin 3D Pro ḳâͣƅưĽĄÃ4 Đ:ǻՈ Öǎۘۘऺ4ńཡ࿓àϬzɜ3£ ʼᡅ ☦ë╓Ŀƚtʻäƫ])ȴʌ ¦ĿᢧZȀՈdzᢊĚۘऺǣ4ẟPǹǕʉ YමₑņäƫńĿћ5ྐ '«ẕƛęͱႮ ՈňϬKỔ¼Ϥº4Mimics «ֲQàϬż&ËͯՈĿƚĚʻYමₑņḳâ Arigin 3D Pro ǕՈPǒȖz 3D ·ŴՈĿƚₑȀḳâிඣ4ۘ ՈȆᩬ Arigin 3D Pro ḳâʐ Mimics ḳâńĿƚĚʻYමₑņ̠ˊՈஂܲò4ֲ 5ͩọǚཡ࿓3࿎ɭ3ၡ͟ᅆ3ȏ࿓ᾬĹՈĚʻϔǒ Ñ Mimics ḳâₑȀȒՈ 3D µƧ&Ɖǒ ẟᜐǒ Ȍọǚ 10 ŷ͐9ᾬĹǎ 1 ŷཥɜ୍ݒɳɜüՈĚʻϔǒ ẟᜐYමₑņ ȭɣₑ ḳâₑȀµƧՈȻ: ņµƧţẟᜐ 10 ඈĽǍɮȬՈϟₓ ᪈ĜǒḳâₑȀµƧĽǍɮȬՈ:Ŏ4 Ș^Arigin 3D Pro ʐ Mimics ḳâȭཡ࿓3࿎ɭ3ၡ͟ᅆ3ȏ࿓ՈYමₑņµƧ Ȼ:ՈţȨ±ʃβ : /&(0.93±1.05) (0.36±0.74) (0.45±0.74)ǎ(0.18±0.41) mm4Arigin 3D Pro ʐ Mimics ḳâₑņཡ࿓ /& 3 min335 min ǒḳâₑņ͢µƧՈrⒸţɃz 1 min4ȭz͐93ཥɜ୍ݒɳɜü µƧՈrⒸ Ո 3D ₑȀµƧ ǒḳâ Arigin 3D Pro ḳâ^ Mimics :Ŏ\ඣᩥƚ͛5(P ţ> 0.05)4᪸ Arigin 3D Pro ḳâ^ Mimics ḳâ 3D ₑȀµƧՈஂòּƟ ȭzཡ࿓µƧ໐ᣄ Arigin 3D Pro ḳâՈₑņrⒸºĄz Mimics ḳâ4 ͟⏲᪑ Arigin 3D ProMimicsYමₑņĿƚĚʻஂòȻ: ȌɜΉ͑ĭ 'L᪑ tʻ Yමᩥਜ਼ƶµŃඈඋ1࣏ Ȗₕᰈ (ᆓׅႮϢȖₕ☦Z-ֲ(BK20151251˳ Accuracy of three-dimensional reconstruction models using Arigin 3D Pro and Cao Gui-ping, Master Mimics software programs Candidate, Suzhou Academy, Xi'an Jiaotong 1 2 1 3 2 1 Cao Gui-ping , Zhang Ming-jiao , Liu Fei , Lian Qin , Xu Xian-hui ( Suzhou Academy, Xi'an Jiaotong University, University, Suzhou 215021, 2 Suzhou 215021, Jiangsu Province, China; Suzhou Arigin Medical Co., Ltd., Suzhou 215021, Jiangsu Province, Jiangsu Province, China 3 China; Laboratory for Manufacturing System Engineering, Xi'an Jiaotong University, Xi'an 710049, Shaanxi Province, China) Corresponding author: Lian Qin, Laboratory for Abstract