Progress in Polymer Science 37 (2012) 1192–1264
Contents lists available at SciVerse ScienceDirect
Progress in Polymer Science
j ournal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/ppolysci
Polyfluorene-based semiconductors combined with various periodic
table elements for organic electronics
∗
Ling-Hai Xie, Cheng-Rong Yin, Wen-Yong Lai, Qu-Li Fan, Wei Huang
Key Laboratory for Organic Electronics & Information Displays (KLOEID) and Institute of Advanced Materials (IAM), Nanjing University of Posts &
Telecommunications (NUPT), Nanjing 210046, China
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Polyfluorenes have emerged as versatile semiconducting materials with applications in
Received 12 April 2011
various polymer optoelectronic devices, such as light-emitting devices, lasers, solar cells,
Received in revised form 8 February 2012
memories, field-effect transistors and sensors. Organic syntheses and polymerizations
Accepted 10 February 2012
allow for the powerful introduction of various periodic table elements and their build-
Available online 16 February 2012
ing blocks into -conjugated polymers to meet the requirements of organic devices. In
this review, a soccer-team-like framework with 11 nodes is initially proposed to illus-
Keywords:
trate the structure–property relationships at three levels: chain structures, thin films
-Conjugated polymers
and devices. Second, the modelling of hydrocarbon polyfluorenes (CPFs) is summarized
Band-gap engineering
Light-emitting diodes within the framework of a four-element design principle, in which we have highlighted
Photovoltaic cell polymorphic poly(9,9-dialkylfluorene)s with unique supramolecular interactions, various
Field-effect transistors hydrocarbon-based monomers with different electronic structures, functional bulky groups
Memories
with steric hindrance effects and ladder-type, kinked, hyperbranched and dendritic confor-
mations. Finally, the detailed electronic structure designs of main-chain-type heteroatomic
copolyfluorenes (HPFs) and metallopolyfluorenes (MPFs) are described in the third and
fourth sections. Supramolecular, nano and soft semiconductors are the future of polyfluo-
renes in the fields of optoelectronics, spintronics and electromechanics. © 2012 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Contents
1. Introduction ...... 1194
1.1. Background and scope ...... 1194
1.2. Basic knowledge and principles ...... 1195
1.2.1. Performance and stability of polymer devices ...... 1196
1.2.2. Optoelectronic property and morphology of semiconducting polymer films...... 1197
1.2.3. Four-element design of semiconducting polymers ...... 1199
2. Hydrocarbon polyfluorenes (CPFs) ...... 1202
2.1. Poly(9,9-dialkylfluorene)s (PDAFs) ...... 1202
2.2. Polyfluorenes with hydrocarbon-based -conjugated monomers ...... 1204
2.3. Polyfluorenes substituted with various bulky groups ...... 1206
2.4. Fused and ladder-type polyfluorenes ...... 1207
2.5. Polyfluorenes with kinked conformations...... 1208
2.6. Hyperbranched and dendritic polyfluorenes ...... 1209
∗
Corresponding author. Tel.: +86 25 8586 6008; fax: +86 25 8586 6999.
E-mail address: [email protected] (W. Huang).
0079-6700/$ – see front matter © 2012 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.progpolymsci.2012.02.003
L.-H. Xie et al. / Progress in Polymer Science 37 (2012) 1192–1264 1193
3. -Conjugated heteroatomic copolyfluorenes (HPFs) ...... 1210
3.1. Copolyfluorenes containing heterocycles in 16th group ...... 1210
3.1.1. Copolyfluorenes containing oxygen heterocycles ...... 1211
3.1.2. Copolyfluorenes containing sulphur heterocycles...... 1212
3.1.3. Copolyfluorenes containing selenium heterocycles ...... 1217
3.2. Copolyfluorenes containing heterocycles in 15th group ...... 1217
3.2.1. Copolyfluorenes containing nitrogen heterocycles ...... 1218
3.2.2. Copolyfluorenes containing phosphorus heterocycles ...... 1229
3.3. Copolyfluorenes containing heterocycles in 14th group ...... 1231
3.4. Copolyfluorenes containing heterocycles in 13th group ...... 1232
4. Metallopolyfluorenes (MPFs) ...... 1233
4.1. Copolyfluorenes containing main-group metals ...... 1234
4.2. Copolyfluorenes containing transition metals...... 1235
4.2.1. Copolyfluorenes containing Zn(II) complexes ...... 1235
4.2.2. Copolyfluorenes containing Pt(II) complexes...... 1237
4.2.3. Copolyfluorenes containing Ir(III) complexes ...... 1237
4.2.4. Copolyfluorenes containing Hg, Fe, Ru, Os, Re, or Zr complexes ...... 1242
4.3. Copolyfluorenes containing rare-earth metals ...... 1245
4.3.1. Outlook ...... 1248
Acknowledgements ...... 1248
References ...... 1248
Nomenclature
MLCT metal-to-ligand charge transfer
AFM atomic force microscopy MPFs metallopolyfluorenes
BT benzothiadiazole NIR near-infrared region
BHJ bulk heterojunction NTSC National Television System Committee
Cz carbazole OXD 1,3,4-oxadiazole
CD circular dichroism PC71BM phenyl-C71-butyric acid methyl ester
CIE Commission Internationale de l’Éclairage PCBM (6,6)-phenyl C61-butyric acid methyl ester
CV cyclic voltammetry PCE power conversion efficiencies
CPFs hydrocarbon polyfluorenes PEDOT:PSS poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene):
D–A donor–acceptor poly(styrenesulphonate)
DRAM dynamic random-access memory PF6 poly(9,9-dihexylfluorene)
DSC differential scanning calorimetry PF2/6 poly(9,9-di(2-ethylhexyl)fluorene)
DTBT 4,7-di-2-thienyl-2,1,3-benzothiadiazole PFO poly(2,7-(9,9-dioctylfluorene))
DTTP 5,7-dithien-2-yl-thieno[3,4-b]pyrazine PFs polyfluorenes
EA electronic affinity PL photoluminescence
EL electroluminescence PLEDs polymer light-emitting devices
ET energy transfer PSCs polymer solar cells
EQE external quantum efficiency QE quantum efficiency
FET field-effect transistor RGB red, green and blue
FF fill factor SAM self-assembled monolayer
FRET Förster resonance energy transfer SAXS small-angle X-ray scattering
HOMO highest occupied molecular orbital SEM scanning electron microscope
HPFs heteroatomic copolyfluorenes TEM transmission electron microscopy
LUMO lowest unoccupied molecular orbital TFTs thin-film transistors
IP ionization potential TGA thermogravimetric analysis
ISC intersystem crossing TOF time-of-flight
ITO indium tin oxide UPS ultraviolet photoelectron spectrum
I–V–L current–voltage–luminance WOLEDs white organic light-emitting devices
LC liquid crystal UV–vis ultraviolet-visible
LE luminance efficiency WORM write-once/read-many-times
LECs light-emitting electrochemical cells WRER write-read-erase-reread
LEPs light-emitting polymers XRD X-ray diffraction
1194 L.-H. Xie et al. / Progress in Polymer Science 37 (2012) 1192–1264
1. Introduction groups [59,60], including those of Bazan [61–63], Huang
[64–69], Liu [70,71] and others [72–74]. Furthermore,
1.1. Background and scope ionic-functionalized PFs have become next-generation
electron-injection or electron-extraction layers for poly-
Since poly(p-phenylenevinylene) (PPV)-based polymer mer devices such as light-emitting electrochemical cells
light-emitting diodes (PLEDs) were reported by Friend (LECs), PLEDs and solar cells. Cao and coworkers [75–79],
in 1990 [1], polymer semiconductors and devices [2] Bazan and coworkers [80–82], and other groups [83–85]
have attracted scientific and industrial interest as plastic have performed elegant research in this respect.