Manufacturing System Engineering, Xi'an Jiaotong BACKGROUND: With the improvement of medical imaging technology, the visualization of human anatomy has University, Xi'an 710049, been further developed; the role of three-dimensional (3D) reconstruction in medical treatment is also becoming Shaanxi Province, China increasingly prominent. Mimics is the most widely used medical image reconstruction software. Arigin 3D Pro is a 2384 তේǻ:2095-4344(2018)15-02384-06 Cao GP, Zhang MJ, Liu F, Lian Q, Xu XH. Accuracy of three-dimensional reconstruction models using Arigin 3D Pro and Mimics software programs. Zhongguo Zuzhi Gongcheng Yanjiu. 2018;22(15):2384-2389. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.2095-4344.0729 recently developed 3D reconstructed medical software system based on 3D printing. OBJECTIVE: To study the accuracy of 3D reconstruction models obtained by using Arigin 3D Pro and Mimics with medical images. METHODS: The image data of liver, spine, knee joint and heart were selected, and the deviations of two software reconstruction models were analyzed based on the 3D model reconstructed by Mimics. Totally 10 cases of skull and 1 case of femoral comminuted fracture image data were selected and reconstructed. Each reconstruction model was measured with 10 groups of feature sizes to evaluate the differences between the two software programs. RESULTS AND CONCLUSION: Arigin 3D Pro and Mimics were used to reconstruct the liver, spine, knee and heart data. The mean ± standard deviation of model deviations were (0.93 ± 1.05), (0.36 ± 0.74), (0.45 ± 0.74), (0.18 ± 0.41) mm. It took 3 minutes and 35 minutes for Arigin 3D Pro and Mimics to reconstruct the liver model respectively, and both software reconstructed other models for less than 1 minute. There was no statistically significant difference between the feature sizes of the two software for the 3D reconstruction models of skull and femoral comminuted fracture data (P > 0.05). The 3D reconstruction model of Arigin 3D Pro is comparable to that of Mimics. For the liver model, the reconstructed time of Arigin 3D Pro is significantly shorter than that of Mimics. Subject headings: Imaging, Three-Dimensional; Computer Simulation; Tissue Engineering Funding: the Natural Science Foundation of Jiangsu Province, No. BK20151251 0 šᣄ Introduction 1.00 mm)ᾬĹՈĿƚĚʻϔǒȈ1ŷọǚ10ŷ3545ʵ\ ᩥਜ਼ƶĚƮƚʐĚʻ̠ˊäƫՈǕʉ ĿƚĚʻ 9࿕҂҉ՈɑătÀϻɳ ₋Ϭ64ǶᙾGCTƶ(ᡃ⒬Ƅ╓ YමₑņäƫdzȺÏȳǣ4Ո)ɶxමĚʻÛₑņtY ȃę)ÏȳՈ¿ᵾĹϔǒ(ɶƞ1.00 mm)ọǚ1ŷ28ʵཥɜ මĚʻ ÂǒɴএĿᢊĚՈdzᢊĚ4ּṇzxම)ɶĚʻ ୍ݒɳɜüՈϻɳ˯້ ₋ϬȐ᪂̣ÏȳՈ¿ᵾĹϔǒ ĿƚĚʻYමₑņdzńYමाⒸͱº߾҉̢ĽǍǎɬĐඈ (Û͝471Ŭ ɶƞ1.25 mm)4 උाⒸĹา͟ி ẟ໐ṉĿϣஂܲȷợŌẟᜐƫQ) 1.4 pΛŀˇ̵Ƃ ƨ₋ϬՈĿƚĚʻYමₑņḳ ὃ̹᪳[1]4Ǹ̲ Ŀϣdz-ϬₑȀḳâȭYමµƧẟᜐ âƅǒ /&Arigin 3D Pro V4.0ḳâ(Z#ɑĿћ GḰ3¿ࢿ3෭3ϟₓ̱ň Ởẋ̶ᢖòᢆȓǎϟₓ ę)3Mimics V13.0ḳâ(Materialise͘Ǽ ɨ-r)4 Ȍ dzۤƚ3βܲՈẟᜐ҉̑)ǎ¯ƫ5˄:ǎ[2-3]4 ¤5ǎՈĿƚĚʻₑȀ3ϔǒϟₓǎ Ȍ ţńȐPǴ ẕÀǡ ƻ๒ǕẂęǪń3D·Ŵ:ǻȖƨȋ:rĿƚ Ϲ࿕Zẟᜐ̱ň ᪩Ϲ࿕‑าΞ[̱ňḳâ&Windows 7 ƽʻ̠ˊYමņµḳâՈۘǕ Ξɨ-rMaterialise͘Ǽ 64Ĺ CPU&Intel i5-4590 ƽញͱƌ(RAM)&8 GB º Ō Ǖ Ո Mimics(Materialise's interactive medical image ť&NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1060 ܰ֜ाⒸ&1 TB4 control system) ḳ â [4-5] 3 ᆵ ę Simpleware ͘ Ǽ Ո 1.5 ǒƽ ඈ5ͩ ȺZẴቻǣՈཡ࿓3ȏ࿓3ၡ͟ᅆ3࿎ Simplewareḳâ[6-7]3๒ęFEI͘ǼՈAmiraḳâ[8-9]4ּ 1.5.1 ɨṇ ęͱ>ƅęƚ┦Ⴎ¬Ěۘऺ¤ϴǛνǬþⓣŌ ɭᾬĹՈĿƚϔǒň&ǒɀP Ⱥ10ŷ͐9ϔǒ31ŷཥ Ȍிඣ3DMed(3D Medical ɜ୍ݒɳɜüϔǒň&ǒɀx4 ǕՈYමĿƚƽʻ̠ˊ^ Image Processing and Analyzing System)[10-12]4ZẴό 1.5.2 YමĚʻₑņ5ͩ ǒḳâţdzȺxමĿƚĚʻỞẋYම☦ග:ϣtdzϬz ǒɀP /Ⱥ࿎ɭ3ၡ͟ᅆ3ȏ࿓ᾬĹՈDICOMϔ v5 3D·ŴՈSTLʸśµƧ ֲQ>àϬzɜ3@☦̲3 ǒȰ͑Mimicsḳâ ϣtƣϧ፝ǻĚʻ ₋ϬⓌȨ ȏᜄۘऺ:ǻ ͢ MimicsḳâՈàϬż&Ëͯ4 ͩẟᜐµƧ3DₑȀ ࿎ɭĚʻⓌȨọō1501 368 ၡ͟ ẕƛ ɑĿћȌϦrႮ'ۘǕՈȖz3D·ŴՈĿƚₑȀ ᅆĚʻⓌȨọō2261 765 ȏ࿓ĚʻⓌȨọō1809034 ḳâிඣArigin 3D Pro KǷỔǹŤ:ęͱĿћNŖ  Ⱥཡ࿓ᾬĹՈDICOMϔǒȰ͑Mimicsḳâ ₋ϬⓌȨ ቻǣrϬՈʌòᩨdz[13]4তÑཡ࿓3ȏ࿓3ၡ͟ᅆ3 v3ľǻʺ⑃3¬ɍľǻʺ⑃3ේṕ፝ǻ3̶ɶේṕ̶ ᩨₑņڌv4żȒ ọϬ ࿎ɭ3͐93ཥɜᾬĹՈĚʻϔǒ&Ɖǒ ẟᜐµƧ3Dₑ £࿁ ẟᜐཡ࿓ϔǒՈĚʻ Ȁ dńȆᩬArigin 3D ProḳâʐMimicsḳâńĿƚĚʻ µś8Custom9 ȭZẴµƧẟᜐYමₑņ ቻǣȈ3Dₑ Yමₑņ̠ˊՈஂܲò4 ȀµƧ ÂÑstlʸśljƌ4 Ȑˊ /Ⱥ࿎ɭ3ၡ͟ᅆ3ȏ࿓ᾬĹՈDICOMϔǒ 1ȭᬥʐ5ͩSubjects and methods Ȱ͑Arigin 3D Proḳâ ϣtƣϧ፝ǻĚʻ ọǚZẴȭ v5ͩȭ࿎ɭ3ၡ͟ᅆ3 Éα ʳƨᢆȓ᪙ɀ4 àּȐՈⓌȨľⒸ ₋ϬⓌȨ 1.1 ᩨ ₑ ņ µ ś ڌ / ẟ ᜐ µ Ƨ 3D ₑ Ȁ ọ Ϭ ðϏΛıļ z2016À8ƄႷ2017À9ƄńᡃƽỞ ȏ ࿓ 1.2 ƚᆓ*ۘऺ┦ǀt4 8Recommend9 ẟᜐYමₑņ ÂÑstlʸśljƌ4Ⱥཡ̓ 1.3 Ƌ̈ 2016À8ƄႷ2017À9Ƅ ńᡃƽỞ̓ƚᆓ ࿓ᾬĹՈDICOMϔǒȰ͑Arigin 3D Proḳâ ūϬཡ࿓ņ v3 ऺ┦ȌňĿ┦Ոƽʻϔǒிඣ ọǚ₋Ϭ64Ƕᙾ µ£࿁ ỔƵẟᜐQëʃᩴ3ྐëʃᩴ ǀtĚʻ8ۘ* GCTƶ(ᡃ⒬Ƅ ȃę)ÏȳቻǣՈཡ࿓(Û͝301Ŭ ɶ ཡ࿓ v4ọϬ8Recommend9ₑņµś ẟᜐYමₑ ƞ1.25 mm)3ȏ࿓(Û͝259Ŭ ɶƞ1.00 mm)3ၡ͟ᅆ ņ ቻǣ3DₑȀµƧ ÂÑstlʸśljƌ4 (Û͝501Ŭ ɶƞ1.00 mm)3࿎ɭ(Û͝311Ŭ ɶƞ ₋Ϭ3-maticḳâV12.0(Materialise͘Ǽ ɨ-r)ḳ P.O. Box 10002, Shenyang 110180 www.CRTER.org 2385 .[☢ Ảᅭ ǜºṍ. Arigin 3D Pro ḳâ^ Mimics ḳâYමₑņµƧՈஂòۘऺ[J ŵʾ¿ Ŭ; ęඈඋ1࣏ۘऺ 2018 22(15):2384-2389. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.2095-4344.0729 â ÑMimicsḳâₑȀȒՈ3DµƧ&Ɖǒ ẟᜐǒḳâ 2ȘResults ₑȀµƧՈȻ: Ȍ ɉЩµƧȻ:ľⒸ☤ẕՈṽ 2.1 ôκBˌ ₋ϬArigin 3D ProʐMimicsḳâ / Аᾬ ǚµƧȻ:ľⒸ90%ՈⒸľǻ ȘΞĚ1¤߾4 ȭཡ࿓3࿎ɭ3ၡ͟ᅆ3ȏ࿓ᾬĹϔǒẟᜐYමₑņ ͢ Ě1¤߾ՈµƧ &ǒḳâₑȀ4]ȐඈඋȒՈₑǤ Arigin 3D ProʐMimicsḳâₑņཡ࿓µƧՈrⒸ / Ěʻ4 &3 min335 min ǒḳâₑņ͢µƧՈrⒸţɃz /Ȱ͑ 1 min4ZẴₑņrⒸ&ႮµƧt£Ȱ͑ḳâȒŌϧᩥਜ਼ ǒɀxȺཥɜ୍ݒɳɜüՈDICOMϔǒ ᩨՈⓌȨǎ Ⴗ3DµƧႮ¬ǀtņµ&Ƕ ŷZẴrⒸĉŐḳâ̱ňrڌ4Arigin 3D ProʐMimicsḳâ ₋Ϭḳâ ₑņµś ẟᜐµƧYමₑņ ቻǣ3DµƧ(Ě2)4ǎ5 ⒸǎYමႮ¬ņµrⒸ ]ĉŐµƧȰ͑rⒸ4ϵĚ13ᜬ Arigin 3D ProʐMimicsḳâȭ کȌȘdz µƧ͟⏲ĽǍͥ ΞĚ3A¤߾ẢȉּàĽǍͥ ቻǣ 3¤߾ՈȻ: 3DµƧ10ඈ͟⏲ĽǍɮȬ(ĽǍɮȬՈǎ5Ξᜬ1¤߾) ཡ࿓3࿎ɭ3ၡ͟ᅆ3ȏ࿓ϔǒẟᜐYමₑņ µƧȻ: żȒ-ϬǒḳâȈႮՈYමϟₓ£࿁ ẟᜐ10ඈĽǍɮ ՈţȨ±ʃβ: /&(0.93±1.05) (0.36±0.74) (0.45± ȬՈϟₓ4ɣඈĽǍɮȬ /ϵȐP̱ň້dž+Ě3A¤ 0.74) (0.18±0.41) mm µƧₑȌɋ /&99.26% ߾ՈĽǍͥĹา ẟᜐ5Ƶϟₓ ̱ň້ɣƵẟᜐ10ඈĽ 99.89% 99.91% 99.85%4 ǍɮȬՈ͔ᾬϟₓȒ ẟᜐ[PƵ10ඈĽǍɮȬՈϟ 2.2 ôκƵBˌ ₋ϬArigin 3D ProʐMimicsḳâₑņ ₓ4ৰ2Ƶϟₓr ū͢ৰ1ƵϟₓՈϔǒȘ]dzᢅৰ ཥɜµƧ3͐ɜµƧ  /ẟᜐ10ඈĽǍɮȬՈϟₓ Arigin 3D ProḳâₑȀµƧՈ ک3Ƶϟₓr ū͢ৰ1 2ƵϟₓՈϔǒȘ]dzᢅৰ4 ϵᜬ4 5ՈඣᩥȘdz Ƶϟₓr ū͢ৰ13ƵϟₓՈϔǒȘ]dzᢅৰ5Ƶ 10ඈĽǍɮȬ^MimicsՈ:Ŏ\ඣᩥƚ͛5(Pţ> 0.05)4 ϟₓr ū͢ৰ14ƵϟₓՈϔǒȘ]dzᢅ Ñlj᪅ϟ ₓϔǒՈβܲɳ ɱₓλɃϟₓ້'ᢆüՈƽˑ4żȒ 3ᩬDiscussion ΧĴĝƷĚ˫Ǒ ֲQ CT3MRI ɣඈĽǍɮȬȨՈ5ƵϟₓȨ ƿǭPż̓Ȩ3ƿǭP 3.1 ȕ̆ɣƗ żɃȨ ǚm[3ƵϟₓȨՈ¿ţȨ ň&10ඈĽǍɮ )ɶÏȳĚʻ>t&Ŀƚ)ՈₑᡅƉǒ IJĿϣ±º ȬȨ(ΞĚ3B¤߾)4 PிՈxමĚʻǔ▂̿ᬥ҉ǜඈඋՈYමȀ ẝȭĿ /Ⱥ10ŷ͐9ᾬĹՈDICOMϔǒȰ͑4Arigin 3D ϣՈाⒸ̿ᬥ࿁ʐ Öඓɀƅṇʌᡅ˖[1 14]Ǹ̲ ϵ ᩨՈⓌȨǎₑņµś zĿƚĚʻՈµஎɳ Ěʻ҉̢Ոṽො3ĴᢖǎľǻⒸڌProʐMimicsḳâ ₋Ϭḳâ ẟᜐµƧYමₑņ ቻǣ3DµƧ4ǎ5µƧ͟⏲ĽǍͥ Ո͟ி῁▂ÑஂܲȳẴ ºጛʺ¤r)ʐ͏ћՈ▂ò[15]4 ΞĚ4A¤߾ẢȉּàĽǍͥ ቻǣ3DµƧ10ඈ͟⏲Ľ Ǹr ĿƚĚʻYමₑņäƫàẔ໐ϣ ÂűᜩrĚʻx ǍɮȬ(ĽǍɮȬՈǎ5Ξᜬ2¤߾) żȒ-ϬǒḳâȈ මाⒸº߾Ո]ᱷ &Ŀϣ)ȴƇƚβܲՈƉǒ4 ႮՈYමϟₓ£࿁ ẟᜐ10ඈĽǍɮȬՈϟₓ4ϔǒϟₓ 2001À ᡃƽỞ̓ƚNJPɌνǬŌʉrȭĿƚĚʻY ZẴཥɜ୍ݒɳɜü˄ŷՈϟₓ5ͩPႸ ɣඈĽ මₑņäƫՈȆ௦ ÂȴϦₑņȒՈYමǒĿµƧńɜ3^5ͩ ǍɮȬ /ϵȐP̱ň້dž+Ě4A¤߾ՈĽǍͥĹา ẟ ǧဘ@☦̲ϣĭ:Ụ:ǻƅṇΙՈàϬQë[16-17]4 ᜐ5Ƶϟₓ ̱ň້ɣƵẟᜐ10ඈĽǍɮȬՈ͔ᾬϟₓȒ 2007À ីęDzνǬ[18]ɋ̴ȴϦr8ϔƋɜƚ9ՈɁ ẟᜐ[PƵ10ඈĽǍɮȬՈϟₓ4ɣƵϟₓr͢7QՈ ÂūϦĿƚYමₑņ«ǒɴxම4Yම3¿☦4এĿ3☝ 4ּණŌ ęͱ̲cǪƚ້ȭYමₑ܄ϟₓϔǒȘ]dzᢅ Ñlj᪅ϟₓϔǒՈβܲɳ ɱₓλ ɍ4¬ɍՈäƫȖ Ƀϟₓ້'ᢆüՈƽˑ4żȒ ɣඈĽǍɮȬȨՈ5Ƶϟ ņäƫẟᜐr͑Ȇ௦ ÂȺ͢t£àϬzɜ3@☦̲ ₓȨ ƿǭPż̓Ȩ3ƿǭPżɃȨ ǚm[3Ƶϟₓ 3ϘƮ̲3ࠢඓ̲3ǧဘ3Ẕ¬Ŀƚ[19-23]4 ȨՈ¿ţȨ ň&10ඈĽǍɮȬȨ(ΞĚ4B¤߾)4 ╓3D·ŴäƫՈǕʉ ńɳĚĿћ ĿϣdzỞ 1.6 ƶϙʬ+ŷ/ ǒɀPᢆȓ-ϬǒḳâYමₑ ẋ3D·Ŵ^ĿƚYමₑņäƫՈȌẟᜐƫQ)ʐµ ņȒՈּȭàՈYමµƧ ńȻ:ľⒸ&90%ՈⒸľǻ Ń Âȭ˯້ՈǃĐᾬĹẟᜐₓᵯǎ:4-Ϭ3D·Ŵäƫ ͱ ż̓Ȼ:ȨʐżɃȻ:ȨՈ̓Ƀ ǒɀxᢆȓ-Ϭ ȀņՈ˯້ᢧZµƧ3¯ƫ̬µƧʐΉ͑ĭµƧ(Ξₕʒ ǒḳâYමₑņȒՈཥɜ୍ݒɳɜüµƧ10ඈĽǍɮȬ LJų3¦1ΊĿ3ɜ֊ₑņȳĿ) ̲ĿϣdzÑȭP ՈȨ Ñǎ͐ɜµƧ10ඈĽǍɮȬՈȨ4 ̩ƾՈ¯ƫẟᜐƫQᢈʐ̱ňඇL[24]4̩ƾ¯ƫՈƫQ 1.7 Ȍαǫʭ ₋ϬSPSS 17.0ඣᩥḳâ(SPSS͘Ǽ ᪈Ĝǎ Ƨ«ọō¯ƫ5˄ՈȖ܄ ČඣՈƽʻƚᰈ▂ Ȍ4₋ϬArigin 3D Proḳâʐ Ñָᢆrᢧɜü̑Ρ43D·ŴäƫʵǒYමₑņȒՈµƧ ๒ę)ẟᜐඣᩥƚϔǒ MimicsḳâϟₓՈཥɜ୍ݒɳɜü˄ŷ10ඈĽǍɮȬ3͐ ϔǒ ָȉ3ஂܲŌ·ŴϦ¯ƫľǻᢧZȀՈYමǒĿ _ ɜ˄ŷ10ඈĽǍɮȬ ͢ϔȨϬx±sᜬ߾ ǒḳâϟₓ µƧ dzœĿTɆϦŰβܲՈƫQ᪈Ĝ3 Ƨʐ) ϔȨՈɨṇ₋Ϭtඈ᪂ᩥᰈt ̼ɀ ̼ɀˈβαȨǚǐƓ :ǎŰ᪪ඊՈ¯ƫ5˄ ÂńµƧZẟᜐ̱ňǀඇ º໐ ƫrⒸ ȴʌ¯ƫՈt£ɋ[25]4Ǹ̲ ϣĭ3D·Ŵ¯ڱ෭ 0.054 2386 ISSN 2095-4344 CN 21-1581/R CODEN: ZLKHAH Cao GP, Zhang MJ, Liu F, Lian Q, Xu XH.