electronic candidates for the advancement of informa- Recently, copolyfluorenes with wide-absorption ranges
tion technology and the resolution of energy issues. have become attractive due to their potential applications
This reflects several advantages offered by polymer-based in bulk heterojunction (BHJ) polymer solar cells (PSCs)
electonics over their silicon-based counterparts, includ- by the Inganas et al. [86] and Chen and Cao [87]. High-
ing light weight, low cost, large area and flexibility mobility PFs have also been applied in polymer field-effect
[3,4]. To date, polymer semiconductors have been exten- transistors (FETs) by several groups [88–91]. For exam-
sively and intensively investigated [5,6]; these systems ple, Sirringhaus et al. reported active-matrix displays made
include -conjugated poly(p-phenylenevinylenes) (PPVs) using printed polymer thin-film transistors (TFTs) of PFs
[7], polyfluorenes (PFs, Fig. 1) [8,9], polythiophenes (PThs) [92]. In addition, PFs have been also used to achieve poly-
[10], poly(p-phenylene-ethynylenes) (PPEs) [11], and - mer memories by Ouisse et al. [93], Kang and coworkers
stacked poly(N-vinylcarbazoles) (PVKs) [12,13]. Among [94–95], and Zhao et al. [96]. PFs have been isolated as
these semiconductors, PFs exhibit wide-band-gaps (Eg) outstanding -conjugated polymers for plastic electronics.
between 2.8 and 3.5 eV, excellent thermal stability, high Diversity is one distinct advantage that polymer semi-
photoluminescence (PL) quantum efficiency, and good conductors hold over inorganic semiconductors. Indeed,
charge-transport properties [14–17], which make them their band gaps and electronic structures may be flex-
promising blue light-emitting polymers (LEPs) for appli- ibly tailored via organic synthesis and polymerization
cations in PLEDs [18,19]. techniques to meet the requirements of optoelectronic
Liquid–crystalline PFs have been utilized to achieve ori- devices. Within this context, many periodic table elements
ented electroluminescence (EL) by Grell and Neher and and numerous molecular segments have been successfully
coworkers [20,21]. PFs are also potential candidates for use introduced into the main-chain backbones, ends or side-
in lasers and have been demonstrated by several groups, chains of polymer semiconductors [97].
such as Heeger and coworkers [22,23], Heliotis et al. [24] Chemists have developed many polymer semiconduc-
and others [25,26]. However, one key issue regarding the tors with uniquely distributed electronic structures to
use of PFs in optoelectronics is overcoming the low-energy effectively break through the bottleneck in plastic elec-
emission bands at 2.2–2.3 eV (also called g-bands); these tronics. However, the relationships between numerous
may be caused by either aggregates/excimers or ketone building blocks and polymer devices are complex. Elements
defects [27–31], and remain controversial. Many efforts are likely to change, not only the electronic structures
have been made to design and synthesize stable and effi- of conjugated polymer chains dramatically varied, but
cient blue PF-based LEPs by the Müllen group [32,33], also steric hindrance, conformational topology and non-
Carter and coworkers [34], Miller and coworkers [35,36], covalent interaction that all play key roles in determining
Chen and coworkers [37], Jen and coworkers [38] and polymer morphologies and optoelectronic properties. In
the Huang group [39–41]. High-efficiency PFs, which act this review, we focus on PFs as models of semiconduct-
as hosts that harvest energy for dyes and are produced ing polymers to summarize the general and detailed roles
by feasible copolymerization techniques, are an alterna- of periodic table elements and their building blocks, except
tive to achieve high-efficiency green or red LEPs [42–46]. for the radioactive elements of period 7 and the inert ele-
According to similar principles, white PLEDs have been ments of group 18 in the periodic table, which distinguishes
realized through the control of incomplete energy trans- this review from most reviews of -conjugated polymers,
fer by the Wang group [47–51], Cao group [52–54], and including a few reviews on PF semiconductors published
others [57]. Further widening the energy band gap of PFs is in the last 10 years by Grimsdale and Müllen [98], Ler-
a challenge that involves obtaining high triplet energy for clerc and coworkers [57], Neher [21], Scherf and List [9] and
high-efficiency electrophosphorescent PLEDs [55–58]. others [86,99]. Nevertheless, it is useful to establish a gen-
Water-soluble PFs have become another important eral guideline on how to design semiconducting polymers
branch for the application of chemical and biosensors for plastic electronics. It should be noted that this review
and imaging due to their high fluorescence quantum effi- mainly focuses on the incorporation of elements and their
ciency; these materials have been explored by several molecular segments incorporated into PF main chain due to
Fig. 1. Poly(9,9-dioctylfluorene-2,7-diyl) (CPF-01b, PF8 or PFO).
L.-H. Xie et al. / Progress in Polymer Science 37 (2012) 1192–1264 1195
Fig. 2. (a) The device structure of a typical two-terminal sandwich-type polymer, (b) a soccer-team-like framework with 11 nodes indicating concepts that
must be addressed at the levels of polymer chains, semiconducting films and devices.
their simple and desirable models for structure–property aggregates rather than device structures. For polymer
relationships. Most PFs with pendant or side-chain groups devices, one major research task is to improve device
are regrettably omitted due to the limited scope of this performances; the stability and lifetime of devices are crit-
review. ical aspects regarding their commercialization. Polymer
This review is composed of five sections. The first devices generally adopt sandwich-type configurations
section begins with a general introduction of PFs, fol- composed of electrodes, active polymer semiconductor
lowed by the basic framework of polymer semiconductors layers and various interfaces, and their performances
and devices. In the second section, which discusses - are closely related to the optoelectronic properties and
conjugated hydrocarbon PFs (CPFs), we take carbon as an morphologies of polymer films, which are regarded as
example to illustrate the four-element design of PFs. In statistical aggregations of numerous semiconducting
third and fourth sections, the structure–property relation- polymer chains.
ships regarding other element effects in PFs are discussed, The basic knowledge and philosophy regarding poly-
including a discussion of -conjugated heteroatomic PFs mer semiconductors and devices are simply illustrated in
(HPFs) and -conjugated metallopolyfluorenes (MPFs). Fig. 2. Within this framework, plastic electronics research
Finally, a brief summary and outlook are presented in the includes 11 key nodes and involves three conceptual
fifth section. levels: chain structures, films and devices. Multilayered
structures and interface engineering are conventional
1.2. Basic knowledge and principles tools to improve device performance and lifetime at the
device level. Host–guest doping and/or self-assembly
According to Moore’s Law, one driving force of plastic techniques are alternatives to create high-performance
electronics research is the fact that polymer semicon- polymer devices at the film level. Organic synthesis and
ductors are favourable for miniaturisation of devices copolymerization are the distinguishing “bottom-up” tech-
because their functionalities stem from molecules and/or niques at the molecular level to design chain structures of
1196 L.-H. Xie et al. / Progress in Polymer Science 37 (2012) 1192–1264
polymeric semiconductors, including the electronic struc- To date, one great challenge that has persisted is how
ture, steric hindrance, conformation and topology as well to realize electrically pumped polymer lasers. Polymer
as supramolecular interaction. The four-element design control devices mainly include sensors and actuators,
of polymer chains is dramatically different from that of which may be used in environment monitor systems and
inorganic semiconductors. A more detailed description of robotics, respectively [112–114].
this framework is described as follows. Polymer transistors have been applied in the drive
arrays of active-matrix displays (electrophoretic display
1.2.1. Performance and stability of polymer devices pixels) [115,116], sensors [117], information storage
Polymer devices may be roughly divided into energy devices and other applications [118–120]. They have
devices, information devices and control devices by func- also been applied in the organic integrated circuits of
tion and may be categorised into two-terminal devices, radio-frequency identification tags [121]. There are two
three-terminal devices and multi-terminal devices in types of polymer transistors: planar and vertical tran-
terms of their physical structures. PSCs represent a poten- sistors [122,123]. The performance of each is mainly
tial alternative to fossil energy sources [100]. It remains determined by several important parameters, such as
challenging to improve PCEs beyond 10% for commer- field-effect mobility, ON/OFF ratio, threshold voltage,
cialization purposes [101]. To date, Yang and coworkers and sub-threshold slope. In this area, the main issues
have reported the highest PCEs of polymer/fullerene BHJ faced by chemists are improving the mobility of n-type
solar cells, with [6,6]-phenyl-C61-butyric acid methyl and p-type devices with high on/off ratios. Currently,
ester (PCBM) as an electron acceptor, to reach up to 7.4% the charge mobilities of polymer transistors may exceed
2
[102–105]. The record efficiency of organic solar cells has 1.95 cm /(V s), as reported by Bronstein et al. [124]. Note
been updated by Mitsusbishi Co., which has reported an that the introduction of molecular functionality into
efficiency of up to 9.2% [106]. polymer devices is an important strategy in addressing
Information devices include PLEDs for flexible large- the challenges to manipulate desirable and complex
area displays, polymer memories for information storage, current–voltage curves beyond the limit of Moore’s law. To
polymer solid-state lasers and photodetectors for sig- date, PFs have been used in the various devices mentioned
nal processing. PLEDs have been considered as potential above. The details regarding the introduction of their basic
inexpensive, energy-efficient alternatives to liquid–crystal device structures and working principles have been omit-
displays [107,108] since the first report by Burroughes ted, though they may be found in related reviews on PLEDs
et al. [1]. Besides the luminescence efficiency of devices, [5], PSCs [125–132], polymer lasers [23,133], polymer
colour purities are key issues for PLEDs for display appli- memories [134], and polymer transistors [135–139].
cations as they are generally composed of three primary The commercialization of polymer devices is hampered
colours red, green and blue (RGB). Primary red, green, by their performance and lifespan. Device behaviour is
blue and white emission have Commission Internationale dominated by the energy level features, which may be
de l’Éclairage (CIE) coordinates of (0.630, 0.340), (0.310, optimized by altering the configuration of the electrodes
0.595), (0.155, 0.070), and (0.3217, 0.3290), respectively, [140], multilayered semiconducting layers and modified
according to the standards from National Television Sys- interfaces [141]. For example, the use of active metal elec-
tem Committee (NTSC). The colour temperature and the trodes or the introduction of charge-transport layers can
colour-rendering index are two key characteristics besides balance electrons from cathodes and holes from anodes,
the CIE for white PLEDs for applications as solid-state light- to achieve the efficient exciton combination in PLEDs,
ing sources [109]. To update, the highest reported power resulting in high current efficiency [142,143]. The per-
efficiencies of white PLED are still lagging behind the white formances of polymer transistors, lasers and memories
organic light-emitting devices (WOLEDs) that reach up to are still undesirable; therefore only PLEDs and PSCs have
100 lm/W [110]. involved a focus on the evaluation and improvement of
Polymer memory devices are an alternative or supple- device lifetimes. Device encapsulation techniques featur-
mentary technology to conventional devices [92]. They are ing a polymer/inorganic hybrid multilayer barrier such as
divided into write-once read-many-times (WORM) mem- TiOx can greatly improve the storage stability and oper-
ories, dynamic random-access memories (DRAMs), and ating lifetime of polymer devices. Device lifespan is also
flash memories according to their current–voltage curves. closely related to the stability of polymer semiconductors.
These resistance-type memory devices are either volatile Polymer semiconductors are more susceptible to degrada-
or non-volatile. Among them, WORM memory devices tion by exposure to oxygen and water than their inorganic
exhibit the impressive feature of being non-erasable counterparts. It is a challenge to design these materials with
and are considered typical non-volatile memories [111]. high thermal, electrochemical and functional stability. For
DRAMs are volatile memory devices that lose stored data PLEDs, the factors that limit device lifetime in display and
when the power supply is removed. Flash memory is a type lighting applications are primarily spectral stability and
of non-volatile memory, which may be electrically erased colour purity, which principally depend on morphological
and reprogrammed. The ON/OFF current ratio and write- and environmental stability [144]. In particular, blue LEPs
read-erase-read (WRER) and/or programme cycles are are lagging far behind green and red components. Excitons
two key parameters used to evaluate device performances located at vulnerable -conjugated segments by exposure
and lifetimes. For polymer lasers, a low-energy threshold to adsorbed water and oxygen result in the deterioration
is desired [23]. Slope efficiency and beam quality factor of device performance. The thermal decomposition tem-
are two other parameters used to assess performance. peratures (Td) and the glass transition temperature (Tg)
L.-H. Xie et al. / Progress in Polymer Science 37 (2012) 1192–1264 1197
are crucial properties of amorphous polymer semiconduc- the defect of phase separation exists [155,156]. With the
tors in designing LEPs with long lifetimes; Td and Tg may rapid progress in nanotechnology, nanostructure-based
be determined by thermogravimetric analysis (TGA), and polymer films are becoming new-generation materials
differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), respectively. for plastic electronics [157,158]. Self-assembly techniques
For PFs, ketone defects may cause spectra instabil- allow for controlling polymer ordered superstructures. PSC
ity [9,145]. One strategy to alleviate degradation is to performance depends heavily on the morphology of the
induce efficient charge separation and shift the zone of functional films used in PSC design [159]. Semiconduct-
exciton generation to robust regions between trapped elec- ing polymer films are considered to statistical and average
trons and holes via the copolymerization or grafting of ensembles of numerous single-chained semiconducting
appropriate units. Huang reported a method to introduce polymers via complex condensation from solution to the
antioxidant-hindered amine light-stabilizers into conju- solid state. Generally, materials based on single-chained
gated polymers to protect against degradation [146–148]. polymers and condensed polymers exhibit different opto-
The high standard of the stability that has been set for poly- electronic properties due to intrachain bending, torsion and
mer semiconductors must be met to realize polymer lasers, kinking or interchain aggregates. The relationship between
which require large electrical currents. optoelectronic properties and morphology is discussed in
PSCs face the more serious challenge of enhanc- detail as follows:
ing their environmental stability and achieving longer
operating lifetime than PLEDs due to their ease of photo- 1.2.2.1. Optoelectronic properties. Ex situ optoelectronic
oxidation in sunlight-irradiated air [149]. Hauch and characterization of semiconducting polymer films without
coworkers reported that poly(3-hexylthiophene-2,5-diyl) electrodes provide the basis for screening -conjugated
(P3HT):PCBM bulk-heterojunction modules have an out- polymers suitable for high-performance devices. For exam-
door lifetime of more than 1 year [150,151]. Inverted ple, high PL quantum efficiencies of polymer films are
devices dramatically improve stability via the spin-coating generally necessary to obtain higher external quantum
of a PEDOT:PSS layer above the active layers as the top efficiencies of EL in devices, although the EL efficiency
buffer layer. The lifetimes of low-efficiency PSCs reach is also determined by many other factors. The optoelec-
values over 20,000 h [152]. For polymer transistors and tronic properties of semiconducting polymer films include
solar cells, the sensitivity to oxidative doping is closely electronic and photophysical properties, which directly
related to the oxidation potential (IP) of the active poly- reflect the behaviour of basic particles, such as carriers
mer films. Therefore, one of the strategies used to resist and excitons. Several semiconducting parameters, such as
air oxidation is to lower the highest occupied molecular the HOMO, lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO),
orbital (HOMO) of the polymer films while retaining the band gap and charge mobility, are used to character-
self-organization properties of the films. For n-type high- ize polymer films. Generally, the absolute values of the
mobility polymers, air stability is much more difficult to energy of the HOMO and the eigenvalue of the LUMO are
achieve. A high electronic affinity (EA) greatly benefits approximately equivalent to the IP and EA, respectively,
the stabilization of electron carriers, and increasing the according to Koopman theorem. Accordingly, these are
hydrophobicity of polymers helps these materials repel measured by cyclic voltammetry (CV) to determine elec-
moisture and thereby increase their environmental stabil- trochemical turn-on oxidation and reduction potentials.
ity and enhance device stability. To summarize, developing The HOMO energy level can also be calculated by ultra-
high-performance devices with long operating and envi- violet photo-electron spectroscopy (UPS). Semiconducting
ronmental lifetimes is the first objective in the structural properties may be determined by different methods. The
design of polymer semiconductors and their devices. electrical band gap (E ) is associated with the dif-
g electr
ference between the EA and IP. The optical band gap
1.2.2. Optoelectronic property and morphology of (Eg opt) is determined from the absorption-edge wave-
semiconducting polymer films length ( ) (E = 1240/ ). The exciton binding
edge, abs g edge
One clear advantage of polymer devices is their low cost energy may be estimated as the difference between E
g electr
of fabrication with respect to that of their inorganic coun- and Eg opt. Polymer films with large exciton binding ener-
terparts. To date, several solution-processable techniques gies, such as PFO (∼30 meV) are suitable for use in EL
have been demonstrated, including inkjet printing, gravure devices, while polymers with small binding energies pro-
printing, micro-contact printing, roll-to-roll printing, and mote exciton dissociation in PSCs. The emission colour
other techniques [153]. For single-layered polymer devices of light-emitting polymer films depends on the energy
with sandwich-type configurations, it is essential to design gap between the LUMO and HOMO, with the visible-light
and characterize the semiconducting polymer films to spectrum (380–780 nm) corresponding to 1.5–3.2 eV. For
achieve stable, high-performance devices. Generally, the photovoltaic polymer films, the open-circuit voltage (Voc)
typical thicknesses of semiconducting polymer films range is related to the energy difference between the LUMO
from 10 to 200 nm in polymer devices. Host–guest doping of the acceptor (PCBM) and the HOMO of the donor
systems [154] or self-assembly techniques of polymer films (for low-band-gap -conjugated polymers) [160–163]. The
are two effective methods used to tune film properties and HOMO–LUMO band-gap energy is closely related to the
achieve high device performance at the nanometre scale. absorption range of PSCs and the mobility of field-effect
For PLEDs, red or white EL may be achieved by blending transistors. The charge-carrier mobility of polymer films
host matrices with various dye dopants based on energy may be measured by either time-of-flight (TOF) methods,
transfer and tunable charge-transport behaviour, although time-resolved microwave conductivity, or by analysing
1198 L.-H. Xie et al. / Progress in Polymer Science 37 (2012) 1192–1264
diode or transistor configurations [164]. Carrier type and most p-type conjugated polymers, high LUMO energy lev-
concentration could be determined by exploiting the Hall els should be reduced to improve electron injection at the
Effect. Other related transport parameters, such as density cathodes. Consequently, to obtain high-efficiency PLEDs,
of states, reorganization energy, and transfer integration, bipolar conjugated polymers are desirable candidates for
could be investigated by first-principle theoretical calcula- high-efficiency devices in single-layer devices due to their
tions using the Gaussian software package. High-mobility balanced hole- and electron-transport abilities [170]. Gra-
polymers are required for polymer transistors used in inte- dient charge injection and energy transfer have become
grated circuits. For high-mobility polymer films, n-type an effective method to further improve the performance
polymers are relatively rare because most polymers exhibit of PLEDs [171]. For PSCs, electrical currents may be gener-
p-type behaviour. Most conjugated polymers exhibit faster ated by light absorption according to the photovoltaic effect
hole transport than electron transport [165]. For mem- and exciton diffusion and dissociation to generate carri-
ories, charge mobility of polymers need not extremely ers, transport carriers, and collect carriers into electrodes.
high. Stability and trap depth of charge-transfer complexes Low-band gaps and high charge mobilities play key roles in
determine their type: WORM, DRAM or flash memories improving the PCE of BHJ solar cells. For polymer lasing, the
that may be created. active material must exhibit strong stimulated emission
Steady-state or time-resolved electronic absorption and under optical or electrical excitation. Polymer semicon-
emission spectra can measure several many molecular ductors are generally four-level energy systems that afford
optical parameters, including electronic absorption peaks, the possibility to realize population inversion, which is a
molar extinction coefficient and emission bands, Stokes prerequisite for lasing applications. Several distinct prop-
shift, and other photophysical parameters. Conformational erties of polymers such as high luminescence efficiency,
changes may be monitored in UV spectra, such as the rise high chromophore density, large cross section for the stim-
of the planar ˇ chains of poly(9,9-dioctylfluorene) (PFO) ulated emission, and low amplified spontaneous emission
together with the generation of new peaks. The effec- (ASE) threshold characterize a good laser material with a
tive conjugation lengths of polymers can be estimated large gain coefficient.
by examining the plot of absorption energy (or some
proportional quantity) versus the quantity 1/n, where n 1.2.2.2. Morphology. Active polymer films are complex
represents the oligomeric length [166,167]. An extended matrices of polymer channels that feature carrier par-
range of light absorption with a very large molar extinc- ticles according to the channel-wave/particle theory. In
tion coefficient enhances the photocurrents and PCE of polymer semiconductors, channels and carriers are two
PSCs. With respect to PL spectra, the colour purities and interplaying factors that are critical in determining device
CIE coordinates of PLEDs are closely related to the emis- performance and functionality. The electron states of
sion peak and full-width at half-maximum values. A high single-chained polymers in the solid state are much more
QE is favourable for the amplified spontaneous emission complex than those in solution due to interchain aggrega-
of a laser, improves the detection sensitivity of sensors tion and other conformational processes. Exerting control
and enhances the external quantum efficiency (EQE) of over morphology is an effective strategy to tailor the car-
PLEDs. Fluorescence and phosphorescence exhibit dra- rier and exciton transport behaviour of polymer films,
matic photophysical properties, the latter of which has which leads to optimized device performance. Normally,
the advantage of exhibiting almost 100% internal quan- phase morphology may be characterized using atomic force
tum efficiency (IQE). Luminescent longevity may be used microscopy (AFM), scanning electron microscopy (SEM),
to distinguish singlet from triplet excitons. Triplet energy transmission electron microscopy (TEM), small-angle X-
levels are important parameters for electrophosphorescent ray scattering (SAXS) and other analytic methods. The
host–guest materials. Förster resonance energy transfer polymorphism of conjugated polymer films makes the
(FRET) may be effectively harnessed in designing white relationship more complex, in which several condensed
PLEDs, fluorescent sensors and other devices. Charge trap- phases of the same polymer, including amorphous states,
ping plays a key role in electrophosphorescent PLEDs in semi-crystalline phases, liquid–crystal phases and poly-
addition to energy transfer, in which there are large dif- crystal phases, may be obtained by altering the external
ferences in the triplet energies between host and guest preparation conditions, such as temperature, solvent type,
materials [168,169]. concentration, etc. PF materials are good examples of mate-
These electronic and optical properties are fundamen- rials that exhibit extensive polymorphism.
tal in determining whether a polymer semiconductor is Charge mobility and other important electronic param-
suitable for a certain device. In practice, any single device eters are highly sensitive to phase morphology [172].
has a certain set of required optoelectronic properties Self-assembly affords powerful approaches to tailor nanos-
that must be met by the active polymer films that are tructures. The hierarchical architectures of active polymer
used in its design. For PLEDs, under an applied voltage, films also strongly influence their photophysical behaviour.
charge carriers undergo carrier-charge injection, trans- For example, the exciton binding energy of well-oriented
port and combination processes to emit light; in PSCs, polyfluorene films is about 10 times smaller than that of
these processes are controlled to harness solar energy. disordered films [173,174]. Morphology-dependent energy
For light-emitting polymer films, device efficiency is sen- transfer within PF thin films has been investigated by
sitive to the position of the exciton recombination zone, Khan et al. [175]. Microstructures dramatically change
which is determined by the injection and transport abil- the optoelectronic properties and device performance. The
ity of charge carriers from the anode and cathode. For modulation of excitation energy transfer by controlled
L.-H. Xie et al. / Progress in Polymer Science 37 (2012) 1192–1264 1199
self-assembly allows for slow energy migration and par-
tial energy transfer to realize RGB-based white emission,
as reported by Vijayakumar et al. [176]. Generally, there
are specific requirements that must be met by active
polymer films to produce high-performance polymer
devices. Amorphous phases with high Tg are favourable
for PLEDs, nano-scale phases for polymer solar cells,
long-range ordered liquid crystal or polycrystal phase for
high-mobility polymer transistors [90], and phase trans-
formation for non-volatile bistable memories. For PSCs,
Heeger and coworkers introduced the BHJ concept to over-
come the limitation of exciton separation and the length
of exciton diffusion and effectively enhance the photo-
electrical conversion efficiency of solar cell devices [177].
In polymer BHJ solar cells, interpenetrating p–n networks
with a desired domain size of 10 nm are easily formed
by blending -conjugated polymers (p-type) with soluble
fullerenes (n-type) via the driving force of phase separation.
Although the limitation of the exciton separation has been
overcome using the BHJ concept, it is still challenging to
control charge collection kinetics by controlling morphol-
ogy.
1.2.3. Four-element design of semiconducting polymers
From the chemical structure point of view, polymer
semiconductors are essentially charge-transport -orbital
channels, which are mainly divided into -conjugated
polymers and -stacked polymers. Organic synthesis
Fig. 3. (a) Electronic structure design principle, (b) the three basic types
affords flexible tools to control charge-carriers behaviour
of energy level diagrams of p–n (D–A) semiconducting copolymers.
through the combination and reorganization of -orbitals,
resulting in dramatically different optoelectronic proper-
ties as well as morphologies for semiconducting polymer
films applied in various devices. The conceptual frame- HOMO, LUMO and band gap, which has led to the
work established by physical organic chemistry offers optimization of device performance [179]. Frontier molec-
useful templates guiding the principles and strategies of ular orbital theory is suitable for the conceptualization
polymer semiconductor design. Semiconducting polymer of not only organic reactions, but also organic opto-
chains are effectively tuned by means of four fundamen- electronic materials [180,181]. Electron-donating groups
tal nodes, including electronic structure, steric hindrance, and electron-withdrawing groups have been introduced
conformation and topology, and supramolecular inter- into polymer films through substitution, copolymeriza-
action, which have been proposed by Xie–Huang group tion, end-capping and other techniques. Specific electronic
[178]. The introduction of periodic table elements into structure groups may be selected according to doping
polymer chains is used primarily to tailor the electronic or blending host–guest experiments. Charge transfer or
structures of polymers due to the different electroneg- energy transfer make alteration of the electronic behaviour
ativities and dipoles of molecular segments, directly of -conjugated polymers dramatically. The Huang group
resulting in dramatic alteration of the optoelectronic prop- has proposed a novel p–n semiconducting copolymeriza-
erties of polymer films. Correspondingly, supramolecular tion strategy for polymer-band-gap engineering [170], in
interactions alter the morphology of polymer films. The which there are three basic types of electronic energy
four-element design of -conjugated polymers allows diagrams that describe conjugated polymers containing
for stable and high-performance polymer devices to be donors or acceptors, as shown in Fig. 3.
designed at the molecular scale, an approach that is not For type I, there is seldom any energy level overlap
readily feasible for the design of inorganic semiconduc- between donors and acceptors. In this case, ground-
tors. In addition, it has become increasingly important state electron transfer occurs due to the negative
to investigate molecular electronics because they help free-energy driving force. The bulk conductivity of con-
not only to clarify device behaviour of polymer films, ducting polymers may be enhanced by chemical doping.
but also to explore new functionalities of polymer Using this technique, hole or electron carrier injection
films. have been effectively enhanced by either tetrafluo-
rotetracyanoquinodimethane [182,183] and molybdenum
1.2.3.1. Electronic structure design. The introduction of tris-[1,2-bis(trifluoromethyl)ethane-1,2-dithiolene] as p-
molecular segments with various polar or electronic effects dopants [184,185] or cobaltocene and decamethylcobal-
provides an effective method to tune the optoelectronic tocene as n-dopants [186,187]. For type II, there is a partial
properties of semiconducting polymer films, such as the overlap of energy levels between donors and acceptors. In
1200 L.-H. Xie et al. / Progress in Polymer Science 37 (2012) 1192–1264
this case, hybridization after copolymerization generate a of acceptors may be employed to tune the bistable
new HOMO located at the donor and a new LUMO located at switching and stable charge-transfer state, resulting in
the acceptor, thus resulting in a lower band gap [188,189]. WORMs, DRAMs or flash memories [204–206]. Utilization
+ −
↔
Furthermore, mesomerism (D–A D = A ) leads to the of excited-state intramolecular proton transfer or twisted
improvement in a double-bond character between the D intramolecular charge transfer to develop next-generation
and A units, thereby facilitating charge transfer. In this polymer devices presents a current research challenge
system, the improvement in the quinoid states or de- [207,208].
aromaticity occur after the hybridization between donors
and acceptors. As a result, these types of D–A conju- 1.2.3.2. Steric hindrance design. Steric hindrance design
gated copolymers exhibit a strong ground-state dipole due provides a tool used to improve device performance by
to intramolecular charge transfer. Photo-induced electron modifying the spatial arrangement of active molecular
transfer is readily observed in the excited state. The Huang bricks, morphology and the finely optoelectronic proper-
group has demonstrated that the emission colour and ties of conjugated polymers. In contrast with electronic
redox properties of type II p–n light-emitting copolymers structure design, most of the sterically hindered groups do
may be effectively tuned to achieve RGB emission in PLEDs not alter the HOMO and LUMO energy level significantly
by balancing the charge carriers from the anode and cath- when it is introduced into -conjugated polymer chains.
ode [165,190–193]. The Jenekhe group showed that type There are two basic types of hindrance effects: intra-
II -conjugated oligomers and copolymers exhibit excel- and interchain steric hindrances. The former can serve to
lent ambipolar charge-transport behaviour and low-band twist dihedral angles between the adjacent monomer units,
gaps [194,539,669]. The incorporation of electron–hole- while the latter can suppress interchain aggregation. The
transport units into PFs also helps to balance charge-carrier softest sterically hindered groups are various alkyl side-
populations and achieve good spectral stability and excel- chains and pendant groups, which can alter interchain
lent thermal stability [38,195,196]. The reason lies in supramolecular interactions [209]. Rigid bulky groups are
the alternation of charge-transfer state on the polymer favourable for producing high Tg and colour stability
chains, reducing the probability of excited-state trapping in amorphous LEPs [27,210]. The Xie–Huang group has
in undesirable defect states. Currently, D–A conjugated demonstrated that spirobifluorenes and 9-phenylfluorenyl
copolymers offer the most effective tool with which to moieties are outstanding sterically hindered groups that
develop low-band-gap materials with wide light absorp- may be used in conjugated polymers and stacked polymers
tion that can improve the efficiency of polymer solar cells [211–219]. The supramolecular steric hindrance effect is
[102]. Ling and coworkers have developed polymer DRAMs a new design technique that may be used to balance the
using this type of copolymer by controlling the stability of colour of light emitted and current efficiency [220–222].
charge-transfer states [197]. For type III, there is a close Swager and coworkers have developed iptycene-type ster-
relationship between the donors and acceptors. When ically hindered groups [223]. Dendron substitution is
the type III energy structure between molecular segments an extreme example of steric hindrance that exploits
occurs, it has been proven that conjugated copolymers the self-shield and self-packed effect of polymer chains
facilitate FRET more easily than charge transfer. The type [32–34,224]. It should be noted that the substitution of
III energy structure is the basis of the Annette effect used pendant groups often produces binary or multiple func-
to harvest energy for photosynthesis. If efficient energy tionalities [38,225]. Chen and coworkers have designed a
transfer from a wide-gap segment to a narrow gap site series of conjugated PFs with gradient electronic structures
occurs, another prerequisite condition is that exciton trans- to achieve stable colour-purified high-efficiency blue LEPs
fer and trapping between the chromophoric segments [226], in which side and/ or pendant chains serve as both
must be much faster process than radiative and nonradia- electronic structural groups and steric hindered groups.
tive decay. Copolymers of the type III structure are very The -substituent groups are multifunctional to design
useful in designing red and white LEPs. Burn et al. reported sterically hindered donors or acceptors, which represents
the use of exciton confinement in random copolymers to a powerful tool for electroluminescent materials design.
improve the EQE of PLEDs [198], in which efficient energy Wang and coworkers have reported a series of blue-, green-
transfer and exciton trapping occur from segments with and red-light-emitting PFs containing dyes with high PL
wider energy gaps to heterocycle sites with narrow band efficiency [227–230].
gaps. Oligofluorenes have been chosen to harvest energy to
porphyrin dyes for high-efficiency red PLEDs [414]. More- 1.2.3.3. Conformation and topology design. Beyond steric
over, exciton migration and trapping by highly emissive hindrance, conformation and topology determine the basic
chromophoric segments offer a tool with which to tune carrier-transport channels in polymers, which are impor-
colour emissions through the use of copolymers [199]. tant to the design of polymer semiconductors for use in
Colour tuning in blends containing perylene copolymers high-performance devices. Linear -conjugated polymers
has been reported by Tasch et al. [200]. Cao and cowork- might be considered one-dimensional carrier-transport
ers have used intrachain energy-transfer conjugated channels with low-dimensional characteristics. In gen-
polymers to develop high-efficiency red-light-emitting eral, linear and planar conformations afford high charge
polymers [201,202]. Attaching dye-containing copolyflu- mobilities in conjugated polymers. Their degree of electron
orenes to side-chains has become one practical method delocalization is determined by the effective conjugation
of developing commercialized white-light-emitting mate- length, which may be extended by the planarization of
rials [57,109,203]. In polymer memories, the trap depth conformations, resulting in low-band gaps, high charge
L.-H. Xie et al. / Progress in Polymer Science 37 (2012) 1192–1264 1201
mobilities and red-shifted emissions [231]. Ladder-type morphologies of polymers at the highest levels of concep-
-conjugated polymers containing unique linear confor- tualization. In this context, supramolecular analysis could
mation possess high backbone rigidity, which can be further clarify the roles of supramolecular interactions
characterized by the associated Stokes shifts, benefiting in solution, active polymer films and devices. Among the
the improvement of charge mobility [232]. The substi- many supramolecular weak interactions that exist, –
tuted isomerization of linear monomers allows for the stacking interactions play a unique role in organic elec-
construction of zigzagged or kinked conformations with tronics due to their basic effect on the electron-hopping
shorter effective conjugation lengths than those of their channels [251,252]. The edge-on or face-on arrangements
linear counterparts [233,234]. The effective conjugation of -segments and intermolecular self-organization dra-
lengths of -conjugation-interrupted polymers may be matically influence the mobility of polymer transistors
3
further reduced by linking through tetrahedral sp car- [253]. Previously, we proposed the study of supramolec-
bons [235], which generates an amorphous phase with ular semiconductors to explore device functionalities
high spectral and thermal stability that is well suited and performance [13]. Intramolecular supramolecular
for applications violet-light or electrophosphorescent host systems will be a promising tool to explore memory-effect
materials. Beyond the linear and kinked conformations, polymers [245]. Such -stacked polymers as PVK have
other complex polymer arrangements, such as multi- also become important semiconducting polymers, besides
armed macromolecules, hyperbranched polymers and -conjugated polymers [254–256]. The supramolecular
dendrimers [236], have also been developed [237–239]. functionalization of polymer semiconductors allows for
Three-dimensional -conjugated polymers show many the development of various new organic electronic sys-
porous superstructures that are suitable for applications tems. Conjugated polyelectrolytes with supramolecular
in either biosensors or the detection of explosives, such as ionic side-chains, such as the quaternization of the amino
2,4,6-trinitrotoluene [240]. Dendrimer core–shell systems group, are one form of water-soluble fluorescent poly-
are important scaffold of FRET that suppress luminescence mers used in biosensors [257–259]. A recent important
quenching processes and achieve high QE [236]. Macrocy- development in PFs was the development of ionic PFs and
cles are favourable for the construction of many complex their application as electron-injection layers in PLEDs and
conformations and topologies. Macrocyclic PFs have been electron-extraction layers in polymer solar cells. Bazan
synthesized by the Müllen group [241]. They represent an and coworkers, Cao and coworkers, and Park et al. have
important kind of molecular segment that can be used performed elegant research in this field [75–77,80,83,260].
to further construct catenane and rotaxane complexes. Furthermore, conjugated homopolymer amphiphiles
Polyretaxane, an example of a molecule that exhibits a are an alternative to construct well-defined, hierar-
novel conformation, has also been applied as a molec- chically self-assembled architectures. Schenning and
ular wire. Encapsulation can also improve the stability Meijer proposed that supramolecular electronics is an
of polymer chains against thermal and/or photooxidation intermediate field between molecular electronics and
to enhance the colour purity of PFs [242–244]. Further- organic-film electronics [261]. Following the develop-
more, controlling conformational changes is useful in the ment of side-chain supramolecular conjugated polymers
design of memory-effect polymers [245]. Interrupted con- and stacked polymers, main-chain-type supramolecular
jugated polymers exhibit many conformational isomers, polymers with dynamic linkages of noncovalent bonds
which may become a type of memory-effect polymer. were demonstrated to be fantastic semiconducting poly-
In addition, rod-coil conjugated polymers have two dif- mers [262–264]. Researchers have introduced various
ferent block segments, one of which is unique to the hydrogen bonds into conjugated systems to systemically
conformational design, exhibiting versatile supramolecu- investigate the fine control that may be exerted over
lar assembly behaviours [246,247]. More recently, rod–rod self-assembled behaviour and morphology-dependent
copolymers have also been explored to investigate their optoelectronic properties [265]. Wurthner et al. reported
self-assembly behaviours [248]. the development of supramolecular p–n heterojunctions
[266].
1.2.3.4. Supramolecular interaction design. Along with To summarize, the performance as well as stability
the molecular characteristics of organic semiconductors, of polymer devices may be controlled on a large scale or
supramolecular features provide another opportu- finely manipulated via self-assembly techniques and/or the
nity to explore device performance and functionality, organic synthesis of polymer chains. As illustrated in Fig. 2,
which clearly distinguishes organic semiconductors from the four elements electronic structure, steric hindrance,
their inorganic counterparts [249]. In general, the self- conformation and topology as well as supramolecular
organization of semiconducting conjugated polymers interaction have been combined with supplementary
during solution processes results in a complex relationship elements to deeply and clearly understand the relation-
between polymer films and devices. Supramolecular inter- ships that exist among the three conceptual levels of
actions between polymer chains intrinsically determine -conjugated polymers: chain structures, thin films and
the various morphology phases adopted by active polymer devices. It should be noted that the four-element principle
films, resulting in the alteration of the current–voltage is an ideal model. Each node may affect other elements, as
characteristics of devices [250]. Supramolecular interac- shown in the framework. When one periodic table atom
tions and noncovalent bands that serve as molecular-scale with an electronegativity value dramatically different from
interfaces determine the self-assembly behaviour, molec- that of carbon is incorporated into polymer semiconduc-
ular nanostructures, phase separations, and domain tors, it will mainly affect the electronic structures of the
1202 L.-H. Xie et al. / Progress in Polymer Science 37 (2012) 1192–1264
Fig. 4. Polyfluorenes containing various periodic table elements.
polymers, followed by their optoelectronic properties. In way of end-capping functional groups and constructing
fact, this incorporation will also alter the steric hindrance, block copolymers [272–274]. In this section, following
conformation, topology, and even supramolecular interac- the framework of the four-element design principle of
tions exhibited by the polymers. Herein, we will focus on semiconducting polymer design, we first discuss poly(9,9-
PFs as a model semiconducting polymers to demonstrate dialkylfluorene)s (PDAFs) to illustrate the relationship
in detail the effect of various elements with different elec- between morphology and optoelectronic properties, in
tronegativity and their molecular segments with different which the influence of alkyl-substitution and supramolec-
electron-donating or accepting ability on polymer films ular – interactions as well as external conditions on
and devices (Fig. 4). The intrinsic electronic effects of device performance will be addressed. Second, hydrocar-
elements and their molecular segments on optoelectronic bon copolyfluorenes will be introduced to illustrate the
properties and device performance will be highlighted. basic principle of electronic structure design for band-gap
engineering, followed by the steric hindrance design of
bulky groups. Conformation and topology design includes
2. Hydrocarbon polyfluorenes (CPFs)
fused and ladder-type, kinked, hyperbranched and den-
dritic CPFs.
Molecular segments consisting of carbon and hydro-
gen atoms are abundant due to the catenation of their
characteristics and flexible bonding features, which facil- 2.1. Poly(9,9-dialkylfluorene)s (PDAFs)
itate the construction of different electronic and steric
effects. Many CPFs have been reported since the oxida- PFs are regarded as the simplest regular step-
tive polymerization of PFs was demonstrated using ferric ladder-type poly(para-phenylene)s (PPPs), in which
chloride in 1989 by Fukuda et al. [267–269]. Since then, two phenyl rings are locked into a plane via the C-9
transition-metal-catalysed polymerizations, such as those carbon of the fluorene units. PDAFs have good solubil-
performed by such as Suzuki, Yamamoto, Stille and others, ity owing to the introduction of alkyl chains, including
have proved to be more effective methods for synthesiz- poly(9,9-dihexylfluorene) (PF6) (CPF-01a) (Scheme 1),
ing high-molecular-weight PFs [6,19,270,271]. Recently, poly(9,9-di-n-octylfluorene) (PF8 or PFO) (CPF-01b), and
Wang and coworkers and the McCullough group reported poly(9,9-di(2-ethylhexyl)fluorene) (PF2/6) (CPF-01c).
a chain-growth mechanism to synthesize PFO using the PDAFs possess relatively large band gaps, which are suit-
Grignard metathesis method (GRIM), which offers a able for blue-light-emitting materials. PF8 is a basic model
L.-H. Xie et al. / Progress in Polymer Science 37 (2012) 1192–1264 1203
Scheme 1. Poly(9,9-dialkylfluorene)s (PDAFs).
of the structure–property relationships exhibited by semi- or the presence of excimers as being responsible for the
conducting polymers [9]. The HOMO and LUMO energy low-energy emission band [27,292–294]; other reports
− −
levels of PF8 are estimated to be 5.80 and 2.12 eV, suggested that the low-energy emission band might be
respectively, according to CV measurements [275]. PF8 attributed to on-chain chemical ketone defects [9,29,295],
has the difference between the E (3.1 eV) and E interchain ketone-based excimers or hydroxy-terminated
g electr g opt
(2.95 eV) with an exciton binding energy of approximately oxidation at the interfaces of devices [296]. Nevertheless,
30 eV [275,276]. Our group previously reported that PF6 the thermal stress of a device tends to form keto-type
− possess HOMO and LUMO energy levels of 5.50 and defects at the 9-position of PF units by exposure to oxygen
−
2.37 eV (E = 3.13 eV, E = 2.86 eV), respectively and water, which is accompanied by the appearance of the
g electr g opt
[277]. With respect to carrier transport, PF8 exhibits excel- undesirable green emission band. The design of stable PFs
lent nondispersive hole transport, with a mobility of up to without g-bands has become a key objective for organic
× −4 2
3 10 cm /(V s), as measured by the TOF method [278]. and polymer chemists.
Recently, a PF8-based PLEDs using MoO3 ohmic contact PDAFs exhibited complex phase behaviour and numer-
layers was shown to allow for the direct determination ous morphologies that depended delicately on aver-
−5 2
×
of the zero-field hole mobility (1.3 10 cm /(V s)) from age molecular weight [297,298], side-chain architecture
the space-charge-limited current (SCLC) regime [279]. [299,300] and film preparation conditions [301–303]. One
PDAFs are promising light-emitting polymer materials thorny issue in this field is the relationship between poly-
due to their PL efficiency of more than 80% in solution morphs and optoelectronic properties along with the need
and approximately 50% in solid film without heavy-atom to clarify the origin of the g-band [304]. In terms of charge
effects [280]. Their triplet energy level is approximately transport, Redecker et al. have demonstrated that relatively
−3 2
2.15 eV [281], which is high enough to act as a host for high charge-carrier mobilities (up to 8.5 × 10 cm /(V s))
red electrophosphorescent complexes, but not suitable for can be achieved when PF8 was oriented in its nematic
◦
green or blue guests. The influence of the chain length phase (T > 160 C) [305]. The amorphous phase [306],
and side-chains of PDAFs on optical properties has been liquid–crystal phase, crystalline alpha (␣) and alpha’ phase
ˇ
studied. Miller investigated that the effective conjugation [307], beta ( ) phase, and gel phase of PF8 have been
lengths of the PDAFs is ca. 10 monomers [282]. Single- demonstrated by several groups using various microscopy
layer blue PLEDs based on PF6 exhibit a maximum emission techniques and theoretical simulations [308], such as X-ray
wavelength of 470 nm at 10 V and at room temperature, diffraction (XRD), near-field scanning optical microscopy
as reported by Ohmori et al. [18]. In fact, PDAFs exhibited [309] confocal laser spectroscopy [310], NMR spectroscopy
poor electron-transport abilities [283]. Grice et al. reported [311], and Monte Carlo simulations [312].
a PF8-based double-layer blue PLED with a brightness of Pioneering works on the thermotropic liquid–crystal
2
600 cd/m at a bias voltage of 20 V, emission peaks at (LC) behaviour of PF8 were reported by Grell et al. [313].
436 nm, and luminance efficiency (LE) of 0.25 cd/A [284]. According to Bradley’s findings, a nematic (N) mesophase
PDAFs showed excellent thermal stability but a low of PF8 exists when it is heated to its melting temper-
◦ ◦
Tg of 75 C and limited spectral stability in PLEDs. Low- ature of 170 C [313–315]. Ueda and coworkers found
energy green emission bands (also called long-wavelength that a single-crystal-like thin film of PF8 may be created
emission bands, or g-bands) of 2.2–2.3 eV (520–530 nm) by a friction-transfer technique with subsequent thermal
were clearly observed under high or long-term operating treatments [316]. PF8 is known to be crystalline. Su and
voltages [144,285]. Pei and Yang [19] and Kreyenschmidt coworkers investigated the chain-packing behaviour of
et al. [286] first reported the issue of the low-energy green crystalline PF8 featuring eight polymer chains and a space
emission bands of PDAFs in EL devices. These bands in group P212121 [317]. They also performed cold crystal-
PDAFs are manifested as poor colour purity and limited lization and conducted a Gibbs-Thomson analysis of PF8
lifetime in PLEDs. To clarify and identify the origin of [318–321]. Brinkmann developed oriented PF8 by direc-
this long-wavelength emission, various techniques have tional epitaxial crystallization in a 1,3,5-trichlorobenzene
been used to characterize films annealed in an air or N2 solvent [322].
atmosphere, including X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy Unlike the ␣ phase, the ˇ phase of PF8 has a pla-
◦
(XPS) [287], Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy nar conformation with a dihedral angle of 180 between
[288], matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time- repeating fluorene units and exhibits remarkable pho-
of-flight mass (MALDI-TOF-MS) spectrometry [145], tophysical properties. The ˇ phase can be induced by
steady-state UV–vis absorption and PL spectra, and time- annealing or solvent-vapour exposure [304]. Morgado and
resolved PL measurements [289]. However, the origin of Charas reported PF8 based PLEDs with pure ˇ-phase emis-
this low-energy emission band is still the subject of debate sion and higher colour stability upon increasing the driving
[290,291]. Some evidence supports interchain aggregation voltage [323]. Lu et al. created a self-dopant form of the ˇ
1204 L.-H. Xie et al. / Progress in Polymer Science 37 (2012) 1192–1264
ˇ phase of PF8 to develop efficient and stable pure blue elec- to create PF-based nanoparticles with amorphous and
ˇ
troluminescent devices [324]. The -phase of PF8 has been phases controlled by solvent type [350–352]. Polymer gels
proved to help improve the cross sections of organic lasers, represent another important phase, which is featureed as
as illustrated by Rothe et al. [325] and Anni and coworker physical cross-linked networks that can be explored to
[326,327]. investigate the self-assembly mechanisms or new applica-
Different substitutions of alkyl side-chain significantly tion of semiconducting polymers. Several studies on PF gels
impact the conformation, phase behaviour and self- have been reported [353] since PF8/toluene gel was first
assembly of the conjugated PF backbone [209,299,328]. synthesized by Grell et al. [354]. Knaapila et al. noted that
Monkman and coworkers studied the influence of alkyl- PFn (6-9)/methylcyclohexane solutions became viscous or
◦
chain length on ˇ-phase formation in PFs [328,329]. They gel-like when the solutions were cooled to −25 C [355].
ˇ ˇ
concluded that the -phase formation is controlled by the Chen and coworkers observed the -phase PF8 gels in
side-chain interactions in methylcyclohexane solution: PF8 toluene and methylcyclohexane solvents [356,357]. Lin and
is more easily controlled than PF6, PF9, and PF10. Su and coworkers successfully prepared PF8/1,2-dichloroethane
coworkers reported four different phases of PF6, which gels at room temperature to utilize their stimulus-response
had previously received little attention compared to its feature to develop soft polymer semiconductors sensor
homologues PF8 and PF2/6 [330]. PF2/6, as a stiff heli- and actuator applications [292]. PFO/1,2-dichloroethane
cal polymer, possesses better solubility in organic solvents gel exhibits up to 50% ˇ phase and unique photolumines-
than PF8 because of its branched alkyl groups. Knoll and cence peaks at 470, 500 and 550 nm, which are red-shifted
coworkers were the first to synthesize LC-phase PF2/6 with respect to the three emission bands at 419, 443 and
and investigated its blue polarized EL [20]. Lieser et al. 472 nm in solution and the feacturing peaks at 446, 473, and
identified axially oriented PF2/6 with hexagonal unit cells 500 nm in the ˇ-phase, assigned to the 0–0, 0–1 and 0–2
[331]. Knaapila et al. reported biaxially aligned PF2/6 with vibrational transitions. Moreover, xerogels, which exhibit
cylindrically isotropic orientation in a hexagonal phase by porous morphology, can be used in gas sensor applications
grazing-incidence XRD [332–335]. Winokur and cowork- and are promising organic porous semiconductors and soft
ers utilized polarized optical absorption spectroscopy, semiconductors.
near-edge X-ray absorption fine structure spectroscopy PDAFs, as typical PFs, exhibit excellent wide-band-gap
(NEXAFS), and grazing-incidence X-ray diffraction (GIXRD) semiconducting properties in blue electroluminescent or
to investigate PF2/6 [336]. They found that the top host materials. However, their low-energy green emission
and bottom surfaces exhibited appreciable planar, uni- bands (g-bands) hinder their commercialization. The stud-
axial alignment, while the film interior showed a higher ies on PDAFs’ polymorphs have been performed not only to
proportion of tilted chains after thermal cycling. These uncover the origin of these g-bands, but also to extend their
inhomogeneities are likely to influence technologically applications in lasers, sensors, and other photonic devices.
important optical and transport properties. PF2/6 has a hole
−4 2
mobility of 4.4 × 10 cm /(V s) in the nematic liquid phase, 2.2. Polyfluorenes with hydrocarbon-